{"efta_number": "EFTA00077287", "page_count": 4, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00077287", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00077287.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00077287", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "etu Dirk ga \n%  \nWVAILNYLLtOil \n4ournal \nAn Athol Publication \nTHURSDAY, MAY 6, 2020 \nThe Prince and the Proffer \nIn recent months, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York has issued forceful public statements regarding the ap-\nparent failure of Britain's Prince Andrew to cooperate in an ongoing investigation of alleged sex-trafficking by the late Jeffrey Ep-\nstein and his associates. In this Corporate Crime article, Evan Barr examines whether these unusual actions were justified under \nthe circumstances, and some of the challenges that lawyers for the Prince will surely confront as the investigation continues. \nBY EVAN T. BARR \n0\n n two separate occasions \nin recent months, Geoffrey \nBerman, U.S. Attorney \nfor the Southern District \nof New York, has issued \nforceful public statements regard-\ning the apparent failure of Britain's \nPrince Andrew to cooperate in an \nongoing investigation of alleged sex-\ntrafficking by the late Jeffrey Epstein \nand his associates. Berman called \nupon Prince Andrew to live up to a \npurported undertaking to assist in \nthe government's inquiry by meeting \nwith federal authorities to discuss \nhis friendship and contacts with the \ndeceased financier. In making these \npublic remarks, Berman departed \nfrom the traditional practice of avoid-\ning official comment related to ongo-\ning investigations. This article will \nexamine whether the U.S. Attorney's \nunusual actions were justified under \nthe circumstances, and some of the \nchallenges that lawyers for the Prince \nwill surely confront as the investiga-\nEVAN T. BARR is a partner at Fried Frank Harris \nShrive, & Jacobsen and a former federal prosecu-\ntor in New York. He worked on a matter for Epstein \nyears ago while employed at another law firm. \nBy \nEvan T. \nI Barr \ntion continues. \nThe Events in New York and London \nIn an indictment unsealed in July \n2019, the U.S. Attorney's Office for \nthe Southern District of New York \ncharged Epstein with conspiracy \nto commit sex traffic\n... [truncated, 3621 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00077287/0 or ?id=EFTA00077287&page=0]", "char_count": 3621}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00077287", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "litiolorktaflawild \nTHURSDAY, MAY 6, 2020 \nunpersuasive denials. As a result, \non Nov. 20, 2019, the Prince issued \na statement announcing that he \nwould be stepping back from his \npublic duties for the foreseeable \nfuture. Expressing regret for his as-\nsociation with Epstein, the Prince \nnoted \"[o]f course, I am willing to \nhelp any appropriate law enforce-\nment agency with their investiga-\ntions, if required.\" \nThe interview clearly touched a \nnerve at the U.S. Attorney's Office. \nOn Jan. 27, 2020, during a press con-\nference held outside Epstein's Up-\nper East Side mansion, Berman was \nasked about the Prince's November \n20 offer to help and stated, \"[t]o date, \nPrince Andrew has provided zero \ncooperation.\" According to the New \nYork Times, Berman went on to say \nhis office did not typically comment \non cooperation in an ongoing inves-\ntigation, but he felt that it was \"fair\" \nfor the public to know that Prince \nAndrew had failed to live up to his \npromise. Berman noted that the \"in-\nvestigation is moving forward\" and \nadded that \"Jeffrey Epstein couldn't \nhave done what he did without the \nassistance of others.\" \nOn March 8, 2020, the Daily Tele-\ngraph reported that Prince Andrew \nhad hired \"an eminent team of \nlawyers\" including an expert in \nextradition matters in the United \nKingdom to fend off the Ameri-\ncan investigation. The Times had \npreviously reported that following \nthe BBC interview in November, \nfederal \nprosecutors \nand \nFBI \nagents had reached out to Prince \nAndrew's lawyers and asked to \ninterview him but got no response. \nThen, on March 9, 2020, at a \npress conference in another mat-\nter, Berman stated in prepared \nremarks that \"[c]ontary to Prince \nAndrew's very public offer to co-\noperate with our investigation \ninto \nEpstein's \nco-conspirators, \nan offer that was conveyed via \npress release, Prince Andrew has \nnow completely shut the door on \nvoluntary cooperation.\" Berman \nadded that his office was \"consid-\nering its options.