{"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_count": 179, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00601154", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00601154.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL\nCIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072\nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G.\nCASSELL,\nPlaintiffs,\nvs.\nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ,\nDefendant.\nVIDEOTAPE DEPOSITION OF\nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ\nVOLUME 1\nPages 1 through 179\nThursday, October 15, 2015\n9:31 a.m. - 4:13 p.m.\nCole Scott & Kissane\n110 Southeast 6th Street\nFort Lauderdale, Florida\nStenographically Reported By:\nKimberly Fontalvo, RPR, CLR\nRealtime Systems Administrator\n1\nEFTA00601154\n", "char_count": 500}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "1\nAPPEARANCES:\n2\nOn behalf of Plaintiffs:\n3\n4\n5\n6\nSEARCY, DENNEY, SCAROLA\nBARNHART & SHIPLEY, P.A.\n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard\nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33402-3626\nBY: JACK SCAROLA, ESQ.\njsx@searcylaw.com\n7\n8\n9\nOn behalf of Defendant:\nCOLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.\nDadeland Centre II - Suite 1400\n9150 South Dadeland Boulevard\nMiami, Florida 33156\nBY: THOMAS EMERSON SCOTT, JR., ESQ.\nthomas.scott@csklegal.com\nBY: STEVEN SAFRA, ESQ.\nsteven.safra@csklegal.com\n(Via phone)\n10\n11\n12\n13\n--and--\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n21\n22\n23\nSWEDER & ROSS, LLP\n131 Oliver Street\nBoston, MA 02110\nBY: KENNETH A. SWEDER, ESQ.\nksweder@sweder-ross.com\n--and--\nWILEY,\nREIN\n17769 K Street NW\nWashington, DC 20006\nBY: RICHARD A. SIMPSON, ESQ.\nRSimpson@wileyrein.com\nBY: NICOLE A. RICHARDSON, ESQ.\nnrichardson@wileyrein.com\n24\n25\n22\n2\nEFTA00601155\n", "char_count": 823}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "1\nAPPEARANCES (Continued) :\n2\n3\nOn behalf of Jeffrey Epstein:\n4\nMARTIN G. WEINBERG,\nPC\n5\n6\n20 Park Plaza, Suite 1000\nBoston, MA 02116\nBY: MARTIN G. WEINBERG. ESQ.\nmarty@martinweinberglaw.com\n(Via phone)\n7\n--and--\n8\n9\nDARREN K. INDYKE, PLLC\n575 Lexington Ave., 4th Fl.\nNew York, New York\nBY:\nDARREN K. INDYKE, ESQ.\n(Via phone)\n10\n11\nOn behalf of\n:\n12\n13\n14\nBOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER,\n401 E. Las Olas Blvd., Ste. 1200\nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301\nBY: SIGRID STONE MCCAWLEY, ESQ.\nsmccawley@bsfllp.com\nLLP\n15\n16\nALSO PRESENT:\n17\nJoni Jones, Utah Attorney General Office\n18 Travis Gallagher, Videographer\n19\n20\n221\n22\n23\n24\n25\n22\n3\nEFTA00601156\n", "char_count": 642}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "1\n2\nINDEX\n4\n3\n41\n3\nExamination\nPage\n5\n6\nVOLUME 1 (Pages 1\n-\n179)\n7\nDirect\nBy Mr. Scarola\n6\n8\nCertificate of Oath\n176\nCertificate of Reporter\n177\n9\nRead and Sign Letter to Witness\n178\nErrata Sheet (forwarded upon execution)\n179\n10\n11\nNo exhibits marked to Volume 1.\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n221\n22\n23\n24\n25\n22\nEFTA00601157\n", "char_count": 324}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "10\n7\n8\n00\n9\n2\n3\n1\nThereupon,\nthe following proceedings began at 9:31 a.m.:\nVIDEOGRAPHER: This is the 15th day of\n09:31:40\n4\nOctober, 2015. The time is approximately 9:31\n5\na.m. This is the videotaped deposition of Alan\n6\nM. Dershowitz in the matter of Bradley J.\nEdwards and Paul Cassell versus Alan M.\nDershowitz. This deposition is being held at\n110 Southeast 6th Street, Suite 1850, Fort\nLauderdale, Florida, 33301.\nI'm the\n09:31:40\nMy name is Travis Gallagher.\nvideographer representing Above & Beyond\n11\n12\n13\nReprographics.\n14\nWill the attorneys please announce their\n09:31:46\n15\nappearances for the record.\n16\n17\n18\nMR. SCAROLA: My name is Jack Scarola.\nI'm counsel on behalf of Bradley Edwards and\nProfessor Paul Cassell. Mr. Edwards and\n09:31:48\n19\nMr. Cassell are also present.\n20\n20\nAlso with us from the Utah Attorney\n09:31:58\n21\n21\nGeneral's office is Joni Jones.\n22\nMS. MCCAWLEY: Sigrid McCawley.\nI'm with\n09:32:06\n23\nthe law firm of Boies Schiller & Flexner on\n24\nbehalf of\n25\nMR. SCOTT: Good morning. Tom Scott on\n09:32:12\nEFTA00601158\nсл\n5\n", "char_count": 1057}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "7\n6\n1\nbehalf of the Defendant Professor Dershowitz.\n2\nMR. SIMPSON: Richard Simpson on behalf of 09:32:18\n3\n3\nProfessor Dershowitz.\n4\nMR. SWEDER: Ken Sweder on behalf of\n09:32:22\n5\nDefendant and Counterclaimant Alan M.\nDershowitz.\nMR. WEINBERG: This is Martin Weinberg\nappearing by telephone. Thank you for allowing\n09:32:29\n00\n8\n9\nthat on behalf of Jeffrey Epstein.\n10\nMR. SAFRA: This is Steven Safra also on\n09:32:37\n11\nbehalf of Professor Dershowitz.\n12\nMR. INDYKE: This is Darren Indyke on\n09:32:43\n13\nbehalf of Jeffrey Epstein.\n14\nMS. RICHARDSON: Nicole Richardson on\n09:32:46\n15\nbehalf of Professor Dershowitz.\n16\nThereupon:\n09:32:47\n17\nALAN DERSHOWITZ\n09:32:47\n18\nhaving been first duly sworn, was examined and\n09:32:47\n19 testified as follows:\n20\nDIRECT EXAMINATION\n09:32:47\n21\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:32:54\n22\nQ. Would you please state your full name,\n09:32:55\n23\nsir?\n24\n24\nA.\nAlan Morton Dershowitz.\n25\nQ.\nAnd where did you live?\n09:32:57\n09:32:59\nEFTA00601159\n6\n", "char_count": 968}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "7\n1\nA.\nWell, I live in three places. We have a\n09:33:00\n2\nhome in Miami Beach, a small condo apartment where\n3\nwe spend the winters. We live in the fall and part\n4\nof the spring in an apartment in New York, and then\n5\nwe have a summer place on Martha's Vineyard.\n6\nQ. Within the last ten years, have you had\n09:33:21\n7\nother residence besides those that you've described?\n8\nA.\nYes.\n09:33:27\n9\nQ.\nAnd where are they?\n09:33:27\n10\nA.\nWe owned a home in Cambridge,\n09:33:30\n11\nMassachusetts about a mile away from the Harvard Law\n12\nSchool.\n13\nQ. And at what point in time did you no\n09:33:39\n14\nlonger have the Cambridge home?\n15\nA. Well, we moved out of it a couple of years 09:33:45\n16\nago and then it was on the market for a while. And\n17\nthen it was sold. I don't have exact dates in my\n18\nmind.\n19\nQ. Sometime within the last three years\n09:33:57\n20 approximately?\n21\nA. Certainly was sold within the last three\n09:34:02\n22 years, yes.\n23\nQ. And you moved out when?\nA.\nMoved out earlier than that. Moved out\n09:34:04\n09:34:06\n24\n25 when we put it on the market. And when I came back\nEFTA00601160\n", "char_count": 1098}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "8\n00\n1\nto teach at Harvard for my last semester, we stayed\n2\nin the Charles Hotel.\n3\nQ.\nHow long have you had the apartment in\n09:34:20\n4\nNew York?\n5\nA.\nThis apartment, it's been a couple of\n09:34:23\n6\nyears.\n7\nQ. And prior to that, was there a period of\n09:34:26\n8\ntime when you maintained another residence in\n9\nNew York?\n10\nA.\nYes.\n09:34:31\n11\nQ.\nAnd what period of time was that?\n09:34:32\n12\nA.\nProbably 30 years, around 30 years.\n09:34:37\n13\nQ.\nBeginning approximately 30 years ago?\n09:34:42\n14\nA.\nYes, beginning approximately 30 years ago,\n09:34:46\n15\nyes.\n16\nQ. So, have you maintained a residence in\n09:34:49\n17\nNew York continuously for approximately the last\n18\n30 years?\n19\nA. We have not maintained a residence as that 09:34:56\n20\nterm's legally applied. We have had a pied-à-terre\n21\nin New York that we occasionally visited over the\n22\n23\n24\n25\npast 30 years, yes.\nQ. You had property where you could stay\novernight, you had access to that property in\nNew York continuously for the past 30 years?\n09:35:07\nEFTA00601161\n", "char_count": 1033}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "1\nA.\nThat's correct.\n2\nQ.\nIs that accurate?\n3\n41\n3\nA.\nThat's correct, yes.\n9\n09:35:20\n09:35:21\n8\n9\nQ. All right. Can you tell me, please,\n5 whether you agree or disagree with the following\n6 statement: \"According to our philosophical and\n7 ethical traditions, reputation is sacrosanct\"?\nMR. SCOTT: Can I ask what you're\npublishing from?\n09:35:22\n09:35:23\n09:35:39\n10\nMR. SCAROLA: I'm just asking a question.\n09:35:41\n11\nA.\nI believe reputation is sacrosanct and I\n09:35:43\n12\nbelieve that an effort has been made to destroy mine\n13\nby false and malicious charges, yes.\n14\nMR. SCAROLA: I would move to strike the\n09:35:53\n15\nunresponsive portion of the answer.\n16\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n17\n18\nQ. Do you agree or disagree with the\nfollowing: \"A good name is more desirable than\n09:35:56\n09:35:56\n19\ngreat riches\"?\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\nA. I certainly agree with that. And there's\nbeen an effort to destroy my good name by false and\nmendacious charges.\nMR. SCAROLA: I move to strike the\nunresponsive portion of the answer.\n09:36:02\n09:36:09\n25\nEFTA00601162\n", "char_count": 1040}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "10\n1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:36:12\n2\nQ.\nDo you agree or disagree with the\n09:36:13\n3\nfollowing statement:\n\"While throughout history\n4 reputation has been recognized as a priceless\n5\ntreasure, it is fragile\"?\n6\nA. I think that the longer one maintains a\n09:36:28\n7\ngood reputation, as I have for over 50 years, the\n8\nless fragile it is; but, yes, it is fragile and one\n9\nfalse allegation maliciously made by a serial liar\n10\nwith the help of her unethical lawyers could destroy\n11\na fragile or hurt a fragile reputation.\n12\nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the\n09:36:59\n13\nunresponsive portion of the answer.\n14\nMR. SCOTT: Obviously we take a different\n09:37:01\n15\nposition.\nBut go ahead, Jack.\n16\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:37:04\n17\n18\nQ. Do you agree or disagree with the\nfollowing statement: \"Sensational accusations, even\n09:37:05\n19\nwhen baseless, often cause damage that is\n20\nirreversible\"?\n21\nA. That is a perfect description of exactly\n09:37:15\n22\nwhat happened to me, yes, at the hands of your\n23\nclients.\n24\nMR. SCAROLA:\nMove to strike the\n09:37:24\n25\nunresponsive portion of the answer.\nEFTA00601163\n", "char_count": 1093}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Do you degree or disagree with the\n1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n2\nQ.\n3 following statement:\n4\n\"There is no presumption of\ninnocence in the court of public opinion\"?\n11\n09:37:26\n09:37:27\n5\nA. I think there's some truth to that. But\n09:37:35\n6\nwhen you have a good reputation, there are some who\n7\ndo presume innocence, particularly when the charges\n8\nmade against you are so clearly filled with the lies\n9\nand financial motivation as were in the instance\n10\nwhen your clients directed false accusations against\n11\nme.\n12\nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the\n09:38:06\n13\nunresponsive portion of the answer.\n14\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:38:08\n15\nQ. Do you agree or disagree with the\n09:38:09\n16\nfollowing statement:\n\"The usual reaction to ugly\n17\naccusations assumes that fire lies beneath the\n18\nsmoke, rather than that the smoke lies\"?\n19\nMR. SCOTT: You want that read back? You\n09:38:25\n20\ngot it all?\n21\nA.\nCan you\ncan you show me where that\n09:38:31\n22\ncomes from?\n23\n09:38:34\n24\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:38:34\n25\n25\nQ. I'm only asking ultimately whether you\n09:38:35\nEFTA00601164\n", "char_count": 1054}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "1\nagree or disagree with the statement.\n2\nMR. SCOTT: It's our position that you're\n09:38:38\n3\n3\nreading from something that\nespecially if\n4\n5\nyou're reading something that he's published,\nif\n6\nhe has the option to see it in order to\nyou're quoting from it, we would like to ask\nyou to produce it so he can read it.\n7\n8\n00\nA.\nIt's\nit's a metaphorical statement\n9 whose general thrust I agree with, yes.\n09:38:53\n10\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:38:58\n11\nQ.\nThank you.\n09:38:59\n12\nA.\nThank you very much for reading from my\n09:39:01\n13\nfrom my book.\nAppreciate it.\n14\n15\nQ. In light of your agreement with the\nprinciples that I have just read, can we also agree\n09:39:10\n16\n17\nthat a serious injury to a reputation requires\nserious monetary compensation if the injury is\n18\n19\nunjustified?\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form, conclusion,\nspeculation.\n09:39:28\n20\n21\n22\nA. I don't think that there is any possible\nmonetary compensation for the attempt to damage my\n09:39:32\n23 reputation which your clients have maliciously and\ndeliberately set out to do for their own financial\n24\n25\nreasons.\nEFTA00601165\n12\n", "char_count": 1088}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "13\n09:39:47\n1\n2\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:39:47\n3\nQ.\nThat, however, is not a response to the\n09:39:47\n4\nquestion that I asked. So let me try again.\n5\nMR. SCAROLA: And I move to strike that.\n09:39:50\n09:39:52\n6\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n7\nQ.\nCan we agree that in light of the\n09:39:53\n8 statements that you have recognized to be accurate\n9\n10\n11\n12\nregarding the priceless value of reputation, that an\nunjustified injury to reputation is a serious injury\nthat requires serious compensation?\nMR. SCOTT: Same objection.\nA. I don't think that question can be\n13\n14\nanswered in a yes or no way. I will just reiterate\n15\nthat I think the damage to my reputation exceeds any\n16\npossible amount of money. If I had been offered\n17\n$10 million in exchange for somebody making the\n18\nkinds of baseless accusations that your clients made\n19 against me, I would have turned down that\n20\n21\n22\n$10 million. I think that there is no compensation\npossible other than a complete apology and\nwithdrawal of the false accusations, especially\n23\nsince your clients know that the accusations made\n24 against me are baseless and false.\n25\n09:40:17\n09:40:18\nEFTA00601166\n", "char_count": 1130}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nQ.\nDo you agree that if an injury to\n2\n3\nreputation is done purposefully and with malice, it\n09:41:02\n09:41:03\n4\nis deserving of punishment?\n5\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, legal conclusion,\n09:41:13\n6\nform, speculation.\n7\nA.\nI believe that the accusations leveled\n09:41:18\n8\nagainst me were made with malice and with deliberate\n9\n10\nintention, which is why I am going to be seeking\ndisciplinary action, including disbarment, against\n11\nyour unethical and mendacious clients.\n12\n13\nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike as\nunresponsive to my question.\n09:41:36\n14\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15\nQ. The question I'm posing to you, sir, is:\n09:41:38\n09:41:39\n16\nDo you agree that if an injury to reputation is done\n17\nwithout factual basis and intentionally, it is\n18\ndeserving of punishment?\n19\n20\nA. What you have done is to describe with\ngreat precision what your clients did to me. And so\n09:41:58\n21\nthe answer to my question is\nthe answer to your\n22\nquestion is yes, I think your\n--\nI think your\n23\nclients are deserving of punishment, yes.\n24\n25\nQ. Do you believe that you are a special\ncase; that is, that intentional injury to your\n09:42:09\n14\nEFTA00601167\n", "char_count": 1152}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "1 reputation is deserving of punishment but\n2\nintentional injury to the reputation of others is\n3 not deserving of punishment?\n4\n5\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form,\nargumentative, compound.\n09:42:24\n6\nA. I certainly don't think I'm a special\n09:42:26\n7\ncase. I think that I have been defamed and\n8\ndeliberately by your clients and I don't think\n9 lawyers who engage in such deliberate conduct should\nbe allowed to practice law, which is why I am going\n10\n11\nto seek their\n--\ntheir\ntheir disbarment and\n12\nother\nother sanctions.\n13\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n14\n15\nQ. In fact, you have been making public\nstatements of your intention to seek the disbarment\n09:42:49\n09:42:50\n16\nof Bradley Edwards and Paul Cassell for\n17\napproximately ten months, correct?\n18\nA. That's right. That's correct.\n09:43:03\n19\nQ.\nYou are aware of the ethical obligation\n09:43:05\n20\n21\nthat a lawyer has when that lawyer has direct\nknowledge of unethical conduct on the part of\n22\nanother member of the Bar\n23\nA.\nThat's right.\n09:43:16\n24\nQ.\n--\nto report that unethical conduct,\n09:43:16\n25\ncorrect?\n15\nEFTA00601168\n", "char_count": 1074}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "1\nA.\nYes.\n2\nQ.\nHave you done that?\n3\n41\n5\n6\nA. I have conferred with three leading ethics\nexperts and I have been advised that to file a\nreport while there is ongoing litigation is not the\nproper approach. But rather to gather the evidence\n7\nand the information and to make sure that all of the\n16\n09:43:19\n09:43:20\n09:43:21\n12\n13\n8\n9\n10\n11\nallegations I make are well founded, unlike what\nyour clients did, and then at the appropriate time,\nwhen the litigation is concluded, seek the\ndisbarment of Bar associations. I am advised by my\nethics experts do not look kindly on attempts to\ndisbar lawyers that can be perceived as part of an\n14\nongoing litigation strategy.\n15\n16\nI fully intend to seek disbarment, as I\nsaid, of your clients because I believe they engaged\n09:44:10\n17\nin unprofessional, unethical and disbarrable\n18\nconduct. And I've continued to do so until as\n19\nrecently as last week.\n20\nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the\n09:44:28\n21\nunresponsive portion of that answer.\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:44:32\n23\nQ. Who are the three leading experts with\n09:44:33\n24\nwhom you've conferred?\n25\nA. The expert I conferred with initially was\n09:44:37\nEFTA00601169\n", "char_count": 1161}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "1 Dean Monroe Freedman of the Hofstra law school who\n17\n2\nhad been my kind of ethical guru for my entire\n3\ncareer. I spent an extensive amount of time with\n4\nhim conferring about all aspects of this case.\n5\n6\nI then conferred with Professor Stephen\nGillers, who is wildly regarded as the leading\n09:44:59\n7\ncurrent ethics expert in the United States who is a\n8\nprofessor at NYU law school.\n9\nI also conferred with Professor Ronald\n09:45:12\n10\n11\nsome unsolicited\nRotunda, and in the process of also received advice,\nsome solicited from a variety of\n12\nlawyers and other experts. I'll give you an\n13\nexample.\n14\nFor example, when I was speaking at an\n09:45:33\n15\nevent in Florida, a man came over to me who I\nI\n16\ndon't recall his name, but he worked for a big firm\n17\nand was on the\n--\non some ethics committee of a\n18\nFlorida Bar Association.\nAnd he advised me to bring\n19\nethics charges saying that from what he had seen,\n20\n21\nthe conduct of the lawyers were unethical and\nunprofessional and deserved disbarment. But also\n22\nadvised me not to do it until litigation was\n23\nconcluded.\n24\nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the\n09:46:07\n25\nunresponsive portions of that answer.\nEFTA00601170\n", "char_count": 1185}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "18\n1\nAnd I would ask, Mr. Scott, that you\n09:46:10\n2\ncounsel your client to be responsive to the\n3\n41\n3\nquestions in order that we have some reasonable\nexpectation of being able to finish this\n5\n69\n00\n8\ndeposition within my lifetime.\nMR. SCOTT: I'm not here to exchange\nsarcastic comments, Jack, with you. I believe\nmy client is trying to answer your questions.\n09:46:26\n9\n10\nof three individuals.\nMR. SCAROLA: The question asked for names\nWhat I got was a speech.\n09:46:32\n11\n12\n13\n14\nWhat I have gotten repeatedly in response to\ndirect questions are speeches. I would ask\nthat you counsel your client to please respond\nto the questions.\n15\nMR. SCOTT: When we take a break, I'll\n09:46:45\n16\nspeak to my client in general based upon what I\n17\nthink is appropriate. Let's proceed.\n18\nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you.\n09:46:54\n19\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:46:54\n20\nQ. In an interview with Hala Gorani on\n09:46:55\n21\nJanuary 5 of this year, broadcast on CNN Live, you\n22\nsaid, \"I have a superb memory.\"\n23\nDo you acknowledge having made that\n09:47:08\n24\nstatement?\n25\nA. I have a superb memory, so I must have\n09:47:10\nEFTA00601171\n", "char_count": 1113}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "1\nmade that statement.\n2\nMy mother had an extraordinary\n3\nmemory and when I was in college and I was on the\ndebate team, my mother allowed me to debate on the\n4\n5\n6\nSabbath, which was Jewish rest day, only on the\ncondition that I not take notes or write. And at\nthat point I discovered that I have a very good\n7\nmemory and don't have to\n--\ngenerally didn't have to\n8\ntake notes.\n9\nMy memory, obviously, at the age of 77 has\n09:47:41\n10\nslipped a bit; but do I have a very good memory,\n11\nyes.\n12\nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the\n09:47:48\n13\nunresponsive portions of the answer.\n14\nWould you like to take a break now,\n09:47:51\n15\nMr. Scott, so that\n16\nMR. SCOTT: No, I'd like to proceed.\n09:47:55\n17\nMR. SCAROLA:\nOkay.\n09:47:56\n18\nA.\nMe too.\n09:47:57\n19\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:47:58\n20\nQ. So it is your contention that you still\n09:47:58\n21\nhave a superb memory?\n22\nA.\nNo. My contention is that I have a very\n09:48:00\n23\n24\n25\ngood memory and that at the age of 77, occasionally\nmy memory slips. I particularly have difficult time\nnow remembering names of people I've just met, but I\n19\nEFTA00601172\n", "char_count": 1094}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "20\n20\n1\n2\nremember events very well. And when I argue cases\nin front of courts, I generally don't need to have\n3\nnotes in front of me because I remember the cases\n4\nvery well.\n5\n6\nAnd I remember the transcript very well,\nand so I have always relied on my good memory in my\nprofessional life.\n7\nQ. So, on January 5, when you were\n09:48:29\n8\ninterviewed on CNN Live, your memory at that time\n9\nwas superb but in the ensuing ten months, it has\n10\nbecome less than superb?\n11\nA.\nNo\n09:48:41\n12\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form.\n09:48:41\n13\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:48:42\n14\nQ.\nIs that correct?\n09:48:42\n15\nA.\nNo, that's not correct.\n09:48:42\n16\n17\nMR. SCOTT: Let me\nconclusion, not what he said.\nobjection, form,\n09:48:44\n18\nA.\nMemory is a matter of degree and memories\n09:48:48\n19\ndon't\n--\nunless there's an illness or trauma,\n20\ndon't\n--\ndon't suddenly change. I've had no\n21\nnothing in my life to dramatically change. But as I\n22\nsaid, as a 77-year-old, my memory is not what it was\n23\nwhen I was a 25-year-old.\n24\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:49:11\n25\nQ.\nAre you under the influence today of any\n09:49:11\nEFTA00601173\n", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "1\ndrugs or alcohol that might have an affect on your\n2\nmemory?\n09:49:18\n3\nA.\nNo.\n41\nQ. Are you having any physical problems that\n09:49:19\n5 might make it difficult for you to understand or\n6\nproperly respond to my questions?\n7\nA.\nNo.\n09:49:24\n8\nQ.\nDid you get a good night's sleep last\n09:49:25\n9\nnight?\n10\nA.\nYes.\n09:49:28\n11\nQ.\nWhat is the general condition of your\n09:49:28\n12\nhealth?\n13\nA. As a result of some of the tensions caused\n09:49:31\n14\nby these false accusations, I've had a recurrence of\n15\n16\nmy atrial fibrillation and a recurrence of some\nexperiences of high blood pressure. But beyond\n17\nthat, my general health is satisfactory.\n18\n19\n20\nQ. Has any healthcare provider attributed the\nrecurrence of your atrial fibrillation to\ninvolvement in the circumstances that gave rise to\n09:49:58\n21\nthis litigation?\n22\n23\n25\natrial fibrillation.\nA. My cardiologist asked me whether or not\nthere were any tense or tension-causing episodes\n24 recently that might explain my recurrence of the\nAnd in response I did describe\n09:50:15\n21\nEFTA00601174\n", "char_count": 1054}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "1\nthe current false accusations against me in an\n2 attempt to destroy my reputation by false and\n3 malicious charges, yes.\n22\n22\n41\nQ. What is the name of your cardiologist?\n09:50:39\n5\nA.\nJeremy Ruskin, R-U-S-K-I-N. He's the\n09:50:41\n6\nchief of electro cardio physiology at Massachusetts\n7\nGeneral Hospital.\n8\nQ.\nHas any healthcare provider attributed\n09:50:53\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\nyour high blood pressure to events that are the\nsubject of this litigation?\nA. Again, when I complained about high blood\npressure, one of the first questions that I'm asked\nis whether or not there's any tension or any tense\nexperiences occurring in my life and the doctor\nwho's treated me for high blood pressure is\nDr. Harold Solomon, S-0--0-M-0-N, in Brookline,\nMassachusetts.\n09:51:01\n15\n16\n17\n18\nQ. Has Dr. Solomon\n09:51:24\n19\nA.\nRight.\n09:51:27\n20\nQ.\nattributed your high blood pressure to\n09:51:27\n21\nevents related to this litigation?\n22\nA. I think all of my doctors have\n09:51:34\n23\nconcluded\nyou'll have to ask them\nthat this\n24\nlawsuit has been a contributing factor to some of\n25\nthe health issues\n--\nlet me withdraw that. That the\nEFTA00601175\n", "char_count": 1134}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "223\n1 false accusations against me from your client have\n2\n3\n41\ncontributed to some of my health problems, yes.\nQ.\nWhen did your atrial fibrillation recur?\n09:52:00\nA. About a month ago. About a month ago.\nI -- I could get you the exact date because I keep a\n09:52:07\n5\n6\nrecord with a small cardiogram of my afib pretty\n7\nmuch every day.\n8\nQ.\nWhen did your blood pressure increase as a\n09:52:23\n9\nresult of events related to this litigation?\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\nA. Well, it's been up and down. I've had\nrecurring episodes of high blood pressure. And I\nthink particularly since the beginning of the false\ncharges, not the litigation, but it's the false\ncharges, the outrageous allegations, baseless\noutrageous allegations against me have certainly\n16 contributed in my view to my variation in blood\n09:52:31\n17\npressure, yes.\n18\nQ. When were you initially diagnosed with\n09:53:07\n19\natrial fibrillation?\n20\nA. About two and a half years ago I had\n09:53:17\n21\nlet's see, December\ntwo and a half years ago\n22\nDecember I was admitted to Mount Sinai Hospital with\n23\nan episode. It then basically went away. And then\n24\nit returned as atrial flutter.\n25\nAnd then I had an ablation, which cured or\n09:53:48\nEFTA00601176\n", "char_count": 1213}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "24\n1\nrelieved any symptoms of atrial fibrillation or\n2\natrial flutter, until they recurred\n--\nuntil it\n3 recurred about a month or maybe it's a month and a\n41\nhalf now. I can give you the exact dates.\non my machine.\nBecause,\n5\nas I say, I have it on my\n--\n6\nQ.\nWhen did the atrial flutter occur?\n09:54:16\n7\nA.\nI told you that I don't have the exact\n09:54:20\n8\ndate, but it occurred about a month, month and a\n9\nhalf ago, I think sometime in August of this year.\n10\nBut I can give you the exact date. As I said, I\n11\nhave it on my machine.\n12\n13\nQ. So, what you have described as a\nrecurrence of atrial fibrillation you are now\n09:54:33\n14\ndescribing as an atrial flutter?