{"efta_number": "EFTA00011489", "page_count": 5, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00011489", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00011489.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00011489", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "From: Christian Everdell\nTo:\n(USANYS)\"\nCe: \"Mark S. Cohen\"\nBobbi Sternheim\n>, Jeff Pagliuca\n\"Laura Menninger\"\"\nSubject: RE: Discovery Requests\nDate: Fri, 29 Jan 2021 20:52:49 +0000\nInline-Images: image001.jpg; image002.jpg\nThanks for the follow-up. Please send the documents to the FTP link below:\nhttps://cohengresser.sharefile.com/r-r16397a3bc183400da73b80cbfa69f256\nAlso, we are missing the Bates ranges listed below.\nSDNY_GM_00167911 through SDNY_GM_00168477\nSDNY_GM_00168488 through SDNY_GM_00169165\nSDNY_GM_00169184 through SDNY_GM_00169491\nSDNY_GM_00169505 through SDNY_GM_00169735\nWe had discussed these ranges several months ago and I believe you had agreed to reproduce them in the 11/9\nproduction. But we do not appear to have received them. Can you send these ranges via the FTP site as well?\nThanks,\nChris\nFrom:\n[mailto:\nSent: Friday, January 29, 2021 10:31 AM\nTo: Christian Everdell;\n(USANYS)\nCc: Mark S. Cohen; Bobbi Sternheim; Jeff Pagliuca; 'Laura Menninger'\nSubject: RE: Discovery Requests\nChris,\nFollowing up on this, we have now prepared all of the items you requested in point 6 below for production to you. Our\nparalegals have sent a copy of the materials to the MDC for your client. Would you like to provide us with an FTP link for\nthis production, or would you like us to prepare a CD for you instead?\nThanks,\nAssistant United States Attorney\nSouthern District of New York\nEFTA00011489\n", "char_count": 1411}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00011489", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "From:\nSent: Monday, January 25, 2021 3:56 PM\nTo: 'Christian Everdell'\n(USANYS)\nCc: 'Mark S. Cohen'\nSubject: RE: Discovery Requests\nChris,\n>; 'Bobbi Sternheim'\n>; 'Jeff Pagliuca'\n>; 'Laura Menninger'\nFollowing up on point 6 below, our paralegals have re-stamped the materials you identified with a Bates range overlap\nand are prepared to reproduce those materials to you. The materials are small enough to produce via your FTP site.\nWould you like to send us a link to where you would like those materials uploaded? Alternatively, we can load the\nmaterials to a CD and send it to you.\nWe are still waiting to hear back from our vendor about the remaining issues you identified in point 6.\nThanks,\nAssistant United States Attorney\nSouthern District of New York\nFrom:\nSent: Sunday, January 17, 2021 10:05 PM\nTo: Christian Everdell\n(USANYS)\nCc: Mark S. Cohen\n>; Bobbi Sternheim\nJeff Pagliuca\n>; 'Laura Menninger'\nSubject: RE: Discovery Requests\nChris,\nBelow please find our responses.\n1. As we have recently discussed, Ms. Maxwell now has access to the 4TB drive containing a full set of the discovery\nproduced to date. It took a significant amount of time to create this copy due to the volume of discovery and\ndelays on the part of our vendor, who assisted in creating the copy.\n2. As we have recently discussed, Ms. Maxwell now has a drive containing the contents of the CD produced on\nNovember 18, 2020.\nEFTA00011490\n", "char_count": 1417}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00011489", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "3. As I conveyed to you over the phone and in a recent email, the materials produced from the Subject Devices all\ncontain metadata indicating the \"NYC\" CART Evidence Number of the device from which each document was\nextracted. In our November 18, 2020 discovery letter, we provided you with a chart setting forth which \"NYC\"\nCART Evidence Number corresponds with which Subject Device in our warrants. If you still need a detailed index\nof all 1.2 million documents with the specific Subject Device indicated, please let me know, and I will ask one of\nour paralegals to compile one.\n4. We produced the FBI report bearing Bates number SDNY_GM_02050812-14 in the form in which it was\nrecovered from one of Epstein's devices. In other words, we did not apply any redactions to that document;\nrather, the redactions existed on the document at the time the document was found during the FBI's search of\nEpstein's devices. We are not aware of any legal basis for your request for a log of redactions. If you have any\nlegal authority on that point, we would be happy to consider it. As a courtesy, I will note that our office did not\napply redactions to any material that was identified responsive during the searches of Epstein's devices.