{"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_count": 27, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00204936", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00204936.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Page 1 \n1 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \n2 \n3 \nJANE DOE, \n) \nCase No. \n) \n08-80736-CIV-MARRA \n4 \nPetitioner, \n) \n) \n5 \n) \n) \n6 \nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA,) \n) \n7 \nRespondent. \n) \nWest Palm Beach, Florida \n) \nAugust 14, 2008 \n8 \n \n) \n9 \n10 \nTRANSCRIPT OF HEARING \n11 \nBEFORE THE HONORABLE KENNETH A. MARRA \n12 \nU.S. DISTRICT JUDGE \n13 \n14 \nAppearances: \n15 \nFOR THE PETITIONER \nBradley J. Edwards, ESQ., and \nPaul G. Cassell, ESQ. \n16 \n17 \nFOR THE RESPONDENT \n18 \n19 \nReporter \nStephen W. Franklin, RMR, CRR, CPE \n(561)514-3768 \nOfficial Court Reporter \n20 \n701 Clematis Street, Suite 417 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nEFTA00204936\n", "char_count": 683}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Page 2 \n1 \n(Call to the order of the Court.) \n2 \nTHE COURT: Good afternoon. \n3 \nVOICES: Good afternoon, Your Honor. \n4 \nTHE COURT: All right. This is the case of In Re: \n5 \nJane Does 1 and 2, case number 08-80736-C/V-MARRA. \n6 \nMay I have counsel state appearances, please, and \n7 \nif you can please try and speak up so we can hear you. \n8 \nMR. EDWARDS: Okay. Brad Edwards, on behalf of \n9 \nJane Doe 1 and 2. \n10 \nMR. CASSELL: Paul Cassell, along with Mr. Edwards. \n11 \nTHE COURT: Good afternoon. \n12 \nMR. LEE: Good afternoon, Your Honor. For the \n13 \nUnited States Government, Dexter Lee, Assistant U.S. \n14 \nAttorney, and Marie \n15 \nTHE COURT: All right. Good afternoon. \n16 \nMr. -- everyone, we're having trouble hearing you, \n17 \nso if you can try and speak up, and also if you could \n18 \nidentify yourself before you begin speaking so the reporter \n19 \ncan accurately indicate on the record who is speaking. / \n20 \nappreciate that. \n21 \n/ scheduled this for a status conference in order \n22 \nto determine whether I'm going to need additional -- as far \n23 \nas the parties were concerned, whether either of the parties \n24 \nthought that I needed additional information in order to \n25 \nproceed with the pending motion by the Plaintiffs or whether \nEFTA00204937\n", "char_count": 1265}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Page 3 \n1 \nwe have a complete record based upon what's already been \n2 \nsubmitted, and I wasn't quite sure where we were on that \n3 \nsince we last met. \n4 \nSo if I can hear from Mr. Edwards or Mr. Cassell \n5 \nfirst what the Plaintiffs' position as far as where we stand \n6 \non the record in terms of whether I need additional facts, \n7 \nevidence, or there's going to be a stipulation submitted to \nB \nme upon which I can rely. \n9 \nMR. EDWARDS: Sure. \n10 \nYour Honor, this is Brad Edwards. \n11 \n/ believe that you do have a sufficient record, in \n12 \nthat / don't think that -- I think that we're in agreement \n13 \nthat additional evidence does not need to be taken in the \n14 \ncase for Your Honor to make a ruling. We have actually met \n15 \nwith the U.S. Attorney, and we've had meaningful discussions \n16 \nin an attempt to resolve our issues. I think the only issue, \n17 \nwe can probably agree to this right now, is that the victims \n18 \nare unable at this point in time to go any further with \n19 \nrequesting a remedy from the Court without the full and \n20 \ncomplete plea agreement being produced to us from the U.S. \n21 \nGovernment, and the U.S. Government's hands are tied in that \n22 \nthere's a confidentiality agreement within that plea \n23 \nagreement that prohibits them from turning that over. \n24 \nSo at this point in time, we would be asking Your \n25 \nHonor to enter an order compelling them to turn over that \nEFTA00204938\n", "char_count": 1435}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPage 4 \nagreement, and at that point in time I think we can meet \nagain and probably resolve our disputes amongst ourselves. \nTHE COURT: All right. So do I understand that \nyou're modifying your claim for relief at this point and only \nseeking me to compel the Government to produce the plea \nagreement, or are you -- or is this a -- a preliminary step, \nafter which you're then going to evaluate whether you want me \nto do something further? \nMR. EDWARDS: I think it's the latter, Your Honor. \n/t is, and it will likely always be, our position that the \nvictims' rights are violated. However, because of the legal \nconsequences of invalidating the current agreement, it is \nlikely not in my clients' best interest to ask for the relief \nthat we initially asked for. \nSo in order to effectively evaluate the situation \nand ask for the appropriate relief, we would just be asking \nYour Honor at this point in time to allow us to see the full \nentire plea agreement that is purportedly drafted to protect \nmy victims. That