{"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_count": 78, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00076383", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00076383.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Pagel of 78 \n20-2413 \nUnited States Court of Appeals for \nthe Second Circuit \n—against—\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nSHARON CHURCHER, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nPlaintiffiAppellee, \nDefendant-Appellant, \nRespondents, \nJULIE BROWN, MIAMI HERALD MEDIA COMPANY, \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, MICHAEL CERNOVICH, DBA CERNOVICH MEDIA \nIntervenors. \nON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nFOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK, 15-CV-7433 (LAP) \nAPPENDIX \nVolume IV of VIII (Pages App.-0777 to App.-0852) \nTy Gee \nAdam Mueller \nHADDON, MORGAN AND FOREMAN, P.C. \nAttorneys or e en ant-Appellant Ghislaine Maxwell \nEFTA00076383\n", "char_count": 650}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Paget of 78 \nDocket Entries \nApp.-0001 \nOrder regarding Ms. Maxwell's Letter Motion to Reconsider July 23, 2020 Ruling, \nDated July 29, 2020 (Dkt. 1079) \nApp.-0777 \nNotice of Appeal, \nDated July 29, 2020 (Dkt. 1081) \nApp.-0781 \nNon-Redacted Declaration of Sigrid S. McCawley In Support of \nPlaintiff's Motion to Exceed Presumptive Ten \nDeposition Limit in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(A)(2)(a)(ii), \nDated July 30, 2020 (Dkt. 1090-10) \nApp.-0783 \nMs. Maxwell's Letter Response to August 3, 2020 Order, \nDated August 10, 2020 (Dkt. 1100) \nApp.-0787 \nExhibit A to Maxwell's Letter Response to August 3, 2020 Order -\nProtective Order, Dated July 30, 2020 \nU.S. v. Maxwell, No. 20 Cr. 330 (AJN) (S.D.N.Y.) \n(Dkt. 1100-1) \nApp.-0791 \nOrder regarding Ms. Maxwell's Letter Response to August 3, 2020 Order, \nDated August 12, 2020 (Dkt. 1103) \nApp.-0803 \nTranscript of' April 21, 2016 Hearing \nApp.-0805 \nTranscript of July 23, 2020 Hearing \nApp.-0835 \nOrder regarding Modification of Protective Order, \nDated August 18, 2020 \nU.S. v. Maxwell, No. 20 Cr. 330 (AN) (S.D.N.Y.) \n(Dkt. 044) \nApp.-0852 \nEFTA00076384\n", "char_count": 1158}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "CaseaskE2&2411432NARnetAltria &PO!, it,\nApp.-0777 \nCEIRRI 85' \nRegEfaage7Sof 4 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nPlaintiff, \n-against-\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \nNo. 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP) \nMEMORANDUM & ORDER \nLORETTA A. PRESKA, Senior United States District Judge: \nThe Court has reviewed Defendant Ghislaine Maxwell's letter \nrequesting reconsideration of the Court's July 23, 2020, decision \nto unseal (1) the transcripts of Ms. Maxwell's and Doe \ndepositions, and (2) court submissions excerpting from, quoting \nfrom, or summarizing the contents of the transcripts. (See dkt. \nno. 1078.) \nMs. Maxwell's eleventh-hour request for reconsideration is \ndenied. As Ms. Maxwell acknowledges in her letter, reconsideration \nis an \"extraordinary remedy.\" In re Beacon Assocs. Litig., 818 F. \nSupp. 2d 697, 701 (S.D.N.Y. 2011) (quoting In re Health Mgmt. Sys. \nInc. Sec. Litig., 113 F. Supp. 2d 613, 614 (S.D.N.Y. 2000)). Such \nmotions \"are properly granted only if there is a showing of: (1) \nan intervening change in controlling law; (2) the availability of \nnew evidence; or (3) a need to correct a clear error or prevent \nmanifest injustice.\" Drapkin v. Mafco Consol. Grp., Inc., 818 F. \nSupp. 2d 678, 696 (S.D.N.Y. 2011). \"A motion for reconsideration \n1 \nEFTA00076385\n", "char_count": 1298}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "CaseastE2&2871481DIARnetotkinfa &IOC it \nApp.-0778 \nca ii 87 \nRegERageThof 4 \nmay not be used to advance new facts, issues or arguments not \npreviously presented to the Court, nor may it be used as a vehicle \nfor relitigating issues already decided by the Court.\" Bennett v. \nWatson Wyatt & Co., 156 F. Supp.2d 270, 271 (S.D.N.Y. 2001). \nHere, Ms. Maxwell's request for reconsideration hinges on her \nassertion that new developments, i.e., her indictment and arrest, \nprovide compelling reasons for keeping the deposition transcripts \nsealed. \n(See dkt. no. 1078 at 5.) \nBut, despite Ms. Maxwell's \ncontention that she could not address the effect of those events \nin her objections because they occurred after the close of \nbriefing, (id.), 1 this is plowed ground. Indeed, in her original \nobjection to unsealing, Ms. Maxwell argued that the specter of \nongoing \ncriminal \ninvestigations \ninto \nunknown \nindividuals \nassociated with Jeffrey Epstein--a group that, of course, includes \nMs. Maxwell--loomed large over the Court-ordered unsealing \n1 The Court notes as a practical matter that Ms. Maxwell was \narrested on July 2, 2020--that is, three weeks prior to the Court's \nJuly 23 decision to unseal the materials at issue. To the extent \nthat they relate to the to the Court's balancing of interests in \nthe unsealing process, the issues that Ms. Maxwell raises in her \nrequest were surely plain the day that Ms. Maxwell was apprehended. \nMs. Maxwell, however, did not seek to supplement her objections to \nunsealing despite ample time to do so. In fact, the Court notified \nthe parties on July 21, 2020, that it would announce the unsealing \ndecision with respect to Ms. Maxwell's deposition, together with \nother documents, on July 23. (See dkt. no. 1076.) Even then, Ms. \nMaxwell made no request for delay or to supplement her papers. \nMs. Maxwell did not raise her \"vastly different position,\" \n(Transcript of July 23 Ruling at 16:2-3), until moments after the \nCourt had made its decision \n... [truncated, 2051 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076383/3 or ?id=EFTA00076383&page=3]", "char_count": 2051}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "CasGastE2812411431DIARnetibtkInfeitt egooe \nApp.-0779 \nCORSI 81 RegEfage733of 4 \nprocess. (See dkt. no. 1057 at 5.) This argument, specifically \nMs. Maxwell's concern that unsealing would \"inappropriately \ninfluence potential witnesses or alleged victims,\" (id.), and her \nreference \nto \"publicly \nreported \nstatements \nby \nPlaintiff, \nPlaintiff's counsel, the United States Attorney for the Southern \nDistrict of New York, and the Attorney General for the U.S. Virgin \nIslands\" about those investigations, (id.), carried with it the \nclear implication that Ms. Maxwell could find herself subject to \ninvestigation and, eventually, indictment. The Court understood \nthat implication as applying to Ms. Maxwell and thus has already \nconsidered any role that criminal charges against Ms. Maxwell might \nplay in rebutting the presumption of public access to the sealed \nmaterials. \nMs. Maxwell's request for reconsideration of the \nCourt's July 23 ruling is accordingly denied. \nGiven the Court's denial of Ms. Maxwell's request for \nreconsideration, the Court will stay the unsealing of Ms. Maxwell's \nand Doe l's deposition transcripts and any sealed or redacted order \nor paper that quotes from or discloses information from those \ndeposition transcripts for two business days, i.e., through \nFriday, July 31, 2020, so that Ms. Maxwell may seek relief from \nthe Court of Appeals. Any sealed materials that do not quote from \nor disclose information from those deposition transcripts shall be \nunsealed on July 30, 2020, in the manner described by the Court's \nOrder dated July 28, 2020. (See dkt. no. 1077.) Ms. Maxwell's and \n3 \nEFTA00076387\n", "char_count": 1643}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Cas6astabat71431MAPnObritInfeitt egiOe \nApp.-0780 \nCENCI 85' \n/20g4facje743of 4 \nDoe l's deposition transcripts and any sealed materials that quote \nor disclose information from them shall be unsealed in the manner \nprescribed by the July 28 Order on Monday, August 3, 2020, subject \nto any further stay ordered by the Court of Appeals. \nSO ORDERED. \nDated: \nNew York, New York \nJuly 29, 2020 \neZdzat.fo? Yadeitig \nLORETTA A. PRESKA \nSenior United States District Judge \n4 \nEFTA00076388\n", "char_count": 487}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "CaseastE2812€171431NARnedxgrai rAil \nApp.-0781 \nCEilikl 87 \nRagEfragt7Bof 2 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nPlaintiff, \nv. \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \nX \nX \n15-cv-07433-LAP \nNOTICE OF APPEAL \nPLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Ghislaine Maxwell, Defendant in the above-captioned \ncase, hereby appeals to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit from the \ndistrict court's Order of July 23, 2020, unsealing the deposition materials and the Order of July \n29, 2020, denying Ms. Maxwell's motion to reconsider. \nDated: July 29, 2020. \nRespectfully submitted, \ns/ Laura A. Menninger \nLaura A. Menninger (LM-1374) \nJeffrey S. Pagliuca (pro hac vice) \nTy Gee (pro hac vice) \nHADDON, MORGAN AND FOREMAN, P.C. \nAttorneys for Ghislaine Maxwell \n1 \nEFTA00076389\n", "char_count": 793}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "CasastrabiAZI71432)IaAinicDbfidtrieitt ethia \nApp.-0782 \nE0191 85' Pie ROgRageThof 2 \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI certify that on July 29, 2020, I filed this Notice of Appeal with the Clerk of Court \nthrough CM/ECF, which will send notice of the filing to all parties of record. \nhi Nicole Simmons \n2 \nEFTA00076390\n", "char_count": 313}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case Gaga4.407741333-IDARn-Offiuhiefle3MOQIXD, Filki5B33fface9:4191;91 of 4 \nApp.-0783 \nUnited States District Court \nSouthern District of New York \nPlaintiff, \nCase No.: 15-cv-07433-RWS \nv. \nGhislaine Maxwell, \nDefendant. \nNON-REDACTED DECLARATION OF SIGRID S. McCAWLEY IN SUPPORT OF \nPLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO EXCEED PRESUMPTIVE TEN DEPOSITION LIMIT IN \nFEDERAL RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 30(A)(2)(a)(ii), FILED UNDER SEAL \nI, Sigrid S. McCawley, declare that the below is true and correct to the best of my \nknowledge as follows: \n1. \nI am a partner with the law firm of Boies, Schiller & Flexner LLP and duly \nlicensed to practice in Florida and before this Court pursuant to this Court's September 29, \n2015 Order granting my Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice. \n2. \nI respectfully submit this Declaration in support of Plaintiff's Motion to Exceed \nPresumptive Ten Deposition Limit In Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(A)(2)(a)(ii), Filed \nUnder Seal. \n3. \nAttached hereto as Composite Exhibit I, is a true and correct copy of the May 17, \n2016 Email Correspondence from Sigrid McCawley. \n4. \nAttached hereto as Exhibit 2, is a true and correct copy of the May 27, 2016 \nEmail Correspondence from Laura Menninger. \n5. \nAttached hereto as Exhibit 3, is a true and correct copy of the Notice of Service \nEFTA00076391\n", "char_count": 1315}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "CaseClat6-Z0-04433UoWirbotdenelft/20M20, arum/Rigel Petge2 of 4 \nApp.-0784 \nand Subpoena to \n6. \nAttached hereto as Exhibit 4, is a true and correct copy of the May 26, 2016 \nCorrespondence from Sigrid McCawley. \n7. \nAttached hereto as Exhibit 5, is a true and correct copy of the \n8. \nAttached hereto as Composite Exhibit 6, is a true and correct copy of the April \n22, 2016 Deposition Transcript of Ghislaine Maxwell. \n9. \nAttached hereto as Exhibit 7, is a true and correct copy of the Palm Beach Police \nReport. \n10. \nAttached hereto as Exhibit 8, is a true and correct copy of the November 21, 2005 \nSworn Statement of \n11. \nAttached hereto as Exhibit 9, is a true and correct copy of the May 4, 2016 Email \nCorrespondence from Laura Menninger. \nI declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. \nIs! Sigrid S. McCawley \nSigrid S. McCawley, Esq. \nEFTA00076392\n", "char_count": 890}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "CaseCial620-04433112210rrbotóriS11/059320 \nItibeibig0tat 1 PaOS of 4 \nApp.-0785 \nDated: May 27, 2016. \nRespectfully Submitted, \nBOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP \nBy: /s/ Sigrid McCawlev \nSigrid McCawley (Pro Hac Vice) \nMeredith Schultz (Pro Hac Vice) \nBoles_ Schiller & Flexner LLP 401 E. \nDavid Boies \nBoles, Schiller & Flexner LLP \nBradley J. Edwards (Pro Hac Vice) \nFARMER, JAFFE, WEISSING, \nEDWARDS, FISTOS & LEHRMAN, P.L. \nPaul G. Cassell (Pro Hac Vice) \nS.J. Quinney College of Law \nUniversity of Utah \n' This daytime business address is provided for identification and correspondence purposes only and is \nnot intended to imply institutional endorsement by the University of Utah for this private representation. \nEFTA00076393\n", "char_count": 731}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "CaseCla15-20-0;433{140rrOotdria1059-420. AII3Ifinignet1P4dat of 4 \nApp.-0786 \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that on May 27, 2016,1 electronically filed the foregoing \ndocument with the Clerk of Court by using the CM/ECF system. I also certify that the foregoing \ndocument is being served this day on the individuals identified below via transmission of \nNotices of Electronic Filing generated by CMIECF. \nLaura A. Menninger, Esq. \nJeffrey Paliuca, Esq. \nAN, P.C. \n/s/ Sigrid S. McCawley \nSigrid S. McCawley, Esq. \nEFTA00076394\n", "char_count": 538}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Calliatil.S4t-Q-O721313cliAlThelitottmWtallit20 Fatettl3NA3.0PAeFP&ge 1.Ebf 3 \nApp.-0787 \nHADDON \nM ORGAN \nFOREMAN \nAugust 10, 2020 \nHonorable Loretta A. Preska \nUnited States District Court \nSouthern District of New York \n500 Pearl Street \nNew York, NY 10007 \nHaddon. Morgan and Foreman. PC \nLaura A. Menninger \nwww hmacrw tom \n2020 Order (Doc. 1096) \nv. Ghislaine Maxwell, No. 