{"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_count": 25, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00076815", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00076815.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "306 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nt \nIn short, the issue now before the Court \nhas arisen only because Donziger unjustifi-\nably has refused to comply with his discov-\nery obligations. Had he done so — i.e., had \nhe produced responsive documents as to \nwhich there was no colorable claim of priv-\nilege, submitted a privilege log as to re-\nsponsive documents as to which there was \nsuch a colorable claim, and submitted any \ndisputes for judicial resolution - there \nwould be no need to examine his ESI. But \nhe has not. And the Court thus must take \nappropriate action. His arguments to the \ncontrary are meritless. \nConclusion \nFor the foregoing reasons, the Court \nhas entered the protocol for imaging and \nforensic examination of Donziger's elec-\ntronic devices and media. \nSO ORDERED. \nthe six months between being served with \nthe document requests and the Court's \neventual ruling, on October I8, 2018, that \nDonziger had waived any applicable privi-\nlege. \nThird, Donziger disregards the fact that \nwhen he belatedly produced a \"privilege \nlog\" in the prior litigation it was about \n2,000 pages long and scheduled over 8,652 \nsupposedly privileged \ndocuments. \nThe \n\"privilege log,\" however, contained not \neven one communication between Donziger \nand his putative clients. It claimed privilege \nas to more than 2,500 documents \"sent or \ndisclosed to a public relations person, the \nfounder of the Amazon Defense Front ..., \nAmazon Watch, and a host of newspapers \nand magazines\" none of which could have \nbeen privileged if only because they were \nnot confidential lawyer-client communica-\ntions. In re Chevron Corp., 749 F. Supp. 2d \nat 184. Thus, the privilege log tardily sub-\nmitted in the prior case was not a good \nfaith attempt to make only colorable claims \nof privilege as distinguished from an at-\ntempt to stall discovery. See id. at 184-85. \nUNITED STATES of America, \nGovernment, \nv. \nJeffrey EPSTEIN, Defendant \n19 CR. 490 (RMB) \nUnited States District Court, \nS.D. New Yo\n... [truncated, 3326 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/0 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=0]", "char_count": 3326}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEiN \nCute as 425 F.Supp.ld 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \n(2) defendant was serious risk of flight and \nconditions could not be set that reason-\nably would assure his appearance at \ntrial; and \n(3) defendant's proposed bail package did \nnot weigh in favor of pretrial release. \nMotion denied. \n1. Bail €=49(4) \nIn most federal cases the rebuttable \npresumption that applies favors pretrial \nrelease, not remand. \n2. Bail er49(5) \nSex trafficking victims are entitled to \nbe heard in court, including on the ques-\ntion of whether the defendant is to be \nreleased or remanded. \n18 U.S.C.A. \n§§ 3142, 3771. \n3. Bail cr>49(3.1) \nUnder the Bail Reform Act, a finding \nof a defendant's dangerousness must be \nsupported by clear and convincing evi-\ndence. 18 U.S.CA.* 3142. \n4. Bail €=.42 \nUnder the Bail Reform Act, where \nthere is a strong probability that a person \nwill commit additional crimes if released, \nthe need to protect the community be-\ncomes sufficiently compelling that deten-\ntion is, on balance, appropriate. \n18 \nU.S.CA. § 3142. \n5. Bail e=:073.1(1) \nUnder the Bail Reform Act, even a \nsingle incident of witness tampering may \nbe sufficient to revoke bail. 18 U.S.C.A. \n§ 3142. \n307 \n6. Bail e=49(3.1) \nTo order detention under the Bail Re-\nform Act based upon risk of flight, a court \nmust find by a preponderance of the evi-\ndence that no conditions could reasonably \nassure the defendant's presence at trial. \n18 U.S.CA.* 3142. \n7. Bail G=.42 \nThe constitutional limits on a deten-\ntion period under the Bail Reform Act \nbased on dangerousness to the community \nmay be looser than the limits on a deten-\ntion period based solely on risk of flight; in \nthe former case, release risks injury to \nothers, while in the latter case, release \nrisks only the loss of a conviction, and \ntherefore a bail package that may reason-\nably assure the appearance of the defen-\ndant at trial will not necessarily assure the \nsafety of the community. \n18 U.S.C.A. \n§ 3142. \n8. Bail €=.49(5) \nUnder t\n... [truncated, 2842 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/1 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=1]", "char_count": 2842}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "308 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nered among those weighed by the district \ncourt. 18 U.S.C.A. H 1591, 3142(e)(3)(E). \n11. Bail tz=.42 \nDefendant charged with sex traffick-\ning and sex trafficking conspiracy posed \ndanger to others and to community, weigh-\ning against pretrial release under Bail Re-\nform Act, where defendant was alleged to \nhave committed sex crimes with minor \ngirls and tampered with potential wit-\nnesses, victims feared for their safety if he \nwere released, he posed threat to addition-\nal young girls if he was released, and \ncompliance with his legal obligations as \nregistered sex offender was lacking. 18 \nU.S.CA. 0 1591, 3142. \n12. Bail e=49(4) \nUnder the Bail Reform Act, if the \ndefendant in a case involving sexual victim-\nization of a minor comes forward with \nevidence that he will not endanger the \ncommunity or flee the jurisdiction, the pre-\nsumption of remand is not erased; rather, \nthe presumption remains in the case as an \nevidentiary finding militating against re-\nlease, to be weighted along with other \nevidence. 18 U.S.CA. §§ 1591, 3142. \n13. Bail e=42 \nDefendant charged with sex traffick-\ning and sex trafficking conspiracy was ser-\nious risk of flight and conditions could not \nbe set that reasonably would assure his \nappearance at trial, weighing against pre-\ntrial release under Bail Reform Act, where \ndefendant had limited family ties to United \nStates, he had unexplained assets, and he \nhad incentive, motive, and wherewithal to \nflee, given his residence in Paris, his ex-\ntensive overseas travel, his significant \nwealth and his substantial resources, in-\ncluding private planes, and potential 45 \nyear term of imprisonment that could be \nimposed if he was convicted. 