{"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_count": 57, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00144344", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00144344.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "MARSH \nLAW FIRM \nJENNIFER FREEMAN, ESQ \nNew York, New York 10001 \nMay 2, 2023 \nThe Honorable Christopher Wray \nDirector \nFederal Bureau of Investigation \nMichael E. Horowitz \nInspector General \nU.S. Department of Justice \nWashington, D.C. 20535 \nWashington, D.C. 20530 \nThe Honorable Merrick B. Garland \nAttorney General \nU.S. De artment of ustice \nNW \nWashington, D.C. 20530 \nVia Email and US. Mail \nDear Director Wray, Inspector General Horowitz, and Attorney General \nGarland: \nAs counsel to many survivors of the Jeffrey Epstein sex trafficking conspiracy, \nwe write regarding the failure of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) to \nproperly, adequately, or timely investigate the sex trafficking of hundreds of \ngirls and young women. The FBI utterly failed to investigate serious \nallegations involving Epstein's, and perhaps others, child sex abuse materials \n(CSAM), significant additional criminality which, until recently, has been \ndisregarded, disrespected, and essentially denied. \nAs detailed below, in August of 1996 one of our clients, \nS \nreported \nto the FBI that Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell had sexually abused her and \nthat the two of them, together with others, were committing multiple, serious, \nsexual abuse crimes, including hands-on sexual abuse, against minors and \n1 \nEFTA00144344\n", "char_count": 1316}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "vulnerable young women. In addition, she reported to the FBI that Epstein, \nand perhaps others, appeared to be engaged in the production, possession, \nand distribution of sexually suggestive or exploitative images of children that \ncould constitute CSAM. See Exhibits (Exs.) 1, 2, and 3. \nIn 2005, child erotica was found in Epstein's Palm Beach home. In \napproximately 2008, law enforcement \"prematurely\" truncated their \ninvestigation of Epstein's computer hard drives which had been suspiciously \nremoved from his Palm Beach estate immediately before a police raid. See \ninfra p. 7. In 2019, more child erotica was found displayed in Epstein's \nproperties, with additional images located in his home safe. See infra p. 9. \nRecently, for the first time. Epstein's possible connection to CSAM has been \nacknowledged - in ongoing federal litigation in New York, the Epstein Estate \nalerted the parties and the court about the possible existence of CSAM among \nimages the Estate just discovered. Exs. 4 and 5. Last week, it was revealed that \nEpstein maintained government contacts at the highest level, including \nWilliam Burns, director of the Central Intelligence Agency, who had three \nmeetings scheduled with Epstein in 2014. Jeffrey Epstein's Private Calendar: \nCIA Director William Burns. Goldman Sachs's Top Lawyer. Noam Chomsky - \nWSl. \nAs detailed below, in response to Ms. \nclear-eyed, prescient report, \nand despite subsequent repeated red flags that Epstein trafficked girls and \ncollected sexualized images of children, the FBI appears, for years, to have \ndone little to investigate and prosecute Epstein's sex trafficking, and, to date, \ndone nothing regarding reports of possible CSAM. \nIn order to ensure the fair and equitable dispensation of justice and \naccountability, we call on the FBI, the Department of Justice, and the Attorney \nGeneral to conduct a comprehensive investigation to determine why there was \nand remains such abject failure to timely investigate, expose, and p\n... [truncated, 2275 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/1 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=1]", "char_count": 2275}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Law Enforcement Ignored Ms. \n1996 Report to the FBI of \nEpstein's Possible CSAM Crimes and Sex Trafficking Conspiracy -\nWhy? \nIn 1995, Ms. \na struggling artist and recent graduate from \ntook a job working for billionaire Epstein. After purchasing \none of her paintings for several thousand dollars, Epstein told Ms. \nthat \nhe wanted her to be an \"art scour for his collection. This position expanded to \nclerical work in Epstein's mansion. Over the course of several months in 1996, \nMs. \nwitnessed young girls going in and out of Epstein's New York \nmansion, modeling agency representatives present at the house, and Ghislaine \nMaxwell \"scouting\" for new children who Epstein was purportedly also \nfinancially \"helping:' Ms. \nalso witnessed images of what appeared to \nbe children in what was described to her as a \"modeling book\" kept in \nEpstein's safe. At first, Ms. \naccepted what sounded like innocent \njustifications for these activities. \nDuring the summer of 1996, at Epstein's behest, Ms. \nworked as an \nartist in residence at Epstein's home in Ohio. When Epstein and Maxwell \nvisited Ms. \nin Ohio for a few days, they sexually abused her. Shocked \nand deeply shaken, she realized, when they left, that some photographs from \nher private collection, which were all numbered and in her possession in Ohio, \nwere missing, including photographs of her partially dressed 11-year-old \nsister. She then became concerned that Epstein and Maxwell had other \nsexually inappropriate images, whether in Epstein's safe or elsewhere, and \nthat they were engaged in other unlawful activities. Ms. \nleftend \nwhen she returned to New York, confronted Epstein and Maxwell and \ndemanded the return of her personal photographs. Epstein and Maxwell \nretaliated against her by threatening to physically harm her and set all of her \nartwork on fire. \nDeathly afraid, on August 29, 1996, Ms. \nreported in detail Epstein's \nand Maxwell's criminality to her local police department, the NYPD \nThe NYPD said that whi\n... [truncated, 2136 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/2 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=2]", "char_count": 2136}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "occurring outside their jurisdiction, such as the abuse and theft perpetrated in \nOhio, and other illegal activities. They directed Ms. \nto report these \nalle ations to the FBI. See Ex. 1 (NYPD Police Report Complaint \nated 8/29/96) - \" I \nI states...