{"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_count": 16, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00089488", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00089488.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Deferred Prosecution/Misdemeanor Request Memorandum \nUnited States v. Tova Noel, 19 Cr. 830 (AD' \nAUSAs: \n— Federal Bureau of Investigation \nAgent: \n— Department of Justice, Office of the Inspector \nGeneral \nDefendant: Tova Noel \nAge: • al \nNoel graduated from high school in 2005 at the age of 16. At age \n18, she began taking classes at the Borough of Manhattan \nEducation: Community College. She enlisted in the Army National Guard in \n2008 and in 2012 was deployed to Kuwait for active duty in support \nof Operation Enduring Freedom. \nDuring her military service, \nNoel took courses at ASA College in New York City and earned an \nPrior to charging this case, we gave defense counsel for Noel an opportunity to meet with the \ncase team, unit supervisors, and the United States Attorney. During the meeting, defense counsel \nurged a declination or deferred prosecution, but did not raise the majority of the arguments set \nforth in the deferred prosecution request (the \"Request\"). The defendant did not make a written \ndeferred prosecution submission prior to charging. \nAs is discussed in more detail below, the \nRequest provides multiple facts not known to us at the time of the charging decision, as well as a \ndiscussion of how similar cases have been handled in other districts. \nIn particular, the Request \nexplains that Noel intended to do the counts and rounds but could not do so because her co-\ndefendant refused to assist her, and it was against BOP regulations for her to perform them on her \nown. \nNoel's counsel also identified a case in the Western District in which non-prosecution \nagreements were offered to the defendants, correctional officers who were charged for falsely \nrepresenting that they completed rounds in the SHU when an inmate homicide took place. Noel's \ncounsel also provided additional information about United States v. Hernandez, a case from the \nNorthern District of Texas that we relied upon as precedent in making the charging decision in the \ninstant case\n... [truncated, 2247 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/0 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=0]", "char_count": 2247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Associate of Applied Science degree in Criminal Justice in 2014. \nAfter being honorably discharged from the military, Noel enrolled \nin John Jay College of Criminal Justice, where she majored in \ncriminal justice and minored in law. She graduated in 2017 with a \nBachelor of Science degree in Criminal Justice. \nThe deferred prosecution request (the \"Request,\" which is attached \nDrugs: hereto) is silent on drug use, and we do not know of any drug use \nby Noel. \nAccording to the Request, Noel has been diagnosed with a number \nof medical conditions as a result of her military service in a war \nzone, including the following: major depressive disorder; \ngeneralized anxiety; insomnia disorder; post-traumatic stress \ndisorder; contact dermatitis, posterior neck; bronchial asthma; right \nankle posterior tibial tendinopathy (ankle injury sustained in \nKuwait); \ndysmenorrhea \nand \nirregular \nmenstruation \nwith \npedunculated \nfibroid status post-myomectomy (related to \nenvironmental hazard in Gulf War); breast lesion (residual painful \nscar, right breast, sip excisional biopsy); degenerative spondylosis; \nirritable bowel syndrome with nausea (related to environmental \nhazard in Gulf War); and migraines. She was receiving disability \nbenefits from the military until she was suspended from her \nemployment at the Bureau of Prisons (\"BOP\") due to the instant \nHealth: charges. \nAccording to the Request, there is significant use of synthetic \nmarijuana (K2) by inmates throughout the Metropolitan \nCorrectional Center (\"MCC\"), including in the Special Housing \nUnit (\"SHU\"). Noel has experienced illness, including headaches, \nlightheadedness, and nausea, that she believes is associated with \nbreathing in secondhand smoke from the inmates. \nNoel has various mental health conditions, which began during her \nmilitary service and were exacerbated due to family tragedy \n(discussed below) and the instant case. Noel's counsel has told us \nthat since he met her in connection with this case, she\n... [truncated, 2229 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/1 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=1]", "char_count": 2229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Science for therapy to assist with stress stemming from the instant \ncase. \nDespite believing that she could not become pregnant due to certain \nmedical conditions, Noel is currently pregnant, with a due date in \nlate April 2021. Noel is scheduled for a cesarean section on April \n1, 2021. \nNoel was born in Antigua, where she was raised by her single \nmother, her grandparents, and other relatives. Noel's mother left \nAntigua to pursue her education; at age 13, Noel joined her mother \nin the United States. \nBefore Noel joined her, Noel's