{"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_count": 16, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00078646", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00078646.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Smith VlllazorLw \n250 West 55th Street, 30th Floor \nNew York, New York 10019 \nviww.smithvillazor.com \nPatrick J. Smith \nSMITH I VILLAZOR \nNovember 19, 2021 \nBY E-MAIL to NathanNYSDChambers@nysd.uscourts.gov \nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan \nUnited States District Judge \nSouthern District of New York \n40 Foley Square \nNew York, New York 10007 \nRe: \nUnited States v. Maxwell. No. 20 Cr. 330 \nDear Judge Nathan: \nWe represent \nthe independent, neutral administrator of the Epstein \nVictims' Compensation Program (the \"EVCP\"). Pursuant to the Court's memo-endorsement of \nour letter dated November 15, 2021, we respectfully move to quash defendant Maxwell's \nsubpoena directed to \nfor certain documents of the EVCP concerning four victims. \nThe EVCP is a court-approved, litigation-alternative program established to resolve \nconfidentially claims of sexual abuse against Jeffrey Epstein, his Estate, and other related \nindividuals and entities. Protecting the confidentiality of EVCP claimants' information is a \ncornerstone of the program and essential to its success. In program documents, press releases, \nand on its website, the EVCP and \nrepeatedly emphasized the program's promise of \nconfidentiality. That promise allowed for participation by victims who otherwise would have \nbeen reluctant to share their stories. It also encouraged victims to compromise claims that might \notherwise have taken up substantial judicial resources. Only a confidential program can \nEFTA00078646\n", "char_count": 1483}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Two \neffectively achieve the EVCP's important societal goals of providing redress to victims and \nefficiently resolving civil claims outside the glare of a public proceeding. Because Maxwell's \nsubpoena would compromise that confidentiality and eviscerate the foundation of the EVCP and \nsimilar programs, compliance would be \"unreasonable or oppressive\" under Federal Rule of \nCriminal Procedure 17(c)(2). And because Maxwell's subpoena seeks information that is largely \n(if not entirely) inadmissible under Federal Rule of Evidence 408, it fails the test in United States \nv. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683, 702 (1974). Maxwell also seeks to subpoena statements of a witness or \nprospective witness that are not subject to subpoena under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure \n17(h). The subpoena should be quashed in its entirety. \nBackground \nThis background information comes principally from \ndeclaration, which \nis submitted with this motion,' and public documents about the EVCP, also attached as exhibits. \nA. Formation and Development of the EVCP \nIn November 2019, the co-executors of Epstein's estate (the \"Epstein Estate\") sought \napproval from a U.S. Virgin Islands court (where the Epstein Estate is being probated) to create a \nvoluntary claims resolution program for victims of Epstein's sexual abuse.' The program's \ndesign was led by \nKenneth R. Feinberg, and Camille S. Biros—all nationally \nrecognized claims-administration experts.' Mr. Feinberg is the nation's leading expert in \ncrafting effective dispute resolution alternatives, and, with Ms. Biros, they have designed and \n' Ex. A (Decl. of \nin Supp. of Mot. to Quash Rule 17(c) Subpoena a \nDecl.\")). \n2 Ex. B at 1 (Press Release, \"Administrator \nAnnounces Proposed \nEstablishment of the Epstein Victims' Compensation Program,\" dated Nov. 14, 2019 (\"11/14/19 \nPress Release\")). \n3 Ex. C at 1 (Press Release, \"Renowned Claims Resolution Experts Announce Commencement \nof the Epstein Victims' Compensation Program,\n... [truncated, 2088 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00078646/1 or ?id=EFTA00078646&page=1]", "char_count": 2088}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Three \nadministered other large-scale, complex compensation programs, including for the Catholic \nChurch sexual abuse claims, the Penn State sexual abuse claims, and the September 11th Victim \nCompensation Fund.4 \npreviously served as the Deputy Special Master of the \nSeptember 11th Victim Compensation Fund.' \nis the independent, neutral third-\nparty administrator of the EVCP, and she has \"complete autonomy and decision-making \nauthority over program operations and claim determinations.