[Epstein] did call her and \nstate he was going to burn victim's painting and send her polaroids of the \nburnt paintings. [Epstein] has keys to victim's apartment:'). Following the \nNYPD's instructions, and at that time believing that the wrongdoing would be \naddressed, Ms. \nimmediately contacted the FBI to report her wider \ncriminal complaint concerning Epstein and others. \nMs. \nconfirmed her reporting of the Epstein conspiracy to the FBI in a \n1997 entry in her personal journal: \n(lite Litt, \n• tisiontlegote \n;11\n1 \nS / \n&I t%\nltivne`o \nLat \nafr \nzseethi \n7,5; \nttl, al/ttna \n1,141, 91A /116tiO i,i4L 4(2( \nerc j-wm Lfrtegn (.71 :to \nPS \n1 , \nEx. 2 (Journal title page and excerpt). \n*** \nMs. \n1996 report of the Epstein sex trafficking conspiracy and CSAM \nallegations was confirmed by the FBI in field notes of a 2006 meeting between \nMs. \nand the agency, which was the first time she heard from the FBI \nafter her original report. The FBI notes specifically stated that Ms. \nhad \npreviously reported Epstein to the NYPD Sixth Precinct who advised her to \ncontact the FBI. \n4 \nEFTA00144347\n", "char_count": 1350}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "1\n.e.cft(1 diglitta — \nHr e..;&x... \nrigs-- \n• • • \nExcerpt of hand-marked page 19 of FBI redacted notes of 11/14/06 meeting \nwith Ms. \nregarding Epstein (\"6th precinct told MF to call FBI\") in Ex. 3 \n(FBI redacted notes in full).1 The FBI agents acknowledged their awareness of \nMs. \n1996 report to the FBI about Epstein, stating that they tracked \nher down because of that earlier report. \nMs. \nreport of Epstein's sex trafficking and apparent CSAM crimes \nshould have surprised no one who took the time to investigate. Indeed, it is \ncommonplace for sexual abusers to use CSAM to normalize sexual conduct and \ngroom victims. See, e.g., Understanding Grooming Tactics (rehope.org). \nTerrified and alone, and cognizant that the institutions that should have \nprotected her failed to do so, Ms. \nmoved out of New York City, and \neventually out of the New York region, to escape Epstein's and Maxwell's \nabuse and threats. \nIt Took a Decade for Federal Law Enforcement to Take Any Action \nAgainst Epstein Gifted Epstein the Deal of a Lifetime, and Conferred \nFree Reign on Epstein to Continue Sex Trafficking and Producing \nSexually Suggestive Images of Girls and Young Women - Why? \nTen years after Ms. \ninitial report, federal authorities appeared to take \na renewed interest in investigating Epstein which turned out to be nothing \nmore than a paper tiger distraction. \nI Over the past several months, we have repeatedly sought unredacted co ies of the FBI's \nnotes which presumably reveal more, and any prior notes from Ms. \nearlier report \nto the FBI. To date, no substantive response has been provided. \nEFTA00144348\n", "char_count": 1622}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "From 2005 to 2008, dozens of survivors, including Ms. \npresented \nsubstantial evidence to the FBI of Epstein's sex trafficking and sexually \ninappropriate images of children. \nAs noted above, on November 11, 2006, two FBI agents, without warning, \nknocked on the door of Ms. \nthen-home in North Carolina and met \nwith Ms. \nfor hours. She again explained her deep, specific concerns \nabout the ongoing Epstein sex trafficking conspiracy and CSAM allegations. See \nEx. 3 (spanning over 20 pages of meeting notes). \nWhen the Palm Beach police raided Epstein's home in 2005, they found \"naked \npictures of teenage girls:' VIDEO: Inside Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach home: \nWhat the victims saw (palmbeachpost.com). At least one 14-year-old survivor \ntold law enforcement that she had been photographed in the nude. See Report \nof the Department of Justice Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR \nReport). https://www.washingtonpost.comicontext/read-the-report-\ninvestigation-into-the-u-s-attorney-s-office-for-the-southern-district-of-\nflorida-s-resolution-of-its-2006-2008-federal-criminal-investigation-of-\njeffrey-epstein-and-its-interactions-with-victims-during-the-\ninvestigation/db9373e8-22f8-4712-b4a7-be844d162de0/, p. iv. \nAs acknowledged in the OPR Report, law enforcement knew or had reason to \nbelieve that Epstein \"had surveillance cameras stationed in and around his \nhome\" and \"used hidden cameras in his New York residence to record his \nsexual encounters:' OPR Report, pp. 175-79. It was known that Epstein's \n\"computers might have contained child pornography\" and, with his \"multi-\nstate lifestyle[,] it was reasonable to assume that [there was possible] \ninterstate transmission of child pornography...that could have changed the \nentire complexion of the case against Epsteinf OPR Report, p. 176. \nSix computer hard drives were suspiciously missing from Epstein's Florida \nhome just before a police raid--leaving dangling wires attached to monitors--\nwhich Epstein's attorneys refu\n... [truncated, 2214 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/5 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=5]", "char_count": 2214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "drives while law enforcement again turned a blind eye to allegations of \npossible CSAM crimes. See OPR Report, pp. iv, 45-47, 60-61, 70. As the OPR \nReport explained, the U.S. Attorney \"resolved the federal investigation before \nsignificant investigative steps were taken,\" and the investigation ended \n\"prematurely\" OPR Report, p. x. \nInstead, Epstein and his team of high paid lawyers and private investigators \nsought to shift blame onto the victims, gaslighting them as prostitutes, drug \naddicts, and liars. Amazingly, despite a plethora of evidence of a far-reaching \nconspiracy to traffic women, and numerous red flags concerning possible \nCSAM, federal law enforcement stood by silently and didn't take action. OPR \nReport, pp. 11, 15, 147; see also \nhttps://www.palmbeachpost.com/story/news/2020/12/03/prosecutor-\njeffrey-epsteins-victims-im-sorry-deal-labeled-you-prostitutes/3 812499001/ \n(AUSA told an appeals court that it was \"unfortunate\" that the non-\nprosecution agreement had the effect of \"labeling teenage girls as prostitutes \ninstead of victims of sexual assault\"); FBI Records: The Vault — Jeffrey Epstein \nPart 17 of 22 (FBI file rife with what appear to be reams of victim \n\"biographical information\" and MySpace details). Meanwhile, consistent with \nwell-known practices of sex traffickers, Epstein continued trafficking, raping, \nabusing, and collecting sexualized images of women and girls, including some \nof our clients. See OPR Report, p. 44. \nIn 2008, the federal government agreed to a secret, controversial non-\nprosecution agreement (NPA) with Epstein which only required him to plead \nto rather minor state-law crimes and purportedly \"immunized\" his known and \nunknown