{"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_count": 40, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00074964", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00074964.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Ca_4ate.24h24/43134.01FrietibtOrtlefifitin0a0le28013,8111$2eafiabef146f 22 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nX \nPlaintiff, \nv. \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \nX \n15-cv-07433-LAP \nMs. Maxwell's Reply In Support Of Iler Objections to tnsealinu Sealed Materials \nLaura A. Menninger \nJeffrey S. Pagliuca \nTy Gee \nHADDON, MORGAN AND FOREMAN, P.C. \n150 East 10th Avenue \nEFTA00074964\n", "char_count": 407}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Ca_QatIgt24743tictoWneDbtOrfiefiVIMOXIle?BOWERKVaffizte12401 22 \nIntroduction \nThis Court asked the parties to brief three issues: \"(a) the weight of presumption of \npublic access that should be afforded to an item, (b) the identification and weight of any \ncountervailing interests supporting continued sealing/redaction of the item, and (c) whether the \ncountervailing interests rebut the presumption of public access to the item.\" DE 1044 at 1. \nPlaintiff and the Miami Herald's responses improperly afford the highest level of presumption to \ndiscovery dispute documents, deny that any countervailing interests exist, and protest that Ms. \nMaxwell's numerous proposed countervailing interests, and those of yet unheard-from Non-\nParties, cannot possibly rebut the presumption of public access. Because their Responses ignore \nboth the law and the facts, Ms. Maxwell's Objections to Unsealing various of the documents \nshould be granted. \nPlaintiff's ad hominem attacks -- that the Objections are intended to \"stall the unsealing \nprocess,\" are \"unjustified obstacles\" or that the public will never have access to these documents \n-- reflect unjustified criticisms of the Protocol itself and the Second Circuit's decision in Brown, \nboth of which fairly outline the legal process for parties and Non-Parties alike to be heard with \nrespect to unsealing. Notably, many of the documents were sealed in the first instance at the \nrequest of Plaintiff and her counsel. And as to, for example, Plaintiff's medical records, no one \ninterposed any objection to their unsealing until Plaintiff's belated request to do so in her \nResponse. As detailed in Ms. Maxwell's Objection and further below, there are numerous \ndocuments to which Ms. Maxwell does not interpose objections to unsealing, subject to Non-\nParties' opportunity for notice to be heard. That the process for review of literally thousands of \npages of sealed materials takes time to accomplish is not a reason to unseal. Rather, the \nhundre\n... [truncated, 2203 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/1 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=1]", "char_count": 2203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Ca_4atE12-41‘24113actoWneDbthrfiefiVIIMOaElleb3013a1KVaffutbotalef 22 \nher counsel agreed, would be honored subject to the few very limited situations in which the \npublic right to access the court files overcomes the privacy interests at stake. \nARGUMENT \nI. Weight of Presumption \nEach of the Sealed Items currently under consideration relates to a resolved discovery \ndispute. Brown held, yet Plaintiff and the Miami Herald dispute, that the \"weight of presumption \nof public access\" afforded to discovery disputes, which \"play only a negligible role in the \nperformance of Article III duties,\" is \"only a low presumption that 'amounts to little more than a \nprediction of public access absent a countervailing reason.' 929 F.3d at 49-50 (quoting Arnodeo \nII, 71 F.3d at 1050); id. at 50 (describing these \"remaining sealed materials\" as \"subject to at \nleast some presumption of public access\"); id. at 53 (discovery motion materials \"subject to a \nlesser — but still substantial — presumption of public access\"); see also Securities and Exchange \nComm 'n v. Telegram Grp. Inc., Case No. 19-cv-9439 (PKC), 2020 WL 3264264 at *2 (S.D.N.Y. \nJune 17, 2020) (\"The presumption attached to non-dispositive motions... 'is generally somewhat \nlower than the presumption applied to material introduced at trial, or in connection with \ndispositive motions such as motions for dismissal or summary judgment.\"') (quoting Brown, 929 \nF.3d at 50). \nA. Non-Response from Does 1 and 2 Not Dispositive of Countervailing Interests \nPlaintiff argues that all documents mentioning Does 1 and 2 should be released because \nneither requested excerpts nor interposed any objection. She also claims that some information, \nspecifically Doe 1's name, has already been made public, or that a \"Google search\" reveals other \ninformation about Doe 1 and 2. Obviously, the contested sections of the Sealed Materials are not \nalready public or no unsealing issue would exist. The fact that Doe 1's name has already been \n3 \nEFT\n... [truncated, 2010 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/2 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=2]", "char_count": 2010}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Ca_Qatilgag4743D4fAFrieDbethfiefiVIMOXlieb3013fliaMPafftatef446f 22 \nmade public is a different issue from whether there exist other substantially valid countervailing \nreasons to keep Sealed Items mentioning Doe 1 or quoting from Doe 1 sealed. There are. \na. \nThere is no evidence that Doe 1 received or read the Notice from the Court, \nnor even that Doe 1 is still living. The return receipt was signed for by someone other than \nDoe 1. Ex. A. \nb. Doe 1 detailed during \nEx. B, 159:4 — 160:17. \nc. \nDoe 1 repeatedly testified that \ndid not like to be involved in this matter. \nDE 204-3 at 5-13 \nEx. B, 199:10-12 \n234:23-235:2 \n; Ex. B, \nAfter this statement, Plaintiffs \ncounsel agreed that it \"made sense\" to mark Doe l's entire deposition as \"Confidential.\" Id. \nat Ex. B, 235:3-7. (CI-1 — Reliance on Protective Order; CI-3 Annoyance, embarrassment, \noppression, undue burden). \n4 \nEFTA00074967\n", "char_count": 900}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "CaatatIVAL9-4/74394.oWneDbethfielIVIMOXIleb30W0-22tPagtite540 22 \nd. Regarding the fact that Doe l's name is already available via a Google \nsearch, Doe 1 \nattributed false statements to IM \nEx. B,198:4-199:19. \ne. \nThere was no legitimate reason to attach Doe l's deposition to a garden-\nvariety request to exceed the presumptive 10-deposition limit. (CI-5 Improper submission \nof papers). \nf. \nPlaintiff repeatedly misstated Doe l's testimony and misled the Court as to \nits contents, either by omitting critical pieces of the testimony or out-right falsely relaying \nits contents. By way of example, in DE 203 at page 5, Plaintiff's counsel claimed that Doe \n1 \nciting DE 204-3 at 36-41. In fact, Doe 1 testified in excerpts that were not attached to \npleadings that \nEx. B, 174:21-176:2. \nEx. B. 36:17-37:3. \nWithout including other portions of Doe l's \n5 \nEFTA00074968\n", "char_count": 874}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Ca_Qat0.52-Pa-4)743D4cAFneDbaltliefiV3M30Alle?BOWIKVafai6g0616f 22 \ntestimony, Plaintiff's counsel's factually incorrect and misleading statements will be \npresented without the necessary explanations provided by the witness. (CI-2; CI-6) \nContrary to Plaintiff's chart in her Response at 7-8, Ms. Maxwell identified \nnumerous reasons to keep those references to Doe 1 and 2 under seal. See DE 173-6 (Obj. \n7-11). \nh. Plaintiff incorrectly claims that DE 152 \"summarizes publicly available \nstatements.