{"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_count": 45, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00094289", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00094289.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \n \nx \nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA, \nv. \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \n x \n20 Cr. 330 (AJN) \nMEMORANDUM OF GHISLAINE MAXWELL \nIN SUPPORT OF HER RENEWED MOTION FOR BAIL \nMark S. Cohen \nChristian R. Everdell \nCOHEN & GRESSER LLP \nNew York, NY 10022 \nPhone: \nJeffrey S. Pagliuca \nLaura A. Menninger \nHADDON, MORGAN & FOREMAN P.C. \nDenver, CO 80203 \nPhone: \nBobbi C. Stemheim \nLaw Offices of Bobbi C. Stemheim \nNew York, NY 10011 \nPhone: \nAttorneys for Ghislaine Maxwell \nEFTA00094289\n", "char_count": 539}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "TABLE OF CONTENTS \nPage \nPRELIMINARY STATEMENT \n1 \nARGUMENT \n7 \nI. \nReconsideration of the Court's Bail Decision is Appropriate Under 18 U.S.C. \n§ 3142(O \n7 \nII. \nMs. Maxwell Should Be Granted Bail Under the Proposed Strict Bail \nConditions \n 10 \nA. \nMs. Maxwell Has Deep Family Ties to the United States and Numerous \nSureties to Support Her Bond \n10 \n1. \nMs. Maxwell is Devoted to Her Spouse and Stepchildren and \nWould Never Destroy Her Family By Leaving the Country \n 11 \n2. \nA Number of Ms. Maxwell's Family and Friends, and the \nSecurity Company Protecting Her, Are Prepared to Sign \nSignificant Bonds \n13 \nB. \nMs. Maxwell Has Provided a Thorough Review of Her Finances for the \nPast Five Years \n15 \nC. \nMs. Maxwell Was Not Hiding from the Government Before Her Arrest \n 18 \n1. \nMs. Maxwell Was Trying to Protect Herself and Her Family from \na Media Frenzy and from Physical Threats \n 18 \n2. \nMs. Maxwell's Counsel Was in Regular Contact with the \nGovernment Prior to Her Arrest \n22 \n3. \nMs. Maxwell Did Not Try to Avoid Arrest, Nor Was She \"Good \nAt\" Hiding \n23 \nD. \nMs. Maxwell Has Waived Her Extradition Rights and Could Not Seek \nRefuge in the United Kingdom or France \n25 \nE. \nThe Discovery Contains No Meaningful Documentary Corroboration of \nthe Government's Allegations Against Ms. Maxwell \n30 \nF. \nThe Proposed Bail Package Is Expansive and Far Exceeds What Is \nNecessary to Reasonably Assure Ms. Maxwell's Presence in Court \n34 \nEFTA00094290\n", "char_count": 1458}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "G. \nThe Alternative to Bail Is Confinement Under Oppressive Conditions \nthat Impact Ms. Maxwell's Health and Ability to Prepare Her Defense \n35 \nCONCLUSION \n38 \nii \nEFTA00094291\n", "char_count": 178}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "TABLE OF AUTHORITIES \nPage(s) \nCases \nUnited States v. Boustani, \n932 F.3d 79 (2d Cir. 2019) \n3 \nUnited States v. Bradshaw, \nNo. 0040033-04-DES, 2000 WL 1371517 (D. Kan. July 20, 2000) \n8 \nUnited States v. Chen, \n820 F. Supp. 1205 (N.D. Cal. 1992) \n27 \nUnited States v. \nNo. 99-1514, 1999 WL 1456536 (3d Cir. July 13, 1999) \n26 \nUnited States v. Karni, \n298 F. Supp. 2d 129 (D.D.C. 2004) \n27 \nUnited States v. Khashoggi, \n717 F. Supp. 1048 (S.D.N.Y. 1989) \n27 \nUnited States v. Lee, \nNo. CR-99-1417 JP, 2000 WL 36739632 (D.N.M. 2000) \n8 \nUnited States v. Orta, \n760 F.2d 887 (8th Cir. 1985) \n35 \nUnited States v. Petrov, \nNo. 15-CR-66-LTS, 2015 WL 11022886 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 26, 2015) \n8 \nUnited States v. Rowe, \nNo. 02 CR. 756 LMM, 2003 WL 21196846 (S.D.N.Y. May 21, 2003) \n8 \nUnited States v. Salvagno, \n314 F. Supp. 2d 115 (N.D.N.Y. 2004) \n27 \nUnited States v. Stephens, \n447 F. Supp. 3d 63 (S.D.N.Y. 2020) \n7, 38 \nUnited States v. Ward, \n63 F. Supp. 2d 1203 (C.D. Cal. 1999) \n7 \niii \nEFTA00094292\n", "char_count": 998}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Statutes \n18 U.S.C. § 3142(c)(1)(BXi) \n3 \n18 U.S.C. § 3142(f) \n7, 8 \n18 U.S.C. § 3142 \n3 \nRules \nRule 5(F) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure \n5 \niv \nEFTA00094293\n", "char_count": 171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "TABLE OF EXHIBITS \nExhibit A. \nLetter of Scott Borgerson \nExhibit B. \nLetter of Isabel Maxwell \nExhibit C. \nLetter of Christine Maxwell \nExhibit D. \nLetter of Katie Vaughan-Edwards \nExhibit E. \nLetter of Kevin Maxwell \nExhibit F. \nLetter of Pandora Maxwell \nExhibit G. \nLetter of Ian Maxwell \nExhibit H. \nLetter of Anne Holve \nExhibit I. \nLetter of Chloe Maxwell \nExhibit J. \nLetter of Helene Zimmerman \nExhibit K. \nLetter of Jamie Hollomon \nExhibit L. \nLetter of Matilda Munro \nExhibit M. \nLetter of Jeff Paul Roth \nExhibit N. \nLetter of Lady Tang \nExhibit 0. \nFinancial Condition Report \nExhibit P. \nStatement of Bo Faro \nExhibit Q. \nMedia Analysis \nExhibit R. \nTimeline of Discussions with SDNY \nExhibit S. \nStatement of Matthew Hellyer \nExhibit T. \nExtradition Waivers \nExhibit U. \nUK Extradition Opinion \nExhibit V. \nFrance Extradition Opinion \nExhibit W. \nLetter of Emily Waitt \nExhibit X. \nLetter of Simon Lyons \nEFTA00094294\n", "char_count": 933}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "PRELIMINARY STATEMENT \nGhislaine Maxwell respectfully submits this Memorandum in Support of her Renewed \nMotion for Release on Bail. \nAs set forth more fully below, Ms. Maxwell is proposing an expansive set of bail \nconditions that is more than adequate to address any concern regarding risk of flight and \nreasonably assure Ms. Maxwell's presence in court. Ms. Maxwell also provides compelling \nadditional information in this submission, not available at the time of the initial bail hearing \n(which was held 12 days after her arrest), that squarely addresses each of the Court's \nconcerns from the initial hearing and fully supports her release on the proposed bail \nconditions. This information includes: (1) evidence of Ms. Maxwell's significant family ties in \nthe United States; (2) a detailed financial report, which has also been reviewed by a former IRS \nCID special agent, concerning her financial condition and assets, and those of her spouse, for the \nlast five years; (3) irrevocable waivers of her right to contest extradition from the United \nKingdom and France and expert opinions stating that it would be highly unlikely that Ms. \nMaxwell would be able to resist extradition in the implausible event of her fleeing to either \ncountry; (4) evidence rebutting the Government's contention that Ms. Maxwell attempted to \nevade detection by law enforcement prior to her arrest; and (5) a discussion of the weakness of \nthe government's case against Ms. Maxwell, including the lack of corroborative, \ncontemporaneous documentary evidence in support of the three accusers. \nMs. Maxwell vehemently maintains her innocence and is committed to defending herself. \nShe wants nothing more than to remain in this country to fight the allegations against her, which \nare based on the uncorroborated testimony of a handful of witnesses about events that took \nplace over 25 years ago. The Court should grant Ms. Maxwell bail on the restrictive \nconditions proposed below to ensure her constitutiona\n... [truncated, 2046 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/6 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=6]", "char_count": 2046}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "The Proposed Bail Conditions \nMs. Maxwell now proposes the following $28.5 million bail package, which is \nexceptional in its scope and puts at risk everything that Ms. Maxwell has—all of her and her \nspouse's assets, her family's livelihood, and the financial security of her closest friends and \nfamily—if she were to flee, which she has no intention of doing. \n• \nA $22.5 million personal recognizance bond co-signed by Ms. Maxwell and her \nspouse, and secured by approximately $8 million in property and $500,000 in cash. \nAs noted in the financial report, the $22.5 million figure represents the value of all of \nMs. Maxwell and her spouse's assets. The three properties securing the bond include \nall of the real property that Ms. Maxwell and her spouse own in the United States, \nincluding their primary family residence. \n• \nFive additional bonds totaling approximately $5 million co-signed by seven of Ms. \nMaxwell's closest friends and family members. The individual bonds are in amounts \nthat would cause significant financial hardship to these sureties if Ms. Maxwell were \nto flee. These include: \no A $1.5 million bond co-signed by her sisters Christine Maxwell and Isabel \nMaxwell, both U.S. citizens and residents, and fully secured by Christine \nMaxwell's primary residence in Oakland, California. \no A $3.5 million bond co-signed by Ms. Maxwell's brother Kevin Maxwell, \nand his ex-wife, Pandora Maxwell, who are U.K. citizens and residents. \nThe $3.5 million sum represents virtually all of Pandora Maxwell's assets. \nKevin Maxwell is the guarantor of the existing mortgages on these assets. \no A $25,000 bond co-signed by Ms. Maxwell's cousin, Helene Zimmerman, a \nU.S. citizen and resident, and fully secured by $25,000 in cash. \no A $25,000 bond signed by Simon Lyons, a close family friend, and fully \nsecured by $25,000 in cash. The cash security is money that Mr. Lyons \nplanned to set aside for his own daughter's future, but he is prepared to pledge \nit for Ms. Maxwell. \no\n... [truncated, 2485 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/7 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=7]", "char_count": 2485}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "company has confirmed that they have never done this for any client, and that he is \nwilling to do so for Ms. Maxwell because he is confident that she will not try to flee. \n• \nMs. Maxwell will remain in the custody of her sister, Isabel Maxwell, a U.S. citizen \nwho has lived in the United States for 40 years. Isabel Maxwell will serve as Ms. \nMaxwell's third-party custodian under 18 U.S.C. § 3142(c)(1)(B)(i) and will live with \nMs. Maxwell in a residence in New York City until this case has concluded. We have \nidentified an appropriate residence in the Eastern District of New York that has been \ncleared by Ms. Maxwell's security company. \n• \nTravel restricted to the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York, and limited as \nnecessary to appear in court, attend meetings with counsel, and visit with \ndoctors/psychiatrists/dentists, and upon approval by the Court or Pretrial Services. \n• \nSurrender of all travel documents with no new applications. \n• \nMs. Maxwell will provide the Court irrevocable written waivers of her right to contest \nextradition in France and the United Kingdom. \n• \nStrict supervision by Pretrial Services. \n• \nHome confinement at her residence with electronic GPS monitoring. \n• \nVisitors to be approved in advance by Pretrial Services, with counsel and family \nmembers