{"efta_number": "EFTA00078676", "page_count": 7, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00078676", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00078676.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00078676", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "EXHIBIT A \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nX \nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA, \nv. \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \nX \nNo. 20 Cr. 330 (MN) \nDeclaration of \nin support of \nMotion to Quash Rule 17(c) Subpoena \npursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746, declares under penalty of perjury as \nfollows: \nI. \nI am the independent, neutral third-party administrator of the Epstein Victims' \nCompensation Program (\"EVCP\" or \"Program\"), the litigation-alternative program established to \nconfidentially resolve claims of sexual abuse against Jeffrey Epstein, his Estate, and other related \nindividuals and entities. \n2. \nI respectfully submit this declaration in support of the motion to quash a subpoena \ndirected to me by the defendant Ghislaine Maxwell for certain documents submitted to, \ncommunications with, and payments issued by the EVCP. I have personal knowledge of the \nfacts set forth in this declaration. \n3. \nI am a professional in the field of independent claims administration. I previously \nserved as the Deputy Special Master of the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund (\"9/11 \nFund\"), a litigation-alternative program administered by the U.S. Department of Justice to \ncompensate victims who became sick or died as a result of their September Ilth-related \n1 \nEFTA00078676\n", "char_count": 1295}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078676", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "exposures. I worked for the 9/11 Fund for over ten years before leaving in November 2019 to \nserve as Co-Designer and Administrator of the EVCP. \n4. \nCompensation programs like the EVCP and the 9/11 Fund are designed as \nalternative dispute resolution mechanisms through which alleged victims of traumatic events \nhave an opportunity to voluntarily and confidentially resolve related civil tort claims through a \nnon-adversarial administrative process outside of court. \n5. \nConfidentiality is a critical, cornerstone feature in compensation programs like the \nEVCP and the 9/11 Fund. Preserving confidentiality and preventing the disclosure of all \ninformation and/or documentation submitted to, maintained by, exchanged with, and distributed \nby these programs in order to protect the privacy of claimants is of paramount importance. \n6. \nConfidentiality is particularly important in the EVCP given that it involves claims \nof sexual abuse and given the history of the Epstein case. In my experience, it can be incredibly \ndifficult for victims of sexual abuse to share such deeply personal, intimate, private information \nabout their experiences and the impact it has had on their lives. To compound that, victims of \nsexual abuse often suffer from a loss of trust and confidence in individuals in positions of \nauthority as well as a fear of exposure. This is especially true of victims of Jeffrey Epstein, \nmany of whom share a common distrust of the justice system and lack of faith in basic principles \nof fairness. \n7. \nAgainst this backdrop, it is not surprising that many victims were initially \nreluctant to participate in the EVCP — or would have refused to participate — without an express \nassurance of confidentiality. I had countless conversations with victims' counsel and sexual \nabuse experts when the Program was being designed in which they vigorously expressed this \n2 \nEFTA00078677\n", "char_count": 1905}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078676", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "sentiment, a sentiment that was also conveyed to me personally, repeatedly and pleadingly by the \nvictims themselves. \n8. \nWith that confidentiality imperative in mind, we designed the EVCP Protocol \nwith input and support from the victims' lawyers, the Attorney General of the U.S. Virgin \nIslands, the Epstein Estate and other interested parties. The Protocol was approved by the \nProbate Court of the U.S. Virgin Islands (where Epstein's estate is being probated); a copy of the \ncourt order is included with this motion as Exhibit G. The Protocol sets out the terms, conditions \nand guiding principles that govern the Program, the claims process and my role and \nresponsibilities as independent Administrator. In accordance with the Protocol, I had complete \nand exclusive autonomy and decision-making authority over all claim determinations and all \nclaim procedures. The Estate agreed to pay whatever amounts I determined in my independent \njudgment to eligible claimants in exchange