{"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_count": 38, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00207294", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00207294.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nx \nIN RE APPLICATION TO QUASH \nSUBPOENAS TO DAILY NEWS, L.P., \nAND GEORGE RUSH \n• • \nx \nNo. 10 M8-85 (LMM) \nREPLY DECLARATION OF ANNE B. CARROLL \nPursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746, Anne B. Carroll declares as follows: \n1. \nI am Vice President and General Counsel of movant Daily News, L.P., publisher of \nthe New York Daily News (the \"Daily News\"). I am admitted to practice before this Court. \n2. \nI make this Declaration in further support of the motion of the Daily News and \nDaily News journalist George Rush for an Order pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. Proc. 45(cX3XAXiii) \nquashing subpoenas ad testificanduni and duces twain served on than by plaintiff Jane Doe in an \naction pending in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida captioned \nDoe v. Jeffrey Epstein, No. 08-cv-80893-1CAM, or in the alternative for a Protective Order \npursuant to Fed. R Civ. Proc. 26(cXI). \n3. \nAnnexed hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of E & J Gallo Winery v. \nEncana Energy Servs.. Inc. 33 Med. L. Rptr. 1413 (S.D.N.Y. 2005) (Preska, J.). \n4. \nAnnexed hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of L.W. v. Knox County \nBd. of Educ.. 36 Med. L. Rptr. 1721 (E.D. Tenn. 2008). \n5. \nAnnexed hereto as Exhibit C is the Supplementary Affidavit of George Rush in this \nproceeding, sworn to on April 30, 2010. \n6. \nJane Doe's brief in opposition to Jeffrey Epstein's motion for summary judgment \ndismissing the federal claims in this action (\"Si °pp.') may be found on PACER, S.D. Ma. Civil \nDocket for Jane Doe v. Jeffro Epstein, Case # 9:08-cv-80893-KAM (\"Dockerp, \nppeP4 \nEFTA00207294\n", "char_count": 1665}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "expressions of confidence in the strength of the evidence in her own case may be found at, e.g., SJ \nOpp 2 (Doe \"has ample evidence that [Epstein] committed federal sex offenses against her\"); 11 \n(Epstein's fraudulent concealment of assets \"evidences [his] awareness that he is liable to the girls \nfor substantial sums of money because of his sexual abuse of them,\" citing Epstein's Mar. 8, 2010, \ndeposition); 12 (\"Epstein does not deny that he repeatedly sexually abused Jane Doe when she was \na minor\"); 35 (\"Jane Doe can easily prove her case\"). \n7. \nSpecific examples given in Doe's opposition to summary judgment of invocations \nof the 5th Amendment warranting adverse inferences include Epstein's silence in the face of such \nconfrontational Requests for Admission as \"[y]ou have committed sexual assault against Plaintiff, \na minor,\" and \"[y]ou digitally penetrated Plaintiff when she was a minor,\" SJ Opp. at 4, and his \nrefusal to answer numerous questions at a Mar. 8, 2010, deposition, id. at 10 & Ex. D. \n8. \nAnnexed hereto as Exhibit E is a copy of pertinent pages of the Complaint in \nEpstein v. Rothstein, Edwards \n No. 50 2009 CAO 40800 (Cir. Ct., 15th Jud. Cir., Palm \nBeach Co., Dec. 7, 2009), as downloaded from http://www.scribd.com/doc/23947743/121009-\nepstein. \n9. \nShortly after receiving service of the subpoenas served on Daily News, L.P., and \nGeorge Rush which movants seek to quash in this proceeding, I asked plaintiffs counsel Bradley \nEdwards whether he would withdraw them in exchange for an affidavit from Mr. Rush attesting to \nthe fact that he had interviewed Mr. Epstein. Mr. Edwards said he would not. \n10. \nOn Friday, April 30, 2010, I received service of a subpoena from Doe's counsel \nrequiring movant journalist George Rush to appear before this Court on May 4, 2010, at 11:00 \na.m., for the purpose of giving testimony in an evidentiary hearing in connection with this matter. \nA copy of the subpoena is annexed hereto as Exhibit F. \nI I. \nOn Friday, Apri\n... [truncated, 2075 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/1 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=1]", "char_count": 2075}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "George Rush (Exhibit C hereto) in this proceeding to counsel for plaintiff Doe and asked if, \nhaving seen it they would withdraw the testimonial subpoena to Rush, given that there are no \nmaterial facts in dispute among the parties to this proceeding. Counsel responded that they would \ndo so only if movants would stipulate to the accuracy of all facts alleged in the subpoenas of Brad-\nley Edwards and Michael Fisten submitted in support of Doe's opposition to movants' motion to \nquash or for a protective order. I declined. \n1 declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. \nExecuted on May 3, 2010 \n/1/4 A-c e \nAnne B. Carroll (AC 5322) \n- 3 - \nEFTA00207296\n", "char_count": 689}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "EXHIBIT A \nEFTA00207297\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Media Law Reporter \nPage 1 of \nKir-:; Media Law Reporter's \nSource: Media Law Reporter Cases > U.S. District Courts, New York > E&J Gallo Winery v. Encana Energy Services Inc., 33 \nMed.L.Rptr. 1413 (S.D.N.Y. 2005) \n33 Med.L.Rptr. 1413 \nEL) Gallo Winery v. Encana Energy Services Inc. \nU.S. District Court \nSouthern District of New York \nNo. M8-85 \nJanuary 12, 2005 \nEPO GALLO WINERY, a California corporation v. ENCANA ENERGY SERVICES INC., a \nDelaware corporation, f/k/a PANCANADIAN ENERGY SERVICES INC.; ENCANA \nCORPORATION, a Canadian corporation, f/k/a and successor to PANCANADIAN ENERGY \nCORPORATION \nHeadnotes \nNEWSGATHERING \n[1] Forced disclosure of information — Disclosure of unpublished information — In civil actions (.60.1003) \nForced disclosure of information — Common law privilege (.60.20) \nPlaintiff's subpoena seeking documents and testimony from nonparty media entity will be quashed, since information \nsought is subject to full protection of qualified reporter's privilege, in that nonparty engages in newsgathering \nactivities, information sought involves confidential sources and information, information was gathered with intent to \ndistribute it to public in form of published price indices, and creation of price indices involves subjective editorial \njudgment, since plaintiff failed to overcome privilege by making sufficient showing that material sought is highly \nmaterial and critical to its claims, and that it exhausted other available sources of information, and since subpoena is \nunduly burdensome under Fed. R. Civ. P. 45(c). \nCase History and Disposition \nCivil action in which plaintiff issued subpoena seeking documents and testimony from nonparty media entity. On \nnonparty's motion to quash. \nGranted. \nAttorneys \nStephen Williams, of Cotchett, Pitre, Simon & McCarthy, Burlingame, Calif., for plaintiff. \nAllison Gooding, of Gibson Dunn and Crutcher, New York, N.Y., for defendants. \nVictor A. Kovner, Matthew Leish, and Duffy Carolan, of Davis Wright Trema\n... [truncated, 2555 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/4 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=4]", "char_count": 2555}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Meala Law Keporter \nPage 2 of \nconnection with the underlying action pending in the Eastern District of California; and \nThe court having considered the Declaration of Larry Foster in Support, dated December 13, 2004, with exhibits; the \nDeclaration of Duffy Carolan in Support, dated December 8, 2004, with exhibits; the Supplemental Declaration of Larry \nFoster in Support, dated January 6, 2005; the Declaration of Barbara L Lyons in Opposition, dated December 27, 2004; \nthe Declaration of Steven N. Williams \nPage 1414 \nin Opposition, dated December 28, 2004, with exhibits; the Request for Judicial Notice submitted in Opposition by Mr. \nWilliams, dated December 28, 2004; the Joinder by Encana defendants in McGraw-Hill's motion; the Declaration of Julie K \nBuxbaum in Support of the Joinder by Encana, dated December 22, 2004, with exhibits; the Supplemental Confidential \nDeclaration of Mr. Williams in Opposition, dated December 28, 2004, with exhibit; the various Memoranda of law \nsubmitted by McGraw-Hill, Gallo, and the Encana defendants; and argument of counsel; \nThe Court hereby finds as follows: \n[ 1 ] The Gallo subpoena seeks documents and testimony that are subject to the full protections of the qualified reporter's \nprivilege as recognized in this Circuit. In re Petroleum Products Antitrust Litigation, 680 F.2d 5 [8 Med.L.Rptr. 1525) (2d. \nCir. 1982); see also In re Pan Am Corp., 161 B.R. 577 [22 Med.L.Rptr. 1118) (S.D.N.Y. 1993). McGraw-Hill has \nestablished that its division Plans is engaged in newsgathering activities in connection with its publication of price indices \n(also referred to as price assessments); that the subpoenaed documents and testimony involve confidential sources and \nconfidential information; that Platts gathers information from its sources with the intent to distribute it to the public in the \nform of its published price indices; and that the creation of the indices involves subjective editorial judgments. \nAccordingly, to overcome the pr\n... [truncated, 3999 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/5 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=5]", "char_count": 3999}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "EXHIBIT B \nEFTA00207300\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Media Law Reporter \nPage 1 of \n \n Media Law Reporter®\nSource: Media Law Reporter Cases > U.S. District Courts, Tennessee > L.W. v. Knox County Board of Education, 36 Med.L.Rptr. \n1721 (E.D. Tenn. 2008) \n36 Med.L.Rptr. 1721 \nL.W. v. Knox County Board of Education \nU.S. District Court \nEastern District of Tennessee \nNo. 3:05-CV-274 \nMarch 25, 2008 \nL.W., a minor, by and through his parents SAMUEL and TINA WHITSON v. KNOX COUNTY \nBOARD OF EDUCATION, et at. \nHeadnotes \nNEWSGATHERING \n(1) Forced disclosure of Information — Disclosure of unpublished Information — In dvil actions (.60.1003) \nForced disclosure of information — Common law privilege (P60.20) \nForced disclosure of information — Statutory privilege (\"shield\" laws) (P60.25) \nGiven federal claims raised by plaintiffs, nonparty reporter's motion to quash subpoena in civil action must be resolved \nunder federal, and not state, law; motion is granted, even though reportor's privilege does not exist in U.S. Court of \nAppeals for Sixth Circuit, since, under Fed. R. Civ. P. 26, plaintiffs have failed to show that reporter possesses any \nunique evidence not addressed during her previous deposition or otherwise available from individuals referenced in \narticle, since plaintiffs have had ample opportunity to obtain information sought, and since burden and expense of \nproposed discovery outweighs its likely benefit. \nCase History and Disposition \nMotion by nonparty reporter to quash subpoena in civil action. \nGranted. \nAttorneys \nCharles W. Pope Jr., of Pope Law Offices, Athens, Tenn.; Heather G. Hacker, Alliance \nPage 1722 \nDefense Fund, Folsom, Calif., and Nathan W. Kellum and Jonathan Scruggs, of Alliance Defense Fund - Memphis, \nMemphis, Tenn., for plaintiffs. \nMartha H. McCampbell, Office of Knox County Law Director, Knoxville, Tenn.; and Gary M. Prince and P. Alexander Vogel, \nof O'Neil, Parker & Williamson, Knoxville, for defendants. \nOpinion Text \nOpinion By: \nGuyton, U.S. Magistrate Judge: \nThis civil action is be\n... [truncated, 2669 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/7 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=7]", "char_count": 2669}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Media Law Reporter \nPage 2 of \nplaintiffs. \nMs. Mellon moves the Court to quash a deposition subpoena served on her by the plaintiffs, with the deposition set to \noccur on March 26, 2008, in Houston, Texas. ' As grounds, Ms. Mellon states that the plaintiffs seek to depose Ms. Mellon \nregarding a newspaper article 2 she authored in May, 2005, on matters at issue in this litigation. Ms. Mellon argues that \nTennessee's Shield Law protects her from having to testify in this matter, and further argues that, even if Tennessee's \nShield Law does not apply, that the deposition should still be quashed under the standards established by Rule 26(b)(2) of \nthe Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The plaintiffs oppose the motion, arguing that under Rule 501 of the Federal Rules of \nEvidence, it is federal common law, not Tennessee Law, that controls, and that the Sixth Circuit does not recognize a \nreportorial privilege. Plaintiffs further argue that under Rule 26, the discovery sought is highly necessary for plaintiffs' case \nand unavailable from other sources, and thus the deposition should be permitted. \n1 Ms. Mellon, formerly a newspaper reporter in Knoxville, currently resides in Houston, where she continues to \nwork as a newspaper reporter. \n2 The Court notes, for the sake of reference, that the newspaper article at Issue was filed by the plaintiffs in \nconjunction with their motion for preliminary injunction. [Doc. 21, Exhibit G) \n( 1 ] Under Rule 501 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, questions of privilege are generally controlled by federal common \nlaw when the court's jurisdiction is based upon a federal question, but state law generally controls when the court is \nexercising diversity jurisdiction. Fed. R. Evid. 501. In the instant case, the Court is faced with several federal claims, but \nplaintiff also relies in part on claims under the Tennessee Constitution, thus there is