{"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_count": 117, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00621488", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00621488.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "MEETING HELD BEFORE SPECIAL MASTER ROBERT CARNEY\nIN RE:\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL\nCIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nComplex Litigation, Fla. R. Civ. Pro.1201\nCASE NO. 50 2009CA040800XXXXMB AG\nJEFFREY EPSTEIN,\nPlaintiff,\nvs.\nSCOTT ROTHSTEIN, individually,\nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS, individually,\n., individually,\nand\nDefendants.\nDATE TAKEN:\nTIME:\nPLACE:\nTuesday, March 15, 2011\n10:05 AM 12:35 PM\nSEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART &\nSHIPLEY\n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard\nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409\nLee Lynott, Registered Merit Reporter\nRegistered Professional Reporter\nCertified Shorthand Reporter\nHi-Tech/United Reporting, Inc.\n1218 SE 3rd Avenue\nFort Lauderdale, FL 33316\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 1\nEFTA00621488\n", "char_count": 755}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nAPPEARANCES:\nFOWLER, WHITE, BURNETT,\nBY: LILLY ANN SANCHEZ, ESQUIRE\nJOSEPH ACKERMAN, ESQUIRE\nCHRISTOPHER KNIGHT, ESQUIRE\nOne Financial Plaza - 21st Floor\n100 Southeast 3rd Avenue\nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33394\nFARMER, JAFFE, WEISSING, EDWARDS, FISTOS & LEHRMAN,\nP.L.\nBY: BRADLEY EDWARDS, ESQUIRE\n425 N. Andrews Avenue - Suite 2\nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301\nSEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART & SHIPLEY\nJACK SCAROLA, ESQUIRE\nBY:\n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard\nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409\nALSO PRESENT:\nMARTIN WEINBERGER, via telephone\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 2\nEFTA00621489\n", "char_count": 660}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "1\nTHEREUPON,\n2\n3\n15\n4\n(The following meeting took place):\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: We've got, it looks\nlike, two matters right now. I have some\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\nsuggestions, but\nsuggestions.\ncertainly open to\nOne, we are meeting to take a look at the\nprivilege log and see whether we have problems\nwith the privilege log; and if we have\nproblems, what needs to be done to correct the\nproblems. Two, we have a Request for Sanctions\nand we need a resolution on the Request for\nSanctions.\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\ninto either one, is a determination:\n17\n18\nIt seems to me that probably the first thing\non the agenda, because it certainly would play\nDo we\n19\nhave a problem with the privilege log? And if\nso, what's the problem and what is there to\ncorrect it? So, why don't we begin with that.\nBefore we get underway with\nMR. SCAROLA:\nthat specific business. On the record, I want\n20\n21\n22\n23\nto renew our request to a stipulation that you\nbe appointed as Special Master in the State\n24\n25\nCourt proceedings.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Response?\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 3\nEFTA00621490\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "MR. KNIGHT: At this time, let's see where\nall this goes. We haven't brought that under\nconsideration with our client. We need to speak\nwith him.\nMR. SCAROLA: Well, that request has been\nmade repeatedly over an extended period of time\nand I think it is clearly an indication of the\nbad faith of Mr. Epstein that has been\n--\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Actually, I believe\nthat plaintiff had actually written a letter and\nagreed to that quite sometime ago. That was\nactually in one of the responses I think by Mr.\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nat a later time.\nAckerman.\nMR. KNIGHT: Well, obviously, we've had\nthese requests out since last July. They are\nproperly before Judge Rey and properly before.\nyou at this point. It is not a decision that we\nneed to make today. We believe we have good\ngrounds on these TIG objections. It is close to\nwhat should have been accomplished over the last\nsix, seven, eight months now. And so, we note\nMr. Scarola's comment for the record.\nWe want to address the two issues that are\nhere today and we can address those other issues\nPage 4\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621491\n", "char_count": 1154}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "MR. SCAROLA: And it is our position that\nthose issues cannot be properly addressed unless\nand until there is a State Court ruling with\nregard to the discoverability of the information.\nthat has been requested which appropriately must\nproceed any requirement that a privilege log of\nany kind be submitted.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: What I would\nviewing the determination of or the\npresentation of me as a Special Master in the\nState Court can be divided up into either\ninitially yes, no. If the answer is yes, we\nstill don't have duties yet within the State\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\nsuggest,\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\nRey.\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nCourt.\nUltimately, it seems to me that probably\nthe issue at this point, I don't think anyone.\nlooking back on Mr. Ackerman's letter. I\nthink that the letter had pretty much indicated\na copy of this would certainly go to Judge\nActually, I believe that part of the\ndecision-making process in that letter was to\nJudge Rey or, excuse me, to Judge Crow.\nI don't think anyone is really disputing\nparticularly that Judge Crow need be involved in\nsome fashion or another because he is the\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 5\nEFTA00621492\n", "char_count": 1174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\npresiding judge over the case.\nAnd so, these are things that historically\nthere have been agreements, but we're not\nnecessarily seeing fruition on the agreements.\nWe get an agreement and that seems to be kind of\nthe last we hear of it.\nBut\nnot necessarily sure that I agree\nwith what Mr. Scarola did. Right now we have to\nhave a resolution as to what role Judge Crow\nwould take vis-a-vis this matter as opposed to\nJudge Rey. But it seems to me it's easy enough\nto at least get to a stipulation that at least.\nboth are in play somewhat. It seems to me it's\npretty hard to determine that Judge Crow isn't\nin play if he's the presiding judge.\nMR. KNIGHT: We just don't like creating\ndelay by that for Judge Rey of which I think the\ndifferent machinations that come from this\nproceeding that's been --\n20\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nnot saying any\n21\ndelay\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMR. KNIGHT: We're not saying you are. If\nwe entered into that stipulation now, I think we\nwould do it right before Judge Crow, we would\nlose any momentum that we have right now for\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 6\nEFTA00621493\n", "char_count": 1147}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\nJudge Rey. We want to get on to the actual\nissues, the same ones we've been asking for.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: I agree completely\nagain, not necessarily sure\non that. But\nthat we have a particular problem. The reason\n6\n7\n8\nsaying that is when this went in front of\nJudge Crow, Judge Crow, basically, washed his\nhands of it and said it's in front of the\n9\nBankruptcy Court. Let the Bankruptcy Court\n10\n11\ndecide it. It looks like that's exactly what's\ngoing to happen.\n12\nThe only issue that\nseeing right now\n13\n14\n15\nwith respect to Judge Crow is there aught to\nbe something in there that Judge Crow ratifies\nwhat the Bankruptcy Court judge does. Otherwise,\n16\nwe're left hanging in the wind.\nWhatever\n17\nhappens here is not binding at all on the State\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nCourt judge. The State Court judge can do\nwhatever he wants.\nMR. SCAROLA: Respectfully, and maybe we're\nsaying the same thing but in different ways,\nJudge Crow expressly ruled that he will make a\ndetermination as to what is discoverable in the\nState Court proceedings; that he deferred to\nJudge Rey for purposes of Judge Rey determining\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 7\nEFTA00621494\n", "char_count": 1182}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "1\nanything that was pending in the Bankruptcy\n2\n3\n57\n4\nCourt without that having any binding impact\nupon his decisions with regard to what is\ndiscoverable in the State Court.\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\nThe representations were made to Judge Crow\nat the time that he made that ruling that there\nwas an independent basis upon which the\ndiscovery was being sought in the Bankruptcy\nCourt, that is, that it was not only a State\nCourt subpoena that was issued to the Trustee,\nbut that there were independent discovery\nrequests that were made in the bankruptcy\nproceeding upon which Judge Rey was proceeding.\nNow, I don't believe that to have been\naccurate, but those are the representations that\nwere made to Judge Crow. And on that basis,\nJudge Crow said Judge Rey can do whatever he\nwants to but I, Judge Crow, am deciding what is\ndiscoverable in my case. That's where that\nstands.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Which I think he\n22\n23\nabsolutely has the authority to do. I have\nindicated from the very outset, because it is a\n25\n22\n24\nState Court action and the final arbiter of that\nState Court action is Judge Crow, the one who is\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 8\nEFTA00621495\n", "char_count": 1200}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\nreally the best one to resolve this in my view\nis and always has been Judge Crow.\nJudge Rey is doing it. Judge Crow has\nPage 9\n4\ndeferred to Judge Rey. All\ninterested in\n5\ndoing right now is putting Judge Crow in the\n6\nloop in a fashion where Judge Crow can agree or\n7\ndisagree with whatever my findings are as a\n8\nMaster.\n9\nNow, unless and until\nappointed as a\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n24\n22\n23\n25\nMaster in the State Court, he can't do that.\nAnd as I say, that leaves us hanging in the wind\nat that point. I don't think he can on his own\nsimply sua sponte say,\nadopting the findings.\nof the Special Master. I think that would\ncreate all kinds of appellate issues if we did\nthat.\nMR. SCAROLA: Nor do I think that the\nplaintiff should be in the position of waiting\nto see what your rulings are and then deciding\nwhether the plaintiff wishes to stipulate to\nthose rulings as a recommendation in the State.\nCourt.\nThe time to make that decision is now. And\nif they don't choose to make it, they don't\nchoose to make it. But I want the record to be\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621496\n", "char_count": 1117}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\nabsolutely clear that we are offering to allow\nyour rulings to be binding as rulings of the\nSpecial Master in the State Court proceeding as\nwell as the Bankruptcy Court proceeding. We're\nwilling to go so far as to --\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Let me backup for\nPage 10\n6\n7\njust a second, because it's the \"binding\" that's\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nthe word that's causing a little bit of a\nproblem for me.\nMR. SCAROLA: I understand and I was about\nto address that.\n(Telephone Rings)\n(WHEREUPON, an off-the-record discussion\nwas had).\nMR. SCAROLA: The stipulation that we are\noffering is that you serve as Special Master\nin the State Court. We go beyond that and we\nwill agree that we will waive any appellate\nrights that we might have, including appellate\nrights to the Circuit Court judge, and allow\nyour rulings to be binding within the State\nCourt proceeding. They can accept all or any\nportion of that stipulation or reject it in its\nentirety.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nnot necessarily\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621497\n", "char_count": 1067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "1\n2\nsure\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\nunderstanding precisely which way\nyou're going. What\nunderstanding the role\nis and where I see the problem right now,\nordinarily, once I make my various findings and\nrecommendations, I submit them to the judge who\ncan give them a thumbs up or a thumbs down.\nThe judge, generally, in the absence of an\nobjection is pretty much bound by what I do.\nIf we have an objection, the court, of course,\nrules on the objection.\nThe difficulty that\nseeing right now is,\nat the moment we're only going to Judge Rey,\nwhich means that\nAnd Judge Crow has said, I\ndon't care what Judge Rey does. It's my\ndecision. We end up with that problem right\nthere. If we put Judge Crow in the loop, we\nstill have a problem and the problem --\n(Telephone Rings)\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nvery much. And\nsorry that I've disrupted\n(WHEREUPON, Martin Weinberger joins the\nproceeding already in-progress via\nteleconference):\nMR. WEINBERGER: Hello?\nMR. ACKERMAN: We're here, Marty.\nMR. WEINBERGER: Good morning. Thank you\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 11\nEFTA00621498\n", "char_count": 1092}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nanything by not calling in earlier.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Do you want to go\naround the table so he knows who is here?\nMR. ACKERMAN: Yes. Joe Ackerman is here,\nMarty.\nMR. WEINBERGER: Good morning, Joe.\nMR. KNIGHT: Chris Knight.\nMR. WEINBERGER: Hi, Chris.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Hi, Marty. Lilly Sanchez.\nMR. WEINBERGER: Hi, Lilly.\nMR. SCAROLA: Jack Scarola and Bradley\nEdwards.\nMR. WEINBERGER: Good morning to you both.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: And Robert Carney.\nMR. EDWARDS: Hi.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: As I had mentioned,\nthe problem that\nseeing if we have simply\nboth judges copied, as long as we have both the\njudges making rulings, we have the possibility\nof inconsistent rulings. Therein, we have a\nproblem.\nThe solution I think, ultimately, is because\nit is a Judge Crow case and it's being handled\nin State Court and it's a pure State Court\naction, ideally, is to have the Special Master\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 12\nEFTA00621499\n", "char_count": 1010}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n24\n25\n25\nappointed in the State Court and then have Judge\nCrow actually be the one ruling on the\nobjections, if there are any objections, but\nhave the report go back with a copy to Judge\nRey.\nNow, any issues that are exclusively Judge\nRey issues for which Judge Crow would have no\ninterest in would be in front of Judge Rey. But\nwhere there are State Court issues for which\nJudge Crow would ultimately make the final\ndecision as to admissibility in court, as to\ndiscoverability, as to whatever, it seems to me\nthe obvious choice is to have Judge Crow rule on\nthose and not be in a position of a potentially\ndueling judges' orders.\nMR. KNIGHT: I understand what you've said,\nand I'll fill Marty in more on the part he\nmissed. We'll get back to that.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Let's take a look at\nthe privilege log right now. We can come\nMR. SCAROLA: Let me just make sure that my\nposition is clear. I agree with everything that\nyou have said. Obviously, you can only be\nappointed as Special Master in the State Court\nproceeding upon stipulation of the parties.\nPage 13\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621500\n", "char_count": 1180}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "1\n2\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: I agree.\nActually,\nand by order of the court. It's still going to\n3\ntake a court order.\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\nMR. SCAROLA: Well, yes and no.\nYes, it\nwould take a court order for you to be appointed\nas Special Master to follow the proceedings that\nwe have described. The parties are also free to\nagree to arbitrate these issues\n--\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Oh, absolutely.\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMR. SCAROLA:\n--\nto make your decision a\nbinding arbitration decision with regard to the\ndiscovery of these documents. We are offering\nto do both. We are offering to have you\nappointed as Special Master in the State Court\nand to follow the proceedings that ordinarily\nare followed with regard to a Special Master's\nappointment where you report to the court.\nThere is a possibility for objections being\nmade. The court rules on those objections.\nAccepts, rejects or modifies the report of the\nSpecial Master. We agree to that procedure.\nWe also go a step further. We are willing\nto allow all of these discovery issues to be\nresolved by binding arbitration. To have you as\nSpecial Master become the arbiter, the final\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 14\nEFTA00621501\n", "char_count": 1208}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\narbiter of these discovery issues.\nIf the plaintiff is, in fact, interested in\nthe expedited resolution of these issues, the\nfastest way to get them resolved is to agree to\nthat procedure. I don't think they've ever been\ninterested in that.\nTheir rejection of our proposal that you be\nSpecial Master in the State Court proceedings\nindicates they have no real interest in that.\nTheir refusal to agree to have these issues\narbitrated by you is a further indication that\nthey have no interest in that.\nThis is an abuse of process from beginning\nto end and all of these discovery proceedings\nare part of that abuse of the court's process.\nThat's our position. Let them do with it\nwhat they want, but I want to be sure that this\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\nsure that\n21\n22\n23\n24\nAnd the reason\n25\nlooking at it from the point of view of\nrecord reflects what we are willing to do.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: I am not necessarily\nagreeing one hundred percent with\nyour analysis. I think, even if the parties\nstipulate, for me to be a binding arbiter would\nstill require a court order.\nsaying that is, because\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 15\nEFTA00621502\n", "char_count": 1180}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Page 16\n1\n2\nJudge Crow. If I were Judge Crow, the question\nis: Would I want somebody making decisions for\n3\n4\nwhere\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nme that go up on appeal with my name on them\nno part of the decision at all?\nnot necessarily sure that I would agree to\nthat.\nMR. SCAROLA: There would be no appeal. If\nit's binding arbitration, there is no appeal.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Well, ultimately,\nonce the case goes up to the appellate court,\nlet's assume just for the sake of argument that\nI make a ruling and I goof in my ruling. The\nquestion is: It eliminates from Judge Crow any\nability to correct it.\nUltimately, when it goes up on appeal he's\nthe one who's appealed, not me. That's why\nviewing where in Judge Crow's position,\nwhether it's binding arbitration or Special\nMaster, I would like to sign-off on the order.\nMR. KNIGHT: Judge Carney, I heard Mr.\nScarola the first time. I heard him the second\ntime. I heard him the third time. The abuse of\nprocess here, we still haven't been able to get\na proper privilege log since August. We want\nto move forward on that. We understand his\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621503\n", "char_count": 1174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Page 17\n1\nissues and where he wants to go. I don't think\n2\narbitration is something we've even discussed,\n3\n4\n50\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\nso we will consider that.\nAlthough, I think there is a bunch of\nproblems that will come with that relative to\nappellate rights, et cetera, that would be\nbefore Judge Crow because we can't appeal your\nruling to the 4th. We can appeal Judge Crow's.