{"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_count": 16, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00013373", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00013373.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "U.S. v. Montano, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \n873 F.Supp. 1177 \nUnited States District Court, \nN.D. Illinois, \nEastern Division. \nUNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff, \nv. \nChristopher Richard MESSINO, et al., Defendants. \nNo. 93 CR 294. \nJan. 31, 1995. \nSynopsis \nEight defendants, who were charged in connection with \nalleged \ndrug distribution \nand \nmoney \nlaundering \nconspiracy, and government filed pretrial motions in \nlimine. The District Court, Alesia, J., held that: (1) \nevidence and witnesses' testimony would not be \nsuppressed as result of having been derived from leads \nattributable to suppressed evidence; (2) testimony \nregarding \nstatutory \nmaximum \npenalty \nfaced \nby \ngovernment's witnesses was admissible; (3) government \nwould be allowed to recall witnesses during its case in \nchief; (4) evidence regarding weapons possession, taxes, \nand dealings involving large amounts of cash was \nadmissible; (5) district court would not grant additional \nperemptory challenges to defendants; (6) government was \nnot \nrequired to \nput \nnondefendant \nparticipant \nin \nconversation with one of defendants on stand in order to \nplay tape recordings of conversation; (7) court would \nreserve ruling on marital communications privilege; (8) \nreferences to one of defendants in codefendants' \nconversations did not implicate confrontation clause; and \n(9) government could introduce evidence of incarceration \nof one of defendants. \nMotions denied in part and granted in part. \nWest Headnotes (34) \nIll \nCriminal Law \nS-Searches, seizures, and arrests \nCriminal Law \nS-Search or seizure in general \nExclusionary rule prohibits introduction of \nevidence obtained as direct or indirect result of \nillegal search. \nCases that cite this headnote \n121 \nCriminal Law \nS-Causal nexus; independent discovery or basis \nor source \nWhen disputed evidence is attributable to source \nindependent of illegally obtained primary item, \nindependent source doctrine renders evidence \nadmissible despite primary taint.\n... [truncated, 2950 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/0 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=0]", "char_count": 2950}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "U.S. v. Mannino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nCases that cite this headnote \nIsl \nCriminal Law \niil lnevitable discovery \nDefendant, who was charged in connection with \nalleged drug distribution and money laundering \nconspiracy, was not entitled to suppression of \nbank and credit card records and prohibition of \nuse of witness, even though records and witness \nwere derived from \nleads attributable \nto \nsuppressed evidence; records and identity and \nsignificance of witness would have been \ninevitably discovered even absent utilization of \ntainted leads. \nCases that cite this headnote \n161 \nCriminal Law \nS-Motions in limine \nDistrict court would deny government's motion \nin limine seeking to preclude evidence and \nargument, at trial on charges arising from \nalleged drug distribution and money laundering \nconspiracy, of lawfulness, noncorrupt conduct, \nand outrageous government conduct; motion \ncould not be evaluated absent more specific \ncontext provided at trial. \n2 Cases that cite this headnote \nITI \nCriminal Law \naMotions in limine \nDistrict court would deny as moot government's \nmotion in limine seeking to preclude, at trial on \ncharges arising from alleged drug distribution \nand money laundering conspiracy, evidence and \nargument \nof \nentrapment; \nno \ndefendant \nresponded to motion by asserting right to argue \nentrapment in opening statements. \n2 Cases that cite this headnote \nIsl \nCriminal Law \nS-Relevancy in General \nEvidence \nas \nto \ndefense \ncounsel's \nprior \nprosecution experience was not admissible as it \nwas irrelevant. Fed.Rules Evid.Rules 401, 402, \n28 U.S.C.A. \nCases that cite this headnote \nWitnesses \np-Competency of contradictory evidence \nDraft transcript prepared by one witness could \nnot be used to impeach another witness. \nCases that cite this headnote \nPw \nCriminal Law \n4SMotions in limine \nDistrict court would deny government's