{"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_count": 10, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00222778", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00222778.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nJANE DOE NO. 2, CASE NO.: 08-CV-80119-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \n \n/ \nJANE DOE NO. 3, CASE NO.: 08-CV-80232-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \n \n/ \nJANE DOE NO. 4, CASE NO.: 08-CV-80380-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \n/ \nJANE DOE NO. 5, CASE NO.: 08-CV-80381-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \n/ \nJANE DOE NO. 6, CASE NO.: 08-CV-80994-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \nJANE DOE NO. 7, CASE NO.: 08-CV-80993-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \n \n/ \nC.M.A., CASE NO.: 08-CV-80811-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \nI \nJANE DOE, CASE NO.: 08-CV-80893-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN et al, \nEFTA00222778\n", "char_count": 877}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Defendants. \n \n/ \nDOE II, CASE NO.: 09-CV-80469-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN et al, \nDefendants. \n/ \nJANE DOE NO. 101, CASE NO.: 09-CV-80591-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \n \n/ \nJANE DOE NO. 102 CASE NO.: 09-CV-80656-MARRA/JOHNSON \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nDefendant. \n/ \nUNITED STATES' RESPONSE TO COURT'S ORDER \nREQUESTING POSITION ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO STAY  IDE 99] \nComes now the United States, by and through the undersigned Assistant United States Attorney, \nand files this response to the Court's Order requesting the position of the United States on Defendant \nJeffrey Epstein's Motion to Stay Proceedings [DE 99]. For the reasons set forth below, it is the United \nStates' position that a stay of the proceedings is not necessary and was not contemplated by the Non-\nProsecution Agreement between the United States and Defendant Jeffrey Epstein. \nISSUE PRESENTED \nThe United States is not a party to these lawsuits and, accordingly, is not fully aware of the scope \nof the proceedings, the range of arguments presented by counsel, and any correspondence or oral \ncommunications between the parties in these civil suits. Based on the information presented by the \nCourt and a review of Defendant Jeffrey Epstein's Motion to Stay and/or Continue Action for Time \nCertain Based on Parallel Civil and Criminal Proceedings with Incorporated Memorandum of Law \n(Court File No. 08-CV-80811-MARRA/JOHNSON DE 51-1), and responses thereto filed by various \nplaintiffs in their suits, the undersigned understands that the Court has requested the position of the \nUnited States on the following issue: \nAre there \"special circumstances\" that require the imposition of a stay of the civil \nproceedings in the \"interests of justice\" until the \"expiration\" of the Non-Prosecution \nAgreement [\"NPA\"] between the United States and Epstein? \nEFTA00222779\n", "char_count": 1909}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "By filing this response, the United States does not make itself a party to this litigation and takes \nno position with respect to the outcome of any of the civil suits; nor does the United States take any \nposition regarding Defendant Epstein's performance of his obligations pursuant to the NPA. The United \nStates also declines to comment on Defendant Epstein's representations regarding past allegations of \nviolations of the NPA by Epstein. The United States files this response solely as amicus curiae at the \nCourt's request and does not waive any procedural or statutory bars to suit. \nI. STANDARD FOR IMPOSING A DISCRETIONARY STAY \nA. The Defendant Must Show that the Assertion of His Fifth Amendment Privilege \nAgainst Self-Incrimination Would Automatically Result in the Entry of Summary Judgment \nAgainst Him. \n\"The decision whether or not to stay civil litigation in deference to parallel criminal proceedings \nis discretionary. . . . A movant must carry a heavy burden to succeed in such an endeavor.\" \nMicrofinancial, Inc. I Premier Holidays Internatt Inc. , 385 F.3d 72, 77 (1st Cir. 2004) (citations \nomitted). When a defendant facing possible criminal liability invokes his Fifth Amendment right \nagainst compelled self-incrimination in connection with civil litigation, a court can stay discovery or the \nentire civil case. Diaz I Jenne , 2007 WL 624286 *1 (S.D. Fl. Feb. 23, 2007) (Cooke, J.). \"However, \n`the Constitution does not require a stay of civil proceedings pending the outcome of related criminal \nproceedings. Forcing an individual to risk non-criminal disadvantage by remaining silent for fear of self \nincrimination in a parallel criminal proceeding does not rise to the level of an unconstitutional \ninfringement.' Id. (quoting Shell Oil Co. I Altina Assocs., Inc. , 866 F. Supp. 536, 540 (M.D. Fl. \n1994)). \nAs this Court has previously explained: \nThe law regarding stays of civil actions is well-settled in the Eleventh Circuit. In United \nStates, Lot 5, Fox Grov\n... [truncated, 2992 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00222778/2 or ?id=EFTA00222778&page=2]", "char_count": 2992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Lot 5 , 23 F.3d at 364; Penis. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. , 901 F.2d 944 (11th Cir. \n1990). Under this standard, Movants must show that invocation of the privilege in the \ninstant matter will result in certain loss by automatic summary judgment. United States\nTivo Pastels of Real Property , 92 F.3d 1123, 1129 (11th Cir. 1996); Penis , 901 F.2d at \n946-47. This must be an actual adverse judgment, and not \"merely the loss of the \ndefendant's most `effective defense.'\" Securities & Exchange Comm. I Incendy , 936 F. \nSupp. at 955 (S.D. Fl. 1996); Shell Oil Co. , 866 F. Supp. at 540-41. \nCourt-Appointed Receiver of Lancer Mgt. Group LLC I Lauer , 2009 WL 800144 (S.D. Fl. Mar. 25, \n2009) (Marra, J.). \nThus, before reaching the relative benefit and prejudice to each of the parties caused by staying \nthe cases, the Court must determine whether, if defendant Epstein were to invoke his Fifth Amendment \nright against self-incrimination a and the Court were to allow an adverse inference to be drawn \ntherefrom, an adverse judgment against Epstein would be automatically compelled. The United States \nrespectfully submits that it would not. \nFrom a review of the Complaints filed by the plaintiffs in these cases, it appears that some have \nfiled claims based upon Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, some have filed claims based upon \ncommon law torts, and some have filed a combination of the two. Under general principles of tort law, \na plaintiff is required to prove: (1) that the defendant committed a bad act; (2) that the plaintiff suffered \ndamages; and (3) that the damages were caused by the defendant's bad act. To succeed on a claim under \n18 U.S.C. § 2255, a plaintiff must show: (1) that the plaintiff is a person who, while a minor, was a \nvictim of an enumerated offense committed by the defendant; (2) that the person suffered personal \ninjury as a result of that violation; and (3) the amount of damages she sustained. \nEpstein's assertion of his Fifth Amendment priv\n... [truncated, 3036 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00222778/3 or ?id=EFTA00222778&page=3]", "char_count": 3036}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "are two other items for the Court to consider in deciding this issue. First, pursuant to the terms of the \nNPA, as to those victims identified by the United States, Epstein has already made a concession that \nthey are victims of an enumerated offense committed by Epstein. Thus, this inference is drawn not due \nto his invocation of the right against self-incrimination but due to his entry into a contractual agreement \nwith the United States for which the identified victims are third-party beneficiaries. n Second, in Lot S \n, the Eleventh Circuit pointed out the wealth of evidence other than the defendant's testimony that could \nbe used to defeat a liability claim. See Lot 5 , 23 F.3d at 364 (\"Thus, Claimant's assertion that only her \nown testimony could vindicate her is groundless; other participants to the illegal acts that gave rise to \nthe forfeiture were available to testify at trial. Claimant's failure to indicate with precision why she did \nnot use other parties' testimony to substantiate her defense was fatal.\"). For example, Epstein could \nmount a defense using effective cross-examination, telephone records, travel records, documents within \nthe possession of the plaintiffs or third parties, and/or the testimony of third parties to rebut the \nplaintiffs' proof. \nB. Additional Factors to Consider in Balancing the Prejudice to the Parties \nIf the Court is persuaded that the negative inference drawn from Epstein's assertion of his Fifth \nAmendment privilege would result in an automatic grant of summary judgment in favor of the plaintiffs, \nthen the Court must engage in a balancing of equities in determining whether there are \"special \ncircumstances\" warranting the imposition of a stay \"`to prevent a party from suffering substantial and \nirreparable prejudice.\"' Securites and Exchange Comm'rz \nIncendy , 936 F. Supp. 952, 956 (S.D. Fl. \n1996) (quoting S.E.C.I First Financial Group of Texas, Inc. , 659 F.2d 660, 668 (5th Cir. 1981) (add'I \ncitations omitted). \nExam\n... [truncated, 3041 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00222778/4 or ?id=EFTA00222778&page=4]", "char_count": 3041}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "No \"special circumstances\" exist here. First, unlike Wright and Incendy , the United States \nGovernment is not a party to the civil litigation. Each suit is brought on behalf of an individual plaintiff \nrepresented by private counsel. Some of those plaintiffs are adverse to the United States and have filed \nsuit against the Government based upon its handling of the criminal case against Epstein. ( See In re \nJane Doe Litigation , Court File No. 08-80736-Civ-Marra.) There has been no allegation, and certainly \nno showing, that the civil litigation is a ruse to obtain discovery on behalf of the criminal investigation. \nAs some of the plaintiffs