\nI don't want to get into that. I actually\nwant to get into the merits of what this hearing\nis supposed to be today and not this smokescreen\nthat's being pushed on us, because there are\nsignificant deficiencies in this TIG privilege\nlog that we need to discuss. They're very\nimportant. It can put us in a position where at\nthis point we'll need to start reviewing the\ndocuments.\n18\nMR. SCAROLA:\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nLet's get at it.\nMR. KNIGHT: So we need to get into it.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Just before we go.\nUltimately and I do understand the defense\nposition because this has been on the table in\nthe past, apparently, agreed to by the\nplaintiff the position is in the absence of\nfollowing through on the agreement, it's\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621504\n", "char_count": 1170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n60\n7\n8\n9\nultimately waiting to see what the ruling is\nhere. And if you like the ruling, you agree to\nit.\nAnd if you don't like the ruling, you don't\nagree to it.\nAs I say, there is some merits to the\nposition that probably aught be resolved before\nthe court makes a particular ruling, but I can't\ncompel resolution one way or the other. What I\nam advising is, without a resolution of getting\nin front of Judge Crow, all we're doing at this\npoint is spinning our wheels.\nAs I say, it's a State Court action and\nJudge Crow has already said,\nnot bound by\nwhatever the bankruptcy judge does. In the\nabsence of an agreement, this cannot be placed\nin front of Judge Crow as a fait accompli.\nSo, I see really compelling reasons, legal\nreasons to go at least part way with what Mr.\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\nlog.\n25\nMR. ACKERMAN:\nYour Honor, I would like to\nScarola is saying. I see only upside and no\ndownside. To do it without it, I see only\ndownside and no upside.\nAt any rate, having said that, let's\nproceed. Let's start I guess with the privilege\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 18\nEFTA00621505\n", "char_count": 1133}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\njust add a couple of things before we proceed.\nFirst of all, this matter has been brought up\nwithout being properly noticed.\nJudge Crow has entered a case management\norder, which this is one of the items we have to\ndiscuss. It's not as simple as Mr. Scarola puts\nit, because there are issues as we've argued\nbefore that Judge Rey has jurisdiction over,\nincluding the order that we're here for now.\nThat has to be addressed now because of the\noutstanding nature of the orders relating to the\nprivilege log.\nWe have other subpoenas that are going to go\nto the Trustee. The Trustee is under the\njurisdiction of a Bankruptcy Court. Mr.\nScarola, with all due respect, is inaccurate in\nrelating what I said because, initially, when\nthese matters came before Judge Rey there were\nother parties seeking records on adversary\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nthat.\nproceedings.\nBut notwithstanding that, Judge Rey had\nentered an order stating that based on the fact\nthat he had jurisdiction over the property of\nR.R.A.'s records that he has jurisdiction over\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 19\nEFTA00621506\n", "char_count": 1141}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "point in time the matter goes to Judge Rey. And\nI believe that's the time to address these\nPage 20\n1\n2\nAt this point in time we're asking the\ncourt to rule on these two matters, asking the\n3\ncourt to enter a recommendation and at that\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n25\nissues, but it can't be done with a simple\nstipulation because there are other issues that\nhave to be addressed for future subpoenas and\nwhether or not you're going to be appointed on\nanything beside that. That's something that we\nhaven't discussed or resolved, and I say that\nwith all due respect to Your Honor.\nBut right now, your appointment is for these\ndocuments and this subpoena. I believe that\nin order to accomplish what Mr. Scarola is\nsaying or accomplish, rather, what Judge Crow is\nsaying for a review, ultimately, on the issues\nthat have to come before him, those issues have\nto be taken into consideration.\nThey can't be done today. They haven't been\nable to be done before because we haven't\naddressed them. I think the appropriate time\nis to do it as part of the case management and\nnot today.\nMR. SCAROLA:\nreally not sure what Mr.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621507\n", "char_count": 1197}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "1\nAckerman just said, but if what he has said is\nPage 21\n2\nhe doesn't want to proceed today, he wants to\n3\n4\n5\nsaying.\nwait and let Judge Crow do this\nMR. ACKERMAN: No, that's not what\ntalking about your suggestion\nMR. SCAROLA: This matter has not been\nproperly noticed.\nMR. KNIGHT:\njust brought up.\nWhat is the matter --\nHe's talking about what you\nMR. SCAROLA: What is the matter that has\nnot been properly noticed?\nMR. ACKERMAN: What you started this\nconversation with today, that's what\ntalking\nabout. Your request for a stipulation, that's\nnot before us today.\n10\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\ninto a stipulation.\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMR. SCAROLA: Well, I don't know what\nprocedure must be followed to offer to enter\nnot aware that I've got.\nto file some written document or give some\nperiod of time, notice in advance of raising\nthat issue. I have offered this stipulation\nrepeatedly. It has repeatedly been accepted\ninformally and then rejected. No confirmation\nhas ever been made.\nI understand that it's been rejected today.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621508\n", "char_count": 1089}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n50\n10\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nThat's fine. I want it to be clear on the\nrecord that that continues to be our position.\nIt will always continue to be our position. I\nalways expect that we will get nothing but delay.\nfrom the other side. That's okay, too.\nSo, if the matter that has not been properly\nnoticed is our offer of a stipulation, I don't\nknow what that means, let's get on with\nwhatever Mr. Ackerman believes has been properly\nnoticed.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Let's go back to the\nprivilege log at this point and the complaints\nwith the privilege log. Let's see if we have an\nissue with the privilege log. And if we do,\nwhat it is and what needs to be done.\nMR. ACKERMAN: Your Honor, we filed an\nextensive memorandum that summarizes, first, the\nrequirements of a privilege log and where,\nspecifically, the privilege log is deficient.\nWhile we're on the subject of delay, a proper,\nlegally sufficient privilege log was due on\nJanuary 31st. One was not presented. It\nwas, basically, a privilege log that listed\nseveral thousand documents with one entry to\napply to all of them.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 22\nEFTA00621509\n", "char_count": 1182}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "We were before Your Honor again on February\nPage 23\n1\n2\n16th. Mr. Edwards, Mr. Farmer and\n3\nwere\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n25\ngiven the opportunity to prepare a second\nprivilege log that would comply with the TIG\nrequirements. We received that second privilege\nlog, and that's the one we're here before Your\nHonor.\nThe case law is abundantly clear that in\norder for a party that seeks documents claimed\nto be privileged, they must receive a log that\nis complete, adequate and defines the\nrelationship of the parties so that they can.\ndetermine whether a valid privilege has been\nasserted.\nIn this case throughout the entire log there\nis no identification of the parties or their\ncapacities, so we cannot determine whether or\nnot they're a part of Mr. Edwards' law firm or\nwhether they're outside it. And I believe the\ncourt had even at one point thrown a suggestion\nout there to prepare some sort of master list\nto identify that.\nAnd while we may not have stated that\nthat would have complied with the cases, the\nfact is, they have done nothing after being\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621510\n", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "given two opportunities to prepare a privilege\nUnder the cases that we've cited,\nparticularly, the TIG case and the Century case,\nthe court is entitled if it finds it\nappropriate, which we're asking it to do, to\ndetermine a waiver.\nWhat I would like to do is go through the\nspecifics of it. The privilege must\nprovide sufficient information to enable the\nparties to evaluate the applicability of the\nclaimed privilege.\n1\n2\nlog.\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n23\n24\n25\nWith regard to the attorney-client\nprivilege, we listed the elements that have to\nbe shown. We have to be able to see who the\nholder is. There is absolutely no\nidentification as to which client they are\nclaiming the privilege for.\nWe have to determine whether the person to\nwhom the communi\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Don't we only have a\nsingle client in this case?\nMR. ACKERMAN: No. They have made the claim\nof privilege on behalf of three, three potential\nvictims.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 24\nEFTA00621511\n", "char_count": 1016}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Okay.\nMR. ACKERMAN: And now there are two\nadditional claims that they're making that I\nsuspect they're going to claim at least a\nwork-product privilege on.\nSo, we cannot identify whether the privilege\nhas been appropriately invoked, because they\nhaven't identified 1 of 5 possible clients\nthat could be the holder of the privilege.\nThere has to be an identification if that\nperson to whom the communication is made is a\nmember of the Bar or their subordinate. We\ncannot tell that from the privilege log. We\nhave to know that it was, in fact, in connection\nwith the rendering of legal services, it wasn't\ndone in the presence of other outside strangers.\nAs far as this privilege log is concerned,\nas it relates to the attorney-client privilege,\nsince we do not have any capacities described in\nterms of the client, we do not know what the\n--\nspecific purpose They can state the general\npurpose without describing it and revealing any\nconfidentiality. We cannot know what their role.\nis in relationship to the confidentiality in\norder for them to establish an attorney-client\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 25\nEFTA00621512\n", "char_count": 1222}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "1\nprivilege.\n2\n3\n4\n5\n10\n6\n17\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nWith regard to the work-product privilege,\nthat privilege is divided into two parts. It's\na fact work-product privilege, which relates to\ninformation obtained during and in anticipation\nof litigation.\nAnd then there is the privilege that relates\nto the attorney's mental thoughts and\nimpressions. Under almost all circumstances,\nthe thoughts and impressions of a lawyer are\ncompletely privileged as work-product.\nUnder certain circumstances, upon the\ndemonstration of need and upon the demonstration\nof inability to obtain facts from other sources,\nfact work-product can be obtained from the party\nrequesting the information.\nIn this instance there is no effort\nwhatsoever to determine or to state whether the\nprivilege claimed to be work-product is fact or\nsorry. Fact, work-product or\nwork-product.\nopinion work-product.\nNow, I've given the court the cases in\nthere. The case law requires particularized\nfindings in support of your determination as to\nwhether or not they are fact or opinion\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 26\nEFTA00621513\n", "char_count": 1134}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nwork-product. You're not going to be able to do\nthat nor are we going to be able to make a\nclaim unless that distinction is made.\nWe also, respectfully, direct your attention\nto the sheer number of people identified who\nreceived e-mails from Edwards where no objection\nis made on the basis of joint defense but only\nwork-product. They haven't established that\nthose people are within the litigation team or\nthe people that are entitled to receive the\nwork-product.\nBecause if he sends information out to third\nparties that aren't part of his team, we're able\nto argue that that's a waiver of the\nwork-product privilege without knowing their\ncapacity, without knowing the fact that they're\npart of the litigation team. There is at least\nover 20 of those where he's failed to establish\nwho they are.\nIn the pooled joint defense or common\nlitigation interests there are predicates for\nestablishing that. There may be attorneys on\nthere where he's claimed joint defense\nprivilege, although there is no claim of\ndefense against the plaintiffs that's being\nPage 27\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621514\n", "char_count": 1176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nmade, but there's a predicate that needs to be\nestablished as to who the person is, what the\npurpose of the joint litigation or common\ninterest was to be, and that case is requiring\nmatters cited and there is no effort at all to\nbreak those up.\nIn general, because the document is\ndiscussed among participants or transferred\namong participants in a joint common interest\nagreement, it doesn't make it work-product if\nit's not privileged to begin with.\nFor example, there are communications\nrelating to conversations with U.S. Attorneys\nand FBI Agents which under no circumstances\nhave any privity with the joint defense. So\npassing it on, particularly coming from them to\nthese agents, certainly is not a work-product\nprivilege.\nThere has to be an establishment,\nparticularly in the instance where they have\nidentified U.S. Attorneys and FBI Agents, as to\nhow that is any type of privilege, because the\ngovernment does not participate in nor can they\nas a party in a civil proceeding absent a notice\nof being filed and particularly in these cases.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 28\nEFTA00621515\n", "char_count": 1173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n10\n6\n7\n8\n6\nThey have listed confidential informants.\nPage 29\nNow, the case law that we've cited allows the\ngovernment to withhold a confidential\ninformant's identity at least for a certain\nperiod of time. But if that confidential\ninformant has material evidence relevant to the\ndefense of the case then a defendant can get it.\nThere are no cases at all establishing a\nconfidential informant privilege in the civil\narena. There is no comparable purpose to be\nserved and there is no legal basis for claiming\nthat type of privilege.\nHere, the defendants don't claim an\ninformant privilege, which is the one that\nexists in the criminal area, but they claim the\nprivilege of a confidential source. There is no\ncase law at all that indicates that that is a\nlegal privilege under Florida law, under the\nFlorida Evidence Code that deals with privilege.\nAnd just because someone is named a source\ndoesn't make communications from that person to\nthe lawyer privileged or any documents that are\ntransmitted in that fashion.\nSo unless this confidential source is\nidentified to be a lawyer or an investigator\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n25\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621516\n", "char_count": 1208}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n25\nthat's part of Mr. Edwards' litigation team then\nthose are facial waivers of the work-product or\nany other privilege that's claimed, because they\nare clearly third parties. And the lack of\nidentification of those people clearly makes\nthose impossible for us to tell. And if they\nare claiming them to be, for example, in the\ncase of the FBI Agents or the U.S. Attorney,\nthose are clearly third parties.\nThere is also a claim for privilege based on\nprotective privacy rights. They haven't\nidentified any specific privacy right or\ndescribed the person whose privacy interests are\nat stake. They haven't identified any of the\npeople that are claiming the privilege in other\naspects as well. But here, there can be no\nvalid privilege raised to protect a generic\nprivacy right.\nUnder Section 90.501 of the Florida\nStatutes it lists the privileges that apply.\nAbsent the establishment of those privileges,\nany document that is requested should be\nproduced.\nI just want to add one thing that was\nbrought up earlier. Mr. Scarola has argued that\nPage 30\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621517\n", "char_count": 1164}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "1\nthere has been no determination on the relevancy\nPage 31\n2\n3\nof this subpoena. I submit to you, in prior\nmemorandums this issue has already been\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\naddressed and you mentioned it at the last\nhearing.\nWhen this subpoena went out to the U.S.\nTrustee in April, Mr. Scarola asked for copies.\nThere was no objection made at that time at the\ntime the subpoena was sent out. So, it's our\nposition the issues of relevancy are not\nproperly before you on this proceeding.\nBut with regard to the privacy, there is no\nreason there is no case law that extends the\nright of privacy to the issues that are set\nforth here. They haven't claimed why it's\nprivate. They haven't claimed who's stating\nit's private. And we contend that those are\nfacial waivers to the extent documents rely only\non the privacy right.\nNow, we've argued and I've given the court a\nlengthy list of cases that it settled that the\nfailure to supply an adequate privilege log\n23\nresults in a waiver of the privilege under\n24\n25\nFlorida or Federal law. There is a specific\ncase that I cited, Century Business Credit Corp.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621518\n", "char_count": 1178}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Page 32\n1\nIt's in the brief and I have a copy of it.\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nIn that case the 4th District allowed a\nwaiver to be found because the log was not only\nmonths late, but also completely inadequate.\nThe citation for that in my brief and for the\nrecord is: Century Business Credit\nCorporation vs. Fitness Innovations and\nTechnology, 906 So.2d, 1156, Florida 4th DCA,\n2005.\nAs I've indicated to you before, Mr.\nEdwards, Farmer & Jaffe and\nhave had the\nopportunity for the last, you know, from the\ntime the initial orders and documents were\nprovided, and certainly by January 31st, to\nprepare an adequate log.\nWe are now six weeks beyond that and still\ndo not have a log that allows us to identify\nmeaningful objections with sufficient detail to\ncomply with the requirements of Florida Rules of\nCivil Procedure 1.280, as well as the TIG case\nand the Century Business case so that we can\nmake appropriate objections on this.\nAs a result of this we're asking the court\nthat, because no less than four orders directing\nEdwards, et al. to prepare this privilege log\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621519\n", "char_count": 1161}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "do not remotely meet the TIG requirements, we're\nasking the court to enter a finding that the\nPage 33\n1\nhave been complied with and since the last two\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\nprivileges have been waived.\nYour Honor, on Page 83, if you need to see\nthe log.\nMR. KNIGHT: These are just some examples.\nMR. ACKERMAN: To give you an example, if\nyou look at Page 83, it says Brad to source. It\ndoesn't say who the source is. It's claimed\nwithin the work-product privilege. We need to\nhave the identity to know if there is a waiver.\nIf you go to Page 85, you have Brad to\nR.R.A.. We don't know who the attorney is,\nwhether it's Rothstein, whether it's someone in\nthe firm based on the investment team that was\nattempting to arrange these investments through\nthird parties.\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nOn Page 87 and 138, we have Jenne to\nattorneys in Rothstein's firm. If Rothstein\nWe don't know who that's going to. We've\n--\nThere's a similar problem on Page 86 for\nRothstein on e-mail regarding causes of action.\nWe believe that that would be work-product only\nif it relates to a pre-existing client.