{"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_count": 100, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00009229", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00009229.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Page 1 \nTHE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE \nOFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY \nx \nINTERVIEW OF R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA \n: \n \nx \nWashington, D.C. \nFriday, October 18, 2019 \nInterview of: \nR. ALEXANDER ACOSTA \na witness of lawful age, taken on behalf of the United States \nDepartment of Justice in the above-entitled action, before \nBeth Roots, Notary Public in and for the District of \nColumbia, in the offices of the U.S. Department of Justice, \n950 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W., commencing at 9:34 a.m. \nDiversified Reporting Services, Inc. \nEFTA00009229\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nAPPEARANCES: On Behalf of the Department of Justice: [redacted x4 lines]. Department of Justice, 950 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W., Washington, D.C. 20530. [redacted]. On Behalf of the Witness: GORDON D. TODD, ESQ. T.J. HERRON, ESQ. Sidley Austin LLP, 1501 K Street Northwest, Washington, D.C. 20005. [redacted]", "char_count": 886}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Page 2 \nAPPEARANCES: \nOn Behalf of the Department of Justice: \nDepartment of Justice \n950 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W. \nWashington, D.C. 20530 \nOn Behalf of the Witness: \nGORDON D. TODD, ESQ. \nT.J. HERRON, ESQ \nSidley Austin LLP \n1501 K Street Northwest \nWashington, D.C. 20005 \nEFTA00009230\n", "char_count": 288}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Page \nPROCEEDINGS \n2 \nWhereupon, \n3 \nR. ALEXANDER ACOSTA \nwas called as a witness and, having been first duly sworn, \n5 \nwas examined and testified as follows: \n6 \nEXAMINATION \nBY MS. \nQ \nSo, would you tell us your name, please? \nA \nRene Alexander Acosta. \nQ \nAnd Mr. Acosta, you're accompanied by your \n11 \nattorney, Gordon Todd, is that correct? \n2 \n, \n• \nAnd Mr. Todd, would you identify the associate you \nhave with you? \nMR. HERRON: Yes, T.J. Herron. \nMS. \n: H-e-r-r-o-n? \n17 \nMR. HERRON: Correct. \n18 \nMS. \n: \nThank you. Mr. Acosta, I'm \n19 \nI am a counsel with the Office of Professional \n20 \nResponsibility here at the Department of Justice, and with me \n21 \nare my fellow OPR counsel, \nand IIII \n22 \n. We are in a conference room at the Department of \n23 \nJustice main building on today, October 18, 2019, and we're \n24 \nstarting at about 9:30 in the morning. Before we start, I'd \n25 \njust want to put on the record that Mr. \nworked in \nEFTA00009231\n", "char_count": 960}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Page 4 \n1 \nthe Civil Rights Division at the time that you were the AAG \n2 \nheading that division, and I believe had an occasion to \n3 \nbriefly meet you in connection with a matter. \n4 \nTHE WITNESS: Could I ask what section? \n5 \nMR. \nI was in the special litigation \n6 \nsection. \n7 \nTHE WITNESS: Oh, okay. \n8 \nMR. \n: And I provided Mr. Acosta some \n9 \ntalking points for a press situation that we had in that \n10 \ncase. \n11 \nTHE WITNESS: 14141. \n12 \nMR. \n: Yes. \n13 \nTHE WITNESS: Probably. \n14 \nBY MS. \n15 \nQ \nAll right. Thank you. Mr. Acosta, OPR is \n16 \ninvestigating two things. As you know, one, whether one or \n17 \nmore federal prosecutors in the Southern District of Florida \n18 \nU.S. Attorney's Office may have committed professional \n19 \nmisconduct by entering into the non-prosecution agreement, or \n20 \nNPA, in 2007 with Jeffrey Epstein, who at the time was under \n21 \ninvestigation by that office, and the FBI, for engaging in \n22 \nwidespread sexual misconduct involving underage females. \n23 \nThe second thing we're investigating is Judge \n24 \nMarra's finding of February of this year, 2019, that the \n25 \ngovernment may have violated -- or, actually, he found the \nEFTA00009232\n", "char_count": 1190}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Page 5 \n1 \ngovernment did violate the CVRA, or Crime Victims' Rights Act \n2 \nwhen it entered into the MPA without first providing the \n3 \nvictims with notice and a reasonable right to confer with the \n4 \ngovernment. \n5 \nYou are a subject of the OPR investigation, that \n6 \nis, one of -- somebody whose conduct is being reviewed and \n7 \nevaluated by OPR, and specifically as U.S. Attorney at the \n8 \ntime for the Southern District of Florida, you had the \n9 \nultimate authority over the Epstein for a period of two and a \n10 \nhalf years, as we understand it, from the time the line AUSA \n11 \nfirst briefed you and then criminal chief \n12 \nin July of 2006, and until you were formally \n13 \nrecused from the case on or about the 8th of December, 2008, \n14 \nafter notifying the executive office of the U.S. Attorneys \n15 \nthat you were seeking employment with Kirkland S Ellis, a \n16 \nfirm of which two attorneys, Ken Starr and Jay Lefkowitz had \n17 \nbeen representing Jeffrey Epstein. Is that correct? \n18 \nA \nWe may -- we may get into it a little bit later, \n19 \nbut I think the characterization of my seeking employment is \n20 \nnot accurate, we can talk about that a little bit later. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. We have the documents that relate to \n22 \nthat. So, that's what we're -- we're basing it on. \n23 \nA \nCorrect. \n24 \nQ \nAnd I believe the term that's used is seeking \n25 \nemployment. \nEFTA00009233\n", "char_count": 1398}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Page 6 \n1 \nA \nThat -- that is the term used in the e-mail. I \n2 \nthink I addressed that in my -- I believe Mr. Todd addressed \n3 \nthat in the letter that was sent to --\n4 \n5 \n6 \nQ \nAll right. \nA \n-- OPR. \nQ \nAll right. Thank you. So, we recognize that \n7 \nyou're not longer with the Department of Justice --\n8 \nA \nRight. \n9 \nQ \n-- and that it is your choice to come and talk to \n10 \nus, and we very much appreciate your willingness to \n11 \nvoluntarily do so and help us figure this case out. OPR \n12 \nprovided you with a few thousand pages of records, e-mails, \n13 \nand correspondence and some other documents that reflect your \n14 \ninvolvement in the Epstein matter over that two and a half \n15 \nyear period. \n16 \nNow that you've had a chance to review, I hope, \n17 \nthose e-mails and other documents, we hope you can be \n18 \nspecific in helping us understand what happened. Have you in \n19 \nfact been able to review those documents? \n20 \nA \nYes, I have. \n21 \nQ \nThank you. OPR asked you for a written response to \n22 \ncertain questions, and we've received and reviewed a written \n23 \nresponse prepared and submitted not by you, but by your \n24 \nattorney, Mr. Todd, on your behalf. Have you reviewed his \n25 \nresponse to --\nEFTA00009234\n", "char_count": 1238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Page 7 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \nA \nYes. \nQ \n-- you? \nA \nYes, I have. \nQ \nAnd will you now under oath subscribe to that \n5 \nresponse as if you had submitted to it yourself? \n6 \nA \nSo, Mr. Todd spoke to me and conveyed the \n7 \ninvestigation that I provide him. I believe he conveyed that \n8 \ninformation accurately, and the statements that he ascribes \n9 \nto me in that letter I believe are accurate. \n10 \nQ \nAll right. Do you have any changes or corrections \n11 \nto that written response? \n12 \nA \nNo, I do not. \n13 \nQ \nIs there anything in it that you do not agree with? \n14 \nA \nAgain, I think that the statements that he ascribes \n15 \nto me are accurate, and I agree with them. \n16 \nQ \nAll right. So, we are going to accept that \n17 \nstatement as representing accurately your -- what you would \n18 \nhave responded if you had responded to us directly. Is that \n19 \ncorrect? \n20 \nA \nI -- yes, the statements, he basically gives my \n21 \npositions, and I believe that he gave my positions \n22 \naccurately. \n23 \nQ \nPerfect. Thank you. So, as we ask questions and \n24 \nrefer to documents, we would like you to correct any \n25 \nmisstatements in our questions, or any misstatements or \nEFTA00009235\n", "char_count": 1179}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Page 8 \n1 \nerrors that are in the documents themselves, because we want \n2 \nto make sure the entire record --\n3 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n4 \nQ \n-- is correct. Also, there's been an enormous \n5 \namount of publicity about the Epstein case, particularly this \n6 \nyear, including about the events and decisions made back in \n7 \n2006 to 2010 that are the subject of our investigation. And \n8 \nso as best you can, we ask you to try to answer today from \n9 \nyour knowledge, understanding, and recollections as of that \n10 \nperiod of time. However, to the extent you are asked or do \n11 \nspeak retroactively, retrospectively, we'll just make it \n12 \nclear that you're doing so. \n13 \nA \nAll right. \n14 \nQ \nOkay? \n15 \nA \nAnd if I could just say, one of the difficulties is \n16 \nwith everything that -- all the publicity and all the \n17 \ndocuments that have made it to the press and in litigation \n18 \ndistinguishing between recollection versus after the fact \n19 \nQ \nRight. \n20 \nA \n-- speculation, and I will try, but I would \n21 \nappreciate reminders along the way, because it's, it's an \n22 \nimportant distinction, but it's kind of hard sometimes. \n23 \nQ \nwe recognize particularly the importance of it. \n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \nThat's -- that's precisely the heart of --\nEFTA00009236\n", "char_count": 1262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Page 9 \n1 \nA \nYeah. \n2 \nQ \n-- our matter. So, Mr. Acosta, your professional \n3 \nbackground is a matter of public record. I have a couple of \n4 \nquestions. By what state bar are you currently licensed? \n5 \nA \nSo, I am inactive in \nI believe inactive in \n6 \nPennsylvania and also in D.C. \n7 \n8 \n9 \nQ \nAll right, and not in Florida? \nA \nNot in Florida. \nQ \nSo, are -- is it -- do I understand that you are \n10 \nnot currently an active member of any bar? \n11 \nA \nI would have to confirm with D.C. I said not \n12 \ninactive in Pennsylvania and in D.C. because I am not certain \n13 \nwhether I'm currently active or inactive in D.C. I am not \n14 \ncurrently practicing, and so I would have renewed under \n15 \neither active or inactive. \n16 \nQ \nAll right. \n17 \nA \nAnd we can --\n18 \nQ \nwe --\n19 \nA \nWe can --\n20 \nQ \nWe --\n21 \nA \nWe can verify that and get that. \n22 \nQ \nWe would appreciate it if Mr. Todd could let us \n23 \nknow your current status. I also would like to know the \n24 \nstatus -- your bar status in the period of 2006 through 2008. \n25 \nDo you know what that was? \nEFTA00009237\n", "char_count": 1081}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Page 10 \n1 \nA \nMost likely -- I can -- I can speculate. I don't \n2 \nknow as a fact. Mostly likely active in D.C. \n3 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n4 \nA \nAnd inactive in Pennsylvania. \n5 \nQ \nOkay, but likely active somewhere, correct? \n6 \nA \nYes. Yes, I think that's a requirement. \n7 \nQ \nYes, that is a --\n8 \nA \nAnd so --\n9 \nQ \n-- requirement. \n10 \nA \nSo, it would be D.C., the distinction between \n11 \nactive and inactive in D.C. is more minor, as I recall, than \n12 \nPennsylvania where there's a large fee difference. \n13 \nQ \nAll right, thank you, and we look forward to \n14 \nhearing confirmation of that from you, Mr. Todd. So, after \n15 \nserving nearly two years as the assistant attorney general in \n16 \ncharge of the department's civil rights division, you were \n17 \npresidentially appointed the interim U.S. Attorney for the \n18 \nSouthern District of Florida in June of 2005, and then as we \n19 \nunderstand it, you were formally nominated as U.S. Attorney \n20 \nin June of 2006, and after being confirmed by the United \n21 \nStates Senate, you were sworn in by the U.S. Attorney -- as \n22 \nU.S. Attorney in late October 2006. \n23 \nA \nI think that may be inaccurate. I would have to \n24 \nconfirm. When you say presidentially appointed, I believe it \n25 \nmay have been appointed by the chief judge at the request of \nEFTA00009238\n", "char_count": 1315}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Page 11 \n1 \nthe Attorney General. The chief judge has appointing \n2 \nauthority. \n3 \nQ \nOkay. \n4 \nA \nAnd you'd have to go back and confirm whether it \n5 \nwas either an AG designation or the chief judge --\n6 \nQ \nAll right. \n7 \nA \n-- which is different than presidential. \n8 \nQ \nAnd I understand, and again, I would appreciate if \n9 \nyou could --\n10 \nA \nYeah. \n11 \nQ \n-- follow up on that --\n12 \nA \nI -- I'm --\n13 \nQ \n-- Mr. Todd. \n14 \nA \n-- not certain how to confirm that. That's \n15 \nsomething that in all candor the department would know --\n16 \nQ \nAll right. \n17 \nA \n-- much better than I. \n18 \nQ \nThen we will pursue it. My point is that there was \n19 \na change in your status from interim to -- you -- the U.S. \n20 \nAttorney with the -- with the full --\n21 \nA \nCorrect. \n22 \nQ \n-- confirmation. How if at all did that change in \n23 \nstatus affect your view of and your exercise of your \n24 \nauthority as U.S. Attorney? \n25 \nA \nSo, it's difficult to recall. You're now asking \nEFTA00009239\n", "char_count": 992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Page 12 \n1 \nthat just ten years back, but even further back. I was \n2 \ninterim for a sufficiently long period of time that -- that \n3 \nby the time the change in status took place, I would \n4 \nspeculate that I was, in my mind, the, you know, acting as \n5 \nU.S. Attorney whether you have an adjunctive interim, or \n6 \nacting in front of your name or not. \n7 \nYou know, I -- I had great people. I don't recall \n8 \nwhen -- when \ncame on board as first assistant, but he \n9 \nwas my crim chief, and I thought for the continuity of the \n10 \noffice it was important to promote him to first assistant, \n11 \nand --\nQ \nHe was promoted actually effective October of 2006. \n3 \nYou made a series -- according to e-mails -- the \n14 \nannouncement -- the personnel announcement was made to be \n15 \neffective in October 2006 naming \n16 \nchief, and \nas first --\n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \nQ \n-- assistant. \n19 \nA \nRight, and they -- they were both long serving \n20 \nprofessionals within the office, and basically, as my \n21 \nrecollection, everyone just moved up one wrung. \n22 \nQ \nOkay. \nas criminal \n23 \nA \nYou would know better than I, because you have \n24 \nthose records. And so, sitting here today, I don't recall \n25 \nany specific way in which that shift would have impacted --\nEFTA00009240\n", "char_count": 1269}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Page 13 \n1 \nQ \nAll right. \n2 \nA \n-- my thinking. \n3 \nQ \nYou had not served as a -- as a prosecutor before, \n4 \nand had -- didn't have direct criminal experience is my \n5 \nunderstanding. \n6 \nA \nThe -- that is correct. I had supervised -- civil \n7 \nrights, for example, had supervised criminal prosecutions, \n8 \nbut I had not been a line prosecutor previously. \n9 \nQ \nSo, as the U.S. Attorney supervising a couple of \n10 \nhundred --\n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \n-- line prosecutors, most involved in criminal \n13 \nwork, how -- what -- what -- what interested you most, or \n14 \nappealed to you most as you undertook your -- and carried out \n15 \nyour duties as U.S. Attorney? \n16 \nA \nWhat interested me and appealed to me. So, the \n17 \nwork of the office, I mean, the -- it's a broad question, but \n18 \nthe work of --\n19 \nQ \n)t-hmm. \n20 \nA \n-- that office and any U.S. Attorney's Office I \n21 \nthink is incredibly impactful to any local community, and I \n22 \nvery much enjoyed being a part of the effort to bring folks \n23 \nto justice, to move policy initiatives. You know, I recall \n24 \nearly on, we identified healthcare fraud \n25 \nQ \nHa-hmm. \nEFTA00009241\n", "char_count": 1148}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Page 14 \n1 \nA \n-- as one big -- one big area, and we had one of \n2 \nthe largest out of our -- the largest healthcare fraud \n3 \ninitiative. You know, we focused quite a bit on gun \n4 \nviolence, and we did a great job on that, and it's one of \n5 \nthose jobs where people feel very good about what they do, \n6 \nand it's great to be part of it. I'm sure what --\n7 \nQ \nNo, that's --\n8 \nA \n-- okay. \n9 \nQ \nThat's helpful. It just gives us a \n10 \nA \nYeah. \n11 \nQ \n-- some perspective. \n12 \nA \nYeah. \n13 \nQ \nWas there any aspect of it that you particularly \n14 \ndisliked? \n15 \nA \nTo the extent you're dealing with personnel issues, \n16 \nI think personnel issues are -- are rarely the preferred part \n17 \nof any executive function. \n18 \nQ \nYou mean the conflicts among attorneys, things like \n19 \nthat, or performance issues? \n20 \nA \nPerformance issues. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. \n22 \nA \nAnd you know, when you've got -- in any large \n23 \noffice, you get personnel issues, disciplinary issues, and \n24 \nthose are never --\n25 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \nEFTA00009242\n", "char_count": 1035}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Page 15 \n1 \nA \n-- those are never fun. \n2 \nQ \nMM-hmm. So, we talked about the personnel -- high \n3 \nlevel personnel changes you made sort of after your first \n4 \nyear there. I= \nhad, we understand, been functioning \n5 \nde facto as a first assistant while IS \nwas not. \n6 \nHe -- we understand \nhad been first assistant, but \n7 \nhe stepped away, and ME NM \ncame in to essentially take \n8 \nover his brief until he was formerly appointed first \n9 \nassistant. Is that consistent with your memory? \n10 \nA \nSo, you might have characterized that more strongly \n11 \nthat I would have. \n12 \nQ \nOkay. \n13 \nA \nAgain, it's difficult to recreate from back then, \n14 \nbut there was certainly a transition period from Mr. \n15 \nto Mr. \n, and if I could, because when you \n16 \nsaid high level changes, my intent -- it was a great office. \n17 \nGreat professionals. My intent in elevating Mr. \nwas \n18 \njust you go from criminal chief to first assistant, and I \n19 \ndon't recall Mr. \nprior position, but I know that he \n20 \nwas also elevated. I think he might have been major crimes, \n21 \nbut --\n22 \nQ \nThat's correct. \n23 \nA \n-- I'd be -- I'd be speculating. \n24 \nQ \nWe can --\n25 \nA \nI could guess it. \nEFTA00009243\n", "char_count": 1197}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "a e \n1\n1 \nQ \nWe can verify that. \n2 \nA \nOkay. \n3 \nQ \nYes. What was your assessment of \nHis \n4 \ncapabilities, his judgement, and his working relationship \n5 \nwith you on a day to day basis? \n6 \nA \nOutstanding. He had been in the office for \n7 \ndecades. He was respected by everyone. He had a good tone \n8 \nto him. He was someone, you know, I wanted individuals \n9 \naround me that were respected within the office and that were \n10 \ntrusted and that had been there for a long time, and then I \n11 \nthink I was very lucky to -- to have that in my management \n12 \nteam. \n13 \nQ \nAs we understand it, your office as U.S. Attorney \n14 \nwas sort of on one side of the reception area, and the first \n5 \nassistant's office is on the other side. Is that correct? \n_E \nA \nThi,t Ls _erred. \n17 \nQ \nOr, at the time --\n18 \nA \nCorrem \n19 \nQ \n-- that was correct. So, did you and \n20 \nhave a sort of easy back and forth --\n21 \nA \nWalking --\n22 \nQ \n-- open door? \n23 \nA \n-- into each other's offices multiple times a \n24 \nday --\n4 \nAll right. \nEFTA00009244\n", "char_count": 1039}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Page 17 \n1 \n2 \nA \n-- kind of relationship. \nQ \nAll right, and given that he had had experience \n3 \nthroughout his career at the department in the criminal arena \n4 \nand you had not, to what extent would you rely on him, among \n5 \nothers, for guidance, perspective, information, and so on? \n6 \nA \nI named him first assistant because I valued his \n7 \nguidance and his perspectives and I thought those were \n8 \nvaluable. \n9 \nQ \nOkay. You also, as we pointed out, appointed \n10 \nto succeed \nas criminal chief effective \n11 \nOctober of 2006, and he served for about ten months before he \n12 \nleft for private practice. He left at the beginning of \n13 \nAugust --\n14 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n15 \nQ \n-- 2007. What -- you -- you did -- you said you \n16 \ndidn't recall, as we sit here today, what section he'd come \n17 \nfrom. \n18 \nA \nRight. I guessed it was major crimes. \n19 \nQ \nAll right. Were you -- what was your assessment of \n20 \n21 \nA \nOutstanding as well, and if I could say, when I say \n22 \nI don't recall but I guess, when you're going back 12 years, \n23 \nsometimes you get an impression but you can't say it's a \n24 \nrecollection, and that's going to come up multiple times \n25 \ntoday, just because it's a while ago. \nEFTA00009245\n", "char_count": 1220}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Page 18 \n1 \nQ \nAs long as we make that distinction --\n2 \nA \nRight. \n3 \nQ \n-- both are helpful. \n4 \nA \nRight, and so -- so, whether it's a recollection or \n5 \na construction after the fact, I can't \ncan't say, but \n6 \nyou know, I -- I thought that one of the helpful factors with \n7 \nis he had spent a lot of time -- and major crimes is the \n8 \nmost active -- active unit. I assume you all know the \n9 \nstructures of the office --\n10 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n11 \nA \n-- but major crimes is not major crimes, it's sort \n12 \nof the entry level crimes, and I valued the fact that he had \n13 \ntrained and, you know, so many AUSAs, and really spent a lot \n14 \nof time reviewing -- the major crimes chief as opposed to the \n15 \nother chiefs spends a lot of time reviewing the work of \n16 \nAUSAs, and so, he would be someone who is very experienced \n17 \nand able to get in the weeds. \n18 \nQ \nAnd he in fact was around -- during that time \n19 \nperiod, had gone back in the courtroom, if you recall, to \n20 \nactually try a major case. Do you recall that? /t was a --\n21 \nA \nI didn't until you --\n22 \nQ \n-- major fraud case. \n23 \nA \n-- mentioned -- I didn't until you mentioned it, \n24 \nand now there's something in the back of my head that's \n25 \nsaying that sounds right, but I can't give you more detail. \nEFTA00009246\n", "char_count": 1298}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Page 19 \n1 \nQ \nAll right. What was your assessment of \n2 \nsort of working style, and particularly working \n3 \nwith you? \n4 \nA \nYou know, again, positive. You know, we didn't --\n5 \nI didn't see him as often as Mr. \n, but --\n6 \n7 \nQ \nHe -- was he located on the same floor? \nA \nHe was located on the same floor, but not within \n8 \nthe same suite. \n9 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n10 \nA \nAnd -- and that -- that affects interaction, but a \n11 \npositive working relationship. \n12 \nQ \nAll right, and how \nhow -- to what extent would \n13 \nyou, as criminal chief, was he relied on by you as \n14 \ndistinguished from \nwith regard to the criminal \n15 \nmatters pending? \n16 \nA \nAlso relied on. Depend -- that would depend almost \n17 \non the matter for --\n18 \nQ \nOkay. \n19 \nA \n-- as in a typical situation, he would bring things \n20 \nto \nwho would them bring them to me along, and so he \n21 \nwould bring things to \n, and then depending on their \n22 \ndiscussion, they might both walk into my office. But he \n23 \nwould typically run things through \nbefore coming to me. \n24 \nQ \nWere there occasions when he would come to you \n25 \ndirectly? \nEFTA00009247\n", "char_count": 1123}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Page 20 \n1 \n2 \n3 \nA \nSure. That's why I said in a typical --\nQ \nOkay. \nA \nIt's difficult to sort of recreate the \n4 \ninteractions, but he certainly could come to me directly, and \n5 \nin some cases, I would say probably would. \n6 \nQ \nAgain, it being a large office with several \n7 \nphysical locations, and we understand it, a very high \n8 \nvolume --\n9 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n10 \nQ \n-- of cases --\n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \n-- and particularly in the criminal context, is it \n13 \nfair to say you didn't review every prosecution as it was \n14 \nbrought? \n15 \nA \nIt -- it is not just fair, but accurate. I recall \n16 \na conversation with a U.S. Attorney from a small district \n17 \nearly on at one U.S. Attorney's conference where we compared \n18 \nnotes, and the interaction of an office with 30 prosecutors \n19 \nis very different than one with --\n20 \nQ \nHm-hmm. \n21 \nA \n-- a few hundred prosecutors. \n22 \nQ \nSo, when you did engage on a -- on a criminal case, \n23 \nwould you -- whether it was a planned prosecution or a case \n24 \nheading to trial, would you generally rely on written \n25 \nsubmissions, or would you -- this is really an --\nEFTA00009248\n", "char_count": 1133}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Page 21 \n1 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n2 \nQ \n-- inquiry into --\n3 \nA \nRight. \n4 \nQ \n-- your style, or would you have everybody \nS \ntogether, and talk about it, or would you rely on your most \n6 \nimmediate subordinates to be briefing you? How -- which one \n7 \nof those --\nA \nSo --\n9 \nQ \n-- kinds of --\n10 \nA \nSo --\n11 \nQ \n-- approaches --\n12 \nA \nSo --\n13 \nQ \n-- did you take? \n14 \nA \nI would say that really depended, and probably \n15 \nvaried based on -- on individual needs. For the most part, I \n16 \nwould most likely just speak with my first assistant and/or \n17 \ncriminal chief, and assess what else needed to be done. \n18 \nQ \nIn other words, you would sort of do it on a --\n19 \nsort of on a verbal, or based on oral --\n20 \nA \nCorrect. \n21 \nQ \n-- interaction and --\n22 \nA \nCorrect. \n23 \nQ \n-- presentation as opposed to going through stacks \n24 \nof papers? \n25 \nA \nFor -- for the -- I would say that was typical. \nEFTA00009249\n", "char_count": 915}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Page 22 \n1 \nQ \nYeah. \n2 \nA \nI don't want to say that was the case every single \n3 \ntime, but that was -- was typical. \n4 \nQ \nAll right, and to what extent did you go out and \n5 \nabout to encounter the line attorneys, or example? Was that \n6 \nsomething that you were able to do and wanted to do? \n7 \nA \nYes, and yes, and you know, I -- when I started, I \n8 \nmade it a point of walking every floor and meeting everyone, \n9 \nand in -- toward the end of the day, I would also if I could \n10 \nmake it a point -- particularly of major crimes of just \n11 \nwalking down to the floor and seeing who was there and what \n12 \nthey were doing and -- and sort of popping my head in and \n13 \njust saying hi because I think it's the right thing to do. \n14 \nQ \nOkay. Okay. Was that a way to support the troops, \n15 \nor was it more a way for you to find -- to become informed \n16 \nabout what was going on? \n17 \nA \nProbably a little of both, of support the troops, \n18 \nbut also get the temperature for the office, see how matters \n19 \nare progressing. \n20 \nQ \nYou at the criminal -- or, rather, the civil rights \n21 \ndivision, had experience with human trafficking and child sex \n22 \ntrafficking cases --\n23 \nA \nCorrect. \n24 \nQ \n-- under your supervision. We understand that you \n25 \nbrought that concern, or your concern about those issues with \nEFTA00009250\n", "char_count": 1342}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Page 23 \n1 \nyou to the U.S. Attorney's Office, and that -- we know that \n2 \nunder your tenure, the U.S. Attorney's Office had many \n3 \nsuccessful prosecutions involving conduct ranging from \n4 \ninternet child pornography --\n5 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n6 \nQ \n-- to international sex tourism --\n7 \nA \nCorrect. \n8 \nQ \n-- victimizing children in particular. In mid-\n9 \n2007, you -- according to press reports, you set up a new \n10 \nspecial prosecutions unit --\n11 \nA \nCorrect. \n12 \nQ \n-- to focus on, among other things, sex crimes \n13 \nagainst children. Could you tell us what importance those \n14 \nkinds of cases held for you as U.S. Attorney? \n15 \nA \nSure. If I could -- if I could just back up a \n16 \nlittle bit, because the -- the question goes -- the special \n17 \nprosecutions unit, and let me address that part of it. There \n18 \nare a few things embedded in that. \n19 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n20 \nA \nThere's -- there's -- the special prosecutions unit \n21 \nwas set up because there were some issues that -- that I \n22 \nthought were important to pursue in particular, and one of \n23 \nthose was -- was sort of the trafficking issues. Another one \n24 \nwas the gun violence, and the intent of special prosecutions \n25 \nwas to have a group of individuals that would sort of be \nEFTA00009251\n", "char_count": 1264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Page 24 \n1 \ndedicated and not part of the usual major crimes group. So, \n2 \nit wasn't exclusively -- I -- your question may have implied \n3 \nit was exclusively for sex crimes, and it --\n4 \nQ \nOh, no. \n5 \nA \n-- and it wasn't -- yeah. \n6 \nQ \nNo, I understand it was not. \n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \nQ \nOkay. \n9 \nA \nAnd so, I thought it was sufficiently important, \n10 \nand so, it was one of the -- one of the initiatives that we \n11 \nwere certainly pursuing. \n12 \nQ \nAnd was that something that you can -- that -- to \n13 \nwhich you brought your experience as head of the civil rights \n14 \ndivision as well? \n15 \nA \nIt was. I think -- not I think I know when I was \n16 \nhead of civil rights that that's something that I'd put \n17 \nparticular emphasis on, and I thought civil rights really \n18 \nstepped up and did a great job on that. \n19 \nQ \nDid you yourself ever -- I recognize you were never \n20 \na prosecutor as such. \n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \nBut did you ever have experience being involved in \n23 \na prosecution that -- sort of the nitty-gritty of the \n24 \nprosecution of that kind of case? Sort of seconding yourself \n25 \nto a trial team, for example, or an investigation? \nEFTA00009252\n", "char_count": 1177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Page 25 \n1 \nA \nSo, if by nitty-gritty you mean seconding myself to \n2 \na trial team the answer would be no. \n3 \nQ \nAll right. \n4 \nA \nThere are a number of cases that I recall being \n5 \nbriefed on and talking about, but --\n6 \n7 \nA \n8 \n9 \nprogram, \n10 \nA \n11 \n12 \nappointed \n13 \nA \nCorrect. \n14 \nQ \n-- coordinator, and she was also of course the line \n15 \nattorney on the Epstein case. How well did you know \n16 \n, and can you -- can you give us your assessment of \n17 \nher capabilities, judgement, and her interaction with you? \n18 \nA \nSo, a few things in there. How well did I know her \n19 \nprior to appointment? I don't recall. I'm not -- I don't \n20 \nthink I knew her particularly well prior to appointment. She \n21 \nwas clearly respected within the office, and / don't recall \n22 \nbut I can speculate that she was appointed based on \n23 \nrecommendations of management, and her interest and some \n24 \ncombination -- and prior work and some combination thereof. \n25 \nYou asked me to characterize \n--\nBut at that high level? \nCorrect. \nAll right. The department set up in 2006 a PSC \na Project Safe Childhood program --\nCorrect. \n-- focused on internet child pornography, and you \nas your first PSC --\nEFTA00009253\n", "char_count": 1215}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Page 26 \n1 \nQ \nHer -- your view of \n2 \nA \nRight. \n3 \nQ \n-- her capabilities, her judgement \n4 \nA \nRight. \n5 \nQ \nher acumen, her knowledge of the law. \n6 \nA \nI think she was a good, strong, professional AUSA. \n7 \nI mean --\n8 \nQ \nDo you have any -- did you have any negative -- you \n9 \nknow, anything less than fully positive in your assessment of \n10 \nher? \n11 \nA \nNo. \n12 \nQ \nOkay. \n13 \nA \nI think she was a good, strong, dedicated AUSA. \n14 \nQ \nAll right. \n15 \nA \nYeah. \n16 \nQ \n-- was the managing AUSA at the West Palm Beach \n17 \noffice. \n18 \nA \nCorrect. \n19 \nQ \nAt least -- and would -- and \nworked \n20 \nthere. How closely did you work with \nand again, \n21 \nthat --\n22 \nA \n24m-hmm. \n23 \n02 \n-- assessment question --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- what was your assessment of him? \nEFTA00009254\n", "char_count": 792}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Page 27 \n1 \nA \nSo, less so, only because of geographic distance. \n2 \nQ \nMt-hmm. \n3 \nA \nI would also say he was a respected professional. \n4 \nHe had a good reputation. He went on to be chief of staff \n5 \nhere at the -- at the criminal division, which I think speaks \n6 \nto how he was viewed within the department. \n7 \nQ \nmin-hmm. \n8 \nA \nAnd so, I would say positive. \n9 \nQ \nOkay. So, now turning to the Epstein case. \n10 \nA \nYeah. \n11 \nQ \nNow that your recall has been refreshed by virtue \n12 \nof the documents we've provided, before we get into the \n13 \nactual sort of documents and some of the details of the \n14 \nevents, would you please give us a general overview of what \n15 \nyou currently remember, refreshed, about how the case came \n16 \ninto the U.S. Attorney's Office, how it was assessed for \n17 \nprosecution, and how and why the decision was made to resolve \n18 \nit with a two-year state plea that ultimately became an 18 --\n19 \nA \nOkay. \n20 \nQ \n-- I mean, yeah, a two year state plea that \n21 \nultimate became --\n22 \nA \nAll right. \n23 \nQ \n-- an 18 month state plea. \n24 \nA \nOkay, so --\n25 \nMR. HERRON: Before you answer the question, let me \nEFTA00009255\n", "char_count": 1166}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Page 28 \n1 \njust jump in on the notion of refresh your recollection, \n2 \nwhich is -- of course has a very specific legal meaning, and \n3 \nI think to assert that Mr. Acosta's recollection has been \n4 \nrefreshed generally probably overstates it. It's really a \n5 \ndocument by document, issue by issue thing. So, I'd push \n6 \nback on that --\n7 \nMS. \n: I --\n8 \nMR. HERRON: -- a little bit, but the question is \n9 \nfair and accurate. \n10 \nMS. \n: If you're talking about handing him \n11 \na document to refresh an exhausted recollection, that's not \n12 \nthe process we're talking about. We're using it in a more \n13 \nlay term that, you know, if we asked you this before, giving \n14 \nyou all these documents, you'd probably would have not been \n15 \nable to be as full in your responses. So, we're asking for \n16 \nyour full response. Thank you. \n17 \nMR. HERRON: We appreciate the opportunity to \n18 \nreview the documents, and Alex, in your answers, try to \n19 \ndistinguish what you actually recall --\n20 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. \n21 \nMR. HERRON: -- in your own head versus what you \n22 \nsaw in the documents. \n23 \nMS. \n: Yeah. \n24 \nMR. HERRON: And that would make for --\n25 \nMS. \n. Thank you. \nEFTA00009256\n", "char_count": 1193}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Page 29 \nMR. HERRON: -- the cleanest record. \n2 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. So, three parts. How did it \n3 \ncome into the office? How did -- I'm sorry --\n4 \nBY MS. \n5 \nQ \nHow was -- how did it come in? \n6 \nA \nRight. \nQ \nHow was it assessed for prosecution --\n8 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- and then how and -- how and why the decision was \nmade --\nA \n• \n-- to resolve it the way it was. \n13 \nA \nSo, so, let's begin with how did it come into the \n14 \noffice. Putting all the documents aside, I can't say with \n5 \ncertainty how it came in. I can speculate how it came in, \n16 \nand the way it would have come into the office is \ncan \n17 \nspeculate that the chief -- the chief rider from Palm Beach \n18 \nCounty would have brought it to either the FBI or to the Palm \n19 \nBeach Office. I'm not certain that I would have asked who \n20 \nbrought this case to the office as opposed to the case is now \n21 \nin the office, so let's --\n22 \nQ \nRight. \n23 \nA \n-- let's discuss it, right? The format, or the \n24 \nmode in which it came in I think is important, because my \n25 \nrecollection is it arrived to us in the position that the \nEFTA00009257\n", "char_count": 1114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Page 30 \n1 \nstate attorney had negotiated a plea, and that the reason \n2 \nthat we looked at it was that that plea was going to be --\n3 \nthat there had been an initial charge that wasn't pursued, \n4 \nand that required jail time and registration, and that the \nS \nplea that was going to be taken was a charge that didn't \n6 \nrequire jail time, and didn't require registration, and based \n7 \non the preliminary assessment of the facts, that seemed --\n8 \nthat seems wrong. So, that's how did it arrive. The next \n9 \nquestion was --\n10 \nQ \nHow was it assessed for federal prosecution? \n11 \nA \nSo -- so, it was assessed for federal prosecution, \n12 \nmy recollection, from -- from very early on, and I'm sure \n13 \nwe'll talk about this some more, is you have a case that, \n14 \nwhile technically it wasn't final at the state level, but for \n15 \nfederal involvement, would have been final, and -- and so \n16 \nfrom the earliest point, we were thinking federal versus \n17 \nstate and petite, and the contemporaneous record sort of \n18 \nshows \nat least the material that I got, the earliest \n19 \ncommunication was Mr. \ntelling me that \nis \n20 \npreparing a petite policy waiver -- that Ms. \nis \n21 \npreparing a petite policy waiver, and that's consistent with \n22 \nmy recollection of how it was assessed, and -- and then \n23 \nbrought in -- assessed, you know, does it make sense to go \n24 \nforward, yes, investigate, and circle back. And then -- and \n25 \nthen the third part was the --\nEFTA00009258\n", "char_count": 1485}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Page 31 \n1 \n2 \nQ \nHow and why the disposition. \nA \nSo, my general recollection is the view was that if \n3 \nthe state had followed through on an original charge -- I \n4 \ndon't recall which -- that called for jail time and that \n5 \ncalled for registration, that the local police or whoever \n6 \nbrought it would not have seen the need to refer it. \n7 \nAnd so, that was in terms of pre-indictment \n8 \nresolution, a -- a logical and reasonable place given all the \n9 \nother sort of factors, both the petite concerns, the witness \n10 \nconcerns, and the legal concerns. \n11 \nAnd to that, I would add a fourth concern, which is \n12 \nit had already been reviewed by a grand jury at the state \n13 \nlevel, is my recollection. And so, to some extent, that's \n14 \nindicative of how some individuals may sort of view this \n15 \nmatter. \n16 \nQ \nOkay. We're going to pick that apart. \n17 \nA \nI figured. \n18 \nQ \nBut thank you for that. \n19 \nA \nYou -- you asked for an overview, so I tried to \n20 \njust be very --\n21 \nQ \nYeah. \n22 \nA \n-- general. \n23 \nQ \nThat doesn't -- that doesn't -- the second part of \n24 \nthat last prong was -- was why a two year state plea. In \n25 \nother words, you talked about -- you talked about assessing \nEFTA00009259\n", "char_count": 1228}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "PaGe \nthe case and why resolve it, but why with a two year state \n2 \nplea? What's the --\n3 \n5 \nA \nAnd so --\n4 \n-- overview? \nA \nAnd so my general recollection is -- my \n6 \nunderstanding -- if I was asked, what is the best \n7 \nunderstanding that I have of why two years, is that is what \n8 \nwould have been obtained in one of the original state \n9 \ncharges. Again, this is --\n10 \nQ \nHow do you know that? \nA \n12 \nQ \nHow did you know that? \n13 \nA \nI'm -- that's why I say general recollection. I'm \n14 \nreconstructing memories of that 12 years ago. I can \n15 \nspeculate that at some point, the matter came up, and I or \n16 \nsomeone else said if, you know, what would the original --\n17 \nwhat would the original plea have -- you know, what would the \n18 \noriginal charges have likely brought? And someone said this \n19 \namount. \n20 \nQ \nHow would have said that? \n21 \nA \nI -- I'm speculating at this point. I don't have a \n22 \nrecollection, but -- but that's -- that's my general \n23 \nunderstanding. \n24 \nQ \nAll right. All right. We'll now unpack --\n25 \nA \nYeah, I --\nEFTA00009260\n", "char_count": 1077}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Page 33 \n1 \n2 \n3 \nQ \n-- some of that. \nA \n-- I noticed. \nQ \nAnd by the way, my colleagues, we're all in this \n4 \nboat together. So, they're going to feel free to --\n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \nA \nI know. \nQ \n-- chime in --\nA \nYeah. \nQ \nas they see fit. So, the first thing going --\n9 \ngoing to the intake of the case, we know from the records \n10 \nthat -- and by the way, we've obviously done a great deal of \n11 \nother investigation --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- and spoken to many people. So, \n14 \nbriefed you and \npretty much when the case first \n15 \ncame in --\n16 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n17 \nQ \n-- in mid-2006, after the FBI and indeed the \n18 \noffice -- the U.S. Attorney's Office in West Palm had opened \n19 \nthe case, but before Epstein was indicted. So, this first \n20 \nexhibit, Exhibit No. 1 that you have in your binder before \n21 \nyou -- or, in your folder before you -- is that e-mail from \n22 \nto you that you just referred to dated July 24 --\n23 \nA \nRight. \n24 \nQ \n-- 2006, in which he's sort of passing on the \n25 \ninformation that Epstein has by now been arrested -- been \nEFTA00009261\n", "char_count": 1073}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Page 34 \n1 \nindicted -- arrested and indicted by the state. Do you \n2 \nrecall anything about that original briefing from \n3 \n4 \nA \nI -- I don't. \n5 \nQ \nAll right. Did you know at the time that -- at the \n6 \ntime she briefed you --\n7 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n8 \nQ \n-- which is prior to Exhibit 1, did you know who \n9 \nEpstein was? \n10 \nA \nI did not. \n11 \nQ \nNever heard of him, to your knowledge? \n12 \nA \nTo my knowledge, I don't recall having heard of \n13 \nhim. \n14 \nQ \nAnd what did you understand at that early point the \n15 \ncase to be about? \n16 \nA \nSo, I don't recall the briefing, and so I can't \n17 \ngive an independent recollection. You know, based on this, I \n18 \nmean, the --\n19 \nQ \nYou're talking about Exhibit 1, and you're --\n20 \nA \nBased on --\n21 \nQ \n-- looking at --\n22 \nA \n-- based on Exhibit 1, you know, I can -- I can \n23 \ninfer that this would have been my general understanding of \n24 \nthe case, and you know, and the key things that I point here \n25 \nis pre-trial diversion, which is code for no jail time, and \nEFTA00009262\n", "char_count": 1034}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Page 35 \n1 \npetite policy. \n2 \nQ \nBut this -- what -- Exhibit No. 1 --\n3 \nA \nRight. \n4 \nQ \n-- does not make it clear to you that this case \n5 \ninvolved allegations that Jeffrey Epstein had been enticing, \n6 \ncoercing, whatever verb you want to use, young, underage \n7 \nfemales -- we will for the record call them girls here --\n8 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n9 \nQ \n-- as opposed to women, and these underage females \n10 \nwere being paid to provide him essentially with sex, or \n11 \nsexual activity or conduct, of a pretty salacious nature. Do \n12 \nyou recall that as being essentially what you were briefed on \n13 \nfrom the beginning? \n14 \nA \nAgain, I don't recall the initial briefing. I take \n15 \nit based on your review that there was an initial briefing. \n16 \nI can't say the degree of detail. I can't say what it was \n17 \nabout. As a -- as a typical matter, I wouldn't be briefed \n18 \nwhen a case comes into the office other than being made \n19 \naware, this is a case, this is what we're looking at. \n20 \nQ \nSo, then, if you --\n21 \nA \nSure. \n22 \nQ \n-- understanding you don't remember the briefing, \n23 \nis it fair to say that you did have some understanding of \n24 \nwhat the case that was that West Palm Beach was pursuing as \n25 \nof mid-2006? \nEFTA00009263\n", "char_count": 1247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Page 36 \n1 \nA \nI certainly had an understanding of the general \n2 \nfacts of the case early on. I can't speak to whether it was \n3 \nmid-2006 versus late 2006 versus 2007, but --\n4 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n5 \nA \n-- early on, I certainly had an understanding that \n6 \nit was a case that involved, you know, a billionaire who was \n7 \ndoing sordid things with young women or girls who were \n8 \nminors. \n9 \nand the records indicate that her \n10 \nconcern in bringing this all the way to you --\n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \nA \nKm-hmm. \nQ \n-- and her first at that time criminal chief --\nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- but sort of acting First Assistant \nwas because she was afraid of political pressure that \nmight be brought to bear against the U.S. Attorney's Office \n17 \nin this case. Do you have any recollection of that being a \n18 \nconcern that was laid before you? \n19 \nA \nI don't -- again, I don't recall the early -- that \n20 \nbriefing. I've reviewed this e-mail, and -- and I can -- you \n21 \nknow, I take it \nit would have been natural for me to say, \n22 \nshould we approach the state attorney, because we had lots of \n23 \nongoing matters with the state attorney, and it seems that \n24 \nsaid no for fear it'll be leaked straight to Epstein, \n25 \nand I assumed I'd let it be at that point. \nEFTA00009264\n", "char_count": 1274}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Page 37 \n1 \nQ \nAnd do you know -- oh, do you know what he meant by \n2 \nit being leaked to Epstein by the state -- by Barry -- Barry \n3 \nKrischer, the then State Attorney? \n4 \nA \nSo -- so, based on the context --\n5 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n6 \nA \n-- what I would assume is that if the state \n7 \nattorney is cutting this kind of deal, and it appears that \n8 \nthings have already leaked, because you know, there's clearly \n9 \nand article here with leaked -- you know, so, something has \n10 \nalready leaked. \n11 \nQ \nYou're referring to Exhibit 1? \n12 \nA \nExhibit 1. Other things would leak. \n13 \nQ \nHad you ever met Barry Krischer? \n14 \nA \nSure. \n15 \nQ \nWhat was your relationship with him? \n16 \nA \nSo, there were multiple state attorneys within the \n17 \ndistrict. He was -- it was a professional relationship. We, \n18 \nyou know --\n19 \nQ \nIt was an elected position, correct? \n20 \nA \nIt was an elected position. \n21 \nQ \nAnd what was your assessment of his aggressiveness \n22 \nas a prosecutor, and his capabilities? \n23 \nA \nOn the public -- my -- most of my assessment with \n24 \nhim was on the public corruption front, where we had brought \n25 \nseveral cases, and I was a little disappointed that these \nEFTA00009265\n", "char_count": 1199}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Page 38 \n1 \nwere cases he could have brought that he chose not to bring. \n2 \nQ \nRight. So, is it -- can I -- am I accurate in \n3 \ninferring from that that you didn't regard him as a \n4 \nparticularly hard charging prosecutor? \n5 \nA \nSo, I -- with any state attorney, I hesitate to \n6 \nsort of paint broad brush strokes. I don't think that's \n7 \nalways fair, but my experience had been in the public \n8 \ncorruption space. \n9 \nQ \nYeah. \n10 \nA \nAnd in that space, I did not think -- whether it \n11 \nwas him, or whether it was his office, I can't speak, but I \n12 \ndid not think they had done as much as they could have done. \n13 \nQ \nIs there any area in which you thought he and his \n14 \noffice did pursue aggressively? \n15 \nA \nSo, as I recall, we had had -- we had emphasized \n16 \ngun crimes quite a bit, and really had had a lot of success \n17 \nmoving -- moving the ball in the gun crimes space in Palm \n18 \nBeach. \n19 \nQ \nWhat --\n20 \nA \nBut let me -- let me just say, it's also very \n21 \ndifficult to reconstruct time frames. \n22 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n23 \nA \nAnd so, I hesitate, because I don't know if that \n24 \nwas 2006 or 2007, or -- but you asked in another area, and --\n25 \nQ \nIn this Exhibit 1, you ask whether it's \nEFTA00009266\n", "char_count": 1226}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Page 39 \n1 \nappropriate -- appropriate to approach Barry Krischer and \n2 \ngive him a heads up as to where the U.S. Attorney's Office \n3 \nmight go, presumably --\n4 \nA \nRight. \n5 \nQ \n-- with this case? \n6 \nA \nCorrect. \n7 \nQ \nWhy would you want to extend that difference to \n8 \nhim? Why would it matter? \n9 \nA \nA colleague in law enforcement. I thought it was \n10 \nimportant for the office to work with -- with state attorneys \n11 \nas a general matter, and I found that the office worked best \n12 \nwhen it had good working relationships with state attorneys \n13 \nand with -- you know, with -- for that matter, the agency \n14 \nSACs and others, and --\n15 \nQ \nRight. \n16 \nA \n-- but again, you know, rather than my asserting, \n17 \nI'm asking \n, and \nwas saying no, and I don't know \n18 \nwhat the ultimate outcome was, but I would guess that we'd \n19 \njust defer and let it be. \n20 \nQ \nTurning to Exhibit 2, this is an e-mail that was \n21 \nforwarded to you by \n22 \nmail is from \n, the original forwarded e-\ncopying \n, and it \n23 \nessentially relates to a dust up between \nand \n24 \nover chain of command, and her workload, but \n25 \nin the first paragraph, she specifies that, \"When I first \nEFTA00009267\n", "char_count": 1195}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Page 40 \n1 \nheard about the Epstein investigation, I spoke with \n2 \nabout it. \nwas not here.