a mix of state and federal claims. The \nSixth Circuit has held that, when faced with a combina\n... [truncated, 5537 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/8 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=8]", "char_count": 5537}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Media Law Reporter \nPage 3 of \ncase. \nWith these facts in mind, the Court turns to the Rule 26 factors. Under the first factor, the Court finds that the discovery \nsought is unreasonably cumulative or duplicative, or is obtainable from some other source that is more convenient, less \nburdensome, or less expensive. Specifically, the Court finds that the plaintiffs have failed to show that Ms. Mellon posses \nany unique evidence not addressed during Ms. Mellon's previous deposition or otherwise available from the individuals \nreferenced in the article. There is no evidence that any of the individuals referenced in the newspaper articles have denied \nmaking the statements attributed to them in the article, and thus Ms. Mellon's second deposition would be cumulative to \nher own previously given deposition and that of the other witnesses. \nWith respect to the second factor, the Court finds that the plaintiffs have had ample opportunity to obtain the information \nsought. The plaintiffs have previously deposed Ms. Mellon, and had ample opportunity to question her at that time, as well \nas ample opportunity to depose the individuals referenced in the article. With respect to the third factor, the Court finds \nthat the burden and expense of the proposed discovery outweighs its likely benefit. Given the almost three year period \nsince the article was published, and given the plaintiffs' failure to establish the uniqueness of Ms. Mellon's additional \ntestimony, the Court finds that the likely benefit of this deposition would be small, and that any likely benefit is \noutweighed by the cost in time and money to Ms. Mellon posed by the deposition. \nThus, the Court finds that all of Rule 26 factors weigh in favor of Ms. Mellon, and, accordingly, Ms. Mellon's motion is \nhereby GRANTED. The deposition of Ms. Mellon scheduled for Mardi 26, 2008, is hereby QUASHED. \nIT IS SO ORDERED. \n- End of Case - \nContact us at http://www.bna.com/contact/index.html or call 1-800-372-1033 \nISSN 1944\n... [truncated, 2379 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/9 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=9]", "char_count": 2379}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "EXHIBIT C \nEFTA00207304\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \n \nx \nIN RE APPLICATION TO QUASH \nSUBPOENAS TO DAILY NEWS, L.P., \nAND GEORGE RUSH \n x \nNo. 10 M8-85 (LMM) \nSUPPLEMENTARY AFFIDAVIT OF GEORGE RUSH \nSTATE OF NEW YORK \n) \n) ss.: \nCOUNTY OF NEW YORK ) \nGEORGE RUSH, being duly sworn, deposes and says: \n1. \nI make this affidavit in further support of the motion of Daily News, L.P., and \nmyself to quash subpoenas served on us in this action. \n2. \nMy counsel was recently advised by one of plaintiff's attorneys that there is an \nadditional individual -- Michael Fisten, private investigator for Doe's attorney Bradley Edwards \n-- to whom I described certain aspects of the taped interview with Jeffrey Epstein but whom I did \nnot identify in my prior affidavit. Hearing that refreshed my memory that in fact I did speak to \nMr. Fisten about the interview. The attorney's representation that the interview with Mr. Epstein \nmust have occurred prior to October 22, 2009, because my conversation with Mr. Fisten took \nplace on or about that date, is also correct. My statement in my prior affidavit that the interview \ntook place on November 18, 2009, was drawn from an erroneous entry in my Outlook calendar. \n(Despite a diligent effort, I have been unable to establish the exact date on which the interview \nwith Mr. Epstein took place.) My mistakes in failing to recall the discussion six months ago with \nMr. Fisten (which in my memory became conflated with my conversations with Mr. Edwards) \nand in giving the wrong date for the interview were wholly inadvertent and by no means were, as \nEFTA00207305\n", "char_count": 1612}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Doe's lawyers suggest in their opposition papers to this motion, intentional falsities. \n3. \nAlthough I do not have a present memory of every item we discussed concerning \nthe interview, I cannot dispute the subject matters that Fisten and Edwards say in their affidavits \nwere covered, because most of them do at least roughly correspond to parts of the content of the \ninterview. There are, however, additional matters discussed in the interview that plaintiff does \nnot allege were disclosed to her litigation team and that have link or no relevance to this case. \n4. \n1 do dispute both men's characterization of a number of matters discussed, \nhowever. As this Court will be able to confirm if it does an in camera review of the recording, \nEdwards' and Fisten's accounts of what I allegedly told them -- or what is allegedly on the tape - \n- are off the mark or simply untrue in several important respects. Most prominently, Mr. Epstein \ndid not state on the tape either that \"he may have come too close to the line\" (Edwards Aff't ¶ 13) \nor that \"the only thing he might have done wrong was to maybe cross the line a little too closely\" \n(Fisten Afft ¶ 7). \n5. \nMr. Epstein did not make a \"damning admission\" during the interview about Jane \nDoe (or any other woman). (Doe Opp. Br. at 1, 20.) In fact, he made no reference whatsoever \nto Jane Doe, the plaintiff in this case. Therefore, plaintiff's allegation that the tape \"is the only \ndirect evidence in existence or available to Jane Doe to prove what Epstein thinks about what he \ndid to her\" (Opp. Br. at 22-23) is untrue. \n6. \nAs I stated in my prior affidavit, in my meeting with my three sources for whom I \nplayed a short segment of the interview tape in the process of an exchange of information to \nassist my reporting, there was an agreement that the contents of the interview were to be held in \nconfidence. Plaintiff Jane Doe does not contest this. In addition, I have since learned from one \nof those three sources that in fact \n... [truncated, 2082 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/12 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=12]", "char_count": 2082}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "and heard none of it. He has expressed a willingness to submit an affidavit to that effect in this \nproceeding, should the Court find that appropriate or necessary. \n7. \nI reiterate that the disclosures I made about the contents of the tape were solely in \nthe context of seeking information from sources in the course of my reporting. Reporters doing \ninvestigative journalism customarily use information given to them