to be pre-approved. \n• \nSuch other terms as the Court may deem appropriate under 18 U.S.C. § 3142. \nFor her own safety, Ms. Maxwell will also have on-premises security guards 24 \nhours a day, 7 days a week. The security guards will prevent Ms. Maxwell from leaving the \nresidence at any time without prior approval by the Court or Pretrial Services and will escort \nher when she is authorized to leave. If the Court wishes to make private security a condition \nof her bond, the guards could report to Pretrial Services.' We believe these conditions are \nmore than sufficient to reasonably assure Ms. Maxwell's presence in court. \nI As we argued in our initial bail application, this case invo\n... [truncated, 2592 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/8 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=8]", "char_count": 2592}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "New Information for the Court's Consideration \nThe defense has devoted substantial time and effort to compile information that was not \navailable to Ms. Maxwell at the time of the initial bail hearing that squarely addresses each of the \nfactors the Court considered at that hearing. Because of these efforts, Ms. Maxwell can now \npresent the following additional information in support of her renewed bail application: \n• \nLetter from Ms. Maxwell's spouse. This letter demonstrates that Ms. Maxwell has \npowerful family ties to the United States that she will not abandon. It describes the \ncommitted relationship between Ms. Maxwell and her spouse, who is a U.S citizen, \nand how they lived a quiet family life together with his two minor children in the \nUnited States for over four years immediately prior to her arrest. The letter further \nexplains that Ms. Maxwell was forced to leave her family and drop out of the public \neye, not because she was trying to evade law enforcement, but because the intense \nmedia frenzy and threats following the arrest and death of Jeffrey Epstein threatened \nthe safety and wellbeing of herself and her family, especially the minor children. For \nthese same reasons, Ms. Maxwell's spouse did not come forward as a co-signer at the \ntime of the initial hearing. (Ex. A). \n• \nLetters from numerous other friends and family members. These letters from \nMs. Maxwell's other sureties and several family members and friends attest to Ms. \nMaxwell's strong, forthright character and their confidence that she will not flee. The \nsureties also describe the significant financial distress they would suffer if Ms. \nMaxwell were to violate her bail conditions. (Exs. B-N, W-X). \n• \nFinancial report. The financial report, prepared by the accounting firm Macalvins \nLimited, provides an accounting of Ms. Maxwell's financial condition from 2015-\n2020, and discloses (i) all of her own assets, (ii) all assets held in trust, and (iii) all of \nthe assets held by her spous\n... [truncated, 2885 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/9 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=9]", "char_count": 2885}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "contest extradition in both the United Kingdom and France.2 We also provide \nopinions from experts in the extradition laws of the France and the United Kingdom \nstating that it is highly unlikely that Ms. Maxwell would be able to resist extradition \nfrom either country in the event she were granted bail and somehow fled to either \ncountry, which she has no intention of doing. Their opinions also state that any \nextradition proceeding would be resolved promptly. (Exs. T-V). \n• \nLack of corroborating evidence. The government represented to the Court that it \nhad \"contemporaneous documents,\" including \"diary entries\" in support of its case. \n(Dkt. 4 at 5). The defense has now reviewed the discovery produced to date, \nincluding all of the documents that the government described as the core of its case \nagainst Ms. Maxwell. As explained more fully below, the discovery contains no \nmeaningful documentary corroboration as to Maxwell and only a small number of \ndocuments from the time period of the conspiracy charged in the indictment. As an \nexample, the government produced only seven pages of a single diary, apparently \nkept by one of the accusers, and none of those pages even mentioned Ms. Maxwell? \nThe evidence in this case boils down to witness testimony about events that took \nplace over 25 years ago. Far from creating a flight risk, the lack of corroboration \nonly reinforces Ms. Maxwell's conviction that she has been falsely accused and \nstrengthens her long-standing desire to face the allegations against her and clear \nher name in court. \n• \nOppressive conditions of confinement. Ms. Maxwell has now been detained \nfor over 150 days in the equivalent of solitary confinement since she was \nindicted and arrested on July 2, 2020, despite the fact that she is not a suicide \nrisk and has not received a single disciplinary infraction. The draconian \nconditions to which Ms. Maxwell is subjected are not only unjust and \npunitive, but also impair her ability to review the volu\n... [truncated, 3283 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/10 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=10]", "char_count": 3283}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "was arrested and has shown no signs of abating. Indeed, in the three months after her arrest, Ms. \nMaxwell was the subject of over 6,500 national media articles. That exceeds the number of \narticles that mentioned such high-profile defendants as Harvey Weinstein, Bill Cosby, Joaquin \n\"El Chapo\" Guzman Loera, and Keith Raniere in the 90-day period following their arrests, \ncombined. The media coverage has ruthlessly vilified her and prejudged her guilt, and has \nexposed her family and friends to harassment, physical threats, and other negative consequences. \nBut Ms. Maxwell is not the person the media has portrayed her to be; far from it. And \nher response to these unfounded allegations remains unchanged: she resolutely and vehemently \ndenies them, and she is steadfastly committed to remaining in this country, where she has been \nsince Epstein's arrest in July 2019, to fight them in court. For Ms. Maxwell to flee, she would \nhave to abandon her spouse and his two minor children. She will not risk destroying the lives \nand financial well-being of those she holds most dear to live as a fugitive during a worldwide \npandemic. In fact, every action Ms. Maxwell has taken from the time of Epstein's arrest up to \nthe time of the first bail hearing was designed to protect her spouse and the children from \nharassment, economic harm, and physical danger. Ms. Maxwell wants to stay in New York and \nhave her day in court so that she can clear her name and return to her family. \nJustice is not reserved solely for the victims of a crime; it is for the accused as well. \nHere, justice would be served by granting Ms. Maxwell bail under the comprehensive conditions \nwe propose. The alternative is continued detention under oppressive conditions that are \nunprecedented for a non-violent pretrial detainee, which significantly impair her ability to \nparticipate in her defense and prepare for trial and which jeopardize her physical health and \npsychological wellbeing. \n6 \nEFTA00094300\n", "char_count": 1994}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "ARGUMENT \nI. \nReconsideration of the Court's Bail Decision is Appropriate Under 18 U.S.C. \n3142(f) \nA prior determination that a defendant should not be released on bail does not preclude \nthe Court from reconsidering its decision in light of new information. To the contrary, a bail \nhearing \nmay be reopened ... at any time before trial if the judicial officer finds that \ninformation exists that was not known to the movant at the time of the hearing \nand that has a material bearing on the issue whether there are conditions of release \nthat will reasonably assure the appearance of such person as required and the \nsafety of any other person and the community. \n18 U.S.C. § 3142(0. \nCourts have relied on § 3142(0 in revisiting bail determinations where the defendant \npresents material testimony or documentary evidence that was not available to her at the time of \nthe initial hearing, even if the underlying facts might have been within the defendant's \nknowledge. For example, in United States v. Ward, 63 F. Supp. 2d 1203 (C.D. Cal. 1999), the \ncourt granted the defendant's request to reopen his bail hearing to present evidence of his \nimmediate family's willingness to act as sureties for his release. Id. at 1207. The court held that \nalthough \"his immediate family and relatives were obviously known to\" the defendant at the time \nof his arrest, his inability to contact them and secure their appearance at his initial bail hearing \njustified reconsideration. Id. \nCourts also have found § 3142(0 satisfied where there is new information regarding the \ndefendant's guilt or innocence or the nature and seriousness of the alleged offense-facts \ngenerally not known to a criminal defendant at the time of the initial hearing—particularly where \nthe evidence undermines the government's prior representations to the Court regarding the \nstrength of its case. See, e.g., United States v. Stephens, 447 F. Supp. 3d 63, 65 (S.D.N.Y. 2020) \n7 \nEFTA00094301\n", "char_count": 1965}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "(Nathan, J.) (reconsidering bail decision based, in part, on evidence suggesting government's \ncase weaker than alleged at initial hearing and concern about possible outbreak of COVID-19 in \nBOP facilities); United States v. Lee, No. CR-99-1417 JP, 2000 WL 36739632, at *3 (D.N.M. \n2000) (reopening hearing to consider, inter alia, affidavits relating to seriousness of the offense \nthat defendant \"could have not have martialed\" in the 17 days between his indictment and the \noriginal hearing). Changed circumstances also have been found to satisfy § 3142(0 even when \nthe change was within the defendant's control. See United States v. Bradshaw, No. 00-40033-\n04-DES, 2000 WL 1371517 (D. Kan. July 20, 2000) (reopening hearing where defendant \ndecided to seek substance abuse treatment following initial hearing). \nIn addition, the Court may exercise its inherent authority to reconsider its own decision. \n\"[A] release order may be reconsidered even where the evidence proffered on reconsideration \nwas known to the movant at the time of the original hearing.