{"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_count": 129, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00603608", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00603608.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing # 31809747 E-Filed 09/08/2015 04:29:22 PM \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT \nIN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and \nPAUL G. CASSELL, \nPlaintiffs/Counterclaim Defendants, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff. \nDEFENDANT/COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFF ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ'S MOTION \nTO COMPEL PLAINTIFFS' PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS & \nCOMPLETE RESPONSES TO INTERROGATORIES \nDefendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ (\"Dershowitz\") respectfully \nmoves this Court for entry of an Order that (a) overrules the objections asserted by Plaintiffs \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS (\"Edwards\") and PAUL G. CASSELL (\"Cassell\") in response to \nDershowitz's First Set of Document Requests and First Set of Interrogatories; (b) compels \nEdwards and Cassell to produce any and all documents responsive to Dershowitz's First Set of \nDocument Requests; and (c) compels Edwards and Cassell to provide complete responses to \nDershowitz's First Set of Interrogatories. \nIn support of this motion, Dershowitz states as \nfollows: \nBACKGROUND \nPlaintiffs filed this defamation action against Dershowitz on January 6, 2015. In their \nComplaint, Plaintiffs allege that Dershowitz defamed them by \"initiat[ing] a massive public \nmedia assault on the reputation and character of [Edwards] and [Cassell] accusing them of \nEFTA00603608\n", "char_count": 1393}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "intentionally lying in their filing, of having leveled knowingly false accusations against \n[Dershowitz] without ever conducting any investigation of the credibility of the accusations, and \nof having acted unethically to the extent that their willful misconduct warranted and required \ndisbarment\" — even though Dershowitz \"knew [the pleading containing the false and outrageous \nallegations by Plaintiffs' client, Jane Doe No. 3, about Dershowitz] to be an entirely proper and \nwell-founded pleading.\" Exhibit A, Compl. 1 17. \nOn February 11, 2015, Dershowitz served a First Set of Document Requests on each of \nthe Plaintiffs, individually, along with a First Set of Interrogatories on each of the Plaintiffs, \nindividually (together, the \"Discovery Requests\"). On March 13, 2015, Plaintiffs served their \nresponses to Dershowitz's First Sets of Interrogatories. See Exhibit B (the \"Interrogatory \nResponses\"). Throughout the Interrogatory Responses, Plaintiffs raised boilerplate, unfounded \nobjections and conclusorily asserted that some or all of the information sought by Dershowitz is \nprotected by the attorney-client privilege and/or the work product doctrine. See id. Also on \nMarch 13, 2015, Plaintiffs filed their responses and objections to Dershowitz's First Set of \nDocument Requests (the \"Original Responses\"). See Exhibit C. Plaintiffs did not actually \nproduce a single document, however, until late July 2015. \nOn August 28, 2015, and following several discovery conferences between counsel, \nPlaintiffs served supplemental responses to Dershowitz's First Sets of Document Requests to \nwithdraw certain objections and otherwise clarify their responses. \nSee Exhibit D (the \n\"Supplemental Responses\"). \nIn the Supplemental Responses, Plaintiffs continued to raise \nbaseless form objections and also continued to assert conclusorily that the documents Dershowitz \nseeks are (1) not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence and/or \n(2) protected by the a\n... [truncated, 2080 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/1 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=1]", "char_count": 2080}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "ARGUMENT \nAs set forth below, many of Plaintiffs' objections to the Discovery Requests are \nunfounded and should be overruled. \nMoreover, Plaintiffs' document production and \nInterrogatory Responses were deficient in a number of respects, even putting aside the validity of \ntheir objections. \nAccordingly, Dershowitz seeks an order from the Court (a) overruling \nPlaintiffs' objections to Dershowitz's Discovery Requests; (b) compelling Plaintiffs to produce \nin a timely manner all documents responsive to Dershowitz's First Set of Document Requests; \nand (c) compelling Plaintiffs to provide complete responses to Dershowitz's First Set of \nInterrogatories in a timely manner. \n1. \nPlaintiffs have waived any privilege or protection that would otherwise \nattach to responsive documents and information by bringing this defamation action and \nplacing at issue the truthfulness of Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against Dershowitz and the \nadequacy of their investigation into those allegations. Plaintiffs asserted the attorney-client \nprivilege and/or the work product doctrine as a basis for withholding material responsive to the \nDiscovery Requests seeking information and documents concerning: (1) Jane Doe No. 3's \nallegations against Dershowitz asserted in the action captioned Jane Doe #1, et al. v. United \nStates of America, Case No. 08-cv-80736 (S.D. Fla.) (the \"Federal Action\"); (2) Plaintiffs' \ninvestigation into Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against Dershowitz; (3) Plaintiffs' assertion in the \nComplaint that Dershowitz was an alleged participant in the criminal conduct committed by \nJeffrey Epstein (\"Epstein\"); and (4) Jane Doe No. 3's whereabouts and activities during the time \nwhen she claims to have been \"sex slave\" for Epstein. See Exhibit B, Interrogatory Responses, \n3 \nEFTA00603610\n", "char_count": 1811}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Nos. 13, 21; Exhibit D, Supplemental Responses, Nos. 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 15, 16, 21, 22, 25, \n26, 28, 31, 32, 34, 35.1\nPlaintiffs cannot properly assert privilege objections in response to Dershowitz's \nDiscovery Requests seeking these categories of information and documents. By filing this \ndefamation action and placing at issue both the truthfulness of Jane Doe No. 3's allegations \nagainst Dershowitz and the adequacy of their investigation into those allegations, Plaintiffs have \nwaived any right to rely on the attorney-client privilege, the work product doctrine, or any other \npotentially applicable privilege or protection. \nThe Florida Supreme Court has long recognized that \"when a party has filed a claim, \nbased upon a matter ordinarily privileged, the proof of which will necessarily require that the \nprivileged matter be offered in evidence, we think that he has waived his right to insist, in \npretrial discovery proceedings, that the matter is privileged.\" Saving v. Luciano, 92 So. 2d 817, \n819 (Fla. 1957); see also Hearn v. Rhay, 68 F.R.D. 574, 581 (E.D. Wash. 1975) (where the party \nasserting the privilege placed the protected information at issue through some affirmative act for \nhis own benefit, allowing the privilege to protect against the disclosure of such information \nwould be manifestly unfair to the opposing party). An \"at-issue\" waiver occurs when: \n(1) assertion of the privilege was a result of some affirmative act, such as filing \nsuit, by the asserting party; (2) through this affirmative act, the asserting party put \nthe protected information at issue by making it relevant to the case; and (3) \napplication of the privilege would have denied the opposing party access to \ninformation vital to his defense. \nPlaintiffs have to date failed to provide any sort of privilege log to support their broad \nassertions of the attorney-client privilege and the work product protection as a basis for \nwithholding documents and information responsive to Ders\n... [truncated, 2251 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/3 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=3]", "char_count": 2251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Id. at 581 (emphasis added); see also Pitney-Bowes, Inc. v. Mestre, 86 F.R.D. 444, 447-48 (S.D. \nFla. 1980) (applying the Hearn test to hold that, by engaging in the affirmative act of filing suit, \nthe plaintiff injected into \"the very soul of this litigation\" the attorney-client communications he \nsought to withhold and thus \"waived the right to assert the attorney-client privilege with regard \nto these documents\"). \nHere, as in Pitney-Bowes, all three elements of the at-issue doctrine are established. \nFirst, Plaintiffs are asserting the attorney-client privilege and work product protection to \nwithhold documents and information in a defamation action they filed. Thus, their assertion of \nprivilege is the direct result of their own affirmative act in filing suit against Dershowitz for the \npurpose of recovering damages. \nSecond, in bringing this defamation action, Plaintiffs have made the information and \ndocuments they seek to withhold directly relevant to the issues in dispute. To prevail in this \naction, Plaintiffs must substantiate their allegation that Dershowitz defamed them by \"initiat[ing] \na massive public media assault on the reputation and character of [Edwards] and [Cassell] \naccusing them of intentionally lying in their filing, of having leveled knowingly false accusations \nagainst [Dershowitz] without ever conducting any investigation of the credibility of the \naccusations, and of having acted unethically to the extent that their willful misconduct warranted \nand required disbarment\" — even though Dershowitz \"knew [the filing in the Federal Action \ncontaining the allegations about Dershowitz] to be an entirely proper and well-founded \npleading.\" Exhibit A, Compl. I 17 (emphasis added). In other words, to prove that Dershowitz \ncommitted defamation, Plaintiffs must establish — among other things2 — (i) that they conducted \n2 Under Florida law, a defamation plaintiff must establish the following elements: \n(1) publication; (2) falsity; (3) actor must \n... [truncated, 2168 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/4 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=4]", "char_count": 2168}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "an investigation regarding the credibility of Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against Dershowitz, and \n(ii) that the allegations asserted against Dershowitz by Jane Doe No. 3 in the Federal Action \nwere, in fact, \"well-founded.\" The only way for Plaintiffs to meet their burden of proof is \nthrough the use of information that might otherwise be protected by the attorney-client privilege \nand/or the work product doctrine. As just one illustrative example, Plaintiffs cannot establish the \nfact of their investigation into the credibility of Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against Dershowitz \n(let alone the adequacy of that investigation) without disclosing the documents \"concerning their \ninvestigation of Jane Doe #3\" (sought in Request No. 31) and the documents they referred to or \nrelied upon in preparing the filing in the Federal Action (sought in Request No. 34). \nThird, allowing Plaintiffs to withhold responsive documents on the basis of the attorney-\nclient privilege and the work product doctrine would deny Dershowitz access to information that \nis vital to his defense. Among other affirmative defenses, Dershowitz has alleged that, to the \nextent any of his purportedly defamatory statements are deemed to contain assertions of fact \nrather than constitutionally protected expressions of opinion, those factual assertions are true. It \nwould be inequitable to preclude Dershowitz from proving this affirmative defense, which is \nexactly what would result if Plaintiffs' assertions of privilege are upheld. Moreover, Plaintiffs \ncannot be allowed to unilaterally pick and choose which documents are helpful to their case and \nshould be produced, and which documents can be withheld as privileged. See Oil, Chem. & \nAtomic Workers. Union v. Sinclair Oil Corp., 748 P.2d 283, 294 (Wyo. 1987) (observing that \nthe at-issue waiver doctrine is designed to address the unfairness associated with allowing a party \nprivate person; (4) actual damages; and (5) statement must be defamatory. Jews \n... [truncated, 2358 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/5 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=5]", "char_count": 2358}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "to assert the relevancy of information through some affirmative act for his own benefit, while at \nthe same time denying his opponent access to the very evidence that might refute or allow \ndefense of this information). \nIn sum, Plaintiffs' objections to Interrogatory Nos. 13 and 21 and to Document Request \nNos. 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 15, 16, 21, 22, 25, 26, 28, 31, 32, 34 & 35 on the basis of attorney-\nclient privilege and the work product doctrine must be overruled and production should be \ncompelled. \n2. \nPlaintiffs' unfounded relevancy and admissibility objections must be \noverruled. \nPlaintiffs also objected to many of the Discovery Requests propounded by \nDershowitz on the basis that the requests seek information that is irrelevant, inadmissible, and/or \nnot reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. In particular, Plaintiffs \nasserted relevancy and/or admissibility objections in response to the Discovery Requests seeking \ninformation and documents concerning: (1) Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against Dershowitz \nasserted in the Federal Action; (2) Plaintiffs' investigation into Jane Doe No. 3's allegations \nagainst Dershowitz; (3) Plaintiffs' assertion in the Complaint that Dershowitz was an alleged \nparticipant in the criminal conduct committed by Epstein; and (4) Jane Doe No. 3's whereabouts \nand activities during the time when she claims to have been a \"sex slave\" for Epstein. See \nExhibit A, Responses to Interrogatory Nos. 13, 21; Exhibit C, Responses to Document Request \nNos. 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 15, 21, 22, 25, 26, 28, 31, 32, 34, 35. \nPlaintiffs' objections in this regard are not well-taken. Under Rule 1.280 of the Florida \nRules of Civil Procedure, \"[p]arties may obtain discovery regarding any matter, not privileged, \nthat is relevant to the subject matter of the pending action, whether it relates to the claim or \ndefense of the party seeking discovery or the claim or defense of any other party[.]\" Put \n7 \nEFTA006036\n... [truncated, 2003 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/6 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=6]", "char_count": 2003}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "differently, information is discoverable so long as it relates \"to the issues involved in the \nlitigation, as framed in all pleadings.\" Diaz-Verson v. Walbridge Aldinger Co., 54 So. 3d 1007, \n1011 (Fla. 2d DCA 2010) (internal citation omitted); see also Richard Mulholland & Assocs. v. \nPolverari, 698 So. 2d 1269, 1270 (Fla. 2d DCA 1997) (a protective order is required only \"when \nthe pleadings indicate that the documents requested are not related to any pending claim or \ndefense.\"). \nAs noted above, the Complaint in this defamation case expressly alleges that Plaintiffs \nfiled a pleading on behalf of Jane Doe No. 3 in the Federal Action that contained factual \nallegations regarding Dershowitz, including that Dershowitz \"had knowledge of and \nparticipation in Epstein's criminal conduct.\" Exhibit A, Compl. ¶ 16. The Complaint goes on to \nallege that Dershowitz committed the tort of defamation by accusing Plaintiffs \"of having \nleveled knowingly false accusations against [Dershowitz] without ever conducting any \ninvestigation of the credibility of the accusations\" made by Jane Doe No. 3 — even though \nDershowitz \"knew [the filing containing Jane Doe No. 3's allegations] to be an entirely proper \nand well-founded pleading.\" Id. 1 17. Thus, Plaintiffs have placed the credibility of Jane Doe \nNo. 3's allegations against Dershowitz and their investigation of those allegations squarely at \nissue in this case. They cannot now seriously contend that documents and information relating to \nthose issues are not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence \nAccordingly, Plaintiffs' relevancy and/or admissibility objections to Interrogatory Nos. \n13 & 21 and Document Request Nos. 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, 15, 21, 22, 25, 26, 28, 31, 32, 34, & \n35 should be overruled and production compelled. \n3. \nPlaintiffs' remaining boilerplate objections also must be overruled. Plaintiffs \nassert a number of form objections throughout their responses to Dershowitz's Dis\n... [truncated, 2024 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/7 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=7]", "char_count": 2024}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Requests, claiming that the requests are vague, overbroad, overly burdensome, and/or harassing. \nSee generally Exhibits B, C, & D. Such boilerplate objections are improper. \nIn Florida, objections to interrogatories must specify the grounds for the objection; non-\nspecific objections will not suffice. E.g., Christie v. Hixson, 358 So. 2d 859, 860 (Fla. 4th DCA \n1978). Likewise, objections to document requests must also state with specificity the particular \nprovision of the request to which an objection is being asserted. E.g., Am. Funding, Ltd. v. Hill, \n402 So. 2d 1369, 1370 (Fla. 1st DCA 1981) (\"[T]he rule [governing requests for production] \nrequires that a party respond to a request and that any objections be specifically stated.\"). Here, \nPlaintiffs' generalized objections on the grounds of vagueness, over-breadth, burden, and \nharassment are not specifically tailored to the individual interrogatories and document requests \nissued by Dershowitz. It is therefore impossible for Dershowitz to attempt to clarify the asserted \nvagueness or otherwise modify the requests to make them narrower and less burdensome. \nAccordingly, all of Plaintiffs' non-specific, boilerplate objections on the basis of \nvagueness, over-breadth, burden, and harassment should be overruled. \n4. \nPlaintiffs cannot rely on vague, generalized references to purportedly public \ncourt documents and other documents allegedly in Dershowitz's possession. Throughout \ntheir responses to Dershowitz's discovery requests, Plaintiffs make generalized references to \npleadings, deposition transcripts, and other documents that they contend are either available on \npublic court dockets or within Dershowitz's possession, custody or control. By way of example: \n• \nDocument Request No. 2 seeks \"[a]it Documents Concerning Dershowitz's \nalleged `participation in Epstein's criminal conduct' referenced in paragraph 16 of \nthe Complaint.\" After noting that they \"have collected many pages of documents \npointing to Ders\n... [truncated, 2406 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/8 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=8]", "char_count": 2406}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "following civil proceedings in which Jeffrey Epstein was named as a party,\" \nfollowed by a list of 24 different case numbers. Id. Plaintiffs further note that \n\"Dershowitz also possesses significant information that is responsive to this \nrequest — information that Edwards and Cassell have requested from Dershowitz \nin their requests for production.\" Id. \n• \nDocument Request No. 22 seeks \"[a]ll Documents Concerning any assertion that \nDershowitz negotiated the [non-prosecution agreement (\"NPA\")] for his own \nbenefit.\" In response, Plaintiffs state in relevant part that \"Dershowitz possesses, \nor has access to, all information regarding his negotiation of the NPA.\" Exhibit \nD, Supplemental Response to Request No. 22. \n• \nDocument Request No. 25 seeks \"[a]ll Documents Concerning any investigation \nof Dershowitz.\" In response, Plaintiffs state in relevant part: \"[s]ee also all \ndepositions taken in all civil cases involving Jeffrey Epstein in which the \nallegations concerned his molestation of minors\"; \"[s]ee also the criminal Palm \nBeach State Attorney's Office regarding Jeffrey Epstein\"; and \"[s]ee also all \nbooks, articles and publications of or about Dershowitz which are in the \npossession of Dershowitz or in public circulation.\" Exhibit D, Supplemental \nResponse to Request No. 25. \nSee also Exhibit B, Interrogatory Responses, Nos. 5, 10, 11, 12, 17, 22; Exhibit D, \nSupplemental Responses, Nos. 3, 7, 8, 9, 14, 15, 21, 35. \nThese responses are inadequate under Florida law for a number of reasons. First, \nPlaintiffs' vague, unspecific responses provide absolutely no notice to Dershowitz of which \ndocuments Plaintiffs assert support their allegations of defamation. Most notably, Plaintiffs have \nnot identified or produced the specific documents that supposedly support the allegation in the \nComplaint that Dershowitz's statements about Plaintiffs \"were false and known by him to be \nfalse at the time they were made.\" Exhibit A, Compl. 1 17. \nSecond, Plaintiffs seem to s\n... [truncated, 2364 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/9 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=9]", "char_count": 2364}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "extent of Plaintiffs' investigation into the allegations raised in the Federal Action about \nDershowitz, as opposed to their investigation more generally of Epstein. \nThird, by referring generally to the purportedly \"public\" nature of documents filed or \nexchanged in other court cases, Plaintiffs are improperly attempting to shift the burden \nassociated with the collection of documents they have identified as responsive to the Discovery \nRequests. In some circumstances, it may be perfectly valid to assert that the burden of locating \nresponsive documents rests equally on both parties. \nThat is not the case here, however. \nDershowitz understands that many of the civil cases against Epstein that Plaintiffs identified in \nresponse to Request No. 2 contain filings that are under seal. \nDeposition transcripts and \ndiscovery materials exchanged in those civil cases would not be available from the public docket \nin any event. The cases are also voluminous. \nHaving participated in many of the cases identified in response to Request No. 2, \nPlaintiffs are well-aware of the limitations as to what is \"publicly available\" from those dockets. \nPlaintiffs are therefore implying in this regard that Dershowitz automatically has possession, \ncustody, and/or control over any document relating to any case involving Epstein by virtue of \nDershowitz's representation of Epstein in certain criminal actions. This is incorrect. Documents \nrelating to or concerning the civil actions brought against Epstein are, by definition, Epstein's \ndocuments — not Dershowitz's. Dershowitz did not serve as Epstein's counsel of record in \nconnection with any of the 24 civil cases identified by Plaintiffs. Nor does Dershowitz serve as \nEpstein's counsel of record for purposes of the Federal Action. Dershowitz likewise does not \nhave every document relating to the negotiation of the NPA in his possession, custody, or \ncontrol; Plaintiffs, by contrast, have collected those documents, to the extent not privil\n... [truncated, 2028 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/10 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=10]", "char_count": 2028}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "have them in their possession. Plaintiffs cannot treat Dershowitz as being interchangeable with \nEpstein, a non-party.3\nDershowitz is also entitled to know which specific document(s) in these cases are directly \nresponsive to his specific document requests and interrogatories, as Plaintiffs cannot maintain \nthat each case in its entirety — including non-substantive filings like notices of deposition, notices \nof hearing, etc., — is responsive. \nFor these reasons, Plaintiffs should be compelled to (I) produce all documents and \ninformation that is responsive to Interrogatory Nos. 5, 10, 11, 12, 17, 22; and to Document \nRequest Nos. 2, 3, 7, 8, 9, 14, 15, 21, 22, 25, & 35; and (2) identify with specificity the particular \ndocuments that are responsive to the foregoing Interrogatories and Document Requests .° \n5. \nPlaintiffs must be compelled to produce their retainer agreement with Jane \nDoe No. 3. In response to Request No. 30, which seeks \"[a]ll Documents Concerning Your \nretainer agreement with Jane Doe #3,\" Plaintiffs objected on the basis that the request seeks \n\"information not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, attorney-\nclient privilege, work-product doctrine, overly burdensome, overbroad, vague, harassing.\" \nExhibit D, Supplemental Responses, Req. No. 30. Plaintiffs' objections are not well-taken. \nAs an initial matter, the terms of Plaintiffs' engagement by Jane Doe No. 3 are directly \nrelevant to the issues in dispute in this action. The timing of Jane Doe No. 3's retention of \nPlaintiffs is indisputably relevant to determining when Jane Doe No. 3 first raised allegations \n3 Dershowitz maintains that there are no documents or information that support Plaintiffs' \ndefamation claim because Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against him are completely false. \n4 At Plaintiffs' insistence, Dershowitz identified by Bates number the specific documents \nresponsive to Plaintiffs' four sets of document requests, which total nearly 50 sep\n... [truncated, 2198 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/11 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=11]", "char_count": 2198}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "against Dershowitz and Plaintiffs' corresponding investigation into those allegations - issues that \nare in dispute by virtue of Plaintiffs' filing of this litigation and the allegations raised in their \nComplaint against Dershowitz. See Exhibit A, Compl. fi 16-17. Likewise, the financial terms \nof Plaintiffs' engagement by Jane Doe No. 3 are relevant to issues of bias, including whether \nPlaintiffs had any financial incentives to sensationalize the allegations against Dershowitz. \nDershowitz has a right to explore Plaintiffs' and Jane Doe No. 3's bias. See Steinger, Iscoe & \nGreene, P.A. v. GEICO Gen. Ins. Co., 103 So. 3d 200, 203 (Fla. 4th DCA 2012) (discovery \naimed at obtaining evidence of a witness's bias is permissible). \nMoreover, there is no basis for Plaintiffs' assertion that the retainer agreement or \ndocuments relating thereto are protected by the attorney-client privilege or the work product \ndoctrine. It is well-established that a retainer letter between a client and her attorney generally is \nnot protected by the attorney-client privilege, nor is other information relating to the financial \narrangements between the attorney and the client. See, e.g., Lawfinders Assocs., Inc. v. Legal \nResearch Ctr., Inc., 193 F.3d 517, 518 (5th Cir. 1999) (\"[T]he attorney-client privilege does not \nprotect the type of information contained in the retainer letters.