\n15\nA. You're confused, sir. Please listen to my 09:54:42\n16\nanswers. What I've said was that I had atrial\n17\nflutter. Atrial flutter occurred after my initial\n18\natrial fib. I then had an ablation. The flutter\n19\n20\nand the fib both disappeared after the ablation.\nAnd my atrial fib has returned.\n21\nQ. Given your superb memory, would you please\n09:55:13\n22\nname for us each of the lawyers who has represented\n23\nyou in this case?\n24\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form.\n09:55:22\n25\nArgumentative.\nEFTA00601177\n", "char_count": 1174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "1\n2\nIf you need a document or anything to\nrefresh your memory, please let us know.\n09:55:29\n25\n25\n3\n41\nA. Well, I'll start with the names of my\nlawyers. I've been represented by Judge Scott and\n09:55:34\n5\nhis law firm, including several associates and\n6\nparalegals.\nI don't know their status, whether\n7\nthey're partners, associates or paralegals, but I've\n8\nhad contact with them.\n9\n10\n11\n12\nI have been represented by Mr. Simpson's\nlaw firm, including several partners, associates,\nand paralegals. I've been represented by Kenneth\nSweder and presumably some of his partners and\n09:55:54\n13\n14\nassociates.\nI've been represented by Kendall Coffey\n09:56:15\n15\n16\nand several of his associates and partners. I would\nsay those are my main lawyers. But I've also had\n17\nothers.\n18\n19\n20\nI have sought the legal advice of Mark\nFabiani, who was my former research assistant at\nHarvard.\n09:56:34\nI've sought the advice of Mitchell Webber,\n21\nwho was my former research assistant at Harvard.\n22\nI was offered legal advice by Carlos\n09:56:52\n23\nSires, who was\nwho is a partner in the Boise firm\n24\nwho\n--\n25\nwho volunteered to represent me along with\none of his partners, but then withdraw from the\nEFTA00601178\n", "char_count": 1202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "1\nrepresentation when he discovered that I had a\n2\nconflict of interest.\n3\nI've had consultations with a variety of\n09:57:18\n41\nother lawyers over particular issues in the case,\n5 Floyd Abrams, who is probably the leading lawyer in\n6\nthe world on First Amendment, has advised me on my\n7 First Amendment rights to have said what I said\n8\ntruthfully and expressed my opinion about your\n9\nclients.\n10\n11\n12\n13\nI mean, that's the very beginning. But\nwhen the events first occurred, I got calls from\ndozens of lawyers outraged by the unethical conduct\nof your clients and offering to represent me\n09:57:51\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\npro bono, offering to do anything they could to see\nthat these lawyers were appropriately punished and\ndisciplined.\nDavid Markus, for example, of the Miami\nBar called and keeps calling asking if there's\nanything he can do to help me.\n09:58:17\n20\nThere's a lawyer in Broward named Diner,\n09:58:28\n21\n22\n24\nwho has offered to represent me. It goes on and on\nand on. The offers are still coming in. People are\n23 just absolutely outraged by the unprofessional and\nunethical conduct of your clients and are offering\n25\nto help me right a wrong and undo an injustice.\n26\nEFTA00601179\n", "char_count": 1198}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "27\n09:59:00\n1\nMR. SCOTT: Just hold it.\nSomebody's\n2\nmaking noise on the phone and it's causing a\n3\n3\n4\nlittle disruption here. So, you know, I'm not\nsure who it is, one of you-all on the phone.\n5\nThanks.\n6\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n09:59:16\n7\nQ.\nMr. Scott is obviously still representing\n09:59:21\n8\nyou now; is that correct?\n9\nA.\nThat's correct.\n09:59:24\n10\nQ.\nRichard Simpson is still representing you\n09:59:25\n11\nnow; is that correct?\n12\nA.\nThat's correct.\n09:59:27\n13\nQ. Ken Sweder is representing you now; is\n09:59:28\n14\nthat correct?\n15\nA.\nThat's correct, yes.\n09:59:30\n16\nQ.\nIs Kendall Coffey representing you now?\n09:59:30\n17\nA.\nYes.\n09:59:33\n18\nQ.\nIs Mark Fabiani representing you now?\n09:59:35\n19\nA.\nYes.\n09:59:37\n20\nQ. And when I ask \"are they representing you\n09:59:38\n21\nnow,\" they're representing you now in this\n22\nlitigation%;B is that correct?\n22\n23\nMR. SCOTT: I don't think that\n09:59:45\n24\n25\nobjection, form. I don't think that was\nspecified.\nEFTA00601180\n", "char_count": 965}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "1\n2\nMR. SCOTT: As opposed to general advice.\nMR. SCAROLA: Well, that's why I'm asking.\n09:59:48\n09:59:50\n3\nA.\nYes. Yes.\n09:59:52\n41\nBY MR.\nSCAROLA:\n09:59:53\n5\nQ.\nAnd Mark Fabiani is representing you with\n09:59:53\n6\nregard to this litigation; is that correct?\n7\n8\nA.\nYes, yes.\n09:59:57\nQ.\nFloyd Abrams is representing you now with\n09:59:58\n9\nregard to this litigation; is that correct?\n10\n11\nA.\nYes.\n10:00:01\nQ.\nMitch Webber is representing you now with\n10:00:02\n12\nregard to this litigation%;B is that correct?\n13\nA.\nThat's correct, yes.\n10:00:06\n14\nQ.\nIs Steven Safra representing you with\n10:00:11\n15\nregard to this litigation?\n16\nA.\nYes.\n10:00:15\n17\nQ. Is Mary Borja representing you now with\n10:00:15\n18\nregard to this litigation?\n19\nA.\nYes.\n10:00:19\n20\nQ. Is Ashley Eiler representing you now with\n10:00:20\n21\nregard to this litigation?\n22\n23\nA. That's not a name that immediately comes\nto my head, but I believe it's an associate in one\n10:00:24\n24\nof the law firms. I don't know the names of all the\n25 lawyers who are doing the background work on the\n28\nEFTA00601181\n", "char_count": 1075}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "1\ncase for the law firms.\n2\nQ.\nIs Nicole Richardson representing you now\n10:00:37\n3\nwith regard to this litigation?\n4\nA. Again, yes, yes.\n10:00:41\n5\nQ. Is Gabe Groisman representing you now with\n10:00:46\n6\nregard to this litigation?\n7\nA.\nYes.\n10:00:49\n8\nQ.\nIs Ben Brodsky representing you now with\n10:00:51\n9\nregard to this litigation?\n10\nA.\nBen Brodsky? I would have to check on\n10:00:59\n11\nthat.\n12\nQ.\nIs\n13\nNeely representing you now with\nregard to this litigation?\n10:01:06\n14\nA.\nNeely has been my assistant and\n10:01:09\n15\nparalegal for the last some years and I have used\n16\n17\nher to perform paralegal work for me in this\nlitigation.\n18\nQ. Is Nicholas Maisel representing you now\n10:01:27\n19\nwith regard to this litigation?\n20\n21\nA. Nicholas Maisel is my research assistant\nand paralegal on this litigation, yes.\n10:01:31\n22\nQ. Is your wife representing you with regard\n10:01:39\n23\nto this litigation?\n24\n25\nA. My wife has been instrumental in helping\nme gather all the records and information. She\n10:01:42\n29\nEFTA00601182\n", "char_count": 1031}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "1\nknows more about records and where my records are\n2\nkept and I've asked her to perform paralegal service\n3 in addition to her loving service as my wife.\n4\nQ. Is Harvey Silverglate representing you now\n10:02:04\n5\nwith regard to this litigation?\n6\nA.\nYes.\n10:02:08\n7\nQ.\nIs Mark Fabiani representing you now with\n10:02:09\n8\nregard to this litigation?\n9\nA.\nYou've asked me that question and the\n10:02:12\n10\nanswer is\n11\n12\nQ. No, I asked you, sir, if he was your\nlawyer; but I haven't asked you whether he's\n10:02:14\n13\nrepresenting you now with regard to this litigation.\n14\nA. The answer is yes.\n10:02:20\n15\nQ. Is Floyd Abrams representing you now with\n10:02:22\n16\nregard to this litigation?\n17\nA.\nYes.\n10:02:25\n18\nQ.\nIs Jamin Dershowitz representing you now\n10:02:26\n19\nwith regard to this litigation?\n20\nA.\nYes.\n10:02:30\n21\nQ. Is Nancy Gertner representing you now with\n10:02:32\n22\nregard to this litigation?\n23\nA. That requires a lengthier answer, if you\n10:02:36\n24\nwill permit me.\n25\nQ. I haven't stopped you yet.\n10:02:41\nEFTA00601183\n30\n30\n", "char_count": 1047}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "1\nA.\nYou've tried.\n10:02:43\n2\nQ.\nMuch as I may have liked to.\n10:02:44\n3\n3\nA.\nYou've tried.\n10:02:45\n4\nMR. SCOTT: Mr. Scarola, that's probably\n10:02:47\n5\none of the few times you and I agree on\n69\nsomething.\nMR. SCAROLA: No, we've agreed on a lot,\n10:02:52\n8\n00\nTom.\n9\nMR. SCOTT:\nYeah, we\n--\nI'm kidding you.\n10:02:55\n10\nI'm kidding you.\n11\nMR. SCAROLA: I know you are.\n10:02:57\n12\nA.\nNancy Gertner is one of the attorneys who\n10:02:58\n13\ncalled me immediately and expressed outrage at what\n14\nwas happening to me and offered to help me.\n15\nInitially she wanted to help me by calling your\n16\n17\n18\n19\nclient, Professor Cassell, and explaining to him\nthat what I've been accused of could not possibly\nhave happened and there must have been a mistake or\nsomething. And clearly she had confused me with\n20\nsomeone else.\n21\nAnd as I understand it, Nancy Gertner made\n10:03:29\n22\nthat phone call to your client, Professor Cassell,\n23\nand Professor Cassell reiterated his false\n24\naccusation against me.\n25\nThereafter, Nancy Gertner volunteered to\n10:03:42\n31\nEFTA00601184\n", "char_count": 1067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "1\nbecome part of my legal team and to examine some of\n2\nthe witnesses in this case.\n3\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:03:55\n41\nQ. Did you ever accept that offer from Nancy\n10:03:56\n5\nGertner\n6\nA.\nYes.\n10:03:59\n7\nQ.\nso as to establish an attorney-client\n10:03:59\n8\n00\nrelationship with\n9\nA.\nYes.\n10:04:04\n10\nQ.\nSo she is one of your lawyers\n10:04:04\n11\nA.\nShe is currently\nI regard her currently\n10:04:05\n12\nas\none of my lawyers, yes.\n13\nQ. And is Mitch Webber one of your lawyers in\n10:04:08\n14\nthis case?\n15\nA.\nYes.\n10:04:11\n16\n17\nQ. But if I just give you a name without\nrepeating the second part, \"is that one of the\n10:04:12\n18\nlawyers in your case,\" will you understand\n19\nA.\nI understand.\n10:04:21\n20\nQ.\nthat I'm asking you with regard to\n10:04:22\n21\nthese\neach of these individuals whether they are\n22\na lawyer representing you in this case?\n223\n23\nA.\nYes.\n10:04:30\n24\nQ.\nOkay. Anthony Julius?\n10:04:30\n25\nA. Anthony Julius is a British barrister and\n10:04:35\nEFTA00601185\n33\n32\n", "char_count": 973}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "1\nsolicitor who I conferred with regarding the\n2\npossibility of filing lawsuits against your clients\n3\nin Great Britain. I continue to confer with him on\n4\nmatters relating to defamation.\n5\nQ.\nSo you consider him to be one of your\n10:04:54\n6\nlawyers representing you with regard to matters\n7\nrelating to this lawsuit?\n8\nA. I'll stand by\n10:05:00\n6\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form.\n10:05:01\n10\nA.\nmy answer. I'll stand by my answer.\n10:05:02\n11\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:05:04\n12\nQ.\nCharles Ogletree?\n10:05:05\n13\nA.\nCharles Ogletree is a close personal\n10:05:06\n14\nfriend and colleague at the Harvard Law School with\n15\nwhom I have conferred about this case. I always\n16\nhave regarded him as a personal attorney and\n17\ncontinue to confer with him about this case and the\n18\ngeneral picture. So, I do regard him as one of my\n19\n20\nlawyers in this litigation, yes. I certainly regard\nhim as having been given privileged information as\n21\npart of a lawyer-client privilege, yes.\n22\nQ. There\n--\n23\nthere may be a time when I need\nmore than just an answer to the question that I'm\n10:05:47\n24\nasking as to whether these individuals are or are\n25\nnot your lawyers in this case. That's not now.\n33\nEFTA00601186\n", "char_count": 1191}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "1\n2\nSo if you would, please, I would\nappreciate it if you would tell me only whether\n3 these individuals are or are not your lawyers in\n34\n10:06:01\n4\nthis case.\n5\nA. I'm sorry, but I cannot comply with that.\n10:06:09\n6\nI'm\n7\nQ.\nWell, you can but you refuse to.\n10:06:12\n8\n00\nMR. SCOTT: Let's not interrupt him.\n10:06:14\n9\nA.\nLet me complete my answer, please.\n10:06:16\nMR. SCOTT: It doesn't help the court\n10:06:17\nreporter or the record.\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\nA. I've been teaching legal ethics for close\nto 40 years. I understand the complexity of the\nlawyer-client relationship.\nAnd it's impossible as\nto some of the names you've mentioned to simply give\n15\n16\n17\na yes or no answer to whether they are representing\nme in this case.\n18\nWhat I can do is give you the facts and\n19\nthen you and others can draw legal conclusions from\n20\nthose facts.\nBut I\n--\nI cannot, under my oath to\n21\ntell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the\n22\ntruth, respond to questions with yes or no answers\n23\nwhen those questions do not call for simplistic yes\n24\nor no answers.\n25\n10:06:19\n10:06:39\nEFTA00601187\n", "char_count": 1095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "1\n2\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nQ. Is Philip Heymann a lawyer representing\n3 you in this case?\n41\nA. I have conferred with Philip Heymann on\n5 several occasions about several aspects of this case\n35\n10:07:01\n10:07:01\n10:07:04\n6\nand I regard him, for purposes of lawyer-client\n7\nprivilege, as one of my lawyers on this case.\n8\nQ.\nDavid Oscar Markus, same question?\n10:07:18\n9\nMR. SCOTT: We covered him, didn't we?\n10:07:22\n10\nA.\nDavid Oscar Markus is a former student and\n10:07:23\n11\nresearch assistant of mine. Lives in Miami and\n12\n13\npractices law. And he has repeatedly called and\noffered me legal representation. Has offered to\n14\n15\nhelp me in the legal context of this case. And I've\nconferred with him on lawyer-client confidential\n16\nbasis about this case on several occasion.\n17\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:07:49\n18\nQ.\nThomas Wiegand?\n10:07:49\n19\nA.\nThomas Wiegand is a litigator in Chicago\n10:07:51\n20\nwith whom I worked along with Carlos Sires and\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nSigrid McCawley on the Guma Aguiar case in Florida.\nAnd as soon as this case occurred, Thomas Wiegand\nwas one of those lawyers who called and offered to\nrepresent me and do whatever he could to help undo\nthe injustice that had been perpetrated on me by\nEFTA00601188\n", "char_count": 1219}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "1 your clients' false and mendacious allegations\nregarding me and\n2\n3\nQ.\nJeanne Baker?\n41\nA. Jeanne Baker is a long-term associate,\n5\nlegal associate and friend who also called and\n6 offered me legal help, legal representation, and I\n10:08:30\n10:08:32\n7\ncontinue to confer with her on a privileged basis.\n8\nQ.\nRick Pildes?\n10:08:51\n9\nA. Rick Pildes is a professor at New York\n10:08:53\n10\nUniversity law school and I sought his legal advice\n11\non a particular issue in this case. And continue to\n12\nseek his legal advice.\n13\nQ.\nSusan Rosen?\n10:09:03\n14\nA. Susan Rosen is a prominent lawyer in\n10:09:04\n15\nCharleston, South Carolina and a cousin of my\n16\nwife's. And she has offered me legal advice about\n17\nthis case as recently as two days ago.\n18\nQ.\nAlex MacDonald?\n10:09:24\n19\nA.\nAlex MacDonald is my personal lawyer in\n10:09:25\n20\nseveral instances in Massachusetts and he has\n21\noffered me advice and consultation on this case,\n22\nagain volunteering in an effort to undo the horrible\ninjustice that was done to me by your clients'\n23\n24 mendacious willful and unprofessional conduct and\n25\nleveling of false charges, sexual misconduct against\n36\nEFTA00601189\n", "char_count": 1163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "1\nme at a time when they knew it wasn't true and\n2\nseeking to repeat that charge after they knew that\n3\nit was impossible that I could have engaged in any\n4\nof the conduct that they have accused me of.\n5\nQ.\nBarbara Gillers?\n10:10:05\n6\nA.\nBarbara Gillers is at professor at NYU law\n10:10:06\n7\nschool and also the wife of Steven Gillers and she,\n8\n9\nalong with Steven Gillers, have advised me and\nconferred with me about the legal ethics aspects of\n10\nthis case.\n11\nQ. So you consider her to be one of your\n10:10:19\n12\nlawyers in this case, is that\n13\nA.\nI can\n10:10:22\n14\nMR. SCOTT: Object to the form. Go ahead.\n10:10:23\n15\n16\nLet me make an objection. I know you're just\ntrying to answer, but go ahead, you can answer,\n17\nsir.\n18\n19\nA. Sorry. I regard my conversations with her\nas having come within the lawyer-client privilege.\n10:10:29\n20\nWe've conferred on a number of occasions about the\n21 ethical misconduct of your clients.\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n23\nQ. Rana Dershowitz?\n24\nA.\nRana Dershowitz is my niece and Harvard\n25\nlaw school graduate, former chief counsel for the\n10:10:43\n10:10:43\n10:10:45\nEFTA00601190\n33\n37\n", "char_count": 1119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "1\nU.S. Olympic Committee and a prominent lawyer in\n2\nColorado.\nAnd I've conferred with her on numerous\n3\noccasions about litigation and strategy and aspects\n4\nof this case.\n5\nQ.\nElla Dershowitz?\n10:11:05\n6\nA.\nElla Dershowitz is my daughter and she has\n10:11:06\n7\nserved as a paralegal helping me gather material. I\n8\n--\ndon't think I regard her I certainly don't regard\n9\n10\nher as a lawyer in the case. But I regard her as\nsomebody who has been a part of our kind of legal\n11\nteam.\n12\nQ.\nEllen Dershowitz?\n10:11:29\n13\nA.\nEllen\n10:11:32\n14\nQ.\nElon?\n10:11:33\n15\nA.\nElon Dershowitz is my oldest son, child,\n10:11:34\n16\nand he has served repeatedly in a paralegal capacity\n17\n18\nin this case helping me to gather information and\nevidence and doing some investigative work for me.\n19\nQ. Nathan Dershowitz?\n10:11:52\n20\n21\nA. Nathan Dershowitz is my brother.\ndistinguished attorney in New York, had his own law\nHe's a\n10:11:52\n22\nfirm. And he and I did a lot of our legal cases\n23\ntogether and as soon as this case emerged, I\n24\nconferred with him and have conferred with him on\n25\nnumerous occasions about this case.\n38\nEFTA00601191\n", "char_count": 1128}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "☐ 1 Q.\nYou consider him to be one of your lawyers\n10:12:14\n21\nin this case?\n3\nA.\nYes.\n10:12:16\n4\nQ.\nBen Brafman?\n10:12:17\n5\nA.\nBen Brafman is one of the leading criminal\n10:12:19\n6\nlawyers and general lawyers in the City of New York?\n7\nHe has volunteered to help me in any way he could in\n8\nthis case and we have conferred and I have sought\n9\nlegal advice from him in this\n--\nin this matter.\n10\nQ. Arthur Aidala?\n10:12:36\n11\nA.\nArthur Aidala is a distinguished member of\n10:12:38\n12\nthe who's president of the Brooklyn Bar Association\n13\n14\nand a former district attorney in Brooklyn.\nvolunteered to help me. He was outraged at the\nHe has\n15\n16\nunethical behavior of your clients and has sought\nthe opportunity to do everything in his power to try\n17\n18\n19\nto undo the injustice perpetrated on me by your\nclients' mendacious and false and unethical\nallegations against me, and I continue to confer\n20\nwith him.\n21\nQ. David Zornow?\n10:13:15\n22\n23\nA. David Zornow is the senior litigating\npartner at Skadden Arps in New York. He has offered\n10:13:17\n24\nto assist me in this matter and I've conferred with\n25\nhim and sought his legal advice.\n39\nEFTA00601192\n", "char_count": 1155}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "1\nQ.\nCharles Johnson?\n10:13:31\n2\nA.\nCharles Johnson is my former research\n10:13:32\n3\nassistant and paralegal.\nI think we've taken his\n4\n5\nname off the list of lawyers because he now, I\nthink, performs more of a journalistic job than a\n6 legal one, though he has offered to help me gather\n7\ninformation on your clients.\n8\nQ.\nWhen did you cease considering Charles\n10:14:02\n9\n10\n11\n12\nJohnson to be your lawyer with regard to matters\nrelating to this case?\nA.\nAfter a conference with my attorneys in\nWashington, D.C. about ten days ago or so. We went\n10:14:10\n13\nthrough the list and that was one that I said was\n14\ntoo close a question and I would regard him more as\n15\n16\na blogger and a journalist than as a lawyer. But\nit's a close question.\n17\nQ.\nDavid Efron?\n10:14:32\n18\nA. David Efron is a prominent lawyer in\n10:14:33\n19\nMiami, Florida and Puerto Rico. He was one who\n20\ncalled me immediately and offered his assistance,\n21\nthe assistance of his law firm. I've conferred with\n22\nhim repeatedly about this case.\n23\nQ. In an attorney-client capacity; is that\n10:14:54\n24\ncorrect?\n25\nA.\nYes.\n10:14:57\n40\nEFTA00601193\n", "char_count": 1120}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "41\n1\nQ.\nAshe?\n10:14:57\n2\nA. Thomas Ashe is not a lawyer. He was\none\n10:14:58\n3 of the first people I called on the day I was\n4\ninformed of the lies being spread by your clients.\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n5\n6\nBecause he could help me gather all the information\nnecessary to prove that the only time I was ever in\nNew Mexico was visiting him and his wife, who is a\nprominent film person, and his daughter, who is a\nsex offender prosecutor in the Brooklyn District\nAttorney's Office who specializes in sex\ntrafficking.\nI needed to call them to prove what I knew\nimmediately, that the only time I was ever at\nJeffrey Epstein's ranch was when I went to visit the\nAshes in New Mexico. I spoke to their daughter, the\nprosecutor's, class. She was then in high school,\nand took a day trip to Santa Fe.\n10:15:49\n18\nAshe had known\n--\nhad heard that Jeffrey\n10:16:15\n19\n20\n21\n22\nEpstein had bought a ranch, a very large ranch in\nNew Mexico and Ashe was very interested in the\noutdoors and asked me if I would do him a favor and\ncall to see if we could just take a look at what the\n23\nranch looked like. And I did that.\n24\nAnd we spent about an hour looking around\n10:16:35\n25\nthe house that was under construction.\nAnd I needed\nEFTA00601194\n", "char_count": 1233}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "42\n42\n1\nAshe to gather all the evidence for me, including\n2\njournal entries in his daughter's journal,\n3\n41\n5\n6\n7\nphotographs, other evidence and proof of our visit\nto the ranch, which your client encouraged\nto include in an affidavit -- perjurious\naffidavit, that she submitted with details, false\nand mendacious details that could not have occurred\n8\nabout an alleged sexual encounter between her and me\n9\nat the ranch in New Mexico.\n10\nQ. Which of my clients are you swearing under\n10:17:30\n11\noath encouraged\nto include\n12\nallegations of an encounter with you at the\n13\nNew Mexico ranch?\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\nA. Both of them, both of your clients, both\nJudge Cassell and Mr. Edwards were both involved in\nencouraging your client to file a perjurious\naffidavit that they knew or should have known was\nperjurious and did know was perjurious recently when\nthey sought to file another defamatory allegation in\nthe federal proceeding.\n10:17:49\n21\n22\nQ. Was the encouragement such that what you\nare charging Bradley Edwards and Professor Paul\n10:18:21\n23\nCassell with doing was suborning perjury?\n24\nA.\nAbsolutely.\n25\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form.\n10:18:34\n10:18:35\nEFTA00601195\n", "char_count": 1175}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "43\n10:18:36\n1\nGo ahead.\nA. Absolutely. If you ask me the question, I 10:18:37\n2\n3\nam directly charging Judge Cassell and Bradley\n4 Edwards with suborning perjury. I have been advised\ndid not want to mention me,\ntold her friends that she did not want to mention\n5\nthat\n6\n7\n8\n9\nme.\nAnd was, quote, pressured by her lawyers into\nincluding me and including these totally false\nallegations against me. Yes, your clients are\nguilty of suborning perjury.\n10\n11\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:19:06\n12\nQ. Who told you that Bradley Edwards\n10:19:06\n13\npressured\ninto falsely identifying\n14\nyou?\n15\nA.\nA friend of\nwho called\n10:19:17\n16\n17\nme out of the blue, and told me that she was\nhorrified by what was happening to me, and that she\n18\nrecently had meetings with\nand\n19\nhad told her that she never\n20\nmentioned me previously.\nThat the lawyers pressured\n21\nher into mentioning me. And mentioning me over her\n22\ndesire not to mention me, yes.\n23\nQ. Do you remember what the question is?\n10:19:55\n24\nA.\nYes, and I answered it.\n10:19:57\n25\nQ.\nWhat do you understand the question to be\n10:19:59\nEFTA00601196\n", "char_count": 1085}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Object to form.\n1\nthat you were answering?\n2\nMR. SCOTT:\n3\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n41\nQ. Based upon your superb memory, what is it\n5 that I asked you?\n10:20:01\n10:20:01\n10:20:02\n6\nA. I think you asked me to tell me how I\n10:20:07\n7\nfound out who told me that your clients had suborned\n8\nperjury.\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:20:14\n10\nQ. No, sir. What I asked you was to give me\n10:20:14\n11\na name.\nWho?\n12\nMR. SCOTT: Objection.\n10:20:17\n13\nBY MR.\nSCAROLA:\n10:20:18\n14\nQ.\nWho? What's the name of the person?\n10:20:18\n15\nA.\nHer name is\n--\nher first name is Rebecca.\n10:20:20\n16\nQ.\nYes.\n10:20:25\n17\nA.\nI don't know her last name.\n10:20:26\n18\nQ.\nDid you attempt to find out her last name?\n10:20:28\n19\nA.\nI have her last name written down but\n--\n10:20:30\n20\nQ.\nWhere?\n10:20:32\n21\nA.\nIt's in my\nin my notes. And I could\n10:20:34\n22\nget it for you.\n23\nQ. When did you\n--\n10:20:40\n24\n24\nA.\nI have told\n--\n10:20:41\n25\nQ.\nWhen did you write Rebecca's name down?\n10:20:43\n44\nEFTA00601197\n", "char_count": 960}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "45\nA.\nWhen she\nwhen she first called me\n10:20:45\n1\n2\n3\nlet me be very clear since you've asked me the\nquestion.\n4\nAt first her husband and she called me on\n10:20:50\n5\nthe phone. They would not give me their names.\nThey did not want to disclose their names. But they\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\nher.\n6\n7\n8\ntold me the story. We had a series of phone\nconversations in which I asked them, please, to tell\nme their names. And after a period of time, after\nshe told me the story in great detail, she was\nwilling to give me her name. She asked me to\npromise that I would not disclose her identity\nwithout her permission.\nI have been trying to call\nCalled her as recently as this morning and\n15\nlast night.\n16\nI want to recall\n--\nI don't think I called\n10:21:35\n17\nher this morning. I called her twice last night to\n18\n19\ntry to get her permission to reveal her complete\nname and identity. But I have the name and I will\n20\nbe happy to give it to you. I just don't have it on\n21\noff the top of my head.\n22\nQ.\nYou obviously had her telephone number\n10:21:52\n23\nalso?\n24\nA.\nNo. She called me and she wouldn't give\n10:21:54\n25\nme a phone number, initially. And she said and her\nEFTA00601198\n", "char_count": 1170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Q.\n1\nhusband said she would call me back.\nThey were\n2\n3\n4\nbeing quite circumspect about this. Ultimately I\ngot her phone number. Yes, I have her phone number.\nQ. I'm a little bit confused.\n5\nA.\nThere's no reason\n6\nQ.\nIs the answer\n7\nA.\n8\n00\n10:22:10\n10:22:12\n10:22:12\nThere's no reason for you to be confused.\n10:22:12\nWell, I am. Is the answer to the question\n10:22:14\n9\nyou do have her phone number or\n10\nMR. SCOTT: Counsel, you're arguing with\n10:22:19\n11\nthe witness.\n12\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:22:19\n13\nQ.\nyou do have her phone number or you\n10:22:19\n14\ndon't have her phone number?\n15\nA. I don't have the phone number in my head.\n10:22:21\n16\nI have the phone number written down, yes.\n17\nQ. And the last time you called her was\n10:22:27\n18\nA.\nLast night.\n10:22:29\n19\nQ.\n--\nlast night?\n10:22:29\n20\nA.\nThat's right. Left a message.\n10:22:30\n21\nQ.\nFrom where?\n10:22:32\n22\nA.\nFrom my apartment in Miami Beach.\n10:22:33\n23\nQ.\nDid you call her from a cell phone or a\n10:22:41\n24\nlandline?