{"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_count": 11, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00009941", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00009941.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "From:\nTo: \"\nCc:\n(USANYS)\"\n)\".\nSubject: RE: call tomorrow re: search warrant documents?\nDate: Tue, 14 Jul 2020 16:17:36 +0000\nYeah it's sometimes challenging to try to precisely relay\nhelpful - thanks. I'll propose tomorrow at 1:00.\ninfo on this, and given the importance I think it'd be\nFrom:\n| (USANYS) <||\nSent: Tuesday, July 14, 2020 12:16\nTo:\nCc:\nSubject: RE: call tomorrow re: search warrant documents?\nSure, if that would be helpful. 1 is better for me than 12, but I can make it work if need be. Morning I can do 10-11.\nFrom:\nSent: Tuesday, July 14, 2020 12:07 PM\nTo:\n|(USANYS) <\nCc:\nSubject: call tomorrow re: search warrant documents?\nCould you join a call tomorrow? I could do noon or 1:00 if that works? (Or I also could do the morning if I get coverage\nfor a couple VOSR check-ins with Berman.)\nFrom:\n(NY) (FBI)\nSent: Tuesday, July 14, 2020 12:02\nTo:\nCc:\n|(USANYS) [Contractor]\n(NY) (FBI)\n(NY) (FBI)\n(USANYS)\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nI'll fill it out and get it back to you ASAP. I am available tomorrow from 7:30 AM till about 3:30 PM, just let me\nknow when.\nNY CART Coordinator\nSenior Forensic Examiner\ncell\ndesk\nOn Jul 14, 2020 11:58 AM,\n\"\nwrote:\nEFTA00009941\n", "char_count": 1196}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "We've received and reviewed the hard drive you provided last week. Unfortunately it's still not possible for us to\ndetermine which devices have been fully 100% included in that drive? We're not able to tell based on looking at the\ncontents, because the devices do not all appear to have their own folders.\nThe attached spreadsheet is the one you included on the drive, but it does not reflect which devices have been fully\ntransferred. Could you please fill in the two columns I've added, L and M, indicating which devices have been fully\ntransferred to us, and for the ones that are not fully transferred, the estimated time for completion? If you could please\nlet us know that today it will be extremely helpful in figuring out how to proceed.\nAnd separately, could you please let me know what times you're available for a call tomorrow? It would be helpful to\ndiscuss why a number of the devices were combined together in folders on the drive, rather than being provided\nseparately. And also helpful to know how long it would take to correct that.\nthanks very much,\nFrom:\nSent: Wednesday, May 13, 2020 12:25\nTo:\n(NY) (FBI)\n(USANYS) [Contractor] <\nCc:\n(NY) (FBI)\n(NY) (FBI)\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nRespectfully, I think there are some miscommunications here - all we have asked is to receive the materials in a format\nsuch that we can view them using a system we have access to. We're not able to get web-enabled access through any FBI\ntool, so we asked for the materials to be transferred in a loadable format so we could put them on Relativity, which both\nwe and the agents can access. We're required to have the files in a format that we can produce them to defense counsel.\nI've done that in many other cases and it hasn't previously been an issue. My understanding from | is that the best\nway to do it now is just for us (the U.S. Attorney's Office) to get the original files, which our vendor will process-by which\nI just mean converting into file formats that are loada\n... [truncated, 2833 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00009941/1 or ?id=EFTA00009941&page=1]", "char_count": 2833}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Just to be clear. The US Attorney's Office (or it's contractors) are not \"processing\" anything. You are taking files\nthat I will be extracting from processed evidence and putting them into an E-Discovery tool (Relativity) to do a\ntaint review.\nRelativity is NOT a forensic tool. It is incapable of dealing with many things that are found forensically on a\ncomputer like free space, slack space, and system files to name a few. When we started this, and you insisted\nyou do the taint review in Relativity, I warned you that it was adding months worth of work on top of what was\nalready done, and that Relativity was incapable of viewing everything. You insisted we do it this way. So now\nand I have come up with a way to fit this round peg into this square hole. We will get it done.