18 U.S.C.A. \n§§ 1591, 3142. \n14. Bail tz=.42 \nA finding of either danger to the com-\nmunity or risk of flight will be sufficient \nunder the Bail Reform Act to detain the \ndefendant pending trial. \n18 U.S.C.A. \n§ 3142. \n15. Bail er42 \nThe factors to be considered under\n... [truncated, 3337 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/2 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=2]", "char_count": 3337}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nCite u423 F.Supp.34 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \nPro Hac Vice, \nUnited States Attorney's Office, New \nYork, NY, Gloria Rachel Allred, Allred, \nMaroko & Goldberg, Los Angeles, CA, for \nGovernment. \nJames L. Brochin, Michael Campion \nMiller, Michael Gerard Scavelli, Reid \nWeingarten, Steptoe & Johnson, LLP, \nMarc Allan Fernich, Law Office of Marc \nFernich, New York, NY, Martin Gary \nWeinberg, Martin G. Weinberg, PC, Bos-\nton, MA, for Defendant. \nDECISION & ORDER REMANDING \nDEFENDANT \nRICHARD M. BERMAN, U.S.D.J. \nA. Background \nThis ruling follows the Court's bail hear-\ning held on July 15, 2019. The issue before \nthe Court is whether the Defendant should \ncontinue to be remanded (incarcerated) \npending trial or whether he should be \ngranted release while the case proceeds. \nNo matter the answer to this question and \nno matter what has been said in Court in \nanalyzing the matter, this is a criminal \ncase and the Defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, is \ninnocent of the Federal charges alleged \nagainst him now and until such time, if it \ncomes, that a jury or the Court fmds (after \nfair and thorough consideration of the \nfacts and the law) that he is guilty. See \nTranscript, dated July 8, 2019 (\"7/8/19 \nTr.\"), at 2-3; Transcript, dated July 15, \n2019 (\"7/1W19 Tr.\"), at 40. It should also \nbe borne in mind that the Court has not \n(yet) been presented with a motion to dis-\nmiss the Indictment. \nThis is a federal as opposed to a state \ncase. We proceed under federal law and \nfederal rules. The key federal statute that \napplies here is 18 U.S.C. § 1591 which sets \nforth the crime of sex trafficking with \nwhich Mr. Epstein is charged. Mr. Epstein \n309 \nis also charged with conspiring with others \nto commit sex trafficking under 18 U.S.C. \n§ 371. \n[1] With respect to the issue of re-\nmand versus release, 18 U.S.C. § 3142 \napplies. It sets forth a presumption in \nfavor of remand, an exception to the pre-\nsumption in most cases which favors pre-\ntrial release. § 3142 states that\n... [truncated, 3418 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/3 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=3]", "char_count": 3418}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "310 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \namong other things, been given the oppor-\ntunity to testify at the bail hearing. \nB. Counsels' Submissions \nThe Government's letter application, \ndated July 8, 2019, requests that the Court \nremand Mr. Epstein. It argues that Mr. \nEpstein \"poses [ ] an acute danger to the \ncommunity\" and, grounded in past experi-\nence with this Defendant, that \"if [Mr. \nEpstein is] allowed to remain out on bail, \nthe defendant could attempt to pressure \nand intimidate witnesses and potential wit-\nnesses in this case, including victims and \ntheir families, and otherwise attempt to \nobstruct justice.\" Dkt. 11, Ex. 1 at 1. The \nGovernment also contends that \"[i]n light \nof the strength of the Government's evi-\ndence and the substantial incarceratory \nterm the defendant would face upon con-\nviction [45 years], there is an extraordi-\nnary risk of flight, particularly given the \ndefendant's exorbitant wealth, his owner-\nship of and access to private planes capa-\nble of international travel, and his signifi-\ncant international ties.\" Id. \nThe Government also provides the fol-\nlowing background information: \"In or \nabout 2005, the defendant was investigated \nby local police in Palm Beach, Florida, in \nconnection with allegations that he had \ncommitted similar sex offenses against mi-\nnor girls. The investigation ultimately also \ninvolved federal authorities, namely the \nU.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern \nDistrict of Florida and the FBI's Miami \nOffice, and included interviews with vic-\ntims based in the Palm Beach area, includ-\ning some of the alleged victims relevant to \nCount One of the instant Indictment. In \nthe fall of 2007, the Defendant entered into \na non-prosecution agreement (\"NPA\") with \nthe Southern District of Florida in connec-\ntion with the conduct at issue in that inves-\ntigation, which the non-prosecution agree-\nment identified as including investigations \ninto the defendant's abuse of minor girls in \nthe Palm Beach area.\" Id. a\n... [truncated, 3911 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/4 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=4]", "char_count": 3911}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nale as 425 F.Supp-3d 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \n$77 million. Mr. Epstein's private jet can \nbe pledged as further collateral\"; (7) \"Mr. \nEpstein's brother Mark will serve as a co-\nsurety of the bond, which shall be further \nsecured by a mortgage on Mark's home in \nWest Palm Beach, Florida. Mr. Epstein's \nfriend David Mitchell will also serve as a \nco-surety and pledge his investment inter-\nests in two properties to secure the bond\"; \n(8) \"Mr. Epstein shall deregister or other-\nwise ground his private jet\"; (9) Mr. Ep-\nstein \"shall demobilize, ground, and/or \nderegister all vehicles or any other means \nof transportation in the New York area, \nproviding particularized information as to \neach vehicle's location;\" (10) \"Mr. Epstein \nwill provide Pretrial Services and/or the \ngovernment random access to his resi-\ndence\"; (11) \"No person shall enter the \nresidence, other than Mr. Epstein and his \nattorneys, without prior approval from \nPretrial Services and/or the Court\"; (12) \n\"Mr. Epstein will report daily by tele-\nphone to Pretrial Services (or on any oth-\ner schedule the Court deems appropri-\nate)\"; (13) \"A Trustee or Trustees will be \nappointed to live in Mr. Epstein's resi-\ndence and report any violation to Pretrial \nServices and/or the Court\"; (14) \"Any oth-\ner condition the Court deems necessary to \nreasonably assure Mr. Epstein's appear-\nance.\" Id. at 3.4. The Defense also propos-\nes as a \"fallback\" \"round-the-clock, pri-\nvately funded security guards [which] will \nvirtually guarantee - not just reasonably \nassure - Mr. Epstein's presence in the \ncircumstances of this case.