\n25\nA.\nCell phone.\n10:22:44\n46\nEFTA00601199\n", "char_count": 1027}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "1\nQ.\nIs it the cell phone that you have with\n10:22:49\n2\nyou right now?\n3\nA.\nIt is a cell phone that I have with me\n10:22:54\n4\nright now.\n5\nQ.\nWould you take out your cell phone and\n10:22:56\n6\ntell us what that number is, please.\n7\nMR. SCOTT: We'll do\n--\nI'm not going to\n10:23:00\n8\nhave him do that. At a break I'll speak to him\n9\nand we'll provide you the number, as he's\n10\nindicated.\n11\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:23:07\n12\nQ. How many phone conversations did you have\n10:23:12\n13\nwith this person Rebecca?\n14\nA. More than six.\nProbably between six and\n10:23:21\n15\nten, maybe closer to ten.\nThe first few she called\n16\nme and after I got their number I called her a\n17\nnumber of times.\n18\nQ. What is her husband's name?\n10:23:43\n19\nA.\nMichael.\nDifferent last name from hers,\n10:23:44\n20\nbut again. .\n21\nQ.\nWhere do they live?\n10:23:50\n22\nA.\nPalm Beach. Or West Palm Beach, in the\n10:23:51\n23\nPalm Beach area. They have been friends of\n24\nsince she was a young child.\n25\nQ.\nWere there any witnesses to any of these\n10:24:03\n47\nEFTA00601200\n", "char_count": 1033}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "1\nphone conversations other than Rebecca, Michael and\n2\nyou?\n3\nA.\nYes.\n10:24:10\n4\nQ.\nWho?\n10:24:11\n5\nA.\nMy wife.\n10:24:11\n6\nQ.\nWhen did the first conversation occur?\n10:24:14\n7\nA.\nI can probably get you specific\n10:24:17\n8\n00\ninformation about that. But it was months ago.\n9 When the story was in the newspapers, she called and\n10 related the entire story to me and related to me\n11\nthat this was part of a massive extortion plot.\n12\n13\nMR. SCOTT: When you're ready to take a\nbreak, let's take break. You've been going\n10:24:39\n14\nabout an hour.\n15\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:24:43\n16\nQ. How long after the filing of the Crime\n10:24:44\n17\nAct pleading in which you were\n18\nreferenced did you receive the phone call, the first\n19\nphone call from Rebecca?\n20\n21\nA. I would be speculating, but it would\nprobably be about a month or two after that.\n10:24:58\n22\nMR. SCOTT: Don't speculate, sir.\nIf you\n10:25:03\n23\n24\n25\n2 2 2\nknow the facts.\nA.\nI -- I don't recall.\n10:25:06\n48\nEFTA00601201\n", "char_count": 978}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:25:06\n2\nQ. Your best estimate as you sit here today\n10:25:06\n3\nis?\n41\nA.\nTwo two months, probably. So let's say\n10:25:08\n5\nJanuary, February\n--\nprobably end of February,\n6 beginning of March, but I can get you those specific\n7\ndates.\nThere's no secret about that.\n8\nMR. SCOTT: Want to take a break?\n10:25:22\n9\nMR. SCAROLA: In just a moment.\n10:25:24\n10\nMR. SCOTT:\nCertainly.\n10:25:26\n11\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:25:26\n12\nQ. Did you take contemporaneous notes of\n10:25:30\n13\nthose phone conversations?\n14\nA.\nNo.\n15\nI took notes of names, but not really\nnotes of the substance, no.\n10:25:36\n16\nQ. Have you ever made notes with regard to\n10:25:48\n17\n18\nthe substance of any communication that you\nallegedly had with Rebecca and/or Michael?\n19\nA. I didn't allegedly have these\n20\nconversations.\nI had these conversations.\n10:25:58\nAnd I\n21\n22\ndon't recall taking any notes of these\nconversations.\n22\n23\nMR. SCOTT: Let's take a break.\n10:26:09\n24\nMR. SCAROLA: Yes.\n10:26:10\n25\nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The\n10:26:12\n49\nEFTA00601202\n", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "1\ntime is approximately 10:26 a.m.\n2\n(Recess was held from 10:26 a.m. until 10:44 a.m.)\n10:26:16\n3\nVIDEOGRAPHER:\nGoing back on the record.\n10:44:08\n41\nThe time is approximately 10:44 a.m.\n5\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:44:11\n6\nQ. How many phone calls did you have with\n10:44:13\n7\nthis person Rebecca before she informed you as to\n8\nthe reason why she was calling you?\n9\nA. She informed me the first time.\n10:44:29\n10\nQ.\nThe very first conversation?\n10:44:31\n11\nA.\nYes.\n10:44:32\n12\nQ.\nHow many phone calls was it before she\n10:44:34\n13\nasked you for money?\n14\nA.\nNever asked me for money.\n10:44:38\n15\nQ.\nHow many phone calls was it before her\n10:44:40\n16\nhusband asked you for money?\n17\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form.\n10:44:43\n18\nA. I was never asked for money, ever.\n10:44:43\n19\nBY MR.\nSCAROLA:\n10:44:45\n20\nQ.\nDo you know how it is that these people\n10:44:47\n21\nknew how to contact you?\n22\nA. They told me they went on my website and\n10:44:54\n23\ngot my number and left a message for me to call.\n24 Yeah, that's what happened. Oh, no, they sent me\n25\nthey went on my website and sent me an e-mail and\n50\nEFTA00601203\n", "char_count": 1103}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "51\n1\nasked me\nand the e-mail had a blank name but a\n2\nrecollection.\n3\n4\nway to respond. And so I responded to the e-mail\nwith my phone number and then they called, is my\nThat's my best recollection.\n5\nQ. Is that an e-mail that you produced in\n10:45:26\n6 discovery?\n7\nA.\nI have no idea.\n10:45:28\n8\nMR. SIMPSON:\nThe attorneys have handled\n10:45:30\n9\ndiscovery.\n10\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:45:33\n11\nQ. Have you ever seen that e-mail since it\n10:45:34\n12\nwas received?\n13\nA.\nI have no recollection.\n10:45:39\n14\nQ.\nCertainly you recognized the significance\n10:45:40\n15\nof preserving that e-mail?\n16\nA.\nI'm sure I have it.\n10:45:46\n17\nQ.\nYou sure you have it?\n10:45:47\n18\nA.\nI'm positive, of course.\n10:45:48\n19\nQ.\nSo from the very first conversation that\n10:45:55\n20\n21\n22\nyou had with this person, you had information\nindicating that this person was informing you that\nBradley Edwards had engaged in unethical conduct,\n23\ncorrect?\n24\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, form.\n10:46:19\n25\nA. Let me just be very clear what\n--\nwhat she\n10:46:20\nEFTA00601204\n", "char_count": 1032}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "52\n1\nsaid to me.\nShe said to me that she had been told\n2\ndirectly by her friend,\nwho stayed\n3\nwith her overnight for a period of time, that she\n4\nnever wanted to mention me in any of the pleadings.\n5\nAnd that her two lawyers in the pleadings, or her\n6\nlawyers who filed the pleadings, pressured her in to\n7\nincluding my name and the details.\n8\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:46:52\n9\nQ.\nDid Rebecca ever suggest to you that the\n10:46:53\n10\ndetails sworn to by\nwith regard to\n11\nyou were false?\n12\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, form. Go ahead.\n10:47:08\n13\nA. She certainly suggested that, yes. She\n10:47:09\n14\nmentioned to me that\nhad never,\n15\never mentioned to her me, among any of the people\n16\nthat she had had any contact with until she -- until\n17\nshe was pressured into doing so by her lawyers, yes.\n18\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:47:28\n19\n20\n21\n22\nQ. So, from the very first conversation, the\nimpression you had was that this was a witness who\ncould provide information that Bradley Edwards and\nPaul Cassell had acted unethically and dishonestly,\n10:47:29\n23\ncorrect?\n24\n10:47:48\nA. I wasn't sure she could provide the\n25 information because she was very reluctant to come\nEFTA00601205\n", "char_count": 1163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "1\nforward. She didn't want to be involved.\nShe\n2\ndidn't want her name involved. But I knew she had\n3\nprovided me with information, yes, but I didn't\n4\nknow, and still don't know, whether she is prepared\n5\nto be a witness. I don't know the answer to that\n6\nquestion.\n7\nQ. Well, there is a difference, is there not,\n10:48:09\n8\nsir, between what she could do and what she would\n9\ndo?\n10\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form.\n10:48:16\n11\n12\nA.\n13\nArgumentative.\nI don't understand.\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:48:18\n10:48:18\n14\nQ. You don't understand that?\n10:48:19\n15\nA.\nI don't understand that. She could do or\n10:48:19\n16\nwould do.\n17\nQ. She was telling you that she had the\n10:48:22\n18\nability to impeach\n' assertions\n19\nagainst you?\n20\nMR. SCOTT: Same objection.\n10:48:31\n21\nA.\nWhat she told me was the truth, is that\n10:48:32\nnever wanted to mention me, but\n22\n23 that she was pressured by her lawyer into mentioning\n24\nme. And that was the truth.\n25\n53\nEFTA00601206\n", "char_count": 951}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:48:46\n2\nQ.\nWell, you also have told us that not only\n10:48:47\n3\ndid she suggest to you that\ndidn't\n4\nwant to mention you, but that\nhad\n5\nnot had the sexual encounters with you that she has\n6\nsworn under oath she did have, correct?\n7\nMR. SCOTT: Objection. Go ahead.\n10:49:07\n8\nA. What she told me was that she didn't\n10:49:09\n9\nbelieve\n--\nthat is, this woman didn't believe that\n10\nthere had been any contact between me and\n11\nbecause\nhad never mentioned\n12\n13\ninto\n--\n14\nme previously until her lawyers pressured her\ninto allowing my name to be included in the\npleading, that's what she told me.\n15\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:49:31\n16\nQ. Did you have the impression that there was\n10:49:32\n17\nimproper pressure that had been exerted on\n18\nbased upon what you were being told by this\n19\nwoman?\n20\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, form.\n21\nA.\nAbsolutely. Of course.\n10:49:47\n10:49:48\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n23\nQ. So this was based upon what this woman was\n10:49:50\n24\ntelling you, evidence of unethical, unprofessional\n25 dishonest conduct on the part of Bradley Edwards and\n54\nEFTA00601207\n", "char_count": 1087}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "1\nPaul Cassell, right?\n2\n3\nA. That was certainly the impression I got\nand certainly an impression that confirmed what I\n10:50:04\n4\nalready believed. I mean, I've known from day one\n5\nthat they were engaged in unethical, unprofessional,\n6\n7\n8\nin my view and my opinion, disbarrable conduct.\nThis simply confirmed that.\nQ. Yes, sir. We're going to get to that\nshortly, but I want to stay focused right now on\n10:50:20\n9\n10\nthese communications that you claim to have had\n11\nA.\n12\nQ.\nNot claimed to have had.\nwith Rebecca.\n10:50:28\n10:50:29\n13\nA.\nCommunications that I had. Let's be\n10:50:30\n14\nclear.\nCommunications that I had. No claim. I had\n15\nthem.\n16\nQ. Let's first try, if we could, to pinpoint\n10:50:39\n17\na little better when the first of these\n18\n19\n20\n21\nconversations occurred. Do you recall having been\npropounded interrogatories in this case that asked\nyou to identify all persons with knowledge of any\ncircumstance in which it is alleged that Bradley\n22\nEdwards engaged in unethical conduct, unprofessional\n23\nconduct or dishonest conduct?\n24\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, form.\n10:51:13\n25\nA. I have no recollection as to the sequence\n10:51:14\n55\nEFTA00601208\n", "char_count": 1165}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "1\nor chronology.\n2\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:51:17\n3\nQ.\nWell, let me hand you for purposes of\n10:51:18\n4\n5\nrefreshing your recollection the answers to\ninterrogatories that were filed as of February 23,\n6\n2015.\n7\nA. What was the date again? I missed that.\n10:51:55\n8\nMR. SCOTT: He's going to show you the\n10:51:58\n9\nexhibit.\n10\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:52:00\n11\nQ. The answers to interrogatories bear a\n10:52:01\n12\ncertificate of service dated February 23, 2015 and a\n13 verification\n14\nMR. SCOTT: Are you going to mark that as\n10:52:15\n15\nan exhibit, please?\n16\nMR. SCAROLA: I will in just a moment.\n10:52:17\n17\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:52:18\n18\nQ.\nAnd a verification that appears to be your\n10:52:19\n19\nsignature.\n20\nA.\nIt is.\n10:52:22\n21\nQ.\nIs that, in fact, your signature?\n10:52:23\n22\nA.\nIt is, in fact, my signature.\n10:52:24\n23\nQ.\nWere you verifying those answers intending\n10:52:25\n24\nthem to be your sworn responses to those\n25\ninterrogatories?\n56\nEFTA00601209\n", "char_count": 950}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "1\n57\nA.\nI was verifying my lawyer's responses,\n10:52:30\n2\nyes.\n3\nQ.\nWell, were they your responses or were\n10:52:35\n41\nthey your lawyer's responses?\n5\nA.\nMy lawyers\n10:52:38\n6\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, argumentative.\n10:52:40\n7\nYou can answer it.\n10:52:42\n8\n00\nA.\nMy lawyers drafted the responses. I was\n10:52:42\n9 asked to look over them. I looked over them and I\n10\nsigned, yes.\n11\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:52:47\n12\nQ. You signed them\n10:52:48\n13\nA.\nYes.\n10:52:48\n14\nQ.\nand swore to their truthfulness,\n10:52:49\n15\ncorrect?\n16\nA.\nLet me just read what it says.\n10:52:51\n17\nYes, they were true to the best of my\n10:52:57\n18\nknowledge and belief, yes.\n19\nQ. Since there is no reference in those\n10:53:05\n20\n21\n22\nanswers to interrogatories to Rebecca or Michael,\ncan we assume that the first of your phone calls\nmust have occurred some time after February 23 when\n23\nyou verified the answers to those interrogatories?\n24\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form, asked and\n10:53:26\n25\nanswered.\nEFTA00601210\n", "char_count": 984}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "58\n1 A\nA. I don't have a specific recollection as to\n10:53:28\n2\nthe exact date of when the call came.\n3\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n41\nQ. Well, you certainly would not have sworn\n5\n6\n7\nto the accuracy of those answers which ask you to\nidentify every person with knowledge of any\nunethical, unprofessional, or dishonest conduct on\nthe part of Bradley Edwards, and omitted the name of\n10:53:32\n10:53:32\n8\n9\nRebecca and Michael\n10\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, argumentative.\n11\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12\nQ.\n--\nif they already called you?\n13\n14\nA.\n15\nMR. SCOTT:\nI don't recall when Rebecca and Michael\ncalled me, but I do recall that they made me promise\nArgumentative and compound.\n16\n17\n18\n19\nthat I would not disclose the information that they\nhad revealed until they gave me permission to do so.\nThey also did not give me their names, initially,\nand I only learned both the names over time and the\n20\n21\ninformation.\nThe information came out gradually. But\n22\nthere was a time when I did have the information\n23\n24\nthat the two clients pressured -- that was her word,\ninto naming me,\n\"pressured\"\n25\nright.\n10:53:57\n10:53:58\n10:53:58\n10:54:01\n10:54:03\n10:54:23\nEFTA00601211\n", "char_count": 1147}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "59\n10:54:43\n1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n2\nQ.\nYou certainly considered the communication\n10:54:53\n3\nthat you were having with these individuals to be a\n4\n5 phone call, correct, since it was in the first phone\nmatter of significance from the timing of the first\n6\ncall that they disclosed to you the essence of what\n7\nyou are saying they said?\n8\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, compound.\n10:55:10\n9\nA.\nI wasn't sure whether it would be\n10:55:11\n10\nsignificant or not because I didn't know at the time\n11\nwhether I would be free to reveal it or to use it.\n12\nI'm still\n--\nI just wasn't sure whether I\n10:55:24\n13\nwould be free to reveal it. It would not be\n14\n15\nparticularly significant except to my own\nconfirmation of what I knew to be true; namely, that\n16\nyour clients had engaged in unethical and\n17\nunprofessional conduct. I knew that to be true.\n18\n19\nBut this provided me with some confirmation of that.\nBut I didn't know whether I was going to\n10:55:42\n20\nbe able to use that confirmation because I had made\n21\n22\na promise that was elicited from me by them that I\nwould not disclose this information without their\n23\npermission.\n24\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:55:55\n25\n25\nQ. All right. Permission that you swore to a\n10:55:56\nEFTA00601212\n", "char_count": 1218}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "60\n60\n1\nlittle while ago you still haven't received,\n2\ncorrect?\n3\nA. I have not received the permission to\n10:56:01\n4\nidentify them by name, that's right.\n5\nBy the way, in the recess\noh, no,\n10:56:10\n6 that's enough. Okay.\n7\nQ. What happened in the recess?\n10:56:15\n8\n00\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection\n10:56:17\n9\nA.\nI spoke to my lawyers.\n10:56:18\n10\nMR. SCOTT:\n--\ndon't answer that. It's\n10:56:19\n11\nconversations with counsel.\n12\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:56:20\n13\nQ.\nYou spoke to whom?\n10:56:20\n14\nA.\nI spoke to my lawyers.\n10:56:21\n15\nQ.\nWas your promise to these people that you\n10:56:29\n16\nwouldn't disclose their last name?\n17\nA. My promise to the people was that I would\n10:56:36\n18\nnot identify them so that they would not be hassled\n19\nand harassed and any pressure put on them.\nThat was\n20 their concern, that they didn't want to be receiving\n21\nphone calls and they didn't want to be part of what\n22\nthey regarded as a media circus.\n23\nQ. Well, you know you have broken that\n24\npromise at this point, haven't\n25\nA. No, I haven't\n10:56:57\n10:57:01\nEFTA00601213\n", "char_count": 1055}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "1\n2\nA.\n3\nMR. SCOTT: Objection\nbroken that promise.\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:57:01\n10:57:01\n10:57:02\n4\nQ.\nYou have not?\n10:57:02\n5\nA.\nNo.\n10:57:02\n6\nQ. You don't think that they will be able to\n10:57:02\n7\nbe identified by the first names that you have\n8\ngiven? The fact that they live in Palm Beach, and\n9\nthe fact that\nlived together with\n10\n11\nthem for some period of time, that's not identifying\ninformation?\n12\nA.\nNot\n10:57:18\n13\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection.\n10:57:19\n14\nA. Not for the media, which is what they're\n10:57:19\n15\nconcerned about. They're concerned about getting\n16\ncalls from the media and being harassed.\n17\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:57:25\n18\nQ. Well, you are aware of the fact that\n10:57:25\n19\nthere's a press representative sitting in this room,\n20\naren't you?\n21\nA.\nYes. I don't think there's enough\n10:57:29\n22\ninformation for them to identify these folks unless\n23\nyou provide them with that information.\n24\nQ. How long have you been a member of the\n10:57:37\n25\nBar?\nEFTA00601214\n19\n61\n", "char_count": 989}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "62\n62\n1\nA.\nOver 50 years.\n10:57:47\n2\nQ.\nAnd during that period of time, you've\n10:57:48\n3\nbeen involved in many, many litigated matters,\n4\ncorrect?\n5\n6\nA. I'm mostly an appellate lawyer, but I have 10:57:56\nbeen involved in many appeals, yes.\n7\n8\n9\n10\nQ. You do understand that you cannot make a\nbinding promise to a potential witness that would\nauthorize you to withhold information that you are\nrequired to give in the course of discovery\n10:58:01\n11\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, form.\n12\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n13\nQ.\ncorrect?\n10:58:22\n10:58:22\n10:58:22\n14\n15\nA. I told them in the course of my\nconversations with them that I would not violate any\n10:58:23\n16\ncourt orders, that I would not break the law, that I\n17\nwould do my best to maintain what they wanted\n18\n19\n20\nbecause it was very important for me to get as much\ninformation from them as I could. I did not want to\ncut off my sources of information.\nI think I have a\n21\nright to obtain that information.\n22\nAnd so there was a back and forth. And\n10:58:49\n23\nultimately I think we all realized ultimately\n24 probably their names will be revealed, yes.\n25\nEFTA00601215\n", "char_count": 1115}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "63\n1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10:59:02\n2\nQ.\nWhat is their phone number?\n10:59:02\n3\nA.\nI don't have it.\n10:59:04\n4\nMR. SCOTT: You can make a request when\n10:59:06\n5\n6\n7\n8\n00\n9\nyou want to and we'll take it under\nconsideration for the information that you've\nasked my client about. He's not the lawyer. I\nam. There's confidentiality orders. I have to\nreview all of that. You can take whatever\nappropriate discovery you want on that.\n10\n11\nMR. SCAROLA: What\n--\nwhat confidentiality\n10:59:17\n12\norders?\n13\nMR. SCOTT: There's a confidentiality\n10:59:19\n14\n15\norder by the Court.\nMR. SCAROLA: That covers the phone number 10:59:21\n16\nof a witness?\n17\nMR. SCOTT: That covers various issues and\n10:59:24\n18\nI have to review it. And so you can\nI'm\n19\njust telling you that you can make any formal\n20\nrequest you want and we will take it up.\n21\n10:59:33\n22\n23\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nQ. Was it your understanding in February of\nthis year that you had the authority to withhold in\n24 answers to interrogatories the names of these\n25\nindividuals if questions were asked that called for\n10:59:37\nEFTA00601216\n", "char_count": 1079}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "1 the disclosure of those names?\n2\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, asked and answered\n10:59:58\n3\nseveral times.\n4\nA.\nObviously I confer with my lawyers about\n11:00:00\n5\nmatters of that kind.\n6\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:00:05\n7\nQ. That's not my question to you. Was it\n11:00:05\n8\nyour understanding in February of 2015, on\n9\nFebruary 23, 2015, when you signed these answers to\n10\n11\ninterrogatories under oath, that you had the\nauthority to withhold the names of these individuals\n12\nwho you claim to be witnesses?\n13\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, legal conclusion.\n11:00:27\n14\nA. I don't believe I had their names on\n11:00:28\n15\nFebruary 23. I would have to check. But my belief\n16\n17\nis that I didn't have their names. It took quite\nquite a bit of effort for me to obtain their names\n18\nunder promises of confidentiality.\n19\n20\nand ethical questions.\nI think these are very, very hard legal\nThere's obviously a right to\n11:00:41\n21\n22\ninvestigate and to try to get information,\nparticularly information that would proffer that\n23\n24\nyour clients had engaged in criminal actions,\nsubornation of perjury and pressuring witnesses.\n25\nAnd I know that many of you are former\n11:01:00\n64\nEFTA00601217\n", "char_count": 1171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "65\n65\n1\nprosecutors.\n2\n3\n4\nI know that prosecutors also try very\nhard to obtain such information and make promises\nand the Courts have varying approaches to how these\npromises will be dealt with.\n5\nSo it was a complicated question.\nAnd I\n11:01:18\n6\nsought my legal advice based on it being a\n7\ncomplicated question.\n8\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:01:24\n9\nQ. When did you first seek legal advice with\n11:01:25\n10\nregards to these matters?\n11\nA.\nWhen I first found out about it, I told my\n11:01:29\n12\nlawyers that the information had come\n--\nthat it\n13\nhadn't been\nI hadn't gotten permission.\nThat I\n14\n15\nwas getting it in dribs and drabs. And that I was\nanxious to pursue it. I told my lawyers not to call\n16\nher at all, not to call them. Because I thought\n17\nthat would shut down the flow of information.\n18\nQ. Which lawyers did you take these\n11:01:53\n19\ndisclosures to?\n20\nMR. SCOTT: Let him ask that question.\n21\n22\nA.\nMR. SIMPSON: Just the names.\nMy recollection is Ken Sweder, and I would\n23 have to check my records but probably probably\n--\nMr. Simpson, probably. Probably Mr. Scott. But I'm\n24\n25\nnot positive about Mr. Scott at this point, about\n11:02:02\n11:02:04\n11:02:05\nEFTA00601218\n", "char_count": 1185}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "7\n6\n1\nJudge Scott. I'm not positive about that.\n2\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:02:32\n3\nQ.\nAnd what is it that you disclosed to\n11:02:33\n4\nMr. Sweder?\n5\nMR. SCOTT: Objection. Don't answer that.\nAttorney-client privilege and work product.\nMR. SCAROLA: Our position is that it's\nalready been waived voluntarily by virtue of\n11:02:38\n11:02:41\n00\n8\n9\nthe testimony that was just given.\n10\nMR. SCOTT: I understand your position.\n11:02:45\n11\nWe don't agree.\n12\nMR. SCAROLA: That's fine.\nI know you\n11:02:47\n13\ndon't.\n14\nMR. SCOTT: Okay.\n11:02:49\n15\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:02:49\n16\nQ. What information did you give to\n11:02:50\n17\nMr. Simpson with regard to this\n--\n18\nMR. SCOTT: Same objection.\n11:02:54\n19\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:02:54\n20\nQ.\n--\ncommunication?\n11:02:55\n21\nMR. SCOTT: Don't answer that.\n11:02:57\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:02:59\n23\nQ. And since you don't remember whether you\n11:03:00\n24\ndid or did not tell Mr. Scott, I assume you don't\n25\nremember what information you may have given to\nEFTA00601219\n66\n99\n", "char_count": 992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "1\nMr. Scott if you did speak to him;B is that correct?\n2\nMR. SCOTT: The same objection.\nDon't\n11:03:08\n3\nanswer that.\n41\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:03:14\n5\nQ.\nSince you were well, did you make these\n11:03:15\n6\ndisclosures to your lawyers as soon as you got the\n7\nfirst phone call?\n8\nMR. SCOTT: Objection. Don't answer that.\n11:03:29\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:03:33\n10\nQ.\nYou obviously considered this to be a\n11:03:37\n11\nsignificant communication, correct?\n12\nA.\nPotentially\n13\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, repetitious.\n11:03:41\n11:03:42\n14\nYou've asked that several times.\n15\nA.\nPotentially significant, but I did not\n11:03:44\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\nknow well, it was significant to me because it\nconfirmed my own knowledge that your clients had\nengaged in behavior which was unprofessional and\npossibly criminal. And it confirmed it in my own\nmind. So it was very gratifying to me.\n21\nBut I had\ndidn't know at that point\n11:04:07\n22\nwhether I could in any way use that information to\n23\nproduce the truth in the litigation.\nI wasn't sure\n24\nof that.\n25\n67\nEFTA00601220\n", "char_count": 1043}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:04:16\n2\nQ.\nYou knew that you might be able to and so\n11:04:17\n3\nit was significant to you\n41\nMR. SCOTT:\nObject.\n11:04:21\n5\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:04:21\n6\nQ.\nis that correct?\n11:04:22\n7\nMR. SCOTT: Form.\n11:04:23\n8\n00\nA.\nIt was significant to me psychologically\n11:04:24\n9\nbecause it confirmed my firm belief that your\n10\nclients had engaged in unethical behavior, yes.\n11\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:04:34\n12\nQ. As an experienced criminal defense lawyer,\n11:04:34\n13\nyou certainly recognize the importance of a\n14\n15\ncontemporaneous record of significant\ncommunications, don't you?\n16\nA.\nSometimes. But it's more important to me\n11:04:45\n17\nto have the conversation and to try to be in the\n18 moment and elicit the information.\nAnd that was\n19\nwhat my focus was at the time.\n20\nQ. Was there something that prevented you\n11:04:56\n21\nfrom taking contemporaneous notes with regard to\n22\nthese communications?\n23\nA. II generally don't take\n11:05:04\n24\ncontemporaneous notes.\n25\nQ. That's not my question, sir.\n11:05:07\n68\nEFTA00601221\n", "char_count": 1038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "1\nMR. SCOTT: Don't cut him off, please.