\" \n3 \nsaid that she would back me up on the case, \n4 \nbut I knew what has happened to the state prosecution can \n5 \nhappen to the federal prosecution if the U.S. Attorney's \n6 \nOffice isn't on board. So, I spoke with \nabout the case, \n7 \nand he spoke with Alex, and they gave the green light.\" \n8 \nSo, that -- that actually appears to be an initial \n9 \ncontact with \nthat she's talking about prior to the \n10 \nbriefing of you, so, way early when the case first came in in \n11 \nMay of 2006. Do you recall being contacted or having a \n12 \nconversation with --\n13 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n14 \n- \n- \nabout that case so early? \n15 \nA \nAgain, the early recollection, whenever -- whenever \n16 \nit might have taken place, was I was made aware of the \n17 \nmatter. It seemed a reasonable matter to pursue, and that's \n18 \nthe level of detail that I recall. \n19 \nQ \nSo, if \nsaid back in the day that she got from \n20 \nyou all the green light, what did you understand her to be \n21 \nbeing authorized to do -- authorize may be too strong a word, \n22 \nbut --\n23 \nA \nSo, to pursue -- to investigate -- to pursue --\n24 \nQ \nYeah. \n25 \nA \n-- to someone, you know, I -- I'm speculating here, \nEFTA00009268\n", "char_count": 1267}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Page 41 \n1 \nbut there's a case, and they want to know, should we spend \n2 \nour time on this? And the answer is it seems reasonable. \n3 \nSure. \n4 \nQ \nOkay, and do you -- do you recall making that \n5 \nexplicit to her? \n6 \nA \nI -- I don't, and -- and it wouldn't have been my \n7 \npractice to -- to sort of make it explicit to -- yeah, go \n8 \nspend your time, as opposed to, thank you for letting me \n9 \nknow, that sounds reasonable. \n10 \nQ \nAll right. \n11 \nA \nAnd whatever, you know, details it looks like based \n12 \non Exhibit 1, there was subsequent follow up between her and \n13 \n, or with her and the management team, and they said, you \n14 \nknow, go back, work on A, B, and C. \n15 \nQ \nDo you know what \nwas talking about \n16 \nwhen she referred to something happening to a federal \n17 \nprosecution if the U.S. Attorney is not on board? Had there \n18 \nbeen a case in which you were not supportive of a particular \n19 \nprosecution that was being proposed? \n20 \nA \nNone -- none that I recall, and -- and I knew that \n21 \nwhat has happened to the state prosecution can happen to a \n22 \nfederal prosecution if the U.S. Attorney's not on board. I \n23 \ndon't recall any federal prosecution that I wasn't supportive \n24 \nof, at least in -- in this context. \n25 \nQ \nWhat do you mean by this context? \n ,1\n1•111•1 \nEFTA00009269\n", "char_count": 1319}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Page 42 \n1 \nA \nIt was my way of narrowing an answer so I didn't \n2 \nspend the time to go through every office and every division. \n3 \nFor the most part, as I sit here, I'm sort of running through \n4 \neach office. I don't recall any, and -- and if I could, \n5 \nbased on this -- on Exhibit 2, I'm not sure that she's \n6 \nreferring to a specific case as opposed to concerns that the \n7 \nstate prosecution started at point -- you know, with charges \n8 \nthat required jail time and ended up somewhere else, and it \n9 \nmay have been because management --\n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \nQ \nAll right. \nA \n-- wasn't. \nQ \nBut that's -- that's a current -- a reading of --\nA \nYeah. \nQ \n-- this, rather --\nA \nThat -- that's my --\nQ \n-- than a recollection? \nA \n-- that's my reading, not --\nQ \nAll right. Based on the early description you got \n19 \nof the case --\n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- did you have any idea how many victims were \n22 \ninvolved? \n23 \nA \nI did not. \n24 \nQ \nDid you know what the name of the case was? What \n25 \nthe investigation's name was? You know, cases get names. \nEFTA00009270\n", "char_count": 1093}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Page 43 \n1 \nA \nSo, I know that based on review of the \n2 \ncorrespondence, I may have known that then. I did not \n3 \nindependently recall that. \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \nQ \nThat being Operation Leap Year? \nA \nCorrect. \nQ \nAll right, and do you know where that comes from? \nA \nI have -- well, I mean, other than February 20 --\n8 \nyeah, I don't know. \n9 \nQ \nWell, the original allegations that came in \n10 \ninvolved 28 victims, and then subsequently \n11 \nshe was uncovering more victims, so there were --\n12 \nA \nYeah. \nadvised that \n13 \nQ \n-- over 30 victims. \n14 \nA \n15 \nQ \nWell over 30. \n16 \nA \nI did not know that. \n17 \nQ \nAll right. You did not -- you -- as you sit here \n18 \ntoday, you didn't know it? \n19 \nA \nI don't recall knowing that. \n20 \nQ \nBut is it -- is it reasonable that the number of \n21 \nvictims would be one of the factors that you would have been \n22 \ninformed of at the time? \n23 \nA \nI -- I don't know. I -- it all depends how \n24 \ndetailed that briefing was. Again, as a typical matter early \n25 \non, this is what is being done. I would trust my AUSAs and \nEFTA00009271\n", "char_count": 1076}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Page 44 \n1 \nmy management staff --\n2 \nQ \nRight. \n3 \nA \n-- to pursue it. It wouldn't be a, here are all \n4 \nthe facts associated with this case, just heads up. There is \n5 \na high profile case involving a very wealthy man abusing \n6 \nyoung women, a state attorney is prosecuting, but you know, \n7 \nthere's dissatisfaction. I wanted to give you a heads up, \n8 \nboth to inform me, but also so that I'm aware in my \n9 \ninteractions with -- with other Palm Beach officials. \n10 \nQ \nOkay. Based on whatever information you got at the \n11 \ntime, did you think that there was a federal interest to be \n12 \nserved by pursuing a federal prosecution potentially? \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \nglossary convention --\n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \n-- that we are using is -- and we can use in this \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd what was that? \nA \nSo, the exploitation of young women. \nQ \nGirls. \nA \nGirls. \nQ \nI want to be -- I want to be --\nA \nMinors. Minor females. \nQ \nAll right. I -- you know, for a -- for a sort of a \n24 \ninterview, is girls --\n25 \nA \nRight. \nEFTA00009272\n", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Page 45 \n1 \nQ \n-- for the victims who at the time of the conduct \n2 \nwere minors, and women, for those who were not, even though \n3 \nthe girls at a later time became age of --\n4 \nA \nFair. \n5 \nQ \n-- majority. \n6 \nA \nFair. \n7 \nQ \nOkay. So, here, we're really talking about the \n8 \ngirls --\n9 \nA \nOkay. \n10 \nQ \n-- who were victims. \n11 \nA \nYeah, yeah. \n12 \nQ \nOkay. \n13 \nA \nGirls, minor females. I just don't \nsometimes \n14 \nthat term is viewed differently. And so --\n15 \nQ \nRight. \n16 \nA \nYeah, so the exploitation of girls or minor \n17 \nfemales, and that certainly is an important federal interest. \n18 \nQ \nWell, and is the number and the breadth of the \n19 \nscheme -- the scope of the activity also a factor there? In \n20 \nother words, it wasn't one or two on one or two occasions. \n21 \nA \nSo, there's several factors that probably go into \n22 \nwhat's the federal interest. The acts, the sordidness of the \n23 \nacts, the -- the number, the likelihood or the importance of \n24 \nregistration was important to my mind because that -- that \n25 \ngoes to future prevention to putting the community on notice. \nEFTA00009273\n", "char_count": 1117}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Page 46 \n1 \nQ \nAnd were you aware that the individual in this \n2 \ncase, Epstein, also had homes in other districts, and that \n3 \nthere were -- it was an interstate activity on his part, the \n4 \ninterstate travel and so on? \n5 \nA \n6 \nMR. HERRON: I'm sorry, let me just -- we're still \n7 \nin the original intake time frame --\n8 \nMS. \n: Yes. \n9 \nMR. HERRON: -- here? \n10 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. Again, for the intake time, I \n11 \ncan't \nI can't speak to the details, because I don't \n12 \nremember what the extent of that -- that intake briefing. \n13 \nBY MS. \n14 \nQ \nBut as i -- as I -- as i --\n15 \nA \nCould I -- could I ask --\n16 \nQ \nYes. \n17 \nA \n-- a question? Was there -- was there a clear \n18 \nbriefing as opposed to a heads up based on the record? \n19 \nQ \nYes. That \ncame to Miami to conduct \n20 \na briefing of you and --\n21 \nA \nOkay. \n22 \nQ \nin order to tell you about this \n23 \ncase, and get from you \n24 \nA \nOkay. \n25 \nQ \n-- a green light --\nEFTA00009274\n", "char_count": 956}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Page 47 \n1 \nA \n2 \n3 \nQ \n-- to proceed with it. \nA \nI ask, because I recall an e-mail, and I don't know \n4 \nwhat the time would have been, where she's coming to Miami, \n5 \nand \nsays, why don't you stop by my office first? \n6 \nQ \nRight. \n7 \nA \nAnd -- and -- and I keep -- I would -- I would \n8 \nspeculate that, why don't you stop by my office first is, why \n9 \ndon't you give me a bunch of details, and then we will walk \n10 \nacross to the U.S. Attorney --\n11 \nQ \nRight. \n12 \nA \n-- and fill him in, and so that would have been \n13 \nalmost a two-tiered discussion. \n14 \nQ \nAnd is that --\n15 \nA \nAnd I don't know if that -- if that -- the timeline \n16 \non that e-mail is when you say briefing. \n17 \nQ \nWell, we are -- we are asking --\n18 \nA \n19 \nQ \nWhat it -- what it would --\n20 \nA \nYeah. \n21 \n22 \nA \nI'm speaking just based on review of the record, \n23 \nnot based on recollection here. \n24 \nQ \nAll right. So, you have -- to be clear, you have \n25 \nno recollection of any specific briefing in 2006? \nEFTA00009275\n", "char_count": 1010}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \nPage 48 \nA \nI accept that I was made aware of the matter. \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nI can't say how or in what context or to what \n4 \ndegree of detail. \n5 \n6 \nQ \nOr by whom? \nA \nOr by whom. I knew the matter -- it's easier to \n7 \nrecollect at least for me what I knew as opposed to who told \n8 \nme what. \n9 \nQ \nAll right. All right. At this point, would you \n10 \nhave had -- did you have -- if you -- at any point, did you \n11 \nhave any reservation about investigating and potentially \n12 \nprosecuting Jeffrey Epstein, a reservation stemming from his \n13 \nwealth, and reported standing in the community at all, and \n14 \ninfluence? \n15 \nA \nNo, and we had prosecuted lots of influential folks \n16 \nin the office. So, while he had wealth, it's not unusual --\n17 \nUBS was in the office at the time. I mentioned several high \n18 \nprofile Palm Beach public corruption cases. \n19 \nQ \nSo, there was no concern about possible negative \n20 \nblowback in the press or the community or even at Main \n21 \nJustice if you went after someone like Jeffrey Epstein? \n22 \nA \nThere was no concern stemming from his wealth or \n23 \nhis status. \n24 \nQ \nWhat would it have stemmed from? \n25 \nA \nAt some point, I think there was concerns regarding \nEFTA00009276\n", "char_count": 1233}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Page 49 \n1 \nthe -- the law, and we'll probably get into that. I alluded \n2 \nto that earlier in the overview. I don't know if that would \n3 \nhave been developed this early on, but -- but that's not a \n4 \nfunction of his wealth. That's a function of the fact \n5 \npattern. \n6 \nQ \nRight. Right. Okay. So, as you mentioned petite \n7 \npolicy concerns, petite policy, petite policy, could you tell \n8 \nus what your position was on the -- on the policy as it \n9 \napplied in this case as you understood it from -- in the \n10 \nbeginning? \n11 \nA \nSo -- so, the policy, you know, on its face, \n12 \ndoesn't specifically apply. Based on Exhibit 1, I'm now \n13 \ninferring, not recalling, it looks like either \non her \n14 \nown, or \nasked for a -- or, Mr. \n, asked for a \n15 \npetite policy waiver memo to be prepared, in part on the \n16 \nassumption that the state prosecution may or may not have \n17 \ngone for it. \n18 \nI don't know, but I know -- I do recall that early \n19 \non, this was unusual, because it had been -- he had been \n20 \narrested or arraigned. It was going forward on the part of \n21 \nthe state, and so here is the big bad federal government \n22 \nstepping on a sovereign, you know, state, saying you're not \n23 \ndoing enough, and to my mind, when, you know, the whole idea \n24 \nof the petite policy is to recognize that that estate has --\n25 \nyou know, is an independent entity, and that we should \nEFTA00009277\n", "char_count": 1411}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Page 50 \n1 \npresume that what they're doing is correct, even if we don't \n2 \nlike the outcome, except in the most unusual of \n3 \ncircumstances. \n4 \nQ \nAnd what kinds of -- well, so, the petite policy \n5 \nexists because there's a recognition that there are cases \n6 \nthat are appropriately pursued. I mean, you were the head of \n7 \nthe civil rights division, after all. \n8 \nA \nCorrect, which is why I say except in the most \n9 \nappropriate of circumstances. \n10 \nQ \nRight. \n11 \nA \nBut let me add that based on this, I was \n12 \ncomfortable, you know, saying, let's go forward, because the \n13 \nlack of jail time, you know, to use -- to use petite policy \n14 \nlanguage, a plea that did not include jail time or \n15 \nregistration would seem like a manifest injustice. \n16 \nQ \nAll right. So, did you have any doubt that you'd \n17 \nget a waiver if you applied for one? \n18 \nA \nI'm not -- so -- so, I'm now speculating. I don't \n19 \nrecall, but I'm not sure I would have said, is there a doubt \n20 \nthat I'd get a waiver as opposed to, is this something I feel \n21 \ncomfortable doing, or not? And --\n22 \nQ \nAnd this being the prosecution, or this being \n23 \nthe -- applying for a waiver? \n24 \nA \nApplying for a waiver. And so, you know, either \n25 \nmain justice gives it or doesn't give it. That doesn't mean \nEFTA00009278\n", "char_count": 1316}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Page 51 \n1 \nyou don't apply for it if you think it's the right thing to \n2 \ndo. \n3 \nSo, for example, in the UBS case, which was one of \n4 \nour big tax, you know, prosecutions, we asked for a Bank of \n5 \nNova Scotia --\n6 \nQ \nME-hum. \n7 \nA \n-- authorization to the Bank of Nova Scotia \n8 \nsubpoena, and