{"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_count": 13, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00605732", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00605732.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 3 \nEFTA00605732\n", "char_count": 34}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Eleventh Circuit rules that discovery can move forward on my Crime Victims' Rights Act... Page 1 of 3 \nPrint \nEleventh Circuit rules that discovery \ncan move forward on my Crime \nVictims' Rights Act case \nBy Paul Cassell Updated: April 21 at 9:41 am \nOn Friday the 1 1 th Circuit ruled that discovery can move forward in an important \nCrime Victims' Rights Act case that my co-counsel, Brad Edwards, and I are \npursuing. The narrow issue before the court was whether prosecutors and defense \nattorneys could assert some sort of \"privilege\" to prevent crime victims from \nreviewing the correspondence that lead to a plea bargain. More broadly, the ruling \nmeans that the victims will have a chance to return to the district court and seek to \ninvalidate a plea agreement that (we alleged) was consummated in violation of their \nrights. I hope that the case will ultimately set an important precedent that federal \nprosecutors can't keep victims in the dark about the plea deals that they reach. \nHere are the important facts, taken from the 11th Circuit's opinion: The case arose in \n2006, the FBI began investigating allegations that wealthy investor Jeffrey Epstein \nhad sexually abused dozens and dozens of minor girls. The U.S. Attorney's Office for \nthe Southern District of Florida accepted Epstein's case for prosecution, and the FBI \nissued victim notification letters to my two clients, minors Jane Doe No. I and Jane \nDoe No. 2, in June and August 2007. Extensive plea negotiations ensued between the \nprosecutors and Epstein. On Sept. 24, 2007, the prosecutors entered into a non-\nprosecution agreement with Epstein in which they agreed not to file any federal \ncharges against Epstein in exchange for his guilty plea to minor Florida offenses (e.g., \nsolicitation of prostitution). Not only did the prosecutors neglect to confer with the \nvictims before they entered into the agreement with Epstein, they also concealed its \nexistence for at least nine months. For example, the prosecutors\n... [truncated, 3091 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00605732/1 or ?id=EFTA00605732&page=1]", "char_count": 3091}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Eleventh Circuit rules that discovery can move forward on my Crime Victims' Rights Act... Page 2 of 3 \nspecifically her rights to confer with the government, to be treated with fairness, to \nreceive timely notice of relevant court proceedings, and to receive information about \nrestitution. The United States responded by claiming that it used its \"best efforts\" to \ncomply with the rights afforded to victims under the CVRA, but that the act did not \napply to pre-indictment negotiations with potential federal defendants. \nAfter Jane Doe No. 2 joined the initial petition, the district court (Main, J.) found \nthat both women qualified as \"crime victims\" under the CVRA. The district court \nlater rejected the government's argument that the act only applies after the filing of a \nfederal criminal indictment. (I've written a law review article about the issue of how \nearly crime victims' rights attach in the criminal process, which can be downloaded \nhere.) \nAmong other relief, we sought rescission of the non-prosecution agreement as a \nremedy for the violation of the victims' rights. To make the case for such a remedy, \nwe moved for discovery of the correspondence between the U.S. and Epstein's \nattorneys during the plea negotiations. Epstein's attorneys intervened, arguing that \nFederal Rule of Evidence 410 and Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 11 create a \nprivilege for plea negotiations, barring release of the correspondence. They also \nargued that the court should find that the materials were protected under the work \nproduct doctrine or, alternatively, should be protected under a new \"common-law \nprivilege for plea negotiations.