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP) \nDear Judge Preska: \nI write in response to the Court's Order of August 3, 2020 (Doc. 1069), the Order and \nProtocol for Unsealing Decided Motions (Doc. 1044) (\"Protocol\"), and to raise with the Court \nthe legal effect of new information that came to the attention of counsel for Ms. Maxwell on \nFriday, August 7, 2020. \nNew information: On Friday, August 7, 2020, counsel for Ms. Maxwell learned of \ncritical new information that impacts both this action and U.S. v. Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN) \n(the \"Criminal Action\"). The information implicates Ms. Maxwell's right to due process and \nfairness in this civil action and affects the Second Circuit's review of the Court's unsealing \norder of July 23, 2020. Additionally, the information implicates her rights as a criminal \ndefendant guaranteed under the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Amendments. \nCounsel makes the representations about implications of the new information as an \nofficer of this Court. At this time, counsel is not at liberty to disclose the information because \nit is subject to a protective order in the Criminal Action, which forbids its use \"for any civil \nproceeding or any purpose other than the defense\" of the criminal action absent \"further order \nof the Court.\" Protective Order, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN) at ¶¶ 1(a), 18 (Exhibit A). As required by \nthat Protective Order and Judge Nathan's Individual Practices in Criminal Cases, counsel \ninitiated a conferral with the U.S. Attorney's Office over the weekend concerning a \nmodification of the Protective Order to share the information with this Court and the Second \nCircuit. Barring agr\n... [truncated, 2292 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076383/12 or ?id=EFTA00076383&page=12]", "char_count": 2292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Caftetagftg-trrA33€1041TheEtottirff4V1/12O20 radailSAI0PAeFP4kge 2Etg 3 \nHonorable Loretta A. Preska \nAugust 10, 2020 \nPage 2 \nApp.-0788 \nMs. Maxwell requests a temporary stay of the unsealing process for approximately \nthree weeks until the conclusion of (a) the conferral with the U.S. Attorney's Office to a \nmodification of the Protective Order in the Criminal Action and, if necessary, an application \nand ruling by Judge Nathan on the issue, to permit the use of the information in this Court and \nbefore the Second Circuit (under seal in both courts, if necessary), (b) an application to this \nCourt containing the new information in support of a request to stay the unsealing process \nuntil the conclusion of the Criminal Action, and (c) a ruling by this Court on the motion for \nstay. \nStreamlining of Unsealing Process: As directed by the Court, counsel for Ms. Maxwell \nconferred with plaintiff's counsel concerning various proposals to streamline the unsealing \nprocess. Subject to Ms. Maxwell's request to temporarily pause the process as described \nabove, defense counsel has agreed to several potential modifications of the Protocol which we \nhope will ease the burden on the parties and the Court going forward, should the unsealing \nmove ahead. Of note, and as Plaintiff will explain to the Court, the parties have agreed to \nnotify all of the Non-Parties at once so that we can understand which Non-Parties object to the \nunsealing before deciding how to proceed with future redactions. Although this will give the \nCourt and the Original Parties more information about the scope of objectors, there are \nlimitations to the extent to which it will expedite the process. As counsel has made clear in \nthe past, it will take significant effort by the Original Parties and their staff to put together the \nexcerpts for any Non-Party who requests them because each Non-Party will be entitled to see \nhis or her own information (but not that of other Non-Parties). After receiving a requ\n... [truncated, 3771 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076383/13 or ?id=EFTA00076383&page=13]", "char_count": 3771}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Cafilail24144M33flokit elitoththAlal2O20.FailfilaffidEWPAeFPag4 SEbf 3 \nHonorable Loretta A. Preska \nAugust 10, 2020 \nPage 3 \nApp.-0789 \nproviding the Notice to Doe 1 at the new address for any future pleadings that implicate his or \nher deposition, which is currently Subject to the Second Circuit's stay. \nThird, to prevent against some of the errors that occurred during the last round of \nunsealings, we request that the Protocol be amended to require the Responding Original Party \nwho proposes unsealing to supply with their Response a proposed unredacted set of the \npleadings at issue, for the Court's consideration and for the Objecting Original Party or Non-\nParty to have the right of reply. Preparing those redactions after the fact allows much \nambiguity into the Court's ruling and we believe the Court's ruling should specify which \nredactions it is accepting or rejecting at the time of ruling. \nFinally, we request that the Court allow for the any objecting Non-Party or Original \nParty be given 7 days following any unseal order to apply for relief in the Second Circuit from \nthe order prior to the documents being released. \nProposed Next Set of Docket Entries for Review: \nGiven the Second Circuit's stay concerning Ms. Maxwell and Doe l's deposition \ntranscripts and materials that quote from them, we propose that the Court deviate from the \nDoe 1 and 2 chronology (given that Doe 1's deposition is sprinkled throughout those motions) \nand instead take the following five decided motions and their related pleadings. This list \nrepresents the first five chronological decided motions that (a) have sealed or redacted \nmaterials and (b) do not have attached or quote from documents subject to the stay. They are: \n• \n75 — Defendant's Motion to Compel Responses to Defendant's First Set of \nDiscovery Responses to Plaintiff \n• \n139 — Plaintiff's Brief in Support of the Privilege Claimed for In Camera \nSubmission \n• \n155 — Defendant's Motion to Compel Non-Privileged Documents \n\n... [truncated, 2342 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00076383/14 or ?id=EFTA00076383&page=14]", "char_count": 2342}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "C \naseal 15-Z0-0; 433alai rrOot \nEfiftl M20. \nF2Its11308a. \ne feage718of 13 \nApp.-0790 \nEXHIBIT A \nEFTA00076398\n", "char_count": 112}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "CaSeZ113115aDanlaillaIBIADditelitsithittlalrYa 'title:03 \nApp.-0791 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \nx \nUSDC SDNY \nDOCUMENT \nELECTRONICALLY FILED \nDOCS: \nDATE FILED:7/30/2020 \nPROTECTIVE ORDER \n20 Cr. 330 (AJN) \n \n x \nALISON J. NATHAN, United States District Judge: \nWHEREAS the Government intends to produce to GHISLAINE \nMAXWELL, the defendant, certain documents and materials that \n(i) affect the privacy and confidentiality of individuals, \n(ii) would impede, if prematurely disclosed, the Government's \nongoing investigation; (iii) would risk prejudicial pretrial \npublicity if publicly disseminated, and (iv) is not authorized \nto be disclosed to the public or disclosed beyond that which is \nnecessary for the defense of this action, and other materials \npursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 16 (\"Rule 16\") \nand pursuant to any other disclosure obligations (collectively, \nthe \"Discovery\"), which contain sensitive, confidential, or \npersonal identifying information; \nWHEREAS, the Government seeks to protect sensitive, \nconfidential, or personal identifying information contained in \nthe materials it produces consistent with Rule 16 or other \ndisclosure obligations; \n1 \nEFTA00076399\n", "char_count": 1291}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "CaSefill333520}a41213331DIMNDEEttageoSittrEEDN lattat6M2372@ftecie \nApp.-0792 \n&213 \nWHEREAS the Government has applied for the entry of \nthis Order; \nIT HEREBY IS ORDERED: \n1. \nThe Discovery disclosed to the defendant \n(\"Defendant\") and/or to the defendant's criminal defense \nattorneys (\"Defense Counsel\") during the course of proceedings \nin this action: \na) \nShall be used by the Defendant or her \nDefense Counsel solely for purposes of the defense of this \ncriminal action, and not for any civil proceeding or any purpose \nother than the defense of this action; \nb) \nShall not be copied or otherwise recorded or \ntransmitted by the Defendant, except to Defense Counsel, or \nexcept as necessary for the Defendant to take notes, which are \nnot to be further transmitted to anyone other than Defense \nCounsel; \nc) \nShall not be disclosed or distributed in any \nform by the Defendant or her counsel except as set forth in \nparagraph 1(d) below; \nd) \nMay be disclosed only by Defense Counsel and \nonly to the following persons (\"Designated Persons\"): \ni. \ninvestigative, secretarial, clerical, \nor paralegal personnel employed full-time, part-time, or as \n2 \nEFTA00076400\n", "char_count": 1172}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "CaSe&W1520}494-AKERWATWORIMAOMIEDNIEMNIIIMUrApAghgbdiV0213 \nApp.-0793 \nindependent contractors by the defendant's counsel (\"Defense \nStaff\"); \nii. any expert or potential expert, legal \nadvisor, consultant, or any other individual retained or \nemployed by the Defendant and Defense Counsel for the purpose of \nassisting in the defense of this case (\"Defense \nExperts/Advisors\"); \niii. \nsuch other persons as hereafter may be \nauthorized by Order of the Court (\"Other Authorized Persons\"); \ne) \nMay be provided to prospective witnesses and \ntheir counsel (collectively, \"Potential Defense Witnesses\"), to \nthe extent deemed necessary by defense counsel, for trial \npreparation. To the extent Discovery materials are disclosed to \nPotential Defense Witnesses, they agree that any such materials \nwill not be further copied, distributed, or otherwise \ntransmitted to individuals other than the recipient Potential \nDefense Witnesses. \n2. \nThe Defendant and Defense Counsel shall provide a \ncopy of this Order to any Designated Persons to whom they \ndisclose Discovery materials. Prior to disclosure of Discovery \nmaterials to Designated Persons, any such Designated Person \nshall agree to be subject to the terms of this Order by signing \na copy hereof and stating that they \"Agree to be bound by the \nterms herein,\" and providing such copy to Defense Counsel. All \n3 \nEFTA00076401\n", "char_count": 1379}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Cael331S23kIMENERDARINDIttothedutELECTEIIIRMESge \nApp.-0794 \n'F;; 0213 \nsuch acknowledgments shall be retained by Defense Counsel and \nshall be subject to in camera review by the Court if good cause \nfor review is demonstrated. The Defendant and her counsel need \nnot obtain signatures from any member of the defense team (i.e., \nattorneys, experts, consultants, paralegals, investigators, \nsupport personnel, and secretarial staff involved in the \nrepresentation of the defendants in this case), all of whom are \nnonetheless bound by this Protective Order. \n3. \nTo the extent that Discovery is disseminated to \nDefense Experts/Advisors, Other Authorized Persons, or Potential \nDefense Witnesses, via means other than electronic mail, Defense \nCounsel shall encrypt and/or password protect the Discovery. \n4. \nThe Government, the Defendant, Defense Counsel, \nDefense Staff, Defense Experts/Advisors, Potential Defense \nWitnesses and their counsel, and Other Authorized Persons are \nprohibited from posting or causing to be posted any of the \nDiscovery or information contained in the Discovery on the \nInternet, including any social media website or other publicly \navailable medium. \n5. \nThe Government (other than in the discharge of \ntheir professional obligations in this matter), the Defendant, \nDefense Counsel, Defense Staff, Defense Experts/Advisors, \nPotential Defense Witnesses and their counsel, and Other \nAuthorized Persons are strictly prohibited from publicly \n4 \nEFTA00076402\n", "char_count": 1492}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "CaSdia5M)494213M4MNDlittaitioSitaffiEEDICIIMMIE0E6213 \nApp.-0795 \ndisclosing or disseminating the identity of any victims or \nwitnesses referenced in the Discovery. This Order does not \nprohibit Defense Counsel or Defense Staff from referencing the \nidentities of individuals they believe may be relevant to the \ndefense to Potential Defense Witnesses and their counsel during \nthe course of the investigation and preparation of the defense \ncase at trial. Any Potential Defense Witnesses and their \ncounsel who are provided identifying information by Defense \nCounsel or Defense Staff are prohibited from further disclosing \nor disseminating such identifying information. This Order does \nnot prohibit Defense Counsel from publicly referencing \nindividuals who have spoken by name on the public record in this \ncase. \n6. \nThe Defendant, Defense Counsel, Defense Staff, \nDefense Experts/Advisors, Potential Defense Witnesses, and Other \nAuthorized Persons are prohibited from filing publicly as an \nattachment to a filing or excerpted within a filing the identity \nof any victims or witnesses referenced in the Discovery, who \nhave not spoken by name on the public record in this case, \nunless authorized by the Government in writing or by Order of \nthe Court. Any such filings must be filed under seal, unless \nauthorized by the Government in writing or by Order of the \nCourt. \n5 \nEFTA00076403\n", "char_count": 1396}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "CaSed3M5219)(04213MW3NDEBtazitheitilt8REglia IRMEMMIpageSetb213 \nApp.-0796 \n7. \nCopies of Discovery or other materials produced \nby the Government in this action bearing \"confidential\" stamps, \nor designated as \"confidential\" as described below, and/or \nelectronic Discovery materials designated as \"confidential\" by \nthe Government, including such materials marked as \n\"confidential\" either on the documents or materials themselves, \nor designated as \"confidential\" in a folder or document title, \nare deemed \"Confidential Information.