{"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_count": 46, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00277521", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00277521.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Employee \nFlb - Serial Charge Out \nFD-5 (Rev. 10-13-89) \nDate /.0/2-Di 3 - \npile \n/ \nZ1O2-  \nClass. \nOffice of dein \nCase No. \nLast Serial \n0 \nPending \n0 \nClosed \nDate \nSerial No. \n• \nDescription of Serial \nChar \n \nrog \nPbv PA gg..2, 1e,- ,5 \n \nP r) Egh k‘h9Liel.5 /9 \n-7-neL4L51\n9(7 - I\n \ntopm nencm9IL-f000^-i \nEmployee \nRECHARGE \nDate \nTo  \n From  \nO \nLocation \nDate charged \nFPIRBK \nEFTA00277521\n", "char_count": 400}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "BOI\nES \nSCHI\nLLER \n& \nFLEXNER \nLLP \n401 EAST LAS OLAS BOULEVARD• SUITE I200. FORT LAUDERDALE. FL 33301-2211• PH. 954.356.0011 • FAX 954.356.0022 \nSigrid S. McCawley, Esq. \nEmail: \nFebruary 26, 2015 \nVia Federal Express \nFederal Bureau of Investigation \nAttn: FOI/PA Request \nReeord/Information Dissemination Section\nFederal Bureau of Investigation \nDepartment of Justice \nRE: FOL4 Request for pictures, videos and documents relating toy\nDear FOIA Officer, \nI represent \nand pursuant to the federal \nFreedom of Information Act. 5 U.S.C. §552, we are requesting the copies of materials relating to \n \n Specifically, \nwas interviewed by the FBI on March 17, 2011. \nA FD-302 report was entered on July 5, 2013. See Exhibit A. \nDuring the interview process, the FBI agents informed \nt they had retrieved \nfrom Jeffrey E stein's homes, video to es, CDs and DVDs, pictures an documents, that include \nvideo tapes of \nd documents (including but not limited to e-mails \nand other records discussin \nIt is our understanding that these images include naked \nimages of \nalto was a minor at the time, being forced \nto engage in sexual acts with adults and other minors. We are requesting copies of these \nmaterials. It is our understanding that the materials were collected from the following residences \nowned by Jeffrey Epstein. \n1) \n358 El Brillo Way \nPalm Beach, Florida 33480 \n2) \nLittle St. James \n6100 Red Hook Quarters, Suite B3 \nSt. Thomas. Virgin Islands 00802 \nWWW.EISFLI.P.COM \nvr-rot-hocod -0755 \nEFTA00277522\n", "char_count": 1510}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "• \n• \nBOIES. \nSCHILLER \n& \nFLEXNER \nLLP \nLetter to Federal Bureau of Investigation \nFebruary 26, 2015 \nPage 2 \n3) \n9 E. 71g Street \nNew York, NY 10021-4102 \n4) \n49 Zorro Ranch Rd. \nStanley, New Mexico 87056 \n5) \nThis request covers the time period of June 1999 to December 2002. We agree to pay \nreasonable duplication fees for the processing of this request in an amount not to exceed $5000, \nwithout prior authorization. \nIf our request is denied in whole or in part, we ask that you justify all deletions by \nreference to specific exemptions in the act. We will also expect that you will release all \nsegregable portions of otherwise exempt material. We of course, reserve the right to appeal your \ndecision to withhold any information. \nWe have included in our submission a Certification of Identity from our client Virginia \nRoberts, such that records can be released to Sigrid McCawley, her attorney. \nSincerely, \nSSM \nEnclosures \nSigrid S. McCawley \nEFTA00277523\n", "char_count": 970}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "EXHIBIT A \nEFTA00277524\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "(\nRAW (Rev. 5-840) \na \n-1 of 12 -\nFEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION \nSocial Security Account Number \nAustralian Permanent Resident, residence \nwas interviewed at the United States \nConsulate in Sydney, Australia. \nwas advised of the identity of \ninterviewing agents and purpose of the interview. Present during the \ninterview was Federal Bureau of Investigation Special Agent \nDateofemry \n \n07/05/2013\nUnited States Citizen and \nUnited States Attorney) \nfollowing information: \nthe \n(and via telephone, Assistant \nprovided the \nwas born in Sacramento, California to parents) \nI \n'date of birth) \ncurrently resides in \nand \ndate of birth \n \n currently resides in \n \nmoved to Palm \nBeach County, Florida with her parents when she was four years old and \nreturned to California at age 11. She returned to Florida at age 13 and \nwas placed in a rehabilitation or foster care facility in West Palm Beach, \nFlorida. \nan away from the rehabilitation facility when she was \napproximately 14 years old, and while living on the streets in Miami, \nFlorida, she met) \nIwas training \n'gave \nto be an escort) \na life off of the streets which made her feel \nInvestigation on \n03/17/2011 \nat Sydney, Australia (In Person) \nFuel 31E—MM-108062 \nbr \nI\nDate drafted \n07/05/2013 \nThis document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the propcny of the FBI and is loaned to your agency. it and its contents are not \nto be distributed outside your agency. \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nEFTA00277525\n", "char_count": 1509}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "r. _______ \nPr/\nAbatovosas.m \n31E—MM-108062\nConimatinOT0.3Wk0 \na \nAI, \n03/17/2011 \np a 2 of 12 \nlike she was locked into the relationship.) \n'gavel\npharmaceutical drugs toward the end of their relationship. \nrelationship with \nended while she was at a private \nranch near Ocala, Florida. \ntelephonically contacted a childhood \nfriend,' \n from a telephone at the ranch. \nknew' \n'from elementary school and called him at  the home  telephone \nof his parents \nr\n'she was \nvery lonely, an \nked her why she did not leave \ntelephone conversation with \n'the recreational vehicle \nas \nstaying in  at the rancho \n \nnot \nstrike her) \n'pack \nher belongings and told her she was going to live with another man. \nH \nfelt that she was sent to \nspecifics of the arrangement. \nengaged in sexual ac \n'who was described as a white male \napproximately one or two weeks before the police located her and \nher to her parents. \nparents were \nFlorida. \nstayed with \nwas interviewed by a male detective. \nstill married at the time and lived near \nbelieved there was \nShe never saw \nagain after \n1\nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7c \nb6 \nut did not know to \nb7c \nh \nstated \nLNU for \nreturned \nan FBI investigation related to \nIn approximately June 1998 or 1999 \nbegan wo ing at Donald \nTrump's Mar-A-Lago Club in Palm Beach, Florid\nlwas \nemplo \nbaby sitter and later as a locker \nclub. \ntherapist. \napproached \nIn\nbyl \nfather \nher gain \nroom attendant at the \ntarted studying for her GED and wanted to become a massage \nAugust, was \nreading an anatomy/massage book and \nland help her get her masseuse accreditation.' \n I \nwas \n I \nconsulted her father about the opportunity and at approximately \n5:00 p.m. the same day, her father drove her to a residence at \nb6 \nb7C \nEFTA00277526\n", "char_count": 1739}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "r \n• 202.2(Rsv. 05-08•)0) \na \nI \n31E—MM-106062 \nContinuation of F0.702 of \nO, \n03/17/2011 \nflir 3 of 12 \nFlorida. \nspoke with \nfather and told him \nit was a wonderful opportunity for  \nmet \nlalso known asl \nupstairs' \nas led \nOnce upstairs in \n \n'instructed \nbeginning the  massage The massage bega \ntechniques to \nto wash her  hands prior to \ndemonstrated massage \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nDuring the course of the massage\" \nuestioned \nb6 \nabout her past, including her time as a runaway. \nwas also \nb7C \nasked if she took birth control. \nwas given instruction and began kissing \nAt the conclusion' \nclothes. One wash cloth \nsecond was' \ndescribe4 \nand \ninstructed \nwas used to clean \no obtain two warm wash \nto help him relax \nen moved to the steam room and shower where \nwith soap and a loofah in the shower. \nAt the conclusion of the shower, \nwent downstairs and \nssaged \nArrangements were made for Mto \nreturn to the house the following day \nafter work. \ncellular phone number was given t4 \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nEFTA00277527\n", "char_count": 1038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "ke:nRcv 05-08-10) \n31E -MM -108062 \ne l\nCommusuon of FD-302 of 1 \nOn \n03/17/2011 .104, \n4 of 12 \nThe same routine and pattern of massages and sexual activity between \nland \nontinued for between one and two weeks. At \ntimes, \nJob at Mar-A-Lago and travel \nwas also discussion \nbe paid $200.00 per \n'offered\nthe option to quit her \nThere \nmassage training. \nas to \nda ijill\nel and $200.00 per hour for massages. \nEarly in her relationship with' \n lamed\nland was introduced asl \n'assistant. \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nsoon  began traveling \nFor the initial six months, \ntraveled \n'around the United States and Caribbean, \nb6 \nincluding California, New York City, New Mexico, and various business \n \nb7C \ntrips. During those trips,) \nSix to nine months after \nbegan working for' \nintroduced t4 \nIM0,1\n 'Florida. \nWas \nI in \nat the time. \nmet the couple at a condominium next to the'\nla \n'The condominium was bought' \nland was a \nprovided a normal massage t \nNU. Shortly \nprovided an \nand \ncleaned \npaid cash \npaid \nyears old at the tim \nadvised \ned that \nstill function\ndoing with \neight pills per \n  In the condominium, \nthereafter' \nLNU \nerotic massage to \nI S\nM\nShe was \nIn add  tion, \nXanax \nwas 16 \nintroduced her to the drug Xanax. \nhelped her escape from reality but allowed her to \nnormally. Xanax helped her go forward with what she was \nand others. Her habit went from two pills per day up to \nday. \nsecond client was an academic of some sort described as an \nolder American male' \n'sent \nfrom Miami International Airport to' \nI\nlby commercial airline. \nwas picked up at the \nairport byl \nland then taken to the island by boat. \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nof \neceiving \nEFTA00277528\n", "char_count": 1681}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "contract prevented \nperiod. \ninformatio \nµ64(RO' OS-OS-ICJ \n31E-MM-108062 \n(Conumailon of FD-302 of \npointed \n.on \n03/17/2011 \npage 5 of 12 \n. \nb6 \nb7c \nout that' \n'instructed \nI \no entertain the \nclient' \nI\nI \nland wanted \nto ride jet skis and participate in other island activities[ \ntwo days \npent \non the island \nwith the client. \nassumes t e c lent also traveled \ncommercially. \nDuring, thi following several months, \nPrior to her traveling abroad \ngetting her passport. \nprovided them t \ntraveled internationally \nssisted GIUFFRE in \nof passport photographs of herself and \nhe remaining paperwork was taken care of by \nIIIIIIIIIItraveled to Paris, France, the \n \n France, London, England, Africa, and Spain. While in Paris, \nrecalled staying at a hotel overlooking the Champs-Elysees. While \ntravelingr \ntraveled on \na black plane. During the international \ntravel, \ntimes, \nwould' \nAt \n'Rarely a day would pass' \nand wanted to talk to \n(contacted\nthrough \nabou \nland \noffered \na contract. \nagreed to the contract for her story \nand was paid S140,000 for the story, $10,000 when the article was printed, \nand another $10,000 to be wired into \naccount in May 2011. The \nfrom talking to any other press for a specified \nadvised that sheprovided' \n1ith detailed\nI \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7c \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7c \nEFTA00277529\n", "char_count": 1317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "atuattv 05-0840) \n31E -MM - \n( \nConttnuation of It -302 of \no n \n03/17/2011 \nppm, \n6 of 12 \nmet; \nlAt age 16, \napproximately the same age. \nbelieved she and \n'were \n \nI \nwould dress \n I \n-----lexplained \nprovided an \nAn unknown ind \ndescribed' \nsaw' \nwhen she arrived at \nhad' \nsaid that day was a low stage in her relationship \nbecause she could not believe \nnever \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nEFTA00277530\n", "char_count": 434}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "pr\n..111I \n,;:01a (Rcv 05-08-10) \nA \n31E-MM-108062 \nConiinuation of FD-302 0 \no, 03/17/2011 \nFaB0 7 of 12 \nsaw \nbelieved the girls may have been' \nI \nb6 \nI but \nb7c \nb6 \nb7C \nwas not certain \nhad a picture \nofF \n'involvement. \nof herself she wanted to give' \ndescribed some of the unique interior areas of \n'which IIIIIIIIreferred to \nwhich was where \nstayed. \nWhile in New York, \nalso stayed at an apartment  on 66th street \nwas aware of \n'additional\napartments in the same building. According to \nhe \napartment building on 66th street was owned byl \nadvised that she had a photo  raph of the interior of the 66th \nf \napartment among other photos \nStreet \nadvised that some of her photographs that were provided to her \ncivil attorneys by her family were not returned. One of the missing photos \ndepicted \nwearing a pink dress while seated on a quad bike. \nwas' \n(female that formerly lived inl \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7c \nb6 \nb7C \nEFTA00277531\n", "char_count": 937}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "jaiRre 05-08.8” \n31E-MM-108062\nCommumion of FD-302 o. \nLNU \ntoys,\nOn \n03/17/2011 .Page 8 of 12 \nwent shopping  together and purchased clothing and sex \nexplained that \n1 \nused a cellular telephone' \n'She believed  \na New York City number but could not recall the number. \nandF \ndid not \nunsuccessfully to gets \nrecalled \ncould only remember faces' \n'not their names. \nbut she did try \nt was \nnot recall the wording. \nadvised \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nbut she could \nb6 \nILNU. \nb7C \np \nNew Orleans, Louisiana. \nOrleans. \nYork, \nKingdom. \ntraveled' \nto a self-help conference at a hotel in \nThe hotel \ns near the H  rd Rock Café in New \nGIUFFRE traveled the worlw \n'ncluding the USVI, New \nSanta Fe, Palm Beach, France, Africa, Spain and the United \nrecalled visiting \nAlhambra Castle in Spain \nI \neventually traveled to the United Kingdom and \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nEFTA00277532\n", "char_count": 867}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Ao(Rey.05-0840 \n• \n31E-MM-108062 \nCOnttnation of FD-302 0 \n03/17/2012 pPar 9 of 12 \nwhile there' \n'approached \nin a very excited manner and told \nher they had to go shopping to pick out a dress because \nwould be\ndancing with) \nand' \nBurberr ba . The items\nan \nreturned' \ninstructed \nto get ready. When \ncame down after gettin \nready, she was introduced to' \nwent shopping and purchased makeup, clothin  , and a \nwere purchased with) \ndanced \ntraveled to CLUB TRAM \n'at CLUB TRAMP' \n 'stayed at CLUB TRAMP \nfor an hour or hour and a half and drank a couple of cocktails before \nreturning to' \n \nhad not received any direction \nfrom \nAfter returning toj \nrequested' \nIto take a photograph of her' \nadvised that she still had the original photograph in her possession  and \nwould provide it to the interviewing agents. \nproceeded with_ \nJ \nApproximately two months lateruett \nI\nrecalled \nLNU, I \nrecalled \n'joking about trading \nin because \nshe was getting too old. \nb6 \nb7c \n126 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7c \nEFTA00277533\n", "char_count": 1005}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "4023 (Rei 05-08-10) \n31E—MM-108062 \nContinuation of FD402 a \nOn \n03/17/2011 \npag, 10 of 12 \nrecalled meeting' \nand her recollection was not clear. \non the island that did not speak English \nhad an unknown accent. \nas using Xanax heavily at the time, \nb6 \nb7C \nShe remembered there were many models \nalong with a modeling person who \nI \nI \nI \nid not have a problem with \nusing prescription drugs. \n'was described by \nas a \nI \n(TRUE NAME UNKNOWN) \n \nla ranch employee In, \n(but \ncould not recall his name. She did have a photograph of the ranch \nemployee. \naca emits, p\n, \n1\nand \noliticians \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nInc \nb6 \nb7c \nmet numerous famous peopl \nkncluding \n!and 1 \nH\nb6 \nb7c \nShe me \nr\neceived many gifts! \nlincludinq jewelry, watches,\nbags, shoes, make up, clot\n ina, and home furnishings./ \n6IIIIIIM left all of the items behind when she traveled to Thailand to \nreceive massage training. \nIn August 2002, \ntraveled by commercial airline to Bangkok, \nThailand and began her massage training at International Training Massage \nSchool(ITM) where she receivedt hpr magRAae certification. She stayed at \nthe Princess Hotel in Thailand' \n \nI \n1 \n/but never did. \nstet her future husband,/ \n1 \nduring her visit to Thailand. \ncontacted! \n'telephonically and \ni mnld him she had fallen in love with someone. I \n \nI \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7c \nand celebrities. \nEFTA00277534\n", "char_count": 1357}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "4,0023 (Rev 05-08-I0) \n• \n31E-MM-108062 \nContinuation of FD-302 \nhad not heard from \nO, 03/17/2011 .ftg, 11 of 12 \nreceived a \ntelephone call from[ \nDuring that call' \nstated he was an \nFBI agent. \nHe was trying to determine what she knew about \n1 \nShe did not tell \n'anything about her knowledge of \nShe also received another telephone call from a \nperson that indicated he was an FBI agent. She did not tell that \nindividual anything either. She also received a call from an attorney that \nwas trying to determine if she had spoken with anyone or was willing to \nspeak to anyone' \n'She \nexplained that she was receiving telephone calls from people whom she did \nnot know and that she was uncomfortable telling them anything over the \ntelephone. \nOne or two weeks later, an unknown attorney and' \n(contacted \ntelephonically] \nnor her \ncarrier \nwas using a cellular telephone belonging to her husband. She \nhusband could recall the telephone number but advised that the \nwas OPTUS telephone company. \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nreviewed \nthe following: \na series of photographs of individuals and identified \nPage 1, number 1, \nLNU, a.k.a \nb6 \nb7C \nPage 1, number 2, \nPage 2, number 1, \nPage 2, number 6, \nPage 3, number 2, \nPage 4, number 3, \nLNU \nPage 4, number 7, \nPage 4, number 8, \nPage 5, number 1, \nadvised that the following were familiar to her, but she could not \nrecall their names or her association to them: \nEFTA00277535\n", "char_count": 1426}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "ANxammcvos.osdo \n31E-MM-108062 \nContinuaiion of FD-302 of l \nPage 1, number 4 \nPage 2, numbers 7 and 8 \nPage 3, number 8 \nPage 4, number 1 \nPage 5, numbers 5 and 8 \nThe images reviewed by \nfile. \nO, 03/17/2011 \ni p ast 12 of 12 \nwere placed in a lA envelope of the case \nWhen questioned about United States Customs and Border (CBP) Patrol \nrecords of her entries into the United States, \nadvised that her \nJanuary 2001 record was the return from her London, England trip \n'The April 2001 CBP \nsj \nrecord was her return to the United \nuld not recall her travel from \nMarch and May 2001 CPB records \nadvised that her United States \nPassport was turned over to the United States Consulate in Sydney, \nAustralia. \nOn March 18, 2011, writer, SA) \nland\ntraveled to \nresidence where she provided 20 photographs and her \nITM massage sc oo certification. FD-597 Receipts for Property were \nexecuted for the items and a copy was provided to \nIt is noted that \nthe receipts were dated based on the United States Eastern Standard Time \nZone date. The photographs, certification and original FD-597s were placed \nin a lA envelopes of case file. \nb6 \nb7C \nb6 \nb7C \nEFTA00277536\n", "char_count": 1164}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "r \n• \n• \n9W' \nFORM APPROVED OMB NO. Irk; 0016 \nEXPIRES 03,3 \nPrivacy Act Statement. In accordance with 28 CFR Section 16.41 Kt) personal data sufficient to identify the individuals submitting requests by \nmail under the Privacy Act of 1974.5 U.S.C. Section 5523. is required. The purpose of this solicitation is to ensure that the records of individuals \nwho are the subject of U.S. Department of Justice systems of records are not wrongfully disclosed by the Department. Requests will not be \nprocessed if this information is not furnished. False information on this form may subject the requester to criminal penalties under IS L'.S.C. \nSection 1001 and/or 5 U.S.C. Section 5523031. \nPublic reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average 0.50 hours per response, including the time for reviewing \ninstructions, searching existing data sources. gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of \ninformation. Suggestions for reducing this burden may be submitted to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs. Office of Management \nand Budget. Public Use Reports Project (1103-0016), Washington. DC 20503. \nFull Name of Requester \nCitizenship Status 2 \nLX  \n*\n; 4'...2-. en.  Social Security Number 3\nCurrent Addres \nDate of Birth \n, ‘_r\nPlace of Birth \nS\nt,Icitn;e 4, \nOPTIONAL: Authorization to Release Information to Another Person \nThis form is also to he canoleted by a mower who is authorizing information relating to himself or herself to be released to another person. \nFurther. pursuant to 5 U.S.C. Section $52atbl. l authorize the U.S. Department of Justice to release any and all information relating to me to: \nr 6 one. (\\No C \nel  \ns cc . \nPrint or Type Name \ni declare under penalty of perjury exam the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing is true and correct. and that I am the person \nlamed above. and I underst. and dot arry fainfactrice of this statement is punishable under the provisio\n... [truncated, 3202 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/16 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=16]", "char_count": 3202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "CIRCUIT COURT \nCRIMINAL DIVISION \nP.O. Box 2906 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33402-2906 \nSHARON R. BOCK \nClerk & Comptroller \nPalm Beach County \nI III !ill Ili' 'Ili ill a I ill in \n$2 \nFIRST C \nEFTA00277538\n", "char_count": 200}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "ELECTRONIC COURT REPORTING WITNESS LOG \nCASE NO. \n)- \n- \nPage \n• \n.47 - \n• \n• ' \nof \nITNESS \n= \nDIRECT \nCROSS \nREDIRECT \nRE-CROSS \nREDIRECT \nCONTINUED \nRE-CROSS \nCONTINUED \nEND \nTTL \n) \n1 • a' 18 \n/41;/,'!',.:::?-s) \n',;CA\n,!,,..\nI:_:---.v :47 / 0:5g:.---2,<3 \n/Pi/ \n'42- \nif . 31' \nIi\niite=7-\n. \n. \n'1'21- (24 \n- \n. \nzo:./x.:cz:,\nii:34:aci \n.7:_54:47,---\n,y :56:64e \n/2:;4:56, \newva•-ifroic+\n.,fAa),71\".e,e7.2)/\n771,74-5 .2)472F2) 4-/g5/0A. —,4•5A : Alof,o1 I 0 y /INN ZeideszfN \n1.17:22 \n/:3•1:.51\nDefense A torneylsi: \nAsst. State ADM: 4444//zak4ow\nA E \nA-14.cy Abov .2>/eS1,4A/ \nEFTA00277539\n", "char_count": 596}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "ELECTRONIC COURT REPORTING WITNESS LOG \nSTATE V. \n \nCASE NO. \n_ \n______ __ - \n- \n-- -.- \nDAT \n__ \nE \nST \nWITNESS \nDIRECT \nCROSS \nREDIRECT \nRE-CROSS \nREDIRECT \nor \nCONTIA'UEL \nDES \n7.49 /CZ> 7f \nI:14: LC3 \n1O:620:.28 \n7/min it \ninn .. 