only seems fair to know, you know, what the \nplea agreement says, especially in light of the fact that \nMr. Epstein knows what the plea agreement says. \nrelief, \nwhether \nTHE COURT: All \nyou will evaluate \nto either dismiss \nsome additional relief? \nright. And then if I grant that \nthe agreement and then decide \nyour case or go forward and ask for \nEFTA00204939\n", "char_count": 1473}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Page 5 \n1 \nMR. EDWARDS: That's correct, Your Honor. \n2 \nTHE COURT: /s it your plan or is there any kind \n3 \nof -- been any kind of discussion between you and the \n4 \nGovernment as to what you -- if I grant the relief of \n5 \nrequiring the Government to at least present you with the \n6 \nagreement and let you view it, has there been any discussion \n7 \nabout you keeping it confidential and not letting it go any \n8 \nfurther than your clients and using it for your \n9 \ndecision-making purposes, or do you wish to have it released \n10 \nto you, and you would be able to use it however you wished? \n11 \nMR. EDWARDS: Well, Your Honor, we would prefer \n12 \nthat it be produced to us and not have to keep it \n13 \nconfidential. I think that that creates an undue hardship on \n14 \nus. However, if it was Your Honor's order that we do \n15 \nmaintain some confidentiality of the agreement, we would \n16 \ncertainly abide by it. \n17 \nThe reason we want it is not so that it's \n18 \ndisseminated everywhere; however, there is a public interest \n19 \nin viewing what happens in the court process, and this is \n20 \njust part of it. There's no reason that it should be sealed \n21 \nor kept confidential. Seems to be an overwhelming reason \n22 \nto -- to make it public. However, that's not our intention. \n23 \nOur intention is just to view it, represent my clients and \n24 \nthen evaluate it and ask the Court for the appropriate relief \n25 \nafter we've seen it. \nEFTA00204940\n", "char_count": 1453}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Page 6 \n1 \nTHE COURT: All right. And, again, although I hear \n2 \nyou saying you think that it shouldn't be kept confidential \n3 \nbecause there's some public interest in it, but if you had it \n4 \nto use for whatever, to represent your client either in \n5 \nadvising your clients whether to go forward with this case or \n6 \nnot, or I guess to use it in connection with any other \n7 \nlitigation that you might want to initiate on behalf of your \n8 \nclients where that agreement might have some relevance, \n9 \nwhat's the interest in using -- having the ability to \n10 \ndisclose it beyond those purposes? \n11 \nMR. EDWARDS: Well, certainly if -- if the \n12 \nagreement was designed to protect these victims in a criminal \n13 \nas well as a civil context, and we are going to be filing \n14 \ncivil cases against Mr. Epstein, and this agreement, \n15 \nundoubtedly it will play a big role in the amount of \n16 \nprotection the victims have been allotted, as well as the \n17 \ncourse of action in the civil cases. It seems inevitable \n18 \nthat it's going to become, you know, more public at that \n19 \npoint in time, and I think that's in the very near future. \n20 \nAt this point in time, it's not intention to make \n21 \nit public, but I think that inevitably happens as soon as \n22 \ncivil litigation begins, and this is at the heart of it, \n23 \n24 \nTHE COURT: Well, civil litigation has already \n25 \nbegun, hasn't it? \nEFTA00204941\n", "char_count": 1415}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Page 7 \n1 \nMR. EDWARDS: Right. \n2 \nTHE COURT: Okay. All right. \n3 \nMR. EDWARDS: At least for some other parties, with \n4 \nother attorneys and other things, so . . . \n5 \nTHE COURT: Well, you filed a case yesterday, \n6 \ndidn't you? \n7 \nMR. EDWARDS: We filed one of them. It is not on \n8 \nbehalf of one of the Jane Does that /'m representing in this \n9 \naction. \n10 \nTHE COURT: Okay. All right. \n11 \nMR. EDWARDS: Just so that we're clear. \n12 \nTHE COURT: I haven't seen the name, so I didn't \n13 \nknow who it was on behalf of. \n14 \nAll right. Let me hear from Mr. Lee or \n15 \nMs. \n16 \nI understand that you're under a confidentiality \n17 \nagreement, and / understand that you feel restricted in what \n18 \nyou can unilaterally do, but I've already entered some \n19 \nrulings in this case that have made portions of that \n20 \nagreement public. Is there any reason to keep the rest of \n21 \nthe agreement confidential, other than you're obligated by \n22 \nthe agreement and don't want to be in a position where you've \n23 \nunilaterally violated it absent a court order? \n24 \nMR. LEE: Yes, Your Honor. This is Dexter Lee. \n25 \nGood afternoon. \nEFTA00204942\n", "char_count": 1147}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Page 8 \n1 \nYour Honor, we do feel bound by the confidentiality \n2 \nprovision such that we could not voluntarily disclose this \n3 \nnon-prosecution agreement without court order compelling us \n4 \nto do so. \n5 \nThe provision