by one side in a dispute as a \nbasis for questions aimed at testing the veracity of that information and drawing out the positions \nof the other side, as I did in this case. I do not view my having used certain information gained \nduring the Epstein interview in this way to be a waiver of the essential confidentiality of the \ninterview because I did not intend to, and did not, publish the information imparted to me by Mr. \nEpstein during the interview. Mr. Edwards' bald statement that he and my other sources with \nwhom I spoke about the tape \"were not sources in the tradition [sic] sense of the word,\" but \nrather individuals with whom 1 was \"simply chatting\" (Edwards Afft ¶ 23) fundamentally \nmisunderstands how I and reporters generally gather information. \n8. \nWhile it is correct that, in response to Mr. Fisten's request for a copy of the tape, I \nsaid that I would consider doing that but needed to check with the newspaper's lawyer (Fisten \nAfft ¶ 10), in fact I never intended to give him a copy, never discussed the issue with the \nnewspaper's lawyer, and never gave him a copy, as he confirms. \n9. \nThe statements by Mr. Fisten that I told him that I had \"compiled very negative \ninformation on Epstein concerning his exploits with underage girls and how he eluded the justice \nsystem\" and that I presented the story to my publisher, \"who killed [it)\" (Fisten Afft ¶ 6), is \nfalse: I never represented that I had gathered any information about Mr. Epstein that was not a \nmatter of public record, and the Daily News publisher did not \"kill\" my story -- in fact m\n... [truncated, 2121 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/13 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=13]", "char_count": 2121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Fisten's statements are also gratuitous because they have no bearing at all on the issues before \nthis Court. \n10. \nThere is no question that the subpoenas in this case are oppressive and highly \nburdensome to the Daily News and to me as a reporter. Forcing me to testify and to give up the \ntape of my off-the-record interview would compromise my reporting by deterring other sources \nfrom speaking to me out of fear that they will become involved in third-party litigations and \nforce me to change the way I go about my work; for example, 1 would no longer keep newsga-\nthering materials important to my work, and I know I would have to think twice before taking on \nreporting projects that involve civil litigations, which up to now I have done frequently. Such \nsubpoenas against the press in aid of private disputes, seeking information that offers, in this \ncase, at best marginal support, would place extraordinary and undue time demands on myself and \nother reporters and impose heavy financial costs on newspapers seeking to protect their reporting \nat a time when the industry is struggling. \nSworn to before me this \nt) 44—  day of April, 2010 \nNotalyeAR\nNotary Public REs\nOutlined \nYork \nCaraiklion b ias  \n°only \nMatta 29. 2014 \n4 \nEFTA00207308\n", "char_count": 1258}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "EXHIBIT D \nEFTA00207309\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80893-KAM Document 140-1 \nEntered on FLSD Docket 04/13/2010 Page 1 of \n7Q \nPage 527 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \ntimes you went to Mr. Epstein's home? \nA. \nI don't know. Like 17. \nQ. \nAnd I think you testified you never took \nanyone to Mr. Epstein's home, correct? \nA. \nYes. \nQ. \nThat's correct? \nA. \nYes. \nQ. \nI asked you a little bit, I asked you at \n9 \nyour last deposition what occurred at the first time \n10 \nthat you went to Mr. Epstein's home. And whatever \n11 \nyou said will be obviously on the record, so it will \n12 \nbe there. But I want to bring you back to that time \n13 \nso I can ask some follow-up questions. \n14 \nIt's my recollection, correct me if I'm \n15 \nwrong, please, is that when you went to \n16 \nMr. Epstein's home III. was the one who took you, \n17 \ncorrect? \n18 \nA. \nYes. \n19 \nQ. \nAnd it was your testimony that when you, \n20 \nat some point during the time you were in \n21 \nMr. Epstein's home the first time, you took off your \n22 \nclothes in conjunction \n23 \nA. \nYes. \n24 \nQ. \n-- with III., correct? \n25 \nA. \nYes. \n(561) 832-7500 \nPROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. \n(561) 832-7506 \nBectronically signed by cyndila booklets (601.051-976-2934) \nElectronically signed by gnat,. hopkins (601-051.9762931) \nElectronically signed by cyntlis napkins (601-051.976-2931) \nb831330d-33804b69-alce-s607480dd71; \nEFTA00207310\n", "char_count": 1348}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "EXHIBIT E \nEFTA00207311\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "IN \nTHE \nCIRCUIT \nCOURT \nOF \nTHE \nFIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR \nPALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nComplex Litigation, Fla. R. Civ. Pro. 1.201 \nCASE NO. \nPlaintiff, \nv. \nSCOTT ROTHSTEIN, individually, \nilr\nDLEY J. EDWARDS, individually, and \n., individually, \nDefendants. \n50 2009 cAo 03 (JUI0X04B \nCOMPLAINT \nCOPY \nRECEIVED FOR FILING \nAC \n20011 \n0MAMON M, rogrc \nOirtiftts & OOMPTligaiR \nPlaintiff, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, (hereinafter \"EPSTEIN\"), by and through his \nundersigned attorneys, files this action against Defendants, SCOTT ROTHSTEIN, \nindividually, BRADLEY J. EDWARDS, individually, and M., individually. Accordingly, \nEPSTEIN states: \nSUMMARY OF ACTION \nAttorney Scott Rothstein aided by other lawyers and employees at the firm \nof Rothstein, Rosenfeldt, and Adler, P.A. for personal greed and enrichment, in betrayal \nof the ethical, legal and fiduciary duties to their own clients and professional obligations \nto the administration of justice, deliberately engaged in a pattern of racketeering that \ninvolved a staggering series of gravely serious obstructions of justice, actionable frauds, \nand the orchestration and conducting of egregious civil litigation abuses that resulted in \nprofoundly serious injury to Jeffrey Epstein one of several targets of their misconduct \nEFTA00207312\n", "char_count": 1318}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 2 \nand others. Rothstein and RRA's fraud had no boundary; Rothstein and his co-\nconspirators forged Federal court orders and opinions. Amongst the violations of law \nthat are the subject of this lawsuit are the marketing of non-existent Epstein settlements \nand the sanctioning of a series of depositions that were unrelated to any principled \nlitigation purpose but instead designed to discover extraneous private information about \nEpstein or his personal and business associates (including well-known public figures) in \norder to defraud investors and support extortionate