{"efta_number": "EFTA00610108", "page_count": 7, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00610108", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00610108.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00610108", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT\nIN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCASE NO. 502009CA040800XXXXMBAG\nJEFFREY EPSTEIN,\n-vs-\nPlaintiff,\nSCOTT ROTHSTEIN, INDIVIDUALLY,\nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS, INDIVIDUALLY,\nAND L.M., INDIVIDUALLY,\nDefendants.\n1234\n56\n906\n10\nHEARING BEFORE THE HONORABLE DAVID CROW\n11\n12\nMonday, March 11, 2013\n9:05 a.m. 9:17 a.n.\n13\nPALM BEACH COUNTY COURTHOUSE, COURTROOM SC\n205 North Dixie Highway\nWest Palm Beach, Florida\n14\n15\n16\nStenographically Reported By:\nPaula McGuirk, RPR, FPR\nRegistered Professional Reporter\nFlorida Professional Reporter\n67\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n222\n123\n22\nPROCEEDINGS\nTHE CLERK: Epstein vs. Rothstein.\nMR. SCAROLA: Good morning. Jack Scarola on\nbehalf of Bradley Edwards.\nTHE COURT: Give me one second, please.\nMR. SCAROLA: Absolutely.\nTHE COURT: Okay, what do we have?\nMR. SCAROLA: Your Honor, this is the\nCounter-Plaintiff, Bradley Edwards, motion to strike\nuntimely objections, and if I may approach the Court,\nI have a time line that I hope will be of help to\nYour Honor.\nTHE COURT: Okay.\nMR. SCAROLA: Your Honor, this motion relates\nto net worth interrogatories propounded after Your\nHonor permitted the amendment of this complaint to\nassert a claim for punitive damages. We served\ndiscovery relating to Mr. Epstein's financial\ncircumstances on December 21, '12 following that\norder, and pursuant to the provision of Rule 1.340\nand the 1.350 responses to both of those, discovery\nrequests were due within 30 days.\n3\n23\n24\n25\nWithin 30 days rather than filing responses,\nwhat we received was a motion for protective order.\n4\n2\n12\nAPPEARANCES:\n3\nOn behalf of the Plaintiff:\nLAW OFFICES OF TONJA HADDAD COLEMAN, P.A.\n4\n12345\n5\n69\n6\nBY: TONJA HADDAD COLEMAN, ESQUIRE\n8\nOn behalf of the Defendants:\n9\nSEARCY, DENNEY, SCAROLA, BARNHART & SHIPLEY, P.A. 10\n11\n9\nH2\n12\n10\nBY: JACK SCAROLA, ESQUIRE\n11\n12\n13\n13\n14\n15\n16\nThe motion for protective order raised a variety of\nobjections to the discovery. Included among those\nobjections was that the di\n... [truncated, 3139 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00610108/0 or ?id=EFTA00610108&page=0]", "char_count": 3139}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00610108", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "5\n7\n1234\n567\naddressed substantively.\nWe are not before Your Honor this morning to\nask the Court to consider the substance of the\nobjections, but to strike all objections, except for\n12\n345\nthe Fifth Amendment privilege assertion, on the basis 5\nthat those objections are untimely. The significance\nof striking all of the objections, other than the\n69\n8\n9\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\nFifth Amendment privilege objection, is that other\nobjections cannot be commented upon in the presence\nof the jury. If there are valid legal objections to\nnot providing the information, obviously we cannot\ndraw adverse inferences from those other objections,\nnor can we comment upon those other objections.