in the non-prosecution agreement \n6 \nrequired us to notify Mr. Epstein and his attorneys of any \n7 \nattempts to have this document disclosed in a public forum, \nB \nand we have done so. They have expressed their desire that \n9 \nif this document is to be disclosed to the Petitioners in \n10 \nthis case, that it be done pursuant to a protective order \n11 \nwhich would preclude the victims from disseminating it \n12 \npublicly. \n13 \nWe believe that is appropriate in this action. It \n14 \nwould allow them access to the document, which they claim \n15 \nthey have a need to have, and that's fine. They can review \n16 \nit and determine where they wish to go. We believe there's \n17 \nno public interest in having this disseminated. \n18 \nNow, should there be subsequent litigation between \n19 \nMr. Edwards' clients and Mr. Epstein, and the subject matter \n20 \nof this agreement should arise, then Mr. Epstein and \n21 \nMr. Edwards will be in a position to litigate that in \n22 \nwhatever forum it is, rather than having that issue disposed \n23 \nof where they're not present to voice their objections. \n24 \nSo we would ask the Court to, if it compels us to \n25 \ndisclose it, to do so under a protective order which would \nEFTA00204943\n", "char_count": 1443}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Page 9 \n1 \nprovide for no public dissemination. \n2 \nTHE COURT: All right. \n3 \nMS. \n: Your Honor this is \n4 \nJust to add onto what Mr. Lee was saying, one of \n5 \nour concerns is that there are names of individuals in the \n6 \norder who are not currently --\n7 \nTHE COURT: Ms. \n, I'm having trouble \nB \nhearing you. I apologize. \n9 \nMS. \n: I'm sorry. \n10 \nYour Honor, one of our concerns is that the \n11 \nagreement contains names of individuals who are not \n12 \ncurrently -- haven't pled guilty or haven't -- do not have \n13 \ncertain obligations. And / think that there may be a Rule \n14 \n6(e) issue if the agreement is made public or available to \n15 \nthe press, et cetera. \n16 \nTHE COURT: Okay. So, I'm sorry, you say there are \n17 \nnames of other individuals that do what? \n18 \nMS. \n: They were other individuals who are \n19 \nthe subject of these -- who are the subject of the \n20 \nGovernment's investigation but who are not necessarily known \n21 \nto the public in the sense that Mr. Epstein entered the \n22 \nguilty plea and the public is aware of that, but they may not \n23 \nknow about these other individuals who haven't been indicted, \n24 \nand therefore I think they have a bit of a privacy interest \n25 \nhere. \nEFTA00204944\n", "char_count": 1227}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Page 10 \n1 \nTHE COURT: Okay. But they're not parties to the \n2 \nagreement. \n3 \nMS. \n: No. \n4 \nTHE COURT: Okay. Other than the fact that the \n5 \nGovernment bound itself in the agreement not to disclose it, \n6 \nand you require a court order to have it disclosed, what \n7 \nwould be the public interest, or what would be the \n8 \njustification for denying disclosure of the agreement at \n9 \nleast to purported victims of Mr. Epstein's conduct? Why \n10 \nshouldn't the victims who the Government, as I understand it, \n11 \nprovided notice of their rights under the Act that they had \n12 \nthe status of victims, why shouldn't they have the \n13 \nopportunity to see that agreement? \n14 \nMS. \n: Your Honor, I guess I will respond. \n15 \nI was prepared to -- I need to highlight an issue \n16 \nfor the Court. I was prepared to argue today that we had \n17 \nprovided the victims with the portion of the agreement that \n18 \nis relevant to them. \n19 \nLast night and this morning, in conversations with \n20 \nMr. Epstein's attorneys, they have said for the first time \n21 \nthat they do not believe that one portion of the agreement is \n22 \nbinding, and that is the portion that has been disclosed to \n23 \nthe victims. So I can no longer say that they have the \n24 \nportion that is relevant to them. \n25 \nTHE COURT: I'm sorry, I didn't quite follow that, \nEFTA00204945\n", "char_count": 1347}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Page 11 \n1 \nMs. \n. \n2 \nYou've had discussions with Mr. Epstein's counsel \n3 \nas to what? \n4 \nMS. \n: Your Honor, in preparation for \n5 \ntoday's hearing, I was -- I had been working to confirm with \n6 \nMr. Epstein's attorney that the agreement that I have \n7 \ndescribed in my declaration is the one that they are \n8 \nperforming under. Last night and this morning for the first \n9 \ntime, I was told that they believe that a portion of the \n10 \nagreement that is described in my declaration and that was \n11 \ndisclosed to the victims does not bind them. So as of this \n12 \npoint, the victims have not received at least what \n13 \nMr. Epstein claims is the portion relevant to them. \n14 \nTHE COURT: Okay. Your understanding is that \n15 \nMr. Epstein's taking the position that the portions of the \n16 \nagreement that have already been disclosed are not -- is not \n17 \nbinding