{"efta_number": "EFTA00078120", "page_count": 4, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00078120", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00078120.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00078120", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of New York \nThe Si!io J. Mollo Building \nOne Saint Andrew's Plaza \nNew York, New York 10007 \nNovember 6, 2020 \nBY ECF \nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan \nUnited States District Court \nSouthern District of New York \nUnited States Courthouse \n40 Foley Square \nNew York, New York 10007 \nRe: \nUnited States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN) \nDear Judge Nathan: \nThe Government respectfully submits this letter to request an extension of the deadline for \nthe production of a subset of the electronic discovery in the above-referenced case from November \n9, 2020 to November 23, 2020. This extension is necessary solely to allow adequate time for an \noutside vendor to finalize the preparation of documents extracted from electronic devices seized \nfrom Jeffrey Epstein for production. Over the past two days, the Government has conferred with \ndefense counsel, who indicated this morning that they would only consent to the extension on four \nconditions, detailed below. \nAlthough the Government agrees to meet two of the defense \nconditions, it will not agree to the other two, which have no connection to the delay in discovery \nand no basis in law. \nTo date, the Government has produced more than 350,000 pages of discovery to the \ndefense over the course of five productions, and the Government expects to make a sixth \nproduction by the existing November 9, 2020 deadline, as detailed below. \nHowever, the \nGovernment's outside vendor has advised the Government that it requires additional time to \nprepare a seventh and final production of electronic discovery. By way of background, that final \nproduction comes from electronic devices that the Federal Bureau of Investigation (\"FBI\") seized \nfrom Jeffrey Epstein's residences in New York and the U.S. Virgin Islands in 2019. Specifically, \nin July of 2019, the FBI conducted multiple searches of Epstein's residence in New York, and in \nAugust of 2019, the FBI searched Epstein's residence in the Virgin Islands. During both searches, \nthe FBI seized dozens of electronic devices. Pursuant to court-authorized warrants, the FBI then \ninitiated the months-long process of gaining access to and extracting data from those devices. \nIn or about January of 2020, the FBI provided some, but not all, of the data from those \ndevices to the Government. At the request of Epstein's estate, a filter team conducted a review of \nthat subset of data for potentially privileged materials. In or about February of 2020, the privilege \nteam completed its review of a subset of data that the FBI had provided. In or about late February \nof 2020, the Government initiated a responsiveness review of that subset of data. \nOn June 26, 2020, the Government obtained a new warrant expanding the scope of the \nsearch of 62 of the electronic devices seized from Epstein. After the issuance of that new warrant, \nEFTA00078120\n", "char_count": 2930}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078120", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Page 2 \nthe Government requested that the FBI re-produce the data from all 62 devices because the FBI's \nprior production had only included a subset of the seized data and had not identified which file \ncame from which seized device. On or about August 3, 2020, the FBI finished providing the \nGovernment all of the documents from the seized devices, this time organized by device. Because \nthis production included data that the filter team had not previously reviewed, the Government's \nfilter team conducted a full privilege review on this entire set of data. \nOn October 7, 2020, the filter team completed its privilege review of that data and released \nto the case team the non-privileged documents for responsiveness review. The Government \ncompleted its responsiveness review on October 21, 2020, having identified approximately 1.2 \nmillion documents as responsive to the either the original or the expanded warrant. That same \nnight, the Government requested that its outside vendor image, bates stamp, and download all of \nthe responsive documents for production to the defense. Although the Government believed at the \ntime that it had left its outside vendor, which the Government has repeatedly informed of the \nNovember 9, 2020 discovery deadline in this case, sufficient time to complete the process of \nstamping and downloading these materials for production, unfortunately, despite the vendor's best \nefforts, it does not appear the vendor will be able to complete that process by November 9. \nIn particular, on November 4, 2020, the vendor informed the Government that although it \nhas finished imaging the responsive documents, it does not expect to finish bates stamping the \nresponsive documents and loading them onto an external hard drive until November 19, 2020. The \nvendor will then send that drive to the Government. Once the Government receives the drive, it \nwill need a short amount of time to spot check the production and confirm it can be sent to the \ndefense. Given these estimates from the vendor, it will not be technologically possible to produce \nthese responsive documents by the November 9, 2020 deadline. Accordingly, on November 4, \n2020, the Government contacted defense counsel to confer regarding an extension of the discovery \ndeadline solely for this production. \nAfter conferring, the parties have been unable to reach agreement on an extension. This \nmorning, the defense indicated that they would consent to an extension of the deadline for this \nproduction to November 23, 2020 on four conditions. First, the defense asked that the motion \ndeadlines in this case be extended by three weeks. The Government agrees with that proposal and \naccordingly requests that defense motions be due on January II, 2021, Government responses be \ndue on February 12, 2021, and defense replies be due on February 19, 2021. Second, the defense \nasked that the Government provide a laptop for the defendant to use to review her discovery inside \nthe Metropolitan Detention Center (\"MDC\") by November 23, 2020. The Government has already \npurchased a laptop for such