\" United States v. Rowe, No. 02 CR. \n756 LMM, 2003 WL 21196846, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. May 21, 2003); see also United States v. \nPetrov, No. 15-CR-66-LTS, 2015 WL 11022886, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 26, 2015) (noting \n\"Court's inherent authority for reconsideration of the Court's previous bail decision\"). \nHere, Ms. Maxwell has obtained substantial information and evidence that was not \navailable to her at the time of her initial detention hearing. Ms. Maxwell and her counsel have \nalso received and reviewed the voluminous discovery produced by the government (over 2.7 \nmillion pages), which was not available at the initial hearing and which raises serious questions \nabout the strength of the government's case. As a result, Ms. Maxwell can now present for the \nCourt's consideration the additional evidence discussed above in support of her bail application. \nIt cannot be reasonably disputed that this new evidence meets the other requirem\n... [truncated, 2121 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/13 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=13]", "char_count": 2121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "that will reasonably assure the appearance of such person as required and the safety of any other \nperson and the community.\" The evidence submitted herewith relates directly to factors on \nwhich the Court relied in its initial detention order. Among the bases for the Court's initial order \ndenying bail were its findings that: \n• \nMs. Maxwell's lack of \"significant family ties\" in the United States suggested \n\"that flight would not pose an insurmountable burden for her\" (Tr. 84); \n• \nthe Court lacked \"a clear picture of Ms. Maxwell's finances and the resources \navailable to her\" that would allow it to set reasonable bail conditions (Tr. 87); \n• \"[c]ircumstances of her arrest ... may cast some doubt on the claim that she \nwas not hiding from the government\" (Tr. 85); \n• \nMs. Maxwell \"is a citizen of France, a nation that does not appear to extradite \nits citizens\" (Tr. 83); and \n• \nthe government had proffered that its \"witness testimony will be corroborated \nby significant contemporaneous documentary evidence\" (Tr. 82). \nThe additional evidence submitted herewith demonstrates that Ms. Maxwell does have \nsignificant family ties in the United States; that her assets have been thoroughly disclosed and \nreasonable bail conditions can be set; that Ms. Maxwell has never attempted to hide from the \ngovernment; that Ms. Maxwell has waived her extradition rights and it is highly likely she would \nbe extradited from the United Kingdom or France; and that the government's case against her is \nnot supported by the corroborating documentary evidence which the government represented at \nthe initial hearing. \nThe evidence submitted herewith is significant and substantial, and it could not have \nreasonably been obtained, assembled, and submitted in the 12 days between Ms. Maxwell's \narrest and her initial detention hearing. This evidence has a material bearing on whether \nreasonable bail conditions can be set, and it shows that the proposed set of conditions will \nreasonably assure\n... [truncated, 2053 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/14 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=14]", "char_count": 2053}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "II. \nMs. Maxwell Should Be Granted Bail Under the Proposed Strict Bail Conditions \nA. \nMs. Maxwell Has Deep Family Ties to the United States and Numerous \nSureties to Support Her Bond \nAttached to this submission are letters from Ms. Maxwell's spouse and from \nnumerous close family members and friends, many of whom have agreed to serve as sureties \nto support Ms. Maxwell's renewed bail application. (See Exs. A-N, W-X). Far from the \ncruel caricature that the press has so recklessly depicted since the arrest of Jeffrey Epstein, \nthese letters demonstrate that Ms. Maxwell is generous, loving, and devoted to her family \nand friends, and that her life is firmly rooted in this country with her spouse and his two \nminor children. The signatories of these letters have known Ms. Maxwell for decades, and \nsome for her entire life. All know her to be the antithesis of what the government has \nalleged. They trust her completely, including with their minor children. \nThese people have stepped forward to support Ms. Maxwell, despite the considerable \nrisk that, if their names ever become public, they will be subjected to some of the same \nrelentless and harassing media intrusion and personal threats that Ms. Maxwell has \nexperienced for years. As a sign of their confidence that Ms. Maxwell will remain in this \ncountry, the sureties have agreed to sign their own bonds and to post meaningful pledges of \ncash or property in amounts that would cause them significant financial distress if Ms. \nMaxwell were to violate her bail conditions. \nThese letters directly address the concern the Court expressed at the last bail hearing \nthat Ms. Maxwell did not have \"any dependents [or] significant family ties\" to the United \nStates. (Tr. 84). If Ms. Maxwell were to flee, she would be leaving behind the family that \nhas been the center of her life for five years, she would be abandoning her spouse and \nI0 \nEFTA00094304\n", "char_count": 1924}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "stepchildren who are already suffering without her presence, and she would cause financial \nruin to herself and her closest family and friends. \n1. \nMs. Maxwell is Devoted to Her Spouse and Stepchildren and Would \nNever Destroy Her Family By Leaving the Country \nThe letter submitted by Ms. Maxwell's spouse powerfully demonstrates that Ms. \nMaxwell has deep roots in the United States and is not a flight risk. The letter describes Ms. \nMaxwell's domestic life with her spouse and his two minor children in Massachusetts in the \nfour years prior to her arrest. Her spouse describes Ms. Maxwell as a \"wonderful and loving \nperson,\" who has been kind and nurturing to his children and does not remotely resemble \nthe person depicted in the indictment. (Ex. A ¶ 4). Contrary to the government's assertion \nthat Ms. Maxwell lived a rootless, \"transient\" lifestyle (Dkt. 4 at 9), Ms. Maxwell lived a \nquiet family life with her spouse and his two young children for almost four years until \nEpstein's arrest in July 2019 ignited a media frenzy that has ripped the family apart. \nThe person described in the criminal charges is not the person we know. I have \nnever witnessed anything close to inappropriate with Ghislaine; quite to the \ncontrary, the Ghislaine I know is a wonderful and loving person. Over the \nprevious years she established an excellent relationship with my children and \nothers in my life. She was extraordinary loving to my kids, attending soccer \ngames and orchestra concerts, hosting birthday parties, cooking meals, and \notherwise she was lovingly active in their daily lives. My children miss her and \nthey trust her completely. \nUntil the explosion of media interest that followed the arrest and subsequent death \nin custody of Jeffrey Epstein in July thru August 2019, we led an entirely normal, \nhappy, home-based family life. It's hard to imagine with the hindsight of what \nhas occurred over the past year, but our existence was quiet and lovely. \n(Id. ¶¶ 4-5). \nThe letters\n... [truncated, 2261 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/16 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=16]", "char_count": 2261}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Mother, making sure that the children are/feel safe and secure. It is very obvious that they love \nher deeply. They are an incredibly strong and close family unit.\"); Ex. F (\"I and six of my \nchildren (plus their own children) all joined a large family event hosted by Ghislaine and her \nhusband in which she was very hospitable and obviously very much at home and in love.\"); \nEx. C (\"[Ghislaine] has called the United States her home for almost 30 years. She has deep \naffective family ties here in this country — where both my twin sister Isabel and I live. Most of \nall, her own husband and children are here.\"); Ex. B (\"I wish ... to attest to the loving \nrelationship she has with her husband and two stepchildren which I have personally witnessed on \nmany different occasions.\") . \nIndeed, it was because of Ms. Maxwell's devotion to her family, and her desire to \nprotect her spouse and his young children from harassment and threats, that she went \nforward at the first bail hearing without relying on her spouse as a co-signer, even though \nshe knew his support would greatly strengthen her bail application. As her spouse writes: \nI did not initially come forward as a co-signer of her first bail application ... \n[because we were] trying to protect my children from ferocious media \naggression.... Ghislaine and I had discussed we would do everything in our power \nto protect my children from the evil of the media's intrusion into our lives. \n(Ex. A ¶ 13). Her spouse is coming forward now because he is deeply concerned about how \nshe is being treated in the MDC and because the terrible consequences that he and Ms. \nMaxwell were trying to prevent have already occurred. He was recently removed as CEO of \nthe company he built, banks and insurance companies have severed all ties with him, and his \nchildren are still being harassed by the media, simply because of their association with Ms. \nMaxwell. (Id.111, 10-11). \nMs. Maxwell's spouse fully supports her and is prepared to put up\n... [truncated, 2128 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/17 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=17]", "char_count": 2128}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "has agreed to co-sign Ms. Maxwell's $22.5 million bond and to post all three properties he \nowns—all located in the United States and worth a total of approximately $8 million \ncombined—as security for the bond. As the financial report discussed later in this \nsubmission makes clear, $22.5 million represents all of the current assets of Ms. Maxwell \nand her spouse. One of the properties is the family home where Ms. Maxwell, her spouse, \nand his children have lived together for four years. If Ms. Maxwell were to violate her bail \nconditions, which she has no intention of doing, she would be leaving her spouse and \nstepchildren with virtually nothing. It is unfathomable that Ms. Maxwell would abandon her \nfamily, which she has fought so hard to protect, under these circumstances. \n2. \nA Number of Ms. Maxwell's Family and Friends, and the Security \nCompany Protecting Her Are Prepared to Sign Significant Bonds \nIn addition to her spouse, a number of Ms. Maxwell's family members and friends, \nmany of whom are U.S. citizens and residents, have volunteered to step forward as co-\nsigners. These sureties, as well as the others who have written letters on Ms. Maxwell's \nbehalf, know that Ms. Maxwell has never run from a difficult situation and will not do so \nnow. To show the depth of their support and their confidence that Ms. Maxwell will abide \nby her bail conditions and remain in this country, the sureties have agreed to sign separate \nbonds for Ms. Maxwell in amounts that are significant and meaningful to them, and each \nwould cause severe financial hardship if she were to violate her bail conditions. \nFor example, one surety, who is a U.S. citizen and resident, will post the only \nproperty she owns. This property is worth approximately $1.5 million and is her \"only nest-\negg for retirement.