have mentioned, one purpose of the NPA was to place the identified \nvictims in the same position where they would have been if Epstein had been convicted after trial of an \noffense enumerated in 18 U.S.C. § 2255. ( See, e.g., Court File No. 08-CV-80119 DE 49-2.) If Epstein \nhad proceeded to trial and been convicted, those victims would have been entitled to restitution and to \nfile suit pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2255, and would have been entitled to the same sorts of discovery that \nthey now seek. None of the plaintiffs has contacted the United States about passing on materials \ngathered through discovery to any criminal investigators or about seeking discovery that would be \nrelevant only to the criminal proceedings, rather than to their individual cases. If Epstein has legitimate \nconcerns that the civil discovery process is being abused in some way, he can ask the Court for a \nprotective order limiting the scope of discovery or its distribution. Furthermore, if at some time in the \nfuture, Epstein were the subject of a criminal indictment and he alleged that the evidence to be used \nagainst him was gathered improperly, he could file a motion to suppress or to dismiss the indictment in \nthat criminal action. See, e.g., United States, ex. rel. Westrick. Second Chance , 2007 WL 1020808 *4 \n(D.D.C. Mar. 31, 2007) (Defendant in civ\n... [truncated, 3071 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00222778/5 or ?id=EFTA00222778&page=5]", "char_count": 3071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "identification of and extensive discovery from the victims, which he would not have received in the \ncriminal case. Based upon a review of the discovery requests he has promulgated thus far, it appears \nthat Epstein is taking full advantage of this benefit and if a criminal case were ever filed, he would, no \ndoubt, seek to use that information in his defense. Fs \nUnlike Wright and Incendy , Epstein also has not been criminally indicted. In some districts, this alone \nis virtually dispositive. See, e.g., Sterling Nat'l Bank I A-1 Hotels Internal'! , 175 F. Supp. 2d 573, \n576-77 (S.D.N.Y. 2001) (\"district courts in this Circuit `generally grant the extraordinary remedy of a \nstay only after the defendant seeking a stay has been indicted.' (quoting Citibank, N.A.I Hakim , 1993 \nWL 481335 *1 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 18, 1993) (add'l citations omitted). As one court explained: \nthe consensus that a party seeking a stay bears a heavier burden when he has not yet been \nindicted derives logically from the balancing test set out by the courts of appeals that have \nconsidered the question. When a defendant has been indicted, his situation is particularly \ndangerous, and takes a certain priority, for the risk to his liberty, the importance of \nsafeguarding his constitutional rights, and even the strain on his resources and attention \nthat makes defending satellite civil litigation particularly difficult, all weigh in favor of his \ninterest. Moreover, if the potential prejudice to the defendant is particularly high post-\nindictment, the prejudice to the plaintiff of staying proceedings is somewhat reduced, \nsince the criminal litigation has reached a crisis that will lead to a reasonably speedy \nresolution. Furthermore, at that stage in the criminal proceeding, the contours of the \nindictment will provide the Court with a reasonable basis for determining the extent of the \nthreat to the defendant's Fifth Amendment rights, and the likely extent and timing of the \ncriminal litigation. \nPr\n... [truncated, 3422 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00222778/6 or ?id=EFTA00222778&page=6]", "char_count": 3422}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "As the Court aptly noted in its Order denying Epstein's first motion to stay the civil proceedings, \nEpstein has not been indicted and there are no criminal proceedings pending against him. F4 The \nresurrection of criminal proceedings against Epstein lies entirely within Epstein's own hands, by \nperforming or not performing under the terms of the NPA. This tips the balance of equities even further \nin favor of the plaintiffs. Epstein makes allegations that the U.S. Attorney's Office has unfettered \ndiscretion in determining breaches of the NPA, but this is no different than in any contractual setting. If \none party believes that there has been a breach, it may seek the remedy set forth in the contract. If the \nother party believes that there has been no breach, it has a remedy at law or equity. In this situation, \nEpstein would be entitled to seek dismissal of the indictment. See United States I Beeks , 167 Fed. \nAppx 777 (11th Cir. 2006); United States' Diaz , 138 Fed. Appx. 965 (9th Cir. 2005); United States\nDavis , 393 F.3d 540 (5th Cir. 2004). \nEpstein argues that because he is seeking a finite period of delay — until the time that he asserts \nthat the NPA \"expires\" — and that, thereafter, he will promptly provide full and complete responses to all \ndiscovery, the harm to the plaintiffs is de minimis . With all respect, this overlooks a number of obvious \nissues. First, if a