{"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_count": 113, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00009116", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00009116.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Page 300 \n1 \nA \nYeah. \n2 \nright about that same time, he quite quickly \n3 \nidentified a potential problem, and that was the commitment \n4 \nfor the -- or, the agreement that the U.S. Attorney's Office \n5 \nwould identify the representative for the victims. Do you \n6 \nrecall him raising that? \n7 \nA \nI don't recall him raising that as an issue, but I \nknow it was an issue. \nQ \nAll right. /t was an issue, and it was one that he \n10 \nraised as soon as he came back. So, there was an effort, \n11 \nwhich he conducted then in Ma \nabsence to craft \n12 \nan NPA addendum to address that issue. \n13 \nDo you -- are you -- are you aware that MI \nreceived a copy of the NPA in November when Ken \nStarr wrote a letter to \nasking her to review the \n22.55 portion of it? Do you -- do you remember that issue? \nA \nI remember that the issue was appealed to CEOS. \nQ \nOkay. Well, it was -- it was appealed initially by \n19 \nletter to \n, raising an issue that was new to --\n20 \nthat had not been raised with you, and that is what led to \n21 \nyour letter to Ken Starr on December 4. \n22 \nA \nI will accept the timeline. \nQ \nOkay. \n24 \nA \nIt's difficult without all the documents --\nQ \nSure. \nEFTA00009116\n", "char_count": 1184}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Page 301 \n1 \n2 \nA \n-- but yes. \nQ \nAnd at the time theta/MEM \nsaw the NPA, \n3 \nhe sent a message to \nMO about the -- about his view \n4 \nof the NPA, and you didn't see it, but I just wanted to name \n5 \nsome problems that he identified with the disposition, and \n6 \nget your reaction --\n7 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n8 \nQ \n-- to it. So, first, he says I'm not thrilled \n9 \nabout the agreement, but he acknowledges that's out of his \n10 \nhands. He says in terms of the charging and sentencing \n11 \nprovisions, he's getting -- Epstein is getting a much better \n12 \ndeal than the average defendant, with the exception of \n13 \ndefendants who have done physical harm to their victims or \n14 \nabused very young children, we haven't seen more egregious \n15 \nconduct, because of its serial nature. The area we need to \n16 \nbe most careful about relates to the victims. \n17 \nThe U.S. should seek to ensure that the plea, which \n18 \nis not giving him serious jail time, provides the best means \n19 \npossible to address the harm he caused to the victims. That \n20 \ngenerally means restitution and/or therapy. While the \n21 \nagreement provides facility for the victims, the relevant \n22 \nterms still seem pretty advantageous for the defendant, and \n23 \nnot all that helpful to the victims. \n24 \nThey get an attorney who will be paid by the \n25 \ndefendant, which involves at least some conflict of interest, \nEFTA00009117\n", "char_count": 1392}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Page 302 \n1 \nor they could hire their own attorneys on a contingency \n2 \nbasis, and they get waivers from the defendant when his plea \n3 \nwould facilitate their civil cases in any event. Then, they \n4 \nstill have to sue him to get anything. \nMost times with wealthy defendants, we make them \n6 \nagree to a restitution fund, and then still provide that the \n7 \nvictims can sue the defendant independently if they choose. \nWe always make them clearly admit their guilt, no nolo pleas. \n9 \nThis is incredibly important to the victims. I \n10 \nwould have taken the guy to trial unless the victims were \n11 \nclearly against it, and I don't think most of them are here. \n12 \nHe then says to \n, who by this time is working \n13 \nfor --\n14 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n15 \n16 \nA \nRight. \n17 \nQ \nSo, that's the context in which he's addressing it. \n18 \nspecifies that, ' \nwouldn't and \n19 \nshouldn't address the agreement.\" So, that -- so that the \n20 \nissue that was then before \nput there by Ken \n21 \nStarr, was the -- whether this 22.55 scheme or scenario set \n22 \nout in the NPA was appropriate. It appears that she then \n23 \nsent that back to you to address. \n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \nBut as far as \ncommentary on the NPA, \nEFTA00009118\n", "char_count": 1212}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Pagel 303 \nif you had been aware of this perspective at the time you \nwere -- that you and your people were fashioning the NPA, \nwould that have been helpful to you in -- in deciding out to \nproceed? \nA \nSo, may I? \nQ \nYes. \nA \nOkay. I assume you've read the whole thing, but \n8 \nlet me just take a \n9 \nQ \nI have. \n10 \nA \nAnd so, a few comments. First, let me say, he was \n11 \npart of the September meeting. \n12 \nQ \nMe-hmm. \n13 \nA \nAnd -- and to my recollection, these \n14 \nperspectives -- so, so, at least the outlines of the \n15 \nagreement were -- were disclosed at that meeting, and I don't \n16 \nrecall this type of communication at that time. \n17 \nQ \nOkay. \n18 \nA \nI also recall that there was a lot of back and \n19 \nforth around this restitution fund concept, and our \n20 \nperspective was that the restitution fund puts the victim at \n21 \na disadvantage --\n22 \nQ \nMe-hmm. \n23 \nA \n-- because -- let me -- let me try to recreate. I \n24 \ndon't recall the details, but I recall that there was a \n25 \nperspective that the restitution fund --\nEFTA00009119\n", "char_count": 1055}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Page 304 \nQ \nMO-hmm. \n-- put the victims as a disadvantage --\n4 \nMm-hmm. \nA \n-- and there is some reference to --\nQ \nIt's the --\nA \nWas it an Alaska case? \nQ \nIt's called the \ncase. \n5 \nMR. \nTHE WITNESS I'm sorry? \nIC \nMR. \n11 \nTHE WITNESS NM \n12 \nMS. \nor \n13 \nTHE WITNESS a=? \n14 \nBY MS. \n15 \nQ \nYeah. \n16 \nA \nAnd so to the extent that there were better ways of \n17 \ncrafting this, that certainly would have been -- been highly \n18 \nrelevant, because to my recollection, we were not wed to any \n19 \nparticular way of crafting it. \n20 \nThe -- the intent of the 22.55 was to come as close \n21 \nas possible to putting the victims in the -- in the position \n22 \nthey would have been had he been tried and convicted \n23 \nfederally. And so, the answer to your question is yes. \n24 \nQ \nIs yes, that would have --\n25 \nA \nWould have been helpful. \nEFTA00009120\n", "char_count": 853}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Page 305 \n1 \nQ \nOkay. As you set about addressing the 22.55, you \n2 \nconsulted with \n. Do you recall that? \n3 \nA \nI -- I recall consultations. I don't recall that \n4 \nit was specifically with a \nbut --\n5 \nQ \nDid you know her? \n6 \nA \nYes. \n7 \nQ \nOkay, and do you recall the nature of your \n8 \ninteraction with her? \n9 \nA \nI -- I don't. I know from contemporary review of \n10 \nthe record, that there is an e-mail from her. \nQ \nIt's 41a. \nA \n41a. \nQ \nAnd what I -- what I want to ask is, is simply, 41a \nis -- is an e-mail in which you ask -- you note to \n15 \n, who was \n16 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- one of her deputies, and she oversaw CEOS. She, \n18 \n, mentioned to you that \nwas looking at \n19 \nthis, which is the --\nA \n22.55. \n21 \nQ \n-- 22.55, she contacts her counterpart in the civil \n22 \ndivision, \nand there's an e-mail from him, \n23 \nwhich is the second page of this exhibit, which he copies you \n24 \non. So, my question is, is this the extent of your \n25 \ninteraction with \non this issue? \nEFTA00009121\n", "char_count": 1002}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Page 306 \n1 \nA \nI -- 12 years --\n2 \nQ \nOkay. \n3 \nA \n-- after the fact, I don't remember. \n4 \nQ \nOkay. All right. The -- in Exhibit 35, there is a \n5 \nletter from Jay Lefkowitz in which -- I'm sorry, it's an e-\n6 \nmail from Jay Lefkowitz. \n7 \nA \nExhibit? \n8 \nQ \nExhibit 35 to you, and this is substantially later, \n9 \nbut it has a sentence that -- or a phrase that we'd like to \n10 \nask you about, and -- all right, it's highlighted at the top. \n11 \nIt says, back in the beginning of -- back at the beginning of \n12 \nJanuary, when we both agreed that there were significant \n13 \nirregularities with the deferred prosecution agreement, you \n14 \ncalled a time out. Is that accurate? Did you and he agree \n15 \nthat --\n16 \nA \nNo. \n17 \nQ \n-- there were significant irregularities? \n18 \nA \nNo. \n19 \nQ \nOkay. \n20 \nA \nAnd if I could, there are -- there are several \n21 \ninstances where not just, to me, but to other people as well, \n22 \nJay recharacterizes conversations. \n23 \nQ \nRecharactorizes them inaccurately? \n24 \nA \nInaccurately. \n25 \nQ \nOr misleadingly? \nEFTA00009122\n", "char_count": 1067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Page 307 \n1 \nA \nOr misleadingly. \n2 \nQ \nAll right. \n3 \nA \nWhat I recall agreeing to at some point is there \n4 \nwas an appeal to the DAG, or there was an appeal in place, \n5 \nand I basically said -- I think there was a letter that I \n6 \nsent, saying if you want to appeal, go ahead. We're not \n7 \nconcerned about this. \n8 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n9 \nA \nBut that doesn't mean that I agree that there were \n10 \nirregularities --\n11 \nQ \nAll right. \n12 \nA \n-- or that there was a time out, that's -- I'm part \n13 \nof a department. I'm part of a hierarchy. If someone wants \n14 \nto overrule me, that's okay by me. \n15 \nQ \nAll right. So, the NPA addendum was worked out, \n16 \nand the defense team continued its sort of multi-pronged \n17 \nassault. In the middle of the negotiations between \n18 \nand Lefkowitz about the NPA addendum, that's when you had the \n19 \nmuch commented on breakfast --\n20 \nA \nCorrect. \n21 \nQ \n-- on October 12, and you have stated publicly that \n22 \nat -- perfectly accurately that the NPA was signed, and that \n23 \nwas a done deal. And so, that -- that this was not tied in \n24 \nany way to any effort to influence the terms of the NPA, \n25 \nfair? \nEFTA00009123\n", "char_count": 1166}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Page 308 \n1 \nA \nFair, because the way this was reported was that I \n2 \nnegotiated it over breakfast. It was signed, and that's \n3 \nreally important. \n4 \nQ \nOf course. There were, however, a number of open \nS \nissues --\n6 \nA \nYes. \n7 \nQ \n-- right? And in Exhibit 28, Jay Lefkowitz on page \n8 \ntwo, this is an e-mail to you, acknowledges your -- your \n9 \nbreakfast on Friday. This is dated October 18, and -- and \n10 \nfollowing -- following up on -- your conversation with him \n11 \nabout the date for Epstein's plea. \n12 \nSo, he notes that, \"You said you didn't want to \n13 \ndictate a schedule to the state.\" So, all I want to note is \n14 \nthat when you had the breakfast, there was \nthere was \n15 \nthere were issues still open that were the subject of \n16 \ndiscussions between the defense and the U.S. Attorney's \n17 \nOffice. \n18 \nAnd -- and so, I guess my question is, while that \n19 \nwas a meeting of convenience in a public place, in a location \n20 \nwhere you had business later that day, a speech, I believe, \n21 \noptically, do you understand the public concern that this was \n22 \nsort of a one on one negotiation on pending issues? \n23 \nA \nSo, I -- I understand how there can be concern. \n24 \nThis, you know, it is -- it was not unusual -- in this case, \n25 \nI actually very intentionally waited, and tried not to have \nEFTA00009124\n", "char_count": 1337}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Page 309 \n1 \none on one meetings, but there are other instances where : \n2 \nmight from time to time have one on one conversations with \n3 \nthe opposing counsel. \n4 \nI don't remember the breakfast. I can speculate \n5 \nthat one of the issues that was informing this was somewhere \n6 \naround this time, and I can't say with certainty that this \n7 \nwas what it was, but somewhere around this time, there arose \n8 \nallegations that \nhad directed the designation to her \n9 \nboyfriend's partner, or something along those lines. \n10 \nQ \nA former -- I believe it was a former law school \n11 \nclassmate of her former -- of her then boyfriend. \n12 \nA \n1 don't -- yeah, and so I don't remember what the \n13 \ndetails --\n14 \nQ \nOkay. \n15 \nA \n-- were, but I know that that was a topic that he \n16 \nwanted to raise --\n17 \nQ \n18 \nA \n-- with me. \n19 \nQ \nDid he at that breakfast? \n20 \nA \nI honestly -- I don't recall the breakfast. \n21 \nQ \nOkay. \n22 \nA \nYou asked me about one characterization of what I \n23 \nsaid in the record, you know, of that breakfast. I think I \n24 \nresponded --\n25 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \nEFTA00009125\n", "char_count": 1097}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Page 310 \n1 \nA \nthrough, or my counsel responded, and they're \n2 \npointing out that I seem fairly perturbed at how he \n3 \ninaccurately characterized something that I said. And so, we \n4 \ndon't need to revisit that, but --\n5 \nQ \nUh-uh. All right. If you look at Exhibit 27, \n6 \nanother sort of point, just to kind of --\n7 \nA \nAll right. \n8 \nMR. \n: Could we -- before we --\n9 \nMS. \n: Yes? \n10 \nMR. \n: -- leave -- are we leaving the \n11 \nbreakfast meeting? \n12 \nMS. \n: No. This is --\n13 \nTHE WITNESS Okay. \n14 \nMS. \n: -- this is directly related. \n15 \nMR. \n: Okay. \n16 \nBY MS. \n17 \nQ \nAnd that is, Exhibit 27 is the second e-mail down, \n18 \nis from \nto Jay Lefkowitz. The date is October \n19 \n12, so that's the same day as your breakfast. \n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \nAnd the date of it is not \nI'm sorry, the time is \n22 \n9:48 a.m. Your breakfast was at 7:00. So, this would have \n23 \nbeen pretty shortly after your breakfast, and \nwrites \n24 \nto Jay Lefkowitz with a copy to you and \n25 \nstating that he just got off the phone with you, that is, \nEFTA00009126\n", "char_count": 1053}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "1 S \nPage 311 \njust got off the phone with you, and then he furnishes \n2 \na revised paragraph one, which suggests -- I mean, I infer \n3 \nfrom that that shortly after the breakfast, you had a phone \n4 \nconversation with i \na \nabout a revision to this \n5 \nparagraph, and that -- that that was likely something that \n6 \nyou talked to him about. Again, I'm not --\n7 \n8 \n9 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- suggesting that this --\nA \nAgain, I -- I don't -- I don't recall the \n10 \nbreakfast, so I can't say one way or the other. I -- I \n11 \ntake -- I take your point. I don't recall seeing this. \n12 \nQ \nAll right. Well, it was --\n13 \nA \nBut --\n14 \nQ \n-- you were copied on it. Okay. All right. \n15 \nyou wanted to --\n16 \nBY MR. \n17 \nQ \nI just wanted to point to Exhibit 30. \n18 \nA \nCan -- can we back up a second? \n19 \nMS. \n: Sure. \n20 \nTHE WITNESS \n, I'm not sure whether your \n21 \nconcerns are -- so, I would -- I would only raise the \n22 \nquestion where -- or, the point where, based on this, and I \n23 \ndon't recall, so I can't speak, but \nis saying, Jay \n24 \nsuggests revision has been rejected. Here is our latest, \n25 \nEFTA00009127\n", "char_count": 1118}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Page 312 \n1 \nAnd so, to -- there are multiple ways to read this. \n2 \nOne is that this was raised. Another is that we're rejecting \n3 \nsomething that Jay had proposed, and --\n4 \n5 \nMS. \n: Mm-hmm. \nTHE WITNESS -- because I was meeting with Jay, I \n6 \nasked that \nnot reject it until after I met with him, and \n7 \nI -- I'm speculating, because I don't recall the topic, but \n8 \nit does appear that it says, Jay suggested revision has been \n9 \nrejected. Here is our latest. \n10 \nMS. \n: All right. Thank you. \n11 \nBY MR. \n12 \nQ \nCan we just go to Exhibit 30 quickly? There's some \n13 \nhighlighted language. This is a letter from Lefkowitz to you \n14 \non October 23rd, 2007, where he recounts, again, the things \n15 \nthat happened, or his version of the October 12th breakfast \n16 \nmeeting. \n17 \nA \nYes. \n18 \nQ \nAre you at that --\n19 \nA \nYes. \n20 \nQ \n-- at that point right there, Exhibit 30? \n21 \nA \nYeah, I'm there. \n22 \nQ \nOkay. So, in the highlighted language, if you \n23 \ncould just take a look at that quickly? \n24 \nA \nYes. \n25 \nQ \nSo, he is recounting that you had assured him that \nEFTA00009128\n", "char_count": 1097}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "1 \nEVEN/NG \nSESSION \n2 \n6:00 P.M. \n3 \nthe office would not intervene with the state's attorney's \n4 \noffice, and -- or contact the civil claimants, or intervene \nS \nregarding the sentence that Epstein receives pursuant to a \n6 \nplea agreement. \n11 \nQ \nSo, is he correct in his recounting that? \nA \nCan you -- can you find that for me? \nQ \nYeah. \nA \nSo, again, I don't have an independent \n12 \nrecollection. Oh, no, I'm looking --\n13 \nMS. \n: Oh, you have it. \n14 \nTHE WITNESS -- for something -- I don't have an \n15 \nindependent recollection of that breakfast, but in the \n16 \ncontemporaneous e-mails and the contemporaneous record, there \n17 \nis correspondence between -- between \nand I, and you all \n18 \nasked for this, and I \nI spoke with my counsel, who then \n19 \nresponded, and there's an e-mail exchange where there's an \n20 \nOctober 20 -- this was an October 23rd e-mail -- October 23rd \n21 \nletter. \n22 \nAnd then there is a response that's drafted on \n23 \nOctober 25th. I don't know if we can find that. From \n24 \nto Jay that specifically addresses the point, and then I \n25 \nrespond -- \nruns that by me, and I respond -- I edit the \nEFTA00009129\n", "char_count": 1154}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Page 314 \n1 \nletter, and I move it -- I sort of emphasize -- like, I make \n2 \nit firmer, and my edit says our office cannot and will not \n3 \nagree to this, and then my comment to\n is, what do you \n4 \nthink of this rewrite? Is it too strong? \nS \n6 \n7 \nBY MR.IIMIE: \nQ \nWhat day was that? \nA \nThat was two days after this. I don't know if we \n8 \ncan find that in the -- in the chronological record. That \n9 \nwas October 25th. Let's just take a minute. Is that what \n10 \nyou have? \n11 \nMR. \n: Sorry, apparently my ability to separate \n12 \npaper has failed. \n13 \nTHE WITNESS Okay. So, this is --\n14 \nMR. \n: Oh, I see. \n15 \nTHE WITNESS So --\n16 \nMR. \n: Sorry, go ahead. \n17 \nTHE WITNESS So, October 25th, I'm writing to \n18 \nwhat do you think of this rewrite? Is it too strong? And it \n19 \nsays, dear Jay, I'd like to take this opportunity to document \n20 \nour conversation of October 24th which