\" (Ex. C). She writes: \nI do not have any other savings and it would be completely devastating \nfinancially and in every way to my own family were the house to be taken \nover by the G\n... [truncated, 2076 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/18 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=18]", "char_count": 2076}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "(Id.). Nevertheless, she has \"no hesitation\" posting her home because she knows \"in every \nfibre of [her] being\" that Ms. Maxwell \"will never try to flee.\" (Id.). \nSimilarly, another surety who has agreed to sign a $3.5 million bond writes: \nThis amount represents the value of effectively all of my assets, including my \nhome and the other houses that support ... my business. If I lost these assets \nbecause Ghislaine violated the conditions of her release, I would be \nfinancially ruined. I make this pledge without reservation because I know that \nGhislaine will remain in the United States to face the charges against her. \n(Ex. F). Two other sureties, one of whom is a U.S. citizen and resident, will post cash bonds \nin the amount of $25,000, and another will post $2,000 in cash, which are significant \npledges for these individuals. \nIn addition to these bonds, the security company that will provide security services to \nMs. Maxwell upon her transfer into home confinement has agreed to post a $1 million bond \nin support of her bail application. In our collective experience as defense counsel, we are \nnot aware of a previous example where a security company has posted a bond for a \ndefendant. The head of the security company has confirmed that they have never done this \nfor a defendant in the past but are willing to do so here because of his company's \"long-\nstanding relationship with Ms. Maxwell\" and because he is \"confident that she will not try \nto flee.\" (Ex. S). \nIn sum, these bonds reflect the depth of support that Ms. Maxwell has from her \nfamily and friends, who are risking their livelihoods, their safety, and their ability to live \nwithout constant media harassment to support her. (See Ex. B) (\"Absolutely anyone who \ndares to put their head above the parapet so to speak, to ... support Ghislaine personally, gets it \nshot off immediately amid a hail of social vilification and malignancy and reputational \nslaughtering.\"). Ms. Maxwell would never destroy those clo\n... [truncated, 2090 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/19 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=19]", "char_count": 2090}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "B. \nMs. Maxwell Has Provided a Thorough Review of Her Finances for the \nPast Five Years \nThe government raised concerns at the initial bail hearing about the accuracy and \ncompleteness of the financial disclosures that Ms. Maxwell provided to Pretrial Services. \n(Dkt. 22 at 11-12; Tr. 28-29, 34-35). The Court stated that it did not have \"a clear picture of \nMs. Maxwell's finances and the resources available to her and therefore had no way \"to set \nfinancial bail conditions that could reasonably assure her appearance in court.\" (Tr. 86-87). \nTo address the Court's questions about Ms. Maxwell's finances, defense counsel \nretained Macalvins, a highly reputable accounting firm in the United Kingdom, to conduct \nan analysis of Ms. Maxwell's assets and finances for the past five years. The Macalvins \naccountants reviewed thousands of pages of financial documents, including bank statements, \ntax returns, FBAR filings, and other materials to create a clear picture of the assets held by \nMs. Maxwell and her spouse, as well as any assets held in trust for the benefit of Ms. \nMaxwell, and the source of those assets from 2015-2020. This analysis, which is based in \nsubstantial part on documents that the government provided in discovery, has involved a \nsignificant amount of work and has taken substantial time to complete. It was not possible \nto perform this analysis in the brief time between Ms. Maxwell's arrest and the initial bail \nhearing, especially with Ms. Maxwell detained following her arrest. \nThe Macalvins report was also reviewed by Preston Faro, a Certified Fraud Examiner \nand a former IRS Special Agent with over 40 years of experience in complex financial fraud \ninvestigations. As a Special Agent, Mr. Faro investigated numerous financial fraud and criminal \ntax cases, including several in this District. Mr. Faro reviewed the Macalvins report and the \nunderlying documents and determined that it presents a complete and accurate summary of the \nassets held by Ms. Maxw\n... [truncated, 2093 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/20 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=20]", "char_count": 2093}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "trust for the benefit of Ms. Maxwell, from 2015-2020. The Macalvins report and Mr. Faro's \nreport are attached as Exhibits O and P.4\nAs set forth in the Macalvins report, Ms. Maxwell's net worth at the beginning of \n2015 was approximately $20,200,000. (Ex. O1111). The 2015 tax return records the sale of \na residential property in New York City for $15,075,000. The address of this property is \n116 East 65th Street, New York, NY 10065. The proceeds of the sale were deposited at \nUBS in an account of 116 E 65th LLC, an LLC established by Ms. Maxwell. The net \nproceeds were subsequently transferred to other accounts at UBS controlled by Ms. \nMaxwell and were used, in part, to purchase other properties. (Id. ¶ 12). The sale of Ms. \nMaxwell's New York apartment coincided with her intention to move to Massachusetts to \nlive with her spouse and his children. (See Ex. A ¶ 2). \nMs. Maxwell married her spouse in 2016 and commenced filing joint U.S. tax returns \nfrom the 2016 tax year until today. (Ex. O ¶ 13). In 2016, Ms. Maxwell transferred the \nmajority of her assets into a trust controlled by her spouse and her sister. (Id.). All assets in \nthe trust were distributed to Ms. Maxwell's spouse in 2019. (Id. at 9). Ms. Maxwell and her \nspouse's net worth as of October 31, 2020 was approximately $22,500,000. (Id. 15).5\nThere has been no alienation of any assets and no significant sum of cash has been \ntransferred outside of the control of Ms. Maxwell or her spouse in the period from 2015-\n.1 We have not provided the Court with the appendices to the Macalvins report because they are voluminous. If the \nCourt would like copies of the appendices, we are happy to provide them. \n5 At her Pretrial Services interview, Ms. Maxwell reported that she believed she had approximately $3.8 million in \nassets, which included her London residence worth approximately $3 million, and approximately $800,000 in bank \naccounts. Ms. Maxwell was detained at the time and had no access to her financial\n... [truncated, 2410 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/21 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=21]", "char_count": 2410}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "2020, other than daily living expenditures for her family and for professional services in the \ndefense of Ms. Maxwell from the charges she faces. (Id. ¶ 16). \nThe Macalvins report confirms that Ms. Maxwell disclosed all of her foreign bank \naccounts in FBAR filings and properly disclosed her bank accounts, investments and other \nassets in her U.S. tax filings at all times. (Id. 11125, 30). The report also explains that the \ntransfers of funds between various accounts in the past few years, which the government \nhighlighted in their initial bail submission (Dkt. 22 at 11-12), reflected movements between \nbanks triggered by the closure of one banking relationship and the opening of new \nrelationship, as well movements of cash maturing on deposit and other financial \ninvestments. (Id. ¶ 18). \nAt the last bail hearing, the government suggested that Ms. Maxwell's finances were \n\"opaque\" and that she potentially had \"significant [] undetermined and undisclosed wealth.\" \n(Tr. 27; Dkt. 22 at 11-12). The Macalvins report lifts this cloud of unjustified intrigue and \nprovides a straightforward answer: Ms. Maxwell and her spouse currently have assets worth \napproximately $22.5 million.6 Accordingly, the proposed bond amount of $22.5 million \nrepresents all of the couple's current assets. \nThe report further shows that Ms. Maxwell has no undisclosed wealth and is not \nhiding assets overseas. To the contrary, for the past several years, Ms. Maxwell and her \nhusband have disclosed their foreign assets by submitting FBAR filings regarding their \n6 We have redacted the name of the bank where Ms. Maxwell's spouse recently established an account after his \nother banks abruptly severed ties with him due to his connection to Ms. Maxwell following her arrest. Although the \nbalance of the account is fully disclosed in the Macalvins report, we felt it necessary to redact the name of the bank \nbecause the government has not been able to give us assurances that they will not contact the ba\n... [truncated, 2489 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/22 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=22]", "char_count": 2489}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "foreign bank accounts. Ms. Maxwell is not trying to hide anything from the government. \nShe has been entirely transparent with her finances and has filed accurate and timely joint \ntax returns with her spouse for the last four years, and she has put it all at risk of forfeiture if \nshe flees under the proposed bail package. The Macalvins report and the report of Preston \nFaro give the Court a clear picture of Ms. Maxwell's finances. Accordingly, the Court \nshould have no pause about granting her on bail on the proposed terms. \nC. \nMs. Maxwell Was Not Hiding from the Government Before Her Arrest \n1. \nMs. Maxwell Was Trying to Protect Herself and Her Family from a \nMedia Frenzy and from Physical Threats \nThe letter from Ms. Maxwell's spouse also forcefully debunks the fiction that Ms. \nMaxwell was trying to conceal her whereabouts from the government before her arrest, as \nthe government argued at the first bail hearing. (Tr. 25). Ms. Maxwell made efforts to \nremove herself from the public eye solely to prevent the intrusion of the frenzied press into \nher personal family life and to protect herself, her spouse, and his children from third parties \nwho threatened violence. To suggest that she was a fugitive is patently wrong. \nAfter Epstein's arrest and subsequent death in BOP custody, the media coverage of \nMs. Maxwell spiked dramatically, as the press rushed to substitute Ms. Maxwell for Epstein \nas the target of the scandal. The graph below illustrates the volume of press articles relating \nto Ms. Maxwell over the course of the last five years.' The graph shows that Ms. Maxwell \nwas mentioned in news articles only sporadically between October 2015 and June 2019. It \nwas not until Mr. Epstein's arrest in July 2019 that Ms. Maxwell was thrown into the media \nspotlight. For example, Ms. Maxwell was mentioned in only 59 articles in total from \nOctober 2015 to June 2019. Immediately following Epstein's arrest, however, she was \n7 In order to quantify the number of artic\n... [truncated, 2142 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/23 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=23]", "char_count": 2142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "named in 97 articles in the month of July 2019 alone. The level of press coverage spiked \nagain in November 2019 when the British tabloid The Sun ran an advertisement offering a \n£10,000 bounty for information about Ms. Maxwell's whereabouts and it continued at a \nheightened level over the next several months. \nGHISLAINE \nMAXWELL \nMEDIA \nMENTIONS: \n2015-2020 \n300 \nNOVEMBER 2019 \nThe Sun offer; \nE10,000reward \nAUGUST 10, 2019- 1 \nEpstein'odeath \nJULY 6, 2019 \nEpstein arrested \n250 \nNOV 28, 2018 \n200 \nMiami HeratdArtiCle Series \n•Pervervonof3ustice\" \nLL 150 \n0 \na \nW 100 \nz \ns0 \n0  \n' \n4 \n4 \n4 \n4 \n4 \nlo :o 4 \n4. 