\" Id. at 10. The \nbail package originally was not accompa-\nnied by a financial statement reflecting \nMr. Epstein's finances. However, on July \n12, 2019, the Defense filed a one-page doc-\nument which includes five groups of assets \nowned \nby \nMr. \nEpstein \ntotaling \n$559,120,954. Dkt. 14 at 18. \nThe Government responded to the De-\nfense motion on July 12, 2019, arguing, \namong other t\n... [truncated, 3981 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/5 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=5]", "char_count": 3981}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "312 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nrebut the operative presumption and make \nhimself eligible for release.\" Dkt. 24 at 2. \n\"Epstein contends that * 1591 and the \nconcomitant remand presumption do not \ncontemplate or cover the core conduct at \nissue here: performing sexual massages \nfor money.\" Id. at 1.2 n.1. Defense counsel \nalso states that \"Epstein certainly recog-\nnizes the Court's request for further trans-\nparency and is committed to providing a \ncomplete and accurate disclosure. Accord-\ningly, we propose that the Court prelimi-\nnarily accept the initial [financial] disclo-\nsure proffered last Friday and, if intending \nto rant bail, include a release condition \ndirecting Epstein to tender a comprehen-\nsive forensic accounting of his finances as \nexpeditiously as practicable.\" Id. at 4. By \nletters, dated July 16 and July 17, 2019, \nDefense counsel also submitted informa-\ntion regarding Epstein's New Mexico sex \noffender registration status. Defense coun-\nsel also stated that Epstein traveled exten-\nsively over the last eight months and \"in-\nvariably returned to the to the United \nStates. That inescapable reality emphati-\ncally proves he won't flee and entitles him \nto release - on any and all conditions the \nCourt deems appropriate.\" Id. at 8. \nC. Indictment \nA grand jury voted to indict Mr. Epstein \non or about July 2, 2019. The Indictment \ncharges Mr. Epstein with two felonies in-\nvolving minor girls some as young as 14. \nCount I includes conspiracy to commit sex \ntrafficking of minor girls, in violation of 18 \nU.S.C. § 371, and Count II includes sex \ntrafficking of minor girls, in violation of 18 \nU.S.C. § 1591. It states: \"[F]rom at least in \nor about 2002, up to and including at least \nin or about 2005, Jeffrey Epstein, ... en-\nticed and recruited, and caused to be en-\nticed and recruited, minor girls to visit his \nmansion in Manhattan, New York ... and \nhis estate in Palm Beach, Florida, ... to \nengage in sex acts with him, after which he \nwould giv\n... [truncated, 3832 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/6 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=6]", "char_count": 3832}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nale as 423 F.Supp-3d 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \nthe need to protect the community be-\ncomes sufficiently compelling that deten-\ntion is, on balance, appropriate.\" United \nStates v. Chimurenga, 760 F.2d 400, 403 \n(2d Cir. 1985). \"[E]ven a single incident of \nwitness tampering ... [may be] sufficient \nto revoke bail.\" LaFontaine, 210 F.3d at \n134. \n[6,7] To order detention based upon \nrisk of flight, the Court must find by a \npreponderance of the evidence that \"that \nno conditions could reasonably assure the \ndefendant's presence at trial.\" See, e.g., \nUnited States v. Jackson, 823 F.2d 4, 5 (2d \nCir. 1987); 18 U.S.C. § 3142. \"[The consti-\ntutional limits on a detention period based \non dangerousness to the community may \nbe looser than the limits on a detention \nperiod based solely on risk of flight. In the \nformer case, release risks injury to others, \nwhile in the latter case, release risks only \nthe loss of a conviction.\" United States v \nMilan, 4 F.3d 1038, 1048 (2d Cir. 1993) \n(quoting United States v. Orena, 986 F2d \n628, 631 (2d Cir. 1993)). A bail package \nthat \"may reasonably assure the appear-\nance of [the defendant] at trial will not \n[necessarily] assure the safety of the com-\nmunity.\" United States v. Rodriguez, 950 \nF.2d 85, 89 (2d Cir. 1991). \n[8] The Bail Reform Act sets forth the \nfollowing four• factors to be considered in \nthe release/remand analysis: (1) the nature \nand circumstances of the crime(s) charged; \n(2) the weight of the evidence against the \nperson; (3) the history and characteristics \nof the defendant, including the person's \ncharacter and financial resources; and (4) \nthe seriousness of the danger posed by the \ndefendant's release. 18 U.S.C. § 3142(g). \n\"The weight afforded to each factor under \nsection 3142(g) is within the 'special prov-\nince of the district court.\" United States v. \nPaulin, 335 F. Supp. 3d 600, 610 \n(S.D.N.Y. 2018) (quoting United States v. \nShaker, 817 F.2d 189, 196 (2d Cir. 1987)). \n313 \n[9] \"The rules\n... [truncated, 3818 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/7 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=7]", "char_count": 3818}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "314 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nand that Mr. Epstein presents a risk of \nflight (by a preponderance of the evi-\ndence). Id. Even if rebuttal evidence is \npresented, \"the presumption favoring de-\ntention does not disappear entirely.\" Id. at \n436. \"[It] remains a factor to be consid-\nered among those weighed by the district \ncourt.\" Id. \nF. Mr. Epstein Poses a Danger To \nOthers And To the Community \n[11] The Court begins with \"danger-\nousness\" because that concept is at the \nheart of this case. It fords that the Govern-\nment has shown by clear and convincing \nevidence that Mr. Epstein threatens the \nsafety of another person and of the com-\nmunity, as follows on pages 10-21: \n• \nVictims Have Advised The Court \nThat They Would Fear For Their \nSafety If Mr. Epstein Were Re-\nleased \nVictims have \"specifically conveyed\" to \nthe Government that any form of release \nof the Defendant, including home deten-\ntion with full-time private guards, could \n\"result in [their] harassment and abuse.\" \nDid. 11 at 4. At the bail hearing on July \n15, 2019, two victims movingly testified \nabout their past sexual encounters with \nMr. Epstein when they were minors aged \n14 and 16, respectively. 7/1W19 Tr. at 72; \nsee also S. REP. 108-191 (\"CVRA Legisla-\ntive History\"), at 22 (In enacting the \nCVRA, Congress stated that \"[V]ictims de-\nserve the right to be heard at specific \npoints in the criminal justice process,\" in-\ncluding bail hearings. \"Giving victims a \nvoice not only improves the quality of the \nprocess but can also be expected to often \nbenefits to victims.\"). \nMs \nIts introduced by her \ncounsel, David Boies, and stated that she \nwas 16 years old when she \"had the mis-\nfortune of meeting Jeffrey Epstein [in] \nNew York.