\"' \nMr. Feinberg, and Ms. Biros designed the program with input and support \nfrom attorneys representing over 70 victims, the Attorney General for the Virgin Islands, the \nEpstein Estate, and other interested parties.' Among many other tasks, they developed a \nProtocol for administering the program and handling claims,' a set of frequently asked \nquestions,' and a website providing information about the program (including the Protocol and \nFAQs) and through which individuals could register and submit their claims.10\nThe U.S. Virgin Islands court heard testimony from \nand Mr. Feinberg about \nthe proposed Protocol in February 2020.\" Both witnesses publicly testified about the \nconfidentiality protections the Protocol would provide to claimants.12 And the promise of \nconfidentiality was necessary in gaining interested parties' support for the program.13 On June 2, \n4 Ex. B at 1(1 \nPress Release); Ex. C at 1 (6/25/20 Press Release). \n'Ex.AI3 \nDecl.). \n6 Ex. B at 1 (11/14/19 Press Release). \n7 Ex. C at 1 (6/25/20 Press Release). \n8 Ex. D (the \"Protocol,\" dated May 29, 2020). \n9 Ex. E (the \"FAQs,\" dated June 25, 2020). \n' 1 See https://wwwir,cp.corn/ (last visited November 18, 2021). \n11 See Ex. A 10 \nDecl.). \n12 Ex. H at I I I:1-111:16, 118:9-118:24 (M \ntestimony) and 170:25-171:25, 180:23-\n182:8 MM. \ntestitl\n. \n13 See Ex. A \n7-8, 12 \nDecl.). \nEFTA00078648\n", "char_count": 1889}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Four \n2020, the U.S. Virgin Islands probate court approved the EVCP as designed.14 On June 25, \n2020, the EVCP announced that individuals could begin the process of filing claims.15\nIn her motion seeking approval for the subpoena, Maxwell makes at least two \nmischaracterizations of the Protocol for evaluating a claimant's eligibility for compensation. \nFirst, she says that the Protocol \"credits\" victims \"who have had charges filed against Epstein or \nany employee of Epstein.\"\" The Protocol does no such thing. It simply identifies the existence \nof any information or findings of law enforcement as one factor to be considered, as part of a \nnon-exhaustive list of \"appropriate factors and corroborative support\" that the administrator may \nconsider in evaluating claims.\" Maxwell also mischaracterizes the Protocol when she says that \nit \"rewards Accusers who have filed a lawsuit, legal action or claim of sexual abuse.\"18 This is \ninaccurate. As the Protocol makes clear, the existence of \"lawsuit[s], legal action[s] or claim[s]\" \nwas used to identify individuals as potential victims to send them claim forms.19 Individuals \nwho had not previously filed a lawsuit, legal action, or claim were also invited to register a claim \nwith the EVCP.2°\nB. Key Features of the EVCP \nThe EVCP was designed with non-exclusive \"key features\" to provide \"an efficient and \nfair resolution of claims\" on a \"voluntary, non-adversarial, [and] confidential\" basis.2' For \nexample, the EVCP operates \"entirely free from any interference or control by the Epstein \n\" Ex. G (order of the Superior Court of t1\nlit• in Islands Division of St. \n( \nVirgin \ndated June 2, 2020); see Ex. A ¶¶ 8, 13 \nDecl.). \n\" Ex. C (6/25/20 Press Release). \n16 Maxwell's Mot. for an Order Authorizing a Subpoena Pursuant to Fed. \ndated Nov. 14, 2021 (\"Maxwell Mot.\"), at 3, 5. \n\" Ex. D at 5-6 (Protocol); see Ex. A ¶ 16 ( \nDecl.). \n18 Maxwell Mot. at 3, 5. \n19 Ex. D at 4 (Protocol); see Ex. A ¶ 16 \nDecl.). \n... [truncated, 2155 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00078646/3 or ?id=EFTA00078646&page=3]", "char_count": 2155}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Five \nEstate.\"22 The program is also \"purely voluntary\"; claimants' rights are not impacted unless and \nuntil they accept an offer of compensation and execute a release.23 Victims were also eligible to \nparticipate \"regardless of where they were harmed, when they were harmed, whether the claim is \ntime-barred by the applicable statute of limitations, and whether they have previously filed a \nlawsuit against or settled with Epstein and/or the Estate.