co-conspirators. \nhttps://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6184602-Jeffrey-Epstein-non-\nprosecution-agreement. Epstein served only 13 months in a Palm Beach \n\"country club\" county jail with daily releases to his home-office. Nothing in the \nagreement obliged him to stop engaging in sex trafficki\n... [truncated, 2247 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/6 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=6]", "char_count": 2247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Our client, \nalong with other survivors were trafficked at the \nvery same time that the FBI was purportedly investigating Epstein. \nAlthough the Office of Professional Responsibility later examined actions of \nthe Florida federal attorney-prosecutors during that time period, the actions \nof the FBI were not scrutinized. \nIt is not known who in or about this time period had access to and removed \nEpstein's hard drives from his Palm Beach home, where else those hard drives \nmight have been located, what those hard drives contained, and where those \nhard drives are today. \nThe FBI Did Little or Nothing to Prosecute Epstein For an \nAdditional Decade - Why? \nAfter the slap-on-the-wrist sentence, Epstein and others continued their \ncriminal enterprise, while the FBI did little more for another decade. Further \naction against Epstein and his co-conspirators was taken only --\n• after Ms. \nand other survivors complained again to \nlaw enforcement and engaged in substantial efforts working \nwith non-FBI law enforcement; \n• after lengthy prosecution of federal civil litigation alleging \nthe NPA violated the Crime Victims Rights Act guarantees \nand a federal court determination that the failure to notify \nvictims and the NPA violated the Act; E.g., Doe v. United \nStates, 359 F. Supp.3d 1201 (S.D. Fla. 2019); \n• after numerous journalists kept reporting the story; and \n• after numerous other private lawsuits and other efforts \nsought to bring this conspiracy to light and still do so. E.g., \nane Doe v. Epstein, (2009) (579 F. Supp.3d (S.D.N.Y 2012)); \nv. Maxwell, Case No. 1-15-cv-07433-LAP (S.D.N.Y. \ncomplaint filed 2015); Jane Doe 1 v. Deutsche Bank et al., 22-\ncv-10018 (S.D.N.Y. 2022). \nIt was not until approximately 2019 that the federal government finally \nprosecuted first Epstein and then Maxwell regarding the sex trafficking \nconspiracy. The FBI's repeated and continual failures, delays, and inaction \n8 \nEFTA00144351\n", "char_count": 1942}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "allowed Epstein and others to continue their sex trafficking conspiracy \nfor nearly a quarter of a century. See OPR Report, pp. 27 n.38, 33, 44. \nUnfortunately, Ms. \n1996 report regarding Epstein's sex trafficking \nand sexually concerning images proved to be spot on. In 2019 -- just as Ms. \nhad reported to the FBI years decades earlier -- Epstein was charged \nwith sex trafficking while sexually suggestive images of young girls were in \nfact found in a safe in Epstein's New York mansion. According to the SDNY \nprosecutors' memorandum seeking to deny Epstein bail, the 2019 search of \nEpstein's mansion unearthed a \"'vast trove of lewd photographs' of young-\nlooking girls, including hundreds of meticulously labeled nude pictures locked \nin a safe:\" Jeffrey Epstein: Inside billionaire's New York mansion \n(usatoday.com).  \"CDs in the safe had hand-written labels, including 'Young \n[Name] + [Name]; 'Mist nudes 1, and 'Girl pies nude\"' Feds found 'vast trove' of \nnude photos in Jeffrey Epstein's safe (nypost.com) See also Evidence from \nJeffrey Epstein's safe 'went missing' after FBI raid. court hears in Ghislaine \nMaxwell trial (telegraph.co.uk): Ghislaine Maxwell trial: Photos of underage \ngirls in Jeffrey Epstein's home entered as evidence (nbcnews.com). \nHad law enforcement taken even minimal action to respond to Ms. \nand others' 2006, 2008, 2011, and other reports, more sex trafficking and \nlikely CSAM crimes could have been avoided. \nIt is not known if at least some of the materials, such as the labeled nude \nphotographs that were locked in Epstein's New York safe, were among those \nreported by Ms. \nin 1996. \nLaw Enforcement Gave Epstein a Hall Pass for What Appears to Be \nOne of the Largest and Longest Sex Trafficking and Alleged CSAM \nConspiracies in our Lifetime - Why? \nCuriously, Epstein was known and tied to federal authorities for decades, often \nin connection with suspicious and illegal activities. In 1981, Epstein reportedly \nleft Bear Stearns abruptly after c\n... [truncated, 2217 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/8 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=8]", "char_count": 2217}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Towers Financial who was prosecuted and imprisoned for bilking investors \nout of over $450 million in a Ponzi scheme that was then the largest financial \nfraud in American history. Hoffenberg, Epstein's business partner, went to jail \nbut not Epstein. Instead of prosecution, in 1992, the U.S. State Department \nrented Epstein a luxurious townhouse in New York City that had been seized \nfrom the Iranian government. The State Department Once Rented A \nTownhouse Seized From Iran To Jeffrey Epstein — Then Sued Him For \nSubletting It (buzzfeednews.com) \nThere has been rampant speculation for years that Epstein was a confidential \ninformant. Only recently, a new \"trove of papers\" has revealed that \"William \nBurns, director of the Central Intelligence Agency since 2021, had three \nmeetings scheduled with Epstein in 2014 when he was deputy secretary of \nstate..:' Jeffrey Epstein's Private Calendar: CIA Director William Burns, \nGoldman Sachs's Top Lawyer. Noam Chomsky - WSJ. Epstein told colleagues \nand friends that he was an intelligence asset. Andrew's Fixer: She's the \nDaughter of Robert Maxwell and She's Manipulating His Jetset Lifestyle \nfunlimitedhangout.com), Epstein has been connected with many high-level \ngovernment and business elites who accompanied him on multiple trips on \nthe \"Lolita Express\" to the island of \"Little St. Jeffs\" and elsewhere but these \nindividuals have not been the subject of scrutiny. The FBI closed a forfeiture \nproceeding against Epstein, noting \"Epstein... has provided information to the \nFBI as agreed upon:' leffrey Epstein Part 06 of 08.pdf (last page). There is \nstrong circumstantial evidence in the public domain that Epstein's special \nrelationship with the government explains the FBI's failure to investigate or \nprosecute Epstein in 1996, the special treatment he received from 2005 to \n2008, and the failure to