\n5. We are aware of our discovery obligations, have complied with them, and will continue to comply with them. We\nare not aware of any legal basis for your request that we inform you of what, if any, documents have been\nwithheld or the basis for their withholding. If you have any legal authority on that point, we would be happy to\nconsider it. As a courtesy, I will note that we have provided you with all records we received from AT&T and all\nrecords we received from David Rodgers. As to your inquiry about the Bates ranges on the Rodgers documents\nbeginning with Bates number \"28\", I note that the folder containing the Rodgers subpoena returns in our August\n5, 2020 production included two documents. The first (SDNY_GM_00005532-5649) is the document you\nreferenced in your email inquiry. The second (SDNY_GM_00005650-5676) is 27 pages long, accounting for the\nfirst 27 pages of the production from Rodgers. We produced those two documents in the form in which we\nreceived them.\n6. Our paralegals are working on the issues you identified with Bates ranges and metadata load files. I will reach\nback out to you once I have an update on the status of those issues.\n7. We do not have a more detailed index of the November 9 and November 18 productions beyond what we have\nprovided to you.\n8. We are not aware of any legal basis for your request for copies of grand jury subpoenas. Nor are we aware of any\nlegal basis for your request that we identify the date range of documents we requested in each subpoena. If you\nhave any legal authority for those requests, we would be happy to consider it.\n9. The court filings that appear to be referenced in the Daily Beast article you sent are an application for a search\nwarrant and a search warrant filed in the District of New Hampshire. We produced both documents to you in\ndiscovery on August 5, 2020. The DNH judge issued a sealing order in connection with the warrant and\napplication. As you can see at Bates No. SDNY_GM_00000621, the sealing order automatically expired on\nDecember 30, 2020. Our understanding is that the District of New Hampshire unsealed the filing of its own\naccord in conformity with the clear language of that sealing order. Our office took no affirmative steps to unseal\nor otherwise release these filings.\nBest,\nAssistant United States Attorney\nSouthern District of New York\nEFTA00011491\n", "char_count": 3596}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00011489", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "From: Christian Everdell<\nSent: Thursday, January 7, 2021 4:13 PM\nTo:\n(USANYS)\nCc: Mark S. Cohen\nSubject: Discovery Requests\nBobbi Sternheim\n>; Jeff Pagliuca\n>; 'Laura Menninger'\nWe write to raise a number of discovery issues. Please let us know your position on these issues at your earliest\nconvenience.\n1. In our email correspondence on 11/18/2020, you agreed to create a new hard drive containing the entire discovery\nproduction. We provided you with a 4TB hard drive for that purpose on 11/20/2020. It is very important for Ms.\nMaxwell to have this drive as soon as possible to prepare her defense. Do you have an update on when the drive\nwill be ready?\n2. We also informed you that the CD produced on November 18, 2020 did not work on the prison computer at the\nMDC (as you know, the laptop provided to Ms. Maxwell does not have a CD drive). Accordingly, we asked you to\ninclude the material on the CD in the new 4TB hard drive. We followed-up with you about this issue on December\n30, 2020. Given that the new hard drive is still not ready, we ask that you download the material on the CD onto\na separate thumb drive or hard drive and provide it as quickly as possible to Ms. Maxwell at the MDC so that she\ncan review the materials this weekend. Alternatively, you can provide an external CD drive to Ms. Maxwell at\nthe MDC so that she can read the files on the MDC computer. We will provide whatever media device you\nrequire to facilitate this production.