4 \n4 \n4 \n4 \n4 \n4 \n4 \n4 \n# \nIII \n11 Os Ol, \ncr ce 41, \nvo \n0 eft' #1 of 0' \nThis graph depicts in stark visual terms the sea change in media attention that \nupended Ms. Maxwell's life at the time of Epstein's arrest. But it was not only harassment \nfrom the press that Ms. Maxwell suddenly encountered at this time. She also faced a deluge \nof threatening messages on social media in the days immediately following Epstein's arrest \nand death. (See Ex. Q). The hatred directed towards Ms. Maxwell in these posts is palpable \nand unsettling. Despite the fact that Ms. Maxwell was not charged—indeed, not even \nmentioned—in the Epstein indictment, and had not been charged with any crimes, the \nauthors referred to her as a \"crazy, pedophile, pimp, bitch\" and a \"subhuman c*nt,\" and \ncalled for her to \"rot in jail.\" These people also encouraged all manner of violent acts \n19 \nEFTA00094313\n", "char_count": 1505}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "against Ms. Maxwell. For example, one post stated \"they need to get this bitch n string her \nup by her neck . . . Pekin monster.\" Another stated: \nI hope someone finds her and kills her. That would be justice. Obviously her \nlawyers know's [sic] where she is, someone should stick them up to batteries \nuntil we find out where she is. \nThese posts were particularly chilling because some of them suggested that the \nauthors were in close physical proximity to Ms. Maxwell and might be able to carry out the \nviolent acts they had been threatening. For example, in response to an August 14, 2019 \nnews report that Ms. Maxwell might be living in Massachusetts, one person wrote: \nSHE'S HERE in #Massachusetts ?! The bitch #GhislaineMaxwell who \n#SexTrafficked young girls for #Epstein ?!?! Why the hell isn't she being \nbrought in for questioning @ManchesterMAPD ?! WE DO NOT WANT \nHER HERE! #SleezyLeach She is CLOSE ENOUGH to me, I could grab her \nmyself! \nThe intense media attention and violent threats made it no longer possible for Ms. \nMaxwell and her family to live a quiet life and required Ms. Maxwell to take more drastic \nsteps to protect herself and her family. Rather than see the children harmed by even more \nunwanted media attention, Ms. Maxwell made the difficult decision to separate herself from \nher family and leave her home. As her spouse writes: \nThe \"reporting\" of Ghislaine over the past year has exploded exponentially. From \nthe time of Epstein's arrest and death in custody in the summer of 2019 until \nGhislaine's own arrest in July of this year, huge and increasingly frightening \nlevels of media interest meant that our previous quiet existence became \nunbearable. There are many examples of violence whose seeds were born in \nconspiracy theories, and the experiences of QAnon, Pizzagate, and the recent \nJudge Salas attack are terrifying.... \nIt is hard to communicate in words the feeling of being stalked, spied upon and \ntrapped by constant, 24/7 media intrusion fro\n... [truncated, 2247 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/25 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=25]", "char_count": 2247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "It was this aggressive media posture which led to the decision that the only sure-\nfire means of ensuring the children's and my protection was for her to leave \nMassachusetts. The media frenzy has included the publication of an article in the \nBoston Globe about the kids' school, ABC continuing to harass school leadership, \nand tabloid reporters pointing cameras at my children. This harassment is \nunacceptable and dangerous. \n(Ex. A ¶¶ 8-10). Ms. Maxwell had no choice but to separate herself from her family and \n\"live on her own, shielding herself as best she could from the media hunting her.\" (Id. ¶ 11). \nSince Ms. Maxwell's own arrest in July 2020, the press attention has exploded. It \nsignificantly dwarfs the media attention given to other recent high-profile defendants such \nas Harvey Weinstein, Bill Cosby, Joaquin \"El Chapo\" Guzman Loera, and Keith Raniere. \nAs reflected in the graph below, in the 90-day period immediately following her arrest, Ms. \nMaxwell was mentioned in more national media articles than in the analogous 90-day \nperiods for Mr. Weinstein, Mr. Cosby, Mr. Guzman Loera, and Mr. Raniere combined. \nALL U.S. MEDIA COVERAGE COMPARISON \n(90 DAYS OF ARREST) \n7.000 \n6.000 \n5.000 \n5. \na \n4.003 \na \n3.000 \n2.000 \n1.000 \n0 \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL \nHarvey Wein:fro \nBill Cosby \n3coquin Guzman Lon \nWith Ranier, \nEFTA00094315\n", "char_count": 1350}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "2. \nMs. Maxwell's Counsel Was in Regular Contact with the Government \nPrior to Her Arrest \nAt no time, however, did Ms. Maxwell intend to flee or hide from the government, as the \ngovernment argued at the last bail hearing. In fact, her intent was exactly the opposite. As her \nspouse's letter makes clear, after spending a few months away from Massachusetts, Ms. Maxwell \nmoved back to New England so that she could be close to her family, but also to be within \ndriving distance of the prosecutors in New York in case they wished to speak to her. (Ex. A \n12) (\"[Ghislaine] was adamant to not only stay in the United States to fight the smears against \nher, but to be within driving distance of New York.\"). Contrary to the impression given by the \ngovernment, Ms. Maxwell was not \"changing locations on multiple occasions\" as if she were a \nfugitive from justice. (Tr. 87). After Ms. Maxwell moved into the house in New Hampshire in \nDecember 2019, she remained there continuously for approximately seven months until her \narrest. (See Ex. B) (\"[S]he was finally able to locate a place where she could not be moving \naround constantly and collect herself to fight for her life and to clear her name.\"). \nMs. Maxwell, through her counsel, was also in regular contact with the government \nfrom the moment of Epstein's arrest up the time of her own arrest, as would be customary in \nsuch situations. Defense counsel corresponded by email, spoke on the phone, or had in-\nperson meetings with government in July, August, September, and October 2019, and also \nin January and March 2020. The timeline attached to this submission illustrates the extent \nof these contacts. (Ex. R). Defense counsel also requested an opportunity to be heard in the \nevent that the government was considering any charging decisions against Ms. Maxwell. \nWe were never given that opportunity, which is uncharacteristic for the Southern District of \nNew York, nor were we given any notice of her impending arrest. \n22 \nEFTA000\n... [truncated, 2006 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/27 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=27]", "char_count": 2006}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "The government argued to the Court that defense counsel's contact with the \nprosecutors in the months leading up to Ms. Maxwell's arrest prove little about her intent to \nstay in this country simply because she never disclosed her location. (Tr. 26). While Ms. \nMaxwell was understandably not in the habit of volunteering her whereabouts given the \nintensity of the press attention, her counsel would have provided that information had the \ngovernment asked for it. The government never did. \n3. \nMs. Maxwell Did Not Try to Avoid Arrest, Nor Was She \"Good At\" \nHiding \nSimilarly, had the government reached out to defense counsel before Ms. Maxwell's \narrest, we would have willingly arranged for her self-surrender. We were never given that \nchance. Instead, the government arrested her in a totally unnecessary early morning raid \nwith multiple federal agents at her residence in New Hampshire, on the eve of the one-year \nanniversary of the arrest of Jeffrey Epstein, creating the misimpression that Ms. Maxwell \nwas hiding from them. That is simply not the case. \nThe government argued that the events of Ms. Maxwell's arrest—in particular, that \nshe moved herself into an interior room when the officers approached the house and that \nthey found a cell phone wrapped in tin foil—evidence an attempt to evade law enforcement. \n(Tr. 32-34). As we previously explained to the Court, Ms. Maxwell was protecting herself \nfrom the press, not trying to avoid arrest. (Tr. 54-57). \nSince the hearing, we have obtained the accompanying statement from Matthew \nHellyer, the head of the security company guarding Ms. Maxwell at the time of her arrest, \nwhich was not available at the time of the initial hearing. (Ex. S). Mr. Hellyer's statement \ndemonstrates that Ms. Maxwell was not avoiding arrest, but was following an agreed-upon \nprocedure to protect herself in the event of a potential threat to her safety or security. \n23 \nEFTA00094317\n", "char_count": 1939}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "According to Mr. Hellyer, the security guard on duty that day had seen helicopters flying \nover the house, which he assumed to be the press. (Id.). When the guard saw the FBI \nagents walking up the driveway to the house, he again assumed that they were members of \nthe press. (Id.). Accordingly, he radioed Ms. Maxwell to alert her that the press was on the \ngrounds and approaching