{"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_count": 10, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00067343", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00067343.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nResponse to Letter by FAUSA MI\n Dated May 19, 2008 \nIn a Ma 19 2008 letter to Jay Lefkowitz (See Tab 1), SDFL First Assistant U.S. \nAttorney \nprovided what purported to be a summ \nof the events that have \noccurred during the investigation of Mr. Epstein. \nMr. \nletter is fraught with \ninconsistencies, false and misleading characterizations and outright falsehoods. The comparison \nbelow between the false assertions in Mr. letter \nand what actually transpired is only the \ntip of the iceberg. We respectfully submit that Mr. \nletter alone demonstrates the \ndegree to which the record of facts have been distorted and these distortions have permeated this \nunprecedented investigation. \n1. \n\"INDEPENDENT\" AND \"DE NOVO\" REVIEW. \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \n\"[W]e obliged your request for an independent de novo review of the investigation and \nfacilitated such review at the highest levels of the Department of Justice. \" Tab 1, May \n19, 2008 Letter from-, \nP. 5, 1 3. \nThe Truth: \n• \nCEOS' review, concluded in May 2008, was neither independent nor de novo. \no CEOS' review was not \"independent:\" \n• Drew Oosterbaan, who conducted the review on behalf of CEOS, had \nalready reviewed the prosecution memo on this matter eight months \nearlier. During a meeting with defense counsel at the United States \nAttorney's Office in Miami (the \"USAO\") in September of 2007, he \nopined that he so believed in the prosecution that he \"would try the case \nmyself\" \n• Indeed, Mr. \nacknowledges that Mr. Oosterbaan had previously \nopined on this matter, stating: \nThis particular attack on this statute [18 U.S.C. § 2242(b)] \nhad been previously raised and thoroughly considered and \nrejected by . . . CEOS prior to the execution of the \n[Deferred Prosecution] Agreement [in September 2007]. \nId., p. 5 (emphasis added). \n• The statute Ma \nreferred to (§ 2422(b) lies at the heart of the \nEpstein investigation. Thus, according to Mr. \nMr. Oosterbaan \nwas tasked with reviewing his own prior decision reg\n... [truncated, 2102 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067343/0 or ?id=EFTA00067343&page=0]", "char_count": 2102}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \n■ \nThe defense immediately raised concerns regarding the non-independence \nof the review when told that it would be Mr. Oosterbaan tasked with \nproviding the review, but was told that when Mr. Oosterbaan rendered his \nprior opinion, \"he was not really up to speed on the facts\" \no CEOS' review was not de novo: \n• \nBy letter dated May 15, 2008 (four days before Mr. \nletter), Mr. \nOosterbaan advised Mr. Lefkowitz that CEOS reviewed the matter only \nfor abuse of discretion: \nMize question we sought to answer was whether U.S. \nAttorney Acosta would abuse his discretion if he \nauthorized prosecution in this case. \nSee Tab 38, May 15, 2008 Letter from D. Oosterbaan, p. 1 (emphasis \nadded). See also, id., p. 2 (\"Mr. Acosta would not be abusing his \ndiscretion if he decided to pursue such a course of action.\"); and p. 5 \n(\"Mr. Acosta would not be abusing his prosecutorial discretion should he \nauthorized federal prosecution of Mr. Epstein.\"). \n■ \nFor the factual record of its \"abuse of discretion\" review, CEOS relied on \nthe very same prosecution memo that it had already reviewed in rendering \nits prior opinion, stating: \nAs you know, our review of this case is limited, both factually and \nlegally. We have not looked at the entire universe of facts in this \ncase. \nSee Id., p. 1 (emphasis added). \n■ \nNor did CEOS review any facts related to the irregular provisions in the \nDeferred Prosecution Agreement or the numerous complaints of \nprosecutorial misconduct, both of which are inextricably intertwined with \nthe impropriety of the investigation. Id. at 1. \n2. \nNOTIFICATION OF WITNESSES. \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \nMr. \ndismissed the totality of the defense's objections to the inappropriate \nnoti 'cation the SDFL proposed to send to its witnesses, stating merely that: \n\"[Y]ou objected to victims['] being notified of time and place of Epstein's \nstate[-]court sentencing hearing.\" \n2 \nEFTA00067344\n", "char_count": 1929}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "KIRKLANILMILIIS LIP \nSee Tab 1, May 19, 2008 Letter from \np. 4, ¶ 1. \nThe Truth: \n• \nThe defense engaged in days of negotiation and made 1 \nSi\ncarate substantive objections \nto the unprecedented notification letter that Mr. \nthreatened to send to an \nundisclosed list of \"victims.\" The eventual transmission of this highly misleading letter \nwas only halted by an appeal to AAG Fisher. Among those substantive objections \n(which related to far more than the \"time and place\" of the state's sentencing hearing) \nwere: \no Sending the letter would contravene the government's commitment to take no \nposition regarding potential claims of government witnesses. \nSee Tab 39, \nNovember 28, 2008 Email from J. Lefkowitz to a. \no The letter cited to an inapplicable statute (the Justice for All Act of 2004) as its \njustification for being sent. Id. AUSA Acosta later conceded that the citation to \nthis statute as a justification was wholly incorrect. \no The letter wrongly advised all recipients that Mr. Epstein would be required to \nregister as \"a sexual predator for the remainder of this life.\" \no The letter amounted to an invitation to civil litigation against Mr. Epstein, \nadvising recipients that they had the right to seek civil damages from Mr. Epstein, \nand in an underlined instruction, stated that if they chose an attorney other than \nthe one chosen by the government they would be required to pay his fees, but if \nthey chose the government's choice, Mr. Epstein would be required to pay the \nfees. \n3. \nMISCHARACTERIZATION OF OUR ARGUMENTS. \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \nMr. \nletter misleadingly characterizes our substantive defense of the \ngovernment's investigation as, \"the investigation merely produced evidence of relatively \ninnocuous sexual conduct with some minors who, unbeknownst to Mr. Epstein, \nmisrepresented their ages.\" \nSee Tab I, May 19, 2008 Letter from a, \np. 2. \nThe Truth: \n• \nWe never made such a claim. To the contrary, we argued that sworn statements we have \ntaken of the all\n... [truncated, 2176 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067343/2 or ?id=EFTA00067343&page=2]", "char_count": 2176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nevidence that Mr. Epstein routinely and daily receives massages from adults. Only a \nsmall percentage of the masseuses turned out to be minors. The majority of those minors \ninterviewed by law enforcement admitted to lying directly to Epstein about their ages \n(not \"unbeknownst to Epstein\"), and inventing further false details to substantiate their \nlies. Indeed, the civil attorney for several of these women admitted at his recent press \nconference that they lied to Mr. Epstein about their ages. Numerous witnesses testified \nthat Mr. Epstein asked that all masseuses be over the age of 18. Further, the evidence is \nundisputed that Mr. Epstein's assistants scheduled the massages and Mr. Epstein did not \nknow which masseuses his assistants had scheduled on a particular day, until the massage \ntook place. We admitted that there was sexual conduct, and argued—not that it was \n\"innocuous\" as Mr. \nalleges—but that it was mostly Mr. Epstein's own self-\npleasuring, which did not satisfy the requisite federal clement of criminal sexual conduct \n(which is in turn, defined by state law). These are important distinctions and show that \nMr. \nhas misrepresented the record about the most basic part of our defense. \n4. \nDEMANDS AN UNREALISTIC DEADLINE TO COMPLY WITH AN \nAGREEMENT HE UNILATERALLY MODIFIES. \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \"Unless [Mr. Epstein] complies with all of the terms and conditions of the [Deferred \nProsecution] Agreement, as modified by the United States Attorney's December 19, \n2007 letter to Ms. Sanchez by close of business on Monday, June 2, 2008, the SDFL will \nelect to terminate the Agreement\" Id., p.1 \nThe Truth: \n• The Deferred Prosecution Agreement was never modified by U.S. Attorney Acosta's \nDecember 19, 2007 letter. Oddly, Mr. \nacknowledges this on page 4 of his May \n19 letter, where he writes that Mr. Acosta \"proposed\" this modification and that \"[Mr. \nLeficowitz] rejected these proposals.\" Thus, Mr. \nis threatening to terminate the \nDeferre\n... [truncated, 2922 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067343/3 or ?id=EFTA00067343&page=3]", "char_count": 2922}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \ndescribes the additional charge to which Mr. Epstein is required to plead guilty \nunder the Deferred Prosecution Agreement as \"procurement of minors to engage \nin prostitution\" or \"solicitation of minors to engage in prostitution.\" The former \nis an offense for which Mr. Epstein would be required to register, but one for \nwhich the state has no evidence to charge Mr. Epstein and the SDFL refuses or is \nunable to provide evidence that it claims it has. \nThe latter \nuires no \nregistration, but it is the offense which, over and over again, Ms. \ninsisted upon including in the Deferred Prosecution Agreement, and is one which \nthe State believes is appropriate. The inconsistency between the description of \nthe offense required by the SDFL, the elements of an offense that can be justified \non the facts of this case and the SDFL's requirement that the offense be a \nregistrable one has created substantial confusion. \no As a result of this confusion, in December 2007, both the defense and the state \nrequested that the SDFL provide the factual allegations to enable Mr. Epstein and \nthe State to create a truthful factual recitation of a registrable offense required by \nthe Deferred Prosecution Agreement, but, to date, the SDFL has failed to do so \nwithout any explanation. \n• \nMr. \nrefuses to provide the requested factual allegations, which the State cannot \nfurnish, and now demands a two week deadline to comply. Thus Mr. \nhas \nunreasonably imposed a deadline with which he himself has made it impossible for Mr. \nEpstein to comply. \n5. \nWAIVER OF APPEAL TO ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL FISHER. \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \n\"[T]he SDFL provided you with 30 days to appeal the decision to the Assistant Attorney \nGeneral of the United States Alice Fisher\" and \"you chose to forego an appeal to AAG \nFisher.\" \nId., p. 2. \nThe Truth: \n• \nMr. Acosta tolled an August 17 deadline, acknowledging that there were \"serious issues\" \nabout the case that needed to be discussed, and schedule\n... [truncated, 2581 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067343/4 or ?id=EFTA00067343&page=4]", "char_count": 2581}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nAgreement to Defer Prosecution to the State, an agreement without precedent and fraught \nwith substantial practical and legal hurdles to its implementation. \n6. \nTHE SDFL DID NOT DEFER TO TIIE STATE. \nLetter: \n• \"[T]he SDFL indicated a willingness to defer to the State the length of incarceration.\" \nId., p. 2. \nThe Truth: \n• \nThe SDFL neither deferred to the State, nor even discussed with the State, the length of \nMr. Epstein's incarceration. In a letter to the defense, Criminal Division Chief, Matthew \nMenchel rejected the sentence contemplated by the State's plea agreement, writing that \n\"the federal interest will not be vindicated in the absence of a two-year term of state \nimprisonment.\" See Tab 40, August 3, 2007 Email from M. Menchel. Of course, this \nposition is contrary to Section 9-2031D of the U.S. Attorney's Manual (indicating that \nthe \"result\" of a state prosecution is `presumed ' to have vindicated the federal interest). \nIt is understandable, therefore, that Mr. \nmight want to retreat from it now. \nIndeed, the final Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA) restricts the state-court judge \nfrom exercising any of his rightful discretion and to specifically prohibit the judge from \noffering probation, community control or any other alternative in lieu of incarceration. \nDPA, 1 2(a). \n7. \nSUGGESTION OF ADDITIONAL STATE PLEA \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \nThe parties considered: \"as suggested by [the defense], a plea to state charges \nencompassing Epstein's conduct.\" See Tab 1, May 19, 2008 Letter from \np.2, \n¶ 2. \nThe Truth: \n• \nIt was the government, and not the defense, that suggested a plea to state charges to \nresolve the federal investigation. Andrew Lourie proposed declining prosecution in favor \nof the state. Although Mr. Epstein and the State Attorney's Office had already reached \na plea agreement, in August 2007, Mr. \nand AUSA learned \nthat \nthey intended to prosecute Epstein federally unless his counsel (i.e., not the U.S. \nAttorney's Offic\n... [truncated, 2278 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067343/5 or ?id=EFTA00067343&page=5]", "char_count": 2278}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \n8. \nALL IDENTIFIED VICTIMS BE PUT IN SAME POSITION AS IF EPSTEIN \nHAD BEEN TRIED. \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \n\"The Agreement provides for a method of compensation for the victims such that they \nwould be placed in the same position as if Epstein had been convicted of one of the \nenumerated offenses set forth in Title 18, United States Code Section, 2255.\" \nId. \nThe Truth: \n• \nMr. \ncontinues to mischaracterize the highly irregular provisions of the Deferred \nProsecution Agreement. The SDFL did not merely attempt to preserve the compensation \nrights of those it identified as victims; it attempted to create compensation rights for those \nit identified, without imposing on them the burden of proving that they were in fact \nvictims under § 2255. \no In the Deferred Prosecution Agreement, the SDFL required Mr. Epstein to waive \nthe right to contest liability under 18 U.S.C. § 2255 as to a list of individuals that \nthe SDFL would not disclose to Mr. Epstein until after he was sentenced and to \npay for an attorney to secure compensation under § 2255 for those undisclosed \nindividuals, or if they decided to sue Mr. Epstein. \no § 2255 ordinarily provides individuals with a right to recover minimum guaranteed \ndamages of $150,000, without having to prove actual damages, only if: (1) they \nwere victims of an enumerated federal offense, including offenses under 18 U.S.C. \n§§ 2422 and 2423, (2) they were minors at the time of the offense, and most \nimportantly (3) they were personally injured as a result of the offense. \no The defense has confirmed examples of women who testified that they were not \nvictims of Mr. Epstein and suffered no personal injury. These women were, \nnevertheless, on the list of \"victims\" identified by the government. . In fact, when \nconfronted with the testimony of a women who denied both being a victim and \nincurring personal injury, Ms. \nactually acknowledged such testimony. \n61,\nfify inclusion of that woman on the government's list, however,\n... [truncated, 2696 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067343/6 or ?id=EFTA00067343&page=6]", "char_count": 2696}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nthis same individual would nevertheless be entitled to engage an attorney paid for by Mr. \nEpstein to recover $150,000 of damages from Mr. Epstein under § 2255 without ever \nalleging any injury. In fact, the defense was told that the only question Mr. Epstein \nwould be permitted to ask before paying the girls is \" have you ever met Epstein.\". Thus, \nthe Deferred Prosecution Agreement places identified individuals in a far better position \nthan they would be in if Mr. Epstein were convicted at trial. \n9. \nASSIGNMENT OF RIGHT TO SELECT LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE. \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \"Prior to any issues arising concerning the implementation of the 2255 provision, the \nSDFL unilaterally agreed to assign its responsibility to select the attorney representative \nfor the alleged victims to an independent third-party.\" \nSee Tab 1, May 19, 2008 Letter from \np. 4, f.3. \nThe Truth: \n• \nThat such an assignment was the SDFL's \"unilateral\" decision is false. Before the \nSDFL decided to assi \nselection of the \"attorney representative\" to an independent third \nparty, AUSA \nhad already proposed an \"attorney representative.\" She \nhad proposed local products-liability lawyer, Humberto Ocariz, and claimed he had been \nrecommended by a \"good friend in the Appellate Division.\" Ms.l\niaccount was \nmisleading, as it omitted that this \"good friend\" was her live-in boyfriend, and that Mr. \nOcariz was his former law-school roommate. When we discovered this independently, \nwe objected. \nOnly then did the SDFL propose assigning the selection process to an \nindependent special master and agree to amend the Deferred Prosecution Agreement. \nThus, while it may be true that the SDFL assigned its selection responsibility to avoid the \nappearance of favoritism, it did not do it \"unilaterally,\" but, rather, only after Epstein \nuncovered the Office's misleading disclosure and apparent conflict-of-interest. \n10. \nTIMETABLE FOR MOVING FORWARD. \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \"On February 25, 2008, I sent yo\n... [truncated, 2438 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067343/7 or ?id=EFTA00067343&page=7]", "char_count": 2438}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nrole. They said they would only advise on an abuse of discretion standard. Making the \noutcome a foregone conclusion. Furthermore, in response to the February 25 e-mail, \nwhich attempted to establish a schedule to limit the entire review process (the defense has \nrepeatedly suggested that the misconduct was intertwined with the investigation and \nwould therefore seek higher review), Mr. Lefkowitz e-mailed Mr. Acosta directly. On \nFebruary 29, 2028 Mr. \nresponded to Mr. Lefkowitz's e-mail to Mr. Acosta, \nstating that Mr. \nwas acting out of frustration, but \"[p]lease be assured that it has \nnot, and never has been, this Office's intent to interfere or restrict the \"review process\" \nfor either Mr. Epstein or CEOS. I leave it to you and CEOS to figure out how best to \nproceed and will await the results of that process.\" As stated above, CEOS determined \nthat it would not review many of the defense's objections and as to the remainder of those \nobjections, its review would be limited (contrary to Mr. Acosta's assurances), which left \nthe need, supplemented by the defense's subsequent request, for a more thorough review \nof critical issues by others at the Department of Justice. Mr. \nre-imposition of \nthe (albeit modestly extended) timetable was an obvious attempt, in violation of his \nFebruary 29 agreement, to thwart the request made by the defense to the Deputy Attorney \ngeneral, to complete the review process that Mr. Acosta had promised. \n11. \n\"DELAY.\" \nMr. \nLetter: \n• \nIn a section entitled \"Delay,\" Mr. \nstates that \"the SDFL again agreed to \naccommodate Epstein's request to appear in state court for plea and sentencing on \nJanuary 4, 2008.\" \nId., p. 3. \nThe Truth: \n• \nCuriously, Mr. \nfails to mention correspondence from the U.S. Attorney stating \nthat delay of that date would be \"inevitable\" as the defense has raised \"serious questions\" \nabout the propriety of the prosecution. Strikingly, in that same section, Mr. \nclaims that \"the Agreement di\n... [truncated, 2742 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00067343/8 or ?id=EFTA00067343&page=8]", "char_count": 2742}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00067343", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP \nmake an independent decision not adversely affected by conclusions that over and over have \nproven, witness by witness, allegation by allegation, to be inaccurate and unwarranted and not an \nappropriate basis for the exercise of federal prosecutorial authority. \n10 \nEFTA00067352\n", "char_count": 302}]}