\n3. Unlike the November 9, 2020 discovery cover letter, the November 18, 2020 discovery cover letter (attached) does\nnot correlate the Bates numbers to the particular \"Subject Device\" from which the documents were recovered.\nInstead, the cover letter indicates that the documents came from \"SDNY_PROD015\" or \"SDNY_PROD016.\" We do\nnot know what those terms refer to. We request that the government produce a list that correlates the Bates\nnumbers for all of the documents in SDNY_PROD015 and SDNY_PROD016 to the particular devices from which the\ndocuments were recovered.\n4. We request that the government provide an unredacted version of the FBI report, dated December 6, 2006,\nbearing Bates number SDNY_GM_02050812-14 (attached). We also request that the government produce a log\nidentifying all of the redacted documents in the discovery and the bases for each of the redactions.\n5. There are a few documents that seem to be missing from the discovery. For example, the AT&T documents\n(SDNY_GM_00001015-3637) do not seem to include subscriber information for the various phone numbers. Also,\nthe flight logs produced by David Rodgers begin at Bates number \"Rodgers000028,\" suggesting that\nRodgers000001-000027 were not produced to us. Please produce these documents to us or provide an\nexplanation why you are not producing them to us. Please confirm whether there are other documents that were\nremoved from the grand jury subpoena productions that we have not yet identified and the basis for their removal.\n6. There are a few Bates number/metadata issues with some of the documents:\na. There is an overlap between the fourth and fifth document productions. The fourth production ends at\nSDNY_GM_00328863, the fifth production begins at SDNY_GM_00328070. We propose renumbering the\nrange from the fifth production (i.e., renumber SDNY_GM_00328070-328863).\nEFTA00011492\n", "char_count": 3335}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00011489", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "b. The metadata load files (*.DAT) for PROD011 had a number of gaps which are detailed in the attached Excel\nfile. We propose that you send us a new DAT file covering only the missing documents.\nc. The metadata load files (*.DAT) for PROD015 had a gap from SDNY_GM_00723971 to SDNY_GM_00723981.\nWe propose that you send us a new DAT file covering only the missing documents.\n7. To the extent that the government has created an index of the documents produced on November 9 and\nNovember 18 that is more detailed than the production cover letters, we request that you provide a copy to the\ndefense.\n8. We request that the government provide copies of the grand jury subpoenas for documents issued by the\ngovernment in this case. Also, please identify the date range of documents you requested in each subpoena.\nThere is one other issue we'd like to raise. An article in the Daily Beast on Monday referenced the search warrant affidavit\nfor the cell-site simulator used to track Ms. Maxwell's cellphone before her arrest (https://www.thedailybeast.com/how-\nthe-fbi-tracked-down-ghislaine-maxwell-alleged-madam-of-jeffrey-epstein). The article stated that the affidavit appeared\nin a \"newly unsealed court filing.\" I don't recall this affidavit being unsealed or referenced in anything that was filed on\nthe court docket. Please confirm whether or not the government unsealed this affidavit or any other materials from the\ncriminal discovery, and whether any discovery materials were released pursuant to FOIA requests.\nRegards,\nChris\nChristian R Everdell\nCOHEN & GRESSER LLP\nview bio\nwww.cohengresser.com\nNew York | Paris | Washington DC | London\nCG\nCONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: The information contained in this e-mail may be confidential and/or privileged. This e-mail is intended to be reviewed initially by only\nthe individual named above. If the reader of this e-mail is not the intended recipient or a representative of the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any\nreview, dissemination or copying of this e-mail or the information contained herein is prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please immediately notify\nthe sender by telephone and permanently delete this e-mail. Thank you.\nPRIVACY: A complete copy of our privacy policy can be viewed at: https://www.cohengresser.com/privacy-policy.\nEFTA00011493\n", "char_count": 2337}]}