motion \nin limine regarding allegations of witness \nwrongdoing \nnot \ninvolving \ndishonesty; \ngovernment sought to regulate \n... [truncated, 2401 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/1 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=1]", "char_count": 2401}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \npenalties faced by government's witnesses was \nadmissible, notwithstanding contention that such \nnumbers were misleading given realities of \nsentencing \nunder \nSentencing \nGuidelines; \nevidence was relevant as to issue of credibility, \nand, to extent that statutory maximum did not \ntell whole story, government was free to explore \nthat on redirect examination. U.S.S.G. § 1B1.1 \net seq., 18 U.S.C.A.App.; Fed.Rules Evid.Rule \n401,28 U.S.C.A. \nCases that cite this headnote \n1121 \nWitnesses \nfaRecalling Witnesses \nDistrict court has discretionary authority to \nallow government to recall witnesses during its \ncase in chief. \nCases that cite this headnote \n1131 \nWitnesses \n4-Recalling Witnesses \nDistrict court would allow government at trial of \neight defendants on charges arising from alleged \ndrug \ndistribution \nand \nmoney \nlaundering \nconspiracy to recall specific witnesses during its \ncase in chief; such recall would be beneficial to \nJuly's following government's case. \nCases that cite this headnote \nCriminal Law \n4-Conspiracy, racketeering, and money \nlaundering \nCriminal Law \n4-Controlled substances \nCriminal Law \n4-Conspiracy, racketeering, and money \nlaundering \nCriminal Law \n4-Conspiracy, racketeering, and money \nlaundering \nEvidence of defendants' possession of weapons \nwas admissible, at trial on charges arising out of \nalleged drug distribution and money laundering \nconspiracy, on a tool-of-the-trade theory. \nCases that cite this headnote \n1151 \nConspiracy \n4-Admissibility in general \nTax evidence was admissible, at trial on charges \narising from alleged drug distribution and \nmoney laundering conspiracy, to show no \nlegitimate source of income. \nCases that cite this headnote \n118 \nCriminal Law \n4-Evidence calculated to create prejudice \nagainst or sympathy for accused \nEvidence of defendants' use of prostitutes was \nnot admissible at trial on charges arising from \nalleged drug distribution and money laundering \nconsp\n... [truncated, 2699 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/2 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=2]", "char_count": 2699}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \n1191 \nfact that she dated them, and government \nintended \nto \nelicit \nnoninflammatory manner. \nCases that cite this headnote \nConspiracy \n*admissibility in general \ninformation \nin \nEvidence of large cash loans made by defendant \nwas admissible, at trial on charges arising from \nalleged drug distribution and money laundering \nconspiracy, to show defendant's possession of \nsuch cash as evidence of conspiracy. \nCases that cite this headnote \nCriminal Law \n*Motions in limine \nDistrict court would deny defendant's motion in \nlimine seeking to preclude, at trial on charges \narising from alleged drug distribution and \nmoney \nlaundering \nconspiracy, \ntestimony \nregarding \naliases, \ncarrying \nof \nbriefcase \ncontaining $10,000, and putting assets in other \npersons' names; depending on context, those \nincidents \ncould \nbe \nrelevant, \nand \nany \nfoundational issues were properly addressed at \ntrial. Fed.Rules Evid.Rule 401, 2S U.S.C.A. \nCases that cite this headnote \n1201 \nCriminal Law \n4-Motions in limine \nDistrict court would deny defendant's motion in \nlimine seeking to preclude, at trial on charges \narising from alleged drug distribution and \nmoney laundering conspiracy, evidence of debt \nowed to defendant; government's theory was \nthat debt would be linked up when viewed in \ncontext of evidence at trial and, thus, court \nwould reserve ruling. \nCases that cite this headnote \n1211 \nCriminal Law \n*Motions in limine \nDistrict court would deny defendant's motion in \nlimine seeking to preclude testimony at trial on \ncharges arising from alleged drug distribution \nand money laundering conspiracy; government's \ntheory of admissibility was based on witness' \nbeing unindicted coconspirator, and papers \nsubmitted could not supply enough context to \nrule on issue. \nCases that cite this headnote \n122l \nJury \n4Codefendants \nDecision as to whether to grant additional \nperemptory