demands for payment from Epstein. \nThe misconduct featured the filing of legal motions and the pursuit of a civil litigation \nstrategy that was unrelated to the merits or value of their clients' cases and, instead, \nhad as its improper purpose the furthering of Rothstein's misrepresentations and deceit \nto third party investors. As a result, Epstein was subject to abusive investigatory tactics, \nunprincipled media attacks, and unsupportable legal filings. This lawsuit is filed and will \nbe vigorously pursued against all these defendants. The Rothstein racketeering \nenterprise endeavored to compromise the core values of both state and federal justice \nsystems in South Florida and to vindicate the hardworking and honest lawyers and their \nclients who were adversely affected by the misconduct that is the subject of this \nComplaint. \nPlaintiff reserves the right to add additional defendants — co-conspirators as the \nfacts and evidence is developed. \nGENERAL ALLEGATONS \n1. This is an action for damages in excess of $15,000.00, exclusive costs, interest, \nand attorneys' fees. \nEFTA00207313\n", "char_count": 1706}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 15 \n40. EDWARDS filed amended answers to interrogatories in the state court matters, \ni. \nand.., and listed additional high profile witnesses that would allegedly be called \nat trial, including, but not limited to: \n(i) Bill Richardson (Governor of New Mexico, formerly U.S. \nRepresentative and Ambassador to the United Nations); and \n(ii) Any and all persons having knowledge of EPSTEIN'S charitable, \npolitical or other donations? \n41. The sole purpose of the scheduling of these depositions or listing high profile \nfriends/acquaintances as potential witnesses was, again, to \"pump\" the cases to \ninvestors. There is no evidence to date that any of these individuals had or have any \nknowledge regarding RRA's Civil Actions. \n42. In furtherance of their illegal and fraudulent scheme against EPSTEIN, \nROTHSTEIN, EDWARDS (who either know or should have known) and, at times, \nin her Civil Action against EPSTEIN: \na) Included claims for damages in Jane Doe's federal action in \nexcess of $50,000,000.00 rather than simply alleging the \njurisdictional limits. \nb) Organized a Jane Doe TV media interview without any legitimate \nlegal purpose other than to \"pump* the federal case for potential \n2 These high-profile celebrity 'purported* witnesses have no personal knowledge regarding the facts on \nthese \"Three Cases\", but were being contacted, subpoenaed or listed to harass and intimidate them and \nEpstein, and to add \"star\" appeal to the marketing effort of the Ponzi scheme. \nEFTA00207314\n", "char_count": 1526}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 16 \ninvestors or to prejudice Epstein's right to a fair trial in Palm \nBeach County. \nc) EDWARDS, Berger and Russell Adler (another named partner in \nRRA) all attended EPSTEIN's deposition. \nAt that time, \noutrageous questions were asked of EPSTEIN which had no \nbearing on the case, but so that the video and questions could be \nshown to investors. \nd) Conducted and attempted to conduct completely irrelevant \ndiscovery unrelated to the claims in or subject matter of the Civil \nActions for the purpose of harassing and embarrassing witnesses \nand EPSTEIN and causing EPSTEIN to spend tens of thousands \nof dollars in unnecessary attorneys' fees and costs defending \nwhat appeared to be discovery related to the Civil Actions but was \nentirely related to the furtherance of the Ponzi scheme. \ne) After EDWARDS was recruited and joined RRA in the spring of \n2009, the tone and tenor of rhetoric directed to cases against \nEPSTEIN used by Attorney EDWARDS and Berger changed \ndramatically in addressing the court on various motions from \nbeing substantive on the facts pled to ridiculously inflammatory \nand sound-bite rich such as the July 31, 20O9, transcript when \nEDWARDS stated to the Court in ..M.: \n`What the evidence \nis really going to show is that Mr. Epstein — at least dating back as \nEFTA00207315\n", "char_count": 1339}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 17 \n0 \ng) \nfar as our investigation and resources have permitted, back to \n1997 or '98 - has every single day of his life, made an attempt to \nsexually abuse children. We're not talking about five, we're not \ntalking about 20, we're not talking about 100, we're not talking \nabout 400, which, I believe, is the number known to law \nenforcement, we are talking about thousands of children. . . and it \nis through a very intricate and complicated system that he devised \nwhere he has as many as 20 people working underneath him that \nhe is paying well to schedule these appointments, to locate these \ngirls.\" \nAs an example, EDWARDS filed an unsupportable and legally \ndeficient Motion for Injunction Restraining Fraudulent Transfer of \nAssets, Appointment of a Receiver to Take Charge of Property of \nEpstein, and to Post a $15 million Bond to Secure Potential \nJudgment, in Jane Doe v. Epstein, Case No. 08-CV-80893-\nMarra/Johnson. The motion was reported in the press as was the \nultimate goal (i.e., to \"pump\" the cases for investor following). \nHowever, the Court found \"Plaintiffs motion entirely devoid of \nevidence . . \", and denied the motion in toto. \nROTHSTEIN told investors he had another 52 females that he \nrepresented, and that Epstein had offered $200 million to resolve, \nEFTA00207316\n", "char_count": 1330}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 18 \nbut that he could settle, confidently, these cases for $500 million, \nseparate and apart from his legal fees. \nh) ROTHSTEIN and the Litigation Team knew or should have known \nthat their three (3) filed cases were weak and had minimal value \nfor the following reasons: \n(i) \n- testified she never had any type of sex with \nEpstein; worked at numerous strip clubs; is an \nadmitted prostitute and call girl; has a history of \nillegal drug use (pot, painkillers, Xanax, Ecstasy); \nand continually asserted the 5th Amendment \nduring her depositions in order to avoid answering \nrelevant but problem questions for her; \n(ii) \n— testified she worked at eleven (11) \nseparate strip dubs, including Cheetah \nwhich \nRRA represented and in which ROTHSTEIN may \nhave owned an interest and.. also worked at \nPlatinum Showgirls in Boynton Beach, which was \nthe subject of a recent police raid where dancers \nwere allegedly selling prescription painkillers and \ndrugs to customers and prostituting themselves. \n(iii) \nJane Doe (federal case) seeks $50 million from \nEpstein. She and her attorneys claim severe \nEFTA00207317\n", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 19 \nemotional distress as a result of her having \nvoluntarily gone to Epstein's home. She testified \nthat there was never