on Mr. Epstein? \n18 \nMS. \n: Yes. \n19 \nMR. LEE: Your Honor, this is Dexter Lee. If I \n20 \nmay? \n21 \nThe agreement initially negotiated was executed in \n22 \nSeptember of 2007. That's part one, I will call it. \n23 \nIn October, there was an addendum to the executed \n24 \nagreement which occurred the month before. There was some \n25 \nmore discussions, and there was a letter that was submitted \nEFTA00204946\n", "char_count": 1273}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Page 12 \n1 \nto Mr. Epstein's attorneys by the United States Attorney in \n2 \nDecember. That's part three, I will call it. \n3 \nThere is now a dispute between the Government and \n4 \nMr. Epstein's attorneys about whether certain portions after \n5 \nthe original agreement are effective and binding. I just \n6 \nneed to make the Court aware of that and also Mr. Edwards and \n7 \nJudge Cassell. \n8 \nMR. EDWARDS: This is the first time \n9 \nThis is Brad Edwards speaking. \n10 \nThis is the first time we're hearing any of this. \n11 \nThis is obviously even further evidence that the victims were \n12 \nunaware of the plea agreement that was being worked out. \n13 \nBut, nonetheless, I don't think that it changes our \n14 \nposition, in that we believe we're entitled to not only the \n15 \nplea agreement, but all of the addenda that have been \n16 \nattached to that plea agreement and have become part of that \n17 \nplea agreement, just so that what we're asking for is clear. \n18 \nMR. LEE: Your Honor, this is Dexter Lee. \n19 \nWe are prepared to give all three hopefully, in our \n20 \nview, pursuant to a protective order preventing public \n21 \ndisclosure, but we just want the Court and the Petitioners' \n22 \ncounsel to know that there is a dispute ongoing right now \n23 \nabout which portions are effective and which are not. And we \n24 \ncan discuss that with them at the conclusion of the hearing. \n25 \nTHE COURT: All right. But again, as far as my \nEFTA00204947\n", "char_count": 1446}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Page 13 \n1 \nearlier question, even though there's a dispute now \n2 \napparently between Mr. Epstein and the Government as to what \n3 \nportions of the agreement are or are not binding, does the \n4 \nGovernment have any reason why the victims should not have \n5 \nthe benefit of seeing these -- the agreement, whether, you \n6 \nknow, it's going to be held binding down the road or not, \n7 \nother than you agreed in a confidentiality order not to \n8 \ndisclose it? But beyond that, is there any justification \n9 \nthat the Government can provide to me as to why the victims, \n10 \npeople who have been identified by the Government as victims \n11 \nof Mr. Epstein, should not have the benefit of seeing this \n12 \nplea agreement, or non-prosecution agreement, whatever you \n13 \nwant to term it? \n14 \nMR. LEE: Your Honor, this is Dexter Lee. When you \n15 \nrefer to victims, do you mean victims beyond the three that \n16 \nare parties to the instant litigation? \n17 \nTHE COURT: I mean -- yes, I'm talking about anyone \n18 \nwho the Government may have disclosed as a -- as a -- or sent \n19 \nnotice to based upon your understanding of who might have \n20 \nbeen a potential or an alleged victim of Mr. Epstein's \n21 \nconduct, whether they're part of this lawsuit or not. \n22 \nMR. LEE: Well, if the Court is asking whether we \n23 \ncould expand the protective order such that it would permit \n24 \ndisclosure to those other victims identified that have \n25 \nreceived notification already, I believe that would be \nEFTA00204948\n", "char_count": 1504}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Page 14 \n1 \nappropriate. \n2 \nTHE COURT: Okay. But I guess my real question is \n3 \ndo you have any reason that you could advance why they should \n4 \nnot get it? \n5 \nLet's just limit ourselves to the victims who are \n6 \nthe Jane Does in this case before we go beyond that. Is \n7 \nthere any reason that the Government can advance why the two \nB \nJane Does 1 and 2 in this case should not have the \n9 \nopportunity to view the plea agreement, or the deferral \n10 \nagreement or the addenda to it? Can anyone justify not \n11 \nletting them see it? \n12 \nMR. LEE: Your Honor, this iS Dexter Lee. \n13 \nNo, we cannot. \n14 \nTHE COURT: Okay. All right. Now, Mr. Edwards. \n15 \nMR. EDWARDS: Yes. \n16 \nTHE COURT: Is there any reason why I shouldn't, \n17 \nassuming I'm going to allow or require the Government to \n18 \nproduce the agreement and the addenda to your clients in this \n19 \ncase -- and we'll talk about other victims in a minute -- is \n20 \nthere any reason why, at least initially, it shouldn't be \n21 \nsubject to a protective order so that in the case, for \n22 \nexample, that you filed yesterday on behalf of an alleged \n23 \nvictim under a Jane Doe, where you specifically reference \n24 \nthis agreement in your -- in one the counts, that it \n25 \nshouldn't remain subject to a protective order at least until \nEFTA00204949\n", "char_count": 