\" \nThe district court first ruled that rescission of the plea agreement was a possible \nremedy under the act. The court then ruled that we were entitled to review the \ncorrespondence, rejecting all of Epstein's arguments. \nOn Friday, the llth Circuit affirmed the district court's ruling that we could review \nthe plea correspondence. At pp. 18-2\n... [truncated, 3431 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00605732/2 or ?id=EFTA00605732&page=2]", "char_count": 3431}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Eleventh Circuit rules that discovery can move forward on my Crime Victims' Rights Act... Page 3 of 3 \ndoes not create a privilege and the intervenors waived any work-product privilege. \nThe intervenors concede too that the right to counsel under the Sixth Amendment had \nnot yet attached when the correspondence was exchanged. Lumley v. City of Dade \nCity, Fla., 327 F.3d 1186, 1195 (11th Cir. 2003) (\"[T]he Sixth Amendment right to \ncounsel ordinarily does not arise until there is a formal commitment by the \ngovernment to prosecute,\" such as a \"formal charge, preliminary hearing, indictment, \ninformation, or arraignment.\"). The \"conjunctive\" power of three false claims of \nprivilege does not rescue the correspondence from disclosure.... \nThe Supreme Court has identified several considerations relevant to whether a court \nshould recognize an evidentiary privilege—the needs of the public, whether the \nprivilege is rooted in the imperative for confidence and trust, the evidentiary benefit \nof the denial of the privilege, and any consensus among the states, Jaffee v. Redmond, \n518 U.S. 1, 10-15 (1996)—but none of these considerations weighs in favor of \nrecognizing a new privilege to prevent discovery of the plea negotiations. Although \nplea negotiations are vital to the functioning of the criminal justice system, a \nprosecutor and target of a criminal investigation do not enjoy a relationship of \nconfidence and trust when they negotiate. Their adversarial relationship, unlike the \nconfidential relationship of a doctor and patient or attorney and client, warrants no \nprivilege beyond the terms of Rule 410. See Jaffee, 518 U.S. at 10. But the victims \nwould enjoy an evidentiary benefit from the disclosure of plea negotiations to prove \nwhether the United States violated their rights under the Act. \nMoving forward, this case raises the important issue of what kinds of remedies are \navailable for violations of the Crime Victims' Rights Act. Our complaint alleges that, \nprodd\n... [truncated, 2493 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00605732/3 or ?id=EFTA00605732&page=3]", "char_count": 2493}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Appeals court rules against sex offender I \nPage 1 of 3 \nFollow us on \nFriday May 2.2014 356 I. \nSubscnbe Today's paper I Customer care \nSign In I Register \nF3Pagh Da Hi NPVIS \nthe shiny sheet \nPosted- 12 00 a.m. Monday. April 21. 2014 \nAppeals court rules against sex offender \nAttorneys for underage victims seek to overturn 'sweetheart plea.' \nRelated \nBy Michele Dargan \nDaily News Staff Writer \nUnderage victims of billionaire sex offender Jeffrey Epstein are entitled to correspondence between federal prosecutors and \nEpstein's attorneys related to his sweetheart plea deal, a federal appeals court ruled Friday. \nThis is one more step in the fight by victims' attorneys Brad Edwards and Paul Cassell to overturn the secret deal. which \nsaved Epstein from facing serious federal charges and serving significant prison time. \nIf Epstein had been found guilty on federal charges, statutory penalties ranged from 10 years to life in prison. \nInstead, the sealed pact was part and parcel of Epstein's acceptance of a state plea deal. Epstein pleaded guilty to \nsoliciting a minor for prostitution and soliciting prostitution. He received an 18-month sentence. in a vacant wing of the Palm \nBeach County Stockade, and was lel out on work release six days a week for up to 16 hours a day. \nEdwards and Cassell represent Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2, who say the U.S. Attorney's Office violated the Crime \nVictims' Rights Act by signing the federal non-prosecution agreement in 2007 without notifying the victims Their case is \npending in U.S. District Court in Wesl Palm Beach. \nThe 24-page published opinion says U.S. District Judge Kenneth Marra did not err in his June 2013 ruling, when he ordered \nthe correspondence turned over to the victims. \n\"Sweetheart plea' \n`We're now going to get a complete picture of the negotiations that led to this sweetheart plea arrangement.' said Cassell, a \nformer federal judge. 