oral, and or sexual \nintercourse; nor did she ever touch his genitalia. \nYet, Jane Doe suffered extreme emotional distress \nwell prior to meeting Epstein as a result of having \nwitnessed her father murder his girlfriend's son. \nShe was required to give sworn testimony in that \nmatter and has admitted that she has lied in sworn \ntestimony. Jane Doe worked at two different strip \ndubs, including Platinum Showgirls in Boynton \nBeach. \ni) Conducted \nridiculous \nand \nirrelevant \ndiscovery \nsuch \nas \nsubpoenaing records from an alleged sex therapist, Dr. Leonard \nBard in Massachusetts, when the alleged police report reflected \nthat EPSTEIN had only seen a chiropractor in Palm Beach named \nDr. Bard. No records relating to EPSTEIN existed for this alleged \nsex therapist, Dr. Bard, and the alleged subpoena for records was \njust another mechanism to \"pump\" the cases for investor appeal; \nj) Allowed a Second Amended Complaint to be filed on behalf of \nalleging that EPSTEIN forced the minor into \"oral sex,\" yet \n■. \ntestified that she never engaged in oral, anal, or vaginal \nEFTA00207318\n", "char_count": 1244}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 20 \nintercourse with EPSTEIN and she had never touched his \ngenitalia. \nk) Told investors, as reported in an Associated Press article, that \ncelebrities and other famous people had flown on EPSTEIN'S \nplane when assaults took place. Therefore, even though none \n(zero) of RRA's clients claim they flew of EPSTEIN'S planes, the \nLitigation Team sought pilot and plane logs. Why? Again, to \nprime the investment \"pump\" with new money without any \nrelevance to the existing claims made by the RRA clients. \nI) After EDWARDS joined RRA, EDWARDS and former Circuit \nJudge William Berger filed and argued motion to make the Non-\nProsecution Agreement (NPA) between Epstein and USAO \npublic. But, RRA, EDWARDS and Berger, and their three clients, \nalready had a copy of the NPA. They knew what it said and they \nknew the civil provisions in the agreement had no impact \nwhatsoever on the three pending Civil Actions. \nThe concept behind certain civil provisions in the NPA was \nto allow an alleged victim to resolve a civil claim with Epstein, \nmaintain her complete privacy and anonymity and move on with \nher life. \nAs an assistant United States Attomey stated at a \nhearing in federal court, the NPA was not designed \"to hand them \na jackpot or a key to a bank.\" \nEFTA00207319\n", "char_count": 1302}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 21 \n43. ROTHSTEIN, with the intent and improper motive to magnify his financial gain \nso continue to fund the fraudulent and illegal investment and/or Ponzi scheme, had \nEDWARDS demand excessive money from EPSTEIN in the Civil Actions. \n44. The actions described in paragraph 42 above herein had no legitimate purpose in \npursuing the Civil Actions against EPSTEIN, but rather were meant to further the \nfraudulent scheme and criminal activity of ROTHSTEIN so that he and others could \nfraudulently overvalue the settlement value of the existing and non-existent claims \nagainst EPSTEIN to potential investors. \n45. As a result of the fraudulent investment or (Ponzi) scheme, RRA and its \nattorneys in the Civil Actions against EPSTEIN may have compromised their clients' \ninterests. ROTHSTEIN and the Litigation Team would have been unable to give \nunbiased legal counsel because outside investor(s) had been promised a financial \ninterest in the outcome of the actions. Additionally, if a plaintiff received payments from \ninvestment monies while her action is pending, this clearly could impact the plaintiff's \ndecision of whether or not to settle the current litigation or shade their testimony (i.e. \ncommit perjury) to gain the greatest return on the investment and to further promote the \nPonzi Scheme. \n46. \nThe truthfulness of■ \nallegations and testimony in ■.'s state civil \naction have been severely compromised by the need to seek a multi-million dollar \npayout to help maintain RRA's massive fraud. Because fictitious settlements of tens of \nmillions of dollars in cases relating to EPSTEIN were represented to Investors\" in this \nPonzi scheme, RRA and the attorneys in the Civil Actions needed to create a fiction that \nEFTA00207320\n", "char_count": 1777}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Epstein v. PRA, et al. \nPage 22 \nincluded extraordinary damages. However, the actual facts behind her action would \nnever support such extraordinary damages. Therefore, extraordinary measures were \nundertaken to create an entirely inflated value of her claims against EPSTEIN. \na. Though she held herself out as a \"victim\" of Epstein, she admitted to having \nreturned over and over again to him despite her current claim of abuse. She \nhas now admitted, under oath, to being a call girt/escort since the age of 15. \n(in her deposition September 24, 2009 Transcript \"Dr 280:16-19). \nShe \ntestified \"Well, I lived life as a prostitute,\" (see DT 156:7) and \"I am a \nprostitute when I make money\" (see DT 156:12-13). ■. \nadmitted her \nactivity with men other than Epstein to making $1,000 a day from prostitution \non maybe more than 20 occasions in one year alone (DT 157:11-158:21). \nadmitted under oath to keeping a list of amounts she collected from \n\"Johns\" in 'two or three\" lined books including a book of 'Psalms\" that she \nobtained from a religious store (DT 152:1-14). Under the circumstances, her \nclaim for damages against EPSTEIN, one of ■.'s many \"Johns\" during that \nsame period, would be so incredible and certainly not likely to produce the \nextraordinary settlements promised to \"RRA'S investors.\" \n47. \nIn April 2007, before she was represented by EDWARDS, and RRA,.. \ngave sworn taped recorded testimony to the agents of the FBI. She was represented \nby a lawyer other than EDWARDS at that statement She spoke of EPSTEIN in a very \npositive and friendly terms and directly contradicted the central allegations on which \n■.'s civil action against Epstein is now based. \nHowever, once in the hands of \nEFTA00207321\n", "char_count": 1728}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al \nPage 23 \nEDWARDS and RRA, Ill's story changed dramatically. All of a sudden she wanted to \nsue EPSTEIN and like other RRA clients, sought tens of millions of dollars. \na. For example, in her sworn statement to the FBI, \nwas insistent that \n\"Jeffrey is an awesome man.\" (p. 21 — FBI); At the conclusion of she \nstated: \"I hope Jeffrey, nothing happens to Jeffrey because he's an \nawesome man and it really would be a shame. It's a shame that he has to \ngo through this because he's an awesome guy and he didn't do nothing \nwrong, nothing.