{"efta_number": "EFTA00617509", "page_count": 7, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00617509", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00617509.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00617509", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "We use cookies to provide you with a better onsite experience. By continuing to browse the site you are\nagreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.\nSCIENTIFIC\nAMERICAN.\nSUBSCRIBE\nBEHAVIOR & SOCIETY\nHow Fake News Goes Viral-Here's the Math\nModels similar to those used to track disease show what happens when too much information hits\nsocial media networks\nBy Madhusree Mukerjee on July 14, 2017\nEFTA00617509\n", "char_count": 433}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00617509", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Propaganda\nLie\nManipulation\nFake\nNews\nHoax\nFiction Photos\nVideos\nCredit: Peter Dazeley Getty Images\nADVERTISEMENT | REPORT AD\nNASA runs a child-slave colony on Mars!\nPhotos taken by a Chinese orbiter reveal an alien settlement on the moon!\nShape-shifting reptilian extraterrestrials that can control human minds are running the\nU.S. government!\nWhat drives the astonishing popularity of such stories? Are we a particularly gullible\nspecies? Perhaps not-maybe we're just overwhelmed. A bare-bones model of how news\nspreads on social media, published in June in Nature Human Behavior, indicates that just\nEFTA00617510\n", "char_count": 616}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00617509", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "about anything can go viral. Even in a perfect world, where everyone wants to share real\nnews and is capable of evaluating the veracity of every claim, some fake news would still\nreach thousands (or even millions) of people, simply because of information overload. It is\noften impossible to see everything that comes into one's news feed, let alone confirm it. \"If\nyou live in a world where you are bombarded with junk-even if you're good at\ndiscriminating-you're only seeing a portion of what's out there, so you still may share\nmisinformation,\" explains computer scientist Filippo Menczer of Indiana University\nBloomington (I.U.), one of the model's co-authors. \"The competition is so harsh that the\ngood stuff cannot bubble to the top.\"\nChances are that in the virtual world, the beauty of a photograph or the persuasiveness of\nan article do help to spread a \"meme\"-the term Menczer and his colleagues use for a link,\nvideo, phrase or other unit of online information. The researchers demonstrate, however,\nthat just three inexorable factors can explain a network's inability to distinguish truth from\nfalsehood in memes, even if individuals can. They are: the enormous amount of\ninformation out there; the limited amount of time and attention people can devote to\nscrolling through their news feeds and choosing what to share; and the structure of the\nunderlying social networks. All three conspire to spread some of the worst memes at the\nexpense of the best ones.\nMathematical models for exploring how memes spread on social media networks are\nknown as agent-based models because they require the active participation of \"agents,\" a\ntechie term for individuals. These models originate from an older class of simulations that\nstudy how diseases spread through a community. Think of a diagram in which each agent\nis represented by a dot, or node, and is linked via lines to other nodes, representing friends\nor followers. If, say, Alice is \"infected\" by an influenza virus or a piece of fake news, she\nmay transmit the contagion along these links to her friends Bob and Clive by shaking\nhands or sharing the meme with them, respectively. Bob and Clive could in turn pass the\ncontagion to their contacts, and so on. By fleshing out this skeletal framework, scientists\ntry to simulate how far a meme can spread under different conditions.\n\"Information is not a virus,\" however, cautions information scientist Kristina Lerman of\nthe University of Southern California, who was not involved in creating the new model.\nWhereas we are usually dealing with one flu strain at a time, or at worst a few, the number\nof memes competing to infect us is staggering. The modelers incorporate this abundance\nby imagining that each person has a screen on which he or she views incoming memes.\nEFTA00617511\n", "char_count": 2793}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00617509", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "The model assigns a value to the probability that Alice will create and share a new meme—\nsay, a video she has made of her dancing cockatoo-and it also does so for all the possible\nnew memes originating from all other users. Because new memes increase the total\nquantity of information in the system, these values measure the information load\nexperienced by those viewing their screens.\nAnother parameter tracks the number of items Alice views on her long news feed before\nchoosing to simply pass an existing meme along to her connections, instead of creating a\nnew one. This parameter serves as a proxy for the attention span—the information that\nAlice focused on. Once Alice sends along a message, it appears on the screens of Bob, Clive\nand others, who in turn choose whether to create memes of their own or to transmit one of\nthem from their feeds.\nUsing an earlier version of this model, Menczer and others at I.U. showed in 2012 that a\nfew memes will go viral even if all memes are equally “contagious”—that is, equally likely\nto be shared each time they are viewed. The memes in both models roughly follow what is\ncalled a \"power law,\" meaning that the chance of a meme being tweeted or otherwise\nshared a certain number of times decreases as an inverse power of that number. For\nexample, a meme is four times less likely to be tweeted twice than once. \"If you look at the\ndistribution of pictures on Flickr or articles on Facebook or hashtags on Twitter-all of\nthese have power laws,\" Menczer says. Still, memes reaching thousands of recipients are\nsurprisingly commonplace.