clarified some of the \n21 \nrepresentations in your October 23rd letter. \n22 \nI write in particular because you indicated that \n23 \nyour intent in writing the letter was to memorialize our \n24 \nconversations. Our agreement is limited to blank, blank, \n25 \nblank, dot, dot, dot. \nEFTA00009130\n", "char_count": 1182}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Page 315 \n1 \nI specifically want to clarify one of the items \n2 \nthat I believe was inaccurate in the October 23rd letter. \n3 \nYour office claims that this office would not intervene with \n4 \nthe state attorney's office regarding this matter, or contact \n5 \nany of the individuals, potential witnesses, or potential \n6 \ncivil claimants, and their respective counsel in this matter, \n7 \nand neither your office nor the FBI would intervene regarding \n8 \nthe sentence Mr. Epstein received. \n9 \nI'm quoting Jay's letter. As we discussed and \n10 \nhopefully clarified, and as the U.S. Attorney previously \n11 \nexplained in an earlier conference call, such promises equate \n12 \nto the imposition of a gag order. Our office cannot and will \n13 \nnot agree to this. It is the intent of this office to treat \n14 \nthis matter like any other case. \n15 \nThus, as is typical, we do not desire or intend to \n16 \n\"intervene\" the state attorney's office. The non-prosecution \n17 \nagreement provides sufficient mechanisms to achieve the goals \n18 \nof the federal investigation. You should understand, \n19 \nhowever, that there are some communications that are typical \n20 \nin these matters. \n21 \nAnd so, I go on, and so my point is this was \n22 \npretty -- based on -- if you reviewed my -- my e-mails and \n23 \nlanguage, for me to write something up saying, what do you \n24 \nthink of this rewrite, is it too strong? \n25 \nQ \nMist-hmm. \nEFTA00009131\n", "char_count": 1427}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Page 31E \n1 \nA \nAnd to edit \nlanguage to, our office cannot \n2 \nand will not agree to this, is not my agreeing with this \n3 \ncharacterization, but my polite way of saying, this ain't \n4 \nwhat I said. \n5 \nQ \nMn-hmm. \n6 \nA \nLet me be clear. \n7 \nQ \nAnd then --\n8 \nA \nAgain, no independent recollection. This is just \n9 \nbased on inferring from the contemporaneous e-mails. \n0 \nQ \nOkay. \n1 \nBY MS. \nWhat I would like to do is ask a couple of \nquestions in a couple of areas about the main justice review. \nQ \nThen take a short break, and then \nhas some \n6 \nquestions that are CVRA related, and then we have some \nsummary questions. \n8 \nA \n9 \nQ \nIs that all right? \n20 \nA \nCan I -- before you -- you move on, can I address \n21 \nsomething that \nwas getting at, but it's getting late, \n22 \nso I'm going to circle back to -- to --\n23 \nQ \nPlease. \n24 \nA \n-- something that I thought you would bring up. \n25 \nMS. \n: Sure. \nEFTA00009132\n", "char_count": 926}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Page 317 \n1 \nTHE WITNESS So, I think something to talk about \n2 \nis, pre-agreement and post-agreement, I think are different, \n3 \nand one concern that I had, and I certainly shared with --\n4 \nwith Mr.e \nwas once it was signed -- so, we had the \n5 \ninitial issues with the case. \n6 \nOnce the agreement was signed, we now have an \n7 \noverlying issue of, is there \nis the agreement binding? To \n8 \nwhat extent it's binding. And so, you -- your question was, \n9 \nwhy this level of process after the agreement was signed, and \n10 \nI said I think you'll get back to that. And I think to some \n11 \nextent, there are two parts to that. \n12 \nOne is, the office shouldn't be afraid of review. \n13 \nWe're part of the Department of Justice, and review, whether \n14 \nit by main justice or now you all, is -- is part of the \n15 \nprocess. \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \ncriminal case, but we're litigating a civil/criminal issue on \n22 \ntop of that, which is, did the agreement bind? And that's \n23 \nsomething that did inform the exhausting amount of process \n24 \nthat they -- that they received, which didn't change any of \n25 \nthe outcome. \nAnd so, to the extent that they want to appeal to \nmain, it would be unseemly to sort of say, don't review us, \nand I don't think it would help reviewing this, but the \nsecond part of it is if we were to walk away from the \nagreement, that not only are we litigating the underlying \nEFTA00009133\n", "char_count": 1418}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Page \nBY MS. \n2 \nQ \nDidn't bind what? \n3 \nA \nSo, if we were to walk away, were -- could we still \n4 \nprosecute? \n5 \nQ \nI see. \n6 \nA \nRight? Because having signed that, we were now \n7 \nparties to an agreement, and that would overlay any sort of \n8 \nprosecution. And So, you had these collateral issues coming. \n9 \nBY MS. \n10 \nQ \nJust to make sure we're clear, are you saying that \n11 \nthere is -- there would have been difficulty in declaring a \n12 \nbreach so that you could then indict? \n13 \nA \nCorrect, and so we'd have to litigate over a \n14 \nbreach, because as much as they had collateral challenges, \n15 \nthey are very careful in saying, this is not a breach, we \n16 \nwould just like review. \n17 \nAnd so, one of the issues that overlaid the post --\n18 \nthe October going forward time period is on top of this, do \n19 \nwe now want litigation over a breach? And so, I think that \n20 \nis why the post-agreement time period is different than the \n21 \npre-agreement --\n22 \nMS. \nMm-hmm. \n23 \nTHE WITNESS -- time period. \n24 \nBY MS. \n25 \nQ \nBut was part of that problem the result of the \nEFTA00009134\n", "char_count": 1099}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "change from, here is the date that you must comply, to, you \n2 \nmust use best efforts to comply? \n3 \nA \nPossibly. I would -- whether it was that, or \n4 \nothers, or other parts of the agreement, we can talk about, \n5 \nbut how -- once the agreement was signed, and they do not --\n6 \nand they start pushing the date, there becomes a legal issue \n7 \nover, are they really in breach or not? \n8 \nAnd I'm not -- I understand your perspective. I'm \n9 \njust saying, you know, earlier I said that there was a \n10 \ndifference. You asked about the process, and I said from my \n11 \nperspective, there's a difference between the pre-agreement \n12 \nand the post-agreement time period. \n13 \nAnd much of that difference is informed by, if we \n14 \ndeclare a unilateral breach, how does this hold up in court? \n15 \nBecause now there's a signed agreement that the United States \n16 \nis a party to. \n17 \nQ \nAnd are you saying that part of the reason, or \n18 \nmaybe all of the reason that you continued to give \n19 \naccommodations and process and delay was because of the \n20 \nconcern that you couldn't actually win a breach argument? \n21 \nA \nI think that was a consideration. Another part of \n22 \nthe considerations are if someone -- if a party wants to \n23 \ntake -- I mean, main justice gave a lot of process. It \n24 \nwasn't -- it wasn't, you know, it wasn't just to -- to \n25 \nbut it was up to the -- it was just up to the assistant \nEFTA00009135\n", "char_count": 1428}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Page 32C \n1 \nattorney general for criminal division, to be polite, but it \n2 \nwas up to the DAG. \n3 \nAnd so, if main justice is going to give this \n4 \ndegree of process, we should -- we should be in the position \n5 \nof saying go forward, as opposed to, I don't think it looks \n6 \npositive for the office to be viewed as fearing department \n7 \nreview. \n8 \nQ \nBut were you giving the impression to the \n9 \nDepartment of Justice that you were the one who wanted this \n10 \nreview so that they felt like, well, it's not just these \ndefense attorneys who we can blow off, it is an United States \nAttorney who is asking for this review, and so therefore we \n13 \nneed to give the courtesy of reviewing this? \n14 \nA \nI don't think I asked for it as opposed to saying, \n15 \nif you would -- so, from the very beginning, they said that \n16 \nthey're going to take this to the Deputy Attorney General and \n17 \nAttorney General. \n18 \nAnd I said, if you want to, fine. They just \n19 \nfinally did, but that was not -- that was not -- I think they \n20 \nraised that as early as August or September. And so, I'm not \n21 \nsurprised that it ended up there. I also thought it was \n22 \nimportant to not be in the position of fearing review. \n23 \nthink if you look at the contemporaneous record, there's an \n24 \neffort on our part to expedite the review. \n25 \nBY MS. \nEFTA00009136\n", "char_count": 1356}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Page 321 \n1 \nQ \nBut there's a difference between, have at it, go, \n2 \ndo what you want, up at main, and getting that --\n3\n \nRight. \n4 \nQ \n-- that non-opposition, and actually sending a \n5 \nsignal to -- in the -- in the case of the criminal division, \n6 \nthe assistant attorney general, in the case of the DAG's \n7 \noffice, Mark Filip or his assignee, that you supported their \n8 \nreview, that the -- this appeal process. You could have \n9 \nsaid, look, we're going to go ahead and get on with our \n10 \nbusiness. \n11 \nIf they want to -- if -- you could have not so much \n12 \nopposed a review, but not seconded their request for -- the \n13 \ndefense request for reviews, or not in fact invited the \n14 \nreviews. \n15 \nA \nSo, I'd be curious as to the timeline. I would \n16 \ntake issue with, I invited the reviews, and I question \n17 \nwhether, did they initiate the reviews on their own, and then \n18 \nI said have at it, or did I -- based on -- I mean, you've got \n19 \nmore of a record than I do, or did I invite -- I don't -- I \n20 \nwould say I did not invite the reviews. \n21 \nQ \nWell, let me -- bad terminology, perhaps. Let me \n22 \nask you this. If -- would've -- did you convey to the \n23 \ncriminal division that you wanted them to review this matter, \n24 \nas requested by the defense attorneys? \n25 \nA \nSo, from my perspective, I'm thinking back 12 --\nEFTA00009137\n", "char_count": 1364}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Page 322 \n1 \nQ \nMin-hmm. \n2 \nA \n-- 12 years now. The very reason that we invited \n3 \nto come down to Miami back in August was a sense that it \n4 \nwould end up up here. And so, if it's going to end up up \n5 \nhere, let's bring \ndown. \n6 \nLet's make him part of the initial meeting. You \n7 \nknow, if there are concerns, let's raise these. Let's \n8 \naddress them. Let's get them out so that we don't end up, \n9 \nafter we go forward with all of this, back in front of \n10 \nand \nAnd it's much better to involve main justice \n11 \nearlier. \n12 \nAnd so, I would say I was trying, if anything, \n13 \nto \nto involve main justice so that we didn't end up where \n14 \nwe were, and it had been my expectation that that October \n15 \ndate would have been met. \n16 \nThe collateral reviews afterwards, the collateral \n17 \nappeals, obviously did not go as -- as we planned, and -- and \n18 \nit was my sense, we were going to end up at main justice one \n19 \nway or another. \n20 \nQ \nSo, my question is in December, after the December \n21 \nmeeting --\n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \n-- that you had with defense counsel, and they told \n24 \nyou they were going to go to main justice. \n25 \nA \nCorrect. \nEFTA00009138\n", "char_count": 1179}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Page 323 \n1 \nQ \nTo the criminal division. Did you convey to main \n2 \njustice criminal division that you wanted them to conduct the \n3 \nreview that defense counsel were seeking? \n4 \nA \nSo, I don't recall what I may or may not have \n5 \nconveyed. I think my recollection was, if they want a \n6 \nreview, that's their right. We're not -- as a department, \n7 \nwe're not in the business of telling individuals that they \n8 \ncan't take something to your supervisor, or your superior. \n9 \nWhether -- whether main justice takes this on or not is \n10 \nultimately at their discretion. \n11 \nQ \nWould it surprise you to learn that the criminal \n12 \ndivision front office understood you to be requesting their \n13 \nreview, the review that was sought by defense counsel? \n14 \nA \nWould it surprise me? Perhaps. My -- my -- my \n15 \nunderstanding -- recollection is we shouldn't fear it. If \n16 \nthey want it --\n17 \nQ \nmm-hmm. \n18 \nA \n-- that's their right. I thought by inviting \n19 \ndown in the first place that we had at least tried to address \n20 \nthat early on, but I also thought that we might end up there \n21 \nin the first place. \n22 \nQ \nWere you -- were you aware that a decision was made \n23 \nto grant the decision by your office to grant defense \n24 \ncounsel's request \ntheir insistence that \n25 \nrole in the criminal division review be limited to review \nEFTA00009139\n", "char_count": 1361}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Page 324 \n1 \nonly, and that he not be permitted to -- or that the criminal \n2 \ndivisions -- that the -- I'm sorry, I misspoke. That because \n3 \nIIIMINIMIllhad already been involved in essentially \n4 \nbeing a prosecutor on the case --\n5 \nA \nRight. \n6 \nQ \n-- that the -- the criminal division and CEOs' role \n7 \nvis a vis this review should be review only. That is, they \n8 \nshould be taken off the case as a -- as a partner? \n9 \nA \nSo, I sought e-mails to that affect in the record. \n10 \nI don't have an independent recollection 12 years --\n11 \nQ \nyou --\n12 \nA \n13 \nQ \nDo you think you were involved in that decision? \n14 \nA \nTo take them off? \n15 \nQ \nYes. \n16 \nA \nTo my recollection, I wanted them on as a partner, \n17 \nand I think the contemporaneous --\n18 \nQ \nME-hmm. \n19 \nA \n-- e-mails from \nis, can you please come on \n20 \nboard? \n21 \nQ \nBut that was earlier, before this review process? \n22 \nA \nNo. No. Even after the --\n23 \nQ \nAll right. \n24 \nA \n-- review process, I think there are \n25 \ncontemporaneous e-mails where we're saying it's important \nEFTA00009140\n", "char_count": 1066}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Page 325 \n1 \nthat you be part. If we go to trial, it's important that you \n2 \nbe part of the trial. As I -- as I went through the record, \n3 \nat least I remember --\n4 \nQ \nMe-hmm. \n5 \nA \n-- an e-mail, perhaps from \nto \nthat I'm \n6 \ncopied on saying, hey, can you reconsider? It's important \n7 \nthat you be part of this. \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \nQ \nReconsider the review only limitation? \nA \nNo, no. Reconsider being a part of the trial \nQ \nOh. All right. \nA \n-- team. \nQ \nAll right. \nSo, to be clear, do I understand that \n13 \nyou -- correct me, that you don't have a recollection one way \n14 \nor the other whether you requested the criminal division to \n15 \nconduct the review, or could it have happened, or --\n16 \nA \nSo --\n17 \nQ \n-- what? \n18 \nA \n-- to the extent I -- again, I'm going back --\n19 \nQ \nNm-hmm. \n20 \nA \n-- 12 years. To the extent there is a request to, \n21 \nit would be in the context of, this is going to Washington. \n22 \nWe're not fearful of this. Have at it. \n23 \nQ \nAnd you would have conveyed that to Washington? \n24 \nNot just to the defense attorneys, is that correct? \n25 \nA \nI imagine in some way. It's --\nEFTA00009141\n", "char_count": 1136}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Page 326 \n1 \n5 \nQ \nAll right. \nBY MS. \nQ \nAnd just one --\nA \nYeah. \nQ \n-- just one point. This one -- this one was a \n6 \nlittle bit of an --\n7 \nA \nYeah. \n8 \nQ \n-- odd posture, however, because you had a signed \n9 \nagreement. And so, you know, basically a contract between \n10 \nparties --\n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \n-- and particularly on Mr. Epstein's side, a party \n13 \nwho was -- who was extremely well represented. So, was there \n14 \nany consideration on your part, instead of saying, hey, \n15 \neverybody's got a right to review, knock yourself out, go up \n16 \nto Washington, as opposed to saying something like, that ship \n17 \nhas sailed, guys. You signed this agreement. We're going \n18 \nforward. You don't go forward. You're in breach. End of \n19 \nstory? \n20 \nA \nSo, his counsel are raising serious issues that go \n21 \nto ethics and go to fundamental relationships between \n22 \nsovereigns. Is this 22.55 appropriate as a matter of federal \n23 \npolicy? Is what we're doing an overreach, you know, is what \n24 \nwe're doing contrary to law? Are we extracting -- I'm \n25 \ncharacterizing. This may or may not \nEFTA00009142\n", "char_count": 1119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Page 327 \n1 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n2 \nA \n-- be accurate. Are we extracting unduly? Are we \n3 \nusing criminal law to extract civil concessions in an \n4 \nethically suspect way? Those are serious issues. That isn't \n5 \njust, is this a good case? \n6 \nThose are -- those are genuine issues. I happen to \n7 \nthink that, as I recall, that we were in the right or we \n8 \nwouldn't have agreed to it, but by the same token, let's \n9 \nassume that main justice ultimately disagreed. Is that from \n10 \na main justice perspective? And maybe I'm coming at this \n11 \nfrom a -- you know, being informed by having been at main \n12 \njustice. \n13 \nQ \nmm-hmm. \n14 \nA \nWhere there was talk about, can you believe what \n15 \nthis AUSA -- this AUSA may have done or may not have done \n16 \nwithout consulting, that these are serious issues. They \n17 \nestablish precedent. \n18 \nThey -- you know, maybe the DAG would have said, \n19 \nthis is not the kind of thing we'd support, and this is \n20 \nwrong. And so, at the end of the day, let's move forward, \n21 \nbut if -- once these issues are raised, I don't think a U.S. \n22 \nAttorney should say main justice should not review this. \n23 \nI think we're part of one department, and these are \n24 \nvalid issues. Main justice doesn't need to take months to \n25 \nreview this. Main justice can expedite their review, but \nEFTA00009143\n", "char_count": 1338}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Page 328 \n1 \nthose are valid issues for the deputy and the AAG to review. \n2 \nQ \nBut one could look at it and say, well, those are \n3 \nall issues that the defense certainly knew about before they \n4 \nsigned that agreement, and having signed the agreement, they \n5 \nare waiving all of that. That's what contracts are for. \n6 \nYou've got all these issues, don't sign the contract. \n7 \nA \nAnd if I could, I think there's a December letter. \n8 \nI don't know if it's -- if it's in the exhibits, but there's \n9 \na December letter that I wrote that, for me, is --\n10 \nQ \nThis is the 19th? \n11 \nA \nMaybe it's the 19th. Let me --\n12 \nQ \nOr