{"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_count": 100, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00009016", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00009016.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Page 200 \n1 \nday, you were calling for some edits that really reflected --\n2 \nseemed to reflect a real discomfort --\n3 \nA \n4 \nQ \n-- as you identify. \n5 \nA \nAgain, I'm perhaps supporting -- I'm supporting the \n6 \npoint you're trying to make that we were focused on getting \n7 \nthis done, and real concern that he would not go to jail. \n8 \nAnd a question that I think is a valid one in my mind is, did \n9 \nthe focus on, let's just get this done and get a jail term, \n10 \nmean that we didn't take a step back and say, let's evaluate \n11 \nhow this train is moving? \n12 \nQ \nYou --\n13 \nA \nFrom my perspective. \n14 \nQ \nOkay. I want to just sort of round out the little \n15 \nbit of this -- the state -- the state only resolution. You \n16 \nused the term a couple of times backstopping. What do you \n17 \nmean by that? \n18 \nA \nWhat I mean by that is, a sense that the state \n19 \nwasn't doing enough, and perhaps backstopping is a polite way \n20 \nof saying encouraging the state to do a little bit more. \n21 \nQ \nMM-hmm. All right. Did you have any discussions \n22 \nabout whether this disposition comported with the Ashcroft \n23 \nmemo in that you were hunting to the state for a minor \n24 \ncharge, for a fairly minor charge, what you -- your office \n25 \nhad already understood from the evidence was a quite wide \nEFTA00009016\n", "char_count": 1313}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "1 \nranging scheme of predatory, my term, behavior regarding \n2 \nminor victims? \n3 \nA \nSo, I don't recall a discussion around the Ashcroft \n4 \nmemo. I would characterize what we did differently, in that \n5 \nthere are any number of instances where the federal \n6 \ngovernment or the state government can proceed, and state \n7 \ncharges are substantially less and different, and on a fairly \n8 \nregular basis, the federal government allows the state \nno: \n9 \nallows, but stands aside and lets the state proceed. \n10 \nQ \nBut in this case, you actually had an active \n11 \ninvestigation that had been proceeding for a year. \n12 \nA \nSo, let's take the drug context, where there might \n13 \nbe any number of active investigations where the federal \n14 \ncharges can be rather substantial, but ultimately, the \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \nQ \nBut the state goes forward with what? \n21 \nA \nForward with different charges that -- that have a \n22 \nlesser term. And so, I don't think it's unusual. We can \n23 \ntalk about, you know, whether this was the best disposition \n24 \nor not, but I don't think it's unusual to have fact patterns \n25 \nthat are under investigation that proceed in state court, \nfederal government says just let the state proceed with this, \nor violent crime cases where the federal government could \nbring gun charges using felon in possession or another \nmandatory minimum, but the state goes forward with -- so, in \nthat sense --\nEFTA00009017\n", "char_count": 1445}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Page 202 \n1 \nwhere the disposition is different than -- and would have \n2 \nbeen if it had proceeded in federal court. \n3 \nQ \nAll right. Do you have anything on that? \n4 \n: On the two years, or something else? \n5 \n: No. I'm going back to the two \n6 \nyears. \n7 \n: Okay. \n8 \nBY \n9 \nQ \nDid you think -- did you believe at the time, if \n10 \nthis was part of your thinking, that because it was so \n11 \nimportant to get sex offender registration, and even later \n12 \ndeveloped damages -- monetary damages for the victims, under \n13 \nthe state plea arrangement, that pretty much the only thing \n14 \nthat the government had -- the federal government had to give \n15 \nup in this negotiation was jail time? If you wanted -- you \n16 \nwanted --\n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \nQ \n-- three things --\n19 \nA \nCorrect. \n20 \nQ \n-- you've said, jail time, sex offender status, and \n21 \nsome kind of restitution or damages --\n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \n-- mechanisms. Sex offender registration, there's \n24 \nno -- really no give there. You either register or you \n25 \ndon't. I'm being binary --\nEFTA00009018\n", "char_count": 1070}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Page 203 \n1 \n2 \n6 \n7 \n8 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- again, I'm sorry. \nA \nBut it is binary, so --\nQ \nIt is binary. \nA \nYes. \nQ \nAnd likewise, the --\nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- monetary recovery provisions. So, really, the \n9 \nonly thing to negotiate is time, right? \n10 \nA \nAnd so, your question is why did we not start at \n11 \nthree so we ended up at two? \n12 \nQ \nWell, that's -- that's -- that's a consequence of \n13 \nwhat --\n14 \nA \nSo --\n15 \nQ \n-- I was asking. \n16 \nA \nSo, again, my recollection is I understood this to \n17 \nreflect what he would have received as opposed to some \n18 \narbitrary, let's start at three so we end up at two. I \n19 \nalso -- I'm sorry, you have a question? \n20 \nQ \nNo, go ahead. Go ahead. I'll get to my question. \n21 \nA \nYou know, I also -- from my perspective, was, you \n22 \nknow, early on when we set firm on the two years, I thought \n23 \ntwo years would have been the right outcome. We ended up on \n24 \n18 months. I can't say how. There's some documents that \n25 \nmight help, but I -- but I was at least initially firm on \nEFTA00009019\n", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Page 204 \n1 \nthose two years. \n2 \nQ \nRight, so you -- when you say, I thought the two \n3 \nyears was the right amount, is that based on your \n4 \nunderstanding that that's what he would have gotten in the \n5 \nstate? \n6 \nA \nCorrect. \n7 \nQ \nAll right. \n8 \nA \nThat -- and the point I'm trying to convey there is \n9 \nthat this wasn't, to my understanding, a random number, but \n10 \nit was informed by, this is what he would have received, and \n11 \ntherefore it is a reasonable -- agree or disagree with the \n12 \nanalysis, but it was an informed number to begin with. \n13 \nBY \n14 \nQ \nBut you don't recall how that analysis was done, or \n15 \nwho conducted --\n16 \nA \n17 \nQ \n-- that analysis? \n18 \nA \n-- don't recall that. \n19 \nBY -: \n20 \nQ \nOr even whether it was accurate, actually? \n21 \nA \nI -- again, I don't recall that. \n22 \nQ \nAll right. \n23 \nBY \n24 \nQ \nAnd I understand the explanation. \n25 \nA \nRight. \nEFTA00009020\n", "char_count": 914}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Page 205 \n1 \nQ \nAnd --\n2 \nA \nRight. \n3 \nQ \n-- what it's tied to, but was there any \n4 \nconsideration -- because this case --\n5 \nA \nRight. \n6 \nQ \n-- was not about one or two victims. It was a very \n7 \nlarge scheme by this older, wealthy man, to essentially turn \n8 \nminors into prostitutes, have sex with them, oral sex, get \n9 \nother people involved. \n10 \nYou've described it in prior statements as \n11 \ngrotesque and deserving of punishment. What I'm not hearing \n12 \nthrough this process is anybody taking a look at this overall \n13 \nconduct, and saying, what is the appropriate punishment for \n14 \nthis man's conduct? Was there such a consideration, and did \n15 \nyou feel that two years adequately punished him for the scope \n16 \nof his conduct? \n17 \nA \nFair question, and perhaps going back to where we \n18 \nstarted, which is petite. To my mind at the time, there was \n19 \na distinction between what would be the adequate punishment \n20 \nif this was a purely federal case, versus what is necessary \n21 \nso that it is not a -- to put it in petite language \na \n22 \nmanifest injustice, so that it wouldn't have come to the \n23 \noffice in the first place. \n24 \nAnd that I think is the important distinction, \n25 \nbecause if the two years is what he would have received, and \nEFTA00009021\n", "char_count": 1288}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Page 206 \n1 \ntherefore it would not have come into the office under \n2 \npetite, then if there is a state disposition to that, that is \n3 \none possible outcome. \n4 \nIt would be a different outcome if this was truly a \n5 \nfederal pro=section independent of the state, which goes back \n6 \nto the point I was making about concern about a federal \n7 \nprecedent with this kind of sentence, because then when the \n8 \nnext person comes along, they say, well, here is this \n9 \nprecedent under 371, or whatnot. \n10 \nAnd so, this was, rightly or wrongly, and I \n11 \nunderstand the -- the pushback -- an analysis that \n12 \ndistinguished between what is necessary to prevent manifest \n13 \ninjustice, versus what is the appropriate federal outcome to \n14 \nthat. Agree or disagree with the logic is one thing, but did \n15 \nI explain the logic? \n16 \nQ \nYou've -- yes, you've explained the logic. \n17 \nA \nOkay. \n18 \nQ \nAnd I'm going to push back a little bit --\n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \n-- on that, because the petite policy specifically \n21 \nsays it does not apply where the state conduct is only a \n22 \nminor part -- an insignificant part of the entire course of \n23 \nconduct, and they give examples about where you have some \n24 \ntype of a RICO scheme, and the state has indicted or \n25 \nconvicted the perpetrator based on something that could be \nEFTA00009022\n", "char_count": 1344}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "one single overt act in the government's conspiracy, and \n2 \ndoesn't that really show what is going on here, that what the \n3 \nstate had done was really just a small, minor part of this \n4 \nscheme that the federal government had a --\nA \nRight. \n6 \nQ \n-- had a real opportunity to punish him for this \n7 \nentire course of conduct? \n8 \nA \nSo, possibly, but if I can circle back to your \n9 \nquestion previously, it's interesting that you characterize \n10 \nthis as, he's turning these girls into prostitutes, and then \n11 \nI think that's really interesting, because in 2019, 13 years \n12 \nafterwards, despite all the changes in the law, there is \n13 \nstill some element somewhere that says he's turning these \n14 \ngirls into prostitutes, whereas this was a typical \n15 \ntrafficking case of the kind that you'd see in the Lou De \n16 \nBaca days where, you know, it was called modern day slavery. \n17 \nThat's a very different fact pattern. \n18 \nSo, you know, a girl that's held captive, is forced \n9 \nto service multiple men per day, where this is part of an \n20 \nongoing business arrangement. And so, I hear what you're \n21 \nsaying, but if here at this table at least some element of \n22 \nthat characterization is live, what would it mean in 2006 \n23 \nwhen these laws are still being developed? And that \n24 \nconsideration, rightly or wrongly, was part of this analysis. \n25 \nBY \nEFTA00009023\n", "char_count": 1387}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "1 \nQ \nWas it explicitly -- in other words, was -- was \nthat aspect of it, the -- I -- the perception that this was \nperhaps activity that -- in which the victims cooperated? \n4 \nWas that part of the --\nS \nA \nNo, no. Let me -- let me distinguish. I didn't \n6 \nsay the perception that this was activities in which the \n7 \nvictims cooperated. What I was going to -- what I -- and \n8 \nI've gone to before is, would jurors -- is there at least one \n9 \njuror that might say, look, we've got conflicting victim \n10 \ntestimony. \n1.1 \nSome of them said he did nothing wrong. They all \n12 \nknew each other. They kept going back and taking payment. \n13 \nIs this trafficking, or is this prostitution? I'm not --\n14 \nnot saying I agree with that, and I don't think -- I don't \n15 \nthink prosecutors do, I'm saying is there -- is there at \n16 \nleast a possibility of that? And --\n17 \nQ \nWas that articulated to you by the people you were \n18 \nlistening