\" The Government shall \nclearly mark all pages or electronic materials containing \nConfidential Information, or folder or document titles as \nnecessary, with \"confidential\" designations. \n8. \nConfidential Information may contain personal \nidentification information of victims, witnesses, or other \nspecific individuals who are not parties to this action, and \nother confidential information; as well as information that \nidentifies, or could lead to the identification of, witnesses in \nthis matter. The identity of an alleged victim or witness who \nhas identified herself or himself publicly as such on the record \nin this case shall not be treated as Confidential Information. \n9. \nDefense Counsel may, at any time, notify the \nGovernment that Defense Counsel does not concur in the \ndesignation of documents or other materials as Confidential \nInformation. If the Government does not agree to de-designate \nsuch documents or materials, Defense Counsel may thereafter move \n6 \nEFTA00076404\n", "char_count": 1529}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "CaSde9a5a0439M3MPIONDrEttothtfORSHRMIllelitillE0dif36213 \nApp.-0797 \nthe Court for an Order de-designating such documents or \nmaterials. The Government's designation of such documents and \nmaterials as Confidential Information will be controlling absent \ncontrary order of the Court. \n10. Confidential Information disclosed to the \ndefendant, or Defense Counsel, respectively, during the course \nof proceedings in this action: \na) \nShall be used by the Defendant or her \nDefense Counsel solely for purposes of the defense of this \ncriminal action, and not for any civil proceeding or any purpose \nother than the defense of this action; \nb) \nShall be maintained in a safe and secure \nmanner; \nc) \nShall be reviewed and possessed by the \nDefendant in hard copy solely in the presence of Defense \nCounsel; \nd) \nShall be possessed in electronic format only \nby Defense Counsel and by appropriate officials of the Bureau of \nPrisons (\"BOP\"), who shall provide the defendant with electronic \naccess to the Discovery, including Confidential Information, \nconsistent with the rules and regulations of the BOP, for the \nDefendant's review; \n7 \nEFTA00076405\n", "char_count": 1148}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "CaSeAblEagkOMBRAIONDIbitxftWEDISPIedaIDATTapetagb \nApp.-0798 \n(11213 \ne) \nShall be reviewed by the Defendant solely in \nthe presence of Defense Counsel or when provided access to \nDiscovery materials in electronic format by BOP officials; \nf) \nMay be disclosed only by Defense Counsel and \nonly to Designated Persons; \ng) \nmay be shown to, either in person, by \nvideoconference, or via a read-only document review platform, \nbut not disseminated to or provided copies of to, Potential \nDefense Witnesses, to the extent deemed necessary by Defense \nCounsel, for trial preparation, and after such individual(s) \nhave read and signed this Order acknowledging that such \nindividual(s) are bound by this Order. \n11. Copies of Discovery or other materials produced \nby the Government in this action bearing \"highly confidential\" \nstamps or otherwise specifically designated as \"highly \nconfidential,\" and/or electronic Discovery materials designated \nas \"highly confidential\" by the Government, including such \nmaterials marked as \"highly confidential\" either on the \ndocuments or materials themselves, or designated as \"highly \nconfidential\" in an index, folder title, or document title, are \ndeemed \"Highly Confidential Information.\" To the extent any \nHighly Confidential Information is physically produced to the \nDefendant and Defense Counsel, rather than being made available \nto the Defendant and Defense Counsel for on-site review, the \n8 \nEFTA00076406\n", "char_count": 1455}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "CaGedaliiMM=QMJIttottiaiecisfift1ittl6QCIQMOMMO~MI13 \nApp.-0799 \nGovernment shall clearly mark all such pages or electronic \nmaterials containing Highly Confidential Information with \n\"highly confidential\" stamps on the documents or materials \nthemselves. \n12. Highly Confidential Information contains nude, \npartially-nude, or otherwise sexualized images, videos, or other \ndepictions of individuals. \n13. Defense Counsel may, at any time, notify the \nGovernment that Defense Counsel does not concur in the \ndesignation of documents or other materials as Highly \nConfidential Information. If the Government does not agree to \nde-designate such documents or materials, Defense Counsel may \nthereafter move the Court for an Order de-designating such \ndocuments or materials. The Government's designation of such \ndocuments and materials as Highly Confidential Information will \nbe controlling absent contrary order of the Court. \n14. Highly Confidential Information disclosed to \nDefense Counsel during the course of proceedings in this action: \na) \nShall be used by the Defendant or her \nDefense Counsel solely for purposes of the defense of this \ncriminal action, and not for any civil proceeding or any purpose \nother than the defense of this action; \n9 \nEFTA00076407\n", "char_count": 1270}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "CaSe2gMeileallICB3110(P1NOMmOeftelM0PBREMIOM2Me3OW1116213 \nApp.-0800 \nb) \nShall not be disseminated, transmitted, or \notherwise copied and provided to Defense Counsel or the \nDefendant; \nc) \nShall be reviewed by the Defendant solely in \nthe presence of Defense Counsel; \nd) \nShall not be possessed outside the presence \nof Defense Counsel, or maintained, by the Defendant; \ne) \nShall be made available for inspection by \nDefense Counsel and the Defendant, under the protection of law \nenforcement officers or employees; and \nf) \nShall not be copied or otherwise duplicated \nby Defense Counsel or the Defendant during such inspections. \n15. The Defendant, Defense Counsel, Defense Staff, \nDefense Experts/Advisors, Potential Defense Witnesses, and Other \nAuthorized Persons are prohibited from filing publicly as an \nattachment to a filing or excerpted within a filing any \nConfidential Information or Highly Confidential Information \nreferenced in the Discovery, unless authorized by the Government \nin writing or by Order of the Court. Any such filings must be \nfiled under seal, unless authorized by the Government in writing \nor by Order of the Court. \n16. The provisions of this Order shall not be \nconstrued as preventing disclosure of any information, with the \nexception of victim or witness identifying information, that is \n10 \nEFTA00076408\n", "char_count": 1350}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "CaSatitioa01419611BBDAVINDatittefitillite \nIN€601133110WieeiNg11112 6213 \nApp.-0801 \npublicly available or obtained by the Defendant or her Defense \nCounsel from a source other than the Government. \n17. Except for Discovery that has been made part of \nthe record of this case, Defense Counsel shall return to the \nGovernment or securely destroy or delete all Discovery, \nincluding but not limited to Confidential Information, within 30 \ndays of the expiration of the period for direct appeal from any \nverdict in the above-captioned case; the period of direct appeal \nfrom any order dismissing any of the charges in the above-\ncaptioned case; the expiration of the period for a petition \npursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2255; any period of time required by the \nfederal or state ethics rules applicable to any attorney of \nrecord in this case; or the granting of any motion made on \nbehalf of the Government dismissing any charges in the above-\ncaptioned case, whichever date is later. \n18. The foregoing provisions shall remain in effect \nunless and until either (a) the Government and Defense Counsel \nmutually agree in writing otherwise, or (b) this Order is \nmodified by further order of the Court. \n19. The Government and Defense Counsel agree to meet \nand confer in advance of any hearings or trial to discuss and \nagree to any modifications necessary for the presentation of \nevidence at those proceedings. In the absence of agreement, \n11 \nEFTA00076409\n", "char_count": 1453}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "CarAtEISAWIGGISTMOONMstOefttilliteKE1114101S1110MONedgr212 A213 \nApp.-0802 \nDefense Counsel may make an appropriate application to the Court \nfor any such modifications. \nSO ORDERED: \nDated: \nNew York, New York \nJuly \n 30 , 2020 \nHONORABLE ALISON J. NATHAN \nUnited States District Judge \n12 \nEFTA00076410\n", "char_count": 305}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "CaSeatilSth-Q-092I313€1AFtielitotuniftial030,F21183161032CgeNtgelEbf2 \nApp.-0803 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nPlaintiff, \n-against-\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \nNo. 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP) \nORDER \nLORETTA A. PRESKA, Senior United States District Judge: \nThe Court has reviewed the parties' letters dated August 10 \nand August 11, 2020. (See dkt. nos. 1099-1101.) The Court writes \nspecifically to address Defendant Ghislaine Maxwell's request for \na three-week stay of the unsealing process due to the availability \nof \"critical new information\" related both to this action and to \nthe pending criminal case against her, U.S. v. Maxwell, No. 20 Cr. \n330 (AJN). (See dkt. no. 1100 at 1-2.)I \nMs. Maxwell's request is denied. Given that Ms. Maxwell is \nnot at liberty to disclose this new information because it is \nsubject to the protective order in the criminal action, (id. at \n1), the Court has no reasonable basis to impose a stay. And, as \nMs. Maxwell knows, her ipse dixit does not provide compelling \nI Pursuant to the Court's Order dated August 3, 2020 [dkt. no. \n1094], the parties have also submitted to the Court for resolution \nvarious disputes related to (1) methods for streamlining the \nunsealing process, and (2) the next set of docket entries to be \nreviewed for potential unsealing. \nThe Court will address those \ndisputes at a later date. \n1 \nEFTA00076411\n", "char_count": 1405}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "CaSeetagth-Q-0721313doWhelltottinW/0/2030,M013?iff/I2P2Qjentptaf2 \nApp.-0804 \ngrounds for relief. Should the protective order in the criminal \naction be modified to permit disclosure of the relevant information \nto the Court, Ms. Maxwell may renew her request for a stay of the \nunsealing process. \nSO ORDERED. \nDated: \nNew York, New York \nAugust 12, 2020 \n04-eti‘f a? ›adat4 \nLORETTA A. PRESKA \nSenior United States District Judge \n2 \nEFTA00076412\n", "char_count": 449}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08'20/2020, 2913556, Page31 of 78 \nApp.-0805 \n1 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \n2 \n \n3 \n4 \n5 \nv. \n6 \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \n7 \nDefendant. \n8 \nPlaintiff, \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \nBefore: \nX \n15 Civ. 7433 (RWS) \nNew York, N.Y. \nApril 21, 2016 \n11:05 a.m. \nHON. ROBERT W. SWEET, \nAPPEARANCES \nDistrict Judge \n14 \nBOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP \n15 \nAttorneys for Plaintiff \nBY: SIGRID STONE McCAWLEY \n16 \n-and-\nFARMER, JAFFE, WEISSING, EDWARDS, FISTOS & LEHRMAN, P.L. \n17 \nBY: BRAD EDWARDS \n-and-\n18 \nPAUL G. CASSELL \n19 \nHADDON, MORGAN & FOREMAN \nAttorneys for Defendant \n20 \nBY: LAURA A. MENNINGER \nJEFF PAGLUICA \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076413\n", "char_count": 758}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page32 of 78 \nApp.-0806 \n2 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \n(Case called) \n2 \n3 \nWho knows. \n4 \nit fairly well under control. \n5 \n6 \nalready given me. \n7 \n8 \nwould like to start, if it's \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \nyou two pro hac vice motions. My client, \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nthroughout the \nTHE COURT: Welcome back. I have read the papers. \nI might have missed something, but I think I've got \nI would be pleased to hear \nanything anybody wants to tell me in addition to what you've \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your Honor, this is Sigrid McCawley. I \nconvenient with the Court, with \nthe pro hac vice motions that are pending because we would like \ncounsel to be able to anticipate in these proceedings. Would \nthat be all right if I started with that? \nTHE COURT: I don't care. \nMS. McCAWLEY: Thank you. Your Honor, you have before \nwould like to have counsel of record in the case be added as \nProfessor Paul Cassell and Brad Edwards. We have presented \nthose pro hacs to your Honor. This is the first time in my \nyears of practice that I've had a contested one, so I've looked \nat the case law surrounding that and I think it is very clear \nthat a client is entitled to counsel of choice in a case. \nIn this matter she has selected these lawyers. They \nhave been working with her. They had been working on this \nmatter for many months now. We need them as counsel of record \nin the case now because we are going to have depositions \ncountry where, for example, Professor Cassell is \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076414\n", "char_count": 1588}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page33 of 78 \nApp.