{"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_count": 8, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00729076", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00729076.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "DRAFT ONLY \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nCASE NO.:10-CV-21586 \nPODHURST ORSECK \nv. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN \nDefendant's Reply to Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Amended Notice and \nMotion for Leave to Deposit Funds into the Registry of the Court \nThe defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, responds to the Plaintiff's Response to his Motion for \nLeave to Deposit Funds into the Registry of the Court as follows: \nI. The Plaintiff's Response, in its first sentence, indicates that it does not oppose the \nrelief requested. The remainder of the Response is a gratuitous, unnecessary, \ninflammatory, immaterial, series of misrepresentations regarding the Defendant's \nintent in offering to deposit $2,000,000 into the Court and regarding the history \nand nature of the fee dispute that is at the core of the current litigation; \n2. As background, defendant Epstein executed a Non-Prosecution Agreement with \nthe United States Attorney's Office (\"USAO\") on September 24, 2007 \n(hereinafter \"Agreement\"). The Agreement required that Epstein plead to state \noffenses and that the USAO agree not to federally prosecute him for various \noffenses that were under investigation. The Agreement also required that Epstein \npay legal fees for an attorney representative, who was to be selected by an \nEFTA00729076\n", "char_count": 1318}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "independent third party, and provide counsel to a list of individuals which \nremained secret until after Epstein's state plea nine months after the execution of \nthe Agreement. The fee obligation was not intended to be unlimited: it was to \npay the fees of the attorney representative prior to his electing to file and/or filing \n\"contested litigation\" or \"any other contested remedy\" against Epstein and was to \n\"cease\" and not obligate Epstein \"to pay the fees and costs of contested litigation \nfiled against him\" (Addendum to Agreement, Par. 7C). \nThe fee obligation \nrequired that Epstein \"pay such attorney representative his or her regular \ncustomary hourly rate\". The Agreement did not address such issues as whether \nthe attorney representative would be authorized to go outside his firm and hire \nand pay non-firm lawyers, a significant issue given that the Plaintiff is seeking \nover $1,000,000 in fees generated by two non-firm lawyers, one of whom \nremained employed as an Assistant State Attorney while billing over $700,000 for \nher work on the Epstein matters. The Agreement implicitly limited the fees and \ncosts being charged to Mr. Epstein so that they were reasonable and not \nunnecessarily duplicative given that Mr. Epstein, at the essence of these highly \nunorthodox requirements, was being obligated to pay the fees of an attorney who \nwas his adversary both in settlement discussions and thereafter when he filed \nlitigation against him. The Agreement further required that Mr. Epstein waive \nliability and not contest jurisdiction only when certain conditions precedent were \nfulfilled by litigating claimants, see, infra Par 4b. Although the Agreement was \nsilent on the timing of interim payments, and on what procedure would be used to \nresolve disputes as to whether certain invoiced charges were outside the \nEFTA00729077\n", "char_count": 1853}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Agreement's fee obligations, clearly Mr. Epstein was not mandated by the \nAgreement to simply write a blank check for over $2,500,000 of fees upon \ndemand or be automatically in breach of the Agreement as contended by \nPlaintiffs. On numerous occasions before the filing of this litigation, Mr. Epstein \nhas offered to review the invoices with the Plaintiffs on a line by line basis, offers \nthat at the end were refused. Mr. Epstein has repeatedly offered to submit the \ndisputed invoices to a neutral third party, and even executed a Special Masters \nAgreement evidencing his commitment to resolve the disputed fee issues without \nlitigation however such offers were refused by Plaintiff. As will be shown, Mr. \nEpstein has principled disputes with the reasonableness of the fee request, the \nduplication of work by both firm and non-firm lawyers, the including of fees and \ncosts attributable to contested litigation brought by three of the attorney \nrepresentative's clients rather than to \"consideration of potential settlements\" as \nwas contemplated by the Agreement's fee provisions, and to the enormous fee \ndemands made by non-firm lawyers whose retention was unnecessary and \nunauthorized by the Agreement. \nMr. Epstein did not willfully breach the \nAgreement. He paid $526,000 of the Plaintiffs interim bills. He disputes the \nremainder. He is seeking to place $2,000,000 in Trust as security against any \npotential future determination by this Court that any additional fees and costs are \nowed under the Agreement; \n3. Mr. Epstein's intent in seeking that his pending Motion be allowed is only to \nfulfill his obligations under the Non-Prosecution Agreement to pay all reasonable \nsettlement-related fees according to the terms of the Agreement. As stated, Mr. \nEFTA00729078\n", "char_count": 1788}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Epstein should not be required to issue a \"blank check\" to pay interim legal bills \nwhich clearly include excessive or duplicate charges and further include \nlitigation-related fees and costs that are outside the Agreement. Amongst the \nprincipled issues that are raised by the Complaint are as follows: \na) $1,073,000 of the disputed amount result from charges attributed to two \nattorneys who are not members of the attorney representative's firm, one \nof whom was a sitting state prosecutor at the time. Although Mr. Epstein \n\"agreed to pay the fees of the attorney representative selected ...