\" 7/15/19 Tr. at 72. Ms. Farmer \nsaid that Mr. Epstein \"flew [her] to New \nMexico\" and was \"inappropriate\" with her. \nId. She was reluctant to go into details \nabout her experience with Mr. Epstein. Id. \nat 73. Ms. Fanner opposes Mr. Epstein's \npretrial release b\n... [truncated, 3523 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/8 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=8]", "char_count": 3523}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nale as 423 F.Suppld 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \nAccordingly, Mr. Epstein's past sexual \nconduct is not likely to have abated or \nbeen successfully suppressed by fierce de-\ntermination, as his Defense Counsel sug-\ngests. Defense Counsel contends that. \n\"[H]e wasn't a predator that couldn't con-\ntrol his conduct. He disciplined himself.\" \n7/15/19 Tr. at 31-32. Defense Counsel also \nargues that \"appreciating the gravity of \nthese charges .. . putting aside the age of \nthese witnesses and putting the consent \nissue aside, it's not like [Epstein is] an out-\nof-control rapist.\" 7/15/19 'Pr. at 36. It \nseems fair to say that Mr. Epstein's future \nbehavior will be consistent with past be-\nhavior, including the trove of \"lewd photo-\ngraphs of young-looking women or girls,\" \nwhich were recently uncovered during the \nJuly 6-7, 2019, search of Mr. Epstein's \nEast 71st Street mansion. See Dkt. 11, Ex. \n1 at 9. The search results suggest the \n\"possibility that defendant could target an-\nother vulnerable victim.\" See United \nStates v. Baker, 349 F. Supp. 3d 1113, 1135 \n(D.N.M. 2018) (where the defendant was \nalleged to specifically target \"vulnerable \nwomen\" and where he attempted to con-\ntact an alleged victim, the court was pet \nsuaded that the defendant \"would be a \ndanger to society if released\"). \nDespite having been convicted of the \nabove mentioned (two) Florida sex crimes \n(in 2008) involving an underage girl, Mr. \nEpstein, as noted, maintained at his New \nYork residence a \"vast trove\" of sexually \nsuggestive photographs of nude underage \nand adult girls. Dkt. 11, Ex. 1 at 9. That is, \nduring the July 6.7, 2019 authorized search \nof Mr. Epstein's NYC residence, the FBI \nfound a \"substantial collection of photo-\ngraphic trophies of his victims and other \nyoung females.\" Dkt. 11 at 10. This evi-\ndence includes compact discs labeled \n\"Young [Redacted Name] + [Redacted \nName],\" \"Misc nudes 1,\" and Girl pies \nnude.\" Id. The Government contends that \nthis evidence incl\n... [truncated, 3820 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/9 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=9]", "char_count": 3820}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "316 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \n782 F.2d at 1144. If the defendant comes \nforward with evidence that he will not \nendanger the community or flee the juris-\ndiction, the presumption \"is not erased.\" \nSee United States v. Dominguez, 783 F2d \n702, 707 (7th Cir. 1986). \"Rather, the pre-\nsumption remains in the case as an eviden-\ntiary finding militating against release, to \nbe weighted along with other evidence.\" \nUnited States v. Hir, 517 F.3cl 1081, 1086 \n(9th Cir. 2008); see also Martir, 782 F2d at \n1144 (\"The concern underlying the pre-\nsumption applies to the general class of \ndefendants charged with one of the speci-\nfied offenses—not merely to defendants \nwho fail to produce rebuttal evidence. \nWere the presumption ... to vanish upon \nany showing ..., courts would be giving \ntoo little deference to Congress' findings \nregarding this class) (emphasis in original). \n• \nThe US. Pretrial Services Depart-\nment Recommends To The Court \nThat Mr. Epstein Continue to Be \nRemanded \nThe Pretrial Services report, dated July \n8, 2019, concludes, following Pretrial Ser-\nvices' interview of Mr. Epstein, that \n\"[t]here is no condition or combination of \nconditions that [can] reasonably assure ... \nthe safety of the community\" if Mr. Ep-\nstein is released. Pretrial Services Report, \ndated July 8, 2019, at 4. Pretrial Services \nalso concluded that Mr. Epstein is a flight \nrisk and recommends that he be detained \nfor that reason as well. Id. \nIn support of its assessment of Mr. Ep-\nstein's dangerousness, Pretrial Services \ncites the following: the \"Nature of [Mr. \nEpstein's currently charged] Instant Of-\nfence,\" i.e., sex trafficking and conspiracy \ninvolving minor girls; Mr. Epstein's \"Prior \nI. Mr. Epstein is reported to have remarked \nthat: \"I'm not a 'sexual predator,' I'm an \n'offender' ... Its the difference between a \nmurderer and a person who steals a bagel.\" \nArrests,\" ems., in Florida in 2006; Mr. Ep-\nstein's \"History [and] Conviction Involving \n[a] Sex [Offense],\n... [truncated, 3675 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/10 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=10]", "char_count": 3675}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nChess425 F.Supp.34 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \ncator of whether the legislature considered \nan offense to be .. . `serious.\" United \nStates v. Dugan, 667 F.3d 84, 86 (2d Cir. \n2011) (quoting Lewis v. United States, 518 \nU.S. 322, 326, 116 S.Ct. 2163, 135 L.Ed2d \n590 (1996)). \nAnd, the crimes Mr. Epstein has been \ncharged with are among the most heinous \nin the law principally, in the Court's view, \nbecause they involve minor girls. 18 \nU.S.C. § 3142 (e)(3)(E); see also Roger \nPrzybylski, Chapter 5: Adult Sex Offender \nRecidivism, Sex Offender Management \nAssessment \nand \nPlanning \nInitiative \n(\"[R]esearchers widely agree that ob-\nserved recidivism rates are underesti-\nmates of the true reoffense rates of sex \noffenders. Hidden offending presents sig-\nnificant challenges for• professionals work-\ning in sex offender management as it is \ndifficult to know whether offenders who \nappear to be nonrecidivists based on offi-\ncial records are truly offense free.\") (em-\nphasis in original). \n• \nMr. Epstein Or His Representa-\ntives Have Intimidated, Threat-\nened, And/Or Made Payments To \nPotential Witnesses \nThe Government's evidence includes: (i) \nFlorida police reports describing harass-\nment and intimidation of witnesses in-\nvolved in the Florida state criminal investi-\ngation of Mr. Epstein in 2006, and (ii) \nemails, dated September 13, 2007 and Sep-\ntember 19, 2007 (attached hereto), from \nMr. Epstein's former counsel to Federal \nprosecutors in Florida discussing the \"op-\ntion\" of Mr. Epstein pleading guilty to \nwitness tampering, harassment, and/or ob-\nstruction of justice. \nA Palm Beach Police Incident Report, \ndated July 19, 2006, states that one of Mr. \nEpstein's victims reported that Mr. Ep-\nstein's representative said to her: \"Those \nwho help [Mr. Epstein] will be compen-\n317 \nsated and those who hurt [Mr. Epstein] \nwill be dealt with.