to by \nand --\n19 \nA \nSo --\n20 \n21 \nA \nSo, that certainly was part of the discussions when \n22 \nI talk about the victim issues, would at least some jurors \n23 \nview it that way, rightly or wrongly? \n24 \nQ \nAnd you recall having that -- those --\n25 \nA \nEFTA00009024\n", "char_count": 1203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Page \nQ \n-- conversations? \n2 \nA \nI recall having not only how would the witnesses \n3 \nstand up in court, but how would jurors view them? And then \n4 \nthe second part of that is, as it goes up in the appellate \n5 \nprocess with respect to the -- the federal nexus. And so, I \n6 \nhear you, but you know, I -- it's -- it's sort of one of the \n7 \nfactors. And so --\n8 \nBY \n9 \nQ \nAnd so --\n10 \nA \n11 \nQ \n-- what I'm getting though is that there didn't \n12 \nseem like there was a consideration or discussion about, is \n13 \nthis two years capturing the scope of his conduct, versus, \n14 \nwe're just going to tie it to this potential state crime that \n15 \ncould have been charged? \n.6 \nA \nFair, and I would -- I would say that the two years \n17 \nwas not meant -- so, the petite policy has several prongs, \n18 \nand to my recollection, the petite analysis was not based \n19 \non -- and let's not even call it petite analysis. That \n20 \noverstates it. \n21 \nBut it was much more of a, is this a manifest \n22 \ninjustice, and -- and if the original -- and so, you sort of \n23 \nsee it in the Exhibit 3. This would not have been brought to \n24 \nthe office in the first place if -- you know, if he had plead \n25 \nto jail time and registration, and rightly or wrongly, that \nEFTA00009025\n", "char_count": 1269}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Page 210 \n1 \nwas understood from the very beginning of the case, and was a \n2 \nfactor in how the case was viewed. \n3 \nQ \nAnd how do you know that it wouldn't have -- that \n4 \nwouldn't have been upset with a minimal jail \n5 \ntime, even if there was sex registration? \n6 \nA \nSo, I can't 12 years later say how we knew that. I \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n: They did. \n13 \nTHE WITNESS: I can't speak for certain, but you \n14 \nprobably have that from the record, and that when they \n15 \nchanged the ASA involved and took it to grand jury, the \n16 \ncharges that came back were substantially less. \n17 \nBY \n18 \nQ \nDo you remember the circumstances? Did you know \n19 \nthe circumstances under which that ASA was changed? \n20 \nA \nI don't know. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. The -- by the way, do you remember an \n22 \noccasion in which \ncame to your office in Miami \n23 \nto press you on what was going to be happening with the \ncan say that my -- my general impression was that this was \nproceeding at the state, that there were certain charges, and \nthat those charges changed when it went to a grand jury, and \nthat it went from -- I think they even changed the ASA \ninvolved. \n24 \nfederal case? \n25 \nA \nI don't recall. \n• \nEFTA00009026\n", "char_count": 1211}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "1 \nQ \nYou don't recall. I --\n2 \n: Just one more, \n: Yeah. \n4 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. \n5 \nBY \n6 \nQ \nSo, before we --\n7 \nA \nYeah. \n8 \nQ \n-- leave this --\n9 \nYeah. \n10 \nQ \n-- one little thing. So, if this case had come \n11 \ninto the federal system as apart from the --\n2 \nFicht. \nQ \n-- taken the digression through the --\nA \nRlunt. \n-- state system, do you think that the two years \nwas an appropriate punishment, given the scope of his \nconduct? \nA \nI think if it had come into the federal system \n19 \napart from the whole state and the petite considerations and \n20 \nall that, we may have ended up in a different place. I \n21 \nviewed the two years, to my recollection, as a manifest \n22 \ninjustice standard, and not an appropriate punishment \n23 \nstandard. \n24 \nQ \nMeaning whether it was manifestly unjust that he \n25 \nget two years? \nEFTA00009027\n", "char_count": 843}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Page 212 \n1 \nA \nNo, whether it was -- so, let me -- let me -- let \n2 \nme rephrase. No jail time was a manifest injustice. If he \n3 \nhad gone to jail for two years in the state system and \n4 \nregistered, the question of whether it would have come to the \n5 \noffice at all, and to my recollection, the consensus was, and \n6 \nbased on Exhibit 3, agrees with that, that it would \n7 \nnever have come to the office in the first place, because we \n8 \nwould not view that under petite as a manifest injustice. \n9 \nThere are any number of cases that are prosecuted \n10 \naround the country where an individual gets a jail time that \n11 \nthe federal government may not agree with, but that doesn't \n12 \nmean that the federal government reprosecutes those cases. \n13 \nThe instances where the federal government reprosecutes a \n14 \nstate case are pretty rare, to my knowledge. \n15 \nAnd so, under the petite standard, and the \n16 \npetite -- the manifest injustice would -- it would have been \n17 \na manifest injustice to have zero jail time, and zero \n18 \nregistration, but if the original charges had remained, that \n19 \nwould be a different matter. That does not mean that that is \n20 \nthe best outcome in the state system. \n21 \nand so, perhaps beating a -- you know, an issue, \n22 \nbut let me maybe give an example. One concern that I had was \n23 \nthat in the violent crime side, the state brings a case, and \n24 \nyou know, there is a deferment, no jail time. The state then \n25 \nbrings a second case, and there's minimal jail time. Well, \nEFTA00009028\n", "char_count": 1542}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Page 213 \n1 \nnow the person has done three violent crimes, they have a \n2 \ngun, they go federal, and it's like, please don't do that. \n3 \nPretty please don't do that. \n4 \nYou know, we're going to punish you a little bit, \n5 \nand then all of a sudden in comes the federal government with \n6 \nthe big, big punch to the face, because the federal sentences \n7 \nare so different than the state sentences. And that happens \n8 \nall the time in any number of contexts in Florida. That \n9 \ndoesn't mean that all of those cases get reprosecuted as gun \n10 \ncases in Florida. \n11 \nThat means that we understand that the Florida \n12 \nsystem is different than the federal system. And so, the way \n13 \nwe looked at, at least based on my recollection, those two \n14 \nyears was not, what would he have received if this was a \n15 \npurely federal case, but would this case have been prosecuted \n16 \nby the federal system additionally if he had received jail \n17 \ntime and registration in the state system? \n8 \nQ \nAnd would -- is it fair to say that this particular \n9 \nconcern about, for lack of a better word, federalism or the \n20 \npetite policy, was that a primary concern of yours versus any \n21 \nof your employees in terms of \nor \n22 \nA \nI think it's fair to say that I focused more on the \n23 \nlegal side of things, and my team focused more on the trial \n24 \nand how this would play out at trial, and both of them \n25 \nboth of them sort of informed the outcome. \nEFTA00009029\n", "char_count": 1464}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Page 214 \n1 \nQ \nAnd are you including this petite policy in your \n2 \nconsideration of the legal issues? \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \nA \nYes. Yeah. I think those are all tied together. \nBY \nQ \nSo, you mentioned victim --\nA \nBut -- but could I -- could I --\nQ \nYes. \nA \nBut to clarify, I thought we had sufficient to go \n9 \nforward so it wasn't an ethical violation to proceed. \n10 \nQ \nMm-hmm. Okay. The victim -- you mentioned the \n11 \nvictims coming into state court, and you talked about all the \n12 \nvictims coming into state court. Do you have any idea what \n13 \nvictims formed the basis for the original charge that --\n14 \nA \nI do not. \n15 \nQ \n-- he was indicted on? Do you know whether it was \n16 \none -- was it a felony assault pros of a non-minor. \n17 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n18 \nQ \nIt could have been -- it was three instances to \n19 \nfelonize it. You don't know whether it was one person three \n20 \ntimes, three people? \n21 \nA \nI do not. \n22 \nQ \nAnd you don't know whether that person was a minor \n23 \nor not? \n24 \nA \nI do not. \n25 \nQ \nAll right. \nEFTA00009030\n", "char_count": 1049}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Page 215 \n1 \nA \nI would assume they were, but I do not. \n2 \nQ \nLikewise, do you know who was the victim, or who \n3 \nthe victims were who formed the basis for the 796.03 charge \n4 \nto which Epstein ultimately pled in June of 2008? \n5 \nA \nI did not at the time. I've read various accounts \n6 \nof that, but that's based on matters that I've read and not \n7 \nan independent recollection. \n8 \nQ \nAnd what's your understanding? \n9 \nA \nMy understanding is that there's some \nthat there \n10 \nis at least some issue in the media over whether the -- the \n11 \nright or the best victims were chosen from the prosecution's \n12 \nperspective. \n13 \nQ \nAnd do you know -- was there any indication of who \n14 \nthe victims were? Do you know who the victims were who were \n15 \nthe subject of the state charges? \n16 \nA \nWhich particular names? No, I don't. \n17 \nQ \nRight, I'm not asking you --\n18 \nA \nYeah. \n19 \nQ \n-- other than names --\n20 \nA \nYeah. \n21 \nI just want to know if you know who they are or \n22 \nhow many they were. \n23 \nA \nI -- I do not. \n24 \nQ \nRight, it could be one, right? For this -- for the \n25 \nsolicitation. It could be one conceivably. Both the charges \nEFTA00009031\n", "char_count": 1169}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Page 216 \n1 \ncould relate to one victim. \n2 \nA \nRight. So -- so, those matters were very much part \n3 \nof the negotiation that\n and to some extent Andy were \n4 \ninvolved in. I did not --\n5 \nQ \nWhat makes you think that -- that -- the -- your \n6 \npeople were negotiating which victims would form the basis? \n7 \n8 \n9 \nA \nFair. Fair point. \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nFair point. I withdraw. They may not have. I \n10 \ndon't know -- I don't know how in the weeds and how much our \n11 \nfolks, as a federal system, sort of interacted with the state \n12 \nin terms of what punishment. I -- there's at least some \n13 \ndiscussion in the media regarding whether the punishment was \n14 \na function of the victims and registration, and I can't speak \n15 \nto that. \n16 \nQ \nAll right. Are you aware, just as a point of \n17 \ninterest, that the public record of the proceedings in the \n18 \nstate court related to Epstein are utterly silent as to who \n19 \nor how many victims form the basis of the charges to which he \n20 \npled? \n21 \nA \nI -- no. I was not aware. \n22 \nQ \nOkay. So, this idea of many victims coming forth \n23 \nin state court and so on are not -- is not -- it's not really \n24 \nin play. All right. So, you have a two year -- two years \n25 \nhas been now -- a two year state deal has been announced to \nEFTA00009032\n", "char_count": 1296}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Page 217 \n1 \nthe team by \n2 \nA \nYeah. \n3 \nQ \nWith your knowledge and approval, right? Because \n4 \nhe wouldn't do it otherwise. Is that right? \nA \nFair. \n6 \nQ \nThough at least one was surprised. Do you know \n7 \nwhat drove the timing of the plea offer? In other words, why \n8 \ndid it have to be made at that point? \n9 \nA \nI do not. \n10 \nQ \nOkay. You know that \nsubmitted his \n11 \nresignation on the 23rd of July. \n12 \nA \nI saw that in the --\n13 \nQ \nRight. \n14 \nA \n-- in the -- in the documents. \n15 \nQ \nIn the documents, and he submitted that to you \n16 \namong other -- as well as the --\n17 \nA \nYeah. \n18 \nQ \nHR people. Why not -- well, then there was a \n19 \nJuly 31st meeting at which the term sheet was presented. \n20 \nThis document 15 is the term