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621520\n", "char_count": 1158}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "established in deposition that Mr. Jenne brought\n1\n2\nboxes of the\n3\n4\n10\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nfile to at least two\nindividuals who were interested in investing in\nMr. Rothstein's ponzi scheme.\nIf Mr. Jenne is sending the e-mail to\nRothstein, without knowing what the subject\nmatter is, it could be related to the scheme or\nit could be to Mr. Edwards relating to the case\nor the scheme.\nPage 100, there's a listing for Coffey. If\nhe's not an attorney for R.R.A. and he's not in\nthe firm, then there may be a waiver of the\nprivilege.\nWe have Page 136 where there's an e-mail or\na letter from Brad to R.R.A. relating to\nClinton. We don't know which client that is.\nWe believe that part of the scheme to entrap\ninvestors to this ponzi scheme was to subpoena\npeople like Bill Clinton and Donald Trump. And\nthere is testimony from Dean Kretschmar that\ntalks about a log book of people that were on\nMr. Epstein's plane, including Mr. Clinton.\nPage 118, there's a reference to Carl\nLinder. He appears to be involved in the\ntransactions involving the scheme with these\nPage 34\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621521\n", "char_count": 1154}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\noutside investors, but we don't know who he is,\nand he appears to be receiving e-mails from Brad\nEdwards relating to this case.\nPage 155 shows the FBI as a source. That's\nnot work-product.\nAnd if there is information\ncoming from Brad Edwards to the FBI then that's\na waiver of the work-product privilege.\nThose are some of the examples upon which\nwe're relying. But the court can see by an\nexamination of the log in its entirety there is\nabsolutely no identifying of capacities as to\nwho the people are, there is no identifying as\nto who the client is for whom the work-product\nprivilege, attorney-client privilege, privacy\nprivilege, et cetera, has been claimed.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Response.\nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you, very much. There\nare multiple fundamental defects in the\narguments that have been advanced on behalf of\nMr. Ackerman's child-molester client.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Really?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Let's start at this\npoint by eliminating the characterization of\nclients.\nMR. SCAROLA: Well, that's a matter of\nPage 35\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621522\n", "char_count": 1145}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "molestation.\nPage 36\n1\nestablished record. He's pled guilty to\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: That may be, but it\ndoesn't serve any purpose here.\nMR. SCAROLA: There is no privilege log\nrequired until discoverability is first\ndetermined. Gosman, the 4th DCA case that Your\nHonor has cited repeatedly in communications to\nthe parties, expressly holds that a predicate to\nany requirement for the submission of a\nprivilege log is a determination of\ndiscoverability.\nWhat Mr. Epstein's lawyers have argued is\nthat a subpoena was issued to which no objection\nwas raised at the time of the issuance of the\nsubpoena. Under the unique circumstances of\nthis case, it must be remembered that Mr.\nEdwards had no access to those documents. The\ndocuments were within the possession and control\nof the Trustee.\nMr. Edwards didn't know what the documents\nwere, didn't know what the contents of the\ndocuments were and had every right to wait until\nthe time of the deposition and examine documents\non a document-by-document basis and raise his\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621523\n", "char_count": 1133}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\nobjection to discoverability when the documents\nwere in front of him. He had no ability to\nassert objections in advance of having access to\nthe documents.\nOnce he obtained access to the documents,\nclearly, he has persistently and consistently\nobjected to the scope of the discovery sought.\nHe has argued that much of the discovery sought\nis impermissible, beyond the scope of\nappropriate discovery for many reasons before we\never get to privilege issues.\nIt is our position that while we have\ncomplied with the Bankruptcy Court's direction.\nto prepare a privilege log, the direction to\nprepare a privilege log is at odds with state\nlaw as expressly set out in the Gosman case by\nthe 4th District Court of Appeals.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Let me pause here\nfor a second, because I have a couple of\nquestions. I think an argument can be made that\nMr. Edwards had several choices: He could make\nan objection that it's overbroad, in which case\nI would agree with you. If there was an\nobjection overbroad, that stops everything until\nthat objection is ruled on. Or, he can make a\nPage 37\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621524\n", "char_count": 1199}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\nrequest for a protective order claiming\nattorney-client privilege, a separate request.\nThe law actually is gray with the protective\norder. There is a series of cases that say\nthey, too, also have to be resolved prior to\nproceeding forward. But there's some case law\nthat also indicates as long as only privilege is\nraised then it may require the necessity of the\nprivilege log. And that's the issue that\n10\nlooking at right now, because\nnot aware\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nthat Mr. Edwards made an overbroad objection.\n-\nIt's my understanding that because I\nwould agree totally, that stops it it's a\nprivilege log objection. As I say, a privilege\nlog is gray. Excuse me, a protective order is\ngray.\nUnder the Evidence Code, and I've examined\nthat very carefully, the cases go in both\ndirections. They're all over the place on that.\nBut as long as the only thing that is being\nraised, if it is not an overbreadth objection,\nas long as it is only being raised that it's\nattorney-client work-product then\nnot sure\nthere is a good way to resolve it without a\nprivilege log.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 38\nEFTA00621525\n", "char_count": 1166}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\nMR. SCAROLA: The point that attempting\nto make here is that the cases that address this\nissue address it in circumstances where the\nobjecting party has possession, custody or\ncontrol of the documents.\nHe knows what the\ndocuments are. He can look at them and he can\ndecide which of them are subject to relevancy\nand materiality objections, which of them impose\nan undue burden, which of them may be\nprivileged, and he can focus his objections\nbased upon a knowledge of the documents\nthemselves.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: And\nnot in\ndisagreement with that. But if we track a\nlittle of the history of this, the way this came\nabout, originally, Judge Rey entered an order.\nAt least in my view the order was just patently\ndefective on its face. The order had directed\nme to produce a privilege log. There were a\nvariety of issues with the order.\nI had made a request to Judge Rey that we\nneed to clarify that order and we need to modify\nthat order. We've got problems with it. Judge\n21\n22\n23\n24\nRey agreed. A second order was entered.\nUnder\n25\nthe terms of the second order, which is\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 39\nEFTA00621526\n", "char_count": 1186}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\nrelatively in line with what we're doing right\nnow because there was still a third order, but\nat this point documents were produced to the\ndefense.\nNow, we ended up with another problem. The\ndocuments that the Trustee gave to the defense\nwere not the same documents that the Trustee\nnecessarily gave to the Special Master. Some of\nthe documents that were given to the defense\nwere corrupted and not able to be read. That\ncaused still another delay, actually, not\noccasioned by the defendant at that point, that\nwas occasioned actually by the Trustee.\nIt was redone. We did a new document based\non entirely what the Special Master got. So\nthat was what we were all traveling under. I\ngave them my copy, they made their copy. But at\nthis point at least, I believe we were in\nOctober, the defendant had the documents.\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\nAnd so what\n21\n22\nmay not be able to make a good objection until\nhe has the documents and sees what the documents\n23\nare, then,\n24\n25\n25\nwith you on that.\nNevertheless, there was not an objection\nviewing, if I accept that he\nnot necessarily sure I disagree\nPage 40\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621527\n", "char_count": 1182}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "1\nraised on overbreadth.\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\nThe overbreadth\nobjection under the case law normally stops the\nprivilege log, but a protective order based\nexclusively on attorney-client privilege may\nnot. That, again, case law goes both ways on\nthat issue.\nMR. SCAROLA: I understand that concern.\nBut what has consistently been overlooked is\nthe fact that this entire proceeding in the\nBankruptcy Court was an attempted end around\nobjections that had already been filed.\nThe first effort to obtain these documents\nwas a production request directed to Mr. Edwards\nin the State Court proceeding to which we filed\nrelevancy objections, overbreadth objections and\na variety of other objections.\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nnot sure I can\nbootstrap that onto this. I think each request\nultimately requires its objection. As I say,\nsomewhat of the view at this point this one\nis gray, because there was not a direct\noverbreadth objection that was filed on this.\nI think certainly at some point that objection\nhas to be raised or waived.\nUnder the rules it would have been raised\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 41\nEFTA00621528\n", "char_count": 1169}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\nwithin 10 days or 30 days, I've forgotten\nexactly which, from the issuance of the subpoena\nor from the notice of the subpoena. But again,\naccepting that he doesn't have the documents and\ndoesn't know what's in the documents at this\n6\npoint, what they are, again,\nnot sure\n7\nquite as troubled by that.\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\nBut as I say, we still get to the question:\nHow does he object to it? Because the objection\nwas only a privilege objection. I think there\nis a pretty fair argument that could be made at\nthat point that it waives the overbreadth\nobjection and what we're left with is a\nprivilege objection, which would require a\nprivilege log.\nMR. SCAROLA: I have multiple responses for\nthat. The first is that, Gosman tells us how we\n18\ndeal with circumstances where we're in gray\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n24\n25\nareas. And what Gosman explicitly holds is\nthat an implied waiver of privilege is not\nfavored in Florida law.\nThere must be an\nexpressed waiver. There, clearly, has been\nno expressed waiver under these circumstances.\nBut let's move on from procedure to\nsubstance, if we could. This is not a\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 42\nEFTA00621529\n", "char_count": 1177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\ncircumstance where an adverse party seeking\ndiscovery makes the determination of the\nappropriateness of a privilege objection. That\ndetermination is to be made initially by you and\nsubsequently by whichever judge or judges have\nto make that determination.\nThe issue has got to be: Have you been\nprovided with sufficient information in order to\nmake those determinations?\nT-I-G addresses the situation where a\nprivilege log is provided in lieu of the\nproduction of documents. The situation we have\nhere is one where we have turned over the\ndocuments themselves for in-camera inspection.\nThey're available to you. You can look at them.\nWe have told you to turn over anything and\neverything that you think is relevant, material,\nnot privileged by attorney-client privilege, not\nwork-product. Give it to them.\nYou don't need a privilege log where the\ndocument is described, because you have the\ndocument. You don't need a privilege log that\ntells you who the author of the document was,\nbecause you have the document and it identifies\nwho the author was. You don't need a privilege\nPage 43\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621530\n", "char_count": 1203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n60\n7\n8\n6\nPage 44\nlog that tells you to whom the documents were\ndirected, because the documents tell you to whom\nthey were directed.\nEvery inadequacy that they have described in\nthe privilege log is overcome by the fact that\nwe have voluntarily made the documents\nthemselves available and are prepared to answer\nwhatever questions you may have relating to\nthose documents during the course of an\nin-camera inspection, if you determine that\nthat's what needs to be done.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nnot\n--\nLet me\npause here for a second, because I'm not sure\nyou and I are on the same page on this.\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\nWhat\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nsource.\nunderstanding is, the procedure\nthat seems to be set out as the appropriate\nprocedure on a privilege log issue is: Once the\nprivilege log has been filed, there is a\nhearing. It's not an in-camera inspection at\nthat point. It is a hearing where the other\nside challenges, if they will, the privilege.\nWhat their position is is, they can't challenge\nit without more information.\nFor example, the memo to confidential\nThey can't challenge that without the\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621531\n", "char_count": 1167}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Page 45\n1\ninformation as to whether there would be a\n2\nprivilege or whether that's something that falls\n3\noutside of the privilege, because it's a\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\ndisclosure.\nMR. SCAROLA: We are on the same page,\nbecause I agree with you that the standard\nprocedure is: First, the preliminary\ndetermination as to whether the documents are\ndiscoverable, if not, privileged. Then the\nfiling of a privilege log as to discoverable\nmaterial that is claimed to be privileged.\nThat log identifies documents with\nsufficient particularities so that the parties\nseeking the discovery can challenge the\n15\nassertion of privilege and then an in-camera\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\ninspection to make a determination after the\nchallenge is raised as to whether the challenge\nis or is not valid.\nWhat I am suggesting to you is, we have\nvoluntarily skipped ahead and provided\neverything for an in-camera inspection which we\nwould ordinarily not be obliged to do. And\nbecause we have waived our right to have the\n24\ndefense establish a prima facie showing for an\n25\n25\nin-camera inspection, the inadequacies that they\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621532\n", "char_count": 1159}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nare arguing exists in the privilege log become\nabsolutely irrelevant.\nThe documents are there for a determination\nas to whether any of them are privileged. And\nif there is any questions that arise with the\ndocuments in front of you as to whether they are\nor are not privileged or otherwise discoverable,\nwe're prepared to respond to those questions.\nWe have met our obligation by voluntarily\nproducing the documents for in-camera inspection\nwithout putting the parties seeking discovery to\nthe burden of establishing some prima facie\nbasis for the in-camera inspection.\nThat's the whole purpose of the privilege\nlog, so that they have a basis to challenge the\nassertion of privilege and to require that\ncertain documents be inspected in-camera. We've\nwaived it. We've given you everything. I don't\nknow that there is anything more, certainly,\n20\nthat we are obliged to do.\n21\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nJust so we're clear.\n22\n23\n24\nActually, in terms of the Bates Stamp documents,\nI still don't have the Bates Stamp documents.\nI've never had the Bates Stamp documents.\n25\nMR. SCAROLA:\nThey are available. They are\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 46\nEFTA00621533\n", "char_count": 1218}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Page 47\n1\navailable.\nWe've offered them before, we'll\n2\noffer them to you again. Review them.\nWhatever\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n9\nyou think is discoverable, give it to them.\nThat's the bottom line.\nAll of their objections, their T-I-G\nobjections are based upon a procedure that\nsimply does not apply under these\ncircumstances.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Just one moment.\nLet me be sure\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\nunderstanding exactly what\nyou're saying here.\ngoing to use, as an\nexample, the confidential source.\nWhat you're saying is that, out of the\n15,000 statements that are listed here, there\nare various objections that are raised to\nvarious entries. Addressing specifically the\nconfidential source entry, that at this point\nthe next step would be an in-camera inspection\nfor the court to determine whether the\nconfidential source actually meets a privilege\nor not a privilege.\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\nWhat\nunderstanding the reason for an\n23\nin-camera inspection would be, so that there\n24\nwouldn't be a release of the name of the\n25\nconfidential source until such time as the court\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621534\n", "char_count": 1114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\nсл\n5\nmakes that determination.\nMR. SCAROLA: The legal argument has been\nmade that there is no privilege in civil\nlitigation to protect the identity of\nconfidential sources.\ngoing to get to that\nargument. They have cited the cases that\n10\n6\n7\nsupport the fact that confidential source\n8\ninformation is work-product information.\nIt's\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nPage 48\nthe work-product privilege that applies. There\nis no confidential source privilege.\nThere is a\nwork-product privilege that covers the identity\nof persons who are providing information that is\nnot subsequently going to be used at trial.\nIf I may,\ngoing to address that\nissue and I would be happy to\n--\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Okay.\nMR. SCAROLA: Yes, you have the document.\nYou know what the document says. You can make a\ndetermination as to whether it is covered by the\nwork-product privilege or it is not covered by\nthe work-product privilege based upon your\nreview of the document in your in-camera\ninspection of the document.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nBefore we get to\nthat, let's cover a couple of areas right now\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621535\n", "char_count": 1162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "1\nthat are raised by the plaintiff.\nOne,\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\nplaintiff is indicating that there are three\npotential sources who could assert the privilege\nand there aught be some clarification in the\nprivilege log as to which of the sources is\nasserting the privilege.\n7\nMR. SCAROLA: Why?\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nWell, that's a\nMR. SCAROLA: If it is a client of Brad\nEdwards and a claimant against Mr. Epstein, why\nmust Brad Edwards identify to the defense which\nclient it is? Maybe it's a client who hasn't\nyet filed a claim against Mr. Epstein. Why\nshould Mr. Epstein be entitled to know the\nidentity of that person who is asserting an\nattorney-client privilege?\nAnd this brings us to what I think is a very\nimportant and fundamental point here: The\nprivilege belongs to the client; it does not\nbelong to Mr. Edwards, it does not belong to\nR.R.A., it does not belong to the Trustee. Mr.\nEdwards, R.R.A., Mr. Rothstein, the Trustee have\nno ability to waive a privilege that does not\nbelong to them.