15\" \n7404- \n\" \n• \n.. \n7/141/40/ 71 \n9:21: 124C \n7/19/01. \ni  \n/ I:34:er \n7/9/04 1T \n;1 :64:M \nCeMbinty \n.(2.:\".//h3V.(2, -rzemiA ..774Py2)//Cre:7216 \n2)41-2C7) .4/,2_4,/.0 \n7494A TT \n,  i \n. \nB: Bench Conference \nDefense Attorney's': \n*: Motion to Strike \nAsst. State Atty[s]: 411A/NA 45302.0111AVEK \n.thipy•flivAtabekviliN \nForms:Witness Log - 2005 \nEFTA00277540\n", "char_count": 598}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Jy -71/4O, \ngel/4: Ig \n46:o6 „ \n21 . \n16:01.. \n16: \nj7:16 \n17: 37. \n/8: 09 . \n5b \n2e): 25 \n9.21: \n2z:20... \n22: 2q... \n2,3.30... \n2 \n(.; \nZ-\n29115.. \n21:23 \n36:62_ \n3::I E3 \nS- I: /3 \n1,/ \n.\\c.-iSee..A. \nay \netthaehra47e. tedeadoc440,474Vat.) \n77. \none- tat \ndoie/t (dee \notifrx Ieed/ze fradi \n/dee ne:, Mee-\nk/de) edlit e&irze. \n/5. \ntie/se9,4 'it \nayyszy# aided \nAke) tc.ee \nbric \ncde/d/inz\n /fr tOi \n1 5/Se.4 \n./aeari-\n-t2 t‘& -Z \n6/fi(ttz \nfrr\n /emit \nofeA viet) \n<7, \n•:;;A.c7ribry \ndv.c.\n. ,ettfr Lwict\n\" \n01.142 (Gt . /9O \nEFTA00277541\n", "char_count": 543}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "a\n-749\n/ ( 713 \n9t/9._\n.55: /6 \n33: I'5 \n34:a5 \n35:38 \nzz) \n37: se,. \n28: 1L# \nAo \n40: / .3 .49\n40: 3b\n4Z o& \n42:12 \nzialteet (est \nheir:ed \n,reefr \n9 /$07 4e/cher_ \natzfotd.7.4todor_J \n,Efrie:e/ \ndesS.,ze \nz:;9/ \nvie az /8 \nfize \nAna. \nSP-zy \n- \nit+ ditheefiek‘o \n \n6aeS Iwz die \ntat \nde-di \nadwzbe) ae \nileSezzdzailw6e\n7i1E \n43:52 \n \n \na\n-Ad& \n4i: /9  \n \ni-rente -zero \nOr see) \n44:57. . ea \n\"the atAcade( \n46:77.. 6d \ne-af-ez \naredeAdvsei \n17: 0 8 \nat 1\" \nyzet,e.24L.E., \n17: 22* zyied, \ntett, \n14: /5 \n.0r: \n223 \nEFTA00277542\n", "char_count": 530}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "e \n1••-• \n7.heLL- 7 datpesece \n_ \"frixtelacr ,,#‘Zw, \nA-2,c)-Aseati \n52:00 \noh/adz adi-e145\nSae -tan-hi/0d\n52: 5g AAA >irtaayagee.- .oe . de. \n53: 55 lie\n5c 40 ..vatzegadtheeel \naye *zio e..idelokleaff#_2po.eze./ \n.5.5; ¢ \n7 \n.%: 0 Z \nd 012.1-7,1/ Ad si 25-4 ge2e) • -air \na ?ere-12 \nf:510.3 __raft; _ \nST: 55 _ 9iffet 4: \n,5g: 2i _zat \nfot zee2 \nzgatz. \nSe: 4,5 49/fiey : \n59:00z lietr \n.54:/7 *efe :\n10:66 0 P \n17e6Ree \n(a.-ta: 24e \n*cold \nno: \n7-8 _nit \n(89 7 \np So gitA&%/Naftli-x_., \noz:,k9 feniAfrad \n0:77 \n2 ye e 7,742 \n03:1 2_ \nail> lieg \nte__ \net 0 5 - \n9/z /4.5 ✓Ct/aLa2~1i~,' i%\"'ad/a \nfilf,4 \nd5 .5* \nO: \n2_61 \nreCl \n6:5: \n/0/34 \n\u0013 Aek \n**G`45 Allage \n/ \n- \nEFTA00277543\n", "char_count": 683}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "/z727: 50,\nagived\n9 f : 23 \n10:27 \n.„5-\n‘C • \nil /61/12‘ \n./PlefrX ziI& \ndfaZ iitay \nmetz4 ate. \nadiricoe \n_thdr y \ndeLeadc \n._13: /O \nazd -tag. \n. 14; 0 5.- \naareneed. S200 Zie \n;&% \n2e \nAida \n0 -A. atZ daSzed \neZZ fkiage4A-&1 *axed( \n. bee)a(atiakj diezwadazt34gregete# ist \nheec.)gtee\n.. \nAl),\n - \nwL/,SeavA ze) joeir izatie \n4:37 \n/5:3O \n/‘: Zeg \n11:LS \n/5 : O5 \nis: 30 \n41<e \nSe.\" \nali4e \n/ 7>. \n/970 \nAte& \nZ/:03.. \n3 \n23:3O# Ve \n211-04z \nZ6' &C * \n27143. . dee& \n/6) \nZ1: 51 \n:Z¢ \n•\n \nziewidhet?bitty-egz\n-zazedz,43-\n,ftsetowt-\nLeda* \nkrAidazii :CAL \nale./1t2--Levedy \n/42d 71\n/b ati th\n/7\nEFTA00277544\n", "char_count": 610}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "tty 5 \n-7/e OA \n„brit de\n brnezilata2,406i/ \n3/: 05* 6kd \n.t2,4vieegz /7 \n• \n: 5.9794, is,/ \n \n,7).\". \n/9 \n3Z \n. . af.),\"1-xed 4W  G E taelgi-xiept \n▪ \no o \n.33:34 \n.31. 22 \n_Sea: 22 \n37:2e \n4/: /5 \nfrk ionc&A \n(fr-eaci are& \nr.oeiti_) \nvice \nicifilowed \nzal ztitea,,e \nJew()\n77/zesre--,\nfrr.\nicaffoieZ \n_a)zed \n47: 47* thitarteecead geesee \ngrA Asivize-\n?it duoa ow frseeadayzate a? a siedzeitmaite \n42:5£3_. It\n yeleadadeekatilfr \n.15. O \n042 nese,/ \n/ \n• \n43: 54 Pier \neigagezz,z)w.itfrela \nAC \nr5\n, _dr \nrta \n4:2¢ \n*tr \nti.5: oa re\n/\n.95: 3 5 \n• \n15: \n/17: 0 a_177 \n47 /S \n/ 2-\n/c; \nEFTA00277545\n", "char_count": 600}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "lb: \n±5 ie dd. \nneatsaa.\" aide-\n19:38 \nAge-latetOdia4i2 /LI \n20:.¢3 (eze \n20: \n, \ndieldattzi \n/\n:9 \n/0.s. do •Cdr: \n50: 44 \n.5/:40f \n..5/: se). \n62: /2 \n52:2g \n53:20.\n.53: .52 \n.50\": 52 \n/2 \n¢7 \n..5Z; 40 \n.5732 \n.58/_3 \nV: 59, Zg \n//71: /0 \nIt//:/ \nERIE= \ntel'45'F2),\nlb: 02 \n9iitest CC zzaci Jeic \n, \na6a\n iageZ \nee \nEFTA00277546\n", "char_count": 331}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "nal/Atte es-ore, • \n/123: 22 \nZPV/ayt\n23: 3 \n// \n\" \ndad) \n2¢: 10 \nfieedit.ed aVllyievavera -\n40freti-,\n26:14, \nat-z\" heafrhi.laYa/z \n25: Sg \nday#L9 \n/1\n/ 9ea6/2-ge&-ti \n27:20 \ngar 1\", \nze: 4 a _Ina \n29: 00 \n9eler \n29:1S__ 7Gay 4: \n24: .53 \n91/44 ; \n1/31: 5a_ ax Awed \n11:32.; 07 _ \n\"YealEZ \n//-32. \n(21t A \n) ed-a.w \n/ \n1,910 Odd fri)Aii,a /64ice. ase/Afem.Z \nzaizie-zate-Zio-46)---4442:d \ni\n.3t-..o 3 \n:O2: eno \n11:39. 29 \n35 0' \n37: 4is \noe \n563:3c1 \n20 \na--x_ Aga/ \njiff/ \n'ieeezaz-\natetZo,\n/64ic See' ?rr  orz_ /azz :44/4, \nefegis\n \nze \nri jay 7-ez4f:A/ \nezz-d_ \ng61 \nazi/eZ- \nheze \n\"wee /at tzco, \nEFTA00277547\n", "char_count": 616}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "ird0 /5 \n40:418X \n4/:20A \n4z:47.\n13:/0 \n4#:27 \n5-6,31.t \n45. 40 \n17:07 \n47: 3,alc \n47. 5S \n59 \n50:31 \n5z 7 -7 \n52/8 \n52: 32.\n53:39 \nI:51: 4 z \n7:55:3z \n57:¢0 \n57:06 \n7GY: ,9 \nif4y g \n17' 9/a 6 \nntig (ene, .) \ns ze-zee_, \nazi)7,-)ei \nkti#frecsreed_ \nGL led na \na> \nfrazey \n9,- te*.eiekdai6ziact \nAte\nea atitzegeei 52(44ey \niL \ndam. rezeJAegeiredidd \nAtaY/xiezed /2-407,6e7 :Za-e5e-Z \n5keyc L ite-diedfa9.4 eack-atiee,aai,5_flgiezec, \n57//47 1: /4a.41 sky #1.4/7\n,aflfroi \n7\n.n \n..-eiddide \nc \n,Y9i6eZ \nafe,;Pdizt, \n.zedte  \n) ,.;vesta.a.ti \nA,tr,t4say \n1_94atiere.six_ \nEFTA00277548\n", "char_count": 582}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "id* (.7 \n7Ailee \n/2a :s \nlledied>6e/m kekaczz)die2e-\n051.3( \n77/4 .1 Aide<Wx \nitaild,j440% SI/dee c \n- died \n07:2e) \nage I/id ;brae \nesectee4, adz \nnyeas/z4v.../ \nas:29 \n9,41.7 \nDe: 57 \nI \nalias.: ceaer \natlayediati-idedx-yrih,trAZAset \n:\niaszia 7ze lie fr\nedees.i./ \n7/O: /0 9ey \n/0: 2q \ntyear\n:622. _9a/er  : \n/2: 3o \n(10, \n/3: 20 \nrey e: \n5491 \nt \n/1: /5 \nlay 1: \n/11:34_ cleat  1 : \n10/4: 56._ \nkeeled \nAteta/7? \n--. \n(2-5/: 4f_S \n.06Z -39I \ng \n4 -25/ob - \n4: \nthaindlel Fal.e.etc) \n7\n77: /7 \n; ;T. 22 ?Ida/ea \nade ¢ Sa aweet:**,i \nEFTA00277549\n", "char_count": 549}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "scdejezt(eiesci•••-) \n/: 151:00 \nl&tricel \neke., \n/t. 20 \n\" \nP  \n/9: 24 \ne-ti /rier-eiixt, oiee \n, • \n2/ :/,4 \nae) \n \n21: 3 z \n.41/ %ft , \n azetie, aid eie;o/ \nn:00  \nke\nen?.. \na 06 ith /Q44,144. \nal \n[fia4efivocitt,t.t \n24: 10 \n/mei) (de/ \n'tat/bait -4s \n27: 52 .5fr/e2‘ \nfugac./fiefre \n2,9: 0 a _ \nefrix/cilee2thek ak \ne \nAtize-e/d4/ \n29:55-* /friv,ted /CatieVe.6 \nN1/4 /251- 6/27/04_ . _ \n: b4 \ntali \n25 en , \n7erzez Sc\n15 38 44' \nixideigAideetnernei 3/2oM 44211\nX55/24 \n.311:17 \ng et a _./d a ,_ a fitede\niefread \n4,_ *deed \n35:58 /4t \n/Ai ;-/c . 2 r /dile Sal) \n...54,: /7 \nX : itake Se \nxix-edit)2,_Seat--/ \nA\n96:•/-7 \ntall 1: bdirdzea \njr,/a\n64-6-- \"\ne\n37: S-'\n• \n_ IT te, \noZ) \nfaty ge: ‘Pk',a17-/redelegiet ;/,;e0f4,c,lyea.e, \n5g: al \n9l49 \n5/ if 3,w/a \nEFTA00277550\n", "char_count": 776}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "UU/U0, ,CUU0 ZU:41 rAA 001OULII01 \nUbAU Orb ty \ntrJUUZ \nU.