the house. (Id.). In accordance with the procedure that Ms. \nMaxwell's security personnel had put in place for such an event, Ms. Maxwell moved away \nfrom the windows and into a safe room inside the house. (Id.). Ms. Maxwell was not trying \nto avoid arrest; she was simply following the established security protocols to protect herself \nfrom what had been informed was an ambush by the press. \nRegarding the cellphone wrapped in tin foil, we explained to the Court at the initial \nbail hearing that Ms. Maxwell took this step to prevent the press from accessing her phone \nafter the Second Circuit inadvertently unsealed certain court records with the phone number \nunredacted. (Tr. 55-56). Having now reviewed the discovery produced by the government, \nit is clear that Ms. Maxwell was not at all the \"master spy\" the government makes her out to \nbe and was not wrapping the phone in order to evade detection by law enforcement. \nFirst, the cellphone in question was subscribed in the name of \"Terramar Project, \nInc.,\" which is easily identifiable through a simple Google search as Ms. Maxwell's charity. \nSecond, Ms. Maxwell used the phone to make calls as late as May 2020, just before her \narrest. She would never have used the phone if she had been concerned that the authorities \nwere using it to track her. Third, Ms. Maxwell had another phone subscribed in the name of \n\"G Max\" that she was using as her primary phone, which was not covered. It would make \nno sense for her to try to wrap one phone in tin foil to avoid detection and not the other. \n24 \nEFTA00094318\n", "char_count": 1960}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Indeed, the discovery reflects that it was not hard at all for the government to locate Ms. \nMaxwell when they wanted to find her by tracking her primary phone. \nIn sum, the cellphone clearly shows that Ms. Maxwell was not \"good at\" hiding or \nthat she was avoiding arrest, as the government claimed. (Tr. 31-32). She was trying to \nprotect herself as best as she could from harassment by the press, not capture by law \nenforcement. Moreover, this should not be a bar to granting bail. The proposed conditions \nensure her presence at home in plain sight of her sister (and the security guards), GPS-\nmonitored, and under strict Pretrial supervision. \nD. \nMs. Maxwell Has Waived Her Extradition Rights and Could Not Seek \nRefuge in the United Kingdom or France \nAt the initial hearing, the government argued that Ms. Maxwell, a naturalized U.S. citizen \nwho has lived in the United States for almost 30 years, might flee to the United Kingdom or \nFrance if granted bail, despite the fact that she did not leave the country for nearly a year after \nEpstein's arrest. (Dkt. 22 at 6.) The government asserted in its reply brief that France \"does not \nextradite its citizens to the United States pursuant to French law.\" (Id.) At the bail hearing, the \ngovernment represented that \"France will not extradite a French citizen to the United States as a \nmatter of law, even if the defendant is a dual citizen of the United States,\" and that extradition by \nthe United Kingdom would be \"lengthy\" and \"uncertain\" with bail \"very likely\" pending the \nextradition proceeding. (Tr. 27.) These assertions are incorrect, particularly given Ms. \nMaxwell's irrevocable waiver of her extradition rights with respect to both the United Kingdom \nand France. \nAs we noted for the Court at the initial hearing, the concern that Ms. Maxwell would \nattempt to flee the United States is entirely unfounded given that Ms. Maxwell had every motive \nand opportunity to flee after the arrest and death of Jeffrey Epstein, but ch\n... [truncated, 2040 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/30 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=30]", "char_count": 2040}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "country. (Dkt. 18 at 12-14, Tr. 52-53). It is even more unfounded in light of the daily avalanche \nof media coverage of Ms. Maxwell. She is now one of the most recognizable and infamous \npeople in the world. She is being pursued relentlessly by the press, which would no doubt be \ncamped out by her front door every day if she were granted bail. The notion that Ms. Maxwell \ncould somehow flee to a foreign country during a worldwide pandemic (presumably, by plane), \nwhile being supervised and monitored 24 hours a day and with the eyes of the global press corps \non her every minute, without being caught, is absurd. \nTo the extent the Court is concerned that her calculus may have changed since her arrest \nbecause the threat of prosecution has now crystallized into concrete charges (Tr. 85-86), Ms. \nMaxwell has addressed that concern head-on—she will execute irrevocable waivers of her right \nto contest extradition in both the United Kingdom and France. (Ex. T). These waivers \ndemonstrate Ms. Maxwell's firm commitment to remain in this country to face the charges \nagainst her. Moreover, as discussed more fully in the attached expert reports, because of these \nwaivers and other factors, it is highly unlikely that Ms. Maxwell would be able to successfully \nresist an extradition request from the United States to either country, in the extremely unlikely \nevent she were to violate her bail conditions. (Exs. U-V). Moreover, any extradition \nproceedings in either country would be resolved promptly. (Id.). \nCourts have addressed concerns about a defendant's ties to a foreign state that enforces \nextradition waivers by requiring the defendant to execute such a waiver as a condition of \nrelease—including in cases where the defendants, unlike Ms. Maxwell, were not U.S. citizens. \nSee, e.g., United States v. Cirillo, No. 99-1514, 1999 WL 1456536, at *2 (3d Cir. July 13, 1999) \n(vacating district court's detention order and reinstating magistrate's release order, which \nrequired forei\n... [truncated, 2104 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/31 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=31]", "char_count": 2104}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "of release); United States v. Salvagno, 314 F. Supp. 2d 115, 119 (N.D.N.Y. 2004) (ordering each \nof two defendants to \"execute and file with the Clerk of the Court a waiver of extradition \napplicable to any nation or foreign territory in which he may be found as a condition of his \ncontinued release\"); United States v. Karni, 298 F. Supp. 2d 129, 132-33 (D.D.C. 2004) \n(requiring Israeli citizen who lived in South Africa and had \"no ties to the United States\" to sign \nwaiver of rights not to be extradited under Israeli and South African extradition treaties with \nUnited States); United States v. Chen, 820 F. Supp. 1205, 1212 (N.D. Cal. 1992) (ordering as a \ncondition of release that defendants \"execute waivers of challenges to extradition from any \nnation where they may be found\"). Moreover, a defendant's waiver of the right to appeal an \nextradition order has been recognized as an indication of the defendant's intent not to flee. See, \ne.g., United States v. Khashoggi, 717 F. Supp. 1048, 1052 (S.D.N.Y. 1989) (Judge Keenan found \ndefendant's extradition appeal waiver \"manifests an intention to remain here and face the \ncharges against him\"). \nIn response to the government's assertions, Ms. Maxwell has obtained the accompanying \nreports of experts in United Kingdom and French extradition law, who have analyzed the \nlikelihood that Ms. Maxwell, in the event she were to flee to the United Kingdom or France, \nwould be able to resist extradition to the United States after having executed a waiver of her right \nto do so. Both have concluded that it is highly unlikely that she would be able to resist \nextradition successfully. \nUnited Kingdom. With respect to the United Kingdom, submitted herewith is a report \nfrom David Perry (\"Perry Rep.\"), a U.K. barrister who is widely considered one of the United \nKingdom's preeminent extradition practitioners. (Perry Rep. Annex B ¶ 2.1) (attached as Exhibit \nU). Mr. Perry has acted on behalf of many overseas governments in extradition\n... [truncated, 2036 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/32 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=32]", "char_count": 2036}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "appeared in the High Court, House of Lords and Supreme Court in leading extradition cases; and \nhas acted as an expert consultant to the Commonwealth Secretariat on international cooperation. \n(Id.). In 2011 and 2012, Mr. Perry was part of a select team appointed by the U.K. government \nto conduct a review of the United Kingdom's extradition arrangements, a review that formed the \nbasis of changes to the 2003 Extradition Act. (Id. Annex B ¶ 3.1). \nIn Mr. Perry's opinion, it is \"highly unlikely that Ghislaine Maxwell would be able \nsuccessfully to resist extradition to the United States\" in connection with this case. (Perry Rep. \n12(e)). After concluding that none of the potentially applicable bars to extradition or human \nrights objections would prevent Ms. Maxwell's extradition, Mr. Perry explains that Ms. \nMaxwell's waiver of her extradition rights \"would be admissible in any extradition proceedings \nand, in cases, such as this one, where the requested person consents to their extradition, the \nextradition process is likely to take between one and three months to complete.\" (Id. IN 24-39). \nMr. Perry's report also undercuts the government's representation at the initial hearing regarding \nlikelihood of bail (see Tr. 27), opining that \"a person who absconded from [a] US criminal \nproceeding in breach of bail... is extremely unlikely to be granted bail\" in a subsequent U.K. \nextradition proceeding. (Perry Rep. 1 23). \nFrance. The accompanying report of William Julie (\"Julie Rep.\") reviews the French \nextradition process as it would likely be applied to Ms. Maxwell. Mr. Julie is an expert on \nFrench extradition law who has handled extradition cases both within and outside the European \nUnion and regularly appears as an extradition expert in French courts. (Julie Rep.) (attached as \nExhibit V). Mr. Julie explains that, contrary to the government's representation, \"the extradition \nof a French national to the USA is legally permissible under French law.