sheet that was presented, as \n21 \nindicates in her September 6th cover note -- cover e-\n22 \nmail. And you said you approved it. You happen to be copied \n23 \n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- though --\nEFTA00009033\n", "char_count": 953}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \nA \nSo --\nQ \nA \nLet me --\nQ \n-- forwards this, but --\nA \nLet me -- let me be -- let me be accurate. I \n6 \napproved these terms, whether it was this specific term sheet \n7 \nor another -- another document that might have been earlier \n8 \nthat looked highly similar to this. \n9 \nMy recollection is approving a, \nyou know, \n10 \napproving a resolution that had him pleading to certain state \n11 \ncounts that had a binding two-year plus recommendation that - \n12 \n- and that provided for 22.55 restitution. \n13 \nQ \nRight, but you don't know if it was this sheet of \n14 \npaper? \n15 \nA \nI can't say 12 years after the fact whether it was \n16 \nthis specific sheet --\n17 \nQ \nRight. \n19 \nQ \nAll right. \n20 \nA \n-- or others. I -- based on the fact that this was \n21 \nin the e-mail, I think it's safe to -- to assume, but --\n22 \nQ \nTo assume what? \n23 \nA \nTo assume that it was this. \n24 \nQ \noh. \n2S \nA \nBut it's possible that there was as slight \nEFTA00009034\n", "char_count": 962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Page 219 \n1 \ndifference in --\n2 \nQ \nAll right. In fact, this -- this same document \n3 \nwith a couple of --\n4 \n5 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- additional bullets that had to do with the date \n6 \nof entry of the plea, sort of ministerial, is what was \n7 \nprepared by \non or about the 31st -- on or \n8 \nbefore the 31st of July, and this document, as indicated --\n9 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n10 \nQ \n-- here, along with the attached guidelines \n11 \ncalculation is what was provided to the folks who met on the \n12 \n31st --\n13 \nA \nFair. \n14 \nQ \n-- of July. Okay. So, on that 31st, it was \n15 \n, Jerry Lefcourt, \nSanchez, and the purpose of \n16 \nthe meeting with Sloman, Menchel, Lourie, and \nas \n17 \nwell as the case agents was to present the plea offer. And \n18 \ndid you get briefed on how that plea offer went? \n19 \nA \nI don't recall being briefed, but in the regular \n20 \ncourse, I would have been. \n21 \nQ \nAll right, and at that meeting, there was an \n22 \nexpression of concern by the defense team that Epstein wanted \n23 \nto avoid being incarcerated in the state system because of \n24 \nconcerns for his physical safety, and that concern was \n25 \naccommodated to the extent that the U.S. Attorney's Office \nEFTA00009035\n", "char_count": 1193}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Page \nteam agreed to explore federal resolution. How does that \n2 \nsquare with your decision that a state plea is how this case \n3 \nwas going to be --\n4 \n5 \n6 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- decided? \nA \nSo, I think I indicated later that it's a little \n7 \nbit more fluid than a decision here or a decision \nyou \n8 \nknow, than binary situations. My recollection is we were \n9 \nvery focused on, this man should go to jail, and this man \n10 \nshould register. \n11 \nThe two year plea to the state charges seemed \n12 \nreasonable and seemed a way to go. We can agree or disagree. \n13 \nReasonable in terms of -- not in terms of, was it the -- the \n14 \nmost just outcome, but seemed like a disposition that we \nIs \nwould agree to. \n:6 \nBut ultimately, the focus was on getting him to \n:7 \njail, and if that meant exploring a 371, it's at least worth \n18 \nexploring. And so, I don't think it was inconsistent, \n19 \nbecause the focus really was on, he needs to go to jail. \n20 \nQ \nOkay. In this case, that -- that push back of \n21 \nthe -- that resulted --\n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \n-- in the agreement to explore a federal plea --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- was because Epstein was afraid to be in prison. \nEFTA00009036\n", "char_count": 1190}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Page 221 \n1 \nWhy would the U.S. Attorney's Office accommodate that? And \n2 \nhere, we're getting to -- we're beginning to talk about a \n3 \nmajor point of criticism of this whole process and the \n4 \noutcome and that is that it appeared that the U.S. Attorney's \n5 \nOffice was bending over backward to accommodate the concerns \n6 \nof Jeffrey Epstein, and in this case, he was uncomfortable \n7 \ngoing to a federal or state prison, but all child sex \n8 \npredators who go to prison are going to face some --\n9\n \nYeah. \n10 \nQ \n-- challenges, right? \n11 \nA \nRight, and I remember along the way a heavy push \n12 \nthat he be incarcerated at this home under some kind of home \n13 \nconfinement, and my reaction to that was no way. \n14 \nQ \nRight. \n15 \nA \nAnd okay, you don't like prison, but that doesn't \n16 \nmean you get to be incarcerated in your house. \n17 \nQ \nMm-hr. \n18 \nA \nWhich is interesting, because subsequently \n19 \nQ \nYeah. \n20 \nA \nAnd so --\n21 \nQ \nBecause subsequently, what? You might as well \n22 \nfinish --\n23 \nA \nWell, because --\n24 \nQ \n-- that. \n25 \nA \n-- subsequently, the way that the state executed \nEFTA00009037\n", "char_count": 1121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Page 22\n1 \nthe terms of incarceration were not what I would have \n2 \nexpected. And so, again, the focus from my perspective is, \n3 \nhe needs to go to jail. If the team agreed to explore it, \n4 \nyou know, the 371 was on the table to the extent we had \n5 \nbeen -- I'm speculating now. This is not to make the record \n6 \nclear. \n7 \nQ \nMm-hmm. Thank you. \n8 \nA \nI'm speculating, not recalling. I can speculate a \n9 \n371 with a two year rule 11 had been discussed based on the \n10 \ncontemporaneous record, and so, to the extent it had already \n11 \nbeen discussed, even if it was not the direction we were \n12 \ntaking, would it have been unusual for folks in the room to \n13 \nsay, well, look, we've discussed that, let's go back. You \n14 \nknow, let's see where it goes. I can't fault -- to the \n15 \nextent it had been discussed -- I can't fault anyone for \n16 \nsaying, let's go back and look at it. I think that's \n17 \ndistinguishable at least from subsequent --\n18 \nQ \nAll right. At that point, the defense was given \n19 \ntwo weeks to take it or leave it, and if not, you would \n20 \nindict, and there were several occasions --\n21 \nA \nCorrect. \n22 \nQ \n-- when that kind of ultimately was made. Did that \n23 \nmean -- I mean, given all of your concerns about barriers to \n24 \nwhat you would consider a successful federal prosecution, was \n25 \nthat a bluff? \nEFTA00009038\n", "char_count": 1363}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n4 \nA \nQ \nA \nQ \nPage 223 \nNo. \nIt was not. \nIt was not. \nYou were at some level at least prepared to approve \n5 \nthe presentation of the -- or, the presentment of --\n6 \nA \nWe --\n7 \nQ \n-- an indictment? \n8 \nA \nWe should not have gone forward with these \n9 \nnegotiations if we weren't ready to --\n10 \nQ \nAll right. \n11 \nA \n-- to approve. Whether in this form or a different \n12 \nform and indictment, and I say that because it was very much \n13 \na draft indictment that hadn't been reviewed fully by the \n14 \nchain, but it wasn't a bluff. \n15 \nQ \nWell, by this time it -- it had been reviewed, and \n16 \nit --\n19 \nA \nHad it been reviewed, and revised, and --\nQ \nIt had -- there -- there had been some efforts to \nbegin revising, so --\n20 \nA \nSo --\n24 \n4 \nA \n4 \nA \nYeah. \nSome --\nIt wasn't finalized. \nYeah. Some efforts to begin --\n25 \nQ \nExactly. \nEFTA00009039\n", "char_count": 863}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Page 224 \n1 \nA \nRight. \n2 \nQ \nOkay. Looking at 11a, this is a letter that \n3 \ndrafted to sort of actually respond to a \n4 \ncounteroffer by the defense. The counteroffer is represented \n5 \nin Exhibit 10b, which is a letter from \nSanchez \n6 \nwhich we don't need to go into in detail, because as you've \n7 \nalready pointed out, essentially it was a home confinement, \n8 \nand you know, very, very soft --\n9\n \nYeah. \n10 \nQ \n-- landing counteroffer. In 11a, \n11 \ntweaks \nletter, you're copied on this, and the date is \n12 \nAugust 2, Thursday, and he notes that he hadn't discussed it \n13 \nin detail with you, but he wanted to -- he hoped that \n14 \ntomorrow, Friday the 3rd --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- he'd have a chance to, and what's notable here \n17 \nis that -- is that the -- there's strong language that the \n18 \n\"Office believes that the federal interest would not be \n19 \nvindicated in the absence of a two year term of state \n20 \nimprisonment for Mr. Epstein. That offer was not meant as a \n21 \nstarting point for negotiation. It is the minimum term of \n22 \nimprisonment that will obviate the need for federal \n23 \nprosecution.\" \n24 \nA \nYou're on paragraph two? \n25 \nQ \nOne. \nEFTA00009040\n", "char_count": 1190}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Page 225 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \nA \nOne, yes. \nQ \nOh, two. \nA \nYeah. \nQ \nIt's the first --\nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- long paragraph. And then he also states that --\n7 \nthat you in the last paragraph -- the U.S. Attorney, \"U.S. \n8 \nAttorney Acosta has asked me to communicate that the two year \n9 \nterm of incarceration is non-negotiable.\" \n10 \nA \nYes. \n11 \nQ \nThat's pretty firm. That's a -- that's a line --\n12 \nA \nIt is. \n13 \nQ \n-- in the concrete that is setting, right? \n14 \nA \nRight. \n15 \nQ \nAnd lib is the letter as it actually went out the \n16 \nnext day. \n17 \nA \nAnd it's got the same language. \n18 \nQ \nIt's identical. It has the same language. It has \n19 \none typo corrected. This is \nlast day in the \n20 \noffice. \n21 \nA \nYes. \n22 \nQ \nAnd he's gone after that. Do you think that this \n23 \nwas an -- the appropriate timing to extend this offer, or to \n24 \nset this as the minimum offer, or was it something that you \n25 \nwould've liked to have seen more fully developed in \nEFTA00009041\n", "char_count": 980}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Page 226 \n1 \nnegotiations with defense counsel? \n2 \nA \nI'm sorry, I don't understand your question when \n3 \nyou say more fully developed. \n4 \nQ \nWell, you -- you have two years. Would -- would \n5 \nfurther consideration have led the U.S. Attorney's Office to \n6 \ndecide that, well, maybe the two years is too much of a \n7 \ngiveaway; we should stick with a five year federal plea? \n8 \nA \nYeah. I can't -- so, I can't speculate this far \n9 \nafter the fact whether waiting an additional time period and \n10 \nfurther discussion would have changed things. I can tell you \n11 \nhow we came up with it, but that -- that's a lot of \n12 \nspeculation. \n13 \nQ \nWould you say that \nwas -- as the \n14 \ncriminal chief, was essentially the driver of this -- of the \n15 \nresolution --\n16 \nA \nRight. \n17 \n(2 \n-- presented in this letter? \n18 \nA \nI can't. Again, you're asking me to speak to \n19 \nsomething from 12 years ago. I can't speak to it. I was \n20 \naware of the multiple prongs. I approved it. If we had had, \n21 \nyou know, if -- if a -- at some point -- is your question is \n22 \nif at some point there had been a, let's sit down and \n23 \nreconsider meeting, would we have gone in a different \n24 \ndirection? Perhaps, but I can't, 12 years after the fact, \n25 \nspeculate as to what may have happened if something had \nEFTA00009042\n", "char_count": 1320}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Page 227 \n1 \nhappened. \n2 \nQ \nAll right. \n3 \nA \nThat's just a lot of hypotheticals. \n4 \nQ \nUnderstood. The question though is whether Matt \n5 \nMenchel, who was the author --\n6 \nA \nRight. \n7 \nQ \n-- of this, who first raised it --\n8 \nA \nRight. \n-- with \n9 \nQ \nSanchez --\n10 \nA \nYeah. \n11 \nQ \n-- in an informal discussion, and who presented it \n12 \nto the U.S. Attorney's Office team, was this really his baby? \n13 \nA \nI can't --\n14 \nQ \nApproved by you. \n15 \nA \nI can't -- I don't remember who I talked to about \n16 \nwhat, and so it wouldn't be fair for me to -- you know, I \n17 \ncan't single out any one person as having a greater or lesser \n18 \nrole. \n19 \nQ \nWell, you were not the architect of this, right? \n20 \nYou approved it as you've described it. \n21 \nA \nNo, I haven't said I wasn't the architect. What I \n22 \nsaid is I don't recall --\n23 \nQ \nRight. \n24 \nA \nI recall approving it. You know, I -- I think what \n25 \nI'm trying to convey is these discussions are much more fluid \nEFTA00009043\n", "char_count": 995}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Page 228 \n1 \nthan I think any one single architect. You've got multiple \n2 \nlawyers. They interact on a daily basis. They talk back and \n3 \nforth. \n4 \nTo -- to sort of put it in an OPR context, there's \n5 \nprobably not going to be a single author to the report. \n6 \nYou're all going to go back and forth, and there might be \n7 \nsomeone that has \nmaybe there is a single author. Who \n8 \nknows? But it's -- I think it's difficult to say there's a \n9 \nsingle person, and ultimately I was U.S. Attorney, and so I \n10 \napproved it and \n11 \nQ \nTo your knowledge, did anyone in that chain of \n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- that five person chain or anyone else disagree \n14 \nwith this offer? \n15 \nA \nTo --\n16 \nQ \nI'm not talking about --\n17 \nA \nTo my knowledge -- to my knowledge, I think \n18 \nat sometimes may have felt uncomfortable, but whether there \n19 \nwas explicit disagreement or not, I don't recall. In terms \n20 \nof my management chain, I don't recall any disagreement. \n21 \nQ \nThat you were aware of? \n22 \nA \nThat I was aware of. I -- I recalled discussions. \n23 \nSo, for example, \nmight say I might proceed with a 371 \n24 \nwith a two year cap under rule 11, but then we move in this \n25 \nother direction, and I don't recall anyone saying, let's take \nEFTA00009044\n", "char_count": 1264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Page 229 \n1 \na time out, let's reconsider. \n2 \nQ \nAll right. \n3 \nA \nAnd let me -- let me just clarify, I think at \n4 \nvarious points in this case -- and it's hard -- it's hard to \n5 \nsort of single out the timeline. Ms. \nwas \n6 \nsupportive, or maybe I wish we would go in a different \n7 \ndirection, and that sort of went in and out a little bit. \n8 \nQ \nOn her part? \n9 \nA \nYes. \n10 \nQ \nLet me ask you this. Having reached the decision \n11 \nthat you approved --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- that this was the offer, and the term sheet, or \n14 \nthe terms, having that decision made, would you have expected \n15 \nyour line AUSA to frustrate that, or to not abide by that, \n16 \nsince it was your decision? \n17 \nA \nNo, with a caveat that if at any point someone felt \n18 \ntruly uncomfortable, I would expect them to come and talk to \n19 \nme about it. \n20 \nQ \nAnd can you recall any instance in which an AUSA --\n21 \na line AUSA came and talked to you about a disposition that \n22 \nhe or she was uncomfortable with? \n23 \nA \nYes. So, I'll give you an example. I don't recall \n24 \nwho, before you ask me, but there was this AUSA who was new \n25 \nto the office who impressed the hell out of me. I'm sorry, \nEFTA00009045\n", "char_count": 1206}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Page 230 \n1 \nthat's not appropriate language -- who impressed me \n2 \nsignificantly. \n3 \nHe had inherited a case, and it was a fraud case, \n4 \nand the -- the bigger players had been charged, and he was \n5 \nbasically given a lesser player to -- to basically just \n6 \nfinish up on, right? \n7 \nIt was a done deal. The person was ready to plead \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \nQ \nMe-hom. \n14 \nA \nWhich, for a new AUSA in the office is pretty gusty \n15 \nand unusual, but if this person really felt that this lesser \n16 \nplayer wasn't deserving, then that was the right thing to do. \n17 \nQ \nRight. \n18 \nA \nAnd so, I don't -- and the person was not punished \n19 \nfor it. \n20 \nQ \nMm-hem. \n21 \nA \nIf anything --\n22 \nQ \nMm-hmo. \n23 \nA \n-- you know, I recounted that story to others. \n24 \nQ \nOkay. A question, shifting gears --\n25 \nto some minor count, no jail time, and he felt uncomfortable \nwith it, and went to his supervisor, and then ultimately came \nup to me, and I had a discussion with this person about it, \nand it ended up with my telling him to go back and call the \ndefense counsel and tell them we were dropping the case. \nEFTA00009046\n", "char_count": 1129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Page 231 \n1 \nQ \n-- a little bit, about 18 USC 22.55. \nYes, okay. \nQ \nNot to be confused with 22 -- 28 USC 22.55, which \nevery prosecutor is familiar with. So, whose idea was that? \nIt's, it's a civil provision, a civil -- it's not \nrestitution, it's damages. It's a damages recovery provision \n7 \nin the criminal code. \n8 \nA \nRight. \n9 \nQ \nWho came up with that? \nA \nI can't speak to who came up with it. \n11 \nQ \nOkay. \n12 \nA \nI can speak to -- to the reasoning behind it. \n13 \nQ \nYour reasoning, or the proponent's reasoning? \n14 \nA \nMy recollection of the reasoning as to why we \n15 \nthought it was important. \n16 \nQ \nAnd the importance was to provide a mechanism for \n17 \nrecovery of damages? \n18 \nA \nTo -- yeah. \n19 \nQ \nOkay. \n20 \nA \nYeah. I mean, the victims bad situation, and we \n21 \njust \nand here is -- well, go on. \n22 \nQ \nAll right. \n23 \nA \nI might circle back on something. \n24 \nQ \nSo, is it fair to say that's a fairly -- had you \n2'. \never heard of it before? Had you come across it before? \nEFTA00009047\n", "char_count": 1019}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Page 232 \n1 \nA \nI don't know, but I don't think so. \n2 \nQ \nOkay. So, is it fair to say it was novel to the \n3 \noffice? To you, and to this team? \n4 \nA \nI don't want -- I don't think it's fair to say that \n5 \nit's novel to the office. \n6 \nQ \nWell, to the -- do you -- do you recall whether \n7 \nanybody in the team had had experience with 18 USC 22.55 in a \n8 \ncriminal --\n9 \nA \nI don't have a recollection of any discussion as to \n10 \nwhether people had experience with this or not. \n11 \nQ \nDid you believe that any legal research was needed, \n12 \nor should be undertaken to ensure that the procedure was in \n13 \nfact legally sound when embedded, as it was in this case, in \n14 \na criminal plea? \n15 \nA \nSo, I would have expected to the extent that there \n16 \nwere concerns. Again, we had incredibly experienced --\n17 \nbetween the various individuals on my management team, we \n18 \nprobably had 50 years plus of criminal experience. I would \n19 \nhave expected to the extent their concerns, for those \n20 \nconcerns to be raised. \n21 \nQ \nDid you raise any -- any such concerns about it, or \n22 \ndid it seem to make sense to you? \n23 \nA \nFrom my perspective, I recall -- I don't know if it \n24 \nwas at the time or subsequent to it, reading it, and \nand \n25 \nit seemed -- it seemed to -- to make sense. \nEFTA00009048\n", "char_count": 1312}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Page 233 \n1 \nQ \nOkay. After \nletter went out on the \n2 \n3rd of August, you almost immediately -- it appears you \n3 \nreceived a telephone call from Kirkland S Ellis, is that \n4 \ncorrect? \n5 \nA \nThat -- I don't recall it independently, but that's \n6 \nwhat the record shows. \n7 \nQ \nAll right, and that's reflected in Exhibit 12. Do \n8 \nyou remember who called you? \n9 \nA \nI do not. \n10 \nQ \nDo you recall -- it apparently was from the context \n11 \nof this Exhibit 12, it -- and the caption, Epstein. \n12 \nA \nRight. Right. \n13 \nQ \nIt appears that the call related to Epstein, \n14 \ncorrect? \n15 \nA \nCorrect. Again, I don't remember the phone call, \n16 \nbut from the e-mail, I accept that it happened. \n17 \nQ \nSo, what had been your knowledge and relationship \n18 \nof -- with Ken Starr of Kirkland S Ellis --\n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \n-- up to this point? \n21 \nA \nSo, I had been an associate at Kirkland, I think I \n22 \nindicated, what was it --\n23 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n24 \nA \n-- from '94 to '90 -- what was it? Was it '96 or \n25 \n'97? \nEFTA00009049\n", "char_count": 1031}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Page 234 \nQ \nA couple of years. \n2 \nA \nFor a couple of years. I worked on at least one \n3 \ncase that I recall with him. I was the junior associate on a \n4 \nmerits brief that he argued. He, at the time, was also \n5 \nspecial counsel. And so he wasn't in the office nearly as \n6 \nmuch because he was double hatting as special counsel --\n7 \nQ \nMe-ham. \n8 \nA \n-- and partner. \n9 \nQ \nmm-hmm. All right, and what about \n10 \nA \nSc, \nwas a partner at the time. \n11 \ndon't recall working with him on any particular case, \n12 \nalthough I think I worked with him on at least a matter. He \n13 \nwas on my hallway. He had an outside office. I had the \n14 \ntypical inside office. \n15 \nQ \nHad you had any interaction -- any contact with \n16 \nthem in the intervening years, socially or professionally? \n17 \nA \nOff and on, I was in Washington. They -- you know, \n18 \nKen Starr was in Washington. I think III had moved to New \n19 \nYork but then came back to Washington to be in the \n20 \nadministration, and he was in the policy office, and we may \n21 \nhave -- not may have. We likely interacted. \n22 \nQ \nAnd while you were here at the criminal -- at the \n23 \ncivil rights division? \n24 \nA \nCorrec. . \n25 \nQ \nAll right, and did you -- were you friends? Were \nEFTA00009050\n", "char_count": 1251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Page 235 \n1 \nyou professional acquaintances? Were you what? How would \n2 \nyou characterize that? \n3 \nA \nWe were professional acquaintances that had worked \n4 \ntogether several years ago that continued to interact. \n5 \nQ \nIs that true as to the two of them? \n6 \nA \nI mean, it's hard to characterize these things. I \n7 \nthink -- I think that's fair to say. \n8 \nQ \nDid Ken Starr know who you were? \n9 \nA \nYes. \n10 \nQ \nAnd obviously \nas well? \n11 \nA \nYes. \n12 \nQ \nOkay. So, what was your reaction to being \n13 \ncontacted by them in -- by their firm, them, presumably one \n14 \nof --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- them perhaps? \n17 \nA \nSo --\n18 \nQ \nIn --\n19 \nA \nSo, I don't know who called based on the e-mail. I \n20 \ncan infer that it was one of them. \n21 \nQ \n14M-hmm. \n22 \nA \nAnd you know -- and I think my reaction is captured \n23 \nby not my e-mail, but -- but by Jeff's comment, and what -- I \n24 \ndon't have a clear recollection, but I'm going to \n25 \nspeculate/infer that I heard they were being brought onto the \nEFTA00009051\n", "char_count": 1022}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Page 23E \n1 \ncase, and I probably walked down to Jeff's office and said, \n2 \nhey, Kirkland's coming onto the case, I bet you they're going \n3 \nto come on to try to take this up to D.C. \n4 \nAnd then I get a phone call, and -- you know, and \n5 \nthen I tell Matt, who tells Jeff, you know, I didn't know, \n6 \nmaybe -- Kirkland made a call to -- you're right, \n7 \nunbelievable. \n8 \nAnd then I say they're likely to go to D.C. \nWe \n9 \nshould strategize a bit. My concerns behind that are, will \n10 \nD.C. look at this as sort of legally troubled, going back to \n11 \nthe earlier points that I made about the policy issues around \n12 \nthe trafficking issues up here in D.C. \n13 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n14 \nA \nAnd I really do think he should go to jail. And \n5 \nso, I want to strategize a bit. \n16 \nQ \nSo, did you have concern about the fact that you \n17 \nwere -- that the defense team