\"); United States v. Davis, 636 \nF.2d 1028, 1043-44 (5th Cir. 1981) (explaining that \"[f]inancial transactions between the \nattorney and client, including the compensation paid by or on behalf of the client\" generally are \nnot protected by the attorney-client privilege). \nPlaintiffs' remaining boilerplate objections to Request No. 30 lack any specificity or \nsupport and are also improper, as discussed above. For these reasons, Plaintiffs' objections to \nDocument Request No. 30 should be overruled, and production should be compelled. \n6. \nPlaintiffs must be compelled to produce any documents concerning any \nac\n... [truncated, 2103 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/12 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=12]", "char_count": 2103}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "response to Request No. 29, which seeks \"[a]ll Documents Concerning any actual or potential \nbook, television, movie or other media deals Concerning Jane Doe No. 3's allegations about \nbeing a sex slave,\" Plaintiffs objected on the basis that this request seeks \"information not \nreasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, \nwork-product doctrine, overly burdensome, overbroad, vague, harassing.\" \nExhibit D, \nSupplemental Responses, Req. No. 29. Once again, Plaintiffs' objections are improper and \nunfounded. \nThe documents and information requested by Dershowitz in Request No. 29 are directly \nrelevant to the issues in dispute in this defamation action. As noted above, Dershowitz has a \nright to explore any biases held by Plaintiffs and/or their client, Jane Doe No. 3. E.g., Steinger, \n103 So. 3d at 203. Information about movie deals, book deals, or other financial arrangements \nthat could give Jane Doe No. 3 and her lawyers a financial motive to invent sensational \nallegations like those she has made against Dershowitz are directly relevant to the issue of bias. \nSuch information also is highly probative of Jane Doe No. 3's credibility and the adequacy of \nPlaintiffs' investigation into Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against Dershowitz. \nPlaintiffs' objections to Document Request No. 29 should therefore be overruled, and \nproduction should be compelled. \n7. \nPlaintiffs must be compelled to produce responsive documents from the \nFederal Action that have been unsealed. Request No. 22 seeks \"[a]ll Documents Concerning \nany assertion that Dershowitz negotiated the NPA for his own benefit.\" In their Supplemental \nResponses served on August 25, 2015, Plaintiffs stated that: \n[They] [] have received from the U.S. Attorney's Office from the Southern \nDistrict of Florida approximately 1000 pages of correspondence between that \nOffice and Jeffrey Epstein's legal defense team (including Dershowitz) \nexchanged from approximately\n... [truncated, 2063 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/13 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=13]", "char_count": 2063}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "agreement. Those documents are currently under seal by order of the U.S. \nDistrict Court for the Southern District of Florida in connection with the [Federal \nAction]. This seal has been requested by, and obtained by, Dershowitz's close \nfriend, client and co-conspirator, Jeffrey Epstein, over the objection of Edwards \nand Cassell on behalf of their clients. Accordingly, Dershowitz should request \nthat Epstein withdraw his request for sealing so that these materials can be \nproduced to Dershowitz. \nExhibit D, Supplemental Responses, Req. No. 22. \nPlaintiffs' response is incorrect in a number of respects. Dershowitz is not a \"co-\nconspirator\" of Epstein's. Moreover, on July 6, 2015, U.S. District Judge Marra issued a ruling \nin the Federal Action that unsealed many of the communications between Epstein's counsel and \nthe U.S. Attorney's Office relating to the negotiation of the non-prosecution agreement. See \nExhibit E. Plaintiffs therefore should be compelled to produce the responsive documents they \nidentified in Req. No. 22, as their objection on the basis of sealing is no longer proper. \n8. \nLastly, Plaintiffs must be compelled to advise that production is complete. In \ntheir Supplemental Responses to the First Set of Document Requests, Plaintiffs continued to \nassert objections, in part, along with a substantive response. Plaintiffs have been producing \nthose documents they have identified as responsive in a rolling manner. In so doing, Dershowitz \nis not in a position to know if and when production is complete, that all responsive documents \nhave been produced, and/or whether any documents have been withheld. Plaintiffs must be \ncompelled to state same. \nWHEREFORE, Defendant / Counterclaim Plaintiff ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, by and \nthrough his undersigned counsel, respectfully requests this Honorable Court enter an Order \n(a) overruling Plaintiffs' objections to the Discovery Requests; (b) compelling Plaintiffs to \nproduce all documents responsive to Dershowitz's Fi\n... [truncated, 2155 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/14 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=14]", "char_count": 2155}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Interrogatories in a timely manner; and (d) such other and further relief as this Court deems just \nand proper. \nCERTIFICATE OF CONFERRAL \nPursuant to the Court's Rules and Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, the undersigned \ncounsel certifies that he has made a good faith attempt to resolve this matter with opposing \ncounsel prior to filing this motion. \n16 \nEFTA00603623\n", "char_count": 373}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Respectfully submitted, \n/s/ Thomas E. Scott \nThomas E. Scott, Esq. \nFlorida Bar No. 149100 \nThomas.scott@csklegal.com \nSteven R. Safra, Esq. \nFlorida Bar No. 057028 \nSteven.safra@csklegal.com \nCOLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A. \nDadeland Centre II, 14th Floor \n9150 South Dadeland Boulevard \nMiami, Florida 33156 \nPhone: (305) 350-5300 \nFax: (305) 373-2294 \nRichard A. Simpson (pro hac vice) \nrsimpson@ wileyrein.com \nMary E. Soda (pro hac vice) \nmborja@wileyrein.com \nAshley E. Eiler (pro hac vice) \naeiler@wileyrein.com \nWILEY REIN LLP \n1776 K Street, NW \nWashington, DC 20006 \nPhone: (202) 719-7000 \nFax: (202) 719-7049 \nCounsel for Alan M. Dershowitz \n17 \nEFTA00603624\n", "char_count": 667}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a copy of the foregoing has been furnished by electronic mail \n(email) \nat \nemail \naddress: \njsx esearcylaw.com, \nmep searcylaw .com, \nscarolateam@searcylaw.com to: Jack Scarola, Esq, Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, \nP.A., Counsel for Plaintiff, 2139 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd., West Palm Beach, Florida 33409, and \nI electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of Broward County by using the Florida Courts \neFiling Portal this 8th day of September, 2015 . \nBy:  s/Thomas E. Scott \nTHOMAS E. SCOTT \nFBN: 149100 \n18 \nEFTA00603625\n", "char_count": 588}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "EXHIBIT A \nEFTA00603626\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "User ID: c021589, DatelTime: 1/13/2015 10:43 AM, Document Name: Dershowitz ComplaInt.pdf \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN \nAND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, \nFLORIDA \nCASE NO.: \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and \nPAUL G. CASSELL, \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant. \nCOMPLAINT \nPlaintiffs, BRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. CASSELL, by and through their \nundersigned attorneys, sue the Defendant, ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, and allege: \n1. \nThis is an action for damages in an amount in excess of the minimum \njurisdictional limits of this Court. \n2. \nPAUL G. CASSELL is a resident of the Stale of Utah, is sui juris, is a former \nUnited States federal judge, who is a professor at the S.J. Quinney College of Law at the \nUniversity of Utah. He is and at all times material hereto has been a member in good standing of \nthe Bar of the State of Utah and has been and continues to be admitted to practice pro hac vice in \nthe State of Florida. \n3. \nPrior to assuming his teaching responsibilities, PAUL G. CASSELL clerked first \nfor the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit (1984-1985) and then from 1985 to 1986 \nclerked for the United States Supreme Court before serving as an Associate Deputy Attorney \nEFTA00603627\n", "char_count": 1237}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Edwards and Cassell v. Dershowitz \nComplaint \nGeneral with the U.S. Justice Department and as an Assistant United States Attorney for the \nEastern District of Virginia. \n4. \nPAUL G. CASSELL was sworn in as a U.S. District Court Judge for the District \nof Utah in July of 2002 and served in that position for over 5 years before turning his MI time \nattention to crime victims' rights and criminal justice reform. \n5. \nPAUL G. CASSELL has at all material times enjoyed a highly favorable national \nreputation particularly related to his crime victims' rights work. \n6. \nPAUL G. CASSELL has served as co-counsel with BRADLEY J. EDWARDS in \nrepresenting the interests of multiple victims of billionaire, serial child abuser, Jeffrey Epstein, \nincluding in particular a pending action in Federal District Court for the Southern District of \nFlorida under the federal Crime Victims' Rights Act (CVRA) which challenges the legality of a \nsecret deal that immunized Jeffrey Epstein and associates of Epstein from federal criminal \nprosecution despite evidence that Epstein had sexually assaulted over 40 female minors on \nhundreds of occasions with the active help and participation of multiple associates. \n7. \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS is a resident of T3roward County, Florida, is sui juris, \nand is and at all times material hereto has been an attorney duly licensed to practice law and \nregularly engaged in the practice of law throughout the State of Florida and beyond. \n8. \nDespite having previously been the victim of character assassination by the \nDefendant, ALAN M. DERSHOW1TZ'S associate and client, Jeffrey Epstein, BRADLEY J. \nEDWARDS enjoys a highly favorable national reputation particularly related to his work in \ndefending the rights of child victims of sexual abuse. \n2 \nEFTA00603628\n", "char_count": 1791}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Edwards and Cassell v. Dcrshowitz \nComplaint \n9. \nBefore entering the private practice of law, BRADLEY J. EDWARDS was a trial \nattorney at the Broward County Slate Attorney's Office responsible for the prosecution of many \nmajor and violent crimes. Ile is a Florida Bar Board Certified Civil Trial Attorney who has tried \ndozens of jury trials. \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS has been profiled in The Best Lawyers in America and \nrecognized by the National Trial Lawyers Association by inclusion in its \"Top 40 Under 40\" \nlisting. BRADLEY J. EDWARDS' professional peers have given him a Martindale-Hubbell \nrating of \"AV\" attesting to the highest level of professional excellence and unquestionable ethics. \n10. \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS has been actively involved for the better part of the \nlast decade in representing multiple victims of the billionaire, serial child abuser, Jeffrey Epstein. \n11. \nDefendant, ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, upon information and belief is a resident \nof the Slate of Florida and is sui juris. \n12. \nDefendant, ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, is an attorney whose involvement in \nmultiple high-profile legal matters has enabled hint to command easy access to mass media news \nsources. \n13. \nDefendant, ALAN M. DERSIIOWITZ, was one of a very large team of lawyers \ninvolved in defending Jeffrey Epstein during his criminal investigation, and according to \nDERSHOWITZ'S own public statements, DERSIIOWITZ was responsible for negotiating \nEpstein's secret deal with the federal government which afforded protection not only to Epstein \nbut to various of his associates as well. \n3 \nEFTA00603629\n", "char_count": 1587}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Edwards and Cassell v. Dershowii z \nComplaint \n14. \nIn fulfillment of their obligations to two Epstein-victim clients, BRADLEY J. \nEDWARDS and PAUL G. CASSELL filed and have been aggressively prosecuting a legal \naction in the Federal District Court as previously described in Paragraph 6. \n15. \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. CASSELL on behalf of two additional \nEpstein-victim clients sought the agreement of the federal government to permit those clients to \nintervene in the already pending CVRA action. The government declined to agree to the \nintervention, thus requiring EDWARDS and CASSELL to file legal pleadings seeking a Court \nOrder Nrmiuing intervention on the basis of specifically alleged factual allegations. \n16. \nAmong the factual allegations made by EDWARDS and CASSELL were \nallegations that Defendant, DERSHOWITZ, had knowledge of and participation in Epstein's \ncriminal conduct. \n17. \nImmediately following the filing of what the Defendant, DERSHOWITZ, knew to \nbe an entirely proper and well-founded pleading, DERSHOWITZ initiated a massive public \nmedia assault on the reputation and character of BRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL accusing them of intentionally lying in their filing, of having leveled knowingly false \naccusations against the Defendant, DERSHOWITZ, without ever conducting any investigation of \nthe credibility of the accusations, and of having acted unethically to the extent that their willful \nmisconduct warranted and required disbarment. \n18. \nThe details of Defendant, DERSHOWITZ'S character assassination of \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. CASSELL are typified by the contents of the CNN \ninterview available to be accessed on the internet at: \n4 \nEFTA00603630\n", "char_count": 1717}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Edwards aid Cassell v. Dashowitz \nComplaint \nhttp://www.ctin.comknic/m/ockurope/prince-andrew-sex-abuse-allegations/index.himle \nThat interview is incorporated herein by reference. \n19. \nThe same or substantially identical accusations of deliberate misconduct and \nunethical behavior warranting disbannent of the Plaintiffs were repeated by the Defendant, \nDERSI1OWITZ, in multiple nationally televised interviews, in statements to and repeated by \nnational and international print news sources, and various other forms nationally and \ninternationally. \n20. \nThe Defendant, DERSHOWITZ'S statements were false and known by him to be \nfalse at the time they were made. DERSHOWITZ was speaking from his Miami residence at the \ntime he made the false and defamatory statements. \n21. \nAlternatively, DERSHOWITZ made the statements in reckless disregard of their \ntruth or falsity, intending that the statements would provide support for DERSHOWITZ'S false \nprotestations of his own innocence and direct attention away from DERSHOWITZ'S personal \nknowledge of and involvement in Epstein's criminal conduct and the subsequent cover up of that \nmisconduct. \n22, \nDERSHOWITZ'S statements were and are defamatory per se directly attacking \nthe fitness of the Plaintiffs to engage in the honored profession of the practice of law. \n23. \nDERSHOWITZ acted in willful, wanton, reckless, and intentional disregard of the \nrights of the Plaintiffs and under such circumstances as to warrant the imposition of punitive \ndamages. \n5 \nEFTA00603631\n", "char_count": 1529}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Edwards and Cassell v. Dershowitz \nComplain) \n24. \nAs the statements made by DERSHOWITZ are defamatory per se, injury to the \nPlaintiffs is presumed us u matter of law. \nWHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment against the Defendant, ALAN M. \nDERSHOWITZ, for compensatory damages, costs, pre and post-judgment interest, and such \nother and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. Plaintiffs \nreserve the III to assert claims for punitive damages upon satisfying the applicable statutory \nprerequisites. \nPlaintiffs further demand trial by jury. \nData) this _4 rg \nday of January, 2015. \nJACK' \nAROLA \nFlorid \nar No.: 169440 \nart, cy E-Mail(s): jsx@searcylaw.cont and \nipOsearcylaw.com \nt \nrimary E-Mail: _searolateam©searcytaw.com \nSearcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, P.A. \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409 \nPhone: (561) 686-6300 \nFax: \n(561)383-9451 \nAttorneys for Plaintiffs \n6 \nEFTA00603632\n", "char_count": 962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "EXHIBIT B \nEFTA00603633\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN \nAND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL, \nPlaintiff(s), \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant(s). \nNOTICE OF SERVING ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES \nPlaintiffs, Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, by and through their undersigned \ncounsel, hereby file this Notice of Serving Answers to Interrogatories with the Court propounded \nby the Defendant, ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, on February 11, 2015, and that a copy has been \nfurnished to the attorney for the Defendant. \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent via E-Serve \nto all Counsel on the attached list, this \nday of  \nLCIA\"  , 2015. \nOLA 74\nFlorida Bar No.: 169 0 7e\nAttorney E-Mail(s): jsx®searcylaw.com and \nmep®searcylaw.com \nPrimary E-Mail: _scarolateam®searcylaw.com \nSearcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, P.A. \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409 \nPhone: (561) 686-6300 \nFax: \n(561) 383-9451 \nAttorneys for Plaintiffs \nEFTA00603634\n", "char_count": 1071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nNotice of Serving Answers to Interrogatories \nCOUNSEL LIST \nThomas Emerson Scott, Jr., Esquire \nThomas.scott@csklegal.com; Steven.safra@csklegal.com \nCole Scott & Kissane P.A. \n9150 S Dadeland Boulevard, Suite 1400 \nMiami, FL 33156 \nPhone: (305)-350-5329 \nFax: (305)-373-2294 \nAttorneys for Defendant \nEFTA00603635\n", "char_count": 374}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES \n1. State verbatim or as close as possible Each statement by Dershowitz that You assert \ndefamed You. \nANSWER: \nUntil we have transcripts of all of the statements Mr. Dershowitz has publicly \nmade, we are unable to identify each defamatory statement. In addition, it appears that Mr. \nDershowitz continues to make defamatory statements at every opportunity he has to attract the \nattention of an audience. However, the general defamatory themes can be illustrated based on the \ncurrently available information, by the following examples which describe the specific \nstatements made along with the program or source publishing the statements and the \napproximate date on which the statement was made or published by the media: \nPolitico.com — December 31, 2014 \nDershowitz called the allegations against him included in public filings by the Plaintiffs \"totally \nmade up and totally fabricated from beginning to end.\" \nAdditionally: \"I'm planning to file disbarment charges against the two lawyers who signed this \npetition without even checking the manifests of airplanes or travel itineraries, et cetera.\" \nhtm://www.rolitico.com/bloas/under-the-radar/2014/12/court-filing-levels-sex-claims-at-alan-\ndershowitz-200495.html \nWall Street Journal Law Blog — January 2, 2015: \n\"It's a completely, totally fabricated, made-up story,\" Mr. Dershowitz told Law Blog in an \ninterview Friday. \"They made up this story out of whole cloth. I'm an innocent victim of an \nextortion conspiracy.\" \nhtto://bloas.wsj.com/law/2015/01 /02/dershowitz-im-an-innocent-victim-of-an-extortion-\nconspiracy/ \nNew York Times — January 3, 2015: \nOn Saturday, Mr. Dershowitz said he \"categorically and unequivocally\" denied all of the \nallegations. He said he would file disbarment proceedings against the lawyers who filed the \nmotion, Bradley J. Edwards, a lawyer in Florida, and Paul G. Cassell, a former federal judge and \na law professor at the University of Utah. \"They are lying deliberately, an\n... [truncated, 2104 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/28 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=28]", "char_count": 2104}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/04/us/prince-andrew-and-alan-dershowitz-are-named-inuit-\nallegina-sex-with-minor.html? \nEl Nuevo Herald (The Miami Herald's afternoon paper, published in Spanish) — Jan. 2, 2015: \nDershowitz neg6 las acusaciones, y las describi6 como pane de una conspiracion para \nextorsionarlo. Califice la demanda de \"el documento judicial mas sordid° que he visto.\" \n[Translation: Dershowitz denied the allegations, and described them as part of a conspiracy to \nextort him. He described the suit as \"the most sordid judicial document I have ever seeni \n\"Ellos [Cassell y Edwards] manipularon a una muchacha joven y sugestionable que estaba \ninteresada en el dinero\", dijo Dershowitz. \n[Translation: \"They [Cassell and Edwards] manipulated a very young and impressionable \nwoman who was interested in the money\", declared Dershowitz.] \nDershowitz dijo que el se propone presentar acusaciones en contra de Edwards y Cassell. \"Este \nes una ofensa que puede costarles su licencia de abogados, y ellos la van a perder\", dijo \nDershowitz. \"Ellos van a arrepentirse del dia en que hicieron esta acusacion falsa en mi contra.\" \n[Translation: Dershowitz said that he intended to bring accusations against Edwards and Cassell. \n\"This is a type of offense which could cost them their practicing lawyer licenses, and they are \ngoing to lose\", stated Dershowitz. \"They (Cassell and Edwards) are going to regret the \nday [i.e., rue the dayl they made a false accusation against me.\"] \nhttp://www.elnuevoherald.com/noticias/sur-de-la-florida/article5398827.html \nMiami Herald —January 3, 2015: \nDershowitz denied the claims [that he was a witness to the abuse of minors by Epstein and \nothers], describing them as part of an extortion plot He called the filing \"the sleaziest legal \ndocument I have ever seen.\" \"They [Edwards and Cassell] manipulated a young, suggestible \nwoman who was interested in money,\" Dershowitz said. Dershowitz said he intends to file \ncomplaints against Edwards and Cas\n... [truncated, 2457 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/29 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=29]", "char_count": 2457}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "consequences from a defamation suit. The story is totally made up, completely out of whole \ncloth. \n\"And I will prove beyond any doubt not only that the story is totally false, but it was knowingly \nfalse: that the lawyers and the client conspired together to create a false story.\" \n\"Q: They have said that they have tried to get testimony from you but that you have avoided their \ndeposition requests. A: Totally false. That's totally false. I have never been asked to be \ndeposed.\" \n\"I will not rest or stop until the world understands not only that I had nothing to do with any of \nthis, but that she deliberately, with the connivance of her lawyer, lawyers, made up this \nstory willfully and knowingly.\" \nhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/proarammes/p02g7abc \nBoston Globe — January 4, 2015: \n\"They [Edwards and Cassell] are lying deliberately, and I will not stop until they're disbarred,\" \nhttp://www.bostonalobe.com/metro/20I 5/01 /04/suit-accuses-pri nce-andrew-and-alan-\ndershowitz-sex-with-minor/WhJMnZWMEJP3Ut8d7aexUstory.html \n(quoting phone interview with Dershowitz) \nVice News — January 5, 2015: \n\"I never met this woman, I never touched her, I wasn't ever massaged by her — there was no \ncontact, no contact whatsoever,\" Dershowitz told CNN. \"And I will prove it conclusively, and \nthen I will bring disciplinary charges and prove that these lawyers knew that this was false, could \neasily have checked, and didn't. And the end result will be that these lawyers will be disbarred.\" \nhttps://news.vice.com/article/buckinaham-palace-emphaticallv-denies-arince-andrew-had-sex-\nwith-a-teenage-sex-slave \nHuffington Post — January 5, 2015: \nOn Friday, in the voicemail message for Goldman [of the Website Politico], Dershowitz said that \nthe charges against him were \"totally made up.\" Goldman forwarded the message to The \nHuffington Post. Dershowitz called the woman a \"serial liar\" who he contended has a history of \n5 \nEFTA00603638\n", "char_count": 1935}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "making up false charges against public figures, including former President Bill Clinton. \"It's just \na completely categorical lie made up to gain money for her, and I hope no one takes it in any \nway seriously,\" he added. Dershowitz . . told Politico earlier this week that he was planning \nlegal action against the attorneys who signed off on the filing. \"I'm planning to file disbarment \ncharges against the two lawyers who signed this petition without even checking the manifests of \nairplanes or travel itineraries, et cetera,\" he said to Politico. \nhttp://www.huffingtonpost.cotn/2015/01/03/alan-dershowitz-sexual-assault n 6410380.honl \nA copy of the voicemail left by Dershowitz can be found \nat: htta://big.assets.huffingtontost.corn/Dershowitz.AMR \nThe voicemail includes the statement from Dershowitz: \"I don't know what happened with any \nof the public figures [mentioned by Jane Doe No. 3], but I know that in my case I did have any \ncontact with her. I would have been physically impossible for me to. It's just a completely, \ncategorical lie made up out of whole cloth in order to gain money for her.\" \nCNN Live (with Hala Gorani) — January 5, 2015: \n\"And if these lawyers, these sleazy unprofessional, unethical lawyers, Paul Cassell and Brad \nEdwards, if they had just done an hours' worth of research and work, they would have seen she \nis lying through her teeth. That's why I'm going after them, their bar cards. I'm seeking \ndisciplinary action against them. I'm filing defamation lawsuits against them and their client.\" \n\"Ask them [Edwards and Cassell] if they have any evidence . . . They're doing it for \nmoney. She's getting money for having sold her story. She wants to sell the book. They're \ntrying to get into this lawsuit. They see a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. They're \n[Edwards and Cassell] prepared to lie, cheat, and steal. These are unethical lawyers. This is \nProfessor Cassell who shouldn't be allowed near a student. This is Professor Cassell, who is \n... [truncated, 2843 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/31 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=31]", "char_count": 2843}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "http://www.cnn.corn/videos/worldf20 1 5/0 1 /05/wm-uk-sex-abuse-allegations-alan-dershowitz-\nintv.cnn \nToday Show —January 5, 2015: \n\"Her lawyers Paul Cassell, a former federal judge and Brad Edwards, deliberately and willfully \nfiled this interpleading which they knew I had no opportunity to respond to in court, without \ndoing any investigation, if they had simply investigated the manifests of the airplanes, if they had \nchecked my travel records, if they had asked me and I could have given the names of these \npeople who are witnesses, they would know the stories, totally, completely false.