for the claimant releasing the Estate and other related \nindividuals and entities from any civil claims relating to the allegations of sexual abuse. The \nProtocol, as well as other information about the EVCP, is publicly available on its website at \nhttps://epsteinvcp.com/, and the Protocol is attached to the motion as Exhibit D. \n9. \nConfidentiality is an indispensable condition of the EVCP; its importance cannot \nbe overstated. The EVCP Protocol expressly requires confidentiality in order to protect the \nprivacy of claimants. In accordance with the Protocol, information provided to or obtained by \nthe Program was used by me, in my role as Administrator, for the sole purpose of processing and \nevaluating claims and performing other Program-related work (such as resolution of any related \nMedicaid and/or Medicare liens). It was otherwise kept - and must remain - confidential. The \nProtocol provides that the Program's files are not available for inspection or review at any time, \nand that no information obtained solely through the Program will be disclosed publicly or used \n3 \nEFTA00078678\n", "char_count": 2096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078676", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "by the Estate in defending itself from any claim, regardless of forum. And the Protocol expressly \nauthorizes the destruction of Program files to protect the privacy of claimants participating in the \nProgram. \n10. \nIn addition to the Protocol, I testified in open court in the Probate Court in the \nU.S. Virgin Islands about the confidentiality requirement imposed on the Program, as did \nKenneth R. Feinberg, who was a Co-Designer of the EVCP. A copy of relevant excerpts of the \ntranscript is attached to the motion as Exhibit H, and the relevant testimony appears at pages \n111:1-111:16, 118:9-118:24 (my testimony) and pages 170:25-171:25, 180:23-182:8 (Mr. \nFeinberg's testimony). I posted FAQs on the EVCP website that address the scope and \nassurance of confidentiality. A copy of the EVCP FAQs is attached to the motion as Exhibit E \n(see Questions 5, 6 and 11). I also issued several press releases during the claims process that \nhighlight confidentiality as a \"cornerstone\" of the EVCP and of \"paramount importance.\" \nCopies of EVCP press releases are attached as Exhibits B, C, and F. Through numerous public \nforums, confidentiality was discussed as a centerpiece of the Program. \nII. \nThe express condition of confidentiality significantly informed the way I \nadministered the Program and approached the claims process. I implemented a trauma-informed \nprocess where claimants could share information freely and openly without feeling the need to \ncensor themselves - not only about the events that gave rise to the claim but also the often \nprofound impact on their lives. I spent months building trust and confidence in this alternative \ndispute resolution process among claimants and their attorneys — a process that was new and \nunfamiliar to many of them. I dispensed with formal rules of procedure or evidence that would \napply in a court of law in favor of a less formal, non-adversarial approach. And I implemented \n4 \nEFTA00078679\n", "char_count": 1955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078676", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "extensive measures to safeguard the confidentiality and security of all information submitted to, \nmaintained by, exchanged with and distributed by the Program. \n12. \nWith the express assurance of confidentiality, and without the formality of court \nproceedings or fear of exposure and cross examination, victims agreed to participate in the \nProgram, let their guards down and share exceedingly intimate, private information. Claimants \nrelied upon the express condition and assurances of confidentiality in agreeing to support the \nvery existence of the Program, in deciding to participate in the claims process, and in submitting \ntheir claims and any other information to the EVCP. They were willing to trust this process, \ndespite deep-seated distrust of purported systems of \"justice,\" because of Program \nconfidentiality. \n13. \nCompromising confidentiality in any way would eviscerate the very foundation \nand fabric of the EVCP, and would have a disastrous chilling effect on victims who are already \nloath to disclose such personal information. The idea that the information the victims agreed to \ndisclose to the EVCP solely for purposes of evaluation and potential resolution of the claim \nwould be disclosed to anyone outside the EVCP for any other purpose is anathema to the \nintegrity of this Program and others like it. The Program and Protocol were approved by a court \norder from the Probate Court in the U.S. Virgin Islands and I abided by the terms and guiding \nprinciples of the Protocol in