{"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_count": 453, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00226396", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00226396.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "United States District Court \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nTO: \nSUBPOENA TO TESTIFY \nBEFORE GRAND JURY \nFGJ 05-02(WPB)-Fri./No. OLY-24 \nSUBPOENA FOR:  \nPERSON \nI X I DOCUMENTS OR OBJECTISI \nX \nYOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear and testify before the Grand Jury of the United States District \nCourt at the place, date and time specified below. \nPLACE: \nUnited States District Courthouse \n701 Clematis Street \nWcst Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nROOM: \nGrand Jury Room \nDATE AND TIME: \nDecember 1, 2006 \n9:30 am \nYOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following document(s) or object(s): \nAny and all records related to your employment with Jeffrey Epstein, including but not limited to \npaystubs, W-2 forms, correspondence, employment applications, and employment reviews. Any and all \ninformation regarding methods to contact Jeffrey Epstein directly or via any secretaries/assistants from \n1/1/2004 to the present, including but not limited to, telephone numbers, cellular telephone numbers, \nBlackberry addresses, e-mail addresses, and mailing addresses. Any and all information regarding \nappointments for massages performed on Jeffrey Epstein in Palm Beach, Florida or elsewhere. \nPlease coordinate your compliance '\ni\ns \nd confirm the date and time , and location of \nyour appearance with Special Agent \n, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Telephone: \n(561) 822-5946. \nThis subpoena shall remain in effect until you are granted leave to depart by the court or by an officer acting \non behalf of the court. \nCLERK \n(BY) DEPUTY CLERK \nDATE: \nNovember 13, 2006 \nThis subpoena is issued upon application \n•If not applicable. ma ^none.' \nName, Address and Phone Number of Assistant U.S. Attorney \nTo be use' a int ofA0110 \n5 \nFORM ORD-227 \nJAN.86 \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000213 \nEFTA00226396\n", "char_count": 1802}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "RETURN OF SERVICE' \nRECEIVED \nBY SERVER \nDATE \nPLACE \nSERVED \nDATE \nPLACE \nSERVED ON (NAME) \nSERVED BY \nTITLE \nSTATEMENT OF SERVICE FEES \nTRAVEL \nSERVICES \nTOTAL \nDECLARATION OF SERVICE' \nI declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing Information contained in the Return of Service and \nStatement of Service Fees is true and correct. \nExecuted on \nDATE \nSignature of Server \nAddress of Server \nADDITIONAL INFORMATION \n1 As to who may serve a subpoena and the manner of Its service see Rule 17(d). Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, or \nRule 45(c), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. \n2.\"Fees and mileage need not be tendered to the witness upon service of a subpoena Issued on behalf of the United \nStates or an officer or agency thereof (Rule 45(c), Federal Rules of CND Procedure; Rule 17(d), Federal Rules of Criminal \nProcedure) or on behalf of certain Indigent parties and criminal defendants who are unable to pay such costs (28 USC \n1825, Rule 17(b) Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure)\" \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000214 \nEFTA00226397\n", "char_count": 1102}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "United States District Court \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nTO: \nSUBPOENA TO TESTIFY \nBEFORE GRAND JURY \nFGJ 05-02(WPB)-Fri./No. OLY-24 \nSUBPOENA FOR: \nPERSON \nX \nX \nDOCUMENTS OR OBJECT($( \nYOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear and testify before the Grand Jury of the United States District \nCourt at the place, date and time specified below. \nPLACE: \nUnited States District Courthouse \n701 Clematis Street \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nROOM: \nGrand Jury Room \nDATE AND TIME: \nDecember I, 2006 \n9:30 am \nYOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following document(s) or object(s): \nAny and all records related to your employment with Jeffrey Epstein, including but not limited to \npaystubs, W-2 forms, correspondence, employment applications, and employment reviews. Any and all \ninformation regarding methods to contact Jeffrey Epstein directly or via any secretaries/assistants from \n1/1/2004 to the present, including but not limited to, telephone numbers, cellular telephone numbers, \nBlackberry addresses, e-mail addresses, and mailing addresses. Any and all information regarding \nappointments for massages performed on Jeffrey Epstein in Palm Beach, Florida or elsewhere. \nPlease coordinate your compliance \n• \n• \nd confirm the date and time , and location of \nyour appearance with Special Agent \n, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Telephone: \n(561) 822-5946. \nThis subpoena shall remain in effect until you are granted leave to depart by the court or by an officer acting \non behalf of the court. \nCLERK \n(BY) DEPUTY CLERK \nKos% Our \nDATE: \nNovember 13. 2006 \nThis subpoena is issued upon application \nnon\n•If not mastic:able, ma Woe-\nName, Address and Phone Number of Assistant U.S. Attorney \nTo\n mod in le etA0110 \nFORM ORD-227 \nJAN.86 \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000216 \nEFTA00226398\n", "char_count": 1803}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "United States District Court \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nTO: \nSUBPOENA TO TESTIFY \nBEFORE GRAND JURY \nFGJ 05-02(WPB)-Fri./No. OLY-24-2 \nSUBPOENA FOR: \nrd\nPERSON \nr xi \nDOCUMENTS OR OBJECTISI \nYOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear and testifybefore the Grand Jury of the United States District \nCourt at the place, date and time specified below. \nPLACE: \nUnited States District Courthouse \n701 Clematis Street \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nROOM: \nGrand Jury Room \nDATE AND TRAE: \nJanuary 12, 2007 \n9:30 arn• \nYOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following document(s) or object(s): \nAny and all records related to your employment with Jeffrey Epstein, including but not limited to \npaystubs, W-2 forms, correspondence, employment applications, and employment reviews. Any and all \ninformation regarding methods to contact Jeffrey Epstein directly or via any secretaries/assistants from \n1/1/2004 to the present, including but not limited to, telephone numbers, cellular telephone numbers, \nBlackberry addresses, e-mail addresses, and mailing addresses. Any and all information regarding \nappointments for massages performed on Jeffrey Epstein in Palm Beach, Florida or elsewhere. \n*Please coordinate your compliance w't \ns \nnd confirm the date and time , and location of \nyour appearance with Special Agent \nFederal Bureau of Investigation, Telephone: \n(561) 822-5946. \nThis subpoena shall remain in effect until you arc granted leave to depart by the court or by an officer acting \non behalf of the court. \nCLERK \n(BY) DEPUTY CLERK \nDATE: \nDecember 18, 2006 \nThis subpoena is issued upon application \nof the United Slates of \n•Ifnot appl tc able. enter 'none' \nTobtfdaliblavolA0116 \nFORM ORD-227 \nJANA6 \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \n1a-000219 \nEFTA00226399\n", "char_count": 1767}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "LAW OrriCES \nLYONS AND SANDERS \nCHARTERED \nDALE R. SANDERS • \nBRUCE M. LYONS •• \nHOWARD L. OREITZER \nEDWARD 0. BERGER \n11959-1907) \n'ALSO ^mimeo \nIN It/TORINO \n•• ALSO ADMITTED IN COLORADO \nFebruary 14, 2007 \nVIA US \nRe: \n600 NORTHEAST \n0 AVENUE \n1 \nFORT LADMIRDALE. LORIDA 33301 \nTELEPHONE (954) 487-8700 \nTELEFAX 0154/ 783-4.58 \nMAILING ADDRESS \nP. O. BOX 1778 \nFORT LAUDERDALE. FL 33302-1778 \nGrand Jury Subpoena \nDear Ms. Villafana: \non January 25, 2007, Agents\" *Slater and \nwith a grand jury'subpoena for my \nto appear on February 13,'2007. \nI \nindicate \noss would assert her rights under the \nFifth Amendment and on consent, the appearance has been \nextended. \nYou have asked me to set out the basis for my \nrequest and that you apply thirugh appropriate channels for a \normal grant of use immunity or Ms. Ross. I do so here. \nAs I indicated to you when we conversed last week, Ms. Ross is \nno longer employed by Mr. Epstein, but has read much of what \ncan be found on the Internet about the investigation of Mr. \nEpstein. \nFrom that review, she is aware that the police \nconsidered charging several persons close to Mr. Epstein, \nincluding at least one employee. Given that, and the seemingly \nbroad scope of the investigation, Ms. Ross asserts her rights \nunder the Fifth Amendment. \nIndeed, considering that both the state authorities in Palm \nBeach County and your office are conducting investigations, \nthere is every reason for her to be concerned and therefore to \nassert her constitutional rights. If you continue to want her \nto appear before a grand jury, be advised that she will assert \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000220 \nEFTA00226400\n", "char_count": 1657}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "her rights under the Fifth Amendment unless there is a formal \ngrant of immunity. \nIf you should have any questions regarding the above, please \nfeel free to contact me. \nVery truly your \nUCE M. LYONS \nBML/md \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-00022 I \nEFTA00226401\n", "char_count": 262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \n9-27.600 Entering into Non-prosecution Agreements in Return for Cooperation — Generally \nA. Except as hereafter provided, the attomcy for the government may, with supervisory approval, enter into a non-\nprosecution agreement in exchange for a person's cooperation when, in his/her judgment, the person's timely \ncooperation appears to be necessary to the public interest and other means of obtaining the desired cooperation \narc unavailable or would not be effective. \nB. Comment. \nPage I of 5 \nI. In many cases, it may be important to the success of an investigation or prosecution to obtain the \ntestimonial or other cooperation of a person who is himself/herself implicated in the criminal conduct \nbeing investigated or prosecuted. However, because of his/her involvement, the person may refuse to \ncooperate on the basis of his/her Fifth Amendment privilege against compulsory self-incrimination. In this \nsituation, there are several possible approaches the prosecutor can take to render the privilege inapplicable \nor to induce its waiver. \na. First, if time permits, the person may be charged, tried, and convicted before his/her cooperation is \nsought in the investigation or prosecution of others. Having already been convicted himself/herself, \nthe person ordinarily will no longer have a valid privilege to refuse to testify and will have a strong \nincentive to reveal the truth in order to induce the sentencing judge to impose a lesser sentence than \nthat which otherwise might be found appropriate. \n4\nb. Second, the person may be willing to cooperate if the charges or potential charg against him/her are \nreduced in number or degree in return for his/her cooperation and his/her entry \na guilty plea to the \nremaining charges. An agreement to file a motion pursuant to Sentencing Guideline 5K1.1 or Rule \n35 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure after the defendant gives full and complete \ncooperation is the preferred method f\n... [truncated, 4367 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/6 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=6]", "char_count": 4367}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \nPage 2 of 5 \n2. \nIt is important to note that these provisions apply only if the case involves an agreement with a person who \nmight otherwise be prosecuted. If the person reasonably is viewed only as a potential witness rather than a \npotential defendant, and the person is willing to cooperate, there is no need to consult these provisions. \nUSAM 9-27.600 describes three circumstances that should exist before government attorneys enter into \nnon-prosecution agreements in return for cooperation: the unavailability or ineffectiveness of other means \nof obtaining the desired cooperation; the apparent necessity of the cooperation to the public interest; and \nthe approval of such a course of action by an appropriate supervisory official \nUnavailability or Ineffectiveness of Other Means. As indicated above, non-prosecution agreements are \nonly one of several methods by which the prosecutor can obtain the cooperation of a person whose \ncriminal involvement makes him/her a potential subject of prosecution. Each of the other methods--seeking \ncooperation after trial and conviction, bargaining for cooperation as part of a plea agreement, and \ncompelling cooperation under a \"use immunity\" order--involves prosecuting the person or at least leaving \nopen the possibility of prosecuting him/her on the basis of independently obtained evidence. Since these \noutcomes are clearly preferable to permitting an offender to avoid any liability for his/her conduct, the \npossible use of an alternative to a non-prosecution agreement should be given serious consideration in the \nfirst instance. \nAnother reason for using an alternative to a non-prosecution agreement to obtain cooperation concerns the \npractical advantage in terms of the person's credibility if he/she testifies at trial. If the person already has \nbeen convicted, either after trial or upon a guilty plea, for participating in the events about which he/she \ntestifies, his/her testi\n... [truncated, 4661 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/7 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=7]", "char_count": 4661}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \nPage 3 of 5 \n4. Supervisory Approval. Finally, the prosecutor should secure supervisory approval before entering into a \nnon-prosecution agreement. Prosecutors working under the direction of a United States Attorney must seek \nthe approval of the United States Attorney or a supervisory Assistant United States Attorney. Departmental \nattorneys not supervised by a United States Attorney should obtain the approval of the appropriate \nAssistant Attorney General or his/her designee, and should notify the United States Attorney or Attorneys \nconcerned. The requirement of approval by a superior is designed to provide review by an attorney \nexperienced in such matters, and to ensure uniformity of policy and practice with respect to such \nagreements. This section should be read in conjunction with USAM 9-27,640, concerning particular types \nof casts in which an Assistant Attorney General or his/her designee must concur in or approve an \nagreement not to prosecute in ret urn for cooperation. \n9-27.620 Entering into Non-prosecution Agreements in Return for Cooperation - Considerations to be Weighed \nA. In determining whether, a person's cooperation may be necessary to the public interest, the attorney for the \ngovernment, and those whose approval is necessary, should weigh all relevant considerations, including: \nI. The importance of the investigation or prosecution to an effective program of law enforcement; \n2. The value of the person's cooperation to the investigation or prosecution; and \n3. The person's relative culpability in connection with the offense or offenses being investigated or \nprosecuted and his/her history with respect to criminal activity. \nB. Comment. This paragraph is intended to assist Federal prosecutors, and those whose approval they must secure, \nin deciding whether a person's cooperation appears to be necessary to the public interest. The considerations \nlisted here arc not intended to be all-inclusive \n... [truncated, 4571 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/8 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=8]", "char_count": 4571}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \nPage 4 of 5 \n3. Relative Culpability and Criminal History. In determining whether it may be necessary to the public \ninterest to agree to forego prosecution of a person who may have violated the law in return for that person's \ncooperation, it is also important to consider the degree of his/her apparent culpability relative to others who \nare subjects of the investigation or prosecution as well as his/her history of criminal involvement. Of \ncourse, ordinarily it would not be in the public interest to forego prosecution of a high-ranking member of \na criminal enterprise in exchange for his/her cooperation against one of his/her subordinates, nor would the \npublic interest be served by bargaining away the opportunity to prosecute a person with a long history of \nserious criminal involvement in order to obtain the conviction of someone else on less serious charges. \nThese are matters with regard to which the attorney for the government may find it helpful to consult with \nthe investigating agenc y or with other prosecuting authorities who may have an interest in the person or \nhis/her associates. \nIt is also important to consider whether the person has a background of cooperation with law enforcement \nofficials, either as a witness or an informant, and whether he/she has previously been the subject of a compulsion order \nunder 18 U.S.C. §?-6003 or has escaped prosecution by virtue of an agreement not to prosecute. The information \nregarding compulsion orders may be available by telephone from the Immunity Unit in the Office of Enforcement \nOperations of the Criminal Division. \n9-27.630 Entering into Non-prosecution Agreements in Return for Cooperation — Limiting the Scope of \nCommitment \nA. In entering into a non-prosecution agreement, the attorney for the government should, if practicable, explicitly \nlimit the scope of the government's commitment to: \n1. Non-prosecution based directly or indirectly on the testimony o\n... [truncated, 4716 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/9 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=9]", "char_count": 4716}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \nPage 5 of 5 \nFinally, the attorney for the government should make it clear that his/her agreement relates only to non-\nprosecution and that he/she has no independent authority to promise that the witness will be admitted into the \nDepartment's Witness Security program or that the Marshal's Service will provide any benefits to the witness in \nexchange for his/her cooperation. This does not mean, of course, that the prosecutor should not cooperate in making \narrangements with the Marshal's Service necessary for the protection of the witness in appropriate cases. The \nprocedures to be followed in such cases are set forth in USAM 9-21.000. \n9-27.640 Agreements Requiring Assistant Attorney General Approval \nA. The attorney for the government should not enter into a non-prosecution agreement in exchange for a person's \ncooperation without first obtaining the approval of the Assistant Attorney General with supervisory responsibility \nover the subject matter, or his/her designee, when: \n1. Prior consultation or approval would be required by a statute or by Departmental policy for a declination of \nprosecution or dismissal of a charge with regard to which the agreement is to be made; or \n2. The person is: \na. A high-level Federal, state, or local official; \nb. An official or agent of a Federal investigative or law enforcement agency; or \nc. A person who otherwise is, or is likely to become of major public interest. \nB. Comment. USAM 9-27.640 sets forth special cases that require approval of non-prosecution agreements by the \nresponsible Assistant Attorney General or his/her designee. Subparagraph (1) covers cases in which existing \nstatutory provisions and departmental policies require that, with respect to certain types of offenses, the Attorney \nGeneral or an Assistant Attorney General be consulted or give his/her approval before prosecution is declined or \ncharges arc dismissed. For example, see USAM 6-4.245 (tax offenses)\n... [truncated, 3498 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/10 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=10]", "char_count": 3498}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "PART V-IMMUNITY OF WITNESSES \nChapter \nSection \n601. Immunity of witnesses  \n 6001 \nHISTORICAL AND STATUTORY NOTES \n1970 Amendment \nPub. L. 9r\n2. Title \n§ 201(a), Oct. 15, 1970. 84 Stat. \n926, added \nV and items 6001 to 6005. \nCHAPTER 601-IMMUNITY OF WITNESSES \nSec. \n6001. Definitions. \n6002. Immunity generally. \n6003. Court and grand jury proceedings. \n6004. Certain administrative proceedings. \n6005. Congressional proceedings. \nHISTORICAL AND STATUTORY NOTES \n1994 Amendments \nPub.L. 103-322, Title )0()(III, § 330013(1), Sept. 13, 1994, \n109 Stat. 2146, added chapter heading. \n§ 6001. \nDefinitions \nAs used in this chapter—\n(1) \"agency of the United States\" means any \nexecutive department as defined in section 101 of \ntitle 5, United States Code, a military department \nas defined in section 102 of title 5, United States \nCode, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, the \nBoard of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, \nthe China Trade Act registrar appointed under 53 \n•1.\n432 (15 U.S.C. sec. 143), the Commodity \nTrading Commission, the Federal Commu-\nnications Commission, the Federal Deposit Insur-\nance Corporation, the Federal Maritime Commis-\nsion, the Federal Power Commission, the Federal \nTrade Commission, the Surface Transportation \nBoard, tt raNn:tional Labor Relations Board, the \nNational \nportation Safety Board, the Railroad \nRetirement Board, an arbitration board established \nunder 48 Stat. 1193 (45 U.S.C. sec. 157), the Securi-\nepi and Exchange Commission, or a board estab-\nsed under 49 Stat. 31 (15 U.S.C. sec. 715d); \n(2) \"other information\" includes any book, paper, \ndocument, record, recording, or other material; \n. \n(3) \"proceeding before an agency of the United \nStates\" means any proceeding before such an agen-\ncy with respect to which it is authorized to issue \nsubpenas and to take testimony or receive other \n' information from witnesses under oath; and \n(4) \"court of the United States\" means any of the \nfollowing courts: the Supreme Court of the United \n... [truncated, 4726 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/11 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=11]", "char_count": 4726}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "18 * 6001 \nIMMUNITY OF WITNESSES \nPart 5 \n1970 Acts. Section 260 of Pub.L. 91-452 provided that: \n\"The provisions of part V of title 18, United States Code, \nadded by title II of this Act [this part], and the amendments \nand repeals made by title 11 of this Act [sections 835. 89i, \n1406, 1954, 2424, 2514 and 3486 of this title, sections 16, 87( \n13.5e, 499rn(f). and 2115 of Title 7, Agriculture. section 25 f \nformer Title 11. Bankruptcy, section 1820 of Title 12, Banks \nand Banking. sections 32, 33, 49, 77v, 78u(d). 79r(e), 80a-41, \n80b-9, 155, 717m, 1271. and 1714 of Title 15. Commerce and \nTrade, section srof of Title 16. Conservation, section 1333 of \nTitle 19, Customs Duties, section 373 of Title 21, Food and \nDrugs. sections 4874 and 7493 of Title 26, Internal Revenue \nCode, section 161(3) of Title 29, Labor, section 506 of Title \n33, Navigation and Navigable Waters, sections 405(0 and \n2201 of Title 42, The Public Health and Welfare, sections 157 \nand 362 of Title 45, Railroads, sections 827 and 1124 of TStle \n46, Shipping, section 409(1) of Tide 47, Telegraphs, Tele-\nphones, and Radiotelegraphs, sections 9, 43, 46, 47. 48, 916, \nand 1017 of former Title 49, Transportation, and section 1484 \nof Title 49, Appendix, section 792 of Title 50. War and \nNational Defense, and sections 643a, 1152, 2026. and 2155(b) \nof Title 50, Appendix], shall take effect on the sixtieth day \nfollowing the date of the enactment of this Act [Oct. IS, \n1970). No amendment to or repeal of any provision of law \nunder tide II of this Act shall affect any immunity to which \nany individual is entitled under such provision by reason of \nany testimony or other information given before such day.\" \nChange of Name \nReferences to United States Claims Court deemed to refer \nto United States Court of Federal Claims and references to \nClaims Court deemed to refer to Court of Federal Claims, \nsee section 902(b) of Pub.L. 102-572, set out as a note under \nsection 171 of Tide 28, Judiciary and Judicia\n... [truncated, 6313 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/12 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=12]", "char_count": 6313}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Ch. 601 \nIMMUNITY OF WITNESSES \n18 § 6005 \n(h) A I hilted States attorney may, with the approv-\nal of the Attorney General, the Deputy Attorney \nGeneral, the Associate Attorney General, or any des-\nignated Assistant Attorney General or Deputy Assis-\ntant Attorney General, request an order under subsec-\ntion (a) of this section when in his judgment—\n(1) the testimony or other information from such \nindividual may be necessary to the public interest; \nand \n(2) such individual has refused or is likely to \nrefuse to testify or provide other information on the \nbasis of his privilege against self-incrimination. \n(Added Pub.L. 91-452, Title ll, ¢ 201(a), Oct. 15, 1970, 84 \nStat 927, and amended Pub.L. 100-690. Title VII. 5 7020(e), \nNov. 18, 1988, 102 Stat. 4396; Pub.L. 103-322, Title XXXIII, \n§ 330013(4), Sept. 13, 1994. 108 Stat. 2146.) \n§ 6004. \nCertain administrative proceedings \n(a) In the case of any individual who has been or \nwho may be called to testify or provide other informa-\ntion at any proceeding before an agency of the United \nStates, the agency may, with the approval of the \nAttorney General, issue, in accordance with subsection \n(b) of this section, an order requiring the individual to \ngive testimony or provide other information which he \nrefuses to give or provide on the basis of his privilege \nagainst self-incrimination, such order to become effec-\ntive as provided in section 6002 of this title. \n(b) An agency of the United States may issue an \norder under subsection (a) of this section only if in its \njudgment—\n(1) the testimony or other information from such \nindividual may be necessary to the public interest; \nand \n(2) such individual has refused or Ls likely to \nrefuse to testify or provide other information on the \nbasis of his privilege against self-incrimination. \n(Added Pub.L. 91-452, Title IL § 201(a), Oct. 15, 1970, 84 \nStat 927, and amended Pub.L. 103-3tZ, Title \n330013(4), Sept. 13, 1994, 108 Stat. 2146.) \n§ 6005. \nCongressional proceedings\n... [truncated, 4156 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/13 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=13]", "char_count": 4156}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "United States District Court \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nTO: \nSUBPOENA TO TESTIFY \nBEFORE GRAND JURY \nFGJ 05-02(WPB)-Fri./No. OLY-24 \nSUBPOENA FOR: \nPERSON \nX \nDOCUMENTS OR OBJECT'S] \nYOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear and testify before the G rand J ury of th e Un ited States Di strict \nCourt at the place, date and time specified below. \nPLACE: \nUnited States District Courthouse \n701 Clematis Street \nWcst Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nROOM: \nGrand Jury Room \nDATE AND TIME: \nDecember 1, 2006 \n9:30 am \nYOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following document(s) or object(s): \nAny and all records related to your employment with Jeffrey Epstein, including but not limited to \npaystubs, W-2 forms, correspondence, employment applications, and employment reviews. Any and all \ninformation regarding methods to contact Jeffrey Epstein directly or via any secretaries/assistants from \n1/112004 to the present, including but not limited to, telephone numbers, cellular telephone numbers, \nBlackberry addresses, e-mail addresses, and mailing addresses. Any and all information regarding \nappointments for massages performed on Jeffrey Epstein in Palm Beach, Florida or elsewhere. \nilt\nPlease coordinate your compliance ' \n• \nd confirm the date and time , and location of \nyour appearance with Special Agent \nFederal Bureau of Investigation, Telephone: \n(561) 822-5946. \nThis subpoena shall remain in effect until you are granted leave to depart by the court or by an officer acting \non behalf of the court. \nThis subpoena is issued upon application \nNamc Address and P \nAttorney \n5 \n•[ not applicable, enter 'none' \nTo be mai stag a A \nOR -227 \nJAN.86 \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000213 \nEFTA00226410\n", "char_count": 1710}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "RETURN OF SERVICE' \nRECEIVED \nBY SERVER \nDATE \nPLACE \nSERVED \nDATE \nPLACE \nSERVED ON (NAME) \nSERVED BY \nTITLE \nSTATEMENT OF SERVICE FEES \nTRAVEL \nSERVICES \nTOTAL \nDECLARATION OF SERVICE' \nI declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America Mal the foregoing information contained in the Return of Service and \nStatement of Service Fees is true and correct. \nExecuted on \nDATE \nSignature of Server \nAddress of Server \nADDITIONAL INFORMATION \nlAs to who may serve a subpoena and the manner of Its service see Rule 17(d). Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, or \nRule 45(c), Federal Rules of CNII Procedure. \n2.\"Fees and mileage need not be tendered to the witness upon service of a subpoena Issued on behalf of the United \nStates or an officer or agency thereof (Rule 45(c), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure; Rule 17(d), Federal Rules of Criminal \nProcedure) or on behalf of certain Indigent parties and criminal defendants who are unable to pay such costs (28 USC \n1825, Rule 17(b) Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure)\" \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000214 \nEFTA00226411\n", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "United States \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT \nTO: \nYOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear \nCourt at the place, date and time specified below. \nSUBPOENA \nDistrict \nOF \nPERSON \ntestify \nCourt \nFLORIDA \nSUBPOENA \nBEFORE GRAND \nFall 05-02(WPB)-Fri./No. \nFOR: \nr xi \nDOCUMENTS \nTO TESTIFY \nJURY \nOLY-24 \nOR OBJECT [S \nJury of the United States District \nI X i \nand \nbefore the Grand \nPLACE: \nUnited States District Courthouse \n701 Clematis Street \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nROOM: \nGrand Jury Room \nDATE AND TIME: \nDecember 1, 2006 \n9:30 am \nYOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following \nAny and all records related to your employment with Jeffrey \npaystubs, W-2 forms, correspondence, employment applications, \ninformation regarding methods to contact Jeffrey Epstein directly \n1/1/2004 to the present, including but not limited to, telephone \nBlackberry addresses, e-mail addresses, and mailing addresses. \nappointments for massages performed on Jeffrey Epstein \nPlease coordinate your compliance liiiii \nd \nyour appearance with Special Agent \nIIIIII, \n(561) 822-5946. \nThis subpoena shall remain in effect until you are granted leave \non behalf of the court. \ndocument(s) \nEpstein, \nand employment \nor via any \nnumbers, \nAny and \nin Palm Beach, \nconfirm the date \nFederal Bureau \nto depart by the \nor object(s): \nincluding but not limited to \nreviews. Any and all \nsecretaries/assistants from \ncellular telephone numbers, \nall information regarding \nFlorida or elsewhere. \nand time , and location of \nof Investigation, Telephone: \ncourt or by an officer acting \n• \netspitij.\nCLERK\n•-• \nOol t \n0 \ni \ni 4 \nS.: \nDATE: \nNovember 13, 2006 \n(BY) DEPUTY CLERJC \nThis subpoena is issued upon application \nof the U ' dStat \nf Ame ' \nName, Address and Phone Number of Assistant U.S. Attorney \n'If \n'nom' \nboa of A0110 \nFORM ORD-227 \nJAN.86 \nP-000216 \nnot applicable. alto \nTo bnemele \nCasc No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nEFTA00226412\n", "char_count": 1913}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "United States District Court \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nTO: \nSUBPOENA TO TESTIFY \nBEFORE GRAND JURY \nFGJ 05-02(WPB)-Fri./No. OLY-24-2 \nSUBPOENA FOR: \nPERSON \nX \nX \nDOCUMENTS OR OBJECT'S] \nYOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear and testify before the Grand Jury of the United States District \nCourt at the place, date and time specified below. \n• \nPLACE: \nUnited States District Courthouse \n701 Clematis Street \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nROOM: \nGrand Jury Room \nDATE AND TIME: \nJanuary 12, 2007 \n9:30 am• \nYOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following document(s) or object(s): \nAny and all records related to your employment with Jeffrey Epstein, including but not limited to \npaystubs, W-2 forms, correspondence, employment applications, and employment reviews. Any and all \ninformation regarding methods to contact Jeffrey Epstein directly or via any secretaries/assistants from \n1/1/2004 to the present, including but not limited to, telephone numbers, cellular telephone numbers, \nBlackberry addresses, e-mail addresses, and mailing addresses. Any and all information regarding \nappointments for massages performed on Jeffrey Epstein in Palm Beach, Florida or elsewhere. \n*Please coordinate your compliance .* \n• \nnd confirm the date and time, and location of \nyour appearance with Special Agent \n, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Telephone: \n(561) 822-5946. \nThis subpoena shall remain in effect until you are granted leave to depart by the court or by an officer acting \non behalf of the court. \nCLERK \n(BY) DEPUTY CLERK \nDATE: \nDecember 18, 2006 \nThis subpoena is issued upon application \nof the United States of America \n•Knot applicable. enter \"none.` \nName, Address and Phone Number of Assistant U.S. Attorney \nTo beryl .r.. \no(A0110 \nFORM ORD-227 \nJAN.86 \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000219 \nEFTA00226413\n", "char_count": 1834}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "LAW OFFICES \nLYONS AND SANDERS \nCHARTERED \nDALE R. SANDERS • \nBRUCE M. LYONS •• \nHOWARD L. ORCITZER \nCOWARD 0. MERGER \n4195P-I9417) \n'ea° \nwomen° IN WYOMING \n•\nALSO ADMITTED IN COLORADO \nFebruary 14, 2007 \n600 NORTHEAST .3\"17 AVENUE \nFORT LAUDIIILDAI.S. \nFLORIDA \n3300.1 \nTELEPHONE 1954) 467-0700 \nTELEFAX (984) 763-4056 \nMAILING ADDRESS \nP. O. SOX 1778 \nFORT LAUDERDALE, FL 33302-1776 \nRe: Adrian Ross Grand Jury Subpoena \nDear Ms. Villafana: \nindicate \nFifth Amendment \nextended. \nYou \nrequest and that \nformal grant of \nJanuary 25, 2007, IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIlland \nwith a grand jury subpoena for my \nto appear on February 13, 2007. \nI \nss would assert her rights under the \nand on consent, the appearance has been \nhave asked me to set out the basis for my \nyou apply through appropriate channels for a \nuse immunity for \n. I do so here. \nAs I indicated to you when we conversed last week, \nis \nno longer employed by Mr. Epstein, but has read much o w at \ncan be found on the Internet about the investigation of Mr. \nEpstein. \nFrom that review, she is aware that the police \nconsidered charging several persons close to Mr. Epstein, \nincluding at least one employee. Given that, and the seemingly \nbroad scope of the investigation, Ms. Ross asserts her rights \nunder the Fifth Amendment. \nIndeed, considering that both the state authorities in Palm \nBeach County and your office are conducting investigations, \nthere is every reason for her to be concerned and therefore to \nassert her constitutional rights. If you continue to want her \nto appear before a grand jury, be advised that she will assert \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000220 \nEFTA00226414\n", "char_count": 1651}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "her rights under the Fifth Amendment unless there is a formal \ngrant of immunity. \nIf you should have any questions regarding the above, please \nfeel free to contact me. \nVery truly your \nUCE M. LYONS \nBML/md \nd \n2 \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-000221 \nEFTA00226415\n", "char_count": 267}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \n9-27.600 Entering into Non-prosecution Agreements in Return for Cooperation — Generally \nA. Except as hereafter provided, the attorney for the government may, with supervisory approval, enter into a non-\nprosecution agreement in exchange for a person's cooperation when, in his/her judgment, the person's timely \ncooperation appears to be necessary to the public interest and other means of obtaining the desired cooperation \narc unavailable or would not be effective. \nB. Comment. \nPagc 1 of 5 \n1. In many cases, it may be important to the success of an investigation or prosecution to obtain the \ntestimonial or other cooperation of a person who is himself/herself implicated in the criminal conduct \nbeing investigated or prosecuted. However, because of his/her involvement, the person may refuse to \ncooperate on the basis of his/her Fifth Amendment privilege against compulsory self-incrimination. In this \nsituation, there are several possible approaches the prosecutor can take to render the privilege inapplicable \nor to induce its waiver. \na. First, if time permits, the person may be charged, tried, and convicted before his/her cooperation is \nsought in the investigation or prosecution of others. Having already been convicted himself/herself, \nthe person ordinarily will no longer have a valid privilege to refuse to testify and will have a strong \nincentive to reveal the truth in order to induce the sentencing judge to impose a lesser sentence than \nthat which otherwise might be found appropriate. \nb. Second, the person may be willing to cooperate if the charges or potential charge against him/her are \nreduced in number or degree in return for his/her cooperation and his/her entry of a guilty plea to the \nremaining charges. An agreement to file a motion pursuant to Sentencing Guideline 5K1.1 or Rule \n35 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure after the defendant gives full and complete \ncooperation is the preferred method\n... [truncated, 4364 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/20 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=20]", "char_count": 4364}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \nPage 2 of 5 \nIt is important to note that these provisions apply only if the case involves an agreement with a person who \nmight otherwise be prosecuted. If the person reasonably is viewed only as a potential witness rather than a \npotential defendant, and the person is willing to cooperate, there is no need to consult these provisions. \nIJSAM  9-27.6A describes three circumstances that should exist before government attorneys enter into \nnon-prosecution agreements in return for cooperation: the unavailability or ineffectiveness of other means \nof obtaining the desired cooperation; the apparent necessity of the cooperation to the public interest; and \nthe approval of such a course of action by an appropriate supervisory official \n2. Unavailability or Ineffectiveness of Other Means. As indicated above, non-prosecution agreements are \nonly one of several methods by which the prosecutor can obtain the cooperation of a person whose \ncriminal involvement makes him/her a potential subject of prosecution. Each of the other methods--seeking \ncooperation after trial and conviction, bargaining for cooperation as part of a plea agreement, and \ncompelling cooperation under a \"use immunity\" order--involves prosecuting the person or at least leaving \nopen the possibility of prosecuting him/her on the basis of independently obtained evidence. Since these \noutcomes are clearly preferable to permitting an offender to avoid any liability for his/her conduct, the \npossible use of an alternative to a non-prosecution agreement should be given serious consideration in the \nfirst instance. \nAnother reason for using an alternative to a non-prosecution agreement to obtain cooperation concerns the \npractical advantage in terms of the person's credibility if he/she testifies at trial. If the person already has \nbeen convicted, tither after trial or upon a guilty plea, for participating in the events about which he/she \ntestifies, his/her testi\n... [truncated, 4663 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/21 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=21]", "char_count": 4663}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \nPage 3 of 5 \n4. Supervisory Approval. Finally, the prosecutor should secure supervisory approval before entering into a \nnon-prosecution agreement. Prosecutors working under the direction of a United States Attorney must seek \nthe approval of the United States Attorney or a supervisory Assistant United States Attorney. Departmental \nattorneys not supervised by a United States Attorney should obtain the approval of the appropriate \nAssistant Attorney General or his/her designee, and should notify the United States Attorney or Attorneys \nconcerned. The requirement of approval by a superior is designed to provide review by an attorney \nexperienced in such matters, and to ensure uniformity of policy and practice with respect to such \nagreements. This section should be read in conjunction with USAM 9-27.640, concerning particular types \nof cases in which an Assistant Attorney General or his/her designee must concur in or approve an \nagreement not to prosecute in ret urn for cooperation. \n9-27.620 Entering into Non-prosecution Agreements in Return for Cooperation — Considerations to be Weighed \nA. In determining whether, a person's cooperation may be necessary to the public interest, the attorney for the \ngovernment, and those whose approval is necessary, should weigh all relevant considerations, including: \n1. The importance of the investigation or prosecution to an effective program of law enforcement; \n2. The value of the person's cooperation to the investigation or prosecution; and \n3. The person's relative culpability in connection with the offense or offenses being investigated or \nprosecuted and his/her history with respect to criminal activity. \nB. Comment. This paragraph is intended to assist Federal prosecutors, and those whose approval they must secure, \nin deciding whether a person's cooperation appears to be necessary to the public interest. The considerations \nlisted here are not intended to be all-inclusive \n... [truncated, 4577 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/22 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=22]", "char_count": 4577}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \nPage 4 of 5 \n3. Relative Culpability and Criminal History. In determining whether it may be necessary to the public \ninterest to agree to forego prosecution of a person who may have violated the law in return for that person's \ncooperation, it is also important to consider the degree of his/her apparent culpability relative to others who \nare subjects of the investigation or prosecution as well as his/her history of criminal involvement. Of \ncourse, ordinarily it would not be in the public interest to forego prosecution of a high-ranking member of \na criminal enterprise in exchange for his/her cooperation against one of his/her subordinates, nor would the \npublic interest be served by bargaining away the opportunity to prosecute a person with a long history of \nserious criminal involvement in order to obtain the conviction of someone else on less serious charges. \nThese are matters with regard to which the attorney for the government may find it helpful to consult with \nthe investigating agenc y or with other prosecuting authorities who may have an interest in the person or \nhis/her associates. \nIt is also important to consider whether the person has a background of cooperation with law enforcement \nofficials, either as a witness or an informant, and whether he/she has previously been the subject of a compulsion order \nunder 18 U.S.C. §?-6003 or has escaped prosecution by virtue of an agreement not to prosecute. The information \nregarding compulsion orders may be available by telephone from the Immunity Unit in the Office of Enforcement \nOperations of the Criminal Division. \n9-27.630 Entering into Non-prosecution Agreements in Return for Cooperation — Limiting the Scope of \nCommitment \nA. In entering into a non-prosecution agreement, the attorney for the government should, if practicable, explicitly \nlimit the scope of the government's commitment to: \n1. Non-prosecution based directly or indirectly on the testimony o\n... [truncated, 4713 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/23 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=23]", "char_count": 4713}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "USAM 9-27.000. Principles of Federal Prosecution \nPage 5 of 5 \nFinally, the attorney for the government should make it clear that his/her agreement relates only to non-\nprosecution and that he/she has no independent authority to promise that the witness will he admitted into the \nDepartment's Witness Security program or that the Marshal's Service will provide any benefits to the witness in \nexchange for his/her cooperation. This does not mean, of course, that the prosecutor should not cooperate in making \narrangements with the Marshal's Service necessary for the protection of the witness in appropriate cases. The \nprocedures to be followed in such cases are set forth in USAM9-21.000. \n9-27.640 Agreements Requiring Assistant Attorney General Approval \nA. The attorney for the government should not enter into a non-prosecution agreement in exchange for a person's \ncooperation without first obtaining the approval of the Assistant Attorney General with supervisory responsibility \nover the subject matter, or his/her designee, when: \n1. Prior consultation or approval would be required by a statute or by Departmental policy for a declination of \nprosecution or dismissal of a charge with regard to which the agreement is to be made; or \n2. The person is: \na. A high-level Federal, state, or local official; \nb. An official or agent of a Federal investigative or law enforcement agency; or \nc. A person who otherwise is, or is likely to become of major public interest. \nB. Comment. USAM 9-27.640 sets forth special cases that require approval of non-prosecution agreements by the \nresponsible Assistant Attorney General or his/her designee. Subparagrc\n ph (1) covers cases in which existing \nstatutory provisions and departmental policies require that, with respe to certain types of offenses, the Attorney \nGeneral or an Assistant Attorney General be consulted or give his/her approval before prosecution is declined or \ncharges arc dismissed. For example, see USAM 64245 (tax offenses); U\n... [truncated, 3494 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/24 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=24]", "char_count": 3494}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "PART V-IMMUNITY OF WITNESSES \nChapter \nSection \n601. Immunity of witnesses  \n 6001 \nSec. \n6001. \n6002 \n6003. \n6004. \n0005. \nIIISTORICAL AND STATUTORY NOTES \n1994 Amendments \nPub.L. 103-322, Title XXXIII, I 330013(1), Sept. 13, 1994, \n108 Stat. 2146, added chapter heading. \n§ 6001. \nDefinitions \nAs used in this chapter—\n(1) \"agency of the United States\" means any \nexecutive department as defined in section 101 of \ntitle 5, United States Code, a military department \nas defined in section 102 of title 5, United States \nCode, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, the \nBoard of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, \nthe China Trade Act registrar appointed under 53 \n• Stat. 1432 (15 U.S.C. sec. 143), the Commodity \n• Futures Trading Commission, the Federal Commu-\nnications Commission, the Federal Deposit Insur-\nance Corporation, the Federal Maritime Commis-\nsion, the Federal Power Commission, the Federal \n• -- Trade Commission, the Surface Transportation \n.1 -Board, the National Labor Relations Board, the \n' National Transportation Safety Board, the Railroad \nRetirement \nard, an arbitration board established \nunder 48 Sta 1193 (45 U.S.C. sec. 1571 the Securi-\nties\ni\n and Exc ange Commission, or a board estab-\nlished under 49 Stet 31 (15 U.S.C. sec. 715d); \n. (2) \"other information\" includes any book, paper, \ndocument, record, recording, or other material; \n(3) \"proceeding before an agency of the United \nStates\" means any proceeding before such an agen-\ncy with respect to which it is authorized to issue \nsubpenas and to take testimony or receive other \n• information from witnesses under oath; and \n(4) \"court of the United States\" means any of the \n- following courts: the Supreme Court of the United \nStates, a United States court of appeals, a United \nStates district court established under chapter 5, \ntitle 28, United States Code, a United States bank-\nHISTORICAL AND STATUTORY NOTES \n1910 Amendment \nPubl.. 91-152, Title II, 6 201(a), Oct. 15. 1970, 84 Stat. \n926, added Par\n... [truncated, 4755 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/25 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=25]", "char_count": 4755}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "18 § 6001 \nIMMUNITY OF WITNESSES \nPart 5 \n1970 Acts. Section 2 \nof Pub.L. 91-452 provided that: \n6) \n\"The provisions o part \nof title 18, United States Code, \n1b\nadded by title II o this \nt [this part], and the amendments \nand repeals made y title II of this Act [sections 835, 895, \n1406, 1954, 2424, 2514 and 3486 of this title, sections 15, 87(0. \n135e, 499m(1). and 2135 of Title 7, Agriculture, section 25 of \nformer Title II, Bankruptcy, sectio 1820 of Title 12, Banks \nit \nand Banking, sections 32, 33, 49, 77 \n78u(d), 79r(e), 80a-4t, \n80b-9, 155, 717m. 1271, and 1714 of Ile 15, Commerce and \nTrade, section 825f of Title 16. Conservation, section 1333 of \nTitle 19, Customs Duties, section 373 of Title 21, Food and \nDrugs, sections 4874 and 7493 of Title 26, Internal Revenue \nCode, section 161(3) of Title 29, Labor, section 506 of Tide \n33, Nsfigation and Navigable Waters, sections 405(0 and \n2201 \nTitle 42, The Public Health and Welfare, sections 157 \nand \nof Title 45, Railroads, sections 827 and 1124 of Title \n46, Shipping, section 409(1 ) of Title 47, Telegraphs, Tele-\nphones, and Radiotelegraphs, sections 9, 43, 46, 47, 48, 916, \nand 1017 of former Title 49, Transportation, and section 1484 \nof Title 49, Appendix, section 792 of Title 50, War and \nNational Defense, and sections 643a, 1152, 2026, and 2155(b) \nof Title 50, Appendix), shall take effect on the sixtieth day \nfollowing the date of the enactment of this Act (Oct. 15, \n1970). No amendment to or repeal of any provision of law \nunder tide II of this Act shall affect any immunity to which \nany individual is entitled under such provision by reason of \nany testimony or other information given before such day.\" \nChange of Name \nReferences to United States Claims Court deemed to refer \nto United States Court of Federal Claims and references to \nClaims Court deemed to refer to Court of Federal Claims, \nsee section 902(b) of Pub.L. 102-572, set out as a note under \nsection 171 of Title 28. Judiciary. and Judicia\n... [truncated, 6287 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/26 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=26]", "char_count": 6287}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Ch. 601 \nIMMUNITY OF WITNESSES \n18 § 6005 \n(h) A United States attorney may, with the approv-\nal of the. Attorney General, the Deputy Attorney \nGeneral, the Associate Attorney General, or any des-\nignated Assistant. Attorney General or Deputy Assis-\ntant Attorney General, request an order under subsec-\ntion (a) of this section when in his judgment—\n(I) the testimony or other information from such \nindividual may be necessary to the public interest; \nand \n(2) such individual has refused or is likely to \nrefuse to testify or provide other information on the \nbasis of his privilege against self-incrimination. \n(Added Pub.L. 91-452, Title II, § 201(a), Oct. 15 1970, 84 \nStat 927, and amended Pub.L. 100-690, Title VII, § 7020(e), \nNov. 18, 1988, 102 Stat. 4396; Pub.L. 103-322, Title XXXIII, \n§ 330013(4), Sept 13, 1994, 108 Stat. 2146.) \n§ 6004. \nCertain administrative proceedings \n(a) in the case of any individual who has been or \nwho may be called to testify or provide other informa-\ntion at any proceeding before an agency of the United \nStates, the agency may, with the approval of the \nAttorney General, issue, in accordance with subsection \n(b) of this section, an order requiring the individual to \ngive testimony or provide other information which he \nrefuses to give or provide on the basis of his privilege \nagainst self-incrimination, such order to become effec-\ntive as provided in section 6002 of this title. \n(b) An agency of the United States may issue an \norder under subsection (a) of this section only if in its \njudgment—\n(1) the testimony or other information from such \nindividual may be necessary to the public interest; \nand \n(2) such individual has refused or is likely to \nrefuse to testify or provide other information on the \nbasis of his privilege against self-incrimination. \n(Added Pub.L. 91-452, Title 11, § 201(a), Oct. 15, 1970, 84 \nStat. 927, and amended Pub.L. 103-322, Title Mill, \n330013(4), Sept. 13, 1994, 108 Stat. 2146.) \n§ 6005. \nCongressional proce\n... [truncated, 4157 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/27 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=27]", "char_count": 4157}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Memorandum \nSubject \nChanges to Child Exploitation Statutes in \nTitle 18 \nSeptember 26, 2006 \nTo \nR. Alexander Acosta \nThomas Mulvihill \nJeffrey Sloman \nKenneth Now \nRobert Waters \nAndrew Lourie \nRoger Stefin \nKaren Atkinson \nRolando Garcia \nBruce Brown \nRichard Boscovich \nBarbara Martinez \nFrom \ncc: Anne Schultz \nAUSA \nOn July 27, 2006, Congress enacted the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of \n2006. President Bush signed the Act into law on the same day. The Act made some dramatic \nchanges to a number of sections in Title 18 - both sections that traditionally fall within \"child \nexploitation\" laws and other seemingly unrelated sections. The Act also created a series of new \ncrimes that are expected to have a large impact on the District. \nThis memo is meant to update you on the most pressing issue which is the changes that \nimpact child exploitation crimes committed after July 27, 2006'. \nA. Changes to Mandatory Minimum and Maximum Sentences. \n1. 18 U.S.C. § 1001 - False Statements \nThe statutory maximum of 5 years' imprisonment has been increased to 8 years if \"the matter \nrelates tom offense under chapter 109A [§§ 2241-2248],109B [new § 2250], 110 [§§2251- 2260], \nor 117 [§§ 2421-2427], or Section 1591 [sex trafficking of children]\". \nThe Act immediately became effective, but the changes do not appear in the \npocket pan for West's Federal Criminal Code and Rules. Because that book is most frequently \nreferred to by AUSAs, many prosecutors may be unaware of the changes. \nExhibit 16 \nEFTA00226424\n", "char_count": 1533}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "2. 18 U.S.C. § 1591 - Sex Trafficking of Children \nThere arc new statutory minimums and maximums for all of the categories of violations of \nSection 1591: \n(a) if the offense was effected by force, fraud, or coercion, or if the minor was under the age \nof 14, the minimum sentence is 15 years, up to a maximum of life; \n(b) if force, fraud, and coercion were not used and the minor was between 14 and 17, the \nminimum sentence is 10 years. up to a maximum of lift. \n3. 18 U.S.C. § 2241 - Aggravated Sexual Abuse \nWhoever crosses a state line with the intent to engage in a sexual act with a child under 12, \nor whoever, in the special maritime or territorial jurisdiction of the United States or in a federal \nprison, engages in a sexual act with a child between the ages of 12 and 15 by force, threat of force, \nrendering the victim unconscious, or by administering a drug or intoxicant to the victim, shall be \nimprisoned not less than 30 years, up to a maximum of life. 18 U.S.C. § 2241(c). \n4. 18 U.S.C. § 2242 - Sexual Abuse \nWhoever, in the special maritime and territorial jurisdiction of the United States or in a \nfederal prison, engages in a sexual act with an adult by force, threat of force, or with a person \nmentally incapable of appraising the nature of the situation or a person physically incapable of \nrefusing to participate, faces a maximum term of life imprisonment. \n5. 18 U.S.C. § 2243 - Sexual Abuse of a Minor or Ward \nWhoever, in the special jurisdiction of the United States, engages in a sexual act with a \nperson between 12 and 15 or with a prisoner, faces up to IS years' imprisonment. \n6. 18 U.S.C. § 2244 - Abusive Sexual Contact \nIf a person engages in \"sexual contact\" in the special jurisdiction of the United States, he or \nshe faces the following sentences: \n(a) with a child under 12 or with a child between 12 and 15 by force, threats, or by \nincapacitating the victim, up to life imprisonment; \n(b) with an adult by force, threats, or with a person incapable o\n... [truncated, 2146 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/29 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=29]", "char_count": 2146}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "7. 18 U.S.C. § 2245 - Offenses Resulting in Death \nThe death penalty now applies to a person who commits murder in the course of an offense \nunder Chapter I 09A, or section 1591, 2251, 225IA, 2260, 2421, 2422, 2423, or 2425. \n8. 18 U.S.C. § 2251 - Sexual Exploitation of Children \nSection 2251 addresses the sexual exploitation of children for the production of child \npornography (subsection (a)); allowing one's child or ward to engage in sexual conduct for the \nproduction of child pornography (subsection (b)); sexually exploiting a child outside the United \nStates to create child pornography for importation into the United States (subsection (c)); and posting \nor publishing an advertisement or notice offering to receive, exchange, buy, produce, create, or \ndistribute child pornography (subsection (d)). The statutory sentencing limits have remained the \nsame (15 to 30 years for a first offense, 25 to 50 years for a second offense, and 35 to life for a third \noffense), but Congress now imposes a range of 30 years to life or death if the offense results in the \ndeath of a person. \n9. 18 U.S.C. § 2252 - Activities Relating to Material Involving the Sexual \nExploitation of Minors \nViolations of 2252(aX1), 2252(aX2) and 2252(aX3), which cover transporting, distributing, \nreceiving, selling, or possessing with intent to sell, still carry statutory imprisonment ranges of 5 to \n20 years for the first offense, and 15 to 40 years for a second offense. Violations of 2252(aX4), \nwhich addresses possession of child pornography keeps the statutory range of0 to 10 years for a first \noffense and 10 to 20 years for a second offense. The penalty provisions of 2252(b)( I ) and \n2252(bX2) have been amended to expand the definitions of \"prior conviction\" to include sex \ntrafficking of children. \n10. 18 U.S.C. § 2252A - Activities Relating to Child Pornography \nThe statutory sentencing ranges have not changed, but this section also was amended to \ninclude sex trafficking of children as a \"\n... [truncated, 2517 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/30 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=30]", "char_count": 2517}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "13. 18 U.S.C. § 2260 - Production of Child Pornography for Importation into the \nUnited States \nViolations of Section 2260(a) - use of a minor outside the United States to create child \npornography meant to be imported into the United States - will now be punished under the \nsentencing scheme in 18 U.S.C. § 2251(e) - 15 to 30 for the first offense. 25 to 50 for the second. \nand 35 to life for the third, and death or 30 to life if the offense results in the death of a person. \nViolations of2260(b)- receiving, distributing, transporting, selling or possessing with intent \nto distribute child pornography meant for importation into the United States - is punished under the \nsentencing scheme in 18 U.S.C. § 2252(b)(I) - 5 to 20 for the first offense and 15 to 40 for a second \noffense. \n14. 18 U.S.C. § 2422 - Coercion and Enticement \nThe statutory sentence limits for using the mail or any facility of interstate or foreign \ncommerce to persuade a minor to engage in prostitution or other sexual activity, in violation of 18 \nU.S.C. § 2422(b). have increased to 10 years to life. \n15. 18 U.S.C. § 2423 - Transportation of Minors \nThe mandatory minimum and maximum sentences for violations of 2423(a) - transportation \nof a minor with the intent that the minor engage in prostitution or other criminal sexual activity-also \nhas been raised to 10 years to life. \nB. Changes to Sentencing Enhancements and Classification. \n1. 18 U.S.C. § 2260A - New Enhancement for Registered Sex Offenders \nThe Act created a new section, 2260A, which creates a ten-year consecutive sentence for a \nviolation \"involving a minor\" under 18 U.S.C. §§ 1201, 1466A, 1470, 1591, 2241, 2242, 2243, \n2244, 2245, 2251, 2251 A, 2260, 2421, 2422, 2423, and 2425, if the crime was committed while the \ndefendant was required to register as a sex offender. Although not explicitly stated in the \nAmendment, this enhancement probably applies only to crimes of conviction involving a real minor \n(as opposed to an undercover off\n... [truncated, 2529 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/31 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=31]", "char_count": 2529}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "3559(e) also was added in 2004 to impose mandatory life imprisonment if the defendant has \na prior sex conviction with a real minor victim and the crime of conviction is a sex offense with a \nreal minor victim. The Adam Walsh Act added 18 U.S.C. § 1591 (sex trafficking of children) to the \ndefinition of \"sex offense.\" \nThe Adam Walsh Act also added 3559(f) which creates mandatory minimum sentences for \nviolent crimes against children under 18. These mandatory minimums override the maximums and \nminimums in the statute creating the offense unless the sentence there is greater. If the offense is \nthe murder of a minor, the defendant must be sentenced between 30 years and life, unless death is \nimposed. 18 U.S.C. § 3559(f)(I ). If the offense is kidnapping or maiming, the defendant must be \nsentenced between 25 years and life. 18 U.S.C. § 3559(0(2). And if the crime of violence results \nin serious bodily injury, or if a dangerous weapon was used during and in the relation to the offense, \nthe defendant must be sentenced between 10 years and life. 18 U.S.C. § 3559(0(3). \n3. 18 U.S.C. § 3563 - Conditions of Probation \nThe Act changed one mandatory condition of probation and added a discretionary condition. \nSection 3563(aX8) now mandates that, for any person required to register under the Sex Offender \nRegistration and Notification Act, the Court must impose the condition that the person comply with \nthe requirements of that Act. Section 3563(bX23) creates a new discretionary condition to allow \nprobation officers and law enforcement officers to search the person, residence, vehicle, and \ncomputer of any registered sex offender at any time upon reasonable suspicion of a violation of \nprobation or other unlawful conduct. \n4. 18 U.S.C. § 3583 - Supervised Release \nThe Act made four significant changes to supervised release. First, the sexual offense \ndefendant's compliance with the Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act is a mandatory \ncondition. § 3583(d). Second,\n... [truncated, 3163 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/32 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=32]", "char_count": 3163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "5. 18 U.S.C. § 3592 - Mitigating and Aggravating Factors in Determining Whether to \nImpose a Sentence of Death \nSection 3592 (c)(1) has been amended to included a violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2245 as an \naggravating factor for a homicide case. \nC. Creation or Expansion of Federal Offenses \n1. 18 U.S.C. § 1201 - Kidnapping \nThe Adam Walsh Act filled a jurisdictional gap in Section 1201. Now there is federal \njurisdiction over a kidnapping offense if the victim was transported in interstate or foreign \ncommerce, whether or not the victim was alive when the transportation began, or if the perpetrator \ntravels in interstate or foreign commerce, during or in furtherance of the offense, or if the perpetrator \nuses the mail or any means, facility, or instrumentality of interstate of foreign commerce during or \nin furtherance of the offense. \n2. 18 U.S.C. § 1465 - Production and Distribution of Obscene Materials \nSection 1465 has been expanded to prohibit producing obscene materials \"with the intent to \ntransport, distribute, or transmit in interstate or foreign commerce.\" \n3. 18 U.S.C. § 2250 - Failure to Register as a Sex Offender \nThe enactment of Section 2250 now makes it a federal criminal offense for certain sex \noffenders to fail to register or to update their sex offender registrations. To avoid jurisdictional \nproblems, Section 2250 only applies to sex offenders who either: \n(a) is a sex offender due to a conviction under federal law, the Uniform Code of Military \nJustice, the law of the District of Columbia, Indian tribal law, or the law of a U.S. \nterritory or possession, \nor (b) is a sex offender due to a conviction under state, local, or foreign' law and travels in \ninterstate or foreign commerce, or enters, leaves, or resides in Indian Country. \nThe punishment for violating Section 2250 is up to 10 years' imprisonment, but if the \noffender is found to have committed a crime of violence. then he must serve a consecutive term of \n5 to 30 years' imprisonment. \nrA for\n... [truncated, 2162 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/33 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=33]", "char_count": 2162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "4. 18 U.S.C. § 2252C - Misleading Words or Images on the Internet \nThis new offense is an analog to § 2252B, which prohibits the use of misleading domain \nnames to induce someone to view obscene material. Section 2252C expands the prohibition to \n\"embedding\" words or digital images into the source code of a website.\" If those words or images \ndeceive an adult into viewing obscene material, the penalty is up to 10 years' imprisonment. If the \nwords or images arc meant to deceive a minor into viewing material harmful to minors, the penalty \nis up to 20 years' imprisonment. \n5. 18 U.S.C. § 2257 and 2257A - Record Keeping Requirements for Producers of \nPornography \nSection 2257 was enacted several years ago to require the producers of adult pornography \nto keep records of the names, ages, and other information related to the persons appearing in the \npornography. The Adam Walsh Act amended Section 2257 to make clear that the record-keeping \nrequirements also apply to internet-based pornography websites and digital images that are never \nprinted on \"film\" or \"videotape.\" The Act also criminalized a producer's refusal to allow an \ninspection of these records by the Attorney General or his designee. § 22570)(5). \nThe Act also created Section 2257A, which extends these record keeping requirements to \nproducers of \"simulated sexually explicit conduct.\" § 2257A(a)( I ). \nIX Changes to Court Procedures \n1. 18 U.S.C. § 2255 - Civil Remedy for Personal Injuries \nSection 2255 has been expanded to allow a person who, while a minor, was a victim \nof various child exploitation offenses, to pursue a civil action for personal injury damages -\nregardless of when the personal injury occurred. It also raises the presumptive damage amount to \n5150,000. \n2. 18 U.S.C. § 3142 - Release or Detention Pending Trial \nSection 3142 has been amended several times in recent years to create a presumption of \ndetention in child exploitation cases. The Adam Walsh Act makes three changes to Section 3142\n... [truncated, 2779 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/34 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=34]", "char_count": 2779}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "that is not otherwise a crime of violence that involves a minor victim or that involves the possession \nor use of a firearm or destructive device, or involves a failure to register\" as a sex offender. § \n3142(1). \nThird, the factors that the Court is supposed to consider in making its decision on detention \nnow include whether the offense involved a minor victim or a firearm, explosive, or destructive \ndevice. § 3142(g)(1). \n3. 18 U.S.C. § 3299 - Limitations Period \nThe Act rescinded the statute of limitations for any offense under Section 1201 (kidnapping) \ninvolving a minor victim, and for my felony under chapters I 09A, 110 (except Sections 2257 and \n2257A), and 117, and under Section 1591. \n4. 18 U.S.C. § 3509 - Child Victims' and Child Witnesses' Rights \nThe Adam Walsh Act provides a specific instruction regarding the handling and disclosure \nof child pornography. The child pornography must remain in the care, custody, and control of the \nGovernment or the Court. § 3509 (m)(1). Notwithstanding Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of \nCriminal Procedure, a Court shall deny any request by the defense to copy or duplicate any \nchild pornography, so long as the Government makes the material reasonably available to the \ndefense, including defense experts. § 3509(m)(2). \n5. 18 U.S.C. § 4042 - Duties of Bureau of Prisons \nBOP is mandated to provide notice to prisoners about to be released of their obligations to \nregister as Sex Offenders, and to notify state and local law enforcement of the pending release of a \nsex offender. \n8 \nEFTA00226431\n", "char_count": 1560}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "1 \n1 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \n2 \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nWEST PALM BEACH DIVISION \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \nIN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n/ \nGrand Jury #07-103 (WPB) \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \n13 \nTuesday, February 6, 2007 \n14 \n15 \nTESTIMONY \n16 \nOF \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \nAPPEARANCE: \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nExhibit 17 \nEFTA00226432\n", "char_count": 386}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "2 \n1 \nPROCEEDINGS \n2 \n- - -\n3 \nThe sworn testimony of \nas taken \n4 \nbefore the Federal Grand Jury, west Palm Beach Division, \n5 \n701 clematis Street, west Palm Beach, Palm Beach county, \n6 \nstate of Florida, on the 6th day of February, 2007. \n7 \nNANCY SIEGEL, Registered Merit Reporter and Notary \n8 \nPublic was authorized to and did report the sworn \n9 \ntestimony. \n10 \nThereupon, \n11 \n12 \na witness of lawful age, having been first duly sworn by \n13 \nthe foreperson, testified on her oath as follows: \n14 \nBY MS. \n15 \nQ \nplease state and \n16 \nspell your name for the record. \n17 \nA \nIt is \nand I work for \n18 \nthe FBI in Palm Beach county. \n19 \nQ \nCan you spell your last name, please. \n20 \nA \nI'm sorry, it is \n21 \nQ \nAnd I know we have some people in the back \n22 \nhaving trouble hearing you. You said that you work for \n23 \nthe FBI. Can you tell the Grand Jury what particular \n24 \ngroup you are employed with? \n25 \nA \nI am with the violent Crimes Squad here in \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226433\n", "char_count": 1024}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "3 \n1 \nPalm Beach county, I work primarily crimes against \n2 \nchildren, but have been an agent for the last \n3 \napproximately 10 years. \n4 \nQ \nHave you received specialized training in the \narea of crimes against children? \n6 \nA \nYes, I have. \n7 \nQ \nAs part of your employment with the FBI have \n8 \nyou been involved in an investigation of Jeffrey \n9 \nEpstein? \n10 \nA \nYes, I have. \n11 \nQ \nAnd can you tell us who Jeffrey Epstein is? \n12 \nA \nJeffrey Epstein is an investment advisor who \n13 \nhas a part-time residence in the town of Palm Beach, he \n14 \nhas got multiple residences across the country to \n15 \ninclude a ranch in New mexico, an island in the virgin \n16 \nisles, and multiple aircrafts, two airplanes and a \n17 \nhelicopter to be exact, and --\n18 \nQ \nAnd where is his primary residence? \n19 \nA \nHis primary residence, he has an office in New \n20 \nYork, but his primary residence I believe is the island. \n21 \nQ \nIn the virgin islands? \n22 \nA \nYes. \n23 \nQ \nHe also has a home in New York, correct? \n24 \nA \nYes. \n25 \nQ \nHow is it that you started investigating \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226434\n", "char_count": 1126}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "4 \n1 \nMr. Epstein? \n2 \nA \nThe Palm Beach police Department in March of \n3 \n2005 initiated an investigation on Mr. Epstein involving \n4 \nmultiple underage females that had visited Mr. Epstein's \n5 \nresidence and had performed sexual massages or massages \n6 \nfor Mr. Epstein of a sexual nature. \n7 \nMr. Epstein paid the underage females anywhere \n8 \nfrom 200 to $400, that investigation was around an 8 to \n9 \n10-month investigation, and at that point we became \n10 \ninvolved in about July of 2006. \n11 \nQ \nAnd once the case was presented to you by the \n12 \nPalm Beach Police Department did the FBI open its own \n13 \ninvestigation? \n14 \nA \nYes, yes, we initiated our investigation in \n15 \nJuly of 2006, we took a look at focusing in on the \n16 \nunderage minors and in our investigation we interviewed \n17 \nmany of the girls that were underage and we did an \n18 \nindependent investigation issuing Grand Jury subpoenas \n19 \nas well as administrative subpoenas getting different \n20 \ndocuments of financial records, telephone analysis, \n21 \nflight manifests, looking to see if Mr. Epstein engaged \n22 \nin sexual activity with these females. \n23 \nQ \nAll right. And just so the Grand Jury is \n24 \nclear, were some of the girls who went to Mr. Epstein's \n25 \nhouse 18 or older? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226435\n", "char_count": 1327}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "5 \n1 \nA \nYes. \n2 \nQ \nAnd then there were some that were under the \n3 \nage of 18, correct? \n4 \nA \nYes. \n5 \nQ \nAnd as part of the federal investigation did \n6 \nyou have to investigate what we call the interstate \n7 \nnexus aspect of the case? \n8 \nA \nYes. \n9 \nQ \nAnd can you explain to the Grand Jury what \n10 \nthat is? \n11 \nA \nwe looked at -- Mr. Epstein, as I mentioned \n12 \nearlier, has two aircrafts, and we focused in on the \n13 \nyear 2004, 2005, he took approximately 60 trips to his \n14 \nresidence in Palm Beach, the majority of that time \n15 \nfocusing in on his assistant's cell phone, which his \n16 \nassistant's name is MS \nwe took a look at her\n17 \ncell phone records and the majority of the times that \n18 \nMr. Epstein would fly into Palm Beach Mrs. \nms. Kellen \n19 \nwould contact many of our underage victims either prior \n20 \nto coming into Palm Beach, the day of, the day before, \n21 \neven the day after, and certainly throughout the time \n22 \nthat Mr. Epstein was at his residence in Palm Beach. \n23 \nQ \nAnd from the interviews of the girls that have \n24 \nbeen conducted, what was the subject of those telephone \n25 \ncalls? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226436\n", "char_count": 1192}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "6 \n1 \nA \ncan you restate the question? \n2 \nQ \nSure. From the interviews of the girls that \n3 \nhave been conducted, what was the subject matter of the \n4 \ntelephone calls Irom \nS \nA \nwould schedule the underage girls \n6 \nto come and work, perform the massages for Mr. Epstein, \n7 \nso she was responsible, she as well as another \n8 \nassistant, \n, they were his personal \n9 \nassistants who would set up appointments for Mr. Epstein \n10 \nfor the girls to come and perform their sexual massages. \n11 \nQ \nAll right. Is \nlso considered a \n12 \ntarget of this investigation? \n13 \nA \nYes, she is. \n14 \nQ \nAnd I will just \nI will spell \n15 \nor the Grand Jury. The irst name is \n16 \nnd the last name is spelled \n17 \n, and does IIIIIIIIIIIIIhave a new last \n18 \nname? \n19 \nA \nYes, she does, she is married and her name is \n20 \n21 \nQ \nFa \nat least a subject of \n22 \nthis investigation, in other words, you are \n23 \ninvestigating her activity? \n24 \nA \nwe are looking at that. \n25 \nQ \nIn addition to those two assistants, from the \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226437\n", "char_count": 1072}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "7 \n1 \ninterviews of the girls, is there anyone else who is \n2 \nassociated with Mr. Epstein who is thought to be \n3 \ninvolved in this activity? \n4 \nA \n5 \ncompanion, girl Iriend, personal assistant, she through \n6 \nthe testimony of the girls has engaged in sexual \n7 \nactivity with \n8 \nQ \nAnd \nSo Ms. \n9 \nMarcinkova is also at least a subject of the \n10 \ninvestigation, correct? \n11 \nA \nYes, she is. \n12 \nQ \nNow, as part of this investigation you \n13 \nmentioned that subpoenas were issued on behalf of either \n14 \nthe old Grand Jury or this Grand Jury. \n15 \nCan you run through what subpoenas have been \n16 \nissued and what documents have been received in response \n17 \nto that? \n18 \nA \nSure. We issued a Grand Jury subpoena to \n19 \ncolonial Bank and we received financial records on \n20 \ncredit card accounts and individuals. \n21 \nwe subpoenaed washington Mutual and they did a \n22 \nsearch and were unable to locate records at this time. \n23 \nwe issued a Grand Jury subpoena for Capital One and \n24 \nserved that and that is still unresolved at this time as \n25 \nfar as them providing documents to us. \nhas been referred \nat least three of the underage \nto as his \nminors. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226438\n", "char_count": 1228}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "8 \n1 \nwe have subpoenaed chase credit card and we \n2 \nhave received documents from chase. we have subpoenaed \n3 \ntwo businesses that Mr. Epstein has at least partial \n4 \nownership or associated to, Hyperion Air, Inc. and JEGE, \n5 \nInc., they were issued subpoenas and they have provided \n6 \ndocumentation to us. \n7 \nwe have subpoenaed Mr. David Rogers, who is a \n8 \npilot of Mr. Epstein's, and we have received \n9 \ndocumentation from mr. Rogers. we have subpoenaed DTG \n10 \nOperations, who is doing business as Dollar Rent-A-Car, \n11 \nand we have received car rental agreements and financial \n12 \nrecords from that business. \n13 \nwe have subpoenaed Royal Palm Beach High \n14 \nschool and have received documentation regarding the \n15 \nstudents' records. We have subpoenaed three or four of \n16 \nthe victims, \nbeing the first, and we have \n17 \nreceived a bathing suit from \n18 \nwe issued a Grand Jury subpoena to \n19 \nMiller, we actually have issued \nthree subpoenas, \n20 \nand we are still working on resolving her Grand Jury \n21 \nmaterial as well as testimony. \n22 \nwe have issued \na subpoena, we \n23 \nhave issued -- she also is one of our underage victims. \n24 \nwe've issued Reimer Employment Agency a Grand Jury \n25 \nsubpoena and we have received documentation, that is an \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226439\n", "char_count": 1331}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "9 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \nreceived that. By the way, that is the only thing that \n5 \nI did not bring with me today, I brought everything \n6 \nelse, but it is rather a lot of evidence, so we will \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \nTouch Flowers located here \n19 \nhave received documentation \n20 \nGrand Jury subpoena to Bill Hammond, another pilot for \n21 \nMr. Epstein, we have spoken with him. \n22 \nwe have issued a Grand Jury \n23 \nVisoski , another one of Mr. Epstein's \n24 \nhave received documentation \n25 \nemployment agency located on the island of Palm Beach. \nwe have subpoenaed the Palm Beach Police \nDepartment for their evidence in this case and we have \nprobably be bringing that to you another time. \nwe have issued the Clerk of Courts of the \nState of Florida for Grand Jury transcripts in the state \nmatter and we have received those. we have issued the \nGood Samaritan Hospital lor billing records and we have \nreceived those. \nwe have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to the \nDalton school located in New York and at this time they \ndo not have the records we have requested or could not \nlocate those. \nWe have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to Extra \nin west Palm Beach and we \nfrom them. We issued a \nsubpoena to Larry \npilots, and we \nas well as spoken to him. \nWe have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to Janusz \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226440\n", "char_count": 1376}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "10 \n1 \nBanasiak, who is the property manager currently for \n2 \nMr. Epstein at his Palm Beach residence, and we have \n3 \nreceived documentation as well as spoken to him, and we \n4 \nhave issued a Grand Jury subpoena to Adriana mucinska \n5 \nand have received some documentation and are still \n6 \nawaiting a response. \n7 \nQ \nNow, you mentioned that you didn't bring with \n8 \nyou the evidence that you received from the Palm Beach \n9 \nPolice Department, but did you bring with you all of the \n10 \nother evidence that was received in response to the \n11 \nsubpoenas? \n12 \nA \nI have. \n13 \nQ \nAnd is that evidence in the two boxes that are \n14 \nhere in the front? \n15 \nA \nYes. \n16 \nQ \nwe will bring all of this back to you when we \n17 \npresent the indictment, but would anyone like to look at \n18 \nany of the documentation today? \n19 \nA GRAND JUROR: what does the documentation \n20 \nconstitute, basically, the subpoenas? \n21 \nTHE WITNESS: It is primarily business \n22 \nrecords, flight manifests, stuff that came from him \n23 \ntraveling to and from Palm Beach, credit card \n24 \nrecords, the businesses as far as the rental \n25 \nagreement which involves some of the underage girls \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226441\n", "char_count": 1227}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "11 \n1 \nwith the rental cars, and flower shop, you know. \n2 \nA GRAND JUROR: will we have an opportunity \n3 \nlater to go through these it we need to? \n4 \nYes, we will bring them when \n5 \nwe present the indictment. Yes, ma'am. \n6 \nA GRAND JUROR: If I should hold this for \n7 \nlater let me know, she mentioned the hospital \n8 \nrecords were subpoenaed, could more information \n9 \nabout why they were subpoenaed be provided at this \n10 \ntime? \n11 \nBY al \n12 \nQ \nYou can answer that. \n13 \nA \nOne of the girls that was an underage \nthat \n14 \nwas underage at the time that is involved with \n15 \nMr. Epstein has had a baby and we were interested and \n16 \nwondering if possibly he was the father of that baby, \n17 \nwhich at this time we do not believe he was. \n18 \nA GRAND JUROR: Thank you. \n19 \n: A question? \n20 \nA GRAND JUROR: Did the flight manifest show \n21 \npassengers on the plane? \n22 \nTHE WITNESS: Yes, they d0. \n23 \nA GRAND JUROR: were any of the passengers the \n24 \nunderage girls that were a target of the \n25 \ninvestigation? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226442\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "12 \n1 \nTHE WITNESS: At this time we have not \n2 \nassociated any of these underage girls as being the \n3 \npassengers. The flight manifests, sometimes the \n4 \npilot if they did not know who the passenger was \n5 \nwould put one passenger or one female, one male, \n6 \nthese were private planes and they, you know, may \n7 \nnot have felt like they can go up and ask, but we \n8 \ndon't have any evidence at this time to believe \n9 \nthat they were any of our victims. \n10 \n: Any follow-up? Any other \n11 \nquestions from the Grand Jury? Yes, ma'am. \n12 \nA GRAND JUROR: The records that you \n13 \nsubpoenaed from the high school, what were they \n14 \nused for or why were they instrumental in the \n15 \ninvestigation? \n16 \nTHE WITNESS: Those are the girls' school \n17 \nrecords and we are just looking at the girls' \n18 \nrecords. \n19 \nA GRAND JUROR: Absenteeism? \n20 \nTHE WITNESS: Just looking at some of their \n21 \ngrades and performances and how they did in school. \n22 \nLadies and gentlemen, before \n23 \nwe continue, the witness has mentioned a few names \n24 \nof the minors and that is confidential information, \n25 \nobviously everything that you hear within these \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226443\n", "char_count": 1209}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "13 \n1 \nwalls is confidential. \n2 \nBY \n3 \nQ \nNow, \n, after -- in \n4 \naddition to issuing the subpoenas, you mentioned that \n5 \none of the subpoenas was to the Palm Beach Police \n6 \nDepartment. Did you review any of the evidence that \n7 \nthey collected? \n8 \nA \nYes. \n9 \nQ \nAnd can you, for example, did the Palm Beach \n10 \nPolice Department interview any girls? \n11 \nA \nYes, they did, they interviewed several of the \n12 \ngirls, most of the girls, they took taped statements \n13 \nfrom the girls either in the form of a tape-recorder or \n14 \nthrough video. \n15 \nQ \nAnd you have reviewed some of those \n16 \ninterviews, correct? \n17 \nA \nYes, we have. \n18 \nQ \nAnd has the FBI performed any interviews? \n19 \nA \nYes, we have, we have performed interviews of \n20 \npast and current employees of Mr. Epstein as well as \n21 \nfocusing in on the girls, the girls that were underage \n22 \nat the time of the sexual activity, we wanted to \n23 \ndetermine with these girls, again, the sexual activity \n24 \nthat took place with Mr. Epstein as well as how old they \n25 \nwere at the time, if they traveled with mr. Epstein, any \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226444\n", "char_count": 1163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "14 \n1 \ngifts that they may have gotten, so we did reach out to \n2 \nseveral of the underage minors and gathered more \n3 \ninformation Irom them. \n4 \nQ \nAnd through the FBI'S investigation has the \n5 \nFBI identified additional victims that perhaps the state \n6 \npolice officers did not know about? \n7 \nA \nYes, we are still trying to identify, get \n8 \nfirst names of girls and going back and looking through \n9 \nschool yearbooks and attempting to try to locate friends \n10 \nof friends, so we are still in the process, when you \n11 \ninterview one of the girls and you ask if any of their \n12 \nfriends went, they sometimes will give you other names, \n13 \nso we are in the process of still uncovering victims and \n14 \nreaching out and interviewing additional girls that we \n15 \nbelieve possibly were underage at the time of this \n16 \nsexual activity. \n17 \nQ \nIf I could ask you to step outside. \n18 \n(The witness was excused from the Grand Jury \n19 \nroom.) \n20 \n(Questions posed by the Grand Jury.) \n21 \n(The witness was recalled to testify before \n22 \nthe Grand Jury.) \n23 \nBY \n24 \nQ \none of the Grand \n25 \nJurors asked whether there was any evidence of force or \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226445\n", "char_count": 1214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "15 \n1 \ncoercion. \n2 \nA \nwhen talking to the girls they were told that \n3 \nthey may have to -- they were going there to perform a \n4 \nmassage, possibly model lingerie, they went there \n5 \nsometimes on multiple occasions and they may start of \n6 \nwearing their clothing and then he would instruct them \n7 \nto remove their clothing, the girls either performed \n8 \nthese massages in the nude or keeping their underwear \n9 \non. \n10 \nAs they went back again and again on some of \n11 \nthe occasions the girls would take off more and more of \n12 \ntheir clothing, so when they first started they may be \n13 \nfully clothed and then when they came back he would \n14 \ninstruct them to remove more of their clothing, so as \n15 \nfar as coercion, they were paid 8200 to $400 to perform \n16 \nthese massages. \n17 \nThey are not trained in performing massages, \n18 \nthey don't -- they are not masseuses, but yet iI you ask \n19 \nif they were coerced, they were paid quite a bit of \n20 \nmoney for 30 to 45 minutes work. \n21 \nSome of the girls, being that they were minors \n22 \ngoing to his residence, got in over their heads and did \n23 \nnot always return or come back, some of our victims did \n24 \nnot come back after, you know, they did go down to their \n25 \nthong underwear and Mr. Epstein did perform sexual acts \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226446\n", "char_count": 1353}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "16 \n1 \neither by -- and I didn't get into that, but either by \n2 \nstroking their vagina on the outside of their panties or \n3 \nsometimes inside their panties as well as fondling them, \n4 \nand the girls, many of our victims did not realize that \n5 \nthat was what was going to happen. \n6 \nQ \nAnd was there one instance where Mr. Epstein \n7 \nactually engaged in vaginal intercourse with a girl \n8 \nagainst her will? \n9 \nA \nYes, he did, one of our victims who had been \n10 \ngoing there over a lengthy period of time had told \n11 \nMr. Epstein on several occasions that he was not to do \n12 \nthat and he did turn her around, threw her on the \n13 \nmassage table and penetrated her. \n14 \nQ \nA Grand Juror asked how old Mr. Epstein is. \n15 \nA \nHe was 45 at the time that we are looking at \n16 \nhim at that time period. \n17 \nQ \nA Grand Juror asked if you know the proportion \n18 \nof girls who were underage versus 18 or older. \n19 \nA \nThe majority of the girls that we are looking \n20 \nat are victims, well, all of our victims that we are \n21 \nlooking at were under the age of 18. \n22 \nAs far as all of the girls that have been \n23 \ninterviewed, the majority definitely were under 18. To \n24 \ngive you a number, I would have to go and count, but I \n25 \nwould say in the state investigation there were over 25 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226447\n", "char_count": 1356}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "17 \n1 \ngirls identified and more than a majority would have \n2 \nbeen under the age of 18. \n3 \nQ \nA Grand Juror asked whether we have obtained \n4 \nMr. Epstein's DNA and whether there was any DNA testing \n5 \nof the baby that you spoke of earlier. \n6 \nA \nNo, we have not. \n7 \nQ \nA Grand Juror asked how Mr. Epstein would make \n8 \ncontact with the girls, was this done via computer or in \n9 \nsome other method? \n10 \nA \nI am sorry, \nhis personal \n11 \nassistant, would contact, or on some occasions \n12 \nwould also contact the girls via their cell \n13 \nphone and we have message pads from the residents that \n14 \nalso indicate the girls calling the home in response to \nilillill \n15 \nsome of those phone calls, so they would call, \n16 \nwould call, the majority of the calls were made \n17 \nby \nto the girls arranging for these, you \n18 \nknow, can you come at this time, can you come at that \n19 \ntime. \n20 \nQ \nAnd is the cellular telephone a facility of \n21 \ninterstate commerce? \n22 \nA \nYes, it is. \n23 \nQ \nAnd then one of the Grand Jurors asked whether \n24 \nthe assistants knew that the girls were underage or \n25 \ncommitted sex acts. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226448\n", "char_count": 1187}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "18 \n1 \nDid anybody, have you interviewed anybody who \n2 \naffirmatively told you that they told \nKellen their \n3 \nage or what was going on behind closed doors? \n4 \nA \nNo, no, not at this time, not at this time. \n5 \nQ \nAnd what leads you to believe that she, for \n6 \nexample, \nknew or should have known what was \nIIIIIIIIIIIII \n7 \ngoing on? \n8 \nA \nThere are so many girls that \nKellen \n9 \ncontacted to give Mr. Epstein massages that have no \n10 \ntraining in massages, and that \nwas aware \nIIIIIIIIIIII \n11 \nthat girls were bringing other girls, you know, their \n12 \nfriends to do these massages. \n13 \nKellen was also making appointments for \n14 \nlegitimate massages for Mr. Epstein Irom legitimate \n15 \nmasseuses that would come and give him massages, so the \n16 \nnumber of girls, their appearances at the time would \n17 \nlead us to believe that \nhad knowledge that \n18 \nthese girls were underage. \n19 \nQ \nAll right. Thank you very much. Those were \n20 \nall the questions from the Grand Jury. \n21 \nA GRAND JUROR: Actually, I have two more, \n22 \nbut. \n23 \nm5. VILLAFANA: Okay. \n24 \nA GRAND JUROR: what was the actual age range \n25 \nof these girls? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226449\n", "char_count": 1202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "19 \n1 \nTHE WITNESS: 14 to I mean. \n2 \nA GRAND JUROR: The other one was, how did Ms. \n3 \nKellen actually originally get these girls, how \n4 \nwere they brought in, I mean how were they, you \n5 \nknow, because you said she called them when he was \n6 \narriving, but how did these girls come into this in \n7 \nthe first place? \n8 \nA GRAND JUROR: could she speak louder? \n9 \nwe \n10 \njust had a request that you speak louder. \n11 \nA GRAND JUROR: 14 and what? \n12 \nTHE WITNESS: Our victims were 14 to 17, but \n13 \nwe have girls that are 18, we have girls that are \n14 \n20, we have girls that are in their early 20s, and \n15 \nyour question was? \n16 \nA GRAND JUROR: How did she originally get \n17 \nthem in in the first place? \n18 \nTHE WITNESS: we are focusing in on 2004, \n19 \n2005, we have some evidence to show that this \n20 \nactivity was taking place even earlier than that, \n21 \ncertainly to include 2003 if you look at the \n22 \nmessage pads, but focusing in on 2004, 2005, the \n23 \nchain started with one of our minors and from that \n24 \nminor who goes to the house, mr. Epstein tells \n25 \nher -- sees that she is maybe not comfortable with \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226450\n", "char_count": 1191}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "20 \n1 \ndoing the massage the way he would like it and \n2 \ntells her that she could bring other girls to do \n3 \nthe massages and she in fact if she brought another \n4 \ngirl she would be paid $200 for just bringing \n5 \nanother girl, so there starts the chain, and \n6 \nMr. Epstein would ask the girls or \nwould ask \n7 \nthe girls or their phone numbers so each time, you \n8 \nknow, if one of the girls brought a girl and he \n9 \nliked her he would ask for her phone number, ask \n10 \nher to leave the phone number, or \n11 \nwould get the phone number and then that girl would \n12 \nmaybe bring, because if you brought somebody you \n13 \ndidn't have to do the massage, but you also got \n14 \npaid for bringing a new person, so not only if you \n15 \ndid the massage would you get anywhere from 200 to \n16 \n400, but if you brought a new female you would \n17 \nreceive 200 or $400. \n18 \nA GRAND JUROR: Do you know how she solicited \n19 \nthat original minor? \n20 \nTHE WITNESS: I don't. well, I know that \n21 \nminor was approached by two individuals and we have \n22 \ninterviewed one of those individuals who we can \n23 \nconnect back to Mr. Epstein four years, possibly, \n24 \nprior to this, and stated that his job was actually \n25 \nto drive some of the girls to the residence and \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226451\n", "char_count": 1318}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "21 \n1 \nthat's pretty much where we start off. \n2 \n: would the Grand Jury like \n3 \nSpecial Agent Kuyrkendall to maintain the records \n4 \nthat we received in response to the subpoenas? \n5 \nA GRAND JUROR: maintain versus what? \n6 \nA GRAND JUROR: What is our choice? \n7 \na \nI don't know that there is. \n8 \nguess I could maintain them, but I don't believe we \n9 \nhave secure storage in here. \n10 \nwould you like \n11 \nmaintain custody? \n12 \nA GRAND JUROR: Yes. \n13 \nYou should have something to \n14 \nswear her in as a custodian. \n15 \n(The witness was sworn in as the custodian of \n16 \nrecords.) \n17 \nThank you, ladies and \n18 \ngentlemen, I am the last person for today, so you \n19 \nguys are free to go and we will see you probably in \n20 \na couple of weeks, we will be seeing a lot of you. \n21 \n(The witness was excused from the Grand Jury \n22 \nroom.) \n23 \n(The testimony of the witness concluded \n24 \nbefore the Grand Jury.) \n25 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226452\n", "char_count": 981}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "22 \n1 \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \n2 \n3 \n4 \nI certify pages 2 through 21 are a true \n5 \ntranscript of my shorthand notes of the testimony of \n6 \nE. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall before the Federal Grand Jury, \n7 \nwest Palm Beach, Florida on the 6th day of February, \n8 \n2007. \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226453\n", "char_count": 387}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Page 1 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nIN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \nFederal Grand Jury, 07-103 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \nFebruary 27, 2007 \nAPPEARANCES: \nESQUIRE \nAssistant United States Attorney \nForeperson \nTESTIMONY \nOF \nCRIGI\\AL \nExhibit 18 \nEFTA00226454\n", "char_count": 288}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Page 2 \n1 \nThe sworn testimony of \n2 \nwas taken before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm \n3 \nBeach Division, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, \n4 \nState of Florida, on the 27th day of February, 2007. \nCourt Reporter, was authorized to \n6 \nand did report the sworn testimony. \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n1 \nEFTA00226455\n", "char_count": 367}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Page 3 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n(The witness entered the grand jury room.) \nhaving been duly sworn by the grand jury foreperson, \nwas examined and testified on her oath as follows: \nEXAMINATION \nQ \nGood morning, special agent \nyou restate and spell your name for the record. \nA \nIt's \nCould \nQ \nCan you remind the grand jury who you are \nemployed by? \nA \nThe FBI. \nQ \nI know that you testified here a few weeks ago. \nwas there anything from that testimony that you wanted to \ncorrect? \nA \nI did. I was asked by one of you Mr. Epstein's \nage, and I confused him with another individual in another \none of my cases. His birthdate is January 20, 1953. We \nare looking at the time period of 2004 and 2005. So \nMr. Epstein would have been about 51 or 52-years-old, and \nI believe I told you he was 45. So at the time we're \nlooking during this investigation, he is 51 or 52. \nQ \nhow did this case first come \nto the attention of the police? \nEFTA00226456\n", "char_count": 1014}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Page 4 \n1 \nA \nIn March of 2005„ \nour youngest \n2 \nidentified victim -- her stepmother called the Palm Beach \n3 \npolice department and reported that she believed that her \n4 \nstepdaughter had been molested by a male that resided in \n5 \nthe town of Palm Beach. \n6 \nQ \nSo today we are going to talk about ■ \nG? \nA \nYes. \n8 \nQ \nAnd we are using her initial to protect her \n9 \nidentity, correct? \nio \nA \nYes. \n11 \nQ \nCan you tell the grand jurdilIIIIIII \ndate of \n12 \nbirth? \n13 \nA \n14 \nQ \nAnd you mentioned that the call came in from \n15 \nstepmother in March of 2005, correct? \n16 \nA \nYes. \n17 \nQ \nSo how old was \nat that time? \n18 \nA \nShe was 14. \n19 \nQ \nWhere does \nlive? \n20 \nA \nlives in the Loxahatchee-Royal Palm Beach \n21 \narea here in Palm Beach County. \n22 \nQ \nAt the time, in 2005, what school was she \n23 \nattending? \n24 \nA \nRoyal Palm Beach High School. \n25 \nQ \nWhat year was she in school? \nEFTA00226457\n", "char_count": 912}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Page 5 \nA \nShe was a ninth-grader there. \n2 \nQ \nYou mentioned that her stepmother called the \n3 \nPalm Beach police department. What did the police \n4 \ndepartment do in response to that call? \n5 \nA \nThey wanted to interview \nI believe it was \n6 \nthe next day they went out to where \nwas attending \n7 \nschool at that time, which I think was High Ridge. They \n8 \ninterviewed ■ \nat High Ridge and wanted to get her side \n9 \nof what took place. \n10 \nQ \nBecause we'll be referring to this throughout, \n11 \nwhat was the name of the detective who conducted that \n12 \nfirst interview? \n13 \nA \nDetective \n14 \nQ \nSo in March of 2005, detective \ntalked with \n15 \never interviewed at any other times? \n16 \nA \nYes. She was interviewed -- they talked to her \n17 \nagain. She placed some controlled calls for them later \n18 \nthat month, we will talk about that later. As well as \n19 \nshe was interviewed about a year later in July of 2006. \n20 \nNot interviewed, but she testified before the grand jury \n21 \nfor the State of Florida. So she was interviewed by \n22 \ndetective Pagan in March of 2005, and then about a year or \n23 \nthree or four months later, in July of 2006, she testified \n?4 \nbefore a grand jury with the State of Florida. \n25 \nQ \nIn preparation for your appearance today, did \nSINIP•••• \nEFTA00226458\n", "char_count": 1301}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Page 6 \nyou have a chance to interview \n2 \nA \nYes, \nI did. \n3 \nQ \nAnd when was that? \n4 \nA \nLast night. \n5 \nQ \nBack in March of 2005, you mentioned that \n6 \ndetective Pagan met with \non or more than one \n7 \noccasion? \nA \nYes. \n9 \nQ \nIf you could give us sort of an overview of what \nreported during these interviews, and then if there \n11 \nare specific discrepancies or differences, we will return \n12 \nto those later. \n13 \nA \nAll right. On February 5, 2005, it was a \n14 \nSaturday, and \nwas at 'use, \nIIIIIIII \nShe \n16 \nwas there with her boyfriend, \nAnd because these \n16 \nare minors, we'll refer to them without using their last \n17 \nnames, so I'll use those initials. \n18 \nThey were ateresidence, and \nis \n19 \nboyfriend, which is also \ncousin. So they \n20 \nwere all at \nhouse, and \nwas on the phone with \n21 \nan individual that ■ \nrefers to as the assistant. \n22 \ndescribed the assistant as a tall blonde. \n23 \nSo throughout I'll refer to her as the blonde lady, if \n24 \nthat's okay. \nwas unable to recall her name. So \n25 \nis on the phone with the assistant for Jeffrey \n•••••••••11,6 \nEFTA00226459\n", "char_count": 1104}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Page 7 \n1 \nEpstein. \n2 \nIIIMEIverheareon \nthe phone \n3 \ndescribing \ndescribing \nto the lady on \n4 \nthe phone. So when \ngets off the phone, \nand \n5 IIIIIItoth want to know why i \nwas being described to \n6 \nthis lady on the phone. \nbecomes upset when \n7 \nasks\". if she would like to go to Palm Beach and give a \n8 \nman a massage that she knows. \nagrees, and this \n9 \nupsets \nand an argument ensues where \n10 \ngo into the bathroom and they argue outside the presence \n11 \nof \n12 \nQ \nLet me stop you there. Was supposed to be \n13 \npaid for giving this massage? \n14 \nA \nYes. \ntold \nthat she would be paid \n15 \n$200 or $300, I believe. \n16 \n17 \nis also \ncousin, correct? \n18 \nA \nYes. \n19 \nQ \nWhat was \n20 \narguing? \n21 \nA \nShe has told us that she believed that \nust \n22 \nhave known what \nwas doing for this man and the work \n23 \nthat did \nfor Mr. Epstein, and that is why vas \n24 \nSO upset. \n25 \nYou mentioned that \nboyfriend, and \nidea about why they were \nSo le \nnew that this wasn't just a regular \net. \n...rmi.....••••••••••••••••••il.w.,  •••••111•1•0•1••••InT•l•••••••.•••••• \nEFTA00226460\n", "char_count": 1091}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Page 8 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nmassage that was going to take place? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nSo \nilllidecide to do? \nA \ndecides to go. \nhave this argument. What does \nQ \nBecause she wanted to make the $200 or $300? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nSo tell us then what happened after that \nmeeting? \nA \nThe next day, February 6 -- they discussed that \nevening about going the next day. We do have on \nphone records two calls that were placed. One was placed \nto \ncell phone, and the other was placed to \nJef rey Epstein's residence the night of February 5. \nThe next dayais \ncontacted a couple of times \nbefore Arrives. \nEach time prior to ill\"\n eing \ncontacted by... \na call is placed by \nt\no\nn\n \ncell phone. M M.., I should tell you, is \nJeffrey's assistant. \nSo on Sunday a call was placed to IIIIIIIIII!at \nand then shortly after that a call was made to El \nsame series occurs again, but this time \nplaces a \ncall to Mr. Epstein's residence, and then its \ncalled \nagain. \nEventually, =comes \nt\no\n \nMI \nresidence with \nEFTA00226461\n", "char_count": 1072}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n'7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 9 \nanother girl in the car, \nSo the two of them \nIMIS \narrive atIIIIIII residence, and they continue over to \nMr. Epstein's house. \nQ \nI'll'. \nis driving with \nDo you \nknow how they were sitting? \nA \nYou know, I'm not sure how they were sitting, \nbut I know that it was a pickup truck that \ndrove, \nand \nwas the driver. I'm not sure exactly the \nplacement of the other two girls, but they were in the \ntruck. \nQ \nAnd Sas \nable to describe how they travelled \nto the island of Palm Beach? \nA \nYes. She gave directions -- you know, the best \nthat she could on how she was able to come to \nMr. Epstein's residence. \nQ \nOnce they arrived at the residence, what \nhappened? \nA \nI should have mentioned that either the night \nbefore or the day of, there were some things that IIIIII \ntells \nOne, she tells illlithat she is to tell, if \nasked, that she is 18-years-of-age, that she attends high \nschool, that she's in the 12th grade, and I believe it was \nWellington High School that she was to say that she went \nto. \nTalking to illillast night, ■ \ntold us that \nVa....la.....o...10.0•44••••••...”.• • \n• \nEFTA00226462\n", "char_count": 1206}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Page 10 \n1 \nonce she arrived at the residence hells \nher that she \n2 \nmay possibly be asked to take her clothes off. She also \n3 \ntells her that she can stay in her bra, but she may be \n4 \nasked to take her clothes off. And \ntold us last \n5 \nnight that that's when she knew for the first time that \n6 \nshe might have to possibly remove her clothes. \n7 \nAt this point they proceed to enter the \n8 \nresidence. IIIIIIPescribes him as a security person. He \n9 \napproached and asked what they were doing there, and IIIIII \n10 \nsaid they were there to see Mr. Epstein, or see Jeffrey. \n11 \nHe allowed them entry into the kitchen area by the pool, \n12 \nand i \ndescribes that area. So now \nand \n13 \nIIIIllare all sitting in the kitchen. A short time goes \n14 \nby and Mr. Epstein, as well as the assistant, enter the \n15 \nkitchen. \n16 \nQ \nAnd I know that you mentioned thatillildid not \n17 \nknow the name of the lady who was there in the kitchen, \n18 \ncorrect? \n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \nShe just described her as a blonde, tall lady? \n21 \nA \nYes. \n22 \nQ \nWas \nalso interviewed about what happened \n23 \nthat day? \n24 \nA \nShe was interviewed by the Palm Beach police \n25 \ndepartment. \nEFTA00226463\n", "char_count": 1184}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Page 11 \nDid \nidentify the person who was on the \n2 \nphone with her as \n3 \nA \n4 \n5 \nknew \n6 \nA \nYes. \n7 \nQ \nSo you mentioned that the three girls are in the \n8 \nkitchen, along with Jeffrey and the person \ncalls the \n9 \nblonde lady? \n10 \nA \nYes. \n11 \nQ \nWhat happened then? \n12 \nA \nfollows the blonde lady upstairs to \n13 \nMr. Epstein's bedroom. The blonde lady proceeds to take \n14 \nout a massage table and set it up, prepare it. She also \n15 \ntakes out some lotions to be used during the massage. \n16 \ntold me last night that the blonde lady asked her to \n17 \nremove her clothing, and then left the room and said that \n18 \nMr. Epstein would be in shortly. \n19 \nQ \nWhat happened after she left the room? \n20 \nA \nShortly after that, Mr. Epstein does come into \n21 \nthe room and shakes \nhand. \ntold us last night \n22 \nthat Mr. Epstein told her to remove her clothing. He \n23 \nleaves the room and comes back in just a towel, and he \n24 \ntells her again to -- she is at that point -- when he \n25 \nwalked in the lirst time she had on her bra and her pants. \nYes, she did. \nSo even though \nname? \nal\ndoesn't know her name, \nEFTA00226464\n", "char_count": 1131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Page 12 \n1 \nWhen he comes back in, he tells her that she needs to take \n2 \nher pants ofI . So she took her pants of'. So now she's \n3 \nin her bra and underwear. \n4 \nQ \nAt some point did \ntell any of the people \n5 \nwho interviewed her what was running through her mind? \n6 \nA \nShe stated at one point that she was upstairs \n7 \nwith him, with the man, and thatMill was downstairs. I \n8 \nguess she says, \"What could ilIlli \ndo? She's downstairs, \n9 \nI'm upstairs.\" So she did what she was asked to do. \n10 \nQ \nSo now you mention that Mr. Epstein is here \n11 \nwearing just a towel, and \nhas removed both her shirt \n12 \nand her pants, is that correct? \n13 \nA \nYes. \n14 \nQ \nTell us what happens then? \n15 \nA \nMr. Epstein gets on the massage table lying on \n16 \nhis stomach and instructs \nhow to do the massage. He \n17 \ntells her to put some lotion on her hand and instructs her \n18 \non how to actually perform the massage. At one point \n19 \nduring the massage he tells \nthat she would be more \n20 \ncomfortable to get on top of him, so i \ngets on top of \n21 \nhim and straddles Mr. Epstein's back. \n22 \nThe way \ndescribes it is Mr. Epstein is \n23 \nlaying on the table, he has a towel covering his bottom, \n24 \nand she is straddling him with her bottom touching the \n25 \ntowel and some skin touching his lower back. She was kind \n...••••• •••••••\nwwl...•••••.•-m•••••\n•••••••••••A•i•••••••••••\n•...millialtIONSILWS,••C• _I \n1 \nEFTA00226465\n", "char_count": 1431}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "• \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 13 \nof sitting -- it sounds like sitting on his rear end, but \nwith part of her skin touching him -- the front of him, \nbut he had a towel across his bottom. \nQ \nWhat happens as she is providing the massage to \nhis back? \nA \nThe massage goes on. She said the entire \nmassage lasted anywhere from 30 to 45 minutes. At one \npoint Mr. Epstein excuses himself for a few minutes, one \nor two minutes briefly, illlistates that she can hear \nMr. Epstein moaning or groaning, and states that she \nbelieves he was, in her words, \"wacking off\" or \nmasturbating. She didn't say masturbating, she said \n\"wacking off.\" I am going to use that she believes he was \nmasturbating. \nThen he returns. At this point he gets back on \nthe table lying on his back and asks her to start \nmassaging his chest. So she begins to massage his chest. \nQ \nDoes he keep the towel on? \nA \nNo, at this point the towel is removed. When he \ncomes back and he gets back on the table, the towel is \nremoved and she is massaging his chest. \nQ \nWhat does he do as she is massaging his chest? \nA \nHe moves his hand up and down his penis. So he \ncontinued to masturbate on the table. He asked \nat \nsome point during this time, if she would like to make an \nI \nEFTA00226466\n", "char_count": 1330}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Page 14 \n1 \nextra $100. He tells her that it would not involve doing \n2 \nIIIIII \n3 \nvibrator on her, and she does agree. \ndescribes it as \n4 \nS \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \ndigitally penetrated her? \nii \nA \nThe vibrator is used. At some point he does \n12 \ndigitally penetrate her. And these are her words. She \n13 \n14 \nis her word -- he sarcastically says, \"What's the matter?\" \n15 \nAnd she at that point just kind of looks away, and he \n16 \ncontinues on with the digital penetration. In the last \n17 \nthree to lour minutes of that, he begins to masturbate \n18 \nagain. \n19 \nAt the conclusion of the sexual activity, \n20 \nMr. Epstein wipes his penis ofI with a towel. i \nwas \n21 \nasked if he ejaculated. She did not see him ejaculate, \n22 \nbut saw him wipe his penis off with a towel. \n23 \nQ \nwas \nable to provide a physical description \na massage. \nagrees. He asked her if he could use a \na purple vibrator that was used on her vagina, and she \nsaid this goes on for about ten minutes. \nAt some point during that massage the vibrator \nis not used anymore and digital penetration takes place. \ndillidescribes him as fingering her. \nQ \nWhat did she say happened when Mr. Epstein \nlooks at him kind of funny, and he sarcastically -- which \n24 \nof Mr. Epstein? \n25 \nA \nYes. \nEFTA00226467\n", "char_count": 1272}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Page 15 \n1 \nQ \nIncluding of his penis? \n2 \nA \nYes. \n3 \nQ \nWas she also able to provide a description of \n4 \nher surroundings in that massage area? \nA \nYes. \n6 \nQ \nWas that description accurate? \n7 \nA \nYes. According to other testimony we have \n8 \ngotten from other victims, yes. \n9 \nQ \nAnd a search was performed on Mr. Epstein's \nio \nhouse? \n11 \nA \nYes. The Palm Beach police department did \n12 \nperform a search, and several of the items that were \n13 \ndescribed were found in the house. \n14 \nQ \nAfter Mr. Epstein wiped himself off, what \n15 \nhappened? \n16 \nA \nHe told \nthat she was getting the extra \n17 \nhundred dollars because he was allowed to use the vibrator \n18 \non her and had fingered her. The massage had been \n19 \nconcluded, the sexual activity had been concluded. He \n20 \ngets up and leaves for a brief moment of time and comes \n21 \nback with $300 and pays \nthe $300. I believe he told \n22 \nthat she could see herself out. \n23 \nQ \nBefore we leave that room, when i \nwas either \n24 \nbeing directed to the room or was inside that room where \n25 \nthe massage took place, was there anything in particular \nEFTA00226468\n", "char_count": 1129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Page 16 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n8 \n6 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nthat she noted seeing? \nA \nShe noted seeing several naked pictures of girls \nin the room, a mural or pictures of naked girls either \nexposing their breasts or completely naked. \nQ \nWhile the massage was going on, did Mr. Epstein \ntalk tole \nA \nYes, he did. \nQ \nAnd did he talk about sexual conquests with \ngirls? \nA \nYes, he did. \nQ \nOnce Mr. Epstein has provided ■ \nwith the \n$300, what did she do? \nA \nShe went back downstairs and she, \nand \neave the residence. In the car they\nk \na \n as \nhow \nmuch money she has made, and she tells them $300. IIIII \nwants to see the money. She shows the money to\n and \nillill\nasks what did she do. At that point itells \nher \nthat he fingered her, as well as used a vibrator. \nQ \nWhen they left the house, where did they go? \nA \nWhen they left the house, they were on their way \nto a mall to go shopping with the money that they had \nreceived from Mr. Epstein. i \nhad told \nthe night \nbefore that she needed some shoes and wanted to go to the \nmall, and she was going to Mr. Epstein's to pick up some \nmoney. That was another reason that she had for going to \nEFTA00226469\n", "char_count": 1203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Page 17 \n1 \nMr. Epstein's house that day, and that they were going to \n2 \ngo shopping after she got her money, and that \ncould \n3 \nmake some money. \n4 \nQ \nDuring that ride, did 'ill realize that \n5 \nreceived money from Mr. Epstein? \n6 \nA \nYes. At some point\n knows that a \n7 \nreceived S200, but is unsure that \nver gave a \na \n8 \nmassage. So at that particular times \ndid not know why \n9 \nshe had gotten the $200, because she didn't think that \n10 \nillillhad had time to give a massage. \n11 \nQ \nIn \ninterview, did she explain what she \n12 \ngot the $200 for? \n13 \nA \ntold the Palm Beach police department in \n14 \nher interview that she received her $200 for bringing \n15 \nto the house. \n16 \nQ \nYou mentioned that there were these three \n17 \ndifferent time periods that \nwas interviewed: Shortly \n18 \nafter the events, at the time of the state grand jury \n19 \nproceedings, and when you met with her, correct? \n20 \nA \nYes. \n21 \nQ \nAnd there were some discrepancies between the \n22 \ndifferent interviews. Can you explain some of those to \n23 \nthe grand jury. \n24 \nA \nBefore we go and get to that, I want to make \n25 \nsure that -- when we discussed what \nwas told in the \n1.0•.•••••••••••.1••••.b \nEFTA00226470\n", "char_count": 1205}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ncar by al \nthat we learned from \nPage 18 \ninterview with \nthe Palm Beach police department. \ndon't know if I \nsaid that, but I want to make sure you know that we first \nlearned that \nhad been fingered by listening to the \ninterview that was conducted between the Palm Beach police \ndepartment and \nnot from \nWhen I talk later, I \njust want to make sure you realize that that had not \ninitially come out in \ninterview, but through the \ninterview with\nSo going back. I'm sorry, discrepancies? \nQ \nYes. \nA \nI met with \nlast night to discuss some of \nthe discrepancies when looking at what she had talked to \ndetective \nabout in March of 2005 and what she had \ntestified to in the grand jury in July of 2006. Reading \nthe testimony and listening to the tapes, or reading the• \ntranscript, there were a lew discrepancies. \nOne of the first ones we talked about was what \nhad told her about going to Mr. Epstein's house. \nShe tells detective \nthat she was told about the \nmassage, told about getting $200, but that she was not \ntold that she would have to take her clothes ofl. She \ndidn't know she would have to perform the massage naked. \nWhen I asked her last night that question, she \ntold me that when she got to the house prior to going into \nEFTA00226471\n", "char_count": 1347}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 19 \nMr. Epstein's residence, that \ndid tell her that she \nmay be asked to take ofl her clothes. She also did state \nthat \ntold her she could stay in her bra. \nSo I wanted you to know that there was a \ndiscrepancy in what she originally had told detective \nPagan and what she told me last night. That would be one. \nThe second discrepancy I wanted to touch on with \nher was going upstairs and taking off her clothing. When \nshe is in that room, she states to detective Pagan that \nasked her to remove her clothing, and she took off \nher shirt. Then Mr. Epstein came in the room, shook her \nhand and told her to take off her clothes. He leaves, he \nall\ncomes back in a towel. He tells her again. \ntells \ndetective \nin a stern voice, \"Mr. Epstein told me to \ntake off my pants.\" Because she hadn't taken off her \npants from the first time that she met him. \nIn her testimony with the grand jury with the \nstate, she tells the grand jury that it was \nwho \nasked her to remove her clothing. So last night we went \nover with her who told her to remove what. She had a very \nhard time recalling exactly. She knew she had gotten down \nto her bra and underwear. And then at some point, when \nwe're going through the sexual activity, she actually \ntells me that her underwear was off when he was using the \nvibrator and digitally penetrating her. \nEFTA00226472\n", "char_count": 1447}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \nB \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 20 \nLater in the interview, we tell her about what \nwe have in her testimony to the grand jury and her \nstatements made to detective Pagan. And she really is \nhaving a difficult time trying to remember who told her to \ntake ofl her clothes and her pants. As we are walking \nthrough the sexual activity, she does recall and states \nthat it was Mr. Epstein who told her to take ofl her \npants. \nI guess I'll go to the third discrepancy. Is \nthere anything I left off with that? \nQ \nWell, does she report that when the assistant \nleads \nor the blonde lady leads her upstairs, that the \nblonde lady also said, \"Get undressed,\" but that ■ \ndidn't get fully undressed? \nA \nThat's what she said in her statement to the \ndetective, when she gives her first statement. She tells \nus again last night that that's what she recalled. \nQ \nThat the lady said first, •Get undressed,\" but \nshe doesn't get fully undressed. And when Jeffrey comes \nback, he said, \"Take your pants off.•? \nA \nYes. And again, like I said, when we started \ninterviewing her and asking her about this, she did have a \nhard time. But when we were walking through the sexual \nactivity, that's when she recalls who told her to take off \nher pants. \n; \nEFTA00226473\n", "char_count": 1320}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Page 21\n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \noriginally interviewed by detective Pagan about the \n12 \nvibrator or being digitally penetrated. When detective \n13 \n14 \n15 \nShe also says that to the grand jury, she talks about the \n16 \npurple vibrator being used on her. \n17 \n18 \nbeing used on her. When we asked her about him digitally \n19 \npenetrating her, and that \nhad told the police \n20 \ndepartment that she had been fingered, \ntold us last \n21 \nnight that she was fingered by Mr. Epstein, but that she \n22 \n23 \ndid not want her father to know that he had fingered her. \n24 \n25 \nAnd \ntell you, when we talked about the \nsexual activity, and it comes out that she wasn't wearing \nher underwear when he was digitally penetrating her and \nusing the vibrator, she does not recall how they came off. \nShe cannot remember removing her underwear. She doesn't \nremember if Mr. Epstein removed her underwear. She knows \nher underwear was off, but she cannot tell you exactly at \nwhat point her underwear was removed. \nQ \nLet's talk about the third discrepancy. \nA \nThe third is the sexual activity, when she was \nPagan comes and sees her again a few weeks later, she does \ntell her at that time that a vibrator was used on her. \nLast night she told us about the purple vibrator \nthought only her and \nknew about this and that she \nShe didn't want anybody to know, but she especially didn't \nwant her father to know, that that was her business. That\nEFTA00226474\n", "char_count": 1454}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Page 22 \n1 \nshe did not know that \nhad told anybody, she thought \n2 \nit was only her and \nthat knew. She was embarrassed \n3 \nand didn't want anybody to know that. \n4 \nQ \nDid she become visually upset? \n5 \nA \nYes, she began crying when we asked her about \n6 \nbeing digitally penetrated. When she realized that we \n7 \nknew about that, she became very upset and concerned about \n8 \nher father. She mentioned that her father has read a lot \n9 \nof the reports in the State of Florida, and has followed \nto \nthe state's case. She was concerned about even telling \n11 \nus, afraid that he would be able to read in our reports \n12 \nabout this. \n13 \nWe explained to her that the FBI's reporting is \n14 \na little bit different than the way the state -- those are \n15 \npublic records, and ours is part of our case file. \n16 \nQ \nIn addition to the fact that she had these \n17 \nconcerns about her father and she was embarrassed, in your \n18 \nexperience of interviewing victims of sexual abuse, is it \n19 \ntypical for them to not disclose all of the sexual \n20 \nactivity? \n21 \nA \nYes, it's very typical. And young girls, they \n22 \ndon't want to talk about it. This is just another case of \n23 \nher not wanting to tell exactly what took place. \n24 \nQ \nAfter that first visit to Mr. Epstein's house, \n25 \nand the interviews with detective \ndid detective \nEFTA00226475\n", "char_count": 1351}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Page 23 \nI \nask \nto make what are called controlled calls? \n2 \nA \nYes. \n3 \n4 \ncontrolled call is? \n5 \n6 \nlistening device, where we have an individual place a call \n7 \nto somebody and we are able to record the other person's \nB \nvoice and the conversation that takes place between the \n9 \nperson that we're having make the call and the person that \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \nend of March, I believe it was March 30. \ncalled \n18 \nat the Olive Garden where \nworks. \n was \nIIIIIII \n19 \nconcerned that \nfather had found out somehow and \n20 \nthat they knew about it. And she refers to him as \n21 \nJeffrey, but Mr. Epstein. \n22 \ntold her that they did not know about \n23 \nMr. Epstein. Later in the conversation \n■\ntells her \n24 \nthat Mr. Epstein would like her to come back and work for \n25 \nQ \nCan you explain to the grand jury what a \nA \nA controlled call is where we actually have a \nthey are calling. \nQ \nWho did detective Il' ask illlito call? \nA \newes \nasked to callallon the phone. \nQ \nAnd did she do so? \nA \nYes, she did. \nQ \nCan you tell the grand jury when the calls were? \nA \nI believe the first call was made towards the \nhim, and that maybe she could work for him tomorrow. So \nEFTA00226476\n", "char_count": 1204}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Page 24 \n1 \nthey agreed that there would be a call between \nand \n2 \ntomorrow, that \nwill call\nal \na \ntomorrow. \n3 \nQ \nWere there calls also made on March 31 of 2006? \n4 \nA \nThere were two calls made on March 31. The \ns \nfirst one she doesn't connect to \nThe second call \n6 \nthat was made a short time later, Haley answers the phone. \n7 \nAgain, there is a discussion about ■ \ncoming to work for \n0 \nMr. Epstein. \ntells IIIIII- one of the comments that \n9 \nis made is, \"The more you do, the more you make.\" ■ \nis \n10 \nasking her how much can I make. \n11 \nAgain, detective Pagan is there, and \nis \n12 \nasking \nhow much can I make. \nis telling \n13 \nthat she'll have to ask Mr. Epstein that, that she is \n14 \ngoing to see Mr. Epstein tomorrow and that she'll talk to \n15 \nMr. Epstein. There is conversation about ■ \nand her \n16 \ntwin sister possibly coming to Mr. Epstein's house. There \n17 \nis some discussion about her coming to work for \n18 \nMr. Epstein. \n19 \nQ \nJust so it's clear, because there were a lot of \n20 \nshes, Illillis telling i \nthat \ns going to see \n21 \nEpstein the following day? \n22 \nA \nYes. \n23 \nQ \nAnd that \nis going to set up a schedule \n24 \nwith Mr. Epstein for ■ \nand her sister to work for him? \n25 \nA \nYes. \n• \nEFTA00226477\n", "char_count": 1245}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Page 25 \n1 \nQ \nOn April 1, the following day, did \nmake\n2 \ncalls tO\n3 \nA \nFrom the Palm Beach police department, they were \n4 \nable to take voice mail messages left by i \non \n5 \nphone stating that \ncould come and work on Saturday \n6 \naround 11:00. \n7 \nQ \nI think you mentioned this last time, but in \n8 \ncase you didn't, did the Palm Beach police department do \n9 \ntrash pulls at Mr. Epstein's house? \n10 \nA \nYes, they did. \n11 \nQ \nWas there anything of value related to this \n12 \nseries of calls that were recovered? \n13 \nA \nYes. There was a trash pull done in the \n14 \nbeginning of April, and in the trash there was a piece of \n15 \npaper that on it had \ns name, \nname, and I \n16 \nbelieve it was 10:30 listed on the piece of paper. \n17 \nQ \nIt said \nwith Mon \nSaturday at 10:30? \n18 \nA \nYes, it did. \n19 \nQ \nIn addition to the actual recordings of those \n20 \nphone calls and voice mail messages, do you also have \n21 \ntelephone records from both \ncell phone and \n22 \ncell phone that match up? \n23 \nA \nYes. \n24 \nQ \nJust to go back to something that you mentioned. \n25 \nWho actually gave the $300 cash to \nat the day she was \niI••••••••••• \nEFTA00226478\n", "char_count": 1152}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Page 26 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n6 \n7 \nat Mr. Epstein's house? \nA \nMr. Epstein. \n• \nYou mentioned a girl named \nA \nYes. \nWas \nalso interviewed? \nA \nYes, she was. \nQ \nWas she asked about going with \nto take \n8 \ngirls to Mr. Epstein's house? \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWas she asked who the youngest-looking girl was? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWhat did she say? \nA \nShe discussed \nlooking young in her \n14 \ninterview with the Palm Beach police department. \n15 \nThose are all of my questions \n16 \nfor you now. If you could please step outside, I'll \n17 \nsee if the grand jurors have any. \n18 \n(Witness excused, and then returned.) \n19 \nBY \n20 \nQ \nAgent \nwe have just a few questions. \n21 \nOne relates to the conversation between Mr. Epstein and \n22 \n■ \nabout his exploits with other girls. Did Mr. Epstein \n23 \nsay anything about the age of those girls? \n24 \nA \nHe said that -- in particular on one case he \n25 \ntalked about a young girl that he was in the back seat \nEFTA00226479\n", "char_count": 955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Page 27 \nwith, and her parents were in the front seat. He told \n2 \nthat they were having sex in the back seat -- were \n3 \ndoing sexual things in the back seat while he was carrying \n4 \non a conversation with the parents in the Iront seat. I \n5 \nguess they were on their way home from a business party. \n6 \nThis was one of the stories that he had talked about. \n7 \nQ \nBut at no time did he provide any specific ages \n8 \nabout any of those girls? \n9 \nA \nNo. \nlo \nQ \nWhat was \nage at the time she took ■ \n11 \nto Mr. Epstein's house? \n12 \nA \nShe was 18. \n13 \nQ \nDid Mr. Epstein ask Sage anything about her age? \n14 \nA \nHe did. He asked her how old she was, she said \n15 \nshe was 18. He asked her what grade she was in, she said \n16 \nshe was in the 12th grade. He asked her where she went to \n17 \nschool, and she said she went to Wellington. \n18 \nQ \nI know we will be doing a lot more discussion \n19 \nabout ilillillater. But could you tell us briefly how \n20 \nIIIIIILwas recruited to go to Mr. Epstein's house? \n21 \nA \nwas at the beach, and two individuals \n22 \napproached her about making money and giving a massage to \n23 \nMr. Epstein. \n24 \nQ \nHow old was \nwhen she first went to \n25 \nMr. Epstein's house? \n1 \n1 \nEFTA00226480\n", "char_count": 1223}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Page 28 \nA \nThrough phone records, we have contact between \n2 \nThank you. \n4 \n6 \n7 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nB \nstarting at age 17. \nThose are all the questions. \n(Witness excused, and then returned.) \nQ \nThe question was, was there any particular \nevidence to suggest that Mr. Epstein knew that \nwas \nunder the age of 18? \nA \nI would say through the interviews of the \nmultiple girls that went to Mr. Epstein's house -- the way \nthat having seen \nlast night, and now she's 16 -- this \nwas two years ago -- that 1111111age and behavior -- and \nagain, is that more circumstantial evidence? As far as \nconcrete evidence, no. But just by her appearance and her \nmannerisms and how I observed her last night at age 16. \nQ \nAnd that's consistent with what \nduring her statement, correct? \nsaid \nA \nYes, it is. \nMS. a \nAny other questions? \nJUROR: \nDid she look 18? \nTHE WITNESS: Does illillook 18? Not in my \nopinion, sir. \nMS. \nAll right. Any other questions? \nOkay, thank you, very much. \nEFTA00226481\n", "char_count": 1041}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Page 29 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n(Witness excused.) \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \nI CERTIFY pages 1 to 28 is a true transcript of \nmy shorthand notes of the testimony of \nbefore the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm \nBeach, Florida, on the 27th day of February, 2007. \nDated at West Palm Beach, Florida this 18th day \nof March, 2007. \nI /77 \nAl_ 65 \nPhilip W. May, Court Reporter \nEFTA00226482\n", "char_count": 453}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL. 3340/ \n(561) 820.8711 \nFacsimile: (561) 820-8777 \nMarch 15, 2007 \nDELIVE Y Y HAND \nMiss \nRe: \nCrime Victims' and Witnesses' Rights \nDear Miss \nPursuant to the Justice for All Act of 2004, as a victim and/or witness of a federal offense, \nyou have a number of rights. Those rights are: \n(I) \nThe right to be reasonably protected from the accused. \n(2) \nThe right to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of any public court proceeding \ninvolving the crime or of any release or escape of the accused. \n(3) \nThe right not to be excluded from any public court proceeding, unless the court \ndetermines that your testimony may be materially altered if you are present for other \nportions of a proceeding. \n(4) \nThe right to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court \ninvolving release, plea, or sentencing. \n(5) \nThe reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the United States in the case. \n(6) \nThe right to full and timely restitution as provided in law. \n(7) \nThe right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay. \n(8) \nThe right to be treated with fairness and with respect for the victim's dignity and \nprivacy. \nMembers of the U.S. Department of Justice and other federal investigative agencies, \nincluding the Federal Bureau of Investigation, must use their best efforts to make sure that these \nrights are protected. If you have an concerns in this regard, please feel free to contact me at 561 \n209-1047, or Special Agent \nfrom the Federal Bureau of Investigation at 561 \n822-5946. You also can contact t e Justice Department's Office for Victims of Crime in \nWashington, D.C. at 202-307-5983. That Office has a website at www.ovc.gov. \nYou can seek the advice of an attorney with respect to the rights listed above and, if you \nbelieve that the rights set forth above are being violated, you have the right to petition t\n... [truncated, 2048 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/87 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=87]", "char_count": 2048}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "1 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nRE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \nTESTIMONY \nOF \nSPECIAL AGENT \nCOPY \nFederal Grand Jury 07-103 \nFederal Building \nU.S. Courthouse \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \nTuesday, March 20, 2007 \nAPPEARANCES: \nAssistant United States Attorney \nForeperson \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nExhibit 20 \nEFTA00226484\n", "char_count": 463}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "2 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nThe sworn testimony of SPECIAL AGENT \nwas taken before the Federal \nGrand Jury, West Palm Beach Division, \nBuilding, U.S. Courthouse, Palm Beach County, \nState of Florida, on Tuesday, March 20, 2007. \nPaula E. Angelocci, Certified Court \nReporter and Notary Public, State of Florida, \nOfficial Reporting Service, LLC, 524 South Andrews \nAvenue, Suite 302N, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, \n33301 , was authorized to and did report the sworn \ntestimony. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226485\n", "char_count": 605}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "3 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room.) \nTHE FOREPERSON: \nYou do solemnly swear \nthat the testimony you give will be the \ntruth, the whole truth, and nothing but the \ntruth, so help you God? \nTHE WITNESS: \nI do. \nTHE FOREPERSON: Thank you. Please be \nseated. \nEXAMINATION \nQ \nSpecial Agent \ncould you \nplease state and spell your name for the record? \nIt's\nA \n \nIt's \nQ \nNow Special Agent \nlast week \nor the last time that we met, we discussed two \ngirls, correct? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWho visited Mr. Epstein's home? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd those were \nand \nA \nYes. \nQ \nDid you obtain photographs of those \ngirls? \nA \nYes, I did. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226486\n", "char_count": 772}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "4 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAnd do you know approximately when those \nphotographs were taken? \nA \nThey were taken during the same time \nperiod that we are investigating, '04 and '05. \nThere may have been a few in '03, but it was \nwithin a year's time of six months within the \nactivity that we are investigating. \nQ \nAll right. Let me show you what has \nbeen marked as Grand Jury Exhibits 1 and 2, and \ncan you tell us what Exhibit 1 is? \nA \nExhibit 1 is illiblland \nit's a \nphotograph of her with her date of birth listed. \nQ \nAnd what is Exhibit 2? \nA \nA photograph of \nwith her date \nof birth as well on it. \nMS. \nAnd I will just pass \nthose to the grand jury. \nBY \nQ \nNow the last time that we were here, you \nhad described how \nhad \nIIIIIIII \nbrought IIIIIIIII \nto Mr. Epstein's home? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nDid IIIIIIIIIbring other girls to the \nEpstein house? \nA \nYes, she did. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226487\n", "char_count": 1008}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "5 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAnd is one of those girls \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd what is the date of birth of \nA \nShe was born \nQ \nAnd where did \ngo to high \nschool? \nA \nRoyal Palm Beach High School. \nQ \nAnd is that the same school that \n4IIIIIIIIwent to? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd was \nver a student at that \nschool? \nA \nYes, she was. \nQ \nTell us a little bit about -- well, \nfirst of all, did the Palm Beach Police Department \nhave a chance to interview \nA \nYes, they did. \nQ \nAnd what about yourself? \nA \nAnd I did as well. \nQ \nOkay. Tell us, if you will, how \nstarted going to Mr. Epstein's house? \nA \nwas the one who brought \nto \nMr. Epstein's house. \ntold \nthat she \nmay have to remove her clothing and that she could \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226488\n", "char_count": 838}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "6 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nmakes $200 if she performed a massage for Mr. \nEpstein. \nIIIIII \nShe also was told by \nthat he may \ntry to touch you, but if you are uncomfortable, \njust tell him no, and she also said that if \nEpstein asked her age, she was to say she was 18. \nQ \nNow that information that you just \nrelayed, who provided that information? \nA \nIIIIIM\nIIM\nQ \nAnd what did \n--\nA \nI'm sorry. \nprovided in the \ninterview to me that information. \nQ \nDid \nalso admit that she brought \nto Mr. Epstein's home? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWhen did this first occur? \nA \nThis occurred in -- we believe the first \ntime period was when \nwas 16. \nQ \nAnd is there any telephone records that \nshow communications between \nand \nand \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd when are those phone records? \nA \nThose phone records show up in March of \n'04 when \nwould be 16. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226489\n", "char_count": 957}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "7 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nLet me show what has been marked as \nGrand Jury Exhibit Number 3, and what is Exhibit \n3? \nA \nThis is a photograph of \nwith \nher date of birth, \nQ \nNow you mentioned that in March of 2004 \nand April of 2004, there are these records of \nphone calls and did \nsay how old she was \nwhen she first went to Mr. Epstein's house? \nA \nI'm sorry. Did \nsay how old she \nwas? \nQ \nDid she tell you or the police officers \nhow old she was? \nA \nYes. \nI'm sorry. \nI thought your \nquestion was did she tell Mr. Epstein. \nShe told me that she was 16 when she \nwent to Mr. Epstein's house. \nQ \nOkay. That is consistent with those \nphones calls? \nA \nYes, it is. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow during her first visit with \nMr. Epstein, what happened? \nA \nShe went to Mr. Epstein's house. \ntook her there. \ntold her she didn't have \nher driver's license at that time, which she told \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226490\n", "char_count": 1005}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "8 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nher she got her driver's license when she was 17. \nSo \ndrove her to Mr. Epstein's \nhouse. She provided Mr. Epstein with a Iew \nmassages. She remained clothed both times that \nshe gave him a massage. \nAt this time, she kept \nher clothes on. \nI think one time she was wearing shorts \nand a T-shirt, maybe the second time she was \nwearing jeans and a T-shirt. That he constantly \ngrabbed and pulled at her during the massage \ntrying to draw her closer to him, but at that \ntime, you know, there was no sexual activity other \nthan the grabbing and pulling. \nThere was no sexual activity that took \nplace on those Iirst couple of massages, and she \nremained clothed at that time. \nQ \nNow after those first few massages, was \nthere a break in time before \nreturns to \nthe Epstein house? \nA \ntold us that she and \nhad \nhad some kind of a fight or a disagreement, a \nbreakup in their relationship, so there was a time \nperiod where she did not go back to Mr. Epstein's \nhouse. \nQ \nAnd when -- did there then come a time \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226491\n", "char_count": 1170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "9 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nwhen she returned to the Epstein house? \nA \nYes. \nWe have phone activity between \nKellen and \nZ. beginning in December \nof '04. \nQ \nAnd how old was \nin December \nof '04? \nA \nShe had turned 17 at that time. \nIn \nfact, through the course of the phone records \nbeginning in December of \nIIIIIIIIIII \nwe have over 150 phone calls between \n04 to October of 2005, \nand \nMr. Epstein's assistant. \nQ \nWhat did \ntell you about the \nactivity that occurred when she started returning \nin late '04? \nA \nWhen she started giving Mr. Epstein \nmassages after that break, the massages became \nmuch more sexual in nature. Mr. Epstein continued \nto push and there were many times when \nwould perform massages completely nude. \nSeveral times, she would stay in her \nunderwear with no bra on, but stated to me that \nmany occasions she performed the massages to Mr. \nEpstein in the nude. \nIn addition to being unclothed, was \nthere other sexual activity? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226492\n", "char_count": 1091}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "10 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nYes, there was. \nduring my \ninterview with \nshe became very upset when \ndiscussing the sexual activity that took place at \nthat time. \nShe stated that Mr. Epstein had \ndigitally penetrated her. \nIt began first by \nrubbing her on the outside pf her vagina and then \non more than one occasion actually penetrating her \nwith his fingers. \nHe would request her to pinch his \nnipples. \nHe rubbed her breasts as well. She \nstated that there was a vibrator that was used on \nher vagina as well, did not penetrate her, but \nthat she described the vibrator as being a, white \nvibrator with a gray head, and several of the \nother victims have said the same thing, described \nit similar to that. \nQ \nAnd just before I forget, when you \nIMIE\ntestified about \ndid \nalso report \nhaving a vibrator used on her? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd, again, so the record is clear, when \nyou are talking about these vibrators, they are \nthe large back massager type vibrator? \nA \nWe have had some girls just describe \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226493\n", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "1 1 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nthem as a vibrator. We have had some girls just \ndescribe them as a back massager and then we also \nhad girls describe them as both, because of the \nsize of it, I think some girls are more aware of \nwhat a vibrator would look like due to their ages. \nYou know, I don't know that everybody \nknew exactly what a sexual vibrator looked like, \nbut they all vibrated, and we have actually had \nthat described, and \ndescribed it as both, \na vibrator slash massager, saying that it was, you \nknow, large in nature. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow in addition to using that \nmassager and digitally penetrating \nwas \nthere other sexual activity? \nA \nYes. Several times during the massages, \nMr. Epstein would havesstraddle \nhim while \nhe laid on his stomach and then he would reach \nbetween her legs and masturbate and \noccasionally --\nQ \nAnd this is when he was laying on his \nback not his stomach? \nA \nI'm sorry. Did I say that? \n• \nYou said on his stomach. \nA \nHe is laying on his back. \nShe's on top \nof him straddled, and he is reaching between her \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226494\n", "char_count": 1188}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "12 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nmasturbating, and he has attempted to put his \npenis on her vagina, never penetrating her, but \nthat was what was described to us by \n. \nQ \nNow when was \nfirst interviewed \nby the Palm Beach Police? \nA \nShe was interviewed October 6th of 2005. \nQ \nAnd at that time, did she say when her \nlast visit was to Mr. Epstein's house? \nA \nYes, she said October 1st, 2005, was the \nlast massage that she had given Mr. Epstein. \nQ \nIs there any other evidence that was \nrecovered from Mr. Epstein's or his household \nitems that would confirm that statement? \nA \nWe have a message pad. During the \nsearch warrant, several of the message pads -- I \ndon't know if we referred to them at this stage. \nWe may not have. \nWe recovered -- well, I shouldn't say \nwe, the Palm Beach Police Department recovered \nseveral message pads. They were carbon copy \nmessage pads. \nSo we have several of those books from \ntheir search warrant and in there, there is a \nmessage on October 1st confirming \nappointment for the mas \nas well as another \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226495\n", "char_count": 1176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "13 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ngirl, \nQ \nAnd is there also evidence that \nand \nactually spoke on October 1st \nbefore that message? \nA \nWe have cell phone calls between \nKellen and \nas well as the message which \nwas from \nto Jeffrey regarding -- confirming \n='\nthe appointment for \nbut we have a cell \nphone call I believe it was a little bit earlier \nfrom \nto \nor maybe it was \nto \n, but it is definitely between the two of \nthem on that same day. \nQ \nAll right. When \nwas interviewed \nby the Palm Beach Police Department, did she \ndescribe all of the sexual activity? \nA \nNo, she did not. She did not tell them \nabout the vibrator or the -- she didn't tell them \nabout the vibrator or the penetration. \nQ \nAnd, again, you said that when you \nbrought up -- did you sort of confront her with \nthe idea that more had occurred? \nA \nI did, and she was very embarrassed \nabout the vibrator. \nI asked her at one point if \nMr. Epstein had given her any gifts and she got \nvery red in the face and began to tear up and you \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226496\n", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "14 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ncould see that she was very embarrassed. \nSo we took a little bit of a break, but \nthen she was able to say that Mr. Epstein had \nprovided her as a birthday present a vibrator. So \nnot only was there a vibrator back massager used \non her, but at this time -- and I think that's \nkind of what got \ntalking about the sexual \nactivity that she was able to tell me that, and \nshe was very, very embarrassed, but that Mr. \nEpstein had given her for her eighteenth birthday \na vibrator. \nQ \nNow you mentioned that that happened on \nher eighteenth birthday? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd was she able to tell you whether Mr. \nEpstein knew it was her eighteenth birthday? \nA \nShe stated that Mr. Epstein provided to \nher on her eighteenth birthday the vibrator and \nshortly -- well --\nQ \nSo before you had said that \nhad \ninstructed \nto tell everyone that she was \n18; do you remember that? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nBut at some point, the people in the \nEpstein household learned that she hadn't turned \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226497\n", "char_count": 1129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "15 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n18 yet and her birthday was coming up? \nA \nHer birthday was coming up. \nQ \nAnd at some point, was a car provided \nA \nYes. \nIn October of '05, \nwas \nhaving \nasked Mr. Epstein is she could \nborrow one of his cars to go to Orlando and he \nstated that -- at first he said yes, and then he \nsaid he would get her a rental car. \nSo \ncontacted \na few days \nlater and said that a car had been rented for \nand that the house manager used the \ncompany credit card and \npicked up that \ncar, and actually when the police interviewed her \non October 6th, which was five or six days after \nthe last massage, they were able to see that that \nNissan Sentra that had been rented by Mr. Epstein, \nhad that in her possession for at least \nthrough January 1st of 2006 and that car was \nrented by Mr. Epstein for at least that amount of \ntime. \nQ \nDid \ndescribe how the massage \nappointments would be made? \nA \nYes, she did. \nQ \nAnd how was that? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226498\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "16 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nShe stated that \n, that \nJill\" Jeffrey's assistant, would call her and set \nup appointments, and that sometimes she would call \nher on her cell phone from New York, from the \nIslands, and say that they were coming into town, \nwas she available. \nShe would also call \nwhile they \nwere in town to see if she was available for \nmassages, to give massages to Mr. Epstein, and \nstated that \n, who we have identified as \ncalled her a few times as well to set \nappointments up. \nQ \nAnd when those appointments were made \nhow would \nreach \nA \nBy phone. \nQ \nAll right. \nAnd whether she was in town \nor out of town, she would call \n's cell \nphone? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAll right. Now was there any -- during \nthe interview with the police department, did the \npolice department ask \nabout what she \ndiscussed with Jeffrey Epstein during the \nmassages? \nA \nI would have to check the police reports \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226499\n", "char_count": 1040}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "17 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nto give specifics on that. \nQ \nAll right. \nA \nMy answer to your question is yes. \nQ \nOkay. And what did she say were some of \n!the topics of discussion? \nA \nMr. Epstein asked her questions about \nherself, asked her if she was a soccer player or \nthat -- Jeffrey knew that she was a soccer player \nand asked questions about her college, about where \nshe was going to school. \nis currently going to Lynn \n!University, and she had advised Mr. Epstein that \n\\she would be attending college at Lynn University. \nSo that was a -- but that was her future \n/plan? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nSo in other words, did Mr. Epstein know \nthat she was in high school at the time? \nA \nYes, he did. And the Palm Beach Police \nasked \nif Jeffrey knew her age and \ntold the Palm Beach Police Department, he didn't \ncare what my age was. \nNow did \ndescribe either to you \nor to the police department how she would be paid \nfor these massages? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226500\n", "char_count": 1067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "18 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \na \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nShe stated she was paid $200 and that \nshe received anywhere from two to $300. \nQ \nWith every visit? \nA \nWith each visit. \nQ \nOkay. Did she say who would provide her \nwith that money? \nA \nShe said that Jeffrey paid her at the \nend of the massage. \nQ \nAll right. You mentioned the gift of \nthe vibrator. \nWere there other gifts that were \ngiven to \nA \nYes. The time period is unclear, but \nthe vibrator was given to her for her eighteenth \nbirthday. There were three sets of bra and \nunderwear, panties, \nSecret bra and \nunderwear sets that were also given to \nas \ngifts from Mr. Epstein. \nQ \nNow I know that we talked earlier about \nthe fact that \nis the person who brought \nto Mr. Epstein's house. \nDid \never \nbring anyone to Mr. Epstein's house? \nA \nbrought a female by the name of \nM. and that was a friend of \ns. \nQ \nAnd let me show you what has been marked \nas Grand Jury Exhibit 4, and what is Grand Jury \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226501\n", "char_count": 1072}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "19 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \nB \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nExhibit 4? \nA \nIt's a photograph of \nM. with a \ndate of birth of . \nQ \nHow old was \nM. when \ntook \nher to Mr. Epstein's house? \nA \ntook her there in the spring of \n2005 and \nwas 18 at that time. \nQ \nNow can you tell us now \nwent \nabout bringing \nto the house? \nA \ntold \nthat she could make \nsome money giving a massage to Mr. Epstein and \nand \nwent to Mr. Epstein's house \ntogether. \nThe first time that \nwent there, \nshe did not go upstairs and give him a massage. \nIIIIIII \nwas working that day. But in talking to \nfurther, \nstated that she probably \nover the period of time between the spring of '05 \nand October of '05, performed around five to ten \nmassages for Mr. Epstein. \nThe first few of those he did not do \nanything as far as no masturbating, no sexual \nactivity. She would just perform a massage. \nQ \nAnd did that change over time? \nA \nYes, it did. She stated that she \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226502\n", "char_count": 1038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "20 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nperformed two to three massages out of those five \nor ten and in her underwear and bra only, and \nthat he would push her each time. \nHe would just push her to do more and on \nthe third -- I believe she stated the third or \nfourth massage, he told her that she could make \nmore money if she removed her clothing, because \nshe stayed clothed during the lirst lew massages, \nand she was paid $200 for each of those massages. \nOn the third or fourth massage, Mr. \nEpstein said that she could make more money it she \nremoved her clothing. So around the fourth or \nfifth time, she did start taking off her clothing \ndown to her underwear and bra only. \nQ \nAnd then what happened when she was at \nthat point of being unclothed? \nA \nShe would perform the massage. \nHe \nattempted to touch her, but she always would say \nno. \nAt one point, her bra does get undone by Mr. \nEpstein, but she does keep it up. \nQ \nNow that was the extent of his touching \nLauren. \nAt some point, did he begin masturbating \nin front of her? \nA \nYes, he did. \nNot in the very beginning, \nbut throughout this he did. \nNow I should tell you \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226503\n", "char_count": 1265}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "21 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nthat \nstated to us that because she was kind \nof reserved or held back as he made advances \ntowards her, she was able to see Mr. Epstein's \npenis and that he was masturbating, but that he \nnever finished, that he never ejaculated. She did \nnot reel that Mr. Epstein liked her very much. \nQ \nBut just to sort of compare what \nsaid with what \nsaid, they both said that \nat the beginning they remained clothed? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd that Mr. Epstein progressively \npushed and pushed and pushed for more sexual \nactivity? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nNow what was the period of time that \nwent to Mr. Epstein's home? \nA \nMarch of \nI'm sorry, spring of '05 is \nwhen \nsaid that she went there and around, \nyou know, the investigation is heating up with \nPalm Beach, so we know that in September of '05, \nthere was a trash pull done, and in that trash \npull there was a message and that was found and it \nstated -- it had \nphone number on it and \nit stated, for a good time call \nand \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226504\n", "char_count": 1115}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "22 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAnd whose stationery was that? \nA \nIt was on Jeffrey Epstein's stationery. \nQ \nAnd had Jeffrey Epstein been in a Palm \nBeach resident close to those dates? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nNow is there evidence of telephone calls \nbetween \nand \nKellen? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd how many phone calls have you been \nable to identify? \nA \nAt this time, there have been 14 phone \nQ \nAll right. \nAnd just to compare that to \nthe number of phone calls with \nA \nWith = \nthere was over 150 phone \ncalls between \nand \nQ \nAnd that is sort of consistent with the \nnumber of massages that \ndid versus the \nnumber of massages that \ndid? \nA \nIt is consistent with especially the \nactivity that \nwas providing Mr. Epstein \ncompared to the activity that \nwould \nprovide. \n(Thereupon, knocking is heard at the \nGrand Jury door.) \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226505\n", "char_count": 945}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "23 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nMS. \nLet me just step out for \none moment. \n(Ms. Villafana exits the Grand Jury \nRoom.) \n(Ms. \nenters the Grand Jury \nRoom.) \nMS. \nLadies and gentlemen, I \nam going to have to take a break now and we \nwill be back either next week or the \nlollowing week. \nThank you very much. You \nare done for the day. \n(Witness was excused.) \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \nI, Paula E. Angelocci, Certified Court \nReporter and Notary Public, do certify that the \ntranscript is a true and correct transcription of \nmy stenotype notes of the testimony of \nSPECIAL AGENT E. NESBITT \ntaken before \nthe Federal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach, Florida. \nPAULA \nANG LOCCI, CSR #4869 \nCertified Court Reporter \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226506\n", "char_count": 838}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nRE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \nTESTIMONY \nOF \nSPECIAL AGENT E. \nCOPY \nFederal Grand Jury 07-103 \nFederal Building \nU.S. Courthouse \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \nTuesday, April 24, 2007 \nAPPEARANCES: \nAssistant United States Attorney \nore person \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nExhibit 21 \nEFTA00226507\n", "char_count": 463}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "2 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nThe sworn testimony of SPECIAL AGENT \nas taken before the \nFederal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach Division, \nFederal Building, U.S. Courthouse, Palm Beach \nCounty, State of Florida, on Tuesday, April 24, \n2007. \nPaula E. Angelocci, Certified Court \nReperter and Notary Public, State of Florida, \nOfficial Reporting Service, LLC, 524 South Andrews \nAvenue, Suite 302N, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, \n33301 , was authorized to and did report the sworn \ntestimony. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226508\n", "char_count": 600}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "3 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room.) \nTHE /OREPERSON: You do solemnly swear \nthat the testimony you give will be the \ntruth, the whole truth, and nothing but the \ntruth, so help you God? \nTHE WITNESS: \nI do. \nTHE FOREPERSON: Thank you. Please be \nseated. \nEXAMINATION \nBY MS. \nQ \nSpecial Agent \n1, would you \njust remind the grand jurors who you are and who \nyou work for? \nA \nMy name is \n1 and I am \na special agent with the FBI and I work here in \nPalm Beach. \nQ \nSpecial Agent \n1, can you tell \nthe grand jurors who will be appearing before them \nthis afternoon? \nA \nOne of our victims, Haley R., who was a \nminor at the time that she met Mr. Epstein. \nQ \nAnd have you previously testified about \nYes, I have. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226509\n", "char_count": 871}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "4 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nDid you attempt to interview her? She's \ngoing to be coming in, and she is not a minor \nanymore, so what is her full name? \nA \nHer name is \nand I did \nattempt to interview \n, and \nwas \ninterviewed by Palm Beach Police Department and \nbecause of the statements she provided to the \npolice department, she felt as if she needed a \nlawyer. \nSo when I attempted to interview her, we \nended up going through her lawyer. \nQ \nAnd just so the grand jury has a little \nbit of background, the interview with the Palm \nBeach Police Department was quite some time ago? \nA \nYes, it was, in the fall of '05. \nQ \nAnd when \nstarted that \nconversation with the police, she was very \nforthcoming? \nA \nYes, she was. \nQ \nFully cooperative? \nA \nYes. \n• \nAnd what happened in the middle of that \ninterview with the police? \nA \nThe police just let \nknow that she \ncould be charged because \nbrought some of the \ngirls to Mr. Epstein and the police -- she was \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226510\n", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "5 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nvery cooperative, but the police at that point had \nto let \nknow that what she had done that she \ncould be facing charges. \nQ \nAnd that was after they had told her \nearlier that she didn't need an attorney present, \ncorrect? \nA \nExactly. \nQ \nOkay. So this happens to her with the \nPalm Beach Police Department and did the Palm \nBeach Police actually present or propose charging \nMs. \nA \nThey did get a probable cause affidavit \nagainst Haley. \nAnd is that why Ms. \nand her \nattorney were concerned about her testimony here? \nA \nYes. \nNow was a subpoena issued for Ms. \non behall of this grand jury? \nA \nYes, it was. \n• \nAnd before Ms. \nwould comply with \nthat, did she -- did her attorney request some \nsort of order? \nA \nYes. \n• \nAnd what did he ask for? \nA \nHe asked for immunity for Haley. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226511\n", "char_count": 948}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "6 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAnd let me show you the order, that is a \nsealed order in these grand jury proceedings. \nNow \nthe immunity that has been provided for Ms. \nkeeps her statements that are made here from being \nused against her? \nA \nYes, it does. \nQ \nIt doesn't -- if she commits perjury and \nshe lies to the grand jury, can she still be \ncharged? \nA \nYes, she can. \nQ \nOkay. Could you read that? \nI know it \nis only two pages. \nA \nSealed order, on application of the \nUnited States Attorneys for the Southern District \nof Florida and it appearing to the satisfaction of \nthe court that \nhas been called to \ntestify and to provide other information before \nthe United States District Court, the Southern \nDistrict of Florida, including a grand jury \nimpaneled therein. \nAnd number two, that in a judgment of \nthe said United States Attorneys, \nhas \nrefused to testify and provide other information \non the basis of her privilege against self \nincrimination. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226512\n", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 117, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nAnd that number three, in the judgment \nof the United States Attorneys, the testimony and \nother information from Haley \nmade necessary \nto the public interest. \nAnd number four, that the aforesaid \napplication has been made with the approval of the \nAssistant Attorney General in charge of the \ncriminal division of the Department of Justice or \na duly designated acting Assistant Attorney \nGeneral pursuant to the authority vested in him by \nTitle 18, United States Code, Section 6003, and \nTitle 28, Code of Federal Regulations, Section \n0.175 and 0.132, small e. \nNow, therefore, it is ordered pursuant \nto Title 18, United States Code, Section 6002, \nthat \ngive testimony and provide other \ninformation which she refuses to give or to \nprovide on the basis of her privilege against self \nincrimination as to all matters about which she \nmay be interrogated before said United States \nDistrict Court including a grand jury impaneled \ntherein as well as any subsequent proceeding or \ntrial. \nHowever, no testimony or other \ninformation compelled under this order or any \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226513\n", "char_count": 1228}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 118, "text_content": "8 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ninformation directly or indirectly derived from \nsuch testimony or other information may be used \nagainst \nin any criminal case except a \nprosecution for perjury giving a false statement \nor otherwise tailing to comply with this order. \nIt is further ordered that this order \nshall be sealed in accordance with said Federal \nRegulations Criminal. \nBY MS. \nQ \nFederal Rule of Criminal Procedure. \nA \nFederal Rule of Criminal Procedure, it's \nabbreviated, 6, little e, 6, except that a copy of \nthis order shall be provided to counsel for the \nUnited States who may disclose the existence of \nthe order to members of the grand jury, to the \nwitness, to the counsel for the witness, and to \nlaw enforcement officers engaged in the \ninvestigation pending before the grand jury. \nThose persons may review the order, but \nmay not retain a copy of the order nor may it \ndisclose the existence of the order to any others. \nDone and ordered the 16th day of April 2007, at \nWest Palm Beach, Florida. The United States \nDistrict Judge Donald M. Middlebrook, Marie \nVillafana, AUSA. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226514\n", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 119, "text_content": "9 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n14 \n11 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAll right. So has a copy or has this \ndocument been shown to counsel for Ms. \nA \nYes, it has. \nQ \nAnd to Ms. \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd will Ms. \nbe here this \nafternoon? \nA \nYes, she will. \nQ \nHave you had a chance to sit with her? \nA \nYes, we have. \nQ \nAnd she has been very forthcoming? \nA \nShe's very cooperative. \nQ \nOkay. \nMS. \nI don't have any further \nquestions for the witness. Do you have any \nquestions? All right. Seeing no questions, \nyou are excused and I think that right now \nyou are set to come back at 1 : 15. \nHow does \n1 :30 sound? Is that all right? \nTHE FOREPERSON: Fine. \n(Witness was excused.) \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226515\n", "char_count": 765}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 120, "text_content": "10 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \nI, Paula E. Angelocci, Certified Court \nReporter and Notary Public, do certify that the \ntranscript is a true and correct transcription of \nmy stenotype notes of the testimony of \nSPECIAL AGENT \ntaken before \nthe Federal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach, Florida. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226516\n", "char_count": 440}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 121, "text_content": "1 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nRE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \nTESTIMONY \nOF \nCOPY \nFederal Grand Jury 07-103 \nFederal Building \nU.S. Courthouse \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \nTuesday, April 24, 2007 \nAPPEARANCES: \nMARIE \nAssistan \nUnited States Attorney \nHELENA JOSETTE JONES-PARSONS, \nForeperson \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, L'LC \n(954) 467-8204 \nExhibit 22 \nEFTA00226517\n", "char_count": 487}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 122, "text_content": "2 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nThe sworn testimony of \nwas \ntaken before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm \nBeach Division, \nBuilding, U.S. Courthouse, \nPalm Beach County, State of Florida, on Tuesday, \nApril 24, 2007. \nPaula E. Angelocci, Certified Court \nReporter and Notary Public, State of Florida, \nOfficial Reporting Service, LLC, 524 South Andrews \nAvenue, Suite 302N, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, \n33301 , was authorized to and did report the sworn \ntestimony. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226518\n", "char_count": 592}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 123, "text_content": "3 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room.) \nTHE FOREPERSON: \nYou do solemnly swear \nthat the testimony you give will be the \ntruth, the whole truth, and nothing but the \ntruth, so help you God? \nTHE WITNESS: I do. \nTHE FOREPERSON: Thank you. Please be \nseated. \nEXAMINATION \nBY MS. VILLAFANA: \nQ \nGood afternoon, Ms. \nCould you \nstate and spell your name for the record? \nA \nH-A-L-E-Y, R -O-B-S-O-N. \nQ \nAnd where do you currently live? \nA \nI live -- do you want me to give the \naddress? \nQ \nSure. \nA \n, West Palm Beach, \nFlorida 33412. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd you are living with your \nparents now? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWere you served with a subpoena to \nappear before the grand jury today? \nA \nYes. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(9541 467-8204 \nEFTA00226519\n", "char_count": 838}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 124, "text_content": "2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAnd do you understand that an order was \nsigned by a judge compelling you to appear and \nanswer questions? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd that order states that what you tell \nthe grand jury won't be used against unless you \nperjure yourself? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nDo you understand that you are under \noath, and\nyou don't tell the truth \nA\ncan go to jail, yes. \nQ \nOkay. Let's start with where you went \nto high school. \nA \nRoyal Palm Beach High School. \nQ \nHow old are you today? \nA \nTwenty-one. \nQ \nAnd what is your date of birth? \nA \nApril 9, 1986. \nQ \nWhat year did you graduate from Royal \nPalm? \nA \n2004. \nQ \nAnd where are you currently working? \nA \nI currently am not working. \nQ \nBut you are starting a new job? \nA \nThursday. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226520\n", "char_count": 867}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 125, "text_content": "Where will that be? \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nFort Lauderdale, Coral Springs. \nQ \nWhat type of position will that be? \nA \nWaitressing. \nQ \nHave you worked since the time that you \ngraduated from high school? \nA \nUh-huh. \nQ \nCan you tell the grand jury what type of \njobs you have had? \nA \nI worked at T's Lounge as a dancer. \nI \nworked in a club up in Orlando as a dancer as \nwell. \nI have also worked at a sports bar as a \nwaitress. \nQ \nWhen you were in high school, where did \nyou work? \nA \nT's Lounge and Olive Garden. \nQ \nAnd do you know Jeffrey Epstein? \nA \nYes, I do. \nQ \nCan you tell the grand jury how you \nfirst came to meet Mr. Epstein? \nA \nI met Epstein through two acquaintances, \nMolly and Tony, and I met them at a beach resort. \nThey made a proposition to me. \nLater then I \npicked them up and they gave me directions to the \nhouse and that's where I was formerly introduced \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, TAX \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226521\n", "char_count": 1019}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 126, "text_content": "6 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nto Mr. Epstein. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd let me just go back over that \na little bit. \nYou mentioned that you had two \nacquaintances, Molly and Tony, and you met them at \na beach resort, correct? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd you said that they made a \nproposition to you. \nWhat was that exactly? \nA \nMolly had asked me if i wanted to make \nmoney and she was working for this guy, Epstein, \nin Palm Beach. So I told her I was interested and \nshe further went into detail about massaging him, \nthat you would have to take off articles of \nclothing and there would be touching and fondling \ninvolved. \nQ \nHow old were you when this happened? \nA \nAbout 16. \nQ \nAnd how old was \nA \nSame age. \nQ \nAnd how did you know Molly? \nA \nWe went to middle school together. \nQ \nAnd she was in your same grade in high \nschool? \nA \nYeah. \nQ \nAnd you mentioned that Molly had \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226522\n", "char_count": 992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 127, "text_content": "7 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \ni2 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \npreviously worked for Epstein or was currently \nworking for Epstein? \nA \nYes, that's right. \nQ \nSo they explained this proposal to you \nand you said that you would be interested? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWhat happened next? \nA \nWithin a couple of days to a week I \npicked them up and I went to his house to work for \nhim and I was introduced to \n, who is his \nassistant. She took me upstairs to Epstein's \nbedroom and that's where the massage took place. \nwas naked and he tried fondling me and \nI wouldn't have it, so after the massage he gave \nme another proposition to bring girls to the house \nand for every girl that I brought I would make \n$200. \nQ \nAll right. We'll go back over that a \nlittle more slowly. \nI know this is a lot of \ninformation. \nSo let's go back to the proposition \nthat Molly and Tony made tc you. \nDid they say you would be paid for \nmassaging Mr. Epstein? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd how much would you be paid? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226523\n", "char_count": 1072}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 128, "text_content": "8 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \n$200. \nQ \nNow you said that they had told you that \nyou might have to take your clothing off? \nA \nThey told me that I was expected to take \nmy clothing off and that there would be fondling. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd what -- did they explain \nwhat fondling meant? \nA \nJust that he'd be touching me. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd so you agreed to do that and \nwent to Mr. Epstein's home? \nA \nCorrect. \nQ \nAnd where was that located? \nA \nPalm Beach, Brillo Way. \nQ \nB-R -I-L-L-O? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd when you arrived at the home, you \nsaid that you were driving with Molly and Tony? \nA \nThat is correct. \nQ \nTell us how you got into the house. \nA \nWe went through a gate on the side of \nthe house that led to the back and we just rang \nthe doorbell and \nanswered the door and we \nwere standing in the kitchen and then \nbrought me upstairs. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow did you have any -- did \nyou \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226524\n", "char_count": 1010}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 129, "text_content": "9 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ntell you anything about what you would do when you \ngot upstairs? \nA \nNo, she never discussed that with me. \nQ \nDid she say anything to you about taking \nyour clothes off? \nA \nNo, she never discussed that with me. \nQ \nOkay. \nWhen you arrived upstairs, ou \nsaid that you went into a bedroom? \nA \nThat is correct. \nQ \nWhat was in the bedroom? \nA \nIt was a bedroom that had a door that \nled to then I want to say a bigger more than just \na bathroom. \nIt was a bigger room with like a \npretty large size walk-in closet, a shower, a \nsteam shower, and then two sinks on the right, and \nin the middle laid the massage table, and then to \nthe left there was two couches. \nQ \nAnd so the massage table was already set \nup when you arrived? \nA \nThat is correct. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd after \nled you up to the \nbedroom, what did she do? \nA \nShe had left and that's when Epstein \ncame in. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd when Mr. Epstein came in, \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226525\n", "char_count": 1069}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 130, "text_content": "10 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nwhat was he wearing? \nA \nHe was wearing a towel. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd nothing else? \nA \nNothing else. \nQ \nAnd what did he do? \nA \nHe laid on the table and that's when the \nmassage began and later on he -- when he got in, I \ntook off my clothes and I was just wearing my \nbottoms, and he later tried to touch me and he \ngrabbed my butt, and that's when I had a problem. \nI told him that I didn't feel comfortable. \nSo later he took the towel off and he \nwas laying on his back and he started to \nmasturbate asking me to squeeze his nipples really \nhard to ejaculation and then after that everything \nwas done. \nQ \nOkay. So when Mr. Epstein ejaculated \nthen the massage or whatever was over? \nA \nYes, it was. \nQ \nAnd once that happened, what did he do? \nA \nJust got up and dried himself off and \nthen walked me downstairs. \nQ \nAnd you got dressed as well? \nA \nThat's right. \nQ \nAnd when you got back downstairs, what \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226526\n", "char_count": 1068}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 131, "text_content": "1 1 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n'0 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nhappened? \nA \nI went back into the kitchen and he \npulled Tony and Molly aside and then we just left. \nOf course, I got paid. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd tell us where you got paid, \nwho paid you, and how much you received? \nA \nEpstein paid me. \nI received 200, but I \ncannot recall if it was upstairs that he paid me \nor if he waited until I got back downstairs. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd when he paid you the $200, \nwas it in small bills, large bills? \nA \nBig bills, 100s. \nQ \nOkay. So two 100 dollar bills. \nAnd you \nsaid that he pulled Molly and Tony aside. Do you \nknow what that was about? \nA \nHe would never pay them in Iront of me. \nHe always was funny about that. So I'm sure it \nwas just paying them for bringing me. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd you mentioned that you told \nMr. Epstein that you were uncomfortable with him \ntouching you? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nAnd what became of that? \nA \nLater on before I left he had addressed \nme to not massage him anymore, but asked me if I \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226527\n", "char_count": 1114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 132, "text_content": "12 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ncould bring girls over and for every girl that \nbrought to the table he would pay me $200. \nQ \nOkay. So you weren't comfortable with \nhim touching you, so you weren't going to do any \nmore massages? \nA \nNo. \nQ \nHe wanted you to find other girls? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nAnd he wanted girls that would let him \ntouch them? \nA \nUh-huh. \nQ \nAfter that first massage, did you \nperform any other massages at his house? \nA \nAbsolutely not. \nQ \nDid you bring girls? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nTell us how you started to bring girls \nto Mr. Epstein's house. \nA \nJust girls that I met in high school, \nacquaintances, people that I just said hi and bye \nto. \nA lot of them actually heard about it through \na couple of girls that I brought and they were \ninterested. \nSome of the girls asked me about it. \nJust girls in school I'd talk to, just get on the \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226528\n", "char_count": 998}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 133, "text_content": "13 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nsubject. They had no problem with it. \nQ \nOkay. So when you found a girl that you \nthought would be interested, what exactly would \nyou tell her? \nA \nI asked them if they were interested in \nmaking extra money and that I knew an older \nwealthier man in Palm Beach who liked to have \nmassages and they would get paid $200. \nThe more they did, the more they make, \nand I would explain to them in detail what was \nexpected of them when they showed up at the house \nand I also told them that if they are under age \njust lie about it and tell him that you are 18. \nQ \nLet's talk first about what you said \nthat you tell them what was expected of them. \nA \nYes. \nQ \nFirst of all, why did you tell them \nthat? \nA \nBecause that's what I was told. \nQ \nBy whom? \nA \nMolly and Tony. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd did Jeffrey Epstein ever \naddress you about don't bring girls over here iI \nthey don't know what's going to happen? \nA \nAbsolutely. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226529\n", "char_count": 1077}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 134, "text_content": "14 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nOkay. So all the girls were supposed to \nknow that when they got there they would be \nundressing? \nA \nThey would be undressing. There would \nbe touching. There would be fondling. \nHe was \nvery big on that. \nHe told me never to bring a \ngirl over unless they knew what was expected. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd did you also tell them that \nhe would be masturbating? \nA \nI didn't really talk to them about that. \nI didn't know if he did it with everybody or it \nwas just with me that he did that. \nQ \nBut you told them that they all would \nhave to be partially naked or fully naked? \nA \nPartially to fully naked and there would \nbe touching and fondling. \nQ \nOkay. \nHow many girls do you think you \ntook to Mr. Epstein's house? \nA \nSeven, between seven to ten. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd were there any \nin addition \nto this rule about the girls had to know what was \nexpected, did Mr. Epstein have any other rules in \nterms of what the girls looked like or what he \nliked? \nA \nNo. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226530\n", "char_count": 1116}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 135, "text_content": "15 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nOkay. \nWere there girls that you brought \nthat he didn't like? \nA \nThere were a few girls he wasn't crazy \nabout. \nHe didn't really like. He didn't lavor. \nRachel, for instance, 23, he thought she was kind \nof too old. \nQ \nOkay. \nSo you brought a girl named \nRachel, who was 23 years old? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd you were told that she was too old? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nDid you ever bring her back? \nA \nNo. \nQ \nWhat about any other girls that he \ndidn't like? \nIIIII This other girl I went to high school \nwith, \nshe was maybe a year younger, and him \nand her got into an argument about money. \nI told \nher in detail what was expected and she, to me, \nwas all for it and then when she got there, \ndecided she didn't want to perform what was \nnecessary. So they got into an argument about \nmoney and after that I never really brought her \nback. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd did either Jeffrey Epstein \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226531\n", "char_count": 1033}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 136, "text_content": "16 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nor \nsay anything to you about what happened \nwith \n? \nA \nHe had made a comment just about -- I \nhad asked \nhe had asked me for someone to come \nover and work and when I suggested \nhe kind of \nnodded, not really interested. \nHe told me to find \nsomebody else. So I assumed that meant he really \ndidn't care for her. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow the -- you mentioned Rachel, \nwho was 23. \nWhat was the age range of the other \ngirls that you brought to Mr. Epstein's home? \nA \nHigh school, 16 to 18. \nQ \nWere there any girls who were younger \nthan that? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWho was that? \nA \nQ \nAnd how was she? \nA \nShe was 14. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow you were interviewed by the \nPalm Beach Police Department? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nAnd during that interview, you told them \nthat there were two ways to make money with \nJeffrey Epstein. \nCan you explain to the grand \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226532\n", "char_count": 994}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 137, "text_content": "17 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \njury what those two ways are? \nA \nThe more you did is the more you make. \nBasically, the more clothes that come off, the \nmore you let him touch you, the more you just let \nhim have his way with you is the more that you \nwould make, otherwise, you would be demoted down \nto bringing girls over and just making money that \nway. \nQ \nAnd that's what you were doing? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nWas bringing girls? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nIf you could explain to the grand jury \nhow you would go about making an appointment for a \ngirl to come and give a massage? \nA \nHis assistant there would call me either \nbefore they got into town or while he was in town \nand either she would ask me for a particular girl, \npreferably one that he favored, or if I couldn't \nget a hold of that girl just bring somebody over \nto work. \nI would call the girl. She would okay \nit. \nI would call \nback, confirm it, set an \nappointment, and then the next couple of days we'd \ngo. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226533\n", "char_count": 1111}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 138, "text_content": "18 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAnd was \nthe person that you always \nmade the appointment with? \nA \nAlways. \nQ \nDo you remember ever talking to Jeffrey \nEpstein on the telephone? \nA \nNever. \nThe only time I talked to him \nwas physically in person at his house. \nQ \nOkay. \nwas really the person that \nyou had to --\nA \nDeal with. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow you mentioned that sometimes \nwould request a specific girl? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nDid she give you any reason why he \nreally liked this girl or just is this girl \navailable? \nWhat would happen on those calls? \nA \nII it was a specific girl, she would \ncall me and just ask: Can this girl work? \nShe \nwould never give me a reason. \nShe would never go \ninto detail. \nIt was just: Can she work, yes or \nno? \nQ \nAnd \nwas saying to you can she \nwork? \nA \nI can't recall if those were her exact \nwords. \nI can't remember if it was: \nCan she come \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226534\n", "char_count": 1011}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 139, "text_content": "19 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nover and massage or can she work? \nI don't recall \nthe exact words. \nCo \nOkay. \nAnd once you made those \nappointments then who would normally take you and \nthe girls to the house? \nA \nwould. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd you would drive? \nA \nI would drive. \nQ \nAnd were all -- was this always taking \nplace at Mr. Epstein's home? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOn Brillo Way? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nWhen you spoke with \nKellen on the \ntelephone, did you -- were all 0 I these \nconversations about setting up these appointments? \nA \nWhen I would talk to \nQ \nYes. \nA \nYes. \nIt would be pure business whenever \ntalked to \nSo you didn't have any sort of friendly \nrelationship? \nA \nNo friendly relationship, never \nsocialized unless I was at the house. \nI \nlike that at all. \nIt wasn't \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226535\n", "char_count": 909}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 140, "text_content": "20 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nOkay. \nNow when you would bring a new \ngirl over to the house, what would you do? \nA \nWalk up the same way towards the back of \nthe house. They would let us in. \nI could sit in \nthe kitchen with the girl. \nI would either wait \nfor \nto come in or Jeffrey. \nMost of the time \nit was \nwould bring the girl upstairs \nwhile I waited downstairs. After the massage, the \ngirl would come downstairs. \nI would get paid and \nthen we would leave. \nQ \nTell us how you would get paid when you \nwere the person who brought the girls. \nA \nWhat do you mean how I would get paid? \nQ \nWho would pay you? \nA \nJeffrey Epstein would pull me aside \nwhether it be in his, I guess, living room slash \noffice. \nHe would just make sure that when he paid \nme, it was just me and him, nobody else was \naround. \nQ \nAnd how much would you get paid for each \ngirl? \nA \n$200. \nQ \nAnd again with the two 100 dollar bills? \nA \nAlways 10.0 dollar bills. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226536\n", "char_count": 1080}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 141, "text_content": "21 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n2.4 \n25 \nQ \nDid you ever see the girl who actually \ndid the massages get paid? \nA \nNo, I never saw them get paid. \nHe never \npaid us in front of each other. \nQ \nOkay. Did the girls ever tell you that \nthey did get paid or how much they got paid? \nA \nMost of the time. \nQ \nOkay. And how much money would each \ngirl get paid? \nA \nIt ranges. \nQ \nFrom? \nA \nIt ranges from 200 to some got paid 300. \nLike I said, the more you do, the more you make. \nThere were a couple of girls that got paid 300, \n400, and then there were a couple of girls that \ngot paid 200 maybe even 100. \nQ \nNow you mentioned that usually \nwould take the girl upstairs? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nWere there ever instances where you took \nthe girl upstairs? \nA \nVery rarely. \nI think it happened once \nor twice where \nwas doing something or she \nwould need me to go upstairs and set up. \nI would \njust go upstairs. \nI would show her where the \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226537\n", "char_count": 1056}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 142, "text_content": "22 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nmassage table was. \nI would set it up for them. \nI would \nshow them where the towels were, put the towels on \nthe massage table and then I would tell them \nJeffrey would be in, in a minute and then I would \nwalk back downstairs and wait in the kitchen. \nQ \nOkay. And when you were in these other \ninstances where you led the girl upstairs, besides \nthe massage table, did you ever see any other \nimplements that were used during the massage? \nA \nI think there were maybe a few occasions \nwhere I would walk upstairs to show the girl or \nmaybe it was even when I first massaged him, there \nwas like a white massager on the table or a white \nvibrator. \nQ \nAnd can you describe that to the grand \njury? \nA \nWhat it looked like? \nQ \nWhat it looked like, yes. \nA \nIt was like a cylinder. It was really \nbig. The head was bigger. \nIt was white. \nI think \nthe top of it was maybe like pink. \nIt was big, \nthat's all I remember. \nOkay. \nAnd did any of the girls ever \ntell you that that was used on them? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226538\n", "char_count": 1156}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 143, "text_content": "23 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow I'm going to run through the \nnames of some girls that you brought just to \nconfirm with the grand jury that you brought them. \nA \nOkay. \nQ \n? \nA \nThat's correct. \nIIIIIIIIIIIIk? \nA \nCorrect. \nGonzales? \nA \nCorrect. \nQ \nr Siciliano? \nA \nYes. \nJennifer \nA \nYes. \nQ \nYolando \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd then there is another girl, Serina \nFigeroa? \nA \nSerina never, ever, ever worked for \nJeffrey. She accompanied me to his house I think \nonce or twice and waited in the kitchen with me, \nbut she never worked for him. \nQ \nOkay. But she was somebody that you \nbrought along with you? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226539\n", "char_count": 752}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 144, "text_content": "24 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nThat is correct. \nQ \nOn visits? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay \nIn addition to those girls \nthat \nwho I just named, you mentioned a woman, \nRachel, who is 23? \nA \nUh-huh. \nQ \nWere there any other girls that you \nrecall bringing to Jeffrey Epstein's house? \nA \nI cannot recall bringing anybody else. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow one of those girls that we \nmentioned was \nZalis, correct? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd you told the police that Jeffrey \nliked \nthe best? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nHow old was \nA \nShe was around the same age as me, maybe \na grade lower than me. \nQ \nOkay. So she was under age? \nA \nYes, correct. \nQ \nAnd all of those girls who names I read \nwere under age when you brought them there? \nA \nExcept for Rachel. \nQ \nOkay. \nWhat did \nlook like? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226540\n", "char_count": 877}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 145, "text_content": "25 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nwas Hispanic. She kind of looks \nKorean, but she's Hispanic, Hawaiian, maybe. She \nhad a dark complexion. She had hair down to the \nmiddle of her back, long, highlights. \nQ \nWas she thin or heavy? \nA \nNo. \nShe was maybe -- she had a boxy \ntype figure, maybe a little lighter than me. \nQ \nAnd how tall do you think she was? \nA \nAbout 5'S, 5'6. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd you knew that Jeffrey liked \nbecause he would specifically request her? \nA \nThere was a few occasions that he would \nspecifically ask for her, correct. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd you mentioned that some of \nthe girls told you about the massager being used, \ncorrect? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nDid some of girls tell you what happened \ninside of that bedroom? \nA \nA few of them did. \nQ \nLet's talk first about ■ \n_no. \nA \nOkay. \nQ \nDid she tell you what happened? \nA \nAll that she really told me was that \nthey got into a money fight. \nHe had tried \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226541\n", "char_count": 1043}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 146, "text_content": "26 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n6 \n7 \na \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nfondling her. \nShe wasn't having it, and then she \nonly got paid $100 and she Ielt like she was being \nripped off. \nQ \nOkay. \nWhat about \nGonzales, did \nshe tell you about what happened? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWhat did she explain to you? \nA \nSaige, on the way home, had told me she \ngot paid $300, and basically let him insert \nlingers in her and use the massager on her. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd she told you those things? \nA \nShe told me those things. \nQ \nThat he had digitally penetrated her and \nhad used the massager? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd that was -- when did she tell \nyou that? \nA \nRight when we got outside into the \ntruck. \nQ \nAs you were driving away? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nDo you remember which other girls told \nyou about the massager being used? \nA \nI can't recall. \nknow there was \nanother one that said something about the \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226542\n", "char_count": 991}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 147, "text_content": "27 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nmassager, but I wasn't really paying attention. \nQ \nNow when you first went and gave Mr. \nEpstein the massage, did he ask for your telephone \nnumber after you were finished? \nA \nNo, \ndid. \nQ \ndid. And she took down your \ntelephone number? \nA \nShe took down my name and my telephone \nnumber. \nQ \nAfter that, how was all contact made \nwith you? \nA \nQ \nDirectly to you? \nA \nDirectly toward me. \nQ \nOkay. So were there any more instances \nwhere she went either through Molly or Tony to \nreach you? \nA \nAbsolutely not. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow when you brought girls over \nwas it the same thing where they would ask for the \ngirl's name and number? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd when that happened, would they \ncontinue to go through you to set up appointments? \nA \nMost of time they went through me. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226543\n", "char_count": 932}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 148, "text_content": "28 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nActually 99.9 percent of the time they went \nthrough me. On a few occasions, the girls that \nthey liked the best, \nor instance, Vanessa, after \na while me and \nstopped contact with each \nother and Jeffrey just went strictly through her. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd when an appointment was made \ndirectly with the girl, you wouldn't necessarily \nknow about it? \nA \nI would not necessarily know about it \n• \nAnd when the appointment was made \ndirectly with the girl then you wouldn't get paid, \ncorrect? \nA \nCorrect. \nQ \nDid you hear or do you know whether some \ngirls that you brought, brought more girls? \nA \nYeah, I'm sure of it. \nQ \nOkay. \nWhen did you first meet \nKellen? \nWas it that day that you went to give the \nmassage? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nAnd how did you first meet her? \nA \nJust walking in the kitchen and waiting \nfor somebody whether it be Epstein or \ncame and introduced herself as \nand I \nlearned that she was Epstein's assistant. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226544\n", "char_count": 1095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 149, "text_content": "29 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAnd you said that she was the one who \ntook you upstairs on the first day? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nAnd we were talking earlier about how \nappointments would be made for you to bring \nadditional girls, correct? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nHow far in advance would \ncall you \nto make appointments? \nA \n:t depends. Sometimes she would call me \na \ndays\nI\nadvance.\n \new \n in \n \nJeffrey is going to be in \ntown tomorrow or this weekend, have a couple of \ngirls lined up or have a girl lined up. So it \nwould be anywhere between a couple of days to a \nweekend. \nQ \nOkay. Did you ever talk with \nor \ndid \never tell you anything about what \nJeffrey liked to do with the girls? \nA \nAbsolutely not. \nWe never discussed \nthat. \nQ \nDid you ever talk with her about a rumor \nthat you had heard that a girl had intercourse \nwith Jeffrey? \nA \nOne day I was talking on the phone with \nand I addressed her with it, asking her \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226545\n", "char_count": 1055}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 150, "text_content": "30 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nabout a rumor I heard of a girl sleeping with \nJeffrey, having intercourse, and making $1 ,000, \nand she denied it and said that he doesn't do that \nkind of thing, he just plays with them. \nQ \nOkay. So she said that he didn't have \nintercourse, he just liked to play with the girls? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nAnd when you spoke with the police, you \nsaid that Jeffrey liked to masturbate in front of \nthe girls but not have sex? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nwhat led you to believe that? \nA \nHe just did it. \nI just learned that \nEpstein just started masturbating in front of \neverybody. It was like the new thing for him, and \nit just started happening and more and more \nwere making comments. \nSo did \nknow that he was \nmasturbating in frcnt of the girls? \nA \nNot that I know of. \nI didn't say \nanything and I don't think she had an idea. \nI \nthink she knew there was playing going on. \nI \ndon't think she knew of what sort. \nOkay. So she knew that something sexual \nwas going on, but not necessarily what that \ngirls \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226546\n", "char_count": 1168}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 151, "text_content": "31 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nentailed? \nA \nCorrect. \nQ \nOkay. Did Jeffrey or \nor anyone \nelse who worked for Mr. Epstein ever ask you for \nproof of someone's age? \nA \nNever. \nQ \nDid they ever specifically instruct you \nthat you shouldn't bring girls who were under age \nto the house? \nA \nNever. \nQ \nAnd when you spoke with the police \ndepartment you said that at some point Jeffrey \nsaid the younger the better? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nAnd even after that he never said to you \nbut make sure that they are over 18? \nA \nWe never discussed age. He never made a \ncomment about age except for Rachel that one time \nabout her being too old. \nHe never told me to go \nfind under aged girls, but at the same time never \nsaid make sure they are over 18. \nIt was never \ndiscussed. \nQ \nOkay. \nAll right. \nMS. \nIII going to ask you to \nstep outside for a minute and I will find out \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226547\n", "char_count": 995}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 152, "text_content": "32 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nif the grand jury has questions. Thank you \nvery much. \n(Witness exits the Grand Jury Room.) \n* * * \n(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room.) \nBY MS. \nQ \nMs. \nI have to remind you that \nyou are still under oath. There were just two \nfollow-up questions. The first one is something \nthat I think you spoke about earlier, but who \nfirst asked you to find other girls? \nA \nWho first asked me to first other girls? \nQ \nYes. \nA \nThat would be Epstein. \nQ \nOkay. So Jeffrey asked you himself, \nJeffrey Epstein himself asked you? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay. And then the other question was: \nAre you currently in contact with anyone who works \nfor Mr. Epstein or himself? \nA \nI don't talk to any of the lemales that \nI once brought over there. \nI haven't been in \ncontact with Epstein for years. \nHe tried \ncontacting me a few times. \nI haven't contacted him back. \nI refuse \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226548\n", "char_count": 1015}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 153, "text_content": "33 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nto talk to him. \nI refuse to talk to any of the \ngirls that were involved. However, I did live \nwith one of the girls in Orlando for a couple \nmonths to a year. \nI haven't spoken to her in over \na year either. \n• \nOkay. So after -- and just so the grand \njury has a sense here, we are talking about the \n2004 to 2005 period is when you were bringing \ngirls over? \nA \nThat's correct. \nQ \nSo since then --\nA \nI don't -- to be honest with you, I \nthink it was more 2003, 2004. \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nMy junior senior year. \nQ \nOkay. But anyhow it was a couple of \nyears ago? \nA \nSeveral years ago. \n• \nOkay. \nMS. \nIs there any Iollow up \non either of those points? Yes, ma'am. \nA GRAND JUROR: Was it Jeffrey Epstein \nh imself trying to contact you or \nTHE WITNESS: \nI don't know if it was him \ndirectly. \nI know that his number showed up \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226549\n", "char_count": 985}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 154, "text_content": "3e \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \non my house phone. \nI'm assuming because \nSarah was there, I'm assuming that she is the \none that has been trying to contact me in the \npast years. \nEpstein never talked directly to \nme on the phone. \nMS. \nAny other follow up? \nOkay. Thank you, ma'am. \nThank you for \ncoming. \n(Witness was excused.) \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \nI, Paula E. Angelocci, Certified Court \nReporter and Notary Public, do certify that the \ntranscript is a true and correct transcription of \nmy stenotype notes of the testimony of \ntaken before the Federal Grand Jury, \nWest Palm Beach, Florida. \nCert ified Court Reporter \nAULA\nE. ANGE \nCCI, CSR #4869 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226550\n", "char_count": 783}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 155, "text_content": "035 \n2-9O1  \n \netoerfreat-\ntyinsiocethicTA\nOsetS Ey T \na0ClarAtet6.14\nfitiektel\n nF •tuadj Anti \nThar \nIS \nOWSU-q_ \nU4ct se__ER-artinve -  \nLorr-\n-ctiAxr_:-Set2car \n-)RAfr pulvence.r. \nn+eme Alec \nihs5mta visa  bulk \nerw-, tau Olks \nVow \nwas) afar any SAN art /4,/f \nGAM6l4EC_ACC_____ \n--Sat- _wail Scricg i\ng\nivs-waciuS \n/ Am \nC.10044 Jam_  GC 14€ i lom-)  \n1cts.64c14-Wie- Cmg.se Plesc \nTS-) diner-40: \n-eAcm Onfecreilabei \n71-Cle{ \ntizsith \nETA r \n__Sr co \nAu. },Sr-c/ \nAraf3 \n..s..r4Sonl_eildilebk \n• \nNon \n__Spat \ngnannr_7 \nWino& \noc \n_AZIONIZUM W \n_ \nnothnobi \nOtogenosticieleit \nfrget 5//no/n& CAusa :Thar Tssua \n-Cs& 34, \nasr to1/41eis _Sion* Mends+ \n14W6}5&ilAtEgq-  Beirrifrawebilesectsa \nlgoscaosits - \nIlikthfr \nSett-NAS thavir ASZEN ISSiA4ft 7\nAn) Ws, gAure_yzi. ticcemp \nRezreASE \nfleAsE \nno-die-f4ARRA \nP-008543 \nExhibit 23 \nEFTA00226551\n", "char_count": 853}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 156, "text_content": "Mes, I wu. &L a- 5/A \n4peEtabikU- -m -ra-nry \natr \n7-Loo ADDITIon)Ai_. kweRviems- &Ymer& \nPizezees 7NE Mcez6e CrieermeL • \neet-teib tAS \ntee \ncF Vaux- Aime AND mn) Wom \n7/51A. \n,emeLor • \nsew cne ce -rite- OkSe AceMIS Assica.let Tb \ncenta) \nLee) \\MAR? \nDID \\PA feele•fi \n@et./ \ningeemezA.) \nferkt-t M \n? \"-UV° g? \nLA>10 \n-r-e.e57? \nis sscrsovr.' 08) \n14- Wriev LYD youL. thrfeRtne.A) /tg 7 \nPte,' Da) MS • MiLuee.. ;pige It≥ 72/e.. Aličinnonf oc \nWr-oeceree \n• tata, u•dt \nDib \nFAUX *O9tCrEl Pb 79 \nTb it•JTbXV/eLV \n4414-\n/mer evesbuel) 7.n\n-:AÉ/OZ \nr6/ tčcoete iNvotaiez, bib Vat 77Z,S \neireevickv \nMIL-LaZ? &utile weraveD \n. \n-My rD leve tek bwrE A stetem4-\n. \ncri Mir \nor nes cen (.1ty.) \n. Lyse tint \n-17-Arite nee, \nµs. \ncerre, Alo Arneni? \nLalo L‘yts en? \nreqb \nWer ernieeey? \navete Si-fr te° AN 'enlevai/ bt& M. Mit..te-X \n1. heurt -  7D te: //vreainerveb \nMai MW? \nlEbD Ileč6Anct be»erge» ARTI-ArierZE \nJ. &Fies cÉ /mmuivirui? \nu..kts s•tie- gaieté)] \n60,10 was FREIVUI- 2 \n-1;Lettikr bit J1C \nem__Aecew-  eirray 0°Su? \n- - bipw va) Dit, Sée sh-v se\n-ma bak)fo siKr pet \nMer \n/Ma npistrsee_eteAdie \nte-MeaVare \nSei( \nEFTA00226552\n", "char_count": 1138}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 157, "text_content": "WHAT bib ,.5116 7ZU yak. iA  comfar cco../xxiz \nbuigiN4 \ni-LASGerett-S? \n-7cft-eas \ninbIZ \nHe MASnAkertr731) \n- 40CM!) \nnMC \ngelt2F0cme MiNzasss \n5A iN NO TO \nINCA - 0 .1944T7C P1301A77;46 \nAS \n- \npp\ny \nk \n4 34,94\n1)(.7u2i..5 \nIPCS stire-\n- 0V THE omrs Oeivnrief), day MA \nin.k.4 \nizAteetele-\n• - -1-1Av6 Avy_cF- rani eAce s \nfetotgr\nfraiss \n77Pe- TP46-? \nbfaw \nWoastrMENts A4A2E.? \nMIS axAN) c.cAckft-D? \nuficin.mpite A(~e2E 'MAT \nCaANSV1- \ns /AiKcif.MEL -Mar AC- LA.As \n&dm /Nuts nalireb r62 TPWASZ/A/c1 lb eiv6.46E \nrN f34fls7)1l27ON Liji7H- A MiA/674,40,10,  gic7663:15 \nMAIVAlo APR:WOW-AO PKia. 71) TNf 7X,Ii42.7 \n-7Avriuv4 &se 7-i147- sunzol Ceiktist) \n-I! bp Ms. 144-1-6( PC-SCAlee VC WAS 7NA-r.Shr \n2..twaolr ova c \nGIALs && 10 Loy< \nLA/et—Mg.\nErsie?Ai Lan hie Ls bum, (..ocKeziuxe- rk-R? \nou) (,cyti Mg -Aku-oe. pr Tit- Time-\n6 SiiC MEN77crub-D FIAT vie- bt)As -rya \nwitc /8 ovvo 77#47 \nMD 4 FAKE-\n-AD Ms. Pia-4...CA \n70-L. *Lc 7}/47- Cosi-c,„_)\nIfei-Lent Ac.K\n1 \n1/92 AtiC?ASKeb \nTo \nArty ItenmpicAno,..,\nAnn/ Gras NE bray '7 UNE? \ncarry Nor \nslit- \n44-0\n-   A MrSTME-. \n- lie 5774-i- PAO THC-\nGaLti-tio IT L£T 146-g \nDb714£ Main \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-008545 \nEFTA00226553\n", "char_count": 1192}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 158, "text_content": "Ld>vvniiive \n-th \nPeenntv,-) Fez \n7C1-7-nuarui 7U) \nA iws \nslew bwrei \nE WHO/5\"/ CtrySinEn \n70 ec- AN afeeZT \n/AI Tliese %y Pas cr \n• \nCASES? \nrr \nTo Tanni \neaftl &us-Fie-be/1S AN &Peer flu \nrJrjeleri. hue Snire Caws /iv owes niAr kiiteue \n• GurtAT HE CA C. (S reel/air \nvicrieuç \n. \nbalm ece...s He \nCee-iruiler Vows. \n„/Aloojez (A.)aetts, mfrvar-S mye ARC.-  attwatà \n„ \n.SEXUAL Acnveny, au - talc ht Ale \n. \nce Reita Ar Cumper 0X Seieeel \nDer Me4-7 7 \n„ Dneercucnes\nikhe - \n'21'.\ne.\nb•4-• APE age \nIVORY IneVeliewme \nIliac \n71,11C3 of\" Vicrims? \n-tEeiv \n-m,p(miee \n- aNw ea_ eveynieia MAT tizietei5vea \nApex le-veceem4 »aver own-, \ner si viauet \ns 7-52->r vole/ byRxvienàs /Al OILS \nCASC? \n;boes it- A Leo 4t: apterse J/4mzett-\n, \nwoute An) CFrelvbf.4 SaeCT 771C \n. \nvic.17ms -ner eve /Mize /Ai 7I//S Ye\n.\nCC,I \nRL. \nfié -17 WiteS• ()Lb ?_,) \n4\nweAnu-te \nu \n- \nSF-)cu./4t \n eseeenpve,EL \n- Efrisl 7b MAMPut_ArC \n( War r,5 6RoOMiNei \ndua) \ntA4Dcei,riuti ttFert. \nI \nlb frieweltleelln07@te-retit.RA \nP-008546 \nEFTA00226554\n", "char_count": 1024}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 159, "text_content": "45teggits \nn' o Ent-0N use Gtoommic) oN nic GAS \nluvow cz wsi THIS \n- CM' le- if we-  \nExpv man ? \nibm µR Z.ANA-Mici Exasov wily T /s 1HAT 7PC \n, -4.4es-fMcfrifeEtttra--ePa_ \nI A C.onwt--/AAIT GH/Lb Vain WAT LaAal \n. CCA6fax W 1-ie-  \n \nWłokus-7 . \n/A1S-ML4crion.) S \nbuDicrmENT \nINTRoDtacTior-) \n- AI\n-Se-\n- \nm \n-JeC.,  G \ny PER/ o i•-1 \noF E.4.4oeNce..- In.) 746 CASE-\n-Iwo prom /159n \n...SEAKCE OF \nIS EOME--\n. \n-1/vAAVt6wS \nfan \nCal TIRQUeb (14-4-5\n- Inn clArtiocet by f& I \n- INMAVIEWS \n61tiLS, jfecgoaVcS \nPriONC k.00 0,0 S \nRitn e-65 \nP/M,44043/6/Frś \n- liesrvez- 4.. atri eS Aderwr /-tmolpiays \n- °WM bonn.\" \ngotar-E, - CoepotArt tauilaSS \n--IINAUj 2.G DATĄ \nfitj1R3F Hr\") \n-CALLS r Ecin \nes \nAlg** \nfaeOrAla \n%ki5t4/ 11266§5 47 \nEFTA00226555\n", "char_count": 751}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 160, "text_content": ",— \n-- \nIs -rtie iNvesticiA710^-1 (won ts.)u.thlca \n_ \n_ \nTea( !IQ e4 ro Lac.orre\" ANO ihrrestiltoJ mom__ \neutt-57 \n27-Csal ID 7146 SettiAcaviDeAlCaSfliatrlisa \nlit -O Sgt .ACTSr liana \n70_ %Sikh/ea_  hoes .2112,5_ _ \n- -AND crAsAiSfa \nAt 145 \nAatir \" Weir\nnc  \n/ - 1411-0/ \nyou rE6r/r/a) attua- AeoL.L.r \nravnets tertee viis cen .2teRy \nDO8 \nSSE Dcalteig1)Liktu 946.ae-RLtie_ TD fEittittfrt_. \n.61\" 2  inzr-c—ScaS \n4-vtati5C-11-t-\nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-008548 \nEFTA00226556\n", "char_count": 483}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 161, "text_content": "EFTA00226557\n", "char_count": 13}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 162, "text_content": "Page \"I \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nIN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \nFederal Grand Jury, 07-103 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \nMay 8, 2007 \nAPPEARANCES: \nESQUIRE \nAssistant United States Attorney \n, Foreperson \nTESTIMONY \nOF \nExhibit 24 \nEFTA00226558\n", "char_count": 275}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 163, "text_content": "Pag \n1 \nThe sworn testimony ofIIIIIIIIIIII \n2 \nwas taken before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm \n3 \nBeach Division, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, \n4 \nState of Florida, on the 8th day of May, 2007. \n5 \nPhilip W. May, Court Reporter, was authorized to \n6 \nand did report the sworn testimony. \n7 \n14 \n15 \n:6 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nEFTA00226559\n", "char_count": 363}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 164, "text_content": "Page 3 \n1 \n(The witness entered the grand jury room.) \n2 \n3 \nhaving been duly sworn by the grand jury foreperson, \n4 \nwas examined and testified on her oath as follows: \n5 \nEXAMINATION \n6 \nBY MS. \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nCould you start by reminding us of your name and \nwhere you're employed. \nA \nI work for the FBI here in West \nPalm Beach on their violent crimes squad. \nQ \nAnd you are one of the case agents in Operation \nLeap Year? \nA \nYes, I am. \nQ \nDid you recently participate in an interview of \nA \nYes. \n• \nCan you tell us \ns date of birth? \nA \nA \nQ \nA \nTatum was born on July 26, 1988. \nAnd you spoke with her recently? \nYes, we did. \nSo she was 18 at the time of the interview? \nYes, I believe she was. \nWho is Tatum Miller? \nwas identified by the Palm Beach \nEFTA00226560\n", "char_count": 834}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 165, "text_content": "Page 4 \n1 \nPolice Department as one of the girls who had frequented \n2 \nMr. Epstein's house. \n3 \nQ \nHow exactly did the Palm Beach Police Department \n4 \ndetermine that she was one of those girls? \nA \nWhen they did their search warrant at \n6 \nMr. Epstein's residence, some message pads were obtained \n7 \nat his residence, and they had several calls from a girl \n8 \nnamed Tatum, and phone numbers. So they were able to \n9 \ntrack back those messages back to \n10 \nQ \nDid the Palm Beach Police Department try to \n11 \ninterview Miss \n12 \nA \nThey did. \n13 \nQ \nDid she agree to speak with them? \n14 \nA \nNo. She stated that she loved Jeffrey Epstein, \n15 \nand that she would not say anything positive or negative \n76 \nabout what occurred. \n17 \nQ \nAfter the FBI became involved in this \n8 \ninvestigation, did you try to interview \n19 \nA \nWe did, as well, with no such luck, as well. \nJ 0 \nQ \nHow long ago was it that you first made contact \n21 \nwith Miss Miller? \n22 \nA \nIt was back in November of '06. \n23 \nQ \nDid you try to serve her with a subpoena issued \n24 \non behalf of this grand jury? \n25 \nA \nYes, we did. \nEFTA00226561\n", "char_count": 1119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 166, "text_content": "Page 5 \n1 \nQ \nWhat happened? \n2 \nA \nShe refused service of the grand jury subpoena. \n3 \nBut she was notified of when her appearance was expected \n4 \nhere, and a subpoena was left with her. \n5 \nQ \nAfter that, did she obtain an attorney? \n6 \nA \nYes, she did. \nQ \nWho was that? \n8 \nA \nJim Eisenberg. He's a well-known defense \n9 \nattorney here in West Palm Beach. \n10 \nQ \nWho paid for that attorney? \n11 \nA \nMr. Epstein is paying for \nattorney. \n12 \nQ \nNow once Miss \nsecured the attorney, did \n13 \nshe agree to be interviewed? \n14 \nA \nYes, she did, after she was granted 6001 \n15 \nimmunity. She requested immunity. \n16 \nQ \nDid the justice department authorize that grant \n17 \nof immunity? \n18 \nA \nYes, they did. \n19 \nQ \nAfter that, did she agree to be interviewed? \n20 \nA \nYeah. It was only after she was given that \n21 \nimmunity that she would talk with us. \n22 \nQ \nWhen did the interview take place? \n23 \nA \nIt took place at the end of April of this year, \n24 \nso just a few weeks ago. \n25 \nQ \nWho was present at that interview? \nEFTA00226562\n", "char_count": 1043}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 167, "text_content": "Page 6 \n1 \nA \nMyself; my partner, agent Richards; the AUSA, \n2 \n;\nher attorney, Jim Eisenberg, and his \n3 \ninvestigator; as well as\n4 \nQ \nWhat did Miss \ntell you about Jeffrey \n5 \nEpstein? \n6 \nA \nShe stated that she had met an individual by the \n7 \nname of Caroline at a party who had asked her if she \n8 \nwanted to make a few bucks by giving a man a massage. She \n9 \nwas told that Mr. Epstein preferred them to be topless, \n10 \nand she agreed to go to his house to give him a massage. \n11 \nQ \nHow old did Miss MI \ntell you she was at that \n12 \ntime? \n13 \nA \nShe stated she was 16 when she first started \n14 \ngiving Mr. Epstein massages. \n15 \nQ \nBased upon your review of the evidence, is that \n16 \ncorrect? \n17 \nA \nNo. We have phone records where Sara Kellin \n18 \n(phonetic), Mr. Epstein's assistant, is contacting \n19 \non her cell phone, or using her cell phone to call Tatum's \n20 \ncell phone starting in April of 2004, which makes \n21 \n15. \n22 \nQ \nSo she said that she was 16, but your evidence \n23 \nshows that she was 15, and she said that she was told she \n24 \ncould make a few bucks giving a topless massage? \n25 \nA \nYes. \nEFTA00226563\n", "char_count": 1143}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 168, "text_content": "Page 7 \n1 \nQ \nWhat else did Miss \ntell you? \n2 \nA \nThat she went to Mr. Epstein's residence, that \n3 \nCaroline took her there the first time, that when she went \n4 \nupstairs she was paid $200 when she first got there by \nS \nSara Kellin. Then she goes upstairs, and Mr. Epstein \n6 \ncomes in, he disrobes, puts on a towel, lays down on the \n7 \nmassage table and she begins to massage him. \n8 \nShe tells Epstein that she heard he likes \n9 \ntopless massages, and he told her that he did. And she \n10 \nsaid, \"Who wouldn't?\" And she ended up taking of her top \n11 \nduring the first massage. But \nis clear that Mr. \n12 \nEpstein did not at any point touch her during the massage. \n13 \nQ \nBut does she admit that he touched himself? \n14 \nA \nYes. On the second massage, Mr. Epstein asked \n15 \nher to leave her phone number with Sara. Her phone number \n16 \nwas left there. On the second massage, she returned the \n17 \nvery next day and gave him another massage. This time, \n18 \nMr. Epstein masturbated in Iront of her. \n19 \nQ \nDid Miss Miller admit that he masturbated on \nZ 0 \nmore than one occasion in her presence? \n21 \nA \nYes, masturbated. And I think her term was that \n22 \nhe \"released,\" meaning that he ejaculated. \n73 \nQ \nHow long of a period of time did Miss \n24 \ntell you that she performed massages? \n25 \nA \nShe wasn't able to give us a number of massages, \nEFTA00226564\n", "char_count": 1371}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 169, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 8 \nbut just said that it was a lot, and that she had been \ngiving him massages lor a year. \nQ \nYou mentioned to the grand jury that Miss \nsaid that Mr. Epstein never touched her, correct? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd she was very adamant about that? \nA \nYes, she was. \nQ \nWere there other things that she was adamant \nabout in her interview with you? \nA \nwell, she talked about what she would tell the \ngirls that -- and that she told Mr. Epstein that she was \n18. I'm sorry, I take that back. She was told to say \nthat she was 18, and she told us that she had a fake I.D. \nshowing that she was 18. \nSo she passed that information along to the \nother girls when she brought -- eventually she brought \nother girls to perform massages, and that was one of the \nthings that she told -- she told us first that she brought \n18- to 20-year old girls. And then she stated that if the \ngirls lied, and they were underage, she told them that \nthey needed to tell Epstein that they were 18. \nQ \nHave you been able to identify some of the girls \nthat Miss \nbrought to Mr. Epstein's home? \nA \nYes. \n• \nWere any of those girls over 18? \nEFTA00226565\n", "char_count": 1221}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 170, "text_content": "Page 9 \n1 \nA \nNo, not that we found so far. \n2 \nQ \nHave any of the girls told investigators about \n3 \nwhat Mr. Epstein knew about their ages? \n4 \nA \nI'm sorry, say that again. \n5 \nQ \nHave any of the girls who came through Tatum \n6 \nbeen interviewed about what Mr. Epstein knew about \n7 \ntheir ages? \n8 \nA \nWe did interview them regarding that, and I'm \n9 \nnot sure if he asked them. They were all told to say they \n10 \nwere 18, but not on every occasion would Mr. Epstein \n11 \ninquire about their age. \n12 \nQ \nDo you want to check your records on that? \n13 \nA \nYes, could I do that? \n14 \nQ \nYes, please do. \n15 \nA \nI can tell you that one of the girls that she \n16 \nbrought -- this girl told Mr. Epstein that she was in high \n17 \nschool, and actually told him her true age, which was \n18 \nunder 18. \n19 \nQ \nSo what \ntold you about, that wasn't \n20 \nreally the case? \n21 \nA \nNo, that wasn't. Sorry. \n22 \nQ \nThat's all right, I just wanted to make sure \n23 \nit's clear. \n24 \nSo Miss \ntold you that she had been told \n25 \nto say she was 18, and she also told you that she had a \nEFTA00226566\n", "char_count": 1089}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 171, "text_content": "Page 10 \n1 \nfake I.D.? \n2 \nA \nYes. \n3 \nQ \nDid she ever say that Mr. Epstein either asked \n4 \nfor her age or asked to see her I.D.? \n5 \nA \nNo, the topic never came up. \n6 \nQ \nDid you also ask her about how appointments were \n7 \nmade? \n8 \nA \nYes. She was very clear in the fact that Sara \n9 \nKellin would call her to arrange the appointments, but \n10 \nthat Sara Kellin would call her once Jeffrey was in town. \n11 \nQ \nSo she was adamant that the calls only happened \n12 \nwhen she was already here? \n13 \nA \nYes. \n14 \nQ \nWere you made aware that Epstein's counsel was \n15 \ninformed that he was being investigated for traveling to \n16 \nengage in prostitution, which means that the appointments \n17 \nwould have been made before the traveling? \n18 \nA \nYes. \n19 \nQ \nWas there anything else, besides the issue of \n20 \nage and the issue of when the appointments were made, that \n21 \nsounded coached or that she was especially adamant about? \n22 \nA \nNo, I wouldn't say coached. I mean, we talked \n23 \nabout the preferences that Jeffrey discussed, as far as \n24 \nwhich girls he would like \nto bring. \n25 \nOnce \nstarted giving massages to Epstein, \nEFTA00226567\n", "char_count": 1149}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 172, "text_content": "Page 11 \ntold us that he liked different faces, so he would \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \nQ \nAnd he didn't allow that girl to perform a \n18 \nmassage? \n19 \nA \nNo. \n20 \nQ \nwas there anything else that Miss Miller talked \n21 \nabout in the interview that you want to share with the \n22 \ngrand jury? \n23 \n24 \nwas in love with Mr. Epstein. She looked into the camera \n25 \nand said that she loved him like a friend. But then she \nask her to bring other girls. We asked her if he ever \ngave any preferences of what he preferred, and her \nresponse was that Epstein liked girls like her, which is \nthin and blond and attractive. \nQ \nAnd how old was she at the time? \nA \nShe was 15. \nQ \nSo thin, blonde, attractive and --\nA \nYoung, girls like her. I guess we asked if she \never made a mistake, or ever brought somebody that Mr. \nEpstein didn't take to. She said that she had screwed up \nand that she had brought a black girl to Mr. Epstein, and \nthat Epstein was not interested in black girls. But he \ndid pay her, and said that he wasn't a racist. He paid \nher the S200 for her time, but did not want her to perform \na massage for him. \nA \nI did ask her at the end of the interview if she \nEFTA00226568\n", "char_count": 1220}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 173, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 12 \nkind of looked into the camera and gave a wink and a smile \nand said, \"But with your money, I'd marry you any time, \nJeffrey.\" \nQ \nDid she also say that she considered him to be \nan \"awesome guy\"? \nA \nSeveral times she referred to him as an \"awesome \nguy\". She said that the girls begged her to come and that \nthe girls didn't have a complaint, and the girls would \nshare with her everything that happened after the massage, \nand that Jeffrey never touched any of the girls. But as I \ninformed you, we did interview some of the girls that she \ntook, and he has touched them. \nQ \nIn preparation for your testimony today, did you \nalso speak with someone who is considered to be an expert \nin these cases? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd what is that person's name? \nA \nKen Lanning. \nQ \nHas Mr. Lanning been qualified to testify as an \nexpert in federal and state courts in cases that involve \nwhat he calls \"compliant victims\"? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nWhat does he mean by the term \"compliant \nvictims\"? \nA \nA compliant victim is when a victim is not \nEFTA00226569\n", "char_count": 1135}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 174, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 13 \nnecessarily forced into the conduct that the offender \nwants them to engage into, that they actually consent to \nthat kind of activity. \nQ \nSo that would include minors who are subjected \nto sexual activity but weren't necessarily kidnapped or \nforced at gunpoint, or something like that? \nA \nExactly. \nQ \nDid he discuss with you the difficulties that \nexist when you interview those types of victims? \nA \nYes. He stated that a compliant victim is often \ntimes embarrassed that they went along with the behavior. \nThey are also likely to deny the behavior, especially when \nbeing interviewed by investigators, that they'll deny it \nor they'll minimize it. Sometimes it takes two, three or \nmultiple interviews to get compliant victims to either \ntrust their interviewer or realize that their interviewer \nis not going to be judgemental. \nQ \nIn this case, have you found that to be the case \nwith some of the interviews? \nA \nYes, I have. \nQ \nIn addition to being embarrassed, sometimes \nthese victims feel guilty about the fact that they were \ninvolved in this type of activity? \nA \nOh, yes. \nQ \nDoes Mr. Lanning also have expertise in sexual \nEFTA00226570\n", "char_count": 1256}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 175, "text_content": "Page 14 \n1 \npreference of offenders? \n2 \nA \nYes, he does. \n3 \nQ \nDid he explain why an offender would select the \n4 \ntypes of victims that are involved in this case, girls \n5 \nbetween 14 and 17-years-old? \n6 \nA \nThis type of offender, the sexual preference he \n7 \nhas is for post-pubescent females that are physically \n8 \ndeveloped but not necessarily mentally matured. The girls \n9 \nranging in this age are sometimes inexperienced, they are \n10 \npossibly naive, not as worldly. \n11 \nAn offender of this type could also maybe not \n12 \nfeel sexually adequate or feel competent dealing with his \n13 \nown age group. So knowing that these girls are less \n14 \nexperienced, may focus on them as well. \n15 \nQ \nIn addition to their emotional immaturity, did \n16 \nMr. Lanning talk about whether or not younger girls are \n17 \neasier to manipulate than grown women? \n18 \nA \nYes. \n19 \nQ \nDid he talk to you about \"grooming\"? \n20 \nA \nYeah. That's what an offender will use with a \n21 \ncompliant victim. He told us that grooming is a technique \n22 \nwhere you gain the cooperation of those victims by \n23 \nfocusing on their interests and playing up to those \n24 \ninterests. It's a type of seduction, he called it. That \n25 \nwas his words for it. And we actually see this in this \nEFTA00226571\n", "char_count": 1278}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 176, "text_content": "Page 15 \ncase. \n2 \nQ \nCan you give us an example of some of the types \n3 \nof grooming that Mr. Epstein used? \n4 \nS \ntoday, \nP., it's very apparent interviewing her how \n6 \nEpstein groomed her. She only went to three or lour \n7 \nmassages at this time, that she's admitted to. We feel \n8 \nthat due to her phone conversations, the multiple calls, \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \nthat shyness. He told her that she was pretty. He asked \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nbit more -- I guess he sees that it's not working. This \nA \nWith one of the girls we're going to talk about \nthat there may be more there. At this point she has \nstated to us that she has performed three or four massages \nfor Mr. Epstein. \nWhat he did is when she first went there he \nplayed upon -- she was very shy, and he would play upon \nher to remove her clothing, and she would not. So he kind \nof kidded around with her shyness and complimented her, \nshowed interest in her, talked about her boyfriend and \ndifferent interests she had. \nAt the end of that interview, because she did \nnot take off her clothes, he tells her that if she's \nwilling to do more, she will make more. He also tells her \nthat he would pay her if she would bring other girls. As \nthe massages increased, you can see that the next time she \ncomes he plays again to that shyness, but he gets a little \nEFTA00226572\n", "char_count": 1364}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 177, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n:7 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 16 \ntime she does comply and takes off her -- he asked her to \ndisrobe on the second massage. She takes off her blouse, \nbut she refuses to take off the bra after Mr. Epstein \nasked her to. \nSo you can see that he tries through showing \ninterest. And then he actually -- when he sees that this \nisn't working, he takes a more authoritative role with her \nin the last massage. She said that throughout all of \nthese massages he was very nice, and then at the end he \nwas much more frustrated and irritated. She does get down \nto her bra and panties on that one, he's just much \nmore authoritative. \nSo he started with the grooming process, tried \nto get her interest, tried to use that to get her to \ncomply with removing her clothes. But as often happens, \nat the end of this, he took over and was much more \nforceful with his requests. \nQ \nHave other girls described that same situation \nwhere every time they went back, he tried to push it one \nstep further and one step further? \nA \nYes. Several of the girls have said that he \nwould always push for more and more. \nQ \nDid Mr. Lanning explain why it is that a \ncompliant child victim cannot legally consent to the \nsexual conduct? \nEFTA00226573\n", "char_count": 1294}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 178, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 17 \nA \nYeah. He stated that -- you know, we talked \nabout how the law protects children, and stated that we \nhold adults accountable. When it comes to adolescents, \nthey go through normal tendencies that mature offenders \nmay try to take advantage of. But the law is in place lor \nthat reason, to protect -- in the federal law, to protect \nthose individuals under the age of 18. \n• \nAnd that's because of the different maturity \nlevels of the --\nA \nThe offender versus the victims, exactly. \nQ \nDid you put together the photographs of the \ndefendants in this case? \nA \nYes, I did. \nQ \nAre these photographs of the four human \ndefendants who are named in the proposed indictment? \nA \nYes. \n• \nWith their names underneath them? \nA \nYes. \n• \nAgent, who is in the top left-hand corner? \nA \nThat's Jeffrey Epstein. \nQ \nWhen was this photograph taken? \nA \nRecently. There was an article that just came \nout regarding Mr. Epstein and his connection, or his \npersonal relationship with Prince Andrew, and that was a \npicture that was in that article. \nEFTA00226574\n", "char_count": 1153}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 179, "text_content": "Page 18 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nWho is in the to ri ht-hand corner? \nA \nThat's \nQ \nAgain, this is a relatively recent photograph? \nA \nYes, that's his personal assistant. \nQ \nAnd the bottom left-hand corner? \nA \nAgain, that is one of Mr. Epstein's personal \nassistants, that's Adriana Mousenska (phonetic). \nHas Miss Mousenska since gotten married? \nA \nYes, her name now is \nQ \nAnd the bottom right-hand corner? \nA \nThat is \nShe is, again, a \npersonal assistant to Mr. Epstein. There has been some \ntalk that she is also romantically -- or I should say \nsexually involved with Mr. Epstein. \nQ \nHow old are the defendants? \nA \nJeffrey is in his mid-fifties, and the three \ngirls are in their early twenties. \nDo you have a copy of the draft indictment in \nfront of you? \nA \nYes, I do. \nYou mentioned when we were looking at the \nphotographs that the three females work as personal \nassistants for Mr. Epstein, is that correct? \nA \nYes. \nSo he is their employer? \nEFTA00226575\n", "char_count": 1045}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 180, "text_content": "Page : 0\nA \nYes. \n2 \nQ \nAre you familiar with the property located at \n3 \n358 El Brillo Way in Palm Beach? \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \nEpstein. He is the president, the owner, the sole \n10 \ndirector. It's a business that is solely used for the \n11 \nactivities of one of Mr. Epstein's airplanes, which is his \n12 \nBoeing 727. Its tail number is N908JE. \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \nowned by Mr. Epstein. He is also the president, the \n19 \ndirector and the sole shareholder of that company as well. \n20 \nThat company solely does business with his other aircraft, \n21 \nwhich is a Gulf Stream G-1159B. It bears a tail number \n22 \nN909JE. \n23 \nQ \nIs that a smaller aircraft than the Boeing? \n24 \nA \nYes. \n25 \nQ \nJust to briefly remind the grand jury about \nA \nThat's Mr. Epstein residence. \nQ \nAnd he owns that residence? \nA \nYes, he does. \nQ \nAre you familiar with Defendant J.E.G.E., Inc.? \nA \nYes. J.E.G.E., Inc. is owned by Jeffrey \nQ \nAnd you mentioned that he is the president and \nthe sole director. Is he also the sole shareholder? \nA \nYes, he is. \nQ \nAre you familiar with Hyperion Air, Inc.? \nA \nYes. Hyperion Air, Inc. is also a business \nEFTA00226576\n", "char_count": 1145}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 181, "text_content": "Page 20 \n1 \nwhere the evidence has been collected in this case, was \n2 \nthe start of your investigation information that you \n3 \nreceived from the Palm Beach Police Department? \n4 \nA \nYes, it was. \n5 \nQ \nAnd that included evidence seized during a \n6 \nsearch of Mr. Epstein's home at El Brillo way? \n7 \nA \nYes. \n8 \nQ \nAlso controlled calls that the Palm Beach Police \n9 \nDepartment placed? \n10 \nA \nYes. \n11 \nQ \nAnd interviews of girls and other people by the \n12 \nPalm Beach Police Department? \n13 \nA \nYes, as well as trash pulls that the Palm Beach \n14 \nPolice Department conducted on Mr. Epstein's residence. \n15 \nQ \nThen when the FBI became involved, the FBI did \n16 \nadditional interviews of girls and of recruiters? \n17 \nA \nYes. \n18 \nQ \nThey obtained phone records? \n19 \nA \nYes, we have. \n20 \nQ \nAnd records of payments? \n21 \nA \nYes. \n22 \nQ \nDid this grand jury also subpoena travel \n23 \nrecords? \n24 \nA \nYes. \n25 \nQ \nIncluding the flight manifests of the planes \nEFTA00226577\n", "char_count": 981}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 182, "text_content": "Page 2\n1 \nowned by Hyperion and J.E.G.E.? \n2 \nA \nYes. \n3 \nQ \nDid you also get corporate documents related to \n4 \nthose two planes? \n5 \nA \nYes, we have. \n6 \nQ \nOnce you had obtained all of this information, \n7 \ndid the FBI analyze the data, specifically the call \n8 \ninformation and the flight information to put together a \n9 \npattern of activity by the defendants? \n10 \nA \nYes, we did. \n11 \nQ \nSo you have a series of phone calls coming from \n12 \nthese three assistants who were on the board, the two \n13 \ngirls who have been identified through this investigation? \n14 \nA \nYes. \n15 \nQ \nWhen you spoke with those girls, did any of them \n16 \ntell you that they had developed some sort of a personal \n17 \nrelationship with the assistants so that they were just \n18 \nchatting over the telephone? \n19 \nA \nNo, not at all. \n20 \nQ \nAll of them said what about the phone calls? \n21 \nA \nSaid that the phone calls were made to set up \n22 \nappointments for Mr. Epstein. \n23 \nQ \nAnd the girls referred to it as appointments to \n24 \nwork, is that right? \n25 \nA \nYes, they were appointments to work. There is \nEFTA00226578\n", "char_count": 1109}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 183, "text_content": "Page 22 \n1 \none exception, \nwe're going to talk about her \n2 \nprobably next week. She did say on one or two occasions \n3 \nthat \nhad called her when she had gone out \n4 \nto California on a trip, I believe. But that is the only \n5 \ntime that that was ever mentioned. In fact, we asked, and \n6 \nthose phone calls were made for the purpose of setting up \n7 \nappointments for Mr. Epstein. \n8 \nQ \nIs the investigation continuing? \n9 \nA \nYes, it is. \n10 \nQ \nAre you still trying to locate and interview \n11 \nmore girls? \n12 \nA \nYes. \n13 \nQ \nLet's turn to the specific evidence reporting \n14 \nthe overt acts and offenses relating to Jane Doe's 1 \n15 \nthrough 5. I know that every member of the grand jury has \n16 \na copy of the draft indictment before them, and also a \n17 \nchart. \n18 \nDo you have a copy of that chart as well? \n19 \nA \nI do. \n20 \nQ \nDo you have photographs of the five girls that \n21 \nwe are going to talk about today? \n22 \nA \nYes. \n23 \nQ \nAnd these are photographs of the people that we \n24 \nare calling Jane Doe's 1 through 5? \n25 \nA \nYes. \nEFTA00226579\n", "char_count": 1065}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 184, "text_content": "1 \n2 \nPage 23 \nQ \nAnd Jane Doe Number 1, you have previously \ntestified about her? \n3 \nA \nYes, I have, that's Haley. \n4 \nQ \nJane Doe Number 2? \n5 \nA \nThat is \nG. \n6 \nQ \nJane Doe Number 3? \n7 \nA \nThat is \nZ. \n8 \nQ \nJane Doe Number 4? \n9 \nA \nFaith P. \n10 \nQ \nAnd Jane Doe Number 5? \n11 \nA \nThat is IIIIIII E. \n12 \nJUROR: The purpose of Epstein's business with \n13 \nhis planes, did he transport? \n14 \nTHE WITNESS: To travel around. \n15 \nJUROR: So it wasn't like a business of \n16 \ntransporting other people? \n17 \nTHE WITNESS: He flew other guests, sometimes \n18 \nunaccompanied, sometimes accompanied. \n19 \n20 \nany evidence that they started young, like the rest \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nJUROR: Kellin, Ross and Marcenkova, do you have \nof the recruits? \nTHE WITNESS: we have evidence that they are his \npersonal assistants employed by him, not that it was \nanything like what we were discussing. \nJUROR: There was an allegation that was made \nEFTA00226580\n", "char_count": 949}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 185, "text_content": "Page 24 \n1 \nearlier, back in February, during one of these \n2 \ndiscussions, about a specilic act that was performed. \n3 \nCan I ask about that? We were told back in February \n4 \nthat one of the girls when interviewed had alleged \n5 \nrape, and I hadn't heard about that allegation \n6 \nrecently. \n7 \nTHE WITNESS: That's probably Jane Doe Number 6. \n8 \nWe're going to talk about her, that he lorcibly put \n9 \nher on the table and penetrated her. Yeah, she will \n10 \nbe coming up. We're going to do her probably next \n11 \nweek. She'll be the first one we'll talk about. \n12 \nBY MS. \n13 \nQ \nSo turning to Jane Doe Number 1, \nR. You\n14 \ntestified about her earlier before this grand jury, \n15 \ncorrect? \n16 \nA \nYes, I did. \n17 \nQ \nAnd she also testified before this grand jury, \n18 \ncorrect? \n19 \nA \nYes. \n20 \nQ \nCan you remind us of her date of birth? \n21 \nA \nShe was born on April 9, 1986. \n22 \nQ \nCould you briefly refresh the grand jury's \n23 \nrecollection of how she was recruited? \n24 \nA \nShe was approached on a beach by Molly Smyth and \n25 \nTony Figurello (phonetic). They approached her on a beach \nEFTA00226581\n", "char_count": 1114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 186, "text_content": "Page 25 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nand asked her if she wanted to perform massages for \nMr. Epstein and make some money. \nQ \nFrom the review of the phone records that you \nhave received, were you able to identify a telephone \nnumber associated with Tony Figurello? \nA \nYes. \nIn tact, has Tony Figurello been interviewed? \nA \nYes, he has. \nQ \nAnd has he admitted to being a recruiter for Mr. \nEpstein? \nA \nYes, recruiter and driver. \nII you could take a look at Overt Act Number 2, \nwhich appears on page five. That states, \"On or about \nMarch 12, 2004, defendants Jeffrey Epstein and Sara Kellin \ncaused Jane Doe Number 1 to travel to 358 Brillo Way of \nPalm Beach, Florida.\" \nCan you tell us what evidence you have regarding \nthat? \nA \nWe have reviewed phone records for \nand \nSara that indicate the calls took place, as well as phone \nrecords for Tony Figurello and \nand calls that took \nplace on or about those dates. We've also looked at a \nflight manifest, and were able to show that Mr. Epstein \narrived the day before, on the 11th. We also have \nstatement where she describes the sexual activity that \nEFTA00226582\n", "char_count": 1187}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 187, "text_content": "Page 26 \n1 \ntook place. \n2 \nQ \nOn that date, March 12 of 2004, \ndescribed \n3 \ngoing to Mr. Epstein's house and performing a sexual \n4 \nmassage? \n5 \nA \nYes, on or about that day. \n6 \nQ \nOn or about that date, what did \nstate \n7 \nabout being paid? \n8 \nA \nShe was paid $200. \n9 \nQ \nAnd that relates to Overt Act Number 3? \n10 \nA \nYes. \n11 \nQ \nAnd she stated that Mr. Epstein is the person \n12 \nwho gave her that? \n13 \nA \nShe told us that in her statement. \n14 \nQ \nIf you could take a look at Overt Act Number 95, \n15 \nwhich is on page 17. On or about February 6, 2005, \n16 \nEpstein had Jane Doe Number 1 to make one or more \n17 \ntelephone calls to Jane Doe Number 2. \n18 \nFirst of all, who is Jane Doe Number 2? \n19 \nA \nThat would be \nG., our youngest victim. \n20 \nQ \nCan you tell us what evidence you have related \n21 \nto that overt act? \n22 \nA \nWe have the girl's statements that calls were \n23 \nmade. We also reviewed the phone records that indicated \n24 \nthat there was telephonic contact between the numbers \n25 \nbelonging to \nand \nEFTA00226583\n", "char_count": 1047}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 188, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 27 \nQ \nAnd in the statement of both girls, did they \ndescribe that \nis the person who called \nlooking for someone to come and work at Mr. Epstein's \nhouse? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nLooking at Overt Act Number 96. On or about \nFebruary 6, 2005, Epstein caused Jane Doe Number 1 to \ntransport Jane Doe Number 2 to 358 El Brillo Way. \nWhat is the evidence related to that? \nA \nAgain, the statements of \nand ■ \nsupport \nthat as further evidence, and also reviewing the phone \nrecords they indicate that there was telephonic contact \nbetween Sara Kellin and \nand \nand \nQ \nOvert Act Number 97, on or about February 6, \n2005, Epstein made a payment of $300 to Jane Doe Number 2 \nand a payment of $200 to Jane Doe Number 1. \nWhat was the evidence of that? \nA \nBoth \nand \nstated in their statements \nthat ■ \nwas paid $300, and \nwas paid $200 for \nbringing \nQ \nDid ■ \nexplain why she was paid $300? \nA \nYes, she was paid $300 because she performed her \nmassage. Mr. Epstein digitally penetrated and used a \nmassager on Sage's vagina. \n• \nAfter this date, after February 6, 2005, was \nEFTA00226584\n", "char_count": 1171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 189, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 28 \n$300 found in ■ \nG.'s purse when it was searched at her \nschool? \nA \nYes, it was, by a school administrator. \nQ \nIf you could look at Overt Act Number 117, which \nis on page 19, and that states that on or about March 30, \n2005, Kellin caused one or more calls to be made to a \ntelephone used by Jane Doe Number 1. \nWhat evidence do you have related to that? \nA \nWe reviewed the phone records of Sara Kellin and \nthat indicate this. \nQ \nAnd Overt Act 120, on or about March 31, Kellin \ncaused one or more calls to be made to a telephone used by \nJane Doe Number 1. \nA \nAgain, we reviewed the phone records that \nindicated there was telephonic contact between the numbers \nbelonging to Sara and Haley. \nQ \nThen we have Overt Act Number 122, which is also \nMarch 31, that Epstein and Kellin caused Jane Doe Number 1 \nto make a call to a telephone used by Jane Doe Number 2. \nWhat evidence do you have related to that? \nA \nWe have phone records that we have reviewed \nbelonging to Haley and \nIn this case, we also have a \nvoice mail that was provided to us b the Palm Beach \nPolice Department, a voice mail of \nleaving a voice \nmail message on \ns phone. \nEFTA00226585\n", "char_count": 1264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 190, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 29 \nQ \nAnd Overt Act Number 123 refers to April 1st. \nWhat evidence do you have related to that? \nA \nwe have reviewed the phone records of \nand \nthat indicate telephonic contact was made on this \nday. We also again have another recorded voice mail by \nleft on \nphone. \nQ \nThese later calls, the March-April calls, are \nthose the controlled calls that the Palm Beach Police \nDepartment was involved in? \nA \nThere was controlled calls placed to \n's \ncell phone and to \nplace of work by \nunder the \nsupervision of the Palm Beach Police Department. \nof \nQ \nAnd the voice mail message that you referred to \ncalling \nwhat information was \nleaving \nin that voice mail message? \nA \nwas asking for Sage to get back in touch, \nthat she had set up an appointment for \nat Epstein's \nhouse on the following day, on that Saturday at around \n10:30 or 11:00. \nQ \nIn addition to the phone records, was there \nanything that the Palm Beach Police Department found that \nalso confirmed that this appointment actually was made. \nA \nAs I mentioned earlier, the Palm Beach Police \nDepartment was doing trash pulls on Mr. Epstein's \nresidence. In there, there were two messages or notes in \nEFTA00226586\n", "char_count": 1276}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 191, "text_content": "Page 30 \n1 \nthere on Epstein's personalized stationary. On it it \n2 \nsaid, \" \nwith Sage on Saturday at 10:30, and \non \n3 \nSaturday with \nat 10:30.\" That's the exact message on \n4 \nthe two notes that were found in his trash when they \n5 \nretrieved it on April 8. \n6 \nQ \nIf I could direct your attention to Count Number \n7 \nFive, which appears on page 26. That is the charge of \n8 \nenticement of a minor, referring to Jane Doe Number 1, and \n9 \nMr. Epstein and Miss Kellin are charged. \n10 \nI know that you talked about the telephone \n11 \ntraffic. The calls between \nand Tony Figurello, did \n12 \nthey fall within that March 7 through March 11 time \n13 \nperiod? \n14 \nA \nA review of their telephone records do indicate \n15 \nthat there were phone calls made during that time. \n16 \nQ \nAnd Jane Doe Number 1 actually went to Mr. \n17 \nEpstein's home? \n18 \nA \nYes, and performed a massage for him in the \n19 \nnude. \n20 \nQ \nAnd she was paid 'or that? \n21 \nA \nYes, she was paid $200. \n22 \nQ \nAnd he masturbated in front of her, correct? \n23 \nA \nYes, he did. I would like to include that Sara \n24 \nKellin took \nupstairs for that massage, and she also \n25 \nset up the massage table and arranged the oil and lotions \nEFTA00226587\n", "char_count": 1216}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 192, "text_content": "Page 31 \n1 \nfor \nto do that massage. \n2 \nQ \nAnd also, just so it's clear, how old was \n3 \nat that time? \n4 \nA \nShe was 17. \n5 \nMS. VILLAFANA: Are there any questions about \n6 \neither how that evidence was presented or about the \n7 \ncharges related to Jane Doe Number 1? Seeing no \n8 \nquestions, we'll turn to Jane Doe Number 2. \n9 \nBY MS. IILLAFANA: \n10 \nQ \nYou previously mentioned that that was ■ \nG.? \n11 \nA \nYes. \n12 \nQ \nLet's turn to Count Number Six, which is on page \n13 \n26, which is the enticement of ■ \nG. If you could tell \n14 \nthe grand jury about the evidence related to that. \n15 \nA \ndate of birth is \n16 \nQ \nSo during this period of February 5, 2005 to the \n17 \n6th, how old was she? \n18 \nA \nShe was 14. \n19 \nQ \nCan you remind the grand jury about the evidence \n20 \nrelated to the enticement of \n21 \nA \nAs we stated earlier, we talked about the \n22 \ntelephone calls. We have shown that the facility of \n23 \ninterstate commerce was used by the telephone calls made \n24 \nby their cell phones. We examined specifically Sara \n25 \nKellin's, \nand \nThose calls were made to \nEFTA00226588\n", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 193, "text_content": "Page 32 \n1 \nset up and arrange appointments for Mr. Epstein to have \n2 \nhis massages. \n3 \nPertaining to \nduring the massage that \n4 \noccurred on those dates, February 6, in particular, I \n5 \nthink I have discussed with you before what occurred on \n6 \nthat, that he fingered IIIII- and that was his term for \n7 \nit -- and that he used a massager on her. \n8 \nHe did masturbate during that massage, and she \n9 \nbelieved he ejaculated because he wiped off his penis with \nio \na towel. She was paid $300, and we know that she was 14 \n11 \nat the time. \n12 \nQ \nIf we could turn to Count Number 43, which \n13 \nappears on page 31. Count 43 is one of the travel counts. \n14 \nIf you could tell the grand jury, did a trip occur on \n15 \nMarch 31, 2005? \n16 \nA \nYes, we have flight records that indicate a \n17 \nflight occurred on that date. \n18 \nQ \nWhat type of plane was used? \n19 \nA \nI'm going to refer to the J.E.G.E., Incorporated \n20 \naircraft as just the Boeing 727. If we talk about the \n21 \nHyperion Air, Incorporated aircraft, which is the Gulf \n22 \nStream, I will just say the Gulf Stream. So on that date \n23 \nhe did travel on his Boeing 727, on 3-31. \n24 \nQ \nAnd Mr. Epstein was aboard the plane on that \n25 \nday? \nEFTA00226589\n", "char_count": 1226}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 194, "text_content": "Page 33 \n1 \nA \nYes, he was. \n2 \nQ \nWith respect to the March 31st trip, was there \n3 \nevidence of him setting up the appointment with ■ \nprior \n4 \nto that trip? \nA \nWe do have telephonic contact between \nand \n6 \nIIIIIIIIIII \nas well as \nand ■ \non the day before \n7 \nand the day of travel. \n8 \nQ \nAnd even though that appointment was never kept, \n9 \nthat ■ \nnever went to that appointment, you have the \n10 \nnotes that were retrieved from the garbage that showed \n11 \nthat Mr. Epstein was expecting ■ \nto show up for that \n12 \nappointment? \n13 \nA \nYes. \n14 \nQ \nAnything else with respect to that particular \n15 \ncount? \n16 \nA \nWe also have the controlled calls and the voice \n17 \nmails. \n18 \nQ \nTurning to Count Number 60, which appears on \n19 \npage 34, that is the attempted enticement of ■ \nG. \n10 \nduring the period of March 30 to April 1. \n21 \nAgain, at that point, ■ \nG. was how old? \n22 \nA \nShe was 14. \n23 \nQ \nAnd we had talked about the telephone calls that \n24 \nwere used. One of the things that is relevant to this \n25 \nparticular count was that in addition to the fact that \nEFTA00226590\n", "char_count": 1098}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 195, "text_content": "Page 34 \n1 \n■ \nG. was 14, did you interview a girl who went with \n2 \n■ \nwhen she went to Mr. Epstein's house back in \n3 \nFebruary? \n4 \nA \nYes, we did, that would be \n5 \nQ \nAnd \nwas interviewed? \n6 \nA \nYes, she was interviewed by the Palm Beach \n7 \nPolice Department. \n8 \nQ \nwhat did \nII say about \nappearance? \n9 \nA \nThat she was the youngest looking girl that \n10 \ncame. \n11 \nQ \nwhen you talked with \ndid \ntalk about \n12 \ngirls that Mr. Epstein liked in particular? \n13 \nA \nYes. \n14 \nQ \nAnd was ■ \nG. one of those girls? \n15 \nA \nYes, she was one of his preferences. \nalso \n16 \ntold us that Mr. Epstein said to her on one occasion, \"The \n17 \nyounger, the better.\" \n18 \nQ \nAnd there was never any attempt to get \n19 \nI.D. or to confirm her actual age? \n20 \nA \nNo. \n21 \nQ \nAs we discussed before, Sage never actually went \n22 \nto that point, right, so that is just an attempt? \n23 \nA \nYes. \n24 \nMS. VILLAFANA: Are there any questions from the \n25 \ngrand jury? Seeing no questions, we'll see you next \nEFTA00226591\n", "char_count": 1012}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 196, "text_content": "Page 35 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n33 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nweek. Thank you. \n(Witness excused.) \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \nI CERTIFY pages 1 to 35 is a true transcript of \nmy shorthand notes of the testimony of E. \nKUYRKENDALL, before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm \nBeach, Florida, on the 8th day of May, 2007. \nDated at West Palm Beach, Florida this 23rd day \nof May, 2007. \ntic sii>\" 4/1 4/1, \nPhilip W. May, Court Reporter \nEFTA00226592\n", "char_count": 484}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 197, "text_content": "Page 1 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nIN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \nAPP \n• \nESQUIRE \nFederal Grand Jury, 07-103 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \nMay 8, 2007 \nAssistant United States Attorney \nForeperson \nTESTIMONY \nOF \nJASON RICHARDS \nExhibit 25 \nEFTA00226593\n", "char_count": 282}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 198, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 2 \nThe sworn testimony of JASON RICHARDS was taken \nbefore the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach \nDivision, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, State \nof Florida, on the 8th day of May, 2007. \nPhilip W. May, Court Reporter, was authorized to \nand did report the sworn testimony. \nEFTA00226594\n", "char_count": 391}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 199, "text_content": "Page 3 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n(The witness entered the grand jury room.) \nJASON RICHARDS \nhaving been duly sworn by the grand jury foreperson, \nwas examined and testified on his oath as follows: \nEXAMINATION \nBY \nQ \nSpecial Agent \ncould you state and \nspell your name for the record. \nA \n• \nBy whom are you employed? \nA \nI'm employed by the FBI. \nQ \nWhat is your position with the FBI? \nA \na special agent, and have been so for four \nyears. \nQ \nAre you one of the agents assigned to the \ninvestigation known as Operation Leap Year? \nA \nYes, I am. \nQ \nWere subpoenas caused to be issued on behalf of \nthis grand jury in connection with that investigation? \nA \nYes. \n• \nAnd have documents been received in response to \nthose? \nA \nYes. \n• \nWhat additional subpoenas have been issued, and \nwhat have you received in response? \nEFTA00226595\n", "char_count": 905}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 200, "text_content": "Page 4 \nA \nAdditional subpoenas that have been issued \n2 \ninclude OLY-28 to Colonial Bank, along with OLY-29, which \n3 \nwas issued to Palm Beach National Bank & Trust Company. \n4 \nThat was served on March 5, 2007. It should be known that \n5 \nPalm Beach National Bank & Trust Company is now operated \n6 \nby Colonial Bank, which we learned in the issuance \n7 \nprocess. We did receive documents back from Colonial \n8 \nBank, which covered both subpoenas, on April 25, 2007. \n9 \nQ \nAnd those sought information relating to bank \n10 \naccounts belonging to Mr. Epstein? \n11 \nA \nThat is correct. \n12 \nQ \nWhat else? \n13 \nA \nAlso served OLY-30 to Western Union Financial \n14 \nServices seeking documents and records related to Jeffrey \n15 \nEpstein. It was served on February 26, 2007, and we \n16 \nreceived items back from Western Union on two separate \n17 \ndates, and two packages, the first on April 9, 2007, and \n18 \nthe second on April 11, 2007. \n19 \nQ \nAnd those sought records of wire transfers from \n20 \nMr. Epstein to girls whom have been identified for this \n21 \ninvestigation? \n22 \nA \nYes. \n23 \nQ \nWhat else? \n24 \nA \nWe also served OLY-31 to Western Union Financial \n25 \nServices. It was served on February 26, 2007, and they \nEFTA00226596\n", "char_count": 1238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 201, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage \nreturned information which we received on May 3, 2007. \nQ \nThe same type of information? \nA \nYes, the same type of information, seeking wire \ntransfer information from Jeffrey Epstein to victims. \nWe also served OLY-32 to J.P. Morgan Chase Bank. \nAfter serving that one on February 26, 2007, they informed \nus by letter that they are known as Chase, not J.P. Morgan \nChase. So we had to reissue another subpoena, which was \ntaken care of on March 22, '07. \nWe also issued OLY-40 on Chase Bank as well on \nApril 4, 2007. We received records on April 13, 2007 and \nApril 19, 2007 to cover all three subpoenas that were \nserved. \nQ \nAnd those sought information related to bank \naccounts and credit cards related to the defendants? \nA \nYes. Additionally, we served OLY-33 on Dr. \nThomas Rofranno (phonetic), who's a chiropractic doctor. \nWe were seeking records related to Jeffrey Epstein as a \npatient. The subpoena was served on March 6, 2007, and \nThomas Rofranno provided materials on March 16, 2007. \nAlso we have OLY-36, which was served on the \nPalm Beach County Health Department. It was served on \nMarch 5, 2007, seeking birth certificates of our victims \nthat we were researching. We received the records from \nthe Palm Beach County Health Department on April 16, 2007. \nEFTA00226597\n", "char_count": 1388}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 202, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 6 \nWe also served two subpoenas on the Adult video \nWarehouse. The first one was OLY-41, which was served --\nboth of these were served on April 24, 2007, and they were \nseeking any transactions that had occurred on behalf of \nMr. Epstein or those individuals that were working for him \nor with him. We received items back on the OLY-41 \nsubpoena on April 30, 2007. \nThe second subpoena served on Adult Video \nWarehouse was OLY-34. Again, it was served on April 24, \n2007, and the Adult Video Warehouse complied and provided \nus materials on April 30, 2007. \nThat concludes all of the items that we have \nreceived to date for the outstanding subpoenas that were \nissued. \nQ \nAre the documents that you refer to in that box \nthat's on the desk? \nA \nYes, they are. \nMS. VILLAFANA: Does anyone want to review those \ndocuments? At this time, no one is requesting that \nthey want to review the documents today. \nWould you please swear in the witness to \nmaintain those documents. \n(Witness sworn in as custodian of the \nrecords.) \n(Witness excused.) \nEFTA00226598\n", "char_count": 1154}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 203, "text_content": "Page 7 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \nI CERTIFY pages 1 to 6 is a true transcript of \nmy shorthand notes of the testimony of JASON \nRICHARDS, before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm \nBeach, Florida, on the 8th day of May, 2007. \nDated at West Palm Beach, Florida this 28th day \nof May, 2007. \n4. M. \nPhilip W. May, Court Reporter \nEFTA00226599\n", "char_count": 431}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 204, "text_content": "From: \nAFLS) \nSent: \nTo: \nUSAFLS) \nSubject: \ne:Operation Leap Year \nYou will not ha \nproval to go forward tomorrow with an indictment or to poceed \nby complaint. \nhas your memo and lefcourt's letter but he is out of the \ndistrict at the U Attorney's conference for the next several days. \nI'm having trouble understanding - given how long this case has b \nending - \nwhat the rush is. This is obviously a very significant case and \nwants to \ntake his time making sure he is comfortable before proceeding. \nSent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld \nOriginal Message \nSent: Mon May 14 10:38:15 2007 \nSubject: Operation Leap Year \nGood morning: I just received a call that Epstein's plane is flying from the \nVirgin Islands to Newark now, so it looks like Epstein is going to show up for \nhis court appearance tomorrow. Can you let me know if the indictment is going \ntomorrow or, if not whether we are authorized to proceed by Complaint? \nThank you. \nAssistant U.S. Attorney \n500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \nPhone 561 209-1047 \nFax 561 820-8777 \n179 \nExhibit 26 \nEFTA00226600\n", "char_count": 1103}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 205, "text_content": "IlliM  :tneSe\n• \nTo: \nCc: \nSubject: \nOp. Leap Year GJ Subpoena \nHi F \nhought I should run this by you. As I mentioned in the pros memo, when the Palm Beach PD \nsearched Epstein's home, they found computer monitors and equipment, but no CPUs. From the continued \ninvesti ,ation we know that the computers were removed by Paul Lavery, a private investigator, with the help of \none of our targets. Now that we know that Lavery removed the computers, I would like to \nsubpoena the computers to the grand jury. Lavery is a private investigator and is believed to have been working \nfor Roy Black at the time. Today I spoke with a CCIPS duty attorney who told me that grand jury subpoenas \ncan be used to obtain computer equipment. I also spoke with the duty attorney in the Witness Immunity Section \nand explained the situation. She said that we do not need Justice approval to subpoena the private investigator, \nso long as his office is not located within the lawyer's ofl'•ice (it is not—Lavery is in Hialeah and Roy Black is \ndowntown). \nI was intending to ask the grand jury if they will authorize a forthwith subpoena, or I may just give a short lead \ntime. I also intend to include a cover letter explaining that if Lavery turns over the equipment, he does not need \nto appear before the grand jury. If he no longer has the equipment, he can either tell the agents where the \nequipment currently is or he can appear before the grand jury to tell them. So, I am not looking for anything \nthat could be considered \"privileged information,\" (such as who told him to remove the equipment, what were \nthe exact orders, etc.) just the location of physical evidence belonging to the target. \nAny concerns/comments? \nAssistant U.S. Attorney \n500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \nPhone 561 209- I 047 \nFax 561 820-8777 \nTracking: \n150 \nEFTA00226601\n", "char_count": 1866}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 206, "text_content": "Sent: \n• \nTo: \nSubject: \nHi all - I know \n'list got back, so I don't expect a signed indictment. I have time set aside with the grand \njury tomorrow, \nam wondering if you have a sense of the direction where we are headed — i.c., approval of \nan indictment something like the current draft, a complaint to allow for pre-indictment negotiations, an \nindictment drastically different from the current draft? I am concerned about confusing the grand jury, which is \nnever a good thing. \nAny guidance? \nThank you. \nAssistant U.S. Attorney \n500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \nPhone 561 209-1047 \nFax 561 820-8777 \nTracking: \n155 \nEFTA00226602\n", "char_count": 663}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 207, "text_content": "1 \n1 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \n2 \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nWEST PALM BEACH \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \nIN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n/ \nGrand Jury #07-103 (TUES-WPB) \nwest Palm Beach, Florida \nTuesday, may 15, 2007 \n13 \n14 \n15 \nTESTIMONY \n16 \nOF \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \nAPPEARANCE: \n22 \n23 \nNANCY SIEGEL, COURT REPORTER \n24 \n25 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nExhibit 27 \nEFTA00226603\n", "char_count": 408}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 208, "text_content": "2 \n1 \nPROCEEDINGS \n2 \n3 \nThe sworn testimony of \nwas taken \n4 \nbefore the Federal Grand Jury, west Palm Beach Division, \n5 \n701 Clematis Street, west Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, \n6 \nState of Florida, on the 15th day of May, 2007. \n7 \nNANCY SIEGEL, Registered Merit Reporter and Notary \n8 \nPublic was authorized to and did report the sworn \n9 \ntestimony. \n10 \nThereupon, \n11 \n12 \na witness of lawful age, having been first duly sworn by \n13 \nthe foreperson, testified on her oath as follows: \n14 \nBY MS. \n15 \nQ \nGood morning, Special Agent. Could you state \n16 \nand spell your name for the record. \n17 \nA \nSpecial Agent \n18 \n19 \nQ \nAnd with whom do you work? \n20 \nA \nThe FBI here in west Palm Beach. \n21 \nQ \nAnd are you here today on the continuing \n22 \ninvestigation known as Operation Leap Year? \n23 \nA \nYes, I am. \n24 \nQ \nAnd you are one of the case agents on this \n25 \ninvestigation, correct? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226604\n", "char_count": 956}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 209, "text_content": "3 \n1 \nA \nYes, I am. \n2 \nQ \nThe last time you were here we were discussing \n3 \nthe evidence supporting various overt acts and charges \n4 \nrelated to Jane Does number 1 and 2? \nS \nA \nYes. \n6 \nQ \nToday we are going to start with Jane Doe \n7 \nnumber 3. Can you tell the Grand Jury who that is and \n8 \nsummarize briefly your previous testimony about her. \n9 \nA \nJane Doe number 3 is \nz and she first \n10 \nstarted, we have first phone contact with \nKellen \n11 \nstarting in December of 2004, \nwould have been 16 \n12 \nor 17 at that time, let me do the math real quick, she \n13 \nwould have been 16 \nsorry, I am sorry, she would have \n14 \nbeen at that time 17, let's get it right, so she started \nIIIIIIIIIIIII \n15 \nphone contact, \nstarted calling her in \n16 \nSeptember of 2004. \n17 \nFrom testimony we know that \nwent there \n18 \nearlier, much earlier. \nP, which was Jane Doe \n19 \nnumber 4 you will hear about next, they were good \n20 \nfriends and they both went in the spring of '04, prior \n21 \nto \n17th birthday, so \ndid start giving \n22 \nMr. Epstein massages when she was 16, she performed a \n23 \nI ew massages for Mr. Epstein and then took kind of a \n24 \nlittle bit of a break. \n25 \nThe sexual activity that occurred with \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226605\n", "char_count": 1272}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 210, "text_content": "4 \n1 \nMr. Epstein when \nwas under the age of 18 \n2 \nincluded digital penetration, the use of a vibrator on \n3 \ngrabbing and fondling of her breasts and her \n4 \nbuttock, she was given gifts by Mr. Epstein, she was \n5 \ngiven a vibrator, she was given \nsecret \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \nand \nthat you were able to calculate? \n16 \nA \nKellen called her, I guess calls between \n17 \nthe two of them ranged around 125 phone calls from \n18 \nDecember 6th, 2004 until October, 2005. \n19 \nQ \nAnd just briefly can you remind the Grand Jury \n20 \ndid \never tell Mr. Epstein her age? \n21 \nA \nNo, they did not ever discuss, she did not \n22 \ntell him how old she was, but she did tell him where she \n23 \nplanned on going to school and that she was in soccer. \n24 \nshe stated that when it came to her age that \n25 \nMr. Epstein didn't care. As I mentioned earlier, \nunderwear, she was also given a car that Mr. Epstein \nrented for her for a number of months, she was paid $200 \nby Mr. Epstein and \nwas the one that primarily \ncalled \nto set up appointments and as you can see \nthat began in December of '04. \nwas also one of Mr. Epstein's \nfavorites, according to several of the other girls. \nQ \nJust so the Grand Jury has an idea, how does \nthat translate into the number of phone calls between \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226606\n", "char_count": 1343}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 211, "text_content": "5 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nand \n \nwere very good friends and \nS\nwould talk \nabout \nand Mr. Epstein would ask questions about \nwhen \nwas providing massages and as we will \ntalk about when we talk about Jane Doe number 4, which \nis \nshe told Mr. Epstein that she was a junior in \nhigh school and that \nand her were in the same \nclasses together and that they were very good friends \nand \ntold us that at one point Fayth had come to \nher because she had slipped about prom and she was \nworried because Epstein was supposed to think she was 18 \nand she had talked about the prom and \nsaid she \nnever heard anything else about it and they never \nbrought it up. \nQ \nBecause, according to \nMr. Epstein \ndidn't care really how old the girls were? \nA \nExactly. \nQ \nAnd she never mentioned he asked her for her \nage or asked for any form of identification to show \nwhether she was or was not over 18? \nA \nQ \nNow, if you could turn to the proposed \nindictment and if i could ask you to look at overt act \nnumber 59. \nA \nwe had a little knock at the door. Do you \nwant me to get it? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226607\n", "char_count": 1192}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 212, "text_content": "6 \n1 \nQ \nYes. \n2 \n(Thereupon, there was a brief pause.) \n3 \nA \nI will let you see a picture of Jane Doe \n4 \nnumber 4, \nwho we were talking about earlier, and \n5 \nthis is \nIs there anyplace you want to put it \n6 \nright down here in front? \n7 \nQ \nAnd just so the record is clear, those are the \n8 \nphotographs that we showed to the Grand Jury last week? \n9 \nA \nYes, it is. \n10 \nQ \nso if you could turn to overt act number 59 \n11 \nwhich appears on page 12, and if you could explain to \n12 \nthe Grand Jury the evidence we have related to that \n13 \nphone call or phone calls on December 6th, 2004. \n14 \nA \nOn December 6th, 2004 a review of the phone \n15 \nrecords indicate that there was telephonic phone contact \n16 \nbetween the numbers belonging to \nand \n17 \n, as well as we have evidence with \n18 \nstatements of the phone calls being made to \n19 \nher by \nKellen. \n20 \nQ \nAnd overt act number 60? \n21 \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate \n22 \ntelephonic contact between the numbers belonging to \n23 \nKellen and \non December 12, 2004. \n24 \nQ \nAnd overt act number 64? \n25 \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226608\n", "char_count": 1173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 213, "text_content": "7 \n1 \ntelephonic contact between numbers belonging to \n2 \nKellen and \non December 14th, 2004. \n3 \n4 \nJury, when the overt acts says that defendant Kellen \n5 \nmade one or more telephone calls, that means that the \n6 \ncall is originating from \nphone, is that \n7 \ncorrect? \n8 \nA \nYes, it does. \n9 \nQ \nAnd if you could turn to overt act number 71. \n10 \nA \non December 20th a review of the phone records \n11 \nindicate that there was telephonic contact between ■ \n12 \nKellen and \n13 \nQ \nAnd overt act number 79? \n14 \nA \non January 6th, 2005 a review of phone records \n15 \nindicate there was telephone contact between numbers \n16 \nbelonging to \n17 \nQ \nAnd number 83? \n18 \nA \nOn January 14th, 2005 a review of the phone \n19 \nrecords indicate telephonic contact between numbers \n20 \nbelonging to \n21 \nQ \nAnd with respect to the other overt acts \n22 \nrelated to the phone calls which would be 94, 100, 102, \n23 \n104, 112, 118, 125, 129 and 132 is the evidence the \n24 \nsame? \n25 \nA \nYes, on or about each of those dates a review \nAnd just so that it is clear to the Grand \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226609\n", "char_count": 1119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 214, "text_content": "8 \n1 \n2 \nbetween the numbers belonging to \nM \nand \n3 \nillillas well as \nstatements. \n4 \nQ \nNow, if I could direct your attention to count \n5 \nnumber 7 which appears on page 26 of the draft \n6 \nindictment, that is a charge of indictment of a minor \n7 \nduring the period of December 6th, 2004 through June 2nd \n8 \nof 2005, could you summarize for the Grand Jury the \n9 \nevidence related to that count. \n10 \nA \non or about these dates the facility of \n11 \ninterstate commerce, the telephone, specifically ■ \n12 a \n, were utilized to set up \n13 \nappointments, massage appointments for Epstein. \n14 \nDuring the massages and on more than one \n15 \noccasion Epstein digitally penetrated \nZylus, he \n16 \nused a massager directly on her vagina and Epstein \n17 \ndirected \nto straddle him while he masturbated \n18 \nand rubbed his penis between her legs, he would \n19 \nmasturbate, he would reach through her legs as she was \n20 \nstraddling him, there was no penetration of his penis in \n21 \nher vagina, though. \n22 \nHe touched \nbreasts, he would \n23 \nmasturbate. He paid \non multiple occasions $200. \n24 \n25 \nof the phone records indicated telephonic contact \nBOth \nand Jeffrey Epstein have escorted \nupstairs for these massages and Mr. Epstein gave \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226610\n", "char_count": 1294}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 215, "text_content": "9 \n1 \na vibrator, \nsecret bra and panty sets \n2 \nand he also rented her a car for several months. \n3 \nQ \nAnd just so that it is clear, you mentioned he \n4 \npaid her on several occasions, he paid her every time \n5 \nshe performed these lewd acts, correct? \n6 \nA \nYes, 8200. \n7 \nQ \nAnd \nis listed as a defendant with \n8 \nrespect to Jane Doe number 3 as well, and can you \n9 \nexplain to the Grand Jury a little bit more about who \n10 \nis and why she is charged in this count? \n11 \nA \nAdriana Ross is one of Mr. Epstein's personal \n12 \nassistants as well and she made appointments for him for \n13 \nthese massages. \n14 \nWe have contact between \nphone \n15 \nand \nphone, she contacted \napproximately \n16 \n25 times. \n17 \nQ \nAnd that's why she is also charged with \n18 \nsomeone who is either an aider or abetter or a \n19 \ncoconspirator with respect to this? \n20 \nA \nYes. \n21 \nQ \nOkay. If I could direct your attention to \n22 \nCount number 32 which appears on page 30, Count number \n23 \n32. \n24 \nA \nI got 32. \n25 \nQ \nwhat is the evidence related to? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226611\n", "char_count": 1095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 216, "text_content": "10 \n1 \nA \nI am sorry, I didn't hear you ask me the \n2 \nquestion, I thought you said refer to it. \n3 \nThe evidence is we have flight records that \n4 \nindicate on December 13th, 2004 Epstein traveled to Palm \nS \nBeach County on the Gulfstream, there was telephonic \n6 \ncontact between \nKellen and \nthe day \n7 \nbefore or the day of travel , we also have the sexual \n8 \nconduct between Jeffrey Epstein and \nas we\n9 \ndescribed earlier in Count 7. \n10 \nQ \nAnd just to refresh the recollection of the \n11 \nGrand Jury, the Gulfstream aircraft is the one owned by \n12 \nHyperion? \n13 \nA \nAir, Inc. \n14 \nQ \nAnd when you said that there was telephone \n15 \ncontact, you recall that in overt act number 60 that we \n16 \ndiscussed phone calls on December 12th, correct? \n17 \nA \nwe did. \n18 \nQ \nokay. If I could direct you to Count number \n19 \n35 and if you could tell the Grand Jury about the \n20 \nevidence according to that count. \n21 \nA \nAgain, we have flight records that indicate \n22 \nthat on January 6th, 2005 Ipstein traveled to Palm Beach \n23 \nCounty on the Gulfstream again, there was telephonic \n24 \ncontact between \nKellen and Vanessa the day before, \n25 \nthe day of that travel , we also talked about the sexual \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226612\n", "char_count": 1264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 217, "text_content": "11 \n1 \nconduct between Jeffrey and \nbetween Epstein and \n2 \n3 \nQ \nAnd can you tell us again what aircraft they \n4 \nIlew on on January 6th? \n5 \nA \nThat was the Gulfstream which was owned by \n6 \nHyperion Air, Inc. \n7 \nQ \nokay. If I could direct you to Count 36 and \n8 \nagain if you could summarize that evidence. \n9 \nA \nwe have flight records that indicate that on \n10 \nJanuary 14th, 2005 Epstein, \nand Ross traveled to \n11 \nPalm Beach County on the Boeing 727 that Mr. Epstein \n12 \nowns, there was telephonic contact between \n13 \nand \nthe day before, the day of that \n14 \ntravel, as well as we have the sexual conduct between \n15 \nJeffrey Epstein and \nzylus as we described \n16 \nearlier, and I will tell you that \n17 \nKellen, Mr. Epstein's personal assistant, and Ross is \n18 \nwe talked about just a few minutes ago, \n19 \nMr. Epstein, another of Mr. Epstein's personal \n20 \nassistants. \n21 \nQ \nAnd if I could direct your attention to Count \n22 \n37 and ask you to summarize the evidence related to that \n23 \ncount. \n24 \nA \nle have flight records that indicate that on \n25 \nFebruary 3rd, 2005 Mr. Epstein and \ntraveled \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226613\n", "char_count": 1173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 218, "text_content": "12 \n1 \nto Palm Beach County on the Boeing 727, there was \n2 \ntele honic contact between \nand \n3 \nthe day before or the day of travel and we have \n4 \nthe sexual conduct between Epstein and \n5 \nQ \nAnd if i could direct your attention to Count \n6 \nnumber 38. \n7 \nA \nIn Count number 38 we have flight records that \n8 \nindicate on February 10th, 2005 Mr. Epstein, \n9 \n=MEM \ntraveled to \n10 \n11 \n12 \nPalm Beach County on the Gulfstream, there was telephone \ncontact between \nKellen and \nzylus the day \nbefore or the day of travel, we also have the sexual \n13 \nconduct between Mr. Epstein and \n. \n14 \n15 \nQ \nNow, I am sorry, on Count number 38, which \nairline were they on? \n16 \nA \nThey were on the Gulfstream. \n17 \nQ \nCan I ask you to double-check that? There is \n18 \nan inconsistency between the chart and the indictment or \n19 \nwe can save that for a later date. \n20 \nA \nIt is right here. \n21 \n22 \nQ \nI will mark that we need to check on Count \nnumber 38. \n23 \nA \nI have the flight manifest with me i \nyou want \n24 \nme to check, I don't know i \nyou want me to do that now. \n25 \nQ \nYes, il you don't mind. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226614\n", "char_count": 1158}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 219, "text_content": "13 \n1 \n(Thereupon, there was a brief pause.) \n2 \nA \nIn Count 38, plight records indicate on \n3 \nFebruary 10th, 2005 that Mr. Epstein, \nKellen, \n4 \nand \nmarcinkova were in fact on the \n5 \nBoeing 727. \n6 \nQ \nSo the draft indictment contains the correct \n7 \ninformation? \n8 \nA \nYes, it does. \n9 \nQ \nwhat company owns the Boeing 727? \n10 \nA \nJEGE, Inc., incorporated. \n11 \nQ \nAnd if I could take you to count number 39. \n12 \nA \nEvidence shows through flight records that on \n13 \nFebruary 21st, 2005 Epstein, \n14 \nand \ntraveled to Palm Beach County on \n15 \nthe Boeing 727, there was telephonic contact between \n16 \nKellen and \n17 \nof travel, there was also the sexual conduct between \n18 \nEpstein and \n19 \nQ \nAnd if I could take you to count number 40, \n20 \nplease. \n21 \nA \nwe have flight records that indicate on \n22 \nFebruary 24th, 2005 Epstein, \nNadia \n23 \nMarcinkova traveled to Palm Beach County on the Boeing \n24 \n727, there was telephonic contact between \nKellen \n25 \nand \nthe day before, the day of travel, and \nthe day before or the day \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226615\n", "char_count": 1098}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 220, "text_content": "14 \n1 \nthere was sexual conduct between JefI rey Epstein and \n2 \nas we described earlier in Count 7. \n3 \nQ \nAnd \nyou could do count 42. \n4 \nA \nwe have evidence that shows [light records, \n5 \nthat 'light records indicate that on March 18th, 2005 \n6 \nEpstein traveled to Palm Beach County on the Boeing 727, \n7 \nthere was telephonic contact between \nKellen and \n8 \nthe day of or the day before travel , we \n9 \nhave the sexual conduct between Mr. Epstein and \n10 \nQ \nAnd just referring to that count, \n11 \nis named, although she was not on the flight that day, \n12 \nis that correct? \n13 \nA \nYes. \n14 \nQ \nAnd you said that she made the telephone calls \n15 \nwith \ncorrect? \n16 \nA \nYes, and we also do have -- we have \n17 \ninterviewed Mr. Epstein's pilots and one of the pilots \n18 \nindicated that \nwas the one that arranged all of \n19 \nMr. Epstein's travel arrangements and so she is \n20 \nresponsible for making his arrangements to travel to \n21 \nPalm Beach as well as call the girls for the \n22 \nappointments. \n23 \nQ \nIf I could take you to Count number 43, \n24 \nplease. \n25 \nA \nFlight records indicate that on March 31st, \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226616\n", "char_count": 1176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 221, "text_content": "15 \n1 \n2005 Mr. Epstein traveled to Palm Beach County on the \n2 \nBoeing 727, there was telephonic contact between \n3 \nand \nthe day before or the day of travel, \n4 \nwe also have the sexual conduct between Epstein as \n5 \ndescribed earlier in count 7. \n6 \nQ \nAgain, in Count 44, what is the evidence \n7 \nrelated to that? \n8 \nA \nFlight records indicate that on April 8th, \n9 \n2005 Epstein and \ntraveled to Palm Beach \n10 \nCounty on the Gul stream and there was telephonic \n11 \ncontact between \nKellen and \non the \n12 \nday before or the day of travel , we also have the sexual \n13 \nconduct between Mr. Epstein and \n14 \nQ \nAnd if you could go through 45, 46 and 47. \n15 \nA \nCount 45 we have flight records that indicate \n16 \non April 27th, 2005 Epstein and \nKellen traveled to \n17 \nPalm Beach County on the Gulfstream, there is telephone \n18 \ncontact between \nKellen and \nthe day \n19 \nbefore or the day of travel and we have the sexual \n20 \nconduct between Jeffrey and \n21 \nIn Count 46 we have flight records that \n22 \nindicate that on may 6th, 2005 Epstein, \nKellen and \n23 \ntraveled to Palm Beach County on the \n24 \nGulfstream. \n25 \nwe have also telephonic contact between \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226617\n", "char_count": 1226}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 222, "text_content": "16 \n1 \nKellen and \neither the day before or the \n2 \nday of travel and we have the sexual conduct between \n3 \nEpstein and \nand in Count 47 on May 19th, 2005 \n4 \nwe have flight records that indicate Epstein, ■ \n5 \nKellen and \ntraveled to Palm Beach County on \n6 \nthe Gulfstream and we have telephone contact between \n7 \nKellen and \nthe day before or the day \n8 \nof travel. \n9 \nwe also have the sexual conduct between \n10 \nEpstein and \nas described in the earlier \n11 \ncount, count 7. \n12 \nQ \nNOw, if I could direct your attention to Count \n13 \nnumber 51 which appears on page 33, that is the sex \n14 \ntrafficking of a minor involving Jane Doe number 3, and \n15 \ncould you briefly summarize that, the evidence related \n16 \nto that. \n17 \nA \nAs we discussed earlier in Count 7, I told you \n18 \nguys about the sexual conduct between Epstein and \n19 \nthe monies that were paid to \nby \n20 \nMr. Epstein, the phone activity we discussed between \n21 \nKellen and \nzylus, it began in December, \n22 \nand we also have phone calls beginning in January Irom \n23 \nAdriana Ross to \nat that time \nwas 17 \n24 \nyears of age, and we also have statements from \n25 \nand \nregarding Mr. Epstein's knowledge of their \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226618\n", "char_count": 1246}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 223, "text_content": "17 \n1 \nages. \n2 \nQ \nAnd with respect to the affect on interstate \n3 \ncommerce related to that count we have both the \n4 \ntelephone calls, correct? \nS \nA \nYes. \n6 \nQ \nAs well as mr. Epstein actually traveling in \n7 \ninterstate commerce to engage in this activity, correct? \n8 \nA \nYes, we do. \n9 \nQ \nis there anything else that you would like to \n10 \nmention about Jane Doe number 3? \n11 \nA \nNot at this time, no. \n12 \nQ \nIf I could direct you to Jane Doe number 4 and \n13 \nif you could summarize for the Grand Jury the \n14 \ninformation related to Jane Doe number 4's activities. \n15 \nA \nJane Doe number 4 is \nP, I think you \n16 \nwanted their birth dates, her birth date is June 30th, \n17 \n1987, she was 16 years old and attended Royal Palm Beach \n18 \nHigh School. \n19 \nwe first have contact through phone calls from \n20 \nto Fayth on April 25th, 2004 which \n21 \nindicates and shows that \nwas clearly 16 years of \n22 \nage when she started going to Mr. Epstein's and \n23 \nperforming massages for mr. Epstein. \n24 \nour Jane Doe number 1, was the one \n25 \nwho recruited \nshe basically told Fayth that she \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226619\n", "char_count": 1156}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 224, "text_content": "18 \n1 \ncould make $200, she needed to dress cute, he might try \n2 \nto touch you, but it you eel uncomfortable just let him \n3 \nknow and he will stop, and the first massage that ■ \n4 \ndid he repeatedly told \nand I mentioned this to \n5 \nyou in the last Grand Jury session, she was very shy and \n6 \nhe would repeatedly tell her not to be so shy, that she \n7 \ndidn't have to be so shy. \n8 \nEpstein asked her to remove her clothing and \n9 \nshe told him no, and throughout the massage he would \n10 \nrepeatedly grab at her, he grabbed her butt, he did \n11 \nmasturbate through this first massage and pulled her \n12 \nclothes, she would pull away and she was paid $200 for \n13 \nthat. \n14 \n15 \ntold \nthat \nwas willing to do more she \n16 \nwould get paid more. He also informed \nthat if she \n17 \nwould bring her pretty friends he would also pay her for \n18 \nbringing her pretty friends. He told \nthat \n19 \nwould get her phone number. \n20 \nsays that she performed \n21 \nmassages for Mr. Epstein. We have with \n22 \napproximately a hundred phone calls between \n23 \nand \n24 \n25 \nwhen we got to the sexual massages that she did for \nupon leaving the first massage Mr. Epstein \nthree to four \nWhen I interviewed \nshe became very upset \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226620\n", "char_count": 1272}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 225, "text_content": "19 \n1 \nMr. Epstein. At this point, this is as much as we know \n2 \nat this point of what occurred with Mr. Epstein and \n3 \n. \n4 \nShe did three to four massages and those last \n5 \nmassages they became more sexual in nature, he asked her \n6 \nagain to remove her clothing, this time she took her \n7 \nshirt off, he asked her to take her bra off, she said \n8 \nno. \n9 \nHe again would touch her breasts, he would \n10 \ntouch her butt, he did continue to masturbate, this time \n11 \nshe believes he ejaculated. He continued to compliment \n12 \nher, tell her she had a nice body and that she was \n13 \npretty. \n14 \nsays that he was very nice and engaged \n15 \nher in conversation, asked her, you know, if she had a \n16 \nboyfriend. In the last massage she discusses with me, \n17 \nand this massage Mr. Epstein told her to stop being shy \n18 \nand asked her to take her clothes off and Fayth said \n19 \nthat she had a boyfriend and she didn't feel comfortable \n20 \ntaking her clothes off and he told her you should know \n21 \nwhat to expect by now when you come here, and he jerked \n22 \non her pants as to like jerk them down, so she did on \n23 \nthis last massage get down to her bra and underwear. \n24 \nShe describes his tone at this time being \n25 \nfrustrated and irritated, she stayed in her bra and \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226621\n", "char_count": 1339}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 226, "text_content": "20 \n1 \nunderwear, but during the massage he grabbed her bra and \n2 \npulled it down and fondled her breasts, he had \n3 \ninstructed her to pinch his chest, his nipples while she \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \nwas massaging his chest, he tried to grab her all over, \nhe knew that she was upset with this massage. \nAt one point Mr. Epstein asked her if she had \nsex with her boyfriend, \ninforms him that she is \nstill a virgin and he responds what, you don't like sex? \nAnd that's pretty much the way that last massage went. \nQ \nNow, Special Agent Kuyrkendall , just to \n11 \ninterrupt you, you mentioned that Jane Doe number 4 \n12 \nbecame very upset as you were asking her about the \n13 \nmassages, \n14 \nA \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \nreticent at first to tell the entire story until a \n25 \nrapport is built? \ncorrect? \nYes. \nAnd when she was describing this incident with \nhim grabbing at her breast and trying to pull her pants \ndown and instructing her to remove her pants, correct? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nYou had talked last week about the expert that \nyou had spoken with about interviewing victims of these \ntypes of offenses? \nA \nRight. \nQ \nAnd you had told us about how a victim may be \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226622\n", "char_count": 1240}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 227, "text_content": "21 \n1 \nA \nRight. \n2 \nQ \ncan you tell the Grand Jury your impressions \n3 \nof your interview with Fayth? \n4 \nA \nShe became so lisibly upset, and a lot of the \n5 \ngirls are embarrassed of what took place, but when she \n6 \ntalked about the last massage and him grabbing her \n7 \nbreasts and fondling her breasts she was in tears and we \n8 \nstopped the massage and we calmed her down, trying to go \n9 \nback there was just too difficult, 1 could not get her \n10 \nback to discussing anything Iurther that had taken \n11 \nplace. \n12 \nI have since then -- I have since talked to \n13 \nagain and 1 feel there is more there, but I just \n14 \ndon't think she is ready to disclose what took place. \n15 \nQ \nso based upon the more than 60 telephone calls \n16 \nas well as --\n17 \nA \nApproximately a hundred. \n18 \nQ \n-- 100 telephone calls and your conversations \n19 \nwith \nyou think there is probably more than [our \n20 \nmassages that happened? \n21 \nA \nYeS, I do \n22 \nQ \nwas there anything else that you wanted to \n23 \ndiscuss with the Grand Jury? \n24 \nA \nJust, as I stated in the beginning of those \n25 \nmassages, they engaged in conversation and throughout \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226623\n", "char_count": 1195}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 228, "text_content": "22 \n1 \nthat conversation, you know, she did inform Mr. Epstein \n2 \nthat she was a junior in high school and again she is \n3 \none of the girls that talks about \nbeing Mr. \n4 \nEpstein's favorite, so because Mr. Epstein knew they \n5 \nwere friends they would engage in conversation about \n6 \nand Fayth would mention they were in the same \n7 \nclasses at school and they would discuss the friendship \n8 \nthey had between the two girls with Mr. Epstein and I \n9 \nthink that's it. \n10 \nQ \nAll right. If we could turn to the \n11 \npost-indictment to overt act number 4 which appears on \n12 \npage number 5. \n13 \nDid you obtain telephone records for Jane Doe \n14 \nnumber 4? \n15 \nA \nYes. \n16 \nQ \nAnd did you compare those with the phone \n17 \nrecords of \nKellen and others? \n18 \nA \nYes, I did. \n19 \nQ \nAnd can you tell us with respect to overt act \n20 \nnumber 4 what evidence you have related to that? \n21 \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate that \n22 \nthere was telephonic contact between the numbers \n23 \nbelonging to \nand Fayth as well as \n24 \nstatements that \nwould call her to make \n25 \nappointments. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226624\n", "char_count": 1155}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 229, "text_content": "23 \n1 \nQ \nAnd if we could go through overt acts 6, 8, 9 \n2 \nand 11, all of which appear on page 6. \n3 \nA \nA review of the phone records on May 3rd, \n4 \n2004, may 14th, 2004, may 20th, 2004 and lune 3rd, 2004, \n5 \na review of those phone records indicate that there was \n6 \ntelephonic contact between numbers belonging to \n7 \nKellen and \nas well as \nstatements. \n8 \nQ \nIf I could take you to overt acts 14, 15 and \n9 \n19 which appear on page 7. \n10 \nA \nA review of the phone records on June 11th, \n11 \n2004, June 20th, 2004 and July 10th, 2004, they indicate \n12 \nthat there is telephonic contact between the numbers \n13 \nbelonging to \nKellen and \n14 \nQ \nAnd if I could ask you to turn to page 8 and \n15 \nif you could address overt acts 24 and 25. \n16 \nA \nA review of the phone records on July 18th, \n17 \n2004 and July 22nd, 2004, a review of \nKellen's and \n18 \nphone records indicate there is \n19 \ntelephonic contact belonging to both of them as well as \n20 \nstatements that Kellen would arrange \n21 \nappointments with her. \n22 \nQ \nIf I could take you to page 9 of the draft \n23 \nproposed indictment and ask about overt acts 29 and 30. \n24 \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate there \n25 \nis telephonic contact on July 22nd, 2004 and August 4th, \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226625\n", "char_count": 1308}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 230, "text_content": "24 \n1 \n2004 between numbers belonging to \nKellen and \n2 \nas well as \nstatements. \n3 \nQ \nIf I could take you to page 10 of the draft \n4 \nproposed indictment and ask you about overt acts 37 and \n5 \n43. \n6 \nA \nA review of phone records indicate telephonic \n7 \ncontact on August 25th, 2004 and October 3rd, 2004 \n8 \nbetween numbers belonging to \nKellen and ■ \n9 \n10 \nQ \nAnd it you could turn to page 11 of the draft \n11 \nproposed indictment and if you would address overt acts \n12 \n47 and 48. \n13 \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate \n14 \ntelephonic contact on october 30th, 2004 and November \n15 \n4th, 2004 between numbers belonging to \nKellen and \n16 \nP, as well \nstatements. \n17 \nQ \nokay. And i \nyou could go to page 14 of the \n18 \ndraft proposed indictment and address overt act number \n19 \n77. \n20 \nA \nA review of phone records indicate that on \n21 \nJanuary 4th, 2005 there was telephonic contact between \n22 \nKellen and \nas well as \n23 \nstatements. \n24 \nQ \nI'm sorry. If you could turn to page 16 of \n25 \nthe draft proposed indictment and address overt act \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226626\n", "char_count": 1122}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 231, "text_content": "25 \n1 \nnumber 87. \n2 \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate that on \n3 \nJanuary 22, 2005 there is telephonic phone contact \n4 \nbetween numbers belonging to \nKellen and \nand \n5 \nI believe I said on January 22nd, 2005. \n6 \nQ \nOkay. And it you could go to page 17 and \n7 \naddress overt act number 101. \n8 \nA \nOn February 14th, 2005 a review of the phone \n9 \nrecords indicate that there was telephonic contact on \n10 \nthat day between numbers belonging to \nKellen and \n11 \nP, as well as \nstatements. \n12 \nQ \nIf you could turn to pages 18 and 19 and it \n13 \nyou would address overt acts 106, 114 and 116. \n14 \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate that \n15 \nthere is telephonic contact between \nKellen and \n16 \non February 24th, 2005 as well as Fayth's \n17 \nstatements. \n18 \nQ \novert act number 114 says on March 18th, 2005 \n19 \ndefendant Kellen prepared a written message to defendant \n20 \nEpstein regarding Jane Doe number 4, could you tell the \n21 \nGrand Jury what the evidence is related to that? \n22 \nA \nwe have a review of the message pads that were \n23 \nrecovered during the search warrant that the state \n24 \nserved that showed that \nKellen wrote a message to \n25 \nEpstein regarding Fayth and that was done on March 18th, \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226627\n", "char_count": 1290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 232, "text_content": "26 \n1 \n2005. \n2 \nQ \nDo you happen to remember what the message \n3 \nsaid? \n4 \nA \nI have those with me. \n5 \nQ \nwould you mind getting them out? \n6 \nA \nDo you want to mark it? \n7 \nQ \nIf you could just read it to the Grand Jury. \n8 \nA \nIt is a message written by \nfor Jeffrey \n9 \non 3/18/2005, it looks like 4:21 p.m., and the message \n10 \nreads is it okay if \nwill come at 5:00 and there is \n11 \na question mark. \n12 \nQ \nAnd if i could direct you to overt act number \n13 \n116, what the evidence is related to that. \n14 \nA \nA review of the phone records on march 29th, \n15 \n2005 indicate that there is telephonic contact between \n16 \nKellen and \nas well as her --\n17 \nstatements. \n18 \nQ \nAnd il I could take you to overt act number \n19 \n127 which is on page 20. \n20 \nA \nA review of phone records on April 11th, 2005 \n21 \nindicate that there is telephonic phone contact between \n22 \nthe numbers belonging to Adriana Ross and \nas well \n23 \nas \nstatements. \n24 \nQ \nNow, if you could go to Count number 8, which \n25 \nalleges that between April 25th, 2004 and June 29th, \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226628\n", "char_count": 1119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 233, "text_content": "27 \n1 \n2005 Jeffrey Epstein, \nKellen, Adriana Ross enticed \n2 \nJane Doe number 4 to engage in sexual activity or \n3 \nprostitution. \n4 \nA \nOn or about these dates we have a facility of \ninterstate commerce, specifically the telephones, ■ \n6 \nKellen, \nand \nwhich were utilized to \n7 \nset up, arrange massage appointments for Epstein, we \n8 \nhave \n'ellen taking \nupstairs to set up the \n9 \nmassage table, she would set the massage table up as \n10 \nwell as set up the lotions and the oils, we have during \n11 \nthose massages Epstein would grab and pull \ncloser \n12 \nto him as he masturbated, he repeatedly would ask her to \n13 \nremove her clothing, wearing her bra and underwear, \n14 \nEpstein would pull down her bra and grabbed at her \n15 \nbreast, he attempted to touch her vagina at one point \n16 \nbut she stopped him, he masturbated, she believes that \n17 \nhe ejaculated, he paid her $200, he told her that he \n18 \nwould pay her to bring her pretty friends and would pay \n19 \nher more if she would do more. \n20 \nQ \nAnd just so that this is clear to the Grand \n21 \nJury, June 29th of 2005 is the day before Jane Doe \n22 \nnumber 4 turned 18, is that correct? \n23 \nA \nYes. \n24 \nQ \nso was there activity that continued past her \n25 \n18th birthday? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226629\n", "char_count": 1300}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 234, "text_content": "28 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nIf I could direct you to \nwhich appears on page 28, and tell \nrelated to that. \nCount number 17, \nus about the evidence \n5 \nA \nwe have evidence through light records that \n6 \nindicate on May 21st, 2004 that Epstein and \n7 \ntraveled to Palm Beach County on the \n8 \nGulfstream, we have telephonic contact between \nand \n9 \nKellen the day before or the day of travel and we \n10 \nhave the sexual conduct between Epstein and \nas we \n11 \ndescribed earlier in Count 8. \n12 \nQ \nAnd \nyou could go through Counts 18 and 19. \n13 \nA \nwe have 'light records that indicate on June \n14 \n4th, 2004 Epstein and Nadia Marcinkova traveled to Palm \n15 \nBeach County on the Gulfstream, we have telephone \n16 \ncontact between \nKellen and \nthe day before, \n17 \nthe day of travel, we have sexual conduct between \n18 \nMr. Epstein and \nas discussed earlier. \n19 \nwe have also Count 19 on June 20th, 2004 we \n20 \nhave light records that indicate that Epstein and Nadia \n21 \ntraveled to Palm Beach County on the Boeing \n22 \n727. \n23 \nwe have the telephone contacts between \n24 \nKellen and \nthe day before, the day of travel, we \n25 \nalso have the sexual conduct between Jeffrey and \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226630\n", "char_count": 1238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 235, "text_content": "29 \n1 \nas we described earlier in Count 8. \n2 \nQ \nCould you do the same for Counts 22 and 23, \n3 \nplease. \n4 \nA \nCount 22 we have flight records that indicate \n5 \non July 22nd, 2004 Epstein, \nKellen, Nadia \n6 \ntraveled to Palm Beach County on the Boeing \n7 \n727, we have the telephonic phone contact between ■ \n8 \nKellen and \nthe day before or the day of travel, we \n9 \nalso have the sexual conduct between Jeffrey Epstein and \n10 \nas we described earlier, and Count 23 we have \n11 \nflight records that indicate on August 6th, 2004 Epstein \n12 \nand \nKellen traveled to Palm Beach County on the \n13 \nBoeing 727, we have telephonic contact between \n14 \nKellen and \ntwo days prior to Epstein and \n15 \ntraveling to Palm Beach County, we have sexual \n16 \nconduct between Jeffrey Epstein and \nas we \n17 \ndescribed earlier. \n18 \nQ \nAnd if you could do the same for Count number \n19 \n28, please. \n20 \nA \nCount number 28 we have flight records that \n21 \nindicate on November 5th, 2004 Epstein, \nKellen, \n22 \nNadia Marcinkova traveled to Palm Beach County on the \n23 \nGuli stream, we have telephonic contact between \n24 \nKellen and \nP the day before or the day of travel, \n25 \nwe have the sexual conduct between Epstein and \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226631\n", "char_count": 1271}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 236, "text_content": "30 \n1 \nQ \nAnd if I could direct you to Count number 35, \n2 \nyou testified previously about the people who were \n3 \naboard the plane. \n4 \nwas there also telephone contact on January \n5 \n6th \nexcuse me, shortly before the flight on January \n6 \n6th, 2005 between MIN \nand this Jane Doe? \n7 \nA \nYes, two days before. \n8 \nQ \nAnd if you look at Count number 40, again, you \n9 \nhad previously told us about who was on board the plane. \n10 \nCan you tell us whether there was also telephone contact \n11 \nshortly before that? \n12 \nA \nThere was telephone contact the day of or the \n13 \nday before. \n14 \nQ \nAll right. Between who and who? \n15 \nA \nBetween \nKellen and \n16 \nQ \nokay. And i \nyou could look at Count 43, you \n17 \nalso had testified previously about who was aboard the \n18 \nplane on that day. \n19 \nwas there also telephone contact between Jane \n20 \nDoe number 4 -- excuse me, Jane Doe number 4 and \n21 \nKellen? \n22 \nA \nYes, two days before. \n23 \nQ \nAnd if I could direct you to Count number 52, \n24 \nwhich is the sex trafficking offense, and if you could \n25 \nsummarize again for the Grand Jury the evidence related \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226632\n", "char_count": 1172}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 237, "text_content": "31 \n1 \nto that. \n2 \nA \nwe discussed in count 8 the sexual conduct \n3 \nthat occurred between Fayth and Epstein during the \n4 \nmassages that took place, we talked about the money that \n5 \nwas paid to her by Mr. Epstein and the offer of more \n6 \nmoney if she would do more as well as if she would bring \n7 \nher friends. \n8 \nThrough \nstatements we have also that \n9 \nKellen has paid her in the past for bringing a \n10 \nriend, we have the phone acti II \n.ty between\nKellen \n11 \nand \nwhich started in April, 2004, we know \n12 \nwas 16 at the time, we also have phone activity between \n13 \nAdriana Ross and Fayth beginning in the spring of 2005 \n14 \nwhen \nwould be 17, with the statements of \nand \n15 \nthe knowledge that Mr. Epstein knew their age, \n16 \nand we have gone through that regarding \ninforming \n17 \nMr. Epstein that she was a junior in high school, that \n18 \nshe was classmates with \nand then \n19 \nstatements that Fayth was concerned because she was \n20 \ndiscussing prom with Mr. Epstein, and both girls at that \n21 \ntime of the phone calls were under the age of 18. \n22 \nQ \nJust again so it is clear for the Grand Jury, \n23 \nneither \nnor \never specifically said hey, \n24 \nJeffrey, I am 17, but they provided information that \n25 \nshould have caused him to try to figure out whether in \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226633\n", "char_count": 1346}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 238, "text_content": "32 \n1 \nfact they were adults? \n2 \nA \nYes. \n3 \nQ \nAny questions about Jane Doe number 4 before \n4 \nwe turn to Jane Doe number 5? Yes, ma'am. \n5 \nA GRAND JUROR: I have to say something here, \n6 \nit it is a stupid question forgive me if it is, \n7 \nfrom what I heard, maybe I heard wrong, there were \n8 \nthree to four massages that Jane Doe, \nor \n9 \nFayth P said that she had and you enumerated quite \n10 \na few sexual contact. \n11 \nHow do you know about this, do you have \n12 \nrecords, how do you know they were sexual contact? \n13 \nTHE WITNESS: Through interviewing \n14 \nA GRAND JUROR: She said she only had three to \n15 \nfour massages. \n16 \nA GRAND JUROR: Her question is more like \n17 \nthere is 20 phone calls. \n18 \nA GRAND JUROR: There is tons of them. \n19 \nTHE WITNESS: Exactly, that is what we were \n20 \ndiscussing earlier when we discussed that there is \n21 \nmore than what \nis willing to admit at this \n22 \ntime. \n23 \nA GRAND JUROR: I got it. So she said she \n24 \nonly had three to four. \n25 \nA GRAND JUROR: There is a hundred phone \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226634\n", "char_count": 1095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 239, "text_content": "33 \n1 \ncalls. \n2 \nA GRAND JUROR: You said you found out through \n3 \ni am a little bit confused about that. \n4 \nTHE WITNESS: Through interviewing ■ \n, she \n5 \nstated that she had three or four massages from \n6 \nMr. Epstein. \n7 \nBY MS. VILLAFANA: \n8 \nQ \nSpecial Agent \nthe sexual activity \n9 \nthat you described that \nwent through, that is what \n10 \nshe said happened during those three to four massages, \n11 \ncorrect? \n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \nDoes that answer your question? \n14 \nA GRAND JUROR: Not really. How do we know \n15 \nlike about all these 25, 30? \n16 \nA GRAND JUROR: There is more dates that match \n17 \nup with the amount of massages. \n18 \nA GRAND JUROR: There were a hundred phone \n19 \ncalls. \n20 \nA GRAND JUROR: Are we supposed to assume a \n21 \nphone call was made each time they had sexual \n22 \ncontact? \n23 \nTHE WITNESS: No. There are lots of phone \n24 \ncalls made arranging appointments between the \n25 \ngirls, that doesn't mean that every phone call that \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226635\n", "char_count": 1024}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 240, "text_content": "34 \n1 \nwas made was a trip over to Mr. Epstein's house to \n2 \nperform a massage. \n3 \nMS. \nYes, ma'am. \n4 \nA GRAND JUROR: couldn't they put anything in \n5 \nthis indictment about stalking her, are there any \n6 \nrules against stalking children? \n7 \nMS. VILLAFANA: I will address -- that is a \n8 \nlegal question that i will address when the Special \n9 \nAgent is outside of the Grand Jury. Any other \n10 \nfactual questions related? \n11 \nA GRAND JUROR: I don't have a question \n12 \nrelating to Jane Doe number 4, it was a question \n13 \nasked last week, what does Mr. Epstein do for work, \n14 \nhow does he make his money? I asked that late, \n15 \nlate in the ame last week. \n16 \nMS. \nOkay, I guess we can just \n17 \naddress that now. \n18 \nBY MS. VILLAFANA: \n19 \nQ \nWhat is Mr. Epstein's state of profession? \n20 \nA \nHe is an investor. \n21 \nQ \nAnd he manages portfolios valued at about a \n22 \nbillion or more? \n23 \nA \nYes. \n24 \nQ \nwho is his best known client? \n25 \nA \nThe owner of the Limited and victoria secret. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226636\n", "char_count": 1062}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 241, "text_content": "35 \n1 \nQ \nAnd you mentioned that as gifts Mr. Epstein \n2 \ntended to give Victoria secrets panties and bra sets? \n3 \nA \nYes. \n4 \nQ \nDoes that answer the question? \n5 \nA GRAND JUROR: Yes. \n6 \nMS. \nYes, ma'am. \n7 \nA GRAND JUROR: Count 28 I thought I heard \n8 \nthat -- I thought I heard the detective say that it \n9 \nwas the Gulfstream rather than the Boeing 727 on \n10 \nflight records, just for your info. \n11 \nMS. VILLAFANA: Count number 28, let's go back \n12 \nthere. \n13 \nBY MS. VILLAFANA: \n14 \nQ \nCould you restate for the Grand Jury which \n15 \ncompany owns the Gulfstream? \n16 \nA \nThe Gulfstream is owned by Hyperion Air, Inc. \n17 \nQ \nAnd the Boeing is owned by whom? \n18 \nA \nJEGE, Inc. \n19 \nQ \nAny other questions before we go on to Jane \n20 \nDoe number 5? We have four minutes. \n21 \nSpecial Agent Kuyrkendall, why don't I ask you \n22 \nto step outside so I can answer that question for the \n23 \nGrand Jury and address some issues. \n24 \n(The witness was excused from the Grand Jury \n25 \nroom.) \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226637\n", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 242, "text_content": "36 \n1 \n(Questions posed by the Grand Jury.) \n2 \n(The testimony of the witness was concluded \n3 \nbefore the Grand Jury.) \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226638\n", "char_count": 259}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 243, "text_content": "37 \n1 \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \nI certify pages 2 through 36 are a true transcript of my \n6 \nshorthand notes of the testimony of E. \n7 \nKuyrkendall before the Federal Grand Jury, west Palm \n8 \nBeach, Florida on the 15th day of Tuesday, 2007. \n9 \n10 \nkIct\\,,, A \n11 \nNancy Siegel-Notary Public \n12 \nCommission #DD0282274 \n13 \nExpires may 8, 2008 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226639\n", "char_count": 462}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 244, "text_content": "LAW OFFICES OF \nGurtaban B. Laconic, PG \nA PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION \n148 CAST 78,-  STREET \nNEW YORE., NEW YORK 10021 \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT \nIlifCOUR@WCOUSIAT COM \nSHERYL E. REICH \nroichadcouriwtoum \nRENATO C. STABILE \nPabil*Ellefoourtlawcorn \nFAITH A. FRIE0mAN \niMatnenalelowitaw Torn \nVIA E-MAIL \npt\nFt3W\nIEs\ntief, Northern Region \nOffice of the United States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Avenue, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nDear al \nMay 22, 2007 \nJeffrey Epstein \nTELEPHONE \n12 I a) 737-0400 \nFACSIMILE \n(212) 9884102 \nI write as counsel to Jeffrey Epstein, the subject of a grand jury investigation being \nconducted by your office. \nI understand from you that in the next month or two a decision will be made by your \noffice whether to seek an indictment of Mr. Epstein. This will confirm that, prior to any such \ndecision being made, 1 and other attorneys on behalf of Mr. Epstein will be given an opportunity \nto meet with you. \nAdditionally, because we believe that any decision to indict requires both a complex legal \nanalysis in a detailed factual context and resolution of significant policy concerns, if our meeting \ndoes not resolve the matter, we would like an opportunity to make a presentation first to Matthew \nMenchel, Chief of the Criminal Division, and Jeffrey Sloman, First Assistant United States \nAttorney, and then, again, if no resolution is reached, the opportunity to meet with United States \nEXHIBIT 28 \nEFTA00226640\n", "char_count": 1490}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 245, "text_content": "L.Aw Orr ICES or \nGERAIS) 13. InecounT, P.C.. \nDeputy Chief, Northern Region \nOffice of the United States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \nMay 22, 2007 \nPage 2 \nAttorney Alexander Acosta. \nThank you for your cooperation in this matter. If you have any questions, please do not \nhesitate to call. \n,Very truly yours, \nA\ncc: \nGerald B. Lefcourt \nEFTA00226641\n", "char_count": 364}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 246, "text_content": "VilWane, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) \nFrom: \nSent: \nTo: \nCc: \nSubject: \nAttachments: \nGentlemen, \nJeffrey Epstein \n2007-05-22 letter to AUSA Lourie.pdf \nMarie and I have already met with Lefcourt, which is really the meeting I promised him. I spoke to him last week and he \nsaid he had more information they wanted to present. I told him he could make an appointment to come in again if he \nwanted to and that we would meet with him again, but I did not promise that we would wait to give him a meeting \n\"before\" we charged. \nSo, I think he is really ready for the next level rather than a second meeting with me. Mike Tein also mentioned to me \nat some point that they wanted to make a presentation on the law and I suggested to him that he contact Matt without \ntelling him exactly what stage of review we were at. I don't know if Tein and Lefcourt have crossed wires or not. \nIn any event, I am forwarding this letter to you. I am going to suggest to Lefcourt the same thing that I suggested to \nTein. I assume you would grant his attorneys a chance to make whatever presentation they desire. It would probably \nbe helpful to us in any event to hear their legal arguments in case we have missed something. Whether in would be \npresent or grant them another meeting after that is his call. \nAndy \n- - \nFrom: \nSe \nTo: \nCc: \nSubjeet-3effrey Epstein \n-\n.\n\\\n-\n-\n \n-\n-\n-\n-\n-\n \n.\n-\n^\n \nailto:GBL@Iefcourtlaw.corn] \nAndy, attached is a letter seeking meetings. as discussed with you, but with others if it is not resolved. Thanks for your \nattention. Could you email back so that I know you have received this letter? \nGerald B. Lefcourt \nGerald B. Lefcourt, P.C. \n148 E. 78th Street \nNew York New York 10021 \nTel. \nFax \nobkaletcourtlaw com \n153 \nExhibit 28 \nEFTA00226642\n", "char_count": 1761}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 247, "text_content": "From: \nSent: \nTo: \nSubject: IS1 just want to again voice my disagreement with promising to have a meeting or having a \nurt or any other of Epstein's attorneys. As I mentioned, this is not a case where we will be \nsitting down to negotiate whether a defendant will serve one year versus two years of probation. This is a case \nwhere the defendant is facing the possibility of dozens of years of prison time. lust as the defense will defend a \ncase like that differently than they would handle a probation-type case, we need to handle this case differently. \nPart of our prosecution strategy was already disclosed at the last meeting, and I am concerned that more will be \ndisclosed at a future meeting. \n: Jeitrey Epstein \nPM \nu think? \nMy co-chair, \n, who has prosecuted more of these cases than the rest of us combinedianclaAcho \n, also opposes a meeting. We have \nbeen accused of not being \"strategic thinkers\" because of our opposition to these meetings, but we are simply \nlooking at this case as a violent crime prosecution involving stiff penalties rather than as a white collar or public \ncorruption case where the parties can amicably work out a light sentence. \nWith respect to the \"policy reasons\" that Lefcourt wants to discuss, those were already raised in his letter \n(which is part of the indictment package) and during his meeting with Andy and myself. Those reasons are: (I) \nhe wants the Petit policy to trump our ability to prosecute Epstein, (2) this shouldn't be a federal offense, and \n(3) the victims were willing participants so the crime shouldn't be prosecuted at all. Unless the Office thinks \nthat any of those arguments will be persuasive, a meeting will not be beneficial to the prosecution, it will only \nbenefit the defense. With respect to Lefcourt's promised legal analysis, that also has already been provided. \nThe only way to get additional analysis is to expose to the defense the other charges that we are considering. In \nmy opinion this would seriously undermi\n... [truncated, 2739 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/247 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=247]", "char_count": 2739}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 248, "text_content": "fyi \nFrom: \nSent: \nay, ay \nTo: 'Gerald Lefcourt' \nSubject: RE: Jeffrey Epstein \nI have your letter. I think we are on the same page, but to be sure I do want to clarify that we spoke the other week and \nI did say that if you want to meet with me again, I am ready to do so. The wording of your letter, however, suggests \nimplicitly that I agreed to contact you before a decision is made to seek an indictment of Mr. Epstein. If that was your \nunderstanding, then please allow me to clarify. Our investigation is ongoing and if we decide to seek an indictment, we \ndon't intend to call Mr. Epstein's representatives to let him know that. Of course, in the interim, if you would like to \nmake a presentation to us, we are willing to listen. \nAlong those lines, given the fact that we have already met once, with schedules being what they are, it makes sense for \nour criminal chief, Matt Menchel, to be included when you make another presentation, rather than working up the \nchain incrementally. I realize you were being respectful in not attempting to leapfrog over me, which I appreciate. I \nwill pass on your request to meet with the U.S. Attorney as well, but can't commit for him one way or another. When \nyou have some dates in mind, let me know and I will try to set up a meeting in Miami. \nFrom: Gerald Lefcourt [mailto:GBL@Iefcourtlaw.cornj \nSent: Tuesday, May 22, 2007 2:05 PM \nTANIS \nSubje \ne rey Epstein \nM\nI\n \nattached is a letter seeking meetings, as discussed with you, but with others if it is not resolved. Thanks for your \nattention. Could you email back so that I know you have received this letter? \nGerald B. Lefcourt \nGerald B. Lefcourt, P.C. \n148 E. 78th Street \nNew York, New York 10021 \nTel. \nFax \n0blOlefcourtlaw.com \nTracking: \n2 \nEFTA00226644\n", "char_count": 1770}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 249, "text_content": "Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) \nFrom: \nSent: \nTo: \nSubject: \nPlease put in your file. thx \nFW: Jeffrey psein \nFrom: Gerald Lefcourt [mailto:GBLglefcourtlaw.com] \nSent: Wednesda \nMa 23, 2007 5:00 PM \nTo: \nSubject: RE: Jeffrey Epstein \nThanks for the email. I will get back to you as to timing of the meeting. \nGerald B. Lefcourt \nGerald B. Lefcourt. P C \n148 E. 78th Street \nNew York New York 10021 \nTel. \nFax ?Mr\" \nFrom: Lourie, Andrew (USAFLS) [mailto:Andrew.Lourtegusdoj.gov] \nSent: Tuesday, May 22, 2007 6:32 PM \nTo: Gerald Lefcourt \nSubject: RE: Jeffrey Epstein \nI have your letter. I think we are on the same page, but to be sure I do want to clarify that we spoke the other week and \nI did say that if you want to meet with me again, I am ready to do so. The wording of your letter, however, suggests \nimplicitly that I agreed to contact you before a decision is made to seek an indictment of Mr. Epstein. If that was your \n_understanding, then please allow me to clarify. Our investigation is ongoing and if we decide to seek an indictment, we \ndon't intend to call Mr. Epstein's representatives to let him know that. Of course, in the interim, if you would like to \nmake a presentation to us, we are willing to listen. \nAlong those lines, given the fact that we have already met once, with schedules being what they are, it makes sense for \nour criminal chief, Matt Menchel, to be included when you make another presentation, rather than working up the \nchain incrementally. I realize you were being respectful in not attempting to leapfrog over me, which I appreciate. I \nwill pass on your request to meet with the U.S. Attorney as well, but can't commit for him one way or another. When \nyou have some dates in mind, let me know and I will try to set up a meeting in Miami. \nFrom: Gerald Lefcourt [mailto:GBLglefcourtlaw.com] \nMay 22, 2007 2:05 PM \nT \nC \nSu \n191 \nEFTA00226645\n", "char_count": 1889}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 250, "text_content": "Andy, attached is a letter seeking meetings, as discussed with you, but with others if it is not resolved. Thanks for your \nattention. Could you email back so that I know you have received this letter? \nGerald B. Lefcoun \nGerald B. Lefeourt. P.0 \n148 E. 78th Street \nNew York New York 10021 \nTel. \n.0400 \nFax \noblate court aw.com \n142 \nEFTA00226646\n", "char_count": 349}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 251, "text_content": "1 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nCOPY \nRE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR \n/ \nTESTIMONY \nIll=\nSPECIAL AGENT \nFederal Grand Jury 07-103 \nFederal Building \nU.S. Courthouse \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \nTuesday, May 22, 2007 \nAPPEARANCES: \nExhibit 29 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226647\n", "char_count": 419}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 252, "text_content": "2 \nt \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nThe sworn testimony of SPECIAL AGENT \nE. \nwas taken before the \nFederal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach Division, \nFederal Building, U.S. Courthouse, Palm Beach \nCounty, State of Florida, on Tuesday, May 22, \n2007. \nPaula E. Angelocci, Certified Court \nReporter and Notary Public, State of Florida, \nOfficial Reporting Service, LLC, 524 South Andrews \nAvenue, Suite 302N, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, \n33301 , was authorized to and did report the sworn \ntestimony. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226648\n", "char_count": 619}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 253, "text_content": "3 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room.) \nTHE FOREPERSON: \nYou do solemnly swear \nthat the testimony you give will be the \ntruth, the whole truth, and nothing but the \ntruth, so help you God? \nTHE WITNESS: \nI do. \nTHE FOREPERSON: Thank you. \nPlease be \nseated. \nEXAMINATION \nBY MS. \nQ \nGood afternoon, Special Agent. \nA \nGood afternoon. \nQ \nCould you remind the grand jury of your \nname and with whom you are employed? \nA \nIt's \nI'm a \nspecial agent with the FBI here in West Palm Beach \nand I work violent crimes. \nQ \nAre you the case agent on Operation Leap \nQ \nOkay. Before we get back to our review \nof the draft proposed indictment, I know that a \nquestion was raised regarding whether the grand \njury transcripts are being made available to \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226649\n", "char_count": 901}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 254, "text_content": "4 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ncounsel for the defense, are they? \nA \nNo. \nQ \nAnd is Mr. Epstein considered a high \nflight risk by the FBI and the U.S. Attorney's \nOffice? \nA \nYes, he is. \nQ \nSo is the status of the investigation in \nterms of when an indictment might be returned \nconsidered highly confidential? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd are there any personal relationships \nbetween any members of the U.S. Attorney's Office \nand counsel for Mr. Epstein? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd is that one of the reasons why we \nhave decided to use, In Re: Abbott, when referring \nto this case? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow we had left off just prior to \nthe beginning of the discussion of Jane Doe Number \nFive. Could you tell the grand jury a little bit \nabout Jane Doe Number Five? \nA \nJane Doe Number Five is Felicia E. \nHer \ndate of birth is June 18, 1987. \nWe have phone \nactivity that began with Felicia when she was 17 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226650\n", "char_count": 1020}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 255, "text_content": "5 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nyears old beginning in November of 2004, going \nthrough to almost April, I guess, to the end of \nMarch 2005. \nWe have contact, telephone contact \nbetween \nwith \napproximately 70 phone calls in that time period \nas well as approximately seven phone calls with \nAdriana Ross regarding the setting up of \nappointments to provide massages to Mr. Epstein. \nQ \nNow did Felicia explain how she was \nfirst introduced to Mr. Epstein? \nA \nYes, she did.  Il was the one \nthat approached Felicia. III'. \nalso attends \nRoyal Palm Beach High School as well as our other \nfirst four girls on the board, the Jane Does up \nthere. \n told her that she would need to \nwear something sexy, that she would be providing \nMr. Epstein with a massage and that she would \nreceive $200, and if she was asked she should tell \nMr. Epstein that she was 18. \nOn the first massage that Felicia went \nto Mr. Epstein's house, she removed her shirt at \nhis request and she performed the massage. She \nwas paid $300 for that massage. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226651\n", "char_count": 1155}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 256, "text_content": "6 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nDuring that massage, she told Mr. \nEpstein that she was 18 years of age. He asked \nher age. They also discussed many things that \nI'll\" a was interested in. \nThey talked about his ranch. They \ntalked about horses. They actually also talked \nabout cars. \nAt one point later on, Mr. Epstein \nlet's her drive a brand new Lexus, test drive a \nbrand new Lexus. So those were some of her \ninterests and Mr. Epstein talked to her about \nthat. \nIllilla told us that the massages became \nmore sexual in nature and she stated that she did \nmore than ten massages, but that she couldn't \nquite put a number on how many massages she \nprovided to Mr. Epstein, but it was definitely \nmore than ten. \nShe was not -- when she was interviewed \nby the Palm Beach Police Department, she did tell \nthem that it was more around five or six massages. \nShe stated that she minimized to the detectives \nwhen they came to interview her. \nThey came to her house and her dad was \ndue home any time and what was foremost on her \nmind was my dad is going to be here any minute. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226652\n", "char_count": 1207}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 257, "text_content": "7 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nShe cooperated. \nShe told them what had happened, but she \nminimized it more in an effort that she just \nwanted them to leave before her parents got home. \nAt this point, her parents were not aware of what \ntook place. \nAs the massages became more sexual in \nnature, she describes that the first sexual \nmassage -- he always instructed her on what to do, \nand on the first massage he had asked her to \nremove her clothing. \nShe was down to her underwear at this \npoint. \nHe asked her to straddle him while he laid \nface up and continued to massage his chest and \npinch his nipples and rub his chest. \nHe at that \npoint reached through her legs and masturbated. \nOn another occasion, she was completely \nnude and she did several of the massages in the \nnude for Mr. Epstein. \nIn this particular massage, she stated \nthat Mr. Epstein licked his hand and went down and \nstroked her vagina and actually penetrated her \nvagina. \nShe pulled away and he said that he \nwanted to touch her and that he also wanted to \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226653\n", "char_count": 1166}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 258, "text_content": "8 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ntaste her. \nHe stopped at that time, but then \nbefore the massage was over, he digitally \npenetrated her again. \nHe had used a back massager on her on at \nleast two occasions. She did not like that and \nshe told him that and he responded something to \nthe effect: \nWhat are you scared to have pleasure? \nAnd she told him she didn't like it. \nOn the second to the last massage that \n=.a \ngave Mr. Epstein, she was giving him a \nmassage and he took her into the bedroom and asked \nher to get fully unclothed. \nHe actually took a phone call and told \nher that she should get undressed and lay on the \nbed completely naked. \nHe just wanted to look at \nher. He took his phone call. \nAfter the phone call was over, he ended \nup vaginally penetrating Felicia as well as \nperforming oral sex on Illilla. She said that she \nfelt very dirty after that massage or after that \ntime and she had decided that the next massage \nwould be her last massage, that she did not want \nto go back. \nDuring the last massage she gave, she \nkept looking at the clock. \nMr. Epstein commented \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226654\n", "char_count": 1222}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 259, "text_content": "9 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nand noticed that she was looking at the clock and \nshe made reference to that her boyfriend was \nwaiting and Mr. Epstein said that, you know, she \nwas ruining his massage and that if she didn' t \nwant to be here she should leave. \nShe told him at this time this would be \nher last massage. She was paid anywhere Irom $300 \nto $600 during the time that she worked for Mr. \nEpstein. It was \nwho took her upstairs that \nfirst time or took her upstairs and set up the \nmassage table. \nShe was given some gifts by Mr. Epstein \nas well. She received bra and pantie sets Irom \nhim, 'a \nSecret bra and pantie sets. She \nalso received a book of poetry from Mr. Epstein. \nShe was Western Unioned a wire of $200 \nas a Christmas bonus to I'll\"  a from Mr. Epstein. \nQ \nHow did Mia \nget to and from Mr. \nEpstein's home? \nA \nShe had a vehicle that she would drive \nif she didn't ride with one of the other girls. \nIf she was grounded and could not get to Mr. \nEpstein's house, he would send a car for her. \nThere was a local taxi service and she \nstated that on several occasions it was a Lincoln \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226655\n", "char_count": 1241}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 260, "text_content": "10 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nTown Car that was sent and there was an individual \nby the name of Dennis that she got to know pretty \nwell on the drives to and Irom Mr. Epstein's \nhouse, but that even when she didn't have \ntransportation on those particular times, that a \ncar was sent for her to bring her to Mr. Epstein's \nhouse. \nQ \nIs there anything else that you wanted \nto tell the grand jury about Illilla? \nA \nThat's it. \nQ \nAll right. \nIf I could direct you to the \nproposed draft indictment, draft proposed \nindictment, and ask you to look at the Overt Acts \nthat involve Jane Doe Number Five and \nKellen. Specifically Overt Acts 53, 58, 61 , 65, \n69, 74, 81 , 91 , 98, 107, and 1 1 1 . \nCan you explain to the grand jury what \nthe evidence is supporting those Overt Acts? \nA \nWe have reviewed phone records that \nindicates that there was telephonic contact \nbetween \nand as\n on those dates as \nwell as \nIs statements that \nKellen was \narranging the appointments. \nQ \nAll right. \nAnd if I can refer you to \nOvert Act Number 72, which states on or about \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226656\n", "char_count": 1190}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 261, "text_content": "1 1 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nDecember 23, 2004, Defendant Epstein caused a \nWestern Union wire transfer order to be sent to \nJane Doe Number Five. \nWhat evidence do you have to support \nthat? \nA \nWe have \n's statements and we also \nhave the Western Union receipt showing that she \nreceived that amount of money. \nQ \nAnd those were in response to a subpoena \nissued on behall of this grand jury? \nA \nYes. \nIf I could direct you to Overt Act \nNumber 82 involving Adriana Ross. What is the \nbasis for that Overt Act? \nA \nAgain, a review of the phone records \nIrom Felicia and \ntelephone indicate \nthat they had contact at that time. \n4 \nAnd Overt Act Number 88 states that on \nor about January 26, 2005, Defendant \nreviewed \na telephone message from Jane Doe Number Five. \nWhat is the basis for that allegation? \nA \nWe have reviewed the message pads that \nwere recovered during the execution of the state \nsearch warrant and recovered a message that \nIIIIIIa left for Adriana confirming an appointment \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226657\n", "char_count": 1130}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 262, "text_content": "12 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nthat I have a copy of that if you want me to read \nthat to you. \nSure. \nA \nIt's a message for Adriana dated January \n26th, 2005, at 1 :30 p.m. It's from Felicia and it \nsays, in parentheses, you know the number, and it \nsays she is confirming 5:30 p.m. \nQ \nAll right. \nAnd then with respect to \nOvert Acts Numbers 108 and 115 related to Ms. \nRoss, what is the evidence supporting those Overt \nActs? \nA \nAgain, a review of the phone records of \nAdriana Ross and \na. \nWe show that there was \ntelephonic contact on those dates. \nQ \nAnd then if I could refer you to \nsubstantive offense Count Number Nine, which is \nthe enticement charge. Can you just remind the \ngrand jury of the evidence supporting that \nallegation? \nA \nOn or about those dates, a facility of \ninterstate commerce was used, specifically the \ntelephone between \nKellen, \nand \nFelicia. \nThose telephones were used to set up and \narrange appointments for Mr. Epstein. \nAs we \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226658\n", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 263, "text_content": "13 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ndiscussed earlier during the massage the sexual \nactivity that took place, the straddling of him by \nI'll\" a where he began to masturbate between \nhis -- between her legs, excuse me, while she \ncontinued to massage him and rub his nipples, him \nasking her to become completely nude. \nHe digitally penetrated her, as we \ntalked about. \nHe used a back massager on her on \nat least two occasions, and he had sexual \nintercourse with I'll\"  a as well as performed oral \nsex on I'll\"  a. \nHe paid Illilia anywhere from $300 to \n$600. \nHe provided her with gifts, a poetry book, \nIIIIII[a Secret underwear. It was \nKellen \nwho had set up the room with the massage table and \nset out the oils. \nAnd then, of course, we did discuss the \nprivate car that was sent to her when she wasn't \navailable to drive herself. He did pay a -- I \ndidn't mention this earlier -- he paid a truck \npayment for her when she was short on money. So \nthat was another thing that Mr. Epstein provided \nto Felicia, and she was 17 during all of this \nactivity. \nQ \nAll right. And if I could refer you to \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226659\n", "char_count": 1232}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 264, "text_content": "14 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nCount Number 53, which is the sex trafficking \noffense. \nIs the information that you just \nsummarized the same information that supports that \ncount? \nA \nYes. The only thing I wanted to tell \nyou regarding her age, she told Mr. Epstein that \nshe was 18 on the lirst visit. \nA couple of visits \nlater they discussed her birthday. They were \ntalking about her birthday and her plans for her \nbirthday and Mr. Epstein asked her -- said \nsomething to the effect like: You are going to be \n18? \nAnd she said yes. \nAnd he said: So you are not 18? She \nlaughed and said no and they kind of laughed and \nthey continued on with the massage. \nSo Mr. \nEpstein was aware through that conversation that \nhad not yet turned 18. \nQ \nAll right. \nMS. VILLAFANA: \nAre there any questions \nregarding Illilla before we continue? All \nright. \nLet's turn now to Jane Doe Number \nSix. \nTHE WITNESS: Did we do the count, the \ntraveling count? \nMS. \nNo, we are not going to \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226660\n", "char_count": 1108}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 265, "text_content": "15 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ndo those today. \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. \nBY MS. \nQ \nAnd if you could tell us Jane Doe Number \nSix's first name and her date of birth? \nA \nJane Doe Number Six is IIIIIIIIII H. She \nalso attended Royal Palm Beach High School and her \ndate of birth is December 30, 1986. \nQ \nHow did Jane Doe Number Six come to be \nintroduced to Mr. Epstein? \nA \n I \nalso contacted -- or told \nabout providing massages to Mr. Epstein. She told \nAlex -- which I'm going to refer to her as Alex. \nThat's what she goes by, but her name is \nAlexandra. That he wanted cute girls to give him \nmassages and that he would pay $200. \nWe had have contact starting with \nin July of 2000 between \n \nand that \nIMI \nphone contact continues until September 2005. \nBetween this time period, we have over 200 --\napproximately 225 calls between \nKellen and \nDuring Alex's first massage,  \nbrought ■ \nover there and was paid $200 by Mr. \nEpstein. \nShe left. \nperformed the first \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226661\n", "char_count": 1095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 266, "text_content": "16 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nmassage topless. \nHe asked her to take her skirt \nand her shirt ofl. \nShe said no at first and later in the \nmassage, the way \nputs it, is that he talked \nher into it and she removed her shirt, which she \nwas not wearing a bra at the time. \nMr. Epstein fondled her breasts. He \nasked her to remove her panties and she said no. \nHe masturbated and as soon as he ejaculated, the \nmassage was over. \nShe was paid $200 for that. \nShe, at that point, she did start \nworking for Epstein on a regular basis. She \nindicated that she had been there hundreds of \ntimes over this time period. \nShe told us -- and I'm going to read a \nquote to you that she said to me or said to not to \nme but to law enforcement -- she said -- and this \nis referring to after the first time that she went \nthere. \nShe said I first told him that i had a \nproblem with it, what happened the first time, \nbut $200 for 45 minutes that was a lot for a \n16-year-old girl making six bucks an hour. \nNow that was a statement she made to law \nenforcement. Going through her phone records and \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226662\n", "char_count": 1214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 267, "text_content": "17 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nduring her interview with law enforcement, she \ngoes back and forth on whether she is 16 or 17. \nIt's now over a year since she started \nworking -- a year and a half since she started \nworking for Mr. Epstein and going back and trying \nto retrace her age, she did say that, but we \nbelieve at that time she was 17 due to the phone \ncontact. \nSo we are not sure when that first \nmassage started, but the phone contact with \nKellen began in July of '04 when she would have \nbeen 17. \nQ \nAnd just to be clear, during that \ninterview with law enforcement, did Alex have \naccess to her phone records? \nA \nNo. \nQ \nAnd the interviewing officer also didn't \nhave access to those records, correct? \nA \nNo. \nQ \nSo she was just saying she couldn't \nremember if she was 16 or 17 at the time? \nA \nRight. \nAs I said, she became kind of a regular. \nHe increased her pay to $300 to $400 as long as he \ncould touch her. She stated that the massages \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226663\n", "char_count": 1091}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 268, "text_content": "18 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nwould progress over time and at first she would \nnot take off her panties, then she did. \nShe performed the massages naked. He \nwould rub Alex's vagina. \nHe also digitally \npenetrated \nHe performed oral sex on \nHe would masturbate while rubbing himself on \ns breasts. \nLater in the times that \nwas \nperforming the massages, he requested that she \nbecome sexually involved with \nMr. Epstein asked \nto perform oral sex on \nand \nrefused and Mr. Epstein told her \nthat i \nshe was toperform oral sex on \nit\n \nfive minutes, he would give her another $200. So \nshe did. \nAlex and \nengaged in sexual \nactivity less than live times. \nMr. Epstein would \nalso partake in that sexual activity as well. On \none occasion with all three of them, as we had \nmentioned earlier in a grand jury session, \nthe massage was over and ■ \nwas standing up near \nthe massage table and Mr. Epstein bent her face \ndown and held her head and penetrated Alex's \nvagina. \nI think she described it as that he went \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226664\n", "char_count": 1139}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 269, "text_content": "19 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ninside her four or five times with his penis and \nshe had a rule with Mr. Epstein that at lirst was \nthat he would not ever penetrate her with any \nobject, anything. \nAnd when he first digitally penetrated \nher on the first time, she, you know, asked him \nwhy he was doing that. \nHe said: Oh, I thought we \nhad done this before. \nAnd later he continues to digitally \npenetrate her. \nOn this occasion, she said: \nWhat \nare you doing? And he said that he just wanted \nto see this. \nQ \nSo at the time that that occurred, she \nstill had a rule with him, but the rule was that \nhe would not penetrate her vagina with his penis? \nA \nRight. \nAnd Mr. Epstein gave \n-- we'll talk \nabout several gifts. One of the gifts that Mr. \nEpstein gave was a 2005 Dodge Neon. \nIt only had \nseven miles on it. \nbelieves that that car was bought \nfor her. \nWe have reason to believe it was most \nlikely rented and we are determining that right \nnow, but he gave her this. \nIt only had seven miles and she gave \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226665\n", "char_count": 1146}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 270, "text_content": "20 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nthat back to him before she got out of high \nschool. \nAnd she said, and this is her quote: \nIt \ngot too sticky for me. \nHe wanted more than I was \nwilling to give. \nShe stated that Epstein requested her to \nhave sex with him multiple times and also wanted \nhim to -- wanted her to perform oral sex on him \nand she refused to do that, and Mr. Epstein knew \nthat that was not going to happen. \nAnd, again, that's one of the reasons \nwhy she ended up giving back the car because it \njust was getting a little bit, as she referred to, \nsticky for her. \nAfter that occasion, where he did \npenetrate her vagina, he paid her $1 ,000 after \nthat. Some of the gifts that she received other \nthan the car, she describes that as \n' \na \na \nSecret underwear and a bra and pantie set she \nreceived. \nShe received Christmas bonuses, movie \ntickets, VIP show tickets. \nShe went to the David \nCopperfield show. She met with him. She went to \nthe after party. She received a Louis Vuitton \nbag. \nwas in a play at her high school \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226666\n", "char_count": 1170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 271, "text_content": "21 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nand Mr. Epstein sent her a dozen roses -- or two \ndozen roses, I believe, to her high school, had \nthem delivered to her high school while she was \nperforming at this play. \nHe also lor her 18th birthday, he Ilew \nher to New York for her 18th birthday, and she was \nflown up there on her birthday and that was done \nbecause Mr. Epstein didn't want to have to deal \nwith the parental consent needed to fly somebody \nunder the age of 18 to New York. \nSo on her 18th birthday with his \nfunding, she flew to New York. She received show \ntickets to the Phantom of the Opera. Epstein was \nnot present in New York at this time. \nHe was \ncalled away and was not there. \nSo she does have friends in New York and \nshe stayed with those friends and attended the \nshow that Mr. Epstein had purchased those tickets \nfor. The other thing about \nis she said that \nshe would get paid every time she would go over \nthere and she said she feels like she went over \nthere hundreds of times. \nShe said that sometimes he would just \nhave her naked watching TV or reading a book. \nHe \nwould sometimes just ask her to lay with him \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226667\n", "char_count": 1264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 272, "text_content": "22 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nnaked. She was still always paid and he would \ninvite her over for breakfast. \nHe would invite her to dinner and \nsometimes just to use the pool, but that she was \nalways paid for coming over there. \nQ \nLet me ask about a couple of other \nthings. You mentioned the specific conversation \nabout she could only fly up on her 18th birthday \nso that he wouldn't have to get parental consent \nfor her flight? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd you mentioned the delivery of the \nroses to the high school. \nIn addition to those, \nwere other events that occurred that should have \nled Mr. Epstein or probably did lead Mr. Epstein \nto know that she was under the age of 18? \nA \nYes. One of the things that \ntold \nme is that she believed she stayed with him so \nlong because she believed that he was going to \nhelp her get into New York University, NYU. \nShe provided him on multiple occasions \npaperwork. One being her transcript. Trying to, \nyou know, do what she could to keep her grades up, \ndo what she could in the hopes that Mr. Epstein \nwith his influence residing in New York was going \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226668\n", "char_count": 1227}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 273, "text_content": "23 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nto be able to get her into NYU. \nThat again is one of the reasons why she \nstayed because she felt that if she held on for \nso long hoping that this dream would come true. \nShe is currently attending Florida State \nUniversity and doing very well. \nQ \nDo we have any other documentation of \nreceiving payments from someone who worked \nfor Mr. Epstein? \nA \nWe have Janusz Banasiak. \nIt was a house \nmanager I or Mr. Epstein and we were able to get \nhis petty cash receipts and in there is a payment \nthat he paid out of his funds to Alex. \nQ \nNow was \never shown any photo \nlineup? \nA \nYes, she was. \nQ \nAnd was she able to identify any of the \ndefendants? \nA \nShe \nfied =Ma \nQ \nAnd was that the photo array that was \nshown to her? \nA \nYes, it was. \nQ \nWas \nare counsel for the \ndefendants aware of \ns allegations against Mr. \nEpstein? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226669\n", "char_count": 993}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 274, "text_content": "24 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd have they attempted to discredit \nher? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd is one of the bases for their \nattempt to discredit her the fact that she didn't \nappear before the State Grand Jury? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAre you aware of whether or not \nwas \never subpoenaed to appear before the State Grand \nJury? \nA \nThere was a subpoena issued to her. \nnot sure iI she received that. \nEither she \nreceived it the day before or she didn't receive \nit at all and I would need to check my notes and \nshe is up in Tallahassee, mind you. \nSo she was either served the day before \nthat grand jury convened or she never received it \nand I would need to check with probably the \ndetective for sure on that. \nQ \nOkay. \nLet's talk about the allegations \nrelated to Jane Doe Number Six in the proposed \nindictment. If I could refer you to Overt Acts \nNumbers 21 , 26, 34, 38, 49, 51 , 52, 55, 62, 68, \nand 73. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226670\n", "char_count": 1042}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 275, "text_content": "25 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nIf you could tell the grand jury what \nthe evidence is that supports those allegations? \nA \nReview of those phone records on those \ndates indicate that there was telephonic contact \nbetween \nand \nas well as \nstatements that she was called by \nprior to \nand while Mr. Epstein was in town. \nQ \nAll right. And if I could refer you to \nOvert Act Number 57, which states on or about \nDecember 4, 2004, Defendant Kellen provided a \nwritten message to Defendant Epstein regarding \nJane Doe Number Six and Jane Doe Number Seven. \nCould you tell the grand jury about \nthat? \nA \nWe have reviewed message pads that, \nagain, were obtained in the execution of a state \nsearch warrant that indicates that \nleft a \nmessage for Mr. Epstein regarding Alex and \nBritnay, who is Jane Doe Number Seven, and I have \nthat here. \nIf I can read it to you? \nQ \nSure. \nA \nFor Jeffrey, dated 12-4-2004. The time \nis 2:55 p.m. It's from \ny would like \nto work at 4 p.m. if possible. \nIn parentheses, \nis scheduled for 5:00 today. The movie is at \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226671\n", "char_count": 1176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 276, "text_content": "26 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \nS \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n7:30. \nQ \nOkay. And if I could refer you to Count \nNumber Ten, and if you could summarize for the \ngrand jury -- first, if you could refer to the \ndates contained in that count, on July 15th, 2004, \nuntil December 29th, 2004, what was the \nsignificance of those dates? \nA \nThis would be the time period that \nis still under the age of 18. \nQ \nThat she was receiving phone calls from \nsomeone who worked for Mr. Epstein? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd then if you could just \nsummarize the remainder of the evidence according \nto that count? \nA \nOkay. On or about those dates a \nfacility of interstate commerce was used, \nspecifically the telephone, specifically \ntelephones were utilized to \nset up and arrange appointments for Mr. Epstein. \nDuring the massages, Epstein fondled \ns breasts. Epstein used the back massager \nand vibrator directly on \ns vagina. Epstein \nperformed oral sex on \nand Epstein penetrated \nAlex's vagina with his penis. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226672\n", "char_count": 1097}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 277, "text_content": "27 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nMr. Epstein introduced \nMarcinkova \ninto the sexual activity with \n. \nand \nengaged in sexual activity while Epstein \nwatched and masturbated. \nEpstein asked \nto perform oral sex \non \nand when she refused he offered her $200 \nfor five minutes. \ncomplied. There were \ndiI \nIII/ \nerent sex toys used on \nincluding a \nstrap-on dildo that \nused. \nEpstein paid \n$200 up to $1 ,000 \ndepending on the sexual activity that took place. \nKellen had taken \nupstairs. She set up \nfor the massage. \nEpstein paid for a trip to New York for \nher 18th birthday, \nher Phantom of the Opera \ntickets. He rented or provided a car to Alex. \nHe delivered roses to her high school, gave her a \nLouis Vuitton bag, gave her a \nia Secret bra \nand pantie set. \nHe also provided her with a bathing suit \non a return trip he had to Brazil. \nHe told her \nthat he was going to help her get into New York \nUniversity. She believed that was the case. She \nprovided him with her high school transcript and \nshe was 17 at the time. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226673\n", "char_count": 1154}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 278, "text_content": "28 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ \nAnd with respect to Count Number 54, is \nthat the same evidence that supports that count? \nA \nYes, it does. \nQ \nOkay. Before we go on, I know that you \nmentioned with respect to both Jane Doe Number \nFive and Jane Doe Number Six that they were \nintroduced to Mr. Epstein by  IF \nIs  another Jane Doe who will be \ndiscussed at a later time? \nA \nYes. \nMS. \nAny questions about Jane \nDoe Number Six? \nYes. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nI don't know if I'm \nallowed to ask this, and you don't have to \nanswer it, but how did the parents \ndo they \nask where she got the car and a Louis Vuitton \npurse? \nI mean, how do they not know anything \nlike a car? \nBY MS. \nQ \nDid you -- have you interviewed \ns \nparents? \nA \nNo. \nMS. \nYes. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nMy question is that I \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226674\n", "char_count": 912}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 279, "text_content": "29 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nnoticed you are skipping all the travel. \nIs \nthat something that you are going to discuss? \nMS. \nIn the future. As I \nmentioned before, there's -- that question \nis pending and I want to get a definitive \nanswer before we go through that. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nI must have missed that. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nI don't see a Count 54 \non this. \nA GRAND JUROR: Because it is on the \nnext page. \nA GRAND JUROR: Okay. I'm sorry. Thank \nyou. \nTHE WITNESS: \nJust to answer a question. \nThe Palm Beach Police Department -- \ndid \ntell the Palm Beach Police Department that \nher mother believed that she worked there, \nand I would need to go back and check, but I \nbelieve that she worked there as a -- I want \nto say like an assistant or answered the \nphones or something like that. \nAnd at one point, her mother thought \nthere might have been more going on and \nactually ■ \ndid end going over there for a \ntime period, but then she did resume later. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226675\n", "char_count": 1088}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 280, "text_content": "30 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA GRAND JUROR: Okay. \nMS. \nAny other questions? \nOkay. \nBY MS. \nAnd we will turn to Jane Doe Number \nSeven. Could you tell the grand jury the first \nname of Jane Doe Number Seven and her date of \nbirth? \nA \nJane Doe Number Seven is \nand \nher date of birth is \nQ \nHow did Britnay come to go to Mr. \nEpstein's house? \ny worked at the mall, and that \nthrough working at the mall, and \nJane Doe Number Six told \nthat she could \nmake extra money by provi ing a massage to Mr. \nEpstein. \nAlex told her that she may have to be \nnaked for this massage, but if she didn't want to \nshe didn't have to. \nWe have the contact, the \ntelephonic contact between \nKellen and \ny beginning in July 2004 and through \nNovember of 2005. \nThere is approximately 100 calls between \nand \ny B. and there is around \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226676\n", "char_count": 947}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 281, "text_content": "31 \n1 \n2 \n3\n \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nseven calls, approximately seven calls to \nin between \nand Britnay B. and approximately \neight calls between Adriana Ross and \ny. \ny stated that she went about 15 \ntimes to Mr. Epstein's house. \ny is the \nfirst Jane Doe we have talked about that goes to \nLake Worth High School and does not attend Royal \nPalm Beach High School. \nOn \n's first massage, \ntook \nBritnay upstairs for the first massage and set up \nthe room. Epstein instructed \nto leave the \nroom. During the massage, Epstein asked Britnay \nto remove her clothing. She removed only her \nshirt. \ny described Epstein as being --\nshe described him as a respective guy, who would \nconverse with her. \nShe said that they discussed \ndifferent life issues such as where \ny wanted\nto attend college in the future. \nHe also gave her advice. She didn't \nhave the best credit, so he gave her advice on her \ncredit. He also gives her advice on dealing with \nher parents. \nShe performed this massage and she \nwas paid $200 \nor the massage. \ny told us that as the massages \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226677\n", "char_count": 1181}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 282, "text_content": "32 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ncontinued, they would then progress and become \nmore sexual. \nEpstein would try to go further and \nlurther with \nBy the third massage, Britnay had \ncompletely removed all of her clothing. She was \ncompletely nude at Mr. Epstein's respect. Epstein \nla\nwould fondle \ns breasts. \nHe rubbed her vagina. \nHe did not \npenetrate -- did not digitally penetrate her, but \ndid stroke and rub her vagina on the outside. She \nwould tell him no on occasions and she would also \ntake his hand and remove his hand from places that \nshe did not want him to touch. \nMr. Epstein did use a massager directly \non \n's vagina while he continued to \nmasturbate during these massages. On at least two \noccasions, Mr. Epstein \nat Mr. Epstein's \ndirection, \nassisted \ny in giving the \nmassage. \nus that \nAnd on -- the first time Britnay tells \nwas setting up the room and she \nremained in the room and started to undress. \nwas surprised. \nShe was never asked or told this was \ngoing to happen. This is just kind of the way it \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226678\n", "char_count": 1158}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 283, "text_content": "33 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nwent. \nand \ny both massage Mr. Epstein. \nand Epstein began performing sexual acts in \nfront of MI\nEpstein used a massager on M \nvagina in front of \ny as well as they both \nperformed oral sex in front of \ny on each \nother. \nalso touched \n's breasts. \nShe touched her -- touched \nvagina. She took \n's hand and placed it on \nher vagina and \ny pulled it back, pulled It \naway. \ndid use the massager directly on \n's vagina. Some of the gifts that Britnay \nreceived, she did receive also a bathing suit, \nwhich we have from Mr. Epstein's Brazilian trip. \nShe received four tickets for her 18th \nbirthday. Mr. Epstein gave her David Copperfield \ntickets, and on two occasions Mr. Epstein and \nKellen, they wired money to \ny. \nIn June of 2005, on \nsenior \ntrip, her senior graduation trip, \ney went to \nCancun, Mexico. She ran out of money and they \nsent her -- wired her, Western Unioned her $350, \nand then she took a trip in July of '05 to San \nDiego, California, and she also received $200 by \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226679\n", "char_count": 1144}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 284, "text_content": "34 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nWestern Union. \nQ \nAll right. \nMS. \nAnything you want to ask \nbefore we go \no \ne Overt Acts? \nNo. \nAll \nright. \nBY MS. \nQ \nIf I could refer you first to Overt Act \nNumber 23, which says on July 16th, 2004, \nDefendant \ncaused Jane Doe Number Six to \nmake one or more telephone calls to a telephone \nused by Jane Doe Number Seven. \nCould you explain what the evidence is \nsupporting that? \nA \nYes. \nA review of phone records from \ns phone and \ny B. indicated they had \ntelephonic contact at that time. \nQ \nAnd that was following a telephone \ncontact between \nKellen and Jane Doe Number \nSix? \nA \nYes, it was. \nQ \nAll right. \nAnd is that consistent with \nwhat Jane Doe Number Seven told you about how she \nwas recruited to go to Mr. Epstein's house? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nNow with respect to Overt Acts 27, 32, \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226680\n", "char_count": 957}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 285, "text_content": "35 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n39, 41 , 44, 45, 66, 75, 85, 89, and 90, what is \nthe evidence related to those Overt Acts? \nA \nCan we skip 89? \nQ \nOh, yes. \nLet's skip 89. \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate \nthat there was telephonic contact between \nand \non those specific dates as well \nas the statements of \ny that \nKellen \nwould call her in advance or call her while Mr. \nEpstein was in town. \nQ \nAll right. And those records show that \nthe phone calls originated with \nKellen's \ntelephone? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nNow if I could direct you to Overt Act \nNumber 57, which says on December 4, 2004, \nDefendant Kellen provided a written message to \nDefendant Epstein regarding Jane Doe Number Six \nand Jane Doe Number Seven. \nIs that the phone message that you \nmentioned earlier today? \nA \nYes, it is. \nQ \nNow we skipped Overt Act Number 89, and \ncan you tell the grand jury what the evidence is \nrelated to Overt Act Number 89? \ny \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226681\n", "char_count": 1059}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 286, "text_content": "36 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nThat would be a review of the phone \nrecords from \ny B. as well as a review of the \nphone records from \nthat there was \ntelephonic contact on that day. \nQ \nFrom Ms. Ross to \n's telephone? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd then Overt Act Number 92, can you \ntell us what the evidence is related to that? \nA \nThat is on that day a review of their \nphone records of \nphone records \nand \ny B. indicates that there was telephonic \ncontact between the two of them on that date. \nQ \nNow if I could refer you to Count Number \n11 , and if you could summarize for the grand jury \nwhat the evidence is related to that count? \nA \nOn or about these dates, a facility of \ninterstate commerce was used, specifically the \ntelephone, between \n1.1.111, \nand \nB. \nThese phones were utilized to set up and \narrange massage appointments for Mr. Epstein. \nDuring the massages, Epstein asked \ny to \nremove her clothing. \nStarting with the third massage, \ny \nwas completely nude and Epstein touched \n's \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226682\n", "char_count": 1124}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 287, "text_content": "37 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nbreasts. He stroked her vagina. He used a back \nmassager on \n's vagina. He masturbated \nduring the massages. \nOn at least two occasions Epstein \ninvolved MEIME\n into the sexual \nactivity. \nstroked \n's vagina and used \nthe massager on \ns vagina. \nalso placed \n's hand on her \nvagina, which \ny pulled back. Epstein paid \ny $200 on each these occasions. Epstein \nalso provided her with a bathing suit, lour \ntickets to see David Copperfield on her 18th \nbirthday, provided those tickets for her 18th \nbirthday. \nEpstein and \nWestern Unioned \nBritnay on at least two occasions and Epstein \nprovided \ny with advice dealing with her bad \ncredit, with her parents, and her plans for going \nto college, and Britnay was 17 when all this \nactivity took place. \nQ \nOkay. \nSo the dates that appear in Count \n11 run through the day before her 18th birthday, \ncorrect? \nA \nYes, they do. \nQ \nNow with respect to Count Number 55, is \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226683\n", "char_count": 1076}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 288, "text_content": "38 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nthat the same evidence that relates to the sex \ntrafficking charge? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay. \nAnd the date ranges between up \nuntil she turns 18? \nA \nYes, it is. \nQ \nAll right. \nMS. VILLAFANA: \nAny questions about Jane \nDoe Number Seven? \nAll right. \nWe'll go on to \nJane Doe Number Eight. \nBY MS. VILLAFANA: \nQ \nAnd if you could tell the grand jury \nJane Doe's first name and her date of birth? \nA \nJane Doe Number Eight is \nD. \nShe \nwas born October 10, 1987. She attended Royal \nPalm Beach High School and she had been to Mr. \nEpstein's house approximately 15 times. \nQ \nAnd who first introduced I'll\" to Mr. \nEpstein? \nA \nH., Jane Doe Number Six. \nQ \nAnd tell us how that contact began. \nA \nAlex told Ashley that she could make \n$200 if she provided Mr. Epstein with a massage. \nShe told her that she would have to take off her \nclothes, but that she could keep her underwear on. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226684\n", "char_count": 1037}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 289, "text_content": "39 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n, on the first massage, we have -- I guess I \nshould tell you, we have phone contact between \nand \nstarting February 25, \n2005, and that phone contact continues through \nOctober of 2005. \nWe have over 50 calls between \nKellen and \nD, and we have approximately 25 \ncalls between \nand \nOn that \nfirst massage, \nbrought \nand set up the \nmassage table. \nleft the room. \nShortly after that, Mr. Epstein entered \nwearing only a towel. \nmassaged Mr. \nEpstein's leg and back \nMr. Epstein masturdated \nduring this massage. \nI should tell you that \n told us \nthat -- told law enforcement, that he has the \ngirls take off their clothes, and in this massage \nshe did remove her clothing down to her underwear. \nShe kept her underwear on. \nHe would touch her breasts and he would \nalso grab her buttock while he was masturbating. \nThe massages became more sexual. Mr. Epstein used \na massager on \ns vagina, over her panties, \nand \ntold us that on one or two occasions \nshe was completely nude and he did use the \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226685\n", "char_count": 1157}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 290, "text_content": "40 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nmassager directly on her vagina. \nOn one of the times that she was \ncompletely nude, Mr. Epstein had cracked Ashley's \nIIIIII \nback before and she -- Epstein told \nto lay \ndown and that he was going to crack her back like \nhe had done before. \nWhen she laid down, Mr. Epstein \nperformed sexual intercourse on Ashley. \nstated that he did pull out and ejaculated outside \nof her vagina. He gave her an extra 100, $150. \nShe had made $200 up to this point, so it would be \n300, $350 that Mr. Epstein paid her. \nOn another occasion, \nwas brought \ninto the massage. \nand Mr. Epstein engaged \nin sexual acts while \nwould continue to \nmassage Mr. Epstein. \nEpstein did ask Nadia and Ashley to kiss \nand he watched as they touched each other. \n, \nI guess, touched -- I should say \ntouched \ns breasts and continued to touch Mr. \nEpstein as well as this all went on. \nAs tar as the gifts that Mr. Epstein \nprovided to IIIIII , he gave her a photography book \nas well as a digital camera. \ntold us that \nactually gave her the camera, but it was per \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226686\n", "char_count": 1197}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 291, "text_content": "41 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nMr. Epstein's instructions. She was 17 at the\ntime all this activity occurred. \nQ \nAnd what did \nsay about Mr. \nEpstein's knowledge of her age? \nA \nShe told Mr. Epstein how old she was. \nShe told him that she was 17. \nQ \nNow \nwas interviewed shortly after \nthe activity ended, correct? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nDo you remember the approximate date \nwhen Mr. Epstein left Palm Beach County and has \nreturned only for court appearances? \nA \nI believe it was October 6th. It was \nthe beginning of October was the last time we have \nhim \nor when he left the area. \nQ \nAnd \nwas interviewed by the police \nshortly after that time? \nA \nYes, she was interviewed on November 8. \nQ \nAnd during that interview, did she \nexplain when the last time was when she had seen \nMr. Epstein? \nA \nShe had said shortly before her \nbirthday. \nQ \nAnd she said it was actually the first \nweek in October? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226687\n", "char_count": 1027}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 292, "text_content": "42 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n5 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nNow was \nlater called to appear \nbefore the State Grand Jury? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd during that testimony, did she --\ndid she confuse the last day that she saw Mr. \nEpstein? \nA \nYes. She stated -- and this was done \nbelieve in July of '06, so this would have been \nover a year and some months. She did state that \nthe last time she saw Mr. Epstein was the day \nbefore her birthday and that is when the sexual \nintercourse took place. \n• \nOkay. So she thought it was the day \nbefore her birthday, but based on her earlier \nstatement and the records that we have, we know it \nwas a few days before her birthday? \nA \nThe first week of October. \nQ \nOkay. \nIS. \nLet's -- actually, \nbefore we go to the Overt Acts, do you mind \nif I ask the agent a question outside? \nI \nthink I caught another error. Excuse us for \na moment. \n(Ms. Iowa \nand the witness exit the \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226688\n", "char_count": 1021}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 293, "text_content": "43 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nGrand Jury Room.) \n(Ms. IIIIIIIIn a and the witness enter the \nGrand Jury Room.) \nMS. \nThere is a discrepancy \nin Overt Act Number 138. \nThe chart that I \nprovided to you says -- has the name Ross as \nthe relevant defendant and in the indictment \nSo we are trying to confirm \nwho the right caller was. \nA GRAND JUROR: Can I ask a question? \nMS. \nSure. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nYou had said that he had \nnot been in Florida? \nMS. VILLAFANA: Uh-huh. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nHow do they know that he \nhas not come into Florida? \nMS. \nOkay. \nWe can address \nthat wither-' et the agent. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nCould I ask a question? \nMS. \nSure. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nIs there any way that he \nmight have been filming this? Does anybody \nknow about it, I mean, you know? \nMS. \nOkay. \nWe will answer \nthose after we finish going through these \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226689\n", "char_count": 969}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 294, "text_content": "44 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nitems. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nI knew there was a \nreason you were hauling all those records \nback and forth. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nAfter the case is over, \nhow long do you actually have to keep all \nthat? \nMS. \nThis is all on the \nrecord. \nA GRAND JUROR: Yeah. It's curiosity. \nMS. \nOkay. \nAll right. \nQ \nSo from your review of the phone \nrecords, Special Agent \n1, Overt Act \nNumber 138 relates to \nKellen? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay. All right. \nNow let's run through \nOvert Acts 110, 128, 133, 136, 138, \n145, 152, 154, and 156. \nCould you let the grand jury know what \nthe evidence is supporting those Overt Acts? \nA \nA review of the phone records indicate \non those dates there was telephonic contact \nbetween the \n139, 141 , 142, \nKellen and \nD. as well as \nstatements that \nKellen called her \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226690\n", "char_count": 937}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 295, "text_content": "45 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nand in advance as to when Mr. Epstein was in town \nto set up appointments. \nQ \nAnd if you could look at Overt Acts 124, \n146, and '49. \nA \nA review of phone records between \nAdriana Ross and \nD. indicates there was \ntelephonic phone contact on those dates. \nQ \nPhone calls originating with \nending with \nD.? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd Overt Act Number 147? \nA \nOvert Act 147, a review of the phone \nrecords indicate that there was telephonic contact \nbetween \nand IIIIII D. on that \ndate as well. \nQ \nAnd then Overt Act Number 150, says that \non September 8, 2005, Defendant Ross received a \ntelephone call from Jane Doe Number Eight, and \nwhat is the evidence related to that? \nA \nThe evidence on that date is that a \nreview of those phone records indicates that \ncontacted \nQ \nSo with respect to that one, the phone \ncall originated with \nas opposed to being \nwith Ross? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226691\n", "char_count": 1019}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 296, "text_content": "46 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay. \nNow if you could turn to Count \nNumber 12 and summarize for the grand jury the \nevidence supporting that charge of the enticement \nof a minor? \nA \nOn or about these dates, a facility of \ninterstate commerce was used, specifically the \ntelephone, specifically \nKellen, Adriana \nRoss, \n, and \nD., phones were \nutilized to set and arrange massages, massage \nappointments for Mr. Epstein. \nDuring the massages, Epstein would ask \nAshley to remove her clothing. She would perform \nthe massages either in her underwear or completely \nnude. Epstein masturbated while Ashley performed \nthese massages. \nEpstein used a massager on \nvagina with her panties on and with them off. \nEpstein had intercourse with IIIIII. He \nejaculated outside her vagina. \nOn one occasion, Epstein brought \nMarcinkova into the sexual activity, introduced \ninto the sexual activity. They performed \nsex acts on each other, that being \nand Jeffrey Epstein, in front of \nOFFICIAL. REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226692\n", "char_count": 1115}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 297, "text_content": "47 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n, and she continued to massage Mr. Epstein. \nAt Mr. Epstein's request, \nand \nIIIIII did kiss as well as \ntouched Ashley's \nbreasts. Epstein paid 200 to 300 to $350 to \nand that depended on the sexual activity. \nEpstein gave \na book on \nphotography as well as a digital camera provided \nto her by \nand \ntold Mr. Epstein that she was 17 years \nof age. \nQ \nAll right. And is that the same \nevidence with respect to Count Number 56? \nas well as bra and underwear sets, \nA \nYes, it is. \nQ \nOkay. \nMS. \nBefore we go to those \nother two questions that were posed, are \nthere any questions that relates to Jane Doe \nNumber Eight? \nYes, sir. \nA GRAND JUROR: \nIs there any explanation \nfrom any of the girls about the number of \ncalls versus the number of times they say \nthey went there? \nMS. \nI'm sorry. Say it one \nmore time. \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226693\n", "char_count": 977}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 298, "text_content": "48 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nA GRAND JUROR: The number of times they \nwent to visit versus the number of phone \ncalls. There seems to be a big diflerence. \nTHE WITNESS: Yes. There's a lot of \nphone calls and we have phone calls showing \nup prior to his arrival and during his \narrival and some of the phone calls are \nlengthy and some of them are, you know, \nseconds. \nSo either maybe they didn't get through. \nWe are looking at a cell phone bill and \ngetting those totals from looking at the cell \nphone bill and the calls just vary in time \nlength and, you know, the only explanation I \nguess, you know, would be -- and that's just \nme giving you my opinion -- is that, you \nknow, either they didn't reach each other, so \nthey would continue to call back and forth. \nThere was a lot of calls between these \nteenage girls or these adolescent girls as \nwell as the phone activity between \nand \nand Adriana with the girls. \nBY MS. VILLAFANA: \nQ \nAll right. \nAnd also Special Agent \n1, I know that you testified about this \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226694\n", "char_count": 1150}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 299, "text_content": "49 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nearlier in terms of the tendency of victims of \nthis type of offense to minimize the number of \nvisits, for example, minimize the conduct that \nthey engaged in? \nA \nThat is true as well. \nQ \nSo it is possible that the girls went \nmore than five times or ten times? \nA \nYes. \nI mean, it's difficult to try to \nget them to tell you an exact number and that's \nwhy we have approximated, and, again, they have \nminimized either with local law enforcement and \nnow when we go back either through time or just \nbeing able to -- you know, the approach, they have \nbeen able to tell us a little more of what took \nplace. \nAgain, \nstated she went hundreds of \ntimes. Can we put her down to a number? Two \nhundred and twenty-five phone calls. \nYou know, we \njust know that she went a lot of times. \nYou can look at the phone activity of \nseeing the phone calls that are made prior to his \narrival and during his arrival to try to gage when \nthey were there. \nMS. VILLAFANA: All right. \nAny other \nquestions related to Jane Doe Number Eight? \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226695\n", "char_count": 1190}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 300, "text_content": "50 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nOkay. \nBY MS. \n• \n• \nQ \nThen we have two questions that were \nraised earlier. One of which was whether there is \nany evidence to suggest that Mr. Epstein filmed \nany of these encounters? \nA \nWe don't have any evidence at this time. \nSome of girls were asked that question but there's \nno evidence to show that he did or indicate that \nhe did. \nQ \nAll right. And then the second one was \nwe had talked earlier about Mr. Epstein leaving \nFlorida and not returning. What evidence do you \nhave regarding where Mr. Epstein has been since \nOctober of 2005? \nA \nHe has -- and I may have misspoke if I \nsaid he has not ever come back. \nHe has come back \nbecause of the state charges he has faced. He has \nhad to come into Palm Beach County for that. \nWe do not believe that he has been here \nother than that since the investigation broke in \nOctober of '05, other than having to appear before \nthe state charges. \nWe know where Mr. Epstein resides and we \nhave a partner, ICE, Immigration and Customs \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226696\n", "char_count": 1151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 301, "text_content": "51 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \nEnforcement, who can -- is helping us monitor his \nplane activity, and, although, we were not privy \nto all of his domestic flights when he comes in \nand out of the country, we are alerted to that. \nQ \nAnd you mentioned earlier that you \n6 \ninterviewed Janusz Banasiak, correct? \n7 \nA \nYes. \n8 \nQ \nWho currently serves in what position of \n9 Mr. Epstein? \n10 \nA \nHe is currently the house manager for \n1 1 \nMr. Epstein and maintains the property over in \n12 Palm Beach. \n13 \nQ \nAnd what did he tell you about Mr. \n14 \nEpstein? \n15 \nA \nHe also said that Mr. Epstein has not \n16 \nbeen back. \n17 \nQ \nOkay. \n18 \nMR. \nAny other questions? \n19 \nAll right. You guys get a break next. All \n20 \nright. \nWe will see you \nI will be out of \n21 \ntown next week and I will probably see you \n22 \nthe week after that. \n23 \n(Witness was excused.) \n24 \n25 \nOFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226697\n", "char_count": 920}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 302, "text_content": "52 \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7\n9 \n10 \n1 1 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 .\n25 \nI, Paula E. Angelocci, Certified Court \nReporter and Notary Public, do certify that the \ntranscript is a true and correct transcription of \nmy stenotype notes of the testimony of \nSPECIAL AGENT E. NESBITT \ntaken before \nthe Federal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach, Florida. \nPAULA E. ANGEjICCI, CSR #4869 \nCertified Cou \nReporter \nOFFICIAL. REPORTING SERVICE, LLC \n(954) 467-8204 \nEFTA00226698\n", "char_count": 505}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 303, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 3340! \n(561) 820-8711 \nFacsimile: (561)8204777 \nJune 7, 2007 \nD LIVERY BY HAND \nMiss \nRe: \nCrime Victims' and Witnesses' Rights \nDear \nPursuant to the Justice for All Act of 2004, as a victim and/or witness of a federal offense, \nyou have a number of rights. Those rights arc: \n(I) \nThe right to be reasonably protected from the accused. \n(2) \nThe right to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of any public court proceeding \ninvolving the crime or of any release or escape of the accused. \n(3) \nThe right not to be excluded from any public court proceeding, unless the court \ndetermines that your testimony may be materially altered if you are present for other \nportions of a proceeding. \n(4) \nThe right to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court \ninvolving release, plea, or sentencing. \n(5) \nThe reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the United States in the case. \n(6) \nThe right to full and timely restitution as provided in law. \n(7) \nThe right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay. \n(8) \nThe right to be treated with fairness and with respect for the victim's dignity and \nprivacy. \nMembers of the U.S. Department of Justice and other federal investigative agencies, \nincluding the Federal Bureau of Investigation, must use their best efforts to make sure that these \nrights are protected. If you have an concen i r this regard, please feel free to contact me at 561 \n209-1047, or Special Agen \nfrom the Federal Bureau of Investigation at 561 \n822-5946. \nYou also can con ac \na ustice Department's Office for Victims of Crime in \nWashington, D.C. at 202-307-5983. That Office has a website at www.ovc.gov. \nYou can seek the advice of an attorney with respect to the rights listed above and, if you \nbelieve that the rights set forth above arc being violated, you have the right to petition the Court for \n... [truncated, 2035 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/303 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=303]", "char_count": 2035}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 304, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \n(561) 820-8711 \nFacsimile: (561) 820-8777 \nJune 7, 2007 \nDELIVERY BY HAND \nMiss \nRe: \nCrime Victims' and Witnesses' Rights \nDearan \nPursuant to the Justice for All Act of 2004, as a victim and/or witness of a federal offense, \nyou have a number of rights. Those rights are: \n(4) \n(5) \n(6) \n(7) \n(8) \nThe right to be reasonably protected from the accused. \nThe right to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of any public court proceeding \ninvolving the crime or of any release or escape of the accused. \nThe right not to be excluded from any public court proceeding, unless the court \ndetermines that your testimony may be materially altered if you are present for other \nportions of a proceeding. \nThe right to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court \ninvolving release, plea, or sentencing. \nThe reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the United States in the case. \nThe right to full and timely restitution as provided in law. \nThe right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay. \nThe right to be treated with fairness and with respect for the victim's dignity and \nprivacy. \nMembers of the U.S. Department of Justice and other federal investigative agencies, \nincluding the Federal Bureau of Investigation, must use their best efforts to make sure that these \nrights are protected. If you have an concerns in this regard, please feel free to contact me at 561 \n209-1047, or Special Agent \nfrom the Federal Bureau of Investigation at 561 \n822-5946. You also can contact the Justice Department's Office for Victims of Crime in \nWashington, D.C. at 202-307-5983. That Office has a website at www.ovc.gov. \nYou can seek the advice of an attorney with respect to the rights listed above and, if you \nbelieve that the rights set forth above are being violated, you have the right to petition the Court for \nrelief\n... [truncated, 2016 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/304 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=304]", "char_count": 2016}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 305, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \n(561) 820-8711 \nFacsimile: (56O 820-8777 \nJune 7, 2007 \nDELIVERY BY HAND \nMiss \nDear \nRe: \nCrime Victims' and Witnesses' Rights \nhe Justice for All Act of 2004, as a victim and/or witness of a federal offense, \nyou have a number of rights. Those rights arc: \n(1) \nThe right to be reasonably protected from the accused. \n(2) \nThe right to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of any public court proceeding \ninvolving the crime or of any release or escape of the accused. \n(3) \nThe right not to be excluded from any public court proceeding, unless the court \ndetermines that your testimony may be materially altered if you are present for other \nportions of a proceeding. \n(4) \nThe right to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court \ninvolving release, plea, or sentencing. \n(5) \nThe reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the United States in the case. \n(6) \nThe right to full and timely restitution as provided in law. \n(7) \nThe right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay. \n(8) \nThe right to be treated with fairness and with respect for the victim's dignity and \nprivacy. \nMembers of the U.S. Department of Justice and other federal investigative agencies, \nincluding the Federal Bureau of Investigation, must use their best efforts to make sure that these \nrights are protected. If you have an concerns in this regard, please feel free to contact me at 561 \n209-1047, or Special Agent \nfrom the Federal Bureau of Investigation at 561 \n822-5946. You also can contact the ustice Department's Office for Victims of Crime in \nWashington, D.C. at 202-307-5983. That Office has a website at www.ovc.gov. \nYou can seek the advice of an attorney with respect to the rights listed above and, if you \nbelieve that the rights set forth above are being violated, you have the right to petition the Court for \nrelief. \n... [truncated, 2014 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/305 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=305]", "char_count": 2014}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 306, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Ave.. Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \n(561) 820-8711 \nFacsimile: (561) 820-8777 \nJune 7, 2007 \nDELIVERY BY HAND \nMiss \nRe: \nCrime Victims' and Witnesses' Rights \nDear \nPursuant to the Justice for All Act of 2004, as a victim and/or witness of a federal offense, \nyou have a number of rights. Those rights are: \n(4) \n(5) \n(6) \n(7) \n(8) \nThe right to be reasonably protected from the accused. \nThe right to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of any public court proceeding \ninvolving the crime or of any release or escape of the accused. \nThe right not to be excluded from any public court proceeding, unless the court \ndetermines that your testimony may be materially altered if you are *sent for other \nportions of a proceeding. \nThe right to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court \ninvolving release, plea, or sentencing. \nThe reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the United States in the case. \nThe right to full and timely restitution as provided in law. \nThe right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay. \nThe right to be treated with fairness and with respect for the victim's dignity and \nprivacy. \nMembers of the U.S. Department of Justice and other federal investigative agencies, \nincluding the Federal Bureau of Investigation, must use their best efforts to make sure that these \nrights are protected. If you \nconcerns in this regard, please feel free to contact me at 561 \n209-1047, or Special Agent \nfrom the Federal Bureau of Investigation at 561 \n822-5946. \nYou also can contact the Justice Department's Office for Victims of Crime in \nWashington, D.C. at 202-307-5983. That Office has a website at www.ovc.gov. \nYou can seek the advice of an attorney with respect to the rights listed above and, if you \nbelieve that the rights set forth above are being violated, you have the right to petition the Court for \nrelief. \nEFTA002\n... [truncated, 2006 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/306 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=306]", "char_count": 2006}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 307, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Ave.. Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \n(561) 820-8711 \nFacsimile: (561) 820-8777 \nJune 7, 2007 \nDELIVERY B HAND \nMiss \nRe: \nCrime Victims' and Witnesses' Rights \nDear \nPursuant to the Justice for All Act of 2004, as a victim and/or witness of a federal offense, \nyou have a number of rights. Those rights are: \n(1) \nThe right to be reasonably protected from the accused. \n(2) \nThe right to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of any public court proceeding \ninvolving the crime or of any release or escape of the accused. \n(3) \nThe right not to be excluded from any public court proceeding, unless the court \ndetermines that your testimony may be materially altered if you are present for other \nportions of a proceeding. \n(4) \nThe right to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court \ninvolving release, plea, or sentencing. \n(5) \nThe reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the United States in the case. \n(6) \nThe right to full and timely restitution as provided in law. \n(7) \nThe right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay. \n(8) \nThe right to be treated with fairness and with respect for the victim's dignity and \nprivacy. \nMembers of the U.S. Department of Justice and other federal investigative agencies, \nincluding the Federal Bureau of Investigation, must use their best efforts to make sure that these \nrights are protected. If you have an concerns in this regard, please feel free to contact me at 561 \n209-1047, or Special Agent \nfrom the Federal Bureau of Investigation at 561 \n822-5946. You also can contact \ne ustice Department's Office for Victims of Crime in \nWashington, D.C. at 202-307-5983. That Office has a website at www.ovc.gov. \nYou can seek the advice of an attorney with respect to the rights listed above and, if you \nbelieve that the rights set forth above are being violated, you have the right to petition the Court f\n... [truncated, 2026 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/307 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=307]", "char_count": 2026}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 308, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \n(561) 820-8711 \nFacsimile: (561) 820-8777 \nJune 7, 2007 \nDELIVERY BY HAND \nMiss \nRe: \nCrime Victims' and Witnesses' Rights \nDear \nPursuant to the Justice for All Act of 2004, as a victim and/or witness of a federal offense, \nyou have a number of rights. Those rights are: \n(1) \nThe right to be reasonably protected from the accused. \n(2) \nThe right to reasonable, accurate, and timely notice of any public court proceeding \ninvolving the crime or of any release or escape of the accused. \n(3) \nThe right not to be excluded from any public court proceeding, unless the court \ndetermines that your testimony may be materially altered if you are present for other \nportions of a proceeding. \n(4) \nThe right to be reasonably heard at any public proceeding in the district court \ninvolving release, plea, or sentencing. \n(5) \nThe reasonable right to confer with the attorney for the United States in the case. \n(6) \nThe right to full and timely restitution as provided in law. \n(7) \nThe right to proceedings free from unreasonable delay. \n(8) \nThe right to be treated with fairness and with respect for the victim's dignity and \nprivacy. \nMembers of the U.S. Department of !once and other federal investigative agencies, \nincluding the Federal Bureau of Investigation, must use their best efforts to make sure that these \nrights are protected. If you have an concerns in this regard, please feel free to contact me at 561 \n209-1047, or Special Agent \nfrom the Federal Bureau of Investigation at 561 \n822-5946. \nYou also can contact the Justice Department's Office for Victims of Crime in \nWashington, D.C. at 202-307-5983. That Office has a wcbsitc at www.ovc.gov. \nYou can seek the advice of an attorney with respect to the rights listed above and, if you \nbelieve that the rights set forth above are being violated, you have the right to petition the Court\n... [truncated, 2027 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/308 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=308]", "char_count": 2027}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 309, "text_content": "From: \nSent: \nu \nay, June 14, 2007 2:14 PM \nTo: \nSubject: \nAddendum to Pros Memo \nHi all — I have attached hereto an addendum to the Pros Memo ad \ning some of the \n• ' • \ncems that \nyou raised regarding Jane Doe #6. I have not sent this directly to \nthe book containing the pros memo and the attachments. \nli\n, but I would ask \nadd it to \nOn another note, we have all discussed different strategies regarding how the final indictment should appear. \nAt this time, I have not made any revisions to the indictment. Based upon the continued investigation there are \nsome things that I would like to add (another Jane Doe has been identified and interviewed) and, based upon \nyour comments, some items that could be deleted. Do you want me to make those changes now or wait until we \nhave received approval of the current charging strategy? \nThank you. If there is anything that you would like me to prepare in advance of the meeting on the 26th, please \nlet me know. \nAddendum to \nPros Memo.pdf \nAssistant U.S. Attorney \n500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400 \nWest \n0 I \nTracking: \n132 \nExhibit 31 \nEFTA00226705\n", "char_count": 1104}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 310, "text_content": "Read \nRead: 6/14/2007 2:22 PM \nRead: 6/14/2007 3.48 PM \n133 \nEFTA00226706\n", "char_count": 74}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 311, "text_content": "From: \nSent: \nTo: \nSubject: \nRE: Meeting Next Week \nAMP111117,11KIIIISIPZI• \nSounds good. I will stop by on Monday afternoon. Could you just let you assistant know that I may be \nstopping by to get a copy of whatever the defense sends over? \nThanks. \nAssistant U.S. Attorney \n500 S. Australian Ave. Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach FL 33401 \nFrom: Menchel, Matthew (USAFLS) \nSeniailay, June 21, 2007 2:58 PM \nTo: \n, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) \nCc: Lourie, Andrew (USAFLS) \nSubject: RE: Meeting Next Week \nMeeting on Monday is fine. I have meetings with Nand Jeff till around 11 but after that I'm gas As for who is going \nto be at the meeting from our side, I thought you, me, Andy, and Jeff. I thought it best to leave \nout of it at this \nventure. As for the Epstein camp, I'm not entirely sure because I don't think Lily was sure last time we spoke. Probably \nher, Lercourt, Black and maybe Lewis. \nLily told me that they wanted to present something in writing before the meeting which was why she was pushing us for \nthe statutes. I view the meeting more as us listening and them presenting their position so I would say that you don't \nneed to prepare anything (you are quite knowledgeable on the law in any event) but if you disagree we can discuss on \nMonday. As for the documents that they have yet to produce, I'll mention it to Lily if you like or we can raise it with \nthem at the Tuesday meeting. \nFrom:1=, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) \nSent: \nursday, June 21, 2007 1:37 PM \nTo: \nCc: \nSu\nImportance: High \nHi =I \nwould like to prepare for next week's meeting, and I am wondering if you can tell me who will \nattend, both from our side and for Mr. Epstein. I am hoping that we can meet on Monday to discuss any issues \nand/or strategy before the meeting on Tuesday, so please let me know when you will be available on Monday. \n114 \nEFTA00226707\n", "char_count": 1837}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 312, "text_content": "Also, if there are any issues that you would like me to be prepared to address — either with you on Monday or \nwith defense counsel on Tuesday — please give me a list and I will bring the appropriate items with me. \nSince Lilly has been communicating with you directly about the meeting, and I have given them the list of \nstatutes that they have requested, perhaps you could ask her to reciprocate by providing us with their written \nanalysis (or documents they want us to consider) prior to the meeting so we can address any issues then and \nthere. Also, during a previous meeting, I asked Lilly and Gerry for copies of Epstein (or his assistants') agendas \nand calendars to show that, as they claim, Epstein's travels to Florida were consciously coordinated so that he \ncould maintain his Florida residency for tax purposes. Lilly said she would try to get them to us, but has never \ndone so. I have subpoenaed all of the corporate entities with which Epstein is affiliated and they all claim that \nthey do not have any responsive documents. \nI will plan to be in Miami by around 10:00 on Monday morning, so any time after that is fine. \nThank you. \nAssistant U.S. Attorney \n500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \nPhone 561 209-1047 \nFax 561 820-8777 \nTracking: \n115 \nEFTA00226708\n", "char_count": 1306}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 313, "text_content": "Recipient \nReed \nMenchel. Matthew (USAF LS) \nRead: 6121/20073:28 PM \n116 \nEFTA00226709\n", "char_count": 87}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 314, "text_content": "From: \nSent: \nur ay, une \nTo: \nCc: \nJeff (USAFLS) \nSubject: \nMeeting Next Week \nImportance: \nHigh \nHi Matt: I would like to prepare for next week's meeting. and I am wondering if you can tell me who will \nattend, both from our side and for Mr. Epstein. I am hoping that we can meet on Monday to discuss any issues \nand/or strategy before the meeting on Tuesday, so please let me know when you will be available on Monday. \nAlso, if there are any issues that you would like me to be prepared to address — either with you on Monday or \nwith defense counsel on Tuesday — please give me a list and I will bring the appropriate items with me. \nSince Lilly has been communicating with you directly about the meeting, and I have given them the list of \nstatutes that they have requested, perhaps you could ask her to reciprocate by providing us with their written \nanalysis (or documents they want us to consider) prior to the meeting so we can address any issues then and \nthere. Also, during a previous meeting, I asked Lilly and Gerry for copies of Epstein (or his assistants') agendas \nand calendars to show that, as they claim, Epstein's travels to Florida were consciously coordinated so that he \ncould maintain his Florida residency for tax purposes. Lilly said she would try to get them to us, but has never \ndone so. I have subpoenaed all of the corporate entities with which Epstein is affiliated and they all claim that \nthey do not have any responsive documents. \nI will plan to be in Miami by around 10:00 on Monday morning, so any time after that is fine. \nThank you. \nAssistant U.S. Attorney \n500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \nPhone 561 209-1047 \nFax 561 820-8777 \nTracking: \n117 \nEFTA00226710\n", "char_count": 1729}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 315, "text_content": "Recipient \nRoad \nRead: 6121/2007 1:52 PM \nRead: 6/21/2007 2:24 PM \nRead. 6/27/2007 4:43 PM \nRead: 6/21/2007 2:03 PM \n118 \nEFTA00226711\n", "char_count": 135}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 316, "text_content": "JsI-16-07 \nI I :00il \nFrom-Fowl ur-Illitte Burnett \n3057898301 \nFOWLER WHITE BURNETT P.A. \nEspirito Santo Plaza \nFourteenth Floor \n1395 Bnckell Avenue \nAtom. Florida 33131.3302 \n(305) 789-9200 \nDate: \nTo: \nFax Number: \nFAX TRANSMITTAL \nMonday, July 16.2007 \n1-151 \nF.001/004 \nF-95; \nFrom: \nFax Number: \nMatter No: \nRemarks: \n(305) 789-9201 \nTelephone Number: (305) 789-9200 \n71200 - Epstein \nPlease see attached correspondence from Roy BI \ne \nJeffrey Epstein matter and the letter in response of \nGerald Lefcourt and I would like to speak to you further regar ing same \nsince we do not believe that Marie's letter \nes \nraised by Roy Black. I am in my office at \nOriginal documents will not Follow by mail. \nTime of Transmittal: \na.m./p.m. \nTransmitted By: \nPhotocopy:them& be token of this tronpuission VII IS 10 6, martinet,  sate facsimile paper has limited stu•ate hie \nTHE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS FACSIMILE MESSAGE IS ATTORNEY PRWILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL \nINFORMATION INTENDED ONLY FOR THE USE OF THE INDNIDU.N. OR ENTITY NAMED ABOVE. M THE READER \nOF THIS MESSAGE IS NOT THE INTENDED REGIMENT. YOU ME HERESY NOTIFIED THAT ANY crasersNAnoN. \nOtSTroatfriON OR COPYING OF THIS COMMUNICATION IS STRICTLY PROMOTED. IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED \nTHIS COMMUNICATION IN ERROR. PLEASE IMMEDIATELY NOTIFY uS BY TELEPI-IONE \n(IF LONG DISTANCE. PLEASE CALL COLLECT) AND RETURN THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE \nTO US AT THE ABOVE ADDRFCs VIATHE U.S. POSTAL SERVICE. THANK YOU. \nPLEASE NOTIFY US IMMEDIATELY BY CALLING (305) 789-9200, IF THERE IS ANY PROBLEM. \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nExhibit 32 \nP-011924 \nEFTA00226712\n", "char_count": 1601}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 317, "text_content": ";,!-16-07 \nII:00at \nFrom-Fowler—P..14 Burnett \n3051099201 \n07/16/2667 \n09:06 \n3053582006 \nBLACK SFEB 8 K0RN \nRoy BLACK \nHones M. EiRtAtatek \nSCUTT A. KORNAPAN \nWRY A. STUMPF \nMARIA NCYHA \nJACtIt PtRCZIK \nMARX A.J. SHAPIRO \nJAIME) \nBLACK \nSREBNICK \nKORNSPAN \n& STUMPF \nJuly 13, 2007 \nMneantatigliallatatinaliktflatiSIL \nAssistant United States Attorney \nOffice of the United States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Avenue, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nRe: \nGrand Jury Subpoena William Riley \nDear Ms. \nT-I5I \nP 002/004 \nF-050 \nPAC£ \n32 \nCHRRITIKZ It No \nJessica FOWSZCA-NADLP \nKan-0.102d P. PHIU1P11 \nWON ANNOta \nIturcoe Defacer. JR. \nMArnave P. 0llevi \nRElioolagtoplack.coro \nrepresent\nI \n Jeffrey Epstein, the target of a pending Grand Jury investigation. \nPrior to the initiation of this federal investigation, I represented Mr. Epstein on a \nPalm Beach Florida State Attorney's Office investigation and subsequently an \nInformation, the factual basis of which is identical to, and gave rise to, the federal \ninvestigation presently underway. \nIn connection with my earlier representation of Mr. Epstein, I hired Mr. \nWilliam Riley as a private investigator to act under my direction in anticipation of \ndefending Mr. Epstein against possible criminal charges and any litigation which \nmay have followed. All his investigations were done as my agent and thus are \ncovered by the work product privilege, and all communications to him are \nprotected by the attorney client privilege. \nThough we are not conceding the existence of any computers that would be \n/Lk \nresponsive to the subpoena served upon Mr. Riley, to the extent there are any \ni n. \nsuch computers, they would contain documents that are privileged attorney-client / \nf -t!:›1\ncommunications and attorney work-product. \nYour subpoena also asks fo -e:). -, ) r \nmaterials describing the scope of hits investigation and thus they are our work \ni r ,.../ \nproduct.  \n201 S. tusayne Boulevard. Sui\n... [truncated, 2134 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/317 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=317]", "char_count": 2134}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 318, "text_content": "LIP -1 6-01 \nI I:0las \nFros-Falsr-/hit. Surat' \n3057809201 \nT-!3I \nP 003/004 \nF-853 \n97/16/2097 09:46 \n3853582886 \nPACK SRFB 8 KERN \n2007\nPage 2 \nPACE \n23 \nC\nAs you know, the ;Inked States Attorneys Office Manual., Guideline. for \nIssuing Grand Jury and Thal Subpoenas  to Attorneys for Information Relating to \nthe Representation of Clients, requires that the attorney client and work-product \nprivilieged information sought by the Grand Jury subpoena issued to Mr. Riley \nmust first be authorized by the Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal \nDivision before it may issue. \nTherefore, please advise me as to whether the applicable sections of the \nUnited States Attorneys Office Manual was complied with prior to the issuance,\n' \nepv\nof the Grand Jury subpoena to Mr. Riley. Please also advise as to the preliminary \nsteps taken in advance of the issuance of the subpoena, as required by the \nManual. Finally, please provide rue with the name of the Assistant Attorney \nGeneral of the Criminal Division who undertook the evaluation of the request for \nthe Grand Jury subpoena, as required by the same section of the Manual and, if \nan evaluation was made, the basis upon which the Assistant determined that the \ninformation sought in the subpoena was not protected by a valid claim of privilege. \nRB/wg \nSincerely, \nR r  Black \nBlack Srebnick.. Komspan & Stumpf. P). \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011926 \nEFTA00226714\n", "char_count": 1427}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 319, "text_content": "n1-16-07 \n11:01 eta \nPros—fowler-014 Burnett \n07/14/:UUY VU:J4 !AA auspu4sio.\n3051000201 \nT-151 \nP 004/004 \nF-050 \nU.S- Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District ofFlorida \n300 South Aktznaten AYR, Suite 400 \nWert Palm Beath, FL 13401 \n(561)820-8711 \nFacrtmik: (561) 820-8777 \nJuly 16, 2007 \nVIA FACSIMILE \nRoy Black, Esq. \nBlack Srebnick 1Cornspan & Stumpf PA \n201 S. Biscayne Blvd, Suite 1300 \nMiami, FL 33131 \nRe: \nCorrespondence Dated July 13, 2007 \nDear Mr. Black: \nThank you for your letter ofJuly 13, 2007. You and your firm are neither a subpoenaedparty \nnor counsel to a subpoenaed parry. Accordingly, pursuant- to the Federal Rules of Criminal \nProcedure, I am not at liberty to discuss this matter with you. Moreover, it is nor the practice of this \nOffice to discuss internal Department of Justice policies Aith non-Justice Department persormel. \nIf Mr. Riley believes he has cause to move to quash the subpoena, or if Mr. Epstein does for that \nmatter, counsel for the respective parties should so move. Otherwise, we expect compliance by \ntomorrow, which includes a one-week extension already requested by Ms. Sanche2 prior to Mr. \nRichey's appearance as counsel for Mr. Riley. \nSincerely, \nAssistant United States Anorncy \ncc; \nAndrew Laurie, Esq. \nWilliam Richey, Esq. \nLilly Ann Sanchez, Esq. \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011927 \nEFTA00226715\n", "char_count": 1385}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 320, "text_content": "LAW O1•1Of • Of \nGISliALD 13. Incotrirr, \n•ROYESSioRRL CORIORaft0. \nalf EAST 7/3'-  STREET \nNEW YORE. NSW YORE 10021 \nGERALD 0. LEFCOURT \nleloarypekouituroccom \nSHERYL E RE1CR \nNv \nC. STABILE\now \nFRIEDM•N \n-Oln\nJune 25, 2007 \nBY HAND DELIVERY \nJeffrey Sloman, Esq., First Assistant United States Attorney \nMatthew Menchel, Esq., Chief, Criminal Division \nThe United States Attorney's Office \nSouthern District of Florida \n99 NE 4th Street \nMiami, Florida 33132 \nAndrew Lourie, Deputy Chief, Northern Region \nA. Marie Villafatla, Assistant United States Attorney \nThe United States Attorney's Office \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Avenue, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nRe: Jeffrey E. Epstein \nDear Messrs. Sloman, Menchel and Lourie and Ms. Villafana: \nLLLLL .R3Nt \n.2o2I 7370400 \nFACSIMILE \n221/066102 \nAs you are aware, we represent Jeffrey E. Epstein in connection with your ongoing \ninvestigation. We write to you in advance of our June 26, 2007, meeting to address some of the \nconcerns that have been raised during our recent conversations. Although not exhaustive of all \nthe issues we wish to discuss, or points we intend to raise, we believe this submission will \nfacilitate a more productive meeting by giving you an overview of our position and the materials \nwe plan to present in order to demonstrate that none of the statutes identified by you can rightly \nbe applied to the conduct at issue here. We are prepared to discuss the issues raised herein \nfurther at tomorrow's meeting as well as to discuss additional concerns you may voice, all for the \npurpose of demonstrating why no federal prosecution should lie. \nThe Federal Criminal Statutes Identified Should Not Be Applied Here \nIt is clear from both the fundamental principles of federal criminal law and the specific \nstatutes in question that federal law is not intended to prohibit, nor does it prohibit, all \n\"wrongful\" sexual activity. Indeed, there_is no federal crime of sex with an undera\n... [truncated, 2072 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/320 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=320]", "char_count": 2072}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 321, "text_content": "Gratato B. Impcouirr, \neven assuming such an act took place in this case — nor could there be such a crime under the \nUnited States Constitution.) By and large, the delineation of such conduct (that is, determining \nwhat conduct is wrongful), and the prosecution for such conduct, have been delegated to the --\nstates. Such conduct is punishable under state laws, under which the age of consent varies from \n14 to 18 with many states making sex with a 16 year old completely lawful regardless of the age \nof the other person.2 In short, the role of federal law in this area is carefully circumscribed. \nThe legislative history of the federal \"sex\" statutes at issue evinces no federal concern \nwith the prevalent local phenomenon of young adults — 16 or 17 years of age — voluntarily \nchoosing to engage in sexual contact with anyone they desire. This is strictly a state concern, \nwhich some states have chosen to criminalize, while others have not, and some local prosecutors \nhave chosen to prosecute, while others have not. It is not an accident that, as far as we have been \nable to determine, there is no federal case involving a defendant who maintains a reasonable \nmistake of fact defense, wheralitdefendant reasonably believed IliTc\"ffher person was 18 years \na. p. The federal statutes were not meant to apply in those eiTCUMSULDIXS as such conduct is a \nmatter of state law. The federal statutes were intended to address those cases involving sexual \nactivity with children. Indeed, the federal concerns intended to be redressed by these statutes, as \nevidenced by the legislative history; the advisory tides of the statutes; and even their sometimes \nbroad language, are: the use of coercion and violence to lead children into a life of prostitution \n(12, 13, or 14 years old, or younger); sex trafficking and slavery of children; interstate or foreign \ntravel to have sex with children (or engage in other illegal sexual activity); and trolling for \nchildren on the interne: in order to\n... [truncated, 3367 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/321 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=321]", "char_count": 3367}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 322, "text_content": "tAiV Or VICES Or \nGERALD B. Intoner, P.G. \nunlikely to be sanctioned by the courts.4 To stretch the statutes in the unprecedented way it \nappears is contemplated would do just that. \nAlthough in this memo we have focused primarily on the federal sex statutes, in the same \nway that those statutes cannot logically be expanded to cover the conduct at issue, neither can the \nstatutes governing monetary transactions. These latter statutes, designed to curb the use of what \nwould appear to be otherwise innocent financial transactions to disguise proceeds of unlawful \nactivity and avoid Internal Revenue Code requirements, have no place in this case. The ills \nsought to be remedied by these statutes are far removed from the conduct in which Mr. Epstein \npurportedly engaged. \nWe address each statute in turn, starting with those regulating monetary transactions. \n18 U.S.C. § 1956(aX3) - The Money Laundering Statute - Does \nNot Apply to Mr. Epstein's Alleged Misconduct \nNo reasonable reading of the money laundering statute can countenance such a charge \nagainst Mr. Epstein, for the statute on its face, or as even applied by the courts, has absolutely no \napplication to the alleged misconduct. Under the facts of this case, to charge Mr. Epstein with \nviolating the money laundering statute would be both unprecedented and inappropriate. \nThe money laundering statute was designed to be used and has been consved as a \n\"concealment\" statute, not a spending statute. See Unity. \nShepard,\ni\n  II3d 1116 (10th \nCir.), cert denied, 545 U.S. 1110 (2005); United States \n4 \nF.3d 42 (1st Cir. 2006) \n(money laundering statute does not criminalize the mere spending or investing of illegally \nobtained assets. Instead, at least one purpose for the expenditure must be to conceal or disguise \nthe assets). \nThe Eleventh Circuit has held that 'Igo prove money laundering under § 1956(a)(3), the \ngovernment must show that the defendant (1) conducted or attempted to conduct a financial \ntransaction (2) \n... [truncated, 2964 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/322 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=322]", "char_count": 2964}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 323, "text_content": "Lew Oirfla• \na \nGERALD B. Int:our, P.G \nI\nproceeds of specified unlawful activity,' or ) 'to avoid araction reporting requirement \nunder State orf ederal law\"'. United States \nPuche, 350 \n3d 1137 (11\" Cir. 2003);' see also \nUnited States I Arditti, 955'.2d 331 (5° Cir.), reh'g denied cert. denied 506 U.S. 998 (1992), \ncert. denied 506 U.S. 1054, reh'g denied 507 U.S. 967 (1993) (undercover agent's representation \nthat he was in the cocaine business and that the initial 515,000 were the proceeds of a collection \nsatisfied requirement for establishing basis for money laundering \"sting\" operations that \ngovernment agent represent that property involved in the transaction was the \"proceeds of \nspecified unlawful activity, or property used to conduct or facilitate specified unlawful activity'). \nThus, it is clear that the statute unquestionably and explicitly requires (a) the use of \nproceeds of specified unlawful activity, or (b) cash which is or was represented to be the product \no-  T fo\n activity, with neither paradigm being applicable in the case. That this was how the \nstatute was intended to be used and is understood is further evidenced by section 9-105 of the \nUnited States Attorney's Manual, which states: \nSections 1956 and 1957 both require that the property involved in \nthe money laundering transaction be the proceeds of specified \nunlawful activity at the time that the transaction occurs. The statute \ndoes not define when property becomes \"proceeds,\" but the context \nimplies that the property will have been derived from an already \ncompleted offense, or a completed phase of an ongoing offense, \nbefore it is laundered. Therefore, as a general rule, neither § 1956 \nnor § 1957 should be used where the same financial transaction \nrepresents both the money laundering offense and a part of the \nspecified unlawful activity generating the proceeds being \nlaundered. \nThe allegations of this case simply do not support a money laundering charge. Any \nattempt to make su\n... [truncated, 2975 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/323 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=323]", "char_count": 2975}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 324, "text_content": "Off gee' Or \nOakum B. Lrarcoun, Pt. \nused to purchase airline tickets to fly prostitutes to Las Vegas). Nor did Mr. Epstein use money \nhe knew otherwise to be unlawfully tainted in a financial transaction designed to facilitate, \nconduct, or promote prostitution or other criminal conduct. Rather, to the extent the evidence \nmay show that Mr. Epstein paid for sexual services, he most certainly did so with untainted, \nlegitins4Mknamed funds. \nIn addition, unlike the typical \"sting\" case which 1956(aX3) was enacted to address, \nthere is no evidence that Mr. Epstein was aware, or that government or law enforcement \npersonnel made him aware of circumstances from which he could reasonably have inferred that \nthe finds were from specified unlawful activity. This is not a case where large amounts of cash \nof questionable origin were repeatedly delivered to Mr. Epstein in small denominations in duffel \nbags and boxes. See, e.g.. Puche, supra, 350, 3d 1137; see also United States v. Rahseparian, \n231 k3d\n 1257 \n(10th \nCir. \n2000) \n(government \nfailed \nto \nprove \nthat\n defendant knew that money \nwas o tained by mail fraud, the unlawful activity underlying money laundering count). \n(\n------- \nTo proceed under a view that the statute covers such behavior would lead to the \nunintended result of making use of a credit card or wire transfer to pay for sexual services \nprovided by a prostitute money laundering. That was surely not what Congress intended, how \nthe courts have interpreted the language of the statute, or even how it is viewed by the \nDepartment of Justice. \n18 U.S.C. § 1960 - Prohibition of Unlicensed Money Transmitting Business Does Not \nApply to Mr. Epstein's Alleged Misconduct \nLikewise, a prosecution under § 1960 cannot lie. \n18 U.S.C. § 1960 is a regulatory statute that was enacted in order to combat the growing \nuse of money transmitting businesses for the purpose of transferring large sums of illegally \nobtained monies and to avoid the strictures of the Internal\n... [truncated, 2738 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/324 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=324]", "char_count": 2738}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 325, "text_content": "1-^\"' 4 .ct\nGERALD B. LEPOOTLRT, P.G. \nI .3d at 567 (Iranian immigrants operated money transmitting \nmess rn \nary an ,• elastegui, \n199 I3d at 593 (money transferred to Mexico by unlicensed agent); United States \nBah, 2007 \ntransmitted cash overseas); United Stares \nAbdullah, 2006 U.S. Dist. I.EXIS 47493 (W.D.Va.\ndefendant operated restaurant in New York which also\nU.S. Dist. LEXIS 25274 (S.D.N.Y. 2007)i \n2006) (Iraqi defendant charged customers a fee for transferring money from the United States to \nMiddle Eastern countries). However, as noted, in many instances, due to the lack of uniform \nregulation, these businesses have served to transfer funds which were the proceeds of illegal \nactivity. See United States' Valdes, 2006 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 12432 (S.D.N.Y. 2006) (defendants \ntransmitted proceeds of drug trafficking to Colombia); see also P.L. 103-325, Title IV, § 408, \n108 Stat. 2252. In response to the growing concern about this improper use of these businesses, \nCongress enacted § 1960, in conjunction with § 5330, establishing a regulatory scheme to assist \nin the effective enforcement of criminal, tax, and other laws and prevent such businesses from \nparticipating in any illegal enterprises. Id. \nIt is clear that § 1960 does not apply, and was never intended to apply, to Mr. Epstein's \nS.2 \npurported misconduct. Mr. Epstein did not own or operate a \"money transmitting business\" as \ndefined in § 5330. Nor was he in the money transmitting business. Mr. Epstein was not \nproviding check cashing, currency exchange, or money transmitting or remittance services. Nor \nwas he issuing or redeeming money orders, travelers' checks, or other similar instruments, or \nacting as a person engaged as a business in the transmission of funds. \nIndeed, he was not carrying on a business at all through these transfers. The term \n\"business\" is defined as an \"activity or enterprise for gain, benefit, advantage or livelihood\" \n(Black's Law Dictionary (7°  ed. 2007)) or as \"a usually com\n... [truncated, 3088 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/325 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=325]", "char_count": 3088}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 326, "text_content": "taw Or net, \nOr \nGERA in H. lartaxxarint. P.C. \nI8 U.S.C. § 1591 - The Misconduct Alleged Does Not Fall Within the Ambit \nof the Statute \n18 \n§ 1591 - \"Sex Trafficking of Children or by Force, Fraud, or Coercion\" — was \npassed as part of the Trafficking Victims Protection Act (\"TVPA\") to address a problem far \nremoved from the present set of circumstances: human trafficking, in general, and human sex \ntrafficking, in particular, involving both a commercial and coercive component. The statutory \nscheme was designed to prevent the organized exploitation of women and children for profit and \nwas not intended to address the conduct alleged here: \nThe central principle behind the Trafficking Victims Protection Act \nis that criminals who knowingly operate enterprises that profit \nfrom sex acts involving persons who have been brought across \ninternational boundaries for such purposes by force or fraud, or \nwho force human beings into slavery, should receive punishment \ncommensurate with the penalties for kidnapping and forcible rape. \n147 Cong. Rec. E2179.02; see also United States Department of Justice Civil Rights Division \nAnti-Trafficking News Bulletin, April 2005, Vo. 2, No. I at 1; July 2004, Vol. 1, No 7. at 6; and \nJanuary 2004, Vol. 1, No. I, at 1, 3 (reflecting the positions of President Bush, Attorney General \nformer Attorney General Ashcroft, and former Assistant Attorney General for the \nivi \nt is Division Acosta that human trafficking involves force, fraud and coercion, and is a \nform of modern day slavery). The behavior and actions of Mr. Epstein are far removed from the \nhuman trafficking concerns addressed by Congress in enacting § 1591. Any attempt to prosecute \nhim under this section would be unprecedented and highly irregular. \nNot surprisingly, the case law does not support any such prosecution. Nationwide there \nare relatively few appellate decisions dealing with prosecutions under § 1591. In the Eleventh \nCircuit, there are only a handful, several of\n... [truncated, 2948 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/326 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=326]", "char_count": 2948}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 327, "text_content": ".O.cet at \nGramm B. Liwcount, P.C. \nSims, 161 Fed. Appx. 849, 2006 WL 14581 (I I° Cir. 2006) (unpublished). See also Evans, \nsupra, 47613d 1176. The second involves sex tourism sting operations where the defendants \nsigned up for a \"Taboo Vacation,\" usually to go to Costa Rica to have sex with children. In these \ncases the state interest is relatively minimal and United States treaty obligations have made \nfederal intervention a high priority. See, e.g., United States' Clarke, 159 Fed. Appx. 128, 2005 \nWL 3438434 (11th Cir. 2005Xunpublished); United StatesIStrevell, 185 Fed. Appx. 841, 2005 \nWI. 1697529 (II' Cir. 2006Xunpublished), cent. denied, I 7 U.S. 692 (2006). No such federal \ninterest is implicated in the purely local case of Mr. Epstein. \nHere, there was no trafficking — no \"force, fraud or coercion\"; no threats; no sexual \nservitude; no financial venture; no profit from a financial venture; no forced work in the \ncommercial sex industry; and no transporting of children from underdeveloped countries to the \nUnited States or even across state lines. Nor was there any conduct which can be considered so \nextremely abusive or violent, that an expansion of the statutes beyond their intended purpose \nwould be warranted. \n18 U.S.C. § 2421 - Mann Act - The Statute Was Not Intended To Address \nThe Misconduct Alleged Here \nAny attempt to charge Mr. Epstein under 18 U.S.C. § 2421 would violate both the spirit \nand purpose of the statute. Section 2421 was first enacted by Congress in 1910 to prevent the use \nof intistate commerce to facilitate prostitution, conTbinage, or other forms of immorality. \nflake I Uted States, 227 U.S. 308 (1913); Wilson \nUnited States, 232 U.S. 563 (1914); \nCaminetti \nUnited States, 242 U.S. 470 (1917). The statute's primary purpose was to address \nthe so-called commercial case of transporting females for immoral purposes. Cleveland \nUnited States, 329 U.S. 14 (1946) (even though the Act includes some non-commercial ekses \nfocus is commercial\n... [truncated, 2741 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/327 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=327]", "char_count": 2741}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 328, "text_content": "LAW OII.CCS Or \nGERALD D. LEPOOlat \nIndeed, a nationwide search of reported prosecutions \nconvictions \ner a ct \nreveals that the statute has primarily been limi \nto cases involving prostitution rings/businesses \ntelt\nand their owners. United States! Hearn( 381 .3d 80 (2d Cir. 2004) (woman running \nprostitution business convicted for recruiting and transport of prostitutes under § 2421); United \nStates' Footman, 215 1.3d 145 (I\" Cir. 2000) (pimp who ran a prostitution ring convicted of \nviolating § 2421). Likewise, in keeping with its purpose and title, the statute has been used in \nsex trafficking cases involving the exploitation of the poor and disadvantaged from foreign \ncountries. See, e.g., United States IJulian, 427 I3d 471 (7th Cir. 2005) (sex tourism operator in \nMexico facilitating travel of poor \nexican boy for sexual relationship in the United States \nviolated § 2421). On the other hand, other cases which have targeted non-owners of prostitution \nrings, have further limited § 2421 prosecutions to circumstances involving egregious conduct, \nsuch as the use of force or kidnapping. See, e.g United States v. Lowe, 145 F.3d 45 (1\" Cir. \n1998) (defendant transported woman across state lines against her will and then raped her). See \nalso Poindexter 'United States, 139 12d 158 (8th Cir. 1943) (transportation by defendant of \nwoman across state line with purpose of raping her violated 18 U.S.C. § 2421 since statute \ncovers interstate transportation of woman withoi pecuniary \nmotivei \ne intent is to have illicit \nrelations with her by force or otherwise); Brown United States, 237 .2d 281 (8th Cir. 1956) \nver \n(the defendant violated the Act when he tricked woman into his car and drove her across state \nlines where he threatened, choked, struck and raped her, and then drove her back to the bus depot \nwhere he had picked her up). As we have previously pointed out, the allegations being levied \nagainst Mr. Epstein involve no such misuar4uct \nWe have found no reported \n... [truncated, 3227 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/328 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=328]", "char_count": 3227}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 329, "text_content": "taw MIKES 0/ \n(imam) B. Urecourrr, \ncyberspace - to target children for criminal acts. Congress enacted the intemet trolling statute to \ncombat the alarming increase in interne predators, who were able to maintain their anonymity, \nwhile making unwanted sexual solicitations of vulnerable youngsters. \nThe statutory language and reported decisions confirm the statute's important, but \nnarrow, focus. Section 2422(b) does not establish any federal sex crimes with a minor, which \nremain a matter of state, not federal, concern. Instead, as the reported cases reveal, it defines a \ncrime of communication, not of sexual contact. Indeed, what all of the cases have in common is \nthat the defendant used thkinternet.\")to communicate with a child or purported child (or a person \nwith influence over such a child or purported child), and with the intent to arrange a sexual tryst \nwith the child, with both the belief that the person was a child and with full knowledge that \nsexual activity with an individual of that age was illegal - precisely the situation the statute was \ndesigned to reach. \nMr. Epstein's case lies far outside those parameters, and far outside the language and \nintended reach of the statute. In Mr. Epstein's case, even if there were inappropriate sexual \ncontact with one or more 16 or 17 year olds, there was no use of the Internet to lure young \nvictims, and no danger presented by Internet predation. \n18 U.S.C. § 2423(6) — No Travel For The Purpose of Engaging In Illicit \nSexual Conduct, As Required By The Statute \nThe linchpin of a prosecution under § 2423(b) is \"travel for the purpose of engaging in . . \n. illicit sexual conduct\". The evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that no case can be made \nthat Mr. Epstein ever traveled to Florida in order to engage in illicit sexual conduct. \nElimination of the \"purpose\" requirement of the statute would undermine congressional \nintent, as recently expressed and re-affirmed in the Trafficking Act of 2002 and PROTECT Act \n\n... [truncated, 2925 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/329 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=329]", "char_count": 2925}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 330, "text_content": "LAW orr las or \nGMitit in a Lepcotnrr•, P.G \nLegislative intent, and concepts of federalism, would be undermined if interstate travel with only \nincidental sexual conduct were prosecuted. \nThe nature and scope of Mr. Epstein's activities in Florida do not support the conclusion \nthat any purported illicit sexual conduct was an \"important\" \"purpose of the travel, a significant \nmotivating factor\", or in other words, more than merely incidental. See United States'. \nHorsehauer, 2007 WL 979931 (I I d' Cir. 2007) (unpublished). \nWe understand from conversations with Ms. Villatitfla that she believes that Mr. Epstein \nwas and is a resident of New York, and that all trips to other homes were trips \"away from \nhome,\" undertaken for a limited period and with a specific purpose. The evidence clearly does \nnot support this view.' \nMr. Epstein has owned a home in Florida since September, 1990 - longer than any other \nresidence he has owned - when he purchased the property on El Brillo Way. lie spent \nsubstantial amounts of money during the relevant period to improve and to maintain this home. \nIn addition, his travel records demonstrate that during the relevant period Mr. Epstein both spent \nthe majority of his weekends, and additional time in Florida. Although he left Florida for \nbusiness and other projects, he consistently returned to Florida, weekend after weekend, year \nafter year. Specifically, the flight logs establish that for the period 2003 - 2005 (through \nSeptember) , there is no month when he did not spend at least one long weekend in Florida, \nincluding in the summer months, and that he spent well over half of all weekends in Florida.10\nUpon returning to Florida, Mr. Epstein routinely visited with various family members and \nclose friends, all of whom reside or have homes in Florida, saw his primary care physician for \ncheckups and prescribed tests, and frequented movie theaters and comedy clubs. Notably, during \nthe relevant period, Mr. Epstein's mother took ser\n... [truncated, 3160 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/330 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=330]", "char_count": 3160}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 331, "text_content": "La O. tet S \nGemara, B. l.rsociumr, \nFlorida during that time was to visit with and attend to his mother's needs, sec to her funeral \narrangements, and address matters relating to her estate. \nIn recognition of the amount of time he spent in Florida, during the relevant period Mr. \nEpstein worked with several local real estate agents to purchase a larger home. For example, in \n2004, as publicly reported, he attempted to acquire the Gosman Estate, a unique property that \nwas eventually auctioned by the Bankruptcy Court. \nSimilarly, due to the extensive amount of time he spent in Florida and his desire to have \nhis pilots close by and available should a flight out of Florida be required, the home base for Mr. \nEpstein's flight operations was Florida. Routine maintenance of the aircraft, periodic FAA \ninspections, and interior refittings were all carried out in Florida. Indeed, the regular crew \nmembers - the pilots and engineer - all resided in Florida, as did the majority of contract cr ew \nmembers who were hired from time to time. Both Hyperion Air Inc. (legal owner of Mr. \nEpstein's Gulfstream G-IIB), and JEGE, Inc. (legal owner of Mr. Epstein's Boeing 727), rent \noffice space and a storage facility in Florida for the purpose of housing airplane records, \nincluding flight logs and wiring drawings, and providing the crew with a local office. \nThe amount of time Mr. Epstein spent at his home in Florida, and the extensive list of \nFlorida-based activities clearly undermines the contention that Mr. Epstein is a New York_ \nresident and defeats the notion that his purpose in traveling to Florida was to engage in illicit \nsexual conduct. On the contrary, Mr. Epstein returned to Florida to engage in the routine \nactivities of daily living. We do not believe that the government could overcome the many \nsubstantial hurdles to be encountered when attempting to prove that a specific trip to Florida was \nfor the required statutory \"purpose\" of engaging in specific \"illicit sexu\n... [truncated, 3184 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/331 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=331]", "char_count": 3184}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 332, "text_content": "LAW 0 , 1,ICC• \nGET/ \nt) B. Larceuat P.C. \nconducted pursuant to the state search warrant would need to be litigated. The warrant suffers \nfrom such substantial glaring, facial deficiencies that a motion to suppress would likely result in \nthe suppression of all items seized during the search of 358 El Brilb, as well as all evidence \nderived from the search, both physical and testimonial. \nIn addition, the affidavit prepared by Det. Recarey in support of the search warrant is \nreplete with material misstatements and omissions which, if not intentional, at a minimum, were \nmade with reckless disregard for the truth. The principal misstatements and omissions all \ninvolve Dct. Recarey's assertions of what the women interviewed said in their recorded sworn \nstatements, statements taken by Det. Recarey himself and with which he was fully familiar. \nHowever, a comparison of the transcripts of those interviews with the information set forth in the \naffidavit reveals many instances in which Del. Recarey represented to the issuing judge that the \nwomen interviewed said things which they did not in fact say, or tailed to reveal material \ninformation contained in those same statements that would have been important for the judicial \nofficer to know in determining whether the warrant should issue at all and, if so, whether the \nseizure of the broad categories of items outlined in the warrant should be authorized. \nAdditionally, the execution of the warrant resulted in the seizure of a number of items which \nclearly fell outside the scope of the warrant, thus, requiring suppression of these unlawfully \nseized items. \nThe material misstatements and omissions fall into three categories: (I) the \nmischaracterization of the significance of surveillance/videotape equipment located in Mr. \nEpstein's home; (2) the mischaracterization and misrepresentation of facts associated with the \nages of the women and Mr. Epstein's claimed knowledge of their ages; and (3) the \nmischaracterization \n... [truncated, 2777 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/332 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=332]", "char_count": 2777}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 333, "text_content": "la CO KC.. Of \nOF-ILALD 1i.LErcousrr, \nthe residence. Epstein had purchased covert cameras which were \nbuilt in wall clocks and table clocks. These images were then \ndownloaded onto proprietary spyware software for later viewing. \n(Affidavit at 10). \nThe clear implication of Det. Recarey's statement is that images of the purported \"victims\" may \nhave been captured on the cameras and downloaded to computers where they remained, and \ncould be seized, pursuant to a warrant. \nOct. Recarey, however, knew full well, but failed to inform the court, that the cameras \nwere part of a security system installed with the assistance of the Palm Beach Police Department \nand were located in only two areas of the house - Mr. Epstein's office and the garage. Dm. \nRecarey was also aware - but did not tell the court - that none of the women interviewed alleged \nthat she visited, much less engaged in illicit conduct, with Mr. Epstein in either location. Finally, \nnone of the witnesses ever claimed, even when asked, that Mr. Epstein videotaped her, or \nevidenced any knowledge whatsoever that he may have videotaped her visit. There can be no \ndoubt that hipnisstatements andcmissioAwere intentional and designed to establish probable \ncause that did not exist and to overcome staleness concerns. \nMisrepresentations Regarding The Age Of The Witnesses and Mr. \nEpstein's Knowledge \nOct. Recarey affirmed that \nclaimed: \n(Mr. Epstein) told her the younger the better. (Affidavit at 4) \nAnd, that: \nstated she once tried to bring a 23 year old female and \nEpstein stated that the female was too old. (Affidavit at 4) \nWhat Det. Recarcy, no doubt intentionally, omitted was MEs further explanation, which \nrendered Mr. Epstein's comments innocuous: \nA: \nLet me put it this way, he — I tried to bring him a woman \nwho was 23 and he didn't really like it. \nQ: \nIle didn't go for it? \nA: \nIt's not that he didn't go for it. It's just that he didn't care \nfor it. And he likes the aids that are between the arts o\n... [truncated, 2108 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/333 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=333]", "char_count": 2108}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 334, "text_content": "tAvr pricy\" Or \nGERALD 13. LEFGOCERT. \n! lad that critical information - information that turns allegedly illegal conduct into more innocent \nconduct - been included it would have seriously undermined the probable cause for the search \nwarrant. \nSimilarly, and equally problematic, Det. Recarey refused to include statements \ndemonstrating that when asked by Mr. Epstein, the girls affirmatively misrepresented their ages \nas bein 18, and/or Mr. Ein i  was not aware of their true ages. (Gonzales Statement at 39, \nStatement at 12, \nStatement at 5, \nStatement at 9). Indeed, although he \nnoted that Gonzales had told Mr. Epstein she was 18, omitted from the affidavit why she lied: \nsaid tell him you're 18 because if you're not, he won't let \nyou in his house. So I said I was 18. As I was giving him a \nmassage, he was like how old are you. And then 1 was 18. But I \nkind of said it really fast because I didn't want to make it sound \nlike I was lying or anything. (Gonzales Statement at 39). \nMisrepresentations Regarding The Conduct In Which Mr. Epstein Purportedly \nEngaged \nIn the following statement Det. Recarey affirmatively misrepresented what \n■ \nstated: \n\"Hall states Epstein would photograph them naked and having sex \nand proudly display the photographs within the home\". (Affidavit \nat 9). \nMs.. actually made the following statement: \nA: \n1 was just like, it was me standing in front of a big white \nmarble bathtub ... And it, it wasn't like I was you know \nspreading my legs or anything for the camera, I was like, I \nwas standing up. I think 1 was standing up and I just like it, \nit was me kind of like looking over my shoulder kinda \nsmiling, and that was that. (Hall Statement at 35). \nOct. Recarey further swore in his affidavit that  \nAdvised that sometime during the massage, Epstein grabbed her \nbuttocks and pulled her close to him. (Affidavit at 6). \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-01 1942 \nEFTA00226730\n", "char_count": 1930}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 335, "text_content": "O/ICCS Or \nGICRALL1 a \nLEFGO1,121; P.C. \nsquarely denied being touched \"inappropriately\" or otherwise by Mr. Epstein: \nQ: \n.. . . He did not touch you inappropriately? \nA: \nNo. ( \nStatement at I I). \nThese misrepresentations were compounded by Det. Recarey's failure to include accounts \nby the witnesses that Mr. Epstein did not in fact engage in illicit conduct during their encounters. \nSpecifically, Oct. Recarey did nor inform the court that witnesses stated' \nwere not asked \nto and did not touch Mr. Epstein's genitals, (Gonzales Statement at 43, \nStatement at 12); \n(2) they did not have sex with Misfetispin, (Gonzales Statement at 43); (3) r. Epstein did not \nmasturbate during the massage, \nStatement at I I; \nStatement at 13; and \nStatement at 7); and, (4) Mr. Epstein did not touch them inappropriately. ( \nStatement at \nI 1; \nStatement at 13, IS; Gonzales Statement at 42). \nAfter all the misstatements are corrected, the omissions included, and the irrelevant facts \nomitted, what is left is an equivocal account of an encounter eight months prior to the warrant \napplication and an equally unreliable account of an encounter which, even assuming arguendo it \noccurred, was more than eleven months old. Surely this evidence was too stale to support \nissuance of a search warrant, as it did not provide probable cause to believe that any items \nevidencing a violation of the subject statutes — let alone any items of the type described as \"kept \nand used\" in such violations — would still be on the premises at the time of the search. \nUnlawful Search Of The Second Residence \nThe officers executing the search warrant exceeded the scope of the warrant when they \nentered and proceeded to search the second residence on Mr. Epstein's property. Even if those \nagents did not know in advance that the building was a second residence, which they did,\" that \nfact would have been immediately obvious to them upon entry. Notwithstanding such \nknowledge, they disregarded the tents of the war\n... [truncated, 2755 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/335 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=335]", "char_count": 2755}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 336, "text_content": "GERALD B. Inc:tourer, \nHowever, even assuming the warrant could possibly be read to encompass the search of \nthe second residence, the affidavit is completely devoid of probable cause to search it. \"[W]hen \nlaw enforcement wishes to search two houses or two apartments, it must establish probable cause \nas to each\". United States, Cannon, 264 I3d 875, 879 (9th Cir. 200O. \nThere Was No Probable Cause To Seize Many Of The Items Listed In The Warrant \nIn addition, there was no probable cause to search for videotapes since all the women \nwho were asked whether they had been videotaped denied knowledge of any videotaping. These \nare crucial facts which Det. Rccarey omitted from his affidavit. Moreover, as noted, Det. Recarey \nhad actual knowledge from his prior investigation that that were a limited number of video \ncameras located in the house and they were focused only on Mr. Epstein's desk and the garage -\ntwo locations where money was kept and where no one alleged any wrongdoing took place. \nLikewise, nothing in the affidavit could support a finding of probable cause to believe \nthat computers or computer-related items were used in the commission of the alleged offenses. \nThe seizure and subsequent search of the computers and computer-related items clearly violated \nthe Fourth Amendment. See, e.g., United States' Riccardi, 40513d 852, 862-63 (10th Cir. \n2005) (warrant authorizing seizure of computer, all electronic an magnetic media stored therein, \nand a host of external storage devices without limitation unconstitutional as authorizing general \nsearch); United States 1Joe, 2007 WL 108465 at *7 (N.D.Cal. January 10, 2007) (\"computers \nand related or similar devices, and information on hard or floppy drives, which m\n contain any \ndocuments and records ....\" overbroad and ordering suppression); United States 'Stacy, 433 \nI Supp.2d 499, 500 (E.D.Pa. 2006) (\"[a]ny records, documents, materials and files maintained on \na computer\" overbroad because it authorized agents to\n... [truncated, 3086 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/336 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=336]", "char_count": 3086}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 337, "text_content": "Law *mon or \nGrain) a LatICOURT, P.C. \ninvestigation cannot avoid being tainted by Det. Recarey's actions. Many of the leads the FBI \nfollowed, the witnesses it interviewed, and the documents it subpoenaed all inexorably flowed \ndirectly from the fruits of Det. Recarey's investigation. \nDet. Recarey's credibility is interwoven in the federal investigation given the overlap of \nwitnesses and documentary evidence with the antecedent state investigation. Not only would a \nfederal prosecution implicate issues of the scope of taint of both physical evidence and witness \ntestimony emanating from the state search, a federal prosecution would inexorably result in \nscrutiny of the extent to which Det. Recarers pre-search investigation was adversely \ncompromised by his zeal to prosecute Mr. Epstein. \nThat Det. Recarey's desire to prosecute Mr. Epstein ran so deep is no more evident than \nthrough his participation in the unprecedented, selective, and prejudicial public release of \nmaterials such as the Palm Beach Police Reports and Probable Cause Affidavits. These \ndocuments, like the search warrant affidavit, were replete with material misstatements and \nomissions, one of the most glaring of which was the reference in the Police Reports to the \ndiscovery of a \"sex toy\" in Mr. Epstein's trash. Through the execution of the search warrant, it \nwas discovered that the \"sex toy\" purportedly found in a trash pull was in fact only a piece of a \nbroken salad fork. Despite this discovery, Det. Recarey, bent on painting the facts to support Mr. \nEpstein's prosecution, never took any steps to correct the Police Report and note the innocent \nnature of the item. \nPetite Policy \nWe have previously submitted extensive materials regarding the role the Petite Policy \nshould play in this matter. Rather than restate our position, we would like to discuss it in detail \nat the meeting, \nConclusion \nThis case started as and should end as a state matter. It involves local issues which are \nbest add\n... [truncated, 2663 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/337 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=337]", "char_count": 2663}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 338, "text_content": "Vex Off ICt• Of \nGERALD B. Lzrrcoturr, P.G. \nJeffrey Sloman, Esq. \nMatthew Mcnchcl, Esq. \nAndrew Louric, Esq. \nA. Marie Villafafla, Esq. \nOffice of the United States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \nJune 25, 2007 \nPage 19 \nThank you for your cooperation in this matter. We look forward to meeting on June 26, \n2007. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call. \ntruly yours \nrtjieotuclk...0\nGerald I3. Le co \ncc: \nLilly Ann Sanchez, Esq. \nRoy Black, Esq. \nAlan Dershowitz, Esq. \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011946 \nEFTA00226734\n", "char_count": 551}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 339, "text_content": "Villatina, Mn Mad C. (USAFLS) \nFrom: \ntrivia. »Wow (liSAFISI \nSent \nlAwday..linte 25,2007 4.30PM \nTo. \nManche& 14•Ww« (USAFIS) \nCo \nWain. \nArai Mane C (O*Ft SI \nSub)ect. \nThoughts en lefewaill tear \nWeaker point, pages 9.t0. Section 2122(b). The argument that tit was meant to be Ignited to We neonet Krot \npersuasne. srxe congress used we language \"mail \nany (witty ot intestate \nco•nmetw \nis Ow hest \ncharge ase the man cletenitble lar te<leal MTV tit \nPages 74). Section 1591' the language meardets effect on interstate commerce is broad and the argument that this es \nfar outside the intent of the stalt/te rf not ow twine. They want to wake this teurd like a Cale Ol a local widen swig \na <ell girl that offers nciederal Interest \nIt:I (otter: if more thankful - eit eato \nItem into a btlanesf:hey ate om \nwivolvedIr and there \ner vies tteir tenkes These are not galt who are «hewn.. giving erotic massage, for fronts. \nNet hatacarhe * PTO that pays other girls to be sub-Dimes Once a prostitute Ofterwled to late sub pm& he charges \nroles 'into toe ase and Pay, for the seven \nIf the prostitute does not want CO provide tempts anymore, he tum, back \n.nto the pimp end gruel them the chance to wake saner ty Isecoewg tutethwen \nStronger Pointe: pages 10.12. Section 2423(0) they her of a number of things that I think a coon would find \nPenal/of on the hid. of travel 'with the purpose of Mira \nIn Alit se*. We only have le prow it wit ore of the \nOurDOSes. but most circuits havedefined that as 'a WM cant or motivating purpose of the ravel won Hate or foreign \nbounden's...Is to have \nlegal sanyl aci\"ily\" and thai the sex was rot 'reerely incidental to the Vave: \nOur preel \non purpose n, rat he eels massages every brae he comes to Floral...and makes ammetwents Stole he leaves they. \non tre \nhand. has  a pretty strong argument that (owe Isa resident with nano big  stand\"' ties to DOW dead' \nMt Warta, mad be that MIL\"( dine*, a theatre refatteltOn$ before he lens We to come to his hone d\n... [truncated, 3749 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/339 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=339]", "char_count": 3749}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 340, "text_content": "Ltd' tu0 .244CAIYU 0:r ti \n44);,U kat. \n4e.o/114,4 \nc,) \nwere tianctik- \nujikun tdvr, rnd \nv..p-ctor I122 ord. ctAcciA.0044:* \n(4-ifee exual2_ \nrcu-locip4 \nkincLocicat • \n(2.) \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011948 \nEFTA00226736\n", "char_count": 228}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 341, "text_content": "Constitutionality \n1) Commerce else is su Mir justification \n-Harms \nU.S. , 272 \n2d 478, 481 (4\" Cir. 1959) (addressing 2422(a)). \ni\n2) Lack of de nse re mistakeff age does not violate Due Process. \nU.S.\nRansom, 942 \n2d 775 ( I0\" Cir. 199I ) \n-Also .S. v. Juvenile Male, 211 I. 3d 1169 (9\" Cir. 2000) \n3) Congress has the power to enact a comprehensive regulatory scheme that regulates purely \nlocal activities that ha \na substantial effect on interstate commerce, including the trafficking of \nwomen and girls U S s, \n476 F. 3d 1176 (II\" Cir. 2007) \n-where defendant used hotels that serve interstate travelers and distributed \ncondoms that traveled in interstate commerce, defendant also loses has \"as \napplied\" challenge. \n4) Congress has the power to regulate the instrumentalities of interstate commerce, even if \nthose instrumentalities are used only for interstate activities pursuant to the Commerce Clause. \nEvans.\n5) Section 2422(b) is not unconstitutionally vague. U.S. I Bolen, 136 Fed. Appx. 325 (111°\nCir. 2005). \n6) Section 2422(b) is not unconstitutionally overbroad or vague. U.S.' Thomas, 410'. \n3d 1235 (10\" Cir. 2005) • \nI\nAlso U.S. I Dhingra, 311 I. 3d 557, 161-63 (9\" Cir. 2004); U.S.' Meek, 366 \n3d 705, 720- 22 (9\" Cir. 2004); U.S. \nPanti I, 338 \n3d 1299, 1300-01 (I I\" Cir. 2003); U.S. \nBailey, 228 F. 3d 637, 639 (6\" Cir. 2000). \nCase No. 08-80736-C V-MARRA \nP-011949 \nEFTA00226737\n", "char_count": 1408}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 342, "text_content": "eattWithentiali \nth\numse \nCt. S.An \nr•&it EIVVY,_\nLOHen \n1/66) Caaldocatitt \n2 42 2 (04)• \nafht dote rce Le jail& AAR 83:42-at \nIse. &WS WV' Sand \n71. 5 coi\nl\" \nCjes elf-j) \nr .. \n1.11 t.'\n.4 3\n'VI \nCU !ILI \nCg HA Cie. ZOCA \n- \n. \nCO'llal InA4 Wt PAS. 46 artaCirtip L\ncs\nuniniun\nSat\n \ng-ht•ta \n4rot \nfortli \nbota. \n0111- 4 4-ok hewt \nSubs/aad \n44J\n-  \nrkethot.+- CEPVAIWei uhdu-d \n4 La \ntaibanN \nn \nCw-\nU. S v. euart,S)  ) ;tic. F34 irn at. \n. \n2001) \nrnicisitestomite Sotto-4 \n4rzur0.0 5 o.ed at:eiribtat4 \nuncto r ks \n_ 3Siak \naveutyaret \nalso \n/2.9..a_Jesa 1/4 4 srptact \nchator \n41) \nCo' tots kw\" \ntaniitrunbaday“ \nUrn -egret , \nir \non \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-NIARIM 1950 \nEFTA00226738\n", "char_count": 688}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 343, "text_content": ".11 \n;rri-msiata., or-Rviiite \n0.1,04t \nsx.fig,, \nCAS v. \nv. 6o1u4 ,3c. Fed,-\n32-5 tid-HIC-;/-1 2.-cos • \n• \nC.) \n2-t -12-02) \nHofcmcoY7qi \nark-i lk-Oa a! V \n. \nLG.S. \nn \nF. '/ \n,tz35 C/ \n2.00.5) \n \n \n. \n-A&6LS-- \n_F 34 .551  \n.0,11\n. 2004-0 \n(A. S. >l Magi.L3 \n4„. . \n705., \n \nfm.)-42-0f-FIA. \n2c0-0 U.,S. v:_esun 11 5 \n,,/ 3 Y \nAd \n/24.; i3osa \nVIA_ Cir. \nS v., 8.41, \n22-g- \n3.1 63 '7, Of CSC Cir. 2.0a1,3„_ \n-Rt \\ Ciwy\\r\"o4-eit \n• \n„ \n, \n• \n_ \nw02, 01.4,1\n\\I! \n, \n, \nis ;fig\n1/4\nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011951 \nEFTA00226739\n", "char_count": 534}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 344, "text_content": "Definitions of Inducument \nI) U.S. I Murrell, 3681. 3d 1283, 1287 (II\" Cir. 2004). In a charge of violation §2422(b), \nthe term \"induce means to stimulate the occurrence of \"or to\" cause the minor the engage in sexual \nactivity.\" \n2) Harms' U.S., 272 12d 478 (4\" Cir. 1959). In a charge of violating what is now \n§2422(a) (whoever knowingly persuades, induces, entices, or coerces any individual to travel in \ninterstate commerce... to engage in prostitution... shall be fined, etc.\"), the Fourth Circuit \ned \nthat a single telephone call invitation to a former prostitute, asking him to return to \nto \nresume her prostitution, was sufficient. \n-The fact that the prostitute has previously expressed her desire to return to \nor that she paid her own fare, was immaterial. \n-\"An affirmative directive act [like buying a ticket or doing the transporting) is not \ninvolved. The inducement in and of itself, without consideration of intent and \nwith no further direct act, is the moving cause of what follows. The inducement may \nbe any offer sufficient to cause the woman to respond. The inducement \nsets in motion the successive acts that constitute the crime. (p. 481) \n3) U.S.1 Reed, 96 1. 2d 785(2d Cir. 1938). Evidence was sufficient to find that defendant \ninduced woman to travel in interstate commerce to engage in prostitution, even though woman \nclaimed she had always wanted to go to Ncw York and she paid her own way. \n4) LaPage 1 U.S., 146 1 2d 536 (8\" Cir. 1945). Evidence that defendant called victim, \nwho was one of his regular prostitutes who was away (out of state) on vacation, and asked her to \nreturn because another prostitute was leaving was sufficient to prove inducement to travel in \ninterstate commerce for the purpose of prostitution. \n5) Prdjun 1 U.S., 237 1 799 (6\" Cir. 1916). Evidence was sufficient to convict defendant \nof enticing girl to travel in interstate commerce to engage in prostitution even if there \"is no \nevidence\" that the girl knew of the purpose for wh\n... [truncated, 2824 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/344 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=344]", "char_count": 2824}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 345, "text_content": "-1..s 4  tev(44.,e,tryvz.--1-\nI is \n:7 \ncp.a.s„. V, Ml.,<PrO, a•A \n3A. :{2_13;(1 HP1 Ur \n2.)GLO. Ina \n4 vie io_liovt \n2-,4-2:2-CO \nuly \n41Na_ cc_c_wrren.ei cyba it\n4-7) \nryu.no-\n4t, \n. - \n(2). ,{.lawns v. U.S., 2.)2_ rad ,flo (ott-, \nCr. -I q 64) Ina 6-0..-•,/ 4, irk,/ \nv7aA., f7142-2-Cu) (CA_Jeowt, tiinowf \naSti.042-0, \net\"..N.J2-0, \nCV C.O.e.,14.0 aryl \nt:PS.A.LO \nfp imr-cl \nISO-SAWY_CD,Th 'Ufrek \n• \n. 411.11 ‘t \nit\"10(t \n*1.4-* C,vt.u.4\" c.t.da-rn4;.e.d \na \nc,d! wwita-6a4... 4-D \na \nfy,,D5\n \nto \ntArr7lb \n11.frria. 10 reA2U•ne, \nAA-6a,, we:L/3 \nkyr} ye.) vAe. \npvtvieu-\n- fixe-e4g \n(7(eau--4 tb \nyr.?kkr? •tiz ire k o i \nihti- i \n2J \ntow31-1-0-i \nCRerniiire, dux-eine—el* ck-4.-+\" \nDike \ni\nztsra=104-- \nbevy-1 \ntn_ cud 4 \nLmi-geml \n4, \nr0 \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-01 I qs \nEFTA00226741\n", "char_count": 800}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 346, "text_content": "O0A4 ;5  th k niaritly \nca \n? 4- (A.,ho- aciAx. • \ndaft., .5,46ziuNt. \nacts\n- \n,..ock-4,),LJ4_162 ets04 , 71fuz \n.5/az) Cezm;tiOn_-_...11na \nWics-t co-6'13u_\na (L.S.. v Rya, qc, F',24_785/2At \n EyokAcx \n \nBedEWevut- \nirukta. 14.4 \nwin-YIP-%  \n4.k.t.ka \nU4 1,404Cal_tcstrfpNivW3Vhl \nrligusticvN  \nevtb., IqcytvAaf'vron \nAlldt\n \"47:54i4-\nCt tT2 \nA.ktA, \n04-Aeltv \nu. 5\nNf6 F Zd \n5 %;\"Crii °1 Cr. Pr/ 45E \n- ..6agen-c4 44f -A \n \n IAA) cox°, \n-- ors- xt, 14i.2 PTW4 peu.--..pftztiokSAa adlo Gazo way \nArekeAtitvg.2.(erd, euaki.d kti/- fa 31,44hy?_ \n_ \nppoghhata. wax) ..Ria.8.\n24fri....e4-4-\nJo floa_ AluxArisit 6 -frs4,4 A.A \n- --cmoeutx \ncif 4024-i4-u3scrL \n, \nIALs 2,17-F.  711 ((,f& Gr. 190.1 \nAwes Euid-%t.<- _extzt_5441,6.a.\"4 Iospnu-c-f-\n&4-*/ \ninxecZ' ott onlePs\" 4-(, co+w-u.t.ft \n-eriffe* \nwuk iFAre \"is no \ntuidso‘c÷ *0;1 1\n ff,spi krami- et. +V% pttrigesk \nuola\ns.dAXL0 eaahti 4t) \niitt-tb- lb *kit ode`arJ . \n114 \n:an \nalien (4- twci-t \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011954 \nEFTA00226742\n", "char_count": 997}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 347, "text_content": "trgistnetki-\nCg \nliar sLit a( \n-to \navol.S0( r  •\nt\n, .4- car Got \nwiftk wca iin fweve. ot, -fea.. pref\n411\na4\nH.e4 do, \nAu' 1\n4 Skulat 4...qcw_ in ty,,o\nto ottotl'eaT le....n \ni-' 4-'1\n4\n a RS Lc -Th'vb°, 44 to r si pas ooft,,a, \n. st.ai 0A ziezza) \n- \ncriatcy+ H.& \nC. ibctipd tt &at a \nI nd- itai *U icA,\nirkard in (and \nik \ncdrcaltetiiieti Pala gat \nGan\ntt\\\nrd-ict rbit-itii Lit3 \n. \n%net ercAsq're 40 hut \nInduct:- ftaoluicl ar wiorini_ \nffisetan or \nWeLma ; 41) prtm«Ci \nPteSuagh z clua-oae-AS:reiura <t. \n1.1,1=\n11 \nrielanS 4 whitall Ore, \nCTY-\nko coettirteSL . \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRN1 1955 \nEFTA00226743\n", "char_count": 617}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 348, "text_content": "Motive to Travel Cases \n1) U.S.' Garcia-M234 F.3d 217 (51° Cir. 2000). \nFacts: Defendant took his 13-year-old stepdaughter to Mexico and obtained fake identification dots \nto allow her to travel. Defendant raped the girl twice in Mexico and was charged and convicted of \nviolating 242304. \nIssue: Defendant argues that government must prove that his dominant motive for traveling was to \nengage in sex with a minor. \nHolding: The instruction that \"it was sufficient for the government to prove that one of the \ndefendant's motives in traveling las to engage in a sexual act with a minor \"was sufficient\". \n2) U.S.' I1oschouer, 2007 WL979931 (11th Cir. Apr. 3, 2007). \nFacts: Defendant began a sexual relationship with his daughter when she was 13. In March 2003, \nthe victim gave birth to defendant's son. Defendant continued to have sex with her. In Sept. 2003, \ndefendant was arrested in Texas. Victim wrote a bad check to get defendant out on bond and they \nfled. Victim asked to stay behind, but defendant refused. Defendant was arrested while they were \ndriving through Georgia when defendant was arrested for shoplifting. Victim testified that they were \non their way to North Carolina where defendant was looking for work. Victim also testified that she \nbelieved that, if they stayed in Georgia long enough, she and defendant would have had sex. \nDefendant was charged with violating 2423(a) and 2432(b). \nIssue: Defendant raised the issue of \"the purpose\" instruction and the sufficiency of the evidence. \nHolding: (1) The jury was properly instructed that the government does not have to show that \nengaging in criminal sexual activity with a minor was defendant's only purpose or even his primary \npurpose, but it must have been tins of the motives or purposes of the travel. In other words, the \ngovernment must show that the defendant's criminal purpose was not merely incidental to the travel. \n(2) Based upon the length of the sexual relationship and defendant's refusal to leave victi\n... [truncated, 3364 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/348 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=348]", "char_count": 3364}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 349, "text_content": "Motive to Travel Cases - Page 2 \nand compelling purposes of the travel.\" Evidence related to the \"grooming process\" was relevant \nto whether the defendants had the illicit intent necessary under 2423(b). \n5) U.S.' Scisum, 32' 3d 1479 (10th Cir. 1994). For a violation of 2423(a), the \ngovernment must prove that the defendant had formed the intent to have the victim engage in \nprostitution before the defendant transported or moved a person in interstate commerce. The \ngovernment does not have to prove that prostitution was the sole purpose of the transportation. \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011957 \nEFTA00226745\n", "char_count": 619}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 350, "text_content": "ACtive ,t) Tro,vtiCam \nu.S. \n6c4-\n.—/..cpe_ , 234- F. 34. \n(54€--1 \nCAr. 2000) \nr q.c)s, n took \n,i3-T-old• sic.fda÷,\n:JP I' co \nqts c .to ol,na \nAterd\n1 -twice \no44- cam \nCini!PA4Q(\navck cAroicitot- c,F tf;olcxtv \n2423(b\nLs5,2-..• 4? ctetriA. \n44-04- \n.ry,wok \nryptiy-c. \ninvet,44,01 \nevylci(ur s \nwielc-\ntomhav- . \ncr6-61...civerv‘ #42.* \n,•, •0? Su-144;o..4 \nCAerro-nreard-, -tb I/eve +inak tIAL. Crlz, O.' \nvnOt \n14.4 \nhak.44:412 \n°Jag \n:t1) 0\n, 0,0,9(e. efr-• \nact \nviw-Nk•\n4u. c. \nC. e. i-los&outf, .zoo \nva:ci-nci3i (1 \nCif.\nApv. 3,209,71) \n• \nrad-% \nI•opolooN, \nre.1.0-tievechk.r..64.Oteh \nV•v:. \n- 13 . \n1144,-rvin \n,kA CNNA Opre \n&S son \nWriiNv4-01- \n1/0-1,k sgx. \n6;1 \n2°0 3 p, u \no-s-re.akv. \n\"fey.a.o. \nL.ocit \nlook_,C--\"d 4,‘) e \n(51j-\ncY\\ i7\" 4\" \nvcv‘-. \nackuk. 31,\nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011958 \nEFTA00226746\n", "char_count": 832}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 351, "text_content": ":/A.IPEAiekok, \n \n4.,320(;,a4-1-\nrni a\nd:44f \n_ \n__4cAticuotitkiimEtuttz. \nIrsitv \nNorAt<orcl; \nVis.E,,  AO itzhVgA_Alazi-\niteo 464,if *am trod \neArs46, \n• \n544\n_AssvA:._LN_Jm4 \n1:44Pis 61, \" \nipetk_i4sa_ - s,444ti\na db. +IA•13\n. \n,Aa:Lo 4atopulattaSiloAckal 4412# \nOJsto \n4Psuat_041,01 \n6s!.1 .)044.1_44,4^\"‘ \nfrivroan \n4,44_,Afity2th-0__•\n4,4dirw. of- 41444r.41_4c0m tbsfra, \n014Ak_Algh&spicktlente&__Ars_skolk) \n14_cbgakhIna\n.4eAL.9= \n,APA:14_,14r.tuitAl\n1.2 \n,d \ni'do-ti1440 \n \n V 12/11/;44,14-44.)ni \nJO. \n \n:LigtiOrgAnkLINIKk(AAn \nileLc. \n_ AAVAip' rt .lf^•1' a••L 4 iht-hictivekv) tx44-Fcas__Ak \nZ=t- \nA*rpc=tV \n41171,47-44-_\n• \n_ \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011959 \n-- -4> 0-10.0 adult uaix viotaiin4_2a13(9)_oci \nEFTA00226747\n", "char_count": 738}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 352, "text_content": "Wirt 4.6 TroJet) \np• \n•S • v_feiru-\"t  39'1 k Lief,. \niS? .1bi • \nKt • \n2-00.5),11uo Co.hte \nfierea tect,ecto \ncOmueog. \n_ \n_ \n;Am> hedei \nYeuk :let° 0.....tekeye.\n• ...a.Licr_Yeae. \ncgiellecéattal.' \nkreg, .≤:41 \n_ \ndeeLeyytt\ne • \"\n-Fee). 4'13 \n(-511,1 \navd- \nr1:141- \n/3 \no \noecl \nle Ctizeixe !Doz.,\n /ad AV io geivo.e-\nLt!\") teeikei- 1120 bu.Aeci-.S. Saw firit Mr; \nAV lb et 6elbolt ' \nAp...;.4teéle (or-PeSS &hit. \nAVelX1O ta \nefeee \nofreitAv-  \nhµ.t,â4...t \n2/.0 \n(.1,` wad, vrooto. 40 eve= e \n, \n..u.ete‘ NJ- cre4-Cimwel.. AV Lea» -SViel4-Dit` \neelcu.a.itot._ \nWm_ As ?tee re \n01^01` \nqie't steve0. ozhowlcoAtir›..4.d. kw- al.e0A-\n114_ \nceased u-re Vic/Afir, \ne.e623(..b), .2x#7.3(44;ed\n.rd reez2-&-). \n7/m. \nAt -sch•decAa.tuj dg \nimkesse...L.— \neolce \nfeerneed »awe /KM Irecaf \nlet ...T4.44.4.4 arh \nto:Le 4 O's-e \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011960 \nEFTA00226748\n", "char_count": 873}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 353, "text_content": "1A, *44,4- 0.4 cavy:w_,w, i-VOLtd \nriytwa -\" he -vide/vex 0-cloaca( 4c, \n\" \nplivey. \nMASAO\"' \n \nWe- 4S \nA2A v61  (11Z64-et . \n \nLtinck*: AZZ,3 Le) \n‘,.  \ntA..5.--r—aisar,  3Z P. 34, \n/99q) \n_For 0-_t_o4itAta 4 \n \n \n/2/ \nif‘c \n1\"401. \n•  stRAvint.4&_vitsiiy, \n14,‘, 4n, Avr....2er-icat 0-• \n____Ariffkr,k\net \n* ewe \nposE.44—iku_ \n, \n• r \nyAt\nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011961 \nEFTA00226749\n", "char_count": 392}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 354, "text_content": "Third-Party Liability \n1) U.S. \nPisman, 443 13d 912 (70 Cir. 2006). \nPisman and Wilkerson were involved in asexual relationship and planned for Pisman \nto travel from Iowa to Illinois to meet Wilkerson and others to engage in sex. Wilkerson arranged \nfor the other sex partners - some of whom were minors - via the Internet. Pisman was aware that \nsome were minors. \nCharges: Ct. I- Conspiracy to travel interstate to have sex with minors 18 USC §§ 2423(b) & (c). \nCt. 2 - Substantive charge of 2423(b) \nCt. 3 - Use of interstate commerce to entice a minor 2422(b) \nIssue: The government urged a theory of co-conspirator liability as the basis of Pisman's guilty on \nthe substantive offenses. Pisman was acquitted of Count I and convicted of Count 3. \nHolding: These are merely inconsistent verdicts, which is not grounds for a motion for judgement \nof acquittal. \n2) U.S. I \nStrewth 185 Fed. Appx. 841 (11th Cir. 2006): Telephone calls to Costa Rica \nTaboo Vacations to arrange trip to Costa Rica to meet with underage prostitutes is sufficient to prove \nviolations of 2423(c), 1591(a), and 2422(b). \n3) U.S. I Bolen, 136 Fed. Appx. 325 (11° Cir. 2005). Defendant challenged §2422(b)'s \napplicability w crc defendant did not communicate directly with victim-child but only \ncommunicated (via Internet and phone) with parent of purported child. \n\"We held that §2422(b) encompasses conduct where a defendant arranges to have sex with \na minor through communications with an adult intermediary, including an adult law enforcement \nagent posing as a parent of a minor child.\" \nCase No. 08-80736-C V-MARRA \nP-011962 \nEFTA00226750\n", "char_count": 1626}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 355, "text_content": "4)UAie \n_.ltd \n-54.,tto \ndstrxe,_44 3 Fad ,9! \n(Wig Cir. .2_00‘) \n \n \nCampshot-\nPicrmin \nittako-sm-, tuck, iba= \neruzek_,Legi64-40A \nde/1oz \"tr> cl.-#24e \ntvilleau \nYr\".4_1.-./ \nCaw- \nuilbOan_ _ _ \ntue.H- ',Awl's —via \nirpy.trut ttsnauqtata. \n.414,9 witiz gemeghs.„ \nt;Ilepsht.tk. \nknee. \ncklYtt lat4iteT 6 (AK_ \n01434)4.) \n. \n44\n5.11ito \n4L,rikoviz4\net \"\nIlk., dT 214-2-36.9i,) \ncx inw-VSY \n_ \n: 71ne 90,0^rirrIvit\n.„40.647( \naYAWLS \nCaC,Cnisk;adav \naz) (11ta \nPulhalk2oca,f4.1tn ztoetd214t4\nlhe.\n'-<\nfirgrar• win \n \n \nJ. mat. _._ \ncaszk—Ack et, \n3 \narc\n7.01.i.t .:ettue9(.0\n°.cztA4ztal\n.\nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-01 1903 \nEFTA00226751\n", "char_count": 642}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 356, "text_content": "et-ti a \n_ \n_cceinRici,T2.6a)\nci  \n \n iv\n 6cel- 47? ierv2J-\n11) \nKArt \n \nc2E \n15g I Co.), \n. \n.„. \n. (.7 \n3)-( .S_it• 40/4tqf  /SG AA—A*4— 32-5 \nCir. .74sos) . \n that-Mei-1v( t 211.22-07.) ) \nARiathfs.- .6 oka„-AnektztV-srfx4AisaLd<-\n1411/1 \n- kg.4 \nGita\nltri-urria AlaniockANLIAPiYA \npLugatt ckosk. \n \nwe.A34.4tAti. *a)\" t 2s1-2,-2_(h) -e-J/Icompi2,0 \ncstp\n_ bokilke_ \nAt451,-,610.44 \n- liortzv\nflA .4 .WIA.inae% \nCA'ilk-ata--a-Atat ivikErAidjaktl), \n__Lam \npos 1,1( .1 co A \nia_km:Alm \nchtio \n \nL .\nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011964 \nEFTA00226752\n", "char_count": 552}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 357, "text_content": "Knowledge of Agc Issue \nI) U.S.' Griffith, 284 13d 338 (2d Cir. 2002). Government does not have to prove \nknowledge of age of violations of 2251(a) or 2423(a). \n2) U.S.' Scott, 1993 WL 280323 (6th Cir. 1993). Knowledge that a girl is under 18 years \nof agc when transported is not part of the proof required of the goverrunent in order to sustain a \nconviction under §2423. \n3) U.S.' Taylor, 239 13d 994 (9'\" Cir. 2001). Government does not have to prove \nU.S.\nHamilton, 456 \n2d 171 (3d Cir. 1972). \ndefendant's knowledge \nvictim was and i 18 years of agc in prosecution under §2323(a). \n-also \n. \n-also U.S. \nJones, 471 F. 3d 535 (4'\" Cir. 2006). \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-0I 1965 \nEFTA00226753\n", "char_count": 701}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 358, "text_content": "r5jLaaWg\n.E. 2f:!IO \n,\ni3,(O Y701- 4-1416._ frEforre._ 14/14014 \n \n \n--4-at—fr---qnlasikos of 226 IQ dr 2423‘,). \nA its—v. sc.-0;11/3_4,x 2:037a ath 4-\nKrau4k \n \nnci-po4ifLick \nels y1,1 \n.00vii,e,4,, \n& ..swieu;e, _42— \nccvivichi\n_2a.231 \n3. ilA•5• v T \nII\n,) • \n4 6 \n23/ P-3.( 94y CPA \not cceLot iegm\nsit/W-vichal \ni•fr.) 10224.Latiri-{AinAle--_ \n§ 211 \n-deo U.S. \ntionwittivl, VE4K 2d 171 (Er \n-72- • \n \n -ago  iA \n...1v4.0, *71 \n53s MA G.: \n3004 \nCase  No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011966 \nEFTA00226754\n", "char_count": 502}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 359, "text_content": "Law Or/ iCCS or \nGERALD 13. LEFcourrr, Y.G. \n•MOt SSIONAL COORPORATIO \nNB CAST ie.\" \nSTREET \nNEW YORK, NEW YORE 10021 \nGERALD B. LCFCOURT \nWICOortaskourUari.Com \nsmcnyi. C. RtiCti \nnichlatektmetra corn \nRENATO C. STABILE \nada•Okoltostaa. corn \nFAITH A. FRIEDMAN \nMearnageskeurstet teen \nBY FEDERAL EXPRESS \near T essrs. \noman, T enc e an \nJuly 6, 2007 \nrey Epstein \nuric and Ms. Villafaila: \n \nHONE \nI/ zJ 7370400 \nFAcSIMILE \n421211388.6102 \nWe %Tice as counsel to Jeffrey Epstein to follow-up on our meeting on June 26, \n2007. We thought the meeting was extremely productive and appreciate your giving us \nthe opportunity to engage you on the facts, law and policy that will inform any decision \nyou make on how and whether to proceed. \nI. \n18 U.S.C. §2422(6) Has No Applicability to the Facts Here. \nEven assuming the facts as you believe them to be, as demonstrated below, a \nprosecution under 18 U.S.C. §2422(b) would violate the explicit terms of the statute, pose \ninsurmountable constitutional barriers, and be unprecedented, unwise, and utterly \ninappropriate. This statute, with its mandatory minimum sentence' was designed to reach \nThe statute in effect during the events at issue carries a mandatory five-year period of \nincarceration. The current ten-year mandatory minimum was instituted in 2006. \nExhibit 33 \nEFTA00226755\n", "char_count": 1337}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 360, "text_content": "toes Or e•CES 0• \nGERALD B. LEPCOURT. P.C. \nthose who deliberately, knowingly, and intentionally target and exploit children through \nthe Internet. Though the literal language may superficially apply to a wider variety of \nbehaviors, we submit that the statute cannot properly be used to prosecute what have \ntraditionally been viewed as state offenses, even if some facility or means of interstate \ncommerce can be said to have been used by someone at some point during the course of \nevents. \n1. \nCongress's Purpose \nSection 2422(b), the so-called \"Internet Luring Statute\", addresses online \nenticement of children. The subsection was included in Title I of the \nTelecommunications Act of 1996, entitled \"Obscenity and Violence\", after the Senate \nJudiciary Committee held a hearing regarding child endangerment via the Internet. See \nH.R. Conf. Rep. No. 104.458, at 193 (1996), quoted in United States' Searcy, 418 I3d \n1193, 1197 (11ih Cir. 2005); see also K. Seto, \"Note: How Should Legislation Deal with \nChildren and the Victims and Perpetrators of Cyberstalking?\" 9 Cardozo Women's L.J. 67 \n(2002). \nIn enacting the statute, Congress recognized that young people were using the \nInternet in ever-increasing numbers, and it was proving to be a dangerous place. \nAccording to a DOJ study, one in five youths (aged 10 to 17) had received a sexual \napproach or solicitation over the Internet in the previous year. One in 33 had received an \n\"aggressive sexual solicitation\", in which a predator had asked a young person to meet \nsomewhere or called a young person on the phone. U.S.D.O.J., Office of Justice \nPrograms, 0 VC Bulletin,\" Internet Crimes Against Children\" (12/2001); \nwww.oip.usdoi.gov/ove/publications/bulletons/intemet \"2 2001/intemet _2_01 6.html. \nCongress saw that, with so many children online, the Internet created a new place \n— cyberspace — where predators could easily target children for criminal acts. Use of the \nInternet. which occurs in private, and the secrecy and d\n... [truncated, 2490 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/360 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=360]", "char_count": 2490}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 361, "text_content": "• WI \nVICC• Dr \nGERALD B. LEECOURT. P.C. \n§3299.2 The law was named in memory of Adam Walsh who, 25 years earlier, had been \nabducted from a department store and was later found murdered, and whose parents had \nbecome advocates for missing children. In his signing statement, President Bush noted \nthat it increased federal penalties for crimes against children, imposing \"tough mandatory \nminimum penalties for the most serious crimes against our children.\" 2006 \nU.S.C.C.A.N. S35, 2006 WL 3064686 (emphasis added). The five-year mandatory \nminimum it replaced was itself established as part of the PROTECT Act of 2003, another \nlaw designed to strengthen the government's ability to deal with certain dangerous sexual \npredators who exploited children in ways the states had been unable to address fully.;\n2. \nGeneral Overview \nIt must be remembered that §2422(b), by using the phrase \"any sexual activity for \nwhich any person can be charged with a criminal offense\": in some sense incorporates \nall the sex offense laws of all 50 states, in all their variety and in all their ambiguity. This \nin itself raises questions of the utmost seriousness, implicating fairness and the due \nprocess clause. It also constitutes an extreme example of federal pre-emption, or, more \nprecisely, the wholesale annexation of the enforcement responsibility of each of the 50 \nstates' sex-related crime statutes — whether felony, misdemeanor or violation — wherever \nthere has been use of the ever-present wires. To make every state sex \"offense\" involving \na person under 18 potentially into a mandatory minimum ten-year federal felony without \nany statute of limitations is certainly not what Congress had in mind when it enacted \n§2422(b). \nI Other federal crimes with ten-year mandatory minimum involve very serious acts. See, e.g., 18 \nU.S.C. §2113(e) (bank robbery where a person is killed or kidnapped); 18 U.S.C. §924 (involving \ndischarge of firearm). \n3 Section 2422(b) has always carried a substantial p\n... [truncated, 2429 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/361 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=361]", "char_count": 2429}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 362, "text_content": "LAW OrrICCO or \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT. PC. \nThe bulk importation of complex bodies of state law is highly problematic, and \nstrongly counsels that such matters should be left to the states except in those rare \ncircumstances where both a federal interest is clear and weighty, and the states are for \nsome reason incapable of acting. Like issues of family law, these issues are \nquintessentially of state concern within our federal system. \nState laws regarding both sexual activity and the age of consent to engage therein \nare hugely varied, reflecting different histories, values, politics, and personalities. See \nRichard A. Posner & Katharine B. Silbaugh, A Guide to America's Sex Laws (1996). The \nvarious and shifting societal reasons underlying those laws, and the societal pressures \noperating in the area, where sexual mores change over time, complicate the matter even \nfurther. See generally Richard A. Posner, Sex and Reason (1992). The history of the \nMann Act confirms the caution with which the federal government should approach this \nentirc area. For example, historically, the Act was used by some prosecutors in some \njurisdictions to prosecute acts — such as a man traveling with his paramour — which, we \nsubmit, never implicated a legitimate federal concern. See generally U.J. Langum, \nCrossing the Lines: Legislating Morality Under the Mann Act (1994). \nEven where there is broad agreement that certain conduct should be criminalized, \nthe various states treat the very same conduct differently; to apply such laws selectively \nby different federal prosecutors would undermine further what uniformity does exist. In \nNew York, for example, a 50 year old man who patronizes a 15 year old prostitute is \nguilty of a Class A misdemeanor. New York Penal Law §230.04. If §2422(b) were read \nexpansively, then such person would face a 10-year mandatory minimum if he used the \ntelephone to set-up his date with the young prostitute even if the date never happened. \nAnd that would be \n... [truncated, 2893 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/362 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=362]", "char_count": 2893}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 363, "text_content": "LAW OIIICCS or \nGERALD B. LEPCOURT. P.C. \nperpetrator. Section 2422(b), with its ten-year mandatory minimum is far too blunt a tool \nto use in any circumstances except the narrow, clear-cut, and egregious circumstances \nCongress had in mind when it enacted this law.5\nThough §2422(b) is susceptible to multiple interpretations, it was designed to \naddress a specific a problem with which Mr. Epstein's case has nothing in common. I \nstretched to reach beyond the core concern of the statute, a host of problems immediately \narise. A simple reading of the words of the statute leaves any reasonable reader with far \nmore questions than answers as to what is illegal. Any attempt to apply the statute to Mr. \nEpstein's situation highlights the many problems of vagueness, overbrcadth, and simple \nincomprehensibility lurking in or just below the statute's text. \n3. \nThe Statute's Text And Its Thrust \nSection 2422(b) currently provides: \nWhoever, using the mail or any facility or means of \ninterstate or foreign commerce, or within the special \nmaritime and territorial jurisdiction of the United \nStates knowingly persuades, induces, entices or \ncoerces any individual who has not attained the age \nof 18 years, to engage in prostitution or any sexual \nactivity for which any person can be charged with a \ncriminal offense, or attempts to do so, shall be fined \nunder this title and imprisoned not less than ten \nyears or for life. \nThe statutory language and reported decisions confirm the statute's important, but \nnarrow, focus: the luring of children over the Internet. Unlike 18 U.S.C. §§2241 er seq., \n'Penalties under state statutes criminalizing online enticement also vary widely. According to the \nNational Center for Missing and Exploited Children, though the offense can be a felony in all \nstates, 15 states permit misdemeanor sentences in some cases (generally where the victim is 14 or \nolder). Nineteen states classify online enticement as a felony, but grant judges statutory \ndiscr\n... [truncated, 2147 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/363 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=363]", "char_count": 2147}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 364, "text_content": "tat °ryas or \nGERALD B. LEPCOLTRT. P.C. \n§2422(b) does not establish any federal sex crimes with a minor. Section 2422's subject \nis not sex or sexual activity or face-to-facc sexual exploitation of minors. Such behavior \nremains a matter of state, not federal, concern. The plain language of the statute \nmandates focus on the communication and demands that the knowing \"persuasion\", \n\"inducement\", \"enticement\" or \"coercion\" be done \"using the mail or any facility or \nmeans of interstate . . .commerce\" (emphasis added). Any other reading would violate \nconstitutional principles of fair warning, notice, lenity and due process. Additionally, any \nbroader reading would violate the clearly stated intent of Congress that enacted the law \nand the President who signed it. It would also exceed the authority of Congress under the \nCommerce Clause by federalizing virtually all state sex offenses involving people under \nthe age of 18. \nSection 2422(b) defines a crime of communication, not of contact. It makes \nunlawful a narrow category of communications, ones not protected by the First \nAmendment. Both the attempt and the substantive crime defined by §2422 are complete \nat the time when communication with a minor or purported minor takes place; the essence \nof the crime occurs before any face-to-face meeting or any sexual activity with a minor, \nand regardless of whether any meeting or activity ever occurs. \nTurning the statute on its head by first looking at the alleged sexual activities and \nthen seeking to find a mailing, a use of the wires, or the involvement of another facility or \nmeans of interstate commerce as a pretext for the invocation of federal jurisdiction would \nbe without precedent and make a narrowly-focused statute into virtually a complete \nfederalization of all state sex offenses involving minors. \n4. The Statute Is Violated Only If A Facility Or Means Of Interstate \nCommerce Is Used To Do the Persuading Or Inducing \nThough the statute raises several difficu\n... [truncated, 2584 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/364 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=364]", "char_count": 2584}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 365, "text_content": "OI/ICCIS Of \nGERALD B. LEMOURT. PC. \nThe statutory language can bear no other construction. The words \"whoever, \nusing . .. knowingly persuades ...\" necessarily requires that the \"whoever\" must \"use\" \nthe interstate facility to knowingly persuade. That is, the word \"using\" is in the present, \nnot the past, tense. Thus, the \"using\" must occur at the same time as the \"persuading\". If \nthe statute meant otherwise, it could and would have been drafted differently: \"whoever \nhaving used the mail and knowingly persuades\" or \"whoever uses the mail and \nknowingly persuades\". But, as it is written, the actor must use the interstate facility to \npersuade or to entice, or to attempt to do so; use of the instrumentality cannot be \nincidental or peripheral. \nIndeed, assuming, arguendo, that the grammar and structure of the statute would \nallow another interpretation — which we believe it does not — nevertheless the obvious, \nstraightforward reading controls. Anything else would violate the rule of lenity, requiring \nstrict construction of penal statutes, as well as the requirement of fair notice guaranteed \nby the due process clause. 6 As Thomas Jefferson put it in 1823: \"Laws arc made for men \nof ordinary understanding, and should therefore be construed by the ordinary rules of \ncommon sense. Their meaning is not to be sought for in metaphysical subtleties, which \nmay make any thing mean every thing or nothing, at pleasure\". \nAccording to one of the world's leading experts on grammar and specifically, the \nsyntax and semantics of verbs, these rules of \"ordinary understanding\" and \"common \nsense\" dictate that \n. . . an English speaker, reading the statute, would naturally \nunderstand it as applying only to persuasion (etc.) that is \ndone while \"using the mail\" (etc.). To understand it as \napplying to persuasion (etc.) done subsequent to the use of \n6  We note that the structure of this statute is radically different from the structure of §134I, the \nmail fraud statute. There, th\n... [truncated, 2448 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/365 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=365]", "char_count": 2448}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 366, "text_content": "LAW or \n'g[• or \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT. P.C. \nthe mail, phone, etc., would be an unnatural and \ngrammatically inaccurate reading of the language. 