mother got \nmarried in the United States and had a son, who is approximately \n11 years younger than Noel and is currently attending college. \nNoel married in 2007; she and her husband separated in 2011 and \nare now divorced. \nFamily: In 2013, Noel's 7-year-old half-brother and his mother were \nmurdered in St. Croix. \nThe perpetrators were never arrested. \nThis event exacerbated Noel's mental health issues, including \nanxiety; she attended mental health treatment and managed her \ncondition with medication. \nIn March 2020, Noel rekindled a friendship with Lloyd Gunnings, \nwhom she previously dated. Noel and Gunnings are currently in a \nromantic relationship, and Gunnings is the father of Noel's child, \ndue in April 2021. \nImmigration Status: As of 2009, Noel is a naturalized American citizen. \nEmployment: \n2014.08 \nNoel attempted to join the military at age 17, but her mother refused \nto allow Noel to enlist as a minor. \nNoel then attended some \ncollege classes and worked low-level jobs in New York City. \nAs noted above, in 2008, at age 19, Noel enlisted in the Army \nNational Guard. \nShe served for six years before her honorable \ndischarge in 2014, eventually gaining the rank of E4 Specialist. \nCD \n3 an \nEFTA00089490\n", "char_count": 1777}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Noel was deployed to Kuwait for active duty in 2012 in support of \nOperation Enduring Freedom. \nDuring her military service, Noel also worked other jobs, including \nthe following: security at Macy's (October 2008 — January 2009); \nEMT-B at Transcare Ambulance (January 2009 - July 2011); Life \nSkills Instructor at Ability Beyond Disability (November 2011 -\nJanuary 2013). \nWhile attending John Jay College from 2014 through 2017, Noel \nheld the following positions: Intern/Case Manager for EAC Bronx \nTASC (summer 2014); Toll Booth Cashier for the MTA Bridge and \nTunnel (June 2014 - April 2016); Cashier for Home Depot (January \n2017 — August 2017). \nAfter graduating from John Jay in May 2017, Noel began working \nas a mail handler assistant with the United States Postal Service (the \n\"USPS\") in White Plains. \nNoel left the USPS to join the BOP. \nShe began working at MCC on June 24, 2018. \nShe received two \nweeks of training after joining the BOP and attended another \ntraining course in August 2018 that was supposed to last for three \nweeks but was cut short due to a hurricane. \nAccording to the Request, and as confirmed from our review of her \nwork history, Noel and her MCC colleagues were forced or \n\"mandated\" to work many overtime shifts, including working two \neight-hour shifts back-to-back. Due to difficulties finding parking \nnear the MCC, Noel often drove to work at 5:00 a.m. and slept in \nher car before beginning her 8:00 a.m. shift. Noel was required to \nwork so many overtime shifts that in a six-month period she earned \nthe entirety of her annual base salary. \nAccording to the Request, during her employment at MCC, Noel \nreceived multiple threats from inmates, including threats of violence \nand sexual assault. When she reported the threats, she did not always \nfeel supported by her superiors. \nAs is set forth in the Request, or about March 15, 2019, Noel had an \naccident and fell at work. She was injured and did not return to work \nuntil June 26, 2019. \nWhen she \n... [truncated, 2333 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/3 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=3]", "char_count": 2333}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "indicating that she had received the SHU training. Even though Noel \ninformed the lieutenant that she had not received the training, the \nlieutenant told Noel that she needed to sign so that the facility could \npass program review. \nNoel was suspended from the BOP in 2019 due to the pending charges. \nSince the fall of 2020, Noel has been applying for jobs, but she has not \nreceived any employment offers to date. \nPotentially disqualifying factor: as a guard at the MCC who made \nPotentially Disqualifying false statements relating to the performance of her duties, Noel may \nFactors:* qualify as \"a public official or former public official accused of an \noffense arising out of an alleged violation of a public trust.\" \nCriminal History: None (convictions or arrests). \nOffenses: \nConspiring to knowingly defraud the United States and to \nknowingly make and use a false writing or document, in violation \nof 18 U.S.C. § 371 (one count). \nKnowingly making and using a false writing or document, in \nviolation of 18 U.S.C. § 1001 (five counts). \nAt approximately 6:33 a.m. on August 10, 2019, correction officer \nMichael Thomas, Noel's codefendant, found Jeffrey Epstein dead \nin cell L220 in the ninth floor SHU at MCC. \nAlthough Epstein \nSummary of Offense: committed suicide by hanging himself, two significant failures at \nthe MCC created the conditions in which Epstein could do so: the \nfailure to reassign Epstein a cellmate, and the failure to perform any \nof the required rounds and counts during the overnight shift. \n* Pursuant to USAM 9-22.100 Eligibility Criteria, pretrial diversion (deferred prosecution) is \nnot available against any individual against whom