a purpose, and the MDC has agreed to allow the defendant use that \nlaptop for discovery review once the Government's IT department has disabled all wireless and \ncommunications capabilities on the laptop. Accordingly, the Government agrees to meet this \ncondition. Third, the defense asked that the Government provide it with the names of the three \nMinor Victims listed in the Indictment by November 23, 2020, and fourth, the defense asked that \nthe Government provide the defense with all Jencks Act material by November 23, 2020. \nThe Government cannot agree to the final two conditions set out by the defense, which \nhave no connection to the two-week delay in completion of discovery and no basis in law. The \nfirst two conditions are reasonably related to the delayed production. The three-week extension \nEFTA00078121\n", "char_count": 3924}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078120", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Page 3 \nof the defense's deadline to file motions will ensure the defense has adequate time to review \ndiscovery before finalizing its motions and is therefore rationally related to the two-week delay in \nthis production. Similarly, the requested laptop will expedite and streamline the defendant's \nreview of discovery by avoiding technological delays on the MDC computer system that may \notherwise slow the defendant's discovery review. \nBy contrast, a two-week delay in the completion of discovery, caused by technical \nconstraints on the part of an outside vendor, has no bearing on the defense's entitlement to a \nwitness list or witness statements. This Court has already ruled that such a request is premature \nwhen the \"parties have not yet engaged in discussions regarding an appropriate schedule for \npretrial disclosures, including witness lists and § 3500 material.\" (Dkt. 49 at 1). The Court \naccordingly ordered that the parties \"meet and confer on an appropriate schedule\" \"[f]ollowing the \nclose of discovery.\" (Id. at 2). Consistent with that order, the Government is prepared to engage \nin good faith discussions with the defense about an appropriate schedule for disclosure of Jencks \nAct and Giglio material. The standard practice in this District is to produce such material shortly \nin advance of trial, a practice that has been widely held to be sufficient to satisfy the requirement \nthat Giglio be produced \"in sufficient time that the defendant will have a reasonable opportunity \nto act upon the information efficaciously.\" United States v. Rodriguez, 496 F.3d 221, 226 (2d Cir. \n2007). Immediate disclosure of such material is not warranted simply because the defendant \nprefers it. See, e.g., United States v. Wey, 15 Cr. 611 (AJN), 2017 WL 237651, at *23 (S.D.N.Y. \nJan. 18, 2017) (denying defendant's motion for immediate disclosure of Giglio material as \ndefendant \"fails to articulate any persuasive reason why immediate disclosure is required in this \ncase, and the Court otherwise sees no basis to deviate so substantially from the typical practice\"); \nUnited States v. Thompson, 13 Cr. 378 (AJN), 2013 WL 6246489, at *9 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 3, 2013) \n(denying request for early production of Jencks Act material); United States v. Davis, No. 06 Cr. \n911 (LBS), 2009 WL 637164, at *14 (S.D.N.Y. March II, 2009) (\"The Second Circuit has held \nthat a request for immediate or early disclosure [of Giglio material] has no basis in the law.\") \nBecause the Government's brief delay in completing discovery does not entitle the defense to such \nmaterials more than seven months in advance of trial, the Government respectfully requests that \nthe Court extend the deadline for this production to November 23, 2020 solely on the first two \nconditions set out by the defense. \nOther than these responsive documents from Epstein's electronic devices, the Government \nexpects to complete its production of Rule 16 discovery to the defense by the November 9, 2020 \ndeadline. In that vein, the Government is currently preparing its sixth discovery production to the \ndefense, which will include, among other things, thousands of images and videos from Epstein's \nelectronic devices identified as responsive to the expanded warrant, portions of iPads and an \niPhone seized from Epstein identified as responsive to the expanded warrant, the four emails \nquoted in the Government's application for an expanded warrant, and documents from the FBI's \nFlorida files. The Government expects to make that sixth production to the defense on November \n9, 2020. \nMoreover, while the Government appreciates that the volume of materials it proposes to \nproduce after the deadline is large, the Government has no reason to believe these materials will \nbe central to any motion the defendant may seek to make. In particular, as noted above, all of \nthese materials come from devices seized from Epstein's residences, and none of the devices is \nEFTA00078122\n", "char_count": 3960}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00078120", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Page 4 \nbelieved to have belonged to the defendant. Further, of the approximately 1.2 million documents \nto be produced, only a handful were specifically relied upon by the Government in the investigation \nthat led to the charges in the current Indictment, I and the Government intends to produce those \ndocuments on November 9 with the rest of the sixth production. Additionally, as a result of the \nwork being completed by the vendor, these materials will be produced to the defense in a manner \nthat is readily sortable and searchable which should facilitate and expedite its review. \nThe Government therefore respectfully requests that the Court extend the deadline for \nproduction of documents being prepared by an outside vendor to November 23, 2020, and that the \nCourt similarly extend the motions schedule in this case by three weeks as requested by the \ndefense. \nRespectfully submitted, \nAUDREY STRAUSS \nActing United States Attome \nAssistant United States Attorneys \nSo \n' \nw York \nTel \nCc: All Counsel of Record (By ECF) \n1 In particular, the application in support of the July 2020 warrant included quotations from four \nemails extracted from the devices, and, as noted, the Government will produce all four of those \ndocuments to the defense by November 9, 2020. \nEFTA00078123\n", "char_count": 1292}]}