\" Resp. at 8. This is not true. DE 152 selectively quotes from the deposition \ntestimony of a deceased individual, who Ms. Maxwell never had the opportunity to cross-\nexamine, and who (contemporaneous with his deposition) was convicted of a felony and \nsent to prison for stealing, and then trying to sell, documents related to Jeffrey Epstein. See \nDE 679, \nt also \nquotes from Doe I's prior sworn statements and testimony, which he explained earlier, e.g., \n'liven Doe 1's further explanations, which are not included \namong the Sealed Materials, countervailing interests CI-2 and CI-6 rebut the minimal \npresumption of access attendant to these Sealed Items. \nSee SEC v. Telegram Grp., Inc., 2020 WL 3264264 at *3 (finding \"privacy interests of non-\nparties ... represents a legitimate basis for sealing judicial documents\"). \nB. Effect of Previous Unsealing of Documents by Second Circuit \nPlaintiff claims that if a document is already public in another context, then it should be \nunsealed. She cites no law for this proposition, which runs contrary to the Second Circuit's \nholding in Brown. The Circuit made clear that this District Court must engage in its own review \nwith respect to each document and provide notice to the Non-Parties for documents that were not \n6 \nEFTA00074969\n", "char_count": 1793}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "CaaM152-a,‘2-0743134o%PleDbtOrfiefiVM30Alle?BOMIV2eafabef746f 22 \nentitled to the highest presumption of access, i.e., those attached to summary judgment \npleadings. \nII. Identification and Weight of Any Countervailing Interests \nA. DE 143 and Related Pleadings \nDocket Entry 143 and its associated pleadings involve Plaintiff's effort \nwhich were not and should not \nhave been relevant to Plaintiffs false claim that she was sexually abused by Epstein as a minor. \nThe Second Circuit in Brown itself redacted from the summary judgment pleadings and exhibits \nall of Ms. Maxwell's deposition answers involving her intimate, sexual matters, based on its \napparent finding that the selected questions involved \"deposition responses concerning intimate \nmatters where the questions were likely only permitted — and the responses only compelled — \nbecause of a strong expectation of continued confidentiality.\" 929 F.3d at 48 n.22; Brown, 18-\n2868, DE 280 at 15 (redacting Plaintiff's contention \nDE 283 at 195-201 (redacting four pages of \ndefendant's deposition testimony concerning private, intimate matters). \nEven though the Second Circuit itself found a countervailing interest on these matters \nsignificant enough to remove the materials from summary judgment pleadings and exhibits, \nwhich enjoy the highest presumption of public access, Plaintiff makes a number of frivolous \narguments that a Motion to Compel her to answer deposition questions \nhas insufficient countervailing interests, even though the dispute relates to a \njudicial document with lesser presumptive access. Plaintiff's Response represents a gross \ndistortion of the record in this case and highlights the substantial, countervailing need for the \nMotion and all associated pleadings to remain sealed. DE 143 contains material \n7 \nEFTA00074970\n", "char_count": 1818}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "CaatatIg-retiR-4743N.OWneDbeurfiefIVIMOTaieb3OMIIKVaRt6W8461 22 \nmisrepresentations of fact, and the attached portions of deposition testimony demonstrate that \nPlaintiff's questions themselves were packed with inadmissible, false representations. \n1. \nReliance on a protective order by a party or non-party (CI-1) \nAs it pertains to DE 143 and related pleadings, the issue is not, as Plaintiff complains, \nthat Ms. Maxwell must demonstrate she relied on the protective order in answering every single \nquestion during her deposition. Resp. at 10. The subject matter of DE 143, the representations \nin the Motion and Reply, and the associated deposition excerpts attached, each pertain to the \ntopic of Ms. Maxwell's refusal to answer irrelevant questions concerning her \nThat she relied on the Protective Order in answering questions, or refusing to \nanswer questions, is obvious from the procedural posture of the case: \n• \nMarch 2, 2016 (DE 38): Defendant moved for a Protective Order, citing Plaintiff's \nanticipated deposition of Ms. Maxwell would include questions \"concerning her \npersonal and professional relationships as well as matters concerning her private \naffairs.\" \n• \nMarch 17, 2016 (DE 66 at 9): At hearing on the Protective Order, Ms. McCawley \nstated \"I can have the deposition of the defendant in this case and move this case \nforward. I will agree to their protective order. I just want that deposition....It is that \nimportant to me.\" \n• \nMarch 22, 2016 (DE 63): Maxwell moves for a Protective Order regarding her \nDeposition in part due to Plaintiff's attempt to ambush her at her deposition without \nhaving produced requested, responsive documents in advance. \n• \nApril 22, 2016: At deposition of Ms. Maxwell, the excerpts of which are attached to \nDE 143, 144-1, 144-2, 144-4, 144-5, 144-6, 144-7, 150-1, and 153-1, the first \nsubstantive question posed to Ms. Maxwell was \nEx. C, at 1, 6-7. \nEven a cursory review of the deposition excerpts at issue, as well as the redacti\n... [truncated, 2211 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/7 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=7]", "char_count": 2211}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Ca_4ate.2-et241111394sAffrienbtOrliefitA303030103013.8/13$20a§t(befghtif 22 \nrespect to other of her deposition answers) a sufficiently compelling countervailing interest to \nmaintain the records under seal. \nPlaintiff and Miami Herald also complain the Protective Order at issue is \"an umbrella \nprotective order\" that only governed until trial and so there could have been no reasonable \nreliance that the \"documents would always be kept secret.\" Resp. at 11; Miami Herald Resp. at \n3. For the reasons recently briefed to the Court concerning Professor Dershowitz's identical \nargument, the position is without merit. See DE 892 (Judge Sweet's May 2017 Order); DE 1059 \n(law of the case that parties and deponents reasonably relied on protective order); DE 1062 at 3-6 \n(protective order tracks permissible scope under Rule 26(c)(1), includes provisions to challenge \nimproper designation of confidentiality, contained no temporal limit, and appropriately limited \nuse of confidential materials to \"preparation and trial of this case\"). \n2. Prevention of the abuse of court records and files (CI-2) and \nUntrustworthy, unreliable and incorrect information (CI-6) \nRemarkably, Plaintiff claims as dicta the Circuit's clear directive in Brown that a district \ncourt should exercise the full range of its substantial powers to ensure their files do not become \nvehicles for defamation. 929 F.3d at 51. Her position is nonsense. The Brown court described \nthe district court's \"supervisory function\" not merely as within its \"power, but also among its \nresponsibilities.\" Id. The Circuit then described the \"several methods\" of fulfilling this function \nto include \"issu[ance of] protective order forbidding dissemination of certain materials to protect \na party or person from annoyance, embarrassment, oppression or undue burden\" and \"requir[ing] \nthat filings containing such materials be submitted under seal.