\" (pp. 57-58 - FBI). \nIn fact, III \nspoke so highly of \nEPSTEIN and her interactions with him that the US Attorney's office \ninformed a federal court in July 2008 that the US Attorney could not \nconsider \na victim. \nYet, by September 24, 2009, the date on which In \nbegan her \ndeposition in her civil action and now represented by RRA and \nEDWARDS, Ill's \nnew and very different tale about purported sexual \nmisconduct under the supposed influence of EPSTEIN had been \nthoroughly rehearsed and her role into the ROTHSTEIN scam was \ncomplete. In her deposition in her civil action,.. declared that: \n\"I, I don't realty care about money.\" (DT 206:8) \n\"He needs time in jail. He doesn't want to be — this is not right for \nhim to be on the streets living daily . .\" (DT 219:21-23) \nEFTA00207322\n", "char_count": 1352}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 24 \n\"You don't think my whole life I have lived that shifty life because of \nJeffrey Epstein?\" (DT 222:7-8) \nb. \nIn her sworn FBI testimony (pre-EDWARDS and RRA), ■. \nwas \nemphatic that her interactions with Epstein involved no inappropriate \nsexual touching in any way. In fact, it was exactly the opposite: \nQ: Did he at any point kiss you, touch you, show any kind of \naffection towards you? \nA: Never, never. (p. 21 — FBI) . . . \nQ: So he never pulled you closer to him in a sexual way? \nA: I wish. \nNo, no, never, ever, ever, no, never. \nJeffrey is an \nawesome man, no. (p. 21 - FBI) \nYet, \nfiled her second amended complaint in April 20O9, \nafter EDWARDS joined RRA, the allegations against EPSTEIN in \n■.'s complaint became even more salacious. In paragraph 12 of \n■.'s Second Amended Complaint, ■. \nalleges among other \nthings, that: \n\"Jeffrey Epstein coerced, induced, or enticed . \n.the then minor \nPlaintiff to commit various acts of sexual misconduct. These acts \nincluded, but were not limited to, fondling and inappropriate and \nillegal sexual touching of the then minor Plaintiff, forcing or inducing \nthe then minor plaintiff into oral sex or other sexual misconduct...\" \nEFTA00207323\n", "char_count": 1230}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et at. \nPage 25 \nc. In her sworn FBI statement (pre-EDWARDS and RRA), \ntestified that \n, the individual who first brought ■. \nto EPSTEIN's \nhome, told ■. \n\"make sure you're 18 because Jeffrey doesn't want any \nunderage girls.\" (p. 8 - FBI). \nYet at her September, 2009 deposition now represented by \nEDWARDS and RRA,■. told a very different story: \nQ: My question was what did Carolyn tell you to tell Mr. Epstein \nabout your age? \nA: She said it didn't matter. \nQ: That's your recollection about what she said? \nA: Yes, she said — I remember her saying it doesn't matter. Don't \nworry about it. \n(DT 199:20-25) \nd. \nPre-EDWARDS and RRA, \ntestified to the FBI : \"I always made \nsure — I had a fake ID, anyways saying that I was 18? (p. 8 - FBI). \nYet, when questioned about her fake ID at her September 2009 depo, she \nstated: \nO: And did you have a fake ID? \nA: No. \nQ: Have you ever had a fake ID? \nEFTA00207324\n", "char_count": 930}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 26 \nA: No. \n(DT 300:5-8) \ne. \nIn her FBI statement (pre-EDWARDS and RRA), \nf\nl\n \ntestified \nabout others ■ \nbrought to the Epstein home. \ntestified that women she \nbrought to EPSTEIN's home were eager for the opportunity and content with their \nexperiences: \nA: None of my girls ever had a problem and they'd call me. They'd \nbeg me, you know, for us to go to Jeffrey's house because they \nlove Jeffrey. Jeffrey is a respectful man. He really is. I mean, and \nhe all thought we were of age always. This is what's so sad about \nit. (p 30 - FBI). \nQ: Did any of the girls complain about what happened after they left \nthere? \nA: No. You asked me that question. No, everybody loved Jeffrey. \n(p. 44 - FBI) \nA: Every girl that I brought to Jeffrey, they said they were fine with \nit. and like for example j.\n— another of RRA's clients in the \nCivil Actions], a lot of girls begged me to bring them back for the \nmoney. And as far as I know, we all had fun there. (p. 45 - FBI) \nEFTA00207325\n", "char_count": 1016}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al.\nPage 27 \nYet, with EDWARDS and RRA as her attorneys, • \ndid a \"180\" at her \nSeptember, 2009 deposition in saying: \nA: . . . Once they were there, they were scared out of their mind. \nThey did it anyways and some of them walked out and said a \ndon't ever do this to me again. That was the worst thing that ever \nhappened to me. (DT 170:6-11) \n. . A: And then, a lot of girls weren't comfortable. (DT 171:13) \nf. \nThe above represent only a few of the dramatic changes 115 made \nin her testimony prior to her representation by EDWARDS/RRA and after she \nhired ROTHSTEIN, EDWARDS and RRA. \n48. As a result of the fraudulent investment or (Ponzi) scheme, \nmay knowingly \nhave compromised her alleged interests in her Civil Action, or committed a fraud on the \ncourt. \n49. RRA and the Litigation Team took an emotionally driven set of facts involving \nalleged innocent, unsuspecting, underage females and a Palm Beach Billionaire and \nsought to turn it into a gold mine. Rather than evaluating and resolving the cases based \non the merits (i.e. facts) which included knowledgeable, voluntary and consensual \nactions by each of the claimants and substantial pre-Epstein psychological and \nemotional conditions of each of the claimants and substantial sexual experiences pre-\nEpstein, RRA and the Litigation Team sought through protective orders and objections \nto block relevant discovery regarding their claimants. They instead forged ahead with \ndiscovery the main purpose of which was to pressure Epstein into settling the cases. \nEFTA00207326\n", "char_count": 1564}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 28 \nFortunately, their tactics have not been successful. \nAs Magistrate Judge Linnea \nJohnson wrote in a discovery order dated September 15, 2009 (DE 299 in Federal Case \n#08-80119) in denying Plaintiffs' Motion for Protective Order: \n\"This is his [Epstein's] right. The Record in this case is clear that the childhood of \nmany of the Plaintiffs was marred by instances of abuse and neglect, which in \nturn may have resulted, in whole or in part, in the damages claimed by the \nPlaintiffs.\" \nIn addition, in an Omnibus Order dated October 28, 2009 (DE 377 in Federal \nCase #08-80119) Magistrate Judge Linnea Johnson wrote: \n\"Here the request at issue goes to the very heart of the Plaintiff's damage claims, \nrequesting not only general information relating to Plaintiffs sexual history, but \ninquiring as to specific instances wherein Plaintiff received compensation or \nconsideration for sex acts, claim other males sexually assaulted, battered, or \nabuses her, and/or claim other males committed lewd or lascivious acts on her. \nAs a global matter, Plaintiffs clearly and unequivocally place their sexual history \nin issue by their allegations that Epstein's actions in this case has negatively \naffected their relationships by, among other things, \"distrust in men,\" \"sexual \nintimacy problems,\" \"diminished trust,\" \"social problems,\" s problems in personal \nrelationships,\" \" feeling of stress around men,\" \"premature teenage pregnancy,\" \n\"antisocial behaviors,\" and \"hyper-sexuality and promiscuity.