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \nSeptember 6, 2006 \nDELIVERY BY FACSIMILE \nDenise Coffman, Esq. \nCounsel to the Clerk of Court and Comptroller \n15th Judicial Circuit of Florida \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \nRe: \nFederal Grand Jury Subpoena \nDear Ms. Coffman: \nThank you for your agreement to accept service of the attached subpoena by facsimile. As \nI discussed with Kim Collins, the Clerk of Court is the custodian of the transcripts' of the state grand \njury proceedings. Ms. Collins asked me to inform you that the transcripts are kept in the Circuit's \nCriminal Department. Florida Statute Sections 905.17(1) and 905.27 discuss the disclosure of state \ngrand jury transcripts. Pursuant to those statutes, a transcript can be released upon an order of \"a \ncourt.\" The statutes do not require that the order be issued by the Palm Beach County Court. \nI have attached two cases regarding the procedures for obtaining state grand jury transcripts \nfor use in federal grand jury investigations. The cases that I have enclosed suggest that the \nappropriate way is to issue a federal grand jury subpoena to the party currently in possession of the \ntapes and/or transcripts of the proceedings. The cases that I have enclosed both involve orders issued \nby a federal court that compel the production of the transcripts. \nIf the Clerk of Court feels that she cannot comply with the grand jury subpoena absent an \norder from the United States District Court compelling the production, then you must file a motion \nto quash the grand jury subpoena before the United States District Judge who empaneled the federal \ngrand jury. Alternatively, if you like, you can state in writing your inability to produce the transcript \nabsent a court order, and I can proceed before the United States District Judge by filing a motion to \nII do not know whether the grand jury proceedings have yet been transcribed. The\n... [truncated, 2361 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/30 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=30]", "char_count": 2361}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "U9/Ub/ZUUb ZU:4Z FAA D010041/6( \n \nUSA° nro FL \n14,1 Qua \nDENnECtolauuskEsQ. \nSerrEABER6.2006 \nPAGE 2 \ncompel with a proposed order for the United States District Judge to sign. If you prefer to file your \nown motion, I can assist in notifying the Court of the motion, which should be filed ex parte and \nunder seal in accordance with Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(e)(5) and (6). \nThe subpoena calls for the production of the tape(s) OT transcripts by September 15, 2006. \nIf you need any additional time, please let me know. \nIf you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to call me. Thank you for your \nassistance. \ncc: \nSpecial Agent \nBy: \nSincerely, \nAssistant United States Attorney \nEFTA00277552\n", "char_count": 725}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "UU/U6/ZUUb ZU:4Z !AA Obl4UZII4/ \nUSAU nre I-I. \nV.J 0.0V \nUnited States District Court \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nTO: \nCUSTODIAN OF RECORDS \nClerk of Court and Comptroller \n15th Judicial Circuit of Florida \nPalm Beach County Courthouse \n205 North Dixie Highway \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \nSUBPOENA TO TESTIFY \nBEFORE GRAND JURY \nFGJ 05-02(WPB)-Fri./No. OLY-17 \nSUBPOENA FOR: \nPERSON \nDOCUMENTS OR OBJECT[S] \nYOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear and testify before the Grand Jury ofthe United States District \nCourt at the place, date and time specified below. \nPLACE: \nPalm Beach County Courthouse \nJuvenile Courts Building \n205 N. Dixie Highway \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \n(Temporary location for the United States District Courthouse, West Palm Beach) \nROOM: \nRoom 4-A \nDATE AND TIME: \nAugust 18, 2006 \n9:00am \nYOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following document(s) or object(s): \nTapes or transcripts of any and all proceedings before the Grand Jury on Wednesday, July 19, 2006, \nreferring or relating to Jeffrey Epstein and/or Sarah Kellen, including but not limited to witness \ntestimony, statements made by any member of the State Attorney's Office, and instructions given by any \nmember of the State Attorney's Office. \nPlease coordinate your compliance of this subpoena and confirm the date and time of your appearance with \nSpecial Agent Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Telephone: (561) 822-5946. \nPlease sec additional information on reverse \nThis subpoena shall remain in effect until you are granted leave to depart by the court or by an officer acting on behalf \nof the court. \nCLERK \nThis subpoena is issued upon application \nSeptember 6, 2006 \nName, Address and Phone Number of Assistant U.S.  Attorney \nEFTA00277553\n", "char_count": 1773}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "UN/VD/LOUD ZU:4C rAA 0010V41JOI \nVaAv tiff, IL, \n832 F.2d 554 \n832 F.2d 554, 24 Fed. R. Evid. Sm. 275 \n(Cite as: 832 F.2d 554) \nH \nUnited States Court of Appeals, \nSeventh Circuit. \nIn re GRAND JURY PROCEEDINGS—Subpoena to \nState Attorney's Office. \nThomas H. Greene, Dawson A. McQuaig, Jake \nGodbold, Don McClure, Intervenors-\nAppellants. \nNos. 87-3228, 87-3412-87-3414, and 87-3472. \nOct. 26, 1987. \nRehearing and Rehearing En Banc Denied Dec. 10, \n1987. \nPersons whose state grand jury testimony had been \nsubpoenaed by a federal grand jury appealed from \norder of the United States District Court for the \nMiddle District of Florida. Nos. MISC-J-86-183-14, \nMISC-J-86.183- 4, Susan H. Black, J., which \ndenied motions to suppress subpoenas. \nThe Court \nof Appeals, Tjoflat, Circuit Judge, held that: (1) \nappellants could appeal denial of the motions to the \nextent that they asserted a privilege, but (2) Florida \nstatute imposing secrecy on grand jury does not \ncreate evidentiary privilege. \nAffirmed in part and dismissed in part. \nWest Headnotes \n[1) Criminal Law C=01023(3) \n110k1023(3) \nGrand jury proceeding is not a \"civil action\" for \npurposes of statute permitting interlocutory appeals \nin civil actions with respect to controlling questions \nof law. 28 U.S.C.A. § 1292(b). \n[2) Criminal Law (C\n1023(3) \n1101c1023(3) \nPersons whose state grand jury testimony had been \nsubpoenaed by federal grand jury could appeal the \ndenial of their motions to quash the subpoenas to \nthe extent that they asserted a privilege as to the \nmaterial, but could not raise issues of procedural \nviolations or federal-state comity on appeal. \n[3) Criminal Law e8=1023(3) \n110k1023(3) \nWhen party has been subpoenaed to testify or \nproduce records for grand jury and third-party \nmerely fears that privileged material may be \ndisclosed along with other, nonprivileged material, \nPage 1 \nthe case is not ripe for appellate review until the \nsubpoenaed party has actually been asked to reveal \nspecific mate\n... [truncated, 3599 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/33 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=33]", "char_count": 3599}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "88/66/2086 20:43 FAX 5618021787 \ntISA0 UPS FL \n1j006 \n832 F.2d 554 \n(Cite as: 832 F.2d 554, *555) \ninfluence peddling by certain public officials of the \nCity of Jacksonville. \nWitnesses appearing before \nthe state grand jury included the four appellants in \nthis case: \nJake Godbold, then the mayor of \nJacksonville. Don McClure, \nGodbold's chief \nadministrative aide, Dawson McQuaig, a former \ngeneral counsel for the city, and Thomas Greene, a \npracticing attorney and an associate of Godbold's. \nEach of these witnesses appeared and testified \nvoluntarily. \nNo criminal charges resulted from the state grand \njury investigation. \nIn August 1985, however, the \nstate grand jury issued a report that identified \nseveral instances in *556 which 'political favors and \ngame-playing for friends\" had infected the City's \nprocess of awarding contracts for professional \nservices. \nGodbold. McClure, McQuaig, and \nGreene each waived his right under Fla.Stat. § \n905.28(1) (1985) to suppress the report. \nThe \nreport, however, did not contain the substance of \ntheir testimony. \nMeanwhile, federal prosecutors had initiated a \nfederal grand jury investigation into substantially \nthe same matters investigated by the state grand \njury. \nGodbold. McQuaig, McClure, and Greene \neach indicated that he would assert the fifth \namendment if subpoenaed to testify before the \nfederal grand jury. \nRelying on the disclosure \nprovisions of Fla.Stat. §n905.27(1)(c) (1985). [FNI) \nthe United States in August 1985 petitioned a state \nto order the StateAttomev_to_nim over tnjhe \nfederal grand jury the appellants' state grand jury \ntestimony. \nThe United States made no factual \nsubmission in support of its petition. \nJle_state \ntiigerefagegij\ni, characterizing the \neffort to obtain the testimony as a -fishing \nFNI. Undo this provision, a cowl may order \ndisclosure of grand jury testimony for the purpose \nof 'fflurthering justice.