\" Id. That is precisely what \noccurred in this case. To contend that the Brown court mean\n... [truncated, 2194 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/8 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=8]", "char_count": 2194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Ca&c:152agelanIcAlmeDbtOrfieliVig7203tIleb30-65a12ea \n§bc11046f 22 \nMoreover, that Plaintiff hopes and intends for the court records and files in this case to be \nabused by the media is readily apparent in DE 143 and its related pleadings combined with \nPlaintiff and her counsel's extensive media participation. For example, in DE 144-6 at 55, \nPlaintiff's counsel asked Ms. Maxwell the questions, \nlawsuit filed a lawsuit against Mr. Epstein \nto produce \nIn fact, \nin connection with her current \nfailed \ncounsel insinuated during her questions \nSimilarly, in DE 144-4 at 62, Plaintiff's \nSee' \nUnsealing the deposition question posed by \nPlaintiffs counsel, which suggests that there was \nwhen in fact there was not, would promote a defamation-proof lie to be perpetuated \nby the media. The deposition transcript also reflects numerous meritorious objections to the \nquestions, including foundation, asked and answered, form of the question, and otherwise \nimproper questions. Were this case to have gone to trial, many of the questions would never \nhave been admitted in a court of law; opening them up to the press presents an opportunity for \nabuse and misuse of the court's files. See United States v. Gatto, 17-CR-686 (LAK), 2019 WL \n4194569, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 3, 2019) (\"documents merely shown to witnesses or otherwise \ndiscussed in Court but not offered into evidence\" do not constitute judicial documents because \n\"neither relevant to the performance of the judicial function nor useful in the judicial process\"). \n10 \nEFTA00074973\n", "char_count": 1548}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Ca\natcMag0743134.cAPnetibtOrfieliFlIC6203Qie2f3913BICIS2eafttlperi4Of 22 \nPlaintiff's counsel's persistent and repeated statements to the press, including those that \non their face appear to violate Rule of Professional Conduct 3.6 given the ongoing litigation in \nthis district, also reflect her hope and intent that the misrepresentations, untested allegations and \nother inadmissible evidence contained in the pleadings and their attachments will be abused by \nthe press. See, e.g. https://www.dailvmail.co.ukhzews/article-7896171/Lawvers-Chislaine-\nMaxwell \n-hash-plan-release-docs.html (Plaintiff's counsel statements to the \npress that the \"document dump\" would include evidence that would \"expose that sex trafficking \nscheme,\" implying it contains evidence that young females \"as young as 11\" were abused, \ndespite absolute lack of any such evidence in the Sealed Materials); Kevin G. Hall, \"Ghislaine \nMaxwell says she was Epstein's employee not his madam,\" MIAMI HERALD (Mar. 18, 2020) (quoting \nSigrid McCawley, \"It is absolutely appalling that Ghislaine Maxwell, who committed crimes with \nEpstein against these victims, is seeking to drain funds from the very estate that should be paying the \nEpstein victims' claims...We view her actions as unconscionable but this is an individual who lost \nsight of right from wrong a very long time ago.\"). \nThe potential for abuse by the press is all the more acute because, as Judge Sweet noted, \nthis case did not go to trial, nor will it ever, given the settlement of the matter more than three \nyears ago. Were there a trial, then each of the allegations could be met with contrary evidence, \nthe witnesses would be subject to cross-examination, and inadmissible evidence (such as \ndeposition questions lacking a good faith foundation) would be excluded. Instead, by unsealing \nmaterials that were never subject to cross examination or rebuttal will permit these inaccurate \nand false statements to be widely publicized in the media without a f\n... [truncated, 2240 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/10 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=10]", "char_count": 2240}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "CasliaMlfiati.247213DIAWneBbtOrflefiVIIMOne2BOWE1382eapaljec112401 22 \npeddle with great frequency. In the absence of continued Sealing these items, the Second \nCircuit's prediction that the court files will be \"used to gratify private spite or promote public \nscandal\" is an assured result. \n3. Annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden (CI-3) \nAlthough Rule 26(c) and Brown expressly permit continued sealing of materials that \ncause a party or non-party \"annoyance, embarrassment, oppression or undue burden,\" Plaintiff \nand Miami Herald dismiss these concerns as unspecific or, worse, suggest that the Sealed \nMaterials contain evidence of \"misconduct.\" Resp. at 13; Miami Herald Resp. at 4. To the extent \nthat Plaintiff makes this assertion, implying knowledge of the contents of the Sealed Materials, \nthat alone is a violation of the Protection Order. \nAs Plaintiff well knows, Ms. Maxwell was forced to answer substantial, numerous, ill-\nfounded questions regarding her private life, her \nher \nresidences, her friends, and her living arrangements. She is not citing this countervailing interest \nbecause she believes there is any evidence of \"misconduct\" or the \"sexual abuse of young girls at \nthe hands of the wealthy and powerful,\" as the Miami Herald speculates. While the Court's \nreview of the Sealed Materials will speak for itself on this score, to be specific, a few examples \nthe \"annoying\" and \"embarrassing\" items contained in DE 143 and its related documents to \nwhich Ms. Maxwell asserts this countervailing interest are: \n12 \nEFTA00074975\n", "char_count": 1572}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Casliataa2a24113134cAReDbalrfieliVitinOarne26013,511382eaptilfr clf340f 22 \nThese annoying, embarrassing, and highly personal questions are exactly the type that the Brown \ncourt itself redacted and the very type of questions that Rule 26(c) shields via a protective order. \n4. Ongoing criminal investigation and other pending civil lawsuits warrant \ncontinued sealing. \nFeigned ignorance aside, Plaintiff and her counsel are well aware of the purportedly \nongoing criminal investigation into all persons surrounding Mr. Epstein; Plaintiff and her \ncounsel have been the primary instigators of such a prosecution.' Indeed, Plaintiff's counsel has \nobjected to production of responses and documents in another pending civil case \"insofar as it \ncalls for information related to an ongoing criminal investigation.\" See Ex. D. \nMoreover, Plaintiff's counsel also is well aware of the numerous civil actions pending in \nthis district against Ms. Maxwell and related to Ms. \nclaims; she is counsel of record in \none of them and filed another in which Plaintiff is a party, after which this Court disqualified her \nfrom continued representation. See, e.g., Farmer v. Indyke, Case No. 19-cv-10475-LGS \nSee, e.g., \nwants Ghislaine Maxwell to `rot in jail,\" NY \nPost (Dec. 4, 2019); Andrew Denney and Bruce Golding, \"Jeffrey Epstein's no-bail ruling may \nencourage more accusers to come forward,\" NY Post (July 18, 2019) (\"McCawley wouldn't \nidentify her new clients but said she encouraged them to report their alleged abuse to the FBI. \nMcCawley  declined to say if any had been interviewed by the feds, but Manhattan federal \nprosecutor I \n... told Berman that the case against Epstein was `getting stronger \nevery day.'\"); Mark Townsend, \"Prince Andrew: US prosecutor leading inquiry into Epstein \nlinks refuses to quit,\" The Guardian (June 20, 2020) (\"Geoffrey Berman says he will continue to \ninvestigate duke's relationship with sex offender despite pressure to resign.\"). \n13 \nEFTA00074976\n", "char_count": 1989}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Ca\natagag0743fillcAlitieDbaltflefiFM202{1le289114282eaftlabbt11440f 22 \n(S.D.N.Y.); \nv. Dershowitz, Case No. 19-cv-3377-LAP. This Court recently presided over \na telephone conference in which Mr. Dershowitz has asserted that all of the pleadings in this \nmatter are relevant to his dispute with Ms. \nbecause she has put her credibility at issue. \nWhile Ms. Maxwell disagrees with that assertion, no doubt many of the same witnesses will be \nrelevant in both disputes and pre-trial publicity concerning exhibits and deposition testimony \ncould work to undermine the right to a fair and impartial trial based on the evidence for any of \nthe defendants, including Ms. Maxwell and Professor Dershowitz, should any of these pending \nmatters eventually be tried. Plaintiff's efforts to publicize the court files, again, present a \ncountervailing interest to their unsealing. \n5. Privacy Rights of Non-Party Does 1 and 2 \nDoe 1 is mentioned in DE 152 at 6. Although many of the attachments (DE 153-4, 153-5 \nand 153-6) are unsealed, Plaintiff's misrepresentations contained in DE 152 are countervailing \ninterests to the unsealing of that pleading. As described more fully above, see Section I(A)(f) \nsupra, Plaintiff's counsel claimed in her Reply that \ntestified \nCoupled with IN \nrepeated statements that \ndoes not want to be hounded by the media, some of whom had \nbroken into \nhome, Doe l's privacy interests should be respected. \nB. DE 164 and Related Pleadings \nMs. Maxwell does not assert any countervailing interests to the unsealing of DE 164 and \nits related pleadings. However, the Court should be aware that DEs 165-3, 185-2 and 185-15 are \npleadings that were stricken pursuant to Rule 12(0 by U.S. District Court Judge Marra and thus \nare not, as Plaintiff claims, \"publicly available on the docket of Doe v. United States, 08-cv-\n80736 (S.D.Fla.).