\" Dkt. 11, Ex. 3 at 2 \n(emphasis added.) The Report also states: \n\"[Mr. Epstein's representative] assured \n[the victim that\n... [truncated, 3771 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/11 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=11]", "char_count": 3771}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "318 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nthinking about the same statutes.\" Id. On \nSeptember 18, 2007, a Federal prosecutor \ntold Mr. Epstein's counsel that if Mr. Ep-\nstein pled guilty to obstruction of justice, \nthe factual proffer \"could rely on the inci-\ndent where Mr. Epstein's private investi-\ngators followed [a victim's] father, forcing \n[him] off the road.\" Id., Dkt. 361-10; see \nalso supra p. 15. On September 19, 2007, \nMr. Epstein's counsel proposed that Mr. \nEpstein admit that he verbally harassed \nvictims or the family of victims in connec-\ntion with his \"attempt to delay their volun-\ntary receipt of process\" in a civil action \nagainst Mr. Epstein, in violation of a Fed-\neral witness tampering statute. Doe Dkt. \n361-9. \nAnd, the Government has recently con-\ntended that, on November 28, 2018 and on \nDecember 3, 2018 - very soon after the \npublication of a 3-part investigative report \nin the Miami Herald (authored by Julie K. \nBrown) relating to Mr. Epstein's Florida \nNon-Prosecution Agreement dated Sep-\ntember 24, 2007 - Mr. Epstein paid \n$100,000 to \"a company founded and run \nby [Individual 1],\" and he paid $250,000 to \n[Individual II]. Dkt. 23 at 1. The Govern-\nment states that Individual I was \"a poten-\ntial coconspirator—[ for whom Epstein \nobtained protection in [] the NPA.\" Id. \nIndividual I was named and featured \nprominently in the Miami Herald. See•\nJulie K. Brown, \"Even From Jail, Sex \nAbuser Manipulated The System. His Vic-\ntims Were Kept in The Dark, Miami Her-\nald, Nov. 28, 2018. \nThe Government states that Individual \nII was also \"a potential co-conspirator—[ ] \nfor whom Epstein also obtained protection \nin [ the NPA.\" Dkt. 23 at 2. She is \"one of \nthe employees identified in the Indictment, \nwhich alleges that she and two other iden-\ntified employees facilitated the defendant's \ntrafficking of minors by, among other \nthings, contacting victims and scheduling \ntheir sexual encounters with the defendant \nat his residences in Manhattan and Pa\n... [truncated, 3712 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/12 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=12]", "char_count": 3712}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEiN \nale as 425 F.Supp-341 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \nwhich he was required to register [as a sex \noffender],\" since his 2008 Florida convic-\ntions. Counsel argues that this shows that \nhe \"is no longer a danger to anyone and \nwill faithfully obey all conditions of release \nif ordered.\" Dkt. 6 at 3. \nThe record shows that Mr. Epstein has \nchallenged his sex offender \"level\" in at \nleast one jurisdiction since 2008 in an ef-\nfort to minimize his reporting obligations. \nAnd, one recent press account states that \nEpstein is not in compliance in New York \nState. See Elizabeth Rosner, Tina Moore, \nLarry Celona, and Bruce Golding, NYPD \nlet convicted pedophile Jeffi•ey Epstein \nskip judge-ordered check-in, New York \nPost, July 10, 2019 (\"July 10, 2019 NY \nPost Article\") (\"Jeffrey Epstein never once \nchecked in with City cops in eight-plus \nyears since a Manhattan judge ordered \nhim to do so every 90 days\"). \nMr. Epstein is a Level III sex offender \nin New York State which is the highest \ncategory of risk to reoffend. This designa-\ntion requires that Mr. Epstein report his \npresence in New York to law enforcement \nauthorities every 90 clays. As discussed at \nthe July 15, 2019 bail hearing, counsel for \nMr. Epstein made an application in New \nYork State Supreme Court in 2011 to re-\nduce Epstein's sex offender registration \nstatus from Level III to Level I. If grant-\ned, this reduction would have allowed Mr. \nEpstein to avoid his reporting obligations. \nIn a Sex Offender Registration Act Hear-\ning on January 11, 2018, held before the \nHonorable Ruth Pickholz, Mr. Epstein's \napplication was (firmly) denied, principally \nbecause it had been established by the \nBoard of Examiners of Sex Offenders. See \nPeople v. Epstein, Indict. # 30129/2010, \n(N.Y. Sup. Ct.), SORA Hearing Transcript, \ndated Jan. 18, 2011. \nAt the hearing, New York County Assis-\ntant District Attorney Jennifer Gaffney \njoined in Defense Counsel's appeal to re-\n319 \nview and overturn the decision of the \nB\n... [truncated, 3861 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/13 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=13]", "char_count": 3861}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "320 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nshould lead to his release. See LaFontaine, \n210 F.3d at 135 n.6 (where the Court or-\ndered detention noting that the defendant \n\"had previously disregarded court or-\nders\"). \nThe Court has also read the story in the \nJuly 17, 2019, New York Post in which \nattorney Brad Edwards contends that \nwhile Epstein was serving his Florida \nstate sentence (after pleading guilty to \nprocuring a minor under 18 for prostitu-\ntion and solicitation of prostitution), Ep-\nstein was allowed to leave the jail on work \nrelease. While on work release \"[h]e was \nhaving .. . female visitors ... and continu-\ning to engage in .. . [sexual] conduct ... \nwhile he was in jaill.\" Mr. Edwards is \ncounsel to one of Mr. Epstein's victims. \nSee Reuven Fenton and Kate Sheehy, Jef-\nfrey Epstein had sex den while serving \ntime: lawyer, New York Post, July 16, \n2019. The Court is also aware of an article \npublished by Palm Beach CBS local news \nwhich reports that the Palm Beach County \nSherriffs Office \"disputes [the] claim that \nJeffrey Epstein had sex on work release.\" \nA spokeswoman for the sheriffs office is \nquoted as saying \"If he violated any condi-\ntions of his release he would have been \nbrought back to the Stockade and work \nrelease would have been terminated.\" \nChuck Weber, PBSO disputes claim that \nJeffrey Epstein had sex on work release, \nCBS 12 News, July 17,2019. \n• \nNew Mexico, Florida And The Vir-\ngin Islands \nWith respect to Mr. Epstein's sex of-\nfender status in New Mexico, Defense \nCounsel has submitted a letter, dated Au-\ngust 19, 2010, from Regina Chacon, Assis-\ntant Bureau Chief, Law Enforcement \nRecord Bureau of the New Mexico De-\npartment of Public Safety, which states \nthat Mr. Epstein \"is not required to regis-\nter [as a sex offender] with the State of \nNew Mexico at this time for [his] 2008 \nFlorida conviction of Procuring [a] Person \nUnder 18 for Prostitution.\" Dkt. 25, Ex. \nA. The Court requested from the Defense \nall application mat\n... [truncated, 3611 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/14 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=14]", "char_count": 3611}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nale as 423 F.Supp-3d 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \ndant; (3) the history and characteristics of \nthe defendant, including the person's char-\nacter and financial resources; and (4) \"the \nseriousness of the danger posed by the \ndefendant's release.\" 18 U.S.C. § 3142(g). \n\"The weight afforded to each factor under \nsection 3142(g) is within the `special prov-\nince' of the district court.\" Paulin, 335 F. \nSupp. 3d at 610. \nAt the outset, it should be noted that the \nPretrial Services Report, dated July 12, \n2019, concludes that: \"The defendant poses \na risk of nonappearance for the following \nreasons: \n1. [Mr. Epstein's] Extensive foreign \ntravel and possession of travel docu-\nments \n2. [Mr. Epstein's] Residential and Fi-\nnancial Ties outside this District and \nCountry \n3. [Mr. Epstein's] Employment ties \noutside this country \n4. [Mr. Epstein's] Unexplained assets \n5. [Mr. Epstein's] Criminal History in-\ncluding [his] conviction for a [] sex of-\nfense [with minors in Florida in 2008].\" \nPretrial Services Report, dated July 12, \n2019 at 4. \n• \nThe Crimes Charged Against Mr. \nEpstein \nMr. Epstein has been charged with \namong the most serious crimes recognized \nby U.S. Federal law. The Government has \nalleged that Mr. Epstein intentionally \nsought out and sexually abused minor \ngirls, including those \"particularly vulnera-\nble to exploitation.\" Dkt. 11, Ex. 1, at 2. He \ndid this in multiple locations, including \nNew York and Palm Beach. Id. And Mr. \nEpstein allegedly \"worked and conspired \nwith others, including employees and asso-\nciates who facilitated his [unlawful] con-\nduct, by ... contacting victims and sched-\nuling their sexual encounters.\" Indictment \n1 4. These crimes, as already noted, carry \n321 \na maximum sentence of 45 years of incar-\nceration and give rise to a presumption of \npre-trial remand. 18 U.S.C. \n§ \n3142 \n(e)(3)(E); see United States v. Hardy, 2019 \nWL 2211210, at *10 (D.D.C. May 22, 2019) \n(\"The significant harms and dangers of \nthese crimes \n... [truncated, 3538 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/15 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=15]", "char_count": 3538}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "322 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nHe also held plea discussions regarding \nwitness tampering in Florida in 2008. He is \na registered Level III sex offender in New \nYork and a registered sex offender in \nFlorida (Level I) and the Virgin Islands \n(Level I). Mr. Epstein is 66 and is report-\ned to be a self made multi-millionaire. He \ndid not graduate from college. Mr. Ep-\nstein's vast wealth, including substantial \nliquid assets, multiple residences, private \nplane(s), a $8,672,823 residence in Paris, \nFrance, and relatively limited family ties \nto the United States in the sense that he is \nsingle with no children and his parents are \ndeceased. He has a brother who Defense \ncounsel asserts has offered to serve as a \nguarantor for Mr. Epstein by pledging his \nhome in West Palm Beach, Florida. (The \nCourt notes that the Pretrial Services Re-\nport, dated July 12, 2019, states that \"[tjhe \ndefendant stated he maintains minimal \ncontact with his brother, Mark Epstein, \nand that his exact location is unknown at \nthis time.\" Pretrial Services Report at 2.) \nMr. Epstein engages in extensive over-\nseas travel often relying on his own \nplane(s). The Government argues persua-\nsively that \"there is an extraordinary risk \nof flight, particularly given the defendant's \nexorbitant wealth, his ownership of and \naccess to private planes capable of interna-\ntional travel, and his significant interna-\ntional ties. Indeed, the arrest of the defen-\ndant occurred when he arrived in the \nUnited States on his private jet after hav-\ning returned from a multi-week stay \nabroad.\" Dkt. 11, Ex. 1 at 1. \"Wri the past \n18 months alone, the defendant has trav-\neled abroad, via private jet, either into or \nout of the country on approximately more \nthan 20 occasions.\" Id. at 3. \nIn a recent search of Defendant's New \nYork City home, law enforcement seized \nan expired Austrian passport bearing Mr. \nEpstein's photo but not his name. (The \npassport is in another name.) The Austrian \npassport lists r\n... [truncated, 3991 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/16 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=16]", "char_count": 3991}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nCute as 423 F.Supp.34 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \ndating his receipt of the document, do not \nreflect Mr. Epstein's entries or exits.\" Dkt. \n31. \nDefense counsel has submitted a one \npage document called \"Asset Summary -\nJune 30, 2019.\" It indicates that Epstein \nhas cash in the amount of $56,547,773; \nfixed income valued at $14,304,679; equi-\nties valued at $112,679,138; hedge funds \nand private equity valued at $194,986,301; \nproperties located at 9 East 71st Street, \nNY, NY 10021 valued at $55,931,000, 49 \nZorro Ranch Road, Stanley, New Mexico \n87056 valued at $17,246,208, 358 El Brillo \nWay, Palm Beach, Florida 33480 valued at \n$12,380,209, 22 Avenue Foch, Paris France \n75116 valued at $8,672,823, Great St. \nJames Island No. 6A USVI 00802 (parcels \nA, B, and C) valued at $22,498,600 and \nLittle St. James Island No. 6B USVI \n00802 (parcels A, B, and C). Dkt. 14 at 18. \nThe Court has advised Defense counsel \nthat this \"cursory\" asset statement is in-\nsufficient to support a bail package for the \nreasons, among others, that it is not veri-\nfied and does not show expenses, indebted-\nness, or liabilities. \nLaw enforcement has informed the Gov-\nernment that a safe in the Defendant's \nNew York home very recently contained \n\"more than $70,000 in cash ... 48 loose \ndiamond stones, ranging in size from ap-\nproximately 1 carat to 2.38 carats, as well \nas a large diamond ring. The Government \nis currently unaware of whether the De-\nfendant maintains similar [amounts] of \ncash and/or jewels at his multiple proper-\nties, or in other locations. Such ready cash \nand loose diamonds are consistent with the \ncapability to leave the jurisdiction at a \nmoment's notice.