the --\n13 \nM . \nThe 19th is the -- your sort of \n14 \nill-fated NPA addendum effort. \n15 \nTHE WITNESS No. No, a letter to -- to Ken Starr \n16 \nthat I -- that I wrote. But --\n17 \nMR. \n: The 4th letter is to Ken Starr. \n18 \nTHE WITNESS I'm sorry? \n19 \nMR. \n: Is it the December 4th letter? \n20 \nTHE WITNESS Yeah, it's probably --\n21 \nMR. \n: December 4? \n22 \nTHE WITNESS It's the December 4th. \n23 \nMS. \n: Yeah, it didn't have a date. \n24 \nMS. \n: All right. That's the one you \n25 \nwrote --\nEFTA00009144\n", "char_count": 1131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Page 329 \n1 \nTHE WITNESS So --\n2 \nMS. \n: -- to him --\n3 \nTHE WITNESS -- so --\n4 \nMS. \n: -- in response to the --\n5 \nTHE WITNESS So --\n6 \nMS. \n-- 22.55 issue. \n7 \nTHE WITNESS I think, you know, I -- you know, I'm \n8 \nstarting on page four. I have responded personally in some \n9 \ndetail to your concerns because I care deeply about both the \n10 \nlaw and the integrity of this office. I have responded \n11 \npersonally and in detail as well, because your letter \n12 \ntroubled me on a number of levels. Upon your understanding \n13 \nof the negotiations are. The 22.55 was first discussed July \n14 \n31st. \n15 \nYou know, and one of these four points in -- in the \n16 \nmiddle of 2007, your defense team decides -- asked to meet \n17 \nwith me. On September 7th, I met. After considering of the \n18 \narguments, and after conferring with FBI and \n19 \nour office decided to proceed with the indictment. At that \n20 \ntime, I offered to delay -- our prosecutors to delay \n21 \npresentation to allow you to appeal our decision if you \n22 \nchoose. You chose not to. \n23 \nInstead, you elected to enter into the NPA. Since \n24 \nthe signing of this agreement, the feds in our office have \n25 \naddressed several issues that have arisen, although the \nEFTA00009145\n", "char_count": 1242}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Page 330 \n1 \nexchanges at the time were a bit litigious. \n2 \nBY MS. \n3 \nQ \nThis -- could I -- could I thought point out --\n4 \ni•. \nYeah. \n5 \nQ \n-- that this letter is in response to not the at \n6 \nthe request for a review by the criminal division, that comes \n7 \nlater. This is in response to Ken Starr's letter to \n8 \nabout -- raising 22.55 -- 22.55 issues that had not \n9 \nbeen raised with you before. \n10 \nA \nRight, which is -- which is in essence a review. \n11 \nmean, he -- they're coming to main justice, and you know, \n12 \nit's against these many previous foregone opportunities to \n13 \nobject that I receive with surprise your letter requesting an \n14 \n11th hour after the fact review of our agreement. Although \n15 \nit happens rarely, I don't mind this office's decision being \n16 \nappealed to Washington, and have previously directed our \n17 \nprosecutors to delay. \n18 \nIndeed, I'm confident in our prosecutor's evidence \n19 \nand legal analysis. I nonetheless \n20 \ndirected them to consult with subject matter experts in the \n21 \ncriminal CEOS division to confer to our interpretation of the \n22 \nlaw before proceeding with this indictment. So, I guess, you \n23 \nknow, we consulted CEOS. \n24 \nI'm thus surprised to read a letter addressed to \n25 \nthe department headquarters that raises issues that either \nEFTA00009146\n", "char_count": 1329}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Page 331 \n1 \nhave not been raised with this office previously, or have \n2 \nbeen raised and in fact resolved in your client's favor. \n3 \nI'm troubled likewise by the apparent lack of \n4 \nfinality in this agreement. The AUSAs have been negotiating \n5 \nwith defense counsel and have for sometimes complained to me \n6 \nregarding the tactics used by the defense team. It appears \n7 \nto them that as soon as resolution is reached on one issue, \n8 \ndefense counsel finds ways to challenge the resolution \n9 \ncollaterally. \n10 \nQ \nSo, this is your protest of, it sounds like Starr's \n11 \neffort to bypass you and go to \nwith new issues? \n12 \nA \nIt is, and I'm pushing back in that, was I inviting \n13 \nthis, or was I sort of saying -- you know, that said, there \n14 \nmust be some closure on this matter. \n15 \nSome in our office are deeply concerned that \n16 \ndefense counsel will continue to mount collateral challenges \n17 \nto provisions of this agreement, even after Mr. Epstein has \n18 \nentered his guilty plea and thus rendered the agreement \n19 \ndifficult, if not impossible to unwind. In closing, I ask \n20 \nthat you consult with co-counsel. \n21 \nIf after consultation with your defense team you \n22 \nbelieve that our agreement is unethical, unlawful, or \n23 \nunconstitutional, I'd ask us that you notify us immediately \n24 \nso we can discuss the matter by phone or in person. I've \n25 \nconsulted the chief prosecutor in this case who has advised \nEFTA00009147\n", "char_count": 1459}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Page 332 \n1 \nme that she's ready to unwind the agreement and proceed to \n2 \ntrial if necessary, or appropriate. \n3 \nQ \nSo, are you suggesting that this represents your \n4 \nprotest of their appeal to \n5 \nA \nSo \no' \nQ\n-- on this point? \n7 \nA \nSo, protest is a \nis a loaded word. What I'm \n8 \nsuggesting is, this is not an invitation to appeal to main \n9 \njustice. This is sort of saying, enough is enough is enough. \n10 \nQ \nBut Mr. Acosta, in fairness, this, to clarify --\n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \n-- this is in response to a letter directed to \n13 \ndated November 28th --\n14 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- 2007 raising issues that he had not raised with \n16 \nyou. The appeal subsequently that I was asking about was --\n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \nQ \n-- an appeal for a de novo review -- a de novo \n19 \nreview of the whole case. \n20 \nA \nUnderstood, and my -- the reason that I -- that I \n21 \nread this, you know, is this is not -- on the one hand, I'm \n22 \nsaying we do not fear review, but I don't -- this is not an \n23 \ninvitation to defense counsel to do a de novo -- I am not \n24 \ninviting them. I'm not saying, let's have more review. I'm \n25 \nsaying, enough's enough. If they appeal, that's fine, but \nEFTA00009148\n", "char_count": 1194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Page 333 \n1 \nthis is not an invitation to appeal. \n2 \nQ \nBut there was nothing you could do to stop their \n3 \nappeal, right? Except indict? \n4 \nA \nAnd so the department shouldn't stop an appeal to \nmain justice by -- you know, by threatening. \n6 \nQ \nFair enough. \n7 \nA \nBecause main justice has a right to review. \n8 \nQ \nI should have said that -- that this -- that this \n9 \nappeal process was stymying progress in resolving the Epstein \n10 \ncase. \n11 \nA \nIt was. \n12 \nQ \nAnd you had no way -- you had no recourse, other \n13 \nthan, at least theoretically, you could have just said, you \n14 \nknow, we're --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- going to tear it up and indict, because you're \n17 \nin breach, in effect. \n18 \nA \nWhich would have raised civil litigation --\n19 \nQ \nLitigation. \n20 \nA \n-- overlays, which is the point that I thought \n21 \nmerited --\n22 \nQ \nAll right. \n23 \nA \n-- at least flushing out. \n24 \nBY MS. \n: \n25 \nQ \nSo, short of the department itself getting a move \nEFTA00009149\n", "char_count": 986}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Page 334 \n1 \non, and getting this thing through expeditiously, did you \n2 \nfeel like you just had to sit there and wait for everything \n3 \nto get done? \n4 \nA \nI'm not sure sit there and wait, but -- but \n5 \nultimately, the case did not get better with time, and there.\n6 \nwas frustration on our apart about, you know, the witnesses \n7 \nare not getting better. You know, time \n8 \nQ \nThey're getting older. \n9 \nA \nThey're getting -- which goes back to how a juror \n10 \nmay see them. \n11 \nMS. \n: Right. \n12 \nTHE WITNESS And I do recall conversations of their \n13 \ngetting older, you know, this case is not getting better. We \n14 \nnow have the civil overlay that we need to deal with. And \n15 \nso, yes, that -- there was process, but while there was, \n16 \nshould we just call it a day, all of that factored into, \n17 \nwell, if the department is reviewing the department is \n18 \nreviewing. \n19 \nBY MS. \n20 \nQ \nOkay. Are you -- what is your view of whether the \n21 \ncriminal division's review encompassed the NPA itself? \n22 \nA \nSo, the criminal division, by its terms, did not \n23 \ndid not encompass the -- the NPA. I would say that's \n24 \ndifferent than the deputy's review that encompassed the \n25 \ntotality of the -- of the circumstances. \nEFTA00009150\n", "char_count": 1251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Page 335 \n1 \nQ \nOkay. Did you discuss the -- did you have \n2 \nconversations with the DAG -- with Mark Filip about this \n3 \ncase? \n4 \nA \nNot to my recollection. \n5 \nQ \nOkay, and we've already talked about the submission \n6 \nthat\n made on behalf of your office? \n7 \nA \nWhich -- which -- yes, which I thought was a \n8 \nfulsome submission, and included the draft indictment, the \n9 \nNPA. I believe it included the term sheet and other \n10 \ndocuments. \n11 \nQ \nDid you or anyone else to your knowledge ask ODAG \n12 \nto review or assess the NPA, or approve it? \n13 \nA \nNot to -- before signature, not to my recollection, \n14 \nbut it was part of the ultimate review when \nsubmitted \n15 \nthe matter to the deputy, he included the --\n16 \nQ \nIt was --\n17 \nA \n-- the agreement. \n18 \nQ \nIt was included. Their very brief letter, you \n19 \nremember --\n20 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n21 \nQ \n-- the letter that \n22 \nA \nYes. \n23 \nQ \n-- authored, that he authored. Addressed really \n24 \nonly the issue of the appropriateness of the case for \n25 \nprosecution in your office. It did not in any way reference \nEFTA00009151\n", "char_count": 1086}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Page 336 \n1 \nthe disposition, the plea agreement, or the NPA. \n2 \nA \nSo -- so, it was a brief letter. Based on \n3 \nsubmission, I would have read that letter as, they had all \n4 \nthe material in front of them, and they were saying that \n5 \nthere was no misconduct or abuse of discretion. \n6 \nQ \nThat's correct, but they did not say that they \n7 \ncontacted -- that they addressed or assessed, reviewed even. \n8 \nThey didn't say they reviewed or approved the NPA. \n9 \nA \nThey -- I again, you know, I -- if the letter is \n10 \nhere, I don't know, but --\n11 \nQ \nYeah. I have it right here. It's not marked as an \n12 \nexhibit, but this is an \nletter to Jay Lefkowitz and \n13 \nKen Starr dated --\n14 \nA \nRight. \n15 \nQ \n-- June 23, 2008 It states that this office, \n16 \nmeaning the Office of the Deputy Attorney General, has \n17 \ncompleted a thorough review of the U.S. Attorney's handling \n18 \nof the matter involving your client. \n19 \nA \nAnd --\n20 \nQ \nAnd addresses the -- or, states that they've \n21 \nreceived and reviewed submissions from both parties, and then \n22 \nstates that the deputy attorney general, \"Will intervene only \n23 \nin the most unusual of circumstances,\" in a U.S. Attorney's \n24 \nmatter, and, \"we do not believe such intervention is \n25 \nwarranted here. Even if we were to substitute our judgement \nEFTA00009152\n", "char_count": 1325}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Page 337 \n1 \nfor that of the U.S. Attorney, we believe that federal \n2 \nprosecution of this case is appropriate. Moreover, having \n3 \nreviewed your allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, and \n4 \nthe facts underlying them, we see nothing in the conduct of \n5 \nthe U.S. Attorney's Office that gives us any reason to \n6 \nalter,\" --\n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \nQ \n-- \"our opinion.\" \n9 \nA \nAnd so, so, if I could point out, this office has \n10 \ncompleted a thorough review of the U.S. Attorney's handling \n11 \nof the matter. And so, handling is a broad -- is a broad \n12 \nterm, and in reference to, we believe that federal \n13 \nprosecution of this case is appropriate, the way I recalled \n14 \nreading that is, the federal prosecution of this case, the \n15 \nargument was that the agreement was inappropriate because \n16 \nthis case should not have even been prosecuted, and therefore \n17 \nthat the disposition -- the federal prosecution of this case, \n18 \nwas appropriate. \n19 \nAnd so, the handling of the matter, we reviewed the \n20 \nhandling of the matter, not -- not the agreement, but the \n21 \nhandling of the matter, and that the ultimate disposition, \n22 \nif -- you know, is at least not an abuse of discretion, or is \n23 \nappropriate. \n24 \nQ \nThat's how you read it? \n25 \nA \nThat -- that is how I read it. \nEFTA00009153\n", "char_count": 1311}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Page 338 \n1 \nQ \nAnd did you ever discuss that -- did you ever \n2 \ndiscuss with anyone in ODAG what the scope of their review \n3 \nwas? \n4 \nA \nNot to -- not to my recollection. It was a fulsome \n5 \nsubmission. \n6 \nQ \nCorrect, but if -- if -- but the issues presented \n7 \nby the defense were essentially federalism issues, right? \n8 \nA \nSo, the -- the -- again, this is -- this is based \n9 \non, you know, as much recollection as contemporaneous record. \n10 \nThe issues presented by the defense were, it -- in essence, \n11 \nit was the heart of the non-prosecution agreement, which is, \n12 \nwas it -- was it an abuse of discretion to -- to proceed in \n13 \nthis case in the way that we did on the grounds that there \n14 \nmay not -- there should not have been a federal prosecution \n15 \nin the first place, or that we were using federal criminal \n16 \nlaw to -- to elicit a civil outcome. \n17 \nAnd so, I don't think it's fair to sort of \n18 \nnarrow -- you can't -- you can't say that our handling was --\n19 \nyou know, that their handling was reviewed without reviewing \n20 \nthe non-prosecution agreement. \n21 \nQ \nDo you have any reason to believe that the -- that \n22 \neither ODAG or the criminal division did -- well, that the \n23 \nODAG, let's stick with that --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- did in fact review the NPA, other than to be \nEFTA00009154\n", "char_count": 1340}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Page 339 \n1 \naware it existed, whatever its status might have been? \n2 \nA \nSo, again, it was clearly submitted. It was \n3 \nclearly referenced. \n4 \nQ \nME-hmm. \n5 \nA \nAnd it was clearly part of the complaint. The \n6 \ncomplaint -- the heart of the complaint about our office was \n7 \nthat we were using this agreement to impose civil liability. \n8 \nAnd so, I think it is fair to infer if the complaint \n9 \nimplicates the agreement, that the agreement would have been \n10 \nreviewed. \n11 \nQ \nThat -- but that's your inference. You don't have \n12 \nany -- you don't -- didn't have any specific communications \n13 \nwith ODAG --\n14 \nA \nI don't --\n15 \nQ \n-- to that effect? \n16 \nA \nI don't recall a specific communication. \n17 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. I would like to take a short \n18 \nbreak. We're getting there. \n19 \nA \nI hear you. \n20 \nQ \nThere is --\n21 \nA \nI'm good. \n22 \nQ \n-- one area that my colleague, \nwill \n23 \ntake on --\n24 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n25 \nQ \n-- which has to do with the CVRA \nEFTA00009155\n", "char_count": 987}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Page 340 \n1 \nA \nRight. \n-- and then we have some kind of wind up questions. \n3 \nA \nOkay. \n4 \nMR. IIIIIIII Can we -- before we take a break, \n5 \ncan I just --\n6 \nMS. IIIIIIII/ \nYes. \n7 \nMR. IME \nI'll try to queue up what's going to \n8 \nbe coming next --\n9 \nTHE WITNESS Mm-hmm. \n10 \nMR. \n-- and maybe that'll help us move \n11 \nthrough it, because --\n12 \nTHE WITNESS Right. \n13 \nMR. \n-- you've been through a very long \n14 \nday. \n15 \nTHE WITNESS Yeah. \n16 \nMR. \nWe appreciate your -- the time \n17 \nyou've put into this. You've been here for quite a long \n18 \ntime. \n19 \nTHE WITNESS Well, yeah. \n20 \nBY MR. \n21 \nQ \nThe area that I want to discuss after the break has \n22 \nto do with the ultimate notification to the victims about the \n23 \nresolution of the case, the state plea, and the result of the \n24 \nfederal investigation, and there's going to be -- we have \n25 \ndocuments that are in your -- that are already marked there \nEFTA00009156\n", "char_count": 939}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Page 341 \n1 \nthat might be helpful if you take a look at a couple of them \n2 \nso we don't have to go through -- maybe during the break so \n3 \nwe don't have to go through them one by one, or I can just \n4 \ngive you a very quick overview of sort of where we're going. \n5 \n/ want to find out basically how you were getting \n6 \nfrom there -- what would be the -- the state asking for the \n7 \nU.S. Attorney's Office to make the notification to the \n8 \nvictims about the upcoming state plea that happens in \n9 \nNovember of 2007. \n10 \nThat would be document 32b, to the defense then \n11 \nfinding out that the government want to notify the victims by \n12 \nletter, and then demanding that they see the letter and have \n13 \nsome kind of comment on it. That would be document 33, an e-\n14 \nmail from Lefkowitz. \n15 \nThen we have an exchange of letters, but the one \n16 \nI'd like you to look at is document 37, which is a letter \n17 \ncoming from \nto the defense -- not now, but you know, \n18 \nduring the break. So, I want to find out how we get from \n19 \nthat document, 36, where \nis writing --\n20 \nMS. \n36. \n21 \nBY MR. \n22 \nQ \n-- as letter saying that -- citing the CVRA \n23 \nregulations saying that the government is obligated to notify \n24 \nthe victims about the resolution of the case, and attaching a \n25 \ndraft letter to the victims telling them the time and date of \nEFTA00009157\n", "char_count": 1375}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Page 342 \n1 \nthe state resolution and plea, inviting them to come. \n2 \nTo ultimately a letter from you coming on the 19th \n3 \nof December 2007, which is No. 41b agreeing to not notify the \n4 \nvictims of the state plea, and agreeing with the defense to \n5 \nhave the state be responsible for putting out that \n6 \nnotification. \n7 \nAnd then we end ultimately with a letter or draft \n8 \nletter that we have that goes out to the victims in the case \n9 \non -- after the plea in July. Well, we have the draft I'm \n10 \ngoing to show you, which comes in June, showing that the \n11 \nletter was clearly meant to be sent after the plea as per the \n12 \nagreement, and that is document number 51. \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \nA \nOkay. That's --\nQ \nSo, it's a lot to --\nA \nThat's a --\nQ \n-- unpack there. \nA \nThat's a lot to unpack. We should probably take it \n18 \na step at the time? \n19 \nQ \nYes. I just wanted to --\n20 \nA \nAll right. \n21 \nQ \n-- give you an overview, because I think that some \n22 \nof what you had mentioned earlier -- and I know -- I know \n23 \nit's --\n24 \nA \nYeah. \n25 \nQ \n-- been a long time, so --\nEFTA00009158\n", "char_count": 1109}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Page 343 \n1 \nA \nYeah. \n2 \nQ \n-- I'll try to orient you for the timelines. So, \n3 \nif you'd just have a -- I've highlighted the sections of \n4 \nthose letters that we want to talk about, and if you have a \nS \nchance while we're taking a break to look through them, that \n6 \nmay help orient you so that we're not --\n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \nQ \n-- spinning our wheels on this. I don't want to \nwaste any of your time. \nA \nFair. \nMS. \n: All right. Off the record. \n(Off the record.) \nMS. \n: All right. Back on the record. \n14 \nMR. \n: Are we back on the record? \n15 \nMS. \n: Yes. \n16 \nBY MR. \n17 \nQ \nOkay, great. So, I know I gave you a lot to unpack \n18 \nover the short break we just had. One -- basically what \n19 \nwe're trying to get to find out is how the -- your decision \n20 \nmaking process regarding the victim notification issue. So, \n21 \nmaybe if you could just give us a -- anything with your \n22 \nDecember 19th decision, could you give us an explanation \n23 \nabout how you got there? \n24 \nA \nSo, I think we should probably take this in stages. \n25 \nQ \nOkay. \nEFTA00009159\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Page 344 \n1 \nA \nAs a general matter, I recall that there was back \n2 \nand forth regarding -- after the agreement -- regarding how \n3 \nto notify the victims, and there was back and forth between \n4 \nand Jay Lefkowitz and \naround all that. \n5 \nSorry, I'm losing my voice. \n6 \nI recall that there was an issue in particular that \n7 \nwas raised that I tried to address in the letter, and I \n8 \nrecall at the end of the day, it was my impression that once \n9 \nthere was an agreement for him to plead, that there was an \n10 \nattempt by \nto provide notice to the victims, but it was \n11 \na very -- it was I think on a Friday, and he was pleading on \n12 \na Monday morning or something along those lines. \n13 \nAnd finally, I recall that the view of the office \n14 \nwas that the CVRA did not apply, and so that this was a \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \ng \nOkay. \n21 \nA \nAnd look, let me -- let me add, I -- so, I think \n22 \nit's important -- so, I came in and out of the case at \n23 \nstages, and -- and I was involved in certain aspects more \n24 \nthan others, and while we had a long discussion about the \n25 \nterms sheet and matters like that, while I was clearly \ndiscretionary balancing that included consideration of what \nimpact notification of the 22.55s would have at trial -- the \n22.55 provision, if we had to go to trial. So, we can -- we \ncan unpack that, but those are my -- my general \nrecollections. \nEFTA00009160\n", "char_count": 1412}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Page 345 \ninvolved in at least one dispute around the 22.55, the nuts \n2 \nand bolts of how victims were notified is not something that \n3 \nI have a recollection about. \n4 \nQ \nOkay. Fair. \n5 \nA \nBut we can unpack it. \n6 \nQ \nOkay. Let's start with the Exhibit 33. So, there, \n7 \nwe have an -- as you can see, it's an e-mail from Lefkowitz - \n8 \n9 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n10 \nQ \n-- to you, and to ISM, \nobjecting to the \n11 \nletter being sent to the victims, unless the defense gets to \n12 \nreview it. And later on in some of your other \n13 \ncorrespondence, you discuss that you -- you extended to the \n14 \ndefense the courtesy of allowing them to review these \n15 \nletters. Is this the genesis of that courtesy? \n16 \nA \nI can't -- I don't have a recollection as to what \n17 \nthe genesis might be. I know that there was back and forth \n18 \nbetween our office and the defense about the -- that letter. \n19 \nQ \nOkay, but as you can see on 33 that you're not on \n20 \nthe response from \nbut \ninstructs \nto \n21 \nsend the proposed letter to Lefkowitz, and --\n22 \nA \nYeah. \n23 \nQ \n-- I assume that \nwouldn't have done that had \n24 \nyou objected to it. \n25 \nA \nAgain, I don't -- I don't recall any specific \nEFTA00009161\n", "char_count": 1199}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Page 346 \n1 \nconversation. As a general matter, this is not something I \n2 \nwas getting into the weeds on unless I had to. There was a \n3 \nlot of back and forth. \n4 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n5 \nA \na \nis someone that I trusted. He was handling \n6 \nthis matter. He's incredibly experienced. I know that there \n7 \nwere concerns and issues around the impact that notification \n8 \nwould have on the witnesses. I know there were -- there were \n9 \nissues around the language, and I trusted that folks were \n10 \nworking those out. \n11 \nQ \nMm-hmm. One of the -- the criticisms that's come \n12 \npost, you know, the CVRA --\n13 \nA \nRight. \n14 \nQ \n-- litigation that's been the government allowing \n15 \nthe defense to have review of these letters, or potential \n16 \nvictim notification letters coming out of the government, and \n17 \nthat that's unusual. Have you ever -- have you had any other \n18 \ncases where you've let the defense review such documents? \n19 \nA \nI've had no other cases where I'm even aware of \n20 \nvictims being notified, because I assume it all operates \n21 \nwithout it rising to management level. \n22 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n23 \nA \nAnd so this is the first and only time that how \n24 \nindividuals are notified, to my recollection, was even in the \n25 \nexecutive suite. \nEFTA00009162\n", "char_count": 1268}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Page 347 \n1 \nQ \nMm-hmm. Isn't that usually done -- accomplished by \n2 \nalmost a computerized task? \n3 \nA \nI -- I would assume so, so yes. \n4 \nQ \nAnd it's a -- given that that's the usual way that \n5 \nnotifications are made by a victim witness specialist, who is \n6 \nusually that person? \n7 \n8 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nDo I have that right? And so, the FBI has their \n9 \nvictim witness specialist? \n10 \n11 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd your office, the U.S. Attorney's Office has \n12 \ndedicated people who do that job as well? \n13 \nA \nCorrect. \n14 \nQ \nSo, why in this case, not direct, the -- this --\n15 \nthis notification to that person to be done in the usual \n16 \ncourse, why elevate to something that the defense is going to \n17 \nbe able to review? \n18 \nA \nSo, so, I can't address the second half of that, \n19 \nbut the first half of that question, why -- why was it \n20 \nelevated? You know, I think \naddressed some of that in \n21 \nher, was it 2017 affidavit, and -- and so, we had an \n22 \nagreement that had been signed, and we also had substantial \n23 \nquestions as to whether that agreement -- whether ultimately \n24 \nJeffrey Epstein would plead in court or not. \n25 \nAnd so, one of the questions is, how do you deal \nEFTA00009163\n", "char_count": 1211}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 48, "text_content": " \n4\nPage 348 \n1 \nwith notification of a possibility, where that possibility \n2 \ncould be used to impeach potential future witnesses who are \n3 \nalso the victims, and that is a matter that was being worked \n4 \nout by the AUSAs in the office. \n5 \nQ \nAnd the -- and the impeachment is what? \n6 \nA \nAnd so, the impeachment -- and I -- I would -- : \n7 \nbelieve\n went into it in some detail, is you stand \n8 \nyou, Miss Victim, stand to gain quite a bit of money if \n9 \nthere's a conviction, correct? \n10 \nIsn't -- weren't you aware of this agreement, if we \n11 \nhave to go to trial? Weren't you aware of this agreement? \n12 \nAnd this isn't based on my recollection. This is based on \n13 \nthe \naffidavit, where she says that she had concerns \n14 \nthat the impeachment go along -- somewhere along the lines \n15 \nof, were you aware that if Mr. Epstein's convicted, you stand \n16 \nto receive substantial sums? Yes. Were you influenced by \n17 \nthis? \n18 \nAnd there was some -- according to her affidavit, \n19 \nthis isn't my independent recollection, this is according to \n20 \nher affidavit, there had already been dispositions of the \n21 \nvictims -- of at least some of the victims that raised these \n22 \nissues. And so, I do think it was a valid concern by the \n23 \nAUSAs how these notifications took place. \n24 \nQ \nOkay, but isn't that the -- that type of line of \n25 \ncross examination the same for any case where there's a super \nEFTA00009164\n", "char_count": 1436}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Page 349 \n1 \nwealthy defendant? \n2 \nA \nIt may be. The 22.55 may make it a little \n3 \ndifferent because it's automatic, but ultimately, these are \n4 \nthe judgements that line attorneys make, and as U.S. \n5 \nAttorney, I think it's appropriate to back up their judgment \n6 \nunless there was some reason for me to believe it was \n7 \nincorrect. \n8 \nQ \nWas there any thought ever to just giving the \n9 \nvictims notification that there will be a proceeding that \n10 \nwill end the federal case, just separating that in a -- maybe \n11 \na later notification about the 22.55? \n12 \nA \nI can't speak to what thought there was or was not. \n13 \nI can say around this time frame, it was far from clear that \n14 \nthere would ever be -- that Epstein would ever go into court, \n15 \nand we were thinking we may have to just go to trial, because \n16 \nthese collateral attacks keep going. \n17 \nQ \nOkay. Okay. Let's get back on track to the -- the \n18 \nquestion that I asked earlier about allowing the defense the \n19 \ncourtesy to look at these letters. Is -- can you just remind \n20 \nus again, what was -- what was the reasoning that you're --\n21 \nthat they're allowed to look at the --\n22 \nA \nSo --\n23 \nQ \n-- victim notification letters? \n24 \nA \nI can't speak to that. This is something that --\n25 \nthat \nand \nwould have handled. I think that, you \nEFTA00009165\n", "char_count": 1341}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Page 350 \n1 \nknow, I'm responsible for the office. I'm not shirking, I'm \n2 \njust saying that this is -- that this was for the most part \n3 \nwithin their wheelhouse, and not something that -- that I was \n4 \ninvolved in. I can -- I can speculate. \n5 \n6 \nQ \nSure. \nA \nThe agreement was notifying them -- the letter was \n7 \nnotifying them of certain rights in the agreement, and \n8 \ntherefore, this is a time when we weren't sure what was \n9 \nhappening with the agreement. And so, perhaps this was a way \n10 \nto -- to address some of the concerns around the 22.55. I \n11 \ndon't know. I'm just speculating. \n12 \nQ \nOkay. Let's move onto Exhibit 36. This is a \n13 \nletter that goes out to Lefkowitz under \nsignature. \n14 \nYou are cc'd on the letter. \n15 \nA \nAll right. \n16 \nQ \nAnd what he is doing is sending a draft victim \n17 \nnotification letter, which is attached as the attachment \n18 \nthere, dated December 6th, 2007. And I wanted to get your \n19 \nimpressions of -- if you go to page three of the letter, \n20 \nplease? And that -- the first little paragraph there, when \n21 \nit --\n22 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n23 \nQ \n-- refers to the Victims' Rights and Restitution \n24 \nAct, and then ultimate for the CVRA, if you could just read \n25 \nthat paragraph to yourself, please? \nEFTA00009166\n", "char_count": 1273}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Page 351 \n1 \nA \nAre you referring to paragraph 10? \n2 \nQ \nI'm sorry, I'm not on the -- I'm on the letter, \n3 \nnot -- I'm sorry, I'm on the --\n4 \nA \nOh. \n5 \nQ \n-- left -- the letter to --\n6 \nA \nSorry. \n7 \nLefkowitz, not the draft letter. This one right \n8 \nhere. \n9 \nA \nThe additionally? \n10 \nQ \nYes, additionally, pursuant to the Victims' Rights \n11 \nand Restitution Act of 1990, our office is obligated, \n12 \netcetera. \n13 \nA \nOkay. \n14 \nQ \nDo you agree with that language? That \n15 \ninterpretation of the victims' rights, as far as the \n16 \nnotification? \n17 \nA \nSo, let's -- let's sort of take this -- this one \n18 \nsentence at a time. With respect to notification of other \n19 \ninformation that we were supposed to disclose, the statute \n20 \nrequires that we provide victims with the earliest possible \n21 \nnotice of -- I -- I will assume that that is a restatement of \n22 \nthe statute. \n23 \nI don't have it in front of me, but let's assume \n24 \nthat that's a restatement of the statute. Just as in 18, \n25 \nthese sections are not limited to -- the victims, through \nEFTA00009167\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Page 352 \n1 \nthis federal -- should be appropriately informed that a non-\n2 \npros does not require to forego its legal obligation. On a \n3 \nsentence by sentence basis, I mean, do I agree, sitting here? \n4 \nSure, but I would want to sort of sit down before I gave a \n5 \nlegal opinion and spent more time with it, but --\n6 \nQ \nOkay, because coming out of your office, sort of \n7 \nthis and that -- well, let's go to the next page, page four. \n8 \nA \nYeah. \n9 \nQ \nThere is a citation to the right to confer in the \n10 \nfirst paragraph there, citing the CVRA's reasonable right to \n11 \nconfer with the attorneys of the government in this case. \n12 \nA \nOkay. \n13 \nQ \nSo, we have -- you know, it looks like to me -- I \n14 \nmean, let's --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- well, it -- it appears that there is two \n17 \nreferences to the CVRA obligations that the government has \n18 \nthat ultimately the government argues that it did not have. \n19 \nCan you explain why that is a correct interpretation? \n20 \nA \nSo, what I can say is I recall -- so, it looks like \n21 \nat least some of the victims were notified. I recall a \n22 \ndiscussion and a view that the CVRA did not require it -- it \n23 \nwas discretionary, because it wasn't -- the case had not \n24 \nindicted, so it did not attach on its terms. That doesn't \n25 \nmean that it's not something you aspire to. That just means \nEFTA00009168\n", "char_count": 1374}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Page 353 \n1 \nit wasn't legally binding. \n2 \nQ \nSo -- and in the same manner though, while the CVRA \n3 \nisn't legally binding, it also doesn't prevent you from \n4 \nnotifying the victims, does it? \nS \nA \nIt does not, no. \n6 \nQ \nAnd you have the discretion to notify, should you \n7 \nchoose to. \n8 \nA \nCorrect. \n9 \nQ \nOkay. And so, if you look at the letter that's \n10 \nattached to this, this is a draft that goes out where on page \n11 \none -- two -- page three of the letter, and the second to \n12 \nlast paragraph, the letter is giving notice of Mr. Epstein's \n13 \nchange of plea and sentencing that will occur on -- well, at \n14 \nthis time, it was December 14th at 2007, and it gives the \n15 \naddress, and it says underneath there you are entitled to be \n16 \npresent and make a statement under oath. \n17 \nIf you choose, you can submit a written statement \n18 \nunder oath, etcetera, etcetera. So, this is a letter that's \n19 \nactively inviting victims to come to the state. Would you \n20 \nagree that that's inviting victims to come to the state plea? \n21 \nA \nThat -- I think that's fair. \n22 \nQ \nAnd with the letter's reasoning that the government \n23 \nis sending -- would like to send this letter because it \n24 \nbelieves it's obligated to, because it resolves the federal \n25 \ncase? \nEFTA00009169\n", "char_count": 1296}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Page 354 \nA \nSo, I -- I don't want to speak to the reasoning, \n2 \nbut it's clearly a draft that the government is saying, it \n3 \nintends to send. \n4 \nQ \nOkay. Now, ultimately, just this is not a \n5 \nquestion, just --\n6 \nA \nGot it. \n7 \nQ \n-- some information that will help to move us \n8 \nalong. \n9 \nA \nRight. \n10 \nQ \nThe -- obviously, this letter is never sent. Ms. \n11 \ndrafts, we have them, and I'm not going to show \n12 \nthem to you, 30 letters, copies of the letter \n13 \nA \nRight. \n14 \nQ \n-- to different victims, addresses them, puts them \n15 \nin envelopes, and is then told not to send the letters. \n16 \nA \nAll right. Well, the plea never -- it's scheduled \n17 \nfor December 14th, so yeah. \n18 \nQ \nYes, but one of the issues that's still percolating \n19 \nuntil the end of December is who is going to make this \n20 \nnotification? Because as you can expect, the defense pushes \n21 \nback on this letter. \n22 \nAnd so now we go to the -- the -- number 39, \n23 \nplease? And this is a December 11th, 2007 letter from Ken \n24 \nStarr to you, and if you look on page two, at the front -- at \n25 \nthe top of the -- the top of the page there, he is -- this \nEFTA00009170\n", "char_count": 1165}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Page 355 \n1 \nletter is complaining about an oral notification that Ms. \n2 \ngave to a -- one of the defense -- one of the \n3 \nvictim's attorneys that a letter would be coming. \n4 \nAnd so, Mr. Starr is writing you to complain about \n5 \nit, and he mentions in -- later in that paragraph that we \n6 \nhave thought that the notification process had been in \n7 \nabeyance until completion of our ongoing discussions with \n8 \nrespect to that process. So, were you having discussions \n9 \nwith Mr. Starr about the process at this time? \n10 \nA \nI don't recall discussions. I -- I think there was \n11 \nat least correspondence, or -- I'm sorry, where are you? I \n12 \nwas reading the -- reading the letter. This -- I'm sorry, \n13 \nwhere are you? What paragraph? \n14 \nQ \nLet's take a look -- and it's been a long day. \n15 \nLet's slow down here. We're on the second page of the Starr \n16 \nletter. \n17 \nA \nYes. \n18 \nQ \nAnd it would be this and that, the -- the language \n19 \nin there -- in the second sentence, which goes towards the \n20 \nbottom. \n21 \nA \nThis notification, but quite apart from our \n22 \nsubstantive concerns, which -- we had thought the \n23 \nnotification process had been in abeyance until the \n24 \ncompletion. That appears not to be so. This is \n25 \nrespectfully -- so, where does it imply that I was having \nEFTA00009171\n", "char_count": 1322}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Page 356 \n1 \nI don't recall