investigate the possible wrongdoing of important \npublic officials and powerful businessmen. \nThe Epstein Estate Recently Alerte\n... [truncated, 2328 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/9 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=9]", "char_count": 2328}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "In a stipulated motion dated March 27, 2023, as part of a lawsuit brought by \nthe Virgin Islands against JP MorganChase concerning the bank's financing of \nEpstein's activities, the parties advised the federal district court that the \nEpstein Estate had on March 14, 2023 discovered new videos and \nphotographs (the Epstein Media). Government of the United States Virgin \nIslands v. JPMorgan Chase Bank N.A., Case No. 1:22:cv-10904-JSR, Stipulated \nMotion dated March 27, 2023, Ex. 4. The Epstein Estate expressly recognized \nthe danger of serious criminal and civil liability attendant to possessing or \ndistributing the Epstein Media which might contain CSAM. \nThe Estate...advised counsel for the Government and Jane Doe1 of its \nconcern that some of the Epstein Media might contain child sex abuse \nimagery (\"CSAM\"). The knowing accessing, possession, or distribution \nor CSAM is forbidden by federal law. See 18 U.S.C. §§ 2252, 2252A. The \nEstate has expressed concern that its counsel's review of the Epstein \nMedia could subject counsel to criminal investigation or charges or civil \nclaims.... \nEx. 4 (footnote omitted). The parties prepared a stipulated motion to \n\"[p]rovide the Epstein Estate with an approved protocol for reviewing the \nEpstein Media for purposes of this litigation only without fear or criminal or \ncivil liability...and [p]rotect against disclosure or dissemination of CSAM...\" Ex. \n4. \nOn April 5, 2023, the federal district court issued an Order establishing such a \nprotocol, calling for the Estate to be on alert for CSAM. \nIf, during the course of that review [of images], the Estate sees a \nparticular recording that appears to contain possible CSAM, it shall \npromptly stop further review of that recording and notify the Federal \nBureau of Investigation (\"FBI\") or such other agency or entity as the FBI \nmay direct of the recording's existence. No CSAM shall be copied or \ntransmitted to another party, except as directed by the FBI or other \ngovernment. \n11 \n\n... [truncated, 2013 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/10 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=10]", "char_count": 2013}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Ex. 5. (Order April 5, 2023). It is telling that the Epstein Estate, the parties, \nand the Court believe it necessary to set up a CSAM protocol before \nEpstein media is reviewed. \nIt is not known if at least some of the Epstein Media contains what Ms. \nreported in 1996. Much like the hard drives that went missing in Palm Beach \nor the nude photographs locked in Epstein's New York safe, it is not known \nwho had access to the Epstein Media before the Court's Order, where else \nthose materials might have been located, and what those materials contained. \nAs to all three of these tranches of Epstein images, it is not known what the \nimplications might be as to such access, possession, and location, by persons \nother than Epstein. See United States v. Russell, 639 F.Supp.2d 226 (D. Conn \n2007) (attorney who took possession of laptop and destroyed hard drive \ncontaining CSAM indicted for obstruction of justice). \nThe FBI Must be Held Accountable for Failures Regarding Epstein -\njust as Was Done Regarding the Parkland Shooting, Nassar Sex \nAbuse, and Charleston Shooting \nIn 1996, federal law enforcement failed to investigate Ms. \n1996 \nreporting of the Epstein sex conspiracy. There should be no question that Ms. \nwho had never gone to law enforcement before, was credible and at \nleast deserved a modicum of attention. In 2008, the FBI cut off their \ninvestigation \"prematurely.\" To date, law enforcement still has not seriously \npursued possible CSAM crimes involving Epstein. Had law enforcement done \ntheir job, the Epstein trafficking and possible CSAM crimes could have been \nstopped. Had law enforcement taken even minimal action to respond to \nrepeated reports, many girls would never have been trafficked and the taking, \ndistribution or transportation of sexually exploitative images would have been \nsubstantially reduced. \nThe FBI's failure to seriously investigate Epstein and others is even more \negregious than its documented failures in the investigation of the Parkland \n\n... [truncated, 2251 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/11 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=11]", "char_count": 2251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "and Timeline Related to Parkland Shooting Investigation — FBI (House \nJudiciary Committee investigation). As the FBI explained regarding the \nParkland shooting, \"Under established protocols, the information provided by \nthe caller should have been assessed as a potential threat to life. The \ninformation then should have been forwarded to the FBI Miami Field Office \nwhere appropriate investigative steps would have been taken7 FBI Statement \non the Shooting in Parkland. Florida — FBI. As a result of the investigation of \nFBI failures, FBI employees were disciplined and Parkland victims were \ncompensated. Justice Department to Pay About $130 Million to Parkland \nShooting Victims - The New York Times (nytimes.com). \nIn the Nassar case, a federal investigation found that two FBI agents in \nIndianapolis committed \"fundamental errors\" for not acting sooner on \nallegations of abuse. The Inspector General investigated and released a report \nconcerning the FBI's failure to respond to the allegations of abuse \"with the \nutmost seriousness and urgency that they deserved and required\" and \nviolations of FBI policy. DOI OIG Releases Report of Investigation and Review \nof the FBI's Handling of Allegations of Sexual Abuse by Former USA \nGymnastics Physician Lawrence Gerard Nassar (justice.gov): Inspector \nGeneral Says F.B.I. Botched Nassar Abuse Investigation - The New York Times \n{nytimes.com). In response to claims filed against the government, additional \nreview of FBI failures is underway. \nAs to the Charleston Church massacre, a federal investigation demonstrated \nthat the FBI's lapses in background checks allowed the perpetrator, a self-\nproclaimed white supremacist who wanted to start a \"race-war,\" to buy the \nsemiautomatic weapon used in the shootings. In connection with the federal \ninvestigation, there have been changes in background check procedures, an \nappellate court ruled that the families of the survivors could seek redress from \nthe federal government, and the gove\n... [truncated, 2329 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/12 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=12]", "char_count": 2329}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Much like the Parkland, Nassar, and Charleston Church cases, government \nagencies have a responsibility to investigate and explain why the FBI failed --\nfor a quarter of a century -- to properly investigate Ms. \nand others' \nrepeated allegations of Epstein's abuse. Those failures allowed his sex \ntrafficking to continue unabated for decades. It is imperative that the Epstein \nallegations similarly be accorded the \"utmost seriousness and urgency that \nthey deserved and required\" and that the Epstein victims are also brought \n\"some modicum of justice.