\nEvery case that has been cited by opposing\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 49\nEFTA00621536\n", "char_count": 1141}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "privilege found for failing to provide an\nadequate privilege log or otherwise comply with\nPage 50\n1\ncounsel where there has been a waiver of\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\nsome discovery obligation, every case has been a\ncase in which the failure was attributable to\nthe client.\nThe discovery is sought from a litigant who\nis the client. The client fails to meet the\nclient's obligation and a waiver is found as a\nconsequence of the client's failure to meet the\nobligation to provide an appropriate log.\nThe privilege belongs to the client. The\nclient can waive the privilege. And failing to\ncomply with discovery obligations, some courts\nhave found in particular circumstances where it\nhas been particularly egregious, constituted a\nwaiver of the client's privilege.\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nclient's privilege. It can't waive\n20\nprivilege. It can't waive the privilege of any\n21\n22\n23\n24\nof the other victims who he represents or has\nrepresented. That privilege belongs to them.\nIn order for there to be a waiver of the\nprivilege, they must be the ones who by their\n25\nactions or inactions or misconduct have waived\nNothing Bradley Edwards does can waive the\n's\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621537\n", "char_count": 1205}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "SPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: That may be a\nargument for a little bit later down the road.\ntrying to focus in on now is\nThe issue that\n1\nthe privilege.\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\na narrow one: Whether we have a problem with\nthe log or whether we don't have a problem with\nthe log.\nMR. SCAROLA: Well, part of the argument\nthat has been made is, because there is a\nproblem with the log there has been a waiver of\nprivilege.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Well, that's what\nthey're suggesting as a sanction at this point.\nnot dealing with that issue\n12\n13\n14\nBut right now,\n15\nat the moment. What\ndealing with is: Do\n16\n17\n18\n19\nwe have a problem with the log at all or do we\nnot have a problem with the log?\nMR. SCAROLA: Obviously, my primary argument\nin that regard is: You have all of the\n20\n21\ninformation that you need to make a\ndetermination with regard to privilege.\nThat's\n22\n23\n24\n25\nthe purpose of a privilege log, that's the\nthrust of T-I-G; to give an independent finder\nof fact and law the ability to be able to make\nthe determination ultimately.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 51\nEFTA00621538\n", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "asserted to show some prima facie basis to\n1\n2\nThe procedure that is outlined usually\ninvolves a shifting of burden to the party\n3\nseeking discovery after the privilege has been\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\novercome the privilege or to challenge it, and\nthen an in-camera inspection. We've given it to\nyou. Conduct an in-camera inspection. Give\nthem whatever you think may be discoverable.\nThe other objection that they have raised is\nthat we have asserted in our privilege log a\nright to privacy that they contend does not\nexist. The point in their memo is, there is no\nright of privacy that protects against any\ndiscovery. They are absolutely wrong about\nthat.\nThis is the Florida Supreme Court, former\nJustice Rosemary Barkett, speaking for the\ncourt. The case is Rasmussen vs. South Florida\nBlood Service. If you turn to Page 535 of the\nopinion, I have highlighted the relevant\nlanguage. You can read it faster than I can\nread it to you, so I won't bother reading it to\nyou. It's highlighted and copies were provided\nto opposing counsel as well.\nFlorida law unquestionably recognizes a\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 52\nEFTA00621539\n", "char_count": 1180}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Page 53\n1\nright to privacy and requires that the trial\n2\ncourt balance the right of privacy against the\n3\n4\nright to discovery. And to the extent that a\nright of privacy has been asserted in this\n5\ncase again, you have the documents\nyou know\n6\nwhat their content are. You have an ability to\n7\nbe able to waive the right of privacy that has\n8\nbeen asserted against the need for discovery in\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\nthis abuse of process case. And if you\ndetermine that the right of privacy is\noutweighed by the need for the discovery of any\nof those documents, you have the ability to\norder that they be turned over.\nAn additional argument that is made, that\nthere are documents as to which we have claimed\na joint defense privilege that are not covered\nunder the terms of a joint defense privilege.\nAs I believe opposing counsel recognizes\nwhat is often referred to as the joint defense\nprivilege is really a common interest privilege.\nThe law recognizes the fact that persons with\ncommon interests are entitled to share\ninformation in a privileged and confidential way\n24\nregarding the advancement of that common\n25\ninterest against a common adversary.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621540\n", "char_count": 1225}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "1\n2\nAll of the requirements for the application\nof the common interest privilege are met under\nPage 54\n3\nthe circumstances of this case both with regard\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\nto the common interests that were shared by\nlawyers who were simultaneously prosecuting\nidentical claims against Mr. Epstein; there was\nan express agreement among counsel that\ninformation shared among them concerning Mr.\nEpstein would be kept confidential; there were\nregularly-scheduled conferences among counsel\nfor purposes of sharing that confidential\ninformation; and the appropriate predicate\nexists to guard that information against\ndiscovery in matters that are still ongoing\nagainst Mr. Epstein.\nThe same holds true with regard to the\ncommon interests that were shared between\ngovernmental prosecuting authorities and those\nprosecuting civil claims arising out of\nidentical conduct by the same defendant in both\nthe civil and the criminal proceedings.\nThe common interest existed. The agreement\nexisted that information would be shared\nconfidentiality. Information was shared\nconfidentiality with a reasonable expectation of\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n22\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621541\n", "char_count": 1201}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Page 55\n1\nprivacy. The law cited by opposing counsel\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n25\nrecognizes the fact that that common interest is\nsufficient to support an assertion of\nprivilege.\nIf you decide otherwise, you have the\nauthority to decide otherwise. You have the\ndocuments. You can look at them. You can make\nthat determination.\nMuch of what is argued in this memo seeks to\nadd significant requirements to the elements\nthat are necessary in a T-I-G log, privilege\nlog. And even if those elements were to be\nadded, the in-camera production of the documents\nsatisfies those added elements, but they are not\nappropriately imposed under T-I-G or any other\nauthority that has been cited by opposing\ncounsel.\nI think that I have covered the points that\nMr. Ackerman made. If there is something that I\nmissed, I would be happy to address it.\nMR. ACKERMAN: May I respond, Your Honor?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Yes.\nMR. SCAROLA: One thing I might add. Also,\nwith regard to the common interest privilege,\none of the elements that is recognized in cases\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621542\n", "char_count": 1128}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Page 56\n1\nthat have been cited by the defense, excuse me,\n2\nby Mr. Epstein's lawyers is an agreement to\n3\npool expenses.\nSuch an agreement, in fact,\n47\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nexisted and we're prepared to support that by\ntestimony.\nI think that completes my response.\nMR. ACKERMAN: Your Honor, I briefly want to\naddress some of the things that Mr. Scarola\ntalked about. We have been through this even at\nthe last hearing. I have a copy of the\ntranscript, if you need it.\nAt the last hearing we had, we had the same\nissue about overbreadth and whether it's\nrelevant, whether it's determined, and you\naddressed it.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Let me cut straight\nto the chase for a second. What\nunderstanding - and\nultimately\nparaphrasing and\ntranslating some of the things that Mr. Scarola\nis saying not every single entry on the\nprivilege log has been objected to. What is\nbeing pointed out is that there are certain\nentries that are argued as being deficient.\nSome examples of the entries are being argued.\nFrom a practical point of view, it can make\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621543\n", "char_count": 1133}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n10\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\nit very difficult to craft an order and can\ncause all kinds of delay in doing that. What is\nbeing suggested is a cut-straight-to-the-chase\nof having an in-camera inspection, both parties\npresent. And if there is a particular issue,\nfor example, confidential source, because I\nwould then have the document and I would know\nwho the confidential source is, I can ask\nwhatever questions are necessary to determine\nwhether a privilege exists or it does not. If\nit doesn't, it's released. If the privilege\nexists, we still have yet to cross the bridge.\nBut this is a threshold question, because a\nlot of what seeing that you're arguing, the\nmajority are situations where there is\ndisclosure and the privilege no longer exists.\nGenerally, it deals with disclosure to\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\nthird parties, but\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\nMR. ACKERMAN:\n25\nYour Honor?\nnot necessarily sure that\nit wouldn't be a lot quicker and easier to do an\nin-camera inspection and, if need be,\nline-by-line say yes, no.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: With both sides?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Both sides.\nMay I address that one,\nPage 57\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621544\n", "char_count": 1162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: As I say, the\nalternative is, let's assume right now that I\ntake the position that the log is inadequate.\n4\nWhat the defense or what the plaintiff\n5\nseems to suggest\nwe'll use confidential\n6\nsource for a second\n-\nis that the confidential\n7\nsource be revealed.\nWell, at that point, the\n8\ncat's out of the bag.\nNo way to take that one\n6\nback.\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nThe question is: Can they argue\nconfidential source or must they in a privilege\nlog always reveal a confidential source? The\nplaintiff seems to take the position that a\nprivilege log would require that you reveal a\nconfidential source, and I don't think the case.\nlaw really supports that.\nAnd if it doesn't, then it seems to me that\nthere has to be an alternative method of doing\nit where we have a Master who now has or will\nhave all the Bates Stamp documents.\nIt seems to me at least determining the X\nor the O, privileged or not privileged, in terms\nof the X or the O it may be a lot quicker and\neasier to do the in-camera inspection on that.\nOnce we determine what's left, what's privileged\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 58\nEFTA00621545\n", "char_count": 1173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n10\n5\nor work-product, then we go through the\nprocedure of the hearing at that point to\ndetermine whether there's been some situation,\ncrime fraud or otherwise, that somehow\neliminates that particular privilege.\nMR. ACKERMAN: Your Honor, I think Mr.\n10\n6\n7\n8\nScarola has glossed over an important\nrequirement in the rule. The rule doesn't\n--\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nHis proposal neglects the portion of the rule\nthat says and this is Rule 1.280 (b) 5 of the\nFlorida Rules and there is a similar provision\nin the Federal Rules - and the idea and what\nthese cases say, I mean, we're not trying to\ncraft additional work for them. We're asking\nthem to do what the law requires: The\ninformation must be sufficient to enable the\nparties to assess the applicability of the\nprivilege or protection.\nThe problem with Mr. Scarola's suggestion\nis, we can't make any assessment because\n--\nAnd\nwe did object to the entire entry in the initial\nletter that I sent out, because there is no\n-\nidentification and these are requirements in\nthe cases there is no identification as to who\nthe person is or what their capacity is. There\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 59\nEFTA00621546\n", "char_count": 1207}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "is no identification as to who is claiming the\nprivilege in which case it is.\nI don't want to repeat what I said, but\nwe cannot make any arguments of waiver. You\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\nwith both parties here.\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nwill not know who is who when you do the\nin-camera inspection.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Actually, I would\nThat's why I would want\nboth parties there to be able to say who is John\nDoe.\nMR. ACKERMAN: Your Honor, we can't\nformulate, we can't make a meaningful assessment\nas to whether the privilege claim is appropriate\nor not without having the basic information\nthat's required by TIG. That is a requirement\nin the rule. It is a requirement in the cases.\nBecause he, Mr. Scarola, believes.\nyou can do it\ndoesn't satisfy the rule where it says: In a\nmanner without revealing information itself\nprivileged or protected will enable other\nparties to assess the applicability of the\nprivilege or the protection.\nWe don't know who these people are. We\ndon't know what capacity they've acted. Mr.\nScarola has come in and represented all the\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 60\nEFTA00621547\n", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n10\n6\npredicates for the common interests have been\nmet. There's nothing in the log or that we've\nseen that will establish that.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nnot sure\nthat part of my concern is the plaintiff is\nseeking more in the log than is necessarily\n7\nfully required. For example, on the\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n--\nYou\nknow, whether it's fact work-product or opinion\nwork-product,\nnot sure that the log has to\ndistinguish this is fact work-product and this\nis opinion work-product.\nI think the log simply need to claim\nwork-product. It may have to identify whether\n-\nit's a if it's a photograph. In this case,\nit's identifying a memorandum, but\nnot sure\nit has to say that the memorandum is a fact\nwork-product memorandum or an opinion\nwork-product or it's both.\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n--\n21\n22\n23\n25\n22\n24\nMR. ACKERMAN: But it's gotta say something\nExcuse me, Your Honor.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nIt's gotta say\nwork-product.\nMR. ACKERMAN: How are we going to know\nwhat the document is if they just say\nwork-product? They don't describe it. They\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 61\nEFTA00621548\n", "char_count": 1102}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\ndon't say whether it's a statement. They don't\nsay whether it's a photograph. They don't say\nwhether it's a memorandum of law. And I submit\nto you that that's what these cases require.\nYou're not going to be able to conduct\nmeaningful review. We're not going to be able\nto make meaningful objections. And that's the\npurpose of this rule, so that we can do that.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Well, the issue I\nPage 62\n10\nguess what\nlooking at, because\ngoing to\n11\nhave the documents,\nnot sure that I agree\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nthat I cannot conduct a meaningful review.\nThere is a practical side that\nat I think both sides really aught consider.\nWe can go back and forth from pillar to post\ntrying to get what the plaintiff considers a\nperfect privilege log.\nnot sure we'll ever\nget that. We can spend the next six or eight\nmonths doing that.\nlooking\n20\nMR. ACKERMAN:\nWhat's wrong with them just\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nidentifying who these people are?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: We can have an\nin-camera inspection and resolve it. It may\ncost us a day or two, but we can have an\nin-camera inspection and simply put the Xs or\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621549\n", "char_count": 1179}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "1\nOs.\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n15737\nOnce we do that, we can proceed and move\npretty well. It seems to me, even if the log\neven if there are defects in the log, if one\nlooks from the practical side, both sides seem\nto be taking the position at this point: Let's\nmove this along. The fastest way to move it\nalong would be an in-camera inspection. No\nquestion that would be the absolute quickest\nBecause in the long run, we're going to\nhave to have an in-camera inspection of some\nway.\nsort any way. Down the road, sooner or later,\nthat issue is going to raise.\nAs I say, we can wait three or four months\nbattling back and forth trying to get a perfect\nprivilege log or we can do the in-camera\ninspection expeditiously and resolve those\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\nissues right off the bat. It just seems to me\n19\n20\nthat from a practical side it may be a lot\nquicker to do it that way.\n21\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Maybe\nnot understanding\n22\n23\n24\n25\nthe in-camera inspection, because to me it\nalmost seems as if now you're doing their job\nwhich is fine.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Not at all. What\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 63\nEFTA00621550\n", "char_count": 1131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\ncourt reporter.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: No, but\n--\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: As an example, just\nto illustrate, go to Page 1.\n1\ndoing is\n--\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Take the first document?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: The first document.\nThe transcript of Alfredo Rodriguez deposition.\nWe can make a determination: Privileged, not\nprivileged. Work-product, not work-product. I\nmean, I can give it an X or an O. We can\nprobably right this minute, right now, determine\nwhether that's privileged or not privileged\nright off the bat. It's taken in front of a\nDoes the court reporter waive\n15\nthe privilege?\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\nThere are various things that we can end up\ndoing. Is presumably a properly noticed\ndeposition a privileged document? Again, I can\nprobably rule on that right now.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Depositions are usually\n21\npublic proceedings so\n22\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: What\nsaying is,\n23\n24\n25\na lot of this, things are being raised here. No\nmatter how many orders are how many interim\nthings I tell the defendant, we're still going\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 64\nEFTA00621551\n", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\nPage 65\nto have to sit down and have that decision.\nIt's an X or an O.\nWhat I don't necessarily want to do at an\nin-camera inspection is do an in-camera\ninspection where I don't give anybody any\nopportunity to say anything.\nAnd so, if I take the position off the bat,\nGee, if this is done in front of a court\nreporter at a deposition, a regularly-scheduled\ndeposition in a civil case, is this privileged\nat all? And why in the world would I find that\nto be privileged? They can give me their\nreasons why they think it's privileged or not,\nbut I can put an X or put an O at the end of\nthat, ultimately, in the absence of an\nagreement, since right now they're saying we\ndon't want to give any of this stuff.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Right.