communications with Mr. Starr, that's why I'm \n2 \ncurious where -- at least verbal communications. I'm curious \n3 \nwhere you're reading that from. \n4 \nQ \nI thought he -- he's saying, we had thought that \n5 \nthe notification process had been held in abeyance until \n6 \ncompletion of our ongoing discussions. Are you saying that \n7 \nthat's -- he's --\n8 \nA \nSo, I don't know where that may have come from, and \n9 \nI don't recall. I recall at one point -- I think I sent a \n10 \nletter saying we'll hold off for a week. I don't recall the \n11 \ndate of that letter, while you review some matters. Where \n12 \nthe abeyance came from, I can't -- I can't speak to. \n13 \nQ \nOkay. Let's go to Exhibit 41b. This is your \n14 \nDecember 19th letter, and what I'd like to draw your \n15 \nattention to is page two, the second to last paragraph there. \n16 \nA \nYes. \n17 \nQ \nSo, could you tell us how your decision making \n18 \naround this paragraph, how you got to this decision? \n19 \nA \nSo, so, you're asking me to recreate -- I -- at \n20 \nsome point, the issue clearly moved from \ninteracting \n21 \nwith defense counsel to -- to my desk, and my recollection 12 \n22 \nyears after the fact is -- so, you're saying we shouldn't \n23 \nnotify them about the state proceeding, and sure, the \n24 \nstate -- this was negotiated between Epstein and the state \n25 \nattorney. \nEFTA00009172\n", "char_count": 1383}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Page 357 \n1 \nWe did not direct the state proceeding. So, \n2 \nwhatever state process is appropriate for the state process \n3 \nwill be given. But with respect to the federal resolution, \n4 \nwe intend to provide victims with notice of the federal \n5 \nresolution as required by law, and your question is if we \n6 \nthought it was discretionary. \n7 \nI recall our believing it was discretionary, but \n8 \nyou could also -- it doesn't hurt to in a letter say we're \n9 \nkind of required to do this, and I think it was the right \n10 \nthing to provide them notice of the federal resolution. \n11 \nAnd once that resolution was reached, and part of \n12 \nthe key word is what the resolution is, my understanding is \n13 \nthat \nmade efforts to notify victims of that resolution \n14 \nand let them know that -- that there would be a hearing the \n15 \nfollowing Monday, that they should attend, because these --\n16 \nit would bring an end to the case. \n17 \nQ \nWell, let's just back up real quick. As far as --\n18 \nso, do you -- as far as the state attorney notifying people \n19 \nof -- victims of the --\n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \n-- state resolution, did you have any concerns with \n22 \nthat particular part of it? \n23 \nA \nSo, difficult to recreate the thought process 12 \n24 \nyears later, but ultimately you've got federal, and you've \n25 \ngot state, and the state attorney will do what the state \nEFTA00009173\n", "char_count": 1384}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Page 358 \n1 \nattorney thinks is appropriate. It's not for me to direct \n2 \nthe state attorney. \n3 \nI'm inferring, based on this language, it's not for \n4 \nme to direct the state attorney, or for our office to direct \n5 \nthe state attorney's office on its obligations with respect \n6 \nto the state outcome. \n7 \nQ \nOkay. I'm just asking because, you know, the whole \n8 \ncase came to your office because of some issues with the \n9 \nstate attorney's resolution of the case. So, now it's going \n10 \nback, and they're going to be in charge of the notification. \n11 \nDid that raise any flags with you, or did you have any \n12 \nconcern about whether it would be done correctly, or done at \n13 \nall? \n14 \nA \nSo, again, you've -- I -- this has come up in \n15 \ndifferent contexts, and I think it's -- there was obviously a \n16 \nconcern about how it was being charged, but that doesn't mean \n17 \nthat they will not fulfill whatever obligations they have. \n18 \nLet's not assume that -- that the state attorney's office is \n19 \nfull of bad actors. \n20 \nQ \nOkay. \n21 \nBY MS. \n22 \nQ \nBut even if not assuming that they're full of bad \n23 \nactors --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- it's going to be difficult for them to notify \nEFTA00009174\n", "char_count": 1218}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Page 359 \n1 \nthe victims, wasn't it, that they didn't even necessarily \n2 \nknow the same list as the federal victims, because you had \n3 \nfound more victims. \n4 \nA \nSo, we could certainly have shared that list with \n5 \nthem. I mean, there are -- there are ways that this could \n6 \nhave happened. I don't know how -- what the communication \n7 \nwere, but as a conceptual matter, having the state notify \n8 \nthem of the state hearing and having the federal government \n9 \nsay, and this is the federal resolution, is consistent with \n10 \nthe law. \n11 \nQ \nBut since the federal resolution is tied to the \n12 \nstate plea, is -- why not just combine the two of them in the \n13 \nnotification? Here's the federal resolution. We're tying it \n14 \nto the state plea, and here's --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- the date of the state plea? \n17 \nA \nI can't speak to the why not. I can -- you know, I \n18 \ncan speak to my belief that this would be consistent with \n19 \nlaw. That could also be one approach. I can't speak to why \n20 \nA versus B. \n21 \nQ \nDid somebody instruct you that -- or did you have a \n22 \nconversation consulting with somebody about whether this was \n23 \nthe better approach? \n24 \nA \nI -- I would have said -- you know, based on \n25 \npractice -- not recollection, but based on practice, I would \nEFTA00009175\n", "char_count": 1310}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Page 36C \n1 \nhave sat down with \n, most likely, since he was handling \n2 \nthis matter, and we would have talked about it. I \nwould\n3 \nnot have sent this without running it by at least \nif \n4 \nnot other individuals in the office. I don't know if based \n5 \non your record there is -- there's e-mails with drafts, but \n6 \nyou know, every document that I'm aware of was sort of shared \n7 \nwithin the management team, and this would have been one of \n8 \nthose. \n9 \nQ \nWith respect to that one specific decision about \n10 \nthis should be at the discretion of the state's attorney, did \n11 \nyou consult with anybody in D.C. about that issue? \n12 \nA \nI don't recall consulting with someone in D.C. \n13 \nabout this issue. I recall a general perspective that the \n14 \nCVRA as a technical matter did not attach because ultimately \n15 \nthis was not -- it hadn't -- this was not an indictment. \n16 \nBY MR. \n17 \nQ \nOh, can we -- before we leave this letter --\n18 \nA \nIf I could, I -- I -- and I understand your \n19 \nquestions, but I feel some obligation to raise the tension \n20 \nbetween, did you consult in D.C. versus should you allow D.C. \n21 \nreview. \nAnd so, just, you know, we certainly were allowing \n23 \nreview, but U.S. Attorney's Offices don't consult on every \n24 \nmatter, especially offices that have the kind of \n25 \nexperience --\nEFTA00009176\n", "char_count": 1343}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Page 361 \n1 \nMS. \nMm-hmm. \n2 \nTHE WITNESS -- that Miami does. \n3 \nMR. \nBack to me? \n4 \nMS. in \nMm-hmm. \n5 \nMS. \nMm-hmm. \n6 \nMS. \n: Back to you. \n7 \nBY MR.\n8 \nQ \nBefore we finish with this latter from the 19th, \n9 \ncan we look at page three, please? There is -- if you could \n10 \nread the first paragraph on page three to yourself, please? \n11 \nA \nOkay. \n12 \nQ \nCould you -- in that section, you mention that \n13 \nprosecutors had asked you to declare a breach, and you \n14 \nresisted. Can you discuss that? \n15 \nA \nSo -- sure. That's -- that's referencing -- I \n16 \nthink increasing frustrations by the -- by the prosecutors, \n17 \nand I think that's reflected in contemporaneous e-mails \n18 \nsaying, why don't we just rip this up? \n19 \nAnd I recall conversations with \nand that goes \n20 \na little bit to what we talked about earlier, which is \n21 \nconcern that a unilateral breach would overlay not just the \n22 \ninitial issues that we had, and not just the fact that the \n23 \nvictims are getting older and the case isn't getting better, \n24 \nbut then we have, was the unilateral breach a valid breach, \n25 \nor was it not a valid breach? \nEFTA00009177\n", "char_count": 1150}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Page 362 \n1 \nAnd is -- is the delay justified or not justified. \n2 \nAnd ultimately, that additional -- that additional \n3 \nliability -- not liability, that additional legal uncertainty \n4 \nwas -- would have made the case even harder, because they \nS \nwere very careful to always say there is no breach. \n6 \nMS. \nMm-hmm. \n7 \nTHE WITNESS Let me -- let me address, because I \n8 \nwent on to read the next paragraph as well. And so let me \n9 \ncircle back to an earlier issue --\n10 \nMR. \nGreat. \n11 \nTHE WITNESS -- because I at least want to address \n12 \nit because the next paragraph then says, and it's clear that \n13 \nI'm increasingly frustrated. It's against that -- that my \n14 \nfrustration with it appears to be an 11th hour appeal weeks \n15 \nbefore the now scheduled July 4th plea date. That said, the \n16 \nissues raised are important and must be fully vetted \n17 \nirrespective of timelines concerns. We hope to preserve the \n18 \nJuly 4th date. \n19 \nI understand defense counsel shares our -- with \n20 \nthis in mind, and in the event the defense counsel may wish \n21 \nto seek review of our determination in Washington, I spoke \n22 \nthis past Monday with Attorney Gen \nconfirming if it's \n23 \npossible appearing to ask her to grant the potential request \n24 \nfor review, and to in fact review this case in an expedited \n25 \nmanner in an attempt to preserve the July 4th date. \nEFTA00009178\n", "char_count": 1390}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Page 363 \n1 \nMR.IIIIF: January 4th. \nMS. \n: That address -- January. \n3 \nTHE WITNESS I'm Sorry, the January 4th plea date. \n4 \nSorry, it's --\n5 \nBY MS. \n6 \nQ \nAnd that addresses the question I was asking. \n7 \nA \nAnd that goes to the question you're asking, and \n8 \nagain, I'm recreating and I'm speculating. Having that \n9 \nfollowing the -- another 11th hour appeal here, I would say \n10 \nI -- I wouldn't say, let's appeal this again. I think I'm \n1 \nsaying pretty clearly, it's against my frustration with what \n12 \nappears to be an 11th hour appeal weeks before the now \n13 \nscheduled July -- January 4th plea date that this is not an \n14 \ninvitation to do another appeal, because the appeal is \n1 5 \nalready in Washington. \n16 \nBut my -- my saying, if -- if we're going to do \n17 \nthis appeal, let's get it over and done with, then I'm sort \n18 \nof speculating based on the language, so that we can get this \n19 \npled on January 4th, and let's not put it off until after the \n20 \nholidays. \n21 \nQ \nBut you did say, \"To ask her to grant the potential \n22 \nrequest,\" --\n23 \nA \nWhich is --\n24 \nQ \n-- \"for review.\" \n25 \nA \nWhich is why I wanted to on my own raise it, \nEFTA00009179\n", "char_count": 1181}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Page 364 \n1 \nbecause is that saying please appeal me, or is that saying --\n2 \nthis is an 11th hour appeal that you have now taken to \n3 \nWashington. \n4 \nIt is December 19th. We're about to go into the \n5 \nholidays. There's a January 4th plea date. This should not \n6 \nbe another way to put it off. And so, if you're going to do \n7 \nthis, I'm going to try to expedite it so we can get this \n8 \ndone. \n9 \nQ \nAnd in fact, it took until May --\n10 \nA \nYeah. \n11 \nQ \n-- 15. \n12 \nA \nAnd it did, and apologies, I just realized my voice \n13 \nis --\n14 \nQ \nAll right. \n15 \nA \n-- rising. So, I don't know if that's my \n16 \nfrustration at reading this again, or it's getting late, but \n17 \nit -- but it was a frustrating matter. Apologies. \n18 \nBY MR. \n19 \nQ \nLet's just move to Exhibit 46. So, this is an e-\n20 \nmail from Ms. \nto you and \ndiscussing how she \n21 \nhas interviewed some victims that day. There's a mention \n22 \nthat one of the victims said that she would rather not get \n23 \nany money and she'd have \nshe would rather have Epstein \n24 \nspend a significant time in jail. Did that piece of \n25 \ninformation go into your character list at all about how the \nEFTA00009180\n", "char_count": 1170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Page 36\n1 \ncase should be resolved? \n2 \nA \nSo, again, not based on recollection, because this \n3 \nis maybe if not 12, 11 years ago. \n4 \nQ \nOkay. \n5 \nA \nBut at this point, there had been an agreement. \n6 \nThe agreement was signed. It was being reviewed. Based on \n7 \nthis e-mail, we're trying to get and expedite the criminal \n8 \ndivision, because I -- I see it says please reach to \nto \n9 \nmake her decision. \n10 \nAnd I -- I think at this point, as I said, if --\n11 \nwe knew earlier -- if we knew that it was going to go this \n12 \nlong and take all of this, I think we may have approached the \n13 \ncase differently, but we were so far along on this, there was \n14 \na signed agreement. \n15 \nThe United States can't unwind an agreement just \n16 \nbecause it's frustrated, or just because some victim \n17 \nindicates that they don't like it. That's not -- you know, \n18 \nif the agreement is not legally valid, if there are some \n19 \nother concerns, but I don't think this in and of itself would \n20 \nhave been grounds for unwinding an agreement. \n21 \nQ \nDo you think it's misleading for the government to \n22 \nhave been interviewing these witnesses and preparing them for \n23 \na trial when there's already a signed NPA that resolves the \n24 \nissue? \n25 \nA \nSo, that was part of the judgement that there's a \nEFTA00009181\n", "char_count": 1316}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Page 366 \n1 \nsigned agreement, but based on the course of conduct, is that \n2 \nagreement really an agreement that will be honored? And so \n3 \nthere was an ongoing investigation as well, because we didn't \n4 \nknow if we'd go to trial, and I know that -- not I know. \n5 \nMy recollection is that the judgement was until we \n6 \nknow that this agreement is really going to be performed \n7 \nfully, that to inform victims of the possibility of civil \n8 \nrecovery is problematic, and -- and I can't say that \n9 \njudgement's incorrect. That -- I think that's a valid \n10 \njudgement. \n11 \nQ \nFair enough, and then the last question on this e-\n12 \nmail is at the bottom, Ms. \ninvites you to attend \n13 \ninterviews with four of the girls who would be coming in the \n14 \nfollowing day. \n15 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n16 \nQ \nDid -- did you attend? \n17 \nA \nI -- I did not, and as U.S. Attorney, I don't think \n18 \nI attended -- that's not -- that wasn't typical for our \n19 \noffice. \n20 \nQ \nWould -- was that ever -- had you ever had that \n21 \ntype of request come from a line assistant? \n22 \nA \nNot to my recollection, but I also tended not to \n23 \nhave communications come from line assistants in the first \n24 \nplace. \n25 \nQ \nWere you at all curious, given the -- you discussed \nEFTA00009182\n", "char_count": 1266}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Page 367 \n1 \nthe issues with the witnesses in this case --\n2 \nA \nRight. \n3 \nQ \n-- that, potential impeachment, and that -- you \n4 \nknow, that caused you to -- that went into the negotiation \nphase. Did you have any interest in seeing these people --\n6 \neven interacting with them personally so you could make your \n7 \nown assessment? \n8 \nA \nSo, any interest is --\n9 \nQ \nWould there be value in doing that? \n10 \nA \nSo, we had very experienced prosecutors. It's not \n11 \njust interacting with the -- the -- the victims were in a \n12 \nreally hard position. It's not -- how I would draw a \n13 \ndistinction between a victim being interviewed by an agent, \n14 \nand how a victim holds up in court, in a public setting under \n15 \ncross examination, and in that, I don't think anyone in the \n16 \noffice was questioning the pain or the suffering of the \n17 \nvictims. I think that the issues were how would they hold up \n18 \nin court, which are uniquely trial issues. \n19 \nwhat \nOkay. Then let's move onto \nwhat \nwhat \n20 \nwas your understanding that -- that the federal government \n21 \nwas going to do as far as the notification about the \n22 \nresolution of the case? \n23 \nA \nSo, my understanding was that once we believed that \n24 \nthe case was going to be -- that the -- that the plea was \n25 \ngoing to go forward, that we would notify the victims of the \nEFTA00009183\n", "char_count": 1361}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Page 368 \n1 \nresolution, and of the agreement, and how -- basically, how \nit played out. \n3 \nQ \nNow, are you saying now -- now, you had agreed to \n4 \nnot notify -- well, did you -- I mean, you're -- one would \n5 \nread your December 12th -- 19th letter as an agreement that \n6 \nthe federal government is not going to notify the victims of \n7 \nthe state plea. That's -- and that will end that part of the \n8 \ncase. Is that correct? \n9 \nA \nSo, so, I would parse my letter differently, and \n10 \nthis is 12 years after the fact, and so this isn't based on \n11 \nrecollection, but on my reading and my understanding of the \n12 \ncourse of conduct in this case, sitting here now. \n13 \nQ \nMe-hmm. \nA \nMy understanding was that our office was \n15 \nnotified -- was it on a Friday afternoon? \n16 \nQ \nYes. \n17 \nA \nThat he would be pleading on Monday, and that at \n18 \nthat time, \nmade efforts to notify victims that he would \n19 \nbe pleading, and that that would terminate the federal \n20 \nresolution of this matter, and that the victims should attend \n21 \nthat hearing, which wasn't the state resolution of the case. \n22 \nIt was the federal resolution. \n23 \nQ \nAnd so, you -- you're saying that the state plea \n21 \nwas also the federal resolution of the case? \n5 \nBased on my understanding of what happened, that's \nEFTA00009184\n", "char_count": 1316}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Page 369 \n1 \nhow my recollection -- based on having reviewed the record, \n2 \nthat's how I believe it proceeded, although I think \n3 \nattempted to do so, couldn't reach some attorneys, and \n4 \nexercised best efforts to let them know, but did not get \n5 \nahold of all of the victims --\n6 \nQ \nLet's --\n7 \nA \n-- over the weekend. \n8 \nQ \nBefore we get too deep into that, let's just take a \n9 \nquick look at Exhibit 51. So, this is an e-mail forwarded to \n10 \nyou from \nfrom January -- June 25th, 2008. So, that is \n11 \nfive days prior to the plea in this case. \n12 \nA \nYes. \n13 \nQ \nOr, the state court plea, and the attachment there, \n14 \nyou'll notice is a letter with a notification of identified \n15 \nvictims, and the letter is written, would you disagree --\n16 \nit's written with, on June 30th, Epstein pled guilty. Do you \n17 \nsee that? \n18 \nA \nYes. \n19 \nQ \nSo, the inference -- it appears to be that this \n20 \nletter was to be sent after the plea. \n21 \nA \nI -- I see that. I also -- based on my review of \n22 \nthe record, where I think I'm recalling the \n23 \naffidavit, where she said that she made an attempt to notify \n24 \nthe victims as soon as she was made aware that he would be \n25 \npleading -- that he would be pleading in state court. \nEFTA00009185\n", "char_count": 1259}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \nPage 370 \nQ \nWell, the -- what \nsays in affidavit --\nA \nCorrect. \nQ \n-- I believe is that she made notification, and the \n4 \npolice department -- Chief \npolice department made \n5 \nnotifications. Is that -- is that correct? Does that ring a \n6 \nbell? \n7 \nA \n8 \nMR. TODD: Do you have a copy of the affidavit, so \n9 \nwe can just look at it? \n10 \nMR. \n: Do you have \naffidavit e-\n11 \nmail? \n12 \nMS. \n: It's right here. One copy. \n13 \nTHE WITNESS I'll hand it back. \n14 \nMR. \n: Almost done. \n15 \nTHE WITNESS So, relevant to this paragraph 34, and \n16 \nthen another paragraph, these and other attacks and efforts \n17 \nto avoid the NPA's terms led the FBI investigative team, the \n18 \noffice, and me to conclude that prosecution at trial remained \n19 \na possibility, and we should prepare as such. \n20 \nThis meant that the victim notification letters had \n21 \nto cease, because one, we no longer knew whether Epstein \n22 \nwould perform under the NPA, and hence, we did not know \n23 \nwhether providing information about the NPA would be \n24 \naccurate, until we believed that Epstein, through his \n25 \ncounsel, would attempt to use victim notification concerning \nEFTA00009186\n", "char_count": 1177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Page 371 \n1 \nthe NPA to suggest that victims had been encouraged by the \n2 \nFBI or the office to overstate the victimization for monetary \n3 \ncompensation. And then fast forwarding because you can read \n4 \nit on your own. \n5 \nOn Friday, June 27th at approximately 4:15, \n6 \nreceived a copy of Epstein's proposed state plea agreement, \n7 \nand learned that Epstein's state court change of plea was \n8 \nscheduled for 8:30 a.m. on Monday. \n9 \nThe Palm Beach Police Department and I attempted to \n10 \nnotify the victims about the hearing in the short time \n11 \navailable to us. I specifically called to Attorney Edwards \n12 \nto provide notice to his clients regarding the hearing. \n13 \nI believe it was during this. I never told that \n14 \nthe state charges involved other victims, and neither the \n15 \nstate court charging instrument nor the factual proffer \n16 \nlimited the procurement of prostitution charges to a specific \n17 \ncell. \n18 \nSo, that was what I was referring to. Again, \n19 \nam -- I am basing this based on my review of the affidavit \n20 \nand not on recollection of how this may or may not have \n21 \nproceeded 12 years ago. \n22 \nQ \nOkay. You know, would it surprise you to learn \n23 \nthat Ms. \nonly communicated with Mr. Edwards that \n24 \nday? That's because she was under the direction from a \n25 \nmanger to only contact Edwards regarding this -- the \nEFTA00009187\n", "char_count": 1377}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Page 372 \n1 \npotential plea for that Monday? \n2 \nA \nThe affidavit said she attempted to notify the \n3 \nvictims, so I can't speak to that. \n4 \nQ \nOkay. \n5 \nA \nAnd I don't have an independent recollection of \n6 \nthis going back 12 years. \n7 \nQ \nWere you aware that Ms. \nwas directed to \n8 \nhave no communication with the state's attorney's office, and \n9 \nprobably during the later period of the case in 2008? \n10 \nA \nNot to my recollection. \n11 \nQ \nOkay, so did you have -- would you not recall \n12 \nhearing anyone directing her to not communicate with the \n13 \nstate attorney's office? \n14 \nA \nI can't speak 12 years later, what role I may or \n15 \nmay not have had. I question how, if we need -- if there is \n16 \na -- an attempt to schedule a plea in all that, how can there \n17 \nnot be communication? But I can't -- I can't say whether I \n18 \ndid or did not. When I say I have no recollection, I mean \n19 \nthat in the broadest sense of the word. \n20 \nQ \nOkay. In your December 19th letter, you -- you did \n21 \nagree that the state attorney's office would notify the \n22 \nstate's victims, right? \n23 \nA \nYes. \n24 \nQ \nAnd do you have any idea how that was to be \n25 \naccomplished? \nEFTA00009188\n", "char_count": 1194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Page 373 \n1 \n2 \nA \nI can't speak to that, no. \nQ \nAnd would you have any knowledge of who the state \n3 \nvictims are? \n4 \nA \nI would infer that -- that our office would have \n5 \nhad sufficient communication with the state attorney's office \n6 \nto communicate who the victims were in this case, because it \n7 \nwas an ongoing -- it was an ongoing matter, and -- but I \n8 \ndon't know. \n9 \nQ \nDo you want to go on? \n10 \nMS. \nOkay. Are you -- are you done with \n11 \nyour -- that portion at least, for the moment? \n12 \nMR. =mg \nYes. Thank you. \n13 \nBY MS. \n14 \nQ \nI'd just want to clarify something you said a \n15 \nmoment --\n16 \nA \nSure. \n17 \nQ \n-- ago, Mr. Acosta. You said you referred to the \n18 \nagreement, the NPA, as having been -- it was signed and was \n19 \nbeing reviewed. Were you talking about Washington? \n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \nThe criminal division, but we established earlier, \n22 \ndid we not, that the NPA was not the subject of the criminal \n23 \ndivision review. They expressly declined to review it. \n24 \nA \nI stand corrected. \n25 \nQ \nOkay. I just wanted to be clear on the record. \nEFTA00009189\n", "char_count": 1105}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Page 374 \n1 \nThank you. So, we -- we've had a lot of conversation about \n2 \nfacts. We are fortunate in this case to have a plethora of \n3 \ndocuments upon which we can rely even 12 years or so after \n4 \nthe fact, and we've tried to plum your -- the depths of your \n5 \nmemory as to the events. \n6 \nAre there any facts -- any conversations, any \n7 \nincidents, anything based on the questions that you've heard \n8 \nhere today that you recall, have recalled, that you want to \n9 \ntell us about, want us to know? \n10 \nA \nSo, give me a minute to just sort of think this \n11 \nthrough. \n12 \nQ \nOf course. \n13 \nA \nI think we've covered most of the issues pretty \n14 \nclearly. I guess I would have two general comments. The \n15 \nfirst is, whether folks agree or disagree with the initial \n16 \ntwo years, you know, registration and restitution. \n17 \nThe office's focus was on having Mr. Epstein go to \n18 \njail at a time when, from our perspective, these -- these \n19 \ncases were, at least presented with these facts, federally at \n20 \nleast unusual, and that most trafficking cases involved \n21 \ndifferent -- a different sort of nexus. \n22 \nIt involved bringing individuals into the country, \n23 \nor holding individuals against their will, or doing something \n24 \nlike that, and -- and this will go to my second point which \n25 \nis, you know, sitting here, we now see several high profile \nEFTA00009190\n", "char_count": 1392}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Page 375 \n1 \nindividuals who abused power, and have now been prosecuted --\n2 \nwho were known at the time who abused drugs, like Bill Cosby \n3 \nand -- who were -- there were rumors at the time, and you \n4 \nknow, and -- and so, looking back, maybe it was the right \n5 \ncall. \n6 \nMaybe it wasn't the right call, but there is some \n7 \ndegree of -- I'm not sure what the right adjective is. \n8 \nFrustration, that -- and certainly, some of this goes to me, \n9 \nbut I think a lot of this goes to \nand the individuals \n10 \ninvolved, that the attempt to put someone in jail as opposed \n11 \nto decline the case and say this is just a state case, \n12 \nthat -- that the -- that the federal issues are too tricky, \n13 \nthat ultimately, this is sort of novel interpretations, that \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \nthe attempt to come up with an outcome has rebounded in the \nway that it has, and I'm not -- I'm not saying, look, that \nthat's life, and I understand that. \nBut I do think it's important to look back on this, \nand try to be in the shoes of the thought process in 2006 and \n'07 when trafficking prosecutions were fairly new, when, you \nknow, more so than today, some jurors may have looked at this \nas prostitution, and were -- perhaps more so than today --\njudge's tolerance for victim shaming may have both caused \n23 \nmore hesitation on the part of victims, but also created more \n24 \nissues at trial. And so, I think we've touched on that, but \n25 \nI think as we sort of wrap up --\nEFTA00009191\n", "char_count": 1503}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Page 376 \n1 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n2 \nA \n-- this portion of it, it's important to just \n3 \nrestate that. \n4 \nQ \nAnd -- and to -- in addition, are there any facts \n5 \nthat you -- conversations, or anything that you --\n6 \n7 \nA \nFair, you did ask this. \nQ \n-- that we have -- that we've not really elicited \n8 \nfrom you that you want us to know? And to be clear, you'll \n9 \nhave an opportunity to --\n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- supplement this. \nA \nNot that I can think of \nQ \nAll right. \nA \n-- sitting here. \nQ \nAll right. How do you respond to public criticism \n16 \nthat the defense attorneys -- the Epstein defense team, were \n17 \ngaining extraordinary access to an influence on prosecutors \n18 \nfrom the line level all the way up through the department? \n19 \nA \nSo, I would point out early on in the case -- when \n20 \nI said early, you pushed back, but from my perspective, early \n21 \non in the case. Not when it was first investigated, but when \n22 \nit first bubbled up for decision. \n23 \nQ \nAnd that would be mid-2007? \n24 \nA \nMid-2007. June-ish, May to June 2007, May, June, \n25 \nJuly. We determined, here are -- here is what we'd need for \nEFTA00009192\n", "char_count": 1161}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Page 377 \nresolution. And I -- I think I addressed some of this in the \n2 \nDaily Beast's letter. \n3 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n4 \nA \nBecause we were receiving criticism back then, and \n5 \nI think that letter has been misconstrued to some extent, \n6 \nbecause it was not, oh, here are influential people, we're \n7 \nbacking off. \n8 \nIt was, we, early on, set three criteria. Two \n9 \nyears, registration, restitution. Despite all these \n10 \nattorneys, despite all these appeals, despite all these \n11 \nefforts, the office did not budge with the caveat of the 24 \n!2 \nto 18 months, which we've discussed, and from my perspective, \n13 \ndespite all of that, I backed the office in sticking by that \n14 \nresolution in the various appeals to Washington. \n15 \nAnd so ultimately, it was a year-long process, but \n16 \nwe ended up a year later exactly where we started with the \n17 \ncaveat of the 24 to 18. And so, to the extent that there was \n18 \ninfluence, there was -- there was no change in position. \n19 \nQ \nWell, my question was access. That this team of \n20 \ndefense attorneys --\n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \n-- had extraordinary access, that they asked for \n23 \nmeetings, they --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- pressed for -- with communications, and they had \nEFTA00009193\n", "char_count": 1243}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Page 378 \nthat access. Was -- did that seem extraordinary to you? \n2 \nA \nSo, they asked for a meeting with me before the \n3 \nagreement was signed. \n4 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n5 \nA \nI granted that. That's not the first and only time \n6 \nthat I granted a meeting to -- to defense attorneys. I don't \n7 \nthink it's atypical, particularly as a case is coming to --\n8 \nto resolution \nfor a U.S. Attorney to sit down and meet \n9 \nwith opposing counsel, and I can think of several cases where \n10 \nthat happened \nThere was certainly a lot of access in \n11 \nWashington. I would speak to -- you know, I think that's a \n12 \nquestion to direct to this building. \n13 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n14 \nA \nBecause the process here was lengthy, and \n15 \nfrustrating. But I think we successfully held firm in our \n16 \npositions, despite all the process in this building. \n17 \nQ \nAnd again, my focus is not on your response, but on \n18 \nthe access. \n19 \nA \nAnd --\n20 \nQ \nBased on the prominence and the -- the prominence \n21 \nof the defense attorneys. If these had been local attorneys, \n22 \nyour sort of average criminal defense attorney from, you \n23 \nknow, name where they hang out in --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- Miami coming to you and pressing for this, you, \nEFTA00009194\n", "char_count": 1232}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "1 \nwrit large, the department, do you believe they would have \n2 \nhad the same or a comparable level of access? \n3 \n4 \n5 \nA \nSo --\nQ \nI don't know the answer. I'm asking. \nA \nYeah. So, I guess I'd respond this way. If an \n6 \nattorney after meeting with my management staff asked for a \n7 \nmeeting with me, I believe I did and would have granted it, \n8 \nand I can think of several matters on which those types of \n9 \nmeetings were granted. And so, that was not unusual. \n10 \nQ \nAll right. \n11 \nA \nWith respect to the back and forth after the \n1 2 \nagreement was signed? This was an unusual agreement, and to \n13 \nsome extent, as a result, the back and forth quickly \n14 \nelevated, particularly because matters would elevate in \n15 \nparticular when they were being addressed at main justice. \n16 \nThat would be one natural way for matters to elevate within \n17 \nthe office. And so, the fact that they were being addressed \n18 \nand reviewed, and letters were coming here, would naturally \n19 \nelevate the way the matter was treated in Miami. \n20 \nQ \nIn particular, Jay Lefkowitz had ready access to --\n21 \nof course, he was involved in the negotiations with \n22 \ndirectly in creating the NPA, but after that, it appears from \n23 \nthe record that he was often contacting you, and running or \n24 \ngoing above the people who worked for you, and on numerous \n25 \noccasions, you -- again, my characterization -- reprimanded \nEFTA00009195\n", "char_count": 1430}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Page 380 \n1 \nhim, or instructed him not to do that, and to direct his \n2 \ncommunications to the line attorney or her supervisors. Is \n3 \nthat -- is that --\n4 \nA \n5 \nQ \n-- a fair characterization? \n6 \nA \nYes, on -- I think on several occasions, I said \n7 \ndirect them, and again, that was after the agreement was \n8 \nsigned, but yes. \n9 \nQ \nBut there were many issues still pending, correct? \n10 \nA \nYes. \n11 \nQ \nOkay, and that was his ability to reach out to you \n12 \nas a function of your personal association. Is that fair? \n13 \nA \nSo, I don't think that's a fair characterization. \n14 \nI think it -- you could also say that it was the ability \n15 \nof -- a function of his -- his insistence in not doing what \n16 \nwe asked, and the fact that in a typical course, a Miami \n17 \nattorney would not have done this, because they would have to \n18 \ninteract with the office on an ongoing basis. \n19 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n20 \nA \nAnd so, the repeat litigator behaves very \n21 \ndifferently than the one time razed earth litigator. \n22 \nQ \nMm-hem. Razed, R-a-z-e-d? \n23 \nA \nCorrect. \n24 \nQ \nIs it reasonable to -- for us to understand that \n25 \nyou have followed the media coverage of what happened in the \nEFTA00009196\n", "char_count": 1203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Epstein case over the years? \nQ \nIn your view overall, and in whatever specific \nrespect you wish to address, is -- has it been accurate or \n$ \nnot so? \n6 \nA \nI think it has been inaccurate in several ways, and \n7 \nwe can go through them, but --\n8 \nQ \nIf you could just tick those off? \n9 \nA \nSo, I think it's inaccurate in that it has been \n10 \ncharacterized as our approving a state plea, and --\n11 \nQ \nMm-bean. \n12 \nA \n-- the complexity of this case was a state plea, \n13 \nand we were deferring to -- in favor of a state prosecution \n14 \nhas been lost, and it's something that I have attempted to \n15 \ncorrect, but it's very difficult to sort of explain that in \n16 \nthe media. \n17 \nYou know, this is a bad analogy, and so I haven't \n18 \nused it in the media, but I've thought about it, and so I'll \n19 \nshare it. So, after the Jessie Smollett plea in Chicago, \n20 \nthere was some discussion of whether the federal government \n21 \nshould bring charges, and I remember the media saying that, \n22 \nand I haven't used this analogy, because I don't want to \n23 \ncompare, and I think it would be disrespectful to compare the \n24 \nfacts of that case to what happened to these victims, and I \n25 \nstill -- and I don't want the comparison to be drawn, but \nEFTA00009197\n", "char_count": 1265}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Page 382 \n1 \nthere is a legal comparison, right? \n2 \nThe U.S. Attorney in Chicago could have stepped in \n3 \nand said, whether or not the state takes this plea, we may \n4 \ninvestigate this federally, and sort of stopped that plea \n5 \nfrom going forward, or at least put a wrench in those gears, \n6 \nor the U.S. Attorney could have pursued that under petite \n7 \npolicy, and did not. \n8 \nAnd so, our stepping into this sort of reminded me \n9 \nof how many times cases that are viewed as a manifest \n10 \ninjustice do occur, and yet the federal government does not \n11 \nstep in? And the fact that we stepped in has been construed \n12 \nas, this became a federal prosecution, and sort of going --\n13 \ngoing to -- is it \nor --\n14 \n15 \nA \nsort of question earlier, the \n16 \ndistinction between -- it was not a manifest injustice versus \n17 \nthis was the right outcome, is something that I think has \n18 \nbeen lost in the coverage of this matter. \n19 \nI think a second issue that has been lost in the \n20 \ncoverage of this matter is, there are references to Prince \n21 \nAndrew, and Alex Dershowitz and Governor Richardson and Bill \n22 \nClinton, and thing happening in London, and the so called \n23 \nLolita Express where things may have happened on airplanes. \n24 \nAnd so, this is viewed from the public as this international \n25 \nmatter, where the victims were local, the actions, to my \nEFTA00009198\n", "char_count": 1390}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Page 383 \n1 \nrecollection, was local. \n2 \nAnd so, the distinction between this Palm Beach \n3 \nincident and what the media likes to cover, which is, you \n4 \nknow, was, you know, did Mr. Epstein force a minor to have \n5 \nsexual relations with Prince Andrew, is a very different fact \n6 \npattern both in terms of the public perception of forcing a \n7 \nminor to have sex with a third party, that they have -- you \n8 \nknow, that is outside the solicitation context. \n9 \nIt's sort of -- I'm travelling with these women, \nand forcing them to have sex, versus a more local matter \n11 \nthat -- I don't want to say solicitation, because I think \n12 \nwe've covered that, but that some may view as that. \n13 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n14 \nA \nAnd I think those are two major elements --\n15 \nQ \nRight. \nA \n-- that have been lost in the coverage. \n17 \nQ \nThe case has been criticized as having involved \n18 \nimproper influences, or favors, or payments that affected \n19 \ndecisions that were made within your office, and you're aware \n20 \nof all those --\n21 \n22 \nQ \n-- allegations as well. In connection with this \n23 \ncase. Were you yourself ever offered any -- any payments, or \n24 \nany favors, or any promises or job assistance or anything \n25 \nlike that --\nEFTA00009199\n", "char_count": 1244}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Page 384 \n3 \n4 \nA \nNo. \nQ \n-- in connection with this case? \nA \nNo. \nQ \nAnd to your knowledge, was there any such offer to \n5 \nanyone associated with this case in your office? \n6 \n7 \nA \nNot to my knowledge. \nQ \nIt's been asserted also that the -- the handling of \n8 \nthe case in the office was affected by Epstein's wealth and \n9 \ninfluence in the Palm Beach community. Do you -- what is \n10 \nyour -- what's your response to that criticism? \n11 \nA \nAgain, my response would be, you know, sometime in \n12 \nMay or June we came up with these three points, and we stuck \n13 \nto them, and -- and you know, I -- despite all of this, you \n14 \nknow, when people make these assertions, somewhere along the \n15 \nway, the fact that we stuck to those points is lost and is \n16 \nnot talked about. \n17 \nAnd so, we did stick to those points. You know, \n18 \nand -- and questioned whether the case would have come to us \n19 \nin the first place but for -- and so, you know, I think that \n20 \ncould also go the other way. \n21 \nQ \nI don't understand that. \n22 \nA \nThat it's highly unusual for a case to be brought \n23 \nto the state -- to the U.S. Attorney's Office after the state \n24 \nattorney declined \nnot declines, but --\n25 \nQ \nFails to fully prosecute? \nEFTA00009200\n", "char_count": 1253}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Page 385 \nA \nRight, and so, so one question that at -- that also \n2 \ndoesn't get asked is, you know, to what extent was this case \n3 \nbrought to us in the first place because of this, because of \n4 \nhis profile? \n5 \nQ \nIn other words, are you suggesting that his wealth \nand influence in the community affected the state \nauthorities? \n8 \nA \nI'm not suggesting that. What I'm suggesting is \n9 \nthe case came in, the case proceeded, and someone can make \n10 \nthe argument that the only reason that Chief \nbrought \nit to us was because it had such a high profile -- are there \n12 \nother matters that take place in Palm Beach that a state \n13 \nattorney declines in the first place that isn't brought to \n14 \nthe state attorney because it doesn't rise to that \n15 \nQ \nYou mean to the V.S. Attorney. \n16 \nA \n-- to the -- to the U.S. Attorney because it \n17 \ndoesn't rise to that profile. \n18 \nQ \nAll right. All right. \n9 \nBY MS. \n20 \nQ \nWell, in fairness, he might've done it because of \nthe number of victims too, right? \n22 \nA \nHe may have. I don't know. What I'm suggesting is \n23 \nwe tried to treat it fairly, not looking at, hey, how wealthy \n24 \nis he, but also not saying we need to do this because he is \n25 \nso wealthy. \nEFTA00009201\n", "char_count": 1238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Page 386 \n1 \n2 \nQ \nWhat do you think about the media's treatment of \n3 \nthe line assistant, \n=ME? \n4 \nA \nI think she -- I wish her name wouldn't be in the \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \nnot why they take the pay cuts that they take to go into \n12 \nfederal service, and you know, I think the media coverage of \n13 \nthis case has been unfair, and has lost a lot of the \n14 \ncomplexities. \n15 \nIt's not surprising, because I mean, here, we're \n16 \ntalking about -- about a lot of those complexities, and it \n17 \ntakes a fairly sophisticated discussion, but I think it's \n18 \nparticularly unfair on \n19 \nQ \nIn your attorney's written response, he used the \n20 \nterm relentless for -- to characterize the team of lawyers --\n21 \nthe defense lawyers, and in that Daily Beast article that \n22 \nyou --\n23 \nF.• \n24 \nQ \n-- wrote, you referred to the yearlong assault on \nmedia. You know, to some extent, U.S. Attorneys, when they \ntake the job, realize that part of their job is to take the \nslings and arrows. \nYou know, there are instances when AUSAs were \naccused of misconduct, and -- and I always sort of felt that \nthat was -- I don't want to say below the belt, but that's \n25 \nthe prosecution and the prosecutors, you noted that the \nEFTA00009202\n", "char_count": 1237}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Page 387 \n1 \ndefense was, \"More aggressive than any of which I or the \n2 \nprosecutors in my office had previously encountered.\" You \n3 \nnoted that the defense investigated prosecutors and tried to \n4 \ndisqualify two, and I believe that those two are \n5 \nand\n. Is that -- \n6 \nA \nThat is correct. \n7 \nQ \nAll right. \nA \nYeah. \n9 \nQ \nAnd you also noted, or asserted that there were \n10 \ninvestigations into the family lives of individual \n11 \nprosecutors, accusations of bias and misconduct against \n12 \nindividual prosecutors, and even the threat of a book on \n13 \nprosecutorial zeal. Do you still regard that \n14 \ncharacterization as accurate? \n15 \nA \nI do. You know, whether I would use those same \n16 \nwords now, we can spend a lot of time talking about it, and \n17 \nI'd want --\n18 \nQ \nAll right. \n19 \nA \n-- to think about, but I do think that's accurate. \n20 \nI think this really was a razed earth type of matter, and in \n21 \nthe office's typical interactions, the prosecutors know they \n22 \nhave to come back to the office. And so, they would not \n23 \nsorry, not the prosecutors. It's getting late, though. The \n24 \ndefense counsel. \n25 \nAnd so, they would not -- it's not just the \nEFTA00009203\n", "char_count": 1198}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "Page 388 \n1 \naccusations against the attorneys, but the \n2 \nmischaracterization. I -- you know, I could go through the \n3 \nrecord, and there's several instances where my words, or \n4 \nother AUSAs words are being mischaracterized, or where \n5 \ngoing back to one of the Mlle -mails, people walk out of the \n6 \nmeeting believing they have an agreement, and then that's \n7 \nunwound, and -- that that is not -- I don't know if that's \n8 \ntypical in Washington, but that's certainly not typical in \n9 \nthe Miami office. \n0 \nQ \nAll right, in that Daily Beast article, I think you \nalso used the term peccadillos. \nWhat did you mean by that in particular? \n14 \nA \nCould I see the -- could I see the --\n15 \nQ \nMm-hmm. I was afraid you'd ask that. I have it \nright in front of me, and I don't at the moment, but --\nMS. \nAre you talking about the to whom it \n8 \nmay concern letter? \nMR. \n: Yes. \n20 \nTHE WITNESS Yes. \n21 \nBY MS. \n22 \nQ \nYes. Thank you, and it's a reference on the second \n23 \nnumbered page of this copy, to personal peccadillos, in the \n24 \nmiddle of the page. \n25 \nA \nAlso, individual prosecutors and their families \nEFTA00009204\n", "char_count": 1137}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Page 389 \nlooking for personal peccadillos that provide a -- so, \n12 \n14 \nwas, to my recollection, she wasn't investigated. \nI \ntri \nand I haven't encountered that in other cases. \nI recall it -- at one point, they also looked in \n, and \nfamily, and his background, and I thought that was \nlittle out of line. \nQ \nQ \n15 \nF. \n:8 \nQ \nEFTA00009205\n", "char_count": 345}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Ni\n13 \n14 \n15 \nA \ntl\nlilt the point I was trying to convey is, this is \nnot a -- this is not typical behavior by defense counsel. \nQ \nDid --\nA \nAnd despite all this, my point was, despite all \nthis, we did not budge. \nQ \nAnd again, that's not the focus of --\nRight. \nQ \n-- of this guestion.I \n16 \nA \n17 \n19 \nQ \nQ \nAll right. Are there any other examples where \ndefense counsel came to you that have not otherwise been \n21 \naddressed with --\nQ \n-- allegations about someone --\n25 \nA \nI'm hesitating --\nEFTA00009206\n", "char_count": 514}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Page 391 \n1 \nQ \n-- else --\n2 \nA \n-- just because I'm trying to think through, and \n3 \nnot to my recollection, no. \n4 \nQ \nDid they ever raise or imply that there were \n5 \nthat there was information regarding you of whatever respect, \n6 \nthat was in the nature of a sort of a threat, or a veiled \n7 \nwarning? \n8 \nA \nSo, the book reference was that I might be \n9 \npersonally embarrassed by pursuing this matter, because I \n10 \nwould be the subject of a chapter in a book on prosecutorial \n11 \noverreach. \n12 \nQ \nAnd who was going to write that book? Do you know? \n13 \nA \nProfessor Dershowitz. \n14 \nQ \nMM-hmm. Okay. Did you consider him a professional \n15 \nfriend at all? \n16 \nA \nI had not, to my recollection, met him. I -- I \n17 \nunderstand in this letter I sort of grouped him in. \n18 \nQ \nma-hmm. \n19 \nA \nBut I would -- I'd say for the record that it's \n20 \nhard to know what my intent was in 2011, but that's for \n21 \nsimplicity of grouping individuals, because I did go to \n22 \nHarvard. \n23 \nI may have run into him at Harvard, but he was not \n24 \nmy professor, and I don't -- I didn't work for him as a \n25 \nteaching assistant. I had some interest in criminal law, so \nEFTA00009207\n", "char_count": 1184}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Page 392 \n1 \nI may have chatted with him, but -- but that would have been \n2 \nit. \nQ \nAnd did you consult with him at all in connection \nwith your efforts -- your interest in potentially teaching or \nbeing involved in the -- sort of the law school world, either \nat Harvard, or at Florida International, or anywhere else? \nA \nNot to my recollection. At some point when I \n8 \napplied for the deanship -- I wasn't aware of the deanship \n9 \nuntil -- so, let's -- let's take this -- let's take this in \n0 \npart. I thought about looking at Harvard for a teaching \n1 \nposition. To my recollection, I never followed through on \n2 \nthat. \nQ \nMn-bmm. \nA \nI knew Elena Kagan, and may have had a conversation \nwith her that would have been a preliminary, how does this \n6 \nprocess work? But I don't recall taking it -- if I took it \nthat far, and I'm not saying that I did -- this was a long \ntime ago -- I never sort of went through -- the way law \n19 \nschools hire is a very -- they call it the \"meat market.\" \n20 \nQ \nMin-hmm. \n21 \nA \nTake that for what it's worth. It's something that \n22 \nhappens at the hotels here, at the -- at the Marriott here \n23 \nin -- on Connecticut, and it's a very formalized process, and \n24 \nI never --\n25 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \nEFTA00009208\n", "char_count": 1253}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Page 393 \n1 \nA \n-- went through that. I don't recall any \n2 \nconversation with Professor Dershowitz about that. To the \n3 \nextent I was thinking about it, it'd be natural for me to \n4 \ntalk to \nbut I don't recall talking to him. With \n5 \nrespect to Professor Dershowitz, with respect to FIU, the \n6 \ndean process is very decentralized. \n7 \nTo the extent a faculty member spoke to him, I \n8 \ndon't know. To my recollection, and again, this is a long \n9 \ntime ago, I did not ask him for a reference or a letter or \n10 \nsomething to that regard, although I may have. It was a \n11 \nlong, long time ago. I was also no longer active in this \n12 \ncase at the time. \n13 \nQ \nAll right, and what about with respect to that same \n14 \nprocess on your part, Ken Starr, who actually was a dean of a \n15 \nlaw school at the time? Did -- did he provide you with a \n16 \nreference, or --\n17 \nA \nNot --\n18 \nQ \n-- advice? \n19 \nA \nNot to my recollection. \n20 \nQ \nAil right. \n21 \nA \nAs -- as the letter from -- from Ken at the end, \n22 \nthere was some -- by the time this was over, there was some \n23 \ndegree of tension between us on my resolution of this matter. \n24 \nQ \nBut it also appeared to be tension that both of you \n25 \nwere eager to leave aside. \nEFTA00009209\n", "char_count": 1247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Page 394 \n1 \nA \nI'm a big believer, and I had good relationships \n2 \nwith the defense bar. I think lawyers can disagree and not \n3 \nbe disagreeable, and we would be a better profession if we \n4 \nall learned to do that. \n5 \nQ \nSo would the world. \n6 \nA \nYes. \n7 \nQ \nThere is an -- sort of investigative journalist \n8 \nauthor named \n9 \nA \nYes. \n10 \nQ \nDo you know that name? \n11 \nA \nYes. \n12 \nQ \nDid you ever speak with her? \n13 \nA \nSo, she was the recipient of the do -- to whom it \n14 \nmay concern letter at the Daily Beast. \n15 \nQ \nOh, really? \n16 \nA \nYes. \n17 \nQ \nAll right. All right. Thank you. I didn't -- we \n18 \ndidn't know that. Did she comment back to you on it? \n19 \nA \nIt was a long time ago. I don't -- I don't recall. \n20 \nQ \nSo, she wrote a book called trafficking. Have you \n21 \nread that --\n22 \nA \nShe did --\n23 \nQ \n-- about this case? \n24 \nA \nShe did. I haven't read it recently, but I read it \n25 \na while ago. \nEFTA00009210\n", "char_count": 943}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "Pane 395 \n1 \nQ \nAnd she says in that book that you told her a few \n2 \nyears after the NPA was signed that as she writes, \"He felt \nincapable of going up against those eight powerful attorneys. \nHe felt his career was at stake.\" Did you say that to her? \n5 \nA \nNot to my recollection, and what I tried to do was, \n6 \nfor the record, provide this letter to her, and the purpose \n7 \nof this letter was to say the exact opposite, which is -- and \n8 \nyou know, we have this -- you know, and she and the New York \n9 \nTimes, and I think the New York Times called it -- what --\n10 \nwhat's the word? Like, apologia? Does anyone know what --\n11 \nQ \nApologia. \n12 \nA \nApologia. \n13 \nQ \nIt's a -- it's an --\n14 \nA \n-- \n15 \nQ \n-- apology. It's a fancy way of saying --\n16 \n17 \nQ \n-- you're --\n18 \nA \nYe4h. \n19 \nQ \n-- explaining yourself. \n20 \nA \nYeah. I looked it up, and it's a little more \n21 \nderogatory than explaining yourself, because I felt a need \n22 \nQ \nMa-ham. \n23 \nA \n-- to look it up, but the New York Times called \n24 \nthis letter an apologia. \n25 \nQ \nMa-ham. \nEFTA00009211\n", "char_count": 1074}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Page 396 \n1 \nA \nAnd this was recently, and I say this, because when \n2 \nfolks read this letter, they read it as, this is why, you \n3 \nknow, we had these -- they -- I think sometimes they \n4 \nselectively read language. The prosecutors and agents in \n5 \nthis case -- and what followed was a yearlong assault. I \n6 \nused the word assault as it was more aggressive than anything \n7 \nin which I or the prosecutors in my office had previously \n8 \nencountered. \n9 \nExcuse me. Mr. Epstein hired an army of legal \n10 \nsuperstars, Harvard Professor Dershowitz, former judge and \n11 \nthen Pepperdine lodging Ken Starr, former deputy assistant to \n12 \nthe president then Kirkland & Ellis law partner Jay \n13 \nLefkowitz, and several others, including prosecutors that \n14 \nformerly worked in the U.S. Attorney's Office, the child \n15 \nexploitation section -- I'm not sure who that was -- of the \n16 \nDepartment of Defense, and they --\n17 \nQ \nDepartment of Defense? \n18 \nA \nNo, no, in the child exploitation and obscenity \n19 \nsection of the Justice Department. Defense attorneys next \n20 \nrequested a meeting with me. And they read that as saying \n21 \nthese -- there were all these powerful lawyers in the case, \n22 \nbut they don't then go on to talk about, despite this army of \n23 \nattorneys, the office held firm to the terms first presented \n24 \nto Mr. Black in the original meeting. \n25 \nQ \nSo, is it your -- so, what I understand you saying \nEFTA00009212\n", "char_count": 1448}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "Page 397 \n1 \nis that the panoply, this pantheon of attorneys did not have \n2 \nthe influence on you that's alleged? \n3 \nA \nAnd -- and the purpose of this letter was to say, \n4 \ndespite all this \nO \n9 \n10 \n1 \nQ \nRight. \nA \n-- we held firm. So, how can you say that there's \ninfluence if we held firm? \nQ \nSo, the --\nA \nAnd I would -- I would also -- I'm sorry. \nQ \nNo, no. \nA \nI would also note, and I think we talked about \n12 \nthis, that those terms were developed before many of these \n13 \nindividuals came on board. \n14 \nQ \nMm-hmm. Mm-hmm. \n15 \nA \nSo, it's not like these terms were developed \n16 \nbecause, oh, now these individuals are on board. \n17 \nQ \nAll right. And we haven't, of course, talked about \n18 \nthe whole work release issue, but --\n19 \nR \nYeah. \n20 \nQ \n-- I think that speaks -- the record --\n21 \nA \nYeah. \n22 \nQ \n-- speaks for itself on that. \n23 \nA \nYeah. \n24 \nBY MS. \n25 \nQ \nSo, I'm not sure I'm clear. Did you have an \nEFTA00009213\n", "char_count": 954}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "interview, or give a -- have a conversation with Ms. \n2 \naside -- or, just sent her this letter? \n3 \nA \nI spoke to her briefly saying, I'm not going to \n4 \nspeak on the record. I'm not going to address even off the \n5 \nrecord details of this case, but I will provide a letter to \n6 \nyou. I've had a lot of requests over the years to talk about \n7 \nthis case. \n8 \nThere were enough requests