\" Resp. at 15 n.5. These three documents were \"restricted/sealed until further \n14 \nEFTA00074977\n", "char_count": 1953}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "CasliaM52a24143D4sAfFneDbtOrfiefineW2OnetEOIWIS2eaptilfr '11540122 \nnotice\" by U.S. District Court Judge Marra in that proceeding after he sea sponte found the \nmaterials contained in those pleadings were \"redundant, immaterial, impertinent, or scandalous.\" \nSee Doe v. United States, 08-cv-80736 (S.D.Fla.), DE 324 at 4. Ex. F. Specifically as to Jane \nDoe 3, \nJudge Marra found her allegations of being \"sexually trafficked to \nseveral high-profile non-party individuals\" to be \"lurid\" and \"unnecessary\" to the determination \nof whether she should be allowed to join the proceedings, particularly given that \"these details \ninvolve non-parties who are not related to the respondent Government\" and \"shall be stricken.\" \nId. at 5. Therefore, although Ms. Maxwell does not object to their unsealing, this Court may \nwish to preserve the seal on these documents, and any related argument contained in the \npleadings, in deference to Judge Marra's findings. See also Brown, 929 F.3d at 51-52 \n(documents stricken per Rule 12(0 \"not relevant to the performance of the judicial function,\" \n\"not considered a judicial document\" and enjoys \"no presumption of public access.\"). \nFurther, in addition to Doe 1, other Non-Parties are included in DE's 185-3, 185-11, 185-\n14 and 185-15 each of whom has not yet been notified or had the opportunity to object under this \nCourt's Protocol. (CI-1) \nC. DE 172 and Related Pleadings (CI-1 through CI-7) \nIn asking the Court to permit her to exceed the presumptive ten deposition limit, Plaintiff \nattached 803 pages of exhibits including, as is pertinent, the complete 160-page deposition \ntranscript of Doe 162 (DE 173-5) and the complete 418-page deposition of Ms. Maxwell (DE \n173-6). Plaintiff's Reply and Corrected Replies additionally attached deposition transcripts of \nDoe 151 (DE 204-2, 212-2), additional excerpts from Doe 162's deposition (DE 204-1, 212-1), \nand portions of Doe 1's deposition (DE 204-3, 212-3). Additional sealed and related items \nincl\n... [truncated, 2143 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/14 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=14]", "char_count": 2143}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Ca&d.E2age/43(14.cAPiefilbtOtfiefiFtaCnOnal30130182ea \nlie (116461 22 \nAs to these Sealed Materials, Ms. Maxwell asserted countervailing interests that \noverlapped with those she raised as to DE 144 and related pleadings (CI-1 through CI-6), as well \nas asserting that the exhibits each are non judicial documents (CI-7) because none \"would \nreasonably have the tendency to influence a district court's ruling on a motion....\" Brown, 929 \nF.3d at 49 (quoting Arnodeo 1, 44 F.3d at 145). In Response, Plaintiff makes no effort to explain \nto this Court why the wholesale attachment of deposition transcripts \"would reasonably have a \ntendency to influence a district court's ruling on a motion.\" See Resp. at 15-18. Her silence is \nunsurprising because there is no reasonable explanation for the attachment of entire deposition \ntranscripts. The failure to establish that the exhibits are \"judicial documents\" alone justifies their \ncontinued sealing. See, e.g., United States v. Gatto, I7-CR-686 (LAK), 2019 WL 4194569, at *4 \n(S.D.N.Y. Sept. 3, 2019) (documents not offered into evidence not judicial documents); Newsday \nLLC v. County of Nassau, 730 F.3d 156 (2d Cir. 2013) (report used to refresh witness's \nrecollection not a judicial document). \n1. DE's 204-3 and 212-3 are excerpts from Doe l's Deposition That Should \nRemain Sealed (CI-1) \nDEs 204-3 and 212-3 contain the same portions of Doe l's deposition discussed supra at \nSection I(A)(f) and should remain sealed for the same reasons, as should the redactions at DE \n203-5 and 211-5. Additionally, Plaintiff has not explained why excerpts from a deposition she \nhad already is something upon which a court would reasonably rely to determine whether \nadditional depositions of other witnesses are justified. \n2. DE 172 and 173-6 Should Remain Sealed (CI-1 through CI-6) \nMs. Maxwell incorporates by reference her argument, supra at Section II(A), as it \npertains to her deposition transcript (DE 173-6) and purported references to the tra\n... [truncated, 2119 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/15 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=15]", "char_count": 2119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Ca\naV1.52-6B0733114.cAlmeDbtOrflefil7211620301e2B9131E182eafWaf7443f 22 \ndeposition bore some relationship to the topic of the motion and Plaintiff only attached a few \nexcerpts. By contrast, regarding DE 172 and exhibit DE 173-6, Ms. Maxwell's full deposition \nbears no relationship to Plaintiff's request to take additional depositions of other witnesses; \nPlaintiff does not even attempt to explain how it might. In DE 172, Plaintiff purports to \nsummarize in sound-bites her spin on the content of Ms. Maxwell's 7 'A hour deposition, but as \nis her wont, inaccurately summarizes the deposition and falsely claims that Ms. Maxwell refused \nor failed to answer a number of questions concerning events purportedly occurring 15 years \nprior. See DE 172 at 5-8. Ms. Maxwell pointed this out in her Response. DE 189 at 1 & n. 1 . \nFurther, Plaintiff's argument that Ms. Maxwell did not rely on the Protective Order in sitting for \nthe 7 V2 hour deposition is belied by the record regarding the origins of the Protective Order and \nthe exclusion of non-entered attorneys from attending the deposition. \nAs a last gasp, Plaintiff claims that certain of her \"summary\" bullet points should be \nunsealed because, she claims, the bullet points summarize citations to Ms. Maxwell's deposition \ntranscript that the Second Circuit already unsealed. Resp. at 15-16. This is the proverbial cart \nbefore the horse. Plaintiff's inaccurate \"summaries\" are not judicial documents, nor are the \ndeposition pages to which they cite, and so it is of no moment that the excerpts may have been \nunsealed by the Second Circuit as relates to a pleading which undisputedly was a \"judicial \ndocument.