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: As unpleasant as\nit's going to be, in the long run what we're\ngoing to need to do is at least sit down and\nmake the threshold determination: Yes,\nfacially, it's privileged. Or, no, it's not.\nAs I go through many of these things, many of\nthese things at least on their face to me don't\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n22\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621552\n", "char_count": 1155}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "MRS. SANCHEZ: This in-camera inspection,\nwould there be a court reporter so that we could\n1\nappear to be privileged at all.\n2\n3\n4\n5\n10\n7\n8\n9\nobject later?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Yes. The way I like\nto do an in-camera inspection just so that both\nsides are aware: In camera means that\nnot\nshowing it to you. So, we know that. You're\n10\nnot going to get to see it. However, what the\nin-camera does, I can generically identify\nsomething and make a determination that it falls\nwithin a category or it doesn't.\nFor example, using this deposition.\nI can\nsay the deposition is yes or no. I can give\nthem an opportunity to raise whatever they feel\nis appropriate.\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nbecause\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nWhen we get to a confidential source,\ngoing to know who the confidential source is,\ngoing to have the paper directly in\nfront of me. You're not going to know the\nconfidential source initially. I'll try and\nfind from them at the hearing why this would\nfall within some type of a privilege.\nWhat\nlooking for is initially to take\nthe 17,000 or 15,000 entries and assign an X or\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 66\nEFTA00621553\n", "char_count": 1143}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "1\nan O to the 15,000 entries.\nPage 67\n2\n3\n4\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Right. Basically, during\nthis in-camera hearing, essentially, what would\nhappen is that the information that we believe\nis missing from the log to make that\ndetermination, you would look at the document\n5\n6\n7\n8\nfor us to make that argument?\nand you would provide the information necessary\n6\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: When you say\n10\n\"provide the information,\"\nnot\n--\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\nMR. ACKERMAN: Here's an example, Your\nHonor. If there is a letter from Brad Edwards\nto John Jones, you look at it. How are we\ngoing to be able to argue that's a waiver of\nthe privilege without knowing who John Jones.\nis?\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Right.\n18\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nThat's an easy one.\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nLet's take Entry 2. It's from Brad Edwards to\nKatherine Ezell. I have no clue who Katherine\nEzell is, but we know Katherine Ezell is\nformally listed here.\nI can ask Brad Edwards: Who is Katherine\nEzell? He can say this is a secretary in the\nlaw firm. He can say it's an outside\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621554\n", "char_count": 1081}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "1\naccountant. I have no idea who Katherine Ezell\nPage 68\n2\nis.\n3\nMR. ACKERMAN:\nCan't we get that information\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\nbefore you have an in-camera hearing, that's\nwhat we're asking for, so that we can\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: I don't actually\nhave a particular problem if we look to do an\nin-camera hearing to try and trim the in-camera\nhearing if we can trim it.\nMR. KNIGHT: That certainly would make it\na lot more efficient if we would already\n--\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Would be to go with\nwhat I had originally suggested. If we get a\nmaster list of who the players are so that when\nyou're listing people such as Katherine Ezell,\nJackie Johnson is another one who I think is a\nparalegal or with the firm from reading before.\nMR. EDWARDS: Right.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: But when you're\nlisting Jackie Johnson\nMR. SCAROLA: We'll give you a score card.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: -- and it's to Adam\nHorowitz, as to who Adam Horowitz is. So that\n22\n24\n25\nat least we get a score card of who's who.\nsaying, if we do that we may be in a\nWhat\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621555\n", "char_count": 1128}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n10\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\nposition, maybe not, but we may be in a position\nwith a score card of paring down what we\nactually have to do at an in-camera hearing.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: The other thing that's\ninteresting on the privilege log, and I know we\nwent through this, is that a lot of these\ne-mails and/or letters or whatever they are, I\nthink they're all e-mails, usually have ccs and\nbccs which are important to us also. There's\nnot any of them that have that information.\nAnd\na cc or a bcc is very, very important, because\nthat in and of itself would be the waiver of the\nPage 69\n13\n14\nprivilege if it went to an outside source or\nsomeone that's not within the privilege and\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nrelatively unwieldy.\nthat's not here either.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: But I am still\n-\nsaying that to have the privilege log because\nnot sure that we're going to get a privilege\nlog that is going to satisfy the plaintiff and\nI don't mean that disrespectfully at all - but I\nthink to get a privilege log when you're dealing\nwith e-mails where there are copies, the blind\ncopies, where you have e-mail strings, they go\non forever, the privilege log really becomes\nAnd the very unwieldiness\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621556\n", "char_count": 1249}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Page 70\n1\nof the privilege log is going to always create\n2\nthe objection that can be raised.\n3\nWhat\nconcerned with is we can end up\n4\n10\n5\n10\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nwith privilege log objection, new privilege log\nobjection, new privilege log objection and go on\nfor months doing that, which is the way I see\nthis going.\nOr, alternatively, we just take the bull by\nthe horns and sit down and do it. If we sit\ndown and do it, what I normally -- what I would.\nenvision is having this and putting an X or an O\nor a check on those things that are privileged,\nthose things that are not privileged.\nAt the end of the hearing the Bates Stamp\ndetermining that it is privileged,\nitem, if\nwe have it subject to appellate review, subject\nto court review if Judge Rey wants to look over\nit, but it's subject to review. We have it set.\nOnce we determine where there are privileges\nthen we can cross the bridge if there are other\nexceptions to the privilege as it would require\na further evidentiary hearing.\nBut\nsaying a lot of this stuff, probably\nthe majority of it, can be either eliminated as\nit's not privileged and it is discoverable or\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621557\n", "char_count": 1213}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Page 71\nnot looking to raise at this\npoint or to rule on relevancy objections.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: How long do you think it\nwould take for us to go through these 15 or\nHow many documents are there in the privilege\nlog, Jack?\nMR. EDWARDS: I think there's about 2,000\ne-mails.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: 2,000 e-mails?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: 2,000? I would\nthink 2,000 e-mails, if we began in the\nmorning, probably a day. We could probably get\nthrough it.\n1\nit's not.\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMR. ACKERMAN: Your Honor, when we\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: But it would\nprobably take a day.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: I would think it would take\na little longer than that.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: It might take a\ncouple of days to do it, but it depends on how\nmuch argument we're going to end up having.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Correct.\nnot\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: And\nenvisioning -- There are certain things that I\nknow Jack has talked about evidentiary this or\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621558\n", "char_count": 1000}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Page 72\n1\nyou all have talked about evidentiary that.\n2\n3\nnot looking at the initial culling down as doing\nevidence.\n4\nWhat\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\nseeing.\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nlooking at is, basically, a\nquick determination, for example: Is a\ndeposition in its entirety, is a deposition\nwork-product? And it seems to me\nanswer to that one. A lot of these, that's\nultimately what\nAs I have gone through the privilege log,\nthat's what most of them are. There are going\nto be some that aren't, but most are. And the\nones that we actually get to that aren't, we set\nthose aside and that can be a separate\nevidentiary hearing, but I just think we're\ngoing to spin our wheels for a long, long time\ntrying to get a perfect TIG log out of this.\nWhen you're dealing with this type of\nevidence, when you're dealing with the e-mails,\nwith copies and blind copies, strings, I mean,\nwe're just never going to get a perfect\nprivilege log. And as I say, I think that the\nplaintiff in one respect is expecting more than\nthe plaintiff is likely to get on a privilege\nlog to begin with.\nget an\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621559\n", "char_count": 1141}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Well, I think we're just\nlooking for something a little bit more\nmeaningful so that we can narrow what you need\nto do. For instance, even if we just had the\nnames of the ccs or bccs and who these players.\nare and what connection they had.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: How long would it\ntake to get names for the -- The players that\n--\nwe have, anyone who's named in here Now,\nwe've got a lot of entries, for example, Jackie\nJohnson is just mentioned hundreds of times.\nMR. EDWARDS: That was my secretary, so I\nwould imagine.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Right.\nnot\nnecessarily sure that in terms of a list that\nthe list is going to be all that long.\nWe may\nhave 2,000 documents, but we're not going to\nhave 2,000 names. We may have 50 names or\nthereabouts, but we're just not going to have\nthat many names. A lot of them are repetitive.\nWhat saying, if we can get a master list\nof who is who, so that we know that Jackie\nJohnson is your secretary.\nMR. EDWARDS: And I realize you may be at\nsomewhat more a disadvantage than they are. I\nPage 73\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621560\n", "char_count": 1162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\nthink that you're being somewhat misled in that\nall of these people dealt with Epstein and his\nattorneys for a two-year period of time. To say\nI don't know who Kathy Ezell is when that is an\nattorney that represented 21 underaged girls and\nyou dealt with on a daily basis for two years is\njust not true. I didn't realize that I had to\ntell them that this is somebody you dealt with\nfor two years every single day. You know who\nthese people are. You may not know and I think\nSO--\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: I think it will be,\nif nothing else, it's helpful for me. But the\nproblem that\nseeing right now and again,\ntrying to do is craft something that\nbecomes workable if we try and parse out\nwhich ones they aught know and which ones maybe\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\nwhat\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nthey don't, we're going to spend forever doing\nit. We're going to end up with more battles.\nMR. SCAROLA: We will provide a roster. It\nwill cover at least all the principal players.\nIf somebody's name comes up that we have somehow\nmissed on a copy list, we'll tell you who that\nperson is during the course of the inspection.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: We'll pick it up\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 74\nEFTA00621561\n", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Page 75\nHow long would it take\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\nduring the inspection.\nto get a master list out?\nMR. SCAROLA: A week.\n00\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\nMRS. SANCHEZ: A week?\nMR. ACKERMAN: Your Honor, if we're going to\nproceed down this path, we're not going to take\nthe position that TIG is waived because\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Of course not.\nMR. ACKERMAN:\nwe need to be able to have\na second opportunity. If you're going to set\naside stuff that you're putting an X on, then we\nwant to be able to have the opportunity at that\npoint in time to tell you the additional\ninformation we're going to need to assert any\ntype of objection.\n16\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nAbsolutely.\nHere's\n17\nwhat\nenvisioning. Again, this is in\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\nsomewhat of a perfect world assuming that nobody\nhas a big objection or is filing objections on\nthis and the initial objections would probably\ncome out of the defense side. Let's say we have\n100 entries and let's assume that I decide that\n75 of those entries, there simply is not either.\nThen my view\nattorney-client or work-product.\n25\nis, you get the 75.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621562\n", "char_count": 1134}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Now, of course, they can raise an objection\nat that point if they decide that it's wrong,\n1\n2\n3\n4\nwhat\n5\n10\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nbecause I can write out my findings that this is\nfinding, that these entries are not\nwork-product. But assuming we don't have a\nproblem with that, then you get the 75.\nFor the 25 that we find that there is\nwork-product, we still then go through the\nprocedure. At this point once I make a\ndetermination that there is at least a threshold\nshowing right now that we have an\nattorney-client privilege or we have a\nwork-product privilege, the burden then may\nshift to you at that point to come up with, Why\nnot?\nWhat we still do according to our original\nplan is we make a determination at a subsequent\nhearing: What are the ground rules we're all\nfollowing? What is the procedure now? What is\nthe standard as a preponderance of the evidence?\nIs it clear and convincing? What is our\nstandards and what exactly -- who's got what\nburden to establish what?\nWe lay out the ground rules so that we're\nall clear on that and then we have a hearing on\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 76\nEFTA00621563\n", "char_count": 1162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n25\nthat issue.\nMR. ACKERMAN: But you're going to have an\nadditional step with that. In one sense you\nthink you may be saving time in one area, but\nwhat's going to happen is, you're going to come\nup with a stack of documents for which you think\nthere is a privilege and then we're going to\nneed to know which those documents are and we're\ngoing to need to know or at least be able to\nexpress what information we need in order to\nproceed with our claim that it's privileged or\nnot.\nSo, for example, if there is additional\ninformation -\ngoing to pick the capacity\nargument for the sake of it, for the sake of\n-\nillustrating my point if they don't tell us.\nwho the capacity is and you don't tell us, we\ncan't argue that there is a waiver because we\ndon't know whether the person that received this\ndocument was, in fact, part of the litigation\nteam or is protected by some other legal\nprivilege.\nWe need to have an understanding,\nrespectfully, sir, that once the pile of the Xs\nis determined we have an opportunity at that\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 77\nEFTA00621564\n", "char_count": 1144}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\npoint to say we need this additional information\nif we're going to assert an exception or a\nwaiver.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: I had cited a case,\nand I don't recall off the top of my head the\ncase, but what my recollection of the case is:\nThe threshold burden in this case is upon the\ndefendant to establish that there is a\nprivilege. Whatever the privilege is, it's\ntheir burden to establish that there is a\nprivilege.\nThere is a particular standard and the case\ndealt with the standard that they had to meet to\nbe able to establish that, whether it was prima\nfacie or what their standard is. Once that's\nestablished then we know, exactly what the\nprivilege is and exactly what they're claiming.\nIf they are claiming that this is team\ninformation, they're going to have to establish\nthe basis upon which they're claiming a\nprivilege; and that's their burden. Your\nburden doesn't come until after that.\nOnce they establish that, then you have to\nestablish why there is an exception to it, that\nthere has been outside disclosure. Whether we\nPage 78\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621565\n", "char_count": 1162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\nhave, for example, a litigation team privilege,\nwhether that applies, they have to establish\nlitigation team. That's the point where you\nwould argue, no, it's not litigation team.\nEither there is no such privilege as litigation\nteam or these people aren't on the litigation\nteam. They have to put on sufficient evidence\nto establish the litigation team.\nOnce they establish it, if they can, then\nthe burden comes on you to come up with some\nreason why then; because there's been disclosure\nto a third party, because there's been some\nother thing that would somehow obviate that\nparticular privilege. But the threshold\nquestions that you're talking about they have to\nestablish first.\n17\nMR. ACKERMAN:\nnot sure I agree with\n18\nyou.\nnot sure\n--\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMy concern is to\naddress if they're not established at the time\nthat you finish your review.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: No. What\nMR. ACKERMAN: Because they haven't\nestablished it in terms of this log, in terms\nof, for example, whether there's a waiver\nbecause they haven't identified the people.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 79\nEFTA00621566\n", "char_count": 1154}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Page 80\n1\nThat's an example of what\ntalking about, and\n2\nthere may be others.\n3\n4\n5\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Well, what\nlooking at right now is, in terms of what I see,\nthe first in-camera inspection is more one of\n6\nexclusion than inclusion. What\nsaying is,\n7\n8\n6\ntaking out the stuff that is fairly.\nobviously not privileged. When we get to things\nwhere there may be an evidentiary hearing,\nwhether it's privileged or not, what\nlooking\nat are certain things that are not privileged.\nThere maybe an\nLet's say, the deposition.\nargument the deposition simply is not\nprivileged. If it's not privileged, it's not\nprivileged. If there has been disclosure to\nthird parties and on the face of it I can see we\nhave disclosure to third parties and they're not\nraising litigation team, they're not raising\nwhatever they're raising, then it's not\nprivileged.\nNow, if they raised litigation team and so\nwe end up with that Katherine Ezell and they're\nraising this is litigation team, what my view is\ninitially at that point at the first in-camera\ninspection, I'll let that go. I'll let them\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621567\n", "char_count": 1177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n10\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nraise what they are raising.\nAt a second hearing once we narrow down,\nbecause at this point now you're going to know\nthat Katherine Ezell, what they are raising\nactually is the litigation team. And so you're\ngoing to know that at the end of the first.