\nHowever, the Defendant's failure to respond to\nthis financial discovery on the basis of the Fifth\nAmendment privilege assertion is obviously something 16\nthat can be raised in the presence of the jury, and\nwe can draw adverse inferences from his refusal to\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n17\n18\n19\nprovide any financial information whatsoever. That's\n19\n20\nthe purpose of this motion.\n20\n21\nTHE COURT: Yes.\n21\n22\n23\n24\nMS. COLEMAN: Good morning, Judge. Tonja\nHaddad Coleman on behalf of Mr. Epstein. First, I'm\nreally not quite sure how to respond to this since\n22\n23\n24\n25\nMr. Scarola has yet, again, filed a motion that\n25\n6\nis raising a motion for protective order because, and\nI quote, \"This follows from the fact that\nRule 1.280(c) refers to issuance of protective order\nonly to protect a party or person from annoyance,\nembarrassment, oppression or undue burden or\nexpense.\" It does not refer to privilege.\nWe think the omission was intentional and,\ntherefore, the word objectionable in Rule 1.380(d),\ntherefore, should be construed as referring only to\nitems which are within the scope of discovery; that\nis, not privileged.\nAs such, Judge, once you denied our motion for\nprotective order, we were still well within our legal\nrights -- our client's legal rights -- to raise any\nobjections that were not raised in \n... [truncated, 4807 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00610108/1 or ?id=EFTA00610108&page=1]", "char_count": 4807}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00610108", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "11\n2\n12345\n69\ndrafted, unable to file a response. I don't know how\nit would be work product. The accountant privilege\nwould not be applicable. So your position is that\nyou have not waived any -- certainly not waived any\nprivilege objections. I understand that. Your claim\nis that you have not waived any objections?\nMS. COLEMAN: Me?\nTHE COURT: Yeah, Haddad.\nMS. COLEMAN: Yes.\n1\nwill have to look at it today. By the way, is your\n2\n34\nfather an attorney, or is that your brother that's an\nattorney?\n8\n9\n10\nMS. COLEMAN: Yes, Your Honor, we never raised\nany issue of overly burdensome. We raised the three\ngrounds one can raise in a protective order. We did\nnot raise, in our objection to his discovery\n7\nTHE COURT: Are you related?\n8\nMS. COLEMAN: I'm related to a lot of\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\nrequests, any grounds that you had already ruled upon\nin your motion for protective order. As such,\nthey're timely objections.\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\nTHE COURT: I honestly don't remember what I\nruled or didn't rule.\n14\n15\n16\nMS. COLEMAN: I have a copy of your order right\n16\n17\nhere. It's attached to our response to his motion.\n17\n18\n19\nTHE COURT: It says -- you've got here\noverbroad.\n18\nattorneys. I don't know which Haddad you're\nreferring.