{"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_count": 99, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00009329", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00009329.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Page 101 \n1 \ncarefully -- the -- each -- each victim was tied to a \n2 \nparticular set of criminal activity. In other words, these \n3 \nvictims were not lumped in an aggregate sort of formless \n4 \npetri dish. \n5 \nA \nYes. \n6 \nQ \nThey were individuals. \nhad met -- was \n7 \nmeeting with them, *indeed was finding new victims along with \n8 \nthe FBI, and they were conducting individualized assessments \n9 \nof the viability of each victim witness, and indeed \n10 \nsubmitted a follow on pros memo, a pros memo addendum in \n11 \nJuly, and another one in September, and tailored -- continued \n12 \nto tailor her indictment -- proposed indictment to these \n13 \nindividualized acts. \n14 \nThe question -- when I -- when I hear the victims \n15 \nreferred to in the aggregate, I wonder what effort there was \n16 \nto sit down and address each individual victim, because there \n17 \nwere so many, and a credibility issue that could be very \n18 \ntroubling with one victim, if -- or, two victims, or four \n19 \nvictims --\n20 \nA \nFair. \n21 \nQ \n-- could well be overcome by other victims who had, \n22 \nnot those credibility issues, perhaps others, and if I may \n23 \nfinish, that in the aggregate, when presented individually in \n24 \ntotal, a kind of a persuasive case could be made that would \n25 \nbe impossible with one or two or three? Does that -- is that \nEFTA00009329\n", "char_count": 1347}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Page 102 \n1 \na fair --\n2 \nA \nSo, that is fair, and I think -- and your point \n3 \nthat we shouldn't sort of talk about the victims in aggregate \n4 \nis a fair point. I would -- I would respond, and Ms. \n5 \ngoes into this in her affidavit a little bit, and \n6 \nI've got it -- and I have a recollection of some discussion \n7 \nof this between myself, and you're going to ask me who, so \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \nanother victim that said horrendous things happened, to what \n14 \nextent does defense cast this as, they are trying to recover, \n15 \nthey're trying to do -- and so one of the concerns was when \n16 \nyou have victims that know one another, that brought one \n17 \nanother in, even if you've got similar patterns, if some of \n18 \nthem cast doubt, how would that be taken by -- by the jury? \n19 \nQ \nIs that assessment or analysis your own, or is it \n20 \none that you developed with the people you talked to about \n21 \nthis case? \n22 \nA \nSo, that -- that assessment would have been, in my \n23 \ngeneral recollection, but also based on my practice, that \n24 \nkind of witness assessment is the kind of thing that I would \n25 \nhave relied more on the AUSA -- on my management team for, \nlet me just say I don't know who. \nBut the concern is when you have victims that know \none another, to what extent would defense -- if you've got \ntwo victims that say A happened, even if it's similar sets of \nfacts, and another victim that said he did nothing wrong, and \nEFTA00009330\n", "char_count": 1466}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Page 103 \n1 \nbecause that was more within their -- their area of \n2 \nexpertise. \n3 \nQ \nRight, and \nin particular was known as \n4 \na trial attorney. \n5 \nA \nRight. \n6 \nQ \nCorrect? \n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \nQ \nDo you recall having discussions with \nabout \n9 \nthat? \n10 \nA \nHe would have been the logical --\n11 \nQ \nRight. \n12 \nA \n-- person. I know that we had those discussions, \n13 \nand we talked about what happened, how will they -- how will \n14 \nthey play out at trial, and -- and the takeaway was, it could \n15 \nplay out well, it could not play out well. \n16 \nQ \nSo, as of the time that all --\n17 \nA \nAnd again, I say they as a collective. \n18 \nQ \nRight. \n19 \nA \nUnderstanding that some would say exonerating \n20 \nthings. Some would have contradictory statements. Some may \n21 \nnot want to testify, and -- and so, that conversation was \n22 \nhad. \n23 \nQ \nSo, was had, it -- you and \ntalked about it? \n24 \nA \nI can't say -- \nand I can say, I recall the \n25 \ndiscussion, you know, I don't know -- 12 years ago, you might \nEFTA00009331\n", "char_count": 1025}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Page 104 \n1 \nrecall a discussion from 12 years ago. What -- what you \n2 \npresented to me, for the record, I'm pointing to \n, or I'm \n3 \nindicating \nthe -- the issue about civil rights, do you \n4 \nrecall who else was in the room or wasn't in the room at the \n5 \ntime? \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \nsubstance without remembering who was in the room at the \n15 \ntime. \n16 \nQ \nAnd understanding --\n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \nQ \n-- that this was one case of thousands that were \n19 \nunder your --\n20 \nA \nCorrect. \n21 \nQ \n-- authority, although a particularly sensitive and \n22 \nhigh profile one, but the -- a -- the question to you is, do \n23 \nyou know what individualized assessment \ndid of \n24 \nthe victim witnesses? \n25 \nA \nI -- I can't speak to that. \nA \nYeah, I --\nQ \nIt's a rhetorical question. \nA \nIt's a rhetorical question. \nQ \nWe'll take it, I guess. \nA \nBut --\nQ\nA \n-- you know, it's very -- it -- one can remember \nEFTA00009332\n", "char_count": 930}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Page 105 \n1 \nQ \nDo you know whether he actually met with any of the \n2 \nvictim witnesses? \n3 \nA \nI can't speak to that. \nQ \nDo you know whether \nwent to West Palm \n5 \nand sat down and actually went through the evidence as to \n6 \neach one of the potential --\n7 \nA \nI --\n8 \nQ \n-- witnesses? \n9 \nA \nI can't speak to that. \n10 \nQ \nDo you know any of that information as to \n11 SNP \n12 \nA \nAgain, I can't -- I can't speak to that. I \n13 \nwould -- I would say that -- that \nwas first assistant, \n14 \nand to the extent he relied on the criminal chief, that would \n15 \nbe -- he used to be criminal chief, and so --\n16 \nQ \nRight. \n17 \nA \n-- he would naturally view the role of criminal \n18 \nchief as being important, and someone that would naturally \n19 \nreview matters before they went to the first assistant. \n20 \nQ \nOkay. So, when you talk -- when you were -- as you \n21 \nrecall, having these conversations about the -- the victim \n22 \nissues, as -- as matters of evidence, it -- it -- you cannot \n23 \ntell us what the basis for \nanalysis was? \n24 \nA \nI can't. I mean, as a general matter, I don't \n25 \nrecall the specific. As a general matter, when I talk to \nEFTA00009333\n", "char_count": 1168}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Page 106 \n1 \nindividuals about a case, I would assume that they had \n2 \ninformed themselves, and had done the diligence necessary to \n3 \nhave that discussion with me. \n4 \nQ \nDo you remember him parsing out for you, or --\n5\n6 \nQ \n-- you know --\n7 \nA \n-- I don't recall that --\n8 \n4 \n-- the individual --\n9 \nA \n-- that level of granularity. \n10 \nQ \nAll right. The -- to finish my sentence, to the \n11 \nindividual witnesses, and you're saying you don't. \n12 \nA \nYeah. \n13 \nQ \nAnd by witness, I mean victim witness. Did you \n14 \never sit down with \nand have her present to \n15 \nyou each witness -- each victim as a potential witness, and \n16 \nher individualized credibility issues, and how as a -- as a \n17 \nprosecutor and an experienced trial attorney, \n18 \nwas going to overcome those issues? \n19 \nA \nI don't recall doing that, and as a matter of \n20 \ngeneral practice, particularly when it came to what I'll call \n21 \ntrial issues --\n22 \nQ \nmm-bms. \n23 \nA \n-- we had really experienced individuals in the \n24 \noffice, and that's not something that I would typically do on \n25 \nthis or other high profile cases, because they're the trial \nEFTA00009334\n", "char_count": 1150}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Page 107 \n1 \nlawyers. They -- this is what they do. I would tend to \n2 \nfocus more on the legal issues. \n3 \nQ \nAll right. I want to stay with the -- the witness \n4 \nissues, and the evidence of that for the moment. \n5 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n6 \nQ \nIn Exhibit 3, this lively exchange between \n7 \nand \n, she asks to make a presentation to you in the last \n8 \nmajor paragraph of her e-mail on page four. She says, \"I \n9 \nwould like to make a presentation to the U.S. Attorney, \n10 \nand you, with our side of the investigation and a \n11 \nrevised indictment. The presentation will address the points \n12 \nraised by Epstein's counsel, and will convince you of the \n13 \nstrength of the case.\" Bearing in mind that by this time, \n14 \nand \nhad in front of them --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- her pros memo, her proposed indictment, this \n17 \nanalysis she did as evidenced in Exhibit 8, but also the \n18 \nsubmissions from Jerry Lefcourt, and that -- that \nhad \n19 \nnot had a chance to actually make a presentation to them. \n20 \nresponse is on page three, his last paragraph. \n21 \nHe chides \nand tells her that, \"You may \n22 \nnot dictate the dates and people you will meet with about \n23 \nthis or any other case. If the U.S. Attorney or the first \n24 \nassistant desired to meet with you, they will let you know.\" \n25 \nShe, in her final response on page one points out that she's \nEFTA00009335\n", "char_count": 1367}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Page 108 \n1 \nnot trying to dictate anything. She's just asking. Are you \n2 \naware that -- bear in mind, you didn't see --\n3 \n4 \nA \nCorrect. \nQ \n-- Exhibit 3, were you aware that \n5 \nvery much wanted to make a presentation to you and to \n6 \nand \nabout her case, and her evidence? \n7 \nA \nSo, I don't recall this. \n8 \nQ \nBy this, you mean --\n9 \nA \nI don't -- I don't recall being aware of this \n10 \nrequest. \n11 \nQ \nAll right. \n12 \nA \nAs a -- as a general matter, it seemed that there \n13 \nwas communications going back and forth. And so, she \n14 \ncertainly felt comfortable e-mailing me when she wanted to, I \n15 \nguess is my point, rightly or wrongly. And so, I wasn't \n16 \naware of that request, and --\n17 \nQ \nSo, are you suggesting that she could easily have \n18 \ne-mailed you and said, Alex, I really want to make a \n19 \npresentation to you? \n20 \nA \nI'm not suggesting -- let me -- what I'm suggesting \n21 \nis from my perspective, there was a lot of communication in \n22 \nthis case, more than is typical. I wasn't aware of -- I \n23 \ndon't recall the request, but there was communication in this \n24 \ncase. \n25 \nQ \nWhat do you -- what do you mean by communication? \nal \n• \nEFTA00009336\n", "char_count": 1187}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Page 109 \n1 \nI mean, there are a lot of e-mails, but --\n2 \nA \nThere is. There are a lot of e-mails, right. \n3 \nQ \nBut a lot of them are because there are draft --\n4 \nlater on, we have drafts and so on, but --\n5 \nA \n6 \nQ \n-- we don't --\n7 \nA \nSo, what I mean by that is, I do not recall an \n8 \nimpression that she wasn't being -- that she didn't have \n9 \naccess, or wasn't being heard. \n10 \nQ \nTo you? \n11 \nA \nCorrect. \n12 \nQ \nYou've already seen two e-mails here where she was \n13 \nscolded pretty seriously, and in one case for approaching --\n14 \nA \nCorrect. \n15 \nQ \nand you without \nbeing \n16 \ninvolved back when --\n17 \nA \nCorrect. \n18 \nQ \nwas crim chief, and then here, she --\n19 \nthe -- what \nsays to her is quite strong, isn't \n20 \nit? Would you have ever used that language to a subordinate? \n21 \nA \nYou've seen my e-mails and my style. \n22 \nQ \nI think not. \n23 \nA \nI -- so, what I -- what I am saying is, from my \n24 \nperspective at the time to the best of my recollection, this \n25 \nwas not a case where she was not -- where she was frozen out. \nEFTA00009337\n", "char_count": 1066}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Page 110 \n1 \nThis was a case where there was ample communication --\n2 \nMR. \n: Well --\n3 \nBY MS. \n4 \nQ \nDid \never tell you, hey boss, this line \n5 \nassistant, she's being a pain. You know, she's asked for to \n6 \nmake a presentation to you. Do you want to do it? \n7 \nA \nI -- I don't -- look, this was 12 years ago. I \n8 \ndon't recall it. Whether he did or not, I can't say, but I \n9 \ndon't recall it. \n10 \nQ \nIf he or \nor even \nhad \n11 \ndirectly asked you for that opportunity, would you have \n12 \nentertained it? Would you have agreed to a presentation from \n13 \nthe line attorney? \n14 \nA \nAs a general matter, if someone makes a direct --\n15 \nsaying, this is a case that I have worked, I need to sit down \n16 \nand talk to you, I would have said, yes. \n17 \nQ \nDo you recall any occasion when a line assistant on \n18 \nhis or her own initiative came to you and made such a request \n19 \nand you granted it? \n20 \nA \nI don't, because it rarely got to that level. \n21 \nfrom my impression and my recollection, we had pretty good \n22 \ncommunications in the office. \n23 \nQ \nAll right, I'm sorry, I --\n24 \nMR. \n: That's okay. \n25 \nMS. \n: -- cut you off. \nEFTA00009338\n", "char_count": 1157}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Page 111 \n1 \nBY MR. \n2 \nQ \nYou've talked about needing to respect the chain of \n3 \ncommand. \n4 \nA \nRight. \nWould there have been any repercussions for a line \n6 \nassistant actually trying to approach you about this \n7 \npresentation? \nA \nI would hope not. I mean, it's -- I think it's \n9 \nimportant for line assistants to be respectful and to, you \n10 \nknow, let their supervisor know, and issues -- you know, and \n11 \nto do it with -- with respect, and not go around supervisors, \n12 \nbut I would hope -- I mean --\n13 \nQ \nWell --\n14 \nA \n-- not --\n15 \nQ \nIf she had raised it with a supervisor first, and \n16 \nthat supervisor said, no, that's not your place, would you \n17 \nhave expected her to have followed what the supervisor had \n18 \ntold her on that regard? \n19 \nA \nFair. Look, fair point. I'm not aware of this e-\n20 \nmail. I can't speak to that. AS a general matter, I \nwould \n21 \n-- you know, going back to where I started, you know, I would \n22 \nat 6:00 o'clock walk around the office and say, how are \n23 \nthings going? What case are you working on? In part, \n24 \nbecause I thought it was important to. \n25 \nBY MS. \nEFTA00009339\n", "char_count": 1138}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Page 112 \n1 \nQ \nDid you wander up down -- up to West Palm and do \n2 \nthat too? \n3 \nA \nLess often, but yes. \n4 \nBY MR. \n5 \nQ \nYou talked a little bit about the experience of \n6 \nyour senior staff. \n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \nQ \nWhat do you know about the experience \n9 \nhad in handling these types of cases? \n10 \nA \nYou -- when you say these types, you mean --\n11 \nQ \nSex crimes --\n12 \nA \n13 \n1 4 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \nhad \n25 \nA \nI can't. \nQ \n-- cases involving children --\nA \nI can't --\nQ \n-- or child victims? \nA \nI can't speak to that. I don't know. \nQ \nWhat about \nA \nI can't speak to that. \nQ \nor \nA \nI can't speak to that. \nBY MS. \nQ \nBut you do know that \nsubstantial experience with child sex crimes? \nEFTA00009340\n", "char_count": 732}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Page 113 \n1 \nA \n2 \nQ \nYou named her PSA coordinator. \n3 \nA \nI know that she had experience with prior cases. \n4 \nQ \nAll right. \n5 \nA \nYeah. \n6 \nQ \nOkay. We're going to go for half an hour more, \n7 \nthen we'll take our break, and then we'll --\n8 \nA \nOkay. \n9 \nQ \n-- come back. I -- and we will get back to that \n10 \nother piece of the evidence and the legal issues --\n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \n-- and then -- and then we'll spend a lot of time \n13 \non the alternatives. Haven't forgotten that. In June of \n14 \n2007, there was a meeting that defense counsel requested of \n15 \nthe sort of next level up from \n. In other words, \n16 \nthey had already made a --\n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \nQ \n-- presentation to the line assistant, and her \n19 \nsupervisor. They wanted to come to Miami and talk to, in \n20 \nthis case, \nand \n--\n21 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n22 \nQ \n-- and they did meet with them. Were you aware --\n23 \ndo you have a recollection of whether you were aware that \n24 \nthey -- there was such a meeting? \n25 \nA \nIt -- so, / don't have a recollection, but it rings \nEFTA00009341\n", "char_count": 1056}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Page 114 \n1 \na bell. I don't know if that distinction is a fair one. \n2 \nQ \nWell, I can -- I may help amplify the bell a little \n3 \nbit. One of the defense attorneys who was present there in \n4 \naddition to Gerald Lefcourt, Roy Black, and Lillian Sanchez \n5 \nwas Alan Dershowitz. \n6 \nA \nYeah. \n7 \nQ \nDoes that ring a bell? \n8 \nA \nSo, it does. There's --\n9 \nQ \nOkay. \n10 \nA \nI -- I can't say it's a recollection, but it sounds \n11 \nlike there -- it sounds right, and in my usual course, once \n12 \nwas meeting with someone, he would typically have let me \n13 \nknow. \n14 \nQ \nAll right. All right, and where would such a \n15 \nmeeting take place? Would it be in \noffice? Was it \n16 \nbig enough? Or would you use the executive conference room? \n17 \nA \nBased on the number of people, almost definitely \n18 \nthe executive conference room. \n19 \nQ \nAnd is that -- do people have to go by your office \n20 \nto get there? \n21 \nA \nThey do not. \n22 \nQ \nOkay, and would you in a case like this make a --\n23 \nas you said a moment ago, pop your head in --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- and say hello? \nEFTA00009342\n", "char_count": 1092}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Page 115 \n1 \nA \nRight. As a typical matter, I probably would not, \n2 \nbecause then it very rapidly turns into a meeting with me as \n3 \nopposed to a --\n4 \nQ \nMn-hmm. \n5 \nA \n-- meeting with --\n6 \nQ \n14M-hmm. Okay. \n7 \nA \nIf that makes sense. \n8 \nQ \nThere was some written submissions also submitted. \n9 \nPretty substantial ones. These addressing more of the legal \n10 \nissues --\n11 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n12 \nQ \n-- both before and after this. Did someone -- and \n13 \nif so, who -- brief you about what happened at the meeting, \n14 \nand what was contained in the written submissions? \n15 \nA \nSo, I do not recall a briefing. I would assume \n16 \nthat, again, based on practice, there's a senior level \n17 \nmeeting in the office. Based on practice, \nwould have \n18 \ntold me, and then afterwards, he would have said this is what \n19 \nhappened. \n20 \nQ \nAll right, but you have no actual recollection of \n21 \nwhat happened in this case? \n22 \nA \nI have no actual recollection of -- other than the \n23 \nmeeting sounding familiar, I have no recollection. \n24 \nQ \nSo, Exhibit 50 in this packet, it's almost at the \n25 \nend. It's the next to last, really, is a letter that \nEFTA00009343\n", "char_count": 1163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Page 116 \n1 \nIMP \noffered to the DAG -- the then DAG --\n2 \nA \nYes. \n3 \nQ \n-- in June of 2008, a whole year later. The DAG, \n4 \nDeputy Attorney General Mark Filip, and this is -- you \n5 \ncertainly recall that there was an appeal, if you will, a \n6 \nsmall appeal to the DAG's office --\n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \nQ \n-- by defense counsel, and \nsubmitted a \n9 \nfairly substantial accounting of what had gone before in the \n10 \ncase, and he also submitted a number of other documents \n11 \nrelevant to that. \n12 \nHe says on page three that at this June 26th, 2007 \n13 \nmeeting, which he characterizes arguments, legal and factual, \n14 \nwere presented against a federal indictment, and \n15 \nwrites that, \"The arguments and written materials provided by \n16 \nthe defense were examined by the SDFL and rejected.\" Do \n17 \nyou -- is that consistent with any understanding you have of \n18 \nwhat happened at this meeting? \n19 \nA \nSo, I don't recall, so I'm going to speculate, and \n20 \nthe speculation is that by the time this happened, we were \n21 \nfairly far along in how we were viewing this matter. \n22 \nQ \nThis being 2008, or --\n23 \nA \nNo, June. \n24 \nQ \nJune 26th, 2007. Okay. \n25 \nA \nYou know, and as I reviewed the documents, I tried \nEFTA00009344\n", "char_count": 1233}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Page 117 \n1 \nto establish a timeline, but clearly, by July 31st, we had --\n2 \nyou know, we had sort of concluded how we were approaching \nit. \n4 \nAnd so, I'm going to speculate that when he said \nthe arguments and written materials provided to defense \n6 \ncounsel were examined by the SDFL and rejected, it was they \n7 \nasked us to drop the matter, and we said we're not dropping \n8 \nthe matter. \n9 \nQ \nOkay. Okay, and by the way, is -- just to clean \n10 \nthis up, this letter was -- to the DAG, was signed by \n11 \nunder your type name, as is --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- standard but you're not cc'd on it. Do you \n14 \ndo you recall why you didn't sign this letter? why it was \n15 \nsent by \n16 \nA \n17 \n18 \nA \nI do not recall. \n19 \nQ \nI just -- that's a -- that's a point of interest. \n20 \nand so, I'll draw your attention to \n21 \nA \nAll right. \n22 \nQ \n-- Exhibit 49, which is actually dated the day \n23 \nprior, that is, June 2, 2008, and this is \nan e-mail to \n24 \nyou from \n25 \nA \nYes. \nIII, who is -- was and is the ethics --\nEFTA00009345\n", "char_count": 1041}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Page 118 \n1 \nQ \n-- officer for the U.S. Attorney's Office, correct? \n2 \nReporting back to you an assessment by the executive office \n3 \nof U.S. Attorneys general counsel's office that they did not \n4 \nsee you as having an either actual or apparent conflict of \n5 \ninterest that would necessitate your recusal from the Epstein \n6 \nmatter by virtue of the fact that you apparent, according to \n7 \nthis, intended to seek employment with Harvard Law School. \n8 \nA \nRight, or was considering seeking. \n9 \nQ \nWas considering. All right. Right. Should you \n10 \nseek employment, it says. So, is it -- is it reasonable for \n11 \nus to infer that this potential recusal --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- was pending at the time the letter to Mark Filip \n14 \nwas being drafted, and that's why it went out over \n15 \nsignature, and without you as a CC? \n16 \nA \nSo, I would not infer that. \n17 \nQ \nOkay. \n18 \nA \nIn part because it was potential -- and in part \n19 \nbecause \nhad the facts at his disposal, and was \n20 \nthe natural -- this was a very detailed letter. I did not \n21 \nfeel that -- I'm speculating here -- as a general matter, \n22 \nthings don't have to go out under my name, and some letters \n23 \nwent out under his name, and some letters went out under my \n24 \nname, and the ones that went out under my name tended to be \n25 \nones that I had more authorship in, and the ones that went \nEFTA00009346\n", "char_count": 1391}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Page 119 \n1 \nout under his name in this case were the ones that he had \n2 \nmore authorship in. And so, I would just say that this was \n3 \nthe continuing course of that. \n4 \nQ \nOkay. Thank you. Minor technical issue. \n5 \nBY MS. line: \n6 \nQ \nWould you have read the letter before it went out? \n7 \nA \nProbably. I would say in my usual course, he would \n8 \nhave shown it to me, but not always. \n9 \nQ \nNot always letters that would have been sent to the \n10 \nDeputy Attorney General's Office, or just letters in general? \n11 \nA \nWell, he would have \nI think he would have shown \n12 \nthis to me because it's going to the deputy's office. The \n13 \nflip side is, I trust \n. I think he's a professional. \n14 \nSomething that I -- so, an important distinction tc \n15 \ndraw, I remember talking to an AUSA that had spent time at \n16 \nmain justice, and contrasting the experience of an AUSA with \n17 \nthe experience of a trial lawyer here, and sort of the line \n18 \nwas you can't send a letter from main justice without three \n19 \nletters of approval, whereas an AUSA in their case typically \n20 \ndoesn't even get approval from their line supervisor. And \n21 \nso, as a usual matter, particularly in this case, \nwould \n22 \nrun letters by me. \n23 \nThat doesn't mean that every letter had to be run \n24 \nby me, and you know, I was certainly aware that the letter \n25 \nwas being transmitted. I was aware of the appeal to D.C. \nEFTA00009347\n", "char_count": 1422}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Page 120 \n1 \nhad comfort in what we had done, and so I thought the appeal \n2 \nwould be fine, and if I was out of the office, or if there \n3 \nwas some reason that I wasn't going to be consulted, \nwas \n4 \nquite capable of doing it without my review. \n5 \nQ \nBut if you were in the office, it would have been \n6 \ntypical for him to run it by you first? \n7 \n9 \n10 \n11 \nA \nIt would have been. \nBY MS. \nQ \nDid you read the letter in preparation for --\nA \nI did. \nQ \n-- this, and is there anything in it that is --\n12 \nthat in your view is not accurate? \n13 \nA \nI think it's accurate. I think the letter, as it \n14 \nshould be, is an advocacy piece for what the office has done \n15 \nas opposed to a, on the one hand, on the other hand, analysis \n16 \npiece. But at this point, we're defending the actions of the \n17 \noffice, and I think it appropriately should be an advocacy \n18 \npiece. \n19 \nQ \nAll right. Do you disagree with any of the points \n20 \nof advocacy, or the points made in advocacy? \n21 \nA \nWe -- we'd have to go through it --\n22 \nQ \nAll right. \n23 \nA \n-- paragraph by paragraph. \n24 \nQ \nOkay. Okay. \n25 \nA \nBut --\nEFTA00009348\n", "char_count": 1131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Page 121 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \nQ \nBut nothing struck you so much that you --\nA \nI think --\nQ \n-- recall? \nA \n-- I think he fairly presented the totality of \n5 \neverything to the DAG for the DAG to review her for whoever \n6 \nthe DAG designated, and I think that was -- that was an \n7 \nappropriate presentation. \n8 \nQ \nAll right. Thank you. So, now I'd like to launch \n9 \ninto -- and before we break for lunch, sort of the core \n10 \nquestion. \n11 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n12 \nQ \nWhich we addressed a little bit earlier, and that \n13 \nis who at the U.S. Attorney's Office made the decision to \n14 \nresolve this case with an offer of a two year state plea, and \n15 \nwhy? \n16 \nA \nRight. So, how we got to the two years, I can't \n17 \ntell you, because I can give you my general impression. \n18 \nUltimately, all the cases in the U.S. Attorney's Office were \n19 \nunder me. \n20 \nUltimately, I saw what we'll call that, you know, \n21 \nthree pronged resolution, two years -- you know, registration \n22 \nand restitution, and ultimately that was approved on my \n23 \nauthority. \n24 \nQ \nSo, who came -- did you -- did you come up with it? \n25 \nWas it your idea --\nEFTA00009349\n", "char_count": 1141}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Page 122 \n1 \nA \n2 \nQ \n-- of an issue? \n3 \nA \nI don't -- I don't know. The -- this is \n4 \nreconstructing conversations -- I'm going to speculate now. \n5 \nThis was not, let's all get in a room and figure out the \n6 \nresolution in the next half hour. \n7 \nQ \nMh-hmm. \n8 \nA \nBut this was a course as things are discussed and \n9 \nthere's a back and forth over the course of some days or a \n10 \nweek or two, and then people get together and discuss, and a \n11 \nview develops, and then the office proceeds with that. But \n12 \nultimately -- let me -- let me just sort of push back. Look, \n13 \nultimately, I approved it, and so, I --\n14 \nQ \nOkay. \n15 \nA \n-- accept that. I'm not -- I'm not pushing away \n16 \nresponsibility for it. I'm just saying I can't recall how we \n17 \ngot to, for example, two years. I can speculate as to \n18 \nparticular parts of it, but I can't -- you know, but \n19 \nultimately I'm not pushing away responsibility. \n20 \nQ \nI understand, and we're going to delve into that \n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \n-- that two years -- shortly, but I want to turn \n23 \nback to Exhibit No. 3, in which sort of the statement that \n24 \nlaunches this -- what I keep calling a lively exchange, is on \n25 \npage four, the -- the statement from \n, and this \nEFTA00009350\n", "char_count": 1257}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Page 123 \n1 \nis in response to an inquiry from\n to her management, \n2 \nnot including you, about what conversations any of them has \n3 \nhad with defense counsel --\n4 \nA \nRight. \n5 \nQ \n-- about any resolution, because her plan was to \n6 \ntalk to Lilly Ann Sanchez about working a plea to federal \n7 \ntime concurrent to the state -- whatever the state time was, \n8 \nand in response, \ntells her, \"I told Lilly that a state \n9 \nplea with jail time and sex offender status may satisfy the \n10 \nUSA,\" meaning the U.S. Attorney --\n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \n-- I believe. So, that's a -- that's a closed \n13 \nquote after USA. Had he discussed that with you? How did he \n14 \nknow that that might satisfy you? \n15 \nA \nSo, I don't recall. I can \nI can speculate based \n16 \non Mr. \ncourse of conduct, I don't think he would \n17 \nhave raised that possibility in a case of this profile \n18 \nwithout having discussed it with me. \n19 \nQ \nBut you have no specific --\n20 \nA \nI have no --\n21 \nQ \n-- recollection? \n22 \nA \n-- specific recollection, but I don't think he \n23 \nwould have done that without having come by and said. \n24 \nQ \nAll right. At this point, bearing in mind that you \n25 \ndon't have any specific recollection, at this point, do you \nEFTA00009351\n", "char_count": 1241}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Page 124 \n1 \nbelieve you had any understanding of what amount of jail time \n2 \nwas in play at this point when \ntells Lilly Ann \n3 \nSanchez --\n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \nA \nI can't pinpoint that timeline --\nQ \nAll right. \nA \n-- to that degree. \nQ \nAll right. \nA \nOf accuracy. \nQ \nHe also says later in this e-mail that he told this \n10 \nto Lilly Ann Sanchez a couple of weeks prior before the June \n11 \n26th meeting. \n12 \nA \nCorrect. \n13 \nQ \nAll right. Were you aware that \nhad \n14 \nbeen communicating directly with Sanchez about the case, and \n15 \nspecifically that he represented that you might go for a \n16 \nstate disposition if it included jail time and sex offender \n17 \nregistration? \n18 \nA \nI -- I don't recall whether I was aware or not. I \n19 \nrecall at some point adopting the concept of jail time plus \n20 \nregistration, and then plus restitution. And so, I don't \n21 \nknow when that would have happened. Let me also speculate \n22 \nthat the U.S. Attorney might go \ncould also refer to, this \n23 \nis being talked about, no final decision has been made. \n24 \nQ \nRight. If \nhad made that informal \n25 \ndiscussion comment to Lilly Ann Sanchez without having told \nEFTA00009352\n", "char_count": 1174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Page 125 \nI \nyou, without having gotten your clearance ahead of time to \n2 \ntell her that, would that -- would that surprise you, or \n3 \nwould you have expected him to consult with you about whether \n4 \nit was okay to go ahead and raise this? \n5 \nA \nSo, as a general matter, yes, but -- and let me \n6 \nlet me explain that. AUSAs on occasion, and because this is \n7 \na high profile -- higher profile case -- a criminal chief may \n8 \nrun an idea across opposing counsel and say, look, I don't \n9 \nhave authorization. \n10 \nI don't know how the office will react, but it's \n11 \ncertainly possible that X, Y, or Z may work out. And that's \n12 \na very different conversation than, you know, the office will \n13 \naccept. \n14 \nAnd so, a lot of that really depends on how that \n15 \nconversation goes, and you know, certainly if he's \n16 \nrepresenting my view, I would expect him to check on what my \n17 \nview is, if he's, as criminal chief, saying, this is \n18 \nsomething that I could support. I don't know how the office \n19 \nwill react, that may -- you know, but I can run it up the \n20 \nflagpole, that might be a different type of conversation. \n21 \nQ \nOkay, and did you know Lilly Ann Sanchez? \n22 \nA \nI did. She was an AUSA in the office. \n23 \nQ \nAnd she left about a month after you came on board? \n24 \nA \nWas it that -- was it that quick? \n25 \nQ \nThat's our information, yes. \nEFTA00009353\n", "char_count": 1388}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Page 126 \n1 \nA \nOkay. \n2 \nQ \nAlthough she apparently remained a periodic \n3 \npresent. \n4 \nA \nHence, the wasn't that quick. \n5 \nQ \nDid you know that she'd been \n6 \nat major crimes? \n7 \nA \nI don't remember that. \ndeputy \n8 \nQ \nAll right. Did you -- what did -- what did you \n9 \nremember about her? And had you had any dealings with her \n10 \nafter she left the office up to this point? \n11 \nA \nSo, I remember that she was in the office, that she \n12 \nwas a senior attorney. Whether within the management \n13 \nstructure or not, I -- I didn't recollect until you just \n14 \nraised it, and that I can't swear to it, but it rings a bell \n15 \nthat she was in major crimes, and she was someone that you \n16 \nwould see at bar functions that would --\n17 \nQ \nMa-hmm. \n18 \nA \n-- she -- she was active in the local bar, and I \n19 \nwould see her on occasion at a bar function and say hello. \n20 \nQ \nAll right. Did you encounter her in connection \n21 \nwith a case, to your recollection, in the period before \n22 \nEpstein? \n23 \nA \nI'm hesitating not to avoid, but I'm running \n24 \nthrough my --\n25 \nQ \nMa-hmm. \nEFTA00009354\n", "char_count": 1106}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Page 127 \n1 \nA \nNot that I recall. \n2 \nQ \nWhat's your impression of her as a \nas a \n3 \npractitioner? \n4 \nA \nShe did -- she did quite well after she left the \n5 \noffice. She set up -- I think she set up her own practice. \n6 \nQ \nAt the time -- at this time, she was with something \n7 \ncalled Fowler White Burnett. \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \nA \nOkay, so --\nQ \nShe --\nA \n-- she went to Fowler White. \nQ \n-- subsequently --\nA \nShe subsequently set up her own practice, and I \n13 \nthought she's done well for herself. \n14 \nQ \nOkay. Were you aware that \nhad a close \n15 \npersonal relationship with Lilly Ann Sanchez, both because \n16 \nthey had worked together as chief and deputy chief --\n17 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n18 \nQ \n-- in major crimes, but also because they'd had a \n19 \ndating relationship sometime prior? \n20 \nA \nI don't recall them having dated, but I don't \n21 \nQ \nDo you recall knowing that they had dated in the \n22 \npast? \n23 \nA \nI don't recall knowing that, and in all candor, \n24 \nthat's not the kind of thing I ask about. \n25 \nQ \nBut in this case with her representation of \nEFTA00009355\n", "char_count": 1079}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Page 128 \n1 \nsomebody in a matter being ultimately supervised by... \n2 \nwould you have expected= to disclose to you that \n3 \nhe'd had a prior romantic relationship with Lilly Ann \n4 \nSanchez, a member of Epstein's defense team, if only to \naddress a potential appearance of impropriety or conflict of \n6 \ninterest? \n7 \nA \nI think some of that might have depended on how \n8 \nrecently. Was it ten years ago? Was it two years ago? If \n9 \nthey were in the supervisory chain that this happened, that \n10 \ncould raise other -- other issues. So, if to the extent --\n11 \nso, for example, \ndisclosed to me a potential conflict --\n12 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n13 \nA \n-- to the extent that these arise, if there is a \n14 \npotential conflict, I'd like to know. I was aware of \n15 \nconflict. I said, keep going. \n16 \nQ \nAnd in fact, \n, you're talking about the \n17 \nHerman --\n18 \nA \nYes. \n19 \nQ \n-- connection, the prior --\n20 \nA \nYes. \n21 \nQ \n-- short lived law firm connection. Are you aware \n22 \nthat \nin fact vetted that through \nyour \n23 \nethics person? \n24 \nA \nI am -- I don't recall that independently, but I \n25 \nrecall knowing about it. He may have told me he vetted it \nEFTA00009356\n", "char_count": 1167}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Page 129 \n1 \nthrough \nIIIIII is highly respected in the office, \n2 \nand --\n3 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n4 \n5 \nA \n-- that would be the appropriate --\nQ \nSo, are you also aware that \nraised, \n6 \nagain with \nIII, the potential, again, appearance of a \n7 \nconflict of interest, or appearance of impropriety, because \n8 \nof his supervision of the Epstein case, and his concurrent \n9 \nclose friendship with Mike Tein, who was an attorney who was \n10 \nrepresenting Epstein, as well as Guy Lewis, former U.S. \n11 \nAttorney? \n12 \nA \nSo, I was not aware of that. \n13 \nQ \nYou were not aware of it, but -- but I guess what \n14 \nI'm -- what I'm noting is that both \nand \n15 \nperceived appearance issues, and went through the process \n16 \nthat's provided for them to get the blessing to go ahead and \n17 \nproceed with the case by the -- the blessing by the ethics \n18 \nexpert --\n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \n-- but \napparently did not in this case \n21 \nvis a vis Lilly Ann Sanchez. \n22 \nA \nYeah. \n23 \nQ \nDoes that surprise you, or disappoint you, or \n24 \nperplex you, or do you care? \n25 \nA \nI would want to know more. \nEFTA00009357\n", "char_count": 1098}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Page 130 \n1 \nQ \nRight. \n2 \nA \nBut certainly it would provide -- I would want to \n3 \nknow more before saying I'm disappointed, but again, was it \n4 \nten years ago? Was it two years ago? What's the \n5 \ncontinuing -- there are a lot of facts, but certainly it --\n6 \nthat's the kind of -- it's the kind of discussion one would \n7 \ntypically have with \n8 \nQ \nAnd in this case, what we're talking about is an \n9 \ninformal conversation, or informal discussion, to use \n10 \nown term, with Sanchez as opposed to any of the \n11 \nother attorneys in Epstein's team about a particular \n12 \nresolution that we're going to spend all afternoon talking \n13 \nabout, because it has some problematic aspects. Okay? So, \n14 \nyou see why we're --\n15 \nA \nI get it. No, I get it. \n16 \nQ \nOkay. \n17 \nBY MR. \n18 \nQ \nSo, before we break, I'm -- should he have talked \n19 \nabout this potential resolution with the line assistant \n20 \nbefore actually making it? \n21 \nA \nIn a typical case, yes. So, in a typical case, I \n22 \nfostered communication. I would -- I would come -- I'd get \n23 \ninvolved in cases, but we'd want to know what the line \n24 \nassistant thinks, and they can agree or disagree, but we'd \n25 \nwant -- we'd want input. \nEFTA00009358\n", "char_count": 1222}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Page 131 \n1 \nBY MS. \n2 \nQ \nWhat do you make of this really acid tone between \nand IIIII? Between \nand \nin this Exhibit 3 \n4 \nexchange? I mean, \nis really -- as I read it, it's \npretty strong. \n6 \nA \nI -- I can't -- I -- I'm not sure what to make of \n7 \nit. \n8 \nQ \nAll right. All right. There are a couple of --\n9 \nlet's -- could we go off the record for a split second? \n10 \n11 \n12 \nOff the record.) \nBY MS. \nQ \nOkay, back on the record. Going back to Exhibit \n13 \nNo. 3, there are a few things here that we think are \n14 \nimportant to raise with you, albeit you not having seen this \n15 \nat the time. \n16 \nsays that the -- she complains \n17 \nabout this soft -- that's my term -- plea offer that \n18 \nextended to Epstein through Lilly Ann Sanchez. She says that \n19 \nsuch an offer is completely unacceptable to the FBI, ICE, the \n20 \nvictims, and me, meaning \n. Did you have an \n21 \nunderstanding of what the FBI's position about prosecuting \n22 \nthis case was? \n23 \nA \nMy recollection of interaction with the FBI is with \n24 \nwho was the SAC, and as I recall, he supported \n25 \nthe eventual direction of this case. \nEFTA00009359\n", "char_count": 1130}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "1 \nPage 132 \n1 \nQ \nIs he the individual who you identify I believe in \n2 \nactually your -- your attorney's written response as the SAC \n3 \nwho called you to congratulate you about the --\n4 \nA \nHe is. \n5 \nQ \n-- the case? About the result? \n6 \nA \nYes. \n7 \nQ \nAnd was SAC \n-- in that same written \n8 \nresponse from your attorney, there's a mention that he was \n9 \npresent at many meetings on this case? \n10 \nA \nHe was present at, at least some, and in part that \n11 \nwas at my request, because this was a high enough profile \n12 \ncase that I wanted to bring him into this. \n13 \nQ \nSo, the -- we know he was present at the December \n14 \n14, 2007 meeting, right? \n15 \nA \nYeah. \n16 \nQ \nWith Ken Starr and company. He is not present \n17 \nat -- to -- according to our investigation, at any other case \n18 \nwith defense counsel. Others are. His ASAC, \nis \n19 \npresent. \n20 \nA \nSo, recollections aren't nearly as good as \n21 \ndocuments. I don't recall the December meeting. I would \n22 \nhave said that he was present at the September meeting, but \n23 \nit may be that I am, because this was so long ago, mixing the \n24 \ntwo. \n25 \nQ \nOkay. \nEFTA00009360\n", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Page 133 \n1 \nA \nBecause I thought he would have come to the \n2 \nSeptember meeting. \n3 \nQ \nNo, according to all the information we have, just \n4 \nso you know --\n5 \nA \nRight. \n6 \nQ \nwas there as ASAC, but not --\n7 \nactually, I'm not sure she was at the -- at any rate, she \n8 \nwas -- she was --\n9 \nA \nRight. \n10 \nQ \n-- he was present, \nwas present at the \n11 \nDecember meeting only. \n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \nSo, just so --\n14 \nA \nFair. \n15 \nQ \nOkay. Would he have been present at meetings other \n16 \nthan with defense counsel meetings about this case? \n17 \nA \nTypically no. Typically, he and I would have \n18 \ntalked on the phone or had discussion, and I know that he was \n19 \naware of the matter. \n20 \nQ \nso --\n21 \nA \nI recall his being aware of the matter, and \n22 \ngenerally positive as to the direction that we were going. \n23 \nQ \nBy the direction or the eventual outcome? \n24 \nA \nThe eventual outcome. \n25 \nQ \nAll right. So, what about the prosecution? Do you \nEFTA00009361\n", "char_count": 975}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Page 134 \n1 \nknow what the FBI's view was about the prosecution? \n2 \nA \nI can't speak to the timeline. I would have -- and \n3 \nI'm contradicting the documents here, but I would have -- if \n4 \nyou had asked me, said that he was present at the September \n5 \nmeeting, and was aware of the terms that were presented at \n6 \nthe September meeting. Clearly, I'm --\n7 \nQ \nRight. \n8 \nA \n-- my recollection is incorrect, and I take that \n9 \nfor what it is. \n10 \nQ \nJust to finish on -- with this point though, my \n11 \nquestion was an understanding of the FBI's position of the \n12 \ncase, not the ultimate disposition. In other words, as of --\n13 \nas of the date of Exhibit 3, there was no deal on the table. \n14 \nSo, the question is, what was the FBI's view about the case? \n15 \nA \nSo -- so, I -- I'm not trying to be difficult. At \n16 \nsome point, when you say view, the FBI, to my recollection, \n17 \nthought that what Mr. Epstein did was sordid and disgusting \n18 \nand that we should proceed. How we proceeded, I don't recall \n19 \nhaving -- hearing specific views as to the how as opposed to \n20 \nthe, we should. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. Let's -- thank you. Let's take a \n22 \nbreak, 45 minutes. Thank you. \n23 \n(Off the record.) \n24 \nBY MS. \n25 \nQ \nAll right. We're going to go back on the record. \nEFTA00009362\n", "char_count": 1298}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Page 135 \n1 \nWe're beginning after the break at 1:30 in the afternoon. \n2 \nThank you. \n3 \nA \nBefore get started --\n4 \nQ \nYes. \n5 \nA \n-- you referenced an e-mail from \nthat wasn't \n6 \npart of the packet. \n7 \nQ \nCorrect. \n8 \nA \nIs that something that I could see and review, or \n9 \nis there discomfort on that? \n10 \nQ \nYes. No, I am not -- as long as we make it on the \n11 \nrecord. Do you -- do you need to do it now, or can we do it \n12 \nduring the next break? \n13 \nA \nIt depends how long -- how long is it? It would \n14 \njust take --\n15 \nQ \nOne page. \n16 \nA \n-- a minute, if you don't mind. \n17 \nQ \nDo you want to go off the record while Mr. \n18 \nAcosta --\n19 \n(Off the record.) \n20 \nBY MS. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. On the record again. For the record, \n22 \nMr. Acosta has just reviewed and e-mail from-\n23 \nto \n, and \n24 \ndated July 18, 2007 at 2:07 p.m. It's one that I described \n25 \nto Mr. Acosta a moment -- this morning. Do you have any \nEFTA00009363\n", "char_count": 951}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Page 136 \n1 \ncomments? \n2 \nA \nI don't. \n3 \nQ \nAll right. Before we broke, we were -- I mentioned \n4 \nyour statement about SAC\n having attended many \n5 \nmeetings. That to be clear was a representation you made in \n6 \nyour March 2007 letter to the Daily Beast, not the written \n7 \nresponse. \n8 \nLooking briefly at -- back at Exhibit 3 and \n9 \n-- you don't have to read it yourself. \n10 \nrepresentation that in her view the plea offer \n11 \nwas completely unacceptable to the victims. Do you -- do you \n12 \nbelieve that she was correct in her view that the victims' \n13 \nviews should have been solicited before a plea offer was \n14 \nmade? \n15 \nA \nSo, I would have to think that was one through. \n16 \nThere were concerns -- and I don't know about the timeline \n17 \nabout communications with the victims. They're sort of laid \n18 \nout in the \naffidavit. So, whether or not victims' \n19 \nviews were elicited is something I think was the focus of the \n20 \ntrial team and not something that I was focused on at least \n21 \nat this time. \n22 \nQ \nBut do you believe as a matter of sort of principle \n23 \nthat the views of victims should be elicited before a plea \n24 \noffer --\n25 \nA \nRight. \nEFTA00009364\n", "char_count": 1193}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "1 \nQ \n-- is made? \n2 \nA \nSo, as a general matter, yes. \n3 \nQ \nOkay. \n4 \nA \nI think that the -- the reason I'm pushing back is \n5 \nbecause you're saying plea offer, and the CVRA does talk to \n6 \nplea offers as opposed to a situation where deferring \n7 \nprosecution in favor of a state is a very different thing \n8 \nthan a plea offer, and at the time, that was not a, it must. \n9 \nThat was a depending on the facts and circumstances, that's a \n10 \njudgment call. At least that's how the department, to my \n11 \nunderstanding, viewed it. \nAnd was it also your view that it would have, as a \n13 \ngeneral matter, it's a better practice or better approach to \n14 \ntalk to the victims before? \n15 \nA \nAs a general practice, yes. \n16 \nQ \nAll right. Do you think that would have been \n17 \nparticularly important in this case where the proposal \n18 \ninvolved sending the case back to the state, which the \n19 \nvictims were aware had already mishandled the case to begin \n20 \nwith? \n21 \nA \nSo, a few -- there are -- there are a few things in \n22 \nthat question that I think are packed. Whether the victims \n23 \nwere aware and were of the view, from my perspective and my \n24 \nrecollection, were of the view that the state had mishandled \n25 \nthe case, I can't speak to. \nEFTA00009365\n", "char_count": 1272}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "1 \nPage 138 \nSome of the victims were, to my recollection, \n2 \nexonerating him. There was concern that some of the victims \n3 \nwere more on his side than on the prosecution's side. And \n4 \nso, that judgement call of which victims are notified and how \n5 \nmuch I think is something that really is a judgement call \n6 \nthat needs to be done almost on a case by case basis by \n7 \nindividuals that are aware of sort of the facts and \n8 \ncircumstances surrounding each victim. \n9 \nIn the general \nin a general case, you want to \n10 \nhave fulsome communication. I can understand in cases where \n11 \nvictims might be giving exonerating information, where -- or, \n12 \nthere is restitution at stake, that could be different. \n13 \nQ \nAnd by the people involved, are you talking at \n14 \nthe -- at the trial team level? \n15 \nA \nAt the trial team level with whatever appropriate \n16 \nsupervisors \n17 \nQ \nMM-hram. \n18 \nA \n-- are engaged in the victim notification issues. \n19 \nQ \nAnd in this case, that would not include you, is \n20 \nthat correct? \n21 \nA \nThat -- I