\nhearing at least what they're raising.\nWhen we actually get to a second hearing on\nthis, the second hearing, the threshold burden\nis on them. Evidentiary hearing, they're going\nto have to establish litigation team. If they\ndon't, it gets released. If they do, then the\nburden switches over to you and you're going to\nhave to establish what exception you feel is an\nappropriate exception.\nBut what\nsaying, by the end of our first\nhearing we will have culled out everything\nthat is obviously not privileged and, ideally,\nwe would have at least narrowed down what the\nprivilege is.\nIf it's an exotic privilege such as\nlitigation team or this is a right of privacy,\nwhatever they're ultimately alleging as to why\nthat shouldn't be turned over, with each of\nthose documents we're going to go through and\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 81\nEFTA00621568\n", "char_count": 1179}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "1\nmake that determination.\n2\n3\n4\n10\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMR. SCAROLA: I have a question.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Yeah.\nMR. SCAROLA: Why must that be done in a\ntwo-step process? If we've got the document in\nfront of us right now and if it identifies\nKatherine Ezell, if the basis of our privilege\nclaim is that Katherine Ezell shared a common\ninterest with us and the information was being\nshared confidentially pursuant to an agreement\nto exchange information among persons who were\nprosecuting claims against Mr. Epstein on behalf\nof child victims of Mr. Epstein, why can't that\ndetermination be made while we have that\ndocument in front of us as opposed to putting it\naside and coming back to it at a later time to\nargue that?\nWe know what the issues are. They've been\nbriefed by it by opposing counsel extensively in\nthe memo that's already been submitted. We\nargue it. You decide it. That document is out\nof the way.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: My only quarrel with\nWe don't have to come back to it.\nthat is, that suggests an evidentiary hearing.\nAnd as we try to go through 2,000 documents,\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 82\nEFTA00621569\n", "char_count": 1186}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Page 83\n1\n2\nthat's going to take it a lot longer than a\ncouple of days as we go through that.\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nmore inclined to give them a relatively\nclear by \"them,\" being the plaintiff a\nrelatively clear idea of what particular\nprivilege is being asserted. If they want to\nchallenge and cross-examine Katherine Ezell,\nthey can challenge and cross-examine Katherine\nEzell.\nBut I think we'll need to take a look at\nthe case that I had cited at one point which\nseems to be the relatively pole star case on how\nto do these hearings. I can't recall whether\nthat needed a prima facie showing. Ultimately,\nI think we're going to need to sit down and\nfigure out our ground rules on exactly how we're\ndoing it. Can you say it? Is that sufficient?\nDo we have to bring in Katherine Ezell? Does\nshe have to testify? We're going to have to\n20\nlay out the ground rules, and\nnot\n21\nnecessarily sure on the in-camera inspection\n22\nthat it's going to be economical doing it that\n23\nway.\n24\n25\n22\nMR. SCAROLA:\nnot suggesting that the\nright to an evidentiary hearing be eliminated,\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621570\n", "char_count": 1144}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n10\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\nbut taking the specific example that we are\npresently discussing, it is unimaginable that\nthey are going to contest the fact that\nKatherine Ezell was representing child victims\nof Mr. Epstein at the same time that Brad\nEdwards was representing those child victims.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: What I don't have a\nproblem with that we may be able to resolve at\nthis point: If we're dealing with only a legal\nissue where both sides are in accord that the\nfacts are not particularly in dispute, and so if\nwe're dealing with an issue is there such a\nthing as a litigation team privilege, either\nthere is or there isn't\nPage 84\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n22\nMR. SCAROLA: That's all\nsuggesting.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Then\nsaying if\nit's a legal issue only, I can probably resolve.\nit at the in-camera inspection. If it's not a\nlegal issue only, if there is a mixed question\nof fact and law, it requires an evidentiary\nhearing and I wouldn't resolve it.\nBut what\ntrying not to do at the initial\nin-camera inspection is get into evidentiary\nissues, because that will dramatically lengthen\nthe in-camera inspection.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621571\n", "char_count": 1194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "1\n2\nMR. SCAROLA: I understand and I agree.\nMR. ACKERMAN: Your Honor, my concern is\n3\nthat while there may be some documents, it's\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\nhard for us to commit to what's going on without\nknowing who people are. In the case of\nKatherine Ezell, she may have sent this\nlitigation strategy memo to a third party thus\nwaiving it after you look at it.\n9\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nThat's fine.\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\nMR. ACKERMAN: We need to have an\nintermediate step here that allows us to look at\nwhat you are tentatively upholding a privilege\non so that we can see if we have enough\ninformation to make a challenge to the\nprivilege, if we feel it's appropriate, or not\nand brief you on that before there is a final\nruling, as we had discussed at the last\nprocedure hearing we had, where we would have a\nchance to brief you on the procedure and the\nmethod for determining any claims of privilege\nthat you've preliminarily determined exists.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Let me see if we can\nagree on the following. Today is Tuesday. By\nsay Tuesday of next week, get a master list,\n25\n25\nwhich would be\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 85\nEFTA00621572\n", "char_count": 1171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "back\n1\n2\n3\n4\nMRS. SANCHEZ: The 22nd.\nMR. KNIGHT: The 22nd.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Have a master list\nby the 22nd. I had indicated to everybody, I\n5\nthink previously,\nout of town starting\n6\ntomorrow and I will be out of town through the\n7\n25th. Beginning on Monday, the 28th,\n8\nin town.\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nDepending on your schedules,\nanticipating\nI would like to see with a nice\nearly start we get it done in a day. I don't\nthink a day is going to be unreasonable, because\nI think a lot of this, it's not going to require\nthat much argument. It's a question of just\ngoing through 2,000 entries and I think we can\ngo through 2,000 entries in a day.\nMR. SCAROLA: There may be five legal\narguments that's going to be determinative of\nevery issue that's before the court.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: If we do that, if\nyou all are available on the week of the 28th;\nthe sooner we do it, the better we do it.\nBecause at that point, what\nenvisioning is\nwe, hopefully, cull this down significantly.\nOnce we cull this down significantly we then\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 86\nEFTA00621573\n", "char_count": 1121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Page 87\n1\nknow what the issues are, what privileges are\n2\nbeing asserted and on what documents they're\n3\n4\n5\nсл\n6\n7\nbeing asserted.\nWhat\nlike to do, because it will give us\nan idea then of the approximate period of time\nthat we may need for the second hearing,\nactually seeing the second hearing is probably\ngoing to be a lot shorter than the first.\n8\n9\nBecause what\n10\n11\n12\nultimately saying is, it's\nprobably going to be the applicability of four\nor five theories or the non-applicability as\nopposed to going through on a\ndocument-by-document on each one.\nMR. KNIGHT: What specifically are you\n13\n14\n15\nrequiring of a master list, because the TIG\n16\nobjection in the beginning here is we need more\n17\ninformation to be able to make that hearing\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nefficient to move along?\nMR. SCAROLA: We're going to give you an\nalphabetical\nMR. KNIGHT: We need the ccs and the\nbccs.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Right. You're going\nto get a list of anyone that they've named, who\nthey are. So you'll get anyone that they've\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621574\n", "char_count": 1078}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Page 88\n1\nnamed, you'll get who they are. You'll get\n2\nthat done by Wednesday.\n3\n4\nhave is, I will have the log but\n5\n10\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\nAnd then at the hearing, because what I will\nalso going\nto have the Bates Stamped documents. And so\nI'll sit there with that Bates Stamped document\nand we'll go through document by document.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: And at that point you'll read.\nthe ccs and bccs to us?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Yes. Well, whether\nI read the ccs and bcs to you, we'll take it\ncase by case. For example, if we have what\nthey're claiming is a confidential source, I may\nnot name the confidential source for you.\nOtherwise, I may not have any problem doing it.\nMR. KNIGHT: And we still would have our\narguments as to why a confidential source is not\ngoing to be protected and, in fact, it's a\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nwaiver?\n20\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Sure.\nAbsolutely.\n21\nWhat\nsaying is, purely legal arguments, I\n22\n23\n24\ncan handle purely legal arguments at the initial\nhearing. What\nthe end of this hearing on the log, I can put\nsaying is out of this log, at\n25\n25\nyes, no, yes, no, yes, no as to privilege,\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621575\n", "char_count": 1165}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nnon-privilege. For the nos, it's not\nprivileged, you get them.\nFor the yes that it's privileged, at that\npoint now you will know what the privilege is\nthat's being asserted, whether it's\nattorney-client, work-product, whatever is\nultimately being asserted here.\nI will try at the hearing to ensure that you\nhave as much information as you need on a\nparticular document.\nYou can then make a\ndetermination. We should be able to see how\nmany different issues we've got and be able to\niron out the time for our second hearing, how\nlong that second hearing is going to take and\nhow quickly we can do it.\nMR. ACKERMAN: Your Honor, I would\nrespectfully request that as part of the\nmaster list they add the ccs and the bccs,\nbecause if we know who everybody is that's\ngetting these documents then this review will go\na lot faster. I think if they end up looking at\nthese given the kind of list they've got on the\nlog, it's going to end up being the same people.\nI don't think it's going to be that onerous.\nI would request that they do that, because\nPage 89\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621576\n", "char_count": 1165}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\nthen we don't have a dispute at the time as to\nwhether so-and-so is so-and-so and what their\ncapacity is. You'll know and we'll know and\nbe able to address it at the hearing. It will\nbe a lot more efficient.\nMR. SCAROLA: There are 2,000 e-mails. That\n4\n5\n6\n7\nis an extraordinary burden.\n8\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\ninclined to\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n25\nagree. What I will do is this, and I think we\nmay not have any problem with this one: For any\nparticular e-mail where determining that it\nlooks like, facially, we have a privilege where\nwe have non-confidential ccs and bcs, I will\ntell you who they are.\nMR. ACKERMAN: You'll tell us the names,\nbut we won't know who they are and their\ncapacity. That's what we're asking them to do\nnow.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: What they're going\nto give at some point, because\nassuming that\nthis master list that they're going to give is\ngoing to pretty much be covering everyone who is\non the cc and bcc list.\nMR. ACKERMAN: I expect it will, but\nasking you to specifically ask them to do that.\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 90\nEFTA00621577\n", "char_count": 1119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\nBecause if you have all of the people on the bcc\nlist and the cc list, then you're going to be\nable to look right then and there and see\nwhether they're a part of the law firm or not.\nOtherwise, you're going to tell us who the\ncc is and the bcc. And if they're not on the\nlist, we're going to need to know who that is\nand how it impacts it. If we have those people\nin advance, we could move this a lot faster.\nin hopes that\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nwe are actually going to have those people in\nPage 91\n11\n12\nadvance. What\nsaying is,\nnot\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nnecessarily looking that on Bates Stamp number\nsuch-and-such that we get the cc and bcc list\nfor every single person on Bates Stamp 950.\nIf we have, nevertheless, for the 2,000 as\nwe have the players, who these are going to; cc,\nbcc, whatever it is, who these are going to, so\nthat we know who they are. When I actually have.\n20\nthe document in front of me, if\nlooking at\n21\n22\nBates Stamp 950 and I say Bates Stamp 950\nlooks to me like it is a privileged document.\n23\n24\nAnd you say, well, can you tell me who the cc is\nor who the blindcopy goes to? I can tell you,\n25\nyes, it goes to John Smith and so forth. That's\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621578\n", "char_count": 1247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "1\nwho it goes to.\n2\nMR. ACKERMAN:\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\nnot asking them to do\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: But you will have\nthe master list and you'll know that John Smith\nis a paralegal for the firm.\nMR. ACKERMAN: They don't have to do\nclear on what\n--\nSo\nrequesting. If they look\nat a bcc and they see John Smith, they put his\n9\n10\nname on the list. They don't have to put his\nname next to each document if he's on that\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\ndocument. You're going to see that.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Right.\nMR. ACKERMAN: What we want is a list of the\ncapacities of everybody that is originating\ndocuments, receiving them or getting copied.\nWhether they're on there one time or two times,\nI don't think we need to know how many documents\nthey're on or which ones. You're going to see\nthat. What I do think we need to know by the\ntime we do this is who is on them and what their\ncapacity is.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: I don't have a\nproblem with that, because\ntraveling right\nnow initially under the assumption that in spite\nof the number of documents that we have that the\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 92\nEFTA00621579\n", "char_count": 1139}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Page 93\n1\n2\n3\nlist isn't that big. When I went through the\ndocuments, at least a large portion of the\ndocuments, the list isn't all that big. It's\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\nthe same people over and over and over\nagain.\nAnd so to that extent, if we can get\nthat information, it doesn't have to be\nattributable to each and every individual\ne-mail, but at least a master list of who\neverybody is where you're willing to actually\ngive a name.\nFor the ones that you aren't, we'll deal\nwith the confidential source as we get to it.\nsaying then, if we can get a time,\nideally, if you all can check your calendars\nnow, if we can get a time and let's block off a\n11\n12\n13\n14\nBut what\n15\n16\n17\ntime\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Just so I can understand:\nnone of these e-mails have attachments, Joe?\nMR. ACKERMAN: They're not\nMR. SCAROLA: Some do.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: But none of these, the log\ndoesn't seem to\n--\nMR. ACKERMAN:\nThe log doesn't designate\n25\nany attachments.\nDo\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621580\n", "char_count": 1006}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Page 94\nany attachments nor did\n1\nMRS. SANCHEZ:\n2\nany of the documents we received, the irrelevant\n3\nones and the ones that were for attorney's eyes.\n4\nonly, I didn't see any attachments.\nWere you\n10\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nnot printing out attachments?\nMR. EDWARDS: Something was printed out for\nme. I didn't printout anything. They were\ndelivered to my office and I used that. So then\nIf it was irrelevant, I l\ndidn't turn it over. If the attachment was in\nI would turn it over.\nthere, it was in there. I didn't take out an\nattachment that was attached or anything like\nthat.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Okay. I didn't see an\nattachments, that's why\n--\nMR. EDWARDS: Yeah, all that was printed was\nthe e-mail, all the e-mails. So if there was an\nattachment to it, it may or may not have been\nprinted. Although, I think some attachments\nwere there because there were deposition\ntranscripts and things like that, and I think we\nturned those over.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Well, like the first one, 76\nto 89 does not seem like that would be a full\ntranscript of a deposition. But I could be, I\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621581\n", "char_count": 1152}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Page 95\nwrong. Maybe it's a mini\n1\nmean, maybe\n2\n3\nversion or something and we'll have it.\nI mean, you know, if there was I would go\n--\n4\nback to the disk and check the disk to make sure\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\nthat I can't check it to make sure that the\nprinting from the disk with the Bates Stamp\nincluded all the attachments. I just noticed\nnow on the documents you gave us and in this\nthat I don't see attachments. I find that\nstrange.\nMR. EDWARDS:\n12\nturned over or\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n--\nWhatever there was was either\nI didn't take out attachments.\nI don't see how the production of a deposition\nis going to prove that somebody was involved in\nthe ponzi scheme or not.\nprocess.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Let's see if we can\nlost in this\n18\ncome up with a time that everyone is\n--\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMR. KNIGHT: I was just trying to pull up my\ncalendar.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: My only bad day is that\nMonday.\nMR. ACKERMAN: On the 28th. We have a\nnumber of hearings on that case, too.\nMR. SCAROLA: Brad is in trial the week of\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621582\n", "char_count": 1059}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\nthe 28th. I am on Judge Streitfeld's calendar\nin a tobacco trial that is backup on the 28th.\nIf that does not go forward and then I am going\nto have some flexibility the week of April 5 it.\nlooks like.\n6\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nThat's April 4.\n7\n8\n9\nMR. SCAROLA: April 4, yes.\nMR. ACKERMAN: I think that would be a\nbetter week for me.\n10\n11\nMR. KNIGHT: The week of the 28th,\nin\nTexas. Towards the end of the week,\nin a\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nbig hearing on the 28th.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: How about April 4th,\nwe can block off a day on that?\nMR. ACKERMAN: I can do the 4th.\nMR. SCAROLA: The 4th is not good for me. I\nhave a mediation set on the 4th.\nMR. ACKERMAN: How about the 6th?\nMR. SCAROLA: The 6th is good.\n20\nMR. EDWARDS: The 6th is good for me, too.\n21\nMR. KNIGHT: I'll work on it.\nI've got a\n22\n23\ncouple of things I have to work on.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Lilly?\n24\nMRS. SANCHEZ:\nfine.\n25\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: The 6th.\nThe\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 96\nEFTA00621583\n", "char_count": 1005}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Page 97\n1\nlocation is here.