\nTHE COURT: No, I'm sorry, I --\nMR. SCAROLA: Mr. Haddad has actually entered\nan appearance in this case, Your Honor.\nTHE COURT: Is he related to you?\nMS. COLEMAN: Yes, he is.\nTHE COURT: Oh, okay. I just wondered. It's\ninteresting. Do you have a relative that works in\nthe Court? We have a clerk, an attorney.\n19\nTHE CLERK: Monica.\n20\n21\nMR. SCAROLA: Would Your Honor like a copy of\nthe order?\n20\n21\nTHE COURT: Monica Haddad. Is she related?\nMS. COLEMAN: No.\n22\nTHE COURT: Yes. I don't have the motions, so\n22\n23\n24\nI don't know what you raised in the motions, but,\nokay, yes, sir, you want to respond?\n23\n24\n25\nMR. SCAROLA: I would like to respond, Your\n25\nTHE COURT: Because that's not unusual. I\nmean, it's kind of like a Smith, Jones kind of --\nMS. COLEMAN: Which is why for the\n... [truncated, 4397 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00610108/2 or ?id=EFTA00610108&page=2]", "char_count": 4397}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00610108", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "1234567\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n23\n13\nleave to assert a claim for punitive damages. The\npetition for writ of certiori was denied as to that\nmatter.\nTHE COURT: Okay.\nMR. SCAROLA: There was a recent opinion that\nrelated to an effort to recuse Attorney Keitel that\nwas just addressed by the Fourth DCA in another\nmatter, so that may have been what Your Honor was\nseeing.\nTHE COURT: Okay, thank you, guys.\nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you, Your Honor.\nMS. COLEMAN: Thank you, Judge.\n(The hearing concluded at 9:16 a.m.)\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n8\n1234567 00 00 123456\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\nP P P P P PI\nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER\nI, Paula McGuirk, Registered Professional\nReporter, Florida Professional Reporter, certify that I\nwas authorized to and did stenographically report the\nforegoing proceedings and that the transcript, pages 1\nthrough 13, is a true and complete record of my\nstenographic notes.\nDated this 13th day of March, 2013.\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nPaula Me Quil\nPaula McGuirk\nRegistered Professional Reporter\nFlorida Professional Reporter\n13\n14\n4 (Pages 13 to 14)\nEFTA00610111\n", "char_count": 1081}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00610108", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "A\nAbsolutely 3:7\naccountant 9:2\naddress 6:2\naddressed 5:1 13:7\naddresses 10:3\nadmissible 7:23\nadverse 5:12,18\nallegation 6:2\namend 12:12\namendment 3:17 5:5,8\n5:16 10:8\nannoyance 6:16 7:4\nanswer 6:5\nanswers 8:1\napart 4:18\nappeal 12:20\nappealed 12:22,24\nappearance 11:13\nAPPEARANCES 2:1\nAppellate 12:18\napplicable 9:3\napproach 3:11 6:23\nargument 10:16\nasked 4:20\nasking 7:19 8:1\nassert 3:18 12:12 13:1\nassertion 5:5,16 10:8\nattached 8:18 9:17\nattention 4:11\nattorney 11:2,3,18 13:6\nattorneys 11:9\nattorney/client 10:3,4\n10:22\nauthorized 14:5\na.m 1:16,16 13:13\nB\nback 12:7\nBARNHART 2:8\nbasis 5:5,15\nBeach 1:1,17,18 2:8,9\nbehalf 2:2,7 3:5 