\" Dkt. 23 at 3. \nThe Defendant's vast wealth and influ-\nential contacts have provided him with the \nmeans to pay individuals to assist him in \nunlawful endeavors, including potentially \nfleeing the jurisdiction. In the past, \"the \n323 \nDefendant worked with others, including \nemployees and associates who faci\n... [truncated, 3866 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/17 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=17]", "char_count": 3866}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "324 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nof flight ... this Court does not believe \nthat that condition, even coupled with the \nadditional conditions proposed, would be \nsufficient\" U.S. v.Cilins, 2013 WL 3802012, \nat *3. \n• \nThe Danger Posed By The Defen-\ndant's Release \nAs demonstrated infra, Mr. Epstein's \ndangerousness is considerable and includes \nsex crimes with minor girls and tampering \nwith potential witnesses. The discussion at \npp 10-21 is incorporated here by reference. \nSee Minnici, 128 F. App.,: at 829-30 (\"the \nalleged activities [we're of an addictive \nsexual nature that cannot be suppressed \nsimply by a restrictive set of bail condi-\ntions\"); see also Milian, 4 F.3d at 1049 \n(\"The protection of the community can be \nassured only by continued detention.\"). \nThe Court has carefully considered the \nissue of Defendant's ability and motivation \nfor fleeing U.S. jurisdiction. The Court \nfords that the Government has proven by a \npreponderance of the evidence that, among \nother things, the Defendant's limited fami-\nly ties to the United States, his residence \nin Paris, his extensive overseas travel, his \nsignificant wealth and his substantial re-\nsources (including private planes), and the \npotential 45 year term of imprisonment \nthat may be imposed should there be a \nconviction in this case, provide incentive, \nmotive and wherewithal to flee. Indeed, \nthese factors render him a \"classic\" flight \nrisk. See, e.g., United States v. Abdullahu, \n488 F.Supp.2d 433, 445 (D.N.J. 2007) (\"Af-\nter reviewing the totality of the evidence, \nthe Court has reached the inescapable con-\nclusion that the government has proved by \na preponderance of the evidence that no \ncondition or combination of conditions exist \nthat will reasonably assure the defendant's \nappearance at trial. The defendant faces \nserious criminal charges . . . The defen-\ndant faces a potential ten year prison sen-\ntence and involuntary deportation. The de-\nfendant does not have permanent and \nlongstandin\n... [truncated, 3775 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/18 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=18]", "char_count": 3775}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nale as 425 F.Supp-3d 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \naccurate financials for Mr. Epstein. He \nalso suggested that he would do so (only) if \nthe Court were agreeable to granting bail. \nThis \"offer\" appears disingenuous for a \nperson as wealthy and experienced in fi-\nnancial matters as Mr. Epstein. See Tr. \n7/15/19 at 50 (Court: \"There needs to be a \nfuller financial picture to know what would \nbe appropriate.\" Defense Counsel: \"Let me \nbe blunt It was our first effort.. ..\"). That \nMr. Epstein does not have a financial \nstatement, including liabilities and ex-\npenses, readily available is difficult to un-\nderstand. \n(2) The defense bail package proposes \nexcessive involvement of the Court in rou-\ntine aspects of Mr. Epstein's proposed \nhome confinement This is not the Court's \nfunction. See United States v. Zarrab, 2016 \nWL 3681423, at 90 (S.D.N.Y. June 16, \n2016) (\"The (bail package] ... proposed by \nthe defense is not reasonable because, in \ntoo many respects, it substitutes judicial \noversight and management for (more ap-\npropriate) reliance upon trained, experi-\nenced, and qualified professionals from the \nU.S. Bureau of Prisons and the U.S. Mar-\nshals Service.\"). The Defense package \ncomponents would embroil the Court in \nissues, among others, relating to the level \nof force that may be used to secure the \nDefendant, who may enter the residence, \ndaily reporting by Mr. Epstein, and re-\nporting by so-called l'rustee(s) designated \nto live with and supervise Mr. Epstein. See \nUnited States v. Valerio, 9 F. Supp. 3d \n283, 295 (E.D.N.Y. 2014) (\"The questions \nabout the legal authorization for the pri-\nvate security firm to use force against \ndefendant should he violate the terms of \nhis release, and the questions over wheth-\ner the guards can or should be armed, \nunderscore the legal and practical uncer-\ntainties - indeed, the imperfections - of the \nprivate jail-like concept envisioned by de-\nfendant, as compared to the more secure \noption of an actual jail.\"\n... [truncated, 3918 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/19 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=19]", "char_count": 3918}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "326 \n4,i FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nabroad, and residing in part in Paris, \nFrance; there would be little to stop the \ndefendant from fleeing, transferring his \nunknown assets abroad, and then continu-\ning to do whatever it is he does to earn his \nvast wealth from a computer terminal be-\nyond the reach of extradition.\" Dkt. 11 at 5 \n(emphasis omitted). The Defendant, it \nshould also be noted, is already at risk of \nlosing some of his real property because \nthe Indictment contains a forfeiture allega-\ntion regarding any property that was used \nor intended to be used to commit or to \nfacilitate the sex trafficking offenses and \nthat includes, but it is not limited to, the \nproperty located at 9 East 71st Street, \nNew York, New York. \n(5) The appointment and role of \"trus-\ntees\" who will presumably live with Mr. \nEpstein and monitor his compliance with \nbail conditions are unacceptably vague. \nThey do not, for example, address the \nconflict that is created by the salary the \n\"trustees\" are earning from the Defendant \nand their purported role as independent \nmonitors. (The same problem arises in re-\nlation to private 24/7 security guards.) This \nis especially problematic where, as here, it \nis alleged that employees of the Defendant \nmay have engaged in unlawful acts with \nand on behalf of the Defendant. According \nto the Government, \"the defendant worked \nwith others, including employees and asso-\nciates who facilitated his exploitation of \nminors, by among other things, contacting \nvictims and scheduling their sexual en-\ncounters with the defendant, both in New \nYork and in Florida.