a prosecutable case exists and who is: \n(1) accused of an offense which, under existing Department guidelines, should be diverted to the \nState for prosecution; (2) a person with two or more prior felony convictions; (3) a public official \nor former public official accused of an offense arising out of an alleged violation\n... [truncated, 2317 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/4 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=4]", "char_count": 2317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Epstein had allegedly attempted to commit suicide on July 23, 2019, \nand after he was removed from suicide watch, he was required to \nhave a cellmate. \nThomas was aware of Epstein's history, having \nbeen one of the officers who responded to that earlier alleged suicide \nattempt. However, Epstein's cellmate was released from the MCC \non August 9, 2019, and despite being aware of that directive and the \nfact that Epstein did not have a cellmate, numerous correction \nofficers and at least one lieutenant took no steps to assign a new \ncellmate to Epstein. \nDuring the overnight shift on August 10, 2019, Thomas and Noel \nwere assigned to the SHU from midnight to 8 a.m. \nBoth were on \novertime, and had worked 8 of the previous 24 hours at the start of \ntheir overnight shift: Noel had worked her regular shift in the SHU \nbetween 4 p.m. and midnight, and was on a voluntary overtime shift; \nThomas had worked the overnight shift the night before, and while \nhe had not worked during the day, he was on a mandatory overtime \nshift. \nThomas was a material handler who worked in the \nwarehouse, although he had previously worked as a senior \ncorrection officer for six years. Noel had worked for the BOP for \na year, although she was injured during part of that period and spent \nless than two months working in the SHU. \nWhile on duty in the SHU, Noel and Thomas were required to \nperform rounds every 30 minutes, and institutional counts at 12 \na.m., 3 a.m., and 5 a.m. \nBecause Noel had worked the previous \nshift from 4 p.m. to midnight, she was also required to conduct the \n4 p.m. and 10 p.m. institutional counts, in addition to the required \n30-minute rounds during that shift. Based on the investigation, it \nappears that the last time that any correction officer checked on \nEpstein in his cell was between 8:45 and 9:15 p.m. on August 9, \n2019, which was approximately nine hours before he was found \ndead. \nIt appears that the 4 p.m., 10 p.m., 12 a.m., 3 a.m., and 5 \na.m. counts were not\n... [truncated, 2647 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/5 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=5]", "char_count": 2647}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "preparations to serve breakfast, Thomas discovered Epstein's body. \nAfter sounding their body alarms, Thomas and Noel told a \nlieutenant, in sum and substance, that they had made a mistake in \nnot checking on Epstein. \nGuidelines: \nDefendant's Submission: \n2014.08 \nCounts One through Six are grouped into a single Group \nbecause they involve substantially the same harm \n(§§ 3D1.1(a) and 3D1.2(b)) \nBase offense level: 6, because the offense has a statutory \nmaximum term of imprisonment of less than 20 years \n(§§ 2B1.1(a)(2), 2X1.1(a)) \nBecause the defendant or a co-conspirator completed all the \nacts the conspirators believed necessary on their part for the \nsuccessful completion of the substantive offense, a 3-level \ndecrease is not warranted (U.S.S.G. § 2X1.1(b)(2)) \n- \nOffense involved the conscious or reckless risk of death or \nserious bodily injury: increased to 14 (§ 2B1.1(b)(16)) \nOffense level for Group: 14 (§ 3D1.3(a)) \nAcceptance of responsibility: -2 (§ 3E1.1) \n- \nTotal offense level: 12 \nCriminal history category: I \nGUIDELINES RANGE: 10-16 months' imprisonment \nAlthough not itemized as such, the defendant's deferred prosecution \nsubmission (the Request) offers seven reasons for leniency. \nFirst, Noel has lived a law-abiding, admirable life prior to and after \nthe incident that gave rise to the criminal charges against her. She \npursued an education despite difficult family circumstances and \nenlisted in the Army National Guard, serving overseas. \nShe \naccomplished this despite considerable personal tragedies, \nincluding the murder of close family members, and medical and \nmental health issues traceable, at least in part, to her military \nservice. \nSecond, the nature and circumstances of the crime favor leniency. \nNoel had been working at the MCC for a relatively short period, and \nhad only spent about 6 weeks working in the SHU without any \nmeaningful training. \nShe had been working mandated overtime \nshifts for weeks and was fatigued. \nThe strain from he\n... [truncated, 2038 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/6 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=6]", "char_count": 2038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "causing mental health issues. She was not seeing family or friends, \nand she was spending some of her time sleeping in her car. \nAt \nwork, she faced threats and harassment, and was not supported by \nsupervisors or more experienced colleagues. The SHU, where