\nIn 2014 mathematician James Gleeson of the University of Limerick in Ireland and others\ndemonstrated a mathematical similarity between models of the kind concocted by\nMenczer, among others, and \"sandpiles\"-canonical systems for what physicists call “self-\norganized criticality.\" If one gently dribbles sand onto a flat surface, it will pile up until its\nslopes reach a critical angle. A few additional grains of sand may cause nothing much to\nhappen, but all of a sudden yet another grain will trigger an avalanche: the equivalent of a\nmeme going viral. Gleeson's analysis suggests the intrinsic properties of the system, as\nopposed to the particularities of a meme, are driving virality.\nIn the latest paper Menczer, Xiaoyan Qiu and others at I.U. examine what happens if some\nmemes are more contagious than others. They find that if the information load is low and\nthe attention span is high, the more attractive memes prevail. Actual tracking of attention\nEFTA00617512\n", "char_count": 2556}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00617509", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "and information overload, obtained from Twitter and Tumblr data, however, indicate that\nin real life the sheer quantity of information usually overwhelms us. \"You don't have to\nassume that the reason why junk spreads is because people like it or because they can't tell\nthe difference,\" Menczer explains. \"You could assume that people do know the difference,\nand still the fake stuff would go viral, simply because of information overload.\"\nOne key factor influencing the spread of memes is the pattern of connections in the\nunderlying social media network. \"Some network structures will promote the spread being\nfast and others will inhibit the spread,\" says mathematician Mason Porter of the\nUniversity of California, Los Angeles. If the simulated network in the competition-driven\nmodel is assumed to be random, for instance-meaning the connections are randomly\ndistributed among nodes on the network—no memes go viral. Real social media networks\ndisplay a roughly power-law distribution of links, however—a feature Menczer and his\ncolleagues incorporate into their simulation. So whereas most of us-each a node on\nTwitter, for example-have a handful of followers, a few outliers may have tens of\nthousands. If any of these \"superconnected” individuals, or hubs, becomes infected with a\nfake meme, they can presumably transmit it far and wide.\nBut U.S.C.'s Lerman begs to differ. In disease models, highly connected people are called\n\"superspreaders\" because they help drive epidemics. By examining the behavior of actual\nTwitter users, however, she demonstrated in 2016 that superconnected agents pass on\nvery few of the memes they receive. This is because they cannot possibly see, let alone\nread, everything in their staggeringly lengthy feeds. \"People who are highly connected are\nunlikely to see anything that is even five minutes old because it is so far down their feed,\"\nshe notes. Thus information overload ensures they are less likely to get infected in the first\nplace. In her view, hubs suppress the vast majority of memes but may help to spread the\nfew they let through.\nAlso playing a role in virality: friends tend to form clusters. So, for instance, because Alice\nknows Bob and Clive, the latter likely know each other as well, and likely share similar\nviews on many issues. These clusters help establish what social media aficionados think of\nas an \"echo chamber.\" Most of us tend to see some memes several times, increasing the\nlikelihood that we too will share them. Making matters worse, the contagiousness of a\nmeme-unlike that of a flu virus-depends on how often it has been shared. In a Web-\nbased experiment involving more than 14,000 volunteers, sociologist Matthew Salganik,\nthen at Columbia University, and others showed in 2006 that recruits were much more\nEFTA00617513\n", "char_count": 2801}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00617509", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "likely to download a particular song if they were aware that their peers liked it.\nSuch \"social reinforcement\" can ensure that contagiousness increases sharply once a\ncertain threshold of exposure is crossed. \"You see one person post, 'NASA's got slave\ncolonies on Mars,' and you think, 'That's ridiculous,” Porter explains. \"You see a second\nperson post, 'NASA's got slave colonies on Mars.' You see this many times, and it somehow.\nbecomes more plausible the more times you see it.\" And so you share it, too. Several\nresearch groups are exploring the intricate cognitive processes that lead to one meme\nbeing chosen over another.\nDebate persists, though, on the accuracy of the models used in this research. \"In general, I\ntend to be skeptical of agent-based models because there are so many knobs you can\ntweak,\" Lerman says. Menczer concedes that any model used in attempt to reproduce all\nthe subtleties of human cognitive behavior would have many unknown parameters—or\n\"knobs\"--which would make their results hard to interpret. But that is less of a problem\nwith such minimalistic models (often called \"toy models\"), which seek only to explore\nbroad-brush features. \"As long as they are very simple, they are useful,\" Menczer says―\nbecause they reveal surprisingly powerful truths.\nADVERTISEMENT | REPORT AD\nSCIENTIFIC\nAMERICAN.\nScience is Sport. Subscribe today to learn more.\nRights & Permissions\nEFTA00617514\n", "char_count": 1418}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00617509", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "ABOUT THE AUTHOR(S)\nMadhusree Mukerjee\nRecent Articles\n5 Years Later, the Fukushima Nuclear Disaster Site Continues to Spill Waste\nCrippled Fukushima Reactors Are Still a Danger, 5 Years after the Accident\nThe Impending Dam Disaster in the Himalayas\nREAD THIS NEXT\nBEHAVIOR & SOCIETY\nThe Ultimate Cure for the Fake News Epidemic Will Be More Skeptical\nReaders\nFebruary 1, 2017 - David Pogue\nELECTRONICS\nWhat Facebook Is Doing to Combat Fake News\nFebruary 1, 2017 - David Pogue\nARTS & CULTURE\n3 Historical Examples of \"Fake News\"\nDecember 1, 2016 - Krystal |\nEFTA00617515\n", "char_count": 571}]}