\" \nIn October 1986, the federal nand jury issued_a_ \nsubpoena duces tecum orde\n... [truncated, 4910 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/34 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=34]", "char_count": 4910}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "U*14.$0, LUVO LV.40 fAA \nJOAOULLIOI \nVJAV \nOfD fL \nwjvul \n832 F.2d 554 \n(Cite as: 832 F.2d 554, *556) \nconsidering the new information in camera, the \ndistrict court entered an amended order in which it \nreversed its original order denying the motion to \nquash. \nThe district court certified its amended \norder for interlocutory *557 appeal pursuant to 28 \nU.S.C. § 1292(b) (1982 & Supp. 11 1984), and this \ncourt granted permission to appeal. The four \nintervenors appealed, although the State Attorney \ndid not. \nAppellants make two arguments before this court. \nFirst, they argue that the government's motion for \nreconsideration was untimely and that the district \ncourt therefore had no authority to hear it. \nAccording to appellants, the applicable time limit \nfor \nthe \nmotion \nwas \nthe \nten-day \nlimit of \nFed.R.Civ.P. 59(e). not, as the government \ncontends, the thirty-day limit of 18 U.S.C. § 3731 \n(1982 & Supp. 11 1984). Second, appellants argue \nthat the district court's amended order was in error \nfor the following reasons: (1) the government had \nfailed \nto demonstrate a sufficient need for \nappellants' grand jury testimony, and (2) comity \nrequired the court to give greater deference to the \nstate \njudge's \ndecision \nagainst \nreleasing \nthe \ntestimony. \nBecause of the nature of our ruling \ntoday, we do not reach the merits of these \narguments. \nn. \nWe first address the threshold issue whether we \nhave jurisdiction to hear this appeal. Although this \ncourt granted the intervenors permission to appeal \npursuant to section 1292(b), we must of course \ndismiss the appeal if we are without jurisdiction. \nSee Robinson v, Tanner. 798 F.2d 1378, 1379 (11 th \nCir.1986), cen. denied. 481 U.S. 1039, 107 S.Q. \n1979, 95 L.Ed.2d 819 (1987). \nUnder section 1292(b), a district court may certify \nfor appeal a non-final order entered in a civil action \nif the court is of the opinion that the order \"involves \na controlling question of law as to which there is \nsubstantial ground for\n... [truncated, 5095 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/35 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=35]", "char_count": 5095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "u US \n832 F.2d 554 \n(Cite as: 832 F.2d 554, '558) \n[2] We next examine whether there is a separate \nbasis for appellate jurisdiction in this case. \nAs we \nhave already indicated, orders denying motions to \nquash grand jury subpoenas are ordinarily not \nappealable final orders under section 1291. \nThe \nsubpoenaed party can obtain review by refusing to \ncomply with the subpoena and then contesting a \ncontempt citation, which is immediately appealable. \nSee United Stares v. Ryan. 402 U.S. 530, 532-33, \n91 S.Ct. 1580, 1582, 29 L.Ed.2d 85 (1971). The \ncontempt route for obtaining review, however, is \nnot open to a third party who claims a privilege of \nnondisclosure with respect to materials in the \ncustody of the subpoenaed party. \nIn such a case, \nthe putative privilege-bolder has no power to \ncompel the subpoenaed party to incur a contempt \ncitation. \nAnd the subpoenaed party, unless he has \neither a particularly close relationship to the putative \nprivilege-holder \nor \na \npersonal \ninterest \nin \nnondisclosure of the material, is unlikely to risk a \ncontempt citation simply to vindicate the rights of \nthe third party. In this situation, the order denying \nthe motion to quash is indeed final with respect to \nthe putative privilege-bolder, for any prejudice be \nsuffers as a result of disclosure will remain forever \nunredressed unless appeal is permitted. \nAccordingly, this circuit follows the so-called \nPerlman exception to the general rule prohibiting \ninterlocutory appeal of orders denying motions to \nquash grand jury subpoenas. See In re Grand Jury \nProceedings (Twist), 689 F.2d 1351 (11th Cir.1982) \n; In re Grand Jury Proceedings (Fine), 641 F.2d \n199 (5th Cir. Unit A Mar. 1981); \ncf. \nIn re \nInternational Horizons, Inc., 689 F.2d 996 (11th \nCir.1982) \n(discovery \norder \nin \nbankruptcy \nproceedings). \nThis exception, derived from \nPerlman v. United Smiles. 247 U.S. 7, 38 S.Ct. \n417, 62 L.Ed. 950 (1918), and confirmed in United \nSuites V. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683, 691, 94\n... [truncated, 5162 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/36 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=36]", "char_count": 5162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "utni \n832 F.2d 554 \n(Cite as: 832 F.2d 554, *559) \nthose matters and we turn to appellants' claims of \nprivilege. \nFN4. We should emphasize that this discussion \nrelates only to appellants' right to appeal wider the \nPerlman exception. \nIt does not relate to their \nstanding to raise these claims before the district \ncourt. \nThe appellants' motions to intervene in the district \ncourt proceedings reveal the nature of the privilege \nthey assert. \nAppellant McQuaig's motion stated \nthat \"[p)rior to appearing before the [state) Grand \nJury, Mr. McQuaig was advised by the State \nAttorney that pursuant to Section 905.27, Fla.Stat. \n(1985): a) none of the testimony he provided to the \nGrand Jury was disclosable under the law; and b) \nany disclosure of said testimony was a crime.\" \nAppellant Green's motion stated that \"[the) state \ngrand jury proceedings were secret and confidential \nby virtue of the provisions of Chapter 905 of the \nFlorida Statutes.\" \nAppellant Godbold's motion \nstated that \"testimony was provided with the \nunderstanding on the part of Jake Godbold that \npursuant to § 905.27 of the Florida Statures. his \ntestimony would not and could not be disclosed \nunder the law.\" \nFinally, appellant McClure's \nmotion stated that \"[Ole substantial interest of Don \nMcClure is equal to or greater than that of the two \nother parties previously allowed to intervene? \nIn etc/nine, then, appellants derive the privilege \nthey assert from the Florida statutory grand jury \nsecrecy requirement. \nThe statute imposing that \nrequirement provides as follows: \n(I) A grand juror, state attorney, assistant state \nattorney, reporter, stenographer, interpreter, or \nany other person appearing before the grand jury \nshall not disclose the testimony of a witness \nexamined before the grand jury or other evidence \nreceived by it except when required by a court to \ndisclose the testimony for the purpose of: \n(a) Ascertaining whether it is consistent with the \ntestimony given by the witness befo\n... [truncated, 5064 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/37 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=37]", "char_count": 5064}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "tj.J.L.1 \n832 F.2d 554 \n(Cite as: 832 Fad 554,'560) \nFed.R.Crim.12. 