challenges in multidefendant trial \nlies within sound discretion of \n... [truncated, 2710 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/3 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=3]", "char_count": 2710}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \ndemonstrative evidence \n1241 \nCriminal Law \n4—Materiality and probable effect of information \nin general \nUnder Brady rule, prosecution is barred from \nwithholding evidence that is favorable to \ndefendant and material to issue at trial. \nCases that cite this headnote \n1251 \nCriminal Law \n4-Grand jury proceedings \nDefendant was not entitled to disclosure, under \nBrady, of witness' grand jury testimony; \nprosecution did not intend to call witness at trial, \nand, although witness' testimony indicated \nabsence of knowledge of any illegality on part \nof defendant, Brady materiality determination \nwas not search for mere possibilities. \nCases that cite this headnote \n1261 \nCriminal Law \n4-Sound recordings \nCriminal Law \n4-Sound recordings \nGovernment was not required, as foundational \nmatter or under Sixth Amendment, to place \nnondefendant participant in conversation with \ndefendant on stand in order to play tapes of \nconversation, which participant transmitted on \nbehalf of government. U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. \n6. \nI Cases that cite this headnote \n1271 \nCriminal Law \nfaIntroduction of documentary and \nDistrict court would exclude alleged references, \nin \ntape-recorded \nconversation \ninvolving \ndefendant, who was charged in connection with \nalleged drug distribution and money laundering \nconspiracy, to potential intimidation or murder \nof government witness; it was not clear that \ndefendant was agreeing to or encouraging such \nintimidation, either through inaudibility or \ntruncated \ntransmission, \ntranscripts \nwere \nincomplete, and subject matter was highly \ninflammatory. \nI Cases that cite this headnote \n1251 \nWitnesses \n4-Incompetency for or Against Each Other in \nGeneral \n\"Adverse spousal testimony privilege\" gives \nperson presently married to criminal defendant \nright not to testify against his spouse. \nCases that cite this headnote \nWitnesses \n4-Objections to competency in general \nOnly testifying spouse can assert adverse \nspou\n... [truncated, 2512 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/4 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=4]", "char_count": 2512}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nrequired to prove that claim at trial, and adverse \nspousal testimony privilege was threshold \nmatter. \nCases that cite this headnote \n1311 \nCriminal Law \n4-Presence of jury during inquiry as to \nadmissibility \n1321 \n1331 \nDistrict court would require government, before \npresenting attorney-client communications, to \nestablish out of hearing of jury that exception to \nattorney-client privilege operated. \nCases that cite this headnote \nCriminal Law \n4-Confessions or declarations of codefendants \nAdmission of references to defendant in \ncodefendants' conversations which took place \nafter alleged drug distribution and money \nlaundering conspiracy ended did not implicate \nconfrontation \nclause; \nreferences \nrequired \n\"linkage\" to defendant before they implicated \nhim. U.S.C.A. Const.Amend. 6. \nCases that cite this headnote \nConspiracy \n4-Admissibility in general \nGovernment could \nintroduce evidence of \ndefendant's incarceration at trial on charges \narising out of alleged drug distribution and \nmoney \nlaundering conspiracy; superseding \nindictment specifically charged that defendant \ndirected coconspirators while incarcerated. \nCases that cite this headnote \nWl \nCriminal Law \n4-Motions in limine \nDistrict court would deny defendant's motion in \nlimine to preclude, at trial on charges arising \nfrom alleged drug distribution and money \nlaundering conspiracy, evidence \nregarding \nisolated incidents of small controlled substance \ndeliveries; government intended to prove that \ndefendant sold small amounts of cocaine during \ncourse of and in furtherance of conspiracy, and, \nfurthermore, defendant's motion was too vague \nto warrant ruling that all incidents fitting into his \ndescription should be excluded. \nI Cases that cite this headnote \nAttorneys and Law Firms \n*1180 L. Felipe Sanchez, Matthew Schneider, Kathleen \nMurdock, Asst. U.S. Attys., Chicago, IL, for U.S. \nMarc William Martin, Chicago, IL, for Christopher \nRichard Messina. \n\n... [truncated, 2755 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/5 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=5]", "char_count": 2755}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nChicago, IL, for Lawrence Thomas. \nMEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER \nALESIA, District Judge. \nBefore the court are pretrial motions in limine as well as a \nfew remaining pretrial motions and matters. For \nbackground on this case see United States v. Messino, 871 \nF.Supp. 1035 (N.D.I11.1995), and other cases cited at 871 \nF.Supp. at 1037-38 of that opinion. \nI. TAINT ISSUES RELATED TO PREVIOUSLY \nSUPPRESSED EVIDENCE \nOn January 18, 1995, the court conducted a taint hearing \nto determine what, if any, items would be suppressed as \nevidence because of their having been derived from leads \nattributable to already suppressed evidence. The hearings \nwere on the motions of defendants Christopher Richard \nMessino and Clement A. Messino. Based upon the \ncredible evidence of record the court makes the following \nfindings of fact and conclusions of law. The court \nconsiders now only those items challenged in defendants' \npost-hearing submissions. \n*1181 A. Findings of Fact \nCredibility Finding \n1. Special Agent Michael Priess, the sole witness at the \nhearing, was a credible witness in all respects. His \ntestimony \ndemonstrated \ndetailed \nrecall \nof \nfacts \nsurrounding the instant investigation. \nChallenges from Christopher Richard Messina \n2. The lease between Nick Sula and Christopher Richard \nMessino is attributable to an independent source of \ndiscovery. \n3. The government's identification and use of Jerry Haas \nand Lisa Batts as witnesses are attributable to an \nindependent source of discovery. \nChallenges from Clement A. Messino \n4. The government's identification of Clement A. \nMessino's boat and place of purchase are attributable to \nan independent source of discovery. \n5. The government's identification and use of George \nThorpe, John Richard, Phillip Webb, Ed Cozzi, and Frank \nFuscone as witnesses are attributable to an independent \nsource of discovery. \n6. The identity and significance of Chris Smith as a \nwitness would have ine\n... [truncated, 3278 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/6 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=6]", "char_count": 3278}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \n1314-18, 1318 n. I. \nPI 4. When the disputed evidence inevitably would have \nbeen discovered by lawful means, the inevitably \ndiscovery doctrine renders the evidence admissible \ndespite the primary taint. See United States v. Jackson, \n901 F.2d 83, 84-85 (7th Cir.I 990); Markling, 7 F.3d at \n1318 n. 1. \nC. Holding \n141 151 No further items are suppressed as evidence because \nof tainted leads. \nII. GOVERNMENT'S CONSOLIDATED \nPRE—TRIAL MOTION IN LIMINE \nThe \ngovernment's \nmotion \nraises \neight \nseparate \nevidentiary issues. \nA. Impeachment of Joseph Granata \nFor reasons discussed under Clement Messino's motion in \n!amine, the government's motion in this regard is granted. \nB. Evidence and Argument of Lawfulness and \nNon-corrupt Conduct \n161 The government's motion in this respect cannot be \nevaluated absent the more specific context provided at \ntrial. Accordingly, in this respect said motion is denied. \nC. Evidence and Argument of Outrageous \nGovernment Conduct \nThe government's motion in this respect cannot be \nevaluated absent the more specific context provided at \ntrial. Accordingly, in this respect said motion is denied. \n*1182 D. Evidence and Argument of Entrapment \nI'll No defendant has responded to this part of the motion \nby asserting a right to argue entrapment in opening \nstatements. Accordingly, in this regard the government's \nmotion is denied as moot.' \nE. Mention of Prior Prosecution Experience by \nDefense Counsel \n181 Clement Messino's attorney, as far as the court is \naware, is the only person to whom this argument is \ndirected. Counsel represents he has no intention to \nmention his prosecution experience. On the off chance \nanother attorney or a witness might introduce the fact of \ncounsel's prosecution experience, the court holds that the \nsubject is irrelevant, and accordingly grants the motion in \nthis regard. FED.R.EVID. 401, 402. \nF. Evidence and Argument About Draft Transcripts \n191 The government does \n... [truncated, 3091 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/7 