1316}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Page 15 \n1 \nMr. Epstein has the opportunity to litigate whether or not it \n2 \nshould be disclosed beyond -- beyond your clients or other \n3 \nvictims? \n4 \nMR. EDWARDS: At this point, Your Honor, I think \n5 \nthat that would probably be fair. \n6 \nMy only real concern is that if there's an order \n7 \nout there where anybody can access on PACER and it says, \nB \n\"okay, at this point I'm ordering the Government to disclose \n9 \nthis plea agreement,\" I just want to make sure if anybody \n10 \nelse feels entitled to that agreement, whether it's other \n11 \nvictims, or counsel, or what have you, that they be required \n12 \nto request it from the Government or these attorneys rather \n13 \nthan try to subpoena or request it from my office, knowing \n14 \nthat / have access to this confidential agreement. \n15 \nOther than that, no, I don't have any other reasons \n16 \nwhy that's not a reasonable order. \n17 \nTHE COURT: All right. And let's assume I think it \n18 \nshould be available to any person that the Government has \n19 \nidentified as an alleged victim of Mr. Epstein's conduct, and \n20 \nthey've sent notice of their rights under the statute as a \n21 \nvictim to this -- these individuals, and I permit disclose to \n22 \nyour clients, or anyone else who fits into the category of \n23 \nvictim as described by the Government, and require -- you \n24 \nknow, again, impose a protective order that it shouldn't go \n25 \nto anyone beyond that until such time as, in a pending \nEFTA00204950\n", "char_count": 1474}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Page 16 \n1 \nlawsuit, I conclude that the protective order should be \n2 \nlifted after Mr. Epstein has an opportunity to be heard on \n3 \nthat issue, is there anything else that you would need at \n4 \nthis point? \n5 \nMR. EDWARDS: No, Your Honor. \n6 \nThis is Brad Edwards. \n7 \nAt this point in time that's all we're requesting. \n8 \nTHE COURT: And Mr. Lee or Ms. \n, if I \n9 \nconclude that anyone that you've identified as a victim and \n10 \nnotified as a victim of their rights with respect to the \n11 \ninvestigation of Mr. Epstein is entitled to view the \n12 \nagreements, subject to a protective order until such other \n13 \ntime that / say it should be released beyond that, do you --\n14 \nis there any reason why I shouldn't make it available to all \n15 \nof the people who have been identified by you as a victim? \n16 \nMR. LEE: This is Dexter Lee, Your Honor. \n17 \nThe answer is no, there's no problem, with the \n18 \nexception of the grand jury issue that my colleague, \n19 \nMs. \n, mentioned earlier. I may have to defer to her \n20 \nright now on that issue to see if that would preclude what \n21 \nthe Court is asking. \n22 \nTHE COURT: All right. Hold on one second. \n23 \n(Brief pause in proceedings.) \n24 \nTHE COURT: Mr. Edwards, is there any reason why \n25 \nyou would need to see the names of others that the Government \nEFTA00204951\n", "char_count": 1328}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Page 17 \n1 \nmay have been investigating that might appear -- whose names \n2 \nmight appear in these agreements? /s there any interest that \n3 \nyou would have in that or need to see that information? \n4 \nMR. EDWARDS: Well, the primary interest would be \n5 \nthat those are obviously important witnesses for any case \n6 \nthat my clients have against Mr. Epstein, witnesses that \n7 \nMr. Epstein is clearly aware of, since he has access to the \n8 \ncomplete full agreement, and it seems inherently unfair that \n9 \nhe would have access to the names -- to a witness list that \n10 \nmy clients would not be privy to. \n11 \nTHE COURT: Well, why wouldn't you be able to get \n12 \nthose through discovery in the civil litigation? \n13 \nMR. EDWARDS: And that may be an appropriate time \n14 \nto get it. But that would be my primary objection for not \n15 \ngetting the names of the victims, whether now or eventually. \n16 \nTHE COURT: No, as I understand it, this is not the \n17 \nnames of other victims, this is the names of other \n18 \nindividuals that the Government may have been investigating \n19 \nin connection with their investigation of Mr. Epstein, and \n20 \nthey're concerned about grand jury secrecy and information \n21 \nthat may have been brought before the grand jury that should \n22 \nnot be made public at this point, as I understood the \n23 \nGovernment's position. \n24 \nIs that correct, Ms. \n25 \nMS. \n: Yes, Your Honor. \nEFTA00204952\n", "char_count": 1424}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Page 18 \n1 \nMR. EDWARDS: Well, Your Honor, as I understand \n2 \nthis -- and correct me if I'm wrong, anybody -- this \n3 \nnon-prosecution agreement provides for a dismissal or \n4 \nimmunity for other individuals, and I think these are the \n5 \nindividuals that we are talking about. But all of that is \n6 \ninextricably intertwined within this agreement, and it is \n7 \nthis agreement