\" (Id. at 1). \n2\n... [truncated, 2016 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/33 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=33]", "char_count": 2016}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Mr. Julie opines that the French entity with jurisdiction over the legality of extradition \nrequests would not oppose Ms. Maxwell's extradition on the ground that she is a French citizen, \nand that it is \"highly unlikely that the French government would refuse to issue and execute an \nextradition decree\" against her. (Id. at 2). Mr. Julie bases his opinion largely on (i) Ms. \nMaxwell's U.S. citizenship; (ii) her irrevocable waiver of her extradition rights with respect to \nthe United States; (iii) the fact that the issue would arise only if Ms. Maxwell had fled to France \nin violation of strict bail conditions in the United States; (iv) the fact that a failure to extradite \nwould obligate French authorities to try Ms. Maxwell in French courts for the same 25-year-old \nconduct alleged in the indictment, which did not take place in France; and (v) France's \ndiplomatic interest in accommodating an extradition request from the United States. (Id.). Mr. \nJulie adds that the extradition process would likely be \"disposed of expediently\"; where the \nrequesting state emphasizes the urgent nature of the extradition request, \"the extradition decree is \ngenerally issued in only a few weeks.\" (Id. at 2-3). And in any event, while the extradition \nproceedings are pending, \"the French judicial authorities would most certainly decide that [Ms. \nMaxwell] has to remain in custody given her flight from the USA and the violation of her bail \nterms and conditions in this requesting State.\" (Id. at 12). \nMs. Maxwell has no intention of fleeing the country and has relinquished her rights to \ncontest extradition. She has always maintained her innocence and will continue to fight the \nallegations against her here in the United States, as she has in the past. Even if she were to flee \nafter being granted bail (which she will not), it is likely that Ms. Maxwell would be extradited \nexpeditiously from France or the United Kingdom. Accordingly, the Court should give no \nweight in the bail analy\n... [truncated, 2322 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/34 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=34]", "char_count": 2322}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "E. \nThe Discovery Contains No Meaningful Documentary Corroboration of \nthe Government's Allegations Against Ms. Maxwell \nAt the initial bail hearing, the government represented to the Court that \"the evidence \nin this case is strong\" and that the allegations of the alleged victims were \"backed up [by] \ncontemporaneous documents .. [including] flight records, diary entries, business records, \nand other evidence.\" (Dkt. 4 at 5.) The Court credited those representations and accepted \nthe government's proffer that the witness testimony would be \"corroborated by significant \ncontemporaneous documentary evidence.\" (Tr. 82) (emphasis added). The defense, of \ncourse, could not rebut the government's representations at the hearing because the \ngovernment had not yet produced discovery. \nSince then, the government has produced, and the defense has reviewed, hundreds of \nthousands of pages of discovery, including the entire initial tranche of discovery that the \ngovernment represented was the core of its case against Ms. Maxwell.9 The discovery \ncontains no meaningful documentary corroboration of the allegations whatsoever, much less \n\"significant\" corroboration that the Court was led to believe existed. The vast majority of \nthe discovery that the defense has reviewed relates to the time period in the 2O0Os and the \n201Os, well after the conspiracy charged in the indictment (1994-1997). These documents \ninclude court filings and other documents related to the Giuffre v. Maxwell defamation case \nto which Ms. Maxwell was a party, and numerous bank records and other financial records \nfrom this later time period that have nothing to do with the charged conspiracy. In fact, only \nDaily Mail, \"French prosecutors probing Jeffrey Epstein over rape and abuse of children in Paris widen probe to \ninclude Ghislaine Maxwell to see if British socialite was involved in his offending,\" (Oct. 25, 2020), \nhttps://www.dailymail.co.ukinews/article-8878825/French-prosecutors-probing-Jeffrey-Epst\n... [truncated, 2468 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/35 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=35]", "char_count": 2468}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "a very small fraction of the discovery pertains in any way to the individuals we believe to be \nthe three complainants named in the indictment, and none of it corroborates any allegations \nof \"grooming\" or sexual assault or a conspiracy with Epstein involving Ms. Maxwell. \nFor example, the government represented to the Court that it had \"diary entries\" that \ncorroborated the witness testimony, suggesting that more than one of the complainants had \nkept contemporaneous diaries that implicated Ms. Maxwell. (Dkt. 4 at 5). The discovery \nproduced thus far contains only seven pages from a single diary, which we believe belongs \nto Victim 2. The entries relate to two days in January 1996 and purportedly describe \ninteractions with Epstein around this same time. But Ms. Maxwell's name does not appear \nonce on those seven pages, nor is there any suggestion that she was involved in any conduct \npertaining to Epstein. Furthermore, because the discovery does not include the rest of the \npages of the diary, we cannot see whether the author mentioned Ms. Maxwell in any other \nentries. We assume, however, that if the diary did mention Ms. Maxwell—for example, in \nan entry on or around the date the sexual assault was alleged to have occurred—the \ngovernment would have provided those pages. l° The only conclusion to draw from this is \nthat the \"diary entries\" that the government claimed would corroborate its case against Ms. \nMaxwell are, instead, exculpatory. \nIn addition, the flight records that the government touted at the bail hearing, which \ninclude flight logs that purportedly list the passengers who flew on Epstein's jet on \nparticular days, provide little support for their case. The logs do not include any mention of \nthe people we believe to be two of the three complainants, and show only that one of them \nflew on Epstein's jet on four occasions. At most, these records corroborate that this \n1° As previously stated, the government has never seen a complete copy of the diar\n... [truncated, 2050 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/36 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=36]", "char_count": 2050}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "individual may have traveled with Epstein, Ms. Maxwell, and others on a handful of \nparticular days, but they do not support in any way the allegations that Ms. Maxwell \nsexually abused her or \"groomed\" her for Epstein, as charged in the indictment. \nThe discovery also does not contain any police reports in which the people we \nbelieve to be the complainants reported the alleged crimes to law enforcement. To the \ncontrary, the only police reports provided are exculpatory. The discovery includes an \nNYPD police report filed on August 29, 1996 by the sister of the person we believe to be \none of the complainants. This report, however, does not mention the complainant or Ms. \nMaxwell at all. The report does not even claim any sexual abuse; it simply claims that \nEpstein alone threatened to burn the sister's artwork. \nIn sum, the discovery contains not a single contemporaneous email, text message, \nphone record, diary entry, police report, or recording that implicates Ms. Maxwell in the \n1994-1997 conduct underlying the conspiracy charged in the indictment. The few \ndocuments in the discovery that pertain to the people we believe to be the three \ncomplainants referenced in the indictment do little, if anything, to support the government's \ncase against Ms. Maxwell: \n• \nFor the person we believe to be complainant #2, the discovery includes the \ndiary pages already discussed, a photograph (it appears to be a school \nphotograph), and some heavily redacted flight records from 2019. \n• \nFor the person we believe to be complainant #3, the discovery includes a \nfew photographs (fully clothed) and a handful of emails between her and \nEpstein that date from 2008-2012 and do not mention Ms. Maxwell. \nThese emails show that this individual continued to communicate with \nEpstein and asked to get together with him years after he allegedly \nsexually abused her. In fact, in these emails, she offers to send pictures of \nherself to Epstein in jail to cheer him up and asks to stay at his\n... [truncated, 2039 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/37 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=37]", "char_count": 2039}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "• \nFor the person we believe to be complainant #1, the discovery includes a \nfew more records, including school records, photographs (fully clothed, \nincluding professional head shots), flight logs reflecting that she flew on \nEpstein's jet on a handful of occasions—including in the 2000s well after \nshe claims she \"escaped\" from Epstein's orbit—and some heavily \nredacted flight records from 2019-2020. But none of these documents \nimplicate Ms. Maxwell in any criminal conduct. \nIn addition, the discovery appears to show that, apart from issuing a subpoena to the \nlaw firm Boies, Schiller and Flexner, which represents a number of Epstein's alleged \nvictims, the government did not issue subpoenas for documents related to Ms. Maxwell until \nafter Epstein's death. Although the discovery does not include the grand jury subpoenas \nthemselves, the subpoena returns appear to indicate that the government began issuing \nsubpoenas for Ms. Maxwell's financial information on August 16, 2019, six days after \nEpstein's death, and issued additional subpoenas in the months that followed. The facts \nstrongly imply that government only chose to pursue a case against Ms. Maxwell—who was \nnot named in the Epstein indictment—because the main target, Jeffrey Epstein, had died in \ntheir custody. The lack of corroboration in the discovery confirms that the case against Ms. \nMaxwell was an afterthought and was reverse engineered based on allegations of 25-year-\nold conduct from a small number of alleged victims. \nThus, notwithstanding the statement in the government's bail submission, we have \nbeen provided with no meaningful documentary corroboration in this case. It appears that \nthe evidence in this case boils down to witness testimony about events that allegedly took \nplace over 25 years ago. Far from creating a flight risk, the lack of corroboration only \nreinforces Ms. Maxwell's conviction that she has been falsely accused and strengthens her \nlong-standing desire to face the allegatio\n... [truncated, 2135 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/38 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=38]", "char_count": 2135}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "F. \nThe Proposed Bail Package Is Expansive and Far Exceeds What Is \nNecessary to Reasonably Assure Ms. Maxwell's Presence in Court \nIn light of the additional information that Ms. Maxwell has provided in