{"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_count": 21, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00724612", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00724612.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "A Passionate Discussion with Al Seckel\nAl Seckel is a leading authority on visual illusions, and the author of several books\non this topic. He has lectured extensively throughout the world at many prestigious\nuniversities and conferences. He is passionate about science, education, and\nphilanthropy, and is a member and contributor to The Edge Group.\nEpstein: Al, you are an interesting guy. What have been some of the areas that you\nare most passionate about?\nSeckel: That would depend upon the time of my life. Formerly, and for a good part\nof it, my passion was specifically confined to discovery, and the pleasure of finding\nthings out, specifically in theoretical physics and then in cognitive neuroscience.\nNow, my thoughts are directed more on trying to help move the needle forward in a\nqualitative way on the health of this planet, although I still take a great pleasure in\nplayful and productive recreations of the mind.\nEpstein: And other passions?\nSeckel: Ha, one could say that my life has been consumed by passion in many\ndifferent areas. The pursuit of excellence in thought, achievement, craft, not only in\nmy own work, but also in the work of others is perhaps my greatest passion. I am\ndrawn to excellence and avoid myopia. Another great passion of mine is in\nreforming educational systems, specifically in thinking skills, creativity, and\ninnovation.\nEpstein: So, you're a guy of passions?\nSeckel: Very much so and personally I can really only relate to similar passionate\npeople of quality and substance. It's always difficult for me to carry on a\nconversation when it is not passionate, interesting, or meaningful. This makes me\nsomewhat intense. I certainly know that this may not always be everyone's cup of\ntea.\nWhen I was in my teenage years, I was very influenced by the writings of the English\nphilosopher Bertrand Russell, who in the preface of his three-volume autobiography\ndescribed a life of passions: 1. The search for knowledge; 2: The search for love; and\n3: the ne\n... [truncated, 2301 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/0 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=0]", "char_count": 2301}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Epstein: Back to thinking skills...why do you think these are so important? Are they\nsomething that can be taught?\nSeckel: First of all, I think that for the most part, public educational systems,\nreligious institutions, governments, all elements of mass media and communication,\nand even our families, teach us what to think rather than how to think. Propaganda\nand manipulative techniques are used for both good and evil purposes. In spite of\nwhat many people think, they aren't just confined to the people in black hats.\nAs individuals and as a society we have not learned how to ask the right questions:\nto separate the essentials from the non-essentials, and get to the heart of a problem.\nWe also take a very surface approach to things, where we become very much like a\nstone that randomly skips across the surface of the water, never going into any\ndepth. Essentially, we are a society of parrots, who for the most part repeat what is\nsaid and written. Well, the devil is in the detail, and context is the most important\nand essential part of information, and when you don't have the right context (where\nit is presented incorrectly or withheld), you will come to incorrect conclusions.\nParroting, rather than solving, is a severe mental handicap when dealing with the\nvarious problems of the world or any other problem, personal or otherwise.\nI have noticed that many well-meaning groups out there are constantly \"raising\nawareness\" about this or that particular global or local issue, but these same groups\ndon't couple these issue with any specific tractable, scalable, and practical solutions.\nWhat is put out there is often surface and vague: \"We need to do something about\nDarfur,\" \"We need Peace now!,\" \"Imagine,\" or \"We need to do something about\nglobal warming,\" etc. Ok, I as a concerned citizen want to do something about global\nwarming. I don't want all those polar bears to die in 50 years, and so what do I do?\nDo I turn on my air conditioner? Do I set the oven to a lower temper\n... [truncated, 3073 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/1 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=1]", "char_count": 3073}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "about my specific abilities in math and physics. After listening to my responses, he\nthen said, \"Ok, with that skill set, you can work on this or that, but on these other\nproblems, don't even go there.\" At that time, I had to have the problems well defined\nfor me, and in a way that matched my particular skill set. A similar approach would\nmay work today, were various advocacy groups need to present various problems in\na way that will match a person's or group's particular skill set.\nEpstein: I do see a lot of people and institutions lately taking up the rallying cry for\nsparking innovation and creative solutions.