\" \nBut DE 172 contains much more than summaries of Ms. Maxwell's deposition. Plaintiff \nfails to mention that DE 172's redactions also include purported \"summaries\" of Doe 162's \ndeposition and the purported anticipated deposition testimony of Doe 84 (whose name and \ntestimony the Second Circuit redacted in Brown). Both Does\n... [truncated, 2142 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/16 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=16]", "char_count": 2142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Ca\nate.5241\\g0743t114.cAPneDbt0rfieliFtCO20Wale21913.6M82eaftlfraf24Of 22 \ntestifying. Obviously, any ruling on DE 172 is premature in advance of their participation in the \nunsealing protocol. \n3. DE 203, 211 and 224 \nPlaintiff also seeks to unseal certain of the redactions that her counsel made at the time \nshe filed DE 203 (and corrected/amended versions at DE 211 and 224). All of the portions she \ncites include either (a) argument of counsel purporting to summarize the testimony, or \nanticipated testimony, of witnesses Non-Parties who have yet to receive notice or an opportunity \nto be heard pursuant to the Court's protocol, or (b) purport (but fail) to summarize Ms. \nMaxwell's deposition testimony. For the Countervailing Interests 1-4, as well as the fact that the \ninclusion of these materials \"would not have a tendency to influence\" the court's determination \nof the motion and thus fail the \"judicial documents\" test, the cited redactions should remain \nsealed. \n4. DE 173-5, 189, 190, 190-1, 204-1, 204-2, 204-3 (and related 211, 212, 212-1, \n212-2, 212-3, 224) \nEach of these documents include materials pertaining to other Does and any ruling would \nbe premature at this time. \nD. DE 199's Related Pleadings Should Remain Sealed Pending Notification to the \nReferenced Non-Parties Pursuant to this Court's Protocol \nIn DE 199's related pleadings, the redactions and sealed exhibits contain numerous \nreferences to Non-Parties who have yet to be provided notice or an opportunity to be heard \npursuant to his Court's protocol. These include: DE 228 (numerous Non-Parties); 229-1 \n(excerpt of deposition of Doe 151); DE 229-4 (deposition of Plaintiff including multiple Non-\nParty names); DE 229-10 (including Non-Parties); DEs 248, 249-4, 249-13, 249-15, 249-15 \n(same). \n18 \nEFTA00074981\n", "char_count": 1810}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "CaaMIS-41\\.g0743D4A1PneDbalrflefiVtalnOne2E0MIC182eafttljecIf9:10f 22 \nPlaintiff contends that these DEs each should be immediately unsealed, without regard to \nnotice to the Non-Parties discussed therein. She cites no support for doing so and fails to \nacknowledge that her request runs counter not only to this Court's Protocol, but also the Second \nCircuit's requirement in Brown the District Court can \"notify() any outside parties whose privacy \ninterests might be implicated by the unsealing.\" 929 P.2d at 51. Plaintiff's request should be \ndenied. \nE. DE 230 and Related Pleadings \nPlaintiff's response regarding DE 230 is largely the same as her response to DE 199 \ninfra, with one significant exception: buried on page 19 of her Response to Ms. Maxwell's \nObjection to Unsealing, Plaintiff takes the position for the first time that she herself is objecting \nto the unsealing of a number of pleadings because they contain her \"medical records\" or \n\"medical history.\" Resp. at 19. \nOf course, Plaintiff neglected to actually follow this Court's Protocol and object to the \nunsealing by the deadline to do so, June 10, 2020. See DE 1044 at 2(f). Nor did she seek leave \nto file her objection to unsealing out of time, nor explain the \"good cause\" for failing to object on \na timely basis, nor explain why she is making such objection at the end of her response to Ms. \nMaxwell's objection. Without any such request, or leave, this Court should deem her untimely \nobjection to the unsealing of those records waived. See Mattel, Inc. v. Animefien Store, 18 CIV. \n8824 (LAP), 2020 WL 2097624, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. May 1, 2020) (\"By failing either to file their \nreply papers or to request an extension to do so within the allotted time, Defendants waived their \nright a reply.\"). Because the records do not otherwise contain the names of Non-Parties (medical \nproviders having been excluded from the list), and no party has asserted a countervailing interest \nwith respect to those records, they may b\n... [truncated, 2040 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/18 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=18]", "char_count": 2040}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Ca\natE152age/43fittoWneDbtatfieliFtalnOne213913E215320'aeafrff10401 22 \nWith respect to the other DE's related to DE 230, however, those contain the names and \nreferences to numerous Non-Parties apart from Does 1 and 2, and any unsealing determination \nshould await notice and an opportunity to be heard by those Non-Parties. \nConclusion \nFor the foregoing reasons, Ms. Maxwell respectfully requests that the Court grant her \nObjection to Unsealing the following DE's: \nI. 143, 144, 144-1, 144-2, 144-4, 144-5, 144-6, 144-7, 149, 150, 150-1, 152, 153, \n153-1 \n2. 172, 173, 173-5, 173-6, 189, 190, 190-1, 203, 204-1, 204-2, 204-3, 211, 212, 212-\nI, 212-2, 212-3, 224 \nMs. Maxwell respectfully requests that the Court defer ruling on the following pleadings \npending notification to other Non-Parties referenced therein: \nI. 164, 165, 165-3, 165-8, 165-10, 165-11, 184, 185, 185-2, 185-3, 185-11, 185-13, \n184-14, 185-15, 185-16, 194-3. \n2. (Related to 199) 228, 229-; 229-4, 229-10, 248, 249-4, 249-13, 249-15, 249-15. \n3. 230, 235, 235-4, 235-5, 235-7, 235-11, 235-13, 235-14, 260, 268 \nMs. Maxwell has no objection to the immediate unsealing of the following pleadings: \nI. 235-8, 235-6, 235-8, 235-9, 260, 260-1, 260-2, 267, 268-1. \n20 \nEFTA00074983\n", "char_count": 1252}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Ca&Ei.gag074312)4A1PneBbterflellFain0Xlle28913/ila82eaft2j€ (2146f 22 \nDated: July 1, 2020 \nRespectfully submitted, \n/s/ Laura A. Menninger \nLaura A. Menninger (LM-1374) \nJeffrey S. Pagliuca (pro hac vice) \nTy Gee (pro hac vice) \nHaddon, Morgan and Foreman, P.C. \n150 East 10th Avenue \nDenver. CO 80203 \nPhone: \nFax: \nAttorneys for Ghislaine Maxwell \n21 \nEFTA00074984\n", "char_count": 368}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Ca\na:Mag0743tikIcAlPneDbt0rfiefiFO7203(11O3913/%1382eartafr 01246f 22 \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI certify that on July 1, 2020, I electronically served \nObjections to Unsealing Sealed Materials via ECF \nSigrid S. McCawley \nMeredith Schultz \nBOLES, SCHILLER & FLEXN ER, LLP \n401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Ste. 1200 \nFt. Lauderdale. FL 33301 \nBradley J. Edwards \nStan J. Pottinger \nEDWARDS POTTINGER LLC \n425 North Andrews Ave., Ste. 2 \nFt. Lauderdale, FL 33301 \nChristine N. Walz \nSanford L. Bohrer \nCynthia A. Gierhart \nHOLLAND & KNIGHT LLP \n31 West 52' Street \nNew York, NY 10019 \nNicholas J. Lewin \nPaul M. Krieger \nICRIEGER KIM & LEWIN, LLP \n500 Fifth Avenue \nNew York. NY 10110 \nthis Ms. Maxwell's Reply In Support of Her \non the following: \nPaul G. Cassell \n383 S. University Street \nSalt Lake City, UT 84112 \nImran H. Ansari \nAIDALA, BERTUNA & KAMINS, P.C. \n546 Fifth Avenue \n6th Floor \nNew York, NY 10036 \nJay M. Wolman \nMarc J. Randazza \nRANDAZZA LEGAL GROUP, PLLC \n100 Pearl Street, 14th Floor \nIarford m\n CT 06103 \n/s/ Nicole Simmons \nNicole Simmons \n22 \nEFTA00074985\n", "char_count": 1076}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "CaesR294114034B9(1AffenDbOtaneRt3W202( ifi6DOWII/Reglabef140f 3 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK \nX \nPlaintiff, \nv. \nGHISLAINE MAXWELL, \nDefendant. \nX \n15-cv-07,133-RWS \nDeclaration Of Laura A. Menninger In Support Of Ms. Maxwell's \nReply In Support of Her Objection to Unsealing Sealed Materials \nI, Laura A. Menninger, declare as follows: \n1. I am an attorney at law duly licensed in the State of New York and admitted to \npractice in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. I am a \nmember of the law firm Haddon, Morgan & Foreman, P.C., counsel of record for Defendant \nGhislaine Maxwell (\"Maxwell\") in this action. I respectfully submit this declaration in \nsupport of Ms. Maxwell's Reply In Support of Her Objection to Unsealing Sealed Material. \n2. Attached as Exhibit A (filed under seal) are true and correct copies of the certified \nmail return receipts for J. Doe 1 and J. Doe 2. \n3. Attached as Exhibit B (filed under seal) are true and correct copies of excerpts \nfrom the deposition of \ndesignated Confidential under the \nProtective