\nSorry it has taken so long, but we are talking about terabytes worth of data over multiple forms of digital\nevidence. Phones, tablets, loose media, cameras, DVRs, servers, laptops, and desktop computers. We have\ngotten past encryption on multiple devices. When we review devices on such large cases, we usually do it piece\nby piece as things are processed, I was unaware that you didn't want to review as things were processed, that\nyou wanted to do it \"all at once\", so that added to the delay. Sorry for that. Just a differentiation of\nmethodology I suppose.\nand I feel confident that the method we have come up with will be more consistent and preserve the\nattribution of files to devices and links of e-mails to attachments that the load file generation that I did a while\nback was lacking.\nFBI NY CART Coordinator\nSenior Examiner\nFrom:\nSent: Tuesday, May 12, 2020 11:33 AM\nTo:\nCc:\n(NY) (FBI).\n<Christopher.Rozier@usdoj.gov>\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\n(USANYS) [Contractor]\nOkay, so just to check, you both think that there is not a need to do a test run? You're both comfortable with just basically\nsending us copies of everything? I don't totally understand why we couldn't have done that eig\n... [truncated, 2643 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00009941/2 or ?id=EFTA00009941&page=2]", "char_count": 2643}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "NY CART Coordinator\nSenior Forensic Examiner\ncell\ndesk\nOn May 12, 2020 11:15 AM,\nI have no doubt you do, but can you please tell us what that plan is? Thanks!\nwrote:\nFrom:\n(NY) (FBI)<\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <\nSent: Tuesday, May 12, 2020 11:11\nTo:\nCc:\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nI will use the spreadsheet, no problem.\nforward that will meet your needs.\nand I ironed out all the details. We've got a good plan moving\nNY CART Coordinator\nSenior Forensic Examiner\ncell\ndesk\nOn May 12, 2020 10:34 AM,\nwrote:\nit would be very helpful for us if you could please use the attached spreadsheet in transmitting that info so we\nmake sure we get all the info we need. I think you had previously sent us a list of certain information that unfortunately\nwasn't helpful for us, so we want to make sure we're all on the same page.\nIn terms of data transfer, |\nare you just sending a literal copy of all the raw data, and we'll process and upload it on\nour end? I ask to make sure we don't lose any searchability - when FBI sent versions before, it had already been\nprocessed. I think what we talked about on the phone a month ago was getting, for example, data from one device to\nmake sure it transfers correctly, before sending over literally everything - is that still the plan?\nthanks,\nFrom:\n|(USANYS) [Contractor]\nSent: Tuesday, May 12, 2020 10:27\nTo:\nCc:\n(NY) (FBI).\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nHello\nMe and\njust finished our phone call regarding the data.\nwhere the data was collected. I will work to send some hard drives to\nwill put together a list of the all of the data and\nso he can begin to copy the data and send\nit to us. I will need to figure out a way to get the data off of the hard drives.\nPlease let us know if there are any questions.\nThank you.\nEFTA00009944\n", "char_count": 1800}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "From:\nSent: Friday, May 8, 2020 2:15 PM\nTo:\n(NY) (FBI)\nCc:\n(FBI) <\n(NY) (FBI)<\n|(USANYS)<\n(USANYS)\n|(USANYS) [Contractor]\n=\n(NY)\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nOkay thanks - please do let us know if at any point that changes, otherwise we'll look forward to being able to review the\nreturns in early June. Thanks again.\nFrom:\n(NY) (FBI)\nSent: Friday, May 08, 2020 14:14\nTo:\nCc:\n(FBI) <\n| (USANYS) <|\n(NY) (FBI)<\n(USANYS)<\n|(USANYS) [Contractor]\n(NY)\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nThere has been talk of us returning to normal soon, so I don't think it will effect the timeline I initially gave you.\nIf it does, I'll let you know.