\" \nQuestions abound. What did the FBI do and not do to investigate Epstein? Why \nwas absolutely nothing done in response to Ms. \n1996 report of \nEpstein's and Maxwell's sex trafficking and CSAM concerns? Why were other \nrepeated early complaints about Epstein to law enforcement ignored? Was law \nenforcement pressured to limit and truncate the Epstein investigation? Was \nlaw enforcement directed to cut Epstein loose to protect powerful public \nofficials and businessmen who associated with Epstein or to protect Epstein's \nconfidential informant status? Why did law enforcement give Epstein a pass \non potential CSAM crimes by failing to obtain his computer equipment or by \nsuspending investigation? Are any such images, perhaps produced by Epstein, \ncurrently traded and available on the internet? Why haven't the actions and \ninactions of the FBI regarding Epstein been investigated? Even the Florida \nDepartment of Law Enforcement investigated and reported on state law \nenforcement's handling of Epstein's wrongdoing (Investigative Summary: \nWork Release I PDF I Prison I Criminal Record (scribd.com), but not the \nfederal government.) -- but to date federal law enforcement has utterly failed \nto do so. \nFor many years, the public has been asking for a reckoning by the FBI and the \nUnited States government for its clear dereliction of duty to serve and protect \nthe American people against the Epstein sex trafficking conspiracy. The\n... [truncated, 2423 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/13 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=13]", "char_count": 2423}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "no investigation of the FBI and certainly no public disclosure or explanation. \nEpstein's and Maxwell's victims, and the public at large, are owed a full \naccounting of the FBI many failures and missed opportunities. The American \npeople, the victims, and the survivors deserve the truth. \nWe hereby request that a full and fair investigation be promptly launched into \nthe FBI's seriously bungled examination and mismanagement of the crimes \ncommitted by Epstein and others. We look forward to your timely response. \nSincerely, \n15 \nEFTA00144358\n", "char_count": 547}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "EXHIBIT 1 \nEFTA00144359\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "...f\nel\"' \nMew Ink \nCity Police Department \nOmniform \nSystem \n- Complaints \nRain.,\nCrivel \n004 \nJunsdietion: \nN.Y. ',etre DEPT \nICAO*: Record Status: \nNo Suns \nComplaint 9: \n1516004007241 \nNo Other Legacy Blue \nVersions \nNo Other Complaint \nRevision* \nOccurrence \nLocation: STREET \nUntie Or Premise. \nCOMMERCIAL \nPremises Type. SUBBING \nLocation ?Ann OFFICE AREA. \nPremise. \nVisible By Patrol?: NO \nNYC Parks Dept. Property \nDid max arena. occur on NYC Parks Dept \nOrefienr \nCommand: \nNYC Parks Dept Property Name': \n\"Thant 006\nSector: H \nBeat 11 \nPost: 32 \nOccurrence From: 1996-07-11 12:00:00 \nOccurrence MTh 1 t16-0/-17 \n00 \nReported: 19•6-011-21 11-20 \nCallPlaiint Remmod: WALK-IN \nTHURSDAY \nCO 03 \n01 \nAided • \nAccident 0 \n0.C.C.B.\n \n• \nClassification: AGG HARRASSMENT \nAnempted/Completed. COMPT FEED \nMost Serious Offense NAI1 \nIs: \nPOCon: 439 AGGRAVATEDHARASSMENT \nPt Section: 24030 \n361 OF F. AGNST \nKeyooder a \n2M \n2 \nPUB CAD SENSBLEY \nCase Status: CLOSED \nUret Referred To: PATROL \nClearance Code. \nLog/Case v. 0 \nClearance Arrest Id \nClemente AO Cent \nFile s: \nPrints Requested? NO \nIs Ilks Related To Stop And Frisk Report \nNO \nSOF Number. \n0000.00000003 \nWas The Victim's Personal Information Taken Or Possessed? \nWas The Victim's Personal Information Used To \nCommit A Came? \nGang \nRelated? \nDetective Borough Wheel \nLog B \nNome Of Gang: \nChid Abuse Suspected? \nDIR Required? \nNO \nChild in Common? \nIntimate RidetIonship? \nOfficer Body Went C \n• \nIf Burglary: \nAlarm: \nIf Arson: \nTaxi Robbery: \nForced Entry? \nStructure: \nEntry Method: \nEntry Location. \nBypatsed7 \nComp \nResponded?: \nCompany \nNunalPhone: \nCrim Prevention \nSurvey NO \nRequested?. \nCompl Int/Roporter \nPresent?: \nStructure \nOccupied? \nDamage ay \nPartition Present: \nAmber Stress Light Actreated. \nMethod of Coma yanc• \nLocation of Pickup. \nSupervisor On Scene - Rank / Nemo f Command Genres Conducted. \nTranslate /0d used). \nNARRSTIOL \nWITNESS STATES. TAM) THE ABOVE MENTION 0 PERSON C40 CALL HER AND STATED HE WAS GOING \n... [truncated, 3199 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/16 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=16]", "char_count": 3199}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "M Mg Indicate Languages \nII \nI \nLocation \nAddrim \nSlahsrolmbY I,  \nApOloom \nHOME•PERMANENT\nSTREET MYC NEW YORK \n100140000 30 \nPeen..: HOML \neusmssIIIIMMIIIIIMI \nWANTED: #1 of 1 \nNam: \nEPSTEIN. JEFFERY \nComplainte: \n1996-006-007241 \nAmsted \nmcw44448444.4: \nWARM CET IN \nSec MALE \nWight - 204 \nRam. %MEM \nEye Crow. 14 Or \nAge: IS \nHair Casa-. GRAY \nDate Of BIM: - - \nHair Length SHORT \nU.S. Citizen: \nHas StM \nPlace Of BMA \nSkm Tone \nIs this minion not ProMitint in English?: \nComplexion \nIf V.. Indicate Language. \nAccent. \nOrder Of Protection: \nbinang Gime: \nDocket 0 \nExpiration Dale: \nOrder of Protection Violated? \nDom Suspect abuse Drugs I Alcohol? \nSuspect threatened /attempted suicide? \nIs the suspect Parole I Proestion? \nRelation to Mtn.. \nLiving together. \nCan be Identified: \nCsansperms AMbatiorr \nNanw. \nIdentifiers: \nt OCATKIN \nle(I3LIESS \nCITY STATESCOVH1RY ap APT/ROOM HOW LONQ? RES, PCT \nHOME-PERMANENT -NYC \nNEW YORK \n0 \n0 \nPhone • \nALY.C.KA. Resident: N.Y.C. Hosting Employe* On OM-\nDevelOpment: \nN.Y.C. TIMM