\" Dkt. 11, Ex 1 at 2. \n(6) \"As a fallback,\" the Defense sug-\ngests the utilization of and the funding of a \nprivate security guard agency to \"virtually \nguarantee\" Mr. Epstein's presence in court \nand, presumably, also to supervise his be-\nhavior. This contingency plan is not a part \nof Mr. Epstein's 14 point proposal. Never-\ntheless, the Court is asked by the defense \nto \"revisit\" its \n... [truncated, 3015 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076815/20 or ?id=EFTA00076815&page=20]", "char_count": 3015}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nCite .s425 F.Supp3d 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \nAttachment—Continued \nCase 0 013cv.907303•KAM Document 361.11 Entered ors FLSD Docket 02/1(V2016 Page 2 of 3 \nant \nJute \nPar lahowir !Annan: \nkirstrip cool \n200flfs 6000 - \nI .ill be al 7400. set's talk at 9 sm. \nAlready thickly Idol \nthe sane statutes. \nLook ferhar0 to Speaking In the manning. \nPest: 269.\nFrom: \nSent: 09/11/2607 07.26 PM AST \nTo: \nLeAtiOalli \nSubject: at: \nat fl y .• NITS, I am. I hay* Dan soenishs Same Canty ties oath iltle \nIS local% fa-\nalsdemearkws. \nDo you want totakea \nloon at as us( 4.11, 16 use isia(o), asdailet \n22)(4)(3)(0) and we tan talk aboet then togorro6? \n: knOw that Saone Mentioned) there being \nUnity on an airplane. I just want to hake Sure tilt \nthere IS factual Oasis tor the pile\n1\n1 \nt the &testi can confer.. \nI. \nrot sore exactly sore \nI will Se tomirrofhprnlall. SO IS It alright if I Cull youe \neat. a good evOillall. \nsssss \n)ay le1tOwitt (maill0:)lefiOkitt0t1/110, 0.600. \nto \nM\n- AY you free to waft at 9 as toomat? \nThanks. \n3my \ne\nInformation «ntaine0 in this chenkakation is \nconfidential: may be attornerclieet \nprivileged: esti \nCOAStitote Inside information: and IS intended Only for \nP IAA J.IPA \n327 \nEFTA00076836\n", "char_count": 1235}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "328 \n42s FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nAttachment—Continued \nCase 0:0B-cv-60736.KAM Doanent 361.11 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/102016 Page 3 cd 3 \nthe use of the addressee. It is the PreParte of \nKirkland g (Ills lip or Kirkland $ Ellis Internetkeel LW. \nunauthorized use, disclosure or copying of this \neoter\nunlcation or any part thereof is strictly prohibited \nlm\nsay be unlawful. If you have received this \nRation in error, please notify us immediately by \nreturn e.mall or by e•aeil to postfiestergkirkland.coe, zed \ndestroy this cominication and all copies thereof, \nincluding all attachments. \nThe Infonetloo contained in this conmeatication is \nconfidential, say be attorney-client privileged, say \nconstitute inside information, and is intended only for \nthe use of the addressee. It Is the property of \n \nmid a jilts Li, or Kirkland & kills International lip. \nUnauthorized use, disclosure or cowing of FhIS \nttehhetrettehoranY part thereof is strictly prohibited \nand say be unlawful. If you have received this \ncorinunication in error, please notify us iniediataly by \nreturn freell or by •-seil to posteastorilkireland.coe are \ndestroy this communication awl all copies thereof, \nincluding all attachments. \n• \n• \nPi • 1.1403.11le \nEFTA00076837\n", "char_count": 1257}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "U.S. v. EPSTEIN \nCite .s623 F.Supp3d 306 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) \nAttachment—Continued \nCase 908-cv60736-KAM Document 361-10 Emoted on FLSD Docket 02/10,2016 Page 2 of 2 \n*mom \nlueihMt. WPM*. 111. 2C0/ 8 m Ake \nJay Lelkontz* \nOmit ameemmts\" \nII. \nlugs hoping there would be things for Inc to read this morning. but I will ay to remain patien \nI believe there are only Iwo types of speernents that would apply to ibis case (I) a plea ;Lineman to a :kderal \ncharge or charges; and t2) a nun-prosecution agrcemeal (which is really a deferred prosecution agreement \nbecause the defendant agrees chit if he violases the agreement. the US Can prosecute him). \nA plea agramem is part of the coon file. It is not accessible on-line Ss PACER. but someone cm go to the \nClcdes Office to obtain, copy. \nA non-proseeution agreement would not be made public x tiled with the Cost bin it *oak: remain pin oroa \ncase file. h probably would be subject to a FOIA ropes. but ti is no winch ng that we would distnhie \nwithout compulsory process \nOn the et utmccien charges. many of the fats I included S that first Troffer were hypothesized based icon our \ndie:onions and the ages etecruutime of\n We will need ha inlets icw her IC confine, 'he accvnicy of \nthose facts led a second count. we ould rely on the incident wbcre Mr. Epascin's private investigators \nfollowed MSfather forcing him off the road. Or, if litre is something mom mom related to any NM \nwe could consider \nope that helps. \nre SA 008to. \n329 \nEFTA00076838\n", "char_count": 1499}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076815", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "330 \n425 FEDERAL SUPPLEMENT, 3d SERIES \nAttachment—Continued \n0 9O8-cv-60736.KM! Document 361-9 Fitted on FLSO Docket 02/10/2016 Page 2 of 2 \nJay Leftover illersarmsastIttra conS \n. Pint agroornerea \nConfidential • Foe settlement merpows only \nStill winking en redline aut pit lank at this \nOn August \n200. FRI Spinal Agrrn \nrave£J to the ha of \nvestgatiai send am it. tic \nSouthern District of Flossie. Mr. [poem wa informed °filar serske of the \nAs a \nrrauk. Mr. EpSteia attempted to caner both \ndelay and hinder that \nreceipt ofs \nIta attend an official proceeding, rsMrc panktdarly the -'to \nwhich \nMr. Epstein. In Funicular. changed navel pWts and flee with both \nto the exited States Vein Islands rather than in an airport in New Jersey in order to attempt ty \ndelay shot: tntipa of whit Mr. Epsteincanoed to be s \nMr. Eosins (ergs' \nverbally harassed both \nia come:Won to this allniipt to delay our Vultellaly \nroc c5x 0 rimoCcas all in Malaita. of IS USC !SI 2.44)( I ). \n---orbaso Massa e \nrem: \n•\n: \nTo: fay Letkowee \nSubject: RE: Draft Agreemain? \niii h• limn kiwis the le<mul haw £c the litigant \nher AIM ar \nno tneronJum \nevaintec oleo Y. the :gems teed to tak hi Oern a,3 then lean taiga mupowl Noun proffer. I hoe c' an e \nnun si nasty and I an ..a in 3e;gniune ,her aviabkhr) \nThe infomucion contained in OW communication is \nconfidential. may he attorney-rhea Pnvtleged. may \ntonatatne nude information. and is totem:led only for \ntheme of the addressee. S Is the property of \n. .id, \nEllis \nLLP \nes \nKirkland \n& \nEll\nilk..\nis lawniatimal LLP. \ntumhorizet use, disclosure et cop)^ag of tNs \n. mmunication or any pan thacof is strictly whisked \nand may be untamful. If soo have waved this \nBLAKE MARINE GROUP, \nLLC, Plaintiff, \nv. \nFRENKEL & COMPANY, Defendant. \n18-CV-10759 (AT) (CIIP) \nUnited States District Court, \nS.D. New York. \nEFTA00076839\n", "char_count": 1864}]}