{"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_count": 11, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00067353", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00067353.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nSUMMARY OF MISCONDUCT ISSUES IN THE MATTER OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN \nThe manner in \nwhich federal prosecutors have pursued the allegations against Mr. Epstein is highly irregular \nand warrants full review by the Department. While we repeatedly have raised our concerns \nregarding misconduct with the United States Attorney's Office in Miami (the \"USAO\"), not only \nhas it has remained unwilling to address these issues, but Mr. Epstein's defense counsel has been \ninstructed to limit its contact to the very prosecutors who are the subject of this misconduct \ncomplaint. For your review, this document summarizes the USAO's conduct in this case. \nBackground \n1. \nIn March 2005, the Palm Beach Police Department opened a criminal investigation of \nPalm Beach resident, Jeffrey E. Epstein. The press has widely reported that Mr. Epstein \nis a close friend of former President Bill Clinton. \n2. \nIn July 2006, after an intensive probe, including interviews of dozens of witnesses, \nreturns of numerous document subpoenas, multiple trash pulls and the execution of a \nsearch warrant on his residence, Mr. Epstein was indicted by a Florida Grand Jury on one \ncount of felony solicitation of prostitution. \n3. \nIn a publicly released letter, Palm Beach Police Chief Michael Reiter criticized the Grand \nJury's decision and the State Attorney's handling of the case. Shortly after the Grand \nJury's indictment, the Chief took the unprecedented step of releasin his Department's \nraw police reports of the investigation (including Detective \nunedited written \nreports of witness statements and witness identification information), that were later \nproven to be highly inaccurate transcriptions of witnesses' actual statements. The Chief \nalso publicly asked federal authorities to prosecute the case. \nBecomes Involved in Mr. Epstein's Case at the Earliest Stage \n4. \nIn early November of 2006, Epstein's law ers had their initial contact with the newly \nassigned line federal prosecutor, \n... [truncated, 2927 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/0 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=0]", "char_count": 2927}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nsame individual had previously fled the home of another neighbor after entering that \nhouse uninvited, when, looking for the bedroom of their 17-year-old daughter, he \nmistakenly entered the bedroom of their 14-year-old daughter, touched her on the leg and \nstartled her awake. State of Florida v. Johnathan Jeffrey Zirulnikoff, Case No. F078646 \n(June 28, 2007). \n7. \nAfter a thorough review by the Miami State Attorney's Office, and sex-crimes prosecutor \nLaura Adams, the investigation revealed that the defendant and both the neighbor's 17-\nyear-old daughter and Mr. \ndaughter were previously acquainted. \nThe \ndefendant was charged with simple trespass in connection with his unauthorized entry \ninto the neighbor's house. Id. \n8. \nFAUSA \nhowever, demanded that the young man be registered as a sex offender \nand objected to any sentence short of incarceration. The Assistant State Attorney in \ncharge of the sex-crimes unit reported Mr. \nconduct during the proceedings as \n\"outrageous.\" The defendant's attorney described Mr. \nas being \"out of control.\" \nShortly after, Mr. \nbegan publicly deriding the elected State Attorney, his office \nand the state process for prosecuting sex offenses, as \"a joke.\" \nUnauthorized Tactics in Disregard of the United States Attorney's Manual are Used \n9. \nIn June 2007, AUSA \nsubpoenaed the investigating agent of Epstein's attorney, \nRoy Black, in a clear effort to invade the defense camp. The subpoena was specifically \ndrafted to discover the investigator's contacts with all prospective witnesses, Mr. Epstein \nand his attorneys.' Not surprisingly, Ms. \nissued this subpoena without the \nrequisite prior approval by the DOJ's Office of Enforcement Operations. See United \nStates Attorneys' Manual, § 9-13.410. When confronted, she misleadingly responded \nthat she had consulted with the Department of Justice and was not required to obtain \n0E0 approval because her subpoena was not directed to \"an office phuicall located \nwithin \n... [truncated, 3583 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/1 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=1]", "char_count": 3583}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nMr. Epstein