coming that I thought it \n9 \nimportant to provide a statement to defend the actions of the \noffice. I didn't want it to be to one reporter in \n1 \nparticular, because I did not want to play favorites. And \n12 \nso, I provided a to whom it may concern letter that was a \n13 \npublic letter, but then I gave it to her. \n14 \nMS. \n: All right. Go on? \n15 \nBY MS. \n16 \nQ \nAnd just one thing on the work release issue. Did \n17 \nyou tell the defense that -- that the U.S. Attorney's Office \n18 \nwould not object if he got work release as long as he was \n19 \ntreated like every -- like every other defendant? \n20 \nA \nSo -- so, I don't recall what I may or may not have \n21 \nsaid specifically around work release. My recollection of \n22 \nour general position is, you're pleading in state court to \n23 \nincarceration of 18 -- it's now 18 months, it was 24. \n24 \nWhether it was 18 or 24, this would have been -- any \n25 \nconversation I would have had would have been after the \nEFTA00009214\n", "char_count": 1367}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "Page 399 \n1 \nagreement was signed. \n2 \nIt's our expectation that he be treated just like \n3 \neveryone else, if -- if it was typical to provide that kind \n4 \nof work release in these cases, that would have been news to \nS \nme. I certainly would not have expected that, and I think \n6 \nbased on our subsequent communications with the state \n7 \nattorney's office, that was not what our office envisioned. \n8 \nBy the same token, I don't think our office envisioned that \n9 \nhe be treated worth that the typical offender. \n10 \nQ \nWell, did you know that \nwas in fact trying to \n11 \nmake sure that he didn't get work release? \n12 \nA \nYes. And so, I don't see any reason why I would \n13 \nhave contradicted that, is -- is my point. \n14 \nQ \nAll right. You've mentioned a number of times that \n15 \nthe sexual offender registration was the -- one of the three \n16 \nimportant prongs for you and the office. \n17 \nA \nYes. \n18 \nQ \nWhat was it that you saw the sex offender \n19 \nregistration as accomplishing? \n20 \nA \nSo, to some extent it's putting the community on \n21 \nnotice that, irrespective of whether he's in Florida or \n22 \nelsewhere, he's a registered sex offender. To some extent, I \n23 \ndon't know if this is -- but I'll say it anyhow. This was a \n24 \nserious crime, and there is a public sanction associated with \n25 \nthis, and I thought to the extent that he committed the types \nEFTA00009215\n", "char_count": 1391}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "Page 400 \n1 \nof acts that typically are associated with registration that \n2 \nthat should go forward, but the primary motivation there was, \n3 \nput the public on notice that he is a registered sex \n4 \noffender. \n5 \nQ \nAnd did you see any conflict with that as being a \n6 \ngoal with the provision in the NPA that was -- that the NPA \n7 \nwas going to be kept confidential, and the communications in \nB \nwhich the -- in which the U.S. Attorney's Office was having \n9 \nwith the defense about continuing to keep things \n10 \nconfidential? Do you see any inconsistency between those \n11 \ntwo? \n12 \nA \nNo, in that I -- I genuinely was of the opinion \n13 \nthat this NPA would go public, and certainly his public \n14 \nhis state court plea would be public, and his registration \n15 \nwould be public. And so, it would -- what he did would be \n16 \nknown. \n17 \nQ \nAnd given what you know about these office's back \n18 \nand forth on notifying the victims, do you think, looking at \n19 \nthe entire course of conduct of the office, that the victims \n20 \nwere treated fairly, and with dignity and respect? \n21 \nA \nSo, I want to be careful, not because I'm fudging, \n22 \nbut because it's a complex question. If, looking back in \n23 \nhindsight, we knew that there would be a -- what was it? Two \n24 \neight months period, when -- do we have an agreement, do we \n25 \nnot have agreement, is this concluded, is this not concluded? \nEFTA00009216\n", "char_count": 1421}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "Page 401 \n1 \nIs this an ongoing investigation? \n2 \nHow do we deal with all these notification issues? \n3 \nIf we had foreseen all of that, I think I've said before, \n4 \nthat -- that something I certainly think should have been \n5 \nconsidered, and it's very possible we would have done \n6 \nsomething very different. \n7 \nBut that was not foreseen. And so, it's then a \n8 \nvery difficult judgement to be made, because there is an \n9 \nagreement. There is concern as to if we have to go to trial, \n10 \nhow do you address this? \n11 \nThere is, you know, going to the \n12 \naffidavit, at least one instance -- and I'm merging my \n13 \nrecollection here, and -- and my knowledge after the fact, \n14 \nbecause your question sort of calls for an after the fact \n15 \nassessment. \n16 \nSo, you've got the \naffidavit, which \n17 \npoints out that defense counsel did all they could, but is \n18 \nusing this to impeach and weaken witness credibility in a \n19 \ncase where there's already questions around witness \n20 \ncredibility. \n21 \nAnd so, it's a very imperfect situation with \n22 \ndiscretionary judgements to -- to do the best, to sort of \n23 \nbalance all these factors. Is that the best outcome? \n24 \nProbably not, but that's where the -- that's where we were, \n25 \nand that's why I think this case would have been very \nEFTA00009217\n", "char_count": 1316}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "Page 402 \n1 \ndifferently if \nwhat was it, October 24 \n2 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n3 \nA \n-- he would have gone in and plead and taken his \n4 \ntime and served his time like so many other people have done \n5 \nas opposed to mount all these legal challenges that we then \n6 \nhad to work through. \n7 \nQ \nAnd I'll preface my question with the -- with the \n8 \nfact that we're still investigating this. We've made no \n9 \nconclusions --\n10 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n11 \nQ \n-- with respect to this, but if OPR determines that \n12 \nyour office should be criticized for its handling of this --\n13 \nA \nRight. \n14 \nQ \n-- matter, does that criticism fall on you, or does \n15 \nit fall on your senior managers? Because as a non-\n16 \nprosecutor, you were relying on them to keep you informed, \n17 \nand for their judgement. \n18 \nA \nSo, I was the U.S. Attorney. I certainly relied on \n19 \nmy staff, but ultimately, I was the U.S. Attorney, and I \n20 \ndon't think it's justifiable or fair to sort of say this was \n21 \non them. I was sufficiently aware of matters that -- that --\n22 \nit was my office, and -- and while I'll say that I was -- I \n23 \nmight not recall this, or I was relying on A, B, or C for \n24 \nguidance, or to handle this matter, ultimately, I think those \n25 \njudgements always sort of bubble up. \nEFTA00009218\n", "char_count": 1281}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "Page 403 \n1 \nBY MS. \n2 \nQ \nIn your press conference, you reference -- this is \n3 \nthe -- I think July 10, 2019 press conference. You \nreferenced victims, what they went through was \nA \nMm-hmm. \n6 \nQ \n-- horrific, you said, and then you said, I've seen \n7 \nthese videos. I've seen the interviews. I have seen the \n8 \ninterviews on television of these victims, and their stories. \n9 \nJust to be clear, are you talking about interviews and \n10 \ntelevision coverage and videos recently, or back in 2006 \n11 \nand --\n12 \nA \nRecently. \n13 \nQ \n-- 2007? Okay. I just wanted to be very clear \n14 \nabout that. The U.S. Attorney's manual requires us all in \n15 \nthe department to conduct the fair, even handed \n16 \nadministration of the federal criminal laws. What's your \n17 \nview as to how the handling of this case comported with that \n18 \nprinciple? \n19 \nA \nSo, I do think it was fair, and even handed. We --\n20 \nyou know, after the fact, may look back and say that two year \n21 \nmay not have -- you know, it shouldn't have been a manifest \n22 \ninjustice standard. It should have been, you know, a sort of \n23 \na de novo, let's treat this as a new prosecution. \n24 \nThat's a judgement you'll all make, but -- but \n25 \nthose judgements were made with an eye toward fairness and \nEFTA00009219\n", "char_count": 1283}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "Page 404 \n1 \nimpartiality, and once those judgements were made, despite \n2 \nall the attorneys involved, and despite all the litigation, \n3 \nand all the -- all the stuff, all the appeals to Washington \n4 \nand the -- you know, we stuck to that position. \n5 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n6 \nA \nAnd I think that speaks to the way the office \n7 \napproached this matter. \n8 \nQ \nAll right. We -- I -- we spoke sort of offline \n9 \nearlier about an issue that was raised in that press \n10 \nconference that was not clearly answered on your part in that \n11 \ncontext, and the question was -- and this is on page 15 of \n12 \nthe internet transcript of --\n13 \nA \nRight. \n14 \nQ \n-- that press conference. You were asked whether \n15 \nyou were ever made aware that Mr. Epstein was \"an \n16 \nintelligence asset of some sort.\" And you -- you in your \n17 \nresponse you said you couldn't answer it -- couldn't address \n18 \nit directly because of guidelines. Can you clarify -- first \n19 \nof all, were you ever made aware of that --\n20 \nA \nIf he was --\n21 \nQ \n-- assertion? \n22 \nA \n-- I'm not aware of it. \n23 \nQ \nAll right. Did defense counsel ever say to you \n24 \nthat Epstein had that status? \n25 \nA \nNot to my recollection. \nEFTA00009220\n", "char_count": 1202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "Page 405 \nQ \nAll right. \n2 \nA \nAnd -- and to clarify, I also don't know where \n3 \npress reports from multiple sources -- not from multiple \n4 \nsources, but from multiple media outlets that I told someone \nthat he was an intelligence asset. \n6 \nI do not know where that came from. If -- if I can \njust -- so, there are questions that I may be asked publicly, \n8 \nthat I don't think it's right for me to comment as to what \n9 \nclassified information I may or may not know, because that's \n10 \nnot the kind of stuff you'd go into, but the answer is no, \n11 \nand no. \n12 \n• \nAll right. Without reservation, without any --\nA \nNo, and no. \n• \nAll right. Excellent. Thank you. A couple of \n▪ \nfinal questions. As you can tell --\n16 \nA \nCan I -- can I --\n17 \nQ \nYes. \n18 \nA \n-- address as second issue that has come up at \n19 \ntimes? \n20 \nQ \nYes. \n21 \nA \nThere are also media reports that this was because \n22 \nof cooperation in some financial \n23 \nQ \nMe-hmm. \n24 \nA \n-- financial matters. I don't know where that may \n25 \nhave -- I don't know where that may have come from. \nEFTA00009221\n", "char_count": 1081}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "Page 406 \n1 \nQ \nAll right. Thank you, and we are familiar with \n2 \nthat, what you're referring to. \n3 \nA \nWas -- was there cooperation related to financial \n4 \nmatters? \n5 \n6 \n7 \nQ \nWe didn't ask you about it. \nA \nOkay. \nQ \nAs you can tell, OPR obtained many electronic \n8 \nrecords --\n9 \nA \nYeah. \n10 \nQ \n-- mainly e-mails, but other electronic holdings \n11 \nfrom the department. The Department of Justice, however, has \n12 \nnot been able to find/recover a portion of your e-mail \n13 \naccount as U.S. Attorney that contained e-mails received by \n14 \nyou between May 26th, 2007, and March 2008. \n15 \nA \nCorrect. \n16 \nQ \nA period of time rather relevant to this. We have \n17 \nobtained many records of course from senders and from other \n18 \npeople copied. So, we have many of the records, but the fact \n19 \nis, that's a --\n20 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n21 \nQ \n-- gap in the holdings, and this is despite the \n22 \nfact that as you no doubt know, the law requires that U.S. \n23 \nAttorney records be maintained and archived --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- indefinitely. Can you give us any insight, any \nEFTA00009222\n", "char_count": 1094}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "Page 407 \nidea why that might be the case? \n2 \nA \nI can't, and my recollection was after -- after \n3 \nseveral issues that took place, the department had some sort \n4 \nof records retention software that automatically retained \n5 \nthese e-mails. Is that not accurate? \n6 \n7 \n8 \nQ \nThere was a -- there was a switchover from --\nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- a period in which that record retention \n9 \nresponsibility resided with each U.S. Attorney's Office, and \n10 \nat the switchover, it became centralized. \nA \nRight. \nAnd this appears to have sort of gotten lost in \n13 \nthe --\n14 \nA \nBeen caught in the switchover. I -- my \n15 \nrecollection is that there was some automatic retention \n16 \nmechanism --\n17 \nQ \nOkay. \n18 \nA \n-- and I can't address that, although there's \n19 \ncertainly a fulsome -- a fulsome record. \n20 \nQ \nBut just to ask the inevitable question --\n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \n-- did you take any action to discard, destroy, or \n23 \ndispense with any official records --\n94 \nF. \nNot --\n7 \nQ \n-- related to this matter? \nEFTA00009223\n", "char_count": 1033}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "Page 408 \n1 \nA \nNot to my recollection. I think there's a fulsome \n2 \nrecord, and not to my recollection. \n3 \nQ \nAll right, and is there any particular gap that \n4 \nyou've discerned in the records that we've provided to you? \n5 \nA \nNot that I recall. Do you have the e-mails that I \n6 \nsent, out of curiosity? \n7 \nQ \nWe do. \n8 \nA \nOkay. So, you have the sent, but not received. \n9 \nQ \nYes. \n10 \nA \nJust checking. \n11 \nQ \nAnd lik \n, we retrieved from the federal records \n12 \ncenter --\n13 \nA \nRight. \n14 \nQ \n-- records that were boxed up and sent there, hard \n15 \ncopy documents, after your term ended, and there is nothing \n16 \nthat relates to the Epstein case. There were records that \n17 \nwere maintained that were kept in the main office --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- after you left, because it was an ongoing \n20 \nmatter, but it -- do you have any idea why there are not any \n21 \nin the records of yours --\n22 \nA \nSo --\n23 \nQ \n-- that were sent? \n24 \nA \nSo, I have a recollection that when I left, there \n25 \nwere some binders that I passed along to \n, because it was \nEFTA00009224\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "Page 409 \n1 \nan ongoing case, and we sort of had binders out that sort of \n2 \nhad correspondence back and forth. \n3 \nQ \nAll right, and you've already made \nwe've \n4 \nwe -- I asked you about facts, but you addressed a sort of a \n5 \nbroader statement to us for the record about the case. Is \n6 \nthere anything else you want to tell us at this point? \n7 \nA \nGive me a second to --\n8 \nQ \nSure. \n9 \nA \n-- sort of think this through. \n10 \nQ \nIn fact, if you'd like to take a quick break and \n11 \ntalk to your attorney, and that will be the last question. \n12 \nA \nDo we need a break? \n13 \nMR. \n: No. \n14 \nMS. \n: Your attorney says god no. \n15 \nTHE WITNESS I will -- I will follow up on this. \n16 \nMS. \nAll right. \n17 \nTHE WITNESS Nothing that I -- if something comes \n18 \nup, my understanding is that we're receive the transcript, \n19 \nand have enough time given the length of this to review and \n20 \ncomment. \n21 \nBY MS. \n22 \nQ \nExactly, yes, and for the record --\n23 \nA \nRight. \n24 \nQ \nwhen the transcript is prepared, which should be \n25 \nwithin a couple of weeks, we'll ship that off to your \nEFTA00009225\n", "char_count": 1103}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "Pac,-\n1 \nattorney. \n2 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n3 \nQ \nWe'll ask you to review it, to make not only any \ncorrections, but also clarifications, and to add to it --\n5 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n6 \nQ \n-- if you feel having read something that it needs \n7 \nto be clarified or expanded upon, you're invited to do so. \n8 \nA \nAnd if I could ask one -- one other question. Is \n9 \nthere -- and I'm not familiar enough with the way OPR \n10 \noperates, and this may be suigeneris, so you may not be \n11 \nprepared to answer, if there is a report as opposed to a \n12 \nletter, which is what I typically am familiar with, will that_ \n13 \nreport be shared in advance for comment? \n14 \nQ \nI am going to --\n15 \nA \nOr is that to be determined? \n16 \nMS. \nI am going to defer to Ms. \n17 \nfor that. \n18 \nMS. \n: That's a question that doesn't need to \n19 \nbe on the record. Do you have anything else that you'd want \n20 \nto put on the record before we close out? \n21 \nTHE WITNESS: I do not. \n22 \nMS. \nAll right. \n23 \nMS. \n: All right. Thank you. I want to \n24 \nextend our great appreciation for your willingness --\n25 \nTHE WITNESS No problem. \nEFTA00009226\n", "char_count": 1105}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "1 \nMS. \nPage 411 \n-- to come in and help us with this \n2 \ncase. \n3 \nTHE WITNESS So, so, let me -- now that we're off \n4 \nthe record, let me say --\n5 \nMS. \n: Are we off the record? \n9 \nTHE REPORTER: Not yet. \nTHE WITNESS Not yet? Oh. \nMS. \nNo? \nTHE REPORTER: You didn't say it. \n10 \nMS. \n: All right. That's it. We're off \n11 \nthe record. \n12 \n(Whereupon, at 8:38 p.m. the interview of r\". \n13 \nAlexander Acosta was concluded.) \nIA \n* \n* \n* \n15 \n1 \n19 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \nEFTA00009227\n", "char_count": 489}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009116", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "Page 412 \nCERTIFICATE \nTHE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ) \nIN THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA \n) \nI, Beth Roots, Notary Public, before whom the foregoing \ndeposition was taken, do hereby certify that the witness \nwhose testimony appears in the foregoing pages was duly sworn \nby me; that the testimony of said witness was reported by me \nby electronic record, and thereafter reduced to typewritten \nform; that said deposition is a true record of the testimony \ngiven by said witness; that I am neither counsel for, related \nto, nor employed by any of the parties to the action in which \nthis deposition was taken; and, further, that I am not a \nrelative or employee of any attorney or counsel employed by \nthe parties thereto, nor financially or otherwise interested \nin the outcome of this action. \nBeth Roots \nNotary Public in and for the \nDistrict of Columbia \nMy commission expires: \nApril 30, 2020 \nEFTA00009228\n", "char_count": 906}]}