Order. \nEFTA00074986\n", "char_count": 1127}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "CatitsR15840341394AtrenDbetanORtill1202(FiliA96151133./Elegfettef240f 3 \n4. Attached as Exhibit C (filed under seal) are true and correct copies of excerpts \nfrom the deposition of \nI esignated Confidential under \nthe Protective Order. \n5. Attached as Exhibit D (filed under seal) is a true and correct copy of \n6. Attached as Exhibit E is a true and correct copy of an Order Denying Motion to \nJoin Under Rule 21, Doe v. United States, No. 08-80736-Civ-Marra/Johnson (S.D. Fla. Apr. \n7, 2016). \nI declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. \nExecuted on July 1, 2020. \nBy: Is/Laura A. Menninger \nLaura A. Menninger \n2 \nEFTA00074987\n", "char_count": 662}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "CagesR15.614034994AffenDbetanORM242(FiaRaThat/RagEitigef3149f 3 \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI certify that on July 1, 2020, I electronically served this Declaration of Laura A. \nMenninger in Support of Ms. Maxwell's Reply In Support of Her Objection to Unsealing Sealed \nMaterial via ECF on the following: \nSigrid S. McCawley \nMeredith Schultz \nBows, $CHILLER & FLEXNER, LLP \n401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Ste. 1200 \nFt. Lauderdale. FL 33301 \nBradley J. Edwards \nStan J. Pottinger \nEDWARDS POTTINGER LLC \n425 North Andrews Ave., Ste. 2 \nFt. Lauderdale, FL 33301 \nChristine N. Walz \nSanford L Bohrer \nCynthia A. Gierhart \nHOLLAND & KNIGHT LLP \n31 West 52s  Street \nNew York. NY 10019 \nNicholas J. Lewin \nPaul M. Krieger \nKRIEGER KIM & LEWIN, LLP \n500 Fifth Avenue \nNew York NY 10110 \nPaul G. Cassell \n383 S. University Street \nSalt Lake City, UT 84112 \nImran H. Ansari \nAIDALA, BERTUNA & KAMINS, P.C. \n546 Fifth Avenue \n6th Floor \nNew York, NY 10036 \nJay M. Wolman \nMarc J. Randazza \nRANDAZZA LEGAL GROUP, PLLC \n100 Pearl Street, 14th Floor \nS\nartford, CT 06103 \nIs/ Nicole Simmons \nNicole Simmons \n3 \nEFTA00074988\n", "char_count": 1110}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "ca4leml.tba,BM3c.mentotitrdeeiMrt4020FIIKIOSaai'awePeod 403f 1 \nEXHIBIT A \nFILED UNDER SEAL \nEFTA00074989\n", "char_count": 106}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Ca<teVigetatrAMMAPIeMotliMae&IS/2020A1958433PAVeng, 4(bf \nEXHIBIT B \nFILED UNDER SEAL \nEFTA00074990\n", "char_count": 100}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "CaeelaVkatr413actPleCtotikaeff1012020,F3HEISMIP.B.M9, 4(bf \nEXHIBIT C \nFILED UNDER SEAL \nEFTA00074991\n", "char_count": 102}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "CaeatellWAVAMactMeCtotliMiieff1012020,F3HEISMPAVeftg, 4(bf \nEXHIBIT D \nFILED UNDER SEAL \nEFTA00074992\n", "char_count": 102}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "casgasefabalitilatARnertddiMel07180.4ffiCFNSOMRagoaftjaftfif 11 \nEXHIBIT E \nEFTA00074993\n", "char_count": 89}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 9:08CeisiktstPW4MS\n1904WgicilkithfcMk \n04A401140f Mtge 1 of 10 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nCASE NO.:08-CV-80736-ICAM \nJANE DOE 1 and JANE DOE 2, \nPetitioners, \nvs. \nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA, \nRespondent. \nORDER DENYING PETITIONERS' MOTION TO JOIN UNDER RULE 21 AND \nMOTION TO AMEND UNDER RULE 15 \nThis cause is before the Court on Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4's Corrected Motion \nPursuant to Rule 21 for Joinder in Action (\"Rule 21 Motion\") (DE 280), and Jane Doe 1 and Jane \nDoe 2's Protective Motion Pursuant to Rule 15 to Amend Their Pleadings to Conform to \nExisting Evidence and to Add Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 as Petitioners (\"Rule 15 Motion\") (DE \n311). Both motions are ripe for review. For the following reasons, the Court concludes that they \nshould be denied. \nI. Background \nThis is an action by two unnamed petitioners, Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2, seeking to \nprosecute a claim under the Crime Victims' Rights Act (CVRA), 18 U.S.C. § 3771. (DE I). \nGenerally, they allege that the respondent Government violated their rights under the CVRA by \nfailing to consult with them before negotiating a non-prosecution agreement with Jeffrey Epstein, \nwho subjected them to various sexual crimes while they were minors. (Id.). Petitioners initiated \nthis action in July 2008. (Id.). \nEFTA00074994\n", "char_count": 1336}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 9:08C-646iigingkON4N9c#1\n04eigkiltiliWik \nndie4VaitiV Page 2 of 10 \nOn December 30, 2014, two other unnamed victims, Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4, moved \nto join as petitioners in this action pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 21. (DE 280). \nPetitioners (Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2) support the Rule 21 Motion. (IA at 11). Jane Doe 3 and \nJane Doe 4 argue that they \"have suffered the same violations of their rights under the [CVRA] \nas the\" Petitioners, and they \"desire to join in this action to vindicate their rights as well.\" a \nat \nI). The Government vehemently opposes joinder under Rule 21. (DE 290). The Government \nargues that Rule 15 is the proper procedural device for adding parties to an action, not Rule 21. \n(a. at 1). \n\"[O]ut of an abundance of caution,\" Petitioners filed a motion to amend their petition \nunder Rule 15, conforming the petition to the evidence and adding Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 as \npetitioners. (DE 311 at 2). The Government opposes the Rule 15 Motion as well. (DE 314). \nAmong other things, the Government argues that amending the petition to include Jane Doe 3 \nand Jane Doe 4 should be denied because of their undue delay in seeking to join the proceedings, \nand the undue prejudice that amendment will cause. (a.). \nAfter considering the parties' submissions and the proposed amended petition, the Court \nfinds that justice does not require amendment in this instance and exercises its discretion to deny \nthe amendment. \nII. Discussion \n\"The decision whether to grant leave to amend a complaint is within the sole discretion of \nthe district court.\" Laurie v. Ala. Ct. Crim. Apps. 256 F.3d 1266, 1274 (11th Cir. 2001). \"The \ncourt should freely give leave when justice so requires.\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 15(a)(2). Justice does \nnot require amendment in several instances, \"includ[ing] undue delay, bad faith, dilatory motive \n2 \nEFTA00074995\n", "char_count": 1891}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 9:08C431485MWMAMAtikkiftglint*WWW&W \nPftWOROWNitigfif ilige 3 of 10 \non the part of the movant, . . . undue prejudice to the opposing party by virtue of allowance of the \namendment, [and] futility of amendment.'\" Laurie, 256 F.3d at 1274 (quoting Foman v. Davis, \n371 U.S. 178, 182 (1962)). In addition to considering the effect of amendment on the parties, the \ncourt must consider \"the importance of the amendment on the proper determination of the merits \nof a dispute.\" 6 Wright & Miller, Fed. Prac. & Fed. P. § 1488, p. 814 (3d ed. 2010). Justice does \nnot require amendment where the addition of parties with duplicative claims will not materially \nadvance the resolution of the litigation on the merits. See Herring v. Delta Air Lines, Inc., 894 \nF.2d 1020, 1024 (9th Cir. 1989). \nA. \nRule 21 Motion \nJane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4's first attempt to join in this proceeding was brought under \nRule 21. (DE 280). \"If parties seek to add a party under Rule 21, courts generally use the \nstandard of Rule 15, governing amendments to pleadings, to determine whether to allow the \naddition.\" 12 Wright & Miller, Fed. Prac. & Fed. P., p. 432 (3d ed. 2013)• see also Galustian v. \nPeter, 591 F.3d 724, 729-30 (4th Cir. 2010) (collecting cases and noting that Rule 15(a) applies \nto amendments seeking to add parties); Frank v. U.S. West, Inc., 3 F.3d 1357, 1365 (10th Cir. \n1993) (\"A motion to add a party is governed by Fed. R. Civ. P. 15(a) ....