was sort of appealing you to \n18 \nthe big house? \n19 \nA \nI think based on this, I almost predicted this \n20 \nwould happen. \n21 \nQ \nYeah. \n22 \nA \nAnd Jeff is saying, you were right, unbelievable, \n23 \nwhere I in some way, shape, or form predicted that something \n24 \nwould -- someone would be hired, or something would happen to \n25 \ntake this all up to D.C. \nEFTA00009052\n", "char_count": 1238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "1 \nPage 237 \nQ \nAnd had you experienced other cases \nother \n2 \ninstances in which defense team went to D.C. while you were \n3 \nat U.S. Attorney's Office -- while you were the U.S. \n4 \nAttorney? \n5 \nA \nYes. \n6 \nQ \nWas that a concern to you? \n7 \nA \nIt wasn't a concern. It was a, how do we address \n8 \nthis so that we can back our position and our office. \n9 \nQ \nDid you have concerns about the disposition that \n10 \nwas underway? About -- main justice scrutiny of the NPA \n11 \nscheme? \n12 \nA \nSo, I had no concerns about main justice scrutiny \n13 \nof the NPA scheme. In fact, I invited Drew to come down --\n14 \nQ \nRight. \n15 \nA \n-- and he was part of the meeting where we \n16 \ndiscussed the NPA. And so, I say that because if I had \n17 \nconcerns, I wouldn't have invited him. If anything, my \n18 \nconcern was, is main justice on board, or are we going to \n19 \nbasically be told to drop this case when it goes up to main \n20 \njustice? \n21 \nMM-hmm. In your e-mail to \n, when \n22 \nSloman's on vacation --\n23 \nA \nYeah. \n24 \nQ \n-- you say that -- you make reference to a process \n25 \nfoul, that the attorneys in the defense team want to go to \nEFTA00009053\n", "char_count": 1151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Page 238 \n1 \nD.C. on the case on the grounds of a process foul, i.e., that \n2 \nI have not met with them, and you expressed concern that that \n3 \nwould delay matters. Is that what led you to agree to meet \n4 \nwith the defense team on the 7th of September? \n5 \nA \nIt is. My concern was it they came up to D.C., and \n6 \nthe first talking about was the U.S. Attorney didn't even \n7 \nagree to meet with us, that's not the best -- that's not the \n8 \nbest foot to start with when you're having your case \n9 \nreviewed. \n10 \nQ \nSo, what was your understanding of what the purpose \n11 \nof the meeting on September 7th was supposed to be? \n12 \nA \nThey wanted to argue -- they, being defense \n13 \ncounsel, wanted to argue why we should not pursue this case. \n14 \nQ \nAnd in this case, it was Starr and Lefkowitz from \n15 \nKirkland & Ellis, and Lilly Ann Sanchez, I believe who met \n16 \nwith you. \n17 \nA \nFair. I remember it was Starr and Lefkowitz. I \n18 \ndon't know if it was Lilly Ann. \n19 \nQ \nAll right, and our information is it was you, Drew \n20 \nOosterbaan, Sloman, \n, and John MacMillan. Do you --\n21 \ndo you know John MacMillan? \n22 \nA \nVaguely. \n23 \nQ \nAll right. He was an AUSA as well. \n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \nCorrect? In West Palm? \nEFTA00009054\n", "char_count": 1244}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Page 239 \n1 \nA \nRight, and if I can just add, again, I -- I invited \n2 \nDrew --\n3 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n4 \nA \n-- so, Drew became fully aware of that, and my \n5 \nconcern in getting Drew into the meeting was to not have them \n6 \nappeal us, and then having Drew say, not a good case. \n7 \nQ \nAll right. So, were you aware that Drew Oosterbaan \n8 \nhad, in preparation for this, gone to West Palm and actually \n9 \ngone through the evidence and met with the case agent and the \n10 \nline AUSA \n11 \nA \nI was not. Drew is an independent actor and could \n12 \ndo what -- yeah, what he thought appropriate. \n13 \nQ \nDid that -- does that seem like an appropriate \n14 \nthing for him to have done in your eyes? \n15 \nA \nSure. \n16 \nQ \nOkay. Would you describe the meeting -- oh, and \n17 \ntwo other people who were there were, again ASAC Val Parlave \n18 \nand Junior Ortiz --\n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \n-- the SSA. So, and the meeting I think was in \n21 \nWest Palm Beach. \n22 \nA \nYes. \n23 \nQ \nSo, what do you recall about the meeting? The \n24 \ndynamics? Who spoke? How did it go down? \n25 \nA \nI recall there were a lot of people. I think Mr. \nEFTA00009055\n", "char_count": 1122}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Page 240 \nStarr spoke most of the time. I think -- my recollection, as \nbest as I can -- you know, with the caveat I thought \nwas there and clearly he wasn't. So, presented \n4 \nseveral arguments. I then either left the room with my team, \n5 \nor I think I most likely asked them to leave the room. I \n6 \nthen went around and --\n7 \nQ \nAsked who to leave the room? \nA \nAsked the --\nQ \nThe defense? \n10 \nA \n-- defense. I then went around the table, and\n11 \nsaid, does anyone have any concerns, or something to that \n12 \neffect. And then hearing none, I asked them to come back in, \nand I reaffirmed the position of the office. \n'4 \nQ \nIn other words, you sort of decided -- you ruled \nfrom the bench, as it were. Fair enough? \n16 \nA \nFair enough. \n17 \nQ \nOkay. You didn't take -- take it under advisement. \n18 \nYou gave them what your position was right then and there. \n19 \nA \nThat -- that's my recollection. I don't know if \n20 \nyou have information contrary, but at least --\n21 \nQ \nOkay. \n22 \nA \n-- that's my recollection. \n23 \nQ \nOkay. So, is it fair to say it was more of a \n24 \npresentation on the part of Ken Starr and his side rather \n2; \nthan a debate or discussion? \nEFTA00009056\n", "char_count": 1186}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Page 241 \n1 \nA \nI think that that's fair to say. I may have asked \n2 \na question or two, but my -- my recollection was not \nwas \n3 \nnot a negotiation, but a, let's hear you out. \n4 \nQ \nAnd so, we understand it was mainly a federalism \n5 \npresentation, as opposed to evidence, is that accurate? \n6 \nA \nI believe that's accurate, yes. \n7 \nQ \nAnd in your letter to Ken Starr dated -- the letter \n8 \nis actually not dated, but we know that it was sent on the \n9 \n4th of December --\n10 \nA \nOkay. \n11 \nQ \n-- of 2007, and it's in this package. You noted \n12 \nthat --\n13 \nA \nWhich exhibit? \n14 \nMR. GONZALEZ: 34. \n15 \nBY \n16 \nQ \nThank you. Exhibit 34. You note on page four --\n17 \nI'm sorry, page five, you -- you referred to the federalism \n18 \narguments, and you say that after considering the arguments \n19 \nand conferring with the FBI and Drew Oosterbaan, you decided \n20 \nto proceed with the indictment, but that you would delay \n21 \npresentation of the indictment to allow the defense to appeal \n22 \nto D.C. Does that mean that you didn't find the federalism \n23 \narguments sufficiently persuasive to you to change your \n24 \nposition? \n25 \nA \nYes, with the position defined as some concern, but \nEFTA00009057\n", "char_count": 1207}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Page 242 \n1 \nif we need to -- if we don't come to a resolution based on \n2 \nthe sheet, then we indict. \n3 \nQ \nAnd there is a letter of --\n4 \nBY \nQ \nI'm sorry, when you say some concern, some concern \n6 \nabout the federalism argument? \n7 \nA \nYeah. Going -- going back to what we talked about \n8 \nwith respect to the earlier conversation about solicitation \n9 \nversus trafficking, and the federal nexus. But back in July, \n10 \nwe had decided that we were going forward, that either there \n11 \nis this pre-indictment resolution, or we go forward with an \n12 \nindictment. The September meeting did not alter or shift our \n13 \nposition. \n14 \nBY \n15 \nQ \nEven though you had some federalism concerns of \n16 \nyour own, they didn't rise to a sufficiently high level. \n17 \nA \nSo, their request -- their request was to drop the \n18 \nmatter. \n19 \nQ \nRight. \n20 \nA \nAnd -- and --\n21 \nQ \nOkay. \n22 \nA \n-- going back again, understood. There is -- there \n23 \nis legal risk. There is witness risk. All of these. If we \n24 \ncan get pre-indictment resolution, good. If not, the \n25 \nindictment was not a bluff. It was -- it was real. \nEFTA00009058\n", "char_count": 1130}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Page 243 \n1 \nQ \nSo, was -- I mean, Ken Starr is of course well \n2 \nknown. \n3 \nA \nRight. \n4 \nQ \nHe was solicitor general, he's -- you know, \n5 \netcetera. Did you find his arguments well set forth? \n6 \nImpressive? \n7 \nA \nSo, you're asking for something that's 12 years \n8 \nif I had to characterize, by the time this meeting took \n9 \nplace, there had been a fair amount of thought around these. \n10 \nThere had been a fair amount of -- and I at least felt \n11 \ncomfortable that while there was some legal risk, he \n12 \nneeded -- we needed -- you've got to balance the legal risk \n13 \nand the precedent risk with -- with outcomes, and Mr. Epstein \n14 \nshould go to jail, and should register, and I felt \n15 \ncomfortable -- I felt comfortable enough to basically \n16 \nreiterate our position that --\n17 \nQ \nBut my -- but my question with respect to --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- was, did you enjoy the give and take with --\n20 \nwith a man of Mr. Starr's --\n21 \nA \nIn all candor, no. \n22 \nQ \n-- standing? \n23 \nA \nNo. \n24 \nQ \nNo? Not at all. \n25 \nA \nNot at all, because --\nEFTA00009059\n", "char_count": 1075}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Page 244 \n1 \nQ \nAll right. \n2 \nA \n-- it would have been easier to not have the \n3 \nmeeting in the first place. \n4 \nQ \nAll right. Do you recall an exchange -- was he --\n5 \nwas -- were you the parson to whom he was directing most of \n6 \nhis comments? \n7 \nA \nMost \nmost likely. \n8 \nQ \nAnd do you recall any exchange with him about the \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \nA \nDo you mean --\n15 \nQ \n-- a bell? \n16 \nA \n-- was he trying to butter me up? \n17 \nQ \nWas he? I mean, was he? \n18 \nA \nI don't -- I -- look, this was 12 years ago. I \n19 \ndon't recall. You know, I think as we talk about this, it's \n20 \nimportant to note that the position did not change. Whatever \n21 \nexchange there may have had, our position did not change. \n22 \nQ \nRight. After this meeting, within a few days, in \n23 \nfurtherance of the resolution that had been offered, \n24 \nand \nLourie met with the state attorney's \n25 \noffice to sit down and try to work out how this thing would \nfact that -- sort of an observation that the two of you, you \nand he, were the only two people in the room who had been \npresidentially nominated and senate confirmed to any position \nso that the two of you had kind of that commonality. Does \nthat ring --\nEFTA00009060\n", "char_count": 1212}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Page 245 \n1 \nwork, and mind you, this was before -- well before the NPA \n2 \nis --\n3 \nA \nRight. \n4 \nQ \n-- actually formulated. Did you learn what \n5 \nhappened at that meeting? Do you know how it devolved? \n6 \nA \nI may have. I don't -- I don't recall, you know, \n7 \nsitting here today. \n8 \nQ \nAll right. It's at this meeting that somehow, the \n9 \nthree charges that you specified -- your office specified in \n10 \nthe term sheet became one. So, suddenly Epstein was to plead \n11 \nonly to one charge, and this was agreed to by the U.S. \n12 \nAttorney's Office folks who were there. Do you know how or \n13 \nwhy that happened? \n14 \nA \nI haven't the slightest idea. \n15 \nQ \nIf you had known -- if they had called you on the \n16 \nphone, sort of the mid-trial --\n17 \nA \nRight. \n18 \nQ \n-- call to the boss, asking what you wanted them to \n19 \ndo, what would you have said? \n20 \nA \nSo from my perspective, when I said -- you know, \n21 \nwhen I indicated I approved this term sheet, this is the \n22 \nminimum, I meant what I said. I also recognize that AUSAs in \n23 \nthe usual course need some degree of discretion to negotiate. \n24 \nand so, my assumption after that September meeting, I