{"efta_number": "EFTA00304813", "page_count": 5, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00304813", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00304813.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00304813", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "PROFILES \nTHE VISIONARY \nA digital pioneer questions what technology has wrought. \nBY JENNIFER KAHN \n(\"N ne day in June, Jaron Lanier was \nV \nlounging barefoot in the living room \nof his house in the Berkeley hills. Stretch-\ning back on a wom sofa, he began musing \nabout the connection between Represen-\ntative Anthony Weiner's tweeting of lewd \nphotos and Facebook's controversial de-\nployment of facial-recognition software, \nwhich automatically scans uploaded pho-\ntos and identifies a user's friends. \nTo Lanier, a computer scientist and \nauthor, the common thread is that the In-\nternet in general—and social networking \nin particular—has become difficult for the \nordinary person to use with any security. \n'Tve really been struck that a lot of people \nhave said, 'Why would powerful men risk \nso much for some sexual adventure?'\" La-\nnier said. \"But risk can be very sexual.\" He \nbriefly considered the possibility oftwo al-\nternate Internets: one in which everything \nwas viewable by anybody, and one in \nwhich users had absolute control over \ntheir private information. In neither case, \nLanier said, would Weiner have sent his \nillicit snapshots. \"What makes it erotic is \nthe risk,\" Lanier speculated. \"If you had \neither perfect competence or no need for \ncompetence, because everything was a \nhundred per cent transparent, there would \nbe no risk. So, in a way, the whole erotic \nrisk factor of the Internet is being able to \nuse it but not very well.\" \nHe paused to interrogate a tortoise-\nshell kitten that was dozing in a corner of \nthe sofa. \"What's happening, Starlight?\" \nhe cooed. As the kitten peered up sleep-\nily, he added, \"We think she's female, but \nI haven't done the most thorough exami-\nnation.\" Ile paused and said dryly, \"If only \ncats texted, we'd know by now.\" \nLanier is often described as \"vision-\nary,\" a word that manages to convey both \na capacity for mercurial insight and a lack \nof practical job skills. In the nineteen-\neighties, he helped pioneer the field\n... [truncated, 7579 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00304813/0 or ?id=EFTA00304813&page=0]", "char_count": 7579}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00304813", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "seated himself before a tall golden harp. \nHe played a dark, plinky composition in \nwhat sounded like a minor key. \"It's not \nreally minor,\" Lanier said when I inquired. \nHe played another dissonant progression. \n\"It's not that simple.\" He gazed upward \nand added, \"I'm really interested in scales \nthat are harder to resolve.\" \nIn the nineteen-eighties, Lanier came \nto believe that virtual reality—the creation \nof computer-simulated environments in \nwhich real people can interact—would \nprecipitate an extraordinary \nrevolution in art and com-\nmunication. In an inter-\n\"The thing about technology is that it's \nmade the world of information ever more \ndominant,\" Lanier told me. \"And there's \nso much loss in that. It really does feel as \nifwe've sworn allegiance to a dwarfworld, \nrather than to a giant world.\" \ny parents were kind of like me \nin that they had tons and tons of \nweird, amazing stuff,\" Lanier explained. \nHe recalled that, as a boy, he dug \nthrough a pile of his father's junk and \nfound an antique telescope \nthat had once belonged to \nCommodore Petty. `This \nthing was just, like, on the \nfloor,\" he added. \"So this \nenvironment ofdutter, and \ninteresting objects, is ex-\nactly the one that I grew \nup in—just with differ-\nent objects. But I came by \nit honestly.\" \nLanier's mother and father belonged to \na circle of artists in Greenwich Village, but \nthey moved soon after Jaron was born—\non May 3,1960—first to Colorado, and \nthen to a spot near El Paso, Texas, on the \nborder with Mexico. The area was deso-\nlate and impoverished, and Lanier has \nspeculated that the move was driven, at \nleast in part, by fear. Lanier's mother, \nLilly, a pianist, painter, and dancer, had \nemigrated from Vienna when she was \nfifteen, after surviving a concentration \ncamp. His father, Ellery, the child of \nUkrainian Jews who had fled the pogroms, \nworked as an architect, painter, writer, \nelementary-school teacher, and radio host. \nWhen Ellery was seven, a dose relative \nwas murdered\n... [truncated, 9167 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00304813/1 or ?id=EFTA00304813&page=1]", "char_count": 9167}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00304813", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Tombaugh, who had discovered Pluto, in \n1930. As a teen-ager, Lanier took to stop-\nping by Tombaugh's house, where he \nwould sometimes look through his home-\nmade telescopes. With Tombaugh and \nother scientists, Lanier found that it was \npossible to have long conversations about \nabstract subjects like mathematics \"with-\nout even being there yourself\"—that is, \nwith little emotional connection. \nNot long afterward, Lanier began tak-\ning classes in math and chemistry at New \nMexico State University. At seventeen, he \ntransferred to Bard College, in New York \nTo cover the down payment on his tu-\nition, he sold fresh milk and cheese from \na herd of goats that he bred. But the tran-\nsition from goat herding to freshman civ-\nilization proved harsh, and he soon hitch-\nhiked back to New Mexico. \nA t nineteen, Lanier fell in love with a \ngirl named Cynthia Peck, a cellist \nvisiting from Pasadena whose mother \nknew Lanier's father. Peck recalls that La-\nnier was both \"intensely brilliant\" and \"ex-\ntremely needy.