\nNY CART Coordinator\nSenior Forensic Examiner\ncell\ndesk\nOn May 8, 2020 1:58 PM,\nwrote:\nUnderstood, thanks-it will be great to get that list on Thursday. As a refresh, the info we are looking for is in the\nattached spreadsheet template.\nOn the returns themselves, do the changes you mentioned mean that the estimate of a month from now for complete\ntransmission of the search warrant returns is no longer likely? If so could you please let us know what the current\nestimate would be, so we can factor that in? Thanks very much.\nFrom:\n(NY) (FBI)\nSent: Friday, May 08, 2020 13:50\n(NY) (FBI) <\nTo:\nCc:\n(FBI) <\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\n| (USANYS)\n(USANYS)\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <\n(NY)\nEFTA00009945\n", "char_count": 1375}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Sorry for the delay, they reduced us to 1 day a week, so things have been stretched out by a factor of 5. I will be\nback in the office on Thursday and will be able to get you the list then as I have to access some of our systems to\ndo so.\nAlso,\nplease reach out to me at one of the numbers below so we can brain storm. Thanks.\nNY CART Coordinator\nSenior Forensic Examiner\ncell\ndesk\nOn May 8, 2020 12:10 PM,\n\"\nwrote:\nFollowing up on the below, I think you had said you expected to be able to get us a list of the devices seized from the\nsearch warrants at Epstein's residences in New York and the USVI, as well as from his person upon arrest, in about a\nmonth (during our conference call a month ago) - so wanted to check if we can still expect that very soon? We're waiting\non that list to be able to do an updated search warrant on all of those devices. Please let us know the current timeline -\nand also the current timeline on producing the results from those August and September searches? I think you and\nwere going to coordinate on that, and you had mentioned you expected we'd have it a couple months from our call, which\nwould be about a month from now. Wanted to make sure we're still on track.\nthanks,\nFrom:\n(NY) (FBI)<\nSent: Tuesday, April 07, 2020 15:27\nTo:\nCc:\n(FBI)<\n(USANYS)<\n(NY) (FBI)\n|(USANYS) <\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <\n(NY)\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nOk let's plan on 11am tomorrow morning, I am trying to get an FBI line with a larger capacity but I won't know until\ntomorrow am. I will push it out when confirmed.\nThanks\nFrom:\nSent: Tuesday, April 07, 2020 3:15 PM\nTo:\n(NY) (FBI)<\n(NY) (FBI)\nCc:\n[mailto:\n|(USANYS) <||\n| (USANYS) <|\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <Christopher. Rozier@usdoj.gov>;|\n(NY) (FBI)\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nYes, I can do anytime tomorrow, and\nRozier can also join anytime tomorrow. So whenever is good on your end.\nAlso, we can host a conference call, but only up to six lines at a time - so if FBI has larger capacity \n... [truncated, 2065 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00009941/5 or ?id=EFTA00009941&page=5]", "char_count": 2065}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "72345G\n1)\n2)\n3)\n4)\n5)\n6)\nFrom:\nif either of you wants to join (and if not, one of\n(NY) (FBI)<\nSent: Tuesday, April 07, 2020 14:13\nTo:\nCc:\n|(USANYS) <|\n(NY) (FBI)<\n(USANYS)\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <||\n(FBI) <\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nAre you available tomorrow for a conference call to discuss this issue?\nSSA\nFBI New York\nOn Apr 7, 2020 1:55 PM,\n44\n(NY)\nwrote:\nFollowing up on this from a month ago - I know we're living in a different world than what existed four weeks ago, but are\nyou at all able to assist while working remotely? This has been pending for almost two months and we still don't have a\nvery basic list of each device or item that was seized and searched, or for which of those we've received materials. We're\nhappy to have a call if that would be useful, but as a first step the most basic thing we're looking for is the info in the\ntemplate spreadsheet we sent earlier (that's also attached).\nthanks,\nFrom:\nSent: Monday, March 09, 2020 12:00\nTo:\n(NY) (FBI)\nCc:\n(NY) (FBI).