don't recall cases where I got -- where I \n22 \nbecame part of the victim notification judgements. \n23 \nBY MS. \n24 \nQ \nDid you ever issue an instruction to the trial team \n25 \nthat they should not consult with the victims before the NPA \nEFTA00009366\n", "char_count": 1302}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Page 139 \n1 \nwas signed? \n2 \nA \nSo, not that I recall. I know that there's some \n3 \ninstances where after the NPA was signed, I said, you know, \n4 \nI'm directing that we withhold notification for five days, or \nX period of time to work this out. \n6 \nBut before the NPA was signed, I don't recall -- in \n7 \nall candor, I don't recall discussions about victim \n8 \nnotification until after the NPA was signed. I don't know if \n9 \nthere's e-mail traffic before the NPA was signed, but I don't \n10 \nrecall victim notification issues until after the NPA was \n11 \nsigned. \n12 \nQ \nOkay. \n13 \nBY MR. \n14 \nQ \nAnd I just -- one more question on this topic is \n15 \nthat prior to -- we interviewed other people, obviously, in \n16 \nthis --\n17 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n18 \nQ \n-- case, and we interviewed Ms. \n, and one \n19 \nof the things that she told us, she has a recall of a -- of a \n20 \nmeeting with you present, Mr. \n, and Mr. \n, where \n21 \nthis issue of victim notification was discussed in the \n22 \ntimeframe of prior to the FBI, and at that meeting, she was \n23 \nspecifically instructed that we are not going to talk about \n24 \nit with the victims. Do you recall that meeting? \n25 \nA \nI don't -- I don't recall. If that's her \nEFTA00009367\n", "char_count": 1221}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Page 140 \n1 \nrecollection, that's her recollection. I don't -- I don't \n2 \nrecall that. I -- I recall knowing that there were issues \n3 \naround victim notification. I recall, particularly after the \n4 \nNPA was signed, I recall efforts, I believe, to notify as it \n5 \nwas being signed -- to notify the victims of the upcoming \n6 \nstate plea. \n7 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n8 \nA \nAnd I recall discussions -- if not discussions --\n9 \nlet me not say discussions -- a general concern about the \n10 \nvictim notification, what does that do? Because the victim \n11 \nis also a witness, and a --\n12 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n13 \nA \n-- potential witness, and in some cases and adverse \n14 \nwitness. And so, how does all that balance out? \n15 \nQ \nOkay. Well, we're going to drill down into \n16 \nthose --\n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \npost-NPA issues later on. \n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \nJust now, focusing on --\n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \npre-NPA, before it's signed, when the \n23 \nnegotiations are going back and forth. \n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \nYou have memory of this topic coming up? \nEFTA00009368\n", "char_count": 1036}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Page 141 \n1 \nA \nI don't recall discussing the victim notification \n2 \nissues. \n3 \nQ \nOkay, and what would your response be though to --\n4 \nare you -- are you aware of the CVRA litigation that went on? \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nFrom Judge Marra? \nA \nYes. \nQ \nSo, one of the issues that comes up in Judge \n9 \nMarra's decision is, he made a finding that the government \n10 \nviolated the CVRA because they didn't inform -- consult with \n11 \nthe victims --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- prior to signing the NPA, and there is a \n14 \nperception, or he -- from his opinion that the government did \n15 \nthis -- failed to communicate that in order to eventually \n16 \nkeep the victims in the dark and protect the resolution. Why \n17 \nis that an incorrect assumption? \n18 \nA \nAnd so -- so, I would say that \nsets out her \n19 \nreasoning in her affidavit. She talks about --\n20 \nBY MS. \n21 \nQ \nAre you referring to the -- her 2017 affidavit? \n22 \nA \nHer 2017 affidavit. She talks about -- I believe \n23 \nshe notified at least some victims, and it became an issue, \n24 \nand there's concern -- you know, you have this NPA. \n25 \nWhether -- whether or not that NPA will ultimately remain is \nEFTA00009369\n", "char_count": 1182}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Page 142 \nI \na very open question, because from our office's expectations, \n2 \nwe expected him to plead shortly after that, and he did not. \n3 \nAnd so, are we going to trial or are we not is a \n4 \nvery open question, and I think there is -- has to be \n5 \ndiscretion, where there is no legal requirement. There has \n6 \nto be discretion to judge how much you can tell the victims \n7 \nand when. \n8 \nBY MR. \n• \n9 \nQ \nOkay, just -- just one other point, and this is \n10 \nthat -- we've reviewed --\n-- Ms. \ndeclaration, and the \nnotifications that she's referring to there, those \ndiscussions take place after the signing of the NPA. So, \nwe're just talking about here still --\nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- just the pre-NPA --\n18 \nA \nYeah. \n19 \nQ \n-- pre-signing of that. So, does that change your \n20 \nanswer at all? \n21 \nA \nAgain, I don't -- I don't recall the victim \n22 \nnotification being issued before the NPA. I recall a lot of \n23 \ndiscussions afterwards. I don't recall. That doesn't mean \n24 \nthey didn't happen. That just means I don't recall them. \n25 \nQ \nWas there any concern with you or among any of the \nEFTA00009370\n", "char_count": 1114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Page 143 \n1 \nother people involved in this negotiation phase that if the \n2 \nvictims were to find out that we are negotiating this NPA \n3 \nthat it will blow up the NPA, that it will cause us trouble \n4 \nin some way? \n5 \nA \nOur -- my focus before the NPA was signed was, here \n6 \nare -- here are these terms. You know, and then for the \n7 \nteam, go negotiate this. And so, from my perspective, it was \n8 \nmuch more of a, what are the terms, than the victim \n9 \nnotification issues around that. \n10 \nBY MS. \n11 \nQ \nRight, but just to follow up \n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- did you hear any discussion amongst the people \n14 \nthat you were dealing with --\n15 \nA \n16 \nQ \n-- that they were afraid that the victims might \n17 \nraise such objections, or go to the press that this whole \n18 \nthing would be -- you know, come to a -- come to a halt? \n19 \nA \nSo, I tried to think -- I don't recall -- I believe \n20 \nwe notified the victims in advance of the state hearing so \n21 \nthat they would be aware. We didn't notify them before we \n22 \nsigned the NPA to my recollection, but we certainly notified \n23 \nthem of the state hearing. And so, I was aware generally of \n24 \nwhat was being done, but the NPA and what we -- you know, the \n25 \nNPA was the focus, not the victim notification --\nEFTA00009371\n", "char_count": 1290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \nMS. \nTHE WITNESS: \nMS. \nPage 144 \n: When --\n-- part of that. \n: -- when you talk about -- go ahead. \n4 \nMR. \n: \nWe -- we're going to get into the \n5 \nplea --\n6 \nTHE WITNESS: Right. \n7 \nMR. \n: -- and what we're --\n8 \nMS. \n: All right. \n9 \nTHE WITNESS: Right. \n10 \nMR. \n: -- a little bit later on. \n11 \nTHE WITNESS: Right. \n12 \nBY MR. \n13 \nQ \nJust one -- can I just direct you to --\n14 \nA \nYeah. \n15 \nQ \n-- document number 15? \n16 \nMS. \n: Exhibit 15? \n17 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. \n18 \nBY MR. \n19 \nQ \nOkay. So, do you -- that was an e-mail that is \n20 \nfrom Ms. \nto \n, then forwarded to you? \n21 \nA \nYeah. \n22 \nQ \nDo you see the reference in there where she \n23 \nmentions that she spoke to \n, or \n24 \nreminded her -- where is it? \n25 \nMS. \n: It's in the second paragraph --\nEFTA00009372\n", "char_count": 788}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Page 145 \n1 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah, no, I --\n2 \nMS. S \n: \nin the middle. \n3 \nTHE WITNESS: I see it. \n4 \nMR. \n: The middle --\n5 \nTHE WITNESS: It's highlighted. \n6 \nBY MR. \n7 \nQ \nCould you just read that? The agents and I have \n8 \nnot reached out to the victims to get their approval, which \n9 \nas i \npolitely reminded me, is required under the law. Do \n10 \nyou -- do you -- do you recall that e-mail? \n11 \nA \nI -- again, I don't recall this specific e-mail. \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \nand \n17 \nhow you interact with -- with victims who are also potential \n18 \nwitnesses, and I was aware -- I support what the office did. \n19 \nI'm not backing away from it. \n20 \nI'm just saying I can't, 12 years later, \n21 \nreconstruct what the thought process was other than there was \n22 \nno legal obligation. It was a discretionary issue, and this \n23 \nis how the discretion was exercised. \n24 \nQ \nBut did -- do you remember -- so, there's two \n25 \nthings. Any -- do you remember any discussions coming up \nMy recollection is a view that there is no requirement to \nnotify, because it's not a plea, it's deferring in favor of a \nstate prosecution. \nAnd therefore, it becomes a discretionary issue, \nwhat notification is appropriate is really a function of \nEFTA00009373\n", "char_count": 1245}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Page 146 \n1 \nabout the topic of what we have to do as far as notification \n2 \nin the pre-NPA negotiations? \nA \nI -- again, I really don't. I know there was a lot \nof discussion after the NPA. I don't recall pre-NPA \ndiscussions on this. \n6 \nQ \nLast question on this. \n7 \nA \nSure. \n8 \nMS. \n: By him. \n9 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. \n10 \nBY MR. \n11 \nQ \nYou're getting at least forwarded to you an e-mail \n12 \nfrom the trial attorney in the case showing that she is \n13 \nconcerned about the notification issue, and she's raising at \n14 \nleast the -- referencing the head of --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- CEOS about this issue. Did this ring any bells \n17 \nto you? Raise any --\n18 \nA \nSo, from this, I would infer that a discussion was \n19 \nhad as to what the obligations had -- were, and whether we \n20 \nhad to or not, because -- so, I think it's fair to infer she \n21 \nis, you know, e-mailing my first assistant. \n22 \nI don't know what the attachment here -- oh, the \n23 \nattachment here is the term sheet, so to speak, and my first \n24 \nassistant is forwarding it to me in large part so that I get \n25 \nthe attachment, and I think from here, it's fair to infer \nEFTA00009374\n", "char_count": 1163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Page 147 \n1 \nthat -- that some conversation or discussion was had. I \n2 \ndon't remember the conversation or discussion. \n3 \nMy focus was on the terms. I'm willing to accept \n4 \nthat the conversation was had. My recollection of the \n5 \nobligations under the CVRA is that they did not attach, \n6 \nbecause this was not an indictment, it was not a plea, and \n7 \nthat it was entirely discretionary how we proceeded, and \n8 \ntherefore how you proceed is a function of, should you notify \n9 \nvictims? \n10 \nYes, but there are concerns because they're also \n11 \nwitnesses. There are concerns because we are going out of \n12 \nour way to provide for restitution, and all of that played \n13 \ninto a complex calculus. \n14 \nQ \nThat was it. \n15 \nBY MS. \n16 \nQ \nSo, you said that there was a view that there's no \n17 \nrequirement to notify the victims. Who was that view coming \n18 \nfrom? \n19 \nA \nI can't -- I can't speak to person A, B, or C. \n20 \ncan say that if -- if the office thought there was a legal \n21 \nobligation, there are too many professionals involved in this \n22 \nthat if they thought there was a legal obligation to notify, \n23 \nthey would have done so. \n24 \nAt some point in this process, whether it was pre \n25 \nor post, I know that there was some explicit consideration of \nEFTA00009375\n", "char_count": 1291}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Page 148 \n1 \nwhat are the obligations, and some discussion of, this is not \n2 \nthe obligations don't attach until indictment, and therefore, \n3 \nthis is a discretionary matter. \n4 \nWhether that happened in September or in August or \n5 \nOctober, I can't speak to. But I know that that was -- that \n6 \nwas talked about, and I think later on in the record, there's \n7 \nan e-mail from our appellate chief in a different case that \n8 \nhighlights, well, there is this Texas case that just ruled \n9 \nthe other way. So, clearly, it's an issue that had been \n10 \ntalked about, and I recall it being talked about. I just \n11 \ncan't tell you the when, or the with who. \n12 \nQ \nAnd would there have been any -- you've spoken on \n13 \none concern --\n14 \nA \nRight. \n15 \nQ \n-- concerning impeachment of the victims regarding \n16 \ntheir --\n17 \nA \nYeah. \n18 \nQ \n-- financial aspect of the NPA. Would there have \n19 \nbeen any downside to consulting with the victims concerning, \n20 \nhey, the U.S. Attorney's Office is considering a resolution \n21 \nshort of a plea that involves charges in state court. How do \n22 \nyou feel about that, victims? \n23 \nA \nSo, there may not have been a downside. It's \n24 \ndifficult to recreate. My understanding, going back 12 \n25 \nyears, was that the victims would be aware of what was \nEFTA00009376\n", "char_count": 1312}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Page 149 \n1 \nhappening in the state court and have an opportunity to speak \n2 \nup at the state court hearing. \n3 \nQ \nAnd where does that -- where does this come from? \n4 \nA \nSo, my understanding is that when he was going to \n5 \ngo into state court that they would have been notified that \n6 \nthat was an all-encompassing plea, that that state court \n7 \nsentence would also mean that the federal government was not \n8 \nproceeding. \n9 \nQ \nBut again, in terms of --\n10 \nA \nBefore -- your point is before it was signed. \n11 \nQ \nCorrect, so that they could have input --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- into trying, perhaps, if they wanted to, to \n14 \npersuade you that that --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- was not a good idea. \n17 \nA \nIt may have -- it may have been a -- look, looking \n18 \nback on it, it may have been a very good idea. I can't speak \n19 \nto what the thought process was then, other than it was \n20 \ndiscretionary and it was not legally required. \n21 \nQ \nBut at least as we sit here today, you cannot \n22 \nrecall a particular problem that somebody brought up to you \n23 \nand said, we should not consult because of this problem? \n24 \nA \nI don't recall that, and clearly, given the way \n25 \nit's played out, it may have been much better if we had. \nEFTA00009377\n", "char_count": 1263}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Page 150 \nBY MS. \n2 \nQ \nIn the last 15 or --\nA \nRight. \n4 \nQ \n-- 20 minutes, you've several times referred to \ndiscussions and we. \nA \nRight. \n7 \nQ \nI want to make it clear that so far, the people who \nwere involved in this case, the Epstein case in your shop \nwere you, \n, and \nIf -- is \nthere anyone else who was involved in those discussions other \nthan those five? \n2 \nA \nNot to my recollection at this phase. \n13 \nQ \nOkay. Okay. I just want to make sure --\n14 \nA \nYes. \n15 \nQ \n-- we understand who you --\nlE \nA \nYeah. \nQ \n-- who is encompassed --\n8 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- in that general discussion --\n2C \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- of -- of the matter. Okay. So, on July 26, so, \n22 \nwe're now a month after that -- that presentation by the \n23 \ndefense counsel to the team, including \nand \n24 \nA \nCorrect. \n2 \nQ \nThere was a meeting in Miami, and it was, again, \nEFTA00009378\n", "char_count": 876}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Page 151 \n1 \namong \nby telephone, \n2 \n, as well as the two case agents --\n3 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n4 \nand \n. Did you \n5 \nknow them, by the way? \n6 \nA \nI did not, not to my recollection. \n7 \nQ \nOkay, and also their supervisor, \n? Did \n8 \nyou know \n9 \nA \nSomewhat. \n10 \nQ \nAll right, and they were all in West Palm, of \n11 \ncourse. \n12 \nA \nYeah. \n13 \nQ \nAnd then ASAC \n14 \nA \nYeah. \n15 \nQ \nDo you recall