\nSeckel: That's all fine and good, but in reality, I think that this is a little bit\nmisdirected, as many of the \"solutions\" to various problems are already in existence,\nbut for whatever reason they are stuck in the pipeline. There are many reasons\nwhy they may be stuck, a lack of financing, a seasoned management team, proper\nexposure (they are not even on the menu), etc. Simultaneous to sparking innovation\nand creativity, we need to \"unstick\" those solutions that have not progressed past\nthe solution stage into the practical implementation stage. In the real world, if a\nsolution isn't implementable, tractable, scalable, and sustainable, it isn't really a\nmeaningful solution.\nYou need a complete alphabet to form words, sentences, and thought, not a partial\nalphabet. Solutions are only part of the alphabet.\nEpstein: Getting back to our earlier discussion, wouldn't you say that today, we\nhave progressed into an Age of Information? The web, electronic means of\ncommunication, has made information so much more accessible and freely available\nthan ever before.\nSeckel: We have progressed in our technology and knowledge, but not always in the\narea of insight and wisdom. It is said that we live in an Age of Information, but I\nbelieve that we are rapidly transitioning from an Age of Information to an Age of\nMisinformation, and in many cases, outright disinformation. \n... [truncated, 3040 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/2 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=2]", "char_count": 3040}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "like Walter Cronkite conclude his broadcast with, \"And, that's the way it is\", you had\na degree of confidence. Of course, we knew that he wasn't foolproof and mistakes\ncould be made, but at least there was a professionally trained staff, who had gone\nthrough due diligence in checking and verifying information, before it went out at\nCronkite's vetted broadcast. Again, as I say, none of these checks and balances is\nfoolproof. Even seasoned reporters like Dan Rather and Bob Woodward have gotten\nbadly deceived.\nEpstein: What is different about the information today being processed on the web?\nSeckel: The world-wide web has allowed information pipelines to become relatively\ninexpensive, if not free. This has in turn allowed for far greater access to freely\ncontribute and receive information. The combination of these two elements has led\nto what I call, a vast \"democratization of information, \"where \"the good, the bad, and\nthe ugly,\" all gets placed equally on a level playing field. Just look at some of the\nwebsites devoted to physics or astronomy, including some of the \"educational\" ones.\nThey can be a complete disaster, where even fundamental terms like energy, power,\ninertia, etc. are incorrectly defined.\nEpstein: This type of poor quality information is rampant in textbooks as well, so\nthere is nothing new in terms of misinformation being created and spread.\nSeckel: That is absolutely correct, our informational age didn't create, nor does it\nhave a monopoly on misinformation or disinformation; however, it is the scale and\naccess to and contribution to informational pipelines that is different today. You\nwant to be a journalist? Never mind, the Columbia School of Journalism or any other\nprofessional training, etc., just start a blog or be an aggregator of information and\ncollected opinions like Arianna Huffington's site. You want to offer up medical\nadvice, just create a website. On and on it goes. Now, anyone can be anything or\neverything, just by access to those pipe\n... [truncated, 2916 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/3 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=3]", "char_count": 2916}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "supposed to be a self-correcting system. Wikipedia, in spite of the various checks\nand balances that they had to incorporate, is a disaster and unreliable as a resource.\nI have heard a number of people state that statistically, Wikipedia as a primary\nsource of information has as many errors as the Encylopedia Brittanica. I don't know\nwhere this information comes from, but I don't view the Encyclopedia Brittanica as a\nprimary source either. It would be helpful if people started understanding the\ndifference between primary, secondary, and tertiary sources for information.\nEpstein: You talked about necessity of practical solutions and implementing them,\nso what are you going to do about this problem, which is \"practical and\nsustainable\"?\nSeckel: The problem is quite complex, and naturally there are many different\napproaches that one will need to take. I don't have a practical \"solution\" to all these\nproblems, but as I have stated before, one needs to start with tractable solutions.\nWhat I mean by \"tractable,\" is a solution that can be implemented within five years\nand will have a meaningful and sustainable result. I hope that it will scale as well.\nNow, that's the general view, but on the practical implementable side, I am now\nworking very closely with my good friend Caprice Young, who is an absolute\ndynamo as a nationally respected reformer in educational circles. Caprice helped\ngrow the charter school system in this country, and has served on numerous boards,\non both a local and national level, and she has the experience, passion, and\nknowledge to get things implemented on a national level. So, Caprice and I are now\npartially funded to put together a massive interactive website on thinking skills to\nbe incorporated into school curriculums, along with interactive lesson plans and\nprograms.