I didn't think Main Justice would -- you know, \n9 \nI pushed really hard, and I got into the weeds in that case \nfor that purpose, but I still thought, let's go for it, and \nwe did, and Main Justice didn't give in to it, and that's \n12 \nokay. That's how it works. \n13 \nQ \nOkay. So, they denied that request? \n14 \nA \nThey denied that request, and I say that as an \n15 \nexample of -- as a typical matter, I don't think what's main \n16 \njustice going to say, as opposed to how do we \nhow should \n17 \nwe approach this matter? \n18 \nQ \nI don't understand about what you mean by, how \n19 \nshould we approach this matter. \n20 \nA \nSo, honestly, how do I -- how do I explain this? \n21 \nSo, I think there's a difference in saying, let me predict \n22 \nhow main justice will come out, and follow that prediction, \n23 \nversus, folks, what do you all think? Okay. If we're \n24 \ncomfortable with this, let's write it up, and let's see what \n25 \nMain Justice does. \nEFTA00009279\n", "char_count": 1262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Page 52 \n1 \nOne is trying to predict what folks in this \n2 \nbuilding are going to think. Another one is trying to \n3 \npredict -- another one is saying, what do we in Miami think, \n4 \nand then let main justice figure it out. \nQ \nAnd which is the approach you typically took? \n6 \nA \nAnd my point is the approach that I typically took \n7 \nis, what do we think, and let main justice give it a thumbs \n8 \nup or a thumbs down. \n9 \nQ \nAll right, and in this case, did you do that with \n10 \nregard to the petite policy? \n11 \nA \nSo, in this case, we didn't get that far in that we \n12 \ndidn't have to submit to DOJ. \n13 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n14 \nA \nBut -- but we were approaching it not based on what \n15 \nmain justice was going to think, but what do we feel is the \n16 \nright outcome in this office. \n17 \nQ \nSo, as I understand, the bottom line is that you \n18 \ndidn't \nas I hear you, I believe you're saying that you \n19 \ndidn't stand down, or in any way cease or limit pursuing this \n20 \ncase on petite policy grounds. You pursued it as you -- as \n21 \nyou would --\n22 \nA \nSo, we went forward with the matter, although there \n23 \nwere petite policy concerns in the background. So -- so \n24 \nyou're setting this up as a binary -- as a -- did -- was it a \n25 \nfact -- as a binary, you did not limit yourself on petite \nEFTA00009280\n", "char_count": 1314}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Page 53 \n1 \npolicy grounds, and I'm pushing back a little bit, because I \n2 \ndon't think it's, it's part or it's not, as opposed to when \n3 \nyou look at a case, there are all sorts of factors, and it is \n4 \na factor in how you think of a matter going forward. \nBY MS. \nQ \nIf you had those petite policy concerns -- you or \nmembers of your staff? \n8 \nA \nI would say a combination of me and my management \n9 \nstaff. \n11 \n3 \n14 \nBY MS. \nQ \nWho? Who? \nA \nI can't -- I can't recreate --\nQ \nBut who are you dealing with on this case? \nA \nPrimarily, it would be my first assistant and \n15 \ncriminal chief as I typically -- so, there is, you know, to \n16 \nsort of put it in main justice terms, you know, a line \n17 \nattorney has a deputy section chief and a section chief and a \n18 \nDAG and an AAG, and the AAG usually deals with the section \n19 \nchief, or the DAG. And so, I was dealing with my first \n20 \nassistant and my crim chief. \n21 \nQ \nRight, and they were there in Miami. \n22 \nA \nAnd they were there in Miami. \n23 \nQ \nAnd by the way, \nfirst line \n24 \nsupervisor was \n25 \nA \nrect. \nEFTA00009281\n", "char_count": 1095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Page 54 \n1 \nQ \nDo you know why she was not actively participating \n2 \nin this chain of command? \n3 \nA \nI noticed that in the correspondence, and I \n4 \ncouldn't speak to that. \n5 \nQ \nAll right. \n6 \nA \nBut the -- but it goes to the point that if you \nlook at the -- she reported to \n, who reported to \n8 \nwho reported to \nwho reported to \n. And so, as a \n9 \ntypical matter, I tried to empower my first assistant and my \n10 \ncriminal chief and my office heads and work through them, not \n11 \nbypass them. \n12 \nQ \nIn this particular case with regard either to the \n13 \npetite policy --\n14 \nA \nRight. \n15 \nQ \n-- or any other aspect, was there anyone other than \n16 \nthat group of five, if you will, in that chain --\n17 \nA \nCorrect. \n18 \nQ \n-- from you down to \nthrough \n19 \n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- and \nthat you were dealing with? \n22 \nA \nI can't recall. I -- I can -- I can say as a \n23 \ngeneral matter, it would not be unusual for me to walk \n24 \ndown -- walk down the hall and talk to someone that I trust \n25 \nand say, hey, I've got this fact pattern. What do you think? \nEFTA00009282\n", "char_count": 1085}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Page 55 \n1 \nQ \nDo you recall ever doing that in connection with \n2 \nthis case? \n3 \nA \nI -- I don't recall the specific briefings or who I \n4 \ntalked to. I'm just saying as a general matter that there \n5 \nare folks on my -- on the eighth floor that were in \n6 \nmanagement that I would often just walk down the hall, and --\n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \nQ \nBut do you recall doing that --\nA \nI don't --\nQ \n-- in this case? \nA \nI don't recall. \nQ \nOkay. So, we shared with you in Exhibit 3 a pretty \n12 \nlively exchange between \nand \n13 \nYou didn't -- we have no reason to believe you saw this \n14 \nbefore, but it makes some representations about you, and \n15 \nthat's why we brought it to your attention. \n16 \nA \nOkay. \n17 \nQ \nDo you recall this e-mail exchange? \n18 \nA \nI don't recall the e-mail exchange. \n19 \nQ \nI mean, you --\n20 \nA \nBut I --\n21 \nQ \n-- didn't see it then. Do you recall having read \n22 \nit before today? \n23 \nA \nI recall reviewing it, yes. \n24 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. So, starting from the end, \n25 \nusing \nBlackberry, which is a little \nEFTA00009283\n", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Page 56 \n1 \nconfusing to begin with -- notifies .= \nthat -- of a -- of \n2 \na particular conversation he had with one of the defense \n3 \nattorneys. At this point, what I want to do is draw your \n4 \nattention to the -- the comment, and his response, and we're \n5 \nlooking at page --\n6 \nA \nPage --\n7 \nQ \n-- three. \n8 \nA \n-- page three. \n9 \nQ \nSo, in the third paragraph --\n10 \nA \nYeah. \n11 \nQ \n-- \"it was made clear to you by the U.S. Attorney \n12 \nand the first assistant from the time when you were first \n13 \nauthorized to investigate Mr. Epstein that the office had \n14 \nconcerns about taking the case because of petite policy and a \n15 \nnumber of legal issues.\" And then later he says that, \"You \n16 \nwere never given authorization by anyone to seek an \n17 \nindictment in this case.\" \n18 \nAnd -- close quote -- and then on the first page, \n19 \npresents her version of that original contact \n20 \nwith you, meeting with you, at the bottom of the page. \n21 \nHalfway through the last paragraph, she says, \"My \n22 \nrecollection of the original meeting with Alex and \nis \n23 \nquite different than your summary. In that meeting, I \n24 \nsummarized the case and the state attorney's office handling \n25 \nof it.\" \nEFTA00009284\n", "char_count": 1219}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "1 \nPage 57 \nacknowledged that we needed to do work to \n2 \ncollect the evidence establishing a federal nexus, and I \n3 \nnoted the time and month,\" -- that -- I'm sorry, \"I noted the \n4 \ntime and money that would be required for an investigation. \n5 \nI said I was willing to invest time and the FBI was willing \n6 \nto invest the money, but I didn't want to get to the end of \n7 \nit,\" -- \"to the end, and then have the office be intimidated \n8 \nby the high powered lawyers. I was assured that would not \n9 \nhappen.\" Can you tell us which version of that initial --\n10 \nwhich version --\n11 \n12 \n13 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- is correct? \nA \nSo, again, I don't remember that initial briefing, \n14 \nso I can't tell you which version is correct. I would also \n15 \nsay that it's possible neither version is correct and that \n16 \nthere's a little bit of truth -- now I'm just speculating --\n17 \nQ \nAll right. \n18 \nA \nthat there's a little bit of truth in either \n19 \none, because it's certainly possible to say, I hear you, \n20 \nrighteous case, go forward and investigate, work on the \n21 \nfederal nexus, which is what Exhibit 3 is saying, go work on \n22 \nthe federal nexus and find evidence for the federal nexus. \n23 \nBut we have concerns about petite policy and legal matters, \n24 \nso there's a lot of work to be done. \n25 \nQ \nSo, what kind of a direction does that amount to \nEFTA00009285\n", "char_count": 1375}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Page 58 \n1 \nfor the line AUSA? What's her job then? \n2 \nA \nSo, the job would then be to go back and \n3 \ninvestigate, and develop facts and report back. \n4 \nQ \nAnd if she developed enough facts, and supportive \n5 \nlaw to present proposed prosecution? \n6 \n7 \n8 \nA \nRight. \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nAnd so -- so, a lot of times in this he said, she \n9 \nsaid, there's a little bit of truth to both sides of the \n10 \ndiscussion. I'm just -- I'm just saying as a general matter, \n11 \nI wouldn't -- your questions are sometimes either or, and \n12 \nsometimes --\n13 \nQ \nRight. \n14 \nA \n-- it can be a combination of both. \n15 \nQ \nAll right, and -- but in fact you don't recall? \n16 \nA \nBut I'm speculating. \n17 \nQ \nAll right. Is there anything in either of those \n18 \nthat two accounts -- two versions that you say didn't happen, \n19 \ncouldn't happen? \n20 \nA \nI can't, because I don't recall it. I can't --\n21 \nQ \nOkay. \n22 \nA \n-- speak to that. I would speculate that there's \n23 \nprobably a little bit of truth on both sides that -- and if \n24 \nyou read it closely, you'll see that \nacknowledges the \n25 \nneed to work on a federal nexus. So, that goes to, you know, \nEFTA00009286\n", "char_count": 1160}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Page 59 \n1 \nwhere \nor, Mr. la \nI'm sorry, I'm calling -- I'm \n2 \nusing first names. \n3 \nQ \nIts' all right. \n4 \nA \nSo, I'm going to just start --\n4 \nThis is an informal interview. \n6 \nA \nI'm going to just start using first names. I don't \n7 \nmean that disrespectfully -- where, you know, Illlisays, you \n8 \nknow, because of petite policy and legal issues, and \nis \n9 \nacknowledging the legal issues, because she's saying needed \n10 \nwork to do to collect evidence establishing the federal \n11 \nnexus. \n12 \nQ \nAll right. \n13 \nA \nSo --\n14 \nQ \nYeah. \n15 \nA \nSo, they're not as inconsistent as presented \n16 \nQ \nAll right. \n17 \nA \n-- arguably. \n18 \nQ \nSack in 2006, in this Exhibit No. 1, \n19 \ntells you in his e-mail that the indictment target date is \n20 \nAugust 25, 2006. \n21 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n22 \nQ \nIn other words, very shortly --\n23 \nA \nRight. \n24 \nQ \n-- thereafter, within a month or so. Do you know \n25 \nwhy the line AUSA, \n, was keen on getting the \nEFTA00009287\n", "char_count": 962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "federal case against Epstein brought on a fairly -- on a \n2 \nquick basis? \n3 \nA \nSo, I can't speak to that, and -- and can I \n4 \nI ask, based on your record, was that that the -- was that \n5 \nthe state indictment target date, or was that --\n6 \nQ \nHe already --\nA \n-- a federal --\nB \nQ \n-- Epstein had already been indicted and arraigned \non the --\n10 \nA \nRight. \n11 \nQ \n-- indictment, so that's the federal. \n12 \nA \nSo -- so, that's --\n1: \nQ \nThat's talking about a federal indictment. \n14 \nA \nAll right. \n15 \nQ \nThe point --\n16 \nA \nCorrect. \n17 \nQ \n-- is that early on --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- the investigative team, the FBI --\n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- and \nwere hot to trot to get \n22 \nthis --\n23 \nA \nRight. \n24 \nQ \n-- case moving from a federal standpoint. That may \n25 \nwell have been quite unrealistic given --\nEFTA00009288\n", "char_count": 833}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Page 61 \n1 \nA \nCorrect. \n2 \nQ \n-- all of the issues that we've been discussing, \n3 \nbut the question is, do you know why there was some urgency? \n4 \nA \nI haven't the slightest idea. When was it -- when \n5 \nwas it initially brought to the office? \n6 \nQ \nIt was brought to the office in May of --\n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \nQ \n-- 2006. \n9 \nA \nThat -- that would be a really, really fast \n10 \ntimeline. \n11 \nQ \nRight. So, the question is, aspirational though it \n12 \nmay have been, there was a hope --\n13 \nA \n14 \nQ \n-- to get it done quickly. \n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \nSo, the question is, can you think of factors that \n17 \nwould have led a prosecutor to want to pursue --\n18 \nA \nI --\n19 \nQ \n-- this quickly? \n20 \nA \nI don't recall. I can speculate that \nwas \n21 \nvery hard charging and wanted to do a lot, and --\n22 \nQ \nWas that your experience of her? \n23 \nA \nSo, based on this, I see, you know, so, Exhibit 2 \n24 \nis, you know \n25 \nQ \nExcuse me, would -- but just from your memory, is \nEFTA00009289\n", "char_count": 987}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Page 62 \n1 \nthat your recollection of hove \noperated? Hard charging? \n2 \nA \nYeah. I'd say -- so, a lot of really good \n3 \nprosecutors are hard charging. That's --\n4 \nQ \nAll right. \n5 \nA \n-- that's part of the job description. \n6 \nQ \nOkay. \n7 \nA \nAnd so, yes. \n8 \nQ \nOkay. Did -- so, in the child sex offender \n9 \ncontext, are you familiar with a -- the belief on the part of \n10 \npeople who do that kind of case, as did \nand \n11 \nothers in your office -- that those offenders typically don't \n12 \nstop offending, even after somebody's onto them? So that \n13 \nthere was a concern that he -- that in this case, Jeffrey \n14 \nEpstein might be continuing to offend, and therefore getting \n15 \nhim off the streets was --\n16 \nA \nRight. \n17 \nQ \n-- a priority? \n18 \nA \nI have heard that discussed recently in the media. \n19 \nI don't recollect that back in -- part of a discussion back \n20 \nin 2006. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. Do you recall that \n22 \n-- and this is just a, do you recall --\n23 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n24 \nQ \n-- that she periodically would give you in that \n25 \nearly period of 2006, updates -- written updates? \nEFTA00009290\n", "char_count": 1119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Page 63 \n1 \n2 \nA \nI don't. \nQ \nDid you think that it was appropriate for a line \n3 \nAUSA to be shooting e-mails updating on a case that was under \n4 \ninvestigation directly to you and your first assistant? \n5 \nA \nIt was unusual, and -- and so, so, did I think of \n6 \na -- look, I can't reconstruct what I would have thought, but \n7 \nyou know, you're asking not just what did I know, but what \n8 \nwould I have thought 12 years ago. \n9 \nBut I can say that based on general practice, it \n10 \nwould have been unusual, and my best guess as to how I would \n11 \nhave reacted would have been, hey, \n, this is unusual, is \n12 \nthe chain being fully informed? Are feathers being --\n13 \nQ \nRight. \n14 \nA \nruffled? Figure it out, because, you know, you \n15 \nasked me early on to characterize \nqualities. I think \n16 \none of the things that I said was he was very good at \n17 \nsmoothing things --\n18 \nQ \nMW-hmm. \n19 \nA \n-- over. And sort of the interaction, because he \n20 \nwas respected, and so I might say, that's kind of unusual. \n21 \nGo figure it out. \n22 \nQ \nBut you wouldn't necessarily jump that chain \n23 \nyourself, and be --\n24 \nA \n25 \nQ \n-- in direct communication? \nEFTA00009291\n", "char_count": 1177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Page 64 \n1 \nA \nI tended not to --\n2 \nQ \nOkay. \n3 \nA \n-- do that. \n4 \nBY \n5 \nQ \nWould she have sent this to you -- something \n6 \nunusual, if she thought that this was a case that you wanted \n7 \nto be involved in? \n8 \nA \nEven in -- even in those, I tried to be, as a \n9 \ngeneral matter, fairly sensitive to the chain, because I had \n10 \nfound that if you start jumping the chain too much, even if \n11 \nyou become informed, managers feel, you know, out of -- out \n12 \nof the loop, and that's not -- that's not conducive to sort \n13 \nof allowing them to do their job of supervising. It's a big \n14 \nenough office, you have to empower your folks to do their \n15 \njobs. \n16 \nQ \nSo the concern on your part would not be that she \n17 \nwas communicating directly to you, but that as long as all of \n18 \nthe chain was informed as well? \n19 \nA \nYeah. I mean, if you're -- if you're \n20 \nor you know, if you're \n, or you know, don't you want to \n21 \ntalk to the line attorney before the line attorney talks to \n22 \nyour boss? \n23 \nAnd so, it's not just informed, but it's respecting \n24 \nyour supervisor. And it's a difficult balance, because often \n25 \nreally good AUSAs are also the ones that, you know, just want \nEFTA00009292\n", "char_count": 1218}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Page 65 \n1 \nto get things done. \n2 \nBY MS. \n3 \nQ \nDid you have any reason to believe during this \n4 \ninvestigative phase that ME \nwas not pursuing \n5 \nthis case -- this investigation adequately, appropriately, \n6 \nand fully? \n7 \nA \nNo, I did not. \n8 \nQ \nDid you --\n9 \nA \nNot to my recollection. \n10 \nQ \nDid you feel that she did not have appropriate \n11 \noversight? \n12 \nA \nNot to my recollection. \n13 \nQ \nOkay. Do you -- did you feel that she had any \n14 \nresource problem? That is, did she have, as far as you knew, \n15 \nsufficient resources available to pursue her investigation? \n16 \nA \nTo my recollection, yes, I noted her early -- you \n17 \nknow, I noted more recently the e-mail where -- you know, \n18 \nthat was shared with me by \nabout resource concerns, and \n19 \nI would just note that I would allow the management chain to \n20 \nfigure that out. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. Were you -- did you at any point \n22 \nconsider, based on what you then knew, expanding the scope of \n23 \nthe investigation? Did you ever suggest or propose that \n24 \ninstead of simply looking at Epstein's conduct in West Palm \n25 \nBeach vis a vis these girls, that the federal authorities \nEFTA00009293\n", "char_count": 1176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Page 66 \n1 \ncould use their resources to look at other aspects of \n2 \nEpstein's activities? \n3 \nA \nSo, I -- so, I think it's important to take a step \n4 \nback, and I was aware of any number of cases going on in the \noffice, and based on what that stage of case was at, I would \n6 \nget more involved for a time. \n7 \nIt wasn't my practice to direct AUSAs in how they \n8 \nshould investigate, or what the scope of a case investigation \n9 \nshould be. They -- the Miami office, before I got there, and \n10 \nafter I left, had a reputation for knowing their stuff. It's \n11 \na large office. It's got good people. I would assume that \n12 \nAUSAs and their management would follow their natural leads. \n13 \nQ \nAll right. Were you aware that during this \n14 \nperiod -- and by this period, I'm talking about the \n15 \ninvestigative period from the time that the case came in in \n16 \nmid-2006 --\n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \nQ \n-- up until May 1 when \nput forth \n19 \nher pros memo --\n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- and proposed indictment. During that sort of \n22 \nten month period, or almost a year, were you aware that \n23 \ndefense counsel for Epstein were reaching out to \n24 \nand to \nto pitch their view of how the \n25 \ncase --\nEFTA00009294\n", "char_count": 1214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Page 67 \n1 \nA \nRight. \n2 \nQ \n-- should proceed? \n3 \nA \nSo, I don't have a specific recollection of who \n4 \nreached out at what time. I would assume as a general matter \nthat defense counsel -- defense counsel were clearly involved \n6 \nbefore the case came to the office. and so, I would assume \n7 \nthat defense counsel would remain involved while the office \n8 \nwas investigating. I say that not based on independent \n9 \nrecollection, but --\n10 \n11 \n12 \nQ \nRight. \nA \n-- why would they stop being involved? \nQ \nAnd is it in your experience as a U.S. Attorney, \n13 \nwas it common or uncommon for defense counsel to approach the \n14 \nline prosecutor and supervisor to make whatever pitch they \n15 \nwant with respect to a prosecution? \n16 \nA \nFairly common. \n17 \nQ \nAll right, and was it also common for those \n18 \napproaches to be entertained? In other words, for the line \n19 \nAUSA and supervisor --\n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- to meet with defense counsel? \n22 \nA \nAs a -- as a general matter, yeah. \n23 \nQ \nAnd did you view that as appropriate? \n24 \nA \nAs a general matter, it was typical. It happened \n25 \nbefore I got there, and is probably happening now. \nEFTA00009295\n", "char_count": 1170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Page 68 \n1 \nQ \nAnd you view it as an appropriate part of the \n2 \nprocess? Do you? \n3 \nA \nI think AUSAs need to have discretion to meet with \n4 \ndefense counsel, and defense counsel certainly should be able \n5 \nto present perspectives. \n6 \nQ \nThere is an outlook -- this is Exhibit 4, and this \n7 \nis something --\n8\n \nOkay. \n9 \nQ \n-- it's really sort of a point of information here. \n10 \nThis is an outlook that shows you and \nand \nhad \n11 \na scheduled meeting with Roy Black. \n12 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n13 \nQ \nRoy Black, a prominent --\n14 \nA \nRight. \n15 \nQ \n-- local criminal defense attorney at the time in \n16 \nthe Miami area. This was a meeting scheduled in your office \n17 \nfor the 23rd of February of 2007. Do you have any -- he was \n18 \na -- he at the time --\n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \n-- was one of Epstein's attorneys. Do you have any \n21 \nidea whether this meeting related to Epstein or some other \n22 \ncase? \n23 \nA \nI don't. I noticed that and I don't know whether \n24 \nit was this or another matter. \n25 \nQ \nBut you have not particular recollection of meeting \nEFTA00009296\n", "char_count": 1071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Page 69 \n1 \nwith him on the Epstein matter --\n2 \nA \nI don't. \n3 \nQ \n-- at this time? Okay. So, I want to --\n4 \nA \nAnd let me note, I think most of the correspondence \n5 \nwas from other attorneys and not him. And so, yeah. \n6 \nQ \nAll right. Are you -- are you okay? Do you want \n7 \nto take a short break, or --\n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \nbroken at 11:00. Mr. Acosta, we're going to move to that \n20 \ntime frame I mentioned a moment ago, May of 2007 when \n21 \nsubmitted her prosecution memo of more than 80 \n22 \npages, and her proposed indictment -- her initial proposed \n23 \nindictment, which was more than 50 pages. \n24 \nShe submitted that by transmittal memo to her \n25 \nentire chain, \nA \nYeah. \nQ \nDo you --\nA \nLet's -- what time is it? Oh, 11:00. \nQ \nFive minutes? \nA \nYeah. \nQ \nFive minutes? \nA \nYeah. Let's take a five minute break. \nQ \nOff the record. \n(Off the record.) \nBY MS. \nQ \nAll right, back on the record at 11:12, having \nEFTA00009297\n", "char_count": 969}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Page 70 \n1 \n, and you. Was that a typical way for an indictment \n2 \nand proposed prosecution? The memo to come? \n3 \nA \nTo my recollection, it was not, and I don't recall \n4 \nthat happening in other cases. I'm trying -- I'm hesitating, \n5 \njust because I'm trying to think through if there's -- I \n6 \ndon't have any recollection of it happening in another case. \n7 \nQ \nWhy do you think it happened in this case? And who \n8 \ncaused it to happen? \n9 \nA \nI don't know, and I don't know. \n10 \nQ \nAll right. All right. So, you \nwhen you \n11 \nbefore you saw it -- I don't know if you even knew about \n12 \nit -- you -- by reference to Exhibit 6, you learned \n13 \nessentially from \nthat the FBI was planning to do \n14 \na press conference two weeks after that, and \ntold \n15 \nthis office has not approved the indictment, \n16 \ntherefore, \"please do not commit us to anything at this \n17 \ntime.\" Were you -- and eventually that e-mail chain --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- gets to you, apparently by blind carbon, because \n20 \nthere's no indication you actually get it. \n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \nBut you advise Alicia Valle, who I think was your \n23 \npress person --\n24 \nA \nCorrect. \n25 \nQ \n-- that, ' \nhasn't even finished her \nEFTA00009298\n", "char_count": 1223}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Page 71 \n1 \nrecommendation \ni.e., we are a long way off.\" So, \n2 \ndid you have any idea why the FBI was planning a press \n3 \nconference on Epstein? \n4 \nA \nI don't -- I don't know if I did. I don't recall \n5 \nif I did. \n6 \nQ \nWas it -- how typical was it for the FBI to plan a \n7 \npress conference on an indicted -- on a case that was being \n8 \nindicted at the time of an indictment or arrest without \n9 \ncoordinating that with you and your office? \n10 \nA \nUnder \nhighly atypical. \n11 \nQ \nHe was the SAC at the time? \n12 \nA \nHe was the SAC -- he was the SAC -- I know he was \n13 \nthe SAC at the time as of September, and I'm almost certain \n14 \nhe was the SAC at the time. \n15 \nQ \nAll right. And when you said that we are a long \n16 \nway off, and \nhasn't even finished her recommendation to \n17 \n, can -- do you know whether you had any idea that she \n18 \nhad actually submitted her pros memo, and that she had made a \n19 \nrecommendation to \n20 \nA \nI can't -- I can't recollect --\n21 \nQ \nOkay. \n22 \nA \n-- but I'll take my words as reflective of, if I \n23 \nsay she hasn't finished her recommendation, then I assume she \n24 \nhasn't finished her recommendation, but I don't recall --\n25 \nQ \nDoes that mean --\nEFTA00009299\n", "char_count": 1218}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Page 72 \n1 \nA \n-- that level of detail. \n2 \nQ \n-- as you -- as you look at your own words, does \n3 \nthat suggest to you that you were unaware as of that moment \n4 \nthat she'd actually submitted her pros memo? \n5 \nA \nThat suggests that I would not have been aware that \n6 \nshe submitted it. If -- you know, because it sounds like I'm \n7 \nsaying she hasn't even submitted her memo to \nSo --\n8 \nQ \nAll right. \n9 \nA \n-- we're a long way off. \n10 \nQ \nAll right, so, is --\n11 \nA \nBut again, this is based on practice, not \n12 \nrecollection. \n13 \nQ \nAll right, and when you said we are a long way off, \n14 \ndid that reflect, if you recall, an assessment of the length \n15 \nof time to get to a pros --\n16 \nA \nRight. \n17 \nQ \n-- memo, a recommendation, and an assessment of \n18 \nthat, or your expectation that even when you saw a pros memo\n19 \nand an indictment, it would be a long process before it was \n20 \napproved? \n21 \nA \nSo, I would assume -- and again, this is just based \n22 \non speculating from the way that I write, that I'm thinking \n23 \nshe hasn't submitted her recommendation to \nneeds \n24 \nto review it. \n25 \nHe may -- you know, he'd probably want to talk to \nEFTA00009300\n", "char_count": 1177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Page 73 \n1 \n. It needs to be scrubbed. You know, this could be --\n2 \nthis ain't happening next week. \n3 \nQ \nAll right, but in your -- do you have any reason to \n4 \nbelieve that whatever that process is that you were \n5 \ndescribing would be any -- any different in any particular \n6 \nmeasure in this case from the ordinary complex case? \n7 \nA \nSo, from my language, I would take that it's the \n8 \nsame process, but that there is a process, and the process \n9 \nhasn't yet been followed. \n10 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. \n11 \nA \nSo, it would be the typical process in a typical \n12 \ncomplex case. \n13 \nQ \nAll right, and is it fair to characterize this as a \n14 \nrelatively complex case, given the legal issues? \n15 \nA \nI think it is, yes. \n16 \nQ \nOkay. In Exhibit 8, you actually got the \nin \n17 \nExhibit 7, you see that in the bottom part of that that you \n18 \nreceived a copy of the pros memo on the second page of that \n19 \nexhibit at the top. \n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nis forwarding to you the pros memo. \n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \nIn Exhibit 8, you see that \nis \n24 \nforwarding or sending to that chain, excluding \n25 \n, that is, \nand you, additional \nEFTA00009301\n", "char_count": 1149}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Page 74 \n1 \nitems in Operation Leap Year, and that's a summary of the \n2 \nindictment, and evidence regarding the individual victims. \n3 \nOkay? So, as of May 11, you had before you the pros memo, \n4 \nthe proposed indictment, and this substantial amount of \n5 \nadditional --\n6 \nA \nRight. \n7 \nQ \n-- information. Did you read the pros memo? \n8 \nA \nRight. So, I don't recall -- and I know you're \n9 \ngoing to say, why don't I, but this was a long time ago. I \n10 \ndon't recall if I read it, or if I went back to the office \n11 \nand sat down with \nand \nand went over it. I can't \n12 \nrecall from this far. I can say that it looks based on this \n13 \nthat I was at the U.S. Attorney's conference. \n14 \nQ \nMm-hmm, \n15 \nA \nThe idea of printing this out on a hotel printer, I \n16 \nwouldn't -- I can't believe I would have printed this out on \n17 \na hotel printer. \n18 \nQ \nLet alone read it on an airplane, correct? \n19 \nA \nLet alone read it on an airplane. That just \n20 \nwouldn't --\n21 \nQ \nRight. \n22 \nA \n-- have been my practice. \n23 \nQ \nBut going back -- arriving back --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- to your office, was it your practice to take \nEFTA00009302\n", "char_count": 1148}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Page 75 \n1 \nvoluminous documents like this and go through them yourself, \n2 \nor did you rely on your senior staff? \n3 \nA \nI would typically rely on senior staff. They --\n4 \nthey're the experienced ones that have seen these matters \n5 \nbefore. They would go through it. We'd sit down. We'd talk \n6 \nabout the issues. We might have it in front of us, almost \n7 \nlike you've got all those \nQ \nOkay. \n9 \nA \n-- binders there, but you know, you're calling my \n10 \nattention to particular issues, and we'd sort of talk it \n11 \nthrough. \n12 \nQ \nAnd do you recall doing that in this case? \n13 \nA \nI recall having discussions with senior staff about \n14 \nthis case. \n15 \nQ \nWho? \n16 \nA \nCertainly \nand \nat various points, and \n17 \nI can't say that I did that in May versus April versus June. \n18 \nI can't give you \n19 \nQ \nAll right. \n20 \nA \n-- timelines. \n21 \nQ \nWell, we're talking now about May. \n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \nBecause you've got the actual --\n24 \nA \nYeah. \n25 \nQ \n-- process. \nEFTA00009303\n", "char_count": 991}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Page 76 \n1 \nA \nIt would have been my practice based on this to go \n2 \nback and discuss it, and so based on my practiced, I would \n3 \nhave gone back and likely discussed it. I doubt I would have \n4 \nprinted this out at whatever hotel I was at. \n5 \nQ \nBut even when you got back to the office, would you \n6 \nhave had somebody print it out so you would've had it \n7 \navailable? \n8 \nA \nI may have had someone print it out so it's \n9 \navailable. I may have focused on particular parts of it. \n10 \nQ \nWhat kinds of issues would you have focused on? In \n11 \nother words -- in other words, some might go straight to the \n12 \nfacts. \n13 \nA \nRight. \n14 \nQ \nSome might be interested in the legal theories. \n15 \nWhat was -- what was your approach? \n16 \nA \nSo, I think that depended on the case. \n17 \nQ \nOkay. \n18 \nA \nHere, you had legal questions, and you also had --\n19 \nhad witness issues, and I would think those would have been \n20 \nthe two primary areas. \n21 \nQ \nWould you have gone through the indictment and the \n22 \npros memo and all of those other materials, or just relied on \n23 \nyour experience seeing your people, \nand \n24 \nA \nAs a general practice, probably some combination. \n25 \nAs a general -- a general recollection, the concerns in this \nEFTA00009304\n", "char_count": 1258}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Page 77 \n1 \ncase weren't about the sordid details of what happened, \n2 \nbecause we believed he did what he did. The concerns were \n3 \nabout some of the legal issues around it, and some of the \n4 \nissues in terms of testimony. \n5 \nQ \nOf the victims? \n6 \nA \nOf the victims. \n7 \nQ \nAll right. On page --\n8 \nA \nAnd I say that because that would have been what I \n9 \nwould naturally focus on as opposed to reading the sordid \n10 \ndetails, because I think everyone believed the victims. \n11 \nQ \nAll right. Exhibit 9 is an e-mail that you are not \n12 \non, but that -- notes that \nis advising \nthat \n13 \nyou, \n, \"Has your memo and Lefcourt's letter.