\"). \nRule 21, \"Misjoinder and Non-joinder of Parties,\" provides the court with a tool for \ncorrecting the \"misjoinder\" of parties that would otherwise result in dismissal. Fed. R. Civ. P. \n21. Insofar as Rule 21 \"relates to the addition of parties, it is intended to permit the bringing in \nof a person, who through inadvertence, mistake or for some other reason, had not been made a \nparty and whose presence as a party is later found necessary or desirable.\" United States v. Com. \nBank of N. Am., 31 F.R.D. 133, 135 (S.D.N.Y. 1962) (internal quotati\n... [truncated, 2036 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/32 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=32]", "char_count": 2036}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 9:oscasticingte\n4SAiii4V0004617647Wk r' \n6%444Vgit \nPrSof ilage 4 of 10 \nIn their Rule 21 Motion, Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 do not claim that they were omitted \nfrom this proceeding due to any \"inadvertence\" or \"mistake\" by Petitioners; rather, they seek to \njoin this proceeding as parties that could have been permissively joined in the original petition \nunder Rule 20 (\"Permissive Joinder of Parties\"). As courts generally use the standards of Rule \n15 to evaluate such circumstances, the Court will consider the joinder issue as presented in the \nRule 15 Motion.' The Court will consider the arguments presented in the Rule 21 Motion as if \nthey are set forth in the Rule 15 Motion as well. Because the arguments are presented in the Rule \n15 Motion (and because the Court is denying the Rule 15 Motion on its merits, as discussed \nbelow), the Rule 21 Motion will be denied. \nThe Court also concludes that portions of the Rule 21 Motion—and related \nfilings—should be stricken from the record. Pending for this Court's consideration is a Motion \nfor Limited Intervention filed by Alan M. Dershowitz, who seeks to intervene to \"strike the \noutrageous and impertinent allegations made against him and [to] request[] a show cause order to \nthe attorneys that have made them.\" (DE 282 at 1). The Court has considered Mr. Dershowitz's \narguments, but it finds that his intervention is unnecessary as Federal Rule of Civil Procedure \n12(f) empowers the Court \"on its own\" to \"strike from a pleading an insufficient defense or any \nredundant, immaterial, impertinent, or scandalous matter.\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(0. \nPetitioners' Rule 21 Motion consists of relatively little argumentation regarding why the \nCourt should permit them to join in this action: they argue that (1) they were sexually abused by \nThe Court notes that, regardless of which motion it considers, the same standard \ngoverns the addition of parties under Rule 21 and Rule 15. See Goston v. Potter, No. 08-cv-478 \nFJS ATB, 2010 W\n... [truncated, 2151 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/33 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=33]", "char_count": 2151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 9:08Ce;14€410WW4MAIPReV94101WalThagit \nPairogumksof Ilige 5 of 10 \nJeffrey Epstein, and (2) the Government violated their CVRA rights by concealing the non-\nprosecution agreement with them. (DE 280 at 3; see id. at 7-8). However, the bulk of the Rule \n21 Motion consists of copious factual details that Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 \"would prove\" \"[i]f \nallowed to join this action.\" (a at 3, 7). Specifically, Jane Doe 3 proffers that she could prove \nthe circumstances under which a non-party introduced her to Mr. Epstein, and how Mr. Epstein \nsexually trafficked her to several high-profile non-party individuals, \"including numerous \nprominent American politicians, powerful business executives, foreign presidents, a well-known \nPrime Minister, and other world leaders.\" (Id. at 3-6). She names several individuals, and she \noffers details about the type of sex acts performed and where they took place. \nid. at 5).2\nAt this juncture in the proceedings, these lurid details are unnecessary to the \ndetermination of whether Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 should be permitted to join Petitioners' \nclaim that the Government violated their rights under the CVRA. The factual details regarding \nwith whom and where the Jane Does engaged in sexual activities are immaterial and impertinent \nto this central claim (i.e., that they were known victims of Mr. Epstein and the Government owed \nthem CVRA duties), especially considering that these details involve non-parties who are not \nrelated to the respondent Government. These unnecessary details shall be stricken. \nThe original Rule 21 Motion (DE 279) shall be stricken in its entirety, as it is wholly \nsuperseded by the \"corrected\" version of the Rule 21 Motion (DE 280). From the corrected Rule \n21 Motion, the Court shall strike all factual details regarding Jane Doe 3 between the following \nsentences: \"The Government then concealed from Jane Doe #3 the existence of its NPA from \nJane Doe 4's proffer is limited to sexual acts between Mr. Epste\n... [truncated, 2055 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/34 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=34]", "char_count": 2055}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 9:08CalisOISSPNWIMMISIIP§MnegialtqffeMit \nffigkiF04035fteNg Rage 6 of 10 \nJane Doe #3, in violation of her rights under the CVRA\" (id. at 3); and \"The Government was \nwell aware of Jane Doe #3 when it was negotiating the NPA, as it listed her as a victim in the \nattachment to the NPA\" (iij at 6). As none of Jane Doe 4's factual details relate to non-parties, \nthe Court finds it unnecessary to strike the portion of the Rule 21 Motion related to her \ncircumstances. Regarding the Declaration in support of Petitioners' response to Mr. \nDershowitz's motion to intervene (DE 291-1), the Court shall strike paragraphs 4, 5, 7, 11, 13, \n15, 19 through 53, and 59, as they contain impertinent details regarding non-parties. Regarding \nthe Declaration of Jane Doe 3 in support of the Rule 21 Motion (DE 310-1), the Court shall strike \nparagraphs 7 through 12, 16, 39, and 49, as they contain impertinent details regarding non-\nparties. Jane Doe 3 is free to reassert these factual details through proper evidentiary proof, \nshould Petitioners demonstrate a good faith basis for believing that such details are pertinent to a \nmatter presented for the Court's consideration. \nAs mentioned, Mr. Dershowitz moves to intervene \"for the limited purposes of moving to \nstrike the outrageous and impertinent allegations made against him and requesting a show cause \norder to the attorneys that have made them.\" (DE 282 at 1). As the Court has taken it upon itself \nto strike the impertinent factual details from the Rule 21 Motion and related filings, the Court \nconcludes that Mr. Derschowitz's intervention in this case is unnecessary. Accordingly, his \nmotion to intervene will be denied as moot.3 Regarding whether a show cause order should \n3 This also moots Mr. Dershowitz's Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Reply in \nSupport of Motion for Limited Intervention. (DE 317). Denying Mr. Dershowitz's motion to \nintervene also renders moot Petitioners' motion (DE 292) to file a sealed document supp\n... [truncated, 2173 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/35 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=35]", "char_count": 2173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 9:08CasktstWits4114Nti~g\nrk \n?04iftiagti301ktge 7 of 10 \nissue, the Court finds that its action of striking the lurid details from Petitioners' submissions is \nsanction enough. However, the Court cautions that all counsel are subject to Rule 11's mandate \nthat all submissions be presented for a proper purpose and factual contentions have evidentiary \nsupport, Fed. R. Civ. P. 11(b)(1) and (3), and that the Court may, on its own, strike from any \npleading \"any redundant, immaterial, impertinent, or scandalous matter,\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(f). \nB. \nRule 15 Motion \nBetween their two motions (the Rule 21 Motion and Rule 15 Motion), Jane Doe 3 and \nJane Doe 4 assert that \"they desire to join in this action to vindicate their rights [under the \nCVRAJ as well.