\nEpstein: Tell me about this website. Thinking skills? That's a very broad term.\nSeckel: Yes, it is a broad term. Most people think thinking skills means \"critical\nthinking, \"but act\n... [truncated, 2911 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/4 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=4]", "char_count": 2911}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Providing the methods for eliminating mental blocks to thought, creativity,\nand practical solutions.\nEpstein: So, how will this work?\nSeckel: Each section will be largely interactive and will have many examples. There\nwill also be an emphasis to make it fun, delightful, and surprising, along with many\nAHA! moments so as to carry the student through on his or her own accord. That\nthis will be fun to interact with, and external pressure is not necessary to finish the\nprogram. Again, it is not offered as a \"complete\" solution, and I am not so naïve as to\nthink you can just \"teach\" the world to be rational and develop necessary thinking\nskills, but it is a start, an arrow among a quiver of arrows needed...\nEpstein: Won't all this critical thinking cause people to become cynical?\nSeckel: It is not our goal to have people become unduly suspicious or cynical of\nwhat they hear and read, but just more aware of how careful one has to be in coming\nto conclusions, as well as the need for clarity and exactness in thinking. Critical\nthinking is necessary, but also has its limitations too. I know plenty of professional\nskeptics, who fall into their own trap of negating things unnecessarily, because of a\npattern of critical thinking at the expense of finding out what is really happening.\nThought and imagination need to be somewhat tethered.\nEpstein: Where did you develop some of these thinking skills? Did they come from\nyour parents?\nSeckel: Oh, like everyone else, I used to parrot, and on occasion, still do; however,\none of the most helpful lessons I learned was when I was a freshman at Cornell. In\nhigh school, I was a great fan and admirer of the works of the English philosopher\nand mathematician Bertrand Russell. When I came across his books on\nmathematical philosophy: An introduction to Mathematical Philosophy and Principles\nof Mathematics, I found them to be absolutely delightful. I then found out that he\nwrote on other topics and came across his book \"Why I am not a Christian\n... [truncated, 2975 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/5 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=5]", "char_count": 2975}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "parroting Russell, the professor said to me, and in front of the entire class, \"Oh yeah?\nWhat about.... And what about this?\" Well, I was dumbstruck, because Russell\nhadn't discussed either this or that, so it was completely embarrassing to me, and I\nrealized right then and there that my knowledge way down deep was shallow and I\ndidn't have to go very deep at all. I had to derive knowledge and conclusions myself.\nThat history of science professor, L. Pearce Williams, became my close advisor and\nfriend during my four years there. He was a great inspiration to me. We are still in\ntouch. A few years back my then Cornell President Jeffrey Lehman invited me to\nreturn to Cornell to give the Presidential Lecture. I dedicated my talk to Pearce,\nwhich brought tears to his eyes. It is nice to give back and appreciate what you have\nbeen given.\nIt was also from Peace that I learned that you need the help of informed people, who\ncan offer sound criticism and advice. People who take the autodidactic approach\noften run into trouble, because there is no one, who can help provide guidance, your\nown mental blinders get in the way.\nEpstein: This parroting approach is also a problem in how many people learn\nmathematics in high school.\nSeckel: Very much so. Students learn a series of steps of how to arrive at an answer\nwithout much of an understanding of how they got there. This is how I honed my\nskills in math and physics, as I just spent endless hours deriving everything I could.\nEpstein: Who were some of your other inspirations in thought and thinking skills?\nSeckel: I was extremely fortunate through a good part of the 1980's to be very close\nto Richard Feynman. We spend many hours together almost every other day\ndiscussing all manner of topics from quantum computing to vision to aspects of\ntheoretical physics. There were three of us in his very close inner circle, and it was\nan exceptional time. For a number of reasons, he liked me, and we had a lot of fun\ntogether, including campin\n... [truncated, 2717 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/6 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=6]", "char_count": 2717}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Feynman and I discussed it too, and we shared similar prejudices. Of course, Murray\nGell-Mann would have none of our discussions and thought we were just being\nstubborn, \"idiotic,\" and sticking to the \"old stuff.\"\nIn fact, since that time, Michael, who has become a prominent string theorist and I\nhave kept up a long standing and very friendly feud about the validity of string\ntheory, and whether it was in fact either a proto-science or a pseudoscience. My\ngood friend Shelly Glashow and I also shared the same prejudices (and we also\ntalked about it at length), as well as many of my physicist friends who were first-\nrate astrophysicists or general relativists.