-0807 \n3 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \nclient, \n25 \nin Utah. He will be able to handle the Colorado depositions \nand things of that nature. We are here because those pro hac \nvice motions are being contested. The core piece of that is \nthe argument that they should not be allowed to seek \nconfidential information in this case. \nYour Honor will remember that I was before you a \ncouple of weeks ago again trying to get the deposition of the \ndefendant, which is set for tomorrow, but still hasn't occurred \nyet. And in order to expedite that process I agreed to the \nprotective order that was put in front of the Court and I \nwaived all of my objections to that in order to be able to \nfacilitate and move that deposition forward. That protective \norder provides that attorneys who are actively working on the \ncase can receive confidential material. \nMy opposing counsel has interpreted that to mean that \nthat must be a counsel of record in the case. We disagree with \nthat interpretation. I wouldn't have agreed to a protective \norder knowing that they were already working on the case. If \nthat were the situation, as your Honor can understand in this \ncase, the majority of the material has been marked \nconfidential, so it would prohibit my cocounsel from working on \nbehalf of their client. \nYour Honor, I'm here to request on behalf of my \nthat she be entitled to have her \ncounsel of record of choice in this matter. If your Honor will \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076415\n", "char_count": 1645}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page34 of 78 \nApp.-0808 \n4 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nindulge me, I would like Mr. Cassell to address his pro hac \n2 \nmotion, please. \n3 \nMR. CASSELL: Good morning, your Honor, Paul Cassell. \n4 \nI'm a law professor. \n5 \nTHE COURT: I don't want to hear it. Sorry. No. \n6 \nThanks very much. \n7 \nMR. CASSELL: Thank you, your Honor. \n8 \nTHE COURT: Anything from the defense. \n9 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: Yes, your Honor. Jeff Pagliuca on \n10 \nbehalf of Ms. Maxwell. \n11 \nYour Honor, I have never opposed a pro hac motion in \n12 \nmy 34 years of practice, so this is a first for me. But it is \n13 \nclear, your Honor, that these lawyers will be witnesses in this \n14 \ncase. \n15 \nTHE COURT: This we don't know. I can't make that \n16 \ndetermination now. Anything else? \n17 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: Yes. \n18 \nTHE COURT: You may be totally right, but I don't \n19 \nknow. \n20 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: Your Honor, here is the problem. This \n21 \ncase is about the plaintiff's false allegations. \n22 \nTHE COURT: Yes. I think I picked up on that. \n23 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: These are the lawyers that wrote the \n24 \nfalse allegations. \n25 \nTHE COURT: I think I picked up on that, too. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076416\n", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page35 of 78 \nApp.-0809 \n5 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: These are the lawyers that admitted \n2 \nthat these were false allegations. \n3 \nTHE COURT: I know. I don't have to tell you, you \n4 \nknow, there is going to be all kinds of privilege issues, all \n5 \nkinds of issues about whether or not they have to testify. We \n6 \nare not at that stage. I cannot and I will not decide that \n7 \nnow. \n8 \nwhat else? \n9 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: There is a problem with the sharing of \n10 \nconfidential information with these lawyers. These lawyers \n11 \nhave both personal and professional interests. \n12 \nTHE COURT: I understand that. I get that point. \n13 \nAnything else? \n14 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: No, your Honor. \n15 \nTHE COURT: This is what we will do on the pro hac. \n16 \nEverybody agrees, nobody, maybe in the world, but nobody in \n17 \nthis courtroom, including me, has dealt with this kind of \n18 \nproblem before. That's perhaps only one of a number of issues \n19 \nthat are unique about this case. That's neither here nor \n20 \nthere. Clearly, the plaintiff has the right to consult with \n21 \nany lawyer she chooses. However, the materials here are \n22 \nsensitive. I don't know the extent to which they have been \n23 \ndesignated confidential, but I'm quite sure that a substantial \n24 \nnumber of them have been, by the very nature of the case, I \n25 \nguess. Let me put it this way. I want to be sure that we \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076417\n", "char_count": 1494}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page36 of 78 \nApp.-0810 \n6 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nenforce the confidentiality appropriately. \n2 \nNow, with those preliminary thoughts in mind I am \n3 \ngoing to deny the motion at this time because I know that there \n4 \nis a statement, some kind of a statement from the mediator in \n5 \nthe Florida action. When I get a piece of paper that says the \n6 \nFlorida action is dismissed, a court order or whatever, then \n7 \nthis motion can be renewed. \n8 \nAlso, I want an affidavit from the two lawyers that \n9 \nthere is no matter in which they are personally involved, that \n10 \nthey are making no claim, there is no claims, there is no \n11 \nlitigation in which they are involved. The reason I say that \n12 \nis that I would not grant the application for a pro hac status \n13 \nto a party in this or a related litigation. If I get those \n14 \naffidavits and the statement about the closure of the Florida \n15 \ncase in which they are a party, then the application can be \n16 \nrenewed and at that point I would be probably inclined, unless \n17 \nsomething else comes up or unless the defense tells me \n18 \nsomething that I don't now know, I would grant the application \n19 \nthat brings us to the order itself and the meaning of the \n20 \norder. I think active in the litigation is the key phrase. \n21 \nThe plaintiff has listed the people that she considers would be \n22 \nappropriate and it's these two gentleman and I think one other \n23 \nperson, and that's fine. That is the definition. \n24 \nHowever, I'm also going to ask the parties to agree \n25 \nupon an order that would expand the confidentiality agreement \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076418\n", "char_count": 1702}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page37 of 78 \nApp.-0811 \n7 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nto this extent, to require the plaintiff to indicate to me and \n2 \nto the defense if there is anyone else who is going to be \n3 \nactive in the litigation. I'll tell you why I feel this way. \n4 \nI want to be sure that we can enforce the confidential aspect \n5 \nof that agreement, and I think that could be critical down the \n6 \nline. That's the reason for those requests. \n7 \nNow, we also have a motion to compel. \n8 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your Honor, can I just get \n9 \nclarification very quickly because I don't want to have to come \n10 \nback to the court so I want to make sure I'm following \n11 \ncorrectly. Your ruling, because we have a deposition tomorrow \n12 \nthat counsel was going to be assisting me with, particularly on \n13 \nthe Fifth Amendment --\n14 \nTHE COURT: Can't have access unless I get these \n15 \nmaterials by then. If I do, that's something else. If I do, \n16 \nfine. Otherwise, they can't have access to the confidential \n17 \ndata. They can assist. \n18 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Can I just point something out to the \n19 \nCourt as well. \n20 \nTHE COURT: The plaintiff can have any lawyer she \n21 \nwants. The question is the confidential materials. \n22 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Can I just point the Court to one more \n23 \nissue, because this is their protective order. They now said \n24 \nto the Court that these two individuals are witnesses or \n25 \npotential witnesses. The protective order allows in Section G \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076419\n", "char_count": 1554}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page38 of 78 \nApp.-0812 \n8 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nconfidential material to go to deponents, witnesses or \n2 \npotential witnesses. \n3 \nTHE COURT: That's a different issue. I have not \n4 \ndealt with that. Obviously anybody who is a witness may have \n5 \naccess to the confidential material, because they have to buy \n6 \ninto the confidentiality order in order to do that. But they \n7 \nare outside of it at the moment. \n8 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your ruling is, they cannot attend the \n9 \ndeposition tomorrow? \n10 \nTHE COURT: They can. Anybody can attend the \n11 \ndeposition that anybody wants to have, but they can't \n12 \nparticipate in it. They can't have access to the confidential \n13 \nmaterial until we get this matter straightened out. Ok. \n14 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I understand, your Honor. \n15 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: Your Honor, we will be designating the \n16 \ntestimony as confidential. \n17 \nTHE COURT: You see. There you go. That's life. I \n18 \ncan't believe that this entire testimony is going to be \n19 \nconfidential. Honestly, you all are too much. Ok. If that's \n20 \nwhat you do, you know that's not going to work because not all \n21 \nof this stuff at issue is going be to confidential. No, no \n22 \nway. What is your name? Ok. We will deal with tomorrow's \n23 \nproblem tomorrow. \n24 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: Ok, your Honor. \n25 \nTHE COURT: The compel. Anybody want to add anything \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076420\n", "char_count": 1461}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page39 of 78 \nApp.-0813 \n9 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \non that? \n2 \nMS. MENNINGER: Yes, your Honor. Laura Henninger on \n3 \nbehalf of Ms. Maxwell. I have taken the liberty, your Honor, \n4 \nof just making a very short little cheat sheet of the \n5 \noutstanding issues, if I may approach. \n6 \nTHE COURT: Yes. It will be interesting to see if \n7 \nyours is the same as the one we have prepared. Yours is much \n8 \nlonger than ours. \n9 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, I'm happy to address all \n10 \nof the ones on mine. I certainly am also happy to take \n11 \ndirection from the Court regarding issues that you believe to \n12 \nstill be of more interest. \n13 \nTHE COURT: As I say, I've read your papers. I would \n14 \nbe pleased to hear anything you want to add that you think is \n15 \nnot covered or you want to respond or anything like that. \n16 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, one of the largest and \n17 \nmost significant pieces to us are the assertions by plaintiff \n18 \nthat her own communications with law enforcement are somehow \n19 \nprotected by --\n20 \nTHE COURT: I'm prepared to deal with that. \n21 \nMS. MENNINGER: The second one, your Honor, and it \n22 \nrelates somewhat to the issues already presented on the pro hac \n23 \nmotions, are our requests for the fee agreements with all of \n24 \nplaintiff's various 15 or so lawyers who purport to be \n25 \nrepresenting her. Your Honor, I can find no case law that \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076421\n", "char_count": 1495}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page40 of 78 \nApp.-0814 \n10 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nsuggests that the agreements are privileged, as plaintiff \n2 \nargues. She has refused to identify when these individuals \n3 \nbegan their representations, the nature of the representations. \n4 \nTHE COURT: There is a little confusion here, at least \n5 \nin my mind, as to what we are talking about. I certainly \n6 \nunderstand the two gentlemen whose applications I have just \n7 \ndealt with and the third person, who I take it is affiliated \n8 \nwith the Boies firm. \n9 \nObviously, over time the plaintiff has probably \n10 \nconferred with other lawyers. But who cares? Let's assume she \n11 \nhas talked to 20 more lawyers. You want all those retainers? \n12 \nThat doesn't make any sense. What is the universe we are \n13 \ntalking about? \n14 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, I certainly understand all \n15 \nof the members of the Boles firm that currently represent her. \n16 \nThe third individual, if I understand correctly, is a gentleman \n17 \nby the name of Stan Pottinger. He is a lawyer of some renown. \n18 \nHe is also an author of best-selling books. He is listed quite \n19 \nfrequently on plaintiff's privilege log as being part and \n20 \nparcel of advice being given to her on, quote/unquote, media \n21 \nissues. \n22 \nTHE COURT: That is one. \n23 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, there are other persons \n24 \nlisted on their privilege log. Many are listed as counsel for \n25 \nplaintiff, but others are listed. Attorney giving advice to \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076422\n", "char_count": 1574}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08,20/2020, 2913556, Page41 of 78 \nApp.-0815 \n11 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nvictim's --\n2 \nTHE COURT: Is what you want the retainer agreements, \n3 \nif there are any, whatever the arrangements are, with anybody \n4 \non the privilege log that is listed as rendering advice? \n5 \nMS. MENNINGER: Yes, your Honor. That, I think, would \n6 \nbe appropriate because some of our biggest issues concern the \n7 \nprivilege log. \n8 \nTHE COURT: I understand. \n9 \nWhat else? \n10 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, we have asked for, but \n11 \nbeen denied by plaintiff, her own deposition testimony in the \n12 \nFlorida action. In that case the Court entered a confidential \n13 \norder --\n14 \nTHE COURT: I'm prepared to deal with it. \n15 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, the next topic are \n16 \nplaintiff's medical records. \n17 \nTHE COURT: I think I understand that. There is one \n18 \nthing, though. Are there any pre-'99 medical records? \n19 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, the case law is quite \n20 \nclear that injuries that were preexisting --\n21 \nTHE COURT: I'm sorry. Excuse me. Go ahead. \n22 \nMS. MENNINGER: Plaintiff has alleged that the \n23 \ndefamation of this action triggered or caused her to reflect \n24 \nback upon her alleged sexual abuse. She has also alleged, for \n25 \nexample, that many, several, three, I think, at last count, or \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076423\n", "char_count": 1387}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page42 of 78 \nApp.