is Required to Agree to Civil Liability In Order to Avoid a Federal Indictment \n10. \nOn Jul 31, 2007, during ne otiations over a possible federal plea agreement, FAUSA \nand AUSA \ndemanded that Mr. Epstein agree to the imposition of civil \nliability under 18 U.S.C. § 2255 as a pre-condition to deferral of federal prosecution. To \nthe best of our knowledge, the inclusion of such a term in a deferred prosecution \nagreement of this kind is absolutely unprecedented.3 \nSpecifically, Ms. \ndemanded that Mr. Epstein waive the right to contest civil liability to a list of individuals \nshe said were \"victims\" of § 2255, whose names, however, she refused to disclose, and \nagree to pay damages of a minimum of $150,000 to each and every one of such \nundisclosed individuals, and hire an attorney to represent them if they decided to sue \nhim. See Tab 20, July 31, 2007 Draft of Deferred Prosecution Agreement. \n11. \nFAUSA \nand AUSA \ninsisted that the identities of the individuals on the \nlist not be disclosed to Mr. Epstein or his counsel until after Mr. Epstein was already \nsentenced in the state case. \n(a) \nOver the next two months, Mr. \nrefused to negotiate these terms. They \nultimately became incorporated into the final deferred prosecution agreement. \nSee Tab 21, September 24, 2007 Non-Prosecution Agreement, ¶¶ 7-11. \n(b) \nIt was not until seven months later, in February 2008, that Epstein's lawyers were \nable to take their first official statement from one of the women FAUSA \nalleged were minor victims of federal offenses. \n(c) \nThis statement, a deposition of \nthe initial complainant in the state \ncase, taken in the presence of her lawyer, proved that none of the necessary \nelements for any federal charge could be satisfied based on Ms. \nbrief \ncontact with Mr. Epstein. The witness also admitted lying to Mr. Epstein, \ntestifying that she told him that she was an adult and wanted him to believe that \nshe was an adult. See Tab 13, \nTr. (depositi\n... [truncated, 2900 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/2 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=2]", "char_count": 2900}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \n12. \nIn August 2007, in a clear attempt to coerce a state settlement, Ms. \nthreatened \nto broaden the investigation to include a money laundering violation (18 U.S.C. § 1956), \nthough all the funds expended were simply Mr. Epstein's, and a violation for operating an \nunlicensed money-transmitting business (18 U.S.C. § 1960), thougb \nnever \nhad such a business. See Tab 22, August 31, 2007 Letter from M. \nto \n(reciting, in a target letter to one of Epstein's employees, that the investigation concerns \n\"suspected violations of federal law, including but not limited to, possible violations of \nTitle 18, United States Code, Sections . . . 1591, ... 1956, 1960 . . . .\") (emphasis \nadded). \n13. \nOn the very same day that the grand jury issued subpoenas to the records-custodian and \nem to\n of Epstein's businesses for all financial transactions from 2003 forward, Ms. \n(who we were told was not authorized to act in this regard without supervisory \napproval) promised to close the money-laundering investigation \"if the sex offense case \nis resolved.\" See Tab 23, August 16, 2007 Letter from,. \nto G. Lefcourt (\"In \nother words, if the sex offense case is resolved, the Office would close its investigation \ninto other areas as well. The matter has not been, and it does not appear that it will be, \nresolved so the money laundering investigation continues, and Request Number 6 \n[seeking records of every financial 'transaction conducted by Epstein and his six \nbusinesses from \"January 1, 2003 to the present\"] will not be withdrawn.\"). \n14. \nTwo weeks later, when Mr. Epstein continued to oppose federal prosecution during \nnegotiations and Mr. Epstein's counsel sought a meeting with the United States Attorney, \nAUSA \nthen classified all of Mr. Epstein's assistants as targets (sending a target \nletter to one of them and promising the attorney of the other two that additional target \nletters would be served on them as well), dispatched FBI agents to the homes of two \n... [truncated, 3328 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/3 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=3]", "char_count": 3328}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nemailed the defense stating that United States Attorney Acosta would accept no \nless than 18 months of incarceration, following by a one-year term of house arrest. \nFederal Prosecutors Misrepresented the Number of Alleged \"Victims.\" \n17. \nIn September 2007, in order to add additional pressure on Mr. Epstein to execute a \ndeferred prosecution agreement, AUSA \nclaimed that there were \"40\" minors on \nthe government's list of purported § 2255 victims. To compound that misleading \ncharacterization, she continued to insist that a guardian-ad-litem be appointed to represent \nthese suu .or\nlysl \"minors\" in the proceedings. See Tab 24, September 19, 2007 Email \nfrom M. \nto J. Lefkowitz. \n18. \nWhen challenged as to whether there was a genuine need for a guardian, given that Ms. \ncontinued to refuse to disclose the names or any other information about her \nputative list of \"minors,\" she eventually conceded that only \"1 is definitely under l8 still, \nand I think there is another minor.\" See Tab 25, September 23, 2007 Email from \nto J. Lefkowitz (emphasis added). \n19. \nThe next day, AUSA \nretreated from the number \"40,\" stating that she had now \n\"compiled a list of 34 confirmed minor victims with no definition of how they would be \nconsidered as such.. There are six others, whose names we already have, who need to be \ninterviewed by the FBI to confirm whether they were 17 or 18 at the time of their activity \nwith Mr. Epstein.\" See Tab 26, September 24, 2007 Email from E. \nto J. \nLefkowitz (emphasis added). This statement indicated that, at least the \"six others\" (and, \nas it turns out, all those identified except two) had reached the age of majority, and, in \nfact, no guardian was necessary to represent their interests. \nDefense Counsel was Falsely Advised That the Non Prosecution Agreement Would Be Kept \nConfidential. \n20. \nOn September 24, Epstein and the USAO executed a Non Prosecution Agreement. \n21. \nHis attorneys asked Ms. \nto \"please do whatever you \n... [truncated, 2733 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/4 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=4]", "char_count": 2733}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nTab 18, December 13, 2007 Letter from N. \noccurred \"shortly after the signing\"). \n(admitting that the notification \nAUSA \nMisleads Mr. Epstein In An Attempt To Refer Plaintiffs to Her \nBoyfriend's Close Friend \n25. \nOn September 25, Ms. \nrecommended a local products-liability defense \nattorney, Humberto \"Bert\" Ocariz, Esq., for the highly lucrative post of attorney \nrepresentative for the government's list of as-yet-undisclosed \"victims.\"' \n(a) \nMs. \nwrote to the defense, \"I have never met Bert, but a good friend in \nour appellate section and one of the district judges in Miami are good friends \nwith him and recommended him.\" See Tab 28, September 25, 2007 Email from \nIl• \nto J. Lefkowitz (bottom email) (emphasis added). \n(b) \nMs. \nfailed to disclose that this \"good friend in our appellate section\" \nwas her live-in boyfriend. See Tab 18, December 13, 2007 Letter from E. \n(conceding the \"relationship\" with \"my boyfriend\"). \nBeyond her clear conflict-of-interest and affirmative effort to conceal it, it is \nunimaginable that AUSA \nwould have engaged in an ex-parte \ncommunication with a United States District Judge in the same district about the \ndetails of a pending grand-jury investigation without prior disclosure and \nsupervisory approval. \n(c) \n(d) \nLater, it became clear that Ms. \nalso had at least one other ex-parte \ncommunication with that same United States District Judge about lei . \njury's \ninvestigation. See Tab 29, October 5, 2007 Email from II. \nto J. \nLefkowitz (stating that \"one of the District Judges in Miami mentioned [retired \nJudge Joseph Hatchett] as a good choice\" to decide any fee disputes concerning \nEpstein's paying for a lawyer to represent the unnamed women in claims against \nEpstein). \n26. \nThe next day, AUSA \nadvised the defense that she was removing one of the \nalternatives to Mr. Ocariz from our consideration, on the basis that \"one of his partners is \nmarried to an AUSA here,\" and explained that, because of that perso\n... [truncated, 2982 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/5 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=5]", "char_count": 2982}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \n\"[tjhere is too great a chance of an appearance of impropriety.\" See Tab 28, September \n26, 2007 Email from,. \nto J. Lefkowitz. \n27. \nThe following day, Ms. \nrelayed that, and asked us to respond to, the very first \nconcern raised Mr. Ocariz, which was \"how are they going to get paid\" and whether \n\"there is any cap or other limitation on attorney's fees that E stein] will pay in the civil \ncase.\" See Tab 30, September 27, 2007 Email from,. \nto J. Lefkowitz. \n28. \nMs. \nclearly contemplated that Mr. Epstein would be paying for Mr. Ocariz at \nhis \"hourly rate\" to represent the alleged \"victims\" against Epstein even \"if all [the] girls \ndecide they want to sue.\" Id. \n29. \nWhen the defense complained of Ms. \nundisclosed conflict-of-interest in \nselecting her boyfriend's friend to prosecute civil claims a ainst Mr. Epstein on behalf of \nher undisclosed list of purported \"victims,\" Ms. \nlater argued that Mr. Epstein \nhad no right to complain because \"the Non-Prosecution Agreement vested the Office with \nthe exclusive right to select the attorney representative.\" See Tab 18, December 13, 2007 \nLetter from,.. \nShortly after being notified, however, United States Attorney \nAcosta removed Mr. Ocariz from consideration, and requested an amendment to the Non \nProsecution Agreement. \n30. \nIn response to the many complaints about Ms. \nmisconduct and violations of \nthe United States Attorney's Manual, Criminal Division Chief \ncharacterized her as \"unsupervisable.\" \n31. \nContrary to the express agreement of United States Attorney Acosta that the federal \ngovernment would not interfere in the administration of any state sentence, FAUSA \ncontinued to try to deny the right of the State to issue work release and/or gain \ntime by stating that Mr. Epstein must \"make a binding recommendation that the Court \nimpose\" a sentence of 18 months of continuous confinement in the county jail. See Tab \n21, September 24, 2007 Non Prosecution Agreement. Shortly thereafter, Mr. \ns\n... [truncated, 3031 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/6 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=6]", "char_count": 3031}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \ndemand, other than to protect prospective plaintiffs from \nSI\ncinterviewed \nprior to their retaining an attorney (including, as it turned out, Mr. \nformer law \npartner) to bring civil lawsuits against Epstein. \n35. \nMr. \nalso demanded that Epstein \"begin his term of incarceration not later than \nJanuary 4, 2008,\" id., which turned out to be just three weeks before the first civil lawsuit \nwould be filed against Epstein. \n36. \nContrary to the express agreement of United States Attorney Acosta that the federal \ngovernment would not interfere in the administration of any state sentence, Mr. \ntried to limit gain time and or work release by stating that Mr. Epstein must \"make a \nbinding recommendation that the Court impose a sentence of 18 months of continuous \nconfinement in the county jail.\" Id. (This followed Mr. \nposition that the Office \nwould consider a state sentence ordering probation in lieu of incarceration to be a breach \nof the deferred-prosecution agreement.) Shortly thereafter, Mr. \nsent the FBI to \nmeet with the state sex-crimes prosecutor in an attempt to secure her commitment to \noppose work release. \n37. \nMr. \ninsisted that Mr. Epstein not learn the identities of the government's list of \nalleged \"victims\" until after Epstein was sentenced and incarcerated. \n38. \nWe have reason to believe that, around this same time, Mr. \nformer law parrert \nr\nhad met with the father of one of the prospective plaintiffs, \nthe same time (and until as receriss March of 2008), the Official \nFlorida Bar website continued to identify Mr. \nas a named partner in Mr. \nfirm.  See Tab 31, Florida Bar Website page. \n39. \nwho is the named partner in the former firm of \nfiled five lawsuits, each asking for $50 million, against Mr. Epstein. Each \nawsut is entitled \"Jane Doe # vs. Jeffrey Epstein,\" despite the fact that each of the \nplaintiffs is an adult and not entitled to plead anonymously. See Tab 32, Examples of \nFederal Complaints. \n40. \nMr. \nconvened press\n... [truncated, 3041 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/7 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=7]", "char_count": 3041}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nEpstein. \nAll of these plaintiffs are apparently on the above-described government \n\"victim\" list. \nFAUSA \nAttempts to Encourage Civil Suits and the Hiring of the Government's \nChoice of Attorney \n41. \nOn November 27, Mr. \nsent an email to Mr. Epstein's attorneys stating that \"I \nintend to notify the victims by letter after COB Thursday [two days later].\" See Tab 34, \nNovember 27, 2007 Email from J. \nto J. Leflcowitz. \n42. \nThe morning of November 28, attorneys for Mr. Epstein faxed a letter to Assistant \nAttorney General Alice Fisher, requesting a meeting with her to discuss the impropriety \nof the USAO's encouraging civil lawsuits against Mr. Epstein under the guise of the \nterms of the Non Prosecution Agreement. See Tab 35, November 28, 2007 Letter from \nK. Starr to A. Fisher. \n43. \nLate in the day on November 28, Epstein's attorneys received from AUSA \na \ncopy of the USAO's proposed victim-notification letter that \nasked that I \nforward.