\" Considering these \nallegation, there simply can be no question that Epstein is entitled to know \nwhether Plaintiffs were molested or the subject of other \"sexual activity\" or \"lewd \nEFTA00207327\n", "char_count": 1731}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Epstein v. RRA, et al. \nPage 29 \nand lascivious conduct' in order to determine whether there is an alternative \nbasis for the psychological disorders Plaintiffs claim to have sustained, whether \nPlaintiffs engaged in prostitution or other similar type acts and how certain acts \nalleged in the Complaint materially affected Plaintiffs' relationships with others or \nhow those acts did not have such an affect on those relationships and/or whether \nPlaintiffs suffered from the alleged emotional and psychological disorders as a \nresult of other sexual acts prior to the acts alleged in the Complaint. To deny \nEpstein thus discovery, would be tantamount to barring him from mounting a \ndefense.\" \n50. ROTHSTEIN, EDWARDS and l.'s \nactions constitute a fraud upon EPSTEIN \nas RRA, ROTHSTEIN and the Litigation Team represented themselves to be acting in \ngood faith and with the bests interests of their clients in mind at all times when in reality, \nthey were acting in furtherance of the investment or Ponzi scheme described herein. \nEPSTEIN justifiably relied to his detriment on the representations of RRA, and \nDefendants, ROTHSTEIN, EDWARDS and ■. as to how he conducted and defended \nthe Civil Actions brought against him. \n51. As a direct and proximate result of the fraudulent and illegal investment or Ponzi \nscheme orchestrated by ROTHSTEIN and as yet other unknown co-conspirators arid as \na result of the litigation tactics undertaken by the Litigation Team and ■. \nas set forth \nherein, Plaintiff EPSTEIN has incurred and continues to incur the monetary damages \nincluding, but not limited to, having to pay an amount in excess of the Civil Actions' true \nvalue as a result of them refusing to settle in that a percentage of any payment by \nEFTA00207328\n", "char_count": 1766}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "EXHIBIT F \nEFTA00207329\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "AO83 (Rev. 06/D9) Subpxra to Ammar and Testify at a Hoar* or Trial in a Cir0 Action \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nfor the \nSouthern District of New York \nIn Re: Application to Quash Subpoenas \nPlaintiff \nv. \nto Daly News, L.P. and George Rush \nDefendant \nCivil Action No. 10 MB-85 \nSUBPOENA TO APPEAR AND TESTIFY \nAT A HEARING OR TRIAL EN A CIVIL ACTION \nTo: George Rush do New York Daily News Legal Department, Attn: Anne Carrot, 450, West 33rd Street \nNew York, NY 10001 \nYOU ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United States district court at the time, date, and place set forth below \nto testify at a hearing or trial in this civil action. When you arrive, you must remain at the court until the judge or a court \nofficer allows you to leave. If you are an organization that is not a party in this case, you must designate one or more \nofficers, directors, or managing agents, or designate other persons who consent to testify on your behalf about the following \nmatters, or those set forth in an attachment: \nPlace: United States Courthouse \n500 Pearl Street \nNew York, NY \nCourtroom No.: Part One \nDate and Time: 05/04/201011:00 am \nYou must also bring with you the following documents, electronically stored information, or objects (Monk 11/01 \napplicable): \nThe provisions of Fed. R. Civ. P. 45(c), relating to your protection as a person subject to a subpoena, and Fed. \nR. Civ. P. 45 (d) and (e), relating to your duty to respond to this subpoena and the potential consequences of not doing \nso, are attached. \nDate:  04/30/2010\nCLERK OF COURT \nOR \n&gran of Clerk or Deputy Clerk \nAttorney's signature \nThe name, address, e-mail, and telephone number of the attorney representing (name of party) \nReal Party In Interest \nJane Doe \n , who issues or requests this subpoena, are: \nion Pro Hac Vice Pending, 332 S. 1400 E.. Salt Lake City, UT 84112 \nEFTA00207330\n", "char_count": 1865}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00207294", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "AO 88 (Rev 06/09) Subpoena to Appear epd Testify at a Sleazing or Trial in a Civil Action (Mgt 3) \nFederal Rule of Civil Procedure 45 (c), (d), and (e) (Effective 12/1/07) \n(e) Protecting a Person Subject to a Subpoena. \n(1) Avoiding Undue Burden or Expense; Sanctions. A party or \nattorney responsible for issuing and serving a subpoena must take \nreasonable steps to avoid imposing undue burden or expense on a \nperson subject to the subpoena. The issuing court must enforce this \nduty and impose an appropriate sanction — which may include lost \nearnings and reasonable attorney's fees — on a party or attorney \nwho fails to comply. \n(2) Command to Produce Materials or Permit In:pea:ion \n(A) Appearance Not Required A person commanded to produce \ndocuments, electronically stored information, or tangible things, or \nto permit the inspection of premises, need not appear in person at the \nplace of production or inspection unless also commanded to appear \nfor a deposition, hearing, or trial. \n(B) Objections. A person commanded to produce documents or \ntangible things or to permit inspection may serve on the party or \nattorney designated in the subpoena a written objection to \ninspecting, copying, testing or sampling any or all of the materials or \nto inspecting the premises — or to producing electronically stored \ninformation in the form or forms requested. The objection must be \nserved before the earlier of the time specified for compliance or 14 \ndays after the subpoena is served. If an objection is made, the \nfollowing rules apply: \n(i) At any time, on notice to the commanded person, the saving \nparty may move the issuing court for an order compelling production \nor inspection. \n(II) These acts may be required only as directed in the order, and \nthe order must protect a person who Is neither a party nor a party's \nofficer from significant expense resulting from compliance. \n(3) Quashing or Minifying a Subpoena \n(A) When Required On timely motion, the issuing court must \nqu\n... [truncated, 6701 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00207294/37 or ?id=EFTA00207294&page=37]", "char_count": 6701}]}