\nMike later discovered that there are roughly 10500 solutions, and I immediately\ncalled him up and congratulated him for bringing down the theory as not being\nparsimonious. One time Shelly Glashow was staying with me, and Mike was visiting\nCaltech on sabbatical, and so both Shelly and I roped Mike into going down to the\nlocal pub and having it all out. At the end of the discussion, Mike said, \"Yeah, there\nare definitely problems, but we basically hope to work all this out.\"\nBecause of Murray Gell-Mann's staunch advocacy, string theory became the \"in\"\nthing, and started to zap up all the fine new minds, but it didn't really matter for me,\nbecause I got seriously ill with leukemia in 1990, and dropped out of physics and\nanything else, for that matter, for a few years.\nEpstein: And your thoughts about string theory now?\nSeckel: Honestly, I have not kept up with it, like I used to do in the old days, and so,\nthere has been tremendous progress. I often get some catch up lessons when my\nfriends Lisa Randall, Sean Carroll, John Schwartz, or Mike Douglas come by and visit.\nA few months ago, I actually hosted at my home a very prominent group of\ninternational string theorists, who were at Caltech and UCSB for a conference. So, I\ngot completely surrounded, and we had some good discussions then, and I will say,\nfor the reco\n... [truncated, 2950 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/7 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=7]", "char_count": 2950}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Nevertheless, I persisted, because it certainly was to be admitted that he had a\nstrong intuitive sense of the elegance of fundamental theories, and might be able to\nprovide some insight rather than just philosophizing. It was also true that this\nnotion was a successful guiding principle for many great physicists of the twentieth\ncentury including Einstein, Bohr, Dirac, Gell-Mann, etc. Why this was so, was\ninteresting to me.\nWe spent several hours trying to get at the heart of the problem and, indeed, trying\nto determine if it was even a true notion rather than some romantic representation\nof science.\nWe did agree that it was impossible to explain honestly the beauties of the laws of\nnature in a way that people can feel, without their having some deep understanding\nof mathematics. It wasn't that mathematics was just another language for physicists;\nit was a tool for reasoning by which you could connect one statement with another.\nThe physicist has meaning to all his phrases. He needs to have a connection of words\nto the real world.\nCertainly, a beautiful theory meant being able to describe it very simply in terms of\nfundamental mathematical quantities. \"Simply\" meant compression into a small\nmathematical expression with tremendous explanatory powers, which required\nonly a finite amount of interpretation. In other words, a huge number of\nrelationships between data are concisely fit into a single statement. Later, Murray\nGell-Mann expressed this point well, when he wrote, \"The complexity of what you\nhave to learn in order to be able to read the statement of the law is not really very\ngreat compared to the apparent complexity of the data that are being summarized\nby that law. That apparent complexity is partly removed when the law is formed.\"\nAnother driving principle was that the laws of the universe are self-similar, in that\nthere are connections between two sets of phenomena previously thought to be\ndistinct. There seemed to be a beauty in the inter-relationships fe\n... [truncated, 2897 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/8 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=8]", "char_count": 2897}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "something we create? When we spoke of symmetries, we were referring to the\nsymmetry of the mathematical laws of physics, not to the symmetry of objects\ncommonly found in nature. We felt that symmetry was inherent in nature, because it\nwas not something that we expected to find in physics. Another psychological\nprejudice was our love for patterns. The simplicity of the patterns in physics was\nbeautiful. This does not mean simple in action - the motion of the planets and of\natoms can be very complex, but the basic patterns underneath are simple. This is\nwhat is common to all of our fundamental laws.\nIt should be noted that we could also come up with numerous examples where one's\nsense of elegance and beauty led to beautiful theories that were wrong. A perfect\nexample of a mathematically elegant theory that turned out to be wrong is Francis\nCrick's 1957 attempt at working out the genetic coding problem (Codes without\nCommas). It was also true that there were many examples of physical theories that\nwere pursued on the basis of lovely symmetries and patterns, and that these also\nturned out to be false. Usually, these were false because of some logical\ninconsistency or the crude fact that they did not agree with experiment.\nThe best that Dick and I could come up with was an unscientific response, which is,\ngiven our fondness for patterns and symmetry; we have a prejudice that nature is\nsimple and therefore beautiful.