7\nThat the statute is so limited is also confirmed by the fact that prosecutors have \nclearly understood this limitation. After conducting extensive research, we find no case \nof a defendant being prosecuted under §2422(b) where he has used the intemet or the \ntelephone, and then, by some other means, such as personal contact, attempted to \npersuade, induce, or entice. On the contrary, all §2422(b) prosecutions we have reviewed \nare premised on a defendant's use of the intemet (or occasionally the text messaging on a \nphone) as the vehicle of the inducement. See, e.g., United Stares' Murrel, 368 I3d \n1283, 1286 (11th Cir. 2004) (government must ... prove that Murrell, using the intemet, \nacted with a specific intent to persuade a means to engage in unlawful sex). \nIn fact, we have reviewed every indictment filed in the Southem District of \nFlorida in which there is at least one allegation of a violation of §2422(b). To the extent \nthe facts could be discerned from the indictment, we found no case brought where the use \nof the means of communication was remote from the persuading, coercion, etc.' \nSuch prosecutorial restraint is in full accord with the legislative intent, which, as \nset forth above, was to go after intemet predators who use the means of communication \nto persuade, coerce, etc. That the statute also makes reference to the mails and facilities \nor means of interstate commerce other than the intemet does not suggest that the statutory \npurpose was broader: it is a common modus operandi of intemet predators to continue to \npursue young people whom they first contact on the intemet. If the statute were read to \nmake it a crime to induce or persuade where the inducement or persuasion did not occur \nover the wires, the statute would sweep within it conduct that Congress had no intention \nof making a federal crime. Gi\n... [truncated, 2765 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/366 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=366]", "char_count": 2765}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 367, "text_content": "Ortati \nOF \nGERALD B. LEFCOUBT. PC. \nin the lives of young people, de-coupling the \"persuasion/enticement\" element from the \n\"use of the interstate facility\" would make virtually any sexual activity with a minor, \nchargeable under state law, a federal offense — with no statute of limitations and a \nmandatory ten-year minimum sentence. \nIndeed, given that the interstate highway system is itself an avenue of interstate \ncommerce, United States' Home, 474 I2d 1004, 1006 (7th Cir. 2007), allowing a \nprosecution wherever a means or facility of interstate commerce is used and a forbidden \ninducement later occurs, would mean that anyone who used the interstate highways, and \nthen, at some other time, induced a minor face-to-face to engage in forbidden activity (or \nattempted to do so), would be subject to the mandatory ten years. The complete \nfederalization of sex crimes involving children would have occurred, though there is no \nindication whatsoever that such a sea change in the federal/state balance was intended or \nis even needed. \nMoreover, such an expansive reading, even if permissible, would very likely \nexceed the Commerce Clause power as the Supreme Court presently construes it. In \nUnited States' \n514 U.S. 549 (1995), the Supreme Court struck down the Gun-\nFree School Zones ct, holding that it exceeded Congress's Commerce Clause authority. \nIn so ruling, the Court reaffirmed a set of fundamental principles, including that the \npowers delegated to the federal government are few and defined, and that this \n\"constitutionally mandated division of authority was adopted by the Namers to ensure \nprotection of our fundamen I \nrties.\" Id at 552, quoting Gregory' Ashcroft, 501 \nU.S. 452, 458 (1991). The \nmajority concluded that the statute before the Court \n\"upsets the federal balance to adegree that renders it an unconstitutional assertion of the \ncommerce power.\" Id. at 580. In so ruling, the Court expressed its concern that an \noverly expansive view of the interstate C\n... [truncated, 2663 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/367 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=367]", "char_count": 2663}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 368, "text_content": "tsw °evicts, or \nG \nLE, B. LEI/COURT. P.C. \nTo the extent that §2422(b) criminalizes the use of the Internet (or telephone) by a \nsexual predator to target a vulnerable minor and to convince, or to try to convince, her to \nengage in conduc roscribed by law, the statute may not be unconstitutional on its face. \nSee United States\n Tykarsky, 446 I3d 458, 470 (3d Cir. 2006) (both §§ 2422(b) and \n2423(b) \"fall squarely \nCongress's power to regulate the first two categories of \nactivities described in \n). The statute would, however, be plainly unconstitutional if \nit were applied to situationslike Mr. Epstein's, where neither the telephone nor the \ninternet was used in that fashion, and where the use of the telephone was, at most, a \ntenuous link in a chain of events that may, or may not, have preceded or followed sexual \ncontact with a minor.9 In other words, if the instrumentality of commerce is not the \nvehicle used to facilitate the harm Congress is trying to address, but is simply a \n\"jurisdictional hook,\" the hook is too weakly connected to the problem (sexual crimes \nagainst minors) to sustain the statute as a proper exercise of Commerce Clause power. \nQuestions about the nature of federalism, and, specifically, just how far the \nfederal government may go into matters of traditionally state concern, will continue to \narise and vill be answered case-by-case. As Justice O'Connor said in her dissent in \nGonzales \nRaid:, 545 U.S. I, 47 (2005), \"... the task is to identify a mode of analysis \nthat allows Congress to regulate more that nothing . . . ancliess than everything. ..\" \n(O'Connor, J. dissenting). United States I Ballinger, 395 I3d 1218 (1 1 th Cir. 2005), \nillustrates the difficulty of the task. In that case, the deeply split en bane Court \nconsidered whether and to what extent the Commerce Clause authority included the \npower to punish a church arsonist who had traveled in interstate commerce to commit his \narsons. \nThough clearly not settled, what is clear is\n... [truncated, 2976 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/368 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=368]", "char_count": 2976}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 369, "text_content": "Law OP.CCIP. or \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT. P.C. \ncommerce does not, in and of itself, end the inquiry. Where the use of such \ninstrumentality is far removed from the conduct being targeted (in the case of §2422(b), \nsexual exploitation of children), the lack of any basis for federal jurisdiction presents \nitself squarely. \nIn Mr. Epstein's case, since the crime being considered (as Congress intended) is \nthe use of the intemet by intemet predators to target and lure vulnerable children to \nengage in illicit sex, the law is arguably within Congress' Commerce Clause powers. But \nMr. Epstein's conduct would he outside the law's scope. If you were to contend that any \nuse of the telephone which is connected in any fashion to an act of sexual misconduct \nwith a minor is within the statute's scope, Congress would then have reached well into \ntraditional state spheres, and there is a powerful argument that Congress would have been \nacting in excess of its Commerce Clause authority. \nElimination of Constitutional uncertainty regarding §2422(b) depends upon \nconfining it to situations where an instrumentality of interstate commerce has itself been \nused for an immoral or injurious purpose. Statutes must be read to eliminate serious \ndoubts as to Constitutionality, as I ng as such a reading is not plainly contrary to the \nintent of Congress United States \nX-Citement Video, Inc., 513 U.S. 64, 78 (1994), \nciting Edward.\" DeBartolo Corp. \nFlorida GulfCoast Building & Constr. Trades \nCouncil, 485 U.S. 568 (1988). At e least, to eliminate questions as to its \nconstitutionality, §2422(b)'s reach must be limited to situations where there is a very \nclose connection between the use of an instrumentality of interstate commerce and the \npersuasion or attempted persuasion that the statute makes a crime. \nMoreover, even if, arguendo, the expansive reading of the statute would not \nviolate the Commerce Clause — which current case law strongly suggests it would —\nnevertheless the federal interes\n... [truncated, 2754 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/369 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=369]", "char_count": 2754}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 370, "text_content": "• AW Off ICES or \nGERALD B. LEPCOURT. PC. \nand knowledge and, critically, that the shared inten an \nnow e ge cx \nthe communication in question. Absent proof beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr. \nEpstein had actual knowledge that the person making a telephone call would induce or \npersuade a specific underage person during the telephone call to engage in unlawful \nsexual activity or to engage in prostitution, there can be no federal crime. \nIf the telephone call in question were simply to schedule a topless massage, then \nthe call lacked the essential element of inducement, persuasion, enticement, or coercion. \nIf the telephone call in question was to schedule a topless massage (or even more) with a \nwoman whose age was not known by Mr. Epstein to be under 18, it also fails to satisfy \nthe requirements of §2422(b). If Mr. Epstein had not formed the intent to engage in \nunlawful sexual activity as of the time of the communication (even if he did form the \nintent thereafter), an essential element of the federal statute is again lacking. If the \nperson making the call had knowledge or a criminal intent or belief not fully shared by \nMr. Epstein (for example, Mr. Epstein did not know the telephone call was intended to \ninduce a minor to engage in unlawful activity), the essential clement of shared intent and \nshared knowledge is again lacking.10 Finally, even if there were a call to schedule a \nsecond meeting with someone who had previously been to the Epstein residence, this call \nlacks the necessary element of persuasion, inducement, or enticing even if the person \nreceiving the call hoped or expected remuneration from the return visit. That is so \nbecause the statute focuses on the content of the communication, not on any quid pro quo \nthat occurs thereafter at a meeting. The latter conduct is exclusively within the ambit of \nstate prosecution. \n5. Other Reasons Why 4 2422(b) Does Not Apply \nAs we demonstrate above, this statute is addressed to those who purposely and \n\n... [truncated, 2907 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/370 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=370]", "char_count": 2907}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 371, "text_content": "LAM O, FICC• 0 ,\nGERALD B. LEPCOURT. PC. \n1299 (11th Cir. 2003) (scienter requirement discourages \"unscrupulous enforcement\" and \nclarifies §2422(b)). Directed towards those who commit \"the most serious crimes against \nchildren,\" it cannot properly be used as a trap for the unwary, sweeping within its net all \nwho may - even unwittingly and unintentionally - communicate or otherwise interact \nimproperly with persons who turn out to be minors. \nA prosecution of Mr. Epstein would violate the teachings of Bailey and Panfil. As \nwe believe we persuaded you at the June 26th meeting, Mr. Epstein never targeted minors. \nOn the contrary, what he did — at worst — was akin to putting up a sign saying to all, come \nin if you are interested in giving a massage for $200. A few among those who accepted \nthe general invitation may have in fact been under 18 (though they lied about that age and \nsaid they were 18), but that is, at its worst, comparable to \"post(ing) messages for all \nInternet users, either adults or children, to seek out and read at their discretion,\" which the \ncourts have held does not violate §2422(b). \nThus, for this reason as well, Mr. Epstein's case is far outside the parameters of \nthe §2422(b) cases that have been prosecuted. A key factor common to cases brought \nunder §2422(b) is not present here: Prosecutions under this statute have focused on a \nsexual predator who used the Internet to identify and to communicate with a child or \npurported child (or a person with influence over such child or purported child), and did so \nwith the intent to arrange to engage in sexual activity with the child, with full knowledge \nthat sexual activity with an individual of that age was illegal. In light of this common and \nwell-accepted understanding, the cases decided under §2422(b) take as a given that its \nproper application lies only where the defendant knows or believes the person with whom \nhe is interacting is a child. \nVirtually all of the prosecutions brought unde\n... [truncated, 2924 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/371 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=371]", "char_count": 2924}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 372, "text_content": "LA. Or•ICCS Or \nGERALD B. LEPCOURT. PC. \ndefendant's §2422(b) attempt conviction was valid; it mattered not that the 14 year old \nwas really an adult FBI agent engaged in a sting opiation, for the defendant \"believed \nCindy to be a minor and acted on that belief.\" 251 3d at 512. Our own survey of the \ncases brought in this district under §2422(b) confirms that prosecutions in this District \nhave also been all but limited to internet sting cases. See Tab \"B\". \nin the context of this standard fact pattern involving the internet's use by \npredators, other Circuits, including the Eleventh, have been unanimous in holding that the \nnon-existence of an actual minor was of no moment; defendant's belief that he was \n1/\naling with a minor was sufficient to make out thrrime. See nited States v. Root, 296 \nt3d 1222, 1227-32 ( 1°' Cir. 2002). United States \nSims, 428 \n3d 945, 959 (10°  Cir. \n1\n005); United States I Helder, 45213d 751 (8th Cir. 2006); United States !Meek, 366 \n3d 705, 717-20 (9th Cir. 2004). Likewise, the Circuits have rejected void or vagueness, \noverbreadth, and First Amendment challenges to the statute, brought in the context of \nthese prototypical prosecutions where the interact was the vehicle of communication and \nenticement, and the defendant demonstrated in writing his belief that he was dealing with \na child well below the age of onsent. E.g., lifted States' 7),Icarsky, 44613d 458, 473 \n(3d Cii 2006); United State' Thomas, 410 \n3d 1235, 1243-44 (10h Cir. 005); United \nStates \nPang supra, 338 \n3d at 1300-01 (11th Cir. 2003).\" \n\" There are approximately two dozen Eleventh Circuit cases that include a prosecution under \nGarrett, 190 3d 1220 (116 Cir. \n§2424(b), most of which involve the prototypical fact pattern. See, e.g., United States !Morton, \n364 I3d 1300 (I l ° Cij. 2004),judgnwru vacated for Booker consideration, 125 S. Ct. 338 \n006); United States I Orrega, 363 I3d 1093 (116 Cir. 2004); United States91 Miranda, 348 \nI3d 1322 (II6 Cirj003); United St\n... [truncated, 3247 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/372 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=372]", "char_count": 3247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 373, "text_content": "LAW Off.CO \nOf \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT. EC. \nIn light of this common and well-accepted understanding, the cases decided under \n§2422(b) take as a given that its proper application lies only where the facts demonstrate \nbeyond dispute that the defendant knows or believes the person with whom he is \ninteracting is a minor. \nThe Ninth Circuit has so held. United States' Meek, 366 lid 705, 718 (9i° Cir. \n2004), held that the term \"knowingly\" refers both to the verbs -\"persuades\", \"induces\", \n\"entices\", or \"coerces\" - as well as to e object - \"a person who has not achieved the \ni \nage of 18 years,\" citing United States \nX-Citement Video, Inc., 513 U.S. 64 (1994), and \nStaples v. United States, 511 U.S. 606 (1994). The Meek Court wrote: \nThe statute requires mcns rea, that is, a guilty mind. The \nguilt arises from the defendant's knowledge of what he \nintends to do. In this case, knowledge is subjective — it is \nwhat is in the mind of the defendant.\" \nThe very lengthy sentence under §2422(b) speaks against strict liability, \nespecially since it applies in cases where there is no sexual contact at all with any \nperson, let alone with a real minor. The Eleventh Circuit's decision in United States \nMurrell, supra, reflects this same understanding of the statute. The Murrell court wrote \nthat, under the \"plain language\" of §2422(b), \"to prove an attempt the government must \nefficacy of §2422(b) would be eviscerated if a defendant could circumvent the statute simply by \nemploying an intermediary to \nout his intended \nto Murrell's exist in United States \nHotnaday, 392 \ndive. Id. at 1287. Fact patterns simr \nI \n6 (11\" Cir. 2004); United States \nHouston, 177 Fed. Appx. 57 (11th ir. 2006); Unite \nales \nSeamy, 418 F.3d 1193 (II' Cir. \n2005); United States \nScott, 426 F. 3d 1324 (116 Cir. 2005 , and United States \nBolen, 136 Fed. \nAppx. 325 (11th Cir. \n02). \n\" Several Courts of Appeal have held that, in a prosecution under §2422(a), the defendant need \nnot know that the individual that \n... [truncated, 2643 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/373 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=373]", "char_count": 2643}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 374, "text_content": "LAW Ort.CCS er \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT, PC. \nF \nI \nfirst prove that Murrell, using the interne acted with a specific intent to persuade a \nL \ni\niinor to engage \nunlawful sex.\" 368 i 3d at 1286 (emphasis added).\" United States \nRoot, supra, 296 3d at 1227, follows this pattern, and confirms that, at the time the \ndefendant induces or entices the minor, he must intend to have sexual conduct with a \nminor or one he believes to be a minor and know that such conduct is proscribed. \n(\"Root's statement to task force agents upon his arrest confirmed that he believed he \nwould meet a 13-year- d girl for sex, which he said he knew was wrong but 'exciting\"). \nSee also United States \nRojas, 145 Fed. Appx. 647 (11 \n1 \nth Cir. 2005) (unpublished). This \nmens rea requirement \nplies equally where the completed crime occurs.10\nFinally, actus non Tacit reum, nisi mens sit rea - the act alone does not amount to \nguilt; it must be accompanied by a guilty mind. This principle of concurrence mandates \nthat the actus reus and the mens revs concur in time. See Paul H. Robinson, Criminal \nLaw §4.1 at 217 (1997) (concurrence requirement \"means that the required culpability as \nto the element must exist at the time of the conduct constituting the offense\"); LaFave, \nSubstantive Criminal Law §3.11(a) (West 1986) (noting that Concurrence is a basic \nprinciple of criminal law and \"the better view is that there is concurrence when the \ndefendant's mental state actuates the physical conduct\"). See also United States' Bailey, \nsupra, 444 U.S. at 402. In this case, the requisite actus reus is absent; likewise the \nrequired mental state. Even if those two fatal defects could be set aside, nevertheless, \nthere was no concurrence of guilty mind and evil act, providing an additional reason why \na successful prosecution under §2422(b) could not be brought. \n6. Conclusion \nIn Mr. Epstein's case, there was no use of the intemet to induce, etc., and, given \nthe legislative history and purpose, that is itself di\n... [truncated, 2684 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/374 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=374]", "char_count": 2684}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 375, "text_content": "•AW of • eCtib \nGERALD B. LEPCOURT. P.C. \ne \nthen, the statutory language does not fit: Mr. Epstein did not use any facility of interstate \ncommerce to do the forbidden act — to persuade, entice, induce, or coerce — nor did he \nattempt to do so. Others did use the telephone to make a variety of arrangements for Mr. \nEpstein's residence in Palm Beach, including getting the house ready for his arrival, \nchecking movie schedules, and making telephone calls to schedule doctor's \nappointments, personal training, physical therapy and massages. Even if Mr. Epstein \ncould be held responsible for the use of the telephone on his behalf, nevertheless, calls \nmade by others regarding massages were not the statutorily proscribed persuasions or \nenticements of a known minor to do acts known to be illegal. Within his home, even if \nMr. Epstein may arguably have persuaded or induced individuals to engage in forbidden \nconduct with him, he did not violate §2422(b). If he engaged in such persuasion or \ninducement, it occurred only face to face and spontaneously. \nIf such conduct constituted a crime, it would be a classic state offense. The state \nis the appropriate forum for addressing these issues. Though in our meeting it was \nasserted that cases under §2422(b) are often brought where there was simply use of a \ntelephone, and casual use at that, it would not from our survey appear to be so on either \ncount — that is, use of a telephone rather than the intemet, and use of the means of \ncommunication remote from the enticing, etc. This is neither the defendant, nor the \nfactual context, to break new ground. \nH. \nMr. Epstein Warrants Declination to Prosecute as Exercise of Discretion. \nWe believe strongly that no federal case would lie under the facts here. Moreover, \nas we discussed, there is a pending state case against Mr. Epstein which can be resolved \nin a way that vindicates the state's rights and obligations in this matter. \nIn considering an appropriate disposition in a case s\n... [truncated, 2804 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/375 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=375]", "char_count": 2804}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 376, "text_content": "l..w *Orion Or \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT. P C. \ndriving a taxi cab to working as a mechanic. Any notion that he was born with a \"silver \nspoon in his mouth\" should be dismissed. \nAlthough Mr. Epstein is self-made and worked long and hard, he could not have \nachieved his successes without the personal guidance and support of others. These key \npeople first identified the promise in Mr. Epstein and brought him to Bear Steams and \nCompany, Inc. There, starting in 1976 at the age of 23 as a floor trader's junior assistant, \nhe became in 1980 a limited partner. Among the very many benefits that his experience \nthere provided was an introduction to the people who ultimately became his clients. \nEarly in his professional career, Mr. Epstein realized the profound impact that \neven one person can have on the life of another. His gratitude for the assistance he \npersonally received, and his sense of obligation to provide similar assistance and \nguidance to others, is in large part, the motive for the primacy of philanthropy in his life \nor his particular philanthropic interests. Mr. Epstein has devoted a substantial portion of \nhis time, efforts and financial resources to helping others, both on an individual basis and \non a more far reaching scope. Mr. Epstein gives generously, of both his time and his \nfinancial resources equally to individuals whom he knows personally and well and to \nthose with whom he has had little or no personal contact. Just a few examples: \nSome time ago, the two year old son of an employee was diagnosed with retinal \nblastoma. When told, Mr. Epstein not only gave the employee unlimited time off to \nattend to his son and promised whatever financial support was needed, but Mr. Epstein \nmade the full list of his medical and research contacts available. The employee was put \nin contact with a former colleague who was then conducting eye research at Washington \nUniversity. Mr. Epstein organized several meetings to determine how the colleague could \nbe of assis\n... [truncated, 2982 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/376 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=376]", "char_count": 2982}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 377, "text_content": "taw °Fria, 09 \nGERALD B. LRECOURT. PC. \nwas acquainted and assigned personnel to assist the employee with administrative and \nsecretarial needs that arose in seeking a solution to the problem. Mr. Epstein is now the \ngodfather of the employee's seven-year old twins. \nRecently, both a second employee and a consultant of Mr. Epstein each confided \nthat they and their respective spouses were experiencing similar fertility problems. \nAgain, Mr. Epstein offered to pay the uncovered medical costs. The consultant and his \nwife are now expecting their first child. The second employee continues with infertility \ntreatments. \nTwo years ago, a building workman approached Mr. Epstein with news that the \nworkman's wife needed a kidney transplant and that the workman's sister-in-law in \nColombia was a willing donor. The non English speaking workman had neither the \nfinancial resources nor the know-how to get the sister-in-law to the United States. Mr. \nEpstein arranged for immigration counsel to expedite a visa for the sister-in-law and \npurchased the plane tickets for the sister-in-law's visit to the United States. The surgery \nwas a success and both patients recovered completely. The sister-in-law flew back to \nColombia at Mr. Epstein's expense. \nMr. Epstein is a devoted advocate of personal improvement through education. \nAs a former board member of Rockefeller University, Mr. Epstein has made available \nacademic scholarships to worthy students, most of whom he has had no prior connection \nto whatsoever. In addition, Mr. Epstein covers the tuition required to send the family \nmembers of his employees to nursery, private elementary, middle and secondary schools \nand colleges. He has funded and personally encouraged continuing education programs \nfor his adult employees and professional consultants. \nAmong his other acts: \n• On a trip to Rwanda to inspect the genocide camps, Mr. Epstein \napproached the President of Rwanda and offered to help identify and then \nto fund two worthy\n... [truncated, 2540 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/377 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=377]", "char_count": 2540}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 378, "text_content": "OF•Cl• \nor \nGERALD 13. LEFOOURT. PC. \nmonthly with a teenage building workman whose expenses of vocational \nschool are being paid by Mr. Epstein. Each month, Mr. Epstein reviews \nthe workman's school progress and discusses career opportunities. One of \nthe monthly reports is annexed at Tab \"D\". \n• \nIn addition, Mr. Epstein blocks out time each week to meet with young \nprofessionals to discuss their career prospects and counsel them regarding \nappropriate next steps. \nAlthough Mr. Epstein is deeply committed to helping others in very personal and \nmeaningful ways, he has also sought to use his good fortune to help others on a broader \nbasis. Mr. Epstein has sponsored more than 70 athlete wellness programs, building \nprojects, scholarship funds and community interest programs in the United States Virgin \nIslands alone. \nMoreover, Mr. Epstein has given generously to support philanthropic \norganizations across the United States and around the world, including America's \nAgenda; Robin Hood; Alliance for Lupus Research; Ovarian Cancer Research Fund; \nFriends of Israel Defense Forces; Seeds of Peace; the Jewish National Fund; the Hillel \nFoundation; the National Council of Jewish Women; and the Intrepid Fallen Heroes Fund \n-- to name only a few. \nIn a feature article about Mr. Epstein in New York Magazine, former President \nClinton aptly described Mr. Epstein as \"a committed philanthropist with a keen sense of \nglobal markets and an in-depth knowledge of twenty-first-century science.\" President \nClinton reached this conclusion during a month-long trip to Africa with Mr. Epstein, \nwhich Mr. Epstein hosted. The purpose of that trip was to increase AIDS awareness; to \nwork towards a solution to the AIDS crisis; and to provide funding to reduce the costs of \ndelivering medications to those inflicted with the disease. \nBoth before and after that trip to Africa, Mr. Epstein worked hard to achieve \nimprovements in people's lives on a global basis. He actively sought advancement o\n... [truncated, 2614 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/378 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=378]", "char_count": 2614}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 379, "text_content": "LAW 01•FICCS of \nGERALD B. LEPCOURT. PC. \nMr. Epstein was part of the original group that conceived the Clinton Global \nInitiative, which is described as a project \"bringing together a community of global \nleaders to devise and implement innovative solutions to some of the world's most \npressing challenges.\" Focuses of this initiative include poverty, climate change, global \nhealth, and religious and ethnic conflicts. \nMr. Epstein has sought to improve people's lives through active participation in \nworthy scientific and academic research projects, as well. He spent hundreds of hours \nresearching the world's best scientists, and he himself studied as a Harvard Fellow in \norder to increase his own knowledge in fields that he believed could provide solutions to \nthe world's most difficult problems. He is committed to helping the right researchers find \nthose solutions, especially in the fields of medical science, human behavior and the \nenvironment. \nIn the past four years alone, Mr. Epstein has made grants to research programs at \nmajor institutions under the supervision of some of the most highly regarded research \nprofessionals and scholars in their fields, including Martin Nowak, a mathematical \nbiologist who studies, among other things, the dynamics of infectious diseases and cancer \ngenetics; Martin Seligman, known for his work on Positive Psychology — that is to say \nthe psychology of personal fulfillment; Roger Schank, a leading researcher in the \napplication of cognitive learnin theory to the curricula of formal education; the renown \nphysicist/cosmologist \nKrauss, and many others. Institutions funded include \nHarvard University; Penn tate University; Lenox Hill Hospital (New York); the \nBiomedical Research and Education Foundation; the Santa Fe Institute; Massachusetts \nInstitute of Technology; Case Western Reserve University; and Harvard Medical School's \nInstitute for Music and Brain Science. \nMoreover, Mr. Epstein has sponsored and chaired symposia that h\n... [truncated, 2836 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/379 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=379]", "char_count": 2836}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 380, "text_content": "Law orricts or \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT. PC. \nfive years, SRF has made 155 grants to scholars fr \nare placed at host universities in a safe country. More than 87 institutions around the \nworld have hosted SRF scholars to date, including eight of the top ten universities in the \nUnited States. Most recently, SRF launched the Iraq Scholar Rescue Project to save \nscholars in Iraq, many of whom have been particularly targeted for kidnapping and death \nsince the conflict there began. Mr. Epstein is a highly valued member of the selection \ncommittee. Just a few articles mentioning these and other projects are annexed at Tab \n\"E\". \nEven a casual review of the good works large and small in which he has involved \nhimself leads one to conclude that he has a powerful instinct to help others. He does this \nnot simply because he can, but because he has a deeply ingrained desire to do so. In fact, \nhe believes that, as a result of his good fortune, he is obligated to do so. \nSince 2000, Mr. Epstein has funded educational assistance, science and research \nand community and civic activities. As you can see, his philanthropy is not limited to \nfinancial support. To the contrary, it has involved the dedication of a remarkable amount \nof his time and effort and has yielded admirable results. It is noteworthy that a majority \nof the people he has helped over the years have been those with whom he has had little or \nno contact, which further confirms that he derives no personal benefit from his good \nworks, other than the personal satisfaction derived from using his good fortune to help \nothers. \nThe sincere devotion to others evidenced by Mr. Epstein's philanthropic activities \nis no less apparent in his interpersonal relationships. Mr. Epstein has maintained both \nlong term significant, intimate as well as professional relationships. He remains close \npersonal friends with people with whom he went to high school and, to this day, \nmaintains close business contacts with his former colleague\n... [truncated, 2719 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/380 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=380]", "char_count": 2719}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 381, "text_content": "r \nLAW 00 ICC,. Y. \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT. P.C. \nJeffrey Sloman, Esq. \nMatthew Menchel, Esq. \nAndrew LS. \nA. Marie \n, Esq. \nThe Unite!1Mttorney's Office \nSouthern District of Florida \nJuly 6,2007 \nPage 23 \nAgain, we and our colleagues thank you for your attention at the June 26 meeting. \nI welcome any questions or comments you may have and am available to discuss this and \nany other issues at your earliest convenience. \nVery truly yours, \nGo-a( \nGerald B. Lefcourt \nalak,,,.1 \n44A),,5 \nAlan Dcrshowitz \ncc: Lilly Ann Sanchez, Esq. \nRoy Black, Esq. \nEFTA00226777\n", "char_count": 563}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 382, "text_content": "STEVEN PINKER \nJohnstone Family Professor \nDEPARTMENT OF PSYCHOLOGY \nHARVARD UNIVERSITY \nProfessor Alan Dershowitz \nHarvard Law School \nHarvard University \nCambridge, MA 02138 \nJune 28, 2007 \nDear Alan, \nI'm happy to offer the help of my knowledge in linguistics to determine the natural \ninterpretation of a statute you have inquired about. My comments refer to how a literate English \nspeaker would interpret the statute, based on research on the syntax and semantics of verbs. I \nconsider myself an expert on this topic, having written about it in many scholarly articles and in \nthree books: Learnability and Cognition (MIT Press, 1989), Lexical and Conceptual Semantics \n(coedited with Beth Levin; Blackwell, 1992), and The Stuff of Thought: Language as a Window \ninto Human Nature (Viking, 2007). \nThe statute at issue is as follows: \nWhoever, using the mail or any facility or means of interstate or \nforeign commerce, or within the special maritime and territorial \njurisdiction of the United States knowingly persuades, induces, \nentices, or coerces any individual who has not attained the age of \n18 years, to engage in prostitution or any sexual activity for which \nany person can be charged with a criminal offense, or attempts to \ndo so, shall be fined under this title and imprisoned not less than \nten years or for life. \nYour question, as I understand it, pertains to the temporal and causal relationship \nbetween the person's use of the mail (or other interstate/foreign instrument) and his knowingly \npersuading (inducing, enticing, etc.) the minor. Simplifying the various disjuncts and subordinate \nclauses so that we may concentrate on the semantics, the relevant part of the statute is effectively \nthis: \nWhoever, using the mail etc., knowingly persuades a minor to \nengage in a criminal sexual activity, shall be fined and imprisoned. \nSo the question is: does this statute apply (1) to someone who uses the mail (or Internet or \nphone) and subsequently persuades a minor, in \n... [truncated, 2658 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/382 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=382]", "char_count": 2658}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 383, "text_content": "of instrument: something used as a means to the ends specified by the causative verb. So the \nquestion is how an instrument-phrase is ordinarily interpreted. We can clarify this by simplifying \neven further and substituting concrete events for the abstract ones in the statute: \n(a) John, using a hammer, broke the glass. \nNow consider the following scenarios: \n(b) John uses a hammer to bang nails into a piece of wood. Then \nhe puts the hammer down, reaches for a glass, and deliberately \nsmashes the glass against the table. \n(c) With his right hand, John hammers in a nail. While he is doing \nthis, he reaches for a glass with his left hand, and deliberately \nsmashes the glass against the table. \n(d) John takes a hammer and deliberately swings it against the \nglass, breaking it. \nIt's clear that no English speaker would ever use the sentence (a) to describe scenario (b). \nSimilarly, sentence (a) would almost certainly not be used to describe scenario (c): any English \nspeaker would say \"while using a hammer,\" not just \"using a hammer.\" The only scenario that \ncan be described by (a) is the one in (d). In other words, the event denoted by the instnunental \ngerundive phrase must immediately precede the event denoted by the causative verb, and the \nactor has to use the instrument in order to bring about the change indicated by the causative \nverb; that is, it has to be the means to an end. \nThere is an additional condition that has to be met. Consider scenario (e): \n(e) Mary is holding a glass. John stands behind Mary, and bangs a \nhammer against an iron bar. The noise startles Mary, who drops \nthe glass, breaking it. \nHere, too, it would be pretty weird to use sentence (a) to describe the scenario, even if John \nintended for the glass to break as a result of the scenario. As far as English verbs are concerned, \nthe only means to the end that counts is the one that directly and immediately precedes the end. \nIn addition, the way in which the means brings about the end has \n... [truncated, 3226 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/383 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=383]", "char_count": 3226}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 384, "text_content": "the spur of the moment to try to seduce her. No one could possibly describe that as \"John, using \nthe phone, seduced Mary,\" since he had no such intention at the time he used the phone. \nThese properties of the use of verbs—immediateness, means-ends, directness, \nstereotypy—have been discussed in the literature on the lexical semantics of causative verbs for \nalmost forty years. They have also been confirmed in experiments that ask people whether they \ncould use various sentences to describe particular scenarios. I append below a few of the \nreferences to the relevant scholarly literature. \nMy professional conclusion, in sum, is that an English speaker, reading the statute, would \nnaturally understand it as applying only to persuasion (etc.) that is done while \"using the mail\" \n(etc.). To understand it as applying to persuasion (etc.) done subsequent to the use of the mail, \nphone, etc., would be an unnatural and grammatically inaccurate reading of the language. \nI hope this helps to clarify your question. Please don't hesitate to be in touch if I can \nclarify or expand on this analysis. \nSincerely, \nStmia-Rt \nFodor, J. A. (1970). Three reasons for not deriving \"kill\" from \"cause to die\". Linguistic \nInquiry, 1, 429-438. \nGergely, G., & Bever, T. G. (1986). Relatedness intutions and mental represenation of \ncausative verbs. Cognition, 23, 211-277. \nLevin, B., & Pinker, S. (Eds.). (1992). Lexical and conceptual semantics. Cambridge, Mass.: \nBlackwell. \nPinker, S. (1989). Learnability and cognition: The acquisition of argument structure. \nCambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. \nShibatani, M. (1976). The grammar of causative constructions: A conspectus. In M. \nShibatani (Ed.), Syntax and semantics 6: The grammar of causative constructions. New \nYork: Academic Press. \nTalmy, L. (1988). Force dynamics in language and cognition. Cognitive Science, 12, 49-\n100. \nWolff, P. (2003). Direct causation in the linguistic coding and individuation of causal \nevents. Cognition, 88, 1-48. \nWol\n... [truncated, 2132 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/384 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=384]", "char_count": 2132}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 385, "text_content": "Southern District of Florida Cases Charging 18 U.S.C.S. 2422 (b) \nCase # \nDefendant \nCounts \nOther Charges \nSummary \n97-8093 \nPaul Panunzio \n2 \n2 counts 2422(b) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n00-6034 \nJohn Palmer \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(5)(B) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n01-0704 \nMichael Nyberg \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-0734 \nFranco Sabri \nI \n[None) \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on Internet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-0756 \nEduardo Alvarez \nI \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-0783 \nProm D'Szi \nI \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nEFTA00226781\n", "char_count": 1265}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 386, "text_content": "conversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on Internet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-0961 \nJose Mayorga \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-0998 \nGustavo Desouza \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-1004 \nFerrys Miranda \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 12 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-1139 \nJames Patterson \nI \n]None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-1174 \nRoberto \n1 \n[None) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nEFTA00226782\n", "char_count": 1271}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 387, "text_content": "•• \n• \nactivity. \n01-6024 \nJames Boutin \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(5)(B) \nUse of interne( to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n01-6107 \nOtis Wragg \n1 \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n01-6157 \nKelly Jones \n4 \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(aX1); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(2)(A); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(5XB) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n01-6185 \nByron Matthai \n1 \nNone] \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n01-6203 \nAnthony Gentile \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(5XB) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n01-8073 \nJerrold Levy \n5 \n2 counts 2422(b); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(2); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(5)(B); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(a)(4) \nD communicated with u/c \nofficer (posing as 14 y.o. \nboy) on intemet; D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; D \narrested at meeting site. \nPolice obtained SW for \nD's home and seized \ncomputer. Police located \nanother minor boy that D \nhad previously \ncommunicated w/ and \nengaged in sexual activity \nw/; child pornography also \nfound on computer. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-8097 \nJohn Estevez \nI \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13/14 y.o. girl) on \nintemet chat service. D \nhad sexually explicit \nEFTA00226783\n", "char_count": 1322}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 388, "text_content": "conversations with ofc.; D \ngave u/c his cell phone \n#; u/c called D (3 taped \nphone calls); set up \nmeeting on intend for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n01-8161 \nCarlos Navas \nI \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n02- \n14077 \nAnthony Murrell \nI \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas a mother with a 13 y.o. \ndaughter) on intemet chat \nroom; D was looking to be \nw/ a mother and daughter. \nD gave his phone # to u/c. \nD met same u/c (posing as \ndad with 13 y.o. daughter) \nin another chat room; D \nwanted to rent daughter. D \ngave his phone # to u/c and \nu/c called him to speak \nabout arrangements. Next \nday D & u/c had further \nconversation thru the chat \nroom. 4 days later D \ncalled u/c on phone \nmaking meeting \narrangements & agreed to \npay $300. D arrested at \nhotel meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n02- \n14080 \nDouglas \nBourdon \n1 \niNonei \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n02- \n14081 \nJames Homadal \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c (posing as father \nwith 2 minor \nchildren) in intemet \nchatroom. D looking to \nhave sex with family; u/c \ncalled D several times \nand D had sexually explicit \nconversations w/ \n4 \nEFTA00226784\n", "char_count": 1235}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 389, "text_content": "t✓c. I) also sent nude \nphotos of himself for \nminors to see. \n02- \n20342 \nBrian Panfil \n1 \n(None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; D \nasked u/c to call him once \nshe reached the meeting \npoint; u/c called; D \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n02- \n20408 \nJohn Orrega \nI \n[None] \nI) met t✓c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with oft., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n02- \n20437 \nDonald Kent \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n02- \n20705 \nMark Obermaier \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1470 \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas 13 y.o. girl) on \nintemet chat service. D \nhad sexually explicit \nconversation with ofc. D \nsent obscene photos to \nu/c and masturbated on \nwebcam for u/c. D gave \nt✓c his phone #; u/c called \nEFTA00226785\n", "char_count": 1213}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 390, "text_content": "D and D had sexually \nexplicit conversation with \nu/c on phone. \n02- \n21012 \nWilliam Yon \n3 \n3 counts of 2422(6) \nD contacted 2 15 y.o. \ngirls/students via the \nInternet and had sexually \nexplicit conversations with \nthem. Girls went to police. \nD set up meeting with u/c \nofc. posing as one of the \ngirls for purpose of having \nsex. D went to meeting \nsite and then returned \nhome. D arrested at home. \n(Affidavit attached). \n02- \n80042 \nSamuel Morton \n25 \n2 counts 2422(b); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(2); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(a)(2); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(a)(4); \n18 U.S.C.S. 2253 \nD met several u/c officers \n(posing as minor \ngirls) on Internet chat \nservice. D had sexually \nexplicit conversation with \nofcs. D sent obscene \nphotos to u/c. D had \nseveral phone \nconversations w/ different \nu/c officers. \n02- \n80072 \nTodd Kroeber \n6 \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(aX2); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(2); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(5)(B) \nUse of facility of interstate \ncommerce to entice a \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity (does not specify \nthe faciliti). \nKnowingly received child \npornography. \nKnowingly distributed \nchild pornography in \ninterstate commerce by \ncomputer. \n02- \n80171 \nElias Guimaraes \n1 \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n03- \n14028 \nEdgar Searcy \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \nas a dad with a 13 y.o. \n6 \nEFTA00226786\n", "char_count": 1357}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 391, "text_content": "daughter) on intemet chat \nroom utilized by people \ntrading their children for \nsex. D gave his phone ti to \nu/c. U/c called I) at set up \nmeeting. I) stated that he \nintended to have sex w/ \nu/c's daughter. D arrested \nat meeting site. \n03- \nJoesph Poignant \nI \n[None] \nUse of intemet and \n13068 \ntelephone to entice minor \nto engage in sex activity. \n03- \nDavid Brautigam \nI \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \n20043 \nas 13 y.o. girl) on internet \nchat service. D (using 2 \nusernames) had sexually \nexplicit conversation with \nofc., set up meeting on \nintemet for purpose of \nhaving sex; arrested at \nmeeting site. (Affidavit \nattached). \n03- \nJoseph Messier \nI \n[None) \nD met u/c officer (posing \n20060 \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on interne( for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n03- \nMarco Pena \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \n20132 \nas 13 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \nsexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on intemet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n03- \nJaime \n2 \n2 counts of 2422(b) \nD met u/c officer (posing \n20133 \nMontealegre \nas 14 y.o. girl) on intemet \nchat service. D had \n7 \nEFTA00226787\n", "char_count": 1317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 392, "text_content": "sexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on Internet for \npurpose of having sex; \narrested at meeting site. \n(Affidavit attached). \n03- \nKenneth Sciacca \n1 \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \n80164 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n04- \nTimothy Darnall \nI \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \n14009 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n04- \nJames Brown \n1 \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \n14032 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n04- \nWilliam Kemal \nI \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \n14063 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n04- \nAndres Rojas \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \n20040 \nas minor girl) on \nintemet chat service. D \nhad sexually explicit \nconversation with u/c ofc. \n04- \nCarlos Barroso \n3 \n2 counts of 18 \nUse of intemet to entice \n20055 \nU.S.C.S. 1470 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nTransfer of obscene \nmaterial via the Internet. \n04- \nDerek \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1594(a) \nD responded to an \n20408 \nadvertisement in a \nnewspaper \nfor Costa Rica Taboo \nVacations, a fake travel \nagency run by federal \ninvestigators. D \nnegotiated and paid for a \ntrip to Costa Rica in \nwhich he planned to have \nsex with 16-year old \nminors. lie cancelled the \n8 \nEFTA00226788\n", "char_count": 1202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 393, "text_content": "trip, but arranged for \nTaboo Vacations to \nprovide him with underage \nsex with the Costa Rican \ngirls in the U.S. D set \nup meeting at hotel. D \narrested at hotel. \n04- \nJames Marquez \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(e); \nKnowingly attempted to \n20409 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1594(a) \ninduce minor to engage in \nprostitution. [no other \nfacts] \n04- \nWallace Strevell \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(e); \nD called \"travel agency\" to \n20520 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1594(a) \narrange for trip to \nCosta Rica for sex w/ \nminors. D had several \nphone conversations w/ \ntravel agency. D bought \ntickets and made \nreservations at hotel. D \narrested at airport. \n04- \nVincent Springer \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(e); \nKnowingly attempted to \n20551 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1594(a) \ninduce minor to engage in \nprostitution. [no other \nfacts] \n04- \nClarke \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(e); \nD attempted to arrange to \n20656 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1594(a) \nhave sex w/ minor \ngirls in Costa Rica thru \nfake \"travel agency.\" \n04- \nR) an Karmen \n9 \n18 U.S.C.S. \nUse of intemet to entice \n20837 \n2252A(a)(2XA); \n18 U.S.C.S. \nminor under 12 y.o. to \nengage in sex activity. \n2252A(a)(5)(B); \n21 U.S.C.S. 841(a)(1); \nPossessed and distributed \nchild pornography. \n18 U.S.C.S. \n924(c)(1XA); \nPossession with intent to \nsell drugs. \n18 U.S.C.S. 2253; \n21 U.S.C.S. 853 \n18 U.S.C.S. 924(d)(1) \nKnowingly carry firearm \nduring drug trafficking \ncrime. \n04- \nRaymond \n13 \n2 counts 2422(b); \nUse of intemet to entice \n60046 \nBohning \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2251(c)(1), (c)(2), and \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n(e); \nTraveled to England for \n9 \nEFTA00226789\n", "char_count": 1545}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 394, "text_content": "18 U.S.C.S. 2423(6) \nand (I); \npurpose of having sex with \nminor. \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(1); \n18 U.S.C.S. \nSent, distributed, and \nreceived child \npornography. \n2252A(aX2XA); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(2XB); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(6)0; \nI8 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(5XB) \n05- \nGerald Smith \n1 \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \n14011 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n05- \n\"I imothy \n4 \n2 counts of 2422(6) \nUse of intemet to entice \n14024 \nCampbell \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(aX2); \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(AX4)(B) \nReceived and possessed \nchild pornography that had \nbeen transported in \ninterstate commerce. \n05- \nAdam Statland \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(b) \nUse of intemet to entice \n14039 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nTraveled from California \nto Florida w/ intent to \nengage in sexual activity \nwith a minor. \n05- \nRobert Carlo \nI \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \n14046 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n05- \nMark Rader \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. \nUse of intemet to entice \n14047 \n2252(aX1) \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nKnowingly transported \nchild pornography in \ninterstate commerce. \n05- \nRobert Latham \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. \nUse of intemet to entice \n14060 \n2252(a)(1) \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nKnowingly transported \n10 \nEFTA00226790\n", "char_count": 1262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 395, "text_content": "child pomographl by a \ncomputer. \n05- \nRalph Poole, Jr. \n1 \n[None] \nUse of Internet to entice \n14099 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n05- \nMark Madison \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. \nOperation of child \n20444 \nJustin Evans \n3 \n1591(aX1); \nprostitution ring in Miami. \nChad Yearby \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. \n14 y.o. girl worked for \n1591(a)(2); \nEvans as prostitute. \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(e) \nEvans arranged dates for \nher at hotels, and she \ngave money from dates to \nEvans. Evans called \n14 y.o. girl to inform her \nof dates. Evans also \ngave girl's phone # to \ncustomers. Evans \nsupplied girl with \ncondoms. \n05- \nEdward Byrd \n1 \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \n60049 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n05- \nCallahan \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(b) \nUse of intemet to entice \n60073 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n05- \nThomas \nI \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \n80023 \nBohannon \nas 15 y.o. girl) on \nintemet chat service. D \nhad sexually explicit \nconversation with ofc., set \nup meeting on \nintemet for purpose of \nhaving sex; arrested at \nmeeting site. \n05- \n1,aronn Houston \n1 \n[None] \nD met u/c officer (posing \n80029 \nas a mother with a 14 \ny.o. daughter) on intemet \nchat room. D set up \nmeeting w/ mother & \n11 \nEFTA00226791\n", "char_count": 1211}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 396, "text_content": "minor. D arrested at \nmeeting site. \n05- \n80200 \nLucas Phelps \n5 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1470 \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nAttempt to knowingly \ntransfer child pornography \nin interstate commerce to a \nminor. \n06- \n14003 \nOctavio \nVillalona \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(a)(1) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nKnowingly transported \nchild pornography by a \ncomputer. \n06- \n14006 \n1)aniel Williams \n1 \nI None] \nUse of internet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n06- \n14007 \nRicky Barnett \n1 \n(None] \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n06- \n14011 \nJohn Everhart. 11 \n1 \n[None) \nUse of internet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n06- \n14016 \nEric Rollins \n3 \n2 counts 2422(b) \n18 U.S.C.S. 2422(a) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nKnowingly enticed a \nminor to travel in interstate \ncommerce to engage in \nsexual activity. \n06- \n14053 \nRichard Grande, \nJr. \n1 \nI None] \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n06- \n14069 \nEric Matthews \n4 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1470; \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(aX2) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nKnowingly transferred \nobscene material to a \nminor in interstate \ncommerce. \n12 \nEFTA00226792\n", "char_count": 1276}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 397, "text_content": "Knowingly distributed \nchild pornography in \ninterstate commerce. \n06- \nAnthony Perez \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1470; \nUse of Internet to entice \n14074 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2251 (a) \nand (e) \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nKnowingly transferred \nobscene material to a \nminor under 16 y.o. in \ninterstate commerce. \nEnticed minor to engage in \nsexual conduct for purpose \nof transporting visual \ndepiction in interstate \ncommerce. \n06- \nMichael \nI \n'None] \nKnowingly attempted to \n20249 \ninduce minor to engage in \nprostitution. [no other \nfacts] \n06- \nDino Pancaro \n. , \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(e); \nKnowingly attempted to \n20341 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1594(a) \ninduce minor to engage in \nprostitution. \nAttempted to travel to \nengage in commercial sex \nact with a minor. \n06- \nDemond Osley \n8 \n18 U.S.C.S. \nMinor arrested for \n20734 \nStacey Greer \n1591(a)(1); \nprostitution on Miami \n18 U.S.C.S. 2421; \n18 U.S.C.S. 2422(a); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n1001(aX2); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n1028(a)(4) \nBeach. \nWhen questioned by \nofficers, minor said Osley \nbrought her from Michigan \nto Florida for \npurpose of prostitution; \n‘ \nOsley became unhappy \nwith minor b/c she was not \nmeeting daily quota; \nOsley sold minor to Greer. \nGreer takes minor to \nhotel, forces her to have \nsex, video tapes minor \nand takes photos of her to \ndistribute on intemet. \nOmer also forces minor \ninto prostitution tivu \n13 \nEFTA00226793\n", "char_count": 1363}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 398, "text_content": "threats of violence. Minor \nidentified Osley and \nGreer. Both arrested. \n06- \n20783 \nKeith Lanzon \nI \n(None] \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n06- \n80031 \nLynn Mann \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1470; \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(5)(B); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(b)(2) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nDistribute child \npornography to a minor. \nPossession of child \npornography. \n06- \n80034 \nRafael Ramirez, \nJr. \n1 \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n06- \n80058 \nAdam McDaniel \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(b) \nD was 19 in Texas, met 14 \ny.o. girl on intemet \nwho lived in Florida. D & \ngirl communicated \nby email & phone. D flew \nto Florida, met w/ \ngirl and had sex w/ her in a \nhotel. \n06- \n80135 \nDavid Girouard \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(b) \nUse of intemet and cellular \ntelephone to entice minor \nto engage in sex activity. \n07- \n14002 \nBenjamin ■ \n4 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1470; \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252A(a)(2XA); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(b)(1); \n18 U.S.C.S. \n2252(aX4)(B) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nKnowingly transferred \nobscene material to a \nminor under 16 y.o. in \ninterstate commerce. \nKnowingly distributed \nchild pornography in \ninterstate commerce. \nPossession of child \npornography. \n07- \n14004 \nRicky \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2251 (a) \nand (e) \nUse of intemet to entice \nminor to engage in sex \n14 \nEFTA00226794\n", "char_count": 1386}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 399, "text_content": "activity. \nAttempted production of \nchild pornography thru \ninterstate commerce. \n07- \nCarl Beater \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. \nUse of intemet to entice \n14005 \n2252A(a)(2XA); \n18 U.S.C.S. \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n2252A(b)(l) \nKnowingly distributed \nchild pornography in \ninterstate commerce. \n07- \nFrancesco Simo \nI \n[None] \nUse of intemet to entice \n14015 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n07- \nJoseph Crutchley \nI \n[None] \nUse of Internet to entice \n14016 \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n07- \nWesley Evans \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(a); \nUse of intemet to entice \n14024 \nEvans \n1 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(e) \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \nConspiracy to transport a \nminor to engage in sexual \nactivity. \nKnowingly transport (or \nattempt) a minor to engage \nin sexual activity. \n07- \nSammy \n4 \n18 U.S.C.S. 1591(a); \nKnowingly attempted to \n20214 \nCarpenter, \nDarryl Jennings, \nLuroy Jennings \n18 U.S.C.S. 2422(a) \ninduce minor to engage in \nprostitution. \n07- \nNelson Cintron \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. \nUse of intemet to entice \n60049 \n2252A(a)(2)(A); \n18 U.S.C.S. \nminor to engage in sex \nactivity. \n2252A(a)(5)(B) \nPossessed and distributed \nchild pornography. \n07- \nOliver Buelow \n2 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(b) \n[No factual information] \n60084 \n07- \nMarion \n3 \n18 U.S.C.S. 2423(a); \nUse of intemet and cellular \n80099 \nYarbrough \n18 U.S.C.S. 2422(a) \ntelephone to entice \nminor to engage in sex \n15 \nEFTA00226795\n", "char_count": 1398}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 400, "text_content": "activity. \nTransport minor to engage \nin sex activity. \nEntice minor to travel in \ninterstate commerce to \nengage in sex activity. \n16 \nEFTA00226796\n", "char_count": 149}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 401, "text_content": "the \nCity College \nof Newt!: \nINTERNATIONAL. STUDIES PROGRAM \nJeffrey Epstein \ndo Darren Indyke Esq. \n457 Madison Avenue — 14th Floor \nNew York, \nN.Y. 10022. \nDear Mr. Epstein, \nNorth Academic Center, Room 6/141 \n160 Convent Avenue \nNew York, New York 10031 \nTEL \nFAX: \nwww.ccny.cuny.udu \nAugust 21,2006. \nThank you for your continued and generous support of the undergraduate academic \ncareers of Georges Ndabashimiye and Nicole Mutesi. \nBoth students have done very well both academically and in co-curricular life and expect \nto graduate in June, 2008. Georges will return to Rwanda to teach and Nicole plans to \njoin the energy industry which is focused on developing Rwanda's newly found resources \nin natural gas. \nYour support of these two students will thus contribute to the human resource wealth of \nRwanda. \nMarina W. Fernando Ph.D. \nDirector, International Studies Program \nand Deputy Dean of Social Science. \nTHE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK \nEFTA00226797\n", "char_count": 968}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 402, "text_content": "01107. 10C \nbe 01 I \nerttirt., \nkis it , CLA rati \nres \n,yon rrv. \nktnai \nc.ovi \nflzviyxs\nclusb:/\nbaskkuso- beat, . 3 \nErecabi oltrea aEe detruivvrot \nCct, ,a \n0.5•  9,6,4r \noust_ \nRsa, gvateck \nws5 \nI \n9tit- APAR 0,1,1 claet. rn9 acude — \nrnzt sulks \n561c/stay \ncoLe M U TES \nEFTA00226798\n", "char_count": 290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 403, "text_content": "o9. / z \ncr.° \nPeo4 Set \nsk-pi j\n2 4Lrblic \nrior\n-rut r \nalter+ \nllne \nkruk.r\nteen,' Ce gLot burn\n41 \nAeltut \nrk, \nr\na Cho \n19Leida \\taut \ngleol- Lois Lt.') ) \ncescate, Ncioltaolmint \n9laCUal \n4csok \nEFTA00226799\n", "char_count": 213}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 404, "text_content": "ma) Va \ncish, trany) 1 rz \n\\Pei \\A \n3 0-1r\nNalcssreS: \nk•ko \ncotift•No.t.A c(y_SN:s4 \nt•N \nker6 VAT6SI 2 \n52Sa c.c.) \nfl\n \n\\ \n• \\KRONE\nS\\ ukb‘js \n11/4).A \n\\Not‘  \nmaNki, \n• -`, 1s30-14 \n•a-s‘Aa% \nCre\"'S\"3 \nVUOAch \nI \noz> \n;541.0 \n(' l,Mv\\ SA ‘A Lk. \n4-VA\\ \nsva \nO CM \n‘ 1/4.00 \nI 1 4e 4O1 33: it  z \n`o \na \nTa cum .5 sti \n4 wen 61.4-s \n\\s‘val \n-Nst•tm.yr .yact\\ \n?h\ni t \n00* \nks \n,r4sik \n„AN, \\zs \n\\-3, 3...n. \n-6.4k. \n\"^\".\"A\\ \n05 \"\"A .3S\\ tse%3 \n2cs-\"\")$`\\ \nOA* \n•4..ht. \ncS.01 \n-4 r.N.sts \nof c \n.,c..O,vc • •-•„,„..s , t:\\\n- • ...4k ,c\\ \nacallo a e‘ r..m.s\\ e \n_ant; - \nA.6q.co not, pat. \nCi.r a cc \nc441/4\\ \nTz. \n• k  r .\\ i‘ 430c \nist•cstoor.ms..ms \nc-stsi \n4 \\3 \n-nckcia \n1-Y \n'WM rei \n-SI \n• 10 \nvrac•-\\ 'awes\\ \\rats \nI \n5.14 \nosic \ners \ntot\\ \n\\ \n-v\"\\c‘ i  \n-a\\N \"a4c-S \nIt'N \nC'`,C) \njes• \nsa‘3, -rest \n',Anus -ntint\" \nzm\\ e* -raTo \nC.:1‘..kos \ns‘ \nwick \nks5, \nsi'a cis \n.\\ t \n• A..0.e. \nstroVn-o-\\ i ctoc%\n.4v* 9.0A \naSusauca \n\"a Wt. cu r \\ \n.\\-414k \nto.l o s  \n.a\\ \nnOk \n\\\\ \nof \nVat-WOO\\ \n-1-\nI \nSW \n• .40'yc-araStya•\\ \nt,\\\\)%0 \n\\??0,4Cy \no)„44 \nr anssiTn- \no.netva.\\ s \n\" co • \ns.4.3‘.\\\n.41,40(.4 \nvon \n3 %M.\\ \n\\ -‘ 0‘.\\\\ \nok \nAair\n• c,.35. \n4,,,cois.)0.39is \nsec, I \n%%xi\n• i iv\\votaavA wsv.ov\\ \nAsae\\ \n- .;A\\ \n(NO\\ \ns4.,1 \nANArN. c4 0 1/4 \nOA; \n\\-\nr451 0-1. \nethy \nc4-1r, \nCA \n=\nI -IsSakx•Va4aS .. \n$3\\i\n••.1‘,aktS \niN Z-4 -IstZ \n• \n•• \nEFTA00226800\n", "char_count": 1363}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 405, "text_content": "SS \nkres..n-4 \nj. \ncrt...k7 \n.1 \nVb.% \\tr . \nI ckty.Se \nQre..k \nC.V:\\%5 \nVsek\\k \n`fit Mt \nWAND \n*rt. \ncLea.,\\C-Skat \n‘cou \\ 3 r.t SS \n\\fro \ny a „,b,, \nN„,>. \nMy \n\\5 \n}so\n\\M.) y \n\\irt4S.e.5 \nt.\\\n- \n. 0, \nS‘,04ite. \norN \n\\AoA, \n(`.%)r, \nkAce \nWc.o,A-itn )\nPr% cot.‘Aken;.S \nP°e(4°PS \nOtth r tcc1/4‘ )- \n43.-\")g \nt1/4c to -,\\ TN.; . \nAeXt. \nSv-) \nittne \n\\revs \nri:\\e, \nb.\\ \n.w0A \nscw.t. \no‘. \n\\„1„ \n4 O\\ \n...A \n\\It vw-t. \nTh‘f \n\\Crto-,-) \nte. \nSo\\ -V\\ no)  \nc1/4 \n\\AI \n\\ Sr \nt\nS‘'‘)AS \nte°4W \n\\S1Ncl1/4r4 ','tits-es\n\\NIVaNe NM- \n.eiNove \nt\\- k`4.- \nsr. \n.cso.‘Th . . \nshe \n14-ett) S\\-cAv ttlj oviA IC \n\\AD.) \\$ \nc1/4114.4. \n16u \n56 nroa awj \nW\\-on \n\\- \nC-at<96 \n\\-0 \n\\ \nwork \nmk,z) \nkatn,s1Ne.s.3\" \n0.4p \no.\\5°\n‘acet.,‘ \nke \ntroul \n4-o \n`Ne If \n‘ vir \n\\\\`' \nc`f`Y \n\\ `'Vsrve \nw°At \ncci\" \\\n(r.c.t. \nire. \nIn)* \n`tic \nynk \n‘aNtetert \n*NI \nSV4 +' \n\\VT \nWit \n\\VASA' \n.1_ _._c9.,.\\,.._ \n• \nyvQ ) \n\\Nla \nbeer te44-r-ty sQs4-ecn \n,We- \n•Vto \n3r1/4\"0\"V\" \n100 \nr \nIvor \nlet tete \n49 \nWchiS45 \n‘ith) \n\\ \n4•42.1 \n\\Min \n\\,A\\.\\ \ntz14z. \nRS 1 \nIST\\5• \nwo,el \n•r \nAra \nNo 4 \n‘44. ,  \n\"r— \noJe \n{or \n3cce. ‘C‘tc,st. sicesA-\nN:\\;4... \nCAI \n11\\5‘0:K\\ \nOc- \n9t\\rt tbrhnta \n-CtSVtict \n\"Art.\n \n\\ja\\AC \n\\? \nCS'eAlfiv) \n\\et \n\\ \n\\CS,‘.\".\n - \nitt ereN \n'N \nk Nero r \n--1. \n\\a \n\\ \ncan .:te\nc) k \nck. \ny ‘ v..A ,A O rb c \nv.).e. \\ \nyen \ncvoa y \nf \nr e \n*ft \nerfeA *lite\n,  \nhove \nc \nSC4 \n4...3d\\I \nEFTA00226801\n", "char_count": 1381}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 406, "text_content": "447 of 1456 DOCUMENTS \nCopyright 2004 Gale Group, Inc. \nASAP \nCopyright 2004 American Association for Artificial Intelligence \nAl Magazine \nJune 22, 2004 \nSECTION: No. 2, Vol. 25; Pg. 113; ISSN: 0738-4602 \nIAC-ACC-NO: 119024857 \nLENGTH: 7274 words \nHEADLINE: The St. Thomas common sense symposium: designing architectures for human-level \nintelligence. \nBYLINE: Minsky, Marvin; Singh, Push; Sloman, Aaron \nBODY: \nTo build a machine that has \"common sense\" was once a principal goal in the field of artificial \nintelligence. But most researchers in recent years have retreated from that ambitious aim. Instead. each \ndeveloped some special technique that could deal with some class of problem well, but does poorly at \nalmost everything else. We are convinced, however, that no one such method will ever turn out to be \n\"best,\" and that instead, the powerful Al systems of the future will use a diverse array of resources that, \ntogether, will deal with a great range of problems. To build a machine that's resourceful enough to have \nhumanlike common sense, we must develop ways to combine the advantages of multiple methods to \nrepresent knowledge, multiple ways to make inferences, and multiple ways to learn. We held a two-day \nsymposium in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands, to discuss such a project—to develop new architectural \nschemes that can bridge between different strategies and representations. This article reports on the events \nand ideas developed at this meeting and subsequent thoughts by the authors on how to make progress. \nThe Need for Synthesis in Modern Al \nTo build a machine that has \"common sense was once a principal goal in the field of artificial \nintelligence. But most researchers in recent years have retreated from that ambitious aim. Instead, each \ndeveloped some special technique that could deal with some class of problem well, but does poorly at \nalmost everything else. An outsider might regard our field as a chaotic array of attempts to exploit the \nadvantage\n... [truncated, 3203 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/406 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=406]", "char_count": 3203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 407, "text_content": "Marvin Minsky kicked off the meeting by discussing how we might begin to organize the many \ntechniques that have been developed in Al so far. While Al researchers have invented many \nrepresentations, methods, and architectures for solving many types of problems, they still have little \nunderstanding of the strengths and weaknesses of each these techniques. We need a theory that helps to \nmap the types of problems we face onto the types of solutions that arc available to us. When should one use \na neural network? When should one use statistical teaming? When should one use logical theorem proving? \nTo help answer these kinds of questions, Minsky suggested that we could organize different AL \nmethods into a \"causal diversity matrix\" (figure I). Here, each problem-solving method, such as analogical \nreasoning, logical theorem proving, and statistical inference, is assessed in terms of its competence at \ndealing with problem domains with different causal structures. \n[FIGURE I OMITTED] \nStatistical inference is often useful for situations that are affected by many different matched causal \ncomponents, but where each contributes only slightly to the final phenomenon. A good example of such a \nproblem-type is visual texture classification, such as determining whether a region in an image is a patch of \nskin or a fragment of a cloud. This can be done by summing the contributions of many small pieces of \nevidence such as the individual pixels of the texture. No one pixel is terribly important, but en masse they \ndetermine the classification. Formal logic, on the other hand, works well on problems where there are \nrelatively few causal components, but which are arranged in intricate structures sensitive to the slightest \ndisturbance or inconsistency. An example of such a problem-type is verifying the correctness of a computer \nprogram, whose behavior can be changed completely by modifying a single bit of its code. Case-based and \nanalogical reasoning lie between these extrem\n... [truncated, 4058 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/407 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=407]", "char_count": 4058}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 408, "text_content": "Self-Reflective: I'm getting bored with this--at else is there to do? \nSingh argued that no present-day Al system demonstrates such a broad range of commonsense skills. \nAny architecture we design should aim to achieve some competence within each of these and other \nimportant mental realms. He proposed that to do this we work within the simplest possible domain \nrequiring reasoning in each of these realms. He suggested that we develop our architectures within a \nphysically realistic model world resembling the classic Blocks World, but where the world was populated \nby several simulated beings, and thus emphasizing social problems in addition to physical ones. These \nbeings would manipulate simple objects like blocks, balls, and cylinders, and would participate in the kinds \nof scenarios depicted in figure 3, which include jointly building structures of various kinds, competing to \nsolve puzzles, teaching each other skills through examples and through conversation, and verbally \nreflecting on their own successes and failures. \n[FIGURE 3 OMITTED \nThe apparent s' plicity of this world is deceptive, for many of the kinds of problems that show up in \nthis world have not \nt been tackled in Al, for they require combining elements of the following: \nr\nSpatial reasoning about the spatial arrangements of objects in one's environment and how the parts of \nobjects arc oriented and situated in relation to one another. (Which of those blocks is closest to me?) \nPhysical reasoning about the dynamic behavior of physical objects with masses and \ncolhding/supporting surfaces. (What would happen if I removed that middle block from the tower?) \nBodily reasoning about the capabilities of one's physical body. (Can I reach that block without having \nto get up?) \nVisual reasoning about the world that underlies what can be seen. (Is that a cylinder-shaped block or \npart of a person's leg?) \nPsychological reasoning about the goals and beliefs oneself and of others. (What is the other person \n... [truncated, 4292 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/408 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=408]", "char_count": 4292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 409, "text_content": "participants argued that restricting the world would not entirely bypass the need for large databases of \nconunonsense knowledge, for even this simple world would likely require hundreds of thousands or even \nmillions of elementary pieces of commonsense knowledge about space, time, physics, bodies, social \ninteractions, object appearances, and so forth. \nOther participants disagreed with the virtual world domain. They felt that we should instead take the \nmore practical approach of developing the architecture by starting with a useful application like a search \nengine or conversational agent, and extending its common sense abilities over time. But Ben Kuipers \nworried that choosing too specific an application would lead to what happened to most previous projects--\nsomeone discovers some set of ad hoc tricks that leads to adequate performance, without making any more \ngeneral progress toward more versatile, resourceful, or \"more intelligent\" systems. \nIn the end, after long debates we achieved a substantial consensus that to solve harder problems \nrequiring common sense, we first needed to solve the more restricted class of problems that show up in \nsimpler domains like the proposed virtual world. Once we get the core of the architecture functioning in \nthis rich but limited domain, we can attempt to extend it--or it extend itself--to deal with a broader range of \nproblems using a much broader array of commonsense knowledge. \nLarge-Scale Architectures for Human-level Intelligence \nIn the afternoon, we discussed large-scale architectures for machines with human-level intelligence \nand common sense. Marvin Minsky and Aaron Sloman each presented their current architectural proposals \nas a starting point for the meeting participants to criticize, debug, and elaborate. These two architectures \nshare so many features that we will refer to them together as the Minsky-Sloman model. \nThese architectures are distinguished by their emphasis on reflective thinking. Most cognitiv\n... [truncated, 4701 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/409 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=409]", "char_count": 4701}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 410, "text_content": "can rapidly switch to another. There is no single underlying knowledge representation scheme or \ninferencing mechanism. \nHow do such architectures support such diversity? In the case of Minsky's Emotion Machine \narchitecture, the top level is organized as follows. When the system encounters a problem, it first uses some \nknowledge about \"problem-types\" to select some \"way-to-think\" that might work. Minsky describes \"ways-\nto-think\" as configurations of agents within the mind that dispose it towards using certain styles of \nrepresentation, collections of commonsense knowledge, strategies for reasoning, types of goals and \npreferences, memories of past experiences, manners of reflections, and all the other aspects that go into a \nparticular \"cognitive style.\" One source of knowledge relating problem-types to ways-to-think is the causal \ndiversity matrix discussed at the start of the meeting--for example, if the system were presented with a \nsocial problem, it might use the causal diversity matrix to then select a case-based style of reasoning, and a \nparticular database of social reasoning episodes to use with it. \nHowever, any particular such approach is likely to fail in various ways. Then if certain \"critic\" agents \nnotice specific ways in which that approach has failed, they either suggest strategies to adapt that approach, \nor suggest alternative ways-to-think, as suggested shown in figure 6. This is not done by employing any \nsimple strategy for reflection and repair, but rather by using large arrays of higher level knowledge about \nwhere each way-to-think has advantages and disadvantages, and how to adapt them to new contexts. \n[FIGURE 6 OMITTED] \nIn Minsky's design, several ways-to-think are usually active in parallel. This enables the system to \nquickly and fluently switch between different ways-to-think because, instead of starting over at each \ntransition, each newly activated way-to-think will find an already-prepared representation. The system will \nrarel\n... [truncated, 4199 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/410 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=410]", "char_count": 4199}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 411, "text_content": "Educating the Architecture \nOn the morning of the second day of the meeting, we addressed the problem of how to supply the \narchitecture with a broad range of commonsense knowledge, so that it would not have to \"start from \nscratch.\" We all agreed that learning was of value, but we didn't all agree on where to start. Many \nresearchers would like to start with nothing: however, Aaron Sloman pointed out that an architecture that \ncomes with no knowledge is like a programming language that comes with no programs or libraries. \nOne view that was expressed was that approaches that start out with too little initial knowledge would \nlikely not achieve enough versatility in any practical length of time. Minsky criticized the increasing \npopularity of the concept of a \"baby machine--learning systems designed to achieve great competence, \ngiven very little initial structure. Some of these ideas include genetic programming, robots that learn by \nassociating sensory-motor patterns, and online chatbots that try to learn language by generalizing from \nthousands of conversations. Minsky's complaint was that the problem is not that the concept of a baby \nmachine is itself unsound, but rather that we don't know how to do it yet. Such approaches have all failed to \nmake much progress because they started out with inadequate schemes for learning new things. You cannot \nteach algebra to a cat; among other things, human infants are already equipped with architectural features to \nequip them to think about the causes of their successes and failures and then to make appropriate changes. \nToday we do not yet have enough ideas about how to represent, organize, and use much of commonsense \nknowledge, let alone build a machine that could learn all of that automatically on its own. As John \nMcCarthy noted long ago: \"in order for a program to be capable of learning something, it must first be able \nto represent that knowledge.