she \nhad been assigned, was routinely understaffed and it was common \nfor guards to skip rounds and counts. \nIt is against that backdrop \nthat Noel allegedly committed the charged offenses. On the night \nin question, Noel and her co-defendant had worked multiple \novertime shifts in the prior 48 hours. \nThere was no other guard \nassigned. \nAfter Noel pulled out the forms they would need to \ncomplete during their shift, Noel's co-defendant allegedly refused \nto assist her in conducting the counts and rounds. \nUnder BOP \nregulations, Noel was not permitted to conduct rounds and counts \nin the SHU on her own. She did, however, assist another guard in \nconducting a count in a unit neighboring the SHU, evidencing the \nfact that she was willing to conduct counts and rounds. Noel also \nknew that it was common for guards in the SHU—particularly those \nworking the night shift when all inmates were locked in their cells—\nto not complete required counts and rounds. While none of those \ncircumstances excuse the falsification of records, Noel argues they \nshow why she made the decision she did. \nThird, Noel argues that the absence of obstructive intent favors a \ndeferred prosecution. Specifically, according to the Request, there \nwas never a discussion or agreement between the defendants that \nthey would falsify the count and round forms. Rather, Noel filled \nout the initial information on the forms, and when it became time to \ncomplete the forms, she filled them in while Thomas slept. Noel \nacknowledges while she acted wrongfully in filling in the forms \nwithout doing the rounds and counts, she did not do it to obstruct \nany oversight or investigation. \nIndeed, Noel correctly notes that \nshe filled out the forms before Epstei\n... [truncated, 2554 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/7 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=7]", "char_count": 2554}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "her to go to trial, her submission accepts responsibility for her \ninvolvement in the conduct at issue in the Indictment. \nFifth, Noel argues that historically failure to complete rounds and \ncounts, or falsely completing paperwork about doing rounds and \ncounts, is addressed administratively by the BOP. \nThe few \nprecedents for criminal prosecution have largely resulted in deferral, \ndiversion, or dismissal of charges. \nSpecifically, in United States \nv. Hernandez, a case from the Northern District of Texas involving \nthe falsification of round and count slips following an inmate death, \nthe case against one of the guards was dismissed (after entry into a \ndiversion program was not feasible) and another guard pled to a \nmisdemeanor. \nOnly one defendant was convicted of a felony \ncharge. But the facts involving that defendant were different than \nin the instant case: the defendant, who was an experienced officer, \nwas watching pornography instead of doing rounds and made false \nstatements during the investigation after the inmate death. \nIn \nanother case, United States v. Marshall in the Western District of \nVirginia, in which four correctional officers were indicted for \nfalsely representing they completed rounds in the SHU when an \ninmate homicide took place, the U.S. Attorney's Office dismissed \nall the charges. \nEach of the defendants entered into a non-\nprosecution agreement. \nThus, according to Noel, a deferred \nprosecution would be consistent with the outcomes for other \nsimilarly-situated defendants. \nSixth, the Indictment has already caused significant collateral \nconsequences. \nNoel has been subject to public shaming and \nintense media scrutiny, which has exacerbated her depression. \nShe has struggled to find employment. She will lose her BOP job, \nand the very fact of the Indictment will make it difficult for her to \nobtain future employment. \nA felony conviction would result in \nsignificant additional collateral consequences. \nSpecifically, Noel \nwill li\n... [truncated, 2763 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/8 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=8]", "char_count": 2763}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "collateral consequences such as losing the right to vote and \nentitlement to certain public benefits. \nIn short, the collateral \nconsequences of a felony conviction and prohibition from exploring \nthese opportunities would significantly limit her ability to make a \nliving and provide for her child. \nFinally, defense counsel has indicated that Noel is prepared to \naccept responsibility for her conduct pursuant to a deferred \nprosecution agreement, and that she would be prepared to meet with \nand provide information to the Department of Justice, Office of the \nInspector General (\"DOJ-OIG\"), which office is still working on a \nreport about the conditions at the BOP that led to Epstein's suicide. \nAlthough the Request does not seek a misdemeanor disposition, \nthere is a potentially applicable misdemeanor, 18 U.S.C. § 1018, \nwhich provides in relevant part that, \"[w]hoever, being a public \nofficer or other person authorized by any law of the United States to \nmake or give a certificate or other writing, knowingly makes and \ndelivers as true such a certificate or writing, containing any \nCitation and Description statement which he knows to be false, in a case where the \nof Proposed punishment thereof is not elsewhere expressly provided by law, \nMisdemeanor: shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than one year, \nor both.