\n11:05:07\n2\nA.\nI generally don't take notes. I find that\n11:05:08\n3\nit's much more important to concentrate.\nIn fact, I\n4\ntell my students in my classes not to take notes but\n5\nrather to listen, listen carefully to what's being\n6\nsaid. I'm not a particular advocate of note taking.\n7\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:05:23\n8\nQ.\nAnd since you have a superb memory, the\n11:05:23\n9\nnotes don't have much value to you?\n10\nA.\nIn fact\n11:05:28\n11\nMR.\nSCOTT: Objection, form.\n11:05:29\n12\nA. In fact, my memory is one of the reasons\n11:05:30\n13\nthat I don't focus on notes as much as some other\n14\npeople may.\n15\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:05:37\n16\nQ. So let's go through these conversations\n11:05:37\n17\none at a time then.\n18\nA.\nOkay.\n11:05:40\n19\nQ.\nAnd I want you to tell us, based upon your\n11:05:41\n20\n21\nsuperb memory, as best you are able to relate,\nword-for-word exactly how the first conversation\n22\nwent.\n23\nA.\nOkay.\n11:05:55\n24\nQ.\nWho placed the call to whom?\n11:05:56\n25\nA.\nThe first conversation came as a result of\n11:05:59\nEFTA00601222\n69\n69\n", "char_count": 1065}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "me getting a phone number from them by an e-mail or\n70\n1\n2\ntext correspondence.\nI then placed\n--\nthis is my\n3\nbest memory.\nI then placed the conversation and I\n4\nspoke to Michael.\n5\nQ. You then placed the phone call?\n11:06:19\n6\nA.\nI then placed the phone call.\nAnd I spoke\n11:06:20\n7\n8\n9\nto Michael. Michael told me that his wife, Rebecca,\nfelt terrible about what was going on in relation to\nme,\nbut that she was not willing to talk to me about\nit. But he then said to me that if she did talk to\n10\n11\n12\n13\nme, she would tell me that I was not mentioned by\never previously until this case occurred,\nand that she was pressured into mentioning me.\n14\nI said that would be important to me, I\n11:07:04\n15\nwould really like to talk to Rebecca.\n16\nWell, he said, she's very emotional about\n11:07:07\n17\nthis, she's a very close friend of\nshe\n18\nlikes\nand she just doesn't want to get\n19\ninvolved.\n20\nAnd I said, well, let's have\n--\nplease\n11:07:21\n21\nhave her think about it. And let's see if we can\n22\ntalk again.\n23\nI then made a second phone call.\n11:07:29\n24\nQ.\nI'm sorry, I was still on the first one.\n11:07:31\n25\nA.\nOkay. That was the first phone call.\n11:07:33\nEFTA00601223\n", "char_count": 1176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "1\nThat's about the first phone call.\n2\nQ.\nThank you. All right. Now, during the\n11:07:36\n3\n4 why did you ask me to contact you if your wife\ncourse of that phone call, did you ever ask Michael,\n5\ndoesn't want to talk to me?\n6\n7\n8\n00\nMR. SCOTT:\nargumentative.\nObjection, form,\nA.\nI did not.\n11:07:46\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10\n11\nQ.\nWhy not?\nMR. SCOTT: Same objection.\n12\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n13\nQ.\nDid that seem strange to you?\n11:07:48\n11:07:48\n11:07:49\n11:07:51\n11:07:51\n11:07:51\n14\nA.\nNo, never occurred to me. He was\n11:07:53\n15\n16\nobviously reaching out to me. There was obviously\nsome ambivalence. They wanted to talk to me. They\n17\ndidn't want to get involved.\nThey were testing the\n18\nwaters. They wanted to see if I was a reliable\n19\n20\nperson. I think they wanted to get a sense of me,\njust as I was trying to get a sense of them.\n21\n22\nQ. Did they tell you at that point in time\nthat they lived in the Palm Beach area in the first\n11:08:16\n23\nconversation?\n24\nMR. SCOTT: Same objection.\n11:08:25\n25\nA. I don't recall, but I think they did. I\n11:08:26\n71\nEFTA00601224\n", "char_count": 1066}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "1\nthink they did.\n2\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n3\nQ.\nThey or he?\n41\nA.\nHe. He's the only one who spoke to me.\nH\n11:08:31\n11:08:31\n11:08:32\n72\n5\n6\n7\n8\nalso had their phone number, which I think I recall\nis in that area generally. I didn't know\nspecifically where they lived. I did not have their\naddress.\n9\nQ. Were arrangements made during the first\n11:08:52\n10\nconversation for a subsequent communication?\n11\nA.\nNo.\n11:08:56\n12\nQ.\nWas any request made by you for a meeting?\n11:08:59\n13\nA.\nYes.\n11:09:02\n14\nQ.\nLet me back up then, if I could, please.\n11:09:05\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nBecause what I want you to do, based upon your\nsuperb memory, is to tell us in as much detail as\nyou possibly can recall everything that was said.\nAnd when I asked you to do that, you didn't say\nanything about a request for a meeting.\n20\nA.\nI'm not sure\n11:09:28\n21\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, asked and answered.\n11:09:29\n22\nA.\nI'm not sure the request for the meeting\n11:09:30\n23\ncame in the first call or the second call. But\n24\nthere was ultimately a request for a meeting. It\n25 wouldn't surprise me if it came in the first call.\nEFTA00601225\n", "char_count": 1104}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "1\nThe first call was basically, I'd really\nlike to talk to your wife about this. I'm happy to\n73\n73\n11:09:41\n2\n3\nfly down.\nI'm happy to talk to you on the phone.\n4\nAnd we left it that they would think that she\n5\nwould\nthat he would ask her to think about it.\n6\nAnd that I could call back in a\n--\nin a few days and\n7\nfind out what her\nwhat her current feelings were.\n8\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:10:09\n9\nQ. Where were you when you received this\n11:10:09\n10\nphone call\nor when you made this phone call?\n11\nSorry.\n12\nA.\nI think I was in New York.\n11:10:14\n13\nQ.\nDo you know whether that phone call was\n11:10:23\n14\nmade on a cell phone or a landline?\n15\nA.\nI don't remember.\n11:10:26\n16\nQ.\nHave you attempted to gather your\n11:10:37\n17\ntelephone records for purposes of responding to\n18\ndiscovery requests in this case?\n19\n20\n21\nA. I left that to my lawyers. I know that we\ndid produce telephone records during the relevant\nperiods of time when\n11:10:47\nknew Jeffrey\n22\n23\nEpstein and those telephone records established that\nI could not have been at the locations and at the\n24\ntimes that\nclaimed to have had\n25 falsely claimed to have sexual contact with me.\nEFTA00601226\n", "char_count": 1162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "74\n1\nQ.\nI promise you we're going to get to those.\n11:11:15\n2\nA.\nGood.\n11:11:18\n3\nQ.\nPromise you.\nAlong with all the flight\n11:11:18\n4\nlogs that you claim exonerate you.\n5\nA.\nIs that a question?\n6\nQ.\nIt wasn't. It was a comment.\n7\nMR. SCOTT: I object.\n8\n00\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:11:25\n11:11:26\n11:11:28\n11:11:29\n9\nQ.\nIn response to your comment.\n11:11:29\n10\nMR. SCOTT: Let me just say this to you, I\n11:11:31\n11\nthink it's inappropriate to have comments by\n12\ncounsel.\n13\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:11:36\n14\nQ. Let's go to the very second contact that\n11:11:37\n15\nyou had with either Michael or Rebecca. Who\n16\ninitiated the second contact?\n17\nA.\nI think I did. I called and got Michael\n11:11:48\n18\non the phone.\n19\nQ. Where did you call from?\n11:11:53\n20\nA.\nI think New York.\n11:11:54\n21\nQ.\nTell me in as much detail as your superb\n11:12:02\n22\nmemory allows you to recall everything that was said\n23\nduring the course of that phone conversation.\n24\nMR. SCOTT:\nLet's object to the form and\n11:12:14\n25\nthe continued use of the word \"superb.\" He's\nEFTA00601227\n", "char_count": 1049}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "That's your\nGo ahead.\n1\ndescribed his memory.\n2\ncharacterization.\n3\n3\nMR. SCAROLA: No, I think that that was\nMr. Dershowitz's characterization, which I have\n11:12:24\n15\n75\n4\n5\nadopted.\n6\nMR. SCOTT: Okay. Go ahead.\n11:12:29\n7\nA. I called, spoke to Michael. I asked\n11:12:31\n8\nMichael if he had spoken to his wife.\nShe said yes\n9\nand she was still reluctant to talk to me.\n10\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:12:41\n11\nQ. I'm sorry, she said yes when you asked\n11:12:41\n12\nMichael if he had spoken to his wife?\n13\n14\nA. He said yes.\nreluctant to talk to me. I suggested to him that\nAnd that she was still\n11:12:46\n15\n16\n17\nperhaps she could talk to me briefly just so that\nshe hears what I have to say. And he could listen\nand remain on the phone and she could stop at any\n18\ntime she wanted.\n19\nAnd there came a time during that\n11:13:07\n20\n21\nconversation when she did get on the phone, and\nhere's what she told me. She said she had grown up\n22\nwith\nThat they were very, very\n23\n24\n25\nclose friends as young people. That\ncame to stay with her for a number of days,\nI think it was over Halloween, and they had gone out\nEFTA00601228\n", "char_count": 1116}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "76\n1\nand had dinner, just the two of them. And that she\n2\nconfided in\nconfided in her,\n3 Rebecca that she had never wanted to mention me in\n4\nany of the pleadings, but she was pressured by her\n5\nlawyer into doing so.\n6\nRebecca then said that I was not the\n11:14:09\n7\nobject of this effort. The object of the effort was\n8\na billionaire who lives in Columbus, Ohio and who\n9\nowns Victoria's Secret and the Limited, Too.\n10\nRebecca told me she did not know the name of that\n11\nbillionaire, but that\nand her lawyers hoped\n12\n13\n14\nto get 1 billion, B-I---1-0-N, $1 billion or half\nof his net worth from him by alleging that he had\nimproperly engaged in sexual misconduct with\n15\n16\nThat that money would be divided three\n17\nways: A third of it to\n11:15:12\na third of\n18\n19\nit to a charity that she and her lawyers were\nsetting up for battered women, and a third of it to\n20\nthe lawyers.\n21\nShe then told me that they were trying to\n11:15:35\n22\nget ABC News to interview\nso as to\n23\n24\n25\ngive her credibility in order to pressure the\nbillionaire from Columbus, Ohio into paying a large\nsum of money. And that I was named as an effort to\nEFTA00601229\n", "char_count": 1146}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "77\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\ntry to show the billionaire what could happen to\nsomebody if they were accused of sexual misconduct.\nAnd that would encourage him to settle a lawsuit or\npay money in exchange for his name not being\nmentioned or revealed.\n6\nI had no idea about this.\nAnd I didn't\n--\n11:16:44\n7\nI didn't ask about this. She just stated this. And\n8\nI then corroborated the fact that she was absolutely\n9\ncorrect in everything she had said to me.\n10\n11\nQ. You corroborated the fact that she was\nabsolutely correct in everything that she had said\n11:17:09\n12\nto you?\n13\nA. That's right.\n14\nQ.\nHow?\n15\n16\nvery\n--\nA. Okay. Let me answer that question. I was\nI wasn't sure, so I called Leslie Wexner. Ι\n11:17:15\n11:17:20\n11:17:21\n17\ngot his wife on the phone, Abigail Wexner.\n18\nObviously I knew that the only billionaire in\n19\nColumbus, Ohio who owned Limited, Too and who owned\n20\nVictoria's Secret was Leslie Wexner.\n21\nI had met Leslie Wexner on two occasions,\n11:17:47\n22\n23\nI think, and his wife. I called Abigail on the\nphone and I said, I think you ought to know that\n24\nthere is an extortion plot being directed against\n25\nyour husband by unscrupulous lawyers in\n--\nin\nEFTA00601230\n", "char_count": 1179}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "1\nFlorida.\n2\nAnd she said, oh, we're aware of that,\n11:18:09\n3\nthey've already been in contact with us, which\n4\nsurprised me. But was confirmation of that.\n5\nI then also\nI can't give you the\n11:18:24\n6\nchronology of that. I then was in touch with ABC and\n7\nfound out she was absolutely correct about her\n8\n9\nefforts to try to get interviewed on ABC television.\nIn fact, I learned that your client, Brad\nEdwards, had sent a communication to people in\nin the area urging them to watch her\ninterview that was scheduled to be on three\ntelevision programs. If I'm not mistaken, it was\nGood Day Show, the evening news, and the show\n10\n11\nthe\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\nhelped to persuade them that they would be putting\n18\nfalse information on the air if they allowed\nNightline\nand Nightline.\nI then was in communication with ABC and\n11:18:41\n11:19:10\n19\nto tell her false story.\n20\nSo, I was able to corroborate that. I\n11:19:28\n21\nthen also corroborated the fact that she had never\nmentioned me when her boyfriend appeared on\n22\n23 television and publically stated that she had never\nmentioned me in any of her description of people who\n24\n25\nshe had sexual contact with.\n78\nEFTA00601231\n", "char_count": 1175}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "79\n1\nSo, I was then completely satisfied that\n11:19:53\n2\nRebecca was telling me the complete truth. And that\n3\nin my view, there was an extortion plot directed\n4\n5 directed against Leslie Wexner, and that your\nagainst Leslie Wexner, a criminal extortion plot\n6\nclients were involved in that extortion plot.\n7\nQ.\n8\nIf we were to try to fix the time of this\nsecond phone call, one way in which we would fix the\n9\ntime of this second phone call, in addition to\ngetting your telephone records, would be to find out\n11:20:16\n11\n12\n13\n10\nwhen this ABC interview took place, correct? Since\nthe phone call you're telling us came after the ABC\ninterview, that you convinced ABC not to air?\n14\nA.\nNo, I didn't state that.\nLet me be very\n11:20:51\n15\nclear.\n16\nI found out from her that there was going\n11:20:53\n17\nto be an ABC television interview. I don't think I\n18\n19\nwas aware of the fact that there was going to be a\ntelevision interview at that point.\n20\n21\nI remember then getting a either a\nphone call or e-mail from ABC informing me of that.\n--\n11:21:05\n22\nAnd that corroborated to my mind the fact that she\n23\n24\nShe also told me\nwas telling me the truth about the ABC interview.\nand this was\n11:21:27\n25 corroborated, she also told me that the television\nEFTA00601232\n", "char_count": 1268}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "2\n3\n1 interview with ABC had to be postponed because her\nhusband,\nhusband, had beaten her\nup so badly that she was hospitalized and that she\n4\ncould not appear on television with the bruises\n5\nbecause she didn't want to have to explain that her\n6 husband had beaten her up.\n7\nAnd I ultimately corroborated that\n11:21:56\n8\ninformation as well by investigating the fact that\n9\n10\nshe, in fact, filed a complaint against her husband\nand had been hospitalized.\n11\n12\n13\nSo everything that Rebecca told me has\nproved to be absolutely true and absolutely\ncorroborated. And, therefore, I believe it and\n11:22:08\n14\n15\n16\nbelieve that your clients were engaged in what I\nbelieve is an extortion plot against Leslie Wexner,\nconspiracy to commit extortion in which I was a\n17\nvictim, as well as Leslie Wexner, of being a victim.\n18\nQ. Did you speak directly to Leslie Wexner or\n11:22:36\n19\nonly to his wife?\n20\nA.\nOnly to his wife and to his lawyers.\n11:22:41\n21\nQ.\nAnd you spoke by telephone?\n11:22:42\n22\nA.\nYes.\n11:22:43\n23\nQ.\nWhere were you and where was she?\n11:22:44\n24\nA.\nI called from, I think, New York and I\n11:22:48\n25 spoke to her about it. I told her what I said I\n80\nEFTA00601233\n", "char_count": 1183}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "1\nsaid. She said what I said she said.\n2\nAnd then she said that her lawyers would\n3 be in touch with me. And her lawyer then called me\n41\nand corroborated again that there had been contact\nand eventually there was greater contact.\n11:23:00\n5\n6\nQ.\nContact by whom with whom?\n11:23:15\n7\nA.\nContact by\n--\nby\nlawyer,\n11:23:17\n8\nlawyers.\nI wasn't\nit wasn't clear at that point.\n9\nQ.\nWhich lawyer or lawyers?\n11:23:26\n10\nA.\nI wasn't clear at that point. They didn't\n11:23:27\n11\nindicate to me which lawyer or lawyers\n12\nQ. Didn't you ask?\n11:23:31\n13\nA.\ncontact.\n11:23:32\n14\nQ.\nDidn't you want to know, is this Bradley\n11:23:32\n15\nEdwards or Professor Paul Cassell who is\n--\n16\nA.\nI asked\n11:23:35\n17\nQ.\nmaking this\n11:23:36\n18\nA.\nI asked\n11:23:36\n19\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form. Go ahead.\n11:23:37\n20\nA.\nI asked whether there was a letter and\n11:23:39\n21\nthey wouldn't show me a letter. I asked if there\n22\nwere phone calls. They were a\n--\nthey wanted to be\n23\ndiscreet about how the contact had occurred.\nBut\n24\nthey told me that the contact had occurred.\n25\n81\nEFTA00601234\n", "char_count": 1070}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:23:52\n2\nQ.\nBut they wouldn't tell you who?\n11:23:53\n3\nA.\nThey wouldn't show me any letter.\n11:23:55\n41\nQ.\nThat's not my question. Did they tell\n11:23:58\n5\nyou\n--\ndid you ask who contacted Leslie Wexner?\n6\nA.\nThe first answer was\n11:24:07\n7\nlawyer.\n8\nI then subsequently learned that among\n11:24:11\n9\nthose who contacted Leslie Wexner's lawyers was\n10\nDavid Boies and Sigrid McCawley.\n11\nQ. Not Bradley Edwards, correct?\n11:24:24\n12\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection as to the form.\n11:24:27\n13\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:24:28\n14\nQ.\nCorrect?\n11:24:29\n15\nA.\nI was not given the name Bradley Edwards\n11:24:30\n16\nat that time. But was subsequently told by David\n17\nBoies that Bradley Edwards and Paul Cassell\n18\n19\n20\nMS. MCCAWLEY: I'm going to object to the\nextent this reveals any conversations that\nhappened in the context of settlement\n11:24:43\n21\ndiscussions.\n22\nMR. SCOTT: Okay. Note your objection.\n11:24:48\n23\nGo ahead.\n24\nA.\nThat I was ultimately told by David Boies\n11:24:52\n25\nthat he had done an extensive investigation of the\n82\nEFTA00601235\n", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "1\nallegations against Leslie Wexner and had concluded\n2\nthat they were\n3\nMS. MCCAWLEY:\nAgain, I'm going to object\n11:25:05\n4\n5\nto this has happened in the context of\nsettlement\n6\nA.\nfalse.\n11:25:07\nI'm going\n11:25:07\n7\n8\n00\n9\n10\n11\nMS. MCCAWLEY:\n--\nnegotiations.\nto move for sanctions if information is\nrevealed that happened in the context of\nsettlement discussions.\nMR. SCOTT: I don't know whether\n--\nI\n11:25:12\n12\ndon't believe there were settlement\n13\ndiscussions. But even if they weren't, they\n14\nwould still be admissible.\n15\nA.\nLet me continue\n11:25:21\n16\nMR. SCOTT: For discovery purposes.\n11:25:22\n17\nA.\nthat David Boies had done\n11:25:23\n18\nMS. MCCAWLEY: I disagree. I think we're\n11:25:24\n19\ngoing to have to take this to the judge, then;\n20\nif we're going to reveal settlement\n21\nconversations in this conversation, then we\n22\nneed to go to the judge on it.\n23\nMR. SCOTT: Whatever you need to do.\n11:25:31\n24\nA.\nLet me continue the\n--\nwhat he told me.\n11:25:33\n25\nThat David Boies had\n--\n83\nEFTA00601236\n", "char_count": 1017}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "84\n1\n2\nMS. MCCAWLEY: No, we're\n11:25:35\nMR. SIMPSON: No, no, no.\n11:25:37\n3\n41\n3\nMS. MCCAWLEY:\ngoing to discontinue.\n11:25:38\nWe will contact the judge.\n5\nMR. SCAROLA: We'll move on to another\n11:25:41\n6\narea and address that issue with the judge as\n7\nto whether or not a protective order is\n8\n00\nappropriate.\n9\nA. Would you like to establish the foundation\n11:25:46\n10\nfor why it's not protected?\n11\nMR. SWEDER:\nAlan\n11:25:50\n12\nMR. SCOTT: Alan, just let it alone. Let\n11:25:51\n13\nit alone.\n14\nTHE WITNESS: Okay.\n11:25:53\n15\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:25:55\n16\nQ. This second conversation you've told us\n11:26:00\n17\nwas conducted while you were in New York, correct?\n18\nA. That's my best recollection.\n11:26:06\n19\nQ.\nThe first conversation also conducted\n11:26:09\n20\nwhile you were in New York?\n21\nA.\nThat's my best recollection.\n11:26:12\n22\nQ. Are you aware that New York is a one-party 11:26:17\n23\nconsent state for purposes of permitting the\n24 recording of communications, correct?\n25\nMR. SCOTT: Objection. Do you know?\n11:26:31\nEFTA00601237\n", "char_count": 1039}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "☐ 1 A.\nI'm\nI think that's right, yeah.\n2\n3\nQ.\n41\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nOkay. So you knew that these significant\nconversations could have been recorded by you had\n85\n11:26:34\n11:26:40\n11:26:41\n5\nyou chosen to record them, correct?\n6\nA. I don't think I thought about that at the\n11:26:52\n7\ntime. I certainly\nI didn't think about that at\n8\nthe time, no.\n9\nQ. How many conversations in total did you\n11:27:00\n10\nhave with Rebecca and/or Michael when you were in\n11\nNew York and had the legal right, had you chosen to,\n12\nnot only to make contemporaneous notes but to\n13\nactually record the conversations?\n14\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, asked and answered.\n11:27:20\n15\nA.\nI think I was in New York for two of the\n11:27:21\n16\nconversations.\nI think I was in Massachusetts for\n17\nseveral of the conversations.\nI don't think I was\n18\nin Florida. I think it was New York and\n19\nMassachusetts.\n20\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:27:33\n21\nQ.\nMassachusetts is also a one-party consent.\n11:27:33\n22\nstate, is it not?\n23\nA.\nYou don't know the law, sir, no.\n24\nQ.\nIt is not?\n11:27:36\n11:27:38\n25\nA.\nNo.\n11:27:38\nEFTA00601238\n", "char_count": 1085}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "1\n2\nQ. Okay.\nA. It is clearly not.\n3\nQ.\nOkay. So, you\n--\nyou recognize the\n86\n11:27:39\n11:27:39\n11:27:40\n4\n5\n6\nsignificant distinction between making the phone\ncall from New York and making the phone call from\nMassachusetts because in New York you would be\n7\npermitted to\n--\nexcuse me, to record the phone call;\n8\nwhereas, in Massachusetts you could not record it\n9\nwithout the consent of all parties involved?\n10\nA.\nIt never\n11:27:58\n11\nMR.\nSCOTT: Objection, argumentative.\n11:27:58\n12\nA.\nIt never occurred to me.\n11:28:00\n13\nBY MR.\nSCAROLA:\n11:28:02\n14\nQ.\nNever occurred to you?\n11:28:02\n15\nA.\nNo.\n11:28:03\n16\nQ.\nHave we covered the entire content of the\n11:28:09\n17\nsecond conversation?\n18\nA. I think so, yes.\nI continued to ask her\n11:28:25\n19\nif\nif I could use her\nif she was willing to\n20\ngive me\n--\nallow me to use her name. But that's\n21\nall.\nThere were\nthe substance of what she told\n22\nme I think I've covered fairly thoroughly, yes.\n23\nQ.\nDid Michael ever tell you that\n11:28:46\n24\nhad said she never met you?\n25\nMR. SCOTT: Read that back, will you, for\n11:28:53\nEFTA00601239\n", "char_count": 1087}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "1\nme.\n2\nSorry.\n(Requested portion read back.)\n11:28:54\n3\nMR. SCOTT:\nOkay.\nThank you.\n4\nA.\nMichael and I did not discuss the\n11:29:00\n11:29:04\n5\nsubstance of\nconversations with Rebecca\n6\nbecause the conversations were between\nand\n7\nRebecca. So there was no conversation about that.\n8\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:29:18\n9\n10\nQ.\never said that she had never met you?\nDid Rebecca ever tell you that\n11:29:19\n11\nA. The implication was quite clear that she\n11:29:25\n12\nhad never mentioned me, that she didn't want to\n13\nmention me, and that the lawyers pressured her into\n14\n15\nfalsely accusing me of an act that simply never\noccurred.\n16\nQ. Okay. I'm not asking you about what you\n11:29:44\n17\nimplied from what was said.\n18\nA.\nInferred.\n11:29:47\n19\nQ.\nInferred.\n11:29:49\n20\nA.\nRight.\n11:29:50\n21\nQ.\nInferred from what was said.\n11:29:51\n22\nWhat I am asking you is whether Rebecca\n11:29:53\n23\never told you that\nsaid she had never met\n24\nyou.\n25\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, asked and answered.\n11:30:03\n87\nEFTA00601240\n", "char_count": 997}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "88\n☐ 1 A.\nNot in those words.\n11:30:04\n2\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:30:06\n3\nQ.\nDid she say any words that conveyed that\n11:30:06\n4\nmessage?\n5\nA.\nYes.\n6\nQ.\nWhat words did she say?\n7\nA.\nThat she had never mentioned me\n11:30:09\n11:30:10\n11:30:12\n8\npreviously.\nAnd that she was pressured into\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\nmentioning me by her lawyers and that certainly gave\nrise to an inference on my part that the story\ninference that simply confirmed what I knew to be\nthe fact, that her allegations against me were\ncompletely, totally and entirely made up out of\nwhole cloth.\nan\n15\nQ. Let's see if we can make sure that we're\n11:30:37\n16\nunderstanding one another, sir.\n17\nDo you recognize that there's a\n11:30:44\n18\ndistinction between\nhaving met you,\n19\n20\n21\nto\nhaving been sexually abused by you on multiple\noccasions, but not wanting to name you, as opposed\nnever having met you and never\n22\nhaving been sexually abused by you?\n23\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection\n11:31:12\n24\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:31:12\n25\nQ. Are those two things different in your\n11:31:13\nEFTA00601241\n", "char_count": 1041}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "1\nmind?\n2\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, argumentative and\n11:31:15\n3\n3\ncompound.\n41\nA.\nNot in the context of this case.\nBecause\n11:31:17\n5\nsaid that she was going to seek\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n6 justice from everybody that had abused her. And if\n7\nshe didn't want to name me, I think the inference is\ninescapable that I was not among those people that\nshe had had any sexual contact with. So that was\ncertainly the inference I drew and I think it's an\ninescapable inference.\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n13\nQ. When did\nsay she was\n14\ngoing to seek justice from everyone who had abused\n15\nher?\n16\nA.\nIn her\n17\nin her depositions, in her\ninterviews with the media, certainly that's been a\n18\ncommon theme, that it was time that\nthat Jeffrey\n19 Epstein's friends who had abused her were brought to\n11:31:45\n11:31:45\n11:31:50\n20\n21\njustice and were not seen as above the law.\nback and check, you'll see there are repeated\nJust go\n22\nreferences to that in her statements.\n23\nQ.\nWhich depositions?\n11:32:17\n24\nA.\nYou'll have to check those. You know\n11:32:18\n25\nthose as well as I do.\n89\nEFTA00601242\n", "char_count": 1065}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "90\n90\n1\nQ.\nWell, I'm\nI'm sorry. My memory is not\n11:32:22\n21\nsuperb.\n3\nA.\nOkay.\nSo let me go over them.\n11:32:26\n41\nQ.\nAnd\nand I would like you to tell us\n11:32:29\n5\nbased\n6\nMR. SCOTT: Objection. Please just ask\n11:32:29\n7\nquestions, Counsel.\n8\n00\nMR. SCAROLA: I am doing that.\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10\nQ. I would like you to tell us which\n11:32:32\n11:32:32\n11:32:33\n11\ndepositions\nsaid\nin which\n12\ndepositions\nsaid, I am going to\n13\n14\n15\noccasions.\n16\nconversations\n17\nseek justice from everyone who abused me.\nA. My recollection is she said it on multiple 11:32:44\nShe may have said it in her\nin her telephone interview with\nBradley Edwards and you. She may have said it in\n18\nher interviews with various British media for which\n19\nshe was apparently paid. She may have said it in\n20\nher two false affidavits that she filed in the\n21\nfederal court.\n22\nI'm not sure where she said it, but I'm\n11:33:18\n23\ncompletely confident that she said it.\n24\nQ.\nWhat is a deposition?\n11:33:25\n25\nA.\nWhat we're having here now.\n11:33:27\nEFTA00601243\n", "char_count": 1035}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "1\nQ.\nYour testimony was that\n11:33:35\n2\nmade these statements in depositions, plural. You\n3\n4\n5\nthen went on to talk about a telephone interview and\ninterviews with the British media. Let's go back to\nmy question, if we could.