\" His room, when she first \nvisited, was heaped with dirty clothes. For \ntheir first official date, Peck insisted that \nthey visit a laundromat. They stayed for \nhours, washing load after load while La-\nnier serenaded her with a Japanese bam-\nboo flute. \nWhen Peck eventually returned to \nPasadena, Lanier followed, only to be told \nthat the romance had ended. From there, \nhe caught a ride up to Santa Cruz, where \nhe spent a few months engineering sounds \nfor video games before developing an un-\nusual game known as Moondust—a cult \nhit that used the motions of the joystick to \ngenerate the soundtrack Moondust led to \na job at Atari and then to Tom Zimmer-\nman, a coder in Palo Alto who had de-\nsigned an electronic glove that would \nallow the wearer to \"conduct\" a virtual \nsymphony. In 1985, Lanier, Zimmer-\nman, and a couple of partners founded a \ncompany called VPL, with the goal ofde-\nveloping other tools for virtual worlds. \nNot long afterward, the company helped \nthe \n... [truncated, 4655 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00304813/2 or ?id=EFTA00304813&page=2]", "char_count": 4655}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00304813", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "it seemed to be a combination of free-\nwheeling speculation and niggling detail. \nAmong other things, he complained re-\npeatedly about the team's use of NUI \n(pronounced \"newen as shorthand for \n\"natural user interface,\" arguing that the \nterm was used only \"inside the Microsoft \nbubble.\" \n\"What I'd like to say is biorealistic; \" \nLanier said, adding, opaquely, \"I think \nthat's really addressing the human nervous \nsystem on its own terms.\" \nHaynes mentioned that another re-\nsearcher had proposed the phrase \"com-\nputers that arc more like us.\" \nLanier squinchcd up his face. \"You see, \nI don't like that.\" \nHaynes turned to Galore. \"I is doesn't \nlike that.\" \n\"In fact,\" Lanier continued, laying his \nhands flat on the table, and then turning \nthem over to stare at his palms, \"I loathe \nthat. And the reason why is that it implies \nthis philosophical relationship between \npeople and machines that gives machines \na certain status.\" \n\"That they could become like us,\" Ga-\nlore affirmed. \n\"Yes,\" Lanier said. Then, as though \nsuddenly sensing the abstruseness of his \nown oratory, he sat back \"You know, it's \nfine,\" he said, waving a hand. \"I mean, it's \nreally good that there arc different points \nof view here.\" \nUnlike most polemicists, Lanier has a \ndisarming tendency to conclude forceful \nassertions with a momcnt of cheerful self-\ndeprecation. In part, this habit may be \nrooted in his desire to avoid confrontation \neven as he provokes it. But it also seems \nto reflect a worry about falling too deeply \nunder his own spell. During his time as a \npitchman for virtual reality, Lanier said \nat one point, he developed a \"hypnotic \nvoice\" with which he could \"entrance \npeople.\" He told me, \"I could have set \nmyselfup as a guru figure. But I withdrew \nfrom it, because I realized it was the wrong \nthing to do.\" \nThese days, though, a guru figure is \nsomething like what Lanier has become. \nHe was among the first critics to argue \nthat social-networking sites like Face-\nbook, which ge\n... [truncated, 5453 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00304813/3 or ?id=EFTA00304813&page=3]", "char_count": 5453}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00304813", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "computer science at Brown University, \nnotes. \"To create a layer of insulation. \nWe send an e-mail so we don't have to \ncall someone on the phone. Or we call \nsomeone so we don't have to go over to \ntheir house.\" Many of us also use tech-\nnology, he might have added, when we're \ntoo isolated: when someone wants to find \na new friend just because he's feeling \nalone—or because he's living with his fa-\nther in a freezing tent in the desert. \nT\nhe day after I talked with Lanier at \nhis home, we drove together to the \nVirtual Human Interaction Lab, a new \nvirtual-reality lab on the Stanford cam-\npus. As I settled into the car, a battered \nToyota Solara, Lanier apologized for the \ncondition of the front seat, the footwell \nof which was cluttered with old maga-\nzines, half-empty plastic water bottles, \nand a squashed box of tissues. As Lanier \nnavigated carefully into heavy traffic, I \nasked why he hadn't bought a luxury car, \nsince he could presumably now afford \none. Lanier sighed. \"The thing is, we'd \njust beat the hell out of it,\" he said. \nAt the campus parking lot, we were \nmet by the lab manager, Cody Kamm, a \nmellow, collegiate blond in jeans and flip-\nflops, who escorted us into the lab's \"ex-\nperimental room\": a squat chamber pan-\nelled in gray-and-tan fabric. A thin orange \ncarpet covered a \"haptic floor'' that can vi-\nbrate and judder. (Later, when I sawed \ndown a virtual fir tree in a simulated for-\nest, the ripping crash as the tree fell seemed \nto shake the ground.) \nIn one corner of the room, a plastic \nheadset and goggles hung droopily from \na long black cable. Karutz damped them \nfirmly to my head, tight enough to block \nout the light. When he launched the first \nsimulation, I found myself standing in \nwhat appeared to be the same room as be-\nfore, but there was a deep rectangular pit \nin front of my feet. \nThe pit simulation, Karutz explained, \ncan be used to test the degree to which \ncognitive knowledge—in this case, the \nknowledge that the floor does \n... [truncated, 4680 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00304813/4 or ?id=EFTA00304813&page=4]", "char_count": 4680}]}