\" \n\"These lawyers [Edwards and Cassell] engaged in unethical behavior and should be disbarred... \n. Because they filed a paper in which they didn't ask to try to prove it, they didn't say we \nalleged, we want to prove it. They just threw it in there, it's the legal equivalent of scribbling \nsomething on a toilet stall and then running away. They didn't think they would be any response \nand they will rue the day that they filed this unethical complaint because, they I believe will be \ndisbarred.\" \n\"They want to just throw this stink bomb and then avoid any responsibility for it...the truth will \ncome out and it will show these two unethical lawyers should be disbarred.\" \nhttos://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXePKTws0f0 \nBoston Globe — January 6, 2015: \nDershowitz said (in what was described as a brief phone interview Tuesday) that Jane Doe No. \n3's claims are outrageous and her attorneys, including former federal judge Paul Cassell, should \nbe disbarred. \"[Cassell] is a money-grubbing, unethical sleazebag, a former federal judge who \nleft the bench for money. The end result of this will be bankruptcy, disbarment, and eternal \ndisgrace.\" \nhttn://www.bostonglobe.com/lifestvle/names/201 5/01 /06/alan-dershowitz-denies-woman-claim-\nunderage-sex-vows-punish-her-attomevs/qr2kO6MJd2cD2djISHBopOistorv.html \nReuters — January 7, 2015: \n\"Dershowitz told Reuters Monday that he would file a defama\n... [truncated, 2203 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/32 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=32]", "char_count": 2203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "\"They [Cassell and Edwards] also said they had tried to depose Dershowitz and that he had \nrefused, which Dershowitz called a `total lie.' He said he received only one deposition request \nfrom the two lawyers five years ago, asking about his relationship with Epstein - and that it said \nnothing about any of the new allegations.\" \nhttp://www.reuters.com/article/20 1 5/01/07/us-andrew-lawsuit-dershowitz-\nidUSION0KF0DH20150107 \nBoston Globe — January 7, 2015: \nDershowitz said the allegations against him, besides being false, contain faulty legal research, \nsuch as the age of consent in New Mexico and other states. \"The truth is a defense in \ndefamation, and I will prove that my statements about the lawyers are well-founded,\" \nDershowitz said. \"I will not stop until they have acknowledged\" the allegations against him are \nuntrue. \nhtto://www. bostonglobe.com/metro/2015/01/06/sued-for-defamation-dershowitz-thril led-chance-\nauestion-lawyers-sex-crime-accuser/21OibSrwNC343eICMadWNeL/storv.html \nFox Business (Lou Dobbs) — January 7, 2015 \n\"They [Edwards and Cassell] did it for crass financial and political reasons. More to the point is \n[what] they didn't do... I did the investigation in a day and was able to prove through all kinds of \nrecords that I couldn't have been in these places. The woman is a serial liar. If they had done \nthat investigation, they would have come to the same conclusion.\" \nhttp://video.foxbusiness.com/v/3976630676001/alan-dershowitz-the-woman-is-a-serial-liarn - \nsp=show-clips \nLawrence O'Donnell - January 8, 2015: \n\"Right now, they [Edwards and Cassell] have accused me of these horrendous things without a \nsingle affidavit, without a single piece of evidence.\" \n\"Why any responsible lawyer would believe her and file this kind of charge ....they willfully and \ndeliberately made this up in order to gain a litigation advantage, [to] line their pockets with \nmoney. And they have to pay a heavy consequence for this, and they will.\" \n8 \nEFTA00603641\n", "char_count": 1996}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Further statements found at: \nhttp://www.msnbc.com/the-last-word/watch/alan-dershowitz-on-allegations—totally-false-\n381942851573 \nGreta van Susteren - Fox News - January 8, 2015 \n\"Lawyers are putting words in her [Jane Doe No. 3's] mouth.\" \n\"I'm going to file disciplinary charges against the lawyers [i.e., against Edwards and \nCassell]. I've spoken to some of the world's leading experts on ethics. And what they did was \nutterly unprofessional and improper.\" \n\"I still can't understand why they [i.e., Edwards and Cassell] would pick on me. . .. They picked \non the wrong innocent victim. . . . I am not letting go of this thing until they admit that they \nessentially concocted this story and withdraw it.\" \n\"I can now depose them [Edwards and Cassell]. . . . So they're now at risk of a perjury \nprosecution if I can prove that they knowingly made a false allegation against me, which I think I \ncan.\" \n\"It [the allegation against me] is utterly irrelevant to their lawsuit. They [Edwards and Cassell] \njust put it in gratuitously.\" \n\"The end will be that they [Edwards and Cassell] will be disbarred. \n\"These lawyers ought to be ashamed of themselves for doing this.\" \nhttp://radio.foxnews.com/2015/01/08/greta-alan-dershowitz-this-time-its-personal/ \nForbes - January 13. 2015: \nDershowitz has called Cassell and his co-counsel Bradley Edwards \"sleazy, unprofessional, \nunethical lawyers\" who should have known that their client, Jane Doe #3, is \"lying through her \nteeth.\" \nAmerican Lawyer/Palm Beach Daily Business Review - January 20, 2015: \n\"They [Edwards and Cassell] want to void the plea agreement and needed to find a lawyer who \nknew Epstein before [the indictment], and had been on his island, his home in New Mexico, \nPalm Beach. I fit the bill. It was lawyer profiling.\" \n9 \nEFTA00603642\n", "char_count": 1808}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "\"Everyone is shocked that he [Cassell] would be part of this. I think he's always hated me \nbecause Pm his opposite. I'm the conventional liberal he hates: I'm against the death penalty, I'm \npro-abortion rights, pro-gun control.\" \nThe Today Show - January 22, 2015: \nIn response to a question from Savannah Guthrie that \"In legal papers from the lawyers, they say \nyou've had, in fact, the opportunity to be deposed,\" Dershowitz responded: \"They're \nlying. They're lying.\" \nIn response to a question from Savannah Guthrie that \"[t]hey show letters in which they offered \nto depose you,\" Dershowitz responded: \"And they didn't show my letters in response saying, (a), \nif you ask me about my legal relationship with Epstein and I'll be happy to answer. . . . And I \nresponded that I would be happy to be deposed if you could give me any indication that I would \nbe a relevant witness \n\"They will be proved — all of them [i.e., Cassell, Edwards, and Jane Doe No. 3] — to be \ncategorically lying and making up this story. And it will be a terrible thing for rape \nvictims. \nThey have put rape victims in a terrible position. \nBecause when I \nunequivocally prove that they sat down and made this all up, tragically it will hurt all rape \nvictims.\" \n\"The lawyers are lying through their teeth when they say I've refused to be deposed. . . . We \n[Epstein and Dershowitz] had an academic relationship. I was never in the presence of a single, \nyoung, under-aged woman. When I was with him, it was with prominent scientists, prominent \nacademics. And they're just — again — lying about this. I never saw him doing anything \nimproper. I was not a participant. I was not a witness. And I will prove it categorically.\" \nIndependent Online (UK) —January 22, 2015: \n\" The lawyers are lying through their teeth when they say I have refused to be deposed.\" \nAmerican Lawyer — January 28, 2015: \nDershowitz has called both Cassell and Edwards, a Florida personal injury lawyer, \"liars\"... \nhttp://www.americanlawver\n... [truncated, 2100 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/35 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=35]", "char_count": 2100}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Speech to the Dade County Bar Association — Feb. 20, 2015: \n\"Of course, I didn't know this woman [Jane Doe No. 3], I'd never heard of her, I never saw her, \ntotally made up out of the blue, and made up by two irresponsible lawyers who hadn't done \nsufficient checking. If they had called me and checked with me, they would see that I was in the \nplaces they said this happened only once each, both with my wife and my daughter and a group \nof witnesses and friends, including a very prominent professor at the Harvard business school. \nThey never would have filed this drive by shooting. By the way, they didn't even ask for a \nhearing, they didn't say they would prove it.\" \n\"Not only will I prevail in this case, because the accusation is totally — completely, completely —\ntotally fabricated and made up. But I hope it will change the law. I hope it will make it \nimpossible for future lawyers to just do these kind of drive by shootings, where without any real \ninvestigation, without any real preparation, they just make these allegations.\" \n\"And yet these two lawyers — Brad Edwards, from, whose partner Rothstein is now in jail for 50 \nyears for a Ponzi scheme involving the same case, and a guy named Cassell — filed this \ngrievance, not grievance, just allegation again me in passing without doing even the most \nminimal of investigation, which would have proven conclusively that I not only didn't, but \ncouldn't have, possibly done it.\" \nOn information and belief, additional statements of an equivalent defamatory character can also \nbe found in other publications and sources. \nIn addition to the specific sources cited above, many of the statements cited above were \nrepublished or rebroadcast on the Internet and in other places. \nIn addition, on information and belief, Dershowitz made statements of an equivalent character in \nwritten or oral communications with various associates and acquaintances, including Ken \nStarr, Akhil Amar, and members of the faculty at the Harvard Law Sc\n... [truncated, 2753 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/36 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=36]", "char_count": 2753}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "3. Separately for Each statement identified in response to Interrogatory No. 1, if You \nbelieve the statement was made with knowledge that the statement was false or with \nreckless disregard of whether the statement was false or not, describe in detail All facts that \nsupport Your belief. \nANSWER: Facts supporting belief that Dershowitz knew the statements described in response to \nInterrogatory No. 1 were false (and also made the statements with reckless disregard of whether \nthe statements were false) are found in the documents and other materials and \nreferences provided in answer to Request for Production Number 2. \nOn information and belief, Dershowitz also learned significant information during the course of \nhis representation of Jeffrey Epstein that would have made it clear that he was making false \nrepresentations about Edwards and Cassell. He has revealed some of those facts publicly, and \ndiscovery regarding other such facts is on-going. \n4. Describe in detail All facts Concerning the \"character assassination\" referenced in \nparagraph 8 of the Complaint. \nANSWER: See answer to Interrogatory number 1. \n5. Describe in detail All facts Concerning Dershowitz's alleged \"participation in Epstein's \ncriminal conduct\" referenced in paragraph 16 of the Complaint. \nANSWER: At the time of the filing of legal pleadings referencing the Defendant Dershowitz and \ncontinuing up to and including the time of the filing of these response, Plaintiffs had reason to \nbelieve and do in fact believe in good faith believe that Dershowitz participated in Epstein's \nillegal sexual activities, including having criminal sexual relations with Jane Doe No. 3 — at \nEpstein's direction and invitation -- in Florida, New York, and elsewhere. See documents and \nother materials and references provided in answer to Request for Production Number \n2. Dershowitz also failed to disclose his awareness of illegal sexual behavior and abuse of \nminors by Epstein and others that occurred in Florida, N\n... [truncated, 2934 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/37 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=37]", "char_count": 2934}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "6. Describe in detail All facts Concerning Dershowitz's alleged knowledge that the filing \nreferenced in paragraph 17 of the Complaint was \"an entirely proper and well-founded \npleading.\" \nANSWER: See documents and other materials and references provided in answer to Request for \nProduction Number 2. These materials make clear that Dershowitz had sexual relations with \nJane Doe No. 3 and that a pleading filed by her lawyers to that effect was entirely proper and \nwell-founded. In addition, the documents and other materials and references make clear \nthat Dershowitz knew that Edwards and Cassell had conducted significant investigation before \nfiling the pleading — and that Edwards and Cassell had significant supporting evidence for the \npleading. Dershowitz also knew that he (along with Epstein and his criminal associates) had \nevaded efforts to depose him about these subjects, which provided further legitimate support for \nEdwards and Cassell making such a filing. As a law professor and criminal defense attorney, \nDershowitz was also well aware of the obligations of attorneys to zealously advocate on behalf \nof their clients and to pursue the reasonable and legitimate objectives of their clients. \n7. Describe in detail All facts Concerning the \"massive public media assault\" referenced in \nparagraph 17 of the Complaint. \nANSWER: See answers to Interrogatory Number 1 for illustrative examples of statements that \nwere part of the massive public media assault waged by Dershowitz against Edwards and \nCassell, as well as sources where additional statements can be found. Discovery on this subject \nis on-going, as Dershowitz is in the best position to provide this information. He alone knows \nwhich media sources he provided defamatory information to. \n8. Identify the (a) date, (b) time, and (c) broadcast or print media source of Each of the \n\"multiple national televised interviews,\" \"statements to and repeated by national and \ninternational print news sources\" and \"various \n... [truncated, 3042 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/38 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=38]", "char_count": 3042}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "ANSWER: See answers to Interrogatory Number 1 for illustrative examples of statements that \nwere part of the massive public media assault waged by Dershowitz against Edwards and \nCassell. Discovery is on-going regarding additional statements, the contents of which are best \nknown by Dershowitz himself. \n10. Describe in detail All facts Concerning the allegation in paragraph 20 of the Complaint \nthat Dershowitz's \"statements were false and known by him to be false at the time they \nwere made.\" \nANSWER: See answers to Interrogatory Number 1 for illustrative examples of statements that \nwere part of the massive public media assault waged by Dershowitz against Edwards and \nCassell, as well as sources where additional statements can be found. As described above, these \nstatements were all false. With regard to Dershowitz's knowledge of the falsity of these \nstatements, Dershowitz knew (for example) that he had had sexual relations with Jane Doe No. 3 \nmultiple times (in Florida, New York, and elsewhere) when he denied having such relations with \nher. Dershowitz had also seen numerous underage girls while with Jeffrey Epstein, and had \notherwise seen or been made aware of sexual abuse of those girls by Epstein and \nothers. Dershowitz also knew that Edwards and Cassell had conducted a significant \ninvestigation into the allegations. Dershowitz also knew that other witnesses had either invoked \nthe fifth amendment when asked about him or had put him at or near the scene of the crimes \ncommitted by Epstein against minors. Dershowitz also knew of the truth of many of the \nstatements of Jane Doe No. 3. \nDershowitz also knew that Edwards and Cassell had not \nconspired with Jane Doe No. 3. to fabricate charges against him — and that he had no evidence of \nsuch conspiracy or fabrication by them. See Answers to Requests for Production of Documents \nNo. 2 for additional evidence on these points, which show (along with other evidence) that \nDershowitz had knowledge that his statemen\n... [truncated, 2642 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/39 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=39]", "char_count": 2642}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "13. Describe in detail Each instance in which Jane Doe #3 has provided information \nreferencing Dershowitz by name that Concern the allegations set forth in Paragraphs 24-31 \nof the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration. \nANSWER: Edwards and Cassell lack sufficient information to determine all circumstances in \nwhich Jane Doe No. 3 has mentioned to others Dershowitz's name as someone who abused her \nor had information relevant to abuse. \nWith regard to when she has provided information related to this subject to them, Jane Doe No. 3 \nprovided such information in telephone calls with Brad Edwards beginning in 2011. \nJane Doe No. 3 has also provided this information in a public affidavit, filed on January 21, \n2015, in the CVRA case. Jane Doe No. 3 has also provided similar information on other \noccasions, but the specifics of those communications are protected by the attorney-client \nprivilege and the work product doctrine. \n14. If You have ever seen a photograph or video of Jane Doe #3 with Dershowitz, then state \nwhen You saw the photograph or video, identify who took the original photograph \nor video, identify Each person who possesses a copy of the photograph or video, and state \nthe location of Each such original and copy. \nANSWER: Edwards and Cassell have not personally seen such a photograph or \nvideo. Discovery efforts to obtain photographic materials regarding Jane Doe No. 3 held by the \nU.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida and/or other federal law enforcement \nand prosecuting agencies are on-going. \n15. For Each communication between You or anyone acting on Your behalf, and anyone \nfrom, or acting on behalf of, any media outlet Concerning this action, the Joinder Motion, \nor Dershowitz, and regardless of whether such communication was \"on the record\" or \"off \nthe record,\" (a) state the date of the communication; (b) state the participants in the \ncommunication; and (c) describe the contents of the communication. \nANSWER: Objection, not reasona\n... [truncated, 2498 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/40 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=40]", "char_count": 2498}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Dershowitz knew of and participated in Epstein's scheme to commit sexual offenses against \nminors — including Jane Doe No. 3 -- and to cover up those offenses, including providing \nknowingly false information to law enforcement to conceal these crimes and a false affidavit on \nJan. 5, 2015. These actions violated federal and state criminal statutes, including 18 U.S.C. § \n2423(b); 18 U.S.C. § 2422; 18 U.S.C. § 2241(c); 18 U.S.C. § 1591; as well as federal and state \nprohibition against conspiring to violate these statutes or statutes like them, including 18 U.S.C. \n§ 371; and 18 U.S.C. § 2423(e). \n17. Describe in detail All facts Concerning any assertion that Dershowitz negotiated the \nNPA for his own benefit. \nANSWER: The fact that the NPA benefits Dershowitz by blocking his prosecution, in the \nSouthern District of Florida, for his crimes against minor girls does not appear to be \ndisputed. \nSee NPA at 5 (barring prosecution of any \"potential co-conspirator of \nEpstein\"). Many of the facts surrounding the negotiation of the NPA are revealed in \ncorrespondence between Jeffrey Epstein legal defense team (which included Dershowitz) and \nprosecutors the U.S. Department of Justice, including the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern \nDistrict of Florida. That correspondence is well known and available to Dershowitz. Edwards \nand Cassell rely on that correspondence in answer to this interrogatory. But disclosure of the \nspecifics of that correspondence is currently barred by a confidentiality order entered in the \nCVRA case. \nDershowitz has also claimed repeatedly in the media and (on information and belief) elsewhere \nthat he obtained a very favorable deal for Jeffrey Epstein during plea discussions. Dershowitz \nhas also suggested that he was the lead attorney on the defense team. In light of his willingness \nto take credit for the arrangement, it appears reasonable to conclude that he was involved in \nnegotiating the unique co-conspirator arrangement. Further discov\n... [truncated, 3202 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/41 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=41]", "char_count": 3202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "documents reflecting contacts by Prince Andrew, it specifically admitted possessing documents \nreflecting contacts by Dershowitz. Gov't Answer to RFA #6. Since then, however, the \nGovernment has provided approximately 10,000 pages of documents associated with the \nNPA and Jeffrey Epstein to Judge Marra for in camera inspection. The privilege log for those \ndocuments is not sufficiently complete to review those documents for possible connection to \nPrince Andrew. In addition, even though the Government has had approximately one-and-half-\nyears to complete production of documents, it has not yet completed production — and has not yet \ncertified that it has produced all such documents to the Court for in camera inspection. \nEdwards and Cassell are aware that on about May 3 through 8, 2007, Prince Andrew's mother --\nQueen Elizabeth II - visited the United States, and was apparently hosted by President George \nW. Bush. Who came with the Queen and what (if any) discussions were held about the case, \neither directly or indirectly at that time, are unknown at this time. Of course, the NPA was \nconcluded several months later on favorable terms, including the highly unusual \"blank check\" \nprovision that provided immunity from federal prosecution to Epstein's \"potential co-\nconspirators.\" \nEdwards and Cassell are also aware Prince Andrew was a close friend of Jeffrey Epstein at the \ntime that the NPA was being negotiated, and that Jeffrey Epstein hired a battery of attorneys to \nnegotiate favorable terms for the NPA (including Dershowitz). Based on all of the information \nfound in the documents and other materials and references provided in answer to Request for \nProduction Number 2, it also appears that Epstein was gathering blackmail material on his \npowerful friends (through Jane Doe No. 3 and others), including Prince Andrew. Details of \ncontacts between Epstein and Prince Andrew while the NPA was being negotiated are accessible \nto Dershowitz (as a close personal friend a\n... [truncated, 3150 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/42 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=42]", "char_count": 3150}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "ANSWER: Edwards and Cassell were aware that Dershowitz was a close personal friend and \nconfidant of Jeffrey Epstein in approximately 2008 and read whatever public articles were \navailable. Edwards and Cassell also had extensive evidence that Epstein was involved in \nbrazen daily sexual crimes against underage girls in 2008 and following, as shown in the \ndocuments and other materials and references provided in answer to Request for Production \nNumber 2. Those brazen sexual crimes often involved Epstein's friends and confidants. Those \ncrimes were also conducted with such frequency and in such a way that it would have been \nextremely unlikely for someone staying overnight with Epstein (or traveling on his personal jet) \nto have been unaware of those crimes. \nExtensive discovery was taken in the civil cases against Mr. Epstein, and Dershowitz was \nmentioned by several witnesses as being a friend, as opposed to just a lawyer to Epstein, he was \non the private plane of Mr. Epstein numerous times, and each witness who would have actual \nknowledge of Mr. Dershowitz's involvement either invoked the 5th amendment when asked \nabout Dershowitz or provided testimony consistent with Dershowitz's criminal knowledge or \ninvolvement. \nIn about March or April 2011, on a telephone interview with Edwards, Jane Doe No. 3 disclosed \nthat she had been sexually abused by Dershowitz. \nIt is public record that the materials that \nEdwards and Cassell reviewed and collected in connection with related investigations include the \nextensive materials provided in answer to Request for Production Number 2. \n21. Describe in detail All facts Concerning any investigation by You or on Your behalf of \nJane Doe #3. \nANSWER: Except to the extent disclosed in materials provided in response to Request to \nProduce, Plaintiffs object based on the attorney-client and work product privileges. \n22. Are You aware whether Jane Doe #3 ever give her body for sexual activity for hire or \never agreed to secure othe\n... [truncated, 2807 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/43 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=43]", "char_count": 2807}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Edwards and Cassell also suffered presumed damages. \nCassell suffered general damages and special damages. These damages include mental pain and \nanguish and suffering, personal humiliation, damage to reputation both past and future, and \nimpairment of ability to earn a living or seek better employment. These damages also include \nlost income past and future and lost earning capacity, including lost opportunities for legal \nconsulting and paid expert witness testimony. \nEdwards and Cassell have also incurred costs and attorneys' fees associated with efforts to \nprotect his reputation from ongoing assaults including the prosecution of this cause of \naction. The amount of those costs and attorneys' fees is increasing as the action progresses. \nEdwards and Cassell seek recovery for all of the damages, costs, and attorneys' fees. They also \nseek pre- and post-judgment interest. \n24. State separately the amount of compensatory, punitive, and any other damages \nthat You are seeking from Dershowitz and explain how You calculate Each \namount reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. \nANSWER: All damage amounts are presently unliquidated but are reasonably anticipated to \nwell exceed hundreds of thousands of dollars for each of the Plaintiffs. After presentation of the \nfacts to a jury of the circumstances of the defamatory statements and also of the net worth \nof Dershowitz, the Plaintiffs will leave the determination of fair and reasonable compensation \nand appropriate punitive damages in the sound and well-informed discretion of a jury. \nFor lost past and future income, Cassell is gathering the relevant information for an economic \ndamages expert to derive a calculation. It appears that the Cassell's income earned outside of his \nemployment as a law professor has fallen since Dershowitz began his media assault as \na direct result of that media assault and will remain at a depressed level in the future. A \ncalculation of the amount of loss will\n... [truncated, 2991 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/44 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=44]", "char_count": 2991}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "factors punitive damages in the amount of millions of dollars may be appropriate and will not \nunduly economically castigate or bankrupt Dershowitz. \nCosts and attorneys' fees will be sought and calculated in the ordinary manner at the conclusion \nof the proceedings. Pre- and post judgment interest will also be sought and calculated in the \nordinary manner at the conclusion of the proceedings. \n20 \nEFTA00603653\n", "char_count": 415}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "PAUL G. CASSELL \nSTATE OF \nKt \n) \nSAr \nCOUNTY OF\n-C E\n) \nThe foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this It \n day of \na Au \n, 20l 5 \nby 'jilt11 ere \n who is personally known to me \nor who has produced \ner,5cracilicam:Latztr..._ (type of identification) as \nidentification and \nid not take an oath. \nLeSat \nAce? \nNotary Public \nState-off/arida-at-Large Make- cA M\n°1‘t41\nMy Commission expires: \nCommission No: \nNotary Public \nSUSAN BACA \ni \nOvvnIssloc.66584 \nMy Canrnbeko Expire3s \nApril 19, 2017 \nState of Utah \nEFTA00603654\n", "char_count": 534}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Bradley J. Edwards \nSTATE OF FLORIDA \nCOUNTY OF 1-0 vJaA d ) \nBEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared this day Bradley J. \nEdwards, \nwho \nIbis\n \npersonally \nknown \nto \nme \nor \nI ] \nproduced \n \n as identification, and who, after being duly sworn, did state \nthat he/she executed the foregoing Answers to First Set of Interrogatories and that the same are \ntrue and correct to the best of his knowledge \nSubscribed and sworn to before me this IS\n of \n2015. \nIMMA w. *MOM \nWY COMMON aft$40470 \nMRS: OCT 03. 