\"24\nAnd as critically relevant here, the EVCP is confrdential.25 The EVCP and \nrepeatedly emphasized the importance of confidentiality to the integrity of the program and the \nassurance that the EVCP would keep confidential victims' participation in the program and any \ndocuments and other information submitted to, maintained by, exchanged with, or distributed by \nthe program.26 \nprobate-court testimony, the Protocol, the FAQs, the EVCP \nwebsite, and EVCP press releases all highlight the program's promise to maintain confidentiality \nof claimants' information and how that promise is a \"cornerstone\" of the EVCP.27 Victims \nrelied upon the condition of strict confidentiality in agreeing to support the existence of the \nProgram and in deciding to participate in the claims process.28\n22 See https://www.epsteinvcp.coml; see also Ex. D at 1 (Protocol). \n23 Ex. D at 1 (Protocol). \n24 Ex. D at 2 (Protocol). \n25 Ex. D at 2, 6, 8-9 Protocol). \n26 Ex. A 1118-12 \nDecl.). \n27 See: \n• \nEx. H at 111:1-111:16, 118:9-118:24 (testimony). \n• \nEx. D at 8-9 (Protocol section on \"Confidentiality/Privacy\"). \n• \nEx. E at 9 (FAQs no. 11). \n• \nhttps://www.epsteinvcp.corn/ (website noting claimant privacy of \"paramount \nimportance\"). \n• \nEx. C at 2 (6/25/20 Press Release noting claimant privacy of \"paramount importance\"). \n• \nEx. F at 1 (8/9/21 Press Release noting confidentiality \"critical to the success\" and a \n\"cornerstone\" of the EVCP). \n28 See Ex. A ¶¶ 7-8, 12 \nDecl.). \nEFTA00078650\n", "char_count": 1963}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Six \nC. The Critical Importance of Confidentiality to the EVCP and Similar Programs \ndeclaration explains why confidentiality is so critical to programs like the \nEVCP.29 As she notes, \"it can be incredibly difficult for victims of sexual abuse to share such \ndeeply personal, intimate, private information about their experiences and the impact it has had \non their lives,\" and many victims \"suffer from a loss of trust and confidence in individuals in \npositions of authority.s30 The EVCP sought to create an environment where claimants did not \nfeel a need to \"censor themselves\" about their experiences.\" Creating that environment simply \nwould not be possible without strong assurances of confidentiality. As expressed to \nby victims' attorneys and victims themselves, \"many victims were initially reluctant to \nparticipate in the EVCP — or would have refused to participate — without an express assurance of \nconfidentiality.\"32\nAny intrusion on that promise would threaten the foundation of the program. As \nexplains, \"[c]ompromising confidentiality in any way would eviscerate the very \nfoundation and fabric of the EVCP, and would have a disastrous chilling effect on victims.\"33\nCompelling the EVCP to disclose the information it promised to keep confidential would be \n\"anathema to the integrity of this Program and others like it\" and \"would turn the Program on its \nhead with far-reaching consequences to this victim population and beyond\"—meaning for the \nEVCP and the viability of other past, existing, and future litigation-alternative victim \ncompensation programs.34 \nis unaware of any other instance in which an \n29 See Ex. A ill 5-14 \n\"Ex. A 16 \n31 Ex. A \n8-12 \n32 Ex. A ¶ 7 \n33 Ex. All 13 \n34 Ex. A ¶¶ 13-14 \nDecl.). \nDecl.). \nDecl.). \nDecl.). \nDecl.). \nDecl.). \nEFTA00078651\n", "char_count": 1821}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Seven \nadministrator of a program like the EVCP was required to disclose materials like those Maxwell \nseeks here.35\nD. The EVCP's Success \nAs of August 2021, when the EVCP announced that it had concluded its claimant-facing \noperations, the EVCP had awarded nearly $125 million to approximately 150 eligible claimants; \nninety-two percent of eligible claimants accepted their offers, and the EVCP paid over $121 \nmillion to those claimants.36 The EVCP received about 225 claims, which far exceeded the \noriginal expectation of about 100 claims.37\nE. Procedural History \nIn April 2021, Maxwell sought authorization to subpoena the law firm Boies Schiller for \nmaterials it submitted to EVCP on behalf of certain claimants. This Court denied the request, \nfinding that Maxwell appeared to seek the materials for impeachment purposes, and that \"the \nmere fact that certain documents might be impeachment evidence does not render them \n`relevant' for purposes of Rule 17(c); if at all, those documents would become relevant only after \na witness testifies.