Employes: \nPhysical Force: \nUsed Emma System: \nStation Entered: \nTime Entered: \nMetro Card Type: \nMetro Card Med/Poem: \nCard O. \nCRIME DATA DETAILS \nCLOTHING \nACCESSORIES - -UNKNOWN COLOR \nCLOYING \nFOOTWEAR • -UNKNOMI COLOR \nCLOTHING \nHEADGEAR • •UKNOAN CO-OR \nCLOTHING \nOJT ERMAR • •UNKNOtlets COLOR \nEVIDLNO2 \n'casino • I 996-006-007241 \nPnikets Cdkorel; \nI !Mame (bilnine 2 gatnone Steer II.P.A.C,\npet ItrepsoMil!: \nECI Runs. \nCrime Mac Itnomike: \nOm, Sc.... timber. \n146,14nte 144.4“ t \nNo IMEI Data for Complaint # '996406.00724i \nReportinginvestigating M.O.S. Name. \nPO CHANDLER, 00-0E \nCommand: \n006 PCT \nRep.Aracy: \nNYPO \npervisor Approving \ne\nepAgency: \nSupervisor\nZI/LCH \nI \nCommand: \n006 PCT \nR \nNYPO \nComplaint Moon Entered By: \nPAA MARSALA, MARGAR \nI \nCommit \n006 PCT \nRepAgency: \nHYPO \nSegnoff SOPerrisOr Name' \n000000 \nCommand: \nReP.AgenCY: \nI.ND OF COMPLAINT REPORT \n* I oetidemterlt I \nPrint this Repoli I \nEFTA00144361\n", "char_count": 1964}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "EXHIBIT 2 \nEFTA00144362\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "- / 995\" \nEFTA00144363\n", "char_count": 23}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Th7 蓍）？少九l 好; t 241 nUn4gA 4' 1 \nEFTA00144364\n", "char_count": 46}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "EXHIBIT 3 \nEFTA00144365\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION \nPOI/PA \nDELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET \nCivil Actionff 17-cv-03956 \nTotal Deleted Page(s) = 283 \nPage 6 - b3 - 1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; \nPage 10 - 43 - 1; 46 - 1,-3; 47c - 1,-3; \nPage 11 \nb3 - 1; b6 - 1,-3; b7C - 1,-3; \nPage 14 - b3 - 1; b6 - 3; b7C - 3; b7E -\nPage 15 \nb3 - 1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; \nPage 16 - b3 - 1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; \nPage 17 - b3 - 1; b6 - 3; b7C - 3; b7E -\nPage 18 - b3 - 1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; \nPage 19 - \n-\nPage 20 - \n-\nPage 21 - \n-\nPage 22 - \nPage 48 - \nPage 49 - \n- \nPage 50 - \n-\nPage 51 - \n-\nPage 52 -\nPage 53 \nPage 54 - \n-\nPage 55 - \n-\nPage 56 \nPage 57 - \nPage 58 - \n-\nPage 59 - \nPage 60 - \nPage 61 - \nPage 66 - \n-\nPage 67 - \n-\nPage 68 - \n-\nPage 69 - \n-\nPage 70 - \n-\nPage 71 - \n-\nPage 72 - \n-\nPage 73 - \n-\nPage 74 - \n-\nPage 75 - \n-\nPage 76 - \n-\nPage 77 - \n-\nPage 81 -\nPage UZ - \n-\nPage 83 - \nPage 84 - \nPage 85 - \nPage 86 -\nPage 87 - \nPage 88 -\nPage 89 -\nPage 90 - \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb6 \nb6 \nb6 \nb6 \nb6 \nb6 \nb6 \nb6 \nb6 \nb3 \nb3 \nb6 \nb6 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nDi \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \nb3 \n1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; \n1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; \n1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; \n1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; \n1; b6 - 3; b7C - 3; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b72 - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; b7E - 1; \n- 1; b6 - 3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n5; b7C - 5; b7E - 1; \n1; b6 - 3; b7C - 3; b7E - 1; \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1; bb \n1; b6 \n- 1; b6 \n- 1; b6 \n1; b6 \n1: b6 \n- 1; b6 \n- 1; b6 \n- 1; b6 \n1; \nb7E - 1; \nb7E - 1; \n1; \nb7E - 1; \nb7E - 1; \nb7E - 1; \nb7E - 1; \nb7E - 1; \n2,-3; \n2,-3; \n3; b7C \nb7C - 2,-3; b7E \nb7C - 2,-3; b7E \n- 3; b7E - 1; \n1; \n1; \n3,-5; b7C - 3,-5; b7E \n1; \n3,-5; b7C \n3,-5; b7E \n1; \n3,-5; b7C \n3,-5; b7E \n1; \n3,-5; b7C \n3,-5; b7E \n1; \n3,-5; b7C\n... [truncated, 2367 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/22 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=22]", "char_count": 2367}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "FD-340 (Rev. 4-11-03) \nFile Number  31 G--- - -(14 \n--J otz - 0(02  ---(kiem-7 \nField Office Acquiring Evidence nA. fr._ I CDRU.2 A--\nSerial # of Originating Document \nDate Received  \nOa\\ \nc)LA-• \nFrom \n(Name of Contributor/Interviewee) \n(Address) \nBy \nC A \n(Ciry and \n1 \nb6 -2 \nb7C \nTo Be Returned \nReceipt Given \n0 \nYes \n0 \nYes \n12'C \nB-C \nGrand Jury Material - Disseminate Only Pursuant to Rule 6 (e) \nFederal Rules of Criminal Procedure \n0 \nYes \ncleits1C—\nFederal Taxpayer Information (FTO \nEl Yes \nTitle: \nReference:  \n(Communication Enclosing Material) \nDescription: \nG- --Cricinal notes re interview of \n6-en ro, nkt‘i \n1,6 -3 \nb7C \n03956-8880 \nEFTA00144367\n", "char_count": 665}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "wry% arawywywaiii ragrFPIPTIIVW\n1.6 -1,-3, -5 I \n3 pfe \n_ \n-3-ras1413-) k‘s \nArcs \n4 \n0.\" \n.-Laark_ \nb6 -1,-3,-5 - \nb7C -1,-3,-5 \nb3 -1 \n• \n039\n4 5\nh 6901 \nEFTA00144368\n", "char_count": 169}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "PTIIITITTVETP, ZWIWIFIFIWO \n03%6-8902 \nSo \n301 _ \nrl \nEFTA00144369\n", "char_count": 67}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "psi saw \n6_3) \n• -O.- • \n• •-• \n• -( 1-- - - - \nb67 -1.-3 \n/'b7C \nLitiS408.-b3 -17 \n03956'8903-\n- - \nEFTA00144370\n", "char_count": 114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Ps • • s enwinprimprrniqPIPOIlppre. \n_LE \nm_0- .1-4 \nb6 -1,-3,-\nb7C -1,-3,-5 \n/1-4a \n-\nw te-e_\naceio \nk;-\n03956-8904 \nEFTA00144371\n", "char_count": 131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "? fir- - \n--loci \nLoy. \nstr,d \ntc3—: \nLI tea Sep ce.e \n69051 \nEFTA00144372\n", "char_count": 75}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "EFTA00144373\n", "char_count": 13}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "_(41\neitnALIt-_ ',pad-41 ck. \n14111\n(j1\"7r \n4.5:c ClieJ \ns -L_ cces;-<, \n61056-8907 \nEFTA00144374\n", "char_count": 98}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "EFTA00144375\n", "char_count": 13}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "glignIrrMirrThe Lip MN \ncr) \n.6ait 1,:‘A Lana \nt&-ut \nb3 1 \n-c, \n3956-890 \n\"3, \nEFTA00144376\n", "char_count": 93}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "r\nib ‘ 15-FTWITTrPrPOWPrb WWI\" \nl fn \nb6 -3! \nb7C -3 \nb3 -1 \nb6 -1,-3,-5 \nb7C -1,-3,-5 \nb7E \nLk\ne‘: \nb6 -1,-3,-5 \nb7C -1,-3,-\nb76 -1 \n56-8910\n-\n \n•\n \n-\n \nEFTA00144377\n", "char_count": 167}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "EFTA00144378\n", "char_count": 13}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "7\n11 \ncuku < \nc,,I \n+) \nliszkuar \n3.6\n tt\n_Lc._oft \nEFTA00144379\n", "char_count": 65}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "fiiVtFSTf \nirisiivwrwtW \nIFFT \nb6 -3,-5 \nb7C -3,-\nt-V‘1 \nb3 -1 \n03956-8913 \nEFTA00144380\n", "char_count": 89}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "EFTA00144381\n", "char_count": 13}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "priTrriFIFTIPIWW-oT \nEFTA00144382\n", "char_count": 34}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "n\n-rrruir r• rerrnamr, \n.1-71-51 \nY.oO \nCa\" \nV \nAm \ns \n.b6 -1, -9. \nb7C -1,-3 \nSen,5 \nb3 -1 \nCHS \nC%-chrii174ff\n.