{"efta_number": "EFTA00040660", "page_count": 3, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00040660", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00040660.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00040660", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "LAW OFFICES OF BOBBI C.STERNHEIA\\ \n• Main \n• Cell \n• Fax \nAugust 18, 2021 \nHonorable \nJ. Nathan \nUnited States District Judge \nUnited States Courthouse \n40 Foley Square \nNew York, NY 10007 \nRe: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell \nS2 20 Cr. 330 (AJN) \nDear Judge Nathan; \nI write to update the Court regarding MDC ongoing interference with attorney-client \ncommunication between Ghislaine Maxwell and her counsel. \nSince December 2019, video teleconferences (\"VTCs\") between Ms. Maxwell and her counsel \nhave been conducted via defense counsel's WebEx platform. There were no problems with VTCs with \nthe exception of when the MDC placed the VTC monitor inside a box with a screen, which severely \nimpacted Ms. Maxwell's ability to see counsel and documents shown to her. That issue, which arose on \nJune 14, 2021, was resolved between defense counsel and the MDC. \nHowever, on August 6, 2021, MDC Legal sent counsel an email stating that starting Monday \n(August 9th) we could no longer use defense counsel's WebEx platform for the VTCs, and instead had to \nuse any of four Zoom access codes provided by the MDC. When questioned why the platform was \nbeing changed from WebEx to Zoom, MDC Legal stated the VTC platform was changed due to \ncomplaints made by Ms. Maxwell. Upon information and belief, the complaints concerned visual \nevidence that someone on MDC's end of the WebEx connection, other than Ms. Maxwell, appeared on \nthe screen as a VTC participant called \"NER/BRO,\" adjusted the volume during the VTC, and moved \nthe viewing box used to view documents on the screen. During the past several weeks, interruption in \nMs. Maxwell's VTC signal and bandwidth suggested that her connection was split, causing her VTC \nsessions to go in and out, and her screen often turned green and became blurry. No other participants \nexperienced such disruption. \nWhen Ms. Maxwell raised these concerns to various staff members, no one seemed surprised. \nThe fact that MDC immediately provided a \"more secure\" link (in their words) suggests there was some \ntype of breach or interference with the attorney-client VTC which impinged upon confidentiality of \nprivileged attorney-client communication and is placing an on-going chill on communication between \nMs. Maxwell and her defense team. \nIt is my understanding that the new MDC Zoom platform does not preclude third parties who \nhave the access information to the Zoom \"Courtrooms\" from interfering (inadvertently or intentionally) \nwith Ms. Maxwell's privileged communication. That concern manifested itself on August 12ih when \nEFTA00040660\n", "char_count": 2592}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00040660", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "LAW OFFICES OF 13O13131 C.STERNHEIM \nthird parties accessed the Zoom room used by Ms. Maxwell and counsel. This breach was \nreported to, and I believe witnessed by, MDC staff, including an MDC technician named Leon \nwho is tasked with dealing with Ms. Maxwell's electronics issues. \nBy email dated August 12ih to MDC Legal, with government counsel copied, I reported \nthat this purported breach severely impacts confidential privileged attorney-client \ncommunication and is especially concerning in this high-profile case. I requested that the VTC \nrevert to the original WebEx platform controlled by defense counsel. \nIn an email response, dated August 13th, MDC Legal stated: \nThere was a miscommunication on our end internally. There was no \nbreach. The address provided was a very secure line, however, it was \nalready one being used. We are creating a line as secure as possible. \nWe are hoping for this to be complete by the 9:30 scheduled call, but I \ncannot confirm it will be ready by then. \nOn August 16th, I again emailed MDC Legal, with government counsel copied, \nrequesting clarification as to why the VTC is still not proceeding, as it did not on Friday, and \nrenewed my request that VTCs be reinstated on defense counsel's WebEx platform because the \nsubstituted Zoom platform is not secure and seems to have caused cancellation of Ms. Maxwell's \nVTCs. I also informed MDC Legal, with government counsel copied, that during my in-person \nvisit with Ms. Maxwell on Saturday, August \nboth Ms. Maxwell and I were told we could \nnot pass documents. This restriction frustrated and affected the productivity of a four-hour visit. \nIn a reply email later that day, MDC Legal stated: \nPlease understand this is not a simple process and may take a few days. \nWith that said you have had access to your client via telephone. \nAdditionally, as you have had weekend visit on weekend with Ms. Maxwell, \nwe can gladly arrange for the same on any day moving forward. \nAs far as your weekend legal visit- the staff who did not allow the \npassing of legal documents have been informed of the appropriate \ninstructions. \nThe restrictions placed on Ms. Maxwell, including limiting the quantity of legal \ndocuments she may bring to the VTC room or day room and the prohibition on review of \ndocuments during in-person legal conferences- coupled with problems with conducting \nconfidential legal conference VTCs - has limited Ms. Maxwell's ability to prepare for trial. Legal \ncalls do not suffice because we cannot share documents. For example, Ms. Maxwell received \nnew discovery today and yet again a significant amount is not viewable on the hardware and \nsoftware provided by the government. Because we cannot share documents, that discovery \nremains unviewable by Ms. Maxwell. Further, ongoing delays in bringing Ms. Maxwell to the \nday room continue, which reduces the time she is permitted to work on her case and limitations \n2 \nEFTA00040661\n", "char_count": 2947}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00040660", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "LAW OFFICES OF DOH' C. STERNHEIM \nof the quantity of legal materials she is permitted to use during working session severely hamper \nher ability to prepare her defense for trial. \nOn August I7'h, the third day without VTC for Ms. Maxwell and counsel, I told MDC \nLegal that the defense has reason to be concerned that VTCs between Ms. Maxwell and counsel \nmay have been tape recorded by the MDC, a concern that accords with our belief that there has \nbeen inference with the VTCs on the MDC's end. Notably, when Ms. Maxwell reported to \nMDC staff her concern that VTCs were being taped, she received no response. Likewise, \ncounsel have received no response from MDC Legal regarding this concern. \nAs of the writing of this letter, there has been no resumption of VTCs, and the MDC has \nprovided no information. \nAny interference by the MDC, BOP, or other government entity with confidential \nprivileged communication between Ms. Maxwell and her counsel is a serious breach of BOP \npolicy, professional ethics, ABA standards and a violation of Ms. Maxwell's constitutional \nrights. Further, it is seriously impacting her ability to prepare for trial, a situation already \ncompromised by the conditions of her detention. \nBased on the foregoing, I request that the Court direct MDC Legal to show cause \n■ \nWhy the VTC platform has been changed. \n■ \nWhy resumption of VTCs has been delayed. \n■ \nWhy VTCs cannot be reinstated on defense counsel's WebEx platform. \nFurther, it is requested that MDC legal provide a sworn statement regarding whether any \nVTCs between Ms. Maxwell and counsel have been interfered with, listened to, and/or recorded. \nYour consideration is greatly appreciated. \nVery truly yours, \n/s/ \nBOBBI C. STERNHEIM \ncc: All counsel \n3 \nEFTA00040662\n", "char_count": 1766}]}