\"38 The Court also held that Maxwell \"may renew her request for these \ndocuments once she identifies specific individuals whose submissions she seeks and spells out \nwith specificity the relevance of all requested materials. At that time, the Court will determine \nwhether it is proper to require production of these materials to the Court so that the information \n35 Ex. A ¶ 14 \nDecl.); see also Ex. H at 180:23-182:8 (testimony of Mr. Feinberg noting \nthat, in his forty years of experience, no law enforcement agency had sought materials from a \nprogram and, invoking his experience with the compensation programs to resolve sexual abuse \nclaims against the Catholic church, cautioning against attempts to obtain claimant information \nwhen \"individual victims have participated in a program on the absolute guarantee of the \nadministrator that information that have been submitted will not be disclosed to anybody\"). \n36\n... [truncated, 2141 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00078646/6 or ?id=EFTA00078646&page=6]", "char_count": 2141}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Eight \nmay be made available to Maxwell, if appropriate, at the conclusion of each witness's direct \ntestimony.\"39 Maxwell also appears to have sought subpoenas directed to \"four individuals \nseek[ing] similar materials,\" including EVCP materials, a request this Court denied in August \n2021, again without prejudice to renewal.40\nOn November 15, 2021, we learned that Maxwell sought leave to serve a subpoena on \nfor certain EVCP documents and that the Court intended to authorize the subpoena. \nThat same day, we informed the Court that we were authorized to accept service of the subpoena \nand that \nintended to move to quash it. We received a copy of the subpoena on \nNovember 16, 2021. The subpoena requests four categories of materials from four individual \nvictims: (i) \"EVCP Material\" (as defined in the subpoena) for the four victims; (ii) \ncommunications between the EVCP and the four victims \"and/or their Attorneys\"; (iii) copies of \npayments to the victims \"and/or their Attorneys\"; and (iv) any releases that the four victims \nexecuted. \nThe government filed its motion to quash the subpoena yesterday, which provides ample \nbasis to quash the subpoena. \nsets forth the following additional reasons to quash \nthe subpoena. \n39 Order at 7-8 (ECF No. 252). \nOpinion and Order, dated Aug. 13, 2021, at 2, 5, 10 (ECF No. 334). \nEFTA00078653\n", "char_count": 1375}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Nine \nArgument \nThe subpoena should be quashed because (i) compliance would be unreasonable or \noppressive; (ii) it seeks documents that are inadmissible under Rule 408 of the Federal Rules of \nEvidence; and (iii) it seeks \"statements\" of a witness that are not subject to subpoena under Rule \n17(h) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. \nA. Compliance with the subpoena would be unreasonable or oppressive. \nUnder Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 17(c)(2), the Court \"may quash or modify the \nsubpoena if compliance would be unreasonable or oppressive.\" Fed. R. Crim. P. 17(c)(2). The \ndetermination of whether compliance would be unreasonable or oppressive is \"committed to the \nsound discretion of the trial court.\" United States v. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683, 702 (1974). \nCompliance may be unreasonable or oppressive if the subpoena seeks information protected by \n\"constitutional, statutory, or common-law privilege[s],\" or if the subpoena is \"irrelevant, abusive \nor harassing, overly vague, or excessively broad.