6(e). relates to disclosure of federal \ngrand jury records. \nIt cannot be asserted in the \nform of a privilege by appellants. who seek to \nprevent disclosure of their stare grand jury \ntestimony. \n[5] We need not apply any such balancing test \nhere, however, because we find that the privilege \nasserted by appellants is without a basis in Florida \nlaw. We find no evidence that the Florida courts \nderive an evidentiary privilege from Fla.Stat. § \n905.27. \nIndeed, the Florida Supreme Court has \nnoted that \nIt)he \nrule \nof \nsecrecy \nconcerning \nmatters \ntranspiring in the grand jury room is not designed \nfor the protection of witnesses before the grand \njury. but for that of the grand jurors, and in \nfurtherance of the public justice. \nA witness \nbefore the grand jury has no privilege of having \nhis testimony there treated as a confidential \ncommunication.... \nStare a rel. Brown v. Dave11, 167 So. 687, 690 \n(Fla.1936). \nFlorida case law directly construing \nsection 905.27 \nfails to provide a contrary \ninterpretation of the relationship between the \nsecrecy requirement and the rights of grand jury \nwimesses. (FN7j Accordingly, we conclude that \nPage 6 \nappellants have no privilege of nondisclosure under \nstate law. A federal court will not selectively reach \ninto a state code and fashion evidentiary privileges \nmerely to suit the purposes of the parties before it. \nR47. Some Florida cases refer to the \"privilege \nof a grand jury witness, but only with reference to \nthe general principle wider Florida law that a \nwitness' testimony in a judicial proceeding cannot \nbe used as the basis of a defamation mien. See, \ne.g.. \nSae \nv. \nTiller, \n111 \nSo.24 \n716 \n(FLi.Dist.O.App.1959). \nIV. \nIn light of our conclusion that appellants have no \nprivilege of nondisclosure under state law, we \naffirm the district court's order denying their \nmotion to quash. \nBecause we must observe the \nlimitations on our appellate ju\n... [truncated, 2290 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/38 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=38]", "char_count": 2290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "824 F.Supp. 330 \n824 F.Supp. 330 \n(Cite as: 824 F.Supp. 330) \nC \nUnited States District Court. \nW.D. New York. \nIn the Matter of Subpoena Duces Tecum Directed to \nthe Honorable Kevin M. \nDILLON, District Attorney of Erie County. \nCiv. No. 92-13A. \nFeb. 20, 1992. \nState district attorney moved to quash subpoena \nduces return issued by federal grand jury seeking \nproduction of state grand jury records as part of \ninvestigation into whether police officers violated \nfederal criminal civil rights statute when making \narrests. \nThe District Court, Arcata, J., held that \nfederal grand jury was entitled to transcripts and \ntapes \nof \nstate \ngrand \njury \ntestimony \nof \nuncooperating police officers. \nMotion to quash denied. \nWest Headnotes \n[1] Grand Jury C=025 \n193k25 \nGrand jury is to be afforded wide latitude in \nconducting its investigation. \n[2) Grand Jury C=36.4(2) \n1931136.4(2) \nFederal \ngrand \njury \nsubpoena \nmay \nnot \nbe \nunreasonable or oppressive. it may not violate \nconstitutional, common law or statutory privilege. \nFed.Rules Cr.Proc.Rule 17(c), 18 U.S.C.A. \n(3) Grand Jury C=036.9(2) \n193k36.9(2) \nFederal grand jury subpoenas are presumed to be \nreasonable and party seeking to quash subpoena \nbears burden of showing that compliance would be \nunreasonable \nor \noppressive. \nFed.Rules \nCr.Proc.Rule 17(c), 18 U.S.C.A. \n[4] Grand Jury €36.4(2) \n193k36.4(2) \nFederal grand jury was entitled to subpoena \ntranscripts and tapes of state grand jury testimony of \npolice officers as part of investigation to determine \nwhether officers violated federal criminal civil \nrights laws during or after arrests; \ndisputed \ntestimony was relevant and neceseary to federal \nPage 11 \ngrand jury investigation after police officers refused \nto cooperate, subpoena was definite and did not call \nfor \nproduction \nof \nunreasonable \namount \nof \ndocuments, United States bad strong interest in \ninsuring just enforcement of its criminal laws, and \nprivacy limitations on federal grand jury documen\n... [truncated, 3480 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/39 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=39]", "char_count": 3480}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 40, "text_content": ".tJ VA \n824 F.Supp. 330 \n(Cite as: 824 F.Supp. 330, *331) \n*331 John J. DeFranks. J. Michael Marion, Asst. \nErie County Dist. Attys. (Kevin Dillon, Erie \nCounty Dist. Atty., of counsel). Buffalo. NY. \nRussell P. Buscaglia, Asst. U.S. Atty. (Dennis C. \nVacco, U.S. Atty., W.D.N.Y., of counsel), \nBuffalo, NY. \nDECISION AND ORDER \nARCARA, District Judge. \nPresently before the Court is a motion to quash a \nsubpoena duces recum. pursuant to Fed.R.Crim.P. \n17, filed by Kevin M. Dillon. District Attorney for \nErie County, New York. \nThe District Attorney's \nmotion seeks an order from this Court quashing a \nfederal grand jury subpoena for state grand jury \nrecords. \nThe parties were given an opportunity to \nbrief and argue their respective positions. \nAfter \nreviewing the submissions of the parties and hearing \nargument from counsel, the Court denies the \nDistrict Attorney's motion to quash the subpoena. \nBACKGROUND \nA federal grand jury investigation is currently \nbeing conducted regarding an incident which \noccurred on March S, 1990 in the Main Place Mall, \nBuffalo, New York, involving the arrest of Mark \nAiken and Steven Johnson by officers of the Buffalo \nPolice Department. \nSpecifically, a federal grand \njury is investigating allegations that certain officers \nof the Buffalo Police Department violated federal \ncriminal civil tights laws during and after the arrest \nof Mr. Aiken and Mr. Johnson. [FN I) \nFNI. The background and focus of the federal \ngrand jury investigation is set forth in greater detail \nin an in COMM submission of facts surrounding \nthe federal grand jury investigation submitted by \nthe United States. \nThe District Anorney's Office prosecuted Mr. \nAileen and Mr. Johnson on numerous state \nmisdemeanor charges arising from this incident. \nDuring the state trial, only two of the six or more \nofficers who were either involved in or witnessed \nthe \nincident \nin \nquestion \nactually \ntestified. \nConsequently, the state trial shed little light on the \nofficers'\n... [truncated, 4520 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/40 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=40]", "char_count": 4520}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "UOAV \nno\n rL \ni21 UIJ \n824 F.Supp. 330 \n(Cite as; 824 F.Supp. 330, *332) \nunreasonable because it would force him to violate \nstate law relating to grand jury secrecy. \nSecond, \nhe argues that the subpoena was served upon the \nwrong parry. Third, the District Attorney contends \nthat compliance would be unreasonable because it \nwould violate policies of comity. Finally, he \ncontends that the subpoenaed grand jury records are \nprivileged. \nDISCUSSION \n[1][2][3] It is well-established that a federal grand \njury is to be afforded wide latitude in conducting its \ninvestigation. \nSee United States v. R. Enters., \nInc.. 498 U.S. 292. 