\nYou want to meet middle\n2\nground?\n3\n4\n5\nalthough\n6\n7\nMR. SCAROLA:\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: My recommendation\nnot the one driving in traffic at\nthis point when it's up here the earlier we\nget started, the more likely we are to finish\nThis is fine.\n-\n00\n8\nit. As early as you all are\n--\nYou all are\n6\ntraveling. So, again\nMR. KNIGHT: Some people have kid drop-off\nschedules.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Pick the time, but\nas early as we can reasonably get started I\nwould just as soon\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\nearly as we can.\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMR. KNIGHT: We'll try to get back to you as\nI don't know which day.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: Barring no traffic, I usually\nI can get here 9:15, 9:30, the latest.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: You want to\ntentatively set 9:15. And if you're not here,\nwe'll wait until you get here. Tentatively set\nit for 9:15 and then plan on a reasonably quick\nlunch.\nMR. SCAROLA:\nI'll have lunch brought in.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Thank you. Do I\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621584\n", "char_count": 1034}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\nneed to write something up for Judge Rey as to\nwhat we're doing here?\nMR. ACKERMAN: I think you aught to write\nsomething up.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Like an interim\nMR. ACKERMAN: Interim report.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Interim report.\nMR. KNIGHT: Good idea.\n9\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: What\ngoing to do\n10\n11\nis, I'll go ahead and write out an interim\nreport and I'll e-mail it to you. And if you\n12\ncan\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\nMR. ACKERMAN: Put it into a form file.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: Polish it.\nMR. ACKERMAN: I'll send it to Jack.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: And then submit it\nto the judge. It's not going to have I guess a\nhandwritten signature, but it will be I'll\n--\n19\nput my name.\n20\nMR. ACKERMAN:\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nWell, what we can do is, when\nwe get the form, I can send it to you. You can\nsign it. We can do a Notice of Filing of\ninterim report. And then your signed one will\nget filed.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: What you can do, if\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 98\nEFTA00621585\n", "char_count": 1002}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "1\nyou want to catch me where I can be caught, the\n2\nFrench Quarter Inn in Charleston.\nI'll be\n3\nthere Friday and Saturday.\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n22\nMR. ACKERMAN: This Friday and Saturday.\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY:\nYeah, this Friday\nand Saturday. And so, if you get it there on\nFriday, what I can do is sign it and send it\nback to you.\nMRS. SANCHEZ: And you'll e-mail us whatever\nit is?\nSPECIAL MASTER CARNEY: I'll e-mail it\nfirst so that you have it. The easiest way\nthat's going to be fairly quick, if you can Fed\nEx it up with a return package so I can get it\nright back to you. But it's the French Quarter\nInn is the name of the place.\nThat's\nCharleston, South Carolina. And then I'll skip\nit right back to you.\nThen what I'll do is try and get a quick\ninterim report out this afternoon so that you\nactually have one this afternoon so you can work\non it.\nAnything else that needs to be addressed?\nMR. SCAROLA: No, sir. Thank you.\nMR. KNIGHT: Not at this time. Thank you\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 99\nEFTA00621586\n", "char_count": 1067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "for your time.\nMR. ACKERMAN: No, Your Honor.\n(THEREUPON, the meeting concluded at 12:15\n1\n2\n3\n4\np.m.)\n5\n6\n7\n8\n6\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nPage 100\nEFTA00621587\n", "char_count": 220}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "Page 101\nI, Lee Lynott, Certified Shorthand Reporter and\n1\nREPORTER'S CERTIFICATE\n2\nSTATE OF FLORIDA\n)\n3\nCOUNTY OF BROWARD\n)ss\n)\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\nRegistered Merit Reporter in and for the County of\nBroward, State of Florida, do hereby certify:\nThat said meeting was taken before me at the\ntime and place set forth and was taken down by me in\nshorthand and thereafter reduced to computerized\ntranscription under my direction and supervision, and\nI hereby certify the foregoing is a full, true and\ncorrect transcript of my shorthand notes so taken.\nI further certify that I am neither counsel for\nnor related to any party to said action nor in\nanywise interested in the outcome thereof.\nIN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscribed\nmy name this 11th day of April 2011.\nLee Lynott, RMR, RPR\nNotary Public, State of Florida\nMY COMMISSION %23 DD996092\nEXPIRES: June 29, 2014\nNotary Public Underwriters\n25\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621588\n", "char_count": 992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "Page 102\nA\nability 16:14 37:2\n49:23 51:24 53:6\n53:12\nable 16:23 20:21\n24:15 27:1,2,13\n40:10,21 51:24\n53:7 60:9 62:5,6\n67:14 75:9,12\n77:9 78:14 84:8\n87:17 89:11,12\n90:4 91:3\nabsence 11:7 17:24\n18:15 65:15\nabsent 28:24 30:21\nabsolute 63:9\nabsolutely 8:22\n10:1 14:9 24:16\n35:11 46:2 52:14\n75:16 88:20\nabundantly 23:8\nabuse 15:13,15\n16:22 53:9\naccept 10:22 40:20\naccepted 21:22\naccepting 42:4\naccepts 14:20\naccess 36:18 37:3,5\naccompli 18:16\naccomplish 20:15\n20:16\naccomplished 4:20\naccord 84:10\naccountant 68:1\naccurate 8:15\nackerman 2:5 4:13\n11:23 12:4,4\n18:25 21:1,4,12\n22:9,16 24:23\n25:2 33:8 55:19\n55:21 56:7 57:24\n59:6 60:11 61:19\n61:23 62:20\n67:11 68:3 71:14\n75:5,9 77:2 79:17\n79:22 85:2,10\n89:16 90:15,24\n92:2,6,13 93:20\n93:24 95:23 96:8\n96:15,18 98:3,6\n98:13,15,20 99:4\n100:2\nackermans 5:17\n35:20\nacted 60:24\naction 8:24,25\n12:25 18:12\n33:20 101:14\nactions 50:25\nactual 7:1\nadam 68:22,23\nadd 19:1 30:24\n55:10,23 89:18\nadded 55:13,14\nadditional 25:3\n53:14 59:14\n75:13 77:3,13\n78:1\naddress 4:23,24\n10:11 20:5 39:2,3\n48:14 55:20 56:8\n57:24 79:19 90:4\naddressed 5:2\n19:10 20:8,22\n31:4 56:15 99:23\naddresses 43:10\naddressing 47:16\nadequate 23:11\n31:22 32:15 50:3\nadmissibility 13:11\nadopting 9:13\nadvance 21:20\n37:3 91:9,12\nadvanced 35:19\nadvancement\n53:24\nadversary 19:19\n53:25\nadverse 43:1\nadvising 18:9\nafternoon 99:20,21\nag 1:9\nagenda 3:15\nagents 28:14,17,21\n30:8\nago 4:11\nagree 6:7 7:3 9:6\n10:18 13:22 14:1\n14:8,21 15:4,10\n16:5 18:2,4 37:23\n38:13 45:6 62:11\n79:17 85:1,23\n90:9\nagreed 4:11 17:23\n39:24\nagreeing 15:20\nagreement 6:5\n17:25 18:15\n28:10 54:7,22\n56:2,3 65:16\n82:10\nagreements 6:3,4\nahead 45:20 98:10\nal 32:25\nalfredo 64:7\nalleging 81:23\nallow 10:1,20\n14:23\nallowed 32:2\nallows 29:2 32:17\n85:11\nalphabetical 87:20\nalternative 58:2,18\nalternatively 70:8\nanalysis 15:21\nandrews 2:10\nann 2:4\nanswer 5:12 44:7\n72:8\nanticipating 86:10\nanticipation 26:5\nanybody 65:5\nanywise 101:15\napparently 17:23\nappeal 16:3,7,8,15\n17:7,8\nappealed 16:16\nappeals 37:17\nappear 66:1\nappearances 2:3\nappears 34\n... [truncated, 3314 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/101 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=101]", "char_count": 3314}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "94:19 95:7,9,12\nattempted 41:10\nattempting 33:17\n39:1\nattention 27:4\nattorney 30:8\n33:14 34:11 74:5\nattorneyclient\n24:13 25:18,25\n35:14 38:2,23\n41:4 43:18 49:16\n75:24 76:12 89:6\nattorneys 26:8\n27:22 28:13,21\n33:24 74:3 94:3\nattributable 50:5\n93:8\naught 7:13 18:6\n49:4 62:14 74:17\n98:3\naugust 16:24\nauthor 43:23,25\nauthorities 54:18\nauthority 8:22\n55:6,16\navailable 43:15\n44:7 46:25 47:1\n86:21\navenue 1:24 2:6,10\naware 21:18 38:10\n66:7\nB\nback 5:17 13:4,18\n22:11 58:9 62:15\n63:15 82:16,22\n86:7 95:4 97:15\n99:8,15,18\nbackup 10:6 96:2\nbad 4:8 95:21\nbag 58:8\nbalance 53:2\nbankruptcy 7:9,9\n7:15 8:1,8,12\n10:4 18:14 19:15\n37:13 41:10\nbar 25:12\nbarkett 52:17\nbarnhart 1:18 2:12\nbarring 97:17\nbased 19:22 30:10\n33:16 39:11\n40:14 41:3 47:6\n48:21\nbasic 60:14\nbasically 7:7 22:23\n67:2 72:4\nbasis 8:7,16 27:7\n29:11 36:25\n46:13,15 52:4\n74:6 78:20 82:7\nbat 63:18 64:13\n65:7\nbates 46:22,23,24\n58:20 70:14 88:5\n88:6 91:13,15,21\n91:21 95:6\nbattles 74:19\nbattling 63:15\nbec 69:11 90:23\n91:1,6,14,18 92:8\nbecs 69:9 73:5\n87:22 88:9 89:18\nbes 88:11 90:13\nbeach 1:7,19,19\n2:13,13\nbegan 71:11\nbeginning 15:13\n86:7 87:16\nbehalf 24:24 35:19\n82:12\nbelieve 4:9,18 5:20\n8:14 20:5,14\n23:19 33:21\n34:17 40:18\n53:18 67:4\nbelieves 22:9 60:17\nbelong 49:20,20,21\n49:24\nbelongs 49:19\n50:12,22\nbest 9:1\nbetter 86:22 96:9\nPage 103\n71:19,23 73:7,14\n74:12,25 75:8,16\nbeyond 10:17\n32:16 37:9\nbig 75:19 93:1,3\n96:12\n90:7\nburnett 2:4\nbusiness 3:21\n31:25 32:6,21\nс\n78:4 79:21 80:3\n82:3,23 84:7,16\n85:9,22 86:3,20\n87:23 88:10,20\nbill 34:19\nbinding 7:17 8:2\n10:2,7,21 14:11\n14:24 15:22 16:8\n16:18\nbit 10:8 51:3 73:2\nblind 69:22 72:20\nblindcopy 91:24\nblock 93:16 96:14\nblood 52:19\nbook 34:21\nbootstrap 41:18\nbother 52:22\nbottom 47:4\nboulevard 1:19\n2:13\nbound 11:8 18:13\nboxes 34:2\nbrad 33:9,13 34:15\n35:2,6 49:9,11\n67:12,19,23 84:5\n95:25\nbradley 1:13 2:9\n12:11 50:18\nbreak 28:6\nbridge 57:12 70:20\nbrief 32:1,5 85:16\n85:19\nbriefed 82:19\nbriefly 56:7\nbring 83:18\nbrings 49:17\nbrought 4:2 19:2\n21:9 30:25 34:1\n97:24\nbroward 101:3,6\nbull 70:8\nbunch 17\n... [truncated, 3289 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/102 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=102]", "char_count": 3289}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "88:9,11 89:18\n90:13\ncentury 24:4 31:25\n32:6,21\ncertain 26:12 29:4\n46:17 56:22\n71:24 80:11\ncertainly 3:5,15\n5:19 28:17 32:14\n41:23 46:19\n68:10\n48:6 49:25 55:1\n55:16 56:1 78:4\n83:11\nciv 1:8\ncivil 28:24 29:9\n32:20 48:3 54:19\n54:21 65:10\nclaim 24:23 25:4\n27:3,24 29:13,15\n30:10 49:13\n60:13 61:12\ncertificate 101:1\n77:11 82:8\ncertified 1:23\n101:4\ncertify 101:6,11,13\ncetera 17:6 35:15\nchallenge 44:22,25\n45:14,17,17\n46:15 52:5 83:7,8\n85:14\nchallenges 44:21\nchance 85:19\ncharacterization\n35:23\ncharleston 99:2,17\nchase 56:17\ncheck 70:12 93:15\n95:4,5\nchild 82:13 84:4,6\nchildmolester\n35:20\nchoice 13:13\nchoices 37:21\nchoose 9:24,25\nchris 12:7,8\nchristopher 2:5\ncircuit 1:6,7 10:20\ncircumstance 43:1\ncircumstances\n26:9,12 28:14\n36:16 39:3 42:18\n42:23 47:8 50:15\n54:3\ncitation 32:5\ncited 24:3 28:5\n29:2 31:25 36:8\nclaimant 49:10\nclaimed 23:9 24:12\n26:19 27:23 30:3\n31:15,16 33:10\n35:15 45:11\n53:15\nclaiming 24:18\n29:11 30:7,15\n38:1 60:1 78:17\n78:18,20 88:13\nclaims 25:3 54:6\n54:19 82:12\n85:20\nclarification 49:4\nclarify 39:22\nclear 10:1 13:22\n22:1 23:8 46:21\n76:21,25 83:4,5\n92:7\nclearly 4:7 30:4,5,9\n37:6 42:22\nclient 4:3 24:17,22\n25:20 33:22\n34:16 35:13,20\n49:9,12,12,19\n50:6,8,8,12,13\nclients 25:8 35:24\n50:9,10,17,19\nclinton 34:16,19,22\nclose 4:19\nclue 67:20\ncode 29:19 38:17\ncoffey 34:10\ncome 6:18 13:20\n17:5 20:18 60:25\n75:21 76:14 77:5\n78:22 79:10\n82:22 95:18\ncomes 74:22 79:10\ncoming 28:16 35:6\n82:16\ncomment 4:22\ncommission\n101:19\ncommit 85:4\ncommon 27:20\n28:3,9 53:20,22\n53:24,25 54:2,4\n54:17,22 55:2,24\n61:1 82:8\ncommuni 24:20\ncommunication\n25:11\ncommunications\n28:12 29:21 36:8\ncomparable 29:10\ncompel 18:8\ncompelling 18:17\ncomplaints 22:12\ncomplete 23:11\ncompletely 7:3\n26:11 32:4\ncompletes 56:6\ncomplex 1:8\ncomplied 23:24\n33:1 37:13\ncomply 23:4 32:19\n50:3,14\ncomputerized\n101:9\nconcern 41:7 61:5\n79:18 85:2\nconcerned 25:17\n70:3\nconcerning 54:8\nconcluded 100:3\nconduct 52:7 54:20\n62:5,12\nconferences 54:10\nconfidential 29:1,3\n29:5,9,16,24\n44:24 47:12,17\n47:20,25 48:5,7\n48:10 53:23 54:9\n54:11 57:\n... [truncated, 3281 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/103 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=103]", "char_count": 3281}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "credit 31:25 32:6\ncrime 59:4\ncriminal 29:15\n54:21\ncross 57:12 70:20\ncrossexamine 83:7\n83:8\ncrow 5:22,24 6:9\n6:14,24 7:7,7,13\n7:14,22 8:5,16,17\n8:18,25 9:2,3,5,6\n11:13,16 12:23\n13:2,7,10,13 16:1\n16:1,13 17:7\n18:10,13,16 19:4\n20:16 21:3\ncrows 16:17 17:8\ncull 86:24,25\nculled 81:17\nculling 72:2\ncustody 39:4\ncut 56:16\ncutstraighttothe...\n57:3\nᎠ\ndaily 74:6\ndate 1:17\nday 62:24 71:12,16\n74:9 86:11,12,16\n95:21 96:14\n97:16 101:17\ndays 42:1,1 71:20\n83:2\ndea 32:8 36:7\ndd996092 101:19\ndeal 42:18 93:12\ndealing 51:14,15\n69:21 72:18,19\n84:9,12\ndeals 29:19 57:17\ndealt 74:2,6,8\n78:13\ndean 34:20\ndecide 7:10 39:7\n55:5,6 75:22 76:2\n82:21\ndeciding 8:18 9:19\ndecision 4:17 9:23\n11:15 13:11\n14:10,11 16:4\n65:1\ndecisionmaking\n5:21\ndecisions 8:3 16:2\ndefective 39:18\ndefects 35:18 63:4\ndefendant 29:7\n40:12,19 54:20\n64:25 78:8\ndefendants 1:15\n29:13\ndefense 17:21 27:7\n27:20,23,25\n28:15 29:7 40:4,6\n40:9 45:24 49:11\n53:16,17,19 56:1\n58:4 75:21\ndeferred 7:24 9:4\ndeficiencies 17:13\ndeficient 22:19\n56:23\ndefines 23:11\ndelay 6:17,21 22:4\n22:20 40:11 57:2\ndelivered 94:8\ndemonstration\n26:13,13\ndenney 1:18 2:12\ndepending 86:9\ndepends 71:20\ndeposition 34:1\n36:24 64:7,18\n65:9,10 66:13,14\n72:6,6 80:12,13\n94:20,25 95:13\ndepositions 64:20\ndescribe 61:25\ndescribed 14:7\n25:19 30:13\n43:21 44:4\ndescribing 25:22\ndesignate 93:24\ndetail 32:18\ndetermination\n3:16 5:9 7:23\n26:24 31:1 36:11\n43:2,4,6 45:8,16\n46:3 48:1,19\n51:21,25 55:8\n64:8 65:22 66:11\n67:6 72:5 76:10\n76:17 82:1,14\n89:11\ndeterminations\n43:9\ndeterminative\n86:18\ndetermine 6:14\n23:13,17 24:7,19\n26:18 44:10\n47:19 53:10 57:9\n58:25 59:3 64:11\n70:19\ndetermined 36:7\n56:14 77:25\n85:21\ndetermining 7:25\n58:21 70:15\n85:20 90:11\ndidnt 36:21,22\n74:7 94:4,7,10,11\n94:14 95:12\ndifferent 6:18 7:21\n89:12\ndifficult 57:1\ndifficulty 11:11\ndirect 27:4 41:21\ndirected 39:18\n41:13 44:2,3\ndirecting 32:24\ndirection 37:13,14\n101:10\ndirections 38:19\ndirectly 66:19\ndisadvantage\n73:25\ndisagree 9:7 40:23\ndisagreement\n39:14\ndisclosure 45:4\n57:16,17 78:25\n79:11 80:15,17\ndiscoverability 5:4\n\n... [truncated, 3402 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/104 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=104]", "char_count": 3402}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "84:7 86:11 89:24\n90:1 92:6,9,17,22\n95:9,13 97:16\ndownside 18:20,21\ndramatically 84:24\ndriving 97:5\ndropoff 97:10\ndue 19:16 20:12\n22:21\ndueling 13:15\nduties 5:13\neliminates 16:13\n59:5\neliminating 35:23\nemail 33:20 34:5\n34:14 69:23\n90:11 93:9 94:17\n98:11 99:9,11\nemails 27:6 35:2\n69:7,8,22 71:8,9\n71:11 72:19 90:6\n93:19 94:17\nenable 24:10 59:16\n60:20\nE\nearlier 12:1 30:25\nended 40:5\n97:6\nensure 89:8\nearly 86:11 97:8,13 enter 20:3 21:17\n97:16\neasier 57:19 58:24\neasiest 99:12\neasy 6:11 67:18\neconomical 83:22\nedwards 1:13 2:8,9\n12:12,15 23:2,18\n27:6 30:1 32:11\n32:25 34:8 35:3,6\n36:18,21 37:21\n38:11 41:13\n49:10,11,20,22\n50:18 67:12,19\n67:23 68:18 71:7\n73:12,24 84:6\n94:6,16 95:11\n96:20\nefficient 68:11\n87:18 90:5\neffort 26:17 28:5\n41:12\negregious 50:16\neight 4:21 62:18\neither 3:16 5:11\n69:15 70:24\n75:23 79:5 84:13\n95:11\nelements 24:14\n55:10,12,14,25\neliminated 70:24\n83:25\n33:3\nentered 6:23 19:4\n19:22 39:16,24\nentire 23:15 41:9\n59:21\nentirely 40:15\nentirety 10:24\n35:10 72:6\nentitled 24:5 27:10\n49:14 53:22\nentrap 34:17\nentries 47:16 56:23\n56:24 66:25 67:1\n73:10 75:22,23\n76:4 86:15,16\nentry 22:24 47:17\n56:20 59:21\n67:19\nenvision 70:11\nenvisioning 71:24\n75:17 86:23\nepstein 1:10 4:8\n49:10,13,14 54:6\n54:9,15 74:2\n82:12,13 84:5\nepsteins 34:22\n36:13 56:2\nesquire 2:4,5,5,9\n2:12\nessentially 67:3\nestablish 25:25\n27:18 45:24 61:3\n76:23 78:8,10,14\n78:19,23,24 79:2\n79:8,9,16 81:11\n81:14\nestablished 27:8\n28:2 34:1 36:1\n78:16 79:19,23\nestablishing 27:22\n29:8 46:12\nestablishment\n28:19 30:21\net 17:6 32:25 35:15\nevaluate 24:11\neverybody 86:4\n89:19 92:14\n93:10\nevidence 29:6,19\n38:17 72:3,19\n76:20 79:7\nevidentiary 70:22\n71:25 72:1,15\n80:9 81:10 82:24\n83:25 84:20,23\nex 99:14\nexactly 7:10 42:2\n47:10 76:22\n78:16,17 83:16\nexamination 35:10\nexamine 36:24\nexamined 38:17\nexample 28:12\n30:7 33:8 44:24\n47:12 57:6 61:7\n64:3 66:13 67:11\n72:5 73:10 77:13\n79:1,24 80:1 84:1\n88:12\nexamples 33:7\n35:8 56:24\nexception 78:2,24\n81:14,15\nexceptions 70:21\nexchange 82:11\nexclusion 80:6\nexclusively 13:6\n41:4\nexcuse 5:22 \n... [truncated, 3258 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/105 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=105]", "char_count": 3258}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "Page 107\nfill 13:17\nfinal 8:24 13:10\n14:25 85:16\nfinancial 2:6\nfind 65:11 66:22\n76:7 95:9\nfinder 51:23\nfinding 33:3 76:4\nfindings 9:7,13\n11:4 26:24 76:3\nfinds 24:5\nfine 22:1 63:24\n85:9 96:24 97:3\nfinish 79:20 97:7\nfirm 23:18 33:16\n33:24 34:12\n67:25 68:17 91:4\n92:5\nfirst 3:14 16:21\n19:2 22:17 36:6\n41:12 42:17 45:7\n64:5,6 79:16 80:5\n80:24 81:6,16\n87:8 94:23 99:12\nfistos 2:8\nfitness 32:7\nfive 86:17 87:11\n11:25\nfla 1:8\nflexibility 96:4\nfloor 2:6\nflorida 1:7,19 2:7\n2:10,13 29:18,19\n30:19 31:24 32:8\n32:19 42:21\n52:16,18,25\n59:11 101:2,6,19\nfocus 39:10 51:4\nfollow 14:6,15\nfollowed 14:16\n21:17\nfollowing 3:2\n17:25 76:19\n85:23\nforegoing 101:11\nforever 69:24\n74:18\nforgotten 42:1\nform 98:13,21\nformally 67:22\nformer 52:16\nformulate 60:12\nfort 1:25 2:7,10\nforth 31:15 62:15\n63:15 91:25\n101:8\nforward 16:25\n38:6 96:3\nfound 32:3 50:2,9\n50:15\nfour 32:24 63:14\n87:10\nfowler 2:4\nfraud 59:4\nfree 14:7\nfrench 99:2,15\nfriday 99:3,4,5,7\nfront 7:6,8 13:8\n18:10,16 37:2\n46:6 64:13 65:8\n66:20 82:6,15\n91:20\nfruition 6:4\nfull 94:24 101:11\nfully 61:7\nfundamental 35:18\n49:18\nfurther 14:22\n15:11 70:22\n101:13\nfuture 20:8\ngee 65:8\nG\ngeneral 25:21 28:7\ngenerally 11:7\n57:17\ngeneric 30:17\ngenerically 66:10\ngetting 18:9 89:20\n92:15\ngirls 74:5\ngive 11:6 21:19\n33:8 43:19 47:3\n51:23 52:7 64:10\n65:5,12,17 66:14\n68:21 83:3 87:4\n87:19 90:20,21\n93:11\ngiven 23:3 24:1\n26:22 31:20 40:9\n46:18 52:6 89:22\nglossed 59:7\ngo 5:19 10:5,17\n12:2 13:4 14:22\n16:3 17:1,20\n18:18 19:13\n22:11 24:8 33:13\n38:18 59:1 62:15\n64:4 65:24 68:12\n69:23 70:5 71:4\n76:8 80:25 81:25\n82:25 83:2 86:16\n88:7 89:20 95:3\n96:3 98:10\ngoes 4:2 16:10,15\n20:4 41:5 91:24\n91:25 92:1\ngoing 7:11 11:2,12\n14:2 19:13 20:9\n25:4 27:1,2 33:25\n47:11 48:5,13,14\n61:23 62:5,6,10\n63:10,13 64:25\n65:20,21 66:9,18\n66:19,20 67:14\n69:18,19 70:1,7\n71:21 72:11,16\n72:21 73:16,17\n73:19 74:18,19\n75:5,6,10,14 77:2\n77:5,5,7,9,14\n78:2,19 81:3,6,10\n81:13,25 83:1,15\n83:19,22 84:3\n85:4 86:12,13,15\n86:18 87:8,10,12\n87:19,23 88:4,18\n89:14,23,24\n90:19,21,22 91:2\n91:5,7,11,17,18\n92:11,18 95:\n... [truncated, 3255 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/106 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=106]", "char_count": 3255}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "Page 108\nid 87:4\nidea 59:12 68:1\n83:5 87:5 98:8\nideally 12:25 81:18\n93:15\nidentical 54:6,20\nidentification\n23:16 24:17\n25:10 30:5 59:23\n59:24 60:1\nidentified 25:8\n27:5 28:21 29:25\n30:12,14 79:25\nidentifies 43:24\n45:12 82:6\nidentify 23:22 25:6\n32:17 49:11\n61:13 66:10\nidentifying 35:11\n35:12 61:15\n62:21\nidentity 29:4 33:12\n48:4,11 49:15\nill 13:17 66:21\n80:25,25 88:6\n96:21 97:24\n98:10,11,15,18\n99:2,11,17,19\nillustrate 64:4\nillustrating 77:16\nim 3:5 5:9,17 6:7\n6:20 7:4,6,12 9:4\n9:9,13 10:25 11:1\n11:2,11,25 12:17\n15:20,24,25 16:4\n16:4,16,17 18:13\n20:25 21:4,5,13\n21:18 26:20 38:9\n38:10,23 39:1,13\n40:20,23 41:17\n41:20 42:6,6\n44:12,13,15\n47:10,11,22 48:5\n48:14 51:4,14,15\n56:17,18 57:14\n57:18 61:4,9,15\n62:10,10,11,13\n62:17 63:21 64:1\n64:22 66:7,17,19\n66:24 67:10\n68:25 69:18 70:3\n70:15,23 71:1,23\n72:1,4,9 73:14,21\n74:14,15 75:17\n76:4 77:14 79:17\n79:18,21 80:1,3,6\n80:7,10 81:16\n83:3,20,24 84:15\n84:16,22 86:5,7,9\n86:23 87:6,9 88:4\n88:21,23 90:8,11\n90:20,24 91:10\n91:12,12,20 92:2\n92:7,7,23 93:14\n95:1,15 96:10,11\n96:24 97:5 98:9\nimagine 73:13\nimpact 8:2\nimpacts 91:8\nimpermissible\n37:9\nimplied 42:20\nimportant 17:15\n49:18 59:7 69:9\n69:11\nimpose 39:8\nimposed 55:15\nimpossible 30:6\nimpressions 26:9\n26:10\ninability 26:14\ninaccurate 19:16\ninactions 50:25\ninadequacies\n45:25\ninadequacy 