\" Gerald \n14 \nLefcourt was --\n15 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n16 \nQ \n-- a New York attorney who was one of the members \n17 \nof the Epstein defense team. Did you know him? \n18 \nA \nI did not. \n19 \nQ \nDid you ever encounter him as far as you recall? \n20 \nA \nI did not. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. He had, according to the documents we \n22 \nhave, made two substantial submissions to \nand \n23 \nin --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- February of that year in an effort to dissuade \nEFTA00009305\n", "char_count": 1097}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Page 78 \n1 \nthem from pursuing a prosecution, and we have every reason to \n2 \nbelieve and no reason not to believe that that's what is \n3 \nbeing referred to. Do you recall reviewing substantial \n4 \nsubmissions from defense counsel at this time attacking in \n5 \nvery granular detail --\n6\n \nMm-hmm. \n7 \nQ \n-- the credibility of the witnesses, and so on? \n8 \nA \nI don't recall reviewing those. Again, I recall \n9 \ndiscussions with my senior team about issues that included \n10 \nthe credibility, and I'm not sure if it's -- credibility is \n11 \nthe right word, but how the victims would do on the stands. \n12 \nQ \nOkay, and who do you recall talking to you about \n13 \nthat? \n14 \nA \nSo, some combination of \nand \nwould have \n15 \nbene the likely -- I recall the discussion. I don't recall \n16 \nwhether it was \n, or whether it was \nor \nbut the \n17 \nlogical inference would have been it would have been some \n18 \ncombination of \nand \n19 \nQ \nhas told us that during this period, he \n20 \nwas not actively involved in this case --\n21 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n22 \nQ \n-- but that \nwas. Would that be \n23 \nconsistent with your memory, or would --\n24 \nA \nThat -- sure, it -- I mean, they were a team. They \n25 \nbecame more or less involved based on needs. \nEFTA00009306\n", "char_count": 1241}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Page 79 \n1 \nQ \nAnd was there any particular -- if We EMI \nwas \n2 \nworking with you directly on reporting \n3 \nA \nRight. \n4 \nQ \n-- on his assessment of this case, was there any \n5 \nreason for Mi \nto be involved? \n6 \nA \nI might bounce ideas off him. I mean, he was \nhe \n7 \nwas right across, so we worked closely, but you know, \n8 \nwas the criminal chief, and if he was in the weeds, \n, I \n9 \nwould speculate would sort of, much like me, defer to his \n10 \njudgement, because they've known each other, and they've \n11 \nworked together, and they had a good working relationship. \n12 \nQ \nAnd is it -- do we understand correctly that as \n13 \nfirst  \ntant, \nhad a brief that really encompassed \n14 \nthe entire office? \n15 \nA \nHe did. \n16 \nQ \nAll right. \n17 \nA \nHe -- so, he supervised the civil, the criminal, \n18 \nthe appellate, and the forfeiture. \n19 \nQ \nAll right. There is here in this e-mail that you \n20 \ndid not see back in the day, Exhibit 9, a pushback from \n21 \nregarding the rush that \nis in to \n22 \npursue the case, and he says, \"This is obviously a Very \n23 \nsignificant case, and Alex wants to take his time making sure \n24 \nhe is comfortable before proceeding.\" Do you -- can you tell \n25 \nus what the basis would be for, or was, for that assertion by \nEFTA00009307\n", "char_count": 1273}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Page \".7.;. \n2 \nA \nSo, I can't -- well, I can't tell you from \n3 \nrecollection what the basis is. I can -- I can speculate \n4 \nthat the materials being transmitted Friday morning -- oh, I \n5 \nguess it was -- yeah, so --\n6 \nQ \nThe 11th. \nA \nYeah. \nQ \nFriday. \n9 \nA \nSo, Friday morning, it hasn't been reviewed by \n10 \nanyone in the management chain, much less approved and \n11 \nedited, and \nthat Monday is saying why don't I have a \n12 \ndecision? \n13 \nAnd -- and so, absent truly extenuating \n14 \ncircumstances, typically, you'd have -- give -- you know, \n15 \nit'd go through the management chain up to the U.S. Attorney. \n16 \nAnd so, he's pushing back, saying, hey, it's been a day, or \n17 \nit's been a weekend. I'm --\n18 \nQ \nRight. \n19 \nA \n-- I'm just reading between the lines here. \n20 \nQ \nWho had authority to sign off on the Epstein \n21 \nprosecution? To, say, indict? \n22 \nA \nSo, as a delegated matter, \nhad \n23 \nsignature authority. \n24 \nQ \nMe \n-hmm. \n25 \nA \nAs did -- as did \n, as did \nEFTA00009308\n", "char_count": 1006}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Page 81 \n1 \nobviously I did. As a practice matter, this is something \n2 \nthat would have gone through the chain, and that we would \n3 \nhave then discussed. \n4 \nQ \nBut why up at your level? Is it because it is, as \n5 \nsays, \"Obviously a very significant case?\" \n6 \nA \nSo, at my level, not only because of the facts, \n7 \nbecause it's not about the facts, but I do think that there \n8 \nare legal issues that -- that implicated policy, that -- that \n9 \nwe were thinking through. \n0 \nQ \nAnd what were -- what were the legal issues, and \n11 \nwhat were the policy issues? \n12 \nA \nSo -- so, the legal issues, and also factual issues \n13 \nin terms of the witnesses. So, the legal issues \nso, and \n14 \nthere's an e-mail from \nbased on the -- you know, the \n5 \ncontemporaneous record that alludes to some of this. In my \n16 \nexperience at the civil rights division, trafficking cases \n17 \ninvolved -- you know, I can -- I can describe some -- some \n1 8 \nhorrific cases of girls being held against their will, you \n19 \nknow. \n20 \nYou had child pornography matters with young women, \n21 \nsometimes incredibly young, that the office prosecuted. As \n22 \nthe trafficking laws were being developed, there was a lot o \n23 \ndiscussion about, what's the difference between trafficking \n24 \nand solicitation, and that discussion took place as the \n25 \ntrafficking laws were being developed. And so, this \nEFTA00009309\n", "char_count": 1397}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Page 82 \n1 \nimplicated that, and it implicated the -- what is local and \n2 \nwhat is federal. \n3 \nQ \nAll right. So, in the first, you're talking -- in \n4 \nthe first category, you're talking about the individual \n5 \ncharges that had been -- that were being proposed, which \n6 \nincluded both trafficking and coercion and enticement -- or, \n7 \nenticement. \n8 \nA \nCorrect. \n9 \nQ \nAll right. And in the latter, you felt that -- did \n10 \nyou \nto what extent did the witness -- victim witness kind \n11 \nof credibility issues implicate policy? \n12 \nA \nSo -- so, I think I said policy and victim in that. \n13 \nQ \nAll right. \n14 \nA \nIn that there was certainly discussion between me \n15 \nand my management about concerns as to how these victims \n16 \nwould sort of stand up in court. \n17 \nQ \nSo, what would have -- what would make you \n18 \ncomfortable before -- before proceeding? What would make \n19 \nyou -- what at that point would have made you comfortable \n20 \nabout proceeding? \n21 \nA \nSo, I think that at this point, I don't think it's \n22 \nwhat would or would not have made me comfortable, and I'm \n23 \nspeculating here. I think it's, it came in on Friday, let's \n24 \ntalk this through. \n25 \nQ \nBut there -- but you've just identified for us \nEFTA00009310\n", "char_count": 1251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Page 83 \n1 \nissues that --\n2 \nA \nIssues that --\n3\n \n-- in your mind \n4 \nA \n-- we would have --\n5 \nQ \n-- had to be resolved. \n6 \nA \n-- wanted to talk through. \n7 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. At that point, did you -- to \n8 \nyour recollection, have any doubt that some form of \n9 \nindictment or charging instrument against Epstein was likely \n10 \nto be -- become viable? \n11 \nA \nSo, I don't -- it was a case that I thought it very \n12 \nimportant that we do something. How that something played \n13 \nout, I think had all along been a matter of discussion. \n14 \nQ \nAs something other than what the U.S. Attorney's \n15 \nOffice does, which is prosecute? \n16 \nA \nWell -- well, no, I mean, what the U.S. Attorney's \n17 \nOffice does is ensure that justice is served. \n18 \nQ \nRight. \n19 \nA \nAnd whether -- and in partnership with state \n20 \nattorneys, and sometimes that means state attorneys take the \n21 \nlead. Sometimes that means the U.S. Attorney's Office takes \n22 \nthe lead, and it -- and a lot of times, we actually had, you \n23 \nknow, we -- we would share staff, because sometimes it made \n24 \nsense for -- you know, for one part of the other to take the \n25 \nlead. \nEFTA00009311\n", "char_count": 1171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Page 84 \n1 \nSo, writ large, I thought throughout it was very \n2 \nimportant that something happen. There were these concerns \n3 \nall along. I can speculate that this is just a reflection of \n4 \nthose continuing concerns. \n5 \nQ \nAs expressed by you to \nin the ordinary \ncourse? \n7 \nA \nAs developed as a group throughout this -- I can \nso, if we go back to -- what was the Exhibit? \nQ \nJune of -- June of 2006. \nA \nSo, Exhibit 3, \nsays, \"In that meeting, I \nsummarized the case and the state attorney's office handling \n12 \nit. I acknowledged that we needed to do work to collect \n13 \nevidence establishing a federal nexus, and I noted the time \n14 \nand money that would be required for an investigation.\" And \n15 \nso, as far back as that initial meeting, there is the \n16 \ndiscussion about the federal nexus, and is this a state or a \n17 \nfederal --\n18 \nQ \nRight. \n19 \nA \n-- case? \n20 \nQ \nAll right. Exhibit 7 is an early e-mail from= \n21 \nto you. Early, meaning it proceeds the one --\n22 \nA \nCorrect-. \n23 \nQ \n-- we just looked at, and early in that it's right \n24 \nas you're \n25 \nA \n5 \nEFTA00009312\n", "char_count": 1099}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Page 85 \n1 \nQ \n-- receiving the pros memo, and you ask him, have \n2 \nyou read the memo? And curious why you \n3 \nrather than \n4 \nask MI \nA \nI don't recall. I can -- I can speculate, and I \n5 \nhave two thoughts that I'll speculate. One is, ME \nher \n6 \ndirect supervisor. \n7 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n8 \n9 \nA \nAnd I might be thinking --\nQ \nSecond line supervisor. \n10 \nA \nHer second line supervisor, so why is \nsending \n11 \nme this? \n, have you read this? I.e., did you jump the \n12 \nchain? Secondly, I think it \nI may have wanted to have \n13 \nmultiple opinions on this. \n14 \nQ \nMs-hmm. \n15 \nA \nIt's most likely that I had talked to \n16 \nalready, because \nand I talked more often, and I'm asking \n17 \nanother person in the management chain, hey, what do you \n18 \nthink? Let's have multiple opinions on the table here. \n19 \nQ \nWell, this is the first time other than \nthat \n20 \nwe see you getting a recommendation. \n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \nWhen \nsays, he thinks that you should \n23 \ncharge him -- you, the office, should charge Epstein. He has \n24 \nissues with the charging strategy proposed by \nbut \n25 \none, he says, \"We all need to get on the same page as to \nEFTA00009313\n", "char_count": 1157}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Page 86 \n1 \nwhether the statute's covered the conduct, and whether the \n2 \nconduct is the type we should charge. I think the answer to \n3 \nboth is yes, although there is some risk on some of the \n4 \nstatutes.\" He proposes that the office start with a \n5 \ncomplaint, which is not unusual, is it? \n6 \n7 \nA \nIt -- it happens, yes. \nQ \nAll right, which allows the defendant to be \n8 \narrested, and ideally detained, and then the defendant is \n9 \nthen highly motivated or incentivized --\n10 \n11 \n12 \nwhat \nA \nOkay. \nQ \n-- to work a pre-indictment resolution. That's \nis proposing. He also notes that it's \n13 \nimportant to -- in his view, to \"cap him with conspiracy \n14 \ncounts to make a plea attractive,\" and the court could give \n15 \nus a hard time with that if we had to dismiss indicted \n16 \ncounts. \n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \nQ \nOkay. The proposed indictment included one \n19 \nconspiracy -- a conspiracy that has a five year \n20 \nA \nFive year cap. \n21 \nQ \n-- statutory maximum, and this notion is that \n22 \nEpstein be charged with a five-year conspiracy count, and \n23 \ntake it from there. Do you know what he was referring to \n24 \nwhen he noted that a court could give you a hard time in \n25 \ndismissing indicted counts in this case? \nEFTA00009314\n", "char_count": 1243}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Page 87 \n1 \nA \nSo -- so, as a typical matter, once there's an \n2 \nindictment, the -- a pre-indictment -- well, by definition, a \n3 \npre-indictment resolution comes off the table, but in cases \n4 \nof this nature, the resolutions tend to happen before \n5 \nindictment, because once the indictment is done, at least in \n6 \nSouth Florida, dismissal of charges -- for example, if -- you \n7 \nknow, if \nis saying, let's think about a 371 with a five \n8 \nyear cap a rule 11 --\n9 \nQ \nMm-hem. \n10 \nA \n-- that's something that South Florida judges, they \n11 \ntend not to -- you know, dismissing a number of counts, and \n12 \nthen doing a rule 11 is not something that judges tend to do. \n13 \nQ \nAll right. Two -- two pieces to that. One is --\n14 \nA \nOkay. \n15 \nQ \n-- the issue of dismissing substantive --\n16 \nA \nRight. \n17 \nQ \n-- counts -- substantive counts. Is that -- was \n18 \nthat a particular concern in this case because of the nature \n19 \nof the conduct represented in the --\n20 \nA \nSo --\n21 \nQ \n-- substantive counts? \n22 \nA \n-- so, so, your question -- you asked a general \n23 \nquestion, and then now you're moving to a \n24 \nQ \nRight. \n25 \nA \n-- specific. As a general matter, not just in this \nEFTA00009315\n", "char_count": 1205}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Page 88 \n1 \ncase, but in other cases, it is -- it was rare that the \n2 \noffice after an -- in cases like this, after a full charge \n3 \nwas done, that that substantive counts were dismissed. So, \n4 \nfor example, in the public corruption cases that I referenced \n5 \nearlier out of Palm Beach, those were all negotiated pre-\n6 \nindictment, and agreed to, and then by the time the -- the \n7 \ncase was indicted, it was all -- it was all sort of set on \n8 \nauto-pilot. \n9 \nQ \nSo, typically, in my experience, the -- a \n10 \ndisposition like that is -- results in a criminal \n11 \ninformation, not an indictment. \n12 \nA \nCorrect, and --\n13 \nQ \nAre you saying that you would go ahead and indict \n14 \nthen? \n15 \nA \nNo, no, no, what I'm saying is that they were -- it \n16 \nwas all negotiated in advance, and then there was an \n17 \ninformation --\n18 \nQ \nOh, okay. \n19 \nA \n-- and the information would go forward, not an \n20 \nindictment. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. \n22 \nA \nAnd so, that is how a number of high profile cases \n23 \ntypically proceeded, as opposed to indict and dismiss. \n24 \nQ \nAnd that is the experience of the Southern District \n25 \nof Florida in general? \nEFTA00009316\n", "char_count": 1164}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "Page 89 \n1 \nA \nIt -- it was in particularly the Palm Beach office \n2 \nwith other high profile cases that were there at the time. \n3 \nQ \nDo you recall any case in which a judge in an \n4 \nindicted case refused to dismiss counts when the \n5 \ngovernment --\n6 \n7 \n8 \nA \nYeah. \nQ \n-- in an indictment under those circumstances? \nA \nI don't recall specific cases, but I can -- I can \n9 \nsay that typically in the higher profile cases you'd \n10 \nnegotiated with opposing counsel, presenting information. \n11 \nThe information would have agreed to an agreed to guideline, \n12 \nand it would proceed in that way. \n13 \nQ \nUnderstood, but in this case, I'm focusing on the \n14 \nassertion by \nthat the court could give us a hard \n15 \ntime, and that's a little different from, you know, \n16 \nexercising discretion to negotiate and proceed by \n17 \ninformation. So, is there any judge that -- that was \n18 \nparticularly concerning with regard to an unwillingness to --\n19 \nA \n20 \nQ \n-- dismiss? \n21 \nA \nI don't -- so, first, this is 12 years ago, and I \n22 \ndon't recall any specific judge, but I can -- I can sort of \n23 \nthat say that was not the practice of the office. The \n24 \npractice of the office was to proceed by information rather \n25 \nthan indictment with dismissal, because there is more --\nEFTA00009317\n", "char_count": 1299}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Page 9C \n1 \nthere is -- there -- you can -- you can -- you can lay out \n2 \nmore what you've negotiated. I think later there's a letter \n3 \nfrom.. that sort of presents the same perspective. \n4 \nQ \nAll right. In --\n5 \nMS. \nOne moment? \n6 \nMS. \n: Go ahead. \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. \n8 \nBY MS. a: \nQ \nYou said in cases of this nature, the resolution \n10 \nhappens before indicting. What is the -- this cases of this \nnature? \nA \nHigher profile. Higher profile cases. \n13 \nQ \nSo, not necessarily sex offense cases? \n14 \nA \nNot necessarily sex offense, no, no, no, higher --\n15 \nhigher profile cases where --\n16 \nQ \nAnd this made -- this was a higher profile case \n17 \nbecause --\n18 \nA \nThis was a -- just, a -- so, I would say it's a \n19 \ncombination of all of the above, and to my mind, one of \n20 \nthe -- one of the parts of this case is the legal theories \n21 \nwere, if not novel, they were novel within the Southern \n22 \nDistrict of Florida. At least, some of the legal theories, \n23 \nand I -- we'll probably get into that. \n24 \nQ \nDid his wealth make it a high profile case? \n25 \nA \nWell, it was clearly in the paper. And so, that \nEFTA00009318\n", "char_count": 1140}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Page 91 \n1 \nmade it a high profile case. I don't think it -- I don't \n2 \nthink it was his wealth. I think it was all of the above. \n3 \nThis was a matter that the state attorney had been ready to \n4 \ncharge that the federal government is now jumping into and \nS \nsaying, by its presence, that the state did not do enough. \n6 \nThat in and of itself makes it a very high profile \n7 \ncase. I can't remember any other instance, certainly during \n8 \nmy time, when we jumped in and said, you know, the state \n9 \ndropped charges, and so we are going to do more. \n10 \nBY MS. \n11 \nQ \nAs opposed to, or as distinguished from what you'd \n12 \ndescribed a few moments ago, a situation in which the federal \n13 \nauthorities and the state authorities kind of worked together \n14 \nto sort out what would be charged, where, and do it \n15 \ncooperatively? \n16 \nA \nAnd that was more cooperative, and I --\n17 \nQ \nRight. \n18 \nA \ni would -- you know, I do recollect that -- and \n19 \nI think the record bears this out, that this was not a \n20 \nparticularly cooperative relationship between us and the \n21 \nstate attorney. \n22 \nQ \nMm-hmm. Yes, we will get to that. Were you --\n23 \nA \nIf I could -- if I could return, I think your \n24 \nquestion -- the way you posed your question, you said a \n25 \nrecommendation from \n, and let me -- let me push back a \nEFTA00009319\n", "char_count": 1340}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Page 92 \n1 \nlittle bit on that. \n2 \nSaying what are your thoughts? Have you read it, \n3 \nwhat are your thoughts? And he says, yes, we can talk next \n4 \nweek, my current thoughts are \nis very different than, \n5 \nwe've sat down, we've discussed this, this is my now informed \n6 \nposition. \n7 \nQ \nUnderstood, and I -- I should have been clearer. I \n8 \nwas referring to his recommendation that if you were going to \n9 \nproceed, you should start with a --\n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \nI 4 \n15 \n16 \n17 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- complaint. \nA \nRight. \nQ \nJust to be clear. \nA \nAnd I'm just saying --\nQ \nOkay. \nA \n-- initial thoughts are -- yeah. \nQ \nAll right. So, were you aware that \n18 \nbootlegged a copy of the pros memo to \nat \nCEOS? \n20 \n22 \n23\nQ \nQ \nHe did at that time. \nA \n0k:Fcf. \nAnd did you -- did you know \nA \nA little bit. I certainly knew of him. \nQ \nHad you encountered him when -- he was the chief of \nEFTA00009320\n", "char_count": 904}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Page 93 \n1 \nthe child exploitation and obscenities section \n2 \nA \nRight. \n3 \nQ \nin the criminal division here, correct? Had you \n4 \nencountered him while you were in this building also? \n5 \nA \nMost likely. I knew of him enough that the \n6 \ncorrespondence shows -- and I recall asking to involve him \n7 \npretty early on. \n8 \nQ \nSo, it does read as if you were acquainted with \n9 \nhim. \n10 \nA \nYeah. \nQ \nAll right. And did you have any -- did his \n12 \nopinion, his views as chief of CEOS and as \n3 \nwho had been an AUSA --\n14 \nA \nRight. \n15 \nQ \nA \nIn Miami. \nQ \n-- Miami, did his views have influence on your \n8 \nthinking about this case? \n19 \nA \nI don't think at this time I was aware that \n20 \nhad been consulted. \n21 \nQ \nAll right, and in July, just so you know, and I --\n22 \nand this is not something you saw -- he provided a fairly \n23 \nstrong statement to -- by e-mail to \nand \n24 \nin which he advises that he reviewed the pros memo \n25 \nclosely. \nEFTA00009321\n", "char_count": 965}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Page 94 \n1 \nIt's terrific. He says \ndid a terrific job, \n2 \nand he says, \"we agree with her legal analysis. Her charging \n3 \ndecisions are legally sound,\" and then \ngoes \n4 \nthrough the different statutes, and concludes that they are \n5 \nall properly charged, and that although there are some \n6 \nissues, legally, that in his view we should, \"We should \n7 \nprevail.\" \"Our position should prevail.\" \n8 \nAnd that he also reviewed the arguments contained \n9 \nin the letters from defense counsel, and he found none of \n10 \ntheir arguments persuasive. So, at least as of July 18, \n11 \nyour --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- three levels of supervisors down were on notice \n14 \nthat CEOS was on board and wanted to --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \nsee the case move forward, but is it -- am I \n17 \ncorrect in understanding that at that time, you were unaware \n18 \nof that? \n19 \nA \nI do not recall being aware of that. \n20 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. If you had been aware of it, if \n21 \nthey had sent this --\n22 \nA \nYeah. \n23 \nQ \n-- pretty -- I don't want to overstate it, but it \n24 \nis a pretty strong endorsement of the proposed prosecution, \n25 \nwould you have been influenced by that? \nEFTA00009322\n", "char_count": 1177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Page 95 \n1 \nA \nSure, I would have. I mean, I -- I respected MI, \n2 \nand clearly wanted him to be part of the team, and later \n3 \ninvited him down, and so, yes. \n4 \nQ \nOkay. All right. Do you know why they wouldn't \nhave shared -- your people wouldn't have shared this with \n6 \nyou? \nA \nI can't -- I don't know. \n8 \nQ \nAll right. So, when -- as far -- based on the \n9 \nbriefings that you got at -- in this time period when there \n10 \nwas an effort to try to figure out --\n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \n-- what you were going to do, were there any issues \n13 \nof concern of fact or evidence or the charges that were left \n14 \nunaddressed? In other words, if there were issues about \n15 \nvictim credibility, were steps being taken to address those? \n16 \nA \nUnaddressed is a -- again, it -- it's a very \n17 \nbinary, and it's not about addressed versus unaddressed. And \n18 \nso, let me -- let me sort of come at it, if I can try to \n19 \nget -- there were concerns around some legal issues. There \n20 \nwere concerns about how the victims would do when put on the \n21 \nstand. \n22 \nQ \nRight. \n23 \nA \nAs a general matter, we thought there was enough if \n24 \nwe had to go forward, we could, as an ethical matter, go \n25 \nforward. That doesn't mean that there was not value in a \nEFTA00009323\n", "char_count": 1274}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "Page 96 \n1 \npre-indictment resolution. \n2 \nAnd so, here, you havellIII, based on this Exhibit \n3 \n7, saying, we need to get on the same page as to what to \n4 \ncharge, pre-indictment resolution, cap him with conspiracy \n5 \ncount to make up the attractive. \n6 \nSo, a five year cap, something less than five \n7 \nyears, you have\n in her affidavit that was submitted to \n8 \nthe court saying she favored a pre-indictment resolution. \n9 \nAnd so, it's not a, have you addressed everything, yes or no, \n10 \nas opposed to putting all of this, how do we --\n11 \nQ \nAll right. \n12 \nA \n-- how do we move forward? \n13 \nQ \nRight, but there is a binary point here, and that \n14 \nis, you either indict or you don't indict. You either \n15 \npresent an indictment to the grand jury, or you don't, right? \n16 \nThat's a decision. Right? \n17 \nA \nSo, I would -- I would actually push back in that \n18 \nin many cases, it's not quite that binary. In many cases, \n19 \nyou sit down with opposing counsel and say, look, we can go \n20 \nto a grand jury, and we can present this indictment and \n21 \nindict, or we can resolve this now. If we resolve this now, \n22 \nthis is the path that can go forward. Alternatively, we can \n23 \ngo here. And so, it's not an A versus B. \n24 \nQ \nI understand that nuance, but the decision to \n25 \nindict does -- I mean, you either indict or you don't. If \nEFTA00009324\n", "char_count": 1368}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Page 97 \n1 \nyou don't indict, it's for any number of reasons. If under \n2 \nthese circumstances, the choices that are available are you \n3 \nhave a case that's been brought in -- taken in from --\n4 \nA \nRight. \n5 \nQ \n-- the state. You can -- you can decline it. Send \n6 \nit back to the state, make it go away, whatever. \n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \nQ \nWe're not interested. You can indict. You can \n9 \nindict and go to trial. These are the subcategories. Or you \n10 \ncan indict and have the defendant plead to the indictment, or \n11 \nyou can indict and work a post-indictment plea deal, which \n12 \nraises the issues you talked about, or you can negotiate \n13 \nan -- or you can charge -- proceed by complaint, and do as \n14 \nwas suggesting --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- work a pre-indictment but post charge \n17 \ndisposition, or you can work a pre-charge disposition, right? \n18 \nI mean, that's really --\n19 \nA \nSo, so --\n20 \nQ \nThat's the parade of possibles. \n21 \nA \nSure, but that's more than indictment or don't \n22 \nindict. That's six or seven options. \n23 \nQ \nI understand that. That's how it will play out, \n24 \nbut the decision as to whether to indict is binary. You're \n25 \neither indicting or you're not indicting. The -- the act of \nEFTA00009325\n", "char_count": 1240}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "Page 98 \n1 \nindicting is a -- is something that either happens or doesn't \n2 \nhappen. That's all I'm saying. \n3 \nA \nSure. \n4 \nQ \nOkay? So, what I'm getting at is, with respect to \n5 \nthe indictment -- so, as you're looking at this case, \n6 \nyou're -- it sounds as if you're doing sort of one analytical \n7 \ntrack, which is, what do we do with this case? The other \n8 \npiece of that, and a track that could have been followed \n9 \nexclusively is, what do we need to do to get an indictment \n10 \nthat is legally sound and evidentiary -- evidentiarily solid? \n11 \nI'd like to focus on that track --\n12 \nA \nOkay. \n13 \nQ \n-- because they're not unrelated. \n14 \nA \nSure. \n15 \nQ \nIf you never get down the, do we have a viable \n16 \nindictment road, then you're not going to be able to do \n17 \nanything in the other \n18 \nA \nSure. \n19 \nQ \n-- road. So, at this point, you had identified, \n20 \nand you collectively -- you and your people had identified \n21 \nsome witness -- victim witness issues, and some legal issues. \n22 \nMy question is, were steps being taken to -- i used -- I used \n23 \nthe term address --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- let me -- let me clarify, with respect to the \nEFTA00009326\n", "char_count": 1185}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "e , \n1 \nwitnesses, was the FBI and the line attorney with the \n2 \nassistance perhaps of the grand jury, taking steps to \n3 \ncorroborate --\n4 \nA \nRight. \n5 \nQ \n-- shore up victim witness testimony, find new \n6 \nvictims, find additional evidence, and so on? \n7 \nA \nSo -- so, taking that in part is helpful. So, with \n8 \nrespect to the witness issues, I recall, and \ngoes into \n9 \nmuch more detail in her affidavit, but I recall concerns that \n10 \nwere communicated to me about, in essence, to sort of \n11 \nsummarize my impression or recollection, these girls are \n12 \nyoung. \n13 \nThey're impressionable. They are scared. Will \n14 \nthey stand up in court? There are any number of -- there's \n15 \nany number of things that could be used against them. Some \n16 \nof them are -- and this is uncomfortable, but some of them \n17 \nthought he actually cared for them, and that's not atypical \n18 \nin these cases where they -- they sort of develop thoughts \n19 \nthat are wrong, but -- but they are what they are, and were \n20 \nactually saying he did nothing wrong, and because many of \n21 \nthem knew one another, how would that all play out? \n22 \nQ \nRight. \n23 \nA \nAnd so, it would be my assumption, particularly \n24 \ngiven, you know, how much work \nwas doing on this \n25 \ncase -- Ms. \nwas doing on this case -- that she, in \nEFTA00009327\n", "char_count": 1327}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009229", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "Page 100 \n1 \ncombination with the FBI, would be pursuing those matters, \n2 \nand looking to develop the evidence and corroborate, and \n3 \nthroughout this process, it would have been my assumption and \n4 \nhope that she was continuing to develop the facts, because \n5 \nthat can only help. \n6 \nQ \nAnd so as U.S. Attorney, would it indeed have been \n7 \nyour expectation? \n8 \nA \nYes. \n9 \nQ \nAnd the expectation that her -- that all those \n10 \ninterim supervisors would have been supporting her and \n11 \nencouraging her and guiding her? \n12 \nA \nIt would have been, and that -- that's what happens \n13 \nin typical cases. \n14 \nQ \nRight. \n15 \nA \nJust because we're having a legal discussion \n16 \ndoesn't mean you stop pursuing leads. \n17 \nQ \nAll right. Let me stick with the evidence piece of \n18 \nthat. \n19 \nA \nYeah. \n20 \nQ \nI'm going to keep these --\n21 \nA \nHelpful. \n22 \nQ \n-- strains going. You got a very detailed \n23 \naccounting in -- reflected in Exhibit 8 from \nof the \n24 \ndifferent Jane Does, and there were a lot of them, and there \n25 \nwere -- there were many counts in the indictment, and many \nEFTA00009328\n", "char_count": 1111}]}