\nI published some of these issues on the edge website back in 2001, and later, in\n2009, when I was discussing with my close friend physicist Murray Gell-Mann\npossible topics for discussion at TED, I suggested this as an interesting topic, and he\nagreed. His talk expanded on this theme and is well worth listening to:\n1\nEpstein: So, you went into the study of perception from theoretical physics?\nSeckel: Yes, after my recovery from leukemia, which knocked me out for several\nyears, my abilities to do complex mathematics were severely impaired, and I have\nnever rec\n... [truncated, 2748 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/9 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=9]", "char_count": 2748}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "classic book What is Life? based on his discussions with Delbrück. A good number of\nphysicists, who were tired of their work being applied to the science of death in\nmaking atomic bombs, read this book, and applied rigorous hard-core scientific\nprinciples to biological systems, which gave rise to the science of molecular biology.\nThis led to some hope that such an approach would work.\nIn theoretical physics, when you are trying to get at the fundamental issues of the\nuniverse, you don't just confirm and reconfirm the things that have already been\nconfirmed. You look at the so-called quirky areas, those areas that seem a little hard\nto fit in. That's where you scratch, and are liable to find things that are interesting.\nEpstein: So, how did you apply this to the study of the brain?\nSeckel: So, I asked myself, \"What is the brain mainly concerned with?\" Well, it is\ndevoted to visual perception. It was also helpful that we had by that time the\nbeginnings of understanding of the visual system and pathways from studying the\nmacque monkey.\nSo, I asked myself, \"What is the quirky area of visual perception?\" The answer was\nvisual illusions. I was very lucky, because when I started, the timing was opportune,\nas multimedia toolboxes were just developing and being marketed. I still had to\nconstantly push the boundaries of all available software.\nThis was in the early 1990s, and so, I was the very first person to comprehensively\ninvestigate and dissemble various illusions to see how they operated, and what\nwere the critical parameters for making them work. Of course, scientists have been\nstudying illusions seriously since the late 19th century, but they didn't have the box\nof tools that we were developing.\nI embarked on a rigorous task of collecting, saturating, and analyzing myself in the\nsubject. I managed to get amazing results, so much that no one had seen before. It\nwas like taking the cork out of the bottle...it all flowed out. In this process, I was\ngreatly supported in t\n... [truncated, 2872 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/10 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=10]", "char_count": 2872}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "perceptual processes do not. For the past 17 years I have been working on trying to\nunderstand the various mechanism that mediate perception, and in specific cases,\nwhen possible, what are the neuronal correlates of visual illusions. My extensive\ndatabase and knowledge of illusions became also very handy, because when Caltech\nwould have, for example, a visiting professor from MIT, speaking about brightness\nillusions, and what he thought were the underlying mechanisms, he would have\nworked it out from only a very limited sampling available to him. \"Oh, these\nbrightness illusions are caused by the intersection of Y and X junctions, etc.\nHowever, I would be able to point out brightness illusions that had the same effect,\nwhich violated his Y and X junction rule, and so, both my comprehensive\ncompilation of innumerable effects and the saturation of trying to understand their\nunderlying mechanisms became a very powerful tool for understanding some basic\nelements of perception.\nEpstein: Is this what you are still working on still today?\nSeckel: No, not as much anymore, although I still do contribute, because my\ndaughter Elizabeth works in the laboratory of Vilaymar Ramachandran, and is\npublishing papers with him, and so, I can now enjoy kibitzing and suggesting ideas.\nFor many years, I went around to various universities giving talks on these effects\nand underlying mechanisms; however, now, I want to take it to the next level, into a\n\"take away\" for the audience, and how the underlying mechanisms relate to the\nNature of Belief, and steps that we can take to help problem solve.\nEpstein: Aren't you writing a book on this topic?\nSeckel: Yes. This is one of the books I am currently working on, and I have shifted\nmy lecture talk to this focus, and my insights have been so far, well received.\nEpstein: Can you tell me the thrust of your talk and book? I have seen your talk and\nit is quite remarkable.\nSeckel: Thanks. Oh, it's a little difficult to present it powerfully without th\n... [truncated, 2507 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/11 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=11]", "char_count": 2507}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Most people tend to take vision and perception for granted, because it comes to\nthem so easily. After all, we appear to build up a seamless mental and apparently\nexact representation of this visual rich three-dimensional world that we inhabit and\nnavigate. Of course, this leads to the trivialization that the eye/brain is like a camera,\nwhich records incoming light information, but the brain interprets, where as the\ncamera records, and that is a very big qualitative difference.