\" In re Grand Jury Subpoena for THCF Med. \nClinic Recs., 504 F. Supp. 2d 1085, 1088 (E.D. Wash. 2007) (citations omitted) (quashing \nsubpoena under Rule 17(cX2)). In addition, \"[c]ourts have relied on Rule 17(c) to quash a \nsubpoena that intrudes gravely on significant interests outside the scope of a recognized \nprivilege, if compliance is likely to 'entail consequences more serious than even severe \ninconveniences occasioned by irrelevant or overbroad requests for records.' THCF Med. Clinic \nRecs., 504 F. Supp. 2d at 1088 (quoting In re Grand Jury Matters, 751 F.2d 13, 18 (1st Cir. \n1984)). \nHere, it would be unreasonable or oppressive to require a court-approved victims' \ncompensation program whose effectiveness depends on maintaining the confidentiality of \nvictims' information to produce the very information it promised to keep confidential. \nEFTA00078654\n", "char_count": 1918}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Ten \nConfidentiality was a \"cornerstone\" of the EVCP,41 \"critical\" to its success,\" and of \"paramount \nimportance.\"43 Confidentiality was an indispensable term necessary to interested parties' \nsupport for the EVCP.44 Without the expectation of confidentiality, many victims would not \nhave participated, and the whole purpose of the program would have been frustrated.' \nThe Supreme Court in Nixon recognized—in the context of a President's claim of \nconfidentiality over communications with advisors—that the \"interest in preserving \nconfidentiality is weighty indeed and entitled to great respect.\" Nixon, 418 U.S. at 712. And \nwhile the Supreme Court ultimately upheld the denial of a motion to quash given that the \nPresident's confidentiality concerns were \"general in nature\" and would \"not be vitiated by \ndisclosure of a limited number of conversations,\" id. at 713, the facts here show that the EVCP \nhas a particularized interest in maintaining the confidentiality of sexual-abuse victims' \ninformation and that opening the door to any such disclosures poses a real risk of \"vitiat[ingr \nsuch a program's effectiveness, id., and would \"turn the Program on its head with far-reaching \nconsequences to this victim population and beyond.\"\" \nIndeed, as another district court held in quashing a subpoena under Rule 17(cX2), \n\"individuals could be deterred from participating in the program if it were possible for\" outside \nparties \"to obtain this type of information.\" THCF Med. Clinic Recs., 504 F. Supp. 2d at 1090-\n91 (quashing subpoena under Rule 17(cX2) that sought information about participants in state-\nrun medical marijuana program and recognizing the state's interest in \"keeping its contract with \nits citizens to preserve the confidentiality of their records\"). The existence of the U.S. Virgin \n41 Ex. F at 1 (8/9/21 Press Release) (statement of \n42 Ex. F at 1 (8/9/21 Press Release). \n43 Ex. C at 2 (6/25/20 Press Release). \n44 See Ex. A IV -8, 12 \nDecl\n... [truncated, 2077 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00078646/9 or ?id=EFTA00078646&page=9]", "char_count": 2077}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Eleven \nIslands' probate court order approving the program—and the associated, mandatory \nconfidentiality protections of the Protocol—provides yet another reason to quash the subpoena.47\nSee THCF Med. Clinic Recs., 504 F. Supp. 2d at 1090 (quashing subpoena in part where, by \ncomplying, state \"would be violating its own laws\"). Because compliance would be \nunreasonable or oppressive, this Court should quash the subpoena. \nCompliance would also be unreasonable or oppressive because all the information \nMaxwell seeks is \"otherwise procurable\" or, indeed, already in Ms. Maxwell's possession. See \nUnited States v. Pena, No. 15 Cr. 551 (AJN), 2016 WL 8735699, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 12, 2016) \n(subpoena proponent must show materials are \"not otherwise procurable\" (citation omitted)). As \nnoted, Maxwell previously sought to subpoena Boies Schiller and four individuals for EVCP \nmaterial and was denied without prejudice,48 but she apparently has not sought to renew those \nrequests. Instead, she decided to direct her subpoena at a different source: the EVCP's \nadministrator. While the EVCP cannot divine the reason behind that shift in legal strategy, it \nappears as if she is attempting to do an end run around the Court's prior rulings or believes that \nrenewing those requests will be unfruitful. The EVCP is not suggesting that Ms. Maxwell renew \nher earlier requests directed at EVCP claimants. The EVCP believes that no participant should \nbe required to turn over their confidential submissions against their wishes. But there are \nalternative ways to obtain the information she seeks, such as on cross-examination