\ncritsL Ca.sfyir \n03956-8916 \nEFTA00144383\n", "char_count": 156}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "-61fidik \nkyr-,\ny kr 1,151A7I-tr-4—\n19Y-e- to\"-_ !RA ti-toCC-A-‘, \n\"HA-44,7 y \ne_ \nEFTA00144384\n", "char_count": 96}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "(.3 \ne • c\nl \nrho \nJIA67,-, \nEFTA00144385\n", "char_count": 42}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "iFETTTIMTVIrrr\nrsPri \n03956-8919 \nWcI \n44,5..: 3\nEFTA00144386\n", "char_count": 62}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "rive \nWe \nWTI \n66 -1,-3.-5• \n67C -1,-3,-5 \nEFTA00144387\n", "char_count": 56}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "trwrirrrrrs TT IFTYTTITTTre \nottsee \ncatijt hkickdr3t9t5:t1 \nEFTA00144388\n", "char_count": 74}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Ldimeirrrirrin rot We is • *sti\nff- \n I \nb7C -1 \nEFTA00144389\n", "char_count": 62}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "\"a • if Maria \n• lb \na.. \nal\n. \nb6 -3,-5 \nb7C -3,-\nb3 -1 \n03956-8923 \nEFTA00144390\n", "char_count": 83}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "6 -2.-51\n7C -2,-\nb \nb \nF7>c \n110i \n-zos \n:Hot \n21 so \n.z._ \nf 255— cfliss tr. \nrwat s :9C \n/ /0 7 \nUAWAo OPAILIALAAN. r \nt \n4._„ \n5.Oo 11 \n03956-8938 /A\nire^ MAf -/OtOgi - Mit ri 'A \nEFTA00144391\n", "char_count": 196}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "EXHIBIT 4 \nEFTA00144392\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "igaM# 1:42--0,1469044§P 006tiffiefii 14t) Filed @4I /2§ Pa \n9f \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED \n) \nSTATES VIRGIN ISLANDS \n) \n) \nPlaintiff, \n) \n) \nV. \n) \nCase Number: I :22-cv-10904-JSR \n) \nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A. \n) \n) \nDefendant/Third-Party Plaintiff. \n) \n \n) \n) \nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A. \n) \n) \nThird-Party Plaintiff, \n) \n) \nV. \n) \n) \nJAMES EDWARD STALEY \n) \n) \nThird-Party Defendant. \n) \n \n) \nSTIPULATED MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF PROTOCOL FOR REVIEW OF \nVIDEOMATERIALS AND PHOTOGRAPHS FOR THE PRESENCE OF POTENTIAL \nCHILD SEX ABUSE MATERIALS AND FOR DISCLOSURE OF THOSE MATERIALS \nPlaintiffs Jane Doe 1 and the Government of the United States Virgin Islands \n(\"Government\"), by their respective counsel, move pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure \n26(c), and the authority of the Court to administer proceedings before it, for approval of an agreed-\nupon protocol authorizing counsel for the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein (the \"Epstein Estate\") to \nreview videorecorded materials and photographs in the possession, custody, or control of the \nEpstein Estate (the \"Epstein Media\") in response to subpoenas previously issued by Jane Doe 1 \nand, to the extent responsive to those subpoenas, disclose relevant portions of the Epstein Media \nEFTA00144393\n", "char_count": 1322}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Cm@ 02-ev:IONI4:3§R Postinwit HQ fag ®A/AA/2§ t3go 4 et \n(the \"Responsive Media\") to Jane Doe 1's counsel and to other parties in the litigations pending \nbefore the Court involving claims related to Jeffrey Epstein. \nFactual Background \nThe Court is aware of the general nature of this case from earlier proceedings. For purposes \nof this Motion, it is relevant to note that Jane Doe 1 has alleged that she was the victim of coerced \ncommercial sex trafficking by Jeffrey Epstein and his co-conspirators. Jane Doe 1 has issued a \nsubpoena to the Epstein Estate, seeking certain videorecorded materials and photographs within \nthe Epstein Media, and the Estate has agreed to produce Responsive Media in the Estate's \npossession to the extent that the production is not inconsistent with federal or state law, and to the \nextent that the videos or photographs were not downloaded or otherwise obtained at the time \nthrough publicly-available sources.' \nOn March 14, 2023, counsel for the Epstein Estate notified counsel for Jane Doe 1 that it \nhad located materials within the Epstein Media that may be responsive to her subpoenas. The \nEstate also advised counsel for the Government and Jane Doe 1 of its concern that some of the \nEpstein Media might contain child sex abuse imagery (CSAM2). The knowing accessing, \npossession, or distribution of CSAM is forbidden by federal law. See 18 U.S.C. §§ 2252, 2252A. \nThe Estate has expressed concern that its counsel's review of the Epstein Media could subject \ncounsel to criminal investigation or charges or civil claims in light of the possibility that the review \n' Videos or photographs that were not obtained at the time through publicly-available sources is \nmeant to include Responsive Media that may consist of movies or You Tube videos, for example, \nbut does not extend to Responsive Media relating to Epstein activities or properties that may have \nbeen publicly disclosed at any time. \n2 In this motion, the parties use the term \"child sex ab\n... [truncated, 2313 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/50 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=50]", "char_count": 2313}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Com 112e10004,J§R 006thil@fil 1 \nFilod 04/0g/25 Pe 5 of 5 \nof the Epstein Media could involve accessing CSAM. The Epstein Estate has advised that it does \nnot have any specific knowledge that any of the Epstein Media does, in fact, contain CSAM, but \nwishes to put in place an appropriate procedure in case its counsel encounters such material. \nProposed RCN leis Protocol \nAgainst that backdrop, counsel for the Government and Jane Doe 1 and the Epstein Estate \nhave conferred and have agreed that the Government and Jane Doe 1 would move the Court for \nthe entry of an order approving the following protocol for the Epstein Estate's review of the Epstein \nMedia for potential production to parties in the litigations pending before the Court: \n1. \nThe Epstein Estate shall review the Epstein Media to determine its responsiveness \nto the subpoenas that have been issued by