\n6\nWhen you made the statement under oath.\n11:33:50\n7\nthat\nsaid she was going to seek\n8\njustice from everyone who abused her in depositions,\n9\nwhich depositions were you talking about?\n10\nA.\nI was using\n11:34:05\n11\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, asked and answered.\n11:34:06\n12\nHe's already provided\n13\nA.\nI was using the term loosely, I apologize.\n11:34:08\n14\nI meant in statements, including statements under\n15\noath. So I withdraw the statement about\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\ndepositions. But I insist that she made statements\nalong those lines in her interviews of both formal\nand informal, both legal and to the media, so that I\nwas entitled to draw the conclusion, the reasonable\ninference, that when she did not want to name me, it\nI never had any sexual or any\nwas because that I\n22\nother contact with her, which I know to be the\n23\ntruth. So that's an inference that I draw.\n24\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:34:47\n25\n25\nQ. Okay.\nAnd it is an inference that you\n11:34:47\n91\nEFTA00601244\n", "char_count": 1194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "1 drew, not something that either Rebecca or Michael\never told you, correct?\n2\n3\nA. I certainly believe that they believe\n11:34:57\n41\nthat.\nBut Rebecca was very careful about the words\n5\nthat she communicated to me and she told me\n6\nprecisely what it was that\nhad told\n7\nher and didn't go beyond that and didn't draw any\n8\nand didn't tell me any words that weren't, in fact,\n9\nrecited by\n10\nSo the words were she never mentioned you\n11:35:24\n11\n12\n13\n14\nbefore all this stuff in the media, and she told me\nexpressly that she did not want to include you in\nany of the allegations of sexual misconduct but her\nlawyers pressured her into doing it.\n15\nMR. SCOTT: I'd like to take a break in\n11:35:47\n16\nanother five minutes or so. We've been going\n17\nanother hour. So where ever you think is good,\n18\nJack.\n19\nMR. SCAROLA: We're not quite there yet.\n11:35:55\n20\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:35:58\n21\n22\nQ. Who are the people that Rebecca says\nhad previously told her that\n11:35:58\nwas\n23\nabused by?\n24\nA. I never asked her that question.\n11:36:10\n25\n25\nQ.\nDid you ask her was Les Wexner one of the\n11:36:14\n92\nEFTA00601245\n", "char_count": 1109}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "1\npeople that abused\n?\n2\nA.\nI told you I never asked her the question. 11:36:21\n3\nQ.\nAre you aware that years before December\n11:36:48\n41\nof 2014, when the CVRA pleading was filed, that your\n5 name had come up repeatedly in connection with\n6\nJeffrey Epstein's abuse of minors, correct?\n7\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form, overly broad.\n11:37:16\n8\nA. Let me answer that question. I am aware\n11:37:17\n9\nthat never before 2014, end of December, was it\n10\n11\never, ever alleged that I had acted in any way\ninappropriately with regard to\n12\nthat I ever touched her, that I ever met her, that I\n13\n14\nhad ever been with her. I was completely aware of\nthat. There had never been any allegation.\n15\n16\n17\nnotes of any such conversation.\nShe claims under oath that she told you\nthat secretly in 2011, but you have produced no\nYou, of course, are\n11:37:48\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\na witness to this allegation and will be deposed as\na witness to this allegation. I believe it is an\nentirely false allegation that she told you in 2011\nthat she had had any sexual contact with me. I\nthink she's lying through her teeth when she says\nthat. And I doubt that your notes will reveal any\n24\nsuch information.\n25\nBut if she did tell you that, she would be 11:38:24\n93\nEFTA00601246\n", "char_count": 1250}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "1\n2\nabsolutely, categorically lying. So I am completely\naware that never, until the lies were put in a legal\n3 pleading at the end of December 2014, it was never\n41\n5\n6\nalleged that I had any sexual contact with\n7\nI know that it was alleged that I was a\nwitness to Jeffrey Epstein's alleged abuse and that\n11:38:46\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\nwas false. I was never a witness to any of Jeffrey\nEpstein's sexual abuse. And I wrote that to you,\nsomething that you have falsely denied. And I stand\non the record. The record is clear that I have\ncategorically denied I was ever a witness to any\nabuse, that I ever saw Jeffrey Epstein abusing\n14\nanybody.\n15\nAnd\n--\n16\n17\nand the very idea that I would\nstand and talk to Jeffrey Epstein while he was\nreceiving oral sex from\n11:39:18\nwhich she\n18\n19\nswore to under oath, is so outrageous, so\npreposterous, that even David Boies said he couldn't\n20\nbelieve it was true.\n21\nMS. MCCAWLEY: I object. I object.\nI'm\n11:39:40\n22\nnot going to allow you to reveal any\n23\n24\n25\n22\nconversations that happened in the context of a\nsettlement discussion.\nTHE WITNESS: Does she have standing?\n11:39:46\n94\nEFTA00601247\n", "char_count": 1135}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "95\n1\nMS. MCCAWLEY: I have a standing objection 11:39:47\n2\nand, I'm objecting again. I'm not going to\n3\n41\n55 6☑\n3\nTHE WITNESS: No, no, no. Does she have\nstanding in this deposition?\n11:39:49\nMR. SCOTT: Let's take a break for a\n11:39:51\nminute, okay?\n7\nTHE WITNESS: I'm not sure she has\n11:39:54\n8\n00\nstanding.\n9\nMR. SCAROLA: Are we finished with the\n11:39:57\n10\nspeech?\n11\nMR. SCOTT: No. If he\n--\n11:39:58\n12\nMR. SCAROLA: I'd like him to finish the\n11:39:59\n13\nspeech so that we can get to my question and\n14\nthen we can take a break.\n15\nA. So the question\n--\nthe answer to your\n11:40:02\n16\nquestion is\n17\nMR. SIMPSON: Wait a minute. Wait a\n18\nminute. Wait a minute.\n11:40:04\nPlease don't disclose\n19\nsomething that she has a right to raise that\n20\nobjection if she wants to.\n21\n21\nMR. SCOTT:\nExactly.\n11:40:13\n22\n22\n23\n24\nTHE WITNESS:\nOkay.\n11:40:14\nMR. SCOTT: Ask your question.\n11:40:17\nMR. SWEDER:\nMaybe you want to read back.\n11:40:20\n25\nthe last couple of sentences.\nEFTA00601248\n", "char_count": 986}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "96\n11:40:22\n1\n2\n3\n3\n41\n5\n69\n8\n00\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\nMR. SCAROLA: No, how about just reading\nback the last question and maybe we can get an\nanswer to the question.\nMR. SCOTT: Again, I move to strike your\ncomments, Counsel, because it's inappropriate\nand you're too good a lawyer to know that\nthat's not true\nMR. SCAROLA: Nothing inappropriate about\nmy insisting upon an answer to the question\nthat I asked instead of a speech.\nMR. SCOTT: Well, you know, he's trying to\nanswer your question to the best of his\nability. Counsel objected to it. I wanted to\ntake a break to make sure that we explained to\nhim the position so that we didn't have a\nproblem, and I was trying to protect everybody\nin this room. But if you want to proceed, we\ncan do it.\nMR. SCAROLA:\nWell, if we simply answer\nthe questions that are asked, there won't be a\nproblem.\n11:40:27\n11:40:33\n11:40:37\n11:40:52\n21\n21\n22\nMR. SCOTT:\nWell, I guess everybody you\n--\n11:40:59\n23\ncan characterize it one way, I can characterize\n24\n25\n22\nit another, that he's doing the best he can to\nanswer your questions.\nEFTA00601249\n", "char_count": 1095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "1\nMR. SCAROLA: And ultimately Judge Lynch\n2\nwill make that determination.\n3\n3\nMR. SCOTT:\nAbsolutely.\nSobeit.\n41\n5\n69\n8\n00\n97\n11:41:05\n11:41:08\n11:41:08\nMR. SCAROLA: So read back the last\nquestion, if you would, please. We'll get a\nhopefully get an answer to that and then we can\ntake a break.\nMR. SCOTT: Again, I object to the\ncomments, Counsel.\n(Requested portion read back as follows:)\n11:41:14\n9\n10\n11\nTHE COURT REPORTER:\n11:41:16\n\"Are you aware that\n11:41:39\n12\n13\n14\n15\nyears before December of 2014, when the CVRA\npleading was filed, that your name had come up\nrepeatedly in connection with Jeffrey Epstein's\nabuse of minors, correct?\"\n16\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, asked and answered\n11:41:41\n17\nseveral times. Go ahead.\n18\nA. I have answered that question.\nIf you\n11:41:45\n19\nwould like, I will answer it again.\n20\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n11:41:50\n21\nQ. I would like an answer to that question.\n11:41:50\n22\nA.\nI am aware\n11:41:51\n23\nQ.\nSeems to me it calls for yes or no\n11:41:52\n24\nresponse.\n25\nA.\nIt does not\n11:41:54\nEFTA00601250\n", "char_count": 1028}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "98\n1\nQ.\n2\nMR. SCOTT:\nYes, I am aware that my name is\n11:41:55\nAgain, I object to\nI'm not\n11:41:57\n3\n41\n5\ntrying to get into a fight with you, Jack, but\nI object to the comments, you know. Really\njust let him answer the question.\n69\nMR. SCAROLA: You and I don't need to\n11:42:02\nfight.\n00\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\nA.\nMR. SCOTT: I agree.\nThe word \"in connection\" is what requires\na longer answer. Yes, I am aware that it was\nfalsely alleged by you that multiple witnesses had\nplaced me at places and scenes where multiple\nvictims had been abused by Jeffrey Epstein. That\nstatement by you, Mr. Scarola, was a false\nstatement. It is not true that multiple witnesses\nhave said that. And you misstated that.\n11:42:05\n11:42:04\n17\nI am aware that there were false\n11:42:35\n18\n19\nallegations that I was a witness but never a\nparticipant in any improper conduct. And I\n20\ncategorically responded in letters to you, and to\n21\n22\nMr. Edwards, I think, that there was no truth to\nthat. That if any witness had so testified, they\n23\nwould be committing perjury.\n24\nMR. SCAROLA: You have requested a break.\n25\n25\nMR. SCOTT: Let's do it. Good point.\n11:43:04\n11:43:06\nEFTA00601251\n", "char_count": 1165}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "99\n11:43:07\n1\nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The\n2\ntime is approximately 11:43 a.m.\n3\n(Recess was held from 11:43 a.m. until 12:02 p.m.)\n11:43:11\n4\nVIDEOGRAPHER:\nGoing back on the record.\n12:02:12\n5\nThe time is approximately 12:02 p.m.\n6\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:02:16\n7\nQ. Have we completely covered the content of\n12:02:17\n8\nphone call number 2?\n9\nA. To my best of my recollection, yes.\n10\n11\nQ. Okay. Let's go to the very next\ncommunication between you and either Rebecca or\n12:02:22\n12:02:25\n12\nMichael.\n13\n14\nA. My recollection is that I asked them if\nthey had anything else that they were aware of, any\n15 other information, I asked her whether she had been\n12:02:37\n16\nin touch with\nI think in the\n17\nthird conversation we also talked about the charity.\n18\nAnd she agreed.\n19\nQ.\n20\nI'm sorry, I need to stop you for a just a 12:03:01\nmoment. Who contacted whom and when?\n21\nA.\n22\n23\n24\nI think I contacted them. Normally the\nprocedure was I speak to Michael, he would pick up\nthe phone, I only had his number. I only had his\nphone number, not hers.\n12:03:08\n25\nQ.\nSo this was the third phone call initiated 12:03:18\nEFTA00601252\n", "char_count": 1135}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "1\n21\n3\nby you?\nA.\nBy me to the best of my recollection.\n12:03:22\nI called him and he would always be the\n12:03:23\n41\nkind of gatekeeper and often she was putting the\n5 babies to sleep, and sometimes she couldn't come to\n6\n7\n8\nthe phone. The third conversation, substantive\nconversation\n--\nthere may have been conversations\nwhere I called and Michael wasn't there or I left a\n100\n10\n11\nwould\n9\nmessage, or where Michael was there but she was\nputting the babies to sleep and either she said they\neither he said they would call me back or I\n12\ncalled them back.\n13\nBut the third substantive conversation, to\n12:03:48\n14\nthe best\n15\nQ.\nWhere were you?\n12:03:51\n16\nA.\nHuh?\n12:03:52\n17\nQ.\nWhere were you when you\n12:03:53\n18\nA.\n19\nQ.\n--\n20\n20\nA.\nProbably\ninitiated this call?\nProbably in Massachusetts at this point.\n12:03:54\n12:03:55\n12:03:55\n21\nAnd then\nwe discussed the charity. And\n12:04:04\n22\nI think it was called\n23\n24\ndon't know,\nwhich is her initials,\nand also it stood for something, I\nor something like that.\n25\nAnd she said that the lawyers had contributed\nEFTA00601253\n", "char_count": 1076}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n$80,000 of their own money to start the charity.\nShe didn't indicate which lawyers. But the lawyers\nhad contributed $80,000 of their own money to start\n5 charity by contribution from Leslie\nthe charity and that they were going to fund the\nfrom the man\n6\nfrom Columbus who owned Victoria's Secret and they\n7\nexpected a very substantial contribution.\n8\nThey also said that\n12:05:02\n9\nQ.\nI'm sorry, but \"they\" is not helpful to\n12:05:04\n10\nme.\n11\nA.\nShe\nwhen I say \"they\"\nwhen I talk\n12:05:07\n12\nabout the substance, I'm always talking about her.\n13\nI never had any conversations about the substance\n14\nwith him.\n15\nShe said that they were hoping to fund the 12:05:17\n16\ncharity by substantial contribution from Leslie\n17\n18\n19\n20\nWexner and that they thought that by getting on\ntelevision, they would increase the chances of\nraising this money from Leslie Wexner.\nAnd that she thought they had already made\ncontact with Wexner and that they had already\n--\nwith the man from Columbus, and they had\nalready made contact with ABC. But I don't think\n21\n22\nmade\n23\n24\nshe knew at that point whether the actual interviews\n25\ndid or did not occur. Oh, she did tell me that she\n12:05:37\n101\nEFTA00601254\n", "char_count": 1202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "Q.\n\"She\" who?\n1\n2\nwent to New York at some point for the interviews.\n12:06:04\n3\nA.\nShe, Rebecca, told me that\nhad\n12:06:05\n4\ngone to New York and so she assumed that she was\n5\ninto New York for the interviews.\n6\nQ.\nSo this was a conversation that you\n12:06:17\n7\nassumed took place after\nwas\n8\ninterviewed in New York?\n9\nA.\nI don't know. I don't know.\n12:06:25\n10\nQ.\nThat's what you were told?\n12:06:26\n11\nA.\nNo. I was told that she was in New York.\n12:06:27\n12\nI'm just giving you the facts, sir.\n13\nQ. Okay. Any other information exchanged\n12:06:31\n14\nbetween you and Rebecca and/or Michael during the\n15\nthird conversation?\n16\nA. I can't recall during the third\n12:06:44\n17\nconversation any further information that was\n18\nexchanged, no.\n19\nQ. Did you place that phone call on a\n12:06:50\n20\nlandline or cell phone?\n21\nA.\nI don't remember.\n12:06:54\n22\nQ.\nDo you have a landline in New York?\n12:06:58\n23\nA.\nI do.\n12:07:00\n22\n24\nQ.\nDo you have a landline in Massachusetts?\n12:07:01\n25\nA.\nYes.\n12:07:05\n102\nEFTA00601255\n", "char_count": 1018}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "1\nQ.\nWhat's the next communication that you had\n12:07:07\n2\nwith Rebecca and/or Michael?\nWhen did it occur?\n3\nA.\nI don't recall. I don't recall. I know\n12:07:16\n41\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\nwe had further communications. They were mostly\nrepetitions and I have no specific recollection of\nAnd I was constantly\nwhen -- when they occurred.\nsaying to her, can I you know, are you feeling\ncomfortable about being public with this? And she\nkept saying no.\nQ. Were there any more substantive\ncommunications that occurred between you and Rebecca\nand/or Michael?\nA. I would say that none that gave me new\ninformation.\nI would constantly ask them, you know,\nto reiterate has anything changed, have you changed\nyour mind, have you remembered anything new. But\nbasically what I've told you was the substance of\n18\nthe information: A, that she didn't ever mention\n19\nme; B, that she was pressured into mentioning me by\n20\nher lawyers; C, that she was going to raise a\n21 billion dollars or half of the net worth of the guy\n22\nfrom Columbus, Ohio.\n12:07:47\n12:07:54\n23\n24\nAnd the next, that she was going to be\ninterviewed by ABC in an effort to make it clear\n12:08:25\n25 that she had, A, credibility, that ABC would give\n103\nEFTA00601256\n", "char_count": 1233}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "104\n1\nher credibility, and that that would help her in her\n2 efforts to obtain money from her\nI think at some\n3\npoint she also mentioned that she would go after\n4\nother people that she hadn't yet named in an effort\n5\nto obtain money from them as well.\n6\nQ. Did you ever directly ask Rebecca if\n12:08:58\n7\nhad admitted that she had never met\n8\nyou?\n9\nA.\nNo.\n12:09:08\n10\nQ. Did you ever\nwell, why not? Why didn't\n12:09:09\n11\nyou ask that question?\n12\nA. I just\n13\nObjection.\n14\n15\nMR. SCOTT:\nA. I just wanted to get her to tell me what\nshe was going to tell me. I was very satisfied with\n12:09:15\nGo ahead.\n12:09:13\n12:09:15\n16\n17\nher answers. There were a lot of questions I could\nhave asked. I had to treat her very gently. I\n18\nwanted to keep her on the phone for as short a\n19\nperiod of time as possible. I didn't want to be\n20\nperceived as in any way harassing her.\nAnd so I\n21\ndidn't ask that question directly.\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n23\nQ. Well, certainly one of the most\n12:09:41\n12:09:41\n24\n25\nwas: Did\nsignificant questions that you could have asked her\never admit she never met me?\nEFTA00601257\n", "char_count": 1100}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "1\n2\nit?\n3\nThat would be pretty significant, wouldn't 12:09:52\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form,\n12:09:55\n4\nargumentative.\n5\nA. What I asked her was to please recall\n12:09:57\n6\neverything that\nhad said to her.\n7\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:10:00\n8\nQ.\nYes, sir. But that's not my question to\n12:10:00\n9\nyou.\n10\nA.\nI didn't\n--\n12:10:02\n11\nQ.\n12\nIt would have been very significant had\never said, I never met Alan\n12:10:03\n13\nDershowitz, right?\n14\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, argumentative. Go\n12:10:10\n15\nahead.\n16\nA. It wouldn't have been significant to me\n12:10:11\n17\nbecause I know that\nnever met Alan\n18\nDershowitz. It would have been significant to me if\n19\nshe could have so testified.\nBut I didn't want to\n20\n21\nin any way turn off her as a source of information.\nAnd so I didn't ask her very many questions at all.\n22\n23\nI wanted her to tell me her best recollection\nunprompted and unquestioned.\n24\nI didn't want to subject her to a series\n12:10:37\n25\nof examination questions.\nI wanted her to tell\n105\nEFTA00601258\n", "char_count": 1000}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "106\n1\nme\nfor example, the whole thing about the guy\n2\nfrom Columbus, I didn't know anything about that.\n3\nShe just said that in the course of conversing with\n4\n5\nme and led me to conclude that there was an\nextortion plot.\n6\n7\nI had actually believed there was an\nextortion plot from the very beginning and said\n12:10:52\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\nthat. But I had no real knowledge about who the\nultimate object of the extortion plot was until I\nwas able to confirm with Leslie Wexner's people\nthat, in fact, overtures been made to him at about\nthe same time as my name was publicly and falsely\nrevealed. So it all fit together.\n14\n15\nAnd my own view is that a prosecutor would\nlook very, very harshly at the sequence of events\n12:11:21\n16\nthat occurred in this case and might welcome the\n17\nconclusion that there was a criminal extortion plot.\n18\nWhich is my belief.\n19\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:11:37\n20\nQ. Well, we know you never made a Bar\n12:11:37\n21\ncomplaint.\n22\nA.\nHuh-huh.\n12:11:39\n23\nDid you ever file a criminal complaint\n12:11:39\n24\nagainst any of these extortionists or perjury\n25 suborners?\nEFTA00601259\n", "char_count": 1099}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "107\n1\nA.\nWe actually talked about that. And\n12:11:47\n2\nQ.\nWho's the \"we\"?\n12:11:50\n3\n41\n3\nMR. SIMPSON:\nDon't disclose any\n12:11:53\nTHE WITNESS:\nOkay\n12:11:53\n5\nMR. SIMPSON:\nlawyer-client\n12:11:54\n6\nA.\nI had conversations about that with\n12:11:55\n7 appropriate persons, yes.\nAnd I discussed it with\n8\nWexner's lawyers.\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:12:07\n10\nQ. Are you answering yes to my question that\n12:12:08\n11\nyou have filed a criminal complaint?\n12\nA.\nNot yet.\n13\nQ.\n14\nOkay. So it has been ten months since you\nallegedly became aware of that suborning of perjury\n12:12:12\n12:12:14\n15\n16\n17\nand some eight months since your allegedly having\nbecome aware of the extortion plot, but you have\nfiled no criminal complaints against anyone,\n18\ncorrect?\n19\n20\n21\nA. To answer that question requires me to\ndisclose conversations I had with David Boies.\nwould love to answer that question.\n12:12:40\nH\n22\nQ. No, sir, it does not.\n12:12:48\n24\n22\n25\n25\n23\nA. Yes, it does.\n12:12:49\nMR. SCOTT: Whoa, you can't\n--\nhow can you\n12:12:49\nsay\n--\nEFTA00601260\n", "char_count": 1037}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "108\n1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:12:51\n21\nQ.\nWhether you filed a criminal complaint or\n12:12:51\n3\nnot.\n4\nA.\nYes, it does.\n12:12:52\n5\nMR. SCOTT: Please, Jack, he can't say\n12:12:53\n6\nthat.\n7\nA.\nIt does involve conversation I had with\n12:12:54\n8\n00\nDavid Boies.\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:12:57\n10\nQ. Well, in that case, in light of the fact\n12:12:57\n11\nthat that is a matter that will be addressed by the\n12\nCourt, we'll save that question for another time.\n13\nA.\nI'm anxious to answer it.\n12:13:05\n14\nQ.\nAnd I'm anxious to get an answer.\n12:13:09\n15\nA.\nWell, I hope we can agree I should be able\n12:13:10\n16\nto answer it.\n17\nQ. Have we exhausted your recollection of the\n12:13:20\n18\ndetails of conversations that you had with Rebecca\n19\nand Michael?\n20\nA. About the substance of what she told me.\n12:13:27\n21\n22\nThere were many conversations involving would she do\nthis, would she do that. But the conversations, the\n23\nsubstance we've exhausted.\n24\nQ.\nOkay.\nWell\n--\n12:13:40\n25\nA.\nThat is A, B, C, D, E, as I said, those\n--\n12:13:40\nEFTA00601261\n", "char_count": 1033}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "109\n1\nthose are what I've told you is the substance, the\n2\ndetails of what she said. And she said nothing\n3\ndifferent or new, to my recollection, in any of the\n4\n5\n6\nbrief subsequent conversations that we may have had.\nQ.\ndisclosed her full name?\nWhich phone call was it when she finally\n12:14:01\n7\nA.\nNot the first. It was either the second\n12:14:19\n8\nor the third conversation.\nProbably the second\n9\nconversation. First I got his name and I checked\n10\n11\n12\nhim out, checked on Google to make sure that he was\nwho he says he was and lived where he lived. And\nthen she gave me her name.\n13\n14\nQ. So, when you say you checked Michael out,\nwhat you did is you Googled him; is that right?\n12:14:39\n15\n16\nA. I just Googled him to see that he lived in\nthe place where he lived and was\n12:14:43\n17\nQ. Okay. Did you do any other background\n12:14:46\n18\ninformation?\n19\n--\n20\nA. Well, I was no, I was obviously\nconcerned that maybe I was being set up by your\n12:14:49\n21\nclients. And so I wanted to be sure that this\n22\n23\nwasn't a setup, that this was an honorable person,\nwhich is why I asked my wife also to listen to\n24\nthe\n--\nI think it was the second conversation.\nAnd\n25\nshe concluded that she sounded completely honest,\nEFTA00601262\n", "char_count": 1233}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "1\n2\ntrustworthy and and anxious just to say exactly\nand precisely what happened. And so I became\n3\nconvinced that she was authentic and not\nnot a\n4\nsetup.\n5\nQ.\nOkay. So, in order to investigate\n6 Michael, you Googled him but did nothing else?\n12:15:26\n7\nA.\nThat's all. To my recollection, that's\n12:15:32\n8\nall I did is Google him.\n9\nQ. But you also relied upon both your and\n12:15:35\n10\nyour wife's personal assessment of the credibility\n11\nof these people; is that right?\n12\nA.\nAbsolutely. That's right, yes.\n12:15:44\n13\nQ. A skill that you've developed over the\n12:15:46\n14\ncourse of your years of practice, right?\n15\nMR. SCOTT: Objection.\nGo ahead.\n12:15:52\n16\n17\nA. I just relied on it.\ndon't know how good I am at it.\nI mean, I'm not\n--\nI\n12:15:52\nBut some people are\n18\n19\n20\n21\nvery good liars. But I believed her. That was my\njudgment.\nMy wife, who is a, you know, Ph.D.\nneuropsychologist with a lot of experience, we all\n12:16:06\n22\nthought she sounded\n--\nwe both thought she sounded\n23\nincredibly truthful.\n24\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:16:16\n25\n25\nQ. But was it all or was it both?\n12:16:17\n110\nEFTA00601263\n", "char_count": 1112}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "111\n1\nA.\nJust both, just the two of us.\n12:16:19\n2\nQ.\nYou and your wife?\n12:16:20\n3\n3\nA.\nJust me and my wife, yeah.\n12:16:21\n4\nQ.\nSo\n--\n12:16:24\n5\nA.\nMy wife is southern, so I'm used to the\n12:16:24\n6\nphrase \"all.\"\n7\nQ. You relied upon your personal assessment\n12:16:27\n8\nof\n9\nA.\nThat's right.\n12:16:30\n10\nQ.\nRebecca's credibility?\n12:16:30\n11\nA.\nThat's right.\n12:16:32\n12\nQ. And you relied upon your wife's assessment\n12:16:33\n13\nof Rebecca's credibility?\n14\nA.\nThat's right.\n12:16:37\n15\nQ.\nAnd did you do any further investigation\n12:16:38\n16\nof her?\n17\nA.\nNo.\nWell, yes, of course, I corroborated\n12:16:44\n18\neverything she said by talking to Leslie Wexner's\n19\nwife, talking to Leslie Wexner's lawyers, talking to\n20\nABC, and finding out that everything she said to me\n21\nwas absolutely true, yes.\n22\nQ. Well, the one thing that you didn't\n12:17:01\n23 corroborate was anything that\n24\nallegedly said to her about you?\n25\nA. Of course I did. Of course I did.\n12:17:10\nEFTA00601264\n", "char_count": 984}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "1\nQ.\nHow did you do that?\n2\nA.\nI corroborated what\n12:17:12\nsaid, 12:17:13\n3\nthat she was\nwas going to sue Leslie\nshe was\n4\ngoing to go after Leslie Wexner to try to get a lot\n5\nof money\n6\nQ. Let me make sure you understand my\n12:17:26\n7\nquestion.\n8\nA.\nYeah. Yeah.\n12:17:27\n9\nQ. Okay?\nYou have corroborated surrounding\n12:17:28\n10\ncircumstances\n11\nA.\nRight.\n12\nQ.\n--\nrelated to you by Rebecca?\n13\nA.\nRight.\nRight.\n14\nQ. You did not corroborate anything that\n15\nRebecca told you about what\n12:17:36\n12:17:36\n12:17:40\n12:17:41\nsaid\n16\nregarding you personally, correct?\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\nA. Of course I did. No, of course I did. I\ncorroborated it by my absolute firm and complete and\nunequivocal knowledge that your clients' allegations\nagainst me and\nme were totally and completely false and completely\n12:17:53\nallegations against\n22\nmade up.\nSo I knew that. That knowledge\n23\ncorroborated her statements.\n24\nQ. Well, the statement that you have related\n12:18:14\n25\nis that Rebecca said\nwas pressured\n112\nEFTA00601265\n", "char_count": 1015}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "1\ninto naming you\n2\nA.\nThere were\n12:18:24\n3\n3\nQ.\ncorrect?\n12:18:25\n41\nA.\nNo, there were two statements. One that\n12:18:26\n5\nnever mentioned me in connection\n6\nwith anybody that she had any sexual contact with.\n7\nI knew that was true. Your clients know that that\n8\nis false. And me knowing it's true served to\n9\ncorroborate that statement by her.\n10\nQ. How could you possibly know whether\n12:18:45\n11\never mentioned your name before\n12\nDecember of 2014?\n13\nA.