44:4\ninadequate 32:4\n58:3\nincamera 43:14\n44:10,19 45:15\n45:21,25 46:10\n46:13,17 47:18\n47:23 48:22 52:6\n52:7 55:13 57:4\n57:20 58:24 60:6\n62:23,25 63:8,11\n63:16,22 65:4,4\n66:2,6,7,10 67:3\n68:4,8,8 69:3\n80:5,24 83:21\n84:18,23,25\ninclined 83:3 90:8\nincluded 95:7\nincluding 10:19\n19:9 34:22\ninclusion 80:6\ninconsistent 12:20\nindependent 8:7\n8:11 51:23\nindicated 5:18\n8:23 32:10 86:4\nindicates 15:9\n29:17 38:7\nindicating 49:2\nindication 4:7\n15:11\nindividual 93:8\nindividually 1:13\n1:13,14\nindividuals 34:3\ninformally 21:23\ninformant 29:6,9\n29:14\ninformants 29:1,4\ninformation 5:4\n24:10 26:5,16\n27:12 35:5 43:8\n44:23 45:1 48:8,8\n48:12 51:20\n53:23 54:8,12,13\n54:23,24 59:16\n60:14,19 67:4,7\n67:10 68:3 69:10\n75:14 77:10,14\n78\n... [truncated, 3430 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/107 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=107]", "char_count": 3430}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "johnson 68:16,20\n73:11,23\njoins 11:19\njoint 27:7,20,23\n28:3,9,15 53:16\n53:17,19\njones 67:13,15\njoseph 2:5\njudge 4:16 5:19,22\n5:22,24 6:1,9,11\n6:14,15,17,24 7:1\n7:7,7,13,14,15,18\n7:18,22,25,25 8:5\n8:13,16,17,17,18\n8:25 9:2,3,3,4,5,6\n10:20 11:5,7,12\n11:13,14,16\n12:23 13:1,4,6,7\n13:8,10,13 16:1,1\n16:13,17,20 17:7\n17:8 18:10,13,14\n18:16 19:4,8,18\n19:21 20:4,16\n21:3 39:16,21,23\n43:5 70:17 96:1\n98:1,17\njudges 12:18,19\n13:15 43:5\njudicial 1:6\njuly 4:15\njune 101:20\njurisdiction 19:8\n19:15,23,24\njustice 52:17\nK\n6:16,22 12:7,7\n13:16 16:20\n17:19 21:8 33:7\n68:10 86:2 87:14\n87:21 88:16\n95:19 96:10,21\n97:10,15 98:8\n99:25\nknow 21:16 22:8\n25:14,20,23\n32:12 33:12,14\n33:25 34:16 35:1\n36:21,22 42:5\n46:19 48:18\n49:14 53:5 57:7\n60:5,23,24 61:8\n61:23 66:8,18,20\n67:21 69:5 71:25\n73:22 74:4,9,10\n74:17 77:8,9,19\n78:16 81:3,6\n82:18 87:1 89:4\n89:19 90:3,3,16\n91:7,19 92:4,17\n92:19 95:3 97:16\nknowing 27:15,16\n34:6 67:15 85:5\nknowledge 39:11\nknows 12:3 39:5\nkretschmar 34:20\nL\nlack 30:4\nlakes 1:19 2:13\nlanguage 52:21\nlarge 93:2\nkatherine 67:20,20 late 32:4\n67:21,23 68:1,15\n80:22 81:4 82:7,8\n83:7,8,18 84:4\n85:6\nkathy 74:4\nkept 54:9\nkid 97:10\nkind 5:7 6:5 89:22\nkinds 9:15 57:2\nknight 2:5 4:1,14\nlatest 97:18\nlauderdale 1:25\n2:7,10\nlaw 23:8,18 26:23\n29:2,17,18 31:13\n31:24 37:16 38:3\n38:6 41:2,5 42:21\n51:24 52:25\n53:21 55:1 58:16\n59:15 62:3 67:25\n84:20 91:4\nlawyer 26:10 29:22\n29:25\n80:18,21,23 81:5\n81:11,22 84:13\n85:7\nlawyers 36:13 54:5 little 10:8 39:15\n56:2\nlay 76:24 83:20\nleaves 9:11\nlee 1:22 101:4,18\nleft 7:16 42:13\n58:25\nlegal 18:17 25:15\n29:11,18 48:2\n77:21 84:9,17,19\n86:17 88:21,22\nlegally 22:21\nlehrman 2:8\nlengthen 84:24\nlengthy 31:21\nletter 4:10 5:17,18\n5:21 34:15 59:22\n67:12\nletters 69:7\nlieu 43:11\nlilly 2:4 12:9,10\n96:23\nlinder 34:24\nline 40:1 47:4\nlinebyline 57:21\nlist 23:21 31:21\n68:14 73:15,16\n73:21 74:23 75:2\n85:24 86:3 87:15\n87:24 89:18,22\n90:21,23 91:2,2,7\n91:14 92:4,9,13\n93:1,3,9\nlisted 22:23 24:14\n29:1 47:14 67:22\nlisting 34:10 68:15\n68:20\nlists 30:20\nlitigant 50:7\nlitigation 1:8 26\n... [truncated, 3427 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/108 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=108]", "char_count": 3427}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "Page 110\nobtained 26:5,15\n51:2,12 55:22\n56:16 57:23 58:1\n58:19 60:7 61:4\n61:21 62:9,22\n63:25 64:3,6,22\n65:19 66:5 67:9\n67:18 68:6,12,14\n68:19,22 69:16\n71:10,15,19,23\n73:7,14,21 74:12\n74:25 75:2,8,16\n78:4 79:21 80:3\n82:3,23 84:7,16\n85:9,22,24 86:3,3\n86:20 87:15,23\n88:10,20 89:18\n90:8,19,21 91:10\n92:3,4,12,22 93:9\n95:17 96:6,13,23\n96:25 97:4,12,19\n97:25 98:5,7,9,14\n98:16,25 99:5,11\nmasters 14:16\nmaterial 29:6\n43:17 45:11\nmateriality 39:8\nmatter 6:10 19:2\n20:4 21:6,7,10\n22:6 34:7 35:25\n64:24\nmatters 3:4 19:18\n20:2 28:5 54:14\nmean 59:13 64:10\n69:20 72:20 95:1\n95:3\nmeaningful 32:18\n60:12 62:6,7,12\n73:3\nmeans 11:13 22:8\n66:7\nmediation 96:17\nmeet 33:2 50:8,10\n78:13 97:1\nmeeting 1:3 3:2,7\n100:3 101:7\nmeets 47:20\nmember 25:12\nmemo 44:24 52:12\n55:9 82:20 85:7\nmemorandum\n22:17 61:15,16\n61:17 62:3\nmemorandums\n31:3\nmental 26:8\nmentioned 12:16\n31:4 73:11\nmerit 1:22 101:5\nmerits 17:10 18:5\nmet 46:9 54:2 61:2\nmethod 58:18\n85:20\nmiddle 97:1\nmini 95:1\nminute 64:11\nmisconduct 50:25\nmisled 74:1\nmissed 13:18 55:20\n74:23\nmissing 67:5\nmixed 84:19\nmodifies 14:20\nmodify 39:22\nmolestation 36:2\nmoment 11:12\n47:9 51:15\nmomentum 6:25\nmonday 86:7\n95:22\nmonths 4:21 32:4\n62:19 63:14 70:6\nmorning 11:24\n12:6,13 71:12\nmove 16:25 42:24\n63:2,7,7 87:18\n91:9\nmultiple 35:18\n42:16\nN\nname 16:3 47:24\n74:22 88:14 92:9\n92:10 93:11\n98:19 99:16\n101:17\nnamed 29:20 73:9\n87:24 88:1\nnames 73:5,8,18\n73:18,20 90:15\nnarrow 51:5 73:3\n81:2\nnarrowed 81:19\nnature 19:11\nnecessarily 6:4,7\n7:4 10:25 15:19\n16:5 40:8,23\n57:18 61:6 65:3\n73:15 83:21\n91:13\nnecessary 55:11\n57:9 67:7\nnecessity 38:8\nneed 3:12 4:3,18\n5:24 17:14,16,19\n26:13 33:5,11\n39:22,22 43:20\n43:22,25 51:20\n53:8,11 56:11\n57:20 61:12\n65:21 73:3 75:9\n75:14 77:8,9,10\n77:23 78:1 83:10\n83:15 85:10 87:6\n87:16,21 89:9\n91:7 92:17,19\n98:1\nneeded 83:14\nneeds 3:10 22:15\n28:1 44:11 99:23\nneglects 59:9\nneither 101:13\nnever 46:24 72:21\nnevertheless 40:25\n91:16\nnew 40:14 70:4,5\nnice 86:10\nnonapplicability\n87:11\nnonconfidential\n90:13\nnonprivilege 89:1\nnormally 41:2\n70:10\nnos 89:1\n\n... [truncated, 3233 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/109 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=109]", "char_count": 3233}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "19:9,22 20:15\n23:9 25:25 38:1,4\n38:15 39:16,17\n39:18,20,22,23\n39:24,25 40:2\n41:3 43:8 50:23\n53:13 57:1 77:10\norders 13:15 19:11\n32:13,24 64:24\nordinarily 11:4\n14:15 45:22\nparing 69:2\nparse 74:16\npart 5:20 13:17\n15:15 16:4 18:18\n20:23 23:18\n27:13,17 30:1\n34:17 51:8 61:5\n77:20 89:17 91:4\nparticipants 28:8,9\nparticipate 28:23\nparticular 7:5 18:7\n50:15 57:5 59:5\noriginal 76:16\noriginally 39:16\n68:7 78:12 79:14\n68:13\noriginating 92:14\nos 63:1\noutcome 101:15\noutlined 52:1\noutset 8:23\noutside 23:19\n25:16 35:1 45:3\n67:25 69:13\n78:25\noutstanding 19:11\noutweighed 53:11\noverbreadth 38:21\n41:1,1,15,22\n42:12 56:13\noverbroad 37:22\n37:24 38:11\novercome 44:5\n52:5\noverlooked 41:8\nP\npackage 99:14\npage 33:5,9,13,19\n33:23 34:10,14\n34:23 35:4 44:14\n45:5 52:19 64:4\npalm 1:7,19,19\n2:13,13\npaper 66:19\nparalegal 68:17\n92:5\nparaphrasing\n56:18\n83:5 89:10 90:11\nparticularities\n45:13\nparticularized\n26:23\nparticularly 5:24\n24:4 28:16,20,25\n50:16 84:11\nparties 13:25 14:7\n15:21 19:19\n23:12,16 24:11\n27:13 30:4,9\n33:18 36:9 45:13\n46:11 57:4,18\n59:17 60:8,9,21\n80:16,17\nparts 26:3\nparty 23:9 26:15\n28:24 39:4 43:1\n52:2 79:12 85:7\n101:14\npassing 28:16\npatently 39:17\npath 75:6\npause 37:18 44:13\npending 8:1\npeople 27:5,9,10\n30:5,15 34:19,21\n35:12 60:23\n62:21 68:15 74:2\n74:10 79:6,25\n85:5 89:23 91:1,8\n91:11 93:4 97:10\npercent 15:20\nperfect 62:17\n63:15 72:17,21\n75:18\nperiod 4:6 21:20\n29:5 74:3 87:5\npersistently 37:6\nperson 24:19 25:11\n28:2 29:21 30:13\n49:15 59:25\n74:24 77:19\n91:15\npersons 48:12\n53:21 82:11\nphotograph 61:14\n62:2\npick 74:25 77:14\n97:12\npile 77:24\npillar 62:15\nplace 1:18 3:2\n38:19 99:16\n101:8\nplaced 18:15\nplaintiff 1:11 4:10\n9:18,20 15:2\n17:24 49:1,2 58:4\n58:13 61:5 62:16\n69:19 72:23,24\n83:4\nplaintiffs 27:25\nplan 76:17 97:22\nplane 34:22\nplay 3:15 6:13,15\nplayers 68:14 73:5\n73:8 74:21 91:17\nplaza 2:6\npled 36:1\npm 1:17\npoint 4:17 5:16\n9:12 15:25 17:16\n18:11 20:1,4\n22:12 23:20\n35:23 39:1 40:3\n40:12,18 41:20\n41:23 42:6,12\n44:20 47:17\n49:18 51:13\n52:12 56:25 58:7\n59:2 63:6 71:2\n75:13 76:2,9,14\n77:1\n... [truncated, 3292 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/110 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=110]", "char_count": 3292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "29:19 30:3,10,15\n30:17 31:22,23\n32:25 33:11\n34:13 35:7,14,14\n35:15 36:5,11\n37:11,14,15 38:2\n38:7,9,14,14,25\n39:19 41:3,4\n42:10,14,15,20\n43:3,11,18,20,22\n43:25 44:5,17,18\n44:21 45:2,3,10\n45:15 46:1,14,16\n47:20,21 48:3,9\n48:10,11,20,21\n49:3,5,6,16,19,23\n50:2,3,12,13,17\n50:19,20,20,22\n50:24 51:1,11,21\n51:22 52:3,5,10\n53:16,17,20,20\n54:2 55:4,11,24\n56:21 57:10,11\n57:16 58:11,14\n59:5,18 60:2,13\n60:22 62:17\n63:16 64:15\n66:23 67:15 69:5\n69:13,14,17,18\n69:21,24 70:1,4,4\n70:5,21 71:5\n72:10,22,24\n76:12,13 77:7,22\n78:9,9,11,17,21\n79:1,5,14 81:20\n81:21 82:7 83:6\n84:13 85:12,15\n85:20 88:25 89:4\n90:12\nprivileged 23:10\n26:11 28:11\n29:22 39:10\n43:18 45:9,11\n46:4,7 53:23\n58:22,22,25\n60:20 64:8,9,12\n64:12,18 65:10\n65:12,13,23 66:1\n70:12,13,15,25\n77:11 80:8,10,11\n80:14,14,15,20\n81:18 89:2,3\n91:22\nprivileges 30:20,21\n33:4 70:19 87:1\nprivity 28:15\npro 1:8\nprobably 3:14 5:15\n18:6 64:11,19\n70:23 71:12,12\n71:16 75:20\n84:17 87:7,10\nproblem 3:17,18\n7:5 10:9 11:3,15\n11:17,17 12:17\n12:21 33:19 40:5\n51:5,6,10,16,17\n59:19 68:7 74:14\n76:6 84:8 88:15\n90:10 92:23\nproblems 3:8,10\n3:11 17:5 39:23\nprocedure 14:21\n15:5 21:17 32:20\n42:24 44:15,17\n45:7 47:6 52:1\n59:2 76:9,19\n85:18,19\nproceed 5:6 18:23\n19:1 21:2 63:2\n75:6 77:11\nproceeding 6:19\n8:13,13 10:3,4,22\n11:20 13:25\n28:24 31:11 38:6\n41:9,14\nproceedings 3:24\n7:24 14:6,15 15:8\n15:14 19:20\n54:21 64:21\nprocess 5:21 15:13\n15:15 16:23 53:9\n82:5 95:16\nproduce 39:19\nproduced 30:23\n40:3\nproducing 46:10\nproduction 41:13\n43:12 55:13\n95:13\nprofessional 1:23\nproper 16:24\n22:20\nproperly 4:16,16\n5:2 19:3 21:7,11\n22:6,9 31:11\n64:17\nproperty 19:23\nproposal 15:7 59:9\nprosecuting 54:5\n54:18,19 82:12\nprotect 30:17 48:4\nprotected 60:20\n77:21 88:18\nprotection 59:18\n60:22\nprotective 30:11\n38:1,3,15 41:3\nprotects 52:13\nprove 95:14\nprovide 24:10 50:2\n50:11 67:7,10\n74:20\nprovided 32:14\n43:8,11 45:20\n52:23\nproviding 48:12\nprovision 59:11\npublic 64:21\n101:19,20\npull 95:19\npure 12:24\npurely 88:21,22\npurpose 25:21,22\n28:3 29:10 36:4\n46:14 51:22 62:8\npurposes 7:25\n54:11\npursuant\n... [truncated, 3272 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/111 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=111]", "char_count": 3272}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "regarding 33:20\n53:24\nregistered 1:22,23\n101:5\nregularlyschedu...\n54:10 65:9\nreject 10:23\nrejected 21:23,25\nrejection 15:7\nrejects 14:20\nrelated 34:7\n101:14\nrelates 25:18 26:4\n26:7 33:22\nrelating 19:11,17\n28:13 34:8,15\n35:3 44:8\nrelationship 23:12\n25:24\nrelative 17:5\nrelatively 40:1\n69:25 83:3,5,12\nrelease 47:24\nreleased 57:11\n81:12\nrelevancy 31:1,10\n39:7 41:15 71:2\nrelevant 29:6\n43:17 52:20\n56:14\nrely 31:18\nrelying 35:9\nremembered 36:17\nremotely 33:2\nrendering 25:15\nrenew 3:22\nrepeat 60:3\nrepeatedly 4:6\n21:22,22 36:8\nrepetitive 73:20\nreport 13:4 14:17\n14:20 98:6,7,11\n98:23 99:20\nreporter 1:22,23\n1:23 64:14,14\n65:9 66:3 101:4,5\nreporters 101:1\nreporting 1:24\nrepresentations\n8:5,15\nrepresented 50:22\n60:25 74:5\nrepresenting 84:4\n84:6\nrepresents 50:21\nrequest 3:11,12,22\n4:5 21:14 38:1,2\n39:21 41:13,18\n89:17,25\nrequested 5:5\n30:22\nrequesting 26:16\n92:7\nrequests 4:15 8:12\nrequire 15:23 38:8\n42:14 46:16\n58:14 62:4 70:21\n86:13\nrequired 36:6\n60:15 61:7\nrequirement 5:6\n36:10 59:8 60:15\n60:16\nrequirements\n22:18 23:5 32:19\n33:2 54:1 55:10\n59:23\nrequires 26:23\n41:19 53:1 59:15\n84:20\nrequiring 28:4\n87:15\nresolution 3:12 6:9\n15:3 18:8,9\nresolve 9:1 38:24\n62:23 63:17 84:8\n84:17,21\nresolved 14:24\n15:4 18:6 20:11\n38:5\nrespect 7:13 19:16\n20:12 72:23\nrespectfully 7:20\n27:4 77:24 89:17\nrespond 46:8\n55:21\nresponse 3:25\n35:16 56:6\nresponses 4:12\n42:16\nresult 32:23\nresults 31:23\nreturn 99:14\nreveal 58:12,14\nrevealed 58:7\nrevealing 25:22\n60:19\nreview 20:17 47:2\n48:22 62:6,12\n70:16,17,18\n79:20 89:20\nreviewing 17:16\nrey 4:16 5:20,22\n6:11,17 7:1,25,25\n8:13,17 9:3,4\n11:12,14 13:5,7,8\n19:8,18,21 20:4\n39:16,21,24\n70:17 98:1\nright 3:4 6:8,24,25\n7:12 9:5 11:3,11\n11:15 13:20\n20:13 30:12,18\n31:14,19 36:23\n38:10 40:1 45:23\n48:25 51:14\n52:11,13 53:1,2,3\n53:4,7,10 58:2\n63:18 64:11,11\n64:13,19 65:16\n65:18 67:2,17\n68:18 73:14\n74:14 76:11 80:4\n81:22 82:6 83:25\n87:23 91:3 92:12\n92:23 99:15,18\nrights 10:19,20\n17:6 30:11\nrings 10:12 11:18\nrmr 101:18\nroad 51:3 63:12\nrobert 1:3 12:14\nrodriguez 64:7\nrole 6:9 11\n... [truncated, 3306 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/112 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=112]", "char_count": 3306}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "scott 1:13\nse 1:24\nsearcy 1:18 2:12\nsecond 10:7 16:21\n23:3,5 37:19\n39:24,25 44:13\n56:17 58:6 75:10\n81:2,8,9 87:6,7\n89:13,14\nsecretary 67:24\n73:12,23\nsection 30:19\nsee 3:8 4:1 9:19\n11:3 18:1,17,19\n18:20 22:13\n24:15 33:5 35:9\n66:9 70:6 80:4,16\n85:13,22 86:10\n89:11 91:3 92:8\n92:11,18 94:4,14\n95:9,13,17\nseeing 6:4 7:12\n11:11 12:17\n57:14 72:9 74:14\n87:7\nseeking 19:19 43:1\n45:14 46:11 52:3\n61:6\nseeks 23:9 55:9\nseen 61:3\nsees 40:22\nsend 98:15,21 99:7\nsending 34:5\nsends 27:12\nsense 77:3\nsent 31:9 59:22\n85:6\nseparate 38:2\n72:14\nseries 38:4\nserve 10:16 36:4\nserved 29:11\nservice 52:19\nservices 25:15\nset 31:14 37:16\n44:16 70:18\n72:13 75:10\n96:17 97:20,21\n101:8\nsettled 31:21\nseven 4:21\nshare 53:22\nshared 54:4,8,17\n54:23,24 82:8,10\nsharing 54:11\nsheer 27:5\nshift 76:14\nshifting 52:2\nshipley 1:18 2:12\nshorter 87:8\nshorthand 1:23\n101:4,9,12\nshouldnt 81:24\nshow 52:4\nshowing 45:24\n66:8 76:11 83:14\nshown 24:15\nshows 35:4\nside 22:5 44:21\n62:13 63:5,19\n75:21\nsides 57:22,23\n62:14 63:5 66:7\n84:10\nsign 98:22 99:7\nsignature 98:18\nsigned 98:23\nsignificant 17:13\n55:10\nsignificantly 86:24\n86:25\nsignoff 16:19\nsimilar 33:19\n59:11\nsimple 19:6 20:6\nsimply 9:13 12:17\n47:7 61:12 62:25\n75:23 80:13\nsimultaneously\n54:5\nsingle 24:22 56:20\n74:9 91:15\nsir 77:24 99:24\nsit 65:1,21 70:9,9\n83:15 88:6\nsituation 43:10,12\n59:3\nsituations 57:15\nsix 4:21 32:16\n62:18\nskip 99:17\nskipped 45:20\nsmith 91:25 92:4,8\nsmokescreen 17:11\nsoandso 90:2,2\nsolution 12:22\nsomebody 16:2\n74:8 95:14\nsomebodys 74:22\nsomewhat 6:13\n41:20 73:25 74:1\n75:18\nsoon 97:14\nsooner 63:12 86:22\nsorry 11:25 26:20\nsort 23:21 63:12\nsought 8:8 37:7,8\n50:7\nsource 29:16,20,24\n33:9,10 35:4\n44:25 47:12,17\n47:20,25 48:7,10\n57:6,8 58:6,7,11\n58:12,15 66:17\n66:18,21 69:13\n88:13,14,17\n93:13\nsources 26:14 48:5\n49:3,5\nsouth 52:18 99:17\nsoutheast 2:6\nspeak 4:3\nspeaking 52:17\nspecial 1:3 3:3,23\n3:25 4:9 5:8,10\n6:20 7:3 8:21\n9:14 10:3,6,16,25\n12:2,14,16,25\n13:19,24 14:1,6,9\n14:14,16,21,25\n15:8,19 16:9,18\n17:20 22:11\n24:21 25:1 35:16\n35:22 36:3 37:18\n39:13 40:8,15\n4\n... [truncated, 3289 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/113 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=113]", "char_count": 3289}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "sua 9:13\nsubject 22:20 34:6\n39:7 70:16,16,18\nsubmission 36:10\nsubmit 11:5 31:2\n62:3 98:16\nsubmitted 5:7\n82:20\nsubordinate 25:12\nsubpoena 8:10\n20:14 31:2,6,9\n34:18 36:14,16\n42:2,3\nsubpoenas 19:13\n20:8\nsubscribed 101:16\nsubsequent 76:17\nsubsequently 43:5\n48:13\nsubstance 42:25\nsuchandsuch\n91:14\nsufficient 22:21\n24:10 32:18 43:8\n45:13 55:3 59:16\n79:7 83:17\nsuggest 5:9 58:5\nsuggested 57:3\n68:13\nsuggesting 45:19\n51:13 83:24\n84:15\nsuggestion 21:5\n23:20 59:19\nsuggestions 3:5,6\nsuggests 82:24\nsuite 2:10\nsummarizes 22:17\nsupervision 101:10\nsupply 31:22\nsupport 26:24 48:7\n55:3 56:4\nsupports 58:16\nsupposed 17:11\nsupreme 52:16\nsure 6:7 7:4 11:1\n13:21 15:17,20\n16:5 20:25 38:23\n40:23 41:17 42:6\n44:13 47:10\n57:18 61:4,9,15\n62:11,17 69:18\n73:15 79:17,18\n83:21 88:20 95:4\n95:5\nsuspect 25:4\nswitches 81:13\nT\ntable 12:3 17:22\ntake 3:7 6:10 13:19\n14:3,5 58:3,8,13\n64:5 65:7 66:24\n67:19 70:8 71:4\n71:16,17,19 73:8\n75:1,6 83:1,10\n88:11 89:14\n94:11 95:12\ntaken 1:17 20:19\n64:13 101:7,8,12\ntalked 56:9 71:25\n72:1\ntalking 21:5,8,13\n79:15 80:1\ntalks 34:21\nteam 27:9,13,17\n30:1 33:16 77:21\n78:18 79:1,3,4,6\n79:7,8 80:18,21\n80:23 81:5,11,22\n84:13\ntechnology 32:8\nteleconference\n11:21\ntelephone 2:16\n10:12 11:18\ntell 25:13 30:6 44:2\n64:25 74:8,23\n75:13 77:16,17\n90:14,15 91:5,23\n91:24\ntells 42:17 43:23\n44:1\ntentatively 85:12\n97:20,21\nterms 25:20 39:25\n46:22 53:17\n58:22 73:15\n79:23,23 80:4\ntestify 83:19\ntestimony 34:20\n56:5\ntexas 96:11\nthank 11:24 35:17\n97:25 99:24,25\nthats 6:19 7:10\n8:19 10:7,8 15:16\n16:16 17:12 20:5\n20:10 21:4,13,14\n22:1,5 23:6 27:14\n27:25 30:1,3\n33:25 35:4,6,25\n38:9 44:11 45:2\n46:14 47:4 49:8\n51:12,21,22 60:8\n60:15 62:4,7\n64:12 67:14,18\n68:4 69:4,14,15\n72:8,11 78:15,21\n79:3 80:1 82:20\n83:1 84:15 85:9\n86:18,19 89:5,19\n90:17 91:25\n94:15 96:6 99:13\n99:16\ntheories 87:11\nthereabouts 73:19\nthereof 101:15\ntheres 28:1 33:19\n34:10,14,23 38:6\n59:3 61:2 69:9\n71:7 79:11,12,24\ntheyre 17:14 23:18\n23:19 25:3,4\n27:16 38:19\n43:15 51:13\n65:16 69:8 78:17\n78:19,20 79:19\n80:17,18,19,22\n81:7,10,23 87:2\n88:13 \n... [truncated, 3384 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/114 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=114]", "char_count": 3384}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "92:23 97:9\ntrial 48:13 53:1\n95:25 96:2\ntrim 68:8,9\ntroubled 42:7\ntrue 54:16 74:7\n101:11\ntrump 34:19\ntrustee 8:10 19:14\n19:14 31:7 36:20\n40:6,7,13 49:21\n49:22\ntry 66:21 68:8\n74:16 82:25 89:8\n97:15 99:19\ntrying 51:4 59:13\n62:16 63:15\n72:17 74:15\n84:22 95:19\ntuesday 1:17 85:23\n85:24\nturn 43:16 52:19\n94:9,10\nturned 43:13 53:13\n81:24 94:22\n95:12\ntwo 3:4,11 4:23\n20:2 24:1 25:2\n26:3 33:1 34:2\n62:24 74:6,9\n92:16\ntwostep 82:5\ntwoyear 74:3\ntype 28:22 29:12\n66:23 72:18\n75:15\nU\nultimately 5:15\n12:22 13:10 16:9\n16:15 17:21 18:1\n20:17 41:19\n51:25 56:17\n65:15 72:9 81:23\n83:14 87:9 89:7\nunderaged 74:5\nunderstand 10:10\n13:16 16:25\n17:21 21:25 41:7\n85:1 93:18\nunderstanding\n11:1,2 38:12\n44:15 47:10,22\n56:18 63:21\n77:23\nunderway 3:20\nunderwriters\n101:20\nundue 39:9\nunimaginable 84:2\nunique 36:16\nunited 1:24\nunpleasant 65:19\nunquestionably\n52:25\nunreasonable\n86:12\nunwieldiness\n69:25\nunwieldy 69:25\nupholding 85:12\nupside 18:19,21\nuse 47:11 58:5\nusually 52:1 64:20\n69:8 97:17\nV\nvalid 23:13 30:17\n45:18\nvariety 39:20\n41:16\nvarious 11:4 47:15\n47:16 64:16\nversion 95:2\nvictims 24:25\n50:21 82:13 84:4\n84:6\nview 9:1 15:25\n39:17 41:20\n56:25 75:24\n80:23\nviewing 5:9 16:17\n40:20\nvisavis 6:10\nvoluntarily 44:6\n45:20 46:9\nvs 1:12 32:7 52:18\nW\nwait 21:3 36:23\n63:14 97:21\nwaiting 9:18 18:1\nwaive 10:18 49:23\n50:13,18,19,20\n53:7 64:14\nwaived 33:4 41:24\n45:23 46:18\n50:25 75:7\nwaiver 24:7 27:14\n31:23 32:3 33:12\n34:12 35:7 42:20\n42:22,23 50:1,9\n50:17,23 51:10\n60:4 67:14 69:12\n77:18 78:3 79:24\n88:19\nwaivers 30:2 31:18\nwaives 42:12\nwaiving 85:8\nwant 3:21 4:23 7:1\n9:25 12:2 15:17\n15:17 16:2,24\n17:9,10 21:2 22:1\n30:24 56:7 60:3,8\n65:3,17 75:12\n83:6 92:13 97:1\n97:19 99:1\nwants 7:19 8:18\n17:1 21:2 70:17\nwashed 7:7\nwasnt 25:15\nway 11:1 15:4 18:8\n18:18 38:24\n39:15 53:23 58:8\n63:7,10,12,20\n66:5 70:6 82:22\n83:23 99:12\nways 7:21 41:5\nwednesday 88:2\nweek 75:3,4 85:24\n86:21 95:25 96:4\n96:9,10,11\nweeks 32:16\nweinberger 2:16\n11:19,22,24 12:6\n12:8,10,13\nweissing 2:8\nwent 7:6 31:6 69:6\n69:13 93:1\nwest 1:19 2:13\nweve 3:3 4:14 7:2\n... [truncated, 3152 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00621488/115 or ?id=EFTA00621488&page=115]", "char_count": 3152}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00621488", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "64:4\n10 1:17 42:1\n100 2:6 34:10\n75:22\n1156 32:8\n118 34:23\n11th 101:17\n12 1:17 100:3\n1201 1:8\n1218 1:24\n136 34:14\n138 33:23\n15 1:17 47:14\n66:25 67:1 71:4\n97:18,20,22\n100:3\n155 35:4\n15th 1:6\n16th 23:2\n17 66:25\n2\n22:10 67:19 71:7,9\n71:10,11 73:17\n73:18 82:25\n86:15,16 90:6\n31st 22:22 32:14\n33301 2:10\n33316 1:25\n33394 2:7\n33409 1:19 2:13\n35 1:17\n3rd 1:24 2:6\n496:6,7\n425 2:10\n4\n4th 17:8 32:2,8\n36:7 37:17 96:13\n96:15,16,17\n5\n525:8 59:10 96:4\n50 1:9 73:18\n501 30:19\n535 52:19\n6\n6th 96:18,19,20,25\nPage 117\n7\n75 75:23,25 76:6\n76 94:23\n91:16\n20 27:18\n8\n2005 32:9\n83 33:5,9\n2009ca040800xx...\n85 33:13\n1:9\n86 33:19\n2011 1:17 101:17\n87 33:23\n2014 101:20\n89 94:24\n21 74:5\n2139 1:19 2:13\n9\n21st 2:6\n997:18,18,20,22\n22nd 86:1,2,4\n90 30:19\n25 76:7\n25th 86:7\n280 32:20 59:10\n28th 86:7,21 95:23\n96:1,2,10,12\n29 101:20\n2d 32:8\n3\n30 42:1 97:18\n906 32:8\n950 91:15,21,21\nUnited Reporting, Inc.\n(954) 525-2221\nEFTA00621604\n", "char_count": 903}]}