-0816 \n12 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nfour individuals had sexually abused her prior to ever meeting \n2 \nMr. Epstein. \n3 \nIf she has evidence that she already was suffering \n4 \nfrom depression or some type of mental health disorder before \n5 \nmeeting our client, Ms. Maxwell, or Mr. Epstein, then her \n6 \nflashbacks, if you will, could be related to other incidents \n7 \nthat she has put out in the press. And she, I believe, has \n8 \nalso told the press that she was in a drug rehabilitation \n9 \nfacility at the time that she met Mr. Epstein. \n10 \nObviously, to the extent she was under the influence \n11 \nof drugs, which is what she has told the press, at the time she \n12 \nmet him, she persisted in being addicted to drugs during the \n13 \ntime that she knew Mr. Epstein, and it certainly relates to all \n14 \nof her requests for, I believe she has requested $30 million in \n15 \ndamages, your Honor, not just from the defamation, but also \n16 \nharkening back to what she claims were her years as a sex abuse \n17 \nvictim. \n18 \nTHE COURT: What's the basis of your statement that we \n19 \nwill call it the flashback? \n20 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, I believe \n21 \nTHE COURT: Because, quite frankly, I was unaware of \n22 \nthat. Is that my error? Are you telling me something that's \n23 \nnot quite right? \n24 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, I believe that is what \n25 \nplaintiff has alleged in her complaint. If you can give me a \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076424\n", "char_count": 1536}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page43 of 78 \nApp.-0817 \n13 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nmoment. To the extent she is now alleging she suffers from \n2 \nemotional distress from any preexisting --\n3 \nTHE COURT: That's from the defamation. \n4 \nMS. MENNINGER: She claims it's from the defamation. \n5 \nHowever, your Honor, if she has preexisting conditions that \n6 \nwere truly the cause of whatever emotional injury she claims \n7 \nthat she now possesses --\n8 \nTHE COURT: Correct me if I'm wrong, and perhaps \n9 \nplaintiff will make it clear, my understanding is that the \n10 \ninjuries alleged result from the claim of the alleged \n11 \ndefamation, period. \n12 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, she has claimed emotional \n13 \ndistress from the defamation, yes. We are requesting evidence \n14 \nthat would show that she has preexisting emotional conditions. \n15 \nTHE COURT: Not from the defamation. \n16 \nMS. MENNINGER: Not from the defamation. From the \n17 \nmany, many other things that have occurred in her life \n18 \npredating even her meeting Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell, as she \n19 \nhas told the press, not because we told the press that. \n20 \nYour Honor, it is difficult, if not impossible, to \n21 \naddress her claimed $30 million emotional distress from a \n22 \ndefamation statement that was a denial of her allegations \n23 \nversus any emotional distress or emotional conditions she \n24 \nalready had before any such statement was made. \n25 \nSimilarly, your Honor, we have asked for discovery of \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076425\n", "char_count": 1550}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page44 of 78 \nApp.-0818 \n14 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nher claimed prior sexual abuse. She has, again, put in the \n2 \npress a number of statements regarding that, and I can't \n3 \nimagine that it is to the extent she claims privacy now, those \n4 \nmight be relevant in our case both on credibility and also \n5 \ndamage issues. \n6 \nYour Honor, we have asked for a lot of other \n7 \ninterrogatories and documents that go to her damage claims, her \n8 \neducation records, her work history. She has refused to answer \n9 \nany questions before where she has worked. She has refused to \n10 \nanswer any questions about where she went to school. All of \n11 \nthese are appropriate under the local rule for interrogatories. \n12 \nFinally, your Honor, we have asked for her contracts \n13 \nwith media. She has refused to disclose those. She has \n14 \nrefused to disclose her tax returns that show all of the \n15 \npayments that she has received from various media sources. \n16 \nTHE COURT: I take it your view of any funds from the \n17 \nmedia would operate to reduce her damages. \n18 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, it also shows her motive \n19 \nand bias in bringing this case. To the extent she has been \n20 \npaid for her stories to the media, which she has, she has \n21 \nadmitted that she has been paid hundreds of thousands of \n22 \ndollars for giving these stories to the media. \n23 \nBut to the extent that she is now bringing this \n24 \ndefamation claim, if she is still either planning to receive \n25 \nmore money from the media, she has a motive and bias to make \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076426\n", "char_count": 1641}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page45 of 78 \nApp.-0819 \n15 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nher story consistent with her previous stories. She has \n2 \nclaimed S5 million in lost wages, your Honor. This is a person \n3 \nwho has worked primarily as a waitress in the last 15 years, \n4 \nuntil her media sensational story was purchased from her by \n5 \nsome British press. \n6 \nTHE COURT: Anything else? \n7 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, the other issues are \n8 \naddressed in our papers. we have highlighted her incomplete \n9 \nproduction on several fronts and her refusal to answer any \n10 \ninterrogatories. So I would rest on my papers with respect to \n11 \nthe other arguments. Thank you. \n12 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Thank you, your Honor. I'd like to be \n13 \nvery clear here, your Honor. Discovery production, I've tried \n14 \nto do that in our papers. But listening to opposing counsel \n15 \nI'm concerned maybe she hasn't reviewed the documents we have \n16 \nproduced. We have clearly produced all of the media \n17 \ncommunications she has, including records --\n18 \nTHE COURT: All the media. \n19 \nMS. McCAWLEY: All of the media communications. She \n20 \nhas issued wildly broad requests in this case which we have \n21 \ncomplied with. we ran over 200 search terms. Her request No. \n22 \n5 alone seeks communications with over 100 individuals. And we \n23 \nhave complied, your Honor. This is coming from the defendant \n24 \nwho until Monday night, when you directed her to produce \n25 \nprivileged information, has only produced two e-mails in this \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076427\n", "char_count": 1587}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08,20/2020, 2913556, Page46 of 78 \nApp.-0820 \n16 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \ncase. \n2 \nYour Honor, we have complied with our production. We \n3 \nhave produced the materials that she is saying we have not \n4 \nproduced. It's incorrect. We have produced her school records \n5 \nthat we have. We have produced her tax records that we have. \n6 \nWe have produced all of those items that we have. \n7 \nWith respect to her medical records I am going to \n8 \ndirect you to the case that is cited in our brief as the Evanko \n9 \ncase and it was a similar circumstance to here. It was a Title \n10 \nVII case where there were emotional distress damages being \n11 \nalleged and the Court found that the other side could not have \n12 \ncarte blanche ruling over all of her medical records from the \n13 \ntime she was born to the present. We met and conferred on two \n14 \nhours on their discovery requests, your Honor. We agreed to \n15 \nproduce all of her medical records that we had from 1999 to \n16 \n2002 and anything else we had that was related to the sexual \n17 \nabuse she endured at the hands of the defendant and \n18 \nMr. Epstein. We have agreed to produce those. \n19 \nWe have already started producing those records from \n20 \nthe various doctors, from the treating physicians. Those are \n21 \nin their production. Should they be entitled to things that \n22 \nhappened prior to that? Absolutely not, your Honor. They are \n23 \nnot entitled to a full-scale production of everything that's \n24 \nhappened in this young lady's life. She was abused by these \n25 \nindividuals. She shouldn't be reabused by having to disclose \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076428\n", "char_count": 1677}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page47 of 78 \nApp.-0821 \n17 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nthings that happened prior to her time with them. Your Honor, \n2 \nwe do object to the production of that material. \n3 \nTHE COURT: The flashback allegation. \n4 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I think what she may be referring to, I \n5 \nhave not heard that term used, I think what she may be \n6 \nreferring to was the fact that this is a defamation claim and \n7 \nthe person who defamed my client was also an abuser, we allege. \n8 \nSo when she is defamed by the person who abused her and that \n9 \nabuser is calling her a liar, that caused her significant \n10 \nemotional distress. It's different than if some other \n11 \nindividual that she had not had contact with called her a liar. \n12 \nwhen she is talking about a flashback, maybe that's what she is \n13 \nreferring to, but we don't have the word flashback anywhere in \n14 \nour complaint. \n15 \nTHE COURT: No. I made that up. \n16 \nThere will be no claim by the plaintiff that the \n17 \ndefamation caused her distress by making her aware or as a \n18 \nresult of the prior sexual abuse. \n19 \nMS. McCAWLEY: The sexual abuse by the defendants? \n20 \nTHE COURT: No. \n21 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Sexual abuse by others. \n22 \nTHE COURT: Yes. \n23 \nMS. McCAWLEY: No. Sexual abuse that relates to the \n24 \nEpstein period, yes. \n25 \nTHE COURT: That I understand. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076429\n", "char_count": 1423}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08,20/2020, 2913556, Page48 of 78 \nApp.-0822 \n18 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I think we are on the same page. \n2 \nTHE COURT: I think talking about the earlier period. \n3 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Prior to Epstein, no, no, she doesn't \n4 \nhave a claim with respect to that. \n5 \nTHE COURT: Anything else? \n6 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your Honor, I just want to point out \n7 \nagain that our production -- you asked us to complete that. We \n8 \nhave gone through and run over 200 search terms. we have \n9 \nproduced all of those communications she has had with all of \n10 \nthose individuals. The things that we have not produced are \n11 \nthe criminal investigation records. I know your Honor is going \n12 \nto address that. I would like to be very clear there. \n13 \nThe point there is that she has said in the motion to \n14 \nstay papers that she filed Tuesday that she needs to have that \n15 \ninformation so she can decide whether she is going to be \n16 \nasserting her Fifth Amendment privilege. Truthful testimony \n17 \nshouldn't have to be crafted, your Honor. She shouldn't need \n18 \nto know what agency is investigating her in order to decide \n19 \nwhether or not she is going to be asserting her Fifth Amendment \n20 \nprivilege. \n21 \nwe do have with us, your Honor, for an in camera \n22 \nsubmission, if you would like it. That is the way that courts \n23 \nhave dealt with this issue in the past. When there is a claim \n24 \nfrom an agency that the disclosure of that investigation could \n25 \nharm the investigation, we can submit that to you for in camera \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076430\n", "char_count": 1619}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page49 of 78 \nApp.-0823 \n19 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nreview so you are aware of the ongoing investigation. But it \n2 \nis my view that that needs to be protected. \n3 \nAs you probably know, the history of these cases with \n4 \nMr. Epstein, there were a variety of things that went on in \n5 \nthat investigation, so there is reason to keep an investigation \n6 \nin this situation protected so that they can properly \n7 \ninvestigate and move forward with that without being inhibited \n8 \nby other individuals. Your Honor, I would ask that that remain \n9 \nprotected. It's covered by her very, very broad requests, \n10 \nwhich is why we had to lodge those objections. I would \n11 \nappreciate your Honor considering our arguments with respect to \n12 \nthat issue. \n13 \nThe other things, your Honor, that she has raised is, \n14 \nfor example, she had asked for the Epstein settlement agreement \n15 \nand that was one of the things that she asked for. We agreed \n16 \nto produce that if we got the waiver from Mr. Epstein because \n17 \nwe can't produce it without that waiver. \n18 \nI believe that covers it, your Honor. If you have any \n19 \nquestions, I would be happy to answer them. \n20 \nTHE COURT: Thanks very much. \n21 \nThank you all for all the clarification that you've \n22 \ngiven me. I much appreciate it. \n23 \nWith respect to the retainers and the dates of \n24 \nrepresentation, that information will be provided for any \n25 \nattorney that's listed on the privilege log. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076431\n", "char_count": 1562}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page50 of 78 \nApp.-0824 \n20 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nThe plaintiff has told me that they have now supplied \n2 \nall the education and employment records that they have. I \n3 \nthink if there is any question about that, if the defense is \n4 \nskeptical, I would ask the counsel for the plaintiffs to make \n5 \nthat statement on the record, not necessarily here, but by way \n6 \nof a statement to the Court and principally to the defendant. \n7 \nOn the question of residences, that's, in my view, not \n8 \na contention interrogatory because of the nature of this case. \n9 \nI think it's more like listing witnesses. So I would say that \n10 \nthe plaintiff should supply all residences. \n11 \nThe Dershowitz deposition will be produced under the \n12 \nconfidentiality provision. As I read what I've been given, \n13 \nit's to be held in confidence and it will remain in confidence, \n14 \nbut it will be produced. \n15 \nYes, the tax returns should be produced. 15 years \n16 \nseems like -- I see. Ok. 15 years. \n17 \nThe medical records of the period '99 to 2002 will be \n18 \nproduced and the plaintiff will indicate whether that \n19 \nproduction is complete or, if it isn't complete, when it will \n20 \nbe complete. \n21 \nAs for the pre-'99 medical records, based on where we \n22 \nare at the moment, I do not believe that those are relevant. \n23 \nBecause the damage issue relates, in my view, solely to the \n24 \ndefamation. If that changes in any way, I will revisit that \n25 \nissue. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076432\n", "char_count": 1563}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08,20/2020, 2913556, Page51 of 78 \nApp.-0825 \n21 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nThe criminal investigation. Any materials that the \n2 \nplaintiff has with respect to any criminal investigations will \n3 \nbe turned over except for any statements made by the plaintiff \n4 \nto law enforcement authority and those statements, if there are \n5 \nsuch, will be submitted in camera, and I will review them. \n6 \nI hope that clears up our problems. Tell me if I have \n7 \nfailed in my effort to do so. Yes, ma'am. \n8 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, two quick things, I think. \n9 \nWith respect to medical records, we also certainly believe that \n10 \nthe period from the time the statement was made in January 2015 \n11 \nuntil the present, because she has claimed emotional distress \n12 \nfrom that defamation --\n13 \nTHE COURT: Sure, yes. \n14 \nMS. MENNINGER: The problem is, we have asked through \n15 \ninterrogatory what were the names of the medical providers \n16 \nbecause they have not disclosed who her medical providers were. \n17 \nSo there is no way for us to tell whether the records in fact \n18 \nhave been sought from and produced with respect to each of \n19 \nthose medical providers. I will say that other records in the \n20 \npossession of plaintiff lists other doctors who they have not \n21 \nasked for records from or releases. \n22 \nTHE COURT: Let's see if we can clear that up. \n23 \nMS. McCAWLEY: We have disclosed the names. She has \n24 \nthose names. We have also disclosed records, the more recent \n25 \nrecords. We have not contested that. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076433\n", "char_count": 1604}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08,20/2020, 2913556, Page52 of 78 \nApp.-0826 \n22 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nWith respect to the interrogatories, your Honor ruled \n2 \non this previously, but there is a local Rule 33.3, which is \n3 \nwhy we didn't serve interrogatories in this case at this point. \n4 \nShe is deposing the plaintiff in two weeks, next week, whenever \n5 \nit is, and can certainly ask those questions as well. But we \n6 \nhave disclosed the names of the providers. \n7 \nMS. MENNINGER: They have not, your Honor. \n8 \nTHE COURT: Look. Wait just a moment. You two are \n9 \nlawyers. Now, that is not an issue about which you should \n10 \ndiffer. Go over in the corner right now, both of you, and \n11 \nlet's make it clear who is telling me the right story. Now. \n12 \nI take it that I misunderstood the colloquy and that \n13 \nthis matter has been resolved. \n14 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your Honor, I think there was a \n15 \nmisunderstanding with respect --\n16 \nTHE COURT: I was sure. \n17 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Dr. Olsen has been noticed for \n18 \ndeposition in Colorado already. In my view, we have disclosed \n19 \nthe doctors. Ms. Menninger says that there is other doctors \n20 \nthat have been disclosed in documents that we have not yet \n21 \nlisted to her. I think in discovery we are finding \n22 \nadditional --\n23 \nTHE COURT: You think you may not have discovered that \n24 \nyour client has had some doctors \n25 \nMS. McCAWLEY: In the past. We are talking about \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076434\n", "char_count": 1491}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page53 of 78 \nApp.-0827 \n23 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nyears and years ago. The recent doctors we have disclosed they \n2 \nhave noticed for deposition. \n3 \nTHE COURT: What else? \n4 \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, with respect to the \n5 \nemployment and education records, as you heard plaintiff say, \n6 \nshe has disclosed, quote/unquote, what she has. Under local \n7 \nrule 33.3, we are allowed to ask for the names of witnesses \n8 \nwith knowledge at the outset of the case, and they might be \n9 \ncustodians of records. We asked her who have been your \n10 \nemployers. She won't tell us who her employers have been. She \n11 \nhas just gone through her computer and say if I have an \n12 \nemployment record I'll give it to you, but I am not going to \n13 \ntell you who her employers were. \n14 \nTHE COURT: She will. \n15 \nMS. MENNINGER: Same thing with the education records. \n16 \nwe asked her to list where she had gone to school and tell us \n17 \nwhere it is. She won't do it. Those are the things where my \n18 \nskepticism arises from. \n19 \nLargely, to the extent your Honor has ordered the \n20 \nproduction of whatever materials, criminal investigation \n21 \nmaterials that were not to be submitted in camera, those were \n22 \nthe ones that involved plaintiff's statements, we would like \n23 \nthe other materials that they have brought with them today to \n24 \ngive to your Honor that do not encompass their client's \n25 \nstatements to law enforcement. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076435\n", "char_count": 1537}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page54 of 78 \nApp.-0828 \n24 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nTHE COURT: I don't know whether there are such. Is \n2 \nit possible that nothing in this lawsuit is clear? Well, I \n3 \ntried to make it clear what should be produced and what \n4 \nshouldn't. Anything that has been submitted to any law \n5 \nenforcement officer by the plaintiff I will take in camera. \n6 \nAnything other than that with respect to any law enforcement \n7 \nshould be produced. \n8 \nMS. MENNINGER: Thank you, your Honor. \n9 \nTHE COURT: Thank you, all. I think we have the \n10 \npleasure of your company -- do we need you next week? We are \n11 \nup to date, aren't we? \n12 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your Honor, we have a motion with \n13 \nrespect to our discovery that's set for next Thursday. \n14 \nTHE COURT: That's fine. \n15 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Just before we adjourn, because \n16 \nMr. Cassell had a question, and I just want to make sure that I \n17 \nunderstand, with respect to tomorrow's deposition, they are \n18 \nentitled to attend but have to leave the room if confidential \n19 \ninformation is disclosed? \n20 \nTHE COURT: That's where we are at the moment, unless \n21 \nit changes. \n22 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: Your Honor, with regard to next \n23 \nThursday, both Ms. Menninger and I have other matters that are \n24 \npreviously scheduled and it would be impossible for us to take \n25 \ncare of those matters and be here at the same time. I'm \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076436\n", "char_count": 1476}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08,20/2020, 2913556, Page55 of 78 \nApp.-0829 \n25 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nwondering what the Court would like to do about that. \n2 \nTHE COURT: First of all, you know how we play this \n3 \ngame. You don't ask me first. You ask your opponent first. \n4 \nHave you done that? \n5 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: I have not, your Honor. \n6 \nTHE COURT: Will you? \n7 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: I certainly will, your Honor. \n8 \nTHE COURT: Now. \n9 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: Absolutely. \n10 \nTHE COURT: You can go over to the corner, too. \n11 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: I think we need a corner bar on this, \n12 \nyour Honor. \n13 \nMs. McCawley, I'm wondering if we can get a mutually \n14 \nconvenient date to hear that matter as opposed to next \n15 \nThursday. \n16 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Of course. \n17 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: That was simple enough, your Honor. \n18 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your Honor, one more thing. I didn't \n19 \nrealize that my counsel can submit that stipulation to you \n20 \nbecause that case has been settled --\n21 \nTHE COURT: If I get something that closes that case \n22 \nand I get the affidavit that there are no other matters in \n23 \nwhich they have any claims or defenses relating to any of these \n24 \nstatements, that will do it. \n25 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your Honor, so I know, if we can submit \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076437\n", "char_count": 1305}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08,20/2020, 2913556, Page56 of 78 \nApp.-0830 \n26 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nthat by fax this afternoon, will they be able to attend the \n2 \ndeposition tomorrow? \n3 \nTHE COURT: I would think so, if I think those are \n4 \nadequate representations and so on. The statement from a \n5 \nmediator doesn't mean anything to me. Something that has a \n6 \ncourt sign to it. That I understand. But the mediator saying \n7 \nthat it's settled doesn't work for me. \n8 \nMR. CASSELL: Your Honor, maybe Mr. Edwards could \n9 \nbriefly explain Florida procedure. The case has been \n10 \ndismissed, but it does not require a Court's signature. \n11 \nMr. Edwards can elaborate more fully on that. \n12 \nMR. EDWARDS: Sure. If I may. There are two ways in \n13 \nwhich a case can be dismissed in Florida. One is by way of a \n14 \ncourt order. The other is by way of a stipulation. That is \n15 \nwhat was done. There was a stipulation of dismissal signed by \n16 \nboth parties, that being the plaintiff and the defendants and \n17 \ncounsel, that has been done and that was dismissed. \n18 \nTHE COURT: That's filed in the case. \n19 \nMR. EDWARDS: That's filed in the case and filed in \n20 \nthe court. \n21 \nTHE COURT: Do you have a copy of that? \n22 \nMR. EDWARDS: I can get a copy of it immediately. \n23 \nTHE COURT: Give it to the defense. If they have any \n24 \nproblems, they will let me know. That sounds all right to me. \n25 \nWhat do I know about Florida except that it's flat and hot. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076438\n", "char_count": 1526}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page57 of 78 \nApp.-0831 \n27 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nYour representation sounds right. \n2 \nMR. EDWARDS: Additionally, just with respect to the \n3 \naffidavit, there needs to be an affirmation that we have no \n4 \nother claims that relate to the statements in this case. Is \n5 \nthat what we are saying? \n6 \nTHE COURT: I think it should be broader than that. I \n7 \nthink it should be -- look. I don't think it would be \n8 \nappropriate if there is any possibility for either of you to \n9 \nbeing a party. That's what I'm after. And having any \n10 \nproceedings against you arising out of the situation with the \n11 \nplaintiff. I think it would be inappropriate for you to be \n12 \ncounsel if you have the potentiality of being a party, either \n13 \nplaintiff or defendant, in any proceedings. If I get an \n14 \naffidavit saying that you're unaware of any claims against you \n15 \nor any intention to make a claim arising out of the \n16 \ncircumstances surrounding this lawsuit, that should be broad. \n17 \nI think that would satisfy me. \n18 \nMR. EDWARDS: Ok. \n19 \nMR. CASSELL: I'll be filing those materials this \n20 \nafternoon, your Honor. My plan is to attend --\n21 \nTHE COURT: The defense has a thought on this. \n22 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: Your Honor, I am looking at documents \n23 \nfrom Florida. One is a docket sheet captioned: Epstein v. \n24 \nBrad Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, Lower Tribune Cases 15 000072 \n25 \nwhich shows that that matter is still pending. There is \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076439\n", "char_count": 1554}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page58 of 78 \nApp.