2016 \nbrad too* 1616034 Mon \nMy commission expires: \nSignets e of Notary Publik, Sthje4f Florida \nPrint / Typed Name, Notary Public \n10 \nEFTA00603655\n", "char_count": 672}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "EXHIBIT C \nEFTA00603656\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "IN \nTHE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN \nAND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL, \nPlaintiff(s), \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant(s). \nANSWERS TO DEFENDANT DERSHOWITZ'S FIRST SET OF DOCUMENT \nREQUESTS TO BRADLEY J. EDWARDS AND PAUL G. CASSELL \nPlaintiffs, Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, by and through their undersigned \nattorneys and pursuant to Rule 1.350, Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, hereby respond to \nDefendant, Alan M. Dershowitz's, First Set of Document Requests dated February 11, 2015 to \nPlaintiffs as follows: \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \n1. All Documents Concerning the alleged \"character assassination\" referenced in \nparagraph 8 of the Complaint. \nSee complaint from Jeffrey Epstein v. Bradley J. Edwards. See also pleadings and \nmaterials in the case file in this case. \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \n2. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged \"participation in Epstein's \ncriminal conduct\" referenced in paragraph 16 of the Complaint. \nEdwards and Cassell object to this request as being vague, overbroad, and unreasonably \nburdensome, as well as seeking irrelevant and inadmissible evidence and information not \nEFTA00603657\n", "char_count": 1645}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nreasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Edwards and Cassell have \ncollected documents pointing to Dershowitz's involvement in Epstein's sexual abuse of underage \ngirls over a nearly seven year period of time, including legal work that they did in connection \nwith the long-running case of Does v. United States, 9:08-cv-80736-KAM (S.D. Fla. filed July 7, \n2008). They have also represented numerous victims in civil actions against Jeffrey Epstein, \nwhich involved many pleadings which are public documents. Of course, these cases also \ninvolved numerous attorney-client communications as well as materials covered by the work-\nproduct doctrine. \nWithout waiving these objections, privileges, or other protections, Edwards and Cassell \nproduce the following attached materials. \nOn information and belief, Dershowitz also possesses significant information that is \nresponsive to this request - information that Edwards and Cassell have requested from \nDershowitz in their requests for production. \n3. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged knowledge that the filing \nreferenced in paragraph 17 of the Complaint was \"an entirely proper and well-founded \npleading.\" \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n4. All Documents Concerning the alleged \"massive public media assault\" referenced \nin paragraph 17 of the Complaint. \nFor details regarding the massive public media assault, see Edwards' and Cassell's \nanswer to interrogatory #2. Because the media assault was conducted by Dershowitz himself \nmaking statements to media sources of his choosing, Edwards and Cassell do not possess \ndocuments concerning the assault. \n5. All Documents Concerning the \"multiple national televised interviews,\" \n\"statements to and repeated by national and international print news sources\" and \n\"various other f\n... [truncated, 2437 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/50 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=50]", "char_count": 2437}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n6. All Documents Concerning the allegation in paragraph 20 of the Complaint that \nDershowitz's \"statements were false and known by him to be false at the time they were \nmade.\" \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. Additionally, remaining \nrelevant and responsive documents can be found in the public court files of all of the criminal \nand civil actions ever brought against Jeffrey Epstein related to his sexual abuse of children. \n7. All Documents Concerning the allegation in paragraph 21 of the Complaint that \nDershowitz falsely protested his own innocence. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n8. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged \"involvement in Epstein's criminal \nconduct\" as alleged in paragraph 21 of the Complaint. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n9. All Documents that reference Dershowitz by name that Concern the allegations set forth \nin Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n10. All Documents Concerning drafts of any declaration or affidavit of Jane Doe #3. \nObjection, immaterial and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of \nadmissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine. \nWithout waiving any objection, affidavits have been filed by Jane Doe #3 in Does v. \nUnited States, 08-80736. \n11. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) of Jane Doe #3 with Dershowitz. \nNone in Plaintiffs' possession. \n3 \nEFTA00603659\n", "char_count": 1734}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n12. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) not produced in response to any prior Request, of Dershowitz at \n(i) Epstein's Manhattan home in New York City, New York; (ii) Epstein's home in Palm \nBeach, Florida; (iii) Epstein's Zorro Ranch in Santa Fe, New Mexico; (iv) Little Saint \nJames island in the U.S. Virgin Islands; and (v) Epstein's airplane, on the same date and \ntime that Jane Doe #3 also was present at such location. \nNone in the possession of Edwards or Cassell. \n13. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) not produced in response to any prior Request that evidence \nand/or show Jane Doe #3 was present at the same location as Dershowitz on that same date \nand time. \nObjection, not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; \nattorney-client privilege; work-product doctrine. Additionally, because Dershowitz has failed to \nprovide appropriate responses to discovery requests from Edwards and Cassell, it is not possible \nto precisely answer this request. \n14. All Documents Concerning Jane Doe #3's presence at the various locations \nnamed in Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration on the particular dates \nand times when Dershowitz was also present. \nObjection, not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, \nattorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine. Additionally, because Dershowitz has failed to \nprovide appropriate responses to discovery requests from Edwards and Cassell, it is not possible \nto precisely answer this request. \n15. All Documents Concerning whether Dershowitz was present at the various \nlocations named in Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration on the particular \ndates and times when Jane Doe\n... [truncated, 2369 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/52 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=52]", "char_count": 2369}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE I5-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n16. All statements, written or recorded, that Plaintiffs or Jane Doe #3 have provided \nto anyone that reference Dershowitz by name. \nObjection, not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; \nattorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly burdensome, vague, harassing. \n17. All notes, writings, photographs, and/or audio or video recordings made or \nrecorded by or of Jane Doe #3 on the dates on which Jane Doe #3 allegedly was present \nwith Dershowitz, including but not limited to any diary, journal, or calendar entries on \nthose dates, regardless whether the notes, writings, photographs, and/or audio or video \nrecordings refer to Dershowitz. \nTo the extent that any responsive materials are \nphotographs or video recordings, please provide them in the original, native format in \nwhich they were taken (not a paper copy). \nObjection, not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; \nattorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine. Additionally, because Dershowitz has failed to \nprovide appropriate responses to discovery requests from Edwards and Cassell, it is not possible \nto precisely answer this request. \n18. All notes of, or notes prepared for, any statements or interviews in which \nPlaintiffs or Jane Doe #3 referenced Dershowitz by name or other description. \nObjection, not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; \nattorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly burdensome, vague, harassing. \nAdditionally, because Dershowitz has failed to provide appropriate responses to discovery \nrequests from Edwards and Cassell, it is not possible to precisely answer this request. \n19. All Documents Concerning communications between You or anyone acting on \nYour behalf and anyone from, or acting on behalf of, any media outlet Conce\n... [truncated, 2484 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/53 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=53]", "char_count": 2484}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dashowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n20. All Documents Concerning any press release Concerning this action, the Joinder \nMotion, or Dershowitz, or Jane Doe #3. \nObjection as to \"all documents concerning\" in that it requests information not reasonably \ncalculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; attorney-client privilege, work-\nproduct doctrine, overly burdensome, vague, harassing. \nWithout waiving objection, Dershowitz already possesses a copy of a press release sent to \nthe media by Edwards and Cassell on or about January 2, 2015, that read as follows: \nOut of respect for the court's desire to keep this case from being litigated \nin the press, we are not going to respond at this time to specific claims of \nindignation by anyone. As you may know, we are litigating a very important case, \nnot only for our clients but crime victims in general. We have been informed of \nMr. Dershowitz's threats based on the factual allegations we have made in our \nrecent filing. We carefully investigate all of the allegations in our pleadings \nbefore presenting them. We have also tried to depose Mr. Dershowitz on these \nsubjects, although he has avoided those deposition requests. Nevertheless, we \nwould be pleased to consider any sworn testimony and documentary evidence Mr. \nDershowitz would like to provide which he contends would refute any of our \nallegations. \nThe point of the pleading was only to join two of our clients in the case \nthat is currently being litigated, and while we expected an agreement from the \nGovernment on that point, we did not get it. That disagreement compelled us to \nfile our motion. We intend only to litigate the relevant issues in Court and not to \nplay into any sideshow. We feel that is in our clients' best interest and \nconsequently that is what we are doing. \nWe have every intention of addressing all of the relevant issues in the\n... [truncated, 2509 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/54 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=54]", "char_count": 2509}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nDershowitz already possesses a copy a press release sent to the media by Jack Scarola on \nor about January 7, 2015, that read as follows: \nMr. Dershowitz harshly attacks Mr. Edwards and Professor Cassell for not \ntrying to talk to him before naming him in legal papers. But, in truth, and as \nsupported by numerous documents, on at least three occasions since 2009, Mr. \nDershowitz was informed that he was a key witness in the litigation against \nJeffrey Epstein and was requested to testify. We advised him at that time as \nfollows: \n`Multiple individuals have placed you in the presence of Jeffrey Epstein \non multiple occasions and in various locations when Jeffrey Epstein was \nin the company of underage females subsequently identified as victims of \nMr. Epstein's criminal molestation. This information is derived from both \nsomeone's testimony and private interviews. Your personal observations \nregarding such circumstances would clearly not involve any privileged \ncommunications, and it is those observations that will be the primary focus \nof our questioning.' \nDespite this notice to Mr. Dershowitz, he failed to respond or testify in any \nfashion. Mr. Dershowitz has not responded to multiple efforts to take his \ntestimony beginning in 2009. \n21. All Documents Concerning any assertion that Dershowitz was a \"co-\nconspirator\" with Epstein. \nEdwards and Cassell object to this request as vague, uncertain, and overbroad. \nSee also answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \nSee also answer to request #10 above. \n22. All Documents Concerning any assertion that Dershowitz negotiated the NPA \nfor his own benefit. \nDershowitz possesses, or has access to, all information regarding his negotiation of the \nNPA. Edwards and Cassell have asked him to produce this information, and will all be \n7 \nEFTA00603663\n", "char_count": 1980}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nresponsive to this request as well. See Plaintiffs' Third Request to Produce to Defendant Nos. 2, \n3, and 4. \nEdwards and Cassell also have received from the U.S. Attorney's Office from the \nSouthern District of Florida approximately 1000 pages of correspondence between that Office \nand Jeffrey Epstein's legal defense team (including Dershowitz) exchanged from approximately \n2006 to 2008 related to the non-prosecution agreement. Those documents are currently under \nseal by order of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida in connection with the \nDoes v. United States, No. 9:08-cv-80736-KAM. This seal has been requested by, and obtained \nby, Dershowitz's close friend, client and co-conspirator, Jeffrey Epstein, over the objection of \nEdwards and Cassell on behalf of their clients. Accordingly, Dershowitz should request that \nEpstein withdraw his request for sealing so that these materials can be produced to Dershowitz. \nSee also answer to request #2 above (including the NPA itself and its provision granting \nimmunity from prosecution to \"any potential co-conspirators of Epstein\") and to request #24 \nbelow. \n23. All Documents Concerning any actions allegedly taken by Prince Andrew, Duke \nof York, to influence the terms of the NPA. \nEdwards and Cassell have attempted to question Prince Andrew about his actions in this \nregard, but have been rebuffed by Prince Andrew and representatives of the British throne and/or \ngovernment. \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \nEdwards and Cassell have propounded discovery requests seeking such documents in the \nCVRA case. See Request for Admission (RFA) (December 1, 2011) (asking\n... [truncated, 2336 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/56 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=56]", "char_count": 2336}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n24. All Documents Concerning any request for the deposition of Dershowitz. \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \nSee response to RFP #20. \nDershowitz already has in his possession a request from Jack Scarola to take his \ndeposition, sent via email on January 3, 2015, which reads as follows: \nDear Mr. Dershowitz: \nStatements attributed to you in the public media express a willingness, \nindeed a strong desire, to submit to questioning under oath regarding your alleged \nknowledge of Jeffrey Epstein's extensive abuse of underage females as well as \nyour alleged personal participation in those activities. As I am sure you will \nrecall, our efforts to arrange such a deposition previously were unsuccessful, so \nwe welcome your change of heart. Perhaps a convenient time would be in \nconnection with your scheduled appearance in Miami on January 19. I assume a \nsubpoena will not be necessary since the deposition will be taken pursuant to your \nrequest, but please let us know promptly if that assumption is inaccurate. Also, \nnote that the deposition will be video recorded. \nKindly bring with you all documentary and electronic evidence which you \nbelieve tends to refute the factual allegations made concerning you in the recent \nCVRA proceeding as well as passport pages reflecting your travels during the past \nten years and copies of all photographs taken while you were a traveling \ncompanion or house guest of Jeffrey Epstein's. \nThank you for your anticipated cooperation. \nSincerely, \nJack Scarola \n9 \nEFTA00603665\n", "char_count": 1867}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n25. All Documents Concerning any investigation of Dershowitz. \nThis request is vague and overbroad, since it is not clear exactly what the term \n\"investigation\" means in this context. \nWithout waiving this objection: \nSee response to RFP #2. \nSee also all depositions taken in all civil cases involving Jeffrey Epstein in which the \nallegations concerned his molestation of minors. \nSee also the criminal Palm Beach State Attorney's Office file regarding Jeffrey Epstein. \nSee also all books, articles and publications of or about Dershowitz which are in the \npossession of Dershowitz or in public circulation. \n26. All notes of any investigation of Jane Doe #3's allegations against Dershowitz. \nObjection, not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; \nattorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, vague, indefinite, overly broad, burdensome. \n27. All telephone records, including but not limited to records for any cell phone, for \nany telephone used by Jane Doe #3 between January 1, 1999 and December 31, 2002. \nNone in possession of Edwards and Cassell. \n28. All Documents Concerning Jane Doe #3's diary or journal. \nNo diary or journal is in the possession of Edwards and Cassell. \nBeyond that and to the extent that the request for documents \"concerning\" an unspecified diary \nor journal, Edwards and Cassell object to this request because it is uncertain and overbroad, \nseeks irrelevant and inadmissible information and is not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of relevant and admissible evidence. Edwards and Cassell also object to this request \nbecause it seeks information that is protected from disclosure by the attorney-client privilege. \nEdwards and Cassell also object to this request because it seeks information that is protected \nfrom disclosure by the work product doctrine.\\ \n10 \n\n... [truncated, 2013 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/58 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=58]", "char_count": 2013}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n29. All Documents Concerning any actual or potential book, television, movie or \nother media deals Concerning Jane Doe #3's allegations about being a sex slave. \nObjection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly \nburdensome, vague, harassing. \n30. All Documents Concerning Your retainer agreement with Jane Doe #3. \nObjection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly \nburdensome, overbroad, vague, harassing. \n31. All Documents Concerning any investigation of Jane Doe #3. \nObjection, in that this request is vague and overbroad, since it is not clear exactly what \nthe term \"investigation\" means in this context. \nAlso, objection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly \nburdensome, vague, harassing \n32. All Documents identified in Your responses to Dershowitz's First Set of \nInterrogatories to You in this action. \nSee the documents and answers provided to these requests for production of documents. \n33. AD Documents Concerning Your claim for damages in this action. \nSee the documents and answers provided to these requests for production of documents. \nIn addition, see redacted tax return information from Cassell regarding his claim for \nspecial damages. \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \n11 \nEFTA00603667\n", "char_count": 1933}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n34. All Documents referred to or relied upon by Plaintiffs to prepare \"Jane Doe #3 \nand Jane Doe #4's Motion Pursuant to Rule 21 for Joinder in Action,\" which was filed in \nthe Federal Action as Docket Entry #279. \nObjection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly \nburdensome, vague, harassing. \n35. All Documents referred to or relied upon by Plaintiffs to prepare the Complaint \nin this action. \nPlaintiffs relied on the various defamatory statements made by Alan Dershowitz to \nprepare the complaint. See, e.g., Answer to Interrogatory #2. To the extent that materials are \nsought regarding communications with legal counsel, objection under the attorney-client \nprivilege and work-product doctrine. \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent via E-Serve \nto all Counsel on the attached list, this  \nti‘--clay of  /VLOALA--  2015. \n2A\na\nd \nJack Scarola x_(r\nFlorida Bar No.: 169440 \nAttorney E-Mail(s): jsx@seareylaw.com and \nmep@searcylaw.com \nPrimary E-Mail: _scarolateam@searcylaw.com \nSearcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, P.A. \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409 \nPhone: (561) 686-6300 \nFax: \n(561) 383-9451 \nAttorneys for Plaintiffs \n12 \nEFTA00603668\n", "char_count": 1498}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE IS-000072 \nAnswers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nCOUNSEL LIST \nThomas Emerson Scott, Jr., Esquire \nThomas.scott®csklegal.com; \nSteven.safra®csklegal.com \nCole Scott & Kissane P.A. \n9150 S Dadeland Boulevard, Suite 1400 \nMiami, FL 33156 \nPhone: (305)-350-5329 \nFax: (305)-373-2294 \nAttorneys for Defendant \n13 \nEFTA00603669\n", "char_count": 423}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "EXHIBIT D \nEFTA00603670\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "IN \nTHE CIRCUIT COURT \nOF \nTHE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN \nAND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL, \nPlaintiff(s), \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant(s). \nSUPPLEMENTAL ANSWERS TO DEFENDANT DERSHOWITZ'S FIRST SET OF \nDOCUMENT REQUESTS TO BRADLEY J. EDWARDS AND PAUL G. CASSELL \nPlaintiffs, Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, by and through their undersigned \nattorneys and pursuant to Rule 1.350, Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, hereby file this \nsupplemental response to Defendant, Alan M. Dershowitz's, First Set of Document Requests \ndated February 11, 2015 to Plaintiffs as follows: \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \n1. All Documents Concerning the alleged \"character assassination\" referenced in \nparagraph 8 of the Complaint. \nSee complaint from Jeffrey Epstein v. Bradley J. Edwards. See also pleadings and \nresponse to Interrogatory #1 filed in this case. Plaintiffs have requested documents in the \npossession of Defendant Dershowitz which memorialize his character assassination of Plaintiffs. \nNumerous documents within the Defendant's still incomplete production reflect false and \ndefamatory assaults on the Plaintiffs' character by the Defendant. \n2. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged \"participation in Epstein's \ncriminal conduct\" referenced in paragraph 16 of the Complaint. \nEdwards and Cassell object to this request as being vague, overbroad, and unreasonably \nburdensome, as well as seeking irrelevant and inadmissible evidence and information not \nreasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Edwards and Cassell have \ncollected many pages of documents pointing to Dershowitz's involvement in Epstein's sexual \nEFTA00603671\n", "char_count": 1951}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nabuse of underage girls over a nearly seven year period of time, including legal work that they \ndid in connection with the long-running case of Does v. United States, 9:08-cv-80736-KAM \n(S.D. Fla. filed July 7, 2008) including Docket Entry 291 and all accompanying exhibits. See \nalso all publicly available materials in the long-running case of Epstein v. Edwards et al.,\n502009CA040800,0000vfBAO (Circuit Court of the 15 Judicial Cir. For Palm Beach County, \nFlorida), including for example Edwards' motion for summary judgment. See also all publicly \navailable police reports and investigative files generated in the course of the Palm Beach Police \nDepartment's criminal investigation of Jeffrey Epstein. They have also represented numerous \nvictims in civil actions against Jeffrey Epstein, which involved many pleadings which are public \ndocuments. Of course, these cases also involved numerous attorney-client communications as \nwell as materials covered by the work-product doctrine. \nSee also all pleadings, discovery responses and depositions in the following civil \nproceedings in which Jeffrey Epstein was named as a party: \nState Court in Palm Beach County: \n502008CA037319xxxxMB \n502008CA025129moothe \n502008CA006332xxxxMB \n502008CA028058xxxxMB \n502008CA028051mocMB \n502008CA020614xxmcMB \n502008CA006596xxxxMB \n502008CA005240xxxxMB. \nUnited States Southern District of Florida: \n08-80893 \n08-80232 \n08-80380 \n08-80994 \n08-80993 \n08-80811 \n08-80381 \n08-80804 \n08-80811 \n09-80469 \n09-80591 \n2 \nEFTA00603672\n", "char_count": 1682}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n09-80656 \n09-80802 \n09-81092 \n10-81111 \n10-80447 \nSee also pleadings and response to Interrogatories #1 and #2 filed in this case. \nOn information and belief, Dershowitz also possesses significant information that is \nresponsive to this request — information that Edwards and Cassell have requested from \nDershowitz in their requests for production. \n3. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged knowledge that the filing \nreferenced in paragraph 17 of the Complaint was \"an entirely proper and well-founded \npleading.\" \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n4. All Documents Concerning the alleged \"massive public media assault\" referenced \nin paragraph 17 of the Complaint. \nFor details regarding the massive public media assault, see Edwards' and Cassell's \nanswer to interrogatories #1 and #2. Because the media assault was conducted by Dershowitz \nhimself making statements to media sources of his choosing, Edwards and Cassell do not possess \ndocuments concerning the assault. \n5. All Documents Concerning the \"multiple national televised interviews,\" \n\"statements to and repeated by national and international print news sources\" and \n\"various other forms nationally and internationally\" alleged in paragraph 19 of the \nComplaint. \nFor details regarding the interviews, statements, and other similar communications, see \nEdwards' and Cassell's answer to interrogatories #1 and #2. Because the media assault was \nconducted by Dershowitz himself making statements to the media, Edwards and Cassell do not \npossess documents concerning the interviews and statements referenced here. \n6. All Documents Concerning the allegation in paragraph 20 of the Complaint that \nDershowitz's \"statements were false and known by him to be false at the time they were \nmade.\" \n3 \nEFTA00603673\n", "char_count": 1968}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n7. All Documents Concerning the allegation in paragraph 21 of the Complaint that \nDershowitz falsely protested his own innocence. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. Additionally, Defendant \nDershowitz is himself aware of the various television and radio programs on which he spoke \nabout the Plaintiffs, as well as other public statements he made, and is in a superior position to \nobtain video, audio and written transcripts of those statements to the extent they are not already \navailable and readily accessible on the world wide web. Plaintiffs are awaiting Defendant's \nproduction of materials not otherwise available. \n8. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged \"involvement in Epstein's criminal \nconduct\" as alleged in paragraph 21 of the Complaint. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n9. All Documents that reference Dershowitz by name that Concern the allegations set forth \nin Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n10. All Documents Concerning drafts of any declaration or affidavit of Jane Doe #3. \nObjection, immaterial and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of \nadmissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine. \nWithout waiving any objection, affidavits have been filed by Jane Doe #3 in Does v. \nUnited States, 08-80736. \n11. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) of Jane Doe #3 with Dershowitz. \nNone in Plaintiffs' possession. \n4 \nEFTA00603674\n", "char_count": 1810}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n12. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) not produced in response to any prior Request, of Dershowitz at \n(i) Epstein's Manhattan home in New York City, New York; (ii) Epstein's home in Palm \nBeach, Florida; (iii) Epstein's Zorro Ranch in Santa Fe, New Mexico; (iv) Little Saint \nJames island in the U.S. Virgin Islands; and (v) Epstein's airplane, on the same date and \ntime that Jane Doe #3 also was present at such location. \nNone in the possession of Edwards or Cassell. \n13. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) not produced in response to any prior Request that evidence \nand/or show Jane Doe #3 was present at the same location as Dershowitz on that same date \nand time. \nNone. \n14. All Documents Concerning Jane Doe #3's presence at the various locations \nnamed in Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration on the particular dates \nand times when Dershowitz was also present. \nSee Docket Entry 291 and attachments filed in Doe v. U.S., 08-80736. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \nAdditional responsive documents are subject to the attorney-client and work product \nprivilege. \n15. All Documents Concerning whether Dershowitz was present at the various \nlocations named in Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration on the particular \ndates and times when Jane Doe #3 alleges to have been present. \nSee Docket Entry 291 and attachments filed in Doe v. U.S., 08-80736. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \nAdditional responsive documents are subject to the attorney-client and work product \nprivilege. \n5 \nEFTA00603675\n", "char_count": 1885}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n16. All statements, written or recorded, that Plaintiffs or Jane Doe #3 have provided \nto anyone that reference Dershowitz by name. \nSee documents referenced in Cassell's Response to Second Set of Document Requests \nand Supplemental Response to Second Set of Document Requests. Additional documents are \nsubject to attorney-client and work product privilege. \n17. All notes, writings, photographs, and/or audio or video recordings made or \nrecorded by or of Jane Doe #3 on the dates on which Jane Doe #3 allegedly was present \nwith Dershowitz, including but not limited to any diary, journal, or calendar entries on \nthose dates, regardless whether the notes, writings, photographs, and/or audio or video \nrecordings refer to Dershowitz. \nTo the extent that any responsive materials are \nphotographs or video recordings, please provide them in the original, native format in \nwhich they were taken (not a paper copy). \nNone in Plaintiffs' possession, custody or control. \n18. All notes of, or notes prepared for, any statements or interviews in which \nPlaintiffs or Jane Doe #3 referenced Dershowitz by name or other description. \nNone in Plaintiffs' possession, custody or control. \n19. All Documents Concerning communications between You or anyone acting on \nYour behalf and anyone from, or acting on behalf of, any media outlet Concerning \nDershowitz or this action, whether or not such communications were \"on the record\" or \n\"off the record.\" \nSee documents referenced in Cassell's Response to Second Set of Document Requests \nand Supplemental Response to Second Set of Document Requests. Additional documents are \nsubject to attorney-client and work product privilege. \n6 \nEFTA00603676\n", "char_count": 1854}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n20. All Documents Concerning any press release Concerning this action, the Joinder \nMotion, or Dershowitz, or Jane Doe #3. \nObjection as to \"all documents concerning\" in that it requests information not reasonably \ncalculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; attorney-client privilege, work-\nproduct doctrine, overly burdensome, vague, harassing. \nWithout waiving objection, Dershowitz already possesses a copy of a press release sent to \nthe media by Edwards and Cassell on or about January 2, 2015, that read as follows: \nOut of respect for the court's desire to keep this case from being litigated \nin the press, we are not going to respond at this time to specific claims of \nindignation by anyone. As you may know, we are litigating a very important case, \nnot only for our clients but crime victims in general. We have been informed of \nMr. Dershowitz's threats based on the factual allegations we have made in our \nrecent filing. We carefully investigate all of the allegations in our pleadings \nbefore presenting them. We have also tried to depose Mr. Dershowitz on these \nsubjects, although he has avoided those deposition requests. Nevertheless, we \nwould be pleased to consider any sworn testimony and documentary evidence Mr. \nDershowitz would like to provide which he contends would refute any of our \nallegations. \nThe point of the pleading was only to join two of our clients in the case \nthat is currently being litigated, and while we expected an agreement from the \nGovernment on that point, we did not get it. That disagreement compelled us to \nfile our motion. We intend only to litigate the relevant issues in Court and not to \nplay into any sideshow. We feel that is in our clients' best interest and \nconsequently that is what we are doing. \nWe have every intention of addressing all of the relevant\n... [truncated, 2523 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/69 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=69]", "char_count": 2523}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nDershowitz already possesses a copy a press release sent to the media by Jack Scarola on \nor about January 7, 2015, that read as follows: \nMr. Dershowitz harshly attacks Mr. Edwards and Professor Cassell for not \ntrying to talk to him before naming him in legal papers. But, in truth, and as \nsupported by numerous documents, on at least three occasions since 2009, Mr. \nDershowitz was informed that he was a key witness in the litigation against \nJefficy Epstein and was requested to testify. We advised him at that time as \nfollows: \n`Multiple individuals have placed you in the presence of Jeffrey Epstein \non multiple occasions and in various locations when Jeffrey Epstein was \nin the company of underage females subsequently identified as victims of \nMr. Epstein's criminal molestations. This information is derived from both \nsomeone's testimony and private interviews. Your personal observations \nregarding such circumstances would clearly not involve any privileged \ncommunications, and it is those observations that will be the primary focus \nof our questioning.' \nDespite this notice to Mr. Dershowitz, he failed to respond or testify in any \nfashion. Mr. Dershowitz has not responded to multiple efforts to take his \ntestimony beginning in 2009. \n21. All Documents Concerning any assertion that Dershowitz was a \"co-\nconspirator\" with Epstein. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \nSee also answer to request #10 above. \n22. All Documents Concerning any assertion that Dershowitz negotiated the NPA \nfor his own benefit. \nDershowitz possesses, or has access to, all information regarding his negotiation of the \nNPA. Edwards and Cassell have asked him to produce this information, and will all be \nresponsive to this request as well. See Plaintiffs' Third Request to Produce to Defendant Nos. 2, \n3, and 4\n... [truncated, 2019 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/70 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=70]", "char_count": 2019}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nEdwards and Cassell also have received from the U.S. Attorney's Office from the \nSouthern District of Florida approximately 1000 pages of correspondence between that Office \nand Jeffrey Epstein's legal defense team (including Dershowitz) exchanged from approximately \n2006 to 2008 related to the non-prosecution agreement. Those documents are currently under \nseal by order of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida in connection with the \nDoes v. United States, No. 9:08-cv-80736-KAM. This seal has been requested by, and obtained \nby, Dershowitz's close friend, client and co-conspirator, Jeffrey Epstein, over the objection of \nEdwards and Cassell on behalf of their clients. Accordingly, Dershowitz should request that \nEpstein withdraw his request for sealing so that these materials can be produced to Dershowitz. \nSee also answer to request #2 above (including the NPA itself and its provision granting \nimmunity from prosecution to \"any potential co-conspirators of Epstein\") and to request #24 \nbelow. \n23. All Documents Concerning any actions allegedly taken by Prince Andrew, Duke \nof York, to influence the terms of the NPA. \nEdwards and Cassell have attempted to question Prince Andrew about his actions in this \nregard, but have been rebuffed by Prince Andrew and representatives of the British throne and/or \ngovernment. \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \nEdwards and Cassell have propounded discovery requests seeking such documents in the \nCVRA case. See Request for Admission (RFA) (December 1, 2011) (asking the Government to \nadmit that it possesses \"documents, correspondence or other information refle\n... [truncated, 2341 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/71 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=71]", "char_count": 2341}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nDershowitz already has in his possession a request from Jack Scarola to take his \ndeposition, sent via email on January 3, 2015, which reads as follows: \nDear Mr. Dershowitz: \nStatements attributed to you in the public media express a willingness. \nindeed a strong desire, to submit to questioning under oath regarding your alleged \nknowledge of Jeffrey Epstein's extensive abuse of underage females as well as \nyour alleged personal participation in those activities. As I am sure you will \nrecall, our efforts to arrange such a deposition previously were unsuccessful, so \nwe welcome your change of heart. Perhaps a convenient time would be in \nconnection with your scheduled appearance in Miami on January 19. I assume a \nsubpoena will not be necessary since the deposition will be taken pursuant to your \nrequest, but please let us know promptly if that assumption is inaccurate. Also, \nnote that the deposition will be video recorded. \nKindly bring with you all documentary and electronic evidence which you \nbelieve tends to refute the factual allegations made concerning you in the recent \nCVRA proceeding as well as passport pages reflecting your travels during the past \nten years and copies of all photographs taken while you were a traveling \ncompanion or house guest of Jeffrey Epstein's. \nThank you for your anticipated cooperation. \nSincerely, \nJack Scarola \n25. All Documents Concerning any investigation of Dershowitz. \nThis request is vague and overbroad, since it is not clear exactly what the term \n\"investigation\" means in this context. \nWithout waiving this objection: \n10 \nEFTA00603680\n", "char_count": 1770}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 above. \nSee also all depositions taken in all civil cases involving Jeffrey Epstein in which the \nallegations concerned his molestation of minors. \nSee also the criminal Palm Beach State Attorney's Office file regarding Jeffrey Epstein. \nSee also all books, articles and publications of or about Dershowitz which are in the \npossession of Dershowitz or in public circulation. \n26. All notes of any investigation of Jane Doe #3's allegations against Dershowitz. \nObjection, not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; \nattorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, vague, indefinite, overly broad, burdensome. \n27. All telephone records, including but not limited to records for any cell phone, for \nany telephone used by Jane Doe #3 between January 1, 1999 and December 31, 2002. \nNone in possession of Edwards and Cassell. \n28. All Documents Concerning Jane Doe #3's diary or journal. \nNo diary or journal is in the possession of Edwards and Cacsell. \nBeyond that and to the extent that the request for documents \"concerning\" an unspecified diary \nor journal, Edwards and Cassell object to this request because it is uncertain and overbroad, \nseeks irrelevant and inadmissible information and is not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of relevant and admissible evidence. Edwards and Cassell also object to this request \nbecause it seeks information that is protected from disclosure by the attorney-client privilege. \nEdwards and Cassell also object to this request because it seeks information that is protected \nfrom disclosure by the work product doctrine.\\ \n29. All Documents Concerning any actual or potential book, television, movie or \nother media deals Concerning Jane Doe #3's allegations about being a sex slave. \nObjection in t\n... [truncated, 2214 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/73 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=73]", "char_count": 2214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Edwards. Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n30. All Documents Concerning Your retainer agreement with Jane Doe #3. \nObjection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly \nburdensome, overbroad, vague, and harassing. \n31. All Documents Concerning any investigation of Jane Doe #3. \nObjection, in that this request is vague and overbroad, since it is not clear exactly what \nthe term \"investigation\" means in this context. \nAlso, objection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly \nburdensome, vague, and harassing \n32. All Documents identified in Your responses to Dershowitz's First Set of \nInterrogatories to You in this action. \nSee the documents and answers provided to these requests for production of documents. \n33. All Documents Concerning Your claim for damages in this action. \nSee the documents and answers provided to these requests for production of documents \nand the answers to interrogatories, all of which support a claim of statements that are defamatory \nper se. \nCassell withdraws his claim for special economic losses relating to lost wages and \ndiminished earning capacity. \n34. All Documents referred to or relied upon by Plaintiffs to prepare \"Jane Doe #3 \nand Jane Doe #4's Motion Pursuant to Rule 21 for Joinder in Action,\" which was filed in \nthe Federal Action as Docket Entry #279. \nObjection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine. \n35. All Documents referred to or relied upon by Plaintiffs to prepare the Complaint \nin this action. \n12 \nEFTA00603682\n", "char_count": 1962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nPlaintiffs relied on the various defamatory statements made by Alan Dershowitz to \nprepare the complaint. See, e.g., Answer to Interrogatories #1 and #2. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 above. \nTo the extent that materials are sought regarding communications with legal counsel, \nobjection under the attorney-client privilege and work-product doctrine. \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent via E-Serve \n2•r\nto all Counsel on the attached list, this \nday of  \nfroV, 2015. \nNo.: 169440 \nE-Mail(s): jsx@searcylaw.com and \nsearcylaw.com \nmary E-Mail: _scarolateam@searcylaw.com \nSearcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, P.A. \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409 \nPhone: (561) 686-6300 \nFax: \n(561) 383-9451 \nAttorneys for Plaintiffs \n13 \nEFTA00603683\n", "char_count": 993}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No. CACE 15-000072 \nCOUNSEL LIST \nSigrid Stone McCawley, Esquire \nsmccawley@bsfllp.com; sperkins@bsflIp.com; ftleserve@bsfllp.com \nBoies Schiller & Flexner, LLP \n401 E Las Olas Boulevard., Suite 1200 \nFort Lauderdale, FL 33301 \nPhone: (954)-356-0011 \nThomas Emerson Scott, Jr., Esquire \nThomas.scott@csklegal.com; Steven.safra@csklegal.com; Renee.nail@csklegal.com; \nshelly.zambo@csIdegal.com \nCole Scott & Kissane P.A. \n9150 S Dadeland Boulevard, Suite 1400 \nMiami, FL 33156 \nPhone: (305)-350-5329 \nFax: (305)-373-2294 \nAttorneys for Alan M. Dershowitz \nKenneth A. Sweder, Esquire \nksweder@sweder-ross.com \nSweder & Ross, LLP \n131 Oliver Street \nBoston, MA 02110 \nPhone: (617)446-4466 \nFax: (617)-646-4470 \nAttorneys for Alan M. Dershowitz \nRichard A. Simpson, Esquire \nRSimpson@wileyrein.com \nWiley Rein, LLP \n17769 K Street NW \nWashington, DC 20006 \nAttorneys for Alan M. Dershowitz \nEFTA00603684\n", "char_count": 938}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "EXHIBIT E \nEFTA00603685\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 1 of 51 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nCASE NO.:08-CV-80736-ICAM \nJANE DOE 1 and JANE DOE 2, \nPetitioners, \nvs. \nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA, \nRespondent. \nOPINION AND ORDER \nThis cause is before the Court on various discovery related matters. In response to \nPetitioners' first requests for production, the respondent Government asserted various privileges \nin three privilege logs and submitted nearly 15,000 pages of documents for in camera inspection. \n(DEs 212-1, 216-1, 329-1). Petitioners object to every privilege asserted. (DE 265). \nIntervenor Jeffrey Epstein supports the Government's assertion that certain grand jury \nmaterials should remain secret, and he moves to prevent disclosure of those materials. (DE 263). \nPetitioners filed a response. (DE 271). \nFinally, the Government objects to the relevancy of several of Petitioners' requests for \nproduction. (DE 260). Petitioners responded (DE 266) and filed a supporting supplement (DEs \n267, 268). \nThe Court has conducted its in camera review of materials submitted, has carefully \nconsidered the materials and the parties' submissions, and is fully advised in the premises. \nEFTA00603686\n", "char_count": 1258}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 2 of 51 \nI. Background \nThis is a case against the United States for allegedly violating the Crime Victims' Rights \nAct (CVRA), 18 U.S.C. § 3771, by failing to involve Petitioners (and other similarly situated \nvictims of Intervenor Epstein) in the process that ultimately led to a federal non-prosecution \nagreement between the Government and Epstein. (DE I). The parties and intervenors debate the \ndiscoverability of documents that show exactly what led to the non-prosecution agreement. \nIn March 2011, Petitioners moved \"to allow use of correspondence between the U.S. \nAttorney's Office and counsel for Epstein\" to prove their CVRA case. (DE 51 at I). Petitioners \nargued that the correspondence was relevant as it \"shows that the U.S. Attorney's Office was \naware of its statutory obligation to inform the victims of the non-prosecution agreement,\" and \nthat they should be allowed to use it \"as it sheds important light on the events surrounding the \nnon-prosecution agreement, which are central to the victims' arguments that the U.S. Attorney's \nOffice violated their rights.\" (Id. at 5, 6). The Court granted Petitioners' request and ordered the \nGovernment to \"[p]roduce responsive documents in response to all outstanding requests for \nproduction of documents encompassing any documentary material exchanged by or between the \nfederal government and persons or entities outside the federal government (including without \nlimitation all correspondence generated by or between the federal government and Epstein's \nattorneys)\" (DE 190 at 2). The Court also ordered the Government to produce all responsive \ndocuments \"other than communications generated between the federal government and outside \npersons or entities.\" U. If the Government claimed privilege over any of these documents, the \nCourt ordered the Government to (1) file \"a privilege log clearly identifying each document[] by \nauthor(s), addressee(s)\n... [truncated, 2094 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/79 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=79]", "char_count": 2094}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 3 of 51 \ndata,\" and (2) to \"submit all responsive documents withheld on claim of privilege to the court for \nin camera inspection.\" U. \nThe Government produced 1,357 pages of documents to Petitioners, filed three privilege \nlogs, and submitted nearly 15,000 pages to the Court for in camera inspection. \nDE 257 at \n2). The Government asserts that the documents submitted for in camera inspection are privileged \nfor reasons such as the privacy rights of non-party victims, grand jury secrecy under Federal Rule \nof Criminal Procedure 6(e),' and the attorney-client, work product, deliberative process, and \ninvestigative privileges. (DEs 212-1; 216-1, 329-1). Moreover, with the Court's leave (DE 257 \nat 4), the Government objects to the relevancy of several of Petitioners' requests for production \n(DE 260). \nII. Discussion \nDistrict courts have \"broad discretion in shaping the scope of discovery under \nFed.R.Civ.P. 26(b).\" Williams v. City of Dothan, 745 F.2d 1406, 1415 (11th Cir. 1984). The \nCourt will first address matters related to whether a privilege protects the submitted documents \nfrom discovery and then turn to whether any otherwise non-privileged documents are relevant to \nPetitioners' CVRA case. Specific rulings as to the submitted documents are found in the Table \nappended to this Opinion and Order. \nA. \nPrivilege Assertions \n1. Challenge to the Sufficiency of Government's Privilege Assertions \nPetitioners raise several general objections to the Government's privilege logs. They \nIn a previous ruling, the Court noted that Plaintiffs formally requested the release of \ngrand jury materials, but the Court reserved \"ruling as to whether the materials in question are \nprotected from disclosure by Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(e).\" (DE 257 at 3). \n3 \nEFTA00603688\n", "char_count": 1874}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 4 of 51 \nargue that the Government's logs are inadequate because they do not \"clearly identify\" the \ndocuments as ordered by this Court. (DE 265 at 2; DE 190 at 2). The Court has reviewed the \nGovernment's privilege logs and the documents that they describe, and the Court finds that the \nlogs—describing nearly 15,000 pages of documents— are adequate to facilitate a meaningful in \ncamera inspection and assessment of the asserted privileges. To the extent inadequacies may be \npresent, the Court finds that judicial resources would not be best spent by requiring the \nGovernment to submit a revised, more detailed log. See \nv. Jackson Hosp. Corp., 257 \nF.R.D. 302, 307 (D.D.C. 2009) (court may remedy inadequate privilege log by in \ncamera inspection of described documents or permitting party another chance to submit a more \ndetailed log). \nPetitioners also argue that the Government has failed to provide the factual underpinnings \nnecessary to hold that certain privileges apply, specifically the deliberative process privilege, \ninvestigative privilege, work product privilege, and attorney—client privilege. Discussed in more \ndetail below, the Court finds it unnecessary to consider whether the deliberative process and \ninvestigative privilege apply in this case as other, stronger, privileges are at play, or, as discussed \nfurther below, many of the documents over which the deliberative process and investigative \nprivileges are asserted are irrelevant to this proceeding. Regarding the work product and \nattorney—client privileges, and the Court has considered the materials submitted and the \nGovernment's arguments, and finds that the Government has submitted sufficient evidence to \nevaluate its claims of privilege. (See DE 238-1) (discussing documents prepared by the United \nStates Attorney's Office in anticipation of possible Epstein prosecution); see Stern v. O-Quinn, \n253 F.R.D. 663, 675 (S.D. Fla. 2\n... [truncated, 2074 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/81 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=81]", "char_count": 2074}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 5 of 51 \npleading to decide application of work product privilege). The Court will therefore evaluate each \nclaim of privilege as it relates to the documents submitted. \n2. Grand Jury Secrecy \nThe Government asserts that many of the documents identified in its logs are protected by \nFederal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(e), which governs the secrecy of grand jury proceedings. \n(See DE 212-1; DE 216-1 at 4, 6). These documents include subpoenas issued and documents \nreceived and prepared during the course of grand jury investigations into whether Epstein \ncommitted indictable federal offenses. (DE 212-1 at 1). Petitioners argue that the Court can (and \nshould) authorize disclosure in this case. (DE 265 at 17). \n\"It has long been a policy of the law that grand jury proceedings be kept secret .... The \nEnglish rule of grand jury secrecy has been incorporated into our federal common law and \nremains an integral part of our criminal justice system.