in its total form that is supposed to protect \n6 \nthe victims. I think that the victims have a right to know \n9 \nof these other individuals, who my clients were also familiar \n10 \nwith during the course of this conduct, and how it protects \n11 \nthem in this case. And I don't see why they should, once \n12 \nagain, get an incomplete version of this. Because these are \n13 \ncharacters that are very intertwined with the -- the -- with \n14 \nMr. Epstein's conduct. This is not completely and wholly \n15 \nindifferent or irrelevant conduct for some other people. \n16 \nThis is all part of the same conduct, and I think that's \n17 \nprobably necessary for us to evaluate the effect of this \n18 \nagreement and whether or not we're going to continue to \n19 \npursue this case. \n20 \nTHE COURT: All right. So you're assuming that the \n21 \nagreement also provides that the Government will not \n22 \nprosecute these other individuals? That's what your \n23 \nassumption is? \n24 \nMR. EDWARDS: Yes, Your Honor. \n25 \nTHE COURT: Do you have any information to -- upon \nEFTA00204953\n", "char_count": 1438}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Page 19 \n1 \nwhich you make that conclusion, or is that just an \n2 \nassumption? \n3 \nMR. EDWARDS: That is all just, you know, the \n4 \ndiscussions that we've had with various individuals, law \n5 \nenforcement, clients, things like that. And putting it \n6 \ntogether, that's what we believe is a portion of this \n7 \nagreement. /f /'m wrong about that, one of the U.S. \nAttorneys on the phone can probably correct me. But that's \n9 \nmy belief. \n10 \nTHE COURT: All right. Well, assume they're just \n11 \nmentioned in the agreement in some way. And I'm not sure how \n12 \nor why they would be mentioned. But assume they're mentioned \n13 \nin the agreement, but there's no agreement by the Government \n14 \nnot to prosecute them. Is there any reason for you to have \n15 \ntheir names if it's other than for the purpose of finding out \n16 \nthe extent to which the Government has agreed not to \n17 \nprosecute Mr. Epstein and other individuals? \n18 \nMR. EDWARDS: That's a tough question for me to \n19 \nanswer without knowing in what context those individuals are \n20 \nlisted. However, I just renew my previous argument that / do \n21 \nbelieve they're intertwined, and I think that, once again, if \n22 \nwe get a version of this plea agreement without the portions \n23 \nthat pertain to these other individuals, then we could \n24 \npossibly be in the same position where we are not sure as to \n25 \nthe full extent of the protection allowed under this \nEFTA00204954\n", "char_count": 1442}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Page 20 \n1 \nagreement. That would be -- without knowing how they're \n2 \nmentioned, I can't voice any other objection to not getting \n3 \nthose portions but I could certainly foresee where, you know, \n4 \nwe're not going to get out of it what we're asking. \n5 \nTHE COURT: All right. Well, again, I didn't \n6 \nunderstand the Government to want to redact the entire \n7 \nprovisions that relate to these individuals. I understood \nB \nthat they just wanted to redact their names. \n9 \nAm I correct, Ms. \n10 \nMS. \n: Yes. \n11 \nTHE COURT: Okay. So if you were given the \n12 \nagreement with these names redacted but you saw the context \n13 \nin which they were listed, and then, after seeing the \n14 \nagreement and the context in which their names were \n15 \nmentioned, if it presented a problem to you that they were \n16 \nbeing withheld, couldn't you then just, you know, file \n17 \nanother motion for disclosure of the names after you've had \n18 \nan opportunity to, you know, evaluate whether or not there's \n19 \nany real need for you to get these names? \n20 \nMR. EDWARDS: Okay. We could do that at that time, \n21 \nYour Honor. \n22 \nTHE COURT: All right. Anything else that anybody \n23 \nwants to add to what -- our discussion? \n24 \nMR. EDWARDS: One more thing, Your Honor. This is \n25 \nBrad Edwards. \nEFTA00204955\n", "char_count": 1299}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Page 21 \n1 \nSame topic. My clients are currently in a position \n2 \nwhere they may be speaking to local law enforcement regarding \n3 \ncertain issues pertaining to this case, and if we are unable \n4 \nto have access to the other named people in this agreement, \n5 \nit may put them at a disadvantage in terms of whether or not \n6 \nit would be in their benefit to speak with other law \n7 \nenforcement about this case. I mean, certainly if there's \n8 \nindividuals who have been given immunity in this agreement, \n9 \nthen it would only be to the disadvantage of my clients to \n10 \ncontinue to try to pursue criminal charges. \n11 \nSo in that regard, that would be my only objection \n12 \nto not having the names of these other individuals. \n13 \nTHE COURT: All right. Well, again, you're \n14 \nassuming that there's some kind of immunity or deferral of \n15 \nprosecution --\n16 \nMR. EDWARDS: That's correct. \n17 \nTHE COURT: -- given to people other than \n18 \nMr. Epstein, correct? \n19 \nMR. EDWARDS: That's correct. \n20 \nTHE COURT: Okay. And that's something that would \n21 \nbe clear once you got the agreement and you read it, and if \n22 \nthe names were -- you know, if that was apparent in the \n23 \nagreement, then you could come back and ask me to require the \n24 \ndisclosure of the names. \n25 \nMR. EDWARDS: Okay. That sounds fair. \nEFTA00204956\n", "char_count": 1335}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Page 22 \n1 \nTHE COURT: All right. Mr. Lee or Ms. \n2 \ndid you have anything else you wanted to add? \n3 \nMS. \n: Well, Your Honor, I guess I will \n4 \njust tell the Court this. It does indeed contain language \n5 \nrelated to that issue. So I don't know if you want to make \n6 \nMr. Edwards jump through that hurdle or if you want to make \n7 \nthat decision now. \n8 \nTHE COURT: All right. So you're telling me that \n9 \nthere is some language in the agreements that does obligate \n10 \nthe Government to not prosecute individuals other than \n11 \nMr. Epstein? \n12 \nMS. \n: Correct. \n13 \nTHE COURT: All right. So if that's true, why \n14 \nshould the victims not know who those people are? \n15 \nMS. \n: Your Honor, I guess my concern \n16 \nreally relates to disclosure. And if your protective \n17 \norder -- or I don't know if you need a written protective \n18 \norder or an ore tenus order, limit Mr. Edwards to disclosing \n19 \nit only to his clients and to his co-counsel, then I don't \n20 \nthink that we would have a basis to object. \n21 \nTHE COURT: Again, with the right for them to come \n22 \nback and ask for the ability to disclose it beyond that \n23 \nlimited group at a later time after Mr. Epstein has an \n24 \nopportunity to be heard? \n25 \nMS. \n: Right. \nEFTA00204957\n", "char_count": 1257}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Page 23 \n1 \nTHE COURT: Again, Mr. Edwards, do you have any \n2 \nproblem with that procedure, you know, you're permitted to \n3 \ndisclose -- the names of these individuals who are also \n4 \ngetting the benefit of a non-prosecution agreement would be \n5 \ndisclosed to you under the terms of the protective order \n6 \nwithout prejudice to you being able to, in any litigation \n7 \nthat ensues, seeking to disclose it beyond the limited group? \n8 \nMR. EDWARDS: No, Your Honor, that's fine. \n9 \nTHE COURT: All right. Well, then I'm going to \n10 \norder the Government to produce the agreement and any addenda \n11 \nto Mr. Epstein -- Mr. Edwards in this case, and it would be \n12 \navailable also to any other individuals who have been \n13 \nidentified by the United States as victims in connection with \n14 \nthe investigation of Mr. Epstein, subject to a protective \n15 \norder. Which, I'm going to ask the parties to try and work \n16 \non the language of a protective order to submit to me that \n17 \nwould prohibit disclosure to anyone other than Mr. -- to the \n18 \nvictim, or victims' counsel, without prejudice to the victims \n19 \nseeking the ability to disclose it beyond that limited group \n20 \nafter Mr. Epstein has an opportunity to be heard on further \n21 \ndisclosure. \n22 \nMR. EDWARDS: Okay. Thank you, Your Honor. \n23 \nMR. LEE: This is Dexter Lee. \n24 \nVery well, Your Honor. We appreciate your time. \n25 \nTHE COURT: All right. So is there any questions \nEFTA00204958\n", "char_count": 1462}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Page 24 \n1 \nabout it? Is there anything unclear about what I'm ordering? \n2 \nAnd I'm also -- okay. And the names of the --\n3 \nthere will be no redaction in the agreements, but any victim \n4 \nhas to -- who gets notice of this has to agree to be bound by \n5 \nthe protective order until further order of the Court. \n6 \nMS. \n: Your Honor, this is Marie \n7 \n8 \nJust to be clear, we are not under an obligation to \n9 \nadvise the victims of this, but if the victim asks for a copy \n10 \nof the document, this is the procedure that we'll follow? \n11 \nTHE COURT: Well, I'm not going to tell you whether \n12 \nyou have any obligation under the Act to disclose this or \n13 \nnot. I don't want to get into that. I don't know that you \n14 \ndo, but I don't want to say that you don't. So if you have \n15 \nan independent obligation to disclose this to victims under \n16 \nthe Act, then -- then I'm not telling you not to do it. \n17 \nMS. \n: Okay. But your order isn't \n18 \nordering us to do it. We will have to make our evaluation. \n19 \nTHE COURT: I'm only ordering it to be available to \n20 \nvictims, and the -- and then you have to decide whether \n21 \nyou're obligated under the Act to disclose it to anyone else \n22 \nwho falls into that category. \n23 \nMS. \n: Okay. Thank you, Your Honor. \n24 \nTHE COURT: All right. Thank you. \n25 \nVOICES: Thank you, Your Honor. \nEFTA00204959\n", "char_count": 1359}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Page 25 \n1 \nTHE COURT: Have a good day. \n2 \n(Proceedings