stay is imposed until Epstein's proposed \"expiration date,\" it affords Epstein one of \ntwo incentives: (a) to delay any intended breach until a time when he believes that the United States has \nno remedy and then to breach the agreement with impunity ( i.e , to use the NPA as a shield and a \nsword); or (b) to delay the civil litigation as long as possible (until shortly before the \"expiration\" of the \nNPA), and then, after criminal charges have been filed, to seek a mandatory stay of the civil cases until \nthe criminal case is resolved. Thus, contrary to the assertions of Epstein, the delay \n... [truncated, 2877 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00222778/7 or ?id=EFTA00222778&page=7]", "char_count": 2877}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "In considering those factors, the United States respectfully recommends to the Court that all of \nthe factors weigh against a stay. In making its decision, the Court should consider that, unlike all of the \ncases cited herein, Epstein seeks to stay not one suit involving a single plaintiff, but more than a dozen \nsuits filed by individual plaintiffs. Each of those plaintiffs, in turn, impliedly asserts that she is a \"crime \nvictim\" with the \"right to full and timely restitution\" and the \"right to proceedings free from \nunreasonable delay.\" 18 U.S.C. § 3771(a)(6) & (7). As noted above, one of the purposes of the NPA \nwas to provide these rights to victims identified in the Government's investigation. Thus, this factor \nweighs more heavily for the plaintiffs than in the average civil dispute as it embodies both the plaintiffs' \nand the public's interests. The victims who were identified in the government investigation, by and \nlarge, were without financial assets and had significant counseling needs that could be remedied through \nobtaining restitution from Epstein. In addition to those needs, they have legitimate concerns about \nmemories fading, witnesses becoming unavailable, and dissipation of Epstein's assets while the matter \nis stayed. On the other hand, while the potential harm to the defendant normally weighs in the \ndefendant's favor, in this case, Epstein has significant control over whether the criminal investigation \nremains in abeyance and whether criminal charges are ever filed. \nCONCLUSION \nIn accordance with the Court's Order, the United States hereby submits that it is not aware of any \n\"special circumstances\" that warrant staying all of the civil cases pending the \"expiration\" of the NPA. \nRespectfully submitted, \nR. ALEXANDER ACOSTA \nUNITED STATES ATTORNEY \nBy: \nloor \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that on May 28, 2009, I electronically filed the foregoing document with \nthe Clerk of the Court using CM/ECF. According to the Court's website\n... [truncated, 2091 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00222778/8 or ?id=EFTA00222778&page=8]", "char_count": 2091}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00222778", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Tht appears from a brief review of some of Epstein's discovery responses that Epstein has made a \nblanket assertion of the privilege. For example, Epstein has asserted his Fifth Amendment privilege in response \nto a plaintiff's request to produce the NPA and the United States' list of identified victims although these \ndocuments were provided to Epstein by the United States . \nL2The United States notes that it is not aware of the identities of all of the plaintiffs in the civil suits. To \nthe extent that any are not \"identified victims\" under the NPA, this contractual provision would not apply. \nUWith respect to the other \"special circumstances\" mentioned in Incendy , the government obviously \nadvised Epstein of the potential for criminal charges, and that knowledge led to the negotiation of the NPA. \nEpstein also has a number of attorneys listed on the Service List for the civil cases and has retained a similarly \nlarge number of attorneys to handle the criminal investigation and negotiation of the NPA. Epstein alleges a fear \nof adverse publicity, but as the plaintiffs have pointed out, during the course of the state and federal criminal \ninvestigations, Epstein's personal publicist distributed stories to the press impugning the credibility of the \nvictims and other witnesses and averring that the victims' allegations of abuse were made solely to extract \nmoney from the defendant. In the context of some of the civil suits currently pending, Epstein has asked the \nCourt to unseal the victims' names so that he may make use similar press efforts to impugn their credibility. \na tEpstein points to provisions requiring him to maintain certain evidence \"inviolate\" as proof that the \ngrand jury investigation is still active. These provisions are meant only to insure that easily destroyed evidence \nidentified through the investigation, such as computer equipment, that is still in Epstein's control, will still be \navailable to investigators if Epstein does, in fact, breach \n... [truncated, 3197 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00222778/9 or ?id=EFTA00222778&page=9]", "char_count": 3197}]}