\" On March 13, \n\n... [truncated, 4528 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00077287/1 or ?id=EFTA00077287&page=1]", "char_count": 4528}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00077287", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "liebliettgajmuind \nTHURSDAY, MAY 6, 2020 \nThe Department of Justice has is-\nsued regulations dealing with the \nrelease of information to the me-\ndia in criminal and civil cases. 28 \nC.F.R. §50.2. The regulations princi-\npally prohibit DOJ personnel from \nfurnishing any statement which \nmight reasonably be expected to \ninfluence the outcome of a pend-\ning or future criminal trial. But \nthe regulations also apply \"from \nthe time a person is a subject of \na criminal investigation until any \nproceeding resulting from such an \ninvestigation has been terminated \nby trial or otherwise.\" 28 C.F.R \n§50.2(b) (emphasis added). \nThe regulations specifically com-\nmand DOJ personnel to refrain \nfrom making available certain \ntypes of information that generally \ntend to create a danger of preju-\ndice without serving a significant \nlaw enforcement function, includ-\ning, inter alia: (1) observations \nabout a defendant's character; (2) \nstatements, admissions confes-\nsions, or alibis attributable to a de-\nfendant, or the refusal or failure of \nthe accused to make a statement; \nand (3) statements concerning the \nidentity, testimony, or credibility \nof prospective witnesses. 28 C.F.R. \n§50.2.(b)(6). \nThe U.S. Attorney's Manual like-\nwise includes a policy statement \nestablishing guidelines for prosecu-\ntors to comply with the above regu-\nlations. Of relevance here, U.S.A.M. \n1-7.530 (A) (Disclosure of Informa-\ntion Concerning Ongoing Investiga-\ntions) provides that \"components \nand personnel of the Department \nof Justice shall not respond to \nquestions about the existence of an \nongoing investigation or comment \non its nature or progress, including \nsuch things as the issuance or serv-\ning of a subpoena, prior to the pub-\nlic filing of the document.\" U.S.A.M. \n1-7.530(B) allows that comments \nabout or confirmation of an ongo-\ning investigation may need to be \nmade \"in matters that have already \nreceived substantial publicity or \nabout which the community needs \nto be reassured that the\n... [truncated, 4541 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00077287/2 or ?id=EFTA00077287&page=2]", "char_count": 4541}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00077287", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "ifeloliorktaleXenned \nTHURSDAY, MAY 6, 2020 \nwitness. Second, although the al-\nlegations at issue date back to \n2001, there is no statute of limita-\ntions for federal sex trafficking of-\nfenses involving minors. Third, as \na result of his BBC interview, the \nPrince has \"locked himself in\" to a \nversion of events (including some \nhighly specific alibis) that leave \nhim little room to adapt should \nnew evidence come to light. Thus, \neven if he does agree to testify be-\nfore a grand jury or (more likely) \nparticipating in an informal proffer \nsession, he risks possible perjury \nor false statement charges (not to \nmention likely leaks to the media). \nFourth, notwithstanding the fact \nthat the Prince is a member of a \nroyal family that enjoys close ties \nwith the United States, he lacks \nany formal diplomatic or sover-\neign immunity and is facing a pros-\necutor who has already shown a \nwillingness to pursue high profile \nforeign leaders such as the former \nPresident of Venezuela. \nAssessing the US. Attorneys Conduct \nIn light of all of the surrounding \ncircumstances, and the applicable \nrules and regulations that govern \nextrajudicial statements by federal \nprosecutors, did the U.S. Attorney \ncross the line when he discussed \nhis frustrations with Prince An-\ndrew's failure to cooperate dur-\ning the January and March press \nconferences? \nFirst, even assuming arguendo \nthat a federal grand jury is inves-\ntigating \nEpstein's \nco-conspira-\ntors, the U.S. Attorney would not \nhave violated Rule 6(e) merely by \ndiscussing the fact that the Prince \nhad not been cooperative. Those \nstatements do not disclose any ac-\ntions \"occurring\" before the grand \njury (indeed, the gravamen of Ber-\nman's complaint is that the Prince \nhas not made himself available to \nbe a part of the investigation). \nSecond, the Department of Justice \npress regulations found at Title 28 \nof the Code of Federal Regulations \nare clearly focused on trials and \nprotecting the rights of charged \ndefendants, which\n... [truncated, 4590 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00077287/3 or ?id=EFTA00077287&page=3]", "char_count": 4590}]}