\" United States v. Aisenberg, 358 F.3d \n1327, 1346 (11th Cir. 2004) (internal quotation marks omitted). \"Rule 6(e) of the Federal Rules \nof Criminal Procedure codifies this secrecy principle and prohibits the disclosure of grand jury \nmaterial except in the limited circumstances provided for in Rule 6(e)(3).\" Id. One such \nexception is Rule (6)(e)(3)(E)(i), which permits a court to authorize disclosure \"preliminary to or \nin connection with a judicial proceeding.\" Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e)(3)(E)(i). Additionally, a court \nhas inherent authority to disclose grand jury materials beyond the literal wording of Rule 6(e)(3) \nin \"exceptional circumstances.\" Aisenberg, 358 F.3d at 1347. \"The district court has \n'substantial discretion' in determining whether grand jury materials should be released.\" Id. at \n1349 (quoting Douglas Oil Co. v. Petrol Stops N.W., 441 U.S. 211, 223 (1979)). \nWhether proceeding under Rule 6(e)(3) or the court's inherent authority, there ar\n... [truncated, 2024 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/82 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=82]", "char_count": 2024}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 6 of 51 \nsettled guidelines for determining when grand jury secrecy may be broken. Id. at 1347. \nSpecifically, the parties seeking disclosure must show: \n(1) \"that the material they seek is needed to avoid a possible \ninjustice in another judicial proceeding\"; \n(2) \"that the need for disclosure is greater than the need for \ncontinued secrecy\"; and \n(3) \"that their request is structured to cover only material so \nneeded.\" \nId. at 1348 (citing Douglas Oil Co.,N.W., 441 U.S. 211, 222 (1979)). These demanding \nstandards apply even after the grand jury has concluded its operations. Id. The burden of \ndemonstrating that the need for disclosure outweighs the need for secrecy rests on the party \nseeking disclosure. Id. \"In order to carry this burden, the party seeking disclosure of grand jury \nmaterial must show a compelling and particularized need for disclosure.\" Id. That is, \"the \nprivate party must show circumstances had created certain difficulties peculiar to this case, which \ncould be alleviated by access to specific grand jury materials, without doing disproportionate \nharm to the salutary purpose of secrecy embodied in the grand jury process.\" Id. at 1348-49 \n(internal quotation marks omitted) (emphasis in original). \nAccordingly, the grand jury proceedings at issue are \"presumptively secret,\" see In re \nSubpoena to Testify, 864 F.2d 1559, 1562 (11th Cir. 1989), and Petitioners have the heavy \nburden of overcoming this presumption.' Petitioners argue that they have met their burden in \ntheir response to Epstein's motion to uphold grand jury secrecy. (DE 271 at 3). \nBecause the burden lies with Petitioners, Petitioners' argument that disclosure is \nappropriate because the Government \"has not attempted to defend its invocation of grand jury \nsecrecy\" is of no moment. (DE 278 at 10). \n6 \nEFTA00603691\n", "char_count": 1905}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 7 of 51 \nRegarding whether (I) grand jury materials are \"needed to avoid a possible injustice\" in \nthis case, Petitioners argue that \"an injustice may occur\" if the materials are not disclosed to \nthem. (DE 217 at 4). They argue that the possibility for injustice exists because this Court has \nalready recognized that aspects of this case \"must be considered in the historical factual context \nof the entire interface between Epstein, the relevant prosecutorial authorities and the federal \noffense victims—including an assessment of the allegation of a deliberate conspiracy between \nEpstein and the federal prosecutors to keep the victims in the dark on the pendency of \nnegotiations between Epstein and the federal authorities.\" (bit) (quoting the Court's Order at DE \n189 at 12 n.6). They also argue that injustice may result without the grand jury materials because \nthe \"critical starting point for the victims' case\" is proof that the Government had an \"extremely \nstrong case against Epstein.\" (Id.). \nThe Court concludes that Petitioners have not met their heavy burden of demonstrating a \ncompelling and particularized need for the disclosure of grand jury materials pertaining to the \ninvestigation of Epstein. Materials that the Government presented in secrecy to a grand jury \nrelative to a case against Epstein are not part of the \"interface\" that occurred between Epstein, \nprosecuting authorities, and the victims. As the Court has already explained, the harm in this \ncase did not arise out of the Government's failure to secure a grand jury indictment against \nEpstein. (DE 189 at 10) (\"The victim's CVRA injury is not the government's failure to \nprosecute Epstein federally—an end within the sole control of the government.\"). Rather, the \nharm in this case arose from the Government's alleged failure to confer adequately with \nPetitioners before deciding to abandon a federal case against Epstein. (a).\n... [truncated, 2129 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/84 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=84]", "char_count": 2129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 8 of 51 \nfinds that none of the grand jury materials produced has a bearing on the Government's alleged \nfailure to confer with Petitioners before electing to forego a federal prosecution. \nThe Court also concludes that Petitioner's asserted need to prove that the Government \nhad an \"extremely strong case against Epstein\" does not justify the disclosure of secret grand jury \nmaterials. Petitioners seek to use the grand jury materials as the means to an improper end—a \njudicial determination that the Government made an inexplicably poor decision when it decided \nnot to prosecute Epstein. \n\"[T]he Government retains 'broad discretion' as to whom to prosecute.\" Wayte v. United \nStates, 470 U.S. 598, 607 (1985). The CVRA incorporates this principle, providing that \nInJothing in this chapter shall be construed to impair the prosecutorial discretion\" of federal \nprosecutors. 18 U.S.C. § 3771(d)(6). Courts tread lightly where prosecutorial discretion is \nconcerned because \"the decision to prosecute is particularly ill-suited to judicial review.\" Wayte,\n470 U.S. at 607; see also 35 Geo... Ann. Rev. Crim. Proc. 203, 203 n.648 (2006). \"Such \nfactors as the strength of the case, the prosecution's general deterrence value, the Government's \nenforcement priorities, and the case's relationship to the Government's overall enforcement plan \nare not readily susceptible to the kind of analysis the courts are competent to undertake.\" Wayte,\n470 U.S. at 607 (emphasis added); see also Town of Newton v. Rumery, 480 U.S. 386, 396 \n(1987) (courts normally must defer to prosecutorial decisions about whom to prosecute because, \n\"[i]n addition to assessing the strength and importance of a case, prosecutors also must consider \nother tangible and intangible factors, such as government enforcement priorities.\") (emphasis \nadded). \nPetitioners asserted strategy of demonstrating that the Government had an improper \n8 \nEFTA00\n... [truncated, 2007 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/85 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=85]", "char_count": 2007}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 9 of 51 \nmotive to hide its \"extremely strong\" case asks the Court to decide (or assume) that the \nGovernment did in fact have an \"extremely strong\" case against Epstein. As Petitioners point \nout, the Government has not admitted that it believed it had a \"strong case\" for prosecution. (DE \n266 at 8).3 In light of this refusal to admit the strength of the case, Petitioners seek grand jury \nmaterials to present to the Court the case for prosecuting Epstein. a at 9). Basically, \nPetitioners ask the Court to interject itself in place of the Government and adjudicate whether the \nGovernment erred, and thus had a motive for hiding its error, when it decided not to prosecute \nEpstein. As the Supreme Court has articulated, \"courts are [not] competent to undertake\" the \nkind of analysis necessary to assess the \"strength of the case\" for or against any particular \nprosecution. Wayte, 470 U.S. at 607; see also United States v. Armstrong, 517 U.S. 456, 465 \n(1996) (Judicial deference to prosecutors' decisions \"rests in part on an assessment of the relative \ncompetence of prosecutors and courts.\"). Nor is the Court competent to undertake an analysis of \nhow strong the Government perceived its case against Epstein at the time it decided not to \nprosecute. Stated plainly, whether the Government had a \"strong\" case against Epstein was for \nthe Government to decide in its sole discretion; the Court will not foray into matters related to \nassessing the strength of the Government's case against Epstein. \nIn response to Petitioners Request for Admission regarding whether the Government \nhad a case for \"federal prosecution against Epstein for many federal sex offenses,\" (DE 266 at 8), \nthe Government responded: \nThe government admits that the FBI and the U.S. Attorney's Office for the \nSouthern District of Florida (\"USAO\") conducted an investigation into Jeffrey \nEpstein (\"Epstein\") and developed evidence and in\n... [truncated, 2219 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/86 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=86]", "char_count": 2219}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 10 of 51 \nAccordingly, because the Court will not—and cannot—endeavor to assess the strength of \nthe Government's case against Epstein at the time it decided to enter into the non-prosecution \nagreement, the Court concludes that Petitioners have not shown that they will suffer an injustice \nin this case if they are denied access to materials that the Government presented to grand juries \nduring their investigation into whether Epstein committed federal crimes. Likewise, Petitioners \nhave not shown that their need for these materials is compelling or particularized to their asserted \ninterests under the CVRA. Therefore, the Court will deny Petitioners access to the materials over \nwhich grand jury secrecy applies under Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e). \n3. Work Product Doctrine \nThe Government asserts that many of the documents submitted are protected by the \nattorney work-product privilege. (DE 212-1 at 1-21; DE 216-1 at 1-14). These documents \ninclude draft correspondences and indictments, as well as attorney research and handwritten \nnotes. (See, e.g., DE 212-1 at 2, 17). Petitioners argue that the work-product privilege is \nunavailable for a number of reasons. (DE 265 at 6, 8, 14-16). \nThe work-product doctrine traces its roots to the Supreme Court's recognition that \"it is \nessential that a lawyer work with a certain degree of privacy, free from unnecessary intrusion by \nopposing parties and their counsel.\" Hickman v. Taylor, 329 U.S. 495, 510 (1947). The \nprivilege is codified at Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(3): \nOrdinarily, a party may not discover documents and tangible things \nthat are prepared in anticipation of litigation or for trial by or for \nanother party or its representative (including the other party's \nattorney, consultant, surety, indemnitor, insurer, or agent). But, \nsubject to Rule 26(b)(4), those materials may be discovered if: \n(i) they are otherwise discoverable under Ru\n... [truncated, 2035 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/87 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=87]", "char_count": 2035}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 11 of 51 \n(ii) the party shows that it has substantial need for the materials to \nprepare its case and cannot, without undue hardship, obtain their \nsubstantial equivalent by other means. \nFed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(3)(A). Although fact-based work product may be disclosed on a showing \nof \"substantial need,\" the court must avoid \"disclosure of the mental impressions, conclusions, \nopinions, or legal theories of a party's attorney or other representative concerning the litigation.\" \nId. 26(b)(3)(B). Such \"opinion work product enjoys a nearly absolute immunity and can be \ndiscovered only in very rare and extraordinary circumstances.\" Cox v. Adm'r U.S. Steel & \nCarnegie, 17 F.3d 1386, 1422 (11th Cir. 1994). In the context of government attorneys, the \n\"work-product privilege applies to . . . discussions between prosecutors and investigating agents, \nboth state and federal.\" United States v. Zingsheim, 384 F.3d 867, 872 (7th Cir. 2004) (citing \nFTC v. Grolier Inc., 462 U.S. 19 (1983)). \nThe work-product privilege extends only to documents that an attorney prepares \"in \nanticipation of litigation.\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(3)(A). Petitioners argue that the work-product \nprivilege does not apply to the submitted documents because they were not prepared \"in \nanticipation of [the instant] CVRA litigation.\" (DE 265 at 7). Retreating somewhat from this \ninitial assertion, Petitioners argue that \"[m]any of the documents at issue here were not prepared \nin anticipation of litigation, and certainly not in anticipation of the litigation about the Crime \nVictims' Rights Act.\" (a.). \nAlthough \"[s]ome older cases took the position that the work-product immunity applied \nonly to documents prepared in direct relation to the case at bar,\" 8 Wright, Miller & Marcus, Fed. \nPrac. & Fed. P. § 2024, p. 518 (3d ed. 2010), more recent cases \"have generally found that \ndocuments produced in anticipation of litigating one case r\n... [truncated, 2057 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/88 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=88]", "char_count": 2057}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 12 of 51 \nif they were created by or for a party to the subsequent litigation,\" Underwriters Ins. Co. v. \nAtlanta Gas Light Co., 248 F.R.D. 663,668 (N.D. Ga. 2008). These cases rely on the Supreme \nCourt's dicta in Federal Trade Communication v. Grolier, Inc., that \"the literal language of [Rule \n26(b)(3)] protects materials prepared for ars \nlitigation or trial as long as they were prepared by or \nfor a party to the subsequent litigation.\" 462 U.S. 19,25 (1983) (emphasis in original); see also 8 \nWright, Miller & Marcus, Fed. Prac. & Fed. P. § 2024, p. 519 n.47 (3d ed. 2010) (collecting \ncases). Similarly, the work-product doctrine applies regardless of whether litigation actually \nensued, so long as it can be fairly said that the document was prepared or obtained because of the \nprospect of litigation. See Kent Corp. v. \n530 F.2d 612,623 (5th Cir. 1976) (holding \nthat agency documents produced when deciding \"to prosecute or not to prosecute\" were protected \nwork product, regardless of \"whether litigation actually ensured\"). \nAfter its in camera review, the Court finds that the majority of work-product documents \nidentified by the Government were prepared or obtained by the Government because of the \nreasonable prospect of litigating a criminal case against Epstein. (DE 212-1 at 1-21; DE 216-1 at \n1-12; DE 329-1 at 1-18).' This CVRA litigation and the underlying criminal investigation are \nintegrally related, and the work-product doctrine protects from discovery materials prepared in \nanticipation of either in the instant litigation. \n' The Government asserts that the work-product doctrine applies to documents prepared \nby attorneys in the Department of Justice's Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) in \nresponse to Petitioners' counsel's request for an investigation into the Government's handling of \nthe Epstein case. (DE 216-1 at 12-14). Although these documents were prepared by \nGov\n... [truncated, 2435 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/89 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=89]", "char_count": 2435}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 13 of 51 \nPetitioners argue that the work-product doctrine \"does not apply\" in this case for two \nadditional reasons. First, they argue that the doctrine does not apply in a case brought by crime \nvictims against the federal prosecutors who were bound to protect their rights under the CVRA. \n(DE 265 at 13). Second, they argue that the doctrine does not apply because the conduct of those \nprosecutors is a \"central issue\" in this case. (ILL at 15). The Courts finds these arguments \nunavailing. \nFirst, Petitioners argue that the \"work product doctrine does not apply to claims advanced \nby crime victims that federal prosecutors have violated their public responsibilities under the \nCrime Victims' Rights Act.\" (Id. at 14). Because the CVRA compels prosecutors to make their \n\"best efforts\" to notify victims of their rights, Petitioners argue that the Government cannot \nwithhold documents that \"might allow them to protect those very rights.\" (Id. at 15). By way of \nillustration, Petitioners offer the case of In re Grand Jury Subpoena Duces Tecum, where the \nEighth Circuit broadly stated that \"the general duty of public service calls upon government \nemployees and agencies to favor disclosure over concealment.\" 112 F.3d 910, 920 (8th Cir. \n1997). \nA closer inspection of In re Grand Jury Subpoena reveals that it does not stand for the \ncategorical rule that the work product doctrine is inapplicable in cases against public prosecutors. \nThe statement on which Petitioners rely was made in the context of determining whether to \nrecognize a previously undefined privilege: \"whether an entity of the federal government may use \nthe attorney-client privilege to avoid complying with a subpoena by a federal grand jury.\" Id. at \n915 (emphasis added); see also id. at 921 (\"We believe the strong public interest in honest \ngovernment and in exposing wrongdoing by public officials would be ill-served by recognition \n... [truncated, 2021 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/90 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=90]", "char_count": 2021}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 14 of 51 \na governmental attorney-client privilege applicable in criminal proceedings inquiring into the \nactions of public officials.\"). The Eighth Circuit did not purport to espouse a broad-ranging rule \nthat defeated existing, well-defined privileges such as the work product doctrine. This is \nimportant, as the Supreme Court has recognized that the \"work-product doctrine is distinct from \nand broader than the attorney-client privilege.\" United States v. Nobles, 422 U.S. 225, 238 \n(1975) (citing Hickman, 329 U.S. at 508). In fact, the Eighth Circuit went on to consider the \napplication of the work product doctrine and concluded that it did not apply because the materials \nin question were not prepared in \"anticipation of litigation.\" 112 F.3d at 924-25. It did not find \nthe work product doctrine wholly inapplicable based on a goal of public disclosure. \nIn light of the well-established bounds of the work product doctrine—which grants public \nprosecutors \"near absolute immunity\" over their mental impressions in subsequent civil \nlitigation—the Court finds that the CVRA's mandate that prosecutors make their \"best efforts\" to \naccord crime victims their rights does not create a \"very rare and extraordinary circumstance\" in \nwhich discovery of protected work product would be allowed. See Cox, 17 F.3d at 1422. \nSecond, Petitioners argue that the work product doctrine does not apply because the \nconduct of the Government's attorneys is a \"central issue\" in this case. (Id. at 15). Some lower \ncourts have held that disclosure of opinion work product is \"justified principally where the \nmaterial is directly at issue, particularly if the lawyer or law firm is a party to the litigation.\" 8 \nWright, Miller & Marcus, Fed. Prac. & Fed. P. § 2026, p. 567 & n.19 (3d ed. 2010) (collecting \ncases). To satisfy this showing, however, the party seeking disclosure of opinion work product \nmust make \"a far strong\n... [truncated, 2183 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/91 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=91]", "char_count": 2183}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 15 of 51 \n449 U.S. 383, 402 (1981))• see also In re Doe, 662 F.2d 1073, 1080 (4th Cir. 1981) (even under \ncrime-fraud exception to work product doctrine, party \"must show a greater need for the opinion \nwork product material than was necessary in order to obtain the fact work product material\"). \nThe Court finds that Petitioners have not made the strong showing of necessity and \nunavailability required to disclose the mental impressions of counsel that might be at issue in this \ncase. (See DE 265 at 16). Discovery of opinion work product is most often granted in bad-faith \nsettlement cases, where \"mental impressions [of the underlying counsel] are the pivotal issue in \nthe current litigation.\" Holmgren v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 976 F.2d 573, 577 (9th Cir. \n1992). Other than by analogizing to bad-faith actions, Petitioners have not demonstrated how \ndelving in to the \"mental impressions\" of Government attorneys is pivotal to proving their \nallegations that the Government failed to accord them their rights under the CVRA. (See DE 265 \nat 15). Insofar as they seek to demonstrate that the attorneys' mental impressions should have led \nthem to conclude that prosecution was the best course, such inquiry cannot be allowed for \nreasons discussed above. Elsewhere, Petitioners assert that they can prove their case by \ndemonstrating a \"conspiracy between the Government and defense counsel to deliberately \nconceal vital information from the victims.\" (DE 266 at 7). Because of the availability of this \nmethod of proof, Petitioners lack a compelling need to gain access to internal Government work \nproduct evidencing its internal mental impressions regarding the Epstein matter. \nFinally, Petitioners argue that any work-product protection available in this case should \nbe negated because the Government's communications facilitated \"misconduct\" by depriving the \nvictims of their rights under the CVRA\n... [truncated, 2172 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/92 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=92]", "char_count": 2172}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 16 of 51 \nopinion work product is discoverable.\" Cox 17 F.3d at 1422. The Eleventh Circuit has not \nindicated whether this \"rare and extraordinary\" exception extends to instances of \"misconduct\" \nin the form of violating a civil rights statute, such as the CVRA. Even so, the Court finds that \nsuch alleged \"misconduct\" does not rise to the level of conduct that triggers an exception to the \nwork product doctrine. See, e.g. In re Sealed Case 754 F.2d 395, 401 (D.C. Cir. 1985) \n(exception to attorney-client privilege applied where alleged wrongdoing included \"perjured \ntestimony, document destruction, and similar misconduct\"); United States v. Myers, 593 F.3d \n338, 347 n.I4 (4th Cir. 2010) (noting that exception applied where litigant \"defrauded\" public \ndefender by submitting false invoices). Petitioners' allegation that the Government failed to \naccord them their full CVRA rights—the allegation at the heart of this case—does not rise to the \nlevel of conduct sufficiently serious enough to displace the work product privilege. \nMoreover, Petitioners fail to set forth prima facie evidence that the Government in fact \ncommitted \"misconduct\" in this case. To invoke the crime-fraud exception, the party seeking \ndisclosure must (1) make a prima facie showing that the material was produced in the \ncommission of criminal or fraudulent conduct and (2) that it was produced \"in furtherance of the \ncriminal or fraudulent activity or was closely related to it.\" Cox, 17 F.3d at 1416; see also id. at \n1422 (noting that same \"two-part test\" applies in context of both attorney client privilege and \nwork product doctrine). Petitioners argue that the fact that the OPR \"collected information about \npossible improper behavior\" establishes a prima facie case of Government misconduct. (DE 265 \nat 7). An investigation into wrongdoing does not presuppose that wrongdoing took place. After \nits in camera review, the Cour\n... [truncated, 2169 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/93 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=93]", "char_count": 2169}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 17 of 51 \nMaterials constituting the opinion work product of the Government's attorneys shall \ntherefore be withheld from Petitioners. Certain documents that the Court considers fact-based \nwork product may be produced subject to relevancy considerations discussed below. \nB. \nRelevancy of Requests for Production \nIn addition to asserting privileges, the Government responds to Petitioners' first request \nfor production by arguing that many of the materials requested are not relevant to the instant \nCVRA litigation. (DE 260). \nRule 26 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure defines the general scope of discovery as \nfollows: \nParties may obtain discovery regarding any nonprivileged matter \nthat is relevant to any party's claim or defense—including the \nexistence, description, nature, custody, condition, and location of \nany documents or other tangible things and the identity and \nlocation of persons who know of any discoverable matter. . . . \nRelevant information need not be admissible at the trial if the \ndiscovery appears reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of \nadmissible evidence. \nFed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). \"Discovery should ordinarily be allowed unless it is clear that the \ninformation sought has no possible bearing on the claims and defenses of the parties or otherwise \non the subject matter of the action.\" Milinazzo v. State Farm Ins. Co., 247 F.R.D. 691, 695-96 \n(S.D. Fla. 2007) (citing Dunkin' Donuts, Inc. v. Mary's Donuts, Inc. No. 01-0392, 2001 WL \n34079319, at *2 (S.D. Fla. Nov. 1, 2001)). \n1. Request No. 1—the FBI File on the Epstein Matter and Indictment Material \nIn their first request for production, Petitioners seek the file generated by the FBI in the \nEpstein matter, including all documents \"collected as part of its case against and/or investigation \n17 \nEFTA00603702\n", "char_count": 1900}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 18 of 51 \nof Epstein.