'We think it will show the part of the discussion to keep the victims n the \n... [truncated, 2740 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00605732/4 or ?id=EFTA00605732&page=4]", "char_count": 2740}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Appeals court rules against sex offender I \nPage 2 of 3 \nThe ruling also dismissed Epstein's claims that a federal rule of evidence protects his plea correspondence. That rule \napplies only to defendants who withdraw a guilty plea. Because he pleaded guilty, that doesn't apply, the ruling says. \n'While respectful of the panel's decision, given issues of overriding importance to the criminal justice system regarding the \nneed for continued confidentiality for communications between defense lawyers and prosecutors, we wil be petitioning the \ncourt of appeals for further review,' said Boston based attorney Martin Weinberg. who represents Epstein. \nThe U.S. Attorneys Office failed to notify victims prior to striking a non-prosecution agreement with Epstein on Sept. 24, \n2007, and didn't tell them of the agreement's existence for at least nine months, the ruling says. \nOn June 27, 2008, the U.S. Attorney's Office told the victims that Epstein planned to plead guilty to state charges three \ndays later. But federal prosecutors failed to disclose that his pleas to the state charges arose from his federal non-\nprosecution agreement and would bar federal charges. \nJane Does No. 1 and No. 2. who were. respectively, 12 and 13 at the time they were victimized,received confidential \nmonetary settlements in civil cases. \nThey are among more than two dozen underage girls who filed lawsuits or settled claims against Epstein. All alleged they \nwere lured to his Palm Beach mansion to give him sexually charged massages and/or sex in exchange for money. \n•A well-connected billionaire got away with molesting many girls' Edwards said. •These girls should at least know how and \nwhy he was able to get away with these crimes. This ruling wdl allow us access to the documents that will provide Insight \ninto how that happened. I suspect that the answers revealed by these documents will ultimately allow us to invalidate that \nagreement and permit prosecution of Mr. Epstein' \nMore News \nWe Recomm\n... [truncated, 3959 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00605732/5 or ?id=EFTA00605732&page=5]", "char_count": 3959}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Appeals court rules against sex offender I \nPage 3 of 3 \nbeing housed in cheap motels along federal hwy for GUY LIKE THIS to get their sexual perversions satisfied!! Read the \nentire case and see that young girls flowed thru Palm Beach South Ocean Blvd and South County Rd ,to his El Brillo \n\"MANSION OF PERVERSION\" with this guy as its Master!! For people to think \"Palm Beach\" has the \"Elite', the -Upper \nCrust\" of society, it also is home to some of the worst thieves, sexual predators, financial criminals the world has ever \nknown!! Mr Epstein has Billions of Dollars. and can afford the Best Criminal Attorneys, yet Can't or WON'T get Professional \nMenial Help with his sexual desires and fascination with young girls. And the Court systems goes along with him!!! \nUnbelievable.. \n• Posted by Adios at 3:12 p.m. Apr. 22.2014 \n• Report Abuse \nI agree with the post by the palm bleacher. This guy is a pery and needs to sit out of society. When listening to his \ndepositions, he pretended to be insulted by the questions being asked of him and his lawyer shut it down quickly. What \nremains to be seen is if the soon to be released files will bear the fruit we all hope it does. My worry is that the tracks wiU be \ncovered and he will not get his due. \nHis opinion of himself allows him to think he did nothing wrong and these BABIES he molested were not of his place in \nsociety and were simply objects to be thrown away. What would he think d someone did that to his BABIES if he has any? I \ncan bet that the full force of his money would work against whomever played with his kids \nbloody gross! \n2 Comment(s) \nComment(s) 1-2 of 2 \np=recruemediallc&type=gif&segmentr 848add=true \n. <img height=\"1\" width=\"1\" src=\"http://segments.adap.tv!data/? \n5/2/2014 \nEFTA00605738\n", "char_count": 1776}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Victims win right to see negotiations that led to 'lenient' plea agreement for billionaire sex... Page 1 of 3 \n20140421,0,6594687.story \nSun Sentinel \nVictims win right to see negotiations that led to 'lenient' plea \nagreement for billionaire sex offender \nLatest in legal saga involving Jeffrey Epstein, 61, financier convicted of procuring \nminor for prostitution \nBy Brett Clarkson, Sun Sentinel \n7:43 PM EDT, April 21, 2014 \nDid a Palm Beach billionaire being investigated for having sex with young girls use his \nwealth to negotiate a lenient and secret agreement that saw him avoid federal \nprosecution? \nadvertisement \nAttorneys for two victims, known only as Jane Doe 1 and 2, may soon get an answer thanks to an \nappeals court ruling against financier and sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, 61. \nThe ruling, issued Friday, orders federal authorities to disclose the correspondence that took place \nbetween Epstein's attorneys and federal prosecutors when they were negotiating a 2007 agreement, \nwhich allowed him to escape federal prosecution if he pleaded guilty to state charges that carried a \nlesser penalty. \n\"We're trying to figure out if Epstein used his political connections and great wealth to secure this \nkind of arrangement, that was unheard of, frankly, if you look at these charges,\" said Paul Cassell, an \nattorney for the women. \nEpstein is a native New Yorker who according to media reports built a huge fortune as a money \nmanager and owns several properties including a primary residence in Manhattan, a Palm Beach \nmansion and his own island in the Caribbean. At one point he counted among his friends former \nPresident Bill Clinton, Donald Trump and other high-powered figures. \nThe appeal court decision described the background of Epstein's case, stating that in 2006, the Federal \nBureau of Investigation \"began investigating allegations that Jeffrey Epstein had sexually abused \nseveral minor girls.\" \nIn September 2007, federal prosecutors struck the non-prosecution d\n... [truncated, 2447 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00605732/7 or ?id=EFTA00605732&page=7]", "char_count": 2447}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Victims win right to see negotiations that led to 'lenient' plea agreement for billionaire sex... Page 2 of 3 \nIn June 2008, Epstein pleaded guilty to a state charge of procuring a person under the age of 18 for \nprostitution and was sentenced to 18 months in prison. He spent 13 months behind bars, and is \nregistered as a sex offender in Florida. \nThe situation also resulted in civil suits being filed against Epstein, who according to media reports \nsettled claims from about two dozen young women who alleged he paid them for sexual massages at \nhis Palm Beach mansion, some as young as 14, according to media reports. \nTo the attorneys who represent the Jane Does 1 and 2, the sentence was much lighter than the years, \nor possibly decades, that Epstein could've spent behind bars had he been prosecuted in the federal \nsystem. \nThey're hoping that the correspondence, ordered released by the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, \nwill shed light on what they say is an unusually lenient deal. \n\"I can say that I've been teaching criminal law for more than two decades and I have never seen a plea \nagreement as lenient as this one, for hands-on sex offenders,\" said Cassell, who is based in Salt Lake \nCity. \nBut one of Epstein's attorney's, Martin Weinberg, based in Boston, disputed those characterizations. \nWeinberg said Monday that the plea agreement was \"reached in good faith\" and that \"it's not a fair \nconclusion\" to describe the agreement as either improper or tainted by Epstein's wealth. \n\"It's Mr. Cassell's hope that this correspondence may support that theory, but the reality is that the \nU.S. Attorney's Office made a responsible judgment in how to implement the law,\" Weinberg said. \nWeinberg said he was concerned about the potential impact the ruling would have on the ability of \ncriminal defense attorneys and prosecutors to communicate confidentially. \nHe also said he and Epstein co-counsel, Miami criminal defense attorney Roy Black, will ask the \nAtlanta-based appeals \n... [truncated, 2986 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00605732/8 or ?id=EFTA00605732&page=8]", "char_count": 2986}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Victims win right to see negotiations that led to 'lenient' plea agreement for billionaire sex... Page 3 of 3 \nCopyright O 2014, South Florida Sun-Sentinel \nhttp://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/palm-beach/fl-jeffrey-epstein-federal-court-of-appeals-2... 5/2/2014 \nEFTA00605741\n", "char_count": 273}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "5/2/2014 \nAppellate ruling could force feds to reccnsider sex charo es... I \nHelp \n84° \n11:8? \nL74' \n© Friday, May 2,2014 \nThe Palm Beach PostREAL NEWS STARTS HERE \nSign Out \n[ Search Site \nHONE I NEWS \n—1C \n0 \n03 \n.0 \n0 \n0 \nIL. \nforPmthSerrerl \nResize text A \nA \nA \nAppellate ruling could force feds to reconsider sex charges against Palm \nBeacher Epstein \nPosted. 925 pin Monday. April 21. 