\nThe perceptual system is really a framework for allowing you to successfully inhabit\nand survive in our world. Over millions of years of evolution, the human perceptual\nsystem has basically evolved a \"bag of tricks,\" which exploits the regularities of our\nenvironment, and allow us to have a fairly accurate representation of our world.\nIn our physical world, physicists have shown that underneath all this apparent\ncomplexity of the universe are basic fundamental laws and interactions that are\nrepeated over and over again. The universe is constrained by hidden laws, but yet,\nthere is tremendous complexity. In the same way, the complexities of human\nperception, are governed by a set of rules that operate beneath your level of\nawareness.\nThe human perceptual framework, in very general terms, can be divided in three\ndivisions, which feed and interact back and forth with each other.\n(1) The building up of the fundamental scene, i.e, form, brightness, color, motion,\netc.\n(2) The meaning of the scene, which relates to tagging and labeling objects, and\nwhat is salient about the scene\n(3) The building up of a core belief system.\nIt is my thesis that all of these divisions operate through rules that operate beneath\nyour level of awareness, and that you have no mental control over these rules, and\nthat you have no mental control over these rules. Your perception is very context\ndependent.. It takes very little information to flip a perception one way or another\nby switching surrounding context.\nFurthermore\n... [truncated, 2581 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/12 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=12]", "char_count": 2581}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Epstein: Can you give some examples to clarify?\nSeckel: Let us start with the building up of a fundamental scene. When I show you\nan image of an impossible figure, let us say, an impossible figure, you make a mental\nrepresentation of this figure as a three-dimensional object, even though\nconceptually you know that it is completely impossible.\nEpstein: Why is that?\nSeckel: For your entire lifetime, you have interpreted two-dimensional perspective\ndrawings into three-dimensional mental representations. There are rules that have\nbeen developed by your perceptual system for doing that. You can't stop using those\nrules, even when faced with a figure that is clearly impossible. The rules will\novertake the conceptual part, and you will continue to \"map\" it in a way that is\nconsistent with that framework. Also, just think, when you make a perceptual\nmistake, i.e, trip on a curb, knock over a glass, etc., your world doesn't go suddenly\nout of focus, and your perceptual system adopts a new set of internal rules, it just\ncontinues doing what it did before.\nNow, let us look at a Core Belief, something that really defines a person's way of\ninterpreting the world. Let's take the example of a magical thinker versus a non-\nmagical thinker. Both the non magical thinker and the magical thinker can easily\nnavigate the world, but they \"map\" the world that they navigate in very different\nways.\nLet us show both the non-magical thinker and the magical thinker same photograph\nof a young girl pulled out of the rubble in Haiti, and ask them what it represents.\nOf course, both can identify and discern the young girl being pulled out of the\nrubble, but that is where the commonality stops.\nThe non magical thinker will look at this photo and say, Well, Haiti is on a known\nfault line, the houses are poorly constructed, an earthquake happened, thousands of\npeople were killed and injured, and even after ten days, statistically it is highly\nprobably that a child will be pulled out of the rubble aliv\n... [truncated, 2784 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/13 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=13]", "char_count": 2784}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "adept at coming up with ways to keep that core belief intact. After all, it is there to\nhave you be successful. It isn't necessarily there to be the Truth police. Sometimes\nyour perceptions mesh with Reality and sometimes they don't. This is why I define\nReality as that which exists independently of your beliefs or perceptions..\nSo, at some point you have that life defining experience. It convinced you to make\nthat most Personal of all decisions - something that would govern the rest of your\nlife and serve as your moral compass. Subsequent to that experience, the rest of\nyour life experience has reinforced your guiding principles. You are constantly\n\"reaffirmed\" in what you see about you.\nNow, you come into contact with someone who does not share your core beliefs. You\nhave to spend the weekend with them in close quarters, and decide to have \"it out,\"\nbut in a very amicable way. You both present yourselves in the most articulate\nmanner possible, self-satisfied that you could not have done a better job! Not only\ndid you present the information that made you embark on that principle in the first\nplace, but you presented much additional evidence, just to put the argument over\nthe top...