-0832 \n28 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \nanother case, as I understand it, Edwards v. Epstein and \n2 \nRothstein, which is also pending. I can confer about this, \n3 \nyour Honor. \n4 \nTHE COURT: Let's do this. When do you plan to return \n5 \nto the snow fields? \n6 \nMR. PAGLIUCA: There is still snow on the ground, your \n7 \nHonor. Well, Friday night or Saturday morning is my current \n8 \nplan. \n9 \nTHE COURT: That's great. Whatever the applicants \n10 \nhave on this subject, please turn it over. You all can work \n11 \nout how you are going to do that. Turn it over to the defense. \n12 \nAnd if there is anything you want me to do, I would be prepared \n13 \nto do it tomorrow. But that way I hope we can get it cleared \n14 \nup. \n15 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Your Honor, we do have the deposition \n16 \nof the defendant scheduled for tomorrow. \n17 \nTHE COURT: Then everybody will be having a nice time \n18 \ntogether. Maybe you can all go out and have lunch, have a \n19 \ndrink, and exchange these documents and go away happy. Not \n20 \nlikely, but perhaps, depending on where you have lunch. \n21 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Thank you, your Honor. \n22 \nTHE COURT: Anything else? \n23 \nMS. MENNINGER: Nothing. \n24 \nTHE COURT: Thank you, all. \n25 \nOne thing. I would appreciate it if counsel would get \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076440\n", "char_count": 1376}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44. 08120/2020, 2913556, Page59 of 78 \nApp.-0833 \n29 \nG4LMGIUC \n1 \ntogether on my request for additional coverage in the \n2 \nconfidentiality agreement. \n3 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Sure. \n4 \nTHE COURT: Thanks a lot. \n5 \no0o \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076441\n", "char_count": 377}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page60 of 78 \nApp.-0834 \nEFTA00076442\n", "char_count": 86}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08120/2020, 2913556, Page61 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0835 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \n \nx \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPlaintiff, \nv. \n15 CV 7433 (LAP) \nRemote Zoom Conference \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \nBefore: \nNew York, N.Y. \nJuly 23, 2020 \n11:30 a.m. \nHON. LORETTA A. PRESKA, \nDistrict Judge \nAPPEARANCES \nBOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER, LLP \nAttorney for Plaintiff \nBY: SIGRID S. MCCAWLEY \nHADDON, MORGAN, AND FOREMAN, P.C. \nAttorney for Defendant \nBY: LAURA A. MENNINGER \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076443\n", "char_count": 654}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nCase 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page62 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0836 \n(The Court and all parties appearing via Zoom) \nTHE COURT: Are we ready to begin or is there anyone \nelse we're waiting for? OK. \nSo let's begin. I wanted to start out by thanking \ncounsel for organizing the docket entries by motion, by Doe, by \npinpointing the references to the Does and the like. It was \nexceedingly helpful to the Court and really a model of making \nit easy for the Court. \nMy law clerk is on the call and I'm going to invite \nhim to correct me if I make any mistakes in going over charts \nwhen we go document by document. \nTo remind us where we are in the process of unsealing \nmaterials from \nv Maxwell, the Court is to: \nOne, evaluate the weight of the presumption of public \naccess to the materials; \nTwo, identify and evaluate the weight of any \ncountervailing interests; and \nThree, determine whether the countervailing interests \nrebut the presumption. \nThe Court acknowledges that the presumption of public \naccess attaches to judicial documents, that is, to documents \nfiled in connection with a decided motion or to papers that are \nrelevant to the Court's exercise of its inherent supervisory \npowers. The documents at issue here relate to discovery \nmotions previously decided by Judge Sweet, and so the Court \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076444\n", "char_count": 1472}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page63 of 78 \n3 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0837 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nconcludes that they are judicial documents to which the \npresumption of public access attaches. Because the motions are \ndiscovery motions, the presumption is somewhat less weighty \nthan on a dispositive motion but is nevertheless important to \nthe public's interest in monitoring federal courts' exercise of \ntheir Article III powers. \nThe motions at issue today mention Does 1 and 2, the \nfirst long line of nonparties mentioned throughout the sealed \nmaterials. Pursuant to the protocol set out in docket \nno. 1044, these individuals were given notice of the motion to \nunseal and given the opportunity to request the material that \npertains to them and to object to its unsealing. Neither Doe \nrequested the material or lodged an objection to unsealing. \nThe Court notes that the names of Does 1 and 2, portions of \ntheir deposition transcripts, and portions of the Palm Beach \npolice report ascribed to them have already been made public. \nAlso, Doe 1 gave a press interview about the subject matter of \nthis action. \nAlso pursuant to the protocol, the parties were \npermitted to comment on the motion to unseal, and defendant \nMaxwell has lodged objections to unsealing. In her objections, \nMs. Maxwell relies on several countervailing interests, the \nmost weighty of which are that the material concerns personal \nmatters that, if released, might lead to annoyance or \nembarrassment, that the material was abusively filed or is \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076445\n", "char_count": 1668}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page64 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0838 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nuntrustworthy, and that the material concerns the subject of u \ncriminal investigation. \nWith respect to the argument that the material \nconstitutes personal information which might lead to annoyance \nor embarrassment if unsealed, Ms. Maxwell proffers little more \nthan her ipsi dixit; she provides no specifics as to these \nconclusions. In her first deposition, which is among the \ndocuments being considered on this motion, Ms. Maxwell refused \nto testify as to any consensual adult behavior and generally \ndisclaimed any knowledge of underage activity. In the context \nof this case, especially its allegations of sex trafficking of \nyoung girls, the Court finds that any minor embarrassment or \nannoyance resulting from disclosure of Ms. Maxwell's mostly \nnontestimony about behavior that has been widely reported in \nthe press is far outweighed by the presumption of public \naccess. \nWith respect to the argument that the material was \nabusively filed or is untrustworthy, again, ms. Maxwell \nproffers few specifics. That some of the exhibits to the \nmotion papers might not have been technically required on the \nmotion does not make the papers abusively filed. That \nMs. Maxwell's lawyers did not cross-examine some of the \nwitnesses relied on does not make the witnesses' testimony too \nunreliable to be unsealed. In any event, the Court is dubious \nthat such a fine-toothed comb review is required to evaluate \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076446\n", "char_count": 1648}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page65 of 78 \n5 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0839 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nthe public interest in access to these papers. Thus, the Court \nfinds that these interests are entitled to little weight under \nthe facts of this case. \nFinally, that the material relates to a person now \nknown to be under criminal investigation, Ms. Maxwell, is not \nentitled to much weight here. Again, Ms. Maxwell has relied on \nipsi dixits and has not explained how the sealed material, if \nreleased, could, as she posits, \"inappropriately influence \npotential witnesses or victims.\" Again, the Court finds that \nthis interest is entitled to little weight under the facts of \nthis case. \nAs should be clear from the above, the Court finds \nthat the countervailing interests identified fail to rebut the \npresumption of public access to the motions at issue and the \ndocuments filed in connection with those motions. Accordingly, \nthose papers shall be unsealed. \nThe Court also notes that several of the documents \nsealed on these motion papers have already been made public, \nand so those documents will not be discussed. \nAlso, personal identifying information as to any \nperson mentioned in the documents and the names of nonparties \nother than Does 1 and 2 and other portions related to such \nnonparties' specific conduct will be redacted from the \nmaterials being unsealed. Disclosure of the additional \nnonparty names will await notice to those parties and an \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076447\n", "char_count": 1603}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page66 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0840 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nopportunity for them to be heard. \nI won't repeat this caveat as to each document but \nwill only comment when it is not applicable. So unless there's \na specific comment, personal identifying information should be \nredacted and the names of the other Does not yet identified. \nConsistent with the protocol, the Court will now \nannounce its findings with respect to the sealed documents \nrelating to Does 1 and 2 that are the subject of this motion to \nunseal. For ease of reference, as counsel knows, the Court \nwill proceed in the order of the documents listed on Exhibit A, \nthat is docket no. 1068-1. \nDocket entry 143. Plaintiff's motion to compel \ndefendant to answer deposition questions. Unseal subject to \nthe caveat which I won't keep saying. \n144. Plaintiff's declaration of Ms. McCawley in \nsupport of the motion. Unseal. \n144-1. Exhibit 1. Page 21 of Ms. Maxwell's April 22, \n2016 deposition. Unseal. \n144-2. Additional pages of Ms. Maxwell's April 22, \n2016 deposition. Unseal. \nSame thing for 144-4. \nSame thing for 144-5. \nSame thing for 144-6. \nSame thing for 144-7. \n149. Defendant's response to the motion. Unseal. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076448\n", "char_count": 1363}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nCase 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page67 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0841 \n150. Declaration of Mister \nhow does he say it, \nMr. Pagliuca? Say it again. \nMS. MENNINGER: Pagliuca. \nTHE COURT: Mr. Pagliuca in opposition to the motion \nto compel. Unseal. \n150-1. Additional pages from Ms. Maxwell's April 22, \n2016 deposition. Unseal. \n152. Plaintiff's reply memorandum of law on the \nmotion. Unseal. \n153. Ms. McCawley's declaration in support of the \nmotion to compel. Unseal. \nI'm sorry. I'm going to go back to 152 for a minute. \nUnseal the portions summarizing Doe l's public statements. \nThose appear on page 6. Unseal portions summarizing deceased \nnonparties' public statements. Page 6. OK. \nContinuing on. 153-1. Additional deposition \nexcerpts. Unseal. \n164. Defendant's motion to compel all attorney-client \ncommunications and work product put at issue by plaintiff and \nher attorneys. Unseal. \n165. Declaration of Ms. Menninger in support of that. \nThat can be unsealed in full because there are no -- there is \nno material within the caveat in the document. \n165-3. Exhibit C. This is a copy of a motion to join \nin Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2 files in court. That document is \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076449\n", "char_count": 1339}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page68 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0842 \nalready public. \n4 \n5 \n165-8. \nin the Dershowitz \n165-10. \n165-11. \nExcerpts from Ms. \nmatter on January 16, 2016. \nCopy of e-mail correspondence. \ndeposition taken \nUnseal. \nUnseal. \ndeposition, \nExcerpts from Ms. \n6 \nMay 3, 2016. Unseal. \n7 \n184. Plaintiff's response in opposition to the \n8 \nmotion. Unseal the portions relating to Does 1 and 2 which \n9 \nappears on page 3. \n10 \n185. Ms. McCawley's declaration in opposition. That \n11 \ncan be unsealed in full because there is no material included \n12 \nin the caveats in the document. \n13 \n185-2. Copy of Jane Doe's no. 3 and 4 corrected \n14 \njoinder motion. Already filed in public. \n15 \n185-3. Response to the motion to intervene. Already \n16 \nfiled in public. \n17 \n185-11. Various deposition excerpts from \n18 \nMs. \ndeposition. The pages unsealed by the Second \n19 \nCircuit should, of course, remain unsealed. \n20 \n185-13. It's a copy of Ms. \nMay 30, 2016 \n21 \naffidavit. That can be unsealed in full. \n22 \n185-14. Copy of deposition excerpts from Mr. Cassell. \n23 \nUnseal. \n24 \n185-15. Copy of a transcript of the \n25 \ninterview of April 7, 2011. Unseal in full. The document is \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076450\n", "char_count": 1284}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page69 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0843 \nalready public \n185-16. Copy of common interests agreement. Unseal . \n194. Ms. Menninger's declaration in support of the \n4 \nmotion to compel. Unseal in full. \n5 \n194-3. Excerpts of Ms. \nMay 3, 2016 \n6 \ndeposition. Unseal. \n7 \n172. Plaintiff's motion to exceed the presumptive ten \n8 \ndeposition limit. That may be unsealed. Obviously subject to \n9 \nthe caveat. \n10 \n173. Ms. McCawley's declaration in support. Unseal \n11 \n173-5. May 18, 2016 deposition transcript of Doe 162. \n12 \nPages released by the Second Circuit, of course, will remain \n13 \nsealed -- will remain unsealed. Let me say it again. The \n14 \npages unsealed by the Second Circuit, of course, remain \n15 \nunsealed and further unsealing awaits notice. \n16 \n173-6. Excerpts from Ms. Maxwell's April 22, 2016 \n17 \ndeposition. Same thing. Pages unsealed by the Second Circuit \n18 \nremain unsealed. The portions of the deposition relating to \n19 \nDoes 1 and 2 which appear pages 71, 72, 73, and 218 shall be \n20 \nunsealed. \n21 \n189. Response in opposition to the motion. Unseal \n22 \neverything except for the reaction -- I'm sorry, the redaction \n23 \non page 5 pending further nonparty notice. \n24 \n190. Ms. Menninger's declaration in opposition. That \n25 \ncan be unsealed in full. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076451\n", "char_count": 1391}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page70 of 78 \n10 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0844 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n190-1. Excerpts from Ms. \ndeposition taken \non May 3, 2016. Unseal everything except for the inadvertently \nincluded letter on page 2. \n203. Response in support of the motion. The portions \nrelating to Does 1 and 2 which appear at pages 2, 5, and 6 may \nbe unsealed. \n204. Ms. McCawley's declaration in support. Unseal. \n204-1. Doe no. 162's deposition transcript. The \npages unsealed by the Second Circuit will, of course, remain \nunsealed and the remainder of the document remains sealed until \nnotice to the nonparty. \n204-2. It's Doe no. 151's rough deposition transcript \nexcerpts. The pages unsealed by the Circuit will remain \nunsealed. The remainder will await notice to that Doe. \n204-3. Deposition of John Doe 1. Unseal in full. \n211. That's the reply to the motion. The portions \nmentioning Does 1 and 2 which appear at pages 2, 5, and 6 may \nbe unsealed. \n212. Ms. Schultz's declaration in support of the \nmotion. The portions mentioning John Does 1 and 2 which appear \nat page 2 may be unsealed. \n212-1. Doe no. 162's deposition transcript excerpts, \npages unsealed by the Circuit will remain unsealed. \n212-2. Doe 151's final deposition transcript \nexcerpts. The pages unsealed by the Circuit will remain \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076452\n", "char_count": 1453}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page71 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0845 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nunsealed \nin full \n212-3. Doe 1's deposition transcript excerpt. Unseal \n222 -- I'm sorry. 224. It's the reply on the motion. \nThe portions relating to Does 1 and 2 which appear at page 2 \nmay be unsealed. \n199. That's a motion for an extension of time to \ncomplete depositions. That's open in any event. \n228. The response in opposition to the motion. \nUnseal. \nUnseal. \n229. Ms. Menninger's declaration in opposition. \n221 -- 229-1. Excerpts of the deposition of Doe \nno. 151. Hold until notice to that Doe. \n229-2. The billionaire playboy's club book \nmanuscript. The pages unsealed by the Circuit will remain \nunsealed. \n229-4. Excerpts of plaintiff's deposition of May 3, \n2016. Unseal the pages released by the Circuit. \n229-10. This is correspondence released in the case \nbetween Ms. Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein from January 2015. \nUnseal in full. \n229-11. Notices of deposition and a subpoena for Doe \n84 -- Will, I can say these two names, right? \nTHE LAW CLERK: Yes, Judge. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076453\n", "char_count": 1215}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page72 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0846 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nTHE COURT: \nand \ntogether \nwith a letter of production from Ms. McCawley. Unseal in full. \n248. Reply memorandum of law in support of the \nmotion. We're going to await the notice to the Doe on that \none. \n249. Ms. McCawley's declaration in support of the \nmotion. Unseal in full. \n249-4. Ms. McCawley's correspondence with opposing \ncounsel. The portions relating to Does 1 and 2 which appears \nat pages 4 and 5 can be unsealed. \n249-13. Defendant's Rule 26 disclosures. The \nportions relating to Does 1 and 2 shall be unsealed. \n249-14. Ms. Schultz's correspondence with opposing \ncounsel. Unseal. \n249-15. Same. Same. \n230. Defendant's motion to reopen the deposition of \nplaintiff \nIt may be unsealed. However, the \ninformation currently redacted in the document relating to \nplaintiff's medical history shall remain redacted for obvious \nreasons. \n235. Ms. Menninger's declaration in support of the \nmotion. Unseal. \n235-4. The deposition of Ms. \nThe pages \nreleased by the Second Circuit of course remain unsealed. The \nportions relating to Doe 1 and 2 which appears -- which appear \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076454\n", "char_count": 1318}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page73 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0847 \nat pages 122, 126, 134, and 138 shall be unsealed. \n235-5. Ms. Menninger's declaration. The medical \nrecords on pages 5 to 12 should remain sealed; otherwise, \n4 \nunseal. \n5 \n235-6 are medical records. They shall remain sealed. \n6 \n235-7. Excerpts from the -- a deposition of Doe \n7 \nno. 131. That will remain sealed pending notice to the Doe. \n8 \n235-8. Production letters from Ms. Schultz to \n9 \nMs. Menninger. The exhibits will remain sealed. \n10 \n235 -- and they are medical records. \n11 \n235-9. Excerpts from the May 26, 2016 deposition of \n12 \nDr. Stephen Olsen. The material relating to plaintiff's \n13 \nmedical issues shall remain sealed. The other material in the \n14 \ndeposition, for example, how the doctor takes notes, how the \n15 \ndoctor gets new patients, how the doctor writes prescriptions \n16 \nand that sort of thing may be unsealed. \n17 \n235-10. Production letters from Ms. McCawley to \n18 \nMs. Menninger. Unseal. \n19 \n235-12. The June 1, 2016 errata sheet relating to \n20 \ndeposition. Unseal. \n21 \n235-13. Plaintiff's third revised disclosure pursuant \n22 \nto Federal Rule 26. Unseal. \n23 \n260. Ms. McCawley's declaration in opposition to the \n24 \nmotion. The redactions which are medical information will \n25 \nremain. \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076455\n", "char_count": 1386}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page74 of 78 \n14 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0848 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n260-1. Will, is this only the authorization or is it \nthe authorization plus material? \nTHE LAW CLERK: Judge, I believe it's the \nauthorization on the first two pages and then the medical \nrecords on subsequent pages. \nTHE COURT: Thank you. The medical record \nauthorization may be unsealed. The subsequent pages which \nconstitute medical records will remain sealed. \n260-2. Dr. Lightfoot's June 27, 2016 correspondence. \nThat may be unsealed. \n267. The reply on the motion. The information \nrelating to plaintiff's medical history shall remain sealed. \n268. Ms. Menninger's declaration in support of the \nmotion. Unseal. \n268-1. Pages from plaintiff's medical records. They \nshall remain sealed. \n268-2. Excerpts from the deposition of Doe no. 67. \nThe pages unsealed by the Second Circuit will remain sealed --\nI'm sorry, will remain unsealed and the remainder of the \ndocument will remain sealed pending notice to the relevant \nDoes. \nCounsel, I will ask you to confer and to prepare the \ndocuments for unsealing pursuant to this order and post the \ndocuments within a week on the docket sheet as documents \nunsealed pursuant to the Court's order of July 23 or something \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076456\n", "char_count": 1408}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page75 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0849 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nlike that. \nCounsel, do you have any questions? \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, on behalf of Ms. Maxwell \nwould ask if we could have the opportunity for a brief stay in \norder to seek relief in the Second Circuit. There is not a \ncertain mechanism for doing that in an unsealing context but I \nknow that the Brown Court at the conclusion of their opinior \nstated their intent for that panel to maintain jurisdiction \nover this case for purposes of any appeals taken from an \nunsealing order and so we would ask for two weeks, if we could, \nto seek relief in the Second Circuit. \nTHE COURT: Ms. McCawley. \nMS. McCAWLEY: Yes, your Honor. We obviously believe \nthat the material should be unsealed as quickly as possible so \nwe would prefer to obviously have the material unsealed. \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, if I may briefly, to add \nto my record. While I understand and respect the Court's \nruling, there have been some significant changes with respect \nto my client's position since we concluded briefing. In \nparticular, and perhaps known to everyone listening to this, \nwhile we were speaking about a potential ongoing criminal \ninvestigation at the time we submitted our brief, since that \ntime Ms. Maxwell has been indicted and a trial has been \nscheduled for next July in another courtroom in the Southern \nDistrict. So while we were not able to provide specifics \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076457\n", "char_count": 1596}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 0812012020, 2913556, Page76 of 78 \n16 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0850 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nnecessarily with regard to what witnesses might be relevant to \nany such criminal trial, now we are in a vastly different \nposition and certainly have great concerns about our client's \nability to seek and receive an impartial and fair trial and \njury given the intense media scrutiny around anything that is \nunsealed or anything that happens in this or any of the related \ncases. So while we -- your Honor had mentioned at the \nbeginning of this ruling that there was a lack of specifics on \nthe front of the pending criminal investigation, I think there \nmay be the ability to provide a lot more specifics about that \nat this time and certainly I think it's an issue that we would \nlike to, if we may, have a brief amount of time to submit. It \nis important either to this Court's analysis or to the Second \nCircuit. \nTHE COURT: So what are you asking me for? \nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, I ask for two weeks if we \ncould to file an emergency appellate motion in the Second \nCircuit and ask them to stay any further release. \nTHE COURT: I will give you a week to file the motion. \nIn the meantime I will still ask counsel to confer and to \nprepare the papers for release. If the Court of Appeals has \nnot ruled on your motion in a week, then you can let me know. \n(Court reporter dropped off the call; called back in \nand read record to the point where call dropped) \nTHE COURT: After that, I asked counsel to confer \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076458\n", "char_count": 1653}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Case 20-2413, Document 44, 08/20/2020, 2913556, Page77 of 78 \nK7N9GIUD \nApp.-0851 \ngenerally along the outlines of the proposal in Ms. Maxwell's \nletter of April 3, docket no. 1045 to propose the next \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nchronological set of motions to \nalso asked counsel to confer on \nefficient, less time consuming, \nbe considered for unsealing. \nways to make the process more \nand to make it stretch out or \nover a shorter time period. For example, it occurs to me we \ncould shorten the briefing time. We could reduce the number of \npages of briefing, for example, to ten pages each side total or \nsomething like that. I'll ask counsel to confer and to report \nback within a week. \nFinally, going forward, as you all saw, Exhibit A to \nMs. \nmotion -- I said the number of it earlier but \nthat was exceedingly helpful. If you would like to propose a \njoint exhibit similar to that as we go forward with everybody's \npositions, I would welcome it. \nIs there anything else you want to ask, counsel? \nMS. McCAWLEY: No, your Honor. \nMS. MENNINGER: No, your Honor. Not from Ms. Maxwell. \nThank you. \nTHE COURT: Thank you and I'll just tell you lawyers \nagain how useful the work you did in organizing the docket \nentries was. Thank you for it again. \nMS. MENNINGER: Thank you, your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Good afternoon, counsel. Thank you. \nMS. McCAWLEY: Good afternoon. Thank you. (Adjourned) \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. \n(212) 805-0300 \nEFTA00076459\n", "char_count": 1517}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00076383", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "gdall Aft 1 \nCr\nI : 20-2401333061..AD n DOA ueribThO 434)243i I eiSi -038718/2103gP \nApp.-0852 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nUnited States of America, \n—v—\nGhislaine Maxwell, \nDefendant. \nUSDC SDNY \nDOCUMENT \nELECTRONICALLY FILED \nDOC M: \nDATE FILED: 8/18/20 \n20-CR-330 (MN) \nORDER \nALISON J. NATHAN, District Judge: \nOn August 17, 2020, the Defendant filed a letter motion seeking a modification of this \nCourt's Protective Order, which the Court entered on July 30, 2020. Defendant also moves to \nfile that letter motion under seal. The Government's opposition to Defendant's letter motion is \nhereby due Friday, August 21 at 12 p.m. The Defendant's reply is due on Monday, August 24 at \n12 p.m. The parties shall propose redactions to the letter briefing on this issue. Alternatively, \nthe parties shall provide support and argument for why the letter motions should be sealed in \ntheir entirety. \nSO ORDERED. \nDated: August 18, 2020 \nNew York, New York \nCA SL\n g. \nALISON J. NATHAN \nUnited States District Judge \nEFTA00076460\n", "char_count": 1062}]}