\" \nThere is precedent bringing this misdemeanor charge against a BOP \ncorrections officer who knowingly made a false statement in a BOP \nmemo. See United States v. Rodas Castro, No. 5:15-cr-25 (M.D. \nFla., Jan. 13, 2016), 2016 WL 270157 (plea agreement). \nFBI Special Agent \nis the lead agent on the case. \nShe reviewed the Request with her supervisors. \nSpecial Agent \nhas informed us that the FBI supports a deferred prosecution. \nSpecial Agent \nprovided two principal reasons why they \nbelieve a deferred prosecution is appropriate. First, when the FBI \nAgent Recommendation: opened the investigation, the focus was on whether Epstein was \nmurder\n... [truncated, 2417 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/9 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=9]", "char_count": 2417}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "not necessary. Second, the FBI believes a deferred prosecution is \nappropriate because Noel did attempt to do some aspects of her job \n(e.g., she assisted another officer in doing a count that night), but \nfailed to do some specific tasks that night at least\n because \nThomas was sleeping. \nSpecial Agent \nalso said that \navoiding a trial will be helpful to the FBI because they will have a \nnumber of trials later this year, but that was not one of the primary \nreasons they support a deferred prosecution. \nAUSA Deferred prosecution. \nRecommendation: \nAUSA Rationale: \n2014.08 \nAs an initial matter, the nature and seriousness of the offense \nmitigate in favor of a deferred prosecution. Noel is charged with \nfalsifying BOP forms during a period that spanned less than 24 \nhours. She falsified the documents before Epstein was discovered \ndead, and her alleged motive to conceal was to hide the fact that she \nhad not performed a job duty--conducting rounds and counts—not \nobstruct a government investigation. \nAdditionally, as noted \nabove, Noel immediately told her supervisor that she had made a \nmistake and admitted that she had not completed the rounds, further \nevidencing that she did not intend to obstruct any government \ninquiry following Epstein's death. \nNotably, Noel did nothing to \nattempt to hide her conduct, and in fact consented to the \nGovernment's search of her phone months before she was arrested. \nMoreover, while the circumstances at the MCC do not excuse her \nconduct, Noel was a relatively inexperienced employee at the MCC \n(especially in the SHU); she was forced to work very long hours; \nand she claims to not have been supported by her supervisors or \nmore senior colleagues. Indeed, because of the dangers associated \nwith the SHU, the protocol in the SHU is that one officer (who \ncontrols the keys) unlocks the door to go down a range and stands \nat the door, while the other guard goes down the range and inspects \nthe cells. If it is true that Noel asked Thom\n... [truncated, 2500 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/10 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=10]", "char_count": 2500}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "advance general deterrence. \nThis case has already garnered \nsubstantial media attention, which has furthered interests in \ndeterrence. \nThe filing of charges already sent the message that \nThomas and Noel committed serious crimes, which provides some \ndegree of deterrence for any correction officer tasked with ensuring \nthe safety of the prisoners in his or her care. \nIn the course of our \ninvestigation, we learned that even before charges were brought, the \nMCC and its employees had begun taking rounds and counts more \nseriously. And given the low advisory Guidelines range, and thus \nthe anticipated sentence, it is unlikely that any sentence imposed \nwould deter others contemplating the same conduct. \nMoreover, a deferred prosecution would result in an outcome \nconsistent with most cases in which falsification of round or count \nforms has occurred. \nAccording to information provided by \ndefense counsel and the correctional officers' union, most instances \nof failing to complete counts are addressed administratively. That \nseems to be borne out by the fact that there have been relatively few \ncriminal cases relating to falsely certifying the completion of rounds \nand counts, while the practice appears, unfortunately, to be not \nuncommon. \nIn the few cases in which officers have been \ncriminally charged, most defendants had their cases dismissed or \nresolved through deferred prosecution. \nIndeed, all four of the \ndefendants in the Western District of Virginia case discussed \nabove—which we were not aware of when we charged this case—\nhad their cases dismissed pursuant to deferred prosecution \nagreements. \nIn the case in Texas, only one defendant was \nconvicted of a felony, and he undertook obstructive conduct after \nan inmate's death. We are not aware of any felony conviction for \nan