\nBecause it was false and because she would\n12:18:54\n14\nnot have mentioned my name until her lawyers\n15\npressured her into doing it because I had no contact\n16 with her.\n17\nQ.\nDo you have a copy of the statement that\n12:19:11\n18\nmade to the FBI?\n19\nA.\nI don't have it here, no.\n12:19:16\n20\nQ.\nHave you seen it?\n12:19:17\n21\nA.\nHer statement to the FBI?\n12:19:20\n22\nQ.\nYes.\n12:19:22\n23\nA.\nNo, but I do know that she never told the\n12:19:23\n24\nFBI anything about me whatsoever.\nBecause I was\n25\ntold that by Jeffrey Sloman, who was the assistant\n113\nEFTA00601266\n", "char_count": 1019}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "1\nUnited States attorney in charge of this case.\n2\n3\n4\nJeffrey Sloman said he was prepared to file a sworn\naffidavit that my name never came up, period, during\nany investigation whatsoever, and that if my name\n5\nhad in any way come up, I would not have been\n6\nallowed to participate in the negotiations because I\n7\nwould have had a conflict of interest.\n8\nJeffrey Sloman said that to me and to\n9\n10\n11\n12\nother people and tried very hard to get the Justice\nDepartment to allow him to file an affidavit\nasserting that. So I know it's true. And I know\nit's false what you're alleging; namely, that she\nsaid she had sex with me or implying that to the\n12:19:55\n13\n14\nFBI.\n15\n16\nIf she did, she's committed yet an\nadditional crime, 1001, by lying to an FBI agent,\n12:20:14\n17\nwhich if she did I'd like to know about that because\n18\nI'd like to then file a formal complaint with the\n19\nFBI about that, or with the Justice Department.\n20\nI recommend that you speak to Jeffrey\n12:20:33\n21\nSloman.\n22\nQ. You know that\nis not the\n12:20:35\n23\nonly person who has sworn under oath that you were\n24 present at Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach home with\n25\nyoung girls, right?\n114\nEFTA00601267\n", "char_count": 1177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "1\nA.\nNo.\n12:20:54\n2\nQ.\nYou don't know that?\n12:20:55\n3\n41\n3\nA.\nNo.\nI know that\n12:20:57\nQ.\nWell, that's fine. You've answered my\n12:20:59\n5\nquestion.\nThat's not something you know?\n6\nA. A, I was not present in Jeffrey Epstein's\n12:21:02\n7\nhome with any underage young women, period. Never,\n8\never under any circumstances.\n9\n10\nB, I am not aware that anyone has sworn\nunder oath that I was there during the relevant\n12:21:12\n11\n12\nperiods of time, which is a three-year period\nbetween the summer of 1999 and the summer of 2002.\n13\nBecause I was never\nas far as I know, I was never\n14\nin Jeffrey Epstein's home during that period of\n15\ntime, period.\n16\nQ.\nI want to go back to the Ashes, if I\n12:21:36\n17\ncould.\nJoanne Ashe is not a lawyer, is she?\n18\nA.\nJoanne Ashe is not a lawyer, no.\n12:21:42\n19\nQ.\nAnd is Alexi Ashe a lawyer?\n12:21:44\n20\nA.\nYes.\n12:21:46\n21\nQ.\nHas Alexi Ashe ever been your lawyer?\n12:21:49\n22\nA.\nI have discussed the case with Alexi Ashe.\n12:21:53\n23\nShe is a full-time sex trafficking prosecutor whose\n24 whole career has been going after sex traffickers in\n25\nthe Brooklyn District Attorney's office and I have\n115\nEFTA00601268\n", "char_count": 1151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "1\ndiscussed my case with her.\n2\nQ.\nHas Alexi Ashe ever been your lawyer?\n12:22:09\n3\nA.\nI would say not, no.\n12:22:11\n41\nQ.\nBeginning approximately January 3 or 4 of\n12:22:23\n5\n2015, you began a mass media campaign battle against\n6 Bradley Edwards and Professor Paul Cassell alleging\n7\nthat they were sleazy, unethical lawyers who\n8\nfabricated false charges against you, correct?\n9\nA.\nThat's a false\n12:22:46\n10\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, argumentative, mass\n12:22:46\n11\nmedia, et cetera.\n12\nA.\nThat's a false statement.\n12:22:46\n13\nI did not begin. It was your clients who\n12:22:49\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\nbegan it.\nstatements in a federal court which the judge struck\nand sanctioned them for as being irrelevant and\npertinent and he used other language.\nThey began it. It is my belief that they\nbegan it in order to get massive press attention to\nYour clients began it by filing false\n12:23:10\ncalled me, the press called me immediately and asked\n19\n20\nit. And my\n--\nmy responses were when the press\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nme for my reaction. I was totally shocked that any\nlawyer would make these kinds of outrageous\ncareer-destroying allegations without even calling\nme and asking me if I would deny it or have any\n116\nEFTA00601269\n", "char_count": 1213}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "1\nevidence to provide for them.\n2\nAnd when I was called by the media, I did\n12:23:47\n3\nwhat you would do, Mr. Scarola, or what your clients\n4\nwould do, I defended myself. What any American\n5\n6 denied career-destroying false statements and I told\nwould do under the First Amendment, I categorically\n7\nthe truth, which is what the United States\n8\nConstitution is all about and why we fought for\n9\nliberty. Yes, I told the truth to the media.\n10\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:24:10\n11\n12\nQ. You engaged in a mass media campaign to\nconvince the world that Bradley Edwards and\n12:24:11\n13\nProfessor Paul Cassell were unethical lawyers who\n14\n15\n12:24:30\n12:24:31\n16\n17\n18\n19\n21\n22\nhad fabricated false charges against you, correct?\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, argumentative.\nA.\nNo, that's not correct. I responded to\npress inquiries by telling the truth. My goal was\nto let the world know that\nallegations against me were totally false. These\n20 stories appeared, as far as I can tell, in every\nsingle newspaper in the world and on every media,\nwhich was part of their plot and the plan of your\n23 clients, which is why they absurdly mentioned\n24 Prince Andrew, claiming in the most absurd way\nthat they mentioned him because he was trying to\n25\n117\nEFTA00601270\n", "char_count": 1241}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 117, "text_content": "1\nlobby prosecutors to get a reduced sentence for\n2 Jeffrey Epstein, they obviously put Prince Andrew in\n3\nthere in order to get massive publicity around the\n4\nworld. And every media in the world practically\n5\ncalled me from the BBC, to CBS, to ABC, to CNN and I\n6\nresponded to lies with the truth.\n7\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:25:26\n8\nQ.\nAnd the truth that you attempted to convey\n12:25:27\n9\nwas that Bradley Edwards and Professor Paul Cassell\n10\nwere unethical lawyers who fabricated false charges\n11 against you, right?\n12\nA.\nThe truth\n12:25:42\n13\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, form.\n12:25:43\n14\nA.\nThe truth that I intended to convey was\n12:25:44\n15\nthat the charges against me were false and\n16\nfabricated, that I never had any sexual contact\n17\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:25:52\n18\nQ.\nFabricated by whom, sir?\n12:25:52\n19\nA.\nPlease don't interrupt me.\n12:25:54\n20\n20\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, interrupting.\n12:25:55\n21\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:25:55\n22\n22\nQ.\nPlease answer the question.\n12:25:55\n23\nA.\nPlease don't interrupt\n--\n12:25:56\n24\nMR. SCOTT: He's answering them. You may\n12:25:57\n25\nnot like the answer, but he's answering them.\n118\nEFTA00601271\n", "char_count": 1126}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 118, "text_content": "119\n1\nA. Now you've\nyou've made me lose my train\n12:26:02\n2\nof thought, so\n3\nMR. SCOTT: Can you read the question back\n12:26:05\n4\nand the\n--\nread the question back and his\n5\nanswers, please.\n69\n8\n00\n9\n10\n11\n12\n12:26:08\n12:26:08\n(Requested portion read back.)\nTHE COURT REPORTER: The question was:\n\"And the truth that you attempted to convey was\nthat Bradley Edwards and Professor Paul Cassell\nwere unethical lawyers who fabricated false\ncharges against you, right?\"\nAnd the answer was: \"The truth that I\nintended to convey was that the charges against\n12:26:08\n13\n14\n15\nany sexual contact\"\nme were false and fabricated, that I never had\nand then the question\n16\nwas\n--\nthe answer was interrupted.\n17\nA. Okay. Let me continue. That I never had\n18\nany sexual contact with\nbecause\n19\nProfessor Cassell insisted on conveying to the\n20\npublic that he was a former judge and that he was a\nprofessor and that he was using, improperly in my\n12:26:42\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nview, the stationery and name of his university to\nadd credibility to his claims, I felt that it was\nimperative for me to indicate that he was engaging\nin improper and unethical conduct.\nEFTA00601272\n", "char_count": 1157}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 119, "text_content": "1\n2\nIt would have been improper for me to have\nallowed his use of his credibility as a former\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\nfederal judge, as a professor who uses, misuses his\nuniversity imprimatur, it was very important for me\nto attack the credibility of the messengers of the\nfalse information.\nAnd it was important for me to also remind\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\nthe public that Bradley Edwards was a partner of\nRothstein, a man who is spending 50 years in jail\nfor fraudulently creating a Ponzi scheme to sell\nJeffrey Epstein cases that didn't exist. Yes, it\nwas very important for me to indicate the back\nthe real backgrounds of these lawyers and to make\n12:27:18\n12:27:43\n14\n15\nsure that the public didn't believe that because\nthey were credible, their story must be credible.\n16\nIn fact, one of the first questions that I 12:28:22\n17\nwas asked repeatedly by the media is: Why would a\n18\nformer federal judge level a false charge against\n19\nyou? Why would a distinguished personal injury\n20\nlawyer level a false charge against you?\n21\nAnd it was important for me to indicate\n12:28:36\n22\nwhy they would, that they were trying to do it for\n23 crass financial reasons, they were trying to do it\n24\nto open up a non-prosecution agreement, they were\n25 trying to do it for reasons that were improper.\n120\nEFTA00601273\n", "char_count": 1290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 120, "text_content": "121\n1\nSo, yes, I did\n--\nyou know, Mr. Edwards,\n12:28:55\n2\nyour client, is shaking his head, but when he's\n3\ndeposed under oath, he's not going to be able to\n4\nsimply shake his head. He's going to have to answer\n5 specific and direct questions.\n6\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:29:11\n7\nQ.\nLet me try my question.\n12:29:12\n8\nDid you charge Bradley Edwards and\n12:29:16\n9\nProfessor Paul Cassell in your mass media\n10\nappearances with fabricating false charges against\n11\nyou?\n12\n13\n14\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form.\nA. My media appearances were largely in\nresponse to media requests of me. I did not conduct\n12:29:29\n12:29:33\n15\na media campaign. The object of my speaking to the\n16\n17\nmedia was to respond to their questions. Their\nquestions were, number 1, did you ever have any\n18\nsexual contact with\n? And I\n19\nunequivocally stated no.\n20\nI stated that I knew there were no videos\n12:30:01\n21\nor photographs because the event didn't occur. I\n22 stated that I would submit a sworn affidavit, which\n23\nin effect waived the statute of limitations. I\n24 stated unequivocally that I was innocent of those\n25\nfalse charges.\nEFTA00601274\n", "char_count": 1117}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 121, "text_content": "1\nI was then asked by the media, well, why\nwould somebody who is a former federal judge and\n12:30:29\n2\n3\n4\nprofessor at a law school make these false charges?\n5\nI responded to those questions. Why would somebody\nlike a distinguished personal injury lawyer make\n6 those false charges? And I responded to those\n7\nquestions. And everything I said was the truth as I\n8\nbelieved it to be at the time.\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:30:55\n10\nQ. Do you remember the question that was\n12:30:57\n11\nasked of you?\n12\nA.\nYes, I've answered it.\n12:30:58\n13\nQ.\nWhat was the question?\n12:31:00\n14\nA.\nAs part of massive media campaign, did I\n12:31:03\n15\n16\n17\ncharge your clients with deliberately falsifying a\ncharge against me, and my answer satisfies that\nquestion.\n18\n19\nQ. No, I don't think it does. Can you tell\nus whether that's what you did, did you charge\n12:31:18\n--\n20\nA.\nI just did.\n21\nQ.\n--\nthem with having intentionally\n12:31:22\n12:31:23\n22\nfabricated false charges against you?\n23\n24\nA. I believe that they intentionally\nfabricated false evidence against me. I believe\n12:31:28\n25 that they pressured their client into fabricating\n122\nEFTA00601275\n", "char_count": 1138}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 122, "text_content": "123\n1\nfalse evidence against me. I believe that they\n2\nhelped to draft a perjurious affidavit that was\n3\n4\n5\n6\nfiled in court, after they knew that I said I could\nprove that I couldn't have been there four of the\nfive places that the alleged acts could have\noccurred.\n7\nI believe that when they recently sought\n12:31:59\n8\n9\n10\n11\nto submit an additional claim repeating these\ncharges into the federal court, that they did it\nknowing full well that these charges were false.\nThat's my belief, yes.\n12\n13\nQ. Are you aware that your lawyers filed a\npleading on your behalf in this case with the title\n12:32:14\n14\nDefendant Alan M. Dershowitz's Answer to the\n15\nComplaint and Counterclaim?\n16\nA.\nI'm not aware of that.\n12:32:23\n17\nQ.\nPardon me?\n12:32:24\n18\nA.\nI'm not aware of the title of any legal\n12:32:25\n19\npleadings.\n20\nQ.\nDo you know that an answer has been filed\n12:32:28\n21\nto the defamation action that has been brought\n22\nagainst you?\n23\nA.\nOf course. I mean,\nI'm sure there's been\n12:32:34\n24\na legal answer prepared.\nOf course, that's what\n25\nlawyers do.\nEFTA00601276\n", "char_count": 1077}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 123, "text_content": "1\nQ.\nAre you aware that there's also a\n2 counterclaim that has been filed on your behalf?\n124\n12:32:40\n3\nA.\nYes, I authorized the counterclaim to be\n12:32:43\n4\nfiled because I believe that your clients defamed me\n5\nand that Mr. Cassell wrote a letter to ABC, which\n6\n7\nwhich asserts that I had\nnot even plausibly is within the claim of privilege,\nasserts falsely and in a\n8\n00\ndefamatory way that I had had sexual contact with\n9\nyes.\n10\nQ. Did you read the answer to the complaint\n12:33:06\n11\nand counterclaim\n12\nA.\nI'm sure I did.\n12:33:10\n13\nQ.\n--\nbefore it was filed?\n12:33:11\n14\nA.\nI'm sure I did.\n12:33:11\n15\nQ.\nAnd I assume that you approved of it,\n12:33:13\n16\ncorrect?\n17\nA.\nI assume I did, yes.\n12:33:17\n18\nQ.\nOkay.\n12:33:18\n19\nMR. SCOTT: I object to anything as far as\n12:33:20\n20\nusing pleadings like this, but go ahead and do\n21\nit.\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:33:23\n23\nQ. As a law professor, would it be fair for\n12:33:24\n24\nus to assume that you know the difference between\n25 simple negligence and recklessness?\nEFTA00601277\n", "char_count": 1033}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 124, "text_content": "1\nA. That's something that you could spend an\nentire semester teaching the difference between\n12:33:32\n125\n2\n3\nsimple negligence and recklessness.\nThat's very\n4\nmuch a matter of degree and the courts are\n-- are\n5\nsplit very much on what the meaning of\n6\n\"recklessness\" is, particularly in the context of\n7\ndefamation.\nIt's a very complicated subject.\n8\nQ. Do you personally recognize that there is\n12:33:51\n9\na difference between simple negligence and\n10\n11\nrecklessness?\nA.\nAt the extremes, yes, simple negligence is\n12:33:58\n12\nfailure to perform a duty and recklessness is\n13\nfailure to perform a duty knowing that there\n14 knowing or should know that there is a likelihood of\n15\nsome harm being committed.\nThat's just what I\n16\nremember from first year torts.\n17\nQ. And you do also recognize that there is a\n12:34:17\n18\ndistinction between simple negligence and\n19\n20\nrecklessness on one hand and intentional wrongdoing\non the other, correct?\n21\nA. Again, I've argued cases about this issue.\n12:34:27\n22\nAnd it's a continuum.\n23\nSometimes courts say \"that\nshould have known\" is the equivalent of \"knowing.\"\n24\nSo it's a continuum.\nThere's not an absolute\n25\nstraight line between those two, yeah.\nEFTA00601278\n", "char_count": 1214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 125, "text_content": "1\nQ.\n126\nWell, what are you charging Professor Paul\n12:34:48\n2\n3\n4\nCassell and Bradley Edwards with having done? Were\nthey negligent, reckless; or did they knowingly and\nwillfully fabricate false charges against you?\n5\nMR. SCOTT: Let me object to the form.\n12:35:11\n6\nIt's compound.\n7\n8\n00\n9\n10\nAnd, Professor, if you would like to\nreview the complaint and the counterclaim\nbefore you respond to that, you have the\nabsolute right to do that.\n12:35:13\n11\nTHE WITNESS:\nI'd like to do that, yes.\n12:35:21\n12\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:35:23\n13\nQ. Okay. Let me withdraw that question and\n12:35:23\n14\nlet me ask this question.\n15\nMR. SCOTT: My position, just so we\n12:35:26\n16\nunderstand, is\nand this is a legal\n17\nobjection\n--\nis that while I don't think you\n18\ncan use pleadings to cross-examine a witness,\n19\n20\n20\nif you're going to do it, he has the right to\nsee it, have it in front of him and respond to\n21\n21\n22\nit\nMR. SCAROLA:\nThat's why I was\n12:35:37\n23\nMR. SCOTT:\nas opposed to asking\n12:35:38\n22\n24\nquestions in the vagueness.\n25\nMR. SCAROLA: That's why I'm withdrawing\n12:35:40\nEFTA00601279\n", "char_count": 1092}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 126, "text_content": "1\n2\nthe question.\nMR. SCOTT: Thank you.\n3\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n41\nQ. What do you contend, independent of\n5 anything that may be in any pleadings, Bradley\n6 Edwards and Paul Cassell are responsible for,\n7 negligence, recklessness, or intentional and willful\n12:35:43\n12:35:43\n12:35:43\n8\nfabrication of lies?\n9\nA.\nLet me answer that question in full.\nIt\n12:36:02\n10\nis my belief as I sit here today that\n11\n12\n13\nnever accused me of having any sexual\ncontact with her because I never did have any sexual\ncontact with her. And that your clients, Edwards\n14\n15\nand Cassell, sat with her and said to her, look, if\nwe want to get the NPA knocked out, we have to find\n16\n17\n18\n19\na lawyer who worked on the NPA, but who you also had\nsexual contact with. The only lawyer who fits that\ndescription is Alan Dershowitz.\nThink back, think\nhard, did you ever have any sexual contact with Alan\n20\nDershowitz?\n21\n22\nAnd they pressured her into falsely\nstating something that they knew or should have\n12:36:48\n23\nknown was an absolute and deliberate lie. They\n24\ncould have easily found that out. They could have\n25 pressed her very hard on why she hadn't previously\n127\nEFTA00601280\n", "char_count": 1163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 127, "text_content": "128\n1\nnamed me. They could have pressed her very hard on\n2\ndates and times and specifics of where these alleged\n3\nacts could have occurred. And they didn't do that.\n4\nSo I think that it comes much closer to\n12:37:18\n5\nthe intentional side of the continuum than the\n6\nnegligence side of the continuum.\n7\n8\nQ. Well, you've described it earlier as\nsuborning perjury. That's absolutely intentional,\n12:37:35\n9\nisn't it?\n10\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection, argumentative,\n12:37:40\n11\nrepetitious. Go ahead, you can answer it.\n12\nA.\nI believe that when the time came to file\n12:37:44\n13\nthe affidavit in which she described six\n--\nat least\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\nsix alleged incidents of sexual misconduct with me,\nincluding having me standing next to Jeffrey Epstein\nwhile he was receiving oral sex, that they knew that\nthat was false. And that I believe that they\nprobably drafted the affidavit.\nthat is subornation of perjury, yes. A criminal\nAnd to my mind,\n20\nact.\n21\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:38:20\n22\nQ. They encouraged\nto make\n12:38:21\n23\nup lies about you and provided the details of those\n24\nlies to her?\n25\nA.\nNo, no\n12:38:30\nEFTA00601281\n", "char_count": 1121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 128, "text_content": "129\n12:38:32\n1\n2\n3\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, argumentative,\nrepetitious.\nA. I believe they encouraged\n12:38:33\n41\nto make up lies about me and\nand pressed her and\n5 asked her to put in details.\nShe would never on her\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\nown have come up with some of the details. They're\nabsurd details.\nI mean, it's very, very bad lawyering on\ntheir part, by the way. Very bad lawyering for\nhaving her put in details that were so clearly and\ndemonstrably false, such as, for example, meeting\nBill Clinton on the island. And they should have\nknown, by the way, when they put in an allegation\nagainst me that she had also said that she twice met\n12:38:49\n15\nAl Gore with his wife, once on an air\nonce on\n16\n17\nJeffrey Epstein's airplane and once on the island.\nAnd it is completely clear, and David\n12:39:21\n18\nBoies was the lawyer for\nfor Al Gore,\nas was\n--\n19\nas was I, we worked together on that case, that a\n20\nsimple phone call from\nfrom David Boies to\n21\nAl Gore would have established that they don't know\n22\neach other, that he's never been on the island,\n23\nnever been on his airplane.\nI made a simple phone call on day one and\n12:39:46\n24\n25 established that. So your clients could have easily\nEFTA00601282\n", "char_count": 1215}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 129, "text_content": "1\ndetermined that she just lied, lied, lied, lied.\nShe lied about Al Gore. She lied about Ehud Barak,\n2\n3\nshe lied about Bill Clinton.\nShe lied about many,\n4\nmany other people.\n5\n6\nThis is something that your clients could\neasily have found out about, but they closed their\n12:40:06\n7\neyes. They willfully blinded themself to a long\nhistory of lying by your client and willingly put in\n12\n13\n14\n15\n8\n9\nan affidavit that they knew would destroy my career,\nmy 50-year career which I worked so hard to build,\n11 coming from a poor background, with no college\n10\neducation, being the first member of my family to go\nto college, working so hard to build a career,\nhaving an unblemished personal life, and then they\nwillingly put in these false allegations without\n16\nchecking.\nShame on them.\n17\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:40:49\n18\nQ.\nDuring the period of time between 1998 and\n12:40:50\n19\n2002, you owned a home in the Cambridge area,\n20\ncorrect?\n21\nA.\nYes.\n12:41:04\n22\nQ.\nSingle-family home in a residential area?\n12:41:04\n23\nA.\nYes.\n12:41:07\n24\nQ. Would you please describe the exterior of\n12:41:07\n25\nthat home to us?\n130\nEFTA00601283\n", "char_count": 1125}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 130, "text_content": "131\n1\nA.\nYes. It was wooden home, built by an\n12:41:12\n2\n3\n4\none side. It had a swimming pool\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\narchitect named Coolidge.\nhoop where I played basketball with my children on\nan indoor\nswimming pool on the other side. The exterior was\ngray/blue wood.\nQ. If someone were to enter through the front\ndoor of your home, would they see some sort of stone\nconfiguration outside the house?\n12:41:41\nHad a little basketball\n--\n10\nA.\nAfter a period of time, we had a\n12:41:56\n11\nsculpture\n--\na sculptor from Martha's Vineyard make\n12\na stone sculpture and a light that stood outside of\n13\nour house. You can probably see that on Google.\n14\nQ. When\nwhen was that stone sculpture\n12:42:10\n15\ninstalled?\n16\nA. I would have to check. I don't know. But\n12:42:16\n17\nanybody can see that on Google Maps.\n18\nMR. SCOTT: Let me object to the relevancy\n12:42:20\n19\nof all this.\n20\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:42:23\n21\nQ.\nDescribe the floor plan at the entry level\n12:42:24\n22\nof the house, please.\n23\nMR. SCOTT: Can you make a proffer as to\n12:42:26\n24\nwhat the relevancy to this is?\n25\n25\nMR. SCAROLA: Not until after I get the\n12:42:29\nEFTA00601284\n", "char_count": 1128}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 131, "text_content": "1\nquestions answered.\n2\nA. You walk into the house, and there's a\n12:42:33\n3\nfoyer that extends probably about 6-foot wide and\n4\nmaybe 20 feet long. Yeah. Yeah.\n5\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:42:58\n6\nQ.\nIs there a kitchen at the entry level?\n12:42:59\n7\nA.\nThere is only an entry level and so\n12:43:03\n8\n00\nQ.\nOne-story home?\n12:43:05\n9\nA. It's a one-story home.\n12:43:06\n10\nQ.\nAnd so the kitchen is on that first floor?\n12:43:07\n11\nA.\nKitchen is on the first floor to the left,\n12:43:11\n12\nyes.\n13\nQ. And is there a living room or a lounge.\n12:43:13\n14\nroom adjacent to the kitchen?\n15\n16\nA. Adjacent to the kitchen there is a large\nroom which serves part of it as a dining area and\n12:43:22\n17\npart of it as a living room, yes.\n18\nQ. And during this period of time that we're\n12:43:29\n19\nfocusing on between 1998 and\n--\n20\nA.\n1998?\n12:43:38\n21\nQ.\nYes, sir.\n12:43:39\n22\nA.\nOkay, okay.\n12:43:40\n23\nQ.\nBetween 1998 and 2002, how was the\n--\nhow\n12:43:42\n24\nwas that room furnished?\n25\nA.\nWell, it would be easy to tell because\n12:43:47\n132\nEFTA00601285\n", "char_count": 1040}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 132, "text_content": "1\nit's been the subject of many photographic essays\n2\nthat appeared in magazines and newspapers.\nOur home\n3\nwas often photographed. So anybody would know what\n4\nthe interior of it looked like. Just a simple\n5\nGoogle search would show you what the interior of\n6\nthe house looked like.\n7\nQ. Tell us what it looked like, please.\n12:44:07\n8\n00\nA.\nWell, what specifically?\n12:44:08\n9\nQ.\nWell\n--\n12:44:11\n10\nA.\nIt had a couch when you walk in.\n12:44:12\n11\nQ.\nOkay. What other furniture?\n12:44:14\n12\nA.\nIt had chairs. It had a dining room\n12:44:15\n13\ntable, all of which have been pictured in various\n14 magazines and newspapers.\n15\nQ.\nWas there a desk in that room?\n12:44:27\n16\nA.\nNo.\n12:44:31\n17\nQ.\nBookshelves?\n12:44:33\n18\nA.\nIn the living room?\n12:44:34\n19\nQ.\nIn the rooms adjacent to the kitchen.\n12:44:37\n20\nA.\nNo, not to my recollection.\n12:44:41\n21\nWhy, does\nclaim to have\n12:44:47\n22\nbeen in my home?\n23\nQ. What kind of floor coverings are there on\n12:44:50\n24\nthe entry level?\n25\nA.\nFloor coverings?\n12:44:57\n133\nEFTA00601286\n", "char_count": 1029}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 133, "text_content": "1\nQ.\nYes.\n12:44:59\n2\nA. In the entry level right as you walk in,\n12:45:02\n3\nthere are no floor coverings.\nThere are\n--\n41\nQ.\nTile, wood?\n12:45:09\n5\nA.\nNot a rug.\nJust a floor.\n12:45:13\n6\nQ.\nWhat kind of floor?\n12:45:16\n7\nA.\nI don't remember.\n12:45:18\n8\n00\nQ.\nWhat was its composition?\n12:45:18\n9\nA.\nI don't remember.\n12:45:20\n10\nQ.\nHow about the living room, what was the\n12:45:20\n11 composition of the floor in the living room?\n12\nA.\nCork, I think. Cork, yeah.\n12:45:26\n13\nQ.\nHow many times has Jeffrey Epstein been a\n12:45:34\n14\nguest in that Cambridge, Massachusetts house?\n15\nA.\nMaybe\n12:45:44\n16\nMR. SWEDER: When you say \"guest,\" you\n\"\n12:45:46\n17\ndon't mean sleeping over?\n18\nA. He's never slept over.\n12:45:51\n19\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:45:52\n20\n20\nQ.\nI didn't say anything about sleeping over.