her? \n16 \nA \nSomewhat. \n17 \nQ \nAll right. They arrived -- or, at least, the trial \n18 \nteam -- the investigative team arrived ostensibly to discuss \n19 \nthe case. It turned out to be a very brief meeting \n20 \nessentially consisting of \ncoming in, announcing \n21 \nthat you had decided on a two year state resolution, and then \n22 \nessentially leaving without \nthat is, \nleft the \n23 \nmeeting without discussion. \n24 \nThis was -- this has been described to us as \n25 \nstunning to the investigative team. They had no idea this \nEFTA00009379\n", "char_count": 930}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Page 152 \n1 \nwas coming. This was -- they were completely blindsided. \n2 \nThe question is, were you aware that \nwas going \n3 \nto announce that you had decided on this resolution? \n4 \nA \nSo, I don't recall that, but I had decided and \nS \nendorsed this resolution at some point. And so, the fact \n6 \nthat I don't recall doesn't mean that -- I wasn't at the \n7 \nmeeting, I don't recall. But I clearly had endorsed this \n8 \nresolution, and so --\n9 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n10 \nA \n-- his announcement would have been consistent with \n11 \nmy decision. \n12 \nQ \nAnd again, that decision was reached without \n13 \nconsultation and discussion with -- and input from the line \n14 \nAUSA. Does that trouble you? \n15 \nA \nSitting here today, I wouldn't have said that there \n16 \nwas no input from the AUSA. So, to the extent that she felt \n17 \nthere was no consultation or input, that would. From my \n18 \nperspective, trying to recreate things from 12 years ago, \n19 \nthere had been discussions and consultations, and she had \n20 \nspoken with \nand \nand -- and it would have been my \n21 \nguess that views were known and articulated, and there was \n22 \ngood communication back and forth. \n23 \nQ \nBut again, that's your expectation of your people, \n24 \nis that correct? \n25 \nA \nCorrect. \nEFTA00009380\n", "char_count": 1270}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Page 153 \n1 \nQ \nOkay. So -- and also, from our interviews, it --\n2 \nthere's -- our -- it's our understanding that you popped your \n3 \nhead into that meeting and said hello to the folks --\n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \nA \nOkay. \nQ \n-- gathered. Do you have any --\nA \nAgain, I --\nQ \n-- recollection of that? \nA \n-- I don't remember the meeting. \nQ \nAll right. \n10 \nA \nI may have -- I may have done that. \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \nQ \nAnd it's not --\nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- completely uncharacteristic of you? \nA \nRight. \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nIt's not. \nQ \nAll right. \nA \nNo, because that was an internal meeting. That \n19 \nwasn't --\n20 \nQ \nRight, or -- correct, as opposed to the --\n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \n-- scenario we were discussing this morning. Ail \n23 \nright, this deal, and we're not talking about \n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- the term sheet yet, two major prongs me want to \nEFTA00009381\n", "char_count": 871}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Page 154 \n1 \ntalk about. One -- the first one is forgoing federal \n2 \nprosecution, right? Going for a state only disposition, and \n3 \nI talked to you this morning about the five -- sort of the \n4 \nfive ways a case could proceed when it comes from the state. \n5 \nYou can either decline it and give it back to the state. You \n6 \ncan go ahead and indict, but the guy -- let the defendant or \n7 \ndefendants go to trial, or plead to the indictment. You can \n8 \nindict, negotiate a deal, although you talked about some of \n9 \nthe issues there, and you can also file a complaint and \n10 \nnegotiate pre-indictment, or negotiate something. \n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \nSo, why was it that all of those other options were \n13 \nrejected, and the state only deal was settled on? \n14 \nA \nSo, let me -- let me back up a minute, because I \n15 \nthink it was a little more -- a little more fluid. The way \n16 \nthe matter came to the office was, the state wasn't doing \n17 \nenough. \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \nAlternatively, we could look at a pre-indictment \n24 \nresolution, and at various points, the office went back and \n25 \nforth between a federal pre-indictment resolution, and a \nIt didn't provide for prison time. It didn't \nprovide for registration, and then you had the restitution \nissue. There were legal issues, which I'm sure we'll talk \nabout. There were witness issues. And -- and we could go to \ntrial, potentially, and we may or may not prevail. \nEFTA00009382\n", "char_count": 1451}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Page 155 \n1 \nstate pre-indictment resolution. I think you showed me an \n2 \nexhibit where\n said a 371 with the rule 11. There was \n3 \nsome discussion of other statutes at some point. I don't \n4 \nrecall the timeline. \n5 \nAnd so ultimately, the focus was as an initial \n6 \nmatter, what -- how do we get this to resolution with some \n7 \nflexibility for state versus federal? I think -- not I \n8 \nthink. I -- you know, there was a preference for deferring \n9 \nto the state. \n10 \nQ \nWhere does that come from? What --\n11 \nA \nIn part because the legal issues are to some exter. \n12 \nalso present in a federal resolution, because that then \n13 \nbecomes a precedent for other similarly situated cases. \n14 \nQ \nDid you want to avoid a precedent? \n15 \nA \nSo, should we talk about the legal issues? Because \n16 \nwe \nwe say we keep coming back to the legal issues, but --\n17 \nQ \nAll right. Talk about the legal issues. \n18 \nA \nSo -- so, when I was at civil rights, one of the \n19 \nareas of responsibility that I had was trafficking. I was \n20 \nvery supportive. We set up some of the first human \n21 \ntrafficking task forces. I thought civil rights really \n22 \nbecame aggressive. I think III \nwas one of the point \n23 \npeople. \n24 \nWe brought in \nto be a point person on \n25 \nhuman trafficking. One of the background issues that -- that \nEFTA00009383\n", "char_count": 1337}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Page 156 \n1 \ninformed the time and all those prosecutions and also the \n2 \ndevelopment of the trafficking law was, what is the \n3 \ndistinction between trafficking and solicitation, and how --\n4 \nand what is the distinction between a truly federal case and \n5 \na local case? \n6 \nBecause there was a lot of concern at the time \n7 \nabout federalizing something that is traditionally local. \n8 \nNow, that was 12 years ago, and I think that those concerns \n9 \nare no longer in play today nearly -- and certainly not to \n10 \nthe extent that they were 12 years ago. \n11 \nQ \nThis was the state of play at the time you were the \n12 \nAAG for --\n13 \nA \nAt the AAG and afterwards as I was U.S. Attorney to \n14 \nsome extent, there was a lot of discussions about \n15 \nfederalizing state issues generally, and certainly in the \n16 \nlegislative issues that went back and forth, that was -- that \n17 \nwas a consideration. \n18 \nQ \nWasn't that trend very swift as of -- was it '06 \n19 \nwhen the Adam Walsh Act was enacted? \n20 \nA \nSo -- so, sure. I think we're trending in a \n21 \ncertain direction. \n22 \nQ \nAll right. \n23 \nA \nAnd I think that trend has continued and \n24 \naccelerated, but these were very -- these were valid, in my \n25 \nopinion, considerations at the time, and one question to be \nEFTA00009384\n", "char_count": 1292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Page 157 \n1 \nconsidered is, how would a court look at this -- because \n2 \ndifferent judges may look at these statutes differently. And \n3 \nhow would a court consider federal nexus issues? \n4 \nAnd so, that was, to my mind, an important \n5 \nconsideration, because this was at the time to some extent \n6 \nuncharted territory, and while we might prevail, and probably \n7 \nwould prevail, we may not have, and how is that weighed \n8 \nagainst a certain plea with registration that would make sure \n9 \nthat the public knew that this person was a sex offender? \n10 \nQ \nOkay, a couple of things. One, did you engage in \n11 \nthat -- that discussion, based on your experience, with \n12 \n? Did -- did you -- did you engage in that kind of \n13 \nconversation? \n14 \nA \nI don't recall who I may have talked to, but this \n15 \nwas -- when -- when -- you will see in the record reference \n16 \nto legal issues. This -- these were the legal issues, at \n17 \nleast to my mind, that that's referring to. \n18 \nQ \nBut did you sit -- I mean, not to be silly about \n19 \nit, but --\n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- did you sit in your office and ponder them, or \n22 \ndid you in the context of --\n23 \nA \nWe would have -- we would have discussed them. \n24 \nQ \nAll right, we, being you, and --\n25 \nA \nI and -- whether it's \nor \nor \nEFTA00009385\n", "char_count": 1304}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Page 158 \n1 \nwouldn't have sat and pondered them on my own, but we would \n2 \nhave had some level of discussion about these. \nSo, conversely, is it your understanding that --\nthat those three guys understood from you at least your \nperspective on these legal issues? \nA \nI -- let me -- let me push back. Those -- those \n7 \nthree professionals, because they are --\n8 \nQ \nOh --\n9 \nA \nYeah. \n10 \nQ \nI'm sorry. \nA \nWell, in this context, it's --\n12 \nQ \nColleagues, yes. \n13 \nA \nYeah. Yeah. So, there were two large buckets of \n14 \nissues. One was the witness issues, and on those, I would \n15 \nhave deferred more to folks that are experienced trial \n16 \nprosecutors. The other one are these legal issues. \n17 \nQ \nMis-hmm, \n18 \nA \nAnd you see it with the fed -- with the reference \n19 \nat the very beginning to the federal nexus --\n20 \nQ \nMit-hmm. \n21 \nA \n-- and you see it throughout where -- these were \n22 \ndiscussions that we had, and from the very beginning, what is \n23 \nthe federal nexus, and how do we make it clear that we are \n24 \nnot stepping on something that is a purely local matter, \n25 \nbecause we don't want bad precedent for the sake of the \nEFTA00009386\n", "char_count": 1167}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Page 159 \n1 \nlarger human trafficking issue. \n2 \nQ \nDid you have those conversations with your three \n3 \nsubordinate colleagues in this case? \n4 \nA \nI would have had those conversations with those \n5 \ncolleagues. Whether it was with all three, or with two, I \n6 \ncan't recall, but I would have had those conversations. \n7 \nQ \nAnd do you recall whether anyone -- anyone among \n8 \nthem pushed back as, for example, \nindicated \n9 \nhis view of some of those issues? \n10 \nA \nSo -- so, I don't recall specific pushback. I \n11 \ncan \nI can say where we concluded, which is there \nwe are \n12 \ncomfortable enough with the law to believe that we are \n13 \nthat if we need to go to court, we can do so ethically, and \n14 \nwe have a good chance of winning. Because if we could not go \n15 \nforward --\n16 \nQ \nOf course. \n17 \nA \nThen -- then we just can't go forward, right? No \n18 \nmatter what outcome you want. Was it a slam dunk? Was there \n19 \nsome legal risk? Yes, there was some legal risk. \n20 \nQ \nMr. Acosta, you use the term a roll of the dice in \n21 \nyour press conference. \n22 \nA \nYes. \n23 \nQ \nIn -- there's a different -- I mean, at one end, \n24 \nyou have a slam dunk. I would submit that no criminal \n25 \nprosecution --\nEFTA00009387\n", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Page 160 \n1 \nA \nRight. \n2 \nQ \n-- is a slam dunk. \n3 \nA \nCorrect. \n4 \nQ \nLikewise, I would ask you to comment on whether any \n5 \nprosecution is really a roll of the dice, given that a \n6 \nprosecuting authority, in this case, the U.S. Attorney's \n7 \nOffice, will have always done investigation, persuaded at \n8 \nleast a majority of grand jurors to -- that they -- that \n9 \nthere is sufficient proof to bring an indictment --\n10 \nA \nRight. \n11 \nQ \nand so on. Do you -- do you -- would you still \n12 \nhang your hat on a roll of the dice hook? \n13 \nA \nSo, I don't know if I would use that exact phrase. \n14 \nQ \nAll right. \n15 \nA \nBut let me -- let me just say, because you --\n16 \nprodding grand jurors. From our perspective, sitting in the \n17 \noffice in 2006 and 2007, this is a case that someone comes to \n18 \nyou and says, this has been presented, we have no reason to \n19 \nbelieve the state attorney acted -- we're not happy with what \n20 \nthey did, but we have no reason to believe that there was \n21 \nfunny business. \n22 \nQ \nMisconduct? \n23 \nA \nMisconduct. \n24 \nQ \nAll right. \n25 \nA \nAnd let's assume that there is no misconduct, \nEFTA00009388\n", "char_count": 1145}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Page 161 \n1 \nbecause you don't want to assume that again still. So, the \n2 \nstate attorney took this, reviewed it, presented it to a \n3 \ngrand jury, and the grand jury came out with this kind of \n4 \nrecommendation. That at least is indicative of some -- some \n5 \nother authority looking at this and making a judgement as to \n6 \nwhat it looks like. \n7 \nQ \nAre you aware that at least at the investigative \n8 \nand line assistant level, there was -- they had understanding \n9 \nand reason to believe that the state prosecutors had put in \n10 \nwitnesses into their grand jury and set about impeaching \n11 \nthem? I'm not --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- suggesting that this is misconduct, but it's a \n14 \nway of approaching evidence before a grand jury, and if they \n15 \ndid that, it would be perhaps charitably for the purpose of \n16 \nmaking it abundantly clear to the grand jurors how the \n17 \nwitness would fair --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- or not fair under aggressive cross-examination \n20 \nat a trial and so on. \n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \nSo, were you aware of that at the time? \n23 \nA \nI was not. \n24 \nQ \nYou were not. \n25 \nA \nRight. \nEFTA00009389\n", "char_count": 1140}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Page 162 \n1 \nQ \nYou were not aware that that was an actual concern \n2 \nand understanding --\n3 \nA \nThat -- that there was --\n4 \nQ \n-- by your team? \nA \nThat there was a concern that they basically --\n6\n \nTanked the case. \n7 \nA \nTanked. \n8 \nQ \nYes. \n9 \nA \nSo, there was -- I --\n10 \nQ \nYou -- I just --\n11 \nA \n12 \nQ \nYou didn't know that? \n13 \nA \nI was aware of a concern about how the state \n14 \nattorney -- how aggressive they were. \n15 \nQ \nRight. \n16 \nA \nThere's a -- there's a distance between how \n17 \naggressive they were versus tanking a case. \n18 \nQ \nRight, but I am telling you the concern by your \n19 \npeople at the ground level \n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- was the latter. \n22 \nA \nUnderstood. \n23 \nQ \nOkay. \n24 \nA \nAware of lack of aggression, tanking the case, very \n25 \nspecifically, I mean, there might have been, hey, you know, \nEFTA00009390\n", "char_count": 851}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Page 16 -:\n1 \nis there -- this looks really odd, but you've given a level \n2 \nof granularity as to highly unusual conduct. So, my point, \n3 \nthere is at least a perspective coming out of the state. \n4 \nThere are legal concerns. \n5 \nWe believed -- at the end of the day, I thought we \n6 \nwould prevail, but they're valid, and then you overlay that \n7 \nwith witness concerns, and concerns as to how juries, which \n8 \nwere different in 2006 on these issues. \n9 \nQ \nWhat do you base that on, by the way? \n10 \nA \nIt's --\n11 \nQ \nBecause you're not a trial attorney anymore. \nA \nSo, experience with how juries in South Florida \n3 \nlooked at these matters, and with how South Florida looked a-. \nthe project Safe Neighborhood -- I'm sorry, --\nIt's childhood. \n16 \nA \nProject Safe Childhood run initiative generally, \n17 \nand so there had been -- there had been prior instances where \n18 \nwe had talked about this, and we had gotten some pushback. \n19 \nQ \nFrom --\n20 \nA \nFrom within the office, from within the FBI. \n21 \nQ \nOn what? \n22 \nA \nOn -- on sort of sex cases more generally. \n23 \nQ \nAnd pushback in what regard? \n24 \nA \nWhere should we put our resources? And so, there \n25 \nwas -- there was just a general -- just general pushback. \nEFTA00009391\n", "char_count": 1246}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Page 164 \n1 \nQ \nOkay, but there are a couple things there. One is, \n2 \nthe juries -- the juries -- the petite juries, and \n3 \nwhich --\n4 \nA \nRight. \n-- you -- I'd still like the answer on. \n6 \nA \nYeah. \n7 \nQ \nAnd then the other is the FBI being loath to muck \n8 \naround with these cases that they were not --\n9 \nA \nYeah. \n10 \nQ \n-- yet --\n11 \nA \nSo --\n12 \nQ \n-- engaged with. \n13 \nA \nSo, let's -- let's take them one at a time, you \n14 \nknow, and -- and in all candor, I think we're looking at this \n15 \nthrough a 2019 lens. You know, at the time, and I've said \n16 \nthis in different forms, but you know, Weinstein was known \n17 \nand about, and actions weren't taken, and Bill Cosby was \n18 \nknown about. And they're each -- go with me. They're each \n19 \ndifferent --\n20 \nQ \nAll right. \n21 \nA \n-- but I do think the public looked at these cases \n22 \ndifferently in 2006, and there are at least some \n23 \nindividuals -- I'm not saying it was the right view -- but \n24 \nthere are at least some individuals who would have looked and \n25 \nsaid, this is a solicitation case, not a trafficking case. \nEFTA00009392\n", "char_count": 1109}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Page 165 \n1 \nQ \nAll right. Who in your office \nwho in the U.S. \n2 \nAttorney's Office ever said that? \n3 \nA \nSo, this was -- this came up in the context of, how \n4 \nwould the victims do in court? And it wasn't just, you know, \n5 \nhow will they be impeached, but how will jurors look at the \n6 \nfact patterns around this generally? \n7 \nQ \nAnd who was -- who was talking --\n8 \nA \nI can't --\n9 \nQ \nabout that? \n10 \nA \nI can't say. I know that it was discussed. I \n11 \ncan't say A, B, C, or D. I \n12 \nQ \nWell, it wouldn't have been D, because it would --\n13 \nD would be \n, and I think you would agree with \n14 \nme that she would not --\n15 \nA \nI would agree --\n16 \nQ \n-- concede that. \n17 \nA \nI would agree with you. \n18 \nQ \nAll right. \n19 \nA \nWith that, but my point is that when we're \n20 \ntalking -- so, when you're looking at victims in court today, \n21 \nI think it's fair to say that the way we approach -- there's \n22 \nbeen -- you know, there's been a lot of changes in victim \n23 \nshaming, and the degree to which all of that is permitted. \n24 \nThe degree to which I think the public understands \n25 \nthat -- that girls, minor females, may be scared and may \nEFTA00009393\n", "char_count": 1173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Page 166 \n1 \ntestify differently. And I'm suggesting that it's important \n2 \nto sort of think back to 2006 and understand that these \n3 \nissues may have been viewed differently. \n4 \nQ \nYou -- you're -- you have not -- since leaving the \n5 \nU.S. Attorney's Office -- been engaged in the investigation \n6 \nand prosecution or handling in any respect of child sex \n7 \ncrimes, is that correct? \n8 \n9 \nA \nThat is correct. \nQ \nSo, on what do you base this -- is it -- is it a --\n10 \nyour cultural observation? Your perspective on the evolution \n11 \nof popular culture, not in a derogatory way, that leads you \n12 \nto that assessment? \n13 \nA \nSo, on a few -- certainly the law has changed, and \n14 \nthe law has become much more aggressive. So, for example, I \n15 \nbelieve the law on proof of age has changed where proof of \n16 \nage is no longer required. \n17 \nQ \nThe law has, but the case law even at this time was \n18 \nalready --\n19 \nA \nWhat was --\n20 \nQ \n-- reasonably clear on that. \n21 \nA \nWas reasonably clear, and certainly moving in that \n22 \ndirection. \n23 \nQ \nCorrect. Wouldn't you have wanted to be at the \n24 \nforefront of this? \n25 \nA \nSo, I believe I was at the forefront of trafficking \nEFTA00009394\n", "char_count": 1206}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Page 167 \n1 \nissues, and I think if you were to look at my civil rights \n2 \nrecord, I really was at the forefront of trafficking issues. \n3 \nQ \nEven the U.S. Attorney's Office had a very robust, \n4 \nas we discern it now, a very robust initiative. It maybe \n5 \nwasn't a formal initiative, but commitment to prosecute these \n6 \ncases. \n7 \nA \nCorrect, and -- and I fully supported that. All \n8 \nthe more reason why, if there is an issue, and there is a \n9 \npotential for some judge, rightly or wrongly, whether I agree \n10 \nor not -- because you can't always predict -- even though you \n11 \nthink you'll prevail, you can't always predict where holdings \n12 \ngo. To --\n13 \nQ \nAre you talking about on appeal? \n14 \nA \nOn appeal or in trial to \n15 \nQ \nRight. \n16 \nA \n-- to issue a negative precedent on travel for \n17 \npurpose of, or on federal nexus, and if you think back at the \n18 \ntime, on appear, there were -- there's a lot of case law on \n19 \ncommerce clause and federal nexus. \n20 \nQ \nRight. \n21 \nA \nAnd so, I think that that is an important and valid \n22 \nfactor that goes into the decision making that assesses the \n23 \nrisk of trial, not just from the -- this -- you know, how the \n24 \nvictims will testify in this particular case, but also what \n25 \nthis means to the greater -- to the greater effort. \nEFTA00009395\n", "char_count": 1323}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Page 168 \n1 \nQ \nI understand that completely. What I -- what I am \n2 \nnot hearing is where a voice other than you and your team in \n3 \nthis case was being heard, like \nDid --\n4 \ndid you --\n5 \nA \nAnd --\n6 \nQ \n-- talk to him about these issues? Because --\n7 \nA \nNot --\n8 \nQ \n-- CEOS --\n9 \nA \nNot to --\n10 \nQ \n-- was at the forefront of --\n11 \nA \nNot to my recollection. \n12 \nQ \nAll right. Wouldn't --\n13 \nMR. TODD: Let \nfinish her questions. \n14 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. Sorry. Sorry. \n15 \nMS. \n: We're all --\n16 \nTHE WITNESS: I apologize. \n17 \nMS. \n: We're on a mutual role here. \n18 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. \n19 \nBY MS. \n20 \nQ \nBut wouldn't -- if you'd had those concerns, \n21 \nperfectly well founded, why not reach out and engage with \n22 \nCEOS and see what their assessment was about the \n23 \nvulnerability that this case might expose your office to? \n24 \nA \nSo, I can't reconstruct that 12 years later. You \n25 \nknow, one interesting question is would CEOS have come to \nEFTA00009396\n", "char_count": 977}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Page 169 \n1 \nmind versus civil rights crim, because coming from civil \n2 \nrights crim, I -- you know, my primary trafficking contacts \n3 \nwould have been --\n4 \nQ \nDid you pick up the phone and --\n5 \nA \nNot --\n6 \nQ \n-- call them? \n7 \nA \nNot to my recollection. \n8 \nQ \nSo, I guess what I'm -- what I'm getting at is you, \n9 \nbased on substantial experience and a commitment to these \n10 \ncases in your office -- the U.S. Attorney's Office -- had \n11 \nformed your own analytical analysis -- your own analysis \n12 \nlegally. \n13 \nYou've told us you've discussed this or made those \n14 \nissues and concerns known to the people who were below you, \n15 \nat least immediately below you, and that it -- that's where \n16 \nit sort of rested. There was not an effort to go out and \n17 \nenhance or add to your understanding of the case, and legal \n18 \nissues. \n19 \nA \nSo, to my recollection, I don't recall, and it's --\n20 \nwe'll get into perhaps -- you know, I -- from my impression, \n21 \nI actually thought I was being more aggressive than main \n22 \njustice would feel comfortable with, and --\n23 \nQ \nMore aggressive in what respect? \n24 \nA \nIn my interpretation and how comfortable I was \n25 \ngoing forward than main justice, and we can get into that, \nEFTA00009397\n", "char_count": 1255}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Page 170 \n1 \nbut I thought I was being more aggressive, not less, and so I \n2 \nhad these concerns. I did not vet them at main justice. \n3 \nQ \nOkay. When you said more -- more aggressive, are \n4 \nyou talking about the fact that you crafted this state \n5 \ndisposition, or that you were more forward leaning on the \n6 \npotential of prosecuting Epstein federally? \n7 \nA \nMore forward leaning. \n8 \nQ \nAnd yet you didn't. You didn't -- you didn't lean \n9 \nsufficiently far forward to actually pull the trigger and \n10 \nhave an indictment returned. \n11 \nA \nSo, I would push back on that, and that from my \n12 \nperspective, we were leaning forward, because we did \n13 \nprosecute him by deferring to the state, and ensuring that at \n14 \nthe state --\n15 \nQ \nAll right. \n16 \nA \n-- he had a sentence that he -- where he went to \n17 \njail. \n18 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. I want to sort of move on. I \n19 \nwant to ask you a question about 11C1C, please, that you \n20 \nmentioned earlier. \n21 \nA \nOkay. \n22 \nQ \nAnd sort of alluded to here, when we --\n23 \nA \nRight. \n24 \nQ \n-- talked about judges, and we talked about \n25 \ndismissing charges from an indictment. Was your -- what was \nEFTA00009398\n", "char_count": 1174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Page 171 \n1 \nyour position as U.S. Attorney with regard to the binding \n2 \npleas in an 11C1C plea agreement? \n3 \nA \nWe used them very rarely. \n4 \nQ \nBut why? \n5 \nA \nAs a typical matter, judges did not like them. \n6 \nQ \nAnd -- and was that something that as U.S. \n7 \nAttorney, you engaged with the judges on, or was that simply \n8 \na matter of seeing what they did with them? \n9 \nA \nIt -- it happened before I got there. I suspect it \n10 \ncontinued to happen after I left. \n11 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. That said, were there some \n12 \noccasions in which the office, if you recall at all, did do \n13 \n11C1C --\n14 \nA \nThere --\n15 \nQ \n-- plea agreements? \n16 \nA \n-- may have been. I don't recall. \n17 \nQ \nOkay. All right. \n18 \nMR. \n: And \n, before we move onto --\n19 \nMS. \n: Yes. \n20 \nMR. \n-- another issue, can I --\n21 \nMS. \n: Yeah. I'm --\n22 \nMR. \n: -- go back a second --\n23 \nMS. \n-- still with federal -- I'm still \n24 \non the federal prosecution, but go ahead. \n1 \n25 \nBY MR. \nEFTA00009399\n", "char_count": 986}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "=,=3e,\n1 \nQ \nWe had talked about the -- you talked about the \n2 \nstate grand jury, and how their decision informed your \n3 \ndecision, and you said, well, what state grand jury did with \n4 \nthis. What was your understanding of what this was? Like, \n5 \nwhat exactly the state grand jury looked at? \n6 \nA \nSo, so, let me back up. I said it was a factor \n7 \nthat informed, not just --\n8 \n9 \nQ \nI understand. \nA \n-- determined. So, my understanding is that at \n10 \nleast some core amount of facts were presented, and I \n11 \nunderstand that since it was at the state, the FBI may have \n12 \nfound additional witnesses, but when it was presented, the \n13 \nvery reason the office took it in the first place was because \n14 \nit was presented to the state, and it went to a grand jury, \n15 \nand the recommendation from the grand jury was for a -- you \n16 \nknow, a statute that would not require jail time, and that \n17 \nseemed wrong. \n18 \nBut the very fact that it was presented to a grand \n19 \njury certainly was one of several factors that we considered, \n20 \nbecause it at least indicated some level of how individual \n21 \njurors may view this. \nQ \nDo you have any recollection that the state grand \n23 \njury presented a single witness, who, as \ntalked about \n24 \nearlier, that they impeached? \n2i \nhave -- I have read that it was a single witness. \nEFTA00009400\n", "char_count": 1355}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Page 173 \n1 \nSince then, I don't have an independent recollection of that. \n2 \nQ \nOkay. \n3 \nBY MS. \n4 \nQ \nAnd were you -- how familiar were you with Florida \n5 \nstate criminal procedure? \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \nFlorida bar. \n13 \nA \nCorrect. \n14 \nQ \nCorrect. So, really any knowledge you had would \n15 \nhave sort of been picked up? \n16 \nA \nI should -- I should point out that a number of \n17 \nAUSAs in Florida are not a member of the Florida bar, so \n18 \nthat's not unusual. \n19 \nQ \nOh, okay. No -- I'm not -- I'm not --\n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- suggesting --\n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \n-- otherwise. \n24 \nA \nAnd in federal employment, you can move from \nA \nIt depends what -- what area. \nQ \nWell, you never practiced there, right? \nA \nCorrect. \nQ \nI forget what law school you went to. \nA \nNot Florida. \nQ \nNot in Florida, and you were not a member of the \n25 \nQ \nRight. \nEFTA00009401\n", "char_count": 881}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Page 174 \n1 \nA \nYeah. So, I had been U.S. Attorney for quite a \n2 \nwhile, and then I -- you know, I think we would have been \n3 \ninteracting with the state system sufficiently, and if there \n4 \nwas something that I had questions on, I could certainly ask. \n5 \nQ \nWere you aware that in the Florida system, grand \n6 \njuries ware not required to be used to bring federal criminal \n7 \ncharges except in capital cases? \n8 \n9 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay, so even bringing a case to a grand jury was \n10 \nan -- in a non-capital context, was somewhat unusual? \n11 \nA \nAn indication that there were some concerns or \n12 \nsomething, so the state attorney, presenting it in the best \n13 \npossible light, is looking to test the case. \n14 \nQ \nAll right, and without getting into any substance, \n15 \ndid you at any point become aware of the kind of reaction \n16 \nthat the line AUSA, \n, was getting from the \n17 \nfederal grand jurors to whom she was presenting? \n18 \nA \nI did not. \n19 \nQ \nAll right. Another aspect of concern that I think \n20 \nyou mentioned in your press conference was the concern about \n21 \nlabelling or putting the girls -- the girls -- the victims in \n22 \na position where they would be labelled as prostitutes, \n23 \nright? Do you recall --\n24 \nA \nI'm not sure --\n25 \nQ \n-- mentioning that? \nEFTA00009402\n", "char_count": 1302}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Page 175 \n1 \nA \n-- I phrased it that way, but I -- I take -- I take \n2 \nyour --\n3 \nQ \nWe'll defer to the record. \n4 \nA \nRight. \n5 \nQ \nBut -- but you did -- you did express concern, and \n6 \nour understanding is there was some expression of concern in \n7 \nthe U.S. Attorney's Office among the folks about the victims \n8 \nhaving to self-identify, or --\n9 \nA \nRight. \n10 \nQ \n-- admit that they were sort of prostitutes. The \n11 \ndisposition that was reached in the state -- and that -- and \n12 \nthat -- avoiding that was something to be desired --\n13 \nA \nYes. \n14 \nQ \n-- right? \n15 \nA \nYes. \n16 \nQ \nThe charge to which Epstein was ultimately require \n17 \nto plead guilty did just that. It was a solicitation to \n18 \nprostitution of minors. Was that -- did that factor in at \n19 \nall as a -- as a -- as an issue of -- that -- that was not \n20 \nbeing addressed at all --\n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \n-- by the state disposition? \n23 \nA \nSo, I -- I was aware of and signed off on this \n24 \nthree point \n25 \nQ \nThe term sheet? \nEFTA00009403\n", "char_count": 1026}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Page 176 \n1 \nA \n-- it's in here somewhere -- term sheet. In terms \n2 \nof the negotiation over which state statute was used, and \n3 \nwhich victims, that is something that -- that -- to my \n4 \nunderstanding, was being handled by Ms. \n, and from \n5 \nmy perspective, she would certainly have had sensitivity to \n6 \nthat. \n7 \nQ \nAnd do you have any idea how that three -- those \n8 \nthree counts or charges were reduced to simply one? \n9 \nA \nI do not. That would be a function of the course \n10 \nof the negotiations. \n11 \nQ \nWhy was -- why wasn't any reasoning for this \n12 \ndisposition -- deferring to the state -- set forth in \n13 \nwriting? Why didn't anyone do a memo explaining what your \n14 \nreasoning was, or what the office's reasoning was? \n15 \nA \nI can't speak to that directly, but I can say that \n16 \nit would have been unusual. I don't recall other cases where \n17 \nthere was a, this is the reason for our