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=7]", "char_count": 3091}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nexamination. \nAccordingly, \nin \nthis \nregard \nthe \ngovernment's motion is denied. \nIn conclusion, the Government's Motion in Limine is \ngranted in part, denied in part, and denied as moot in part. \nIII. GOVERNMENT'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO \nRECALL CERTAIN WITNESSES DURING ITS \nCASE IN CHIEF \n1121 \" 31 In order to present its case in a \"chronological, \ncoherent manner,\" the government asks to be able to \nrecall certain witnesses during its case in chief. The court \nhas the discretionary authority to allow the case in chief to \nproceed as the government suggests. See United States v. \nDent, 984 F.2d 1453, 1463 (7th Cir.) (citing cases), cert. \ndenied, 510 U.S. 858, 114 S.Ct. 169, 126 L.Ed.2d 129, \nand 510 U.S. 875, 114 S.Ct. 209, 126 L.Ed.2d 165 (1993); \nFED.R.EVID. 611(a). The court agrees with the \ngovernment that, properly executed, its proposal would be \nbeneficial to the jury's following the government's case. \nAccordingly, the Government's Motion for Leave to \nRecall Certain Witnesses During Its Case in Chief is \ngranted. \nIV. DEFENDANT CHRISTOPHER RICHARD \nMESSINO'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE \nINCOMPETENT LAW OPINION EVIDENCE, \nEVIDENCE BASED UPON LACK OF PERSONAL \nKNOWLEDGE AND EVIDENCE BASED UPON \nHEARSAY \nDefendant Christopher Richard Messino's motion, \nphrased as it is, seeks merely to enforce Rules 602, 701 \nand 802. As long as the court is careful to note that \ndefendant's examples of enforcement of these rules are \nnot necessarily valid, the motion may be granted. \n*1183 Defendant Christopher Richard Messino's Motion \nin Limine to Preclude Incompetent Law Opinion \nEvidence, Evidence Based upon Lack of Personal \nKnowledge and Evidence Based upon Hearsay is granted. \nFED.R.EVID. 602, 701 and 802. \nV. DEFENDANT CHRISTOPHER RICHARD \nMESSINO'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE \nEVIDENCE REGARDING CHRISTOPHER \nRICHARD MESSINO'S EMPLOYMENT AS A \nPOLICE OFFICER \nDefendant Christopher Richard Messino's Motion in \nLimine to Precl\n... [truncated, 2902 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/8 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=8]", "char_count": 2902}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1'177 (1995) \n4. Severance \nThe government is right. The severance issue has been \ngiven its due. In this regard the motion is denied. \nB. Tax Evidence for Years Other than 1986 and 1987 \n115) This evidence may be admissible to show no \nlegitimate source of income. See United States v. Briscoe, \n896 F.2d 1476, 1500 (7th Cir.) (\"It is well settled that in \nnarcotics prosecutions, a defendant's possession and \nexpenditure of large sums of money, as well as his or her \nfailure to file tax returns, are relevant to establish that, in \nall probability, the reason for the failure to report this \nincome is due to the defendant's participation in illegal \nactivities.\"), cert. denied, 498 U.S. 863, III S.Ct. 173, \n112 L.Ed.2d 137 (1990). Accordingly, in this regard the \nmotion is denied. \nC. Rumors Regarding Murders \nThe government has no intention of introducing any \nmurder issue, so in this regard the motion is denied as \nmoot. \nD. Sex Evidence/Use of Prostitutes \n1161 1171 The motion and the government's response raise a \nfew issues here. First, any defendant's use of prostitutes is \nirrelevant and overly prejudicial, absent some special \ncircumstances, which the government does not forward. \nSecond, defendant wants to avoid reference to the fact \nthat some defendants may have had sexual relationships \nwith the same women. The government is right, though, \nto note that it may be difficult for a witness to tell her \nstory of her relation to those defendants without \ndiscussing the fact that she dated them. The government \nintends to elicit the information in a \"non-inflammatory\" \nmanner, a representation under which the introduction of \nthe evidence will not be unduly prejudicial. \nIn this regard the motion is granted in part and denied in \npart. \n*1184 E. Possession of Weapons \nThis evidence is admissible on a tool-of-the-trade theory, \nas discussed above. In this regard the motion is denied. \nF. Loan Sharking \nI'M All the government intends to\n... [truncated, 3333 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/9 