\nWhat does the other side do? Shake their head. He/she will have none of it... In fact,\nrather than \"weakening\" your opponent's side, you find out you have \"emboldened\"\nthem! There is a Big Disconnect.\nEpstein: Can you provide any relevant examples of this today?\nSeckel: Yes, actually with the current Climate Change debate. About twenty years\nago, I was very actively involved in the creation science/evolution debate. I debated\ncreationists, and put together an amicus brief on behalf of 72 Nobel laureates before\nthe Supreme Court. Without exception, every creation scientist was a\nFundamentalist Christian. There was a Core Belief behind their views. There was\nnothing in the fossil record, the robust findings of astronomy, geology, biology,\nchemistry, physics, etc., etc., which would change\n... [truncated, 2943 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/14 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=14]", "char_count": 2943}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Belief of the climate skeptics? It wasn't too difficult to discover that they are\nLibertarians. What is the Core Belief of the Libertarian? They do not like\nGovernment Regulation, Government Intrusion, or any invasion of their individual\nRights. That's it. Notice, that the climate change skeptics, accept all the findings of\nthe climate scientists that the world is getting warmer, and accept all their work,\nregarding other contributors to that warming except one! -- that there is a\nsignificant contribution by Humans. IF the climate change scientists are correct, that\nhumans have been a significant factor, it means regulations at a massive scale, which\ngoes completely against their Core Belief system. I have tested this hypothesis very\nextensively now. In arguing with any climate change skeptic, I ask them if they are a\nlibertarian. Their immediate response is \"Yes, but what does that have to do with\nanything?\" Well, everything actually....\nIf you read in the paper about about a \"think tank\" that has shown that the climate\nchange scientists are wrong, and look up the \"think tank\" on the internet, what do\nyou find, but that they are a Libertarian think tank. Penn Jillette and Teller, two\nmagicians, who I know well, and have a popular series debunking all sorts of shame\nscience and pseudoscience, did a program which blasted climate change science.\nWhy? Penn is a very outspoken Libertarian advocate. Same thing was the case with\nthe science fiction author, now deceased, Michael Crichton, who is frequently\nreferred to. Bjorn Lomborg, author of the Skeptical Evironmentalist, the Holy Bible\nof the climate skeptic movement, also is an avowed libertarian. Anytime, you find\nsomeone or some institution critical of climate change in the news, just do a google\nsearch or investigation, and you will find that they are liberatarian.\nIt is easier for them to attack the science of human induced climate change, rather\nthan to change their Core Belief Principles. They are not even consci\n... [truncated, 3049 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/15 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=15]", "char_count": 3049}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Seckel: It would be better defined as \"awareness.\" Yes, I have had many discussions\nwith him, as well as with our dear departed friend and colleague Francis Crick. I\nhave some of my own views on this subject, which I can share, as I have already\npresented them to Christof.\nEpstein: And, they are?\nSeckel: Well, one of the issues relates to when a sentient being becomes \"aware,\"\nand I don't mean \"self-aware,\" which is reserved for very high-level cognitive beings.\nChristof has been wrestling with the idea of this awareness coming in as a sort of\nphase transition or perhaps gradually. Into this discussion, comes the idea of when,\nby \"definition\" does something become \"aware\"?\nIt is my belief that these sorts of conundrums are just semantic, and I view\nawareness that progresses gradually to more and more rich states. The example\nthat I like to use is defining whether someone is \"rich\" by the number of pennies\nthat they have. Suppose they have 100 million pennies. Does that make them rich?\nWell, if you say yes, well, if you remove one penny, are they no longer \"rich\"? At\nwhat point after removing pennies does the person go from a rich state to a non-rich\nstate? Now, just substitute individual neurons for individual pennies and ask\nyourself the same question about awareness.\nChristof does excellent hard-core neuroscience. Everyone knows that, but I also find\nthat he can get quite muddled when he starts thinking in philosophical terms as\nopposed to scientific ones. I find that he falls easily into philosophical or semantic\ntraps.\nEpstein: Can you elaborate further in terms of your use of the word \"richness\" when\napplied to awareness, perhaps using the comparison between a human being and\nanother sentient animal?\nSeckel: Ok, well take my dog and myself. Is my dog \"aware\"? I would argue\ndefinitely yes, but my dog just has a much more impoverished \"awareness\" than I\ndo. For example, when I look around this room, not only do I perceive basic shapes,\ncolor, brightness, and moti\n... [truncated, 2790 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/16 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=16]", "char_count": 2790}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "a chair, telephone, computer, or pen. However, there are certain things that are\nmeaningful that she has labeled. For example, she knows and understands to a\nlimited extent her leash, her dish, my bed, my car, and so on. So, her perception of\nthe world, as I see it, is much more impoverished than mine, and hence her\nawareness is less rich. Think of the plug being pulled on HAL in the movie 2001 as\nhe gradually looses his mental abilities.