disposition type \n18 \nmemo. At least not memos that came to me. \n19 \nQ \nOkay. I'm showing you two, and the caption is --\n20 \nis all that's relevant here, but there are two memos that are \n21 \nboth dated February 2006, and March 2006. One of them is in \n22 \nfact addressed to you from \n, and it attaches a \n23 \nmemo, which is a require for pretrial diversion to resolve \n24 \ncase against an individual named Ronald Sasse, S-a-s-s-e. \n25 \nAnd it is a child pornography possession case in \nEFTA00009404\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nPage 177 / 1  which the conclusion was that the defendant merely possessed / 2  it, and that it was a case that should be resolved by / 3  pretrial diversion, and I'm just only bringing that to your / 4  attention -- / 5  A  Right. / 6  Q  -- as well as this second one that I'll show you, / 7  to show you that there are cases involving, you know, child / 8  sex crimes, where it's -- the office did see fit to set forth / 9  its analysis and reasoning for the proposed result. / 10  The second document, dated February 15, 2006, is a / 11  memo, not to you, but t\n... [truncated, 2682 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00009329/75 or ?id=EFTA00009329&page=75]", "char_count": 2682}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Page 177 \n1 \nwhich the conclusion was that the defendant merely possessed \n2 \nit, and that it was a case that should be resolved by \n3 \npretrial diversion, and I'm just only bringing that to your \n4 \nattention --\n5\n \nRight. \n6 \nQ \n-- as well as this second one that I'll show you, \n7 \nto show you that there are cases involving, you know, child \n8 \nsex crimes, where it's -- the office did see fit to set forth \n9 \nits analysis and reasoning for the proposed result. \n10 \nThe second document, dated February 15, 2006, is a \n11 \nmemo, not to you, but to \nin his capacity as chief \n12 \nof the criminal division, and it requests authorization to \n13 \nenter into a plea agreement with a five year cap, and it --\n14 \nit is a C1C plea, and the handwritten notes indicate that the \n15 \nsupervisors concurred in it. Again, I'm simply suggesting \n16 \nthat there -- that there are at least some examples where the \n17 \noffice, you know, in these kinds of cases --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \n20 \nA \nSo --\n21 \nQ \n-- put it to paper. \n22 \nA \nSo, I can only speculate. \n23 \nQ \nmm-hmm. \n24 \nA \nAnd questions I would have is, to what extent was \n25 \nthis put on paper, because it was a case that \nor others \nEFTA00009405\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nPage 177 / 1  which the conclusion was that the defendant merely possessed / 2  it, and that it was a case that should be resolved by / 3  pretrial diversion, and I'm just only bringing that to your / 4  attention -- / 5  A  Right. / 6  Q  -- as well as this second one that I'll show you, / 7  to show you that there are cases involving, you know, child / 8  sex crimes, where it's -- the office did see fit to set forth / 9  its analysis and reasoning for the proposed result. / 10  The second document, dated February 15, 2006, is a / 11  memo, not to you, but to [REDACTED] in his capacity as chief / 12  of the criminal division, and it requests authorization to / 13  enter into a plea agreement with a five year cap, and it -- / 14  it is a CIC plea, and the handwritten no\n... [truncated, 2467 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00009329/76 or ?id=EFTA00009329&page=76]", "char_count": 2467}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Page 17E \n1 \nwere not involved with. So, this was the way that in this \n2 \ncase, the chief of the -- you know, the economic crimes, or \n3 \nin this case, you know, at \nis chief of the criminal \n4 \ndivision, we're communicating information rather than walking \n5 \nin and having a discussion. \n6 \nWe're just communicating it on paper as a way to \n7 \nobviate a discussion. In this particular case, there were --\n8 \nthere was discussion, there was communication, and so a memo \n9 \nto sort of establish -- in other words, is this a required \n10 \napproval memo, or is this a memo that says, in lieu of \n11 \ngetting together, where are the facts, let me know what you \n12 \nthink. \n13 \nQ \nAll right, and was there not a practice, or even a \n1 4 \nrequirement in the office that plea dispositions should be \n15 \nmemorialized in writing in -- in -- with the rationale? \n4 \nA \nSo, to the extent that a line attorney might be \n17 \nseeking permission from a supervisor --\n18 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n19 \nA \n-- on a plea disposition, I would think that they \n20 \nwould communicate that in writing as the cleanest, most \n21 \ntypical way when you've got 20 or 30 line attorneys and one \n22 \nsupervisor. That is not necessarily the only way, and \n23 \ncertainly as U.S. Attorney, I don't recall a -- you know, a \n24 \npractice of memorializing to me what plea dispositions would \n25 \nbe. \nEFTA00009406\n", "char_count": 1369}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Page 179 \n1 \nQ \nOkay, and in this case, you were involved in the \n2 \ncase, right? \n3 \nA \nAnd in this case, I was involved, and so to be \n4 \nclear, I'm not -- I -- I'm not saying that I disagreed with \n5 \nthis, and I'm not walking away with it. And so, to the \n6 \nextent that I may have in a meeting said this looks good, \n7 \nthat may have obviated a need to --\n8 \nQ \nAll right. \n9 \nA \n-- write that up. \n10 \nQ \nOkay. Thank you. Another aspect of the state \n11 \nresolution that raises concern -- and it -- and let me make \n12 \nclear that -- that many of our questions are framed in this \n13 \nway, but we are also reflecting a concern that's been \n14 \nexpressed in the press, and in the public, and by others. \n15 \nA \nI understand. Understood. \n16 \nQ \nSo --\n17 \nA \nUnderstood. \n18 \nQ \n-- we're sort of coming through that lens. So, \n19 \nanother aspect of the state resolution that raises concern \n20 \nis, doesn't it appear that the -- that by going -- sending \n21 \nthis matter back to the state, there's more federal \n22 \ninterference, more federal involvement in the state process \n23 \nthan there would have been if you had just kept the case? \n24 \nA \nSo in hindsight, one of the issues I think in this \n25 \ncase is after the agreement, and you know, we keep calling it \nEFTA00009407\n", "char_count": 1283}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Page 180 \n1 \na non-prosecution agreement, and I kept saying call it an \n2 \nagreement to defer in favor of state prosecution. \n3 \nQ \nA DPA instead of an NPA? \n4 \nA \nRight. \n5 \nQ \nWhy wasn't it called a DPA, by the way? \n6 \nA \nI don't know. There's one e-mail where I suggested \n7 \nputting in reference to petite policy. \n8 \nQ \nRight. \n9 \nA \nAnd \nsaid, looks strange, take it out. \n10 \nThere's another e-mail in the record where I keep saying --\n11 \neveryone keeps calling it an NPA, call it a deferred to \n12 \nstate. So, I can't -- you know, I can't say why not, but \n13 \nit's an important distinction. \n14 \nQ \nBut if you had said -- it -- I don't want to go --\n15 \nA \nYeah. \n16 \nQ \nto far afield, but if you had said, uh-uh, call \n17 \nit, no, call it a deferred prosecution \n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- agreement, they would have changed it, right? \n20 \nA \nThey would have, and I -- I actually asked that we \n21 \nhave a clause based -- I don't have the independent \n22 \nrecollection of this, but based on the record that we include \n23 \na clause saying that we were doing this in light of the \n24 \npetite policy to defer, and \npushes back and says, \n25 \nI haven't seen that, and he's the local expert, so I deferred \nEFTA00009408\n", "char_count": 1227}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Page 181 \n1 \nto him. I take responsibility, but it's an important \n2 \ndistinction. And so -- I'm sorry, I just lost track of your \n3 \nquestion. \n4 \nQ \nWe were talking about, doesn't this involve more \n5 \nfederal interference? \n6 \nA \nCould I -- could I grab a Red Bull from you that I \n7 \nbought? \n8 \n9 \n0 \n11 \nbreak? \n3 \nMR. HERRON: Yeah. \nTHE WITNESS: Sorry, just a --\nMS. \n: Do you want to take a five minute \nTHE WITNESS: Would you mind? \nMS. \n: Not at all. \n14 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. \n15 \nMS. \n: Call it, please, at any time. \n16 \nTHE WITNESS: Let me grab the Red Bull. \nMS. \n: Off the record. \n(Off the record.) \nBY MS. \nAll right. Thank you. All right. Back on the \n21 \nrecord. So, Mr. Acosta, I was asking you about -- didn't \n22 \nthis -- didn't this resolution end up injecting the feds into \n23 \nthe state business in a pretty aggressive way? \n24 \nA \nAnd -- and so what I was saying is in hindsight, \n25 \none of the -- one of the issues here is I think this would \nEFTA00009409\n", "char_count": 984}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Page 182 \n1 \nhave gone very differently if after the agreement to defer in \n2 \nfavor of state prosecution, all the victims knew about this, \n3 \nthey had gone into state court, he had pled October --\n4 \nwhatever the date was -- had been sentenced, had served his \n5 \nsentence, and case over. \n6 \nAnd so, one -- you know, to the extent there are \n7 \nlessons learned, an attempt to provide a -- an attempt to \n8 \nbackstop the state here, rebounded, because in the process, \n9 \nit got convoluted, and complex, and ended up being arguably \n10 \nmore intrusive than it would have had this just been, here is \n11 \nwhat we'll do, go back to the -- if you go back to the state \n12 \nand work this out, but --\n13 \nQ \nWould that have required or depended on cooperation \n14 \nfrom the state authorities? \n15 \nA \nSo, I think I was clear, and my recollection is \n16 \nthis was an issue where I said it is up to you, and one of \n17 \nthe -- I edited a few parts of this. I got involved \n18 \nselectively. \n19 \nQ \nExhibit 21b is --\n20 \nA \nOh. \n21 \nQ \n-- your edits. \n22 \nA \nOkay. So, let's -- before I say I think, let's go \n2.3 \nto --\n24 \nQ \nBut --\n25 \nA \n-- 21. \nEFTA00009410\n", "char_count": 1157}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Page 183 \n1 \nQ \nBut before me talk about 21b, as a general matter, \n2 \nyou talked earlier about the more -- the sort of more \n3 \ntypical, usual way in which the U.S. Attorney's Office and \n4 \nlocal authorities \nprosecutive authorities would work, and \n5 \nthat is cooperatively, and would decide who gets what, and --\n6\n \nRight. \n7 \nQ \n-- who has what responsibilities. Here, there was \n8 \nnot such cooperation, apparently. \n9 \nA \nThere wasn't, and I was going to say, to my \n10 \nrecollection, we can look at whether it's in 21b or not, one \n11 \nof my edits was make it clear that it's up to him to figure \n12 \nthis out with the state attorney, because we as federal \n13 \nprosecutors are not going to walk in and dictate to the state \n14 \nattorney. \n15 \nQ \nBut in affect, you did. \n16 \nA \n17 \nQ \nBy -- you did -- you did it through Epstein. \n18 \nA \nI understand. And so, in an attempt to -- in \n19 \nan attempt to reach a resolution, particularly as convoluted \n20 \nas this got, I do think a lesson learned is that it ended up \n21 \nperhaps being worse that if we would not have in the first \n22 \nplace. \n23 \nSomething -- I -- we, my team, we very much thought \n24 \nthat it was important that he go to jail. That it was \n25 \nimportant that he register. How we got to that ending is \nEFTA00009411\n", "char_count": 1293}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Page 184 \nunusual, and as an attempt to factor in, here are all the \n2 \nissues around the federal statutes, the concerns about \n3 \ntrafficking law, here are the victim issues as to trial, and \n4 \nhow -- you know, here is -- here are all these things. And \n5 \nso, on the one hand, deferring to state \nto the state, \n6 \nappears -- appears logical. \n7 \nOn the other hand, the way it played out was a lot \n8 \nmore confrontational with the state than I would have hoped, \n9 \nparticularly because rather than go back to the state and \n10 \nwork it out, in the collateral -- subsequent collateral \n11 \nattacks, they almost tried to state to circumvent and to --\n12 \nyou know, to get the state to circumvent and undermine our \n13 \nagreement. \nAnd that was -- when you say they, you mean the \ndefense team? \nSo, you could have -- you could have obviated that \n18 \nwhole thing if you had just offered the same result, which \n17 \nwould be a plea to a criminal charge with, for sake of \n2C \nargument, a two-year cap, which would have required a C1C \nplea. \n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \nAnd you'd get your restitution, because federal law \n24 \nrequires it. They would have been able to proceed under 18 \n25 \nUSC 22.55 anyway, and he would have gone to jail and been \nEFTA00009412\n", "char_count": 1259}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Page 165 \n1 \nregistered as a sex offender. All just within the normal \n2 \ncourse of doing business as the U.S. Attorney's Office. Why \n3 \nnot pursue that? Who was -- who was calling the shots that \n4 \nsaid, yeah, we'll do it, but it's got to be with the state? \n5 \nWas that the defense? \n6 \nA \nSo, something that -- that wasn't the defense. \n7 \nSomething that I think is important to sort of lay out here, \n8 \nis the -- the -- sort of the terms sheet was developed really \n9 \nearly in the case. \n10 \nQ \nExcuse me, it's dated, it's presented to the team \n11 \nby \non the 31st of July. Do you consider that \n12 \nearly? \n13 \nA \nSo, from -- let me -- let me clarify from my \n14 \nperspective. It was developed and approved by me before I \n15 \nbecame involved with interactions with the defense team. \n16 \nQ \nIn the sense that you only met with the defense \n17 \nteam for the first time in the person of Ken Starr and Jay \n18 \nLefkowitz and company on the 7th of September. \n19 \nA \nAnd it wasn't the 7th of -- yeah, the 7th of --\n20 \nQ \nThe 7th of September. \n21 \nA \n-- September. \n22 \nQ \n2007. \n23 \nA \nAnd that is important, because it goes to -- there \n24 \nis a lot of buzz in the media, did they influence this \n25 \noutcome? To my recollection, they may not even have been \nEFTA00009413\n", "char_count": 1282}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Page 186 \n1 \nattorneys of record in this case, and I don't know when they \ncame onto the case. \n3 \nQ \nWell, there's an e-mail in the package that \n4 \nindicates that you got a call from K and E \n5 \n6 \n8 \n9 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- on -- on or about the 6th of August. \nA \nAfter the terms sheet was --\nQ \nCorrect. \nA \n-- presented, and so I say that because we can --\n10 \nwe can -- and probably will talk about whether those terms \n11 \nwere the best judgement or not, but once those terms were \nagreed and approved, with the exception of the 24 to 18 as a \n13 \nmaterial, and then we can talk about how that happened, we \n14 \nstuck, and I backed the office, and I backed \nin her \n15 \nnegotiations on those. And so, I just -- I think that's \n16 \nimportant to note. \n17 \nQ \nI understand. I -- that's not, for the moment, the \n18 \nfocus. \n19 \nA \nFair. \n20 \nQ \nIt's the terms themselves, and in this case, the \n21 \nstate court disposition, everything that you wanted to get \n22 \nwith the state court disposition, you could have gotten with \n23 \na federal plea --\n24 \nA \nWe --\nQ \n-- much more easily. \nEFTA00009414\n", "char_count": 1100}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Page 18-\n1 \nA \nWe could have, and there was certainly some \n2 \nconsideration of a 371, and that may be -- you know, in \n3 \nretrospect, it would have obviated a lot of issues. \n4 \nQ \nSo, who said no, that's not --\n5 \nA \nSo --\n6 \nQ \n-- acceptable? \n7 \nA \nSo, there is e-mails that at the time \nspoke to \n8 \nme about it. I don't recall, but I'll take responsibility \n9 \nfor -- for favoring -- or, not for favoring, but if that's --\n10 \nif that's what happened, I will take responsibility. From my \n11 \nperspective, and my recollection, there are two -- two \n12 \nfactors here. \n13 \nWell, I don't know if it's two factors, but at \n14 \nleast two factors. One, concerns about how this interacts \n15 \nwith federal law, and what precedents this might mean for \n16 \nother trafficking cases. Two, a southern district's general \n17 \ndislike for rule 11, and -- and then third, there were other \n18 \nfederal statutes that were considered at various points, and \n19 \nI remember looking at those and saying, yeah, I don't -- it \n20 \ndoesn't quite -- it doesn't quite fit. \n21 \nQ \nTo -- just to be clear, that process of looking for \n22 \nthe square peg that --\n23 \nA \n24 \nQ \n-- would fit into the round hole of -- of the two \n25 \nyears that had been committed to was a process that came \nEFTA00009415\n", "char_count": 1285}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Page 188 \n1 \nbefore the NPA was actually negotiated, at a time when \n2 \nwas working with defense counsel to see if there \n3 \nwas a federal charges that could be within the two year --\n4\n \nCorrect. \n5 \nQ \n-- scope that would allow Jeffery Epstein to serve \n6 \nhis time in a federal facility, rather than in a state \n7 \nfacility. Is that --\n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \nA \nThat --\nQ \n-- is that correct? \nA \n-- iS correct. \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nAnd I recall -- I recall at least one of those \n13 \nideas, and I recall that my general reaction to it was, we're \n14 \npushing the law that just looks odd, and we don't want to go \n15 \nthere. \n16 \nQ \nAre you talking the assault on an airplane, or the \n17 \nobstruction of a witness, or --\n18 \nA \nI actually -- my recollection is not about the \n19 \nassault on the airplane --\n20 \nQ \nOkay. \n21 \nA \n-- but about his home being a special maritime \n22 \njurisdiction. \n23 \nQ \nOh. \n24 \nA \nWhich is -- no. \n25 \nQ \nDefinitely square peg in round hole. \nEFTA00009416\n", "char_count": 980}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "Page 189 \n1 \nA \nRight. \n2 \nQ \nCorrect? But there were -- so, I guess it -- is \n3 \nit -- is it -- is it accurate that from your standpoint, an \n4 \n11C1C federal disposition was not going to be acceptable? \n5 \nThat that's not something that you would approve? \n6 \nA \nIt would have been unusual, I don't recall with \n7 \nspecificity, but I can -- based on circumstances, infer that \n8 \nit would have been unusual, and -- and I would have looked at \n9 \nit and said this isn't -- this isn't typical. I'm not \n10 \ncomfortable. \n11 \nQ \nSo, why not -- why not offer the five year hit, and \n12 \nsay that's it? \n13 \nA \nI wish I could speculate. I mean, I could sit here \n14 \nand speculate after the fact. I can speak to what I recall. \n15 \nI can speak to what I approved. I can speak to the \n16 \nconsiderations that went into it. There are all sorts of \n17 \nthings that in hindsight we may or may not have done, which \n18 \nmay have worked out well or not. I -- I can't answer that. \n19 \nQ \nSo, I guess -- I guess the -- sort of the big \n20 \nunanswered as yet question is, why was there a fixation on \n21 \nthe two years when that's not something that comported with \n22 \nanything that was possible in the federal scheme? \n23 \nA \nSo, speaking to the two years, I don't remember \n24 \nwith specificity. I -- let me give you my general \n25 \nrecollection --\nEFTA00009417\n", "char_count": 1354}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Met-hum. \n2 \nA \n-- and then let me speculate. \n3 \nQ \nMel-hmm. \n4 \nA \nMy general recollection is that there were earlier \n5 \ncharges, you all may know those in more detail than I do, but \n6 \nthere were earlier state charges that were brought. \n7 \n8 \nQ \nThat were brought? \nA \nThat -- I'm sorry, not that were brought, that were \n9 \ncontemplated. \n10 \nQ \nOf which there is no public record? \n11 \nA \nThere is -- I don't know if there's public record \n12 \nor not. I can just say my recollection is that there were \n13 \nearlier state charges that were contemplated. The state \n14 \nattorney chose to not pursue those earlier state charges and \n15 \ntake it to a grand jury. \n16 \nFrom public information, my understanding is that \n7 \nthat's why Chief \nbecame upset. My general \n18 \nrecollection is that the two years represented what he would \n19 \nhave received if the original recommendation, or the original \n20 \nview of the state attorney's office had gone through, and it \n21 \nhadn't been brought to the grand jury, and I would -- I would \n22 \nsort of point to -- you know, in this Exhibit 3 -- I thought \n23 \nit was in Exhibit 3. \n24 \nSomewhere, there's a reference to -- as you can see \n25 \nit -- Exhibit 3, page three, as you and the agents conceded, \nEFTA00009418\n", "char_count": 1264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Page 191 \n1 \nhad Epstein been convicted of a felony that resulted in a \n2 \njail sentence and sex offender status, neither the FBI nor \n3 \nour office would have interceded. \n4 \nQ \nBut that is completely silent as to what those \n5 \noriginal charges may have been, or --\n6 \nA \n7 \nQ \n-- how they related to --\n8 \nA \nI understand. \n9 \nQ \nOkay. \n10 \nA \nAnd so, so, to just close the loop, my \n11 \nunderstanding is that those two years reflected what that \n12 \nwould have been such that the case would not have come to \n13 \nfederal authorities in the first place. \n14 \nQ \nOkay. Where did that information come from? Who \n15 \nsaid, oh, those charges would have resulted in a two year \n16 \nsentence? Was that something that was analyzed by your \n17 \noffice, or did it come from defense counsel, or --\n18 \nA \n19 \nQ \n-- from who? \n20 \nA \nI can't -- I can't speculate. It had to come from \n21 \nsomeone. \n22 \nQ \nIt did not come from you, is that correct? \n23 \nA \nSo, I would not have the knowledge to know what \n24 \nthat charge would have resulted. As an initial matter, a \n25 \npenalty that says up to blank years is rarely that number of \nEFTA00009419\n", "char_count": 1140}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Page 192 \n1 \nyears, right? \n2 \nQ \nRight. \n3 \nA \nBy the time you apply guidelines and all that, and \n4 \nso I would not have the knowledge to know how to calculate \n5 \nthat state sentence. \n6 \nQ \nAnd in fact were you aware that Florida did have \nits own state guidelines -- sentencing guidelines? \n8 \nA \nGenerally, I -- I know that --\n9 \nQ \nRight. \nA \n-- there is a process. \n11 \nQ \nRight. \n12 \nA \nMight I at some point have said, you know, Mr. or \n13 \nMs. AUSA, or management team member, if this had been done \n14 \nthe right way in the state, what would he have gotten, and \n15 \nsomeone comes back to me, possibly, maybe someone at some \n16 \npoint had said, look, this would never have come to us if it \n17 \nwas done the right way in the state, and this was the term \n18 \nthat he would've gotten. \n19 \nAt some point in this process, my general \n20 \nunderstanding is we got to that two years based on not \n21 \nrandom, but based on, this was the calculation that he would \n22 \nhave received. \n23 \nQ \nRight, and to make sure we understand, is that your \n24 \nactual recollection, or is it your belief based on what you \n2. \nknow happened that that's the way it --\nEFTA00009420\n", "char_count": 1173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Page 193 \n1 \nA \nSo --\n2 \nQ \n-- happened? \n3 \nA \nSo, it is my recollection of my understanding, \n4 \nwhich is convoluted, so let me --\n5 \nQ \nyeah. \n6 \nA \n/t is how I recall viewing the term sheet when I \n7 \napproved it. \n8 \nQ \nOkay. \n9 \nA \nHow it got into -- and so, if we got to the term \n1 0 \nsheet --\n11 \nQ \nIt's 21 -- no, it's not. \n12 \nA \nIt's -- it's one of these exhibits. \n13 \nMR. \n15. \n14 \nBY MS. \n15 \nQ \nThank you, 15. \n16 \nA \n15. So, if we go to the terms sheet, Epstein \n17 \npleads guilty -- contender to an information follow \n18 \ncharging him with -- these particular statutes are -- I am \n19 \nnot familiar with, but I would have assumed that either \n20 \nor someone else would have selected them appropriately. It \n21 \nmakes a binding recommendation to serve at least two years in \n22 \nprison. \n23 \nQ \nLet me back up if I could. Those three statutes, \n24 \ndid you understand those three statutes to be the three \n25 \nstatutes that -- or, to be the statutes that the state \nEFTA00009421\n", "char_count": 998}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Page 194 \n1 \noriginally was going to bring? \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \nA \nI can't speak to that. \nQ \nYou don't know. \nA \nI don't know. \nQ \nSo, you don't know what the statutes were? \nA \nYeah. \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nYeah. You know, it makes a joint binding \n9 \nrecommendation at least two years in prison \nMy -- my \n10 \nunderstanding, my recollection of my understanding, when I \n11 \nreviewed these terms, is that that reflected what he would \n12 \nhave received if he had -- if the state had gone through with \n13 \nan initial -- with an initial charge, and from our \n14 \nperspective at the time, that would have obviated the need in \n15 \nthe first place to have engaged federal authorities. Agree \n16 \nor disagree with the logic, I'm trying to explain the logic. \n17 \nQ \nMm-hmm. No, I understand. Thank you for that \n18 \nclarification. Is it -- you posited a couple of \n19 \npossibilities that you might have said, you know, gee, what \n20 \nwould --\n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \n-- he be looking at if --\n23 \nA \nRight. \n24 \nQ \n-- the state had done what it originally set out to \n25 \ndo or was supposed to do. Is it -- how also likely is it \nEFTA00009422\n", "char_count": 1131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Page 195 \n1 \nthat someone came to you, one of your people, and said, hey, \n2 \nI suggest we go with two years, because the same reason. \n3 \nA \nIt's --\n4 \nQ \nIn other words, it came from --\n5 \nA \nRight. \n6 \nQ \n-- somebody else to you, and you agreed. \n7 \nA \nSo, it's very difficult to reconstruct this in \n8 \nretrospect, in part because I don't want to leave the \n9 \nimpression that there was one meeting where this was \n10 \ndiscussed --\n11 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n12 \nA \n-- as opposed to, you've got -- you're sitting \n13 \nacross the hall from someone, you're sitting down the hall \n14 \nfrom someone. There are ongoing discussions, how do we \n15 \nresolve a matter that has some thorny legal questions, some \n16 \ndifficult victim witness questions, and this is the kind of \n17 \nback and forth where I might have indicated a concern, \n18 \nsomeone was trying to address that concern, or I might have \n19 \nasked the question. It -- it's --\n20 \nQ \nWell, you've already told us that you did express \n21 \nconcern --\n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \n-- about the case, and somebody -- and you were \n24 \nhaving conversations with \n25 \ncorrect? \n, possibly \nEFTA00009423\n", "char_count": 1138}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "Page 196 \n1 \nA \nCorrect. \n2 \nQ \nAnd is it possible \ndoes it -- is it reasonable \n3 \nthat one of them might have come up with a solution for you \n4 \nto your problems? \n5 \nA \nAnd that's the point that I'm --\n6\n \nOkay. \n7 \nA \n-- trying to make. It's certainly possible, and \n8 \nit's difficult to reconstruct that 12 years after the fact. \n9 \nQ \nAll right. All right. I want to go back to wind \n10 \nup this -- this concern about engagement with the federal --\n11 \nI mean, engaging the federal system into the state process. \n12 \n21b is the exhibit that is your comments really on the very \n13 \nfinal version of --\n14 \nA \nRight. \n15 \nQ \n-- the NPA on September 24, and the -- the language \n16 \nis quite striking to us in this regard, looking at the -- at \n17 \nthe first e-mail there, you've talked about deleting the \n18 \npetite policy portion upon \nrecommendation, and \n19 \ninserting global resolution language which you've proposed. \n20 \nAnd then you then say, \"I'm not comfortable with \n21 \nrequiring the state attorney to enter into a joining \n22 \nrecommendation,\" and then you propose essentially taking out \n23 \na mention of the state attorney's office regarding the -- the \n24 \nsentence recommendation, and then you also note, \"I'm not \n25 \ncomfortable with requiring a state court to stick with our \nEFTA00009424\n", "char_count": 1316}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Page 197 \n1 \ntimeline,\" and you ask that the reference be softened -- your \n2 \nterm is to soften. \n3 \nYou also use soften below when you talk about \n4 \nyour -- making it -- a concern about making Epstein an agent \n5 \nof the U.S. regarding negotiations. So, you're really -- and \n6 \nthen at the very top, in the -- in the later follow up e-\n7 \nmail, you express concern about, \"Do we really need to set a \n8 \ndate for his reporting? I'm very nervous about that. If I \n9 \nwere a judge, / would be upset by the federal government \n10 \ntelling a state court how to manage their calendar. Can we \n11 \ndelete?\" \n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \nSo, clearly you're very mindful, right, of the \n14 \nimportance of not injecting the federal sovereign into the \n15 \nstate sovereign. \n16 \nA \nCorrect. \n17 \nQ \nFair? All right, but yet, this whole set up, the \n18 \nwhole NPA did require certain actions to occur, however they \n19 \ncame about, in the state, because of the federal requirement. \n20 \nA \nYes. \n21 \nQ \nAnd why was that a good idea? \n22 \nA \nIn hindsight, the complexity that this took on \n23 \nclearly is something that -- that if I was advising a fellow \n24 \nU.S. Attorney today, I would say, think it through. I do \n25 \nthink it would have played differently if he had actually not \nEFTA00009425\n", "char_count": 1283}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "Page 198 \n1 \ndone all the collateral deals and stuck to what was --\n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \nQ \nBut that came later. \nA \nIt --\nQ \nThis is before it's signed. \nA \nIt came \nit came later, but let me -- let me at \n6 \nleast say that, and stuck to October 26th, but look, I \n7 \nunderstand your point, and -- and the response that I can \n8 \ngive was, you have -- we had these concerns, but we also \n9 \nthought it was very important that he serve some real \n10 \npunishment, and that he register. And whether -- whether we \n11 \nbalance that or not, a lot of people are going to be \n12 \nquestioning for a long, long time, but that's how we balanced \n13 \nit. \n14 \nQ \nBecause the state disposition was not a \n15 \nprecondition to achieving those two objectives. You could \n16 \nhave done it with a federal plea, serving time --\n17 \nA \nArguably --\n18 \nQ \n-- and the offender registration. \n19 \nA \nArguably, we could have done it with a federal plea \n20 \nif judges would have gone -- if judges would have gone for \n21 \nrule lls, which in the Southern District they tend not to, \n22 \nbut arguably. \n23 \nQ \nOkay. Okay. I just wanted to --\n24 \nA \nAnd you know, again, this is -- this is a hindsight \n25 \nthing, but yes. \nEFTA00009426\n", "char_count": 1203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009329", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "Page 199 \n1 \nQ \nIt is, but what we're focusing on is not so much \n2 \nthe hindsight as the -- at the time, did this make sense? \n3 \nAnd it seems that you all were putting in so much effort, and \n4 \nit was so hard to make this come together and work, that \n5 \nit -- it's striking that it didn't collapse of its own -- of \n6 \nits -- of its own weight. \n7 \nA \nAnd to that point, let me say, you know, it's also, \n8 \nif I had to speculate, one question that I'd -- that I'd ask \n9 \nis, everyone's putting in all this effort. You know, \n10 \nput in a lot of work on the negotiations with the defense \n11 \ncounsel that were somewhere between zealous and difficult. \n12 \nQ \nMeaning defense counsel were --\n13 \nA \nYeah. \n14 \nQ \n-- between zealous and --\n15 \nA \nYeah. \n16 \nQ \n-- difficult? \n17 \nA \nYeah. Whether there's zealous advocates or cross \n18 \nline to rude, we can have conversations about, and at what \n19 \npoint, you know, would it have proceeded differently if folks \n20 \nsaid, let's take a big step back, and let's seriously \n21 \nreconsider? But everyone was very, let's get the job done, \n22 \nlet's put him in jail. And I -- look, I'm speculating in \n23 \nhindsight. \n24 \nQ \nBut could you not have pulled the plug at any time \n25 \nbefore it was signed? I mean, clearly by the morning of that \nEFTA00009427\n", "char_count": 1307}]}