at trial, to the \nextent permissible. And—in the case of releases Maxwell seeks—at least two courts in this \n47 See Ex. A ¶ 13 ( \nDecl.). \nECF Nos. 252, 334. \nEFTA00078656\n", "char_count": 1824}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Twelve \ndistrict have ordered plaintiffs to produce their EVCP releases to Maxwell (in one case with the \namount redacted), so she is already aware of the content of the EVCP's general release.49\nForcing the EVCP to turn over information it promised all claimants it would keep \nconfidential—an indispensable condition that victims relied upon—would \"disembowel the very \ncore\" of this program and others like it.S° Compliance would be unreasonable and oppressive \nand, accordingly, this Court should quash the subpoena. \nB. The documents sought are inadmissible under Federal Rule of Evidence 408. \nThe subpoena should also be quashed because the records sought are inadmissible under \nFederal Rule of Evidence 408. Rule 17(c), in general, authorizes subpoenas returnable before \ntrial, as well as subpoenas returnable at trial \"to obtain impeachment material.\" United States v. \nDonziger, No. 19-CR-561 (LAP), 2021 WL 1865376, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. May 10, 2021). The test \nset forth in Nixon \"governs both varieties\" of subpoenas. Donziger, 2021 WL 1865376, at *4. \nUnder Nixon, the subpoena must \"clear three hurdles: (1) relevancy; (2) admissibility; (3) \nspecificity.\" Nixon, 418 U.S. at 700. Here, Maxwell's subpoena fails, at a minimum, to clear the \nadmissibility hurdle, because Rule 408 makes the documents sought largely, if not entirely, \ninadmissible. \nUnder Rule 408(a), evidence of accepting a valuable consideration to compromise a \nclaim, as well as statements or conduct made in connection with negotiations about the claim, are \n\"not admissible—on behalf of any party—either to prove or disprove the validity or amount of a \ndisputed claim or to impeach by a prior inconsistent statement or a contradiction.\" Fed. I. Evid. \n408(a). Inadmissibility under Rule 408 provides a basis to quash a Rule 17(c) subpoena. See \n49 See Order, dated Feb. 16, 2021 (ECF No. 120), at 2 in Farmer v. Indyke, 19 Civ. 10475 \n(S.D.N.Y.); Order, dated Mar. 19, 2021 (ECF No. 102)1 2\n... [truncated, 2085 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00078646/11 or ?id=EFTA00078646&page=11]", "char_count": 2085}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Thirteen \nUnited States v. Carton, No. 17 CR 680 (CM), 2018 WL 5818107, at *5 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 19, \n2018) (quashing subpoena seeking a \"forbearance agreement,\" citing Rule 408). \nThe documents Maxwell seeks here fit within the exclusionary provisions of Rule 408.51\nThe documents sought—submissions to the EVCP, including claim forms; communications \nbetween the EVCP and the victims or their attorneys; records of payments; and releases—\nconstitute evidence of either \"furnishing, promising, or offering—or accepting, promising to \naccept, or offering to accept—a valuable consideration in compromising or attempting to \ncompromise the claim,\" Fed. I. Evid. 408(a)(1), or \"conduct or a statement made during \ncompromise negotiations about the claim,\" Id. 408(aX2). \nThe Protocol makes clear that by submitting a claim, \"a Claimant is seeking to resolve all \nclaims relating to allegations of sexual abuse against Epstein and/or the Estate, and related \nentities and individuals as set forth in the Release.\"52 And it also makes that clear that \"[a]ll \nparties agree that they are using the services of a third-party administrator to help reach a \nresolution of individual claims of sexual abuse.\"53 The Protocol provides that \"this Program is \nentitled to confidentiality, privileges (mediation, settlement and all other pertinent privileges), \nS1 It is true that, in 1996, the Second Circuit held that Rule 408 \"does not require exclusion of \nevidence relating to a civil settlement in a criminal trial.\" Manko v. United States, 87 F.3d 50, 51 \n(2d Cir. 1996). But in 2006, the rule was amended to make clear that it applies in that \ncircumstance. As the Seventh Circuit has noted: \"In 2006 the Supreme Court promulgated an \namendment to Rule 408 demonstrating that at least the new version (which took effect on \nDecember 1, 2006) applies to criminal cases.