\n12:45:52\n21\nMR. SWEDER: I just want to make sure the\n12:45:54\n22\nrecord is clear.\n23\nA. He has never slept over.\nMaybe three\n12:45:55\n24\ntimes.\nMaybe.\nMaybe three times.\nThat would be a\n25\nrough estimate. Not very many.\n134\nEFTA00601287\n", "char_count": 1034}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 134, "text_content": "1\nMR. SCOTT: During the relevant timeframe. 12:46:12\n2\nA. During the relevant timeframe.\n12:46:15\n3\nMR. SCOTT: 1999 to 2002.\n12:46:16\n41\nA.\n1999 to 2002. Oh, either\nmaybe once.\n12:46:17\n5\nMaybe once. Certainly not many times.\n6\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n7\n8\n00\nA.\nQ. At least once?\nI don't\n9\nQ.\nMaybe two, maybe three?\n10\nA.\nNo, no, I have no recollection\n11\nMR. SCOTT: Okay.\n12\n12:46:24\n12:46:27\n12:46:29\n12:46:29\n12:46:31\n12:46:32\nA.\nI have no recollection of him being there\n12:46:33\n13\n14\n15\n16\nat all during that relevant time period. But\nremembering that he had been in my house on a couple\nof occasions, it's certainly possible during that\nrelevant time period he had been there once or\n17\ntwice.\n18\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:46:46\n19\nQ. How many times\n--\nexcuse me. When he did\n12:46:47\n20\n--\n21\n22\nAre we\n--\nvisit, with whom who accompanied him?\nMR. SCOTT: Let me ask you a question.\nis this relevant timeframe or any\n12:46:55\n23\ntime?\nI'm just trying\n24\nMR. SCAROLA: Since we can't narrow it\n12:46:59\n25\ndown to the relevant timeframe, I want to know\n135\nEFTA00601288\n", "char_count": 1061}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 135, "text_content": "1\nany time.\n2\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:47:02\n3\nQ.\nAny time that Jeffrey Epstein visited your\n12:47:03\n4\nhome, who was with him?\n5\nA. Normally Ghislaine Maxwell and\n12:47:07\n6\nAnd he may have had another assistant or\n7\nsecretary or somebody.\nHe usually traveled.\n8\n00\nUsually he would fly in to Bedford\n12:47:20\n9\nAirport, have a car take him\nusually go to his\n10\noffice. He had an office in Harvard Square, and if\n11\n12\nhe came by my house, he came by my house with\nwhoever was his entourage at any given point in\n13\ntime.\n14\n15\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nQ. And that usually was?\n16\nA.\nMaxwell and sometimes\n12:47:41\n12:47:42\n12:47:43\n17\nanother one or two people.\n18\nQ. How old was\nwhen she was part\n12:47:49\n19\nof Jeffrey Epstein's entourage?\n20\nA. If I had to estimate, I would say younger\n12:47:56\n21\nthan 30 and older than 25. Somewhere between 25 and\n22\n30, probably closer to 30.\n23\nQ. You would describe her as a young woman?\n12:48:06\n24\nA.\n25\nI would describe her as a woman between\nthe ages of 25 and 30.\n12:48:08\n136\nEFTA00601289\n", "char_count": 1025}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 136, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n41\n137\nQ.\nDoes that in your mind fit the description 12:48:15\nof a young woman?\nA. I don't want to categorize a woman by her\nage. It's a woman between 25 and 30. It's not a\nteenager. It's not a middle-aged woman. It's a\n12:48:19\n5\n6\nwoman between the ages of 25 and 30.\n7\nQ. What was\nrole in Jeffrey\n12:48:32\n8\nEpstein's entourage?\n9\nA.\nShe would, to my knowledge, arrange\n12:48:37\n10\n11\ntransportation, she would arrange meetings when\nmeetings were occurring. She worked, I think, at\n12\nthe Harvard office where he would have meetings with\n13\nGeorge Church, the man who developed the genome,\n14\nLarry Summers, the president of Harvard, Henry\n15 Rosovsky, the provost, the former provost of\n16\nHarvard; Stephen Kosslyn, the chairman of the\n17 psychology department at Harvard, a man who wrote\nmultiple intelligences, whose name is slipping my\n18\n19\nmind now, but from the Ed School.\n20\n21\n22\n23\nShe would arrange some of those lunch\nmeetings where we would discuss serious issues, some\nof us were asked to present. I presented on one or\ntwo occasions and we were asked to critique and she\n12:49:23\n24\n25\nwould take notes and arrange transportation and do\nthings of that kind.\nEFTA00601290\n", "char_count": 1195}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 137, "text_content": "138\n1\nQ.\nHow old was Ghislaine Maxwell?\n12:49:40\n2\nA.\nGhislaine, Ghislaine Maxwell. I would\n12:49:45\n3\nestimate\n41\nMR. SCOTT: Your French isn't real high.\n12:49:48\n5\nA.\nI would estimate that she was at the time\n12:49:50\n6\nbetween 35 and 40.\n7\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:49:55\n8\nQ.\nAnd what was her role in Jeffrey Epstein's\n12:49:55\n9\nentourage?\n13\n14\n15\n10\n11\n12\nA. She was basically his major domo. She\narranged travel as well. And she would tell you\nwhen you could meet with him, when to come over.\nShe would call me at my office and say, Jeffrey\nwould like to meet with you at 4:10, and then she\nwould call back and say, could you make it at 4:30?\n12:49:58\n16\n17\n18\nI would say that Ghislaine was the senior\nperson organizing his kind of academic contacts and\nwas the junior person. They worked in\n12:50:19\n19\noverlapping roles.\n20\n21\n22\nQ. Were there any other entourage members\nthat traveled with Jeffrey Epstein when he came to\nyour home?\n12:50:34\n23\n24\nA. I have no recollection of any of them ever\ncoming to my home. I don't remember. But if that's\n12:50:41\n25\nwho he traveled with. Sometimes he would travel\nEFTA00601291\n", "char_count": 1123}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 138, "text_content": "139\nAnd I\n1\nhe almost always had a regular girlfriend.\n2\nremember a few of them. One of them was a student\n3 at the business school who's\n--\nI may be merging two\n41\nof them.\n5\nOne of them was a student at the business\n12:51:03\n6\nschool. Another, maybe the same one, was a wealthy\n7\nwoman whose father owned banks in Great Britain.\n8\n9\n10\nAnother was a woman from either the Czech Republic\nor Slovakia who was probably between 20 and 25,\nprobably closer to 25. And he would travel with a\n11\nposse, basically, an entourage of of people. But\n--\n12\nI never met some of the people who are in the\n13\nentourage.\nThey were just there.\n14\nQ. They were there at the same time that you\n12:51:38\n15\nwere there and Jeffrey Epstein was there?\n16\nA. Well, they were\n--\n17\nMR. SCOTT: Wait a minute.\n12:51:42\nThat's vague.\n12:51:43\n18\n19\nI mean, there in the house, there in\nMassachusetts?\n20\nMR. SCAROLA: There wherever.\n12:51:47\n21\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:51:47\n22\nQ. When you were in Jeffrey Epstein's\n12:51:48\n23\npresence, Jeffrey Epstein usually had what you have\n24 described as some regular girlfriend.\n25\nA. That's right.\n12:51:58\nEFTA00601292\n", "char_count": 1130}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 139, "text_content": "☐ 1 Q.\nAnd you have described a variety of\n140\n12:51:59\n2\ndifferent regular girlfriends who were with him,\n3\ncorrect?\n4\nA.\nYes.\n12:52:06\n5\nQ.\nUsually in the age range, you would\n12:52:06\n6\n7\nA.\n8\nestimate, between 20 and 25%; is that correct?\nI would say\nMR. SCOTT: Objection. That's not it.\n12:52:13\n12:52:14\n9\nA.\n10\ncloser\nI would say between 22 and 25 would be a\ncloser estimate. But 23, in that range.\n12:52:15\n11\nThere were none that I ever believed were\n12:52:25\n12\nin any way teenagers.\nAnd they all performed tasks.\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\nThey were taking notes or they were arranging,\nserving coffee or doing various things. And that's\nthe way Jeffrey would travel when he went to\nacademic meetings.\nAnd these people were seen not only by me.\n12:52:45\n18\nThey were seen by Larry Summers, they were seen by\n19\nChurch, they were seen by Marvin Minsky, they were\n20\nseen by some of the most eminent academics and\n21\nscholars in the world. There was no hint or\n22\nsuggestion of anything sexual or improper in the\n23\npresence of these people.\n24\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:53:09\n25\n25\nQ. Describe the motor vehicle that Jeffrey\n12:53:09\nEFTA00601293\n", "char_count": 1138}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 140, "text_content": "141\n1\nEpstein used to travel from the airport to your home\n2\non those occasions when you observed\n3\nA.\nI have no recollection. They were rented\n12:53:20\n41\ncars.\n5\nQ. Limousines?\n12:53:24\n6\nA.\nLimousines, yeah, yeah.\n12:53:24\n7\nQ.\nAnd did you ever travel from your home\n12:53:26\n8\n00\nwith Jeffrey Epstein in a limousine?\n9\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form, overly broad.\n12:53:35\n10\nA.\nNot during the relevant time period, no,\n12:53:37\n11\nno.\n12\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:53:41\n13\nQ. So, you can state with certainty, based\n12:53:43\n14\nupon your superb memory, that at no time between\n15\n16\n1999 and 2002 did you ever travel from your home in\na limousine with Jeffrey Epstein?\n17\n18\n19\n20\nA. I can't imagine any reason why I would\nhave. I did not fly in his plane during that period.\nof time, my records establish. And I would see no\nreason why I would have. I don't have any\nrecollection whether I specifically drove with him\n12:54:03\n21\n22\nduring that period of time. But I think I did not.\n23 Because I did not have any reason.\n24\nNormally if I drove with him, it would be\n25\nto go to the airport to get on his plane.\nThat was\n12:54:25\nEFTA00601294\n", "char_count": 1139}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 141, "text_content": "1 the only reason that I would have ever to go in a\nlimousine that I know of.\n2\n3\nQ.\nWhat records establish that you were not\n12:54:37\n4\non Jeffrey Epstein's plane during what you have\n5\ndescribed as the relevant time period?\n6\nA. No, you've described it as the relevant\n12:54:46\n7\ntime period. You said 2009 to 2000-\n8\nQ.\nNo, sir. In the answer you just\n12:54:51\n9\nA.\n--\n1999\n12:54:52\n10\nQ.\ngave, you used the phrase \"relevant\n12:54:53\n11\ntime frame,\" time period.\n12\nA.\nYeah, I was picking up on your terms\n12:54:54\n13\nbetween 1999 and 2002. So can we agree that's the\n14\nrelevant time period?\n15\nQ. You can tell me what\n16\n17\n18\nwhat your response\nis based on that you never traveled on Jeffrey\nEpstein's airplane during the relevant time period,\nwhatever you consider that to be.\n12:55:03\n19\n20\n21\nA. Okay. Number 1, my own calendars, which\nhave been provided to you. Number 2, my cell phone\nrecords. Number 3, my wife's calendars.\n12:55:15\nNumber 4,\n22\nmy teaching and other schedule.\n23\nNumber 5, my own recollection. And number\n12:55:33\n24\n6, as far as we know, the airplane manifests do not\n25\nhave me on any airplanes during that time period.\n142\nEFTA00601295\n", "char_count": 1169}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 142, "text_content": "143\n1\nQ.\nWhat do you mean as far as\n12:55:49\n2\nMR. SCOTT: We can take a break at some\n12:55:50\n3\npoint.\nIt's about 1:00.\n41\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:55:53\n5\nQ.\n6\nWhat do you mean as far as you know, the\nairplane manifests\n12:55:54\n7\n8\nA. I've only seen some manifests and none of\nthem have me on any airplane during the relevant\n12:55:57\n9\ntime period. I have no idea whether there are any\n10\nother manifests.\nI wouldn't know.\n11\nQ. Well, have you seen manifests from the\n12:56:07\n12\nperiod between 1999 and 2002?\n13\nA. I think I have, yes. I think I have,\n12:56:12\n14\nyeah.\n15\nQ.\nOkay. The entire period, covers the whole 12:56:14\n16 period?\n17\nA.\nYeah.\nI think I've been told by my\n12:56:17\n18\nlawyers\n19\nMR. SIMPSON: Don't\n--\n12:56:20\n20\nA.\nOkay. I have been advised by people who\n12:56:21\n21\nhave seen the records that there is\nthat I was\n22\nnot on any of Jeffrey Epstein's planes during that\n23 period of time. And that comports with my -- with\n24\nmy memory.\n25\nEFTA00601296\n", "char_count": 974}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 143, "text_content": "1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:56:34\n2\nQ.\nWhich people told you they saw airplane\n12:56:34\n3 manifests for the period between 1999 and 2002?\n41\nMR. SCOTT: If that involves lawyer\n12:56:44\n5\nconversations and\n--\n6\nA. It does involve lawyer conversations, yes.\n12:56:46\n7\n8\nMR. SCAROLA: He just waived it.\n12:56:48\n00\nMR. SCOTT: I'm not taking that position.\n12:56:50\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:56:52\n10\nQ. Okay. So your position is that you are\n12:56:53\n11\nnot disclosing\n--\n12\nA. I'm happy to disclose\n12:56:54\n13\nQ.\nwho told you\n12:56:56\n14\nA.\nI'm happy to disclose\n12:56:57\n15\nMR. SCOTT: No, no, I'm the lawyer here.\n12:57:00\n16\n17\nI'm telling him not to answer that question.\nI'll discuss it at the lunch break and I'll get\n18\nback to you.\nAnd I would also like to know\n19\nwhat the relevancy of all those questions were\n20\nabout the house.\n21\nTHE WITNESS: I can figure it out.\n12:57:10\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12:57:15\n23\nQ. Who\ndid you personally see airplane\n12:57:15\n24\nmanifests during that period between 1999 and 2002?\n25\nA. My recollection is that I have looked at\n12:57:23\n144\nEFTA00601297\n", "char_count": 1080}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 144, "text_content": "145\n1\nplane manifests. I think they were prepared to be\n2\nshown to various people who I'm not allowed\n--\nI'm\n3\ntold not to talk about.\n41\nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. You've requested a\n12:57:41\n5\nbreak.\n6\nMR. SCOTT: Take a lunch.\n12:57:44\n7\n8\nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The\n12:57:44\n00\ntime is approximately 12:57 p.m.\n9\n(Recess was from 12:57 p.m. until 3:43 p.m.)\n13:10:50\n10\nVIDEOGRAPHER:\nGoing back on the record.\n13:35:41\n11\nThe time is approximately 3:43 p.m.\n12\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:43:41\n13\nQ. Mr. Dershowitz, did you author a book\n15:43:43\n14\ncalled My Life in Court?\n15\nA.\nNo.\n15:43:47\n16\n17\n18\nQ. Do you recall having said the following:\n\"There's an old saying if you have the law on your\nside, bang on the law. If you have the facts on\n15:43:49\n19\n20\nyour side, bang on the facts. If you have neither,\nbang on the table. I have never believed that, but\n21\nI do believe in a variation of that theme.\nIf you\n22\ndon't have the law or legal facts on your side,\n23\nargue your case in the Court of public opinion\"?\n24\nDid you say that those things?\n25\nMR. SCOTT: Let me object to the form of\n15:44:17\n15:44:19\nEFTA00601298\n", "char_count": 1127}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 145, "text_content": "146\n1\nthat because the statement does not give a\n2\ntime, date, place or anything of his\n3\n41\n3\nrecollections.\n5\nA. No, I remember saying that in following\ncontext, I was accused of an unspeakable heinous\n15:44:25\n6\ncrime by lawyers who deliberately put it in a court\npleading that they believe would give them immunity.\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n7\nThey put it in a pleading which I was not a party.\nI had no realistic legal opportunity to respond to\nthe lies and in that context, my only alternative\nwas to respond to the media when the media called\nme, because obviously the media had been alerted to\nthese lies that were inserted in a judicial\nproceeding, and I had no alternative but to respond\nin the court of public opinion.\nI prefer to respond in courts of law. In\nfact, I've had cases in my career, including a\ndouble capital case, where I made a deal with the\nprosecutor initially that I would never speak to the\npress if he would never speak to the press and we\nhonored that deal even when I won the case and my\n15:45:16\n22\nclients were taken off death row.\n23\nSo my strong preference would be to\n15:45:34\n24\nrespond in the court of law where I think I have\n25 abilities and talents to respond. But when I have\nEFTA00601299\n", "char_count": 1247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 146, "text_content": "147\n1\nno alternative because of the way in which the\n2\nlawyers put the false allegations in a judicial\n3\npleading hoping to get judicial immunity, yes, at\n4\n5\nthat point the appropriate response is in the court\nof public opinion.\n6\nThat's what Justice Blackmun said in a\n15:46:00\n7\nconcurring opinion in the Supreme Court, that the\n8\n9\nbut it continues on to the courtroom steps.\nduty of a lawyer does not stop at the courtroom door\nAnd my\n10\nattitude is you fight the battle wherever the other\n11\nside starts it.\n12\nSo, if the battles are started in the\n15:46:16\n13\ncourt of public opinion, I have an obligation to\n14\ncontinue it in the court of public opinion.\n15\nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the\n15:46:25\n16\nunresponsive answer. Let me try again and I'll\n17\nmake it a little simpler for you.\n18\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n19\nQ. Did you say if you don't have the law or\n15:46:31\n20\nlegal facts on your side, argue your case in the\n21\ncourt of public opinion?\n22\nA. I said that in the context of an\n15:46:39\n23\nability\nan inability to respond in the court of\n24\nlaw. In this case, I think I have\n--\nI know I have\n25\nthe facts on my side. In this case, it was unclear\nEFTA00601300\n", "char_count": 1169}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 147, "text_content": "1\n2\n3\n4\n5\nwhether I had the law on my side at that time when\nI, of course, learned that Professor Cassell made a\nstatement to ABC News that was not privileged and\nwhen I also learned about statements made by both\nCassell and Edwards, I realized at that point I had\n6 the law on my side, the facts on my side, and\nmorality. And that's the most important thing to\n7\n8\nme, morality on my side.\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n10\n11\n12\n13\nQ. You are quoted in an April 2007 edition of\nthe Daily Mail as having said \"The financier,\"\nreferring to Jeffrey Epstein, \"had paid for massages\nbut had not engaged in sex or erotic massages with\n15:47:22\n15:47:24\n14\nany minors.\"\n15\nDid you make that statement?\n15:47:53\n16\nA.\nCan you show me?\n15:47:54\n17\nMR. SCOTT:\nWould you like to see the\n15:47:56\n18\narticle?\n19\nTHE WITNESS:\nYes, of course I would.\n15:47:58\n20\nMR. SCOTT: Can he see it, please?\n15:48:04\n21\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:48:05\n22\nQ.\nDoes that help to refresh your superb\n15:48:06\n23\nmemory?\n24\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection. No\nhe asked to\n15:48:09\n25\nsee it. There's no question pending.\nHe's\n148\nEFTA00601301\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 148, "text_content": "1\nreviewing the document.\n2\nA. I have no recollection of having made that\n15:48:16\n3 statement, nor do I know whether it's an accurate\n4\nrendition. I note that it's not in quotation marks.\n5\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:48:24\n6\nQ.\nSo you can't remember one way or another\n15:48:25\n7\nwhether you said that%;B is that correct?\n8\nA. I can't remember my exact words. I was\n--\n15:48:28\n9\nI was defending Jeffrey Epstein both in the court of\n10\nlaw and in the court of public opinion.\n11\n12\nQ. So, as far as Jeffrey Epstein was\nconcerned, you decided to resort to the court of\n15:48:37\n13\npublic opinion\n14\nA.\nBecause\n15\nQ.\ncorrect?\n16\nA.\nBecause the press had called me because\n15:48:45\n15:48:45\n15:48:46\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\nEpstein's opponents had gone to the press and tried\nto make the case against him in the press. As I\nsaid previously, and I've stated this over and over\nagain, I will fight for my client in any forum in\nwhich the fight is commenced by the other side. If\nthe fight is limited to the court, I much prefer to\n23\nfight in the court.\n24\n25\nNo defendant benefits from having his case\nin the newspapers. Every defendant I know and every\n15:49:09\n149\nEFTA00601302\n", "char_count": 1163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 149, "text_content": "150\n1\ndefense lawyer I know, and I certainly teach this to\n2\nmy students, try to keep the case out of the press,\n3\n4\n5\ntry to keep the press as far away from the case as\npossible.\nBut if the press is covering the opposing\npoint of view, you have an obligation to respond in\n6\nwhatever forum the\nthe prosecution of your\n7\nclients or the persecution of your clients is taking\n8\nplace. That's been a principle that I've applied\n9\nthroughout my professional career.\n10\n11\nQ. And you have an obligation to respond\ntruthfully when you make public statements?\n15:49:42\n12\nA.\nAbsolutely, right.\n15:49:47\n13\nQ. The Code of Professional Responsibility of\n15:49:48\n14\nthe Bar of the State of Massachusetts requires you\n15\nto be truthful in making statements to third\n16\nparties, correct?\n17\n18\nA.\nI'm fully aware of the Code of\nProfessional Responsibility.\nI've always complied\n15:49:58\n19\nwith it. I've never violated it, and I wish I could\n20\nsay the same for your clients, but I can't.\n21\n22\n23\n24\nQ. As you sit here today, knowing that more\nthan 30 underage women have come forward to report\nthat your friend, Jeffrey Epstein, paid them for sex\nand that he pled guilty to procuring underage girls\n15:50:07\n25\nfor prostitution, and that he paid very large sums\nEFTA00601303\n", "char_count": 1266}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 150, "text_content": "151\n1\nof money to settle their civil claims against him,\n2\ndo you still insist that he had not engaged in sex\n3 or erotic massages with any minors?\n41\nA.\nAs I told you\n--\n15:50:45\n5\nMR. WEINBERG:\nI would like to register an\n15:50:46\n69\nobjection\n--\nMR. SCOTT: Wait a minute.\n15:50:46\n8\n00\nMR. WEINBERG:\n--\nto the extent that your\n15:50:46\n9\nopinion\n10\nTHE COURT REPORTER: I'm sorry, I can't\n15:50:46\n11\nhear the gentleman.\n12\nMR. SCAROLA: We're going to\nwe're\n15:50:52\n13\ngoing to object to more than one lawyer\n14\nMR. SCOTT: He's representing Epstein,\n15:50:57\n15\njust like she represents Boies.\n16\nMR. SCAROLA: That's fine.\n17\nMR. SCOTT: This is\n--\nthis is Epstein's\n15:51:01\n15:51:02\n18\nlawyer. And they have attorney-client relation\n19\nthere, so\n--\n20\nMR. SCAROLA: Yeah, is there some\n15:51:12\n21\n21\nvolume\n22\nTHE WITNESS: Go ahead, Marty.\n15:51:13\nMR. WEINBERG: The\nthe objection is to\n15:51:16\n24\n23\n22\n25\n25\nthe extent the question requires you to rely on\ninformation you learned as a result of your\nEFTA00601304\n", "char_count": 1020}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 151, "text_content": "1\nattorney-client communications, representation\n2\nof Epstein, work product, I object.\n3\n4\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nQ. Do you understand the question?\n15:51:31\n15:51:32\n5\nA.\nI understand the question and I understand\n15:51:33\n6\nthe objection.\n7\nQ. Yes, sir. And are you going to answer the\n15:51:36\n8\nquestion?\n9\nTHE WITNESS:\nMarty, you're the lawyer for\n15:51:38\n10\nmy client. Do you\ndo you order me to answer\n11\nthe question or not?\n12\nMR. WEINBERG: The client does not waive\n15:51:46\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n--\n18\n19\nany of the privileges; and, again, to the\nextent you're required to rely on what you\nlearned as a result of your professional legal\nrelationship with Epstein, your representation\nof him in any of\nany of his legal cases, I\nobject and would instruct you to the extent you\nwill accept an instruction from your client's\n20\nlawyer not to answer.\n21\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n22\nQ. Mr. Dershowitz, you know\n--\nI assume\n15:52:11\n15:52:12\n23\nyou're going to follow the instruction, correct?\n24\nMR. SCOTT: Yes, you're going to follow\n15:52:15\n25\nthe instruction.\n152\nEFTA00601305\n", "char_count": 1063}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 152, "text_content": "1\nA. I am going to follow the instruction. I\n2\nhave no choice. He's my client.\n3\n15:52:16\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nQ. I assume you know from sources entirely\nindependent of anything that Jeffrey Epstein told\nyou, from sources entirely independent of attorney\nwork product privileged information, that Jeffrey\nEpstein is guilty of being a serial child molester,\n15:52:19\n15:52:20\n9\nright?\n10\nA.\nAbsolutely not. Absolutely not.\n15:52:37\n11\nQ.\nYou don't know independent of those\n15:52:39\n12\nsources?\n13\nA. Not only\nno, I don't know that\n15:52:41\n14 independent\n15\nQ.\nOkay. Thank you.\n15:52:43\n16\nA.\nof those sources. Of course not.\n15:52:43\n17\nQ. You know that he pled guilty to sexual\n15:52:45\n18\nabuse of minors, correct?\n19\nA. Could you tell me exactly what he pleaded\n15:52:54\n20\nguilty to so I can answer that question?\n21\n22\n23\nhe was\nQ. Well, do you know? You represented him\nduring the period of time that he was under\nthat he was under criminal charges, didn't\n15:52:58\nthat\n24\nyou?\n25\nMR. SCOTT: So you're withdrawing the\n15:53:06\n153\nEFTA00601306\n", "char_count": 1057}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 153, "text_content": "1\nprior question; you're now asking this\n2\nquestion?\nOkay.\n3\n3\nMR. SCAROLA: That's correct, I'm\n15:53:09\n4\nasking\n5\nA. So I represented him\n6\nMR. SCAROLA:\nthis question.\n7\n8\n9\nA. I represented him first in Palm Beach\nCounty, and at that point, he had been prepared to\nplead guilty to, I think, one count\n15:53:10\n15:53:10\n15:53:11\n10\n11\nMR. WEINBERG: Alan, I'm sorry. This is\nagain, going right into the work that you did\n15:53:24\n12\nfor him as his lawyer and I instruct you not to\n13\nanswer.\n14\n15\nMR. SCOTT: That's it then, follow his\nas your attorney, I'm telling you to follow the\n15:53:32\n16\nlawyer's advice.\n17\nTHE WITNESS: Uh-huh.\n15:53:36\n18\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:53:37\n19\nQ. You are aware that on October 20, 2005,\n15:53:37\n20\nthe Palm Beach police department executed a search\n21 warrant on Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach mansion,\n24\n22\ncorrect?\n23\n22\nA. I'm not aware of that, no.\n15:53:45\nQ.\nYou didn't know that?\n15:53:46\n25\nA.\nI don't know that as I stand here today\n15:53:48\n154\nEFTA00601307\n", "char_count": 1002}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 154, "text_content": "1\nwhat date or when\n2\nQ.\nDo you know that a search warrant was\n15:53:52\n3\nexecuted?\n41\nA.\nI recall\n5\nMR. WEINBERG:\n15:53:54\nAgain, the objection is if\n15:53:55\n6\n7\n8\n00\n9\n10\n11\nyou only know it as a result of your legal\nrepresentation of Mr. Epstein, I object to your\nanswering on that basis. If you know it from\nindependent sources, then I have no objection.\nA. I do not know it from independent sources.\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n12\nQ. You know it from having read a very\n15:54:08\n15:54:10\n15:54:11\n13\nlengthy Palm Beach police department investigative\n14\nreport, don't you?\n15\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection.\n15:54:19\n16\nMR. WEINBERG:\nAnd I object. If you read\n15:54:20\n17\nit in the context of providing legal\n18\n19\nrepresentation to Jeffrey Epstein, it's\nattorney-client, it's work product, and it's\n20\nthe same objection.\nTHE WITNESS: Let me put on the record,\ntoo, that I'm happy to answer any of these\nquestions if I were permitted to do so because\n21\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\nmy lawyer\n--\nthey're all exculpatory of me, but I must obey\nthe lawyer's instructions.\n15:54:31\n155\nEFTA00601308\n", "char_count": 1067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 155, "text_content": "156\n1\nMR. SCAROLA: And it is my suggestion that 15:54:43\n2\nthe statement that the answers would be\n3\n41\n3\nexculpatory is a waiver of any privilege that\n5\n6\n7\n8\n00\nmight attach, particularly with regard to work\nproduct, which is not Jeffrey Epstein's\nprivilege, but if it exists at all, is Alan\nDershowitz's privilege.