concluded.) \n3 \n* * * * * \n4 \nCERTIFICATE \n5 \nI, Stephen W. Franklin, Registered Merit Reporter, and \n6 \nCertified Realtime Reporter, certify that the foregoing is a \n7 \ncorrect transcript from the record of proceedings in the \n8 \nabove-entitled matter. \n9 \nDated this 20th day of AUGUST, 2008. \n10 \n11 \nStephen W. Franklin, RMR, CRR \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nEFTA00204960\n", "char_count": 461}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Page 26 \n.4\nablde(1) 5:16 \nability (3) 6:9 112223:19 \nabk. \n5:10 17:11 236 \naboteonlided (1) 25:8 \nabseni 1 ) 7-23 \nmea 46i 8.14 15:724 171.921:4 \naccurately 11/ 119 \nAct Ili 10:1I 24:12.16.21 \nsalos131 6:11 79 8:13 \nadd I31 9:4 2023 22:2 \naddeods(41 12:1514:10.1823:10 \naddtoder01) 1123 \nadditional15) 2:22,243:6.13425 \nadtunev 121 113,7 \nadttre 111 249 \nadtbing 11) 63 \naliern000 (61123.11.12.157:25 \nague 121 117 24:4 \nagiord 121 13:719:16 \namonnest 17213:12102223 4:1.6.12.18.20.21 \n4:23 5:6.15 6:8.12.14 7:P.2021.226:3.5.20 \n9:11.14 10233.131721 116.10.1621.24 \n123.12.15.16.17 13:3.5.12.12 14:9.10.1124 \n15:9.10.14 17:8183.6.7.18.21 16:7.11.13.13 \n19:22 20:1.12.14 213..9.21.2123:4.10 \naztletneot4(41 16:12 17:222924:3 \nalleged()) 13:2114:2115:19 \nalloited 11) 6:16 \nallow 131 4:178:14 14:17 \nallowed III 19:25 \n.4%11(05(4111 1:6 \namount 016415 \nAnn li 1:17 \nanswer ill 16:1719:19 \nanybody 141 15:1.9 18:22022 \napologize(I)9:8 \nanonym III 21:22 \nappartmly 111 13:2 \napptur 121 1712 \nappearances (2) 1:142:6 \napprwLile (2) 2:201124 \nappropriate 15) 4:16 5:24 51114:1 17:13 \nargue (I)10:16 \nargues{ (II 1910 \nasked (114:14 \naddse 144 3:24 4:1612:17 13:22 1621 20:4 \nasks (I) 249 \nAsOnsot 111 113 \nsouse (3) 15:1719:10.12 \nsomidoit13) 14:17 18:2021:14 \nsourapilto 121 18:23192 \nattached 11111:16 \naitempl (1) 3:16 \n&Hemphill) 8:7 \n&Homey14) 2:143:1511:6 12:1 \naltnentla11) 7:416 1020 12:1.4 15:12 19:8 \nAngus:41211125:9 \nAUSA (2) 1:17.17 \navailable (5) 9:1415:18 16:14Z:1224:19 \n*awe43)9:22 12:61127 \n■\nback (21 212322722 \nbased (Z) 3:1 13:19 \nbasin 111 22:20 \nIleadb 121 1.7.20 \nbegins°, 6:21 \nbegun II; 6 23 \nbehalf ;SI 2 s67 7:8.13 14:72 \nbelief (I) 199 \nbrlInt \n3:118:13.16 10721 119 12:14 13:25 \n19:6.21 \nbomb( (4) 13:5.11 21:623:4 \nbest II) 4:13 \nW90=111116:10 132.15 14:6 15:222516:13 \n22:22 23:7.19 \n141116:15 \nNadu) 11:11 \nlanding (9)1022 11:17 11513:3.6 \nhill) 924 \nbond 131 8:1 105 246 \nBrad 15124 3:10 119 11620:25 \nBradley111 1:15 \nMUNI 16:23 \nMali* 0) 1721 \nC(1) 1:17 \n148(3) 2:1 1 1\n... [truncated, 8529 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00204936/25 or ?id=EFTA00204936&page=25]", "char_count": 8529}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00204936", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Page 27 \nMedl (I) 753 \npilot 12) 3:3.14 \nmiatitea) 14:19 \nmodkats(1) 44 \nØ \n(I) 11:24 \nnx.48188(271 1019 11 R \n194410981) 2:25 20 17 \nN \nname(1) 7:12 \nname411) 21:4 \nnasa <NR 93.11.11 1693 1/:1.9.15.17.17 19:13 \n201.12.14.17.19 21:122224 23:124:2 \nnear (II 6:19 \nnasuaril)'<l) 9:20 \nnetemary (1)111:11 \n•,a5 11112:22 3:6.138:15 1915129 16:3.25 \n17:3291922:17 \nneeda \n2:24 \nnealiaied (I) 11:21 \nnlzbt tal 10.1911:8 \nno9prowt8tIcen (5)93.5 1 1:12 182 234 \nnoti« (4) 10.1 11:1915:204,4 \nntwitlestkm III 13:25 \nmAilits1 i 11 16:10 \nlimit, Ill 8:6 \nneia« Ill 23 \nO \n8191111 22:20 \nbinda 13) 17:11202 21:11 \nilie<doem(I) \n~le III 219 \nbials (2) 721 24:21 \n*PR« (3) 24:8.12.15 \n1444411~) (I/ 9:13 \n1918497 a112:11 17:5 \noreurrt4 (1111:4 \n/tana) 11:23 \nOIRna) 15:13 \nPlatt (1)1:19 \nokay II81 281:2.10 916 10:14 11:14 14:2.14 \n158 2011.1/21:20.25 23:22 24:2.1723 \nouve (3) 18:11 19:21 21:21 \n0414989 (I/ 1122 \n0119819•115 171 10:13 149 15:1 16:220182224 \n23:20 \notte ØR 2:1.21.241:234:15 5:147:238:3.10.23 \n9:6 106 12:20 13:7.21 14:21.23 156.16.24 \n16:1.12 22:17.18.18233.10.15.16 24:53.17 \n(9441188(4) 15:84:1.18.19 \nmr 11122:18 \n01119841(I) 123 \nustrobdiellif151 5:21 \nP \nPACER (I/ 15:7 \nNam (2)14.20 \nputl (6) 3:20 11:22 112.16 13:21 18:16 \npartia (61223231:1 MI 13:1623:15 \nPal (21 1:132:10 \npasse11)1623 \npendime(2) 2:25 15:25 \npapir 141 13:10 i&1518:15 2191772:14 \npeamminit (I) 11:8 \nutmål ai 13:11 15:21 \npenali(ed II) 23:2 \nperson 111 15:18 \nperla). ( I1 19:23 \nP91418186(1)213 \nPttition4r <2) 14.15 \nPnition4.912) 8:9 12:21 \n»olm III 19:8 \nPhinIIITR12) 2:25 3:5 \nøm 111 52 \nP141(1)6:15 \nplea 1151 2:202143.18.20.21 92212:12.15.16 \n12:17 11:12 14:9 15:9 19:22 \nnase 12) 2:6.7 \n994(1)9:12 \npob81131 3:182.14:1.4.176:19.20 11:12 15:4.8 \n16:4.7 17:22 \nPall« (7/ 10:17.21.22.24 11:9.1] 196 \nParleer (71 1:19 11:15 12:4.23133 19:22 201 \npaIllee 191 3:5 4:10 1:228:21 11:15 12:1417:23 \n1924 2 I:1 \nP91488 (1119.4 \npoiadial (1113:20 \npred(814 (2)8:11 16:20 \nP4414r \n5:11 \nprePolict ill 134.18 \nprellenlaary \n... [truncated, 7061 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00204936/26 or ?id=EFTA00204936&page=26]", "char_count": 7061}]}