\nEpstein: So you don't believe in any sort of phase transition for awareness?\nSeckel: Well, actually, I do. I believe in both a phase transition, as well as gradual\nawareness.\nEpstein: When in your opinion does the phase transition take place?\nSeckel: I have been advancing my own argument, as yet unproved, but based on my\nown thoughts in perception. It has to do with a split that we have between our\n\"conception\" of something and our \"perception\" of something. Under certain\ncircumstances, especially, in the awareness of perceptual illusions, our conception\nmay be ok, but our perceptions are fooled. In many types of robust illusions, no\namount of conceptual knowledge or experience will override your faulty perception.\nFor example, you may perceive two areas as entirely different colors, but in reality\nthey are absolutely identical. You will be tricked until this fact is brought to your\nawareness, by information, testing, whatever. In other words, you need the\n\"awareness\" to actually know that you are fooled, that there is a split between these\ntwo different mental modalities.\nI believe that \"awareness\" comes in when there is such a split. In some lower\nanimals, for example, you can show them the same perceptual stimulus over and\nover again, along with the reveal, and they will be fooled every time. Other animals,\nonce there is \"awareness\" that their perceptions have been fooled by the stimulus,\nwill not be fooled again. A scarecrow, at first fools the birds, then the birds learn that\nit isn't animate, and they perch on it repeatedly. \n... [truncated, 2824 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/17 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=17]", "char_count": 2824}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Epstein: Conclusions?\nSeckel: I don't know about conclusions. Christof is of the opinion that free will is an\n\"illusion,\" i.e, that we really don't have it. It really comes down to some basic\nsemantic definitions of \"free choice,\" and so on. I have heard his arguments, but as I\nhave said to him, it reminds me of a joke about Niels Bohr, who used to have a\nhorseshoe over his door. When asked why, he replied, \"It is to bring me good luck.\"\nNaturally, his physicist friends were incredulous over his maintaining even the\npresence of such a superstition, and so they proceeded to question him about it.\nBohr responded, \"Well, I know all that, but I am told that it will bring me good luck\neven if I don't believe it.\" Well, that's the same way I feel about the \"free will\"\nargument. I have heard the arguments against it, but I still believe that we have it!\nEpstein: How can we get at the bottom of this discussion?\nSeckel: Well, of course, we need to have some proper experiments, but this is such a\ndifficult area to properly test. Now, I have actually thought of some original ways to\nexperimentally test whether we have \"free will,\" or as I would say \"free choice,\"\nwhich I have suggested to Christof, and that I hope my daughter will carry out soon\nin Rama's lab. I don't know what it will prove or not, but it should be interesting to\nsee the results.\nEpstein: Can you describe the difficulties?\nSeckel: Let us keep the discussion to \"free choice.\" You may have a strong\npreference, for example, for chocolate ice cream, but really have a strong dislike for\nvanilla ice cream. Given the free choice, of which to pick, when offered, your\npreferences, context, will always guide your choice. So, is that free choice? Is there\nany freedom, given the same exact situation, to make a different choice? Well,\nherein lies one of the problems. Suppose you make a choice, well, you can't \"reset\"\nyour internal memories/experience, so that it never happened, and see if you will\nmake a different choice.\n... [truncated, 2969 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00724612/18 or ?id=EFTA00724612&page=18]", "char_count": 2969}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "the maze, let the memory vanish, and present the same maze again. Will the subject\ntake the same path? I predict that the subject won't, which to me suggests that there\nis a certain amount of choice in the matter. Of course, most things are quite\nconstrained by contextual and complex elements. I am just interested to see what\nwill happen in such an experiment.\nEpstein: Finally, one last question. Do you believe in any supernatural entity or\nGod?\nSeckel: No, never ever have, but then He or She doesn't believe in me either.\nEpstein: Thanks for the interview.\nSeckel: You are very welcome.\nPlease note: As a rule, opinions expressed by my subject interviewee do not\nnecessarily reflect my opinions or belief. These interviews are only meant to foster\nfurther thought and discussion about ideas and people that I find interesting.\nJeffrey Epstein, patron of the sciences.\nEFTA00724631\n", "char_count": 887}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00724612", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "EFTA00724632\n", "char_count": 13}]}