\n(USANYS)<\n|(USANYS)<\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <\n(FBI) <\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\n(NY)\nUnfortunately I don't think this is very helpful to us. Did you take a look at the example spreadsheet I sent on 2/24? The\nexcel file you sent has descriptions that don't match up to the items listed in the search warrant returns (that we sent on\n2/23), and we don't have the 1B or CART numbers to be able to cross-reference. We also can't tell what you mean by\n\"loose media\" without a specific comparison to what was seized, we don't know which items you're referring to as\nEFTA00009947\n", "char_count": 1605}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "\"Windows machines,\" and we can't tell whether the entirety of any particular item has been transferred, or just partial.\nFor example, it looks like we have gotten very, very few image files, which is surprising.\nWe have also encountered some very significant problems in trying to review the more than 1 million documents we\nrecently received:\nThe data we've received has no way to put any emails and attachments together. So if an email says, \"see the\nattached flight records,\" for example, we have no way of linking that up with the records themselves. Not only is\nthat a big problem for us in review, it's going to be a huge problem for producing the documents to defense\ncounsel.\nThe load file has no link to the native file, so when we load the data to the database, there's no way to have the\nnative files show up in the database. Because many of the files are too large to open in the viewer, it effectively\nmeans that there are many files that are completely invisible to us.\nRelated, the control numbers in the load file don't match up to the native files. So we have two sets of numbers\nand no way to match up anything-that is, even if we were to try to go hunt down every individual large file in the\nnative files, it would be impossible.\nSo the data that we most recently got, we need to get in a form that addresses those issues, and we likely will need to get\na similar reproduction of the data we received a couple months ago. Otherwise we're sifting through more than a million\ndocuments without much rhyme or reason.\nI've re-attached the spreadsheet we sent last week - I think that's a good place to start in terms of our necessary record-\nkeeping, and we need that info at the very least, as well as anything else you think would be useful. Also attaching the SW\nreturns for reference. And again, we're happy to meet up anytime and hash all this out in person if that's useful.\nthanks,\nFrom:\n(NY) (FBI) <\nSent: Wednesday, March 04, 2020 16:36\nTo:\nCc:\n(USANYS)<\n(NY) (FBI)<\n|(USANYS\n... [truncated, 2899 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00009941/7 or ?id=EFTA00009941&page=7]", "char_count": 2899}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "From:\n|(cell)\n[mailto:\nSent: Tuesday, March 03, 2020 12:25 PM\nTo:\n(NY) (FBI)\nCc:\n(NY) (FBI).\n|(USANYS) <\n| (USANYS) <\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <Christopher. Rozier@usdoj.gov>;|\n(NY) (FBI).\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nI could do Thursday morning, but I think it would be helpful for us to get the accounting in advance of the meeting so we\ncan figure out in advance what (if any) additional steps we need - is that possible?\nFrom:\n(NY) (FBI) <\nSent: Tuesday, March 03, 2020 09:59\nTo:\nCc:\n(FBI)<\n|(USANYS)\n(NY) (FBI)<\n|(USANYS) <|\n|(USANYS) [Contractor]\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nCan we do Thursday morning? My network should be back by then and I can give you a good accounting.\nNY CART Coordinator\nSenior Forensic Examiner\ncell\ndesk\nOn Mar 2, 2020 11:15 AM,\nDoing the weekly check in on this - is there a time this week when everyone can meet on this?\nthanks,\nFrom:\nSent: Monday, February 24, 2020 17:38\nTo:\n(NY) (FBI)\nCc:\n(NY) (FBI).\n(USANYS)<\n(USANYS)<\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <\n(FBI) <\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\n(NY)\nwrote:\n(NY)\nTotally understand about the network issues-we can relate. I do still think it will be helpful to all sit down together to\nhave an in-person discussion, to make sure everybody is on the same page. Are folks available for that next week? And\nwhat I think would be most helpful to facilitate that would be a spreadsheet of each separate device referenced in the two\nEFTA00009949\n", "char_count": 1464}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "search warrant returns, with columns for whether we've dumped the contents, whether they've been reviewed and/or\ntransferred, what portions were transferred, etc.