4:9\n5:23\nBoulevard 2:8\nBradley 1:8 3:5,10\nbrother 11:2\nbrought 4:9,10\nburden 6:17 7:5\nburdensome 7:22 9:8\nс\ncalculated 7:23\ncase 1:2 6:1,21,24 7:16\n10:1 11:13 12:18\ncertainly 9:4\nCERTIFICATE 14:1\ncertify 14:4\ncertiorari 12:11\ncertiori 13:2\nchallenging 12:11\nCIRCUIT 1:1,1\ncircumstances 3:20\n4:21\nclaim 3:18 9:5 12:12\n13:1\nclaims 6:25\nclear 6:13\nclerk 3:3 11:18,19\nclient's 7:14\nColeman 2:3,6 5:22,23\n7:20,24 8:7,11,15,17\n8:21 9:7,16 11:4,6,8\n11:15,21,24 12:4,20\n13:12\ncome 12:7,17\ncomment 5:13\ncommented 5:9\ncompelling 4:12\ncomplaint 3:17\ncomplete 14:7\nconcluded 13:13\nconsequence 10:5\nconsider 5:3\nconsidered 4:5\nconstrued 7:9\ncontains 6:1\ncopies 7:25\ncopy 8:11,14,15 9:16,20\ncounsel 10:1,15\nCounter-Plaintiff 3:10\nCOUNTY 1:1,17\nCourt 1:1 3:6,8,11,14\n5:3,21 6:4,21 7:18,22\n8:4,9,14,16,20,22 9:14\nCOURTHOUSE 1:17\nCOURTROOM 1:17\nCourt's 4:10 10:7\nCROW 1:13\nD\ndamages 3:18 12:13\n13:1\nDated 14:10\nDAVID 1:13\nday 14:10\ndays 3:23,24 4:13,14,23\n6:6\nDCA 6:24 10:1 13:7\ndeadline 10:18\ndecade 11:24\nDecember 3:20\nDefendants 1:9 2:7\nDefendant's 5:14\ndelineated 6:18\ndenied 7:12 13:2\nDENNEY 2:8\ndenying 4:6\ndevelop 10:10\ndiscovery 3:19,22 4:2,3\n4:8,12,14,17 5:15 6:5\n6:9,19 7:10 8:11 9:10\nDixie 1:17\ndrafted 9:1\ndraw 5:12,18\ndue 3:23 6:7\nPage 1\nF\nfact 4:16 7:2 12:16\nfailure 5:14\nfar 10:17\nfather 11:2\nFebruary 4:12 6:7,8,8\n6:10\nFIFTEENTH 1:1\nFifth 5:5,8,15 10:8\nfile 9:1\nfile\n... [truncated, 2859 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00610108/4 or ?id=EFTA00610108&page=4]", "char_count": 2859}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00610108", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Honor 3:9,13,15,17 4:5\n4:11 5:2 9:7,20 10:1\n11:13 12:6 13:8,11\nHONORABLE 1:13\nHonor's 12:11,25\nhope 3:12\nI\nincluded 4:2,7\nincluding 6:20 10:14\nINDIVIDUALLY 1:7,8\n1:8\ninferences 5:12,18\ninformation 5:11,19\n10:13\ninitial 4:23\nintentional 7:7\ninterested 12:3\ninteresting 11:17\ninterrogatories 3:16\n4:24\nissuance 7:3\nissue 9:8 12:24\nissues 6:14,15,18\nitems 7:10\nJ\nJ 1:8\nJack 2:10 3:4\nJanuary 4:6\nJEFFREY 1:4\nJones 11:23\n2:10\nlead 7:23\nleave 12:12 13:1\nlegal 5:10 7:13,14\nlender 8:23\nline 3:12\nlistening 8:4\nlong 10:25\nlook 10:25 11:1\nlot 11:8\nL.M 1:8\nM\nmaking 6:10\nMarch 1:15 14:10\nmarried 11:25\nmatter 4:9,10 13:3,8\nMcGuirk 1:23 14:3,16\nmean 11:23 12:2\nMonday 1:15 6:8\nMonica 11:19,20\nmorning 3:4 5:2,22\nmotion 3:10,15,25 4:1,5\n4:6 5:20,25 6:12,15\n7:1,12,15 8:18,21\n9:12,17 10:5,6,13,19\n10:23\nmotions 9:22,23\nN\nname 4:18 11:25\nneed 4:25\nnet 3:16\nnever 9:7\nNorth 1:17\nJudge 5:22 7:12,24\nnotes 14:8\n0\n8:17 12:21 13:12\nJUDICIAL 1:1\njury 5:10,17\nK\nKeitel 13:6\nkicked 12:18\nkind 11:23,23\nknow 7:24 8:2,17 9:1\n9:23 11:9 12:2\nL\nLakes 2:8\nLauderdale 2:4\nlaw 2:3 6:13 10:10\nobjecting 8:1\nobjection 5:8 6:24 7:17\n8:25 9:10 10:11,21\nobjectionable 7:8\nobjections 3:11 4:2,3\n4:16,17,22,24,25 5:4,4\n5:6,7,9,10,12,13 6:3\n6:20 7:15,19,20 8:6\n8:12 9:5,6,13 10:4,9\n10:17,20\nobviously 5:11,16\nOFFICES 2:3\nOh 11:16 12:23\nokay 3:8,14 8:4,20 9:24\n10:24 11:16 12:2,5,23\n13:4,10\nomission 7:7\nonce 7:12\nones 8:2\nopinion 