Jane Doe I and other parties to the related litigations. \n2. \nIf, during the course of that review, the Epstein Estate sees a particular recording \nthat appears to contain possible CSAM, it shall promptly stop further review of that recording and \nnotify the Federal Bureau of Investigation (\"FBI\") or such other agency or entity as the FBI may \ndirect of the recording's existence. No CSAM shall be copied or transmitted to another party, \nexcept as directed by the FBI or other government agency. \n3. \nIf no CSAM is observed during the review, the Responsive Media will be provided \nto counsel for Jane Doe 1 and the Government in response to the relevant subpoena. To the extent \nResponsive Media is identified prior to the identification of possible CSAM, such materials also \nwill be produced to counsel. Counsel for Jane Doe 1 and any other recipient of Responsive Media \nmay then use this material for the prosecution or defense of the above-captioned case and make \nsuch further disclosures as are required by civil discovery rules (e.g., appropriate disclosures to \nopposing counsel). \nThe attached proposed Order re\n... [truncated, 2053 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00144344/51 or ?id=EFTA00144344&page=51]", "char_count": 2053}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "(few P*-2--ey-4663644§P tztfeewati2 nki4 @x$Mig/g§ Pao 46* \n1. \nProvide the Epstein Estate with an approved protocol for reviewing the Epstein \nMedia for purposes of this litigation only without fear of criminal or civil liability; \n2. \nProvide Jane Doe 1 with Responsive Media that may be relevant to her case; \n3. \nProtect against disclosure or dissemination of CSAM; and \n4. \nFollow the directive of 18 U.S.C. 3509(m) against reproduction of CSAM. \nConclusion \nThis Motion has been agreed to by the parties. \nDate: March 27, 2023 \nRespectfully submitted, \n/s/ Linda Singer \nLinda Singer (pro hac vice) \nMimi Liu (pro hac vice) \nDavid I. Ackerman \nPaige Boggs (pro hac vice) \nMOTLEY RICE LLC \n401 9th Street NW, Suite 630 \nWashington, DC 20004 \nTel: (202) 232-5504 \nFax: (202) 232-5513 \nIsinger@motleyrice.com \nmliu®motleyrice.com \ndackerman@motleyrice.com \npboggs@motleyrice.com \nCarol Thomas-Jacobs (pro hac vice) \nActing Attorney General of the \nUnited States Virgin Islands \nVirgin Islands Department of Justice \n34-38 Kronprindsens Gade \nSt. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands 00802 \nTel: (340) 774-5666 ext. 10101 \ncarol.jacobs®doj.vi.gov \nCounsel for Plaintiff Government \nof the United States Virgin Islands \n/s/ Bradley Edwards \nBradley J. Edwards \nEDWARDS POTTINGER LLP \n425 N. Andrews Ave., Suite 2 \nFort Lauderdale, FL 33301 \nTel: (954) 524-2820 \nFax: (954) 524-2822 \nbrad@epllc.com \nBrittany N. Henderson \nEDWARDS POTT1NGER LLP \n1501 Broadway, Floor 12 \nNew York, NY \nTel: (954) 524-2820 \nFax: (954) 524-2822 \nbrittany@eplic.com \nDavid Boies \nAndrew Villacastin \nBOLES SCHILLER FLEXNER LLP \n55 Hudson Yards \nNew York, NY \nTel: (212) 446-2300 \nFax: (212) 446-2350 \ndboies@bsfllp.com \navillacastin@bsfllp.com \nEFTA00144396\n", "char_count": 1729}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "EXHIBIT 5 \nEFTA00144397\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Ozige11222c&v1D9g64JitiR PriallhitettitIPP21 1:41FicbCgog7g3 FPACielloCf72\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED \n) \nSTATES VIRGIN ISLANDS \n) \n) \nPlaintiff, \n) \n) \nV. \n) \n) \nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A. \n) \n) \nDefendant/Third-Party Plaintiff. \n) \n \n) \n) \nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A. \n) \n) \nThird-Party Plaintiff, \n) \n) \nV. \n) \n) \nJAMES EDWARD STALEY \n) \n) \nThird-Party Defendant. \n) \n \n) \nCase Number: 1:22-cv-10904-JSR \nORDER REGARDING REVIEW OF VIDEOMATERIALS \nPursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 26(c) and the authority of this Court to \nadminister its proceedings, and finding good cause established in the stipulated motion filed by \nJane Doe I and the Government of the United States Virgin Islands, the Court orders that: \n1. \nThe Epstein Estate shall review the Epstein Media to determine its responsiveness \nto the subpoenas that have been issued by Jane Doe I and other parties to the related litigations. \n2. \nIf, during the course of that review, the Estate sees a particular recording that \nappears to contain possible CSAM, it shall promptly stop further review of that recording and \nnotify the Federal Bureau of Investigation (\"FBI\") or such other agency or entity as the FBI may \nEFTA00144398\n", "char_count": 1270}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Celitt1142c671P9P314.W2 Q56611114itrAtiPP21 Fifddeb0Aigii§3 P%Cle23oPfi2\ndirect of the recording's existence. No CSAM shall be copied or transmitted to another party, \nexcept as directed by the FBI or other government agency. \n3. \nIf no CSAM is observed during the review, the Responsive Media will be provided \ncounsel for Jane Doe I and the Government in response to the relevant subpoena. To the extent \nResponsive Media is identified prior to the identification of possible CSAM, such materials also \nwill be produced to counsel. Counsel for Jane Doe I and any other recipient of Responsive Media \nmay then use this material for the prosecution or defense of the above-captioned case and make \nsuch further disclosures as are required by civil discovery rules (e.g., appropriate disclosures to \nopposing counsel). \nSO ORDERED. \nJECatR eA.I' COFFiS \nDated: March ti fr  , 2023 \nNew York, New York \nEFTA00144399\n", "char_count": 914}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00144344", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "gam 1224friON44§14 Do@unimit \nOM§ Pap 5 915 \nSigrid McCawley (pro hac vice) \nBOLES SCHILLER FLEXNER LLP \n401 E. Las Olas Blvd., Suite 1200 \nFort Lauderdale, FL 33316 \nTel: (954) 356-0011 \nFax: (954) 356-0022 \nsmccawley@bsfllp.com \nCounsel for Plaintiflane Doe 1 \nSTIPULATED AND AGREED TO BY: \n/s/John Butts \nJohn Butts \nFelicia H. Ellsworth \nWILMER CUTLER PICKERING \nHALE AND DORR LLP \n60 State Street \nBoston, MA 02109 \nTel: (617) 526-6687 \nFax: (617) 526-5000 \njohn.butts@wilmerhale.com \nfelicia.ellsworth@wilmerhale.com \nCounsel for Defendant \nJPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. \n/s/ Zachary K Warren \nZachary K. Warren (pro hac vice pending) \nWILLIAMS & CONNOLLY LLP \n680 Maine Avenue SW \nWashington, DC 20024 \nTel: (202) 434-5252 \nFax: (202) 434-5029 \nzwarren@wc.com \nCounsel for Third-Party Defendant \nJames Edward Staley \nEFTA00144400\n", "char_count": 833}]}