\" (DE 280 at 1). Although Petitioners already seek the invalidation of Mr. \nEpstein's non-prosecution agreement on behalf of all \"other similarly-situated victims\" (DE 189 \nat 1; DE 311 at 2, 12, 15, 18-19), Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 argue that they should be fellow \ntravelers in this pursuit, lest they \"be forced to file a separate suit raising their claims\" resulting \nin \"duplicative litigation\" (DE 280 at 11). The Court finds that justice does not require adding \nnew parties this late in the proceedings who will raise claims that are admittedly \"duplicative\" of \nthe claims already presented by Petitioners. \nThe Does' submissions demonstrate that it is entirely unnecessary for Jane Doe 3 and \nJane Doe 4 to proceed as parties in this action, rather than as fact witnesses available to offer \nrelevant, admissible, and non-cumulative testimony. (See, e.g., DE 280 at 2 (Jane Doe 3 and \nJane Doe 4 \"are in many respects similarly situated to the current victims\"), 9 (\"The new victims \nwill establish at trial that the Government violated their CVRA rights in the same way as it \nviolated the rights of the other victims.\"), 10 (Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 \"will simply join in \nmotions that the current victims were going to fi\n... [truncated, 2067 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/36 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=36]", "char_count": 2067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 9:08CeS7WOW4NtiliWitgaiDgMlieLACINWit ,..!' \nF04 \n9V Page 8 of 10 \nJane Doe 4's claims would be \"duplicative\"); DE 298 at 1 n.1 (\"As promised ... Jane Doe No. 3 \nand Jane Doe No. 4 do not seek to expand the number of pleadings filed in this case. If allowed \nto join this action, they would simply support the pleadings already being filed by Jane Doe No. 1 \nand Jane Doe No. 2.\"); DE 311 at 5 n.3 (\"[A]ll four victims (represented by the same legal \ncounsel) intend to coordinate efforts and avoid duplicative pleadings.\"), 15 (Jane Doe 3 and Jane \nDoe 4 \"challenge the same secret agreement—i.e., the NPA that the Government executed with \nEpstein and then concealed from the victims. This is made clear by the proposed amendment \nitself, in which all four victims simply allege the same general facts.\")). As the Does argue at \nlength in their Rule 15 Motion, Jane Doe l's original petition \"specifically allege[s] that the \nGovernment was violating not only her rights but the rights of other similarly-situated victims.\" \n(DE 311 at 2). The Court fails to see why the addition of \"other similarly-situated victims\" is \nnow necessary to \"vindicate their rights as well.\" (DE 280 at 1). \nOf course, Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 can participate in this litigated effort to vindicate \nthe rights of similarly situated victims—there is no requirement that the evidentiary proof \nsubmitted in this case come only from the named parties. Petitioners point out as much, noting \nthat, regardless of whether this Court grants the Rule 15 Motion, \"they will call Jane Doe No. 3 \nas a witness at any trial.\" (DE 311 at 17 n.7). The necessary \"participation\" of Jane Doe 3 and \nJane Doe 4 in this case can be satisfied by offering their properly supported—and relevant, \nadmissible, and non-cumulative—testimony as needed, whether through testimony at trial \nsee DE 280 at 9) or affidavits submitted to support the relevancy of discovery requests' (see \n° The non-party Jane Does clearly understand how to \n... [truncated, 2060 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/37 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=37]", "char_count": 2060}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 9:Oce\nilticiiiictiRatt\ngraMilagt4teS0\n11%-bfFSalge 9 of 10 \nid. at 10). Petitioners do not contend that Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4's \"participation in this \ncase\" can only be achieved by listing them as parties. \nAs it stands under the original petition, the merits of this case will be decided based on a \ndetermination of whether the Government violated the rights of Jane Doe 1, Jane Doe 2, and all \n\"other similarly situated victims\" under the CVRA. Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 may offer \nrelevant, admissible, and non-cumulative evidence that advances that determination, but their \nparticipation as listed parties is not necessary in that regard. See Herring, 894 F.2d at 1024 \n(District court did not abuse its discretion by denying amendment where \"addition of more \nplaintiffs . . . would not have affected the issues underlying the grant of summary judgment.\"); cf. \nArthur v. Stem, 2008 WL 2620116, at *7 (S.D. Tex. 2008) (Under Rule 15, \"courts have held \nthat leave to amend to assert a claim already at issue in [another lawsuit] should not be granted if \nthe same parties are involved, the same substantive claim is raised, and the same relief is \nsought.\" ).3 And, as to Jane Doe 4 at least, adding her as a party raises unnecessary questions \nabout whether she is a proper party to this action.' \nPetitioners also admit that amending the petition to conform to the evidence—by \nincluding references to the non-prosecution agreement itself-is \"unnecessary\" as the \"existing \npetition is broad enough to cover the developing evidence in this case.\" (DE 311). The Court \nThe Court expresses no opinion at this time whether any of the attestations made by \nJane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 in support of their motion will be relevant, admissible, and non-\ncumulative.\nThe Govemment contends that Jane Doe 4 is not a true \"victim\" in this case because \nshe was not known at the time the Government negotiated the non-prosecution agreement, and \naccordingly she was not entitled to notification\n... [truncated, 2216 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00074964/38 or ?id=EFTA00074964&page=38]", "char_count": 2216}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00074964", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 9:oacastiMatttlafiltRIN0444144444ES34§44a601S1,40432tie 10 of 10 \nagrees, and it concludes that justice does not require amending the petition this late in the \nproceedings. \nIII. Conclusion \nAccordingly, it is hereby ORDERED AND ADJUDGED as follows: the Rule 21 Motion \n(DE 280) is DENIED; the Rule 15 Motion (DE 311) is DENIED; Intervenor Dershowitz's \nMotion for Limited Intervention (DE 282) and Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Reply in \nSupport of Motion for Limited Intervention (DE 317) are DENIED AS MOOT; Petitioners' \nMotion to Seal (DE 292) is DENIED AS MOOT; the following materials are hereby \nSTRICKEN from the record: \nDE 279, in its entirety. \nDE 280, all sentences between the following sentences: \n\"The Government then concealed from Jane Doe #3 the \nexistence of its NPA from Jane Doe #3, in violation of her \nrights under the CVRA\" (DE 280 at 3); and \"The \nGovernment was well aware of Jane Doe #3 when it was \nnegotiating the NPA, as it listed her as a victim in the \nattachment to the NPA\" (DE 280 at 6). \nDE 291-1, paragraphs 4, 5, 7, 11, 13, 15, 19 through 53, \nand 59. \nDE 310-1, paragraphs 7 through 12, 16, 39, and 49. \nDE 293, in its entirety. \nDONE AND ORDERED in chambers at West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, \nFlorida, this 611' day of April, 2015. \nKENNETH A. MARRA \nUnited States District Judge \n10 \nEFTA00075003\n", "char_count": 1358}]}