\" United States v. Roti, 484 F.3d 934, 936 (7th Cir. \n2007); see 2006 advisory committee note to Rule 408 (noting \"sta\n... [truncated, 2629 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00078646/12 or ?id=EFTA00078646&page=12]", "char_count": 2629}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Fourteen \nand protection from disclosure under applicable law.\"S4 That the EVCP was designed to invoke \nthe exclusionary protections of provisions like Rule 408 is plain. \nAs such, the documents Maxwell seeks are not admissible \"on behalf of any party\" to \neither prove or disprove the validity of a claim or—as especially important here, given the \nCourt's prior recognition that Maxwell sought EVCP Material from Boies Schiller \"for \nimpeachment\"'—to \"impeach by a prior inconsistent statement or a contradiction.\" Fed. R. \nEvid. 408(a). Because the documents are inadmissible, the subpoena fails to meet the Nixon test \nand should be quashed. \nRule 408's limited exceptions to inadmissibility are not applicable here and do not favor \nupholding the subpoena. First, while Rule 408(a)(2) provides a limited exception to \ninadmissibility for statements or conduct \"when offered in a criminal case and when the \nnegotiations related to a claim by a public office in the exercise of its regulatory, investigative, or \nenforcement authority,\" that exception does not apply here, where the underlying claims (Le., the \nvictims' claims for sexual abuse against Epstein) were private matters, not \"related to a claim by \na public office.\" See United States v. Davis, No. Crim. 09-343, 2009 WL 3646459, at *3 (E.D. \nPa. Nov. 4, 2009) (\"Since the agreement was entered into between private parties, it does not fall \ninto the limited exception enunciated in 408(a)(2) involving compromise negotiations with a \npublic agency.\"). \nAnd while under Rule 408(b), the Court \"may admit this evidence for another purpose, \nsuch as proving a witness's bias or prejudice,\" we are unaware of Maxwell having demonstrated \nhow the materials she seeks would demonstrate \"bias or prejudice\" (including for the reasons in \nthe government's motion) as opposed to being impermissibly used to \"impeach by a prior \n54 Ex. D at 8 n.1 (Protocol). \nss ECF No. 252 at 7. \nEFTA00078659\n", "char_count": 1978}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Fifteen \ninconsistent statement or a contradiction.\" Fed... Evid. 408(a). The Court should decline to \nuphold the subpoena based on a possible permissible use under Rule 408(b) when the most \nreadily apparent purpose for the materials is one barred by Rule 408(a). \nC. Rule 17(h) bars Maxwell from subpoenaing statements of a witness or potential witness. \nUnder Rule 17(h), Maxwell is barred from subpoenaing \"a statement of a witness or of a \nprospective witness,\" as the production of any such statements is governed by Rule 26.2. Fed.. \nCrim. P. 17(h). Many of the documents Maxwell seeks are statements of the four victims, such \nas their claim forms or any communications they sent to the EVCP (or statements from \nrepresentatives of the EVCP). As courts have held, such statements are not subject to subpoena, \neven when sought from a third party. See United States v. Yudong Zhu, No. 13 Cr. 761 (VM), \n2014 WL 5366107, at *3 & n.3 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 14, 2014) (quashing request under Rule 17(h) for \nmaterials that \"likely constitute\" statements of a witness or prospective witness and rejecting \nargument \"that Rule 17(h) applies only to witness statements already in the Government's \npossession\" (citing United States v. Vasquez, 258 =. \n68, 73 (E.D.N.Y.2009)). The Court \nshould quash the subpoena to the extent it seeks statements of witnesses or prospective \nwitnesses. \nFor the foregoing reasons, the Court respectfully should quash the subpoena. We also \nrespectfully request oral argument on this motion, and we are available should the Court have \nany questions. \nRespectfully submitted, \n/s/ Patrick J. Smith \nPatrick J. Smith \nSmith Villazor LLP \nEFTA00078660\n", "char_count": 1700}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078646", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "November 19, 2021 \nPage Sixteen \nCC: \nEFTA00078661\n", "char_count": 51}]}