297-98, Ill S.Ct. 722, 726, \n112 L.Ed.2d 795 (1991); \nUnited States v. \nCalandra, 414 U.S. 338, 94 S.Ct. 613, 38 L.Ed.2d \n561 (1974). \"A grand jury investigation 'is not \nfully carried out until every available clue has been \nrun down and all witnesses examined in every \nproper way to find if a crime has been committed.' \n\" Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665, 701, 92 \n2646, 2667, 33 L.Ed.2d 626 (1972) (quoting \nUnited States v. Stone, 429 F.2d 138, 140 (2d \nCir.1970)); In re Grand Jury Subpoena for the \nProd. of Certain New York State Sales Tax Records, \n382 F.Supp. 1205. 1206 (W.D.N.Y.1974) (quoting \nStone. 429 F.2d at 140). \nIn accordance with its \nbroad mandate to investigate possible criminal \nactivity, a federal grand jury has few limitations \nplaced on its subpoena powers. R. Enters.. 498 \nU.S. at 297-98, 111 S.Ct. at 726. \"A grand jury \n'may compel the production of evidence or the \ntestimony of witnesses as it considers appropriate, \nand its operation generally is unrestrained by the \ntechnical procedural and evidentiary rules governing \nthe conduct of criminal trials.' \" \nid. (quoting \nCalandra, 414 U.S. at 343, 94 S.Ct. at 617). The \nonly restrictions that have been placed upon the j \ngrand jury concern reasonablenecc and privileges. \nA grand jury subpoena may not be unreasonable or \noppressive, and it may not violate a constitutional,\n... [truncated, 5053 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/41 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=41]", "char_count": 5053}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "LIMA \n824 F.Supp. 330 \n(Cite as: 824 F.Supp. 330, *333) \n(5) Federal courts have consistently held that state \nstatutes which preclude disclosure of records to the \ngeneral public cannot be used to prevent federal \ngrand juries from obtaining the records through a \nsubpoena. \nThe cases of In re Grand Jury \nSubpoena for New York Stare Income Tax Records, \n468 F.Supp. 575 (N.D.N.Y.), appeal dismissed. \n607 F.2d 566 (2d Cir.1979). and In re Grand Jury \nSubpoena for the Prod. of Certain New York State \nSales \nTax \nRecords, \n382 \nF.Supp. \n1205 \n(W.D.N.Y.1974). are particularly relevant to the \nease at band. Both cases involved federal grand \njury subpoenas issued to officials of the New York \nState Department of Taxation for the production of \ncertain tax records. The petitioners moved to quash \nthe subpoenas on the grounds that compliance \nwould be in violation of certain secrecy provisions \nof New York State tax laws. \nThese laws are very \nsimilar to N.Y.CrimProc.Law § 190.25, subd. 4, \nwhich the District Attorney relies on in his motion. \nThe courts in these cases explicitly rejected the \nargument that compliance was unreasonable because \nit would force the state officials to violate state law \n \n \nprovisions. \nThe courts ruled that the \nSupremacy Clause must prevail over the state \nnondisclosure provisions. \nAs the court in In re \nGrand Jury Subpoena for New York State Income \nTax Records stated: \nThe Supreme Court has several times indicated \nthat, by virtue of the supremacy clause, state \nlegislation must yield whenever it comes into \nconflict with an Act of Congress or the superior \nauthority of the Constitution. Thus, inasmuch as \nthe federal *334 grand jury is a product of the \nFifth Amendment and its powers, as a result of its \nlong history and specific Congressional attention. \nthe \nconflict \nbetween \nstare \nconfidentiality \nprovisions and Congressional or constitutional \ninvestigatory powers has resulted in enforcement \nof federal grand jury subpoenas despite\n... [truncated, 5061 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/42 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=42]", "char_count": 5061}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "yJ L.1.1 \n824 F.Supp. 330 \n(Cite as: 824 F.Supp. 330, •334) \ncontends that, just as the federal government has an \ninterest in protecting the secrecy of federal grand \njury material, the state has an interest in protecting \nstate grand jury material from disclosure. \nThus, \nthe District Attorney argues that, in order to show \nproper deference to the State's interest in the \nconfidentiality of the grand jury records, the United \nStates should be required to move initially for \ndisclosure before the presiding state court judge. \nThe Court finds that no such requirement exists. \n[7] The Court recognizes that \"policies of comity \nand federalism require some deference to the \nobjective \nsought \nto \nbe \nachieved \nby \nstate \nconfidentiality provisions.\" \nIn re Grand Jury \nSubpoena for New York State Income Tax Records. \n468 F.Supp. at 577. \nThe basic purposes of the \nstale grand jury secrecy laws in question are: (1) to \nprevent an accused from escaping before he is \nindicted: (2) to prevent tampering with witnesses; \nand (3) to protect an accused person who is not \nindicted from unwarranted exposure. \nPeople v. \nMcAdoo, 45 Misc.2d 664, 257 N.Y.S.2d 763, \nord. 51 Misc.24 263, 272 *335 N.Y.S.2d 412, \nctn. denied, 386 U.S. 1031, 87 S.Ct. 1479, 18 \nL.Ed.2d 592 (1967). \nIn this case, compliance with the federal grand jury \nsubpoena will not subvert New York's interest in \nmaintaining the secrecy of grand jury proceedings \nbecause federal grand jury proceedings are also \nconducted secretly. \nThe secrecy requirements of \nFed.R.Crim.P. 6(e), will adequately ensure that \nnone of the purposes of the stare grand jury secrecy \nlaws are undermined by compliance with the federal \ngrand jury subpoena. \nSee In re New York Grand \nJury Subpoena for Stare Income Tax Records, 468 \nF.Supp. at 577-78: see also United States v. Field, \n532 F.2d 404, 407-08 (5th Cir.1976), cert. denied, \n429 U.S. 940, 97 S.O. 354, 50 L.Ed.2d 309; In re \nGrand Jury Empaneled Jan. 21, 1975, 541 F.2d at \n377-78. \nM\n... [truncated, 4933 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00277521/43 or ?id=EFTA00277521&page=43]", "char_count": 4933}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "824 F.Supp. 330 \n(Cite as; 824 F.Supp. 330, '335) \nsecrecy of the subpoenaed documents would be \nclosely guarded. \nThus. since the benefits of \ndisclosure in this case substantially outweigh the \npotential harm from disclosure, the Court finds that \nthe state grand jury records are not privileged as a \nmatter of federal common law. \nSee Matter of \nSpecial April 1977 Grand Jury. 581 F.2d at 592-93; \nIn re Grand Jury Proceeding, 563 F.2d 577, 582-85 \n(3d Cir.1977); \nIn re Grand Jury Empanekd \nJanuary 21, 1975, 541 F.2d at 382-83. \nIn sum, the United States has a strong interest in \nensuring the just enforcement of its criminal laws. \nPublic policy has long favored giving the grand jury \nbroad powers of investigation. \nThe District \nAttorney, who has the burden of proving that the \nsubpoena should be quashed, has failed to establish \n*336 that the subpoena is unreasonable or that it \nPage 16 \nviolates any recognized privilege. \nFurthermore, \nbecause of the secrecy provisions of the federal \ngrand jury, little or no prejudice would result to the \nstate from compliance with the federal grand jury \nsubpoena. \nCONCLUSION \nFor the reasons stated, the Court denies the District \nAttorney's motion to quash the federal grand jury \nsubpoena. This Decision and Order and the entire \nfile are to be filed under seal. \nIt is so ordered. \n824 F.Supp. 330 \nEND OF DOCUMENT \n© 2006 Thomson/West. No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works. \nEFTA00277565\n", "char_count": 1447}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00277521", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "CD-R lx-52x \n100MB, 80 min \nrie04. \nEFTA00277566\n", "char_count": 49}]}