13:5\nopposing 4:15 10:1\noppression 4:4 6:17 7:5\noppressive 10:15\norder 3:21,25 4:1,6,7,7\n4:11 6:6,6,13,14,16\n7:1,3,13,16 9:9,12,16\n9:21 10:6,13 12:25\nordered 6:4\noverbroad 7:22 9:19\n10:16\noverly 9:8\nP\npages 10:25 14:6\nPalm 1:1,17,18 2:8,9\nparticular 4:7\nparty 4:15 7:4\npassed 10:18\nPaula 1:23 14:3,16\npermit 10:16\npermitted 3:17\nperson 7:4\npetition 12:10 13:2\nPlaintiff 1:5 2:2\nplease 3:6 8:23\npoint 6:21 10:11\nportions 6:23\nposition 4:22 7:16 9:3\npresence 5:9,17\nprivilege 5:5,8,16 6:20\n7:6,19 8:6,24 9:2,5\n10:3,4,8,20,21,22\nprivileged 6:25 7:11\nprivileges 8:3\nproceedings 3:1 14:6\nproduce 8:23\nproduct 9:2\n\n... [truncated, 2820 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00610108/5 or ?id=EFTA00610108&page=5]", "char_count": 2820}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00610108", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "request 8:12\nrequests 3:23 6:5,10\n9:11 10:12\nrequired 6:25\nrespect 6:12\nrespond 5:14,24 6:4,5\n9:24,25\nresponded 6:9\nresponse 4:19 6:7 9:1\n9:17 10:18\nresponses 3:22,24 4:12\n4:15,24 6:19 8:16,17\n10:25\nright 6:21 9:16 12:9,19\nrights 7:14,14\nRothstein 1:7 3:3\nRPR 1:23\nrule 3:21 6:1,18 7:3,8\n7:19 9:15\nruled 9:11,15\nrules 8:8,8\nruling 10:7\nsaw 12:16\nS\nsays 6:24 8:22 9:18\n10:4\nScarola 2:8,10 3:4,4,7,9\n3:15 5:25 9:20,25\n11:12 12:6,10,22,24\n13:5,11\nscope 7:10\nSCOTT 1:7\nSEARCY 2:8\nsecond 3:6\nsee 12:7\nspecifically 10:3\nstatements 8:23\nstates 6:3 10:6\nstenographic 14:8\nstenographically 1:22\n14:5\nstrange 10:10\nPage 3\nV\n25th 6:8\nvague 8:25\nvalid 5:10\n29th 4:6\n3\nvariety 4:1\nvarious 7:21\nvs 1:6 3:3\nStreet 2:3\nW\n30 3:23,24 4:23\n30-day 10:17\n301 2:4\n315 2:3\nstricken 8:3\nwaived 9:4,4,6 10:5\n33301 2:4\nstrike 3:10 5:4 8:2,5,13 want 9:24\n33409 2:9\n10:9,20\nwants 8:2,5,12\n4\nstriking 5:7\nwasn't 8:18,18\n4th 4:12 6:7\nway 11:1\nWest 1:18 2:9\n5\n502009CA040800XX...\nwhatsoever 5:19\nwondered 11:16\n1:2\n2:9\nsubstance 5:3\nsubstantial 10:14\nsubstantive 4:19\nsubstantively 5:1 10:11\nSuites 2:4\nSunday 6:9\nWe've 6:17\nword 7:8\nsupports 7:16\nwork 9:2\nsure 5:24\nworks 11:17\nworth 3:16\n9C 1:17\n9:05 1:16\nT\nwrit 12:11 13:2\n9:16 13:13\ntake 10:24 12:1\nwrong 12:19\n9:17 1:16\ntaken 6:22\n2:5\nthank 12:5,6 13:10,11\nY\n13:12\nYeah 11:5\nthink 7:7\nyears 8:24\nthought 12:14,16\nY'all 12:8\nthree 9:8\n1\n114:6\n1.280(c) 7:3\n1.340 3:21\ntime 3:12 4:8 6:22\ntimely 6:9,24 7:17 9:13\ntoday 11:1\nTonja 2:3,6 5:22\ntonja@tonjahaddad.... 1.350 3:22\n1.380 6:18\n2:5\ntranscript 14:6\n1.380(d) 7:8\nseeing 13:9\ntried 11:25 12:15,17\n11 1:15\nseeking 10:7,9\ntrue 14:7\n12 3:20\nseparate 10:23\nturn 6:2\n13 14:7\nserially 10:16\nserved 3:18\nU\n13th 14:10\n17 10:25\nunable 9:1\n2\nSeventh 2:3\nSHIPLEY 2:8\nsignificance 5:6\nsingle 4:19\nsir 9:24\nSmith 11:23\nsomebody 12:15,17\nsorry 8:10 11:11\nSoutheast 2:3\nunartfully 8:25\nunderstand 7:18 9:5\nunderstanding 8:8\nundue 6:17 7:5\nuntimely 3:11 4:25 5:6\n6:4 10:9\nunusual 11:22\n20 4:13,14 6:6\n2013 1:15 14:10\n205 1:17\n21 3:20\n2139 2:8\n... [truncated, 2033 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00610108/6 or ?id=EFTA00610108&page=6]", "char_count": 2033}]}