\nSomething roughly like the attached, with any other categories you think would be useful - and the info on the attached is\nmostly hypothetical, obviously, just as examples. That will help us fully understand what's been reviewed, transferred,\nand received so far, and what remains.\n(Also just on the pictures, we do want copies of those as well, please including from the discs and the devices - I think FBI\nwas going to do an initial screen to make sure no CP, and since I think the answer was no, we'll need to get those to be\nable to review them as well.)\nmany thanks,\nFrom:\n(NY) (FBI)<\nSent: Monday, February 24, 2020 09:24\nTo:\nCc:\n(FBI)\n|(USANYS) <||\n(NY) (FBI) <\n(USANYS)<\n|(USANYS) [Contractor]\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\n. (NY)\nSorry for the delayed response. They are tearing out our old network and giving us a new one, they mandated we\ndelete old stuff (about 400 TB worth). Now that they are working on replacing the network, we can do only local\nwork. I should be able to give you an accounting of what is what. I can say, off the top of my head, that all\nwindows based items from the NY search have been handed over as well as all loose media. The CDs from NY\nonly contained pictures, no documents. There are still some Apple items from NY that need to be produced. As\nfar as the Island stuff goes, the 1st item on your spreadsheet, the \"kitchen\" mac has been produced. Still working\non the rest.\nNY CART Coordinator\nSenior Forensic Examiner\ncell\ndesk\nOn Feb 23, 2020 12:21 AM,\nTeam,\nwrote:\nFollowing up on the below from last weekend, I'm still not sure how we're addressing this so I thought it would make\nsense for us to all schedule a (hopefully relatively brief) meeting to all get on the same page? We didn't hear back on\nwhich files had previously been provided, but our tech folks did their best \n... [truncated, 2908 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00009941/9 or ?id=EFTA00009941&page=9]", "char_count": 2908}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009941", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Tuesday through Friday, but then I think generally around the first week of March, which will hopefully be plenty of time\nto schedule a productive meeting.\nthanks all,\nFrom:\nSent: Saturday, February 15, 2020 16:30\nTo:\nCc:\n(NY) (FBI)\n|(USANYS) [Contractor] <\n(NY) (FBI)<\nA\nSubject: RE: Epstein search warrant documents\nI'm not sure who's the exact right person to ask this, so wanted to get everybody on one email chain about it - I have the\nhard drive that | dropped off that has new Epstein search warrant materials, but it looks like there are also old\nmaterials (that I think we had previously received and uploaded??) on the hard drive, and so I'm not sure what's new.\nJust generally, and and I talked about this last week too, but it's basically impossible for us to keep track of what\nwe're getting, and what has been completed, without some kind of identification or labeling system, along with a list of\nwhich devices have been extracted and downloaded.\nSo for example on the hard drive currently, there are 38 folders labeled \"loadFiles\" through \"37loadFiles\" with a modified\ndate of 11/14/19, which I think we may have already previously received - but I'm not sure, because we haven't gotten\nany info on which folders match up to which devices, etc. And then there's another folder titled \"NYC024362\" that has a\nmodified date of 1/27/20, so I think that may be the materials we hadn't previously received? That folder by itself has\nmore than 600,000 items.\nI don't want to give | anything that we've already previously received and uploaded, and I can't tell from the folder or\nfile names whether everything on the drive is new, or whether just additional materials were saved onto it in addition to\nwhat we already have. are you able to give us some guidance on this? Ultimately what we really need is a\nspreadsheet of every device, whether it's been dumped (or partially dumped), and then identifying that same info -\nwhich device, and what materials from it - are being given to us with\n... [truncated, 2282 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00009941/10 or ?id=EFTA00009941&page=10]", "char_count": 2282}]}