\nMR. SCOTT: We obviously don't agree with\n9\n10\n11\nthat.\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nQ. Do you agree, Mr. Dershowitz, that\ndeciding the issues in this case will depend on\n15:55:01\n15:55:03\n15:55:04\n12\n13\nevaluating not only\n'credibility\n14\nbut your credibility as well?\n15\nMR. SCOTT: Objection, legal conclusion,\n15:55:14\n16\nnot relevant here.\n17\nA. I think that I can prove my complete\n15:55:17\n18\ninnocence and the fact that\n--\nthat\n19\n20\nmade up the story out of whole cloth without my\ncredibility being at issue, but I'm perfectly happy\n21\n22\nto put my credibility at issue because I am telling\nthe blue absolute truth about everything regarding\n23\n24\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:55:39\n25\n25\nQ. One way to evaluate credibility is to\n15:55:40\nEFTA00601309\n", "char_count": 1054}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 156, "text_content": "1 compare an individual's statements with available\ndocumentary evidence, correct?\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\nA.\nThat's too broad a question.\nwhat the documentary evidence could be.\nDepending on 15:55:48\nDocumentary\ncould be lies. Documents contain lies and oral\nstatements contain truth. So, no, I don't think\n7\nthat's a particularly good way. It depends on the\n8\nnature of the document.\n9\nFor example, videotape would be very good.\n15:56:04\n10\nIf you had a videotape that in some way supported\n11\n'\nstatements and it undercut what I\n12\n13\n14\n15\nsaid, that would be fine. That's why from day one\nI've asked to have if there are any videotape shown\nor any photographs because I know what happened. I\nknow that I never had any contact, any sexual\n16\ncontact, any improper contact with\n17\nAnd I know, therefore, that there cannot\n15:56:27\n18\n19\n20\nbe any evidence that contradicts that because you\ncan't simply make up facts. So I am telling you the\nabsolute truth.\n21\nQ. You also know that all of the videotapes\n15:56:37\n22\nthat were taken through surveillance cameras\n23\nthroughout Jeffrey Epstein's home were destroyed,\n24\ndon't you?\n25\nA. Of course I don't know that.\n15:56:47\n157\nEFTA00601310\n", "char_count": 1179}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 157, "text_content": "158\n1\nQ.\nYou don't know?\n15:56:48\n2\nA.\nOf course not.\n15:56:49\n3\nQ.\nSo you didn't read the police reports\n15:56:50\n4\nthen?\n5\nMR. SCOTT:\nObjection. Mr. Epstein, do\n15:56:52\n6\n7\n☑\n00\n8\nyou want him to answer that question?\nMR. SIMPSON: Mr. Weinberg.\nMR. SCOTT: Mr. Weinberg?\n15:56:59\n15:57:00\n9\nMR. WEINBERG: It's the same objection.\n15:57:00\n10\nIf you learned it as\na result of the\n--\nor in\n11\n12\nthe context of legal representation and while\nproviding legal counsel to Jeffrey Epstein, I\n13\nobject.\n14\n15\n16\n17\nMR. SCOTT: Based on this lawyer's\nposition, your client's lawyer's position, if\nany of your answers involve that what he's\nsaying, I don't want you to answer them, okay?\n15:57:12\n18\nTHE WITNESS: The only thing I can say\n15:57:21\n19\nthat doesn't\n20\nMR. SIMPSON: Alan\n21\n21\nMR. SCOTT: There's no question.\n22\nA.\nThat doesn't involve.\n23\nMR. SCOTT: There's no question.\n22\n24\n15:57:23\n15:57:23\n15:57:24\n15:57:25\nTHE WITNESS: Oh, there's no question.\n15:57:26\n25\nSorry.\nEFTA00601311\n", "char_count": 990}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 158, "text_content": "159\n1\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:57:28\n2\nQ.\nYou have stated publicly repeatedly that\n15:57:29\n3\n4\n5\nthe airplane manifests will exonerate you, correct?\nA. I have stated publicly that the airplane\nmanifest, the one that I have seen, do not show me\n15:57:35\n6\non any of Jeffrey Epstein's airplanes in the\n7\nrelevant period of time, which I define as the\n8\n9\nsummer of 1999 through the summer of 2002, number 1.\nNumber 2, that none of the airplane\n15:57:52\n10\nmanifests will show me on the same plane with\n11\n12\nAnd 3, that none of the manifests will\n15:58:01\n13\nshow me on an airplane with Jeffrey Epstein and any\n14\nunderage girls that were at least visible in the\n15\npassenger part of the airplane.\n16\nQ. Well, that raises an interesting point,\n15:58:13\n17\nMr. Dershowitz.\nTell us about the interior\n--\n18\nA.\nWhy is it interesting?\n19\nQ.\n--\nof that plane.\n20\nTHE COURT REPORTER: I'm sorry, I didn't\n15:58:16\n15:58:18\n15:58:18\n21\nhear your question.\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:58:18\n23\nQ. That raises an interesting point. Tell us\n15:58:20\n24\nabout that the interior of that plane.\n25\nA. My recollection is the plane was a\n15:58:24\nEFTA00601312\n", "char_count": 1131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 159, "text_content": "1 Gulfstream IV. That it had a cabin that seated\n2\napproximately one, two, three, four maybe ten\n--\n3\nten people. It had mostly seats\n4\nI used to sit in\nthe seat facing backward, that's the way I prefer to\n5\nfly.\n6\nAnd in the back of the plane there was a\n15:58:52\n7\ntoilet, a place to serve food. And a couch that\nthree additional people. But I never saw the\n8\n9\n10\n11\nplane the only time I ever saw the plane filled\nto capacity was when I went down to watch a launch\nserved as a seat with seat belts for maybe two or\n12\nof a satellite\n--\n13\nQ. Does that have\n15:59:19\n14\nA.\nto outer space.\n15:59:20\n15\nQ.\nanything to do with the configuration\n15:59:20\n16\nof the interior of the plane?\n17\nA.\nYes. Yes, I'm telling you that I've\n15:59:25\n18\nmostly seen it only with four or five people. The\n19\nonly time I've seen the couch\n--\n20\nQ. Did I ask you how many people\n15:59:29\n21\nMR. SCOTT:\nWell, you're interrupting\n--\n15:59:30\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:59:31\n23\nQ.\nwere in the plane at the time I asked\n15:59:32\n24\nyou what the configuration of the cabin was,\n25\nMr. Dershowitz?\n160\nEFTA00601313\n", "char_count": 1089}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 160, "text_content": "1\nA.\nI'm explaining\n15:59:35\n2\nQ.\nIs that part of the question that I\n15:59:35\n3\nasked\n41\nA.\nI'm explaining the couch.\n15:59:37\nQ.\nor is that your effort to make speeches\n15:59:38\n5\n6\nin an effort to consume the limited amount of time\n7\nthat we have?\n8\n9\nMR. SCOTT: I would object to that\ncharacterization.\n15:59:44\n10\nA.\nI wanted to start at\n--\nI wanted to start\n15:59:44\n11\nat 12:00\nat 1:30 today.\n12\nMR. SCOTT: And the speech.\n15:59:48\n13\nMR. SIMPSON: Alan, Alan.\n15:59:48\n14\nA.\nAll the delays have been caused by you,\n15:59:49\n15\nnot me. And I'm ready to go to 5:30, but you're\n16\nquitting at 5\n--\nor 4:30.\n17\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n15:59:55\n18\nQ.\nYes, sir, I have\n15:59:55\n19\nA.\nSo don't blame any delays on me, sir.\n15:59:56\n20\nQ.\n--\na commitment\nI have a commitment to\n15:59:58\n21\nchair an\n22\nA.\nDon't we all.\n23\nQ.\nEaster Seals fundraiser.\n15:59:59\n15:59:59\n22\n24\nA.\nWe all have commitments.\n25\nQ.\nYou've known\n16:00:00\n16:00:02\n161\nEFTA00601314\n", "char_count": 947}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 161, "text_content": "1\n162\nMR. SCOTT: Timeout . Timeout . Let's\n16:00:02\neverybody\n2\n3\n4\nQ.\n5\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nthat for three days.\nMR. SCOTT: Everybody cool down.\n16:00:03\n16:00:03\n16:00:05\n6\nEverybody cool down. It's late in the day.\n7\nThat includes Mr. Scarola, my client.\nLet's do\n8\n00\nquestion and answer.\n9\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:00:14\n10\nQ. New question\n16:00:15\n11\nMR. SCOTT: Here we go, new question.\n16:00:15\n12\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:00:15\n13\nQ.\ndid you see a bed in the plane?\n16:00:15\n14\nA.\nI never saw a bed in the plane. As far as\n16:00:16\n15\nI know, there was no bed in the plane. And that's\n16\nwhat I was trying to explain.\nThat the only time\n17\nI've seen that couch used is when two or three\n18 people were sitting in it when we went down to watch\n19\nthe launch of the satellite because that was the\n20\nonly time I saw the plane filled.\n21\nOther than that, it was a plain, ordinary\n22\n23\ncouch that was never used by anybody during the\nflights. We were all sitting in our seats. I do\n24\nnot know for a fact that that couch becomes a bed.\n25\nI never saw it as a bed.\nAnd the answer is\n16:00:36\nEFTA00601315\n", "char_count": 1094}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 162, "text_content": "1\ncategorically no.\n2\n3\n4\n5\nthe plane? The answer to that question is not a\ncategorical no%;B the answer to that question is you\ndon't know%;B is that right?\nQ.\nWell, the question was: Is there a bed on\n16:00:57\n6\nA. The answer to that question is there is a\n16:01:05\n7\ncouch on the plane like it is on all as far as I\n--\n8\nknow, all Gulfstream IVs. I have no idea whether or\n9\nnot that couch becomes a bed.\n10\nQ. You told the American lawyer on\n16:01:15\n11\n12\nJanuary 15, 2015 a statement that you have repeated\non multiple occasions: \"I've been married to the\n13\nsame woman for 28 years. She goes with me\n14\neverywhere.\"\n15\nDo you acknowledge making that statement?\n16:01:29\n16\nA.\n17\ntoday.\nYes. My wife goes with me everywhere\nThese days, now that our daughter is grown\n16:01:30\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\nup and went to high school and college, she travels\nwith me everywhere. It's a rare, rare occasion when\nmy wife doesn't travel with me. In fact, I have a\ncondition of my speakings engagements that the\nspeaking engagements have to pay for my wife to come\n23\nwith me.\n24\nI hate traveling alone. I almost never do 16:01:51\n25\nit unless there is an absolutely essential reason\n163\nEFTA00601316\n", "char_count": 1187}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 163, "text_content": "1\nfor Carolyn to be somewhere else, such as taking\n2\ncare of her 96-year-old mother. But it is true, I\n3\ntravel with my wife.\n4\nQ. In fact, the airplane manifests that have\n16:02:07\n5\nbeen produced reflect your having traveled on\n6 Jeffrey Epstein's airplane on ten separate occasions\n7\nand on none of those occasions\n8\nA.\nIs that testimony, sir?\n16:02:22\n9\nQ.\nOn none of those occasions\n16:02:23\n10\nMR. SCOTT: Wait a minute.\n16:02:25\n11\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:02:25\n12\nQ.\n--\nis your wife reflected as having been a\n16:02:26\n13\npassenger at the same time that you are were on\n14\nJeffrey Epstein's airplane, right?\n15\nMR. SCOTT: Object to the form.\nThere's\n16:02:32\n16\nno timeframe or anything of that nature. If\n17\nyou can answer\n18\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:02:35\n19\nQ. All of the manifests that have been\n16:02:35\n20\nproduced in this litigation, the ones that you say\n21 corroborate your testimony and exonerate you,\n22\n23\ndemonstrate that you never flew on Jeffrey Epstein's\nplane in the company of your wife, correct?\n24\nA.\n25\nNo. That's not true. I flew in the\ncompany of my wife and my daughter from Charleston,\n16:02:50\n164\nEFTA00601317\n", "char_count": 1133}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 164, "text_content": "1\nSouth Carolina to Guadalupe\n2\nQ. I'm asking about what the manifests show,\n16:03:00\n3\nsir\n4\nA.\nI'm telling you what\n16:03:02\n5\nQ.\nthe ones that you say exonerate you.\n16:03:03\n6\nA.\nWell, I said that\n16:03:05\n7\nQ.\nIs there a manifest that shows that you\n16:03:06\n8\nand your wife were on Jeffrey Epstein's plane at the\n9\nsame time together?\n10\nMR. SCOTT:\nLet me object to the\n--\n16:03:11\n11\nA.\nI don't know that.\n16:03:13\n12\nMR. SCOTT:\nargumentative nature and\n16:03:13\n13\n14\ncompound nature. He's trying to answer your\nquestions.\n15\nA.\nLet me go through each of the times\n16:03:18\n16\nMR. SCOTT: There's nothing\n16:03:19\n17\nTHE WITNESS: Okay. Okay.\n16:03:19\n18\nMR. SCOTT: There's nothing pending. Go\n16:03:20\n19\nahead.\n20\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:03:21\n21\nQ. Is there a manifest that shows that your\n16:03:21\n22\n23\nwife ever accompanied you on a flight on Jeffrey\nEpstein's private airplane?\n24\nMR. SCOTT: Let me object again. There's\n16:03:30\n25\nno reference to the timeframe or the relevant\n165\nEFTA00601318\n", "char_count": 1004}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 165, "text_content": "1\ntimeframe\nQ.\nIs there a manifest\nMR. SCOTT: You're cutting him off,\nCounsel.\n2\n3\nMR. SCAROLA: Any time ever.\n16:03:34\nA.\nMy wife accompanied me on two occasions,\n16:03:35\n41\nmy nephew\n--\n5\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n6\n7\n8\n00\n16:03:39\n16:03:39\n16:03:40\n9\nA.\nLet me finish.\n16:03:41\n10\nMR. SCAROLA: He's not answering my\n16:03:41\n11\nquestion.\n12\nMR. SCOTT: Yes, he is answering your\n16:03:43\n13\nquestion.\n14\nA. My nephew accompanied me on one occasion.\n16:03:45\n15\n16\n17\nMy research assistant, Mitch Webber, accompanied me\non one occasion. My son or grandson, I'm not sure\nwhich, accompanied me on one occasion.\n18\nAnd the occasions that I flew on Jeffrey\n19 Epstein's plane were almost always business\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\noccasions during a time when my daughter, Ella, was\nin elementary school, if we're talking about the\nrelevant period of time. And during that period of\ntime, on occasion my wife did not fly with me.\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\nQ.\nIs there\n16:04:04\n16:04:24\n16:04:24\n166\nEFTA00601319\n", "char_count": 981}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 166, "text_content": "1\nA. But let me emphasize\nlet me emphasize\nthat the manifests that do exculp me, do not show me\n167\n16:04:25\n2\n3\nflying with\nthey do not show me\n4\nflying with any young women.\n5\nThey know that on every trip I took, there\n16:04:35\n6\nwas a business reason for it, there were other\n7 people on the plane, and it is inconceivable that\nduring any of those periods of time, the lies that\n00\n8\ntold about me could have been true.\n9\n10\n11\nQ. So it's your contention that no manifests\nshow you traveling outside the company of your wife;\n16:04:49\n12\nis that correct?\n13\nA.\nSaid that again, no manifest\n16:04:58\n14\nQ.\nNo manifest shows you traveling outside\n16:04:59\n15\nthe company of your wife?\n16\nA.\nI'm confused.\nThat's a double, triple\n16:05:02\n17\nnegative.\n18\nMR. SCOTT: Do you understand the\n16:05:07\n19\nquestion?\n20\nTHE WITNESS: I don't, no.\n16:05:07\n21\nMR. SCOTT: Rephrase it.\n16:05:09\n22\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:05:09\n23\nQ. There is not a single manifest of the ten\n16:05:10\n24\nthat shows you as a passenger on Jeffrey Epstein's\n25 plane that shows your wife there at the same time,\nEFTA00601320\n", "char_count": 1090}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 167, "text_content": "1\ncorrect?\n2\nA.\nI am not aware that there are ten\n16:05:18\n3\nmanifests. I would be happy to look at the\n4\nmanifests.\nI have explained\n5\nQ.\nUnfortunately\n16:05:24\n6\nA.\neach of the times\n16:05:24\n7\nQ.\nwe won't have time to do that this\n16:05:25\n8\n00\nafternoon\n9\nA.\nI've been\n--\n16:05:27\n10\nQ.\nbut we will have time to do that\n16:05:27\n11\neventually.\n12\nA.\nWe will\n--\nI welcome that time, because I\n16:05:29\n13\ncan give complete context to every single trip I\n14\ntook. And if you're trying to convey the impression\n15\n16\nthat there was any occasion on which I had any\nimproper conduct while I was on that airplane, that\n17\nis a categorical lie.\n18\nQ. What I am trying to do, sir, is to test\n16:05:45\n19\nthe veracity of your public assertions that you have\n20\nnever traveled outside the presence of your wife.\n21\nA.\nThat is a lie.\n16:05:57\n22\nQ.\nThat is what I'm trying to do.\n16:05:57\n23\nA.\nThat is a lie, sir, a categorical lie. I\n16:05:57\n24\n25\nchallenge you to find any statement where I said I\nhave never traveled outside the presence of my wife.\n168\nEFTA00601321\n", "char_count": 1065}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 168, "text_content": "1\nQ.\nWell, how about this\n2\nA.\nSir, find me that statement.\n3\nQ.\ndo you\n--\ndo you remember having\n41\nhaving stated publicly on multiple occasions that\nyou never received a massage\n5\n6\nA.\nNo.\n7\nQ.\n--\nfrom Jeffrey Epstein?\n8\n00\nMR. SCOTT: Unless you can show them and\ncharacterize them by date and time, you just\n169\n16:06:08\n16:06:09\n16:06:10\n16:06:17\n16:06:18\n16:06:20\n9\n10\ncan't say here\n--\nit's improper impeachment\n11\nthat you've done this ten times.\nIt's just\n12\nimproper completely.\n13\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:06:28\n14\nQ.\nCan you answer the question\n16:06:29\n15\nMR. SCOTT: And it's overly broad.\n16:06:29\n16\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:06:30\n17\nQ.\n--\ndo you have any recollection of saying\n16:06:30\n18\nthat you never received a massage?\n19\nA. I did receive a massage.\n16:06:32\n20\nQ.\nDo you have any recollection\n16:06:34\n21\nA.\nI have no recollection\n16:06:35\n22\nQ.\n--\nof making that public statement that\n16:06:36\n23\nyou never received a massage?\n24\nA. I can't imagine me saying that. If I said\n16:06:39\n25\nit, I was mistaken. I had one massage, to my\nEFTA00601322\n", "char_count": 1056}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 169, "text_content": "1 recollection.\n2\nQ.\nOkay. Tell us about where that occurred.\n16:06:43\n16:06:45\n3\n41\nA. That occurred in my bedroom of Jeffrey\nEpstein's home in Palm Beach. I was asked whether\n5\nI\n--\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\nPalm Beach. I was asked whether I wanted a\nmassage. I had been asked repeatedly whether I\nwanted a massage and I had said no. Then I was told\nthat they had a masseuse coming from Miami who was a\nspecialist of some kind, she was very good, she was\nRussian, and she worked, I think, in the Russian\nbaths or something like that, and I agreed to have a\n11\n12\nmassage.\n13\n14\nI regretted it. She massaged me in a very\ntough and rough way. And she wanted to put her\n16:07:25\n15\n17\nknees on my shoulder and I said no. I immediately\n16 called my wife when the massage was over and I told\nher about the bad experience I had. And I said to\n18\nher, see, I really don't like massages.\nBut my wife\n19\nlikes massages.\nAnd she has had\n--\nshe has massages\n20\nfrequently.\n21\nQ. This massage occurred in your bedroom in\n16:07:55\n22\nJeffrey Epstein's house; is that correct?\n23\nA. Not in my bedroom, in the bedroom that I\n16:07:59\n24\n25\nhad been assigned, which was a guest bedroom. The\ndoor was open. The\n--\na massage table was brought\n170\nEFTA00601323\n", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 170, "text_content": "1\nin. I kept my undergarments on.\nAnd I was massaged\n2\nmaybe for 20 minutes or 25 minutes.\nAnd then and\n3\nthen she left and I had an unpleasant experience and\n4\nI called my wife and I told her about it.\nQ.\n5\n6 assigned, which you previously referred to as your\nWas the bedroom to which you were\n16:08:28\n7\nbedroom\n8\nA.\nNo, no. I said \"my bedroom\" in the sense\n16:08:34\n9\nthat I was in it.\n10\nQ. Was the bedroom to which you were assigned\n16:08:38\n11\nin the private section of the residence?\n12\nMR. SCOTT: Do you understand the\n16:08:46\n13\nquestion?\n14\nA. Yeah, let me explain exactly. This\n16:08:47\n15\nrequires a long answer.\n16\nThere\nwhen you walk into Jeffrey\n16:08:52\n17\nEpstein's house, there are two areas. If you walk\n18\n19\nup the left side of the stairway, there are guest\nbedrooms, three or four guest bedrooms.\nThose were\n20 assigned to people like Senator George Mitchell,\n21\nEhud Barak, prominent guests who would stay in his\n22\nhouse. Each one had its own bathroom and its own\n23\nbed. I stayed there with my wife for a period of\n24\ntime.\n25\nBut then there was another area of the\n16:09:26\n171\nEFTA00601324\n", "char_count": 1118}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 171, "text_content": "172\n1\nhouse, which I have never been in, ever, and which\n2\n3\nnobody was allowed basically into, which was Jeffrey\nEpstein's part of the house, which contained his\n4\nbedroom and whatever other rooms. I've read about\n5\nthem, but I've never seen them. So it was in the\n6\nguest area of the house over the kitchen.\n7\nBY MR. SCAROLA:\n16:09:45\n8\nQ. Who told you no one was allowed in that\n16:09:47\n9\narea of the house?\n10\nA.\nI was told by the people that that was\n16:09:50\n11\noff\n--\noff limits, that that was Jeffrey's\n12\nQ. Which people?\n13\nA.\nGhislaine,\n16:09:54\nthat that\n16:09:56\n14\nwas Jeffrey's area of the house and that the guests\n15\nwere limited to the public areas of the house and\n16\n17\nthe and I think that's common in many houses when\nyou go and stay at somebody's house, you don't go\n18\ninto their bathrooms and their bedrooms.\n19\nQ. And it's common for people to tell you,\n16:10:11\n20\nyou're not allowed in this area of the house?\n21\n22\nA. People - people\nsupposed to go to that area of the house.\nguests are not\n16:10:15\n23\nQ. No, sir.\nThat's my question.\nIs it\n16:10:19\n24\ncommon for you to be told\n25\nA.\nYes.\n16:10:22\nEFTA00601325\n", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 172, "text_content": "1\nQ.\n173\nwhen you enter somebody's house, you're 16:10:22\n2\nnot allowed to go into this portion of the house?\n3\n4\n5\nA. Oh, yes. I just recently went to a\nbreakfast at somebody's house after Yom Kippur and I\nwanted to show friends of mine the art that was in\n-- a\n16:10:26\nthe house and I started walking down the house and\n10\n11\n12\n13\n6\n7\nthe waiter said, oh, I'm sorry, you're not allowed\n8\nin\n9\nin that part of the house, that's the private\nresidence. And so I had to turn around and show my\nfriends the art that was in the public area, not the\nprivate area\nQ. Jeffrey Epstein's art consisted of\nphotographs of young naked girls all over the house,\n14\nright?\n15\n16\n17\n18\nA. Are you testifying? That's false. I\nnever saw any such thing. Ever. Never saw a\npicture, with one exception, of a nude. The one\nexception was a sepia print of Rodin's model that\n19\nappeared on one of his desks.\n20\nBut in all the times I was at Jeffrey\n21\nEpstein's house in Palm Beach, the one time I was in\n22\n--\nhis house in - on the island, certainly the one\n23\ntime in\n--\n24\n25\na picture\nin the ranch because there was nothing\nthere, it was just a construction site, I never saw\nor in his house in New York, I never\n16:10:54\n16:11:01\n16:11:23\nEFTA00601326\n", "char_count": 1236}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 173, "text_content": "1\nsaw a picture of a naked woman, ever.\n2\nQ.\nThe notice for deposition with which you\n16:11:45\n3\nwere served both initially a few months ago and for\n4\ntoday's deposition is a notice of deposition duces\n5\ntecum. Could we please have the documents that\n6\nyou\n7\nMR. SCOTT: We have a disk. I'll hand it\n16:12:01\n8\n00\nto you at the end of the depo with everything\nthat's responsive\n--\n9\n10\nMR. SCAROLA: I would like it now, please.\n16:12:04\n11\nMR. SCOTT: Let the record reflect I'm\n16:12:13\n12\nhanding the disk.\n13\nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you.\n16:12:16\n14\nMR. SIMPSON: Just for the record, it's a\n16:12:17\n15\ndisk of all the documents that have been\n16\n17\nproduced in the case subject to the objections\nand privilege assertions that have been made in\n18\n19\n20\n20\n21\n21\n22\n22\n23\n24\n22\n25\nthe case.\nMR. SCAROLA: All right. And so that the\nrecord is clear, and hopefully you will be able\nto make these arrangements by tomorrow, one of\nthe things that we want are the original of the\nhandwritten documents so that we have an\nopportunity to examine those.\nMR. SCOTT: I'll talk to him\n--\n16:12:25\n16:12:40\n174\nEFTA00601327\n", "char_count": 1107}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 174, "text_content": "175\n1\n2\nMR. SCAROLA:\nCalendars.\n16:12:41\nMR. SCOTT:\n--\nwhether we comply or not.\n16:12:43\n3\n3\nWe'll discuss it off the record.\n41\n5 6☑\nMR. SCAROLA: The flight logs, anything\n16:12:44\nthat's in handwritten form.\nAnd we will reconvene tomorrow. What time\n16:12:50\n7\nwould you like to start?\n00\n8\nMR. SCOTT: 9:30.\n16:12:53\n9\nTHE WITNESS: The earlier the better.\n16:12:54\n10\n9:00.\n11\nMR. SCAROLA:\n9:00?\n16:12:55\n12\nMR. SCOTT: 9:00, good.\n16:12:56\n13\nMR. SCAROLA:\n8:00, want to go to 8:00?\n16:12:57\n14\nMR. SCOTT: No, 9:00 is fine.\n16:12:59\n15\nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. Thank you.\n16:13:00\n16\nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The\n16:13:00\n17\ntime is approximately 4:13 p.m.\n18\n(The proceedings ADJOURNED at 4:13 p.m.,\n19\nand will continue in Volume 2.)\n20\n21\n21\n23\n24\n25\n222\n22\nEFTA00601328\n", "char_count": 781}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 175, "text_content": "STATE OF FLORIDA\nCOUNTY OF BROWARD\n176\nCERTIFICATE OF OATH\nI, the undersigned authority, certify\nthat ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ personally appeared\nbefore me and was duly sworn on the 15th day of\nOctober, 2015.\nSigned this 15th day of October, 2015.\nKIMBERLY FONTALVO, RPR, FPR, CLR\nNotary Public, State of Florida\nMy Commission No. EE 161994\nExpires: 2/01/16\nEFTA00601329\n", "char_count": 366}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 176, "text_content": "177\nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER\nSTATE OF FLORIDA\nCOUNTY OF BROWARD\nI, KIMBERLY FONTALVO, Registered\nProfessional Reporter, do hereby certify that I\nwas authorized to and did stenographically report\nthe foregoing videotape deposition of ALAN M.\nDERSHOWITZ; pages 1 through 170; that a review of\nthe transcript was requested; and that the\ntranscript is a true record of my stenographic\nnotes.\nI FURTHER CERTIFY that I am not a\nrelative, employee, attorney, or counsel of any\nof the parties, nor am I a relative or employee\nof any of the parties' attorneys or counsel\nconnected with the action, nor am I financially\ninterested in the action.\nDated this 15th day of October, 2015.\nKIMBERLY FONTALVO, RPR, FPR, CLR\nEFTA00601330\n", "char_count": 719}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 177, "text_content": "October 15, 2015\nRe:\nBradley Edwards, etc. v. Alan M. Dershowitz\nPlease take notice that on the 15th day of October,\n2015, you gave your deposition in the above cause.\nAt that time, you did not waive your signature.\nThe above-addressed attorney has ordered a copy of\nthis transcript and will make arrangements with you\nto read their copy. Please execute the Errata\nSheet, which can be found at the back of the\ntranscript, and have it returned to us for\ndistribution to all parties.\nIf you do not read and sign the deposition within a\nreasonable amount of time, the original, which has\nalready been forwarded to the ordering attorney, may\nbe filed with the Clerk of the Court.\nIf you wish to waive your signature now, please sign\nyour name in the blank at the bottom of this letter\nand return to the address listed below.\nVery truly yours,\nKIMBERLY FONTALVO, RPR, FPR, CLR\nPhipps Reporting, Inc.\n1615 Forum Place, Suite 500\nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401\nI do hereby waive my signature.\nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ\n178\nEFTA00601331\n", "char_count": 1022}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00601154", "page_number": 178, "text_content": "ERRATA SHEET\nDO NOT WRITE ON TRANSCRIPT\nENTER CHANGES HERE\nIn Re: BRADLEY EDWARDS, ETC. V. ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ\nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ\nOctober 15, 2015\nPAGE\nLINE\nCHANGE\nREASON\nUnder penalties of perjury, I declare that I have\nread the foregoing document and that the facts\nstated in it are true.\nDate\nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ\n179\nEFTA00601332\n", "char_count": 331}]}