officer who falsified count or round slips but did not take \nsubsequent obstructive conduct or make false statements. \nPut \nanother way, while deferred prosecutions have been the outcom\n... [truncated, 2724 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/11 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=11]", "char_count": 2724}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "question, while the guards' failure to conduct rounds and counts \nwere certainly a contributing factor, there is no question that larger \nsystematic issues, as well as the MCC's failure to assign a new \ncellmate to Epstein, contributed significantly to the circumstances \nthat led to his suicide. Noel has offered to provide information to \nthe OIG about those circumstances. \nNext, since charging the case, we have learned more about the \nsignificant collateral consequences to Noel of taking a guilty plea. \nThose include, most notably, that she will be effectively precluded \nfrom pursuing work in areas for which she is otherwise qualified. \nSpecifically, as noted in the Request, a felony conviction will likely \nbar her from certain government positions (like TSA) and prevent \nher from getting private security jobs. \nEven if she was legally \nqualified for those positions, the prohibition on her possession of a \nfirearm will prevent her from obtaining those jobs. \nA felony \nconviction will also likely prevent her from looking for employment \nin other fields, such as becoming an EMT. \nAnd, as noted in the \nRequest and supporting materials, a felony conviction will prevent \nNoel from obtaining certain disability benefits related to her military \nservice overseas. \nThese potential collateral consequences are \nparticularly concerning because Noel will soon be a mother who \nwill need to provide financially for her child. \n(It is worth noting \nthat while Noel became pregnant during the pendency of this case, \nshe previously believed that she was unable to become pregnant due \nto certain medical conditions). \nGiven that a likely sentence if Noel is convicted following a guilty \nplea or a trail would be a term of probation, it does appear that \nprosecution resources could be better allocated to matters other than \na trial against Noel. \nFurther, there is non-trivial litigation risk at \ntrial as Noel can credibly argue that she lacked criminal or \nobstructive intent, and was in f\n... [truncated, 2730 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/12 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=12]", "char_count": 2730}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "deferred prosecution was appropriate because provide a public \naccounting of the events that led to Epstein's death and would \npromote general deterrence, but it would not carry with it the \ncollateral consequences of a felony conviction. \nThat \nrecommendation was not adopted at the time. \nAs noted above, \nprior to charging the defendants, their attorneys made presentations \nto us, but did not submit written deferred prosecution applications. \nNoel's attorney's presentation focused on why, in his view, a charge \nwas unwarranted. \n(Thomas's attorney stated that his client was \nwilling to plead guilty, but then after the charging decision was \nmade, reversed course and said his client would go to trial.) Since \nthe case was charged, we have learned additional information about \nthe circumstances of the offense, the outcome in comparable cases, \nand the collateral consequences to the defendant. In particular, we \nhave learned about Noel's factual claim that she was unable to do \nthe counts because Thomas refused to wake up. \nWe have also \nlearned about at least one other similar prosecution that resulted in \ndeferred prosecutions, as well as additional information about the \ndisposition and factual circumstances in the Texas case we \npreviously cited to as precedent. And we have now obtained new \ninformation about the potential collateral consequences to Noel—\ninformation that is new to us now because Noel's attorney did not \nmake a formal deferred prosecution application previously. Based \non those subsequent developments, we no longer view this as a \n\"close case,\" and believe a felony disposition is not necessary or \nappropriate in light of the circumstances. \nIndeed, in light of the \napplicable precedents, we believe a deferred prosecution is \nappropriate, and that a felony conviction would be unnecessarily \npunitive. \nFinally, as noted above, there is a potential misdemeanor charge that \ncould apply to the facts here. While, in our view, a misdemeanor \ndisposition \n... [truncated, 2678 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00089488/13 or ?id=EFTA00089488&page=13]", "char_count": 2678}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Noel meet with the DOJ-OIG and provide information about the \ncircumstances that led to Epstein's death. \n2014.08 \nEFTA00089502\n", "char_count": 128}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00089488", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Decision \nDP Committee \nMember \nDismissal/ \nNolle \nDP \nMisd \nFelony \nComments \n_r \n16 \n2014.08 \nEFTA00089503\n", "char_count": 109}]}