2014 \nBY DAPHNE DURET - PALM BEACH POST STAFF WRITER \nA federal appellate court has moved two young victims of billionaire sex offender Jeffrey Epstein a step closer \nto wiping out a plea deal that prosecutors made behind their backs. \nThellth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Friday that the underage victims were entitled to see all \ncorrespondence between federal prosecutors and Epstein's lawyers regarding a secret 2007 plea deal that \nkept Epstein from federal charges in exchange for an 18-month work-release sentence in state prison. \nThe plea negotiations took place as Epstein litigated a series of now-settled civil claims surrounding \nallegations that he had sex in his Palm Beach mansion with dozens of underage girls. \nThe two victims who are seeking the documents are not identified in court documents. They were 12 and 13 at \nhttp/Awm.neipalmbeachpoSicem/ne...sinews/appellele-ruling-cadd-forceleds.lo-recceolder-se/ntrtynci& pep intetnallink nbpl:pmitatonbok feb2014_99cda \ntie \nEFTA00605742\n", "char_count": 1399}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "92/2014 \nAppellant ruling could force fees to reconsider sex charges. I \nthe time of their liaisons with Epstein. who pleaded guilty to two prostitution solicitation charges. The girls \nreached an out-of-court settlement with him. \nIn ruling that the correspondence should be public, the appellate court authorized the release of more than \n500 pages of documents. The victims' lawyers would use the documents to prove that, by keeping the \nagreement secret, prosecutors violated a federal act aimed at protecting victims' rights. \nA win in that battle could invalidate Epstein's agreement with federal prosecutors, allowing them to \nreconsider criminal charges, but this time with input from the victims. \nEpstein's lawyers argued that the correspondence constituted confidential plea negotiations and therefore \nshould not be shared with the victims' lawyers. \n\"Although plea negotiations are vital to the functioning of the criminal justice system, a prosecutor and target \nof a criminal investigation do not enjoy a relationship of confidence and trust when they negotiate.\" the \nappellate justices wrote, calling the prosecutor-defense attorney relationship adversarial. \nThey upheld a 2013 ruling by U.S. District Court Judge Kenneth Marra. He ordered the release of all the plea \ndocuments, but only federal prosecutors complied. \nThe victims' attorneys. Brad Edwards and Paul Cassell, have called the ruling a victory for the rights of victims \nto be heard, even in cases like Epstein's, where federal prosecutors ultimately never filed charges. The victims \nwere unaware of the plea agreement until three days before Epstein pleaded to the state charges in June 2008. \nA federal deal had been in place for nine months by then. \nHad prosecutors filed charges and negotiated a plea with Epstein in federal court, they would be barred from \nseeking any additional punishment against him. But because his plea agreement to a sex solicitation charge \ncame in state court, federal prosecutors theo\n... [truncated, 3217 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00605732/11 or ?id=EFTA00605732&page=11]", "char_count": 3217}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00605732", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "52/2014 \nAm elia° Wing cadd bye fads b reconsider sex chafe es . I \nwe get some new eyes on the case and the circumstances are different, things will change.\" \nIn this Section \nPalm Beach CountySheriffs Office offers salute to 16 fallen in the line of duty over the decades \n\\77) \nj't \nkJ? \nFree movie at Boy ton's Dewey Park on Friday \nBoynton Beach officers stop to investigate Camaro. witness theft of BMW; pursuit ends In crash \nGreenacres single-family home development moving forward \nOur Economy. Gardens complex lands 3 sizeable businesses \nMorning commute on 195, turnpike clear of crashes from Boca to Vero \nAnd out how to work on the Riviera Beach marina development \nRoyal Palm Beach Publix sells Fantasy 5 ticket now worth more than $111K \nSun, rain today and mostly rain Saturday in Palm Beach County. TCoast \n3 NYPD officers arrested in separate gun incidents \nPREVIOUS: \nNEXT: \nLOCAL \nOPINION \nTequesta crash sends seven people to \nCommentary: Has GM pulled a Pinto? \nhospitals \nPopular on \nAll Comments (o) \nPost a Comment \nCOMMENTS \nPost comment \nhttp:lMmw.rnwelnbeacrposlcmYne sinews/appekale-rolirg-coulddace-reds-larecomider-se/nfily cid•pbp irdernallink rrwl:cirnitationtcoc feb2014_99cda \n3/6 \nEFTA00605744\n", "char_count": 1230}]}