think I \n25 \nindicated that there was a deadline --\nEFTA00009061\n", "char_count": 1238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Page 246 \n1 \nQ \nmm-hmm. \n2 \nA \n-- that was fairly short, was that \nand UM \n3 \nand some -- working together would go back and work out an \n4 \nagreement based on those terms, and you know, in the give and \n5 \ntake, if they think that this is an important concession, \n6 \nthat's within their discretion, but I would have been \n7 \ncomfortable sticking to that --\n8 \nQ \nWith --\n9 \nA \n-- charge sheet. With -- something that drove me \n10 \nis when I -- when I said something, I -- as a general matter, \n11 \nI didn't bluff. I really meant what I said. \n12 \nQ \nSo, in that terms sheet, I mean, to be fair, what \n13 \nMenchel's letter says is two years --\n14 \nA \nRight. \n15 \nQ \n-- is the minimum. If the decision to agree to let \n16 \nhim plead to one as opposed to all three had no impact on \n17 \nthat two years, would -- would you have cared? \n18 \nA \nFair enough, and so going -- going back to where \n19 \nI -- you know, to an earlier discussion -- can I get another \n20 \nRed Bull? Going -- going back to earlier discussion, I think \n21 \nI indicated that the charges -- the state charges I wasn't \n22 \nfamiliar with. And so if in the give and take, those charges \n23 \nchanged, my focus was on two years registration and \n24 \nrestitution, as long as those charges were -- captured the \n25 \nconduct in some appropriate way. \nEFTA00009062\n", "char_count": 1325}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "1\nQ \nPage 247 \nSo, later -- rather much later, the defense counsel \n2 \nadmitted that at this meeting, they thought --\n3 \n4 \nA \nYes. \nQ \n-- that under misinformation from the state \n5 \nattorney's office that that charge that they got the U.S. \n6 \nAttorney's Office, or somehow the -- the U.S. Attorney's \n7 \nOffice approved, the 793 -- 796.03 charge was not sex \n8 \noffender registerable, and that's a -- that's pretty --\n9 \nthat's a pretty major mistake, right? \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \nA \nIt is, and --\nQ \nI mean, that's -- that goes to the heart of you --\nA \nAnd --\n4 \n-- one of your major concerns. \nA \nAnd they tried -- they tried to get us to change \n15 \nthat, and I said no. \n16 \nQ \nThe defense tried to get you off sex offender \n17 \nregistration. \n18 \nA \nPretty vigorously. \n19 \nQ \nRight? But at this point, the focus is on the \n20 \ncharge, and the defense is -- one might characterize it as \n21 \ntrying to pull a fast one by agreeing wholeheartedly to plead \n22 \nto one charge, knowing or at least believing incorrectly that \n23 \nit was not registerable, and the U.S. Attorney's Office not \n24 \nhaving that belief, but thinking it was registerable. \n25 \nSo, there's a disconnect. There is error, and the \nEFTA00009063\n", "char_count": 1222}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Page 248 \n1 \nerror stems, as they later learned, from the ASA herself. \n2 \nSo, we look at that, and wonder whether that shouldn't have \n3 \nraised some concern that this plan to put things back in the \n4 \nhands of the state, which had kind of mishandled the case to \n5 \nbeing with, as at this point even not a good idea, because \n6 \nthey were continually -- continuing to be -- well, I won't \n7 \ncharacterize it, but less than reliable. Was that a -- is \n8 \nthat a fair comment of concern? \n9 \nA \nSo, one question I would have is, at what point did \n10 \nwe become aware that there had been, first, the error was in \n11 \nour favor, not the defense's favor, because \ngot it \n12 \nright as opposed to the ASA. \n13 \nQ \nCorrect. \n14 \nA \nAnd secondly, at what point did our team become \n15 \naware of them trying to pull a fast one? Was it before or \n16 \nafter the signing of the NPA? \n17 \nQ \nIt was well after. \n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \nBut the -- the point here is that the V.S. \n20 \nAttorney's Office folks were not as familiar with the state \n21 \nprocedure -- the state criminal procedure, and the ins and \n22 \nouts of the sentencing and incarceration, as you learned \n23 \nlater. \n24 \nSo, didn't this put the U.S. Attorney's Office side \n25 \nat a substantial disadvantage in trying to play in the \nEFTA00009064\n", "char_count": 1303}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Page 249 \n1 \nsandbox in which both the defense -- local defense counsel \n2 \nand the ASA, were very comfortable? \n3 \nA \nPossibly, although I would point out that it was \n4 \nthe AUSA who got it right. \n5 \nQ \nEventually. \n6 \nA \nNot eventually. The AUSA --\n7 \nQ \nOh. \n8 \nA \n-- was correct in her analysis. \n9 \nQ \nRight. \n10 \nA \nSo, in this case, she was more familiar than the \n11 \nstate attorney. \n12 \nQ \nNot by practice, but by research, or --\n13 \nA \nBy research, and so --\n14 \nQ \nRight. \n15 \nA \n-- my point is we had good people that were able \n16 \nto, if they weren't familiar with something, the research \n17 \nclearly worked. \n18 \nQ \nBut it took, as you saw in the -- in the -- in the \n19 \nprocess of dealing with the work release and all of that, it \n20 \ntook a lot of --\n21 \nA \nIt --\n22 \nQ \n-- work to keep up with those --\n23 \nA \nIt did. \n24 \nerrors. \n25 \nA \nWhich is why I say in hindsight, if, given all the \nEFTA00009065\n", "char_count": 928}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Page 250 \n1 \neffort that took place after this defer to the state was \n2 \nreached, if all that had been known, I really think the \n3 \nanalysis would have proceeded differently, because that \n4 \nwas -- what was a lot of work. That was probably as much \n5 \nwork, if not more than a trial. \n6 \nQ \nRight. Right. Right. Meanwhile, the -- we'll \n7 \ntalk about the actual text of the NPA in a moment, but \n8 \nfollowing that -- actually, no, before it was being \n9 \nfinalized -- before it was finalized, \nwas \n10 \nworking to identify a federal charge, as we discussed before. \n11 \nIn that process, she came up with a plan that would have \n12 \nresulted -- cobbling things together in an 18 month sentence \n13 \ninstead of --\n14 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n15 \nQ \n-- 24 months. Somehow, that became the new floor. \n16 \nThe -- the new standard. Do you know how that came about, \n17 \nand who actually agreed to that? \n18 \nA \nI -- I don't. I -- I referenced the one e-mail \n19 \nwhere I think \nsays, he argued 12. \n20 \nQ \nRight. \n21 \nA \nI said 24. We agreed to 18. I assume in the give \n22 \nand take, this was an agreement that was reached, and --\n23 \nQ \nBut that was 18, as -- as to the potential federal \n24 \ncharges. It somehow became imported --\n25 \nA \nEFTA00009066\n", "char_count": 1240}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Page 251 \n1 \nQ \n-- into the state disposition. \n2 \nA \nI can't -- I can't speak to that. This was -- this \n3 \nwas something that the \"trial team\" was negotiating, and from \n4 \nmy perspective, this is -- these were the terms that we \n5 \nwanted. These were the terms that I expected if they came \n6 \nback and said, no deal. Disappointed, but go forward, but \n7 \nthey tried to get a deal, and -- and --\n8 \nQ \nThe defense tried? \n9 \nA \nNo, but our prosecutors. \n10 \nQ \nOh. \n11 \nA \nAnd to some extent, you know, they -- and the give \n12 \nand take of any negotiation, I don't think it's unfair for an \n13 \nAUSA to -- to give up some things. \n14 \nQ \nBut did -- you had -- had stated clearly to not \n15 \nonly the defense team through the Menchel letter, but also I \n16 \nbelieve at the end of the September 7 meeting, that two years \n17 \nwas the deal. So, did somebody come to you and say, looks \n18 \nlike it's going to be 18 months, and allow you to then \n19 \napprove that? \n20 \nA \nI don't recall if someone came to me separately or \n21 \nindependently of the final language. I clearly approved it \n22 \nat some point. \n23 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n24 \nA \nAnd so to the extent it was approved, that's --\n25 \nthat's on me, but I would -- I would argue that, you know, \nEFTA00009067\n", "char_count": 1257}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Page 252 \n1 \nsomeone's negotiating, one said says 24, another side says \n2 \n12. They say, let's agree to 18. To some extent as U.S. \n3 \nAttorney, I think I have to back the -- the negotiating \n4 \ndiscretion of my AUSAs. \n5 \nBut you -- you explained quite eloquently the \n6 \nreasoning for the two year plea as being what Epstein would \n7 \nhave faced if he'd been prosecuted --\n8 \nA \nRight. \n9 \nQ \n-- you know, absentia, by the state appropriately, \n10 \nand then suddenly, without any apparent relationship to that \n11 \nanalysis, the 18 months pops up from an effort to try to get \n12 \nfederal charges. And so how do you -- how -- does that not \n13 \nundercut the basis for the two years? \n14 \nA \nSo, I can provide the reasoning for the two years. \n15 \nI also though think as a \nas a supervisor, as U.S. \n16 \nAttorney, it's important to understand that when individuals \n17 \ngo out into the field, negotiations take place. And if every \n18 \ntime there is some give, they need to come back to the U.S. \n19 \nAttorney, or there is a fear that the U.S. Attorney will not \n20 \nback us. \n21 \nYou know, there is -- there's a certain -- I think \n22 \nthere's a management issue there in that if an AUSA speaking \n23 \non behalf of the U.S. makes an agreement, as long as that \n24 \nagreement is within a certain range, the U.S. Attorney should \n25 \nback that, because they're the ones that are in the -- on the \nEFTA00009068\n", "char_count": 1411}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Page 253 \n1 \nline. They're the ones that are managing the case, and it's \n2 \nsort of unfair to consistently second guess those late \n3 \nnight -- I don't -- I don't want to characterize it --\n4 \nQ \nOkay. \n5 \nA \n-- as a late night negotiation, but those -- that \n6 \ngive and take that happens sometimes in a conference room or \n7 \non the phone. \n8 \nQ \nDo you know exactly what give and take occurred in \n9 \nthis case regarding the 18 months? \n10 \nA \nI do not. I read that one document. \n11 \nQ \nOkay. \n12 \nA \nBut I do not. \n13 \nQ \nAll right. Any other questions on this one? \n14 \nBY \n15 \nQ \nReally quick. I agree with what you're saying in \n16 \nprinciple, but in this case, you had had a -- almost like a \n17 \nmandatory, two years is the minimum that the --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- V.S. Attorney will accept. Under those \n20 \ncircumstances, where you have come out and said, this is the \n21 \nminimum we'll accept, would you have expected them to have to \n22 \ncome back to you to get approval for any kind of reduction in \n23 \nthat amount? \n24 \nA \nWould I have expected them? I think Ms. \n25 \nwas in a tough position, because opposing counsel was coming \nEFTA00009069\n", "char_count": 1165}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Page 254 \n1 \nat her. It was a tough negotiation. Would I have wanted two \n2 \nyears? Yes. Would I fault her for agreeing to 18 months? I \n3 \ndon't think that's fair to her. \n4 \nBY \n5 \nQ \nYou could have said no, right? \n6 \nA \nI could have, but it was an -- but she had agreed \n7 \nto it. The process had gone further down, and to some \n8 \nextent, \nI think there is a need to respect that process. \n9 \nThat happens -- I guess I was getting -- you know, this is \n10 \nnot the only case where a supervisor sort of says, this is \n11 \nour -- this is our standard, and -- and at some point, things \n12 \nmove, and you've got to provide some discretion. \n13 \nQ \nAll right. \n14 \nBY \n15 \nQ \nDo you think she misunderstood the priorities? \n16 \nThat she thought you wanted to get to a resolution, and so \n17 \nthe two years could -- could be undercut, versus taking your \n18 \nwords literally and saying this is the line in the sand \n19 \nbeyond which you should not go, even if it means kill this \n20 \nkill the resolution? \n21 \nA \nSo, if I had to speculate, I don't think it was a \n22 \nmisunderstanding of priorities as opposed to opposing counsel \n23 \nwas exhausting, and if you go through the full record, it \n24 \nreally was an exhausting -- opposing counsel in this case was \n25 \nvery good at taking any slight millimeter, and turning it \nEFTA00009070\n", "char_count": 1337}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Page 255 \n1 \ninto, oh, so you said we could do this, and in that back and \n2 \nforth, sometimes there is a, can't we just agree in the \n3 \nmiddle? \n4 \nQ \nAnd I understand what you're saying, but weren't \n5 \nthey exhausting because the U.S. Attorney's Office would not \n6 \nsay no to them? And so they always believed from the get-go, \n7 \nbecause they have a two year minimum that the --\n8 \n9 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- that the office is willing to then say, oh, we \n10 \ncan go down from there, and that that set the tone from then \n11 \non that they could continually chip away at you on virtually \n12 \nevery single term that came about? So, yes, they were \n13 \nexhausting, but isn't that because the V.S. Attorney's Office \n14 \nwould not tell them no? \n15 \nA \nSo I would push back, because after the agreement \n16 \nwas signed, I would argue they did not chip away. They --\n17 \nthey certainly kept appealing collaterally, and we can talk \n18 \nabout that, because there were other concerns raised there, \n19 \nbut once we had that September meeting, between that \n20 \nSeptember meeting and the signing of the deferment in favor \n21 \nof the state, that was all negotiated by the trial team. \n22 \nThat wasn't a, come back to the U.S. Attorney, or come to the \n23 \nfirst assistant. That really, to my recollection, was, go \n24 \nnegotiate with the state -- with the line. \n25 \nQ \nWell, but there were a number of things that came \nEFTA00009071\n", "char_count": 1427}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "about later on. I mean, they -- they continually griped \n2 \nabout the 22.55, and that got -- you know, that got modified. \n3 \nA \nLater on -- and I think later on's are different \n4 \nfor some reasons we can talk about now or later, but there \n5 \nwas an attempt to work this out later on that was clearly \n6 \nthere. \n7 \n: The --\n8 \nTHE WITNESS But I think that's very different \n9 \nthan, how was the agreement negotiated? And I think that's a \n10 \nvery different -- a different sort of timeline. \n11 \nBY \n12 \nQ \nSo in your mind, was she prepared to walk away from \n13 \nthe deal if need be? \nA \nAfter it was signed? \n15 \nQ \nBefore it was signed. \n16 \nA \nBefore it was signed, it honestly was, get a deal \n17 \nor ultimately if we have to indict, we indict, and that's \n18 \nwhat I said, and -- and look at it this way. After having \n19 \nsaid that, if that really was a bluff, what would I look \n20 \nlike, right? I would look awful. \n21 \nAnd so, for that reason, that was not a bluff. \n22 \nThat was a thought through, this is what we will do, and if \n23 \nyou don't agree to this, then we indict, and we indict. You \n24 \ncan't make those kinds of statements and not follow through. \n25 \nThe office loses credibility if you do. \nEFTA00009072\n", "char_count": 1234}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Page 257 \n1 \nQ \nRight, but you can keep giving on certain terms. \n2 \nA \nBut we \nand my point is we did not give, with the \n3 \nexception of that 24 to 18, we did not give. \n4 \nBY \n5 \nQ \nWell, you also gave up two charges. \n6 \nA \nAgain, I'm thinking of a two years, registration, \n7 \nrestitution, and so with the exception of that 24 to 18, we \n8 \ndid not give. \n9 \nQ \nI want to go back. This morning, we were talking \n10 \nabout our tracks, and we talked about the legal track, and a \n11 \nlittle bit about the evidence track. There's another aspect \n12 \nof the evidence track that is in play here, because there was \n13 \na substantial type of evidence, and the question is, to what \n14 \nextent were you aware of this. \n15 \nIn October of 2005, the local police executed a \n16 \nsearch warrant on Epstein's residence, and among things they \n17 \nfound there were cables and cords where there had been \n18 \ncomputers -- computer equipment, video surveillance, cameras, \n19 \nand CPUs, all of that, that computer based stuff. It had \n20 \nbeen removed, forgetting why necessarily. If you look at \n21 \nExhibit 29, were you aware of that, by the way? That that \n22 \nhad occurred? \n23 \nA \nI was aware that the state had gathered evidence, \n24 \nbut not much more --\n25 \nQ \nBeyond that. \nEFTA00009073\n", "char_count": 1286}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Page 258 \n1 \nA \n-- beyond that. \n2 \nQ \nOkay. So, 29 is --\n3 \n4 \nA \nI'm sorry, I'm on 21. \nQ \nWait a minute, this is not the one I'm looking for. \n5 \n73? Let's do -- do you know what? Okay. That's not -- this \n6 \nis not the exhibit I'm looking for, and the numbers are a \n7 \nlittle bit messed up. \n8 \nThere is a -- an e-mail, which I may or may not be \n9 \nable to put my hands on -- in which \ninforms \n10 \nyou that she really wants to get her hands on important \n11 \npotential -- on computer evidence, that it's important \n12 \npotential evidence, and she had a plan to get it. \n13 \nSo, the question is whether you knew at the time \n14 \nthat there was -- that the investigators had identified this \n15 \ncomputer evidence as being out there, and that they believed \n16 \nit contained a potentially very significant evidence against \n17 \nEpstein, computers, surveillance cameras, given his \n18 \nactivity --\n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \n-- in his home --\n21 \n: He's not on it. \n22 \nBY \n23 \nQ \nAll right. She did not inform you. She informed \n24 \nsomeone else that we -- she informed Sloman and Manche]. on \n25 \nJuly 3rd, and Lourie. My apologies. You're not on this. \nEFTA00009074\n", "char_count": 1168}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Page 259 \n1 \nWhere she advises them that she wants -- we want to -- \"we \n2 \nwant to get the computer equipment that was removed from \n3 \nEpstein's home prior to the state search warrant as soon as \n4 \npossible.\" So, there was the stuff out there, and \n5 \nA \nRight. \n6 \nQ \n-- as of July, there was an abiding keen interest \n7 \nin getting it, and the defense team was resisting the \n8 \nprosecutors efforts to get it. Were you aware of that at \n9 \nall? \n10 \nA \nSo, you -- I think you asked about that in your \n11 \nquestions to me. \n12 \nQ \nRight, I did. \n13 \nA \nI have no recollection of -- of this computer \n14 \nevidence that --\n15 \nQ \nAll right. \n16 \nA \nDid the question say that -- without getting into \n17 \nspecifics, that there was a grand jury issue around this? \n18 \nQ \nIt does. It --\n19 \nA \nI don't have that --\n20 \nQ \nIt is addressed in the non-prosecution agreement if \n21 \nyou look at the final non-pros --\n22 \nA \nYeah. I don't have --\n23 \nQ \nIt's referred to --\n24 \nA \nThe question that you asked, what question was \n25 \nthat? \nEFTA00009075\n", "char_count": 1049}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Page 260 \n1 \nQ \nThe question was whether you were aware that that \n2 \nwas something that the prosecutors wanted to get? \n3 \nA \nI don't -- I don't have a recollection of some \n4 \ncomputer evidence. \n5 \nQ \nAll right, and -- and --\n6 \nA \nBut I think -- is there? \n7 \nQ \nAre you --\n8 \nA \nWhat was the question? \n9 \nQ \naware that \nwas instructed by her managers \n10 \nto delay her efforts to get this computer evidence, because \n11 \nthe defense were resisting those efforts, and it became an \n12 \nissue of -- an issue that was in play in the negotiations? \n13 \nA \nI have -- I have no recollection of that. \n14 \nQ \nOkay. \n15 \nA \nIf you can give me one second? \n16 \nQ \nSure. \n17 \nA \nPending federal -- and so, your question said that \n18 \nthere was litigation pending in federal court relating to the \n19 \nU.S. Attorney's efforts to obtain --\n20 \nQ \nYeah. \n21 \nA \n-- computer evidence? \n22 \nQ \nWithout going into further detail. \n23 \nA \nI -- I have no recollection of any litigation \n24 \npending in federal court regarding that. \n25 \nQ \nAll right, and were you -- did anyone suggest to \nEFTA00009076\n", "char_count": 1092}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Page 261 \n1 \nyou and your team that the -- or, getting to a plea deal was \n2 \npremature, because it -- you needed to get this evidence \n3 \nfirst, so that you knew whether you had potentially some very \n4 \nimportant evidence again Epstein? \n5 \nA \nI have no recollection, and if anything --\n6 \nQ \nOkay. \n7 \nA \n-- I think there was a desire to move quickly as \n8 \nopposed to slowly. \n9 \nQ \nOn the plea? \n10 \nA \nYes. \n11 \nQ \nAnd do you -- do you know where that energy came \n12 \nfrom? Who was --\n13 \nA \n14 \nQ \n--wanting to --\n15 \nA \nI don't, but --\n16 \nQ \nmove quickly? \n17 \nA \nas I recall -- so, for example, when we were \n18 \nsetting up the meeting in September, there was a -- a request \n19 \nto set it up in August as opposed to September, and we had to \n20 \npush it back to September because of vacations or something. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. So, in addition to not getting the \n22 \ncomputer evidence, the government curtailed the investigation \n23 \nto a large extent, despite finding more victims. There were \n24 \nwitnesses who were not interviewed, things that were not \n25 \nsearched, property that wasn't searched, target letters not \nEFTA00009077\n", "char_count": 1146}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Page 262 \n1 \nserved. Do you -- so, these all would have been steps taken \n2 \nby the FBI to enhance the federal investigation, right? As \n3 \nopposed to back to the state --\n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \nBY \n13 \nQ \nWere you aware of all -- of those steps that were \n14 \nbeing foregone, or foreclosed? \n15 \nA \nNo. My -- my assumption would have been, we may \n16 \nhave to go to trial, and so we should continue to develop the \n17 \nbasis for trial. So, if I could, for example, I think I --\n18 \nafter Drew came down, I said if we go to trial, can you be on \n19 \nthe trial team? I cite that, because I'm thinking, we may \n20 \nhave to go to trial. \n21 \nQ \nRight. \n22 \nA \nWhy not get Drew who's from Miami on the trial \n23 \nteam? \n24 \nQ \nSo, is it -- is it your understanding that the \n25 \nfederal investigation, notwithstanding the drafting of this \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- case that this was sort of --\nA \nYeah. \nQ \n-- being returned to. \nA \nRight. \nQ \nWas this --\nMR. TODD: Are you asking Alex if he's aware of all \nthe things you just said? \nEFTA00009078\n", "char_count": 1044}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Page 263 \n1 \nNPA, was still continuing? \n2 \nA \nYes. We -- you know, my understanding is you run \n3 \nthese on parallel tracks, and again, I'm -- I'm sitting here \n4 \ninviting the head of CEOS to be part of the trial team, and \n5 \ntalking about how to formulate the trial team. \n6 \nQ \nOkay. \n7 \nA \nThat -- that implies that I was clearly thinking we \n8 \nmight be going to trial. \n9 \nQ \nAll right. When you first received the draft of \n10 \nthe non-pros agreement, and this is 16a, it's a draft by \n11 \n. Do you know who came up with the -- the --\n12 \nit sounds like you didn't, but who came up with the name or \n13 \nthe moniker non-prosecution agreement? \n14 \nA \ni do not. \n15 \nQ \nDo you know what this was modelled on, if anything? \n16 \nWhere it --\n17 \nA \nI --\n18 \nQ \nWhat the genesis was? \n19 \nA \nI do not. I noticed from the contemporaneous e-\n20 \nmails that initially it was done differently, and I think it \n21 \nwas \nLourie who said write it as a contract, or I think \n22 \nthere is -- there is an e-mail to that effect. Someone may \n23 \nrecall it better than I, but --\n24 \nQ \nThis version of September 10, which is the first \n25 \nbusiness day after that --\nEFTA00009079\n", "char_count": 1172}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Page 264 \n1 \nA \nYeah. \nQ \n-- September 7th meeting, from\n3 \ngoes to her management up through you, and you do a rewrite \n4 \nalmost right away, adding original state charges which at \n5 \nthat point were all still in play, and you also added -- this \n6 \nis Exhibit 16b -- a statement that it would be Epstein's job \n7 \nto move the state to add additional charges, and that -- that \n8 \nlatter piece is on page three, just below paragraph eight. \n9 \nSo, you were --\n10 \n11 \n12 \nA \nCan I -- can I back up a second? \nQ \nSure. \nA \nWhen you say I did a rewrite, is there some \n13 \nindication of what I did a rewrite of? \n14 \nQ \nYes. If you compare the two --\n15 \nA \nRight. \n16 \nQ \n-- there's -- there are things that are bracketed \n17 \nin yellow in Exhibit 16b, which represent --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- the changes from 16a. \n20 \nA \nRight. \n21 \nQ \nOkay. So, those are the two things that are \n22 \ndifferent, and they're referenced in your -- your message --\n23 \nA \nYeah. \n24 \nQ \n-- at the beginning. We bracketed them just to \n25 \nmake it easier for you to -- to recognize --\nEFTA00009080\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Page 265 \n1 \nA \nRight. \n2 \nQ \n-- that. So, my point is that right from the \n3 \nbeginning, you were participating in the process -- in the \n4 \ndrafting process. \n5 \nA \nOh. So -- so, I would -- I would characterize that \n6 \nas not participating in the drafting process, but approving a \n7 \ndraft. There is -- there is a --\n8 \nQ \nI --\n9 \nA \n-- slight --\n10 \nQ \n-- I did a small --\n11 \nA \n-- difference. \n12 \nQ \n-- rewrite. \n13 \nA \nYeah. And so, something comes -- here's how I \n14 \nwould distinguish. Someone that's participating in the \n15 \ndrafting process is sitting at the table with two or three \n16 \npeople, drafting it as they go, versus something goes through \n17 \nthe management chain, and someone in the supervisory chain \n18 \nsays, can you change A, B, or C? \n19 \nQ \nAll right. \n20 \nA \nI -- I clearly -- you know, here and in other \n21 \nplaces, it looks like I'm inserting the same themes, which is \n22 \ndeferring to the state -- let's mention the state charges \n23 \nQ \n14M-hmm. \n24 \nA \n-- and we can't force the state to do anything. \n25 \nAnd so, I -- I'm adding to this. I'm clearly aware of it and \nEFTA00009081\n", "char_count": 1123}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Page 266 \n1 \napproving it, but I wouldn't say that I was drafting. \n2 \nQ \nFair enough. Did you read it? \n3 \nA \nI would assume that I read it, or else I wouldn't \n4 \nhave edited it. \n5 \nQ \nAll right. So, we have a draft from \n6 \nworking draft on September 10 with a small rewrite from you. \n7 \nThere is in the Exhibit 17 series indication that -- of the \n8 \nkind of activity that \nwas going through to come up \n9 \nwith a federal plea, but eventually she and the defense \n10 \nattorney who is most actively working on this, Jay Lefkowitz, \n11 \nturn back to the NPA, and if you look at 17d, just to make \n12 \nthe sort of staffing clear, you know, of course \n13 \nhas left, \nis going on vacation as of September \n14 \n15, and so \nLourie has helped finalize. So, the \n15 \nfinalizing of the NPA, the final version of which is in \n16 \nExhibit 22, falls to \nwith \n, right? \n17 \nA \nYes. \n18 \nQ \nOkay, and \nputs you on notice in 18b in that \n19 \nprocess. This e-mail in 18b is sort of a follow on to 18a. \n20 \nDo you see it comes one minute after your e-mail in 18a? \n21 \nIt's a response from her to you, only in which she makes note \n22 \nthat the defense, \"tried to reopen all the loopholes that I \n23 \nhad sewn shut.\" \n24 \nA \nYes. \n25 \nQ \nSo, it's fair to say that you're kind of -- you're \nEFTA00009082\n", "char_count": 1293}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Page 267 \n1 \non notice that they're being difficult? \n2 \n3 \nA \nI -- I -- that's fair. \nQ \nOkay. In the course of that being difficult, 19a \n4 \nis an e-mail to you from\n on September 18 in which she \n5 \nrepresents that -- or, explains that the defense is -- is --\n6 \nthat things are kind of falling apart with the negotiations, \n7 \nand she fears the deal is going to fall apart completely. \n8 \nMR. TODD: Should we take a quick break here? \n9 \nYou're losing your voice. \n10 \n: I'm fine. \n11 \nMR. TODD: You could probably use a minute. \n12 \n: All right. We'll take a break. \n13 \nTHE WITNESS All right. \n14 \n: A four minute break. \n15 \nMR. TODD: Four minutes, that's --\n16 \n: Okay. \n17 \n(Off the record.) \n18 \nBY \n19 \nQ \nBack on the record. Looking at Exhibit 19c, you \n20 \nsay -- you write to \nregarding whether you're \n21 \navailable to -- at a time when she's going to be hashing out \n22 \nlanguage. You advise her that -- but I -- \"I don't think I \n23 \nshould be part of negotiations. I'd rather leave that to you \n24 \nif that's okay.\" \n25 \nA \nYes. \nEFTA00009083\n", "char_count": 1061}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Page 268 \n1 \nQ \nWhy did you say that to her? \n2 \nA \nBecause she was the line lawyer involved, and I \n3 \nthought -- I think it's important for a U.S. Attorney to, \n4 \nabsent truly exceptional circumstances, to not get involved \n5 \nin sort of the negotiations. You can meet, like I did in \n6 \nSeptember, reaffirm the position of the office, back your \n7 \nAUSA, but ultimately, I think your trial lawyer needs \n8 \ndiscretion to do their job. \n9 \nQ \nAt this point, of course we know \n10 \nvacation. \n11 \nA \nRight. \n12 \nQ \nAnd you were aware, were you not, that \nis on \nLourie \n13 \nwas about to decamp for Washington? In other words, he left \n14 \nat the end of September --\n15 \nA \nYes. \n16 \nQ \n-- to become the chief of staff and principle \n17 \ndeputy, assistant attorney general --\n18 \nA \nCorrect. \n19 \nQ \n-- for \n20 \nA \nYes. \n21 \nQ \n-- who headed the criminal division. Okay, so it \n22 \nwas really just the two of them at this point, and with \n23 \nnobody apparently involved between them and you. \n24 \nA \nSo, fair, but when you say just the two of them, \n25 \nis an incredibly experienced lawyer. So, to say just \nEFTA00009084\n", "char_count": 1122}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Page 269 \n1 \nthe two of them is not to take -- not -- should not imply \n2 \nthat there was an experience in that --\n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \nQ \nA \n-- table. \nQ \nI certainly in no way intended to --\nA \nRight. \n7 \n8 \nA \nFair. \nQ \n-- suggest that. \n10 \nA \nFair enough. \n• \nLooking at 19d, in which \nis on page \n• \ntwo, looking at the latest draft from \nmeaning\n:3 \n, and this is in the -- in the -- in the throes of \n14 \nnegotiating the NPA. \nis essentially telling you \n15 \nhe agrees with \nobservations that the defense are just \n16 \nup to all kinds of nonsense in this deal, and constantly \n17 \nchanging their terms, and just not apparently negotiating or \n18 \ndealing with these warring drafts with the drafting process \n19 \nin good faith. \n20 \nAgain, that's my characterization, but \n21 \nsays to you in this e-mail, \"I suggest we simply tell him, \nthat his counteroffer is rejected, and that we \nintend to move forward with our case.\" Right? And then \nresponse is interesting. You say to him, why don't we \njust -- why don't we just call him? Tell him, one, you \nyour \nEFTA00009085\n", "char_count": 1069}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Page 270 \nagree, and then change things. Two --\n2 \nA \nYou being III agrees and changes things? \n3 \nQ \nCorrect. Tell him you agree, meaning, \nagrees? \n4 \nA \nNo. No. \n5 \nQ \nI see. \n6 \nA \nYeah. \n7 \nQ \nTell him --\n8 \nA \nTell him, you, III, agree, and you change things. \n9 \nQ \nI see. \n10 \nA \nThat is not acceptable to us, and is in bad faith. \n11 \nStop it, or we'll just indict, and then try to work it out. \n2 \nQ \nSo, is the try to work it out -- if the -- if \n13 \nnumbers one and two are what you should tell -- what \n:4 \nshould tell \n, is number three something \n15 \nshould tell \nor what you're telling III\"? Try to work it \n16 \nout? \n17 \nA \nIt's what I'm -- what I'm -- what I'm telling \n8 \nQ \nokay. So, just to be clear, you say, tell him, \n19 \nmeaning you, \n, tell Jay, number one --\n20 \nA \nSo --\n21 \nQ \n-- and number two, but number three is then what \n22 \nyou're instructing \nto do? I --\n23 \nA \nYes. \n24 \nQ \n-- I'm just trying to understand. \n25 \nA \nYes. So --\nEFTA00009086\n", "char_count": 978}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "1 \nQ \nOkay. \n2 \nA \nSo, my understanding of this is, they're being \n3 \ndifficult. Hey, this isn't the first time that an attorney \n4 \nagrees to something and then goes back and tries to pull a \n5 \nfast one. So, tell him you're onto this, that they need to \n6 \nstop it, or we'll indict, but then that we'll try to -- you \n7 \nknow, \nshould try to work it out. \n8 \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nBut they need to stop this tactic. \n10 \nQ \nDid you really think that was going to be effective \n11 \nwith this defense --\n12 \nA \nI don't know. \n13 \nQ \n-- team? \n14 \nA \nYou know, I think one of the hard things with this \n15 \nis, if it was right on September 6th, it remained right, \n16 \nirrespective of really -- I think I say, sorry, I know it's a \n17 \npain. \n18 \nQ \nYou do. \n19 \nA \nThis negotiation was a pain, but if it was the \n20 \nright position, the fact that you've got annoying counsel on \n21 \nthe other side doesn't it make it less of a right position. \n22 \nYou tell them stop being annoying, you try to work it out, \n23 \nand if not, then you indict. \n24 \nQ \nAll right, and is that sort of --\n25 \nA \nYou had a question? \nEFTA00009087\n", "char_count": 1115}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Page 272 \n1 \n: I was going to, but \nwas going \n2 \nahead. \n3 \nBY \n4 \nQ \nIs that -- is that consistent with your sort of way \n5 \nof doing business, being even, and working it out? \n6 \nA \nYeah. This is our position. It's not a bluff. \n7 \nIt's what we want. You work it out. People yell and scream \n8 \non the other side. You work it out. If not, then we indict. \n9 \nQ \nWhat would have been the tipping point for you? \n10 \nWhat would have caused you to say, okay, I agree with you, \n11 \nI agree with you, \n. Let's indict? \n12 \nA \nSo, it's really difficult to speculate, but I think \n13 \nthe tipping point would have been a failure to reach -- it \n14 \nwas pretty clear. Jail time, registration, restitution. \n15 \nOkay, we moved from 24 to 18 months. That was a give and \n16 \ntake. But ultimately, if they came back and said, we can't \n17 \nagree to these terms, then we indict. \n18 \nQ \nAll right. \n19 \nBY \n20 \nQ \nIt seemed like your troops were telling you, we've \n21 \nreached the end of our rope. We really want to just go \n22 \nforward and indict. \n23 \nA \nRight. \n24 \nQ \nAnd you were coming back with, tell them again that \n25 \nthe defense is being difficult, but I want you to work it \nEFTA00009088\n", "char_count": 1194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Page 273 \n1 \nout. Does that tell your troops basically that where your \n2 \npriority is, you want them to get to this resolution, and if \n3 \nthey have to give up stuff, it's okay -- it's really okay, \n4 \nbut you want this resolution? \n5 \nA \nSo, it's not if you have to give up stuff. I'm not \n6 \ntelling them to give up stuff. I'm not telling them to \n7 \nnegotiate things away, but I think -- the dynamic from my \n8 \nperspective is incredibly -- so, there's a tactic that \n9 \ncounsel sometimes take where they negotiate, and then they \n10 \ntry to come back and renegotiate, and that is, to my \n11 \nthinking, one of the most annoying tactics that you can have, \n12 \nand it -- and it creates a lot of -- