{"efta_number": "EFTA00066553", "page_count": 4, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00066553", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00066553.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00066553", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "U.S. Department of Justice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of New York \nThe Silvio J. Malta Building \nOne Saint Andrew's Plaza \nNew York, New York 10007 \nOctober 30, 2020 \nBY ECF \nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan \nUnited States District Court \nSouthern District of New York \nUnited States Courthouse \n40 Foley Square \nNew York, New York 10007 \nRe: \nUnited States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN) \nDear Judge Nathan: \nThe Government respectfully submits this letter in response to the defense letter dated \nOctober 23, 2020 in the above-referenced case (the \"Defense Letter\"). For all of its innuendo and \naccusations, the Defense Letter is at base an effort to preview motions that the Court has already \nfound to be premature and to cast the Government's efforts to be transparent with the Court and \nthe defense in a nefarious and deeply misleading light. The Government writes to correct the \ninaccuracies in the Defense Letter, to update the Court regarding the status of the Government's \nongoing discovery productions, and to address the defense complaints regarding the Metropolitan \nDetention Center (\"MDC\"). \n1. The Government Has and Will Continue to Satisfy Its Discovery Obligations \nThe Defense Letter raises numerous accusations, including that the Government has \n\"abandon[ed]\" the discovery deadlines in this case. (Def. Ltr. I). The Government strongly \ndisagrees, and is prepared to respond in detail to the defendant's various claims and accusations at \nthe appropriate stage. But in short, many of the defense's accusations about the Government's \nallegedly deficient discovery productions are not only incorrect, but also include complaints that \nthe Court has already directed the defendant to renew only if unable to reach agreement with the \nGovernment \"[fJollowing the close of discovery,\" which has not yet passed. (Order dated Aug. \n25, 2020, Dkt. 49, at 2). Most notably, the defendant's accusations against the Government rely \non a blurring of the line between Rule 16 and Giglio or Jencks Act material, as well as the same \nfaulty definition of exculpatory material that has no basis in law. (See Gov. Ltr. dated Aug. 13, \n2020, Dtk. No. 41, at 2-3 (noting law supporting delay of production of witness list until shortly \nbefore trial); Gov. Ltr. dated Oct. 7, 2020, Dkt. No. 63, at 2 (noting that Rule 16 does not require \nproduction of witness statements or Giglio); Gov. Ltr. dated Oct. 20, 2020, Dkt. No. 65, at 1-2 \n(noting well-established law in this Circuit precluding defense from offering evidence that a \ndefendant did not participate in criminal conduct on a different occasion than that charged by the \nGovernment)).' \n1 In addition to repeating previously made arguments, the defense now contends that evidence \nabout the \"genesis\" of the non-prosecution agreement between the United States Attorney's Office \nfor the Southern District of Florida and Jeffrey Epstein, is exculpatory. (Def. Ltr. 4). The defense \nEFTA00066553\n", "char_count": 2986}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00066553", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Page 2 \nAs set forth in the Government's prior letters, the Government has produced considerable \nRule 16 discovery to the defendant, which, to date, consists of more than 350,000 pages. Contrary \nto the defense's assertions, that discovery does include both Ic]orroborating [i]nformation\" \nregarding the conduct charged in this case as well as potentially \"[e]xculpatory [e]vidence,\" (Def. \nLtr. 3), and the Government remains willing to discuss that material with defense counsel. In \nadvance of the November 9, 2020 discovery deadline, the Government anticipates making \nadditional productions, including a production of electronic discovery, which will consist of over \n1.2 million documents from devices seized from Jeffrey Epstein's residences? In that regard, the \nGovernment is currently waiting on its outside vendor to image, stamp, and download that \nelectronic discovery, which the Government finished preparing for production last week, from an \nelectronic database. The volume of that production is large and takes significant time for the \nvendor to prepare. It is therefore possible that the vendor may need additional time to complete \nthat process. That said, the Government has repeatedly informed the vendor of the November 9, \n2020 deadline, and the vendor is making every effort to meet it. If the vendor is unable to meet \nthat deadline, the Government will promptly alert the Court and the defendant. Thus, contrary to \nthe defense's suggestion, the Government fully intends to meet the Court-ordered discovery \ndeadline in this case, which has not yet passed. \nIt is the Government's expectation and hope that those productions will, consistent with its \nrepresentations to the Court, substantially complete its production of Rule 16 discovery. As is not \nuncommon in a case of this magnitude, however, it is possible that the Government may identify \nadditional discoverable materials after the deadline. Should that happen, the Government will \npromptly produce such materials to the defense. \nWith respect to the Government's October 7 letter regarding files from other agencies, the \ndefense's claims that the Government has \"minimize[d]\" what it promised and \"redefine[d] who \nit believes is part of the Prosecution Team\" are deeply misleading.3 (Def. Ltr. 4). To be clear, the \nGovernment has always viewed FBI files from both the prior Florida investigation and the more \nrecent New York investigation as part of the Prosecution Team's files, and stated as much at the \nmakes this assertion despite the fact that neither this Office nor the defendant were party to that \nagreement, the agreement covered conduct spanning a different period of time than that charged \nin this case, and the agreement does not mention the defendant by name. To the extent the defense \nnevertheless believes it is entitled to those materials, the appropriate forum to raise those \narguments is on the pretrial motion schedule established by the Court. \n2 Despite the defense's insinuations to the contrary, this is entirely consistent with the discovery \nschedule ordered by the Court. Specifically, the Court ordered the Government to produce \n\"[i]nitial non-electronic discovery, generally to include search warrant applications and subpoena \nreturns\" by August 21, 2020, and the Government made three productions containing those \nmaterials, and more, by August 21, 2020. (Order dated July 15, 2020, Dkt. No. 25). \n3 It bears mention that at no point did the defendant seek to confer with the Government \nregarding any concerns about the Government's October 7 letter or the Government's planned \nproductions prior to filing the Defense Letter with the Court. \nEFTA00066554\n", "char_count": 3689}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00066553", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Page 3 \ninitial pretrial conference, and in its October 7, 2020 letter.4 Because the Palm Beach Police \nDepartment files were incorporated into the Florida FBI files and were so at the time of charging, \nthey are also part of the Prosecution Team's files. Thus, far from trying to \"distance itself from \nits own files\" (Def. Ltr. 5), the Government has thoroughly reviewed those files for Rule 16 \nmaterial and potential Brady material, has made discovery productions from those files beginning \nin August through this month, and is continuing to make productions from those files. \nBy contrast, and as explained more fully in the Government's October 7 letter, this \nProsecution Team—which played no role in the Florida Investigation—had not, prior to August \n2020, received the materials identified in that letter from other prosecutor's offices. The \nGovernment has now obtained those materials not because they constitute Rule 16 discovery, but \nrather because the Government is prepared to go above and beyond its obligations in an effort to \nidentify any arguable 3500 or Giglio material for Government witnesses in this case, or any Brady \nmaterial held in the files of those other offices. The Government is in the process of reviewing \nthose materials, as set forth in its October 7 letter, and to the extent the Government identifies \nmaterial within those files that constitutes Giglio or Jencks Act material, it will produce any such \nmaterial in advance of trial consistent with any agreed upon or ordered schedule for pretrial \ndisclosures. \nIf the Government identifies potential Brady material within those files, the \nGovernment will promptly produce it to the defendant. \nIn sum, through its October 7 letter, the Government sought to be transparent about the \nfiles it has been collecting and reviewing from other offices for disclosures in this case. The \nGovernment fully intends to discharge its obligations carefully, thoughtfully, and thoroughly and \nwill continue to make itself available to confer with defense counsel regarding discovery. \n2. The Government Has Made Considerable Efforts to Address Concerns and \nComplaints Raised by Defense Counsel Regarding the MDC \nThe Defense Letter raises two complaints that the Government has gone to significant \nlengths to address over the past several weeks. First, the defense complains about technical issues \nthe defendant has experienced in reviewing discovery at the MDC. (Def. Ltr. 6-7). The \nGovernment has worked expeditiously and continuously to provide the defendant with discovery \nthat is reviewable at MDC. In that vein, the Government has repeatedly spoken with MDC legal \ncounsel regarding these issues, and is continuing to work with MDC legal counsel and its own IT \nstaff to ensure that the defendant is able to review all of her discovery, including the subset of files \n4 The suggestion to the contrary in the first sentence of the Defense Letter is similarly \nmisleading. (Def. Ltr. 1). At the initial conference, the Government explained that discovery in \nthis case would come, in part, from \"prior investigative files from another investigation in the \nSouthern District of Florida,\" (July 14, 2020 Tr. at 12), and Government counsel clarified, \"the \nfiles in particular that I am referring to are the files in the possession of the F.B.I. in Florida in \nconnection with the previous investigation of Jeffrey Epstein.\" (Id. at 14). Consistent with that \nrepresentation, the Government's October 7, 2020 letter noted that the Prosecution Team has \nreviewed and made discovery productions from those same Florida FBI files. (Dkt. 63 at 5, 6). \nEFTA00066555\n", "char_count": 3650}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00066553", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Page 4 \nthat the defendant has had difficulty opening on the MDC computer system.5 Because those efforts \nare already underway and remain ongoing, there is no need for an order directing them. \nSecond, the Defense Letter complains about issues within the MDC that are not in the \nGovernment's control, but that the Government has nevertheless spent significant time addressing \nat the defense's behest. (Def. Ltr. 6-7). MDC legal counsel has informed the Government that \nMDC staff has been instructed to allow defense counsel to pass papers to their client for her to \nreview during visits. Accordingly, there is no need for an order to address this issue. MDC legal \ncounsel also noted that the table in the attorney visiting room is equipped with a Plexiglas barrier \ndown the middle to prevent the spread of COVID-19. Attorneys and clients are required to sit on \nopposite sides of that barrier for their health and safety, but they can position any laptop they may \nbe reviewing in such a way that both the client and attorneys can view it while remaining on \nopposite sides of the table. Finally, the Government understands from MDC legal counsel that the \ndefendant has access to her discovery for approximately 13 hours per day and therefore receives \nmore time to review her discovery than any other inmate in the MDC. \n* \n* \n* \nThe Government is working expeditiously to meet its obligations and discovery deadlines, \nwhich it takes very seriously. The Government's primary objective, of course, is to finalize the \nproduction of discovery as quickly as possible, while also ensuring that its productions are \ncomplete. To the extent any delays arise in the production of discovery, the Government will bring \nthose to the defendant's and the Court's attention as soon as possible. And at any point, should \nthe defense have questions or concerns about the discovery, the Government has been and remains \navailable to discuss those questions or concerns directly with counsel. \nRespectfully submitted, \nAUDREY STRAUSS \nActing United States Attorney \nBy: \nAssistant United States Attorneys \nSouthern District of New York \nTel: \nCc: All Counsel of Record (By ECF) \n5 It is not clear to the Government what documents the defendant is unable to view at this point. \nThe defense has previously provided the Government with lists of documents that the defendant \ncould not open. In response, the Government sent the defendant replacement productions with \nreformatted versions of each identified document after consulting with MDC staff to ensure that \nthe files would be viewable on the MDC computer system. Yesterday, defense counsel informed \nthe Government that the defendant still cannot view certain files, but the defense has not identified \nall of the specific unreviewable documents. In any event, the Government will continue to work \nwith the defense and the MDC to ensure that the defendant can review all discovery. \nEFTA00066556\n", "char_count": 2947}]}