\" (DE 260 at 2). Petitioners also request that the Government produce all prosecution \nmemoranda and draft indictments prepared in the case. (K.). The Government argues that such \nmaterials regarding its decision to prosecute Epstein are irrelevant to the issue of whether they \ndenied Petitioners their rights under the CVRA. (j ). Petitioners disagree. They argue that \n\"materials going to the strength of the Government's case against Epstein\" are a \"vital part\" of \ntheir case against the Government. (DE at 266 at 8). \"Those materials would directly \ndemonstrate that the Government had an extremely strong case against Epstein, giving the \nGovernment a motive for needing to keep the victims in the dark about the plea deal.\" 01_1). The \nCourt concludes that discovery should not extend to these materials. \nFirst, the Court finds that all prosecution memoranda, research into indictable offenses, \nand draft indictments are protected opinion work product. These documents were created by the \nGovernment in anticipation of a possible prosecution of Epstein and evince the Government's \ninternal mental impressions, legal theories, and strategy concerning the issues presented by a \npossible prosecution. As discussed above, Petitioners have not demonstrated \"rare and \nextraordinary circumstances\" justifying an exception to this well-established protection. \nSecond, the Court finds that the information in the FBI's file regarding its investigation \ninto Epstein has no possible bearing on the CVRA claim that is the subject matter of this action. \nPetitioners assert that the relevancy of this material is to \"directly demonstrate that the \nGovernment had an extremely strong case against Epstein.\" (DE 266 at 8). As discussed above, \nthis Court is ill-equipped to decide that the Government did in fact have a \"strong case\" for \nprosecution and made a hard-to-explain decision to forego a fede\n... [truncated, 2147 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/95 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=95]", "char_count": 2147}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 19 of 51 \nrights under the CVRA, which does not turn on its decision whether to initiate a federal \nprosecution. See 18 U.S.C. § 3771(d)(6). Materials going to the \"strength\" of the Government's \ncase for prosecution—and whether the Government had a motive to hide an embarrassing \nmisstep in failing to prosecute—have no relevance to that inquiry. \n2. Request No. 10—Materials Proving that the FBI was Mislead about Likelihood \nof Prosecution \nRequest number 10 requests \"[a]ll documents, correspondence, and other information \nrelating to discussions between the U.S. Attorney's Office and the FBI concerning the status of \nthe investigation and the plea discussions with Epstein, as well as what kind of charges would \nappropriately be filed against Epstein,\" and lap documents, correspondence, and other \ninformation relating to the U.S. Attorney's Office's representations to the FBI and any other state \nor local law enforcement agency about how this case was being handled.\" (DE 274 at 5). The \nGovernment argues that communications it had with the FBI are irrelevant because the \"decision \non whether to prosecute belongs to the United States Attorney.\" (DE 260 at 3). Petitioners argue \nthat these communications between the United States Attorney's Office and the FBI lie at the \n\"heart of this case\" because they will prove that the Government mislead the FBI about the \nprogress of the Epstein case, and the FBI in turn mislead the victims. (DE 266 at 9). The Court \nconcludes that discovery should not extend to these materials. \nFirst, the vast majority of documents responsive to this request—communications \nbetween the U.S. Attorney's Office and the FBI—are protected from disclosure under either \nprinciples of grand jury secrecy, the opinion work product doctrine, or both. \nTable). \nSecond, the only portion of FBI materials which the Court has not found to be protected \n19 \nEFTA00603704\n", "char_count": 1984}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 20 of 51 \nby either grand jury secrecy or work product protection—the file folder labeled \"(Victims) \nAdditional 302's,\" P-012624-012653 (DE 212-1 at 21)—is not responsive to the instant request \nas it does not contain communications from the United States Attorney's Office to the FBI, \nwhich was then in a position to relay communications to the victims. Rather, these materials \ncontain fact-based summaries of statements provided by victims to interviewing FBI agents. \nThey are not relevant to this proceeding. \n3. Request No. 16—Materials Proving that Prosecutors had Improper Relationships \nwith Persons Close to Epstein \nRequest number 16 seeks materials demonstrating that persons inside the United States \nAttorney's Office had improper relationships with persons close to Epstein. (DE 260 at 3). \nPetitioners argue that these documents \"shown that a prosecutor working inside the U.S. \nAttorney's Office when the deal was being arranged left the office shortly thereafter and began \nrepresenting persons close to Epstein (such as his pilots).\" (DE 266 at 11). They argue that such \nmaterials are relevant to their CVRA case because \"if one of the prosecutors in the Office was \nnot working for the best interests of the United States, but rather for those of Epstein, that would \nbe clear evidence of motive to intentionally keep the victims in the dark.\" a at 11). The Court \nconcludes that production of such documents should not issue. \nAfter its in camera review, the Court finds that the documents discussing the issue of \nwhether an improper relationship existed between a former prosecutor and Epstein's co-\nconspirators are not relevant to this proceeding. The issue of whether a prosecutor violated \nethical canons by representing persons with close ties to Epstein after his retirement from the \nUnited States Attorney's Office does not bear on the issue of whether the Government violated \n20 \nEFTA00603\n... [truncated, 2004 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/97 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=97]", "char_count": 2004}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 21 of 51 \nPetitioners' CVRA rights during its negotiations with Epstein. The only impropriety to which \nPetitioners point occurred after the prosecutor's departure from the Government. The \nOPR—which opened an inquiry into the matter at Petitioners' counsel's request—closed their \ninquiry into the matter by noting that the OPR has jurisdiction to investigate allegations of \nmisconduct involving only current Department of Justice attorneys. (See P-013937.5 see also P-\n0013946). The OPR did not investigate the matter further, and it issued no factual \ndeterminations on whether a conflict existed before the prosecutor's departure. Any OPR \ncorrespondence regarding this inquiry that is not otherwise privileged is irrelevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. (See Table at P-013944, P-013945). \nIn the same vein, correspondence between the United States Attorney's Office and the \nOPR regarding self-reporting of conflicts alleged by Epstein's defense counsel are irrelevant to \nthis proceeding.' (DE 212-1 at 21-22); see Table at P-013227-013247). \n4. Request No. 18—Documents Concerning Recusal of the United States Attorney's \nOffice for the Southern District of Florida \nRequest number 18 seeks information about why the United States Attorney's Office for \nthe Southern District of Florida was \"'conflicted out' of handing various issues related to the \nEpstein case.\" (DE 266 at 11). Specifically, it requests \"all documents, correspondence, and \nother information regarding the potential conflicts of interest that the Justice Department \ndiscussed or determined existed for the USAO SDFL, as well as any referral that was made to \nThis is a draft letter addressed to Petitioners' counsel from an OPR attorney. The Court \nassumes Plaintiff's counsel received the final version of this letter explaining the OPR's reasons \nfor closing its investigation. \nIronically, Epstein's counsel raised conflict-of-interest concerns \n... [truncated, 2121 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/98 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=98]", "char_count": 2121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 22 of 51 \nMain Justice or to any other District, including any documents that were transmitted to any other \nDistrict regarding the conflict and regarding what was to be investigated.\" (DE 260 at 4). \nPetitioners argue that such materials are relevant because they \"show why the victims did not \nreceive proper notifications about the non-prosecution agreement that the [United States \nAttorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida] negotiated with Epstein.\" (DE 266 at 11). \nThe Court concludes that the materials are not relevant in that regard. \nFirst, the Court finds that the responsive documents are shielded by governmental \nattorney-client privilege. The responsive documents are internal Department of Justice \ncorrespondences between attorneys for the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern \nDistrict of Florida and the Executive Office of United States Attorneys. (DE 212-1 at 22-23); \n(see Table at P-013248-13278). One of the Executive Office's functions is to \"[p]rovide general \nlegal interpretations, opinions, and advice to United States Attorneys in areas of recusals.\" \nOffices of the United States Attorneys, United States Department of Justice, \nhttp://www.justice.gov/usao/eousa/mission-and-functions (last visited June 19,2015). The \ninternal documents that Petitioners seek relate to the provision of legal advice by the Executive \nOffice to the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida regarding how \nto proceed in the Epstein matter given the initiation of CVRA litigation by Petitioners. These \ncommunications are solely between attorneys within the United States Department of Justice. \nThe communications do not constitute the commission of crime, fraud, or misconduct, but rather \nsimply advise how to proceed given that allegations of misconduct have been made, i.e., \nallegations that the Government violated the victims' CVRA rights. \nMoreover, \n... [truncated, 2097 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/99 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=99]", "char_count": 2097}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 23 of 51 \nconcerning whether the Government violated Petitioners' CVRA rights several years before. \nPetitioners speculate that the reason that the Southern District recused \"may have to do with the \nOffice's treatment of the victims.\" (DE 266 at 12). The Court has reviewed the recussal \nmaterials, and they do not indicate that the Office had to step away from the Epstein matter \nbecause of its handling of victims' notifications, but rather because of the perceived conflict that \nwould exist if the Office continued to investigate Epstein after the institution of CVRA litigation \nby Petitioners. The recusal materials have no relevancy to anything that occurred prior to the \ninstitution of the instant litigation by Petitioners. \n5. Request No. 19—Materials Related to Defense's Assault on Prosecution \nIn request number 19, Petitioners seek all documents supporting, or contradicting, a \nstatement made by a United States Attorney to the media that Epstein launched \"a yearlong \nassault on the prosecution and the prosecutors.\" (DE 260 at 4). After its in camera review, the \nCourt has not identified any documents that are responsive to this request that are not otherwise \nprotected opinion work product. No production under this request is necessary. \n6. Request No. 25—Initial Disclosures under FRCP 26(a)(1) \nFinally, Petitioners request that the Government comply with its obligation to serve initial \ndisclosures under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(1). Although Petitioners have already \nserved their Rule 26(a)(1) disclosures (DE 266 at 13), and although this Court has repeatedly \nheld that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure \"govern the general course of this proceeding,\" the \nGovernment maintains that the rule governing initial disclosures in civil litigation does not apply \nto it in this case. (DE 274 at 8). The Court disagrees. The Government shall serve its Rule \n26(a)(1) disclosures on P\n... [truncated, 2071 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/100 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=100]", "char_count": 2071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 24 of 51 \nC. \nOther Considerations \nBefore concluding, the Court finds it necessary to address certain aspects of the \nGovernment's privilege logs. \nAs mentioned, the Court previously ordered the Government to provide Petitioners all \n\"documentary material exchanged by or between the federal government and persons or entities \noutside the federal government.\" (DE 190 at 2). Petitioners state that they \"have now obtained \nthe full text of correspondence between the defense attorneys and the prosecutors.\" (DE 298 at \n6). The documents produced for in camera review contain correspondence between the \nGovernment and counsel for both Epstein and Petitioners. Some of the documents were \ninadvertently marked as privileged; some of the documents bear handwritten notes of \nGovernment attorneys, and some are part of communication chains made up of both internal and \nexternal communications. The Table at the end of this order indicates instances where such \ncommunications appear. The Court requests that the Government certify within 14 days that \nPetitioners have been provided with all external communications. \nAdditionally, the Court has identified several documents that are asserted \"work product,\" \nbut which are nothing more than factual complications of information regarding victim \nidentification. The Court finds that Petitioners have a compelling need to know which \nindividuals the Government considered to be victims or potential victims at the time it negotiated \nthe non-prosecution agreement. As indicated in the Table, the Government should confer with \nPetitioners regarding the names of the individuals identified in these documents. If Petitioners \nhave not been previously provided with these names, then Petitioners should have production of \nthe indicated documents. The parties should stipulate to an appropriate protective order to \n24 \nEFTA00603709\n", "char_count": 1956}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 25 of 51 \nprotect the victims' identity. \nIII. Conclusion \nAccordingly, it is hereby ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Government shall \nproduce documents consistent with the following Table. It is further ORDERED AND \nADJUDGED that Intervenor Epstein's Motion for the Court to Protect From Disclosure Grand \nJury Materials (DE 263) is GRANTED, and Petitioners' Motion to Seal (DE 267) is DENIED in \nlight of this Court's Order at DE 326; DE 268 is hereby UNSEALED. \nDONE AND ORDERED in chambers at West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, \nFlorida, this 6ih day July, 2015. \nKENNETH A. MARRA \nUnited State District Judge \n25 \nEFTA00603710\n", "char_count": 706}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 26 of 51 \nTABLE \nDetail of Privilege and Relevancy Holdings \nBates Range \nRuling on Privilege or Relevancy \nComment (as necessary) \n1:000001-000039' \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:000040-000549 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:000550-000621 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000622-000693 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000694.000781 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:000782-000803 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000804-000854 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000855-000937 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000938-000947 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000948-000982 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:000983-001007 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:001008-001056 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:001057-001959 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:001960-002089 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:002090-002169 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:002170-002246 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:002247-002265 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:002266-002386 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:002387-002769 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \nThe first digit indicates the box number, with an \"S\" indicating materials identified in \nthe supplemental privilege logs (DEs 216-1, 329-1). The numbers following the colon are page \nranges. \n26 \nEFTA00603711\n", "char_count": 1914}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 27 of 51 \n1:002770-003211 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003212-003545 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003546-003552 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003553-003555 \nB \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003556-003562 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003563-003629 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:003630-003633 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003634-003646 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003647-003651 \nProduce victim identities. \nDocument bears no indication \nthat it was directly related to \ngrand jury presentation, and it \ndoes not exhibit the mental \nimpressions of counsel but \nrather the cumulation of facts. \nPetitioners should be provided \nwith the victim identities under \nan appropriate protective order. \n1:003664-003678 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003679-003680 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003681-003687 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003688-003693 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003694-003711 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003712 \nProduce victim identity. \nContains nothing other than the \nwritten name of one victim. \nThe Court finds that no \nprivilege applies, and \nPetitioners should be made \naware that this victim was \nknown to the Government. \n27 \nEFTA00603712\n", "char_count": 1794}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 28 of 51 \n1:003713-003746 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:003747-003751 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:003752-004295 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:004296-004350 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy; also \ncontains no materials relevant or likely to lead to \ndiscovery of materials relevant to the instant CVRA \nlitigation. \n1:004351-004381 \nProtected from discovery by work product privilege. \n1:004382-004478 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:004479-004551 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:004552-004555 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:004556-004560 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to the instant \nCVRA litigation. \nContains factual information \nregarding the employment and \nwage history of Epstein's \nemployees, obtained during the \ninvestigation into Epstein and \nhis associates. No bearing on \nvictim notification or rights. \n1:004561-004565 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004566-004716 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:004717-004722 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004723-004725 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004726-004819 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004820-004959 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004960-005059 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy; also not \nrelevant or likely to lead to the discovery of materials \nrelevant to the instant CVRA litigation. \nContains factual information \nregarding the call history of \nEpstein (and associates) to \nvictims, obtained during \ninvestigation into Epstein and \nassociates. Contains no \ninformation bear\n... [truncated, 2069 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/105 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=105]", "char_count": 2069}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 29 of 51 \n1:005060-005081 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nAttorney handwritten notes are \nprotected from discovery; the \nunderlying correspondence is \nnot and should be produced. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided the correspondence. \n1:005082-005083 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005108-005193 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005194-005300 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005301-005331 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:005332-005341 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005342-005387 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:005388-005442 \nExcept P-005420, protected from discovery by grand \njury secrecy and opinion work product privilege. \nThe victims list at P-005420 \nbears no indication that it was \nproduced to a grand jury and \nbears no attorney mental \nimpressions. Petitioners should \nbe provided with the victim \nidentities under an appropriate \nprotective order. \n1:005443-005496 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:005497-005556 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:005557-005576 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005578-005583 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005584-005606 \nExcept P-005590-005595 and P4)05596, protected \nfrom discovery by grand jury secrecy and opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nP-005590-005595 and \nP-005596 are correspondence \ndocuments sent to victim's \ncounsel. No privilege applies. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided the correspondence. \n2:005607-005914 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n29 \nEFTA00603714\n", "char_count": 1929}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 30 of 51 \n2:005915-005977 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:005978-006050 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006051-006065 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006066-006220 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006221-006222 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006223-006522 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006523-006802 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n2:006803-006860 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006861-007785 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:007786-008120 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008121-008139 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n2:008140-008298 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008364-008382 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:08383-008516 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008536-008542 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:008543-008549 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:008550-008615 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:008616-008686 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008687-008776 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n30 \nEFTA00603715\n", "char_count": 1898}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 31 of 51 \n2:008777-008808 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008809-008847 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008848.008862 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008863-008890 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009104-009111 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009126-008134 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009135-009141 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009141A-00914 \n1C \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009142-009152 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009153-009156 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009157-009208 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009209-009213 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009214-009271 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009272-009354 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009355-009403 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009404-009536 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009537-009574 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009575-009603 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009604-009711 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n31 \nEFTA00603716\n", "char_count": 1883}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 32 of 51 \n2:009820-009965 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009966-010096 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:010097-010276 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010277-010394 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010395-010488 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010489-010509 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010510-010525 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010526-010641 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe correspondence between \nthe Government and Epstein's \ncounsel is not privileged and \nshould be produced. The \nGovernment must certify that it \nhas been produced. \n2:010642-010650 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010651-010659 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:010660-010757 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:010758-010793 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010794-010829 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010830-010853 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010854-010876 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010877-010920 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010921-011049 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n37 \nEFTA00603717\n", "char_count": 1681}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 33 of 51 \n2:011050-011212 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011213-011237 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011238-011319 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011320-011361 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011362-011374 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011375-011456 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011457-011626 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:011627-011662 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:011663-012361 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:011699-011777 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:011778-011788 \nProduce victim identities. \nDocument does not exhibit the \nmental impressions of counsel \nbut rather the cumulation of \nfacts. Petitioners should be \nprovided with the victim \nidentities under an appropriate \nprotective order. \n3:011789-011879 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:011880-011922 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:011923-011966 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe underlying correspondence \nbetween Government and \nEpstein's counsel should be \nproduced without attorney \nannotations. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave this correspondence. \n3:011967-012016 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n33 \nEFTA00603718\n", "char_count": 1697}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 34 of 51 \n3:01217-012055 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012056-012088 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012089-012129 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012130-012150 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012151-012167 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012168-012170 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012171-012173 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012174-012176 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nFinal versions of sent \ncorrespondence should be \nproduced. The Government \nmust certify whether Petitioners \nhave any sent version of this \ncorrespondence. \n3:012177-012178 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:012179-012188 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:012362-012451 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:012451-012452 \nProduce victim identities. \nDocument does not exhibit the \nmental impressions of counsel \nbut rather the cumulation of \nfacts. Petitioners' need \noutweighs investigative \nprivilege. Petitioners should be \nprovided with the victim \nidentities under an appropriate \nprotective order. \n3:012453-012623 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:012624-012653 \nProduction not necessary; documents are not relevant or \nlikely to lead to the discovery of materials relevant to \nthis CVRA litigation. \nThe Court has reviewed the \ncontent of the FBI \"302's,\" \nwhich are forms prepared by \nFBI agents to document \ninterviews. These interview \nreports summarize the various \nvictims' interactions with \nEpstein, and do not indicate a \nconveyance of information \nfrom the FBI to the victims \nregarding the likelihood of \nprosecution. \nEFTA00603719\n", "char_count": 1965}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 35 of 51 \n3:012654-012864 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:012865-013226 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:013227 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \nInvolves OPR investigation \ninto Epstein's allegation that \ncertain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \n3:013228-013230 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \nInvolves OPR investigation \ninto Epstein's allegation that \ncertain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \n3:013231-013239 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \nInvolves OPR investigation \ninto Epstein's allegation that \ncertain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \n3:013240-013247 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \nInvolves OPR investigation \ninto Epstein's allegation that \ncertain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CV R:\\ \nrights. \n3:013248-013251 \nProtected from disclosure by the attorney—client \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to the \ndiscovery of materials relevant to this CVRA litigation. \n3:013252-013253 \nProtected from disclosure by the attorney—client \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to the \ndiscovery of materials relevant to this CVRA litigation. \n3:013254-013257 \nProtected from disclosure by the attorney—client \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to the \ndiscovery of materials relevant to this CVRA litigation. \n3:013258-013259 \nProtected from disclos\n... [truncated, 2338 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/112 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=112]", "char_count": 2338}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 36 of 51 \n3:013263-013271 \nProtected from discovery by attorney—client and opinion \nwork product privilege; also not relevant or likely to \nlead to the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \n3:013272-013278 \nProtected from disclosure by the attorney—client \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to the \ndiscovery of materials relevant to this CVRA litigation. \nS:013279-013280 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013281 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013282-013283 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013284 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013285-013289 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013290-013292 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013293-013299 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe portions of this \ncorrespondence between the \nGovernment and Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided with these outside \ncorrespondences. \nS:013300-013303 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013304-013325 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013326-013329 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013330-013333 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013334-013337 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n36 \nEFTA00603721\n", "char_count": 1626}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 37 of 51 \nS:013342-013350 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe underlying correspondence \nbetween Epstein's counsel and \nthe Government should be \nproduced without attorney \nannotations. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave been provided with these \noutside correspondences. \nS:013351-013361 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe underlying correspondence \nbetween Epstein's counsel and \nthe Government should be \nproduced without attorney \nannotations. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave been provided with these \noutside correspondences. \nS:013362-013366 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nAny version of the letter \nactually sent to Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nGovernment must certify \nwhether it has been produced. \nS:013367-013372 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nAny version of the letter \nactually sent to Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nGovernment must certify \nwhether it has been produced. \nS:013373-013503 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013504-013507 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013508-013514 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nOnly the top portion of P-\n013509 contains materials \ninternal to the Government—a \none-sentence email between \ntwo United States Attorneys. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have the \nremainder of P-013509 and P-\n013510-013514, as these \ncommunications are between \nthe Government and Epstein's \ncounsel. \nEFTA00603722\n", "char_count": 1725}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 38 of 51 \nS:013515-013525 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nMy final version of the letter \nactually sent to Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nGovernment must certify \nwhether it has been produced. \nS:013526-013527 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013528-013530, \n013532-013537 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013531 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \nS:013538-013553 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013554-013608 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013609-013615 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \nS:013616-013621 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013622-013643 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013644-013653 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013654-013745 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013747-013810 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013811-013833 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013834-013835 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013836-013837 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013838-013841 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also not relevant material or likely to lead to \ndiscovery of material relevant to the instant CVRA \nlitigation. \nThe underlying correspondence \nbetween Epstein's counsel and \nthe Government should be \nproduced without attorney \nannotations. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave been provided with these \noutside correspondences. \n38 \nEFTA00603723\n", "char_count": 1839}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 39 of 51 \nS:013842 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also not relevant material or likely to lead to \ndiscovery of material relevant to the instant CVRA \nlitigation. \nS:013843-013844 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013845-013846 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013847-013849 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013850 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013851-013853 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013854 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013855 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013856-013857 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013858 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:01386I-013865 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013866 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013867-013868 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013869 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013870-01387I \nProduce; not protected from discovery by any privilege. \nOnly the top portion of the \nemail chain contains \ncorrespondence internal to the \nGovernment, and this does not \ndivulge any mental impressions \nor legal theories. The rest of \nthe email chain is between the \nGovernment and Epstein's \ncounsel. It should be produced. \n39 \nEFTA00603724\n", "char_count": 1615}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 117, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 40 of 51 \nS:013872 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nBesides internal Government \ncorrespondence, contains one \nemail correspondence between \nthe Government and Epstein's \ncounsel, which will be \nproduced at P-013870-013871. \nS:013873 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013876-013877 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe email correspondence at \nP-013877 is between the \nGovernment and Epstein's \ncounsel, and not privileged. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided with these outside \ncorrespondences. \nS:013878-013879 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013880-013882 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nOnly the top two email \ncorrespondences are internal to \nthe Government. The \nremaining emails, starting at \nthe bottom of P•013880 and \nrunning through P-013882, are \nbetween the Government and \nEpstein's counsel, and should \nbe produced. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave been provided with these \noutside correspondences. \nS:013883 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013884-013886 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013887 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013888 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013889-013890 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:01389I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n40 \nEFTA00603725\n", "char_count": 1680}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 118, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 41 of 51 \nS:013894-013898 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013899 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013900-01390I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013902 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013903-013904 \nIdentical to the email chain at S:013870-013871, and \nshould likewise be disclosed. \nS:013905 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nEmail correspondence at \nbottom of page between \nGovernment and Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided with these outside \ncorrespondences. \nS:013906 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013909-013911 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013912-013914 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013915-013918 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013919-013921 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013922-013924 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013925-013927 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nThe final version of this letter, \nwhich is addressed to \nPetitioners' counsel, should be \navailable to Petitioners. \nS:013928-013930 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nThe final version of this letter, \nwhich is addressed to \nPetitioners' counsel, should be \navailable to Petitioners. \n41 \nEFTA00603726\n", "char_count": 1825}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 119, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 42 of 51 \nS:013931-013933 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nThe final version of this letter, \nwhich is addressed to \nPetitioners' counsel, should be \navailable to Petitioners. \nS:013934-013936 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013937-013939 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nThe final version of this letter, \nwhich is addressed to \nPetitioners' counsel, should be \navailable to Petitioners. \nS:013940-013942 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013943 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013944 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013945 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013946 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013947 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013948-013951 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013952-013953 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013954-013955 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013956-013969 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:813970.13971 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also, not relevant or likely to lead to material \nrelevant to this CVRA litigation. \nS: 13972 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13973-13976 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe Government's Second Supplemental Privilege Log begins here. (DE 329-1). \n42 \nEFTA006\n... [truncated, 2006 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00603608/119 or ?id=EFTA00603608&page=119]", "char_count": 2006}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 120, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 43 of 51 \nS:13977-13979 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13980 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:1398I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 13982 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13983-13984 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13985-13989 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13990.13991 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13992-13994 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13995-14010 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also, not relevant or likely to lead to material \nrelevant to this CVRA litigation. \nS:S:I4011-14025 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14026.14027 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14028-14030 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14031-01432 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14033 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14034 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14035 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14036 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14037 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n43 \nEFTA00603728\n", "char_count": 1532}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 121, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 44 of 51 \nS:14038-14041 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:I4042 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14043-14044 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14045-14046 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14047 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14048 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14049-14050 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14051 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14052 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14053 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14054 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14055 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14056 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14057 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14058 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14059-1406I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14062-14068 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14069 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14070.14074 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n44 \nEFTA00603729\n", "char_count": 1500}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 122, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 45 of 51 \nS:14075-14089 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14090.14102 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14103-14107 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14108-14134 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14135-14149 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14150.14156 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14157-15160 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:1416I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14162-14170 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14171-14174 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14175-14203 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14204-14205 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14206.14216 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe portions of the email chain \nfrom Epstein's counsel are not \nprivileged. The Government \nmust certify that this outside \ncorrespondence has been \nproduced. \nS:14217-14238 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe portions of the email chain \nfrom Epstein's counsel are not \nprivileged. The Government \nmust certify that this outside \ncorrespondence has been \nproduced. \nS:14239-14242 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14243-1425I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n45 \nEFTA00603730\n", "char_count": 1670}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 123, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 46 of 51 \nS:14252-14275 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe portions of the email chain \nfrom Epstein's counsel are not \nprivileged. The Government \nmust certify that this outside \ncorrespondence has been \nproduced. \nS: 14276 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14277-14282 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14283-14284 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14285-14298 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14299-14307 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14308-14310 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14311-14329 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege; outside correspondence and P- \n014315.014316 must be produced. \nThe Government must certify \nthat the outside correspondence \nhas been produced. The \ncorrespondence at P-014315-\n014316 must be produced; this \nfact-based material is not \nopinion work product as it does \nnot reveal the mental \nimpressions of counsel, and the \ncourt finds that Petitioners have \na compelling need for the \ninformation contained therein. \nThis need also outweighs any \ndeliberative-process privilege \nthat may apply. It not \nprotected by the attorney-client \nprivilege, as the Government \nhas not demonstrated that FBI \nagent Kuyrkendall provided \nthis information in an attempt \nto secure legal advice or a legal \nopinion from the United States \nAttorney's Office. The \ncorrespondence must be \nproduced pursuant to an \nappropriate protective order. \n46 \nEFTA00603731\n", "char_count": 1725}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 124, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 47 of 51 \nS:14330.14337 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe portions of the email chain \nfrom Epstein's counsel are not \nprivileged. The Government \nmust certify that this outside \ncorrespondence has been \nproduced. \nS:14338-14354 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14355-14361 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14362-14402 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14403-14414 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14415-14420 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14421-14428 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:I4429-14439 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14440 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:1444I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14442 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14443 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14444 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14445-14447 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14448-14454 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14455-14456 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14457-14464 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n47 \nEFTA00603732\n", "char_count": 1556}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 125, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 48 of 51 \nS: 14486 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14487 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14488-14499 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14500 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14501-14506 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14507-14508 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14509-14519 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14520 \nProduce. \nThe Government has not \nsupported its assertion of \nattomey-client privilege: the \nemail does not, in and of itself, \ndemonstrate that it was a \ncommunication between an \nattorney and clients regarding \nthe provision of legal services \nor legal advice. Petitioners' \nneed for this material \noutweighs any deliberative \nprocess or investigative \nprivilege that may apply. \nS:14521-14522 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14523 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14524-14550 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n48 \nEFTA00603733\n", "char_count": 1244}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 126, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 49 of 51 \nS: 14551 \nProduce. \nThe Government has not \nsupported its assertion of \nattorney-client privilege: the \nemail, authored by an FBI \nagent, does not indicate that it \nis a client communication \nseeking legal services or advice \nfrom an attorney, the United \nStates Attorney's Office. \nPetitioners' need for this \nmaterial outweighs any \ninvestigative privilege that may \napply. This must be produced \npursuant to an appropriate \nprotective order. \nS:14552 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14553-14556 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14557 \nProduction not necessary as not relevant or likely to lead \nto material relevant to this CVRA litigation. \nS:14558 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14559-14562 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14563-14565 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n5:14566.14568 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14569-14573 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14574-14583 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14584-14622 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14623-14627 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14628 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14629 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n49 \nEFTA00603734\n", "char_count": 1566}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 127, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 50 of 51 \nS:14630.14631 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14632-14646 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14647-14649 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14650.14653 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14654.14655 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14656.14665 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14666.14693 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14694-14706 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14707-14711 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14712-14716 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14717-14721 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14722-14727 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14728-14742 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14743-14780 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14781-14800 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14801.14810 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14811-14829 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14830.14837 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14838-14843 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n50 \nEFTA00603735\n", "char_count": 1565}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00603608", "page_number": 128, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 51 of 51 \nS:14844-1485I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14852-14864 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to material \nrelevant to this CVRA litigation. \nInvolves self-reporting to OPR \nregarding Epstein's allegation \nthat certain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \nS: 14865 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n5:14866.14883 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14884-14886 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14887-14894 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14895-14900 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14901-14906 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14907-1491I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14912-14919 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n5:14920.14923 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe Government notes that a \nredacted version has been \nproduced to Petitioners. (DE \n329-1 at 18). Only the \nunredacted version is \nprivileged. \n51 \nEFTA00603736\n", "char_count": 1331}]}