{"efta_number": "EFTA00019249", "page_count": 3, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00019249", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00019249.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00019249", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "From: \nTo: \nSubject: FW: WASHINGTON POST; Jeffrey Epstein's scandal of secrecy points to a creeping rot in the \nAmerican justice system \nDate: Tue, 18 Jun 2019 20:34:15 +0000 \nImportance: Normal \nJust FYI. \nFrom: \nSent: Tuesday, June 18, 2019 4:34 PM \nTo: \nSubject: WASHINGTON POST; Jeffrey Epstein's scandal of secrecy points to a creeping rot in the American justice system \nJeffrey Epstein's scandal of \nsecrecy points to a creeping rot \nin the American justice system \nWhen rich people are credibly accused of crimes, does the public have a right to \nknow? Should multimillionaires be allowed to silence their accusers with cash? \nAccording to superlawyer David Boies, \"dozens\" of women who could give \ntestimony about being  sexually assaulted as  girls by mysterious financier Jeffrey \nEpstein are silenced by settlements they reached with their alleged assailant. The \nexact number is yet another secret in this least transparent of criminal cases. \n\"Three dozen or eight dozen, I don't know, but there are dozens,\" Boies told me \nrecently. He himself represents two alleged Epstein victims bound by \"non-\ndisclosure agreements\" (NDAs). \nBecause Epstein can afford to buy silence, he may succeed in shuttering the \nwindow of accountability pried open in a South Florida court back in February. \nU.S. District Judge Kenneth A. Marra ruled that federal prosecutors — led by the \nEFTA00019249\n", "char_count": 1397}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00019249", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "current labor secretary, Alexander Acosta — broke the law by entering a secret \nsweetheart deal to allow Epstein to serve a cushy sentence without facing evidence \nthat he assaulted more than 3o underage girls in Palm Beach. \nThat ruling may prove hollow, however, if the alleged victims are now gagged by \ntheir settlements with Epstein. What a galling next chapter that would be in this \nappalling story. \nEpstein, whose enormous and unexplained wealth attracted a circle of friends that \nincluded Bill Clinton, Donald Trump, actor Kevin Spacey and Britain's Prince \nAndrew, travels from mansion to mansion while poor men accused of lesser \ncrimes rot in prison. \nThis scandal of secrecy points to a creeping rot in the American justice system. \nToo many cases involving potential felonies are resolved through civil settlements \nthat include ironclad NDAs. Once the money changes hands, witnesses can no \nlonger testify to crimes; indeed, penalties for telling the truth after a settlement \noften run to the millions of dollars — ruinous for most crime victims. It's a short \nstep removed from silencing witnesses with cement shoes. \n\"It is a classic case of rich man's justice,\" said Boies. Add the fact that wealthy \npredators often target victims in financial need. That was allegedly Epstein's M.O. \nas he sent recruiters into working-class neighborhoods in search of teenagers to \ngive him \"massages.\" The rich exploit the poverty of their victims to extract \npromises of silence — backed by the force of law because the NDAs are binding \ncontracts. \nWhat's needed is a simple change to the law, Boies contends: \"Simply say that \nagreements to conceal evidence of a crime are not enforceable.\" \nThe Epstein case is particularly creepy but not unique. The #MeToo movement \nhas revealed the pernicious misuse of NDAs to enable crime. Powerful men such \nas producer Harvey Weinstein  and television executive Leslie Moonves reportedly \nmade use of the agreements to hide evidence of sexual assault or harassment. This \nsecrecy in turn allowed offenders to target additional victims. \nThat's where the public interest comes in. Crime is not just a matter between an \noffender and a victim; crime is also an offense against the public order. The public \nEFTA00019250\n", "char_count": 2270}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00019249", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "has an important stake in punishing past crimes and preventing future offenses. \nPurchased secrecy interferes with those aims. \nSome attorneys say NDAs are the only protection the rich and famous have \nagainst unfounded accusations. But that doesn't bear much scrutiny. A person \nwho might falsely claim to be a victim has more to fear from sunlight than from \nsecrecy. And anyone who pays hush money to cover up false allegations is only \nencouraging more extortion. \nI am beginning to worry that the fresh breeze of openness that appeared to be \nblowing through the stink of the Epstein case might be smothered by secrecy. \nAttorneys for Epstein's Palm Beach accusers are losing confidence that their \nclients will ever tell their stories in court. \nMeanwhile, a panel of appeals court judges in New York has gone silent in a \nrelated matter. British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell, an Epstein friend and \nconfidante, is battling to keep details of her settlement with an Epstein accuser \nsealed from public view. In a March hearing at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the \n2nd Circuit, Judge Jose A. Cabranes openly scoffed at Maxwell's attorney as he \nargued for secrecy. Yet here we are on the cusp of summer, and the court has not \nbeen heard from. When will a ray of sunshine pierce the cloud of money? \nIf anything good can come out of this miserable case, maybe this is it: Lawmakers \ncan seize this outrageous moment to outlaw the silencing of witnesses through \nNDAs. The agreements have their place in civil matters, but not to mask evidence \nof crimes. The legal system, meanwhile, can do the right thing. Open the Maxwell \nfiles. Then launch a full-fledged investigation of Epstein's conduct in New York, \nNew Mexico and the Virgin Islands: places where the tainted South Florida \nagreement cannot protect him. \nUnited States Department of Justice \nU.S. Attorney's Office ! Southern District of New York \nEFTA00019251\n", "char_count": 1926}]}