\" See Tab 36, November 28, 2007 Email from.. \nto J. Lefkowitz. \n(a) \nThe proposed victim-notification letter cited as authority the \"Justice for All Act \nof 2004\" (which U.S. Attorney Acosta later agreed had no application to these \ncircumstances). It referred to the addressees as minor \"victims,\" suggested they \nmake statements in state court, that they were not entitled to make, and referred \nincorrectly to Mr. Epstein as a \"sexual predator.\" Id. \n(b) \nFAUSA \nalso proposed advising recipients, in an underlined sentence that, \n\"You have the absolute right to select your own attorney\" to \"assist you in making \n. . a claim\" for \"damages from [Epstein].\" But that \"[i]f you do decide to use \n[two attorneys selected by the U.S. Attorney's \"special master\"] as your attorneys, \nMr. Epstein will be responsible for paying attorney's fees incurred during the time \nspent trying to negotiate a settlement.\" Id. \nThe USAO Leaks Confidential Information to the New York Times \n44. \nPerhaps most troubling of all, the USAO h\n... [truncated, 2913 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/8 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=8]", "char_count": 2913}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nstringent conditions—which Mr. \ncould only have learned from FAUSA \n, AUSA \nor United States Attorney Acosta himself. \n46. \nAUSA \nthen asked why Mr. Epstein should ... be treated differently than \nanyone else. Mr. Thomas apparently stated that he understood that there was evidence \nthat the women had lied about their ages. AUSA \nreplied that this was not a \ndefense and that Mr. Thomas should not believe \"the spin\" of Mr. Epstein's \"high-priced \nattorneys.\" Indeed, Mr. \ntold Mr. Thomas that the USAO was very concerned \nabout a Palm Beach editorial that questioned whether Mr. Epstein would receive a rich \nman's justice. AUSA \nthen stated that, in fact, Mr. Epstein \"doesn't have a \ndefense.\" \n47. \nMr. Epstein's attorneys learned of the call and complained to the USAO. Counsel for \nMr. Epstein then had an in-person meeting with FAUSA \nand United States \nAttorney Acosta describing these leaks to the New York Times. During Mr. Thomas' next \ncall to the USAO, made two weeks later, AUSA \n\"admonished\" him (in the \nwords of Mr. Thomas) for disclosing the contents of their rior conversation to the \ndefense, and strongly \"reminded\" Mr. Thomas that AUSA \nprior comments \nabout Mr. E stein had only been \"hypothetical\" in nature. That claim is sheer nonsense: \nAUSA \nhad disclosed specific details of Mr. Epstein's case, including plea \nterms proposed by the defense, as revealed based on Mr. Thomas's own \ncontemporaneous hand-written notes. \n48. \nShortly thereafter, Mr. \nwrote to the defense that Mr. Thomas was given, pursuant \nto his request, non-case specific information concerning specific federal statutes.\" See \nTab 37, February 27, 2008 Email from J. \n. Again, that claim was utterly false; \nMr. Thomas's contemporaneous hand-written notes, reviewed by Jay Lefkowitz, confirm \nthat the USAO had violated settled Department policy and ethical rules by providing \ncase-specific information about the Department's legal theories and plea negotiations. \nConclusion \nW\n... [truncated, 3207 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067353/9 or ?id=EFTA00067353&page=9]", "char_count": 3207}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067353", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nMost important, however, is that the extraordinary nature of this misconduct, so unusual \nin ordinary federal prosecutions, raises the gravest of concerns about why prosecutors would go \nto such lengths in a case already being prosecuted by the State and with so little, if any, federal \nconcern. Accordingly, we ask you to conduct your own investigation of these matters, because \nwe believe that what we have provided you may constitute only the tip of a very deep iceberg. \nWithout the power of subpoena, which we currently lack, we are unable to dig deeper. We \nstrongly believe that there is far more exculpatory evidence that has not been disclosed, more \nleaks that we have not yet uncovered and more questionable behavior. This is a case that cries \nout for a deeper investigation than we are capable of conducting, before any decision to \nprosecute is permitted. \n1I \nEFTA00067363\n", "char_count": 912}]}