connection \nwith this submission, which responds to each of the concerns raised by the government at \nthe initial bail hearing, the government cannot meet its burden to establish that no set of bail \nconditions would reasonably assure Ms. Maxwell's appearance in court. The proposed bail \npackage is exceptional in its scope, addresses all of the factors that the Court considered in \nevaluating risk of flight, and is more than sufficient to warrant her release from BOP \ncustody and transfer to restricted home detention. \nCourts in this Circuit have ordered release of high-profile defendants with financial \nmeans and foreign citizenship on bonds in lower amounts with less or no security with similar or \nless restrictive conditions: \nDEFENDANT \nSADR \nDREIER \nMADOFF \nKARNS \nwire \nSABHN A N I \nrvera \nBOOMER \nArrozW.Soulhrarm \nMAXWELL \n80ND \nSECURED \nHOW \nDETENTKX4 \nEt ECTRONK \nNK)NITORING \nPRNATF \nSECURITY \nU.S. CITIZEN \nFOREIGN CITIZENSHIP \nS32 6M \nNightly \nCurfew \n0\nNO \nNO \nIran I St Kitts-Newt \n510M \nNO \n0 \nCI\nCif \nNO \nSIOM\nO \n0 I O \nNO \nCif \nNO \n$1OM \n0 \na I 0 \nNO \nVidiToOnly \nNO \ner,\nSaudi Arabia \nNO \nIndonesia \nMUM \n0 \na 1 * \n52.5M \na \na \ne \nS2 m \n52M \n0 0 \nNO \nNO \n0\n \nNO \nIndia \nSwitzerland \ne \n- 0 \na a \n0 \n0 \nNO \nNO \nIsrael I South Africa \n$7.SM \na \nNOT \nREPORTED \n0 I 0 \nNO \nChina \nBSOOK \nNO \nNO \nNO \nNO \nNO \nDenmark \nS2t5M \nxxx-xxr,\nCI 0 \n45( \n45( \n45( \nUK I Franc* \nThe Court should also not give any weight to the government's speculative assertions that \nothers might provide money and other support to Ms. Maxwell if she were to flee. (Dkt. 22 at \n34 \nEFTA00094328\n", "char_count": 1797}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "11-12). Ms. Maxwell is not obligated to rebut every theoretical possibility that the government \nmight raise that may contribute to a potential flight risk in order to be granted bail. That is not \nthe standard. Cl United States v. Orta, 760 F.2d 887, 888 n.4, 892-93 (8th Cir. 1985) (\"The \nlegal standard required by the [Bail Reform] Act is one of reasonable assurances, not absolute \nguarantees.\"). Ms. Maxwell has no intention of fleeing. If she did, then under the proposed bail \nconditions she would lose everything and destroy the family she has been fighting so hard to \nprotect since Epstein's arrest. Ms. Maxwell will not do that, and should be granted bail. \nG. \nThe Alternative to Bail Is Confinement Under Oppressive Conditions \nthat Impact Ms. Maxwell's Health and Ability to Prepare Her Defense \nGranting bail to Ms. Maxwell is all the more appropriate and necessary because the past \nfew months have shown that Ms. Maxwell cannot adequately participate in her defense and \nprepare for trial from the inside the MDC. The alternative to release is her continued \nconfinement under extraordinarily onerous conditions that are not only unjust and punitive, but \nalso meaningfully impair Ms. Maxwell's ability to review the voluminous discovery produced by \nthe government and to communicate effectively with counsel to prepare her defense. \nMs. Maxwell has spent the entirety of her detention—now over five months—in de facto \nsolitary confinement, under conditions that rival those used at USP Florence ADMAX to \nsupervise the most dangerous inmates in the federal system and are tantamount to imprisonment \nas a defendant convicted of capital murder and incarcerated on death row. In fact, multiple \nwardens and interim wardens have remarked that in their collective years of experience they \nhave never seen anything like her current regime. The restrictive regulations to which Ms. \nMaxwell is subjected are not reasonably related to a legitimate goal to ensure the security of Ms. \nM\n... [truncated, 2107 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/40 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=40]", "char_count": 2107}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "exaggerated response to Epstein's death, effectively punishing Ms. Maxwell for the BOP's own \nnegligence with respect to Epstein.11\nCounsel has attempted to address the restrictions in numerous letters, emails and calls to \nthe MDC warden, the MDC legal department, and the prosecutors, but to no avail. Rather than \nrepeating these points here at length, we refer the Court to our letter to the MDC warden, dated \nOctober 29, 2020, which details the most serious and extraordinarily restrictive conditions of \nconfinement. 12 These include: \n■ \nDe Facto Solitary Confinement \n■ \nExcessive Surveillance \n■ \nExcessive Scanning and Strip Searching \n■ \nDeprivation of Food \n■ \nDeprivation of Sleep \n■ \nDeprivation of Communication with Family and Friends \n■ \nCompromised Communication with Legal Counsel \nThe conditions of Ms. Maxwell's detention are utterly inappropriate, and totally disproportionate \nfor a non-violent pretrial detainee with no prior criminal history facing non-violent charges a \nquarter-century old. Moreover, they adversely impact her ability to prepare her defense and \ncompromise her physical health and psychological wellbeing. \nIn addition to these intolerable conditions, Ms. Maxwell has had to contend with \nnumerous unacceptable delays and technical problems with the discovery that the government \nhas produced to her thus far. We have raised these issues with the prosecutors on numerous \noccasions. As we advised the Court in our letter of October 23, 2020, defense counsel first \nII These conditions are especially inappropriate because Ms. Maxwell has been an exemplary inmate and has not \nreceived any disciplinary infractions since her arrest. In fact, she has been made a suicide watch inmate, which is \nthe highest and most trusted responsibility that an inmate can have. It is the height of irony that Ms. Maxwell is \nbeing constantly surveilled as if she were a suicide risk when she, herself, is trusted enough (if she were ever \nreleased from isolation) to mon\n... [truncated, 2436 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/41 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=41]", "char_count": 2436}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "alerted the government on August 27, 2020 that there were significant portions of the first three \ndiscovery productions that Ms. Maxwell could not read. (Dkt. 66). Despite numerous attempts \nto fix these problems over the succeeding weeks, including producing a replacement hard drive \ncontaining these productions, the problems were not resolved and the replacement hard drive was \nbroken. In addition, the fourth and fifth productions, which were produced after the defense \nalerted the government to these problems, contained some of the same technical problems and \nincluded a significant number of unreadable documents. Most recently, the hard drives for the \nsixth and seventh productions have stopped functioning properly. As a result, Ms. Maxwell has \nnot had access to a complete set of readable discovery for over four months. to Ms. Maxwell \ncannot defend herself if she cannot review the discovery. \nMost recently, Ms. Maxwell has had to endure the added burdens of quarantine. On \nNovember 18, 2020, Ms. Maxwell was given a COVID test and placed in 14-day quarantine due \nto contact with a staffer who tested positive. The revolving team of guards assigned to Ms. \nMaxwell, some coming from other BOP institutions confronting their own COVID outbreaks, \nheightens her exposure to the virus. As reported by the associate warden to the Criminal Justice \nAdvisory Board on December 2, MDC does not mandate testing among its staff. A temperature \ncheck and response to a few questions does little to detect an asymptomic carrier. The constant \nstrip searching, touch wanding, and in-mouth checking of Ms. Maxwell heightens her risk for \nexposure to COVID-19. \n13 On November 18, 2020, the government, at our request, provided a laptop computer to Ms. Maxwell in the MDC, \nwhich it believed would remedy the issues with unreadable documents, and has agreed to provide a new hard drive \ncontaining all of the discovery. It is too early to tell whether the new laptop and hard drive will solve\n... [truncated, 2360 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00094289/42 or ?id=EFTA00094289&page=42]", "char_count": 2360}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Ms. Maxwell's quarantine period also resulted in cancellation of weekly in-person legal \nvisits. This is likely to continue in light of the spike in COVID infection within and outside the \nMDC. Within a two-day period from December 1 to December 3, 55 inmates tested positive, \ncompared with 25 from March to December 1. As of the date of this filing, the BOP reports 80 \nMDC inmates and staff with COVID.14 If legal visits are suspended, it will further limit our \nability to review the voluminous discovery (well in excess of one million documents) with Ms. \nMaxwell and will further compromise her ability to prepare her defense. Moreover, as this Court \nobserved in United States v. Stephens, if an outbreak occurs \"substantial medical and security \nchallenges would almost certainly arise.\" Stephens, 447 F. Supp. 3d at 65. We urge the Court to \nweigh the threat of COVID as a factor favoring release in this case, as it did in Stephens. \nCONCLUSION \nGhislaine Maxwell is committed to defending herself and wants nothing more than to \nremain in this country, with her family and friends by her side, so that she can fight the \nallegations against her and clear her name. She is determined to ensure that her sureties and her \nfamily do not suffer because of any breach of the terms of her bond. We have presented a \nsubstantial bail package that satisfies the concerns of the Court and the government, which \ncontains more than ample security and safeguards to reasonably assure that Ms. Maxwell \nremains in New York and appears in court. The Court has the obligation to ensure that a \ndefendant's constitutional right to prepare a defense is safeguarded. The correct—and only \nlegitimate—decision is to grant Ms. Maxwell bail on the proposed strict conditions. \nI4 See httpd/www.bop.govicoronavirus/.\n38 \nEFTA00094332\n", "char_count": 1824}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00094289", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "For the foregoing reasons, Ms. Maxwell respectfully requests that the Court order her \nrelease on bail pursuant to the conditions she has proposed. \nDated: December 4, 2020 \nRespectfully submitted, \n/s/ Mark S. Cohen \nMark S. Cohen \nChristian R. Everdell \nCOHEN & GRESSER LLP \nNew York, NY 10022 \nPhone: \nJeffrey S. Pagliuca \nLaura A. Menninger \nHADDON, MORGAN & FOREMAN P.C. \nDenver CO 80203 \nPhone: \nBobbi C. Stemheim \nLaw Offices of Bobbi C. Stemheim \nNew York, NY 10011 \nPhone: \nAttorneys for Ghislaine Maxwell \n39 \nEFTA00094333\n", "char_count": 533}]}