every way and at every step of the process. Failing to abide by any \nterm of the Protocol, much less the keystone condition of confidentiality, is intolerable, \nimpermissible, and would lead to the unraveling of the Program. Allowing any disclosure of any \ndocuments, information and/or communications submitted to, maintained by, or exchanged with \nthe EVCP would turn the Program on its head with far-reaching consequences to this victim \npopulation and beyond. \n5 \nEFTA00078680\n", "char_count": 1992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078676", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "14. \nAs a matter of public policy, ensuring confidentiality in litigation-alternative \nvictim compensation programs like the EVCP is an absolute imperative. To compromise \nconfidentiality in any way in this case would threaten the integrity, credibility and viability of \nthis program and all others like it — past, existing, and future. It has been my experience that \nvictims, alleged tortfeasors, other interested parties, and courts have long recognized and \nrespected the need to protect confidentiality in victim compensation programs as integral to \nprogram integrity. I personally know of no situation in which an independent administrator has \nbeen forced to disclose information and/or documentation that was submitted to, maintained by, \nexchanged with or distributed by a litigation-alternative compensation program for any purpose. \nTo open the door in any way would disembowel the very core of this program and have \ndevastating consequences for this and other victim compensation programs, particularly those \ninvolving claims of sexual abuse. Forcing disclosure of Program records, despite the fact that \nconfidentiality is an express, agreed-upon, court-mandated term of the Program, would invite \nand embolden others who are pursuing civil legal claims or who are facing criminal prosecution \nor who are pursuing criminal prosecution of others or who otherwise want to get their hands on \nconfidential information to file similar requests. \n15. \nI designed the EVCP with confidentiality as a centerpiece and cornerstone of the \nclaims process. Safeguarding that confidentiality in full and without condition is essential to the \nintegrity and success of this Program, and the viability of other similar compensation programs. \n16. \nMs. Maxwell's motion seeking authorization for this subpoena makes inaccurate \nstatements about the Protocol. Ms. Maxwell's motion expressed that \"the Protocol credits \nclaimants who have had charges filed against Epstein or any employee of Epstein.\" That is not \nan accurate characterization of the Protocol. The Protocol includes a non-exclusive list of factors \n6 \nEFTA00078681\n", "char_count": 2131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078676", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "that I considered in evaluating claims. One of those factors was \"Whether there exists any \ninformation and/or pertinent findings offered by the appropriate Office of the District Attorney, \nUnited States Attorney's Office, or other law enforcement agency.\" (Protocol at 5-6.) The \nProtocol does not use the term \"credit\" nor does it address what weight, if any, is afforded to \nsuch information in the context of an individual claim. That is because there was no formula or \npoint system or quantifiable \"credit\" for this factor or any other factor in the determination of \nindividual claims. Claims were evaluated on a highly individualized analysis based on a host of \nfactors and the overall totality of the circumstances. Ms. Maxwell's motion also states that \n\"[t]he Protocol also rewards Accusers who have filed a lawsuit, legal action or claim of sexual \nabuse against Epstein, or the Estate, which includes any employees or former employees of \nEpstein.\" This too is inaccurate. When the Protocol refers to an individual's \"lawsuit, legal \naction or claim,\" it does so in the context of identifying individuals prior to the Program's launch \nto whom the program would be sending claim forms, because, on the basis of such lawsuits or \nclaims, the program could identify them at the outset as potential claimants. (Protocol at 4.) The \nProtocol also indicates that individuals who had not filed a lawsuit or claim could also register to \nparticipate in the program, and, if my preliminary review determined that they were eligible to \nparticipate, these individuals too would be sent claim forms. The fact that this language falls \nunder the \"Claims Submission Process\" section of the Protocol and not the \"Claims Evaluation \nand Determination\" section demonstrates the purpose for which it was included. \nI declare under the penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. \nDated: November 19, 2021 \n7 \nEFTA00078682\n", "char_count": 1936}]}