\" \nThere are very few general-purpose commonsense knowledge resources\n... [truncated, 5048 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/411 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=411]", "char_count": 5048}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 412, "text_content": "An Important Application \nSeveral of the participants felt that such a project would not receive substantial support unless it \nproposed an application that clearly would benefit much of the world. Not just an improvement to \nsomething existing, it would need to be one that could not be built without being capable of human-level \ncommonsense reasoning. \nAfter a good deal of argument, several participants converged upon a vision from The Diamond Age, \na novel by Nell Stephenson. That novel envisioned an \"intelligent book\"--The Young Ladies Illustrated \nPrimer--that, when given to a young girl, would immediately bond with her and come to understand her so \nwell as to become a powerful personal tutor and mentor. \nThis suggested that we could try to build a personalized teaching machine that would adapt itself to \nsomeone's particular circumstances, difficulties, and needs. The system would carry out a conversation with \nyou, to help you understand a problem or achieve some goal. You could discuss with it such subjects as \nhow to choose a house or car, how to learn to play a game or get better at some subject, how to decide \nwhether to go to the doctor, and so forth. It would help you by telling you what to read, stepping you \nthrough solutions, and teaching you about the subject in other ways it found to be effective for you. \nTextbooks then could be replaced by systems that know how to explain ideas to you in particular, because \nthey would know your background, your skills, and how you best learn. \nThis kind of application could form the basis for a completely new way to interact with computers, \none that bypasses the complexities and limitations of current operating systems. It would use common \nsense in many different ways: (I) It would understand human goals so that it could avoid the silliest \nmistakes. (2) It would understand human reasoning so that it could present you with the right level of detail \nand avoid saying things that you probably interred. (3) It wo\n... [truncated, 4376 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/412 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=412]", "char_count": 4376}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 413, "text_content": "A Collaborative Project? \nAt the end of the meeting, we brainstormed about how we might organize a distributed, collaborative \nproject to build an architecture based on the ideas discussed at this meeting. It is a difficult challenge, both \ntechnically and socially, to get a community of researchers to work on a common project. However. \nsuccesses in the Open Source community show that such distributed projects are feasible when the \ncomponents can be reasonably disassociated. \nFurthermore, this kind of architecture itself should help to make it easy for members of the project to \nadd new types of representations and processes. However, we first would have to develop a set of protocols \nto support the interoperation of such a diverse array of methods. Erik Mueller suggested that such an \norganization could be modeled after the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), and its job would largely be \nto assess, standardize and publish the protocols and underlying tools that such a distributed effort would \ndemand. \nWhile we did not sketch a detailed plan for how to proceed, Aaron Sloman, Erik Mueller and Push \nSingh listed some technical steps that such a project would need: \nFirst, it should not be too hard to develop a suitable virtual model world, because the present-day \nvideo game and computer graphics industry has produced most of the required components. These should \nalready include adequate libraries for computer graphics, physics simulation, collision detection, and so \nforth. \nSecond. we need to develop and order the set of miniscenarios that we will use to organize and \nevaluate our progress. This would be a continuous process, as new types of problems will constantly be \nidentified. \nThird, what kinds of protocols could the agents of this cognitive system use to coordinate with each \nother? This would include messages for updating representations, describing goals, identifying impasses, \nrequesting knowledge, and so forth. We would consider the radical proposal to \n... [truncated, 4251 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/413 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=413]", "char_count": 4251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 414, "text_content": "We would like to thank Cecile Dejongh for taking care of the local arrangements, and extend a very \nspecial thanks to \nfor making this meeting happen. This meeting was made possible by the \ngenerous support ofJeffrev &Mehl, \nNote \n(I.) This meeting was held in St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands, on April 14-16, 2002. The meeting \nincluded the following participants: Larry Birnbaum (Northwestern University), Ken Forbus (Northwestern \nUniversity), Ben Kuipers (University of Texas at Austin),,las Lanai (Cycorp), Henry Lieberman \n(Massachusetts Institute of Technology), Henry Minsky ( \nSystems), Marvin Minsky (Massachusetts \nInstitute of Technology), Erik Mueller (IBM T. J. Watson Research Center), Srini Narayanan (University \nof California, Berkeley), Ashwin Ram (Georgia Institute of Technology), Doug Riecken (IBM T. J. Watson \nResearch Center), Roger Schank (Carnegie Mellon University), Mary Shepard (Cycorp), Push Singh \n(Massachusetts Institute of Technology), le \nark \nPurdue\n Aaron Sloman \n(University of Birmingham), Oliver Steele (1111Systems), \n(independent consultant), Vemor \nVinge (San Diego State University), and Michael Witbrock (Cycorp). \nReferences \nBrachman, Ronald; and Lenudos, Zachary 2002. DARPA's New Cognitive Systems Vision. \nComputing Research News, 14(5): I, 8. \nKitano, Hiroaki; Asada, Minoru; Kuniyoshi, Yasuo; Noda, Itsuki; Osawa, Eiichi; and Maisubara, \nHitoshi. 1997. RoboCup: A Challenge problem for Al. AI Magazine, 18( I ):73-85. \nLaird, John; Newell, Allen; and Rosenbloom, Paul 1987. SOAR: An Architecture for General \nIntelligence. AI Journal, 33(1):1.64. \nLenat, Doug. 1995. CYC: A Large-scale Investment in Knowledge Infrastructure. Communications of \nthe ACM, 38(11):33-38. \nMcCarthy, John; Minsky, Marvin; Sloman, Aaron; Gong, Leiguang; Lau, Tessa; Morgenstern, Leona; \nMueller, Erik; Riecken, Doug; Singh, Moninder; and Singh, Push 2002. An Architecture of Diversity for \nCommonsense Reasoning. IBM Systems Journal, 41(3):530-539. \nMinsky, Marvin. (fo\n... [truncated, 4139 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/414 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=414]", "char_count": 4139}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 415, "text_content": "real-world applications. Singh received his B.S. and M.Eng. in electrical engineering and computer science \nfrom MIT. \nAaron Sloman is a professor of AI and cognitive science at the University of Birmingham, UK. He \nreceived his B.Sc. in mathematics and physics (Cape Town, 1956), and a D.Phil. Philosophy, from Oxford \n(1962). Sloman is a Rhodes Scholar, a Fellow of AAAI, AISB, and ECCAI. He is also author of The \nComputer Revolution in Philosophy (1978) and many theoretical papers on vision, diagrammatic \nreasoning, forms of representation, architectures, emotions, consciousness, philosophy of AI, and tools for \nexploring architectures. Sloman maintains the FreePoplog open source web site and is about to embark on a \nlarge EC-funded robotics project. All papers, presentations, and software are accessible from his home \npage: www.cs.bham.ac.uk/ axs/ \nRELATED ARTICLE: Establishing a Collection of Graded Miniscenarios. \nHow would we guide such a project and measure its progress over time? Some participants suggested \ntrying to emulate the abilities of human children at various ages. However, others argued that while this \nshould inspire us, we should not use it as a plan for the project, because we don't really yet know enough \nabout the details of early human mental development. \nAaron Sloman argued that it might be better to try to model the mind of a four- or five-year-old human \nchild because that might lead more directll toward more substantial adult abilities. After the meeting, \nSloman developed the notion of a \"commonsense miniscenario,\" a concrete description in the form of a \nsimple storyboard of a particular skill that a commonsense architecture should be able to demonstrate. Each \nminiscenario has several features: (1) It describes some forms of competence, which are robust insofar as \nthey can cope with wide ranges of variation in the conditions; and (2) each comes with some meta-\ncompetence for thinking and speaking about what was done. For example compet\n... [truncated, 4349 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/415 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=415]", "char_count": 4349}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 416, "text_content": "unpacking, e.g. regarding sensible sequences of actions, things that can go wrong during the construction, \nand how to recover from them, etc.) \n8. As for 7, but the rungs fit only loosely into the holes in the rails. Person assembles the ladder but \nrefines to climb up it, and if asked why can explain why it is unsafe. \n9. Person watching another who is about to climb up the ladder with loose rungs should be able to \nexplain that a calamity could result, that the other might be hurt, and that people don't like being hurt. \nSuch a system should be made to face a substantial library of such graded sequences of mini-scenarios \nthat require it both to learn new skills, to improve its abilities to reflect on them, and (with practice) to \nbecome much more fluent and quick at achieving these tasks. These orderings should be based on such \nfactors as the required complexity of objects, processes, and knowledge involved, the linguistic competence \nrequired, and the understanding of how others think and feel. That library could include all sorts of things \nchildren learn to do in such various contexts as dressing and undressing dolls, coloring in a picture book, \ntaking a bath (or washing a dog), making toys out of Meccano and other construction kits, eating a meal, \nfeeding a baby, cleaning a mess made by spilling some powder or liquid, reading a story and answering \nquestions about it, making up stories, discussing behavior of a naughty person, and learning to think and \ntalk about the past, the future, and about distant places, etc. \nIAC-CREATE-DATE: July 8, 2004 \nLOAD-DATE: July 09, 2004 \nEFTA00226812\n", "char_count": 1624}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 417, "text_content": "301 of 1456 DOCUMENTS \nCopyright 2005 Gale Group, Inc. \nAll Rights Reserved \nASAP \nCopyright 2005 American Academy of Arts and Sciences \nDaedalus \nJune 22, 2005 \nSECTION: Pg. 42(10) Vol. 134 No. 3 ISSN: 0011-5266 \nACC-NO: 135697725 \nLENGTH: 5572 words \nHEADLINE: Compromised work. \nBYLINE: Gardner, Howard \nBODY: \nOne would like to find an abundance of good workers across the professions: teachers who have \nmastered their subject matter. present itwell, and behave in a civil manner toward students and peers; \nphysicians who are knowledgeable about the latest techniques and medications and who cater to the ill no \nmatter where they are encountered and whether die' have resources; lawyers who can argue a case \npersuasivelyand who make their services available to those in need, irrespectiveof their ability to pay. \nOccasionally the impressive achievements ofsuch individuals are publicly honored; and those concerned \nabout thelong-term welfare of the society hope that aspiring teachers, physicians, and lawyers will have \nample exposure to such exemplars of good work. \nNot surprisingly, the absence of good work commands the attention of scholars, journalists, dramatists, \npoliticians, and ordinary folk. We are, perhaps naturally, perhaps understandably, fascinated to learn about \nthe teacher who fails an exam or seduces a student; the physician who fakes her credentials or operates on \nthe wrong patient; thelawyer who skirts the law or only defends the wealthy. As a friend quipped, Time \nWarner might sell more copies if it renamed its venerable business publication Misfortune. \nIn the Good Work Project in which my colleagues and I are involved,we are focusing on those \nindividuals and institutions that aspire toward, and in the happiest case, exemplify, good work. There is \nmuch to be learned from careful study of a journalist like Edward R. Morrow, a physician like Albert \nSchweitzer, a publisher like Katharine Graham, a public servant like John Gardner (no relation). Yet\n... [truncated, 3567 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/417 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=417]", "char_count": 3567}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 418, "text_content": "It is easiest to spot compromised work in professions that have existed for some time and whose \nprincipal values are widely shared. In such domains there should be consensual processes of training, \nrecognized mentors, and established procedures in place for censuring or ostracizing those whose work \nviolates norms of the domain, with disbarment or loss of license as the ultimate sanction. Of the three \nprofessions I will treat in this essay. law is closest to the prototype, journalism is furthest (many journalists \nlack formal training), and accounting is somewhere in between. \nSince our project began (and no doubt long before), the pages of the newspapers have been filled with \nexamples of compromised work; indeed, in preparing this essay I have sometimes been tempted to clip half \nthe stories in the daily newspaper. Here I focus on three cases from recent years that caught both my \nattention and that of the broaderpublic. The first case involves Jayson Blair, an ambitious reporter for The \nNew York Times who was fired after it was discovered he had plagiarized and fabricated stories. The \nsecond case centers on Hill and Barlow, a venerable Boston law fum that closed abruptly when its \nprofitable real estate department announced it was leaving the firm. The third case centers on the flagship \naccounting firm Arthur Andersenthat went bankrupt after the Enron scandal of 2001. \nIn my initial study of compromised work, (2) I chose these cases because they apparently represented \nthree levels of analysis: Jayson Blair as an instance of compromised work by a single, flawed individual; \nHill and Barlow as an instance of compromised work within a singleinstitution; and the Arthur Andersen--\nEnron debacle as an instance of compromised work throughout a profession. My study revealed, however, \nsurprising continuities across these three apparently distinct levels of analysis. In each case. I found I was \nstudying individuals as well as institutions, and, indeed, an entire i\n... [truncated, 5225 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/418 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=418]", "char_count": 5225}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 419, "text_content": "To be sure, Blair had been a bad egg whose misbehaviors were more flagrant than those of his \ncontemporaries. But at least since publisher Arthur Sulzberger had appointed Raines as managing editor in \n2001,a strong set of explicit and implicit signals had been sent to the Times staff. Reporters were told they \nhad to increase the \"competitivemetabolism\" of the news coverage. Those who wrote flashy, trendy stories \nwere rewarded with promotions, special privileges, and ample front-page coverage. In contrast, reporters \nwho took a more thoughtful, less sensational approach, who emphasized the journalistic precept \nofcarefulness, found themselves increasingly marginalized. Nor was this new culture a secret: in a much-\ndiscussed portrait of Raines that appeared in The New Yorker in June of 2002, the changing milieu at \ntheTimes was detailed and critiqued. \nHad Jayson Blair been a truly isolated case, it is highly likely that the Sulzberger-Raines-Boyd \nmanagerial team would have survived intact and perhaps continued its questionably hectic pace and \nexcessively dramatic bent. Once the Blair case broke, however, other heroes and casualties soon emerged. \nThe most flagrant consequence was the abrupt resignation of star reporter Rick Bragg, who was accused of \nusing unacknowledged stringers and of embellislitis lengthy and highly evocative stories. While Raines \nand Boyd fought to keep their positions. it was \ninevitable that sooner or later they would be \nsqueezed out. The replacement appointment of Bill Keller, an individual widely considered a contrast in \ntemperament and journalistic values, served as a sign that the Times was rejecting the go-go atmosphere of \nthe previous few years. \nUnder Raines and Boyd, the Times had been engaged in an example ofwhat I will call 'superficial \nalignment' The editors were looking for young reporters who exemplified the pace and coverage they \nsought;the fact that Blair was African American was a bonus and, by the editors' own admiss\n... [truncated, 5252 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/419 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=419]", "char_count": 5252}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 420, "text_content": "thereby in one act destroying a distinguished New England law firm. The shock was compounded by the \nfact that the remaining partners did not even try to reconstitute the firm, but instead interpreted this mass \nexodus as a sign that the firm could no longer survive. \nCloser examination reveals that the problems went back many years,perhaps several decades. Through \nthe middle of the twentieth century, Hill and Barlow did indeed have a deserved reputation as a firm of \noutstanding lawyer statesmen who not only were leaders in litigation and trusts, but who also stood out for \ntheir service to the community. Yet, on my analysis, this sterling reputation turns out to have been a mixed \nblessing. By the 1970s and 1980s, the situation in law had changed dramatically throughout the land. \nWhether lamented or not, the era of the lawyer statesman was over. Law firms were becoming much larger \nand more internationalized; corporate law divisions and the high-metabolism specialty of mergers and \nacquisitions were growing morerapidly than other spheres; many large corporations built up their own in-\nhouse legal teams; and individual lawyers were becoming far more mobile, as opportunities to make very \nlarge salaries materialized for those who were willing to jump ship. \nNone of these trends in itself necessitated a de-professionalization of the law. And indeed, many \nmoderately sized law firms in New England and elsewhere took steps to modulate these trends: they \nincreased in size or developed distinctive niches; they actively sought largecorporate clients; and they \nreconfigured salary schedules to reward those lawyers who brought in the most business. Perhaps most \nimportantly, the more reflective firms realized that law was becoming more ofa business; they recruited or \ntrained professional managers; they were sensitive to the clout of specific partners and divisions; they paid \nclose attention to changing patterns of income and expenses; they established governance vehicl\n... [truncated, 5275 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/420 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=420]", "char_count": 5275}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 421, "text_content": "the amount of consulting business often equaled or even surpassed that dedicated to the monitoring of the \nbooks. In the go-go financial milieu of the 1980s and 1990s, as documented in our Good Work Project and \nmany other sources, markets became increasingly dominant in many spheres of life. Indeed, at the end of \nthe 1990s,1 made a quip that turned out to be uncannily prophetic: \"If markets come to control everything, \nin the end there will be only one profession--accounting. And that is because only the auditors will be able \nto tell us whether the books are on the level or have been cooked.\" \nBut like most of the public, I was unprepared for the huge accounting scandals that captured the \nheadlines at the start of the twenty-first century. Led by the renowned firm Arthur Andersen, all the \nmajorfirms were shown to have abandoned their professional disinterestedness (or 'independence,' as it is \nreferred to in the profession) in flagrant ways. It was no longer unusual for accountants to hold stock in, \nwork for, or consult for the firms they were allegedly monitoring;and for their part, firms went out of their \nway to provide lucrativework and extra perks for the supposedly independent auditors. \nThe smoking gun was the relationship between energy giant Enron and the flagship professional \nservices firm of Arthur Andersen. These rums met powerful sanctions: bankruptcy with possible jail terms \nfor those high-level managers whose involvement crossed the line from compromised to frankly bad work. \nAt the time of this writing, other major accounting firms like Ernst and Young and \nPricewaterhouseCoopers have also had to pay significant penalties; punitive new regulations and legislation \nhave been put into place; and many other business firms--established ones like General Electric and Xerox, \nnewer ones like Tyco, WorldCom, and Global Crossing--have undergone probes or have even dissolved. \nMean-while, the tacit or demonstrable complicity of members of boards of di\n... [truncated, 5135 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/421 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=421]", "char_count": 5135}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 422, "text_content": "Studies of the Andersen-Enron connection reveal that it had been deeply compromised for years. \nEnron was one of Andersen's largest clients; it paid a total of over fifty million dollars a year to Andersen's \nauditing, consulting, and tax divisions. Employees shuttled back and forth between the two companies with \nsuch ease and frequency that it was sometimes difficult to tell for which they were working; at least eighty \nformer Andersen auditors were working for Enron. The supposed line between the company being audited \nand the auditors evaluating the books of that company had become so blurted that, in effect, itno longer \nexisted. And yet it has proved difficult to demonstrate sheer illegality. This is both because the nature of \nEnron's business was so new and so convoluted, and because so much of the role of the auditor/accountant \nremains an issue of professional judgment rather than of sheer legality or illegality. \nIn my view, the chief embodiment of compromised work in the accounting profession is the condition \nof wearing two hats--hats that inevitably pit key interests against one another. On the one hand, as \nrepresentatives of the public, auditors and their umbrella organizations are supposed to remain at arm's \nlength from the companies they monitor. On the other hand, the excitement and the monetary gains \navailablefor consulting prove irresistibly seductive for many auditors and their umbrella organizations. One \ncannot at the same time offer advice and feedback to companies while standing disinterestedly apart from \ntheir practices: in effect, one has become judge and litigant at the same time. \nIn each of the cases discussed, the background history covered a much longer period than I had \nanticipated. Jayson Blair's case reflected larger-scale trends at the Times, dating back to the 1980s and \nexacerbated by the appointment of a new managerial regime in 2001: Hill and Barlow failed to recognize. \nlet alone adapt to. forces that middle-sized law fi\n... [truncated, 5384 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/422 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=422]", "char_count": 5384}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 423, "text_content": "In each case, superficial features and blandishments obscured the central values of the domain. During \nthe Blair-Raines period at the Times, scrupulous and fair reporting was sacrificed to the \nimmediatelyaccessible and sexy. At Hill and Barlow, the norms of an effective partnership were \nundermined, as lawyers and entire departments went their own selfish way. And sometime in the last few \ndecades, those responsible for the atmosphere of an accounting company forgot that it was supposed to be a \npublic trust. Those on the inside should have seenthese problems and made loud noises, but efforts to right \nthe culture were too weak and ineffective. And so in each case it took a dramatic event--Blait's plagiarism, \nthe real estate department's exodus, the Enron meltdown--to reveal what should have been clearer to those \nonthe outside and clearest to those entrusted with preserving and embodying the values of the domain. \nWhat happens when such a critical point is reached? It is possible, of course, that the domain will \ncontinue to deteriorate, and may come to be replaced altoget er. Newspaper editor Harold Evans has \nquipped, \"The problem many organizations face is not to sta in business but to stay in journalism\" The \ni \nlawyer statesman no longer exists; it remains unclear whether he is being replaced by a viable option, or \nwhether lawyers have just become high-priced free agents or cogs in a corporate legal machine. And if \nthere are too many Enrons and Global Crossings, the Big Five will dwindle to Little Zero--and it is not \nclear whether the books will be monitored in the future by independent accountants, government officials, \nor private investigators. \nIt is also possible that these professions will continue to survive but attract a different type of person \nwith different kinds of values. With few exceptions, for example, broadcast television joumalismexists as \nentertainment rather than as news. Totalitarian countries have bookkeepers, but, as the old joke\n... [truncated, 4403 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/423 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=423]", "char_count": 4403}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 424, "text_content": "270 of 1456 DOCUMENTS \nCopyright 2005 Telegraph Group Limited \nAll Rights Reserved \nThe Daily Telegraph (LONDON) \nNovember 29. 2005 \nSECTION: FEATURES; Science; Pg. 26 \nLENGTH: 1091 words \nHEADLINE: A DIY guide to saving Planet Earth Human survival depends on problem fixing not \navoidance • in particular learning how to cool down our planet, says David Deutsch \nBYLINE: David Deutsch \nBODY: \nLet's start with a couple of ideas that everyone knows. The first - dramatically named Spaceship Earth -\nis that our planet is uniquely suited to us and our survival. The universe outside is implacably hostile; if we \nmess up our spaceship, we have nowhere else to go. The second is that, despite our traditional self-image, \nhuman beings are not the hub of existence: as Stephen Hawking famously put it, we're just a chemical scum \non the surface of a typical planet in orbit around a typical star on the outskirts of a typical galaxy \nEveryone knows these things, yet they are both false. In fact, if you were looking for a pair of truths so \nimportant that it's worth carving them on blocks of stone and reciting them every morning before breakfast, \nyou could do a lot worse than to carve denials of those two ideas \nAre we at a typical place? Most places in the universe are not on a planet, or even in a galaxy. Travel \nright outside the galaxy • say, 100,000 light years - and you still haven't reached a typical place. You will \nhave to go about 1,000 times as far, into deep, intergalactic space, so remote that if the nearest star were to \nexplode as a supernova, it would be too faint to see. It's also very cold, less than three degrees above \nabsolute zero. And it's empty: less than one millionth the density of the highest vacuum that scientists can \ncurrently attain. \nThat is how unlike Earth a typical location is. Yet the two are similar in one remarkable way. \nTake a telescope and gaze even further out than where we've just been, at a \"quasaf. That was \noriginally short for \"quasi-st\n... [truncated, 3493 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/424 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=424]", "char_count": 3493}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 425, "text_content": "But imagine a solar-system-sized cube of intergalactic space. That cube still contains a million tons of \nmatter. Which is more than enough, say, to build a fusion-powered space station complete with scientists \nwho might be collecting evidence to create an open-ended stream of knowledge, just like us - if the right \nknowledge were there to start it off. \nTherefore we are not in a uniquely hospitable place either. If intergalactic space is capable of creating \nan open-ended stream of explanations, then so is almost anywhere. And the limiting factor, both there and \nhere, is not physical resources but knowledge. \nThe Astronomer Royal, Sir Martin Rees, has written a book about our vulnerability to scientific \naccidents, terrorism using weapons of mass destruction and other dangers: he thinks civilisation has only a \n50 per cent chance of surviving this century. But I believe our survival depends not on chance but on \nwhether we can create the relevant knowledge in time. It always has depended on that, and always will. The \nvast majority of all species and all civilisations that have ever existed are now extinct. If we want to be the \nexception, our only hope is to harness the one feature that distinguishes our species and our civilisation \nfrom all others, namely our special relationship with the laws of physics: our ability to create new \nknowledge. \nTake global warming. According to the best available scientific theories, it is too late to avoid a global-\nwarming disaster. For if it's true that our best option is to suppress carbon-dioxide emissions with the Kyoto \nprotocol at a cost of hundreds of billions of pounds, then that's already a disaster by any reasonable \nmeasure. \nAnd those measures aren't even purported to solve the problem, merely to postpone it a little. Most \nlikely it was already too late before anyone even knew about it: in the 1970s, the best available science was \ntelling us that industrial emissions were about to precipitate a new Ice Age that \n... [truncated, 3582 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/425 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=425]", "char_count": 3582}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 426, "text_content": "233 of 1456 DOCUMENTS \nCopyright 2006 Associated Press \nAll Rights Reserved \nThe Associated Press State & Local Wire \nMarch 17, 2006 Friday 11:52 PM GMT \nSECTION: INTERNATIONAL NEWS \nLENGTH: 1513 words \nII EADLINE: A package of news briefs from the Caribbean \nBYLINE: By The Associated Press \nBODY: \nCARIBBEAN: Sugar producers in final push to get more EU aid \nGEORGETOWN, Guyana (AP) The Caribbean will send another team to several European capitals in \na final push to get more aid for the region's sugar industry after large subsidy cuts were imposed in January•, \nan official said Friday. \nRepresentatives from the African, Caribbean and Pacific trade group head to Europe in April, \nfollowing a first group that went in early March seeking extra funds to deal with the EU's 36-percent cut in \nsugar subsidies. \nThe EU for years gave its former colonies in the Caribbean. Africa and the Pacific preferential access \nto its markets and paid high pnces to encourage development. The World Trade Organization said the \nregime was unfair and ordered the bloc to reduce quotas and prices for sugar, as well as for bananas and \ncotton. \nThe EU has earmarked USS47 million ([#x20ac)40 million) in aid for the I8 sugar producing ACP \ncountries in 2006. Caribbean sugar producers argue the reduced compensation is unfair because EU farmers \nwho face the same subsidy cuts were to be compensated US$7.9 billion ([#x20ac)6.5 billion). \nCaribbean sugar producers include Guyana. Jamaica, Belize, Trinidad and Barbados. St. Kitts closed \nits industry after the cuts were first announced and because of rising production costs. \nST. VINCENT: St. Vincent police find bullet that killed PM's press secretary \nKINGSTOWN, St. Vincent (AP) St. Vincent police have recovered the single bullet that killed the \nprime ministers press secretary and have sent it to another Caribbean island for analysis. an official said \nFriday. \nThe bullet was found imbedded in a seat in Glen Jackson's sport utility vehicle, said Be\n... [truncated, 2770 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/426 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=426]", "char_count": 2770}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 427, "text_content": "JAMAICA: Jamaican man charged with killing six family members \nKINGSTON, Jamaica (AP) A man has been charged with killing six family members, including four \nchildren, whose bodies were found along a beach in western Jamaica last month, police said Friday. \nMichael McLean, 38, was charged Thursday with six counts of murder, police said. \nMcLean, the common-law husband of one of the victims, Terry-Anne Mohammed, 42, has been in \ncustody since Feb. 28. He turned himself into police because he said he feared for his life after neighbors \naccused him of the murders. \nMohammed's burnt corpse was found by police about a half-mile a \nthe mutilated body of her \n8-year-old son, Jessie Ogilvie. The bodies of Mohammed's niece, Farika \nMcCool, 27, and two of \nher children were also found on the beach with their throats slashed. \nOne week later, police say McLean led them to a nearby parish where George-McCool's 6-year-old \ndaughter, Jhaid, was buried in a shallow grave. \nThe slayings may be drug-related, said Arthur Martin, assistant commissioner of police. \nThere were a record 1,669 homicides last year in Jamaica, which has recently received the help of \nScotland Yard and London's Metropolitan Police to fight the crime wave. \nHAITI: New U.S. ambassador arrives, takes up post \nPORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti (AP) The United States will provide support to Haiti and work with the \ncountry's recently elected government, the new U.S. ambassador said Friday. \nJanet A. Sanderson, former ambassador to Algeria, also has served at diplomatic missions in Egypt, \nJordan, Israel, Kuwait and Bangladesh. \n\"With the election of a new president, new perspectives now present themselves to Haiti,\" she said \nwhile presenting her credentials to the Haitian government. \"Haitians are looking for a better life. And they \nare ready though impatient to work ardently to succeed.\" \nPresident \nW. Bush nominated the career diplomat to replace James Foley, who left Haiti late \nlast year. \nThe United States is one of \n... [truncated, 3572 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/427 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=427]", "char_count": 3572}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 428, "text_content": "Norman Olson was convicted of four counts of bribery for paying more than USS73,000 \n(11/x2Oac)60,400) in political favors as pan of a scheme uncovered four years ago. \nOlson, president and owner of National School Services, a Chicago-based business that provides \nteacher training and education consultants, said he plans to appeal. \n\"I respect the decision of this court even though I feel that I am innocent of these charges,\" Olson said \nfollowing his sentencing. \nOlson was found guilty of paying bribes to Victor Fajardo, former education secretary from 1994 to \n2000, in exchange for contracts with the department between 1999 and 2000. \nFajardo pleaded guilty in 2002 to extorting some USS4.3 million from contractors doing business with \nhis agency. \nU.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS: Nobel Prize winning physicists debate universe structure in U.S. Virgin \nIslands \nCHARLOTTE AMALIE, U.S. Virgin Islands (AP) Twenty of the worlds top physicists, including \nthree Nobel Prize winners, are meeting in the U.S. Virgin Islands to debate the structure of the universe. \nNobel prize winners Gerardus 't Hooft, David Gross and Frank Wilczek, and experimental and \ntheoretical physics pioneer Stephen Hawking are among the minds that have converged in the island of St. \nThomas to discuss some of physics most puzzling questions, such as the existence of black holes and \nalternate dimensions. \n\"This is a remarkable group, as far as the level of people who are here,\" said Wilczek, who won the \n2004 Nobel Prize in physics with Gross and H. David Politzer for their explanation of the force that binds \nparticles inside the atomic nucleus. \nJeffrey Epstein, a New York money manager whose J. Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation helped \nfinance the six-day conference that began Thursday night, said the U.S. Caribbean territory's natural beauty \nwill help the scientists relax and concentrate. \n\"You work best with friends. The idea is to take them for a walk on the beach. Take them on a \nsubmarine ride,\" he sa\n... [truncated, 3280 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/428 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=428]", "char_count": 3280}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 429, "text_content": "461 of 1456 DOCUMENTS \nCopyright 2004 SOFTLINE INFORMATION, INC. \nEthnic NewsWatch \nForward \nApril 23, 2004 \nSECTION: Vol. CVII: No. 31; Pg. 6 \nSLI.ACC-NO: 0604FWDM 104 000012 \nLENGTH: 936 words \nHEADLINE: Fund Helps Persecuted Scholars Reach Safe Havens \nBYLINE: Popper. Nathaniel \nBODY: \nIn a seemingly different life, Ahmed Subhy Mansour was a scholar at \nCairo's venerated Al-Azhar University. He studied the history of dictatorship \nin Islam and the place of death and paradise in the Koran. But some aspect of \nhis research did not go over well with the authorities, and in 1987 he was \nfired from his position and jailed for two months. \nSince then he has searched for a place to continue his work and his life, \nparticularly after a number of newspapers accused hint of upholding Zionism, a \ncrime punishable by death in Egypt. After 15 years of wandering, last year he \nfinally found a new home -- as a research fellow at Harvard University. \nThe match was made through the Scholar Rescue Fund, started two years ago \nby the Institute of International Education. Since it was created, the rescue \nfund has enabled Mansour and 44 other scholars to escape persecution in their \nhome countries, and -- just as importantly for many of them -- to continue \ntheir scholarly work with a position at an American university. At Harvard, for \nexample. Mansour has pushed ahead with the creation of a center for studying \nand reforming the Wahabi influence on Islamic institutions in America. \nThe rescue fund is not the first such project run by the International \nInstitute of Education, which also sponsors the Fulbright scholarship program. \nDuring the 1930s and 1940s. the institute's Emergency Committee in Aid of \nDisplaced Foreign Scholars helped bring more than 330 scholars, most of them \nJewish, from Nazi Germany to the United States, including such luminaries as \nphilosopher Martin Buber, physicist Enrico Fermi and novelist Thomas Mann. \nDescendents of several of those earlier scholars,\n... [truncated, 2784 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/429 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=429]", "char_count": 2784}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 430, "text_content": "The fund is being revived at a time when many observers are talking about \nglobal antisemitism reaching its highest levels since the 1930s, when the last \nrescue program was in operation. In the program's =rent incarnation, though, \nnone of the 45 scholars who have been rescued are Jewish. \nThe one scholar so far whose work was connected to the Jewish community \nwas a Palestinian scholar, who felt threatened by both Israeli and Palestinian \nofficials for his work analyzing the policy of political assassinations. \n\"He was advocating less violence on both sides, and it made him unpopular \nwith a lot of people.\" according to Robert Quinn, director of the Scholar \nRescue Fund. \nThe rescue fund has little in the way of guaranteed funds to ensure its \nsurvival. The goal of the night was to raise I million for an endowed chair in \nthe name of Ruth Gruber, a 93-year old photojournalist who was on hand to tell \nof her trip to Europe in 1944, when she helped rescue 1.000 Jewish refugees. \nThe Gruber chair is part of a larger effort to create a 10 million \nendowment that is being lefisefugee-turned-millionaire Henry 'mad, along \nwith fellow businessmen \nSoros, Thomas Russo and Jeffrey Epstein. \nWhile the roster of scholars who have been helped suggests that the \nJewish funding for the program does not come out of a narrow ethnic \nself-interest, the scars of Jewish history were evident beneath the surface of \nthe appeals for donations at Kenner's apartment. \nThe guest speaker for the night was Hanna Holborn Gray, who came over \nwith her parents through the 1930s rescue program and went on to become the \nfirst female president of the University of Chicago. \n\"In the 1930s, the German academic world was seen as a model, and one saw \nhow quickly that could vanish,\" Gray recalled. \nAlmost all of the 45 scholars funded in the last two years have hailed \nfrom either African or Muslim-majority countries. Many of them -- including \nMansour and an Iranian scientist who spoke at Kenner's \n... [truncated, 3088 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/430 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=430]", "char_count": 3088}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 431, "text_content": "math-•counting \nattitude--positive \n10 \n9 \n66.6 \n60.0 \nspeech act \n9 \n60.0 \nspace--size \n8 \n53.3 \nspace--grasping \n7 \n46.6 \nsound--speech \n7 \n46.6 \nlogic-•universal \n7 \n46.6 \nquantification \nspace--housing \n6 \n40.0 \nTable 2 Diverse schemes for story understanding \ndomains \nDomain \nRepresentation/Reasoning \nSchemes \nspace \nframe, generalized cylinder model, \ninterval logic, occupancy grid \ntime, action effects \ncausal model, event calculus, \nsituation calculus, transframe \nreactivity \nneural net, production system, \nsubsumption architecture \nschemas, scripts \nfinite automaton, frame, frame-\nAray, generalized Petri net \nsubgoaling \nfirst-order logic, K-line, marker \npassing, semantic net \nemotions, attitudes \nmicroneme. neural net, temporal \nmodal logic \n** Trademark or registered trademark of Cycorp, Inc. \nCited references and notes \n(1.) M. Minsky, The Emotion Machine, Pantheon. New York (forthcoming). Several chapters are on \nline at http://web.media.mit.eduf minsky. \n(2.) The use of reading comprehension tests as a metric for evaluating story understanding systems \nwas previously proposed in L. Hirschman, M. Light, E. Brcck, and J. Burger, \"Deep Read: A Reading \nComprehension System,\" Proceedings of the 37th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational \nLinguistics, College Park, MD, June 1999, Association for Computational Linguistics (1999). \n(3.)1. McCarthy, \"Programs with Common Sense,\" Proceedings of the Symposium on Mechanisation \nof Thought Processes, Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London (1958), pp. 77-84. \nEFTA00226827\n", "char_count": 1565}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 432, "text_content": "(4.) J. McCarthy, \"From Here to Human-Level Intelligence,\" Proceedings of the Fifth International \nConference on Principles of Knowledge Representation and Reasoning (KR'96), Cambridge, MA, \nNovember 1996, Morgan Kaufmann, San Mateo, CA (1996), pp. 640-646. \n(5.) L. Morgenstern, \"A Formal Theory of Multiple Agent Non-monotonic Reasoning,\" Proceedings \nof the Eighth National Conference on Artificial Intelligence, AAAI Press, Menlo Park, CA (1990), pp. 538-\n544. \n(6.) E. M, \n\"The Naive Physics Perplex,\" Al Magazine 19, No. 4, 51-79 (1998). \n(7.) D. Lenat, \"Cyc: A Large-Scale Investment in Knowledge Infrastructure,\" Communications of the \nACM 38, No. 11, 32.38 (1995). \n(8.) More details can be found in E. T. Mueller, \"Story Understanding,\" to appear in Encyclopedia of \nCognitive Science, Nature Publishing Group, London (2002). \n(9.) E. Charniak, Toward a Model of Children's Story Comprehension, Technical Report AITR-266, \nArtificial Intelligence Laboratory, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA (1972). \n(10.) R. C. Schank and R. P. Abelson, Scripts, Plans, Goals, and Understanding, L. Erlbaum \nAssociates, Hillsdale, NJ (1977). \n(II.) R. E. Cullingford, Script Application: Computer Understanding of Newspaper Stories, Technical \nReport YALE/DCS/tr116, Computer Science Department, Yale University, New Haven, CT (1978). \n(12.) R. Wilensky, Understanding Goal-Based Stories, Technical Report YALEIDCSAr140, Computer \nScience Department, Yale University, New Haven, CT (1978). \n(13.) M.G. Dyer, In-Depth Understanding, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (1983). \n(14.) A. Ram, Question-Driven Understanding: An Integrated Theory of Story Understanding, \nMemory, and Learning, Technical Report YALE/DCSitr710, Computer Science Department, Yale \nUniversity, New Haven, CT (1989). \n(15.) C. Dolan, Tensor Manipulation Networks: Connectionist and Symbolic Approaches to \nComprehension, Learning, and Planning, Technical Report 890030, Computer Science Department, \nUniversity of Califor\n... [truncated, 3370 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/432 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=432]", "char_count": 3370}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 433, "text_content": "•I \n• \nThe reactive and deliberative layers differ in that the deliberative layer evolved much later and \nrequires a far more sophisticated long-term memory, as well as symbolic reasoning capabilities using a \nshort-term reusable memory. The meta-management layer may have evolved at a still later time and \nrequires explicit use of concepts referring to states of an information processing architecture. The earliest \norganisms, such as most existing organisms. were totally reactive. Deliberative and meta-management \nlayers evolved later. Adult humans appear to have all three types of processing, which is probably rare \namong other animals. \nOne of the key features that gives H-Cogaff its generality is the fact that different components, instead \nof forming parts of simple pipelines, can concurrently send information of various kinds to arbitrarily many \nother components, allowing a wide varlet' of feedback mechanisms and triggering mechanisms. \nIn story understanding, the meta-management level may control the deliberative level in a number of \nways. \n• If the deliberative level is spending too much time considering certain details and those details are \nnot crucial to the story, the meta-management level will make the deliberative level stop. \n• If the deliberative level is spending too much time on a task that does not relate to the goal of \nreading the story, the meta-management level will make the deliberative level stop. \n• If the deliberative level becomes confused, the meta-management level will tell it to go back and \nreread. The deliberative level may have ruled out a possibility earlier that needs to be reconsidered in light \nof new information. \nMinsky further elaborates the H-Cogaff architecture into the six-level architecture called \"Model Six\" \nshown in Figure 2. (I) At its bottom lies a \"zoo of instinctive subanimals\" built upon ancient, ancestral \nsystems that still maintain our bodies and brains. These include systems for feeding, breathing, heating, \n\n... [truncated, 4435 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/433 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=433]", "char_count": 4435}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 434, "text_content": "certain book, which he would soon bring to her since he had planned to be \nin her neighborhood. Joan thanked him and ended the call. Soon Charles \narrived and gave her the book. \nFollowing are a few of the understandings an adult reader would have after hearing the story. \n• Joan heard a ring. She recognizes it as a telephone bell and feels the need to respond quickly. She \nknows how to use the telephone. \n• She picked up the phone. She is subsequently holding the phone to her car. \n• Charles was answering her question. Charles and Joan are not in the same room. Charles also knows \nhow to use the telephone. \n• He suggested she read a certain book. Joan probably now feels some relief, since she knows where \nto find the knowledge she needs. \n• He had planned to be in her neighborhood. Joan will not be surprised when he arrives, because she \nwill remember that he said he would come. \n• Ile gave her the book. Will she have to give it back? The story does not tell us that. \nThese conclusions are based on reasoning and representations in many realms, as follow. \nThe physical realm. In this realm, give might mean the motion of the book through space. This could \nbe represented as a transframe that starts with Charles's hand holding the book and ends with Joan's hand \ncarrying it. One must know a lot about physical things and how they behave in space and time. \nThe social realm. In this realm, give may signify social acts that can alter the relationships of the \nactors. What were Charles's motives or his attitudes? Clearly, he was not returning a loan. Was he hoping to \ningratiate himself? Or was he just being generous? How will Joan feel about Charles after he gives her the \nbook? One must know a lot about what people arc, and a certain amount about how people work. \nThe dominion realm. Given Charles gave Joan the book, one infers not only that Joan is holding the \nbook, but also that, at least for a time, she possesses the right to use it. \nThe conversational realm. How d\n... [truncated, 3861 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/434 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=434]", "char_count": 3861}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 435, "text_content": "The reflective realm. People know about themselves. One knows to some degree what one can or \ncannot do, what kinds of problems one can solve, how one's thinking and memory works, and what sorts of \nthings one is able to learn. \n.Along with these positive kinds of knowledge, one also has negative knowledge about what might go \nwrong when using a phone. One must know what to do if one gets a wrong number, if there is no answer, \nor if a modem or intercept recording is reached. \nExample system with architecture of diversity. Thus far, the Sloman and Minsky architectures arc \ntheoretical constructs and have not yet been implemented. However, there are examples of working \nsystems that capture the spirit of such architectures. One such example is the NI system depicted in Figure \n4. (29) M integrates multiple reasoning processes and representations to serve as an assistant to a user \ncollaborating with other workers within a virtual meeting room that hosts multimedia desktop \nconferencing. NI serves to recognize and classify the actions performed by the participants as well as the \nobjects upon which the actions arc applied; example actions and objects are brainstorming on a whiteboard, \ncoauthoring a document, and creating and working with other artifacts. \n[FIGURE 4 OMITTED] \nNext steps \nThe two recent meetings held in March 2002 at the IBM Thomas J. Watson Research Center and in \nApril 2002 on St. Thomas indicate that there is a dedicated group of recognized researchers interested in \nworking together on a project to develop a solution to commonsense reasoning. We are now planning to \nundertake some of the next steps in a plan for such a project. The inspiration for this work comes from \nMinsky's past and forthcoming work. We close with his thoughts on how such a project might be realized, \nas follows. \nOur goal is to aim toward a critical \"change of phase\" that will come when we cross a threshold at \nwhich our systems know how to improve themselves. This is somethin\n... [truncated, 3639 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/435 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=435]", "char_count": 3639}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 436, "text_content": "606 of 1456 DOCUMENTS \nCopyright 2002 Gale Group, Inc. \nASAP \nCopyright 2002 All Rights Reserved. \nIBM Systems Journal \nSeptember 1, 2002 \nSECTION: No. 3, Vol. 41; Pg. 530; ISSN: 0018-8670 \nIAC-ACC-NO: 91469723 \nLENGTH: 6160 words \nHEADLINE: An architecture of diversity for commonsense reasoning; Technical forum. \nBYLINE: McCarthy, J.; Minsky, M.; Sloman, A.; Gong, L.; Lau, T.; Morgenstern, L.; Mueller, E.T.; \nRiecken, D.; Singh, M.; Singh, P. \nBODY: \nAlthough computers excel at certain bounded tasks that are difficult for humans, such as solving \nintegrals, they have difficulty performing commonsense tasks that are easy for humans, such as \nunderstanding stories. In this Technical Forum contribution, we discuss commonsense reasoning and what \nmakes it difficult for computers. We contend that commonsense reasoning is too hard a problem to solve \nusing any single artificial intelligence technique. We propose a multilevel architecture consisting of diverse \nreasoning and representation techniques that collaborate and reflect in order to allow the best techniques to \nbe used for the many situations that arise in commonsense reasoning. We present story understanding--\nspecifically, understanding and answering questions about progressively harder children's texts--as a task \nfor evaluating and scaling up a commonsense reasoning system. \nIn the fall of 2001, a proposal was developed by Marvin Minsky, Erik Mueller, Doug Riecken, Push \nSingh, Aaron Sloman, and Oliver Steele for a project to develop a human-level commonsense reasoning \nsystem. The basic proposal was (1) to develop certain ideas of Minsky and Sloman about a multilevel \ncognitive architecture, and (2) to develop the system in a way that would exploit many existing artificial \nintelligence techniques for commonsense reasoning and knowledge representation, such as case-based \nreasoning, logic, neural nets, genetic algorithms, and heuristic search. \nWe proposed to organize a meeting at which we would bring togeth\n... [truncated, 3511 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/436 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=436]", "char_count": 3511}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 437, "text_content": "Second, there was consensus that the story understanding task provides a strong testbed for evaluating \na commonsense reasoning system. Not only dots such a system need several different forms of reasoning, \nrepresentation, and learning, but it also needs them to work in conjunction with each other. In addition, the \ntask highlights the importance of using and reasoning with common sense. This is illustrated by a sentence \nfrom a story about a child and her grandfather: \"He gently takes my elbow as we walk so that I can help \nshow him the path.\" Knowledge of the fact that the grandfather is blind, and the commonsense facts that \npeople ordinarily use their sight to find paths and that blind people are unable to see, enable the inference \nthat the child is guiding the grandfather and not merely pointing out the path, another frequent sense of the \nword \"show.\" Absence of this commonsense knowledge could lead to the incorrect interpretation of the \nword \"show.\" \nThird, there was agreement on the need to develop a testbed architecture for representation and \nreasoning that allows different systems and representations to work with each other. Researchers often try \nto solve a problem using just one form of representation and reasoning. But such an approach does not \nwork well for sufficiently complex problems such as story understanding. In contrast, enabling various \ntechniques to collaborate will allow the best techniques to be used for a given situation. Any such \narchitecture must provide metalevel control and knowledge that will enable different techniques to \ndetermine whether or not they are suited for a given task, to decide what other techniques may be better for \nthe task, and to communicate information and share partial results with each other. \nWhat makes commonsense reasoning difficult \nCommonsense reasoning--the sort of reasoning we would expect a child to do easily--is difficult for \ncomputers to do. Certainly, the relative paucity of results in this fiel\n... [truncated, 4962 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/437 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=437]", "char_count": 4962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 438, "text_content": "questions about the story, (2) producing paraphrases and summaries of the story, and (3) integrating the \ninformation the story contains into a database. Further, useful results from this work will have a direct \nimpact on many business products and services. \nA brief history of story understanding systems. Starting in the 1960s, (8) researchers have studied \nstory• understanding and have built systems that can read and answer questions about simple stories. An \nearly system built by Chamiak (9) used a single mechanism, test-action demons, for making inferences in \nunderstanding. In the 1970s, Schank and Abelson (10) proposed scripts, plans, and goals as knowledge \nstructures for understanding. These knowledge structures were incorporated into the SAM (I I and PAM \n(12) story understanding systems. \nIn the 1980s. knowledge structures for emotions, story themes, and spatial/temporal maps were \nincorporated into BORIS. (13) AQUA (14) used case-based reasoning to retrieve and apply explanation \npatterns in order to answer questions raised by anomalies encountered while reading a story. CRAM (15) \nused a connectionist approach to story understanding. \nRecent story understanding systems have adopted the approach of understanding a story by building \nand maintaining a simulation that models the mental and physical states and events described in the story, \nas demonstrated in ThoughtTreasure. (16) The advantage of this approach is that it is easy to answer \nquestions about the story simply by examining the contents of the simulation. \nCntical problems for story understanding systems. The story understanding systems built so far work \nonly on the particular stories they are designed to handle. For example, SAM (I I) handles five stories, \nBORIS (13) three, AQUA (14) five, and ThoughtTreasure (16) three. What prevents story understanding \nsystems from scaling up to hundreds of previously unseen stories? \nWe contend that story understanding research is blocked on three critic\n... [truncated, 4625 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/438 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=438]", "char_count": 4625}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 439, "text_content": "Text annotation for domain identification. We cannot hope to deal with the commonsense informatic \nsituation head-on. The point of icCarthy's 1996 paper (4) 's that any domain can be relevant to a particular \nproblem: when reading a story, any area of knowledge ma be necessary for comprehension. This is less \ntrue for stories designed for very young readers: although, as our examples above show, a great many \nconcepts and domains arc still needed for full comprehension even of early reader texts. Nevertheless, we \nbelieve we can make progress by choosing to address those domains that most frequently turn up in \nchildren's stories. Such an approach would, we hope, make the problem tractable. \nWe thus propose the following corpus-based approach. We start with a corpus of stories at the \npreschool and kindergarten levels and divide the corpus into a development set and a test set. We manually \nannotate each story in the development set with an informal inventory of what domains of commonsense \nknowledge and reasoning must be addressed in order to understand the story. We sort the domains by their \nfrequency and attempt to develop methods to understand the domains that occur most frequently. We start \nwith the most frequent domain, proceeding to the next most frequent domain, and so forth. Development \nproceeds on the development set, and a final evaluation of the generality of the system is conducted on the \npreviously unseen test set. Wc iterate this process on successively higher reading levels, progressing to \nstories designed for Grades I, 2, and 3. This approach, based on an incremental series of experiments, will \nenable a significant research focus at each step on an architecture of diversity. \nTo demonstrate how this approach would work, we formed a corpus of 15 early reader stories and \nannotated them as to the domains of common sense necessary for understanding them. The vocabulary size \nwas 561 words. The top 10 domains of common sense arc shown in Table I. \n... [truncated, 4773 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/439 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=439]", "char_count": 4773}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 440, "text_content": "543 of 1456 DOCUMENTS \nCopyright 2003 The Financial Times Limited \nFinancial Times (London,England) \nAugust 20, 2003 Wednesday \nLondon Edition I \nSECTION: BACK PAGE - FIRST SECTION; Pg. 18 \nLENGTH: 7'48 words \nHEADLINE.: Wall Street spearheads push to secure academic freedom: A scheme that began in the 1930s, \nand helped physicist Felix Bloch and writer Thomas Mann, seeks a Dollars 10m revival. Gary Silverman \nreports \nBYLLNE: By GARY SILVERMAN \nBODY: \nAbout a year and a half ago, a small circle of wealthy investors collected Dollars 2m (Pounds I.2m) to \nconduct a novel experiment on the extent of global academic freedom. \nThe group, which included \nSoros, Henry Jarecki and Jeffrey Epstein established a fund to \nhelp scholars escape threats in their ome countries and find teaching work elsewhere. The donors made \ntheir offer in the spirit of the movie, Field of Dreams, which held that \"if you build it, they will come'. Still, \nthey were stunned by the response. \nAbout 300 academics from 65 countries sought help from the Scholar Rescue Fund, which is being \nadministered by the non-profit Institute of International Education. \nMany of the threats to scholars came from likely suspects - African warlords, Colombian drug \ntraffickers, terrorists and religious fundamentalists. But the organisers were also struck by the heartbreaking \nsingularity of so many of the cases. \nA marine biologist in a former republic of the Soviet Union angered government officials by studying \nlocal shellfish populations. An African academic was threatened after discovering that funds had been \nstolen from a university library. One western European government even sought help for a local scholar \nwho was threatened by a separatist movement. \n\"The overwhelming majority of cases involve people who haven't taken sides.\" said Allan Goodman, \nIIE president and chief executive. \n\"They just happened to be scholars who are teaching in the wrong field, or they happened to be from \nthe wrong ethnic group\n... [truncated, 2884 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/440 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=440]", "char_count": 2884}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 441, "text_content": "The fund arranges for the scholars to get teaching positions, providing annual stipends of up to Dollars \n20,000 to smooth the transition. \nThe IIE's role in helping intellectuals is not a new role as it started in the 1930s and was led by Edward \nR. Murrow, an IIE assistant director and later a legendary CBS reporter. Among those it helped were Felix \nBloch, the physicist, theologians Martin Buber and Paul \nTillich, Thomas Mann. the novelist, and philosopher Herbert Marcuse. \nThe latest effort to rescue scholars bears the imprint of Wall Street. Tom Russo, a Lehman Brothers \n,vice-chairman and an LIE trustee, has been a prime mover in the project. He helped recruit the donors and \ndefine the rationale for the rescue work. For Mr Russo, academic freedom is like market transparency - a \n\"source of light\" that keeps society functioning smoothly. \nDeciding on which requests should receive help has been a job worthy of Solomon. The fund has heard \nfrom scholars who live in dangerous places but face no particular threat as individuals - a requirement for \nreceiving help. Mr Goodman says this is often the case in places such as Israel's occupied territories, \nalthough the LIE has made one rescue there. \nDr Jarecki, a psychiatrist who made a fortune in bullion dealing and other ventures, said the fund is \nalso trying hard to avoid contributing to a \"brain drain\" of academic talent in developing countries. Many of \nthe applicants face threats to their security, but others simply want to move for economic reasons. \nHowever, the organisers say they are trying to resist the temptation of being too cautious in their work. \nHe says he frequently brings up the example of a 1938 conference in Evian, France, that was held to \ndiscuss the resettlement of German and Austrian Jews. The Dominican Republic agreed to accept between \n50,000 and 100,000 Jews. But by the time the \"proper\" arrangements were made, a world war was raging \nand it was too late to do much good. \nIn this case, Dr \n... [truncated, 2182 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/441 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=441]", "char_count": 2182}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 442, "text_content": "Page 2 \n581 of 1456 DOCUMENTS \nCopyright 2003 Associated Press \nAll Rights Reserved \nThe Associated Press State & Local Wire \nFebruary 7, 2003, Friday, BC cycle \nSECTION: State and Regional \nLENGTH: 200 words \nHEADLINE: Financier pledges S30 million to support Harvard researcher \nDATELINE: CA4BRIDGE, Mass. \nBODY: \nReclusive financier Jeffrey Epstein has pledged up to S30 million to Harvard University to support a \nnewly recruited professor's research in the field of mathematical biology. \nA spokeswoman for Harvard president \nH. Summers confirmed Friday that Epstein's \ncontribution will support the research of Martin A. owak, who is scheduled to join the Harvard faculty on \nJuly 1. \nEpstein, who reportedly manages billions of dollars from his private island in the Caribbean, already \nmade a donation and plans to eventually establish a 530 million endowment to support Nowak's research, \nspokeswoman Lucie McNeil said. She did not specify how much he has already given. \nNowak, 36. currently a professor at Princeton's Institute of Advanced Study, uses advanced \nmathematics to model human behavior and to study evolutionary theory, viruses and cancers. He was \nrecruited to Harvard as part of Summers' commitment to grant tenure to young professors and those who do \ninterdisciplinary research. \nThe self-educated Epstein is both a longtime Harvard contributor and a benefactor of Nowak, to whom \nhe previously donated $500,000, the Harvard Crimson student newspaper reported. \nLOAD-DATE: February 8, 2003 \nEFTA00226838\n", "char_count": 1531}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 443, "text_content": "(26.) A. Sloman, \"Architectural Requirements for Human-Like Agents both Natural and Artificial,\" K. \nDautenhahn, Editor, Human Cognition and Social Agent Technology, John Benjamins, Amsterdam (2000), \npp. 163-195. \n(27.) M. Minsky, \"Common Sense-Based Interfaces,\" Communications of the ACM 43, No. 8, 67-73 \n(2001). \n(28.) M. Minsky, \"A Framework for Representing Knowledge,\" Al Laboratory Memo 306, Artificial \nIntelligence LabonaMassachusetts Institute of Technology (1974), reprinted in The Psychology of \nComputer Vision, \nWinston, Editor, McGraw-Hill. New York (1975). \n(29.) D. Riecken, \"An Architecture of Integrated Agents,\" Communications of the ACM 37, No. 7, \n107.116 (1994). \nAccepted for publication May 17, 2002. \nJ. McCarthy \nStanford University \nStanford, California \nM. Minsky \nMassachusetts Institute of Technology \nCambridge, Massachusetts \nA. Sloman \nUniversity of Birmingham \nBirmingham, UK \nL. Gong \nIBM Research Division \nHawthorne, New York \nT. Lau \nIBM Research Division \nHawthorne, New York \nL. Morgenstern \nIBM Research Division \nHawthorne, New York \nE. T. Mueller \nIBM Research Division \nHawthorne, New York \nEFTA00226839\n", "char_count": 1151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 444, "text_content": "el \n• \nD. Riecken \nIBM Research Division \nHawthorne, New York \nM. Singh \nIBM Research Division \nHawthorne, New York \nP. Singh \nMassachusetts Institute of Technology \nCambridge, Massachusetts \nIAC-CREATE-DATE: September 26, 2003 \nLOAD-DATE: October 07, 2003 \nEFTA00226840\n", "char_count": 271}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 445, "text_content": "11:00aa \nFron-Fowler-Vhi le Burnett \n67/16/2007 09:46 \n3053582006 \nRoy BLACK \nHOWARD M. aRtneadCR \nBO= A. KOlitiatud \nLean A. Swan \nKau Ntva \nJAcest Ptneux \nMARX A.J. SHAPIRO \nJARED Loin \n305709320) \nBLACK SREB & KORN \nBLACK \nSREBNICK \nKORNSPAN \n&STUMPF \n=PA  = \nJuly 13, 2007 \nVIA IFAC6114772 15611802.1787 AND U.B. inn \nAssistant \nzu \ns Attorney \nOffice of the United States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \n500 South Australian Avenue, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nRe: \nGrand Jury Subpoena - William Riley \nDear \n1-151 \nP 002/00e \nF-Eise \nPAGE \n82 \nattain= Et: \nJantcA Mesta-\nKAnattrr P. PHILlaa \nAARON A/MION \nMutes BUTCH. JR. \nMArnaW P. OBRivr \nE-Mail: REttocagytovillack.com \nI represent Jeffrey Epstein, the target of a pending Grand July investigation. \nPrior to the initiation of this federal investigation, I represented Mr. Epstein on a \nPalm Beach Florida State Attorneys Office investigation and subsequently an \nInformation, the factual basis of which is identical to, and gave rise to, the federal \ninvestigation presently underway. \nIn connection with my earlier representation of Mr. Epstein, I hired Mr. \nWilliam Riley as a private investigator to act under my direction in anticipation of \ndefending Mr. Epstein against possible criminal charges and any litigation which \nmay have followed. All his investigations were done as my agent and thus are \ncovered by the work product privilege, and all communications to him arc \nprotected by the attorney client privilege. \nThough we are not conceding the existence of any computers that would be \n4k \n2\n All, \nresponsive to the subpoena served upon Mr. Riley, to the extent there are any \nsuch computers, they would contain documents that are privileged attorney-client / \n7CL.;>.1 \ncommunications and attorney work-product. Your subpoena also asks fo -e\n(  ). \n, \n) e \nmaterials describing the scope of hia investigation and thus they are our work \nj \nr \n--/ \nproduct.  \n \n. \n20i S. Biscayne Boulevard. Suite i300\n... [truncated, 2141 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/445 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=445]", "char_count": 2141}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 446, "text_content": "JJI-I6-07 \n11:0lan \nFror-Forloi-White Burnett \n305/899201 \n07/16/2007 09:46 \n3053582006 \nBLACg SREB 2, WORN \nT-I51 \nP 003/004 1819 \nPAGE \ne3 \nAs you know, the United States Attorneys Office Manual Guidelines for \nIssuing Grand Jury and Thal Sub-poi-has to-Attorneya for Information Relating to \nthe Representation of Clients, requires that the attorney client and work-product \nprivilleged information sought by the Grand Jury subpoena issued to Mr. Riley \nmust first be authorized by the Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal \nDivision before it may issue. \nTherefore, please Ovise me as to whether the applicable sections of the \nUnited States Attorneys Office Manual was complied with priori° the issuance, \nof the Grand Jury subpoena to Mr. Riley. Please also advise as to the preliminarY \nsteps taken in advance of the issuance of the subpoena, as required by the \nManual. Finally, please provide me with the name of the Assistant Attorney \nGeneral of the Criminal Division who undertook the evaluation of the request for \nthe Grand Jury subpoena, as required by the same section of the Manual and, if \nan evaluation was made, the basis upon which the Assistant determined that the \ninformation sought in the subpoena was not protected by a valid claim of privilege. \nRS/tog \nSincerely, \nR r Black \nBlack SrebrUck. Komspan & Stumpf. P.A \n11/4) QIV) \nCase No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nP-011926 \nEFTA00226842\n", "char_count": 1412}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 447, "text_content": "LAW OF-FMCS O. \nB. LEncourrr, P.G. \n♦ PROFESSIONµ CORPORATION \nCAST 78'\" STIIEET \nNEW \n. NEW YOlltooet \nGERALD U. LEI- COURT \n101071.2414)(COPRIEW corn \nSHERYL E. REICH \nmichalleBourIlso art \nRENATO C. STABILE \n0 2,4013 4ekourtIrs corn \nFAITH A. FRIEDMAN \n1100dITIPATIPIEOWtlawcom \nBY HAND \nDear Mr. Mcnchcl: \nJuly 25. 2007 \nJeffrey Epstein \nTELEPHONE \n12.217370400 \nEAESINI-E \n(212)988.8102 \nWe have previously provided you with a memo as to why we believe no charge under I8 \nU.S.C. §2422(b) could or should be brought against Jeffrey Epstein, even assuming the specific \nconduct that you have alleged actually occurred. In that memo, we detailed Congress's intent in \nenacting this statute. We also posited that the languSe statute would have to be stretched \nbeyond recognition to fit the particular facts of Mr. \ncase.t Enclosed is data that strongly \nsupports the arguments we previously made. We have thoroughly analyzed every prosecution \nbrought under the statute for which data could be obtained. Based on that analysis, we submit \nthat the prosecutions actually brought under the statute overwhelmingly confirm the limits to \nprosecution we have previously identified.2\nI For several months, we have also been consulting on this matter with Stephanie Thacker, former \nPrincipal Deputy Chief, Department of Justice, Child Exploitation & Obscenity Section. Ms. Thacker \nsupports our position without reservation that this is not a matter upon which the federal statues should \nbe brought to bear. Ms. Thacker would also welcome any questions or concerns you would like to raise \nwith her. \n2 Please note that the enclosed chart amends the one provided to you earlier this week by adding \nadditional details recently located. \nExhibit 35 \nEFTA00226843\n", "char_count": 1760}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 448, "text_content": "1/4.1 2. \n5, 2007 LeCCouri 4 DerSkuivii-E. \nl's 1-4-e. \nEFTA00226844\n", "char_count": 69}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 449, "text_content": "LAW OFfICCli or \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT., PC. \nFor example, of the 184 prosecutions in which at least one count alleges a violation of \n§2422(b), in the overwhelming majority of those cases — 160, or over 85% -- the \"means\" of \ninterstate communication was the Internet and involved the classic \"Internet trolling\" — far \ndifferent from the behavior alleged here. Of that subset, the vast majority — 113 -- were \"sting\" \noperations involving \"children\" (actually, agents) said to be between 2 and 14 years of age. The \ngovernment in each of those instances took every precaution to verify that the defendant's actions \nwere undertaken \"knowingly\". To the extent we can determine the facts, it appears that prior to a \ncase being brought, in each instance multiple explicit (and recorded) conversations were had, so \nthere could be no question as to when the inducement was attempted, whether the inducement \nwas of explicit unlawful sexual activity, or what the defendant's belief was as to the age of the \nvictim. Again, this has no applicability to the facts alleged here. \nThe data is informative in other ways, as well. Though there are a handful of cases in \nwhich the telephone is one of a multiple of means of interstate communications allegedly used, in \nonly two such cases, both far different from the facts here,3 was the use of the telephone the sole \nmeans of the wrongdoing alleged. In the remaining telephone cases, the §2422(b) count is only \none of several amongst various charges of possession of child pornography, violence, and the \nlike. \nThe data from the chart also establish that in the vast majority of the cases brought, no \nsexual activity was actually consummated. That confirms that prosecutions under §2422(b) are \nfocused on protecting the federal interest in preventing the means of interstate communication \nfrom being used to commit crimes, particularly with respect to activities that are traditionally \ndifficult for the state to prosecute. A prosecution predicated on\n... [truncated, 2815 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/449 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=449]", "char_count": 2815}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 450, "text_content": "LAW Of IICZ• or \nGERALD B. LEPCOUET. PC. \nspoke directly or indirectly to women who were under 18. As the message books taken \n(unlawfully, in our view) during the search of Mr. Epstein's home clearly show, many women \ninitiated the interactions by repeatedly calling to schedule massages. If the calls on which the \ngovernment might seek to rely were merely \"return\" calls, certainly any alleged \"inducement\" \nwould be far from unambiguous. And of course, the woman who called would have to have been \nknown by Mr. Epstein to be under 18, and further, Mr. Epstein would have to have known and \nintended that a specific sexual activity unlawful under Florida law was being induced. \nThus, contrary to there being unambiguous proof of the required elements of a §2422(b) \nviolation in this case, at least the following defects exist: \nFirst, it is hardly the case that every massage resulted in sexual activity. Thus, merely \nbecause there was a telephone call, even one that might have \"induced\" a massage (which we \ndispute), such telephone call is not tantamount to the use of a telephone in violation of the \nstatute. \nSecond, even where a particular massage involved masturbation by Mr. Epstein or the \ntouching of a woman, we dispute that any such conduct is a violation of any applicable Florida \nlaw. \nW \nfocused on the evidence which reflects the sworn statement of, for \nexample, \n, who told state investigators that she was asked to find women between \n18 and 20 who wo \nprovide Mr. Epstein with topless massages and which sometimes involved \ntheir being touched. Fla. Stat. Ann. §796.07, a general statute which proscribes \"prostitution\" \nand \"lewdness\", regardless of whether an adult or minor is involved, is of very limited \napplicability here. That statute's definition of \"prostitution\" excludes conduct of which there \nmay be evidence, specifically, a man masturbating himself while touching the breasts of another. \nSection 796.07(I)(a) defines \"prostitution\" as the giving or recei\n... [truncated, 2500 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/450 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=450]", "char_count": 2500}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 451, "text_content": "LAW orriccs \nor \nGERALD B. LEECOURT. PC. \nWe are, of course, mindful of the fact that, unbeknownst to Mr. Epstein, some of the \nwomen were in fact not yet 18. It is certainly not clear that any state statutes were violated by \nMr. Epstein's conduct with any of these women, either. Florida law criminalizes relatively little \nsexual activity with persons between the ages of 16 and 18. For example, it is not a violation of \nthe laws regulating sexual activity to receive a massage from a person between 16 and 18 who is \ntopless or even naked. See Fla. Stat. Ann. §800.04 (lewd and lascivious conduct with a child \nbetween the age of 16 and 18). Nor does that statute make it a crime to touch the breasts or \nother private areas of someone between 16 and 18. Id And, of course, even if a state crime was \ncommitted, which we surely do not concede, that does not make out a federal crime, unless it \ncould be proven that the defendant knowingly induced an illegal act over the telephone. \nMoreover, at best, the proof would show that only a small minority of massages resulted \nin what may possibly be characterized as sexual activity with a woman under the age of 18. But \neven where a massage involved sexual activity with a woman under 18, to the extent Mr. Epstein \ndid not know the woman was under 18, or the telephone call did not induce the activity, or Mr. \nEpstein did not intend the sexual activity at the time the telephone call arranging the massage, or \nthe person arranging the massage did not intend the sexual activity, there would be multiple \nadditional barriers to a successful prosecution. \nFurther, putting aside whether there is sufficient proof that Mr. Epstein knew (and not \nmerely that he \"should have\" surmised) that any of the women were in fact under 18, the set of \nfacts hypothesized above has never before provided a legally sufficient predicate for a \nprosecution under §2422(b) - or under any other federal statute. \nThe enclosed chart clearly and compellingly demon\n... [truncated, 2550 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00226396/451 or ?id=EFTA00226396&page=451]", "char_count": 2550}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00226396", "page_number": 452, "text_content": "LAW OrriCCS or \nGERALD B. LEFCOURT, P.C. \nTo our knowledge, the current investigation lacks any direct (or even circumstantial) \nproof that an inducement was made by Mr. Epstein during the pivotal communication that is at \nthe very heart of any potential §2422(b) charge. Even if the government contends that Mr. \nEpstein induced unlawful sexual activity at some point, face to face, after a telephone call, the \nseparation of the communication and the inducement takes Mr. Epstein's alleged misconduct \noutside the ambit of federal prosecution. It would be unprecedented (and unprincipled), as the \nchart demonstrates, to prosecute Mr. Epstein under §2422(b) absent proof beyond a reasonable \ndoubt both that he knew the age of the person and that he intended in that communication to \ninduce sexual activity that is unlawful under Florida law. It would also be unprecedented to \nprosecute Mr. Epstein under §2422(b) based on a telephone call made by a third party without \ndirect proof that Mr. Epstein intended that telephone call to induce unlawful sexual activity. \nFor all of these reasons, as well as those asserted at the meeting of June 26 and in our \nfollow up letter dated July 6, 2007, as well as our earlier letter of June 25, we submit that no \ncharge under 18 U.S.C. §2422(b) can be brought. If you have any questions or would like to \ndiscuss this further, we are available. \nVery truly yours, \na\ng-dtn` -2  111 \nTh OlottotiZ,\nAlan M. Dershowitz \ncc: Lilly Ann Sanchez, Esq. \nEFTA00226848\n", "char_count": 1505}]}