\", NPA \nAddendum Par. 7C, he never agreed to the employment of outside \nattorneys much less agreed to the extensiveness of their involvement and \nthe enormity of the fees that they have sought from Mr. Epstein These fees \nare not within Mr. Epstein's obligations under the Agreement. Over \n$700,000 of these fees (or the equivalent of over 10 years of full-time \nlegal work in this non-firm attorney's ordinary job) are requested for work \nperformed by an Assistant State Attorney for Dade County who has no \nspecialized expertise in areas relevant to the consideration of civil \nsettlements. These charges are not necessary, reasonable, nor within Mr. \nEpstein's NPA obligations; \nb) A review of just one page of one of the bills, e.g., p. 13 of the invoice of \nMay 11, 2010, reflects that Mr. Epstein is being charged for litigation-\nrelated fees when his NPA obligation limits him to paying settlement-\nrelated fees only. This single exemplar reflects hourly billing for \npreparation and attendance of firm members at litigation depositions, for \nEFTA00729079\n", "char_count": 1659}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "preparation and research into client Jane Doe's Response, and further, at p. \n23 of the same bill, includes charges for court reporter fees for depositions \nand filing fees for Complaints. Similar charges permeate the invoices; \nc) A review of the bills shows duplicative and excessive requested fees that \ntotal far more than the monetary value of all the settlements reached for \nthe Plaintiffs' sixteen clients including the three who filed litigation; \nd) The magnitude of the settlement-related charges are unreasonable \nparticularly given that the attorney representative fee obligations were not \nagreed to in arms-length negotiation with the Plaintiffs' own clients, but \nwere instead imposed on Mr. Epstein by his Non-Prosecution Agreement. \nGiven this unorthodoxy, there is even greater need that the charges to \nEpstein must be reasonable, see, e.g. Red Bull GMBH v. Spacefuel Corp \n(1:06cv20948-AJ)(SD Fla)(Court reduces rates charged to losing party in \nlitigation as being unreasonable)(CITE TO OTHER CASES); \ne) Although all of the clients who selected the attorney representative have \nnow settled their cases, Mr. Epstein has not received a final invoice. The \ninterim bills received to date do not include any charges for the two \noutside attorneys referred to in paragraph 3a for March-May, 2010. The \nNPA obligates payment but does not require interim payments. Defendant \nEpstein has at all times informed the Plaintiffs that he reserves the right to \nsubmit disputed bills to a neutral third party, see, e.g., letter of Jay \nLefkowitz to Robert Josefsberg, September 8, 2009. \nEFTA00729080\n", "char_count": 1612}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "4. The claims of Plaintiff contained in his Response that defendant Epstein has \nviolated the NPA are inaccurate, irrelevant and even frivolous: \na) Plaintiff alleges that Epstein failed to formalize his plea of guilty in state \ncourt and \"delayed that action for several months\", Response, pp. 1-2. \nThe reality is that during the time period addressed by Plaintiff, Mr. \nEpstein, through counsel, with the knowledge and approval of the United \nStates Attorney Alexander Acosta and First Assistant Jeffrey Sloman, was \npursuing his right to review the Agreement through meetings and filings \nwith the Department of Justice in Washington M., a review process that \ndid not end until June 23, 2008 just 7 days before Mr. Epstein entered his \nstate plea, see eg letter of US Attorney Acosta to Kenneth Starr dated \nDeember 4, 2007, pg 5 (\"I do not mind this Office's decision being \nappealed to Washington, and have previously directed our prosecutors to \ndelay filings in this case to provide defense counsel with the option of \nappealing our decision\" ) appended hereto as Exhibit \"A\". \nb) Plaintiff further alleges that Epstein was in \"clear breach of the NPA\" by \nfiling a Motion to Dismiss contesting the legality of a lawsuit before Judge \nMarra, Response, p. 2. The waivers of liability and right to contest \njurisdiction were not effectuated, as claimed by Plaintiff, \"so long as the \nclaims were being brought pursuant to §2255\", Id. Instead, the NPA \nlimited the waivers to a claimant who \"elects to proceed exclusively under \n18 U.S.C. §2255, and agrees to waive any other claim for damages, \nwhether pursuant to state, federal, or common law,\" Agreement, Par. 8. \nEFTA00729081\n", "char_count": 1687}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "The plaintiff in question said she was filing only under 18 U.S.C. §2255 \nbut she did not ever agree to waive or relinquish all future claims for \ndamages as required as a condition precedent for any of the NPA waivers \nof liability and jurisdiction.' Nevertheless, when warned by the \nGovernment that there was a perceived breach of the NPA in the Motion \nto Dismiss filing, it was withdrawn on the day of the notice of breach. \n5. \nThe Non-Prosecution Agreement contains highly unorthodox provisions \nincluding a requirement that Mr. Epstein agree to not contest liability as to a list of \n\"victims\" which was not disclosed to him until after his plea and incarceration 9 months \nafter he executed the Agreement. This provision led to settlements with persons he never \nrecalled meeting. Epstein has thus gone beyond the literal terms of the Agreement and \ndeclined to contest liability even as to plaintiffs who never relinquished their future right \nto bring additional claims. But even the spirit of the Agreement does not require that he \npay the full amount of every bill when the charges are either unreasonable or duplicative \nor outside the limiting provisions of the Agreement nor does it prohibit the presentation \nof fee disputes to the Court so long as Mr. Epstein pays what a Court determines is owed. \n6. The defendant wants only to resolve his outstanding fee dispute in conformity \nwith his obligations under the NPA. He requests that the Court grant his now unopposed \nMotion to place $2,000,000 in Trust pending a final determination of whether he owes \nany amounts in addition to the $526,000 he has already paid the Plaintiffs. \nI Additionally, in an authoritative communication by the United States Attorney, Jeffrey \nSloman, to Epstein's counsel Exhibit \"A\" p. 2, fn I, the Government agreed that it was \nthe intentions of the parties that the \"waiver of right to contest subject matter jurisdiction \nwas intended by all parties \"to address issues of venue\" and that \"this Office will not \ninterpret this paragraph as any waiver of subject matter jurisdiction\" \nEFTA00729082\n", "char_count": 2099}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00729076", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "EFTA00729083\n", "char_count": 13}]}