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=9]", "char_count": 3333}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nthis regard the motion is denied as moot. \nK. Timothy Larkin \nTwo concerns are here. First is evidence of an accusation \nby Christopher Richard Messina that Larkin stole money. \nThe government does not seek to introduce such \nevidence. Second is evidence of large amounts of cash, \nwhich the government is entitled to introduce. In this \nregard the motion is denied as moot in part and denied in \npart. \nL. Mary Beth Maroulis \nHere the motion raises foundational issues, reserved for \ntrial. In this regard the motion is denied. \nM. Dawn Peco \nHere the motion addresses a gun shot incident, which the \ngovernment says it will not introduce. In this regard the \nmotion is denied as moot. \nN. Pete Peco, Jr. \n12.1 Here defendant raises an issue of evidence of a debt \nowed by Gray Chrystall to Christopher Richard Messina. \nThe government's theory is that the debt will be linked up \nwhen viewed in the context of the evidence at trial. \nAccordingly, the court reserves ruling by denying the \nmotion in this regard. \n0. Pete Peco, Sr. \nThe government has agreed not to introduce the disputed \nevidence that Christopher Richard Messina asked this \nwitness to beat up a certain \"kid.\" Accordingly, in this \nregard the motion is denied as moot. \nP. Terry Saberhagen \nPH The government's theory of the admissibility of \nchallenged testimony by Saberhagen is based on \nSaberhagen's being an unindicted coconspirator. The \ncourt reserves ruling until trial, as the papers cannot \nsupply enough context presently to rule. In this regard the \nmotion is denied. \nIn conclusion, Defendant Christopher Richard Messino's \nOmnibus Motion in Limine is granted in part, denied in \npart, and denied as moot in part. \n*1185 VII. DEFENDANT CHRISTOPHER \nRICHARD MESSINO'S MOTION FOR \nADDITIONAL PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES \nMI Under Rule 24(b) of the Federal Rules of Criminal \nProcedure, in this non•capital case in which \"the offense \ncharged is punishable by more than one year, the\n... [truncated, 3741 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/10 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=10]", "char_count": 3741}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nMotion for Additional Peremptory Challenges is denied. \nVIII. DEFENDANT CHRISTOPHER RICHARD \nMESSINO'S MOTION FOR PRODUCTION OF \nEXCULPATORY OR IMPEACHING MATERIAL \nDefendant seeks material pursuant to Brady v. Maryland, \n373 U.S. 83, 83 S.Ct. 1194, 10 L.Ed.2d 215 (1963), and \nGiglio v. United States, 405 U.S. 150, 92 S.Ct. 763, 31 \nL.Ed.2d 104 (1972). Specifically, defendant seeks \ninformation regarding three individuals: Fred Maleki, \nCindy Delapena and Patrick Tobin. Regarding Tobin, the \ngovernment represents that it has no written statements. \nRegarding Maleki and Delapena, the government asserts \nthat (1) it does not intend to call those witnesses; and (2) \nnone of the material on them is exculpatory. \n1241 \n1251 The court has verified through in camera \ninspection that the government's files on Malcki and \nDelapena do not contain Brady material. Brady bars the \nprosecution from withholding \"evidence that is favorable \nto the defendant and material to an issue at trial.\" United \nStates v. Carson, 9 F.3d 576, 582 (7th Cir.1993), cert. \ndenied, 513 U.S. 844, 115 S.Ct. 135, 130 L.Ed.2d 77 \n(1994). The Delapena Grand Jury testimony does not \nmeet this test. Stretching materiality to its limits, one \ncould argue that on some theory Delapena's absence of \nknowledge of any illegality on the part of Christopher \nRichard Messino makes her testimony material. But a \nBrady materiality determination is not a search for mere \npossibilities. Id., 9 F.3d at 583. Under this analysis the \ncourt will not order production of the Delapena testimony. \nSimilarly, Maleki's testimony need not be produced by \nthe government. The court's inspection of the testimony \nreveals no Brady material. \n*1186 Accordingly, Defendant Christopher Richard \nMessina's Motion to Produce Exculpatory or Impeaching \nInformation is denied. \nIX. DEFENDANT CLEMENT A. MESSINO'S \nMOHON IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE CERTAIN \nEVIDENCE \nDefendant Clement Messina raises five issue\n... [truncated, 4492 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/11 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=11]", "char_count": 4492}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \n1281 1291 The court does not reach issues of the confidential \nmarital communications privilege, because there is a \nthreshold issue of whether the adverse spousal testimony \nprivilege will apply. See Keck, 773 F.2d at 767. By the \ngovernment's own description, this privilege gives a \nperson presently married to a criminal defendant the right \nnot to testify against his or her spouse. See United States \nv. Fulk, 816 F.2d 1202, 1205 (7th Cir.1987). The \ngovernment has two reasons why the adverse spousal \ntestimony privilege will not apply: first, Pamela Messino \nis not asserting the privilege (as only she can assert it); \nand second, the marriage is a sham. \n1101 As far as the first point, Clement Messino's counsel's \ninformation is that Pamela Messino will assert the \nprivilege. (See Defendant Clement Messino's Reply \nMemorandum in Support of Motion in Limine to Exclude \nCertain Evidence at 9 n. 5.) Therefore, questions under \nthis privilege may arise. As far as the second point, as the \nstrength of the marriage is contested by defendant, the \ngovernment would have to •1187 prove up any exception, \nor at least present uncontested facts on which the \nexception would be based. See generally United States v. \nClark, 712 F.2d 299 (7th Cir.1983). Such a prove up \nwould undoubtedly resolve many of the issues as to the \nconfidential marital communications privilege, which \nClement Messino himself can invoke. Nonetheless, the \nadverse spousal testimony privilege is a threshold matter. \nThe court reserves the factual determinations necessary to \nrule on the privileges until trial, and accordingly denies \ndefendant's motion in this regard. \nC. Michael Gubbins \n1311 As the briefing came to a close, all defendant wants \nhere is to obligate the government, before presenting \nattorney-client communications, to establish out of \nhearing of the jury that an exception to the privilege \noperates. This is a safe and reasonable request, so the \n... [truncated, 3859 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/12 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=12]", "char_count": 3859}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nE. Other Issues \n1. Incarceration \nDefendant wishes to avoid introduction of any \nevidence of his incarceration. The government's most \nimportant response, with which defendant never comes to \ngrips, is that paragraph eleven of Count I of the \nSuperseding Indictment specifically charges that Clement \nMessino directed coconspirators while incarcerated. \nIntroduction of evidence of incarceration is therefore hard \nto avoid. \nIn this regard defendant's motion is denied. \n2. Escape \nThe government does not intend to introduce specific \nevidence of defendant's escape, so the motion in this \nregard is denied as moot. \n3. Employment as Police Officer \nThe motion in this regard is denied. FED.R.EVID. 401, \n402. \n4. Organized Crime References \nThe government does not intend to introduce references to \norganized crime, except perhaps for a statement by \nClement Messina that he is a good gangster because he \nused to be a police officer. The court has been provided a \nparaphrased snippet of testimony from a witness about \nwhom it has heard little *1188 or nothing in the context of \nthis case. The court must therefore reserve ruling, and the \nmotion is accordingly denied. \nIn conclusion Defendant Clement Messino's Motion in \nLimine to Exclude Certain Evidence is granted in part, \ndenied in part, and denied as moot in part. \nX. DEFENDANT DONALD SOUTHERN'S \nMOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE VARIOUS \nINADMISSIBLE STATEMENTS \nDefendant Donald Southern raises two evidentiary issues \nregarding (1) statements of presumption, guesses or \nconclusions by lay witnesses, and (2) testimony of \nSouthern's role without personal knowledge, unless \nfoundation is laid or Rule 80 1(dX2)(E) applies. This is in \nthe category of motions to have the Federal Rules of \nEvidence apply to the trial. \nAccordingly, Defendant Donald Southern's Motion in \nLimine to Preclude Various Inadmissible Statements is \ngranted. \nXI. DEFENDANT CHRISTOPHER B. MESSINO'S \nMOTION IN LIMI\n... [truncated, 2890 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/13 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=13]", "char_count": 2890}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "U.S. v. Messino, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nXII. DEFENDANT BLAISE MESSINO'S MOTION \nIN LIMINE REGARDING THE INTRODUCHON \nOF CERTAIN EVIDENCE \nDefendant Blaise Messino raises two issues. \nA. Possession of Firearms \nAt least as a preliminary matter, evidence of possession of \nfirearms is admissible on a tool-of-the-trade theory. \nB. Violence \nIssues regarding evidence of violence have been reserved \nfor trial. \nDefendant Blaise Messino's Motion in Limine Regarding \nthe Introduction of Certain Evidence is denied. \nXIII. DEFENDANT PAUL MESSINO'S MOTION \nIN LIMINE REGARDING INTRODUCHON OF \nCERTAIN EVIDENCE \nPaul Messino's motion in conclusory fashion raises seven \nevidentiary issues. \nA. Evidence of Robberies or a Fight \nThe government either does not intend to introduce such \nevidence or correctly notes the motion is not specific \nenough to support a ruling. In this respect the motion is \ndenied. \nB. Evidence Regarding His Possession of Weapons \nIn this respect defendant's motion is denied. The evidence \nmay be admissible on a tool-of-the-trade theory. \nC. Evidence of Violence \nIn this respect defendant's motion is denied. the court \nreserving ruling. \nD. Evidence of Drug Deliveries Outside of Charged \nConspiracy \nDefendant's cursory request here is too vague and \noverbroad to support a ruling. *1189 Accordingly, the \nmotion in this respect is denied. \nE. Evidence of Involvement with Stolen Vehicles \nThe government correctly notes that the court has \npreviously reserved ruling on this issue. In this respect the \nmotion is denied. \nF. Evidence that Paul Messino Traveled to Florida to \nPick Up Cocaine for Clement Messino or Others \nAmong other things, this conduct would seem to be part \nof the heart of the case against Paul Messino. The motion \nin this regard is without basis and is denied. \nG. Evidence that Defendant Sold Cocaine to \nConfidential Informant Unless Informant is Produced \nfor Cross-examination \nThe government argues that there is no such requirement. \nHowever\n... [truncated, 2396 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/14 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=14]", "char_count": 2396}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00013373", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "U.S. v. MossIno, 873 F.Supp. 1177 (1995) \nCONCLUSION \nNo further items are suppressed as evidence because of \ntainted leads. Government's Motion in Limine is granted \nin part, denied in part, and denied as moot in part. \nGovernment's Motion for Leave to Recall Certain \nWitnesses During Its Case in Chief is granted. Defendant \nChristopher Richard Messino's Motion in Limine to \nPreclude Incompetent Law Opinion Evidence, Evidence \nBased upon Lack of Personal Knowledge and Evidence \nBased upon Hearsay is granted. Defendant Christopher \nRichard Messino's Motion in Limine to Preclude \nEvidence Regarding Christopher Richard Messino's \nEmployment as a Police Officer is denied. Defendant \nChristopher Richard Messino's Omnibus Motion in \nLimine is granted in part, denied in part, and denied as \nmoot in part. Defendant Christopher Richard Messino's \nMotion for Additional Peremptory Challenges is denied. \nDefendant Christopher Richard Messino's Motion to \nFootnotes \nProduce Exculpatory or Impeaching Information is \ndenied. Defendant Clement Messino's Motion in Limine \nto Exclude Certain Evidence is granted in part, denied in \npart, and denied as moot in part. Defendant Donald \nSouthern's Motion in Limine to Preclude Various \nInadmissible \nStatements \nis \ngranted. \nDefendant \nChristopher B. Messino's Motion in Limine with Regard \nto Certain Evidence is denied. Defendant Blaise \nMessino's Motion in Limine Regarding the Introduction \nof Certain Evidence is denied. Defendant Paul Messino's \nMotion in Limine Regarding Introduction of Certain \nEvidence is denied in part and denied as moot in part. \nAll Citations \n873 F.Supp. 1177 \nThe course of trial may raise other entrapment issues. For now, the court considers only opening statements. \n2 \nAny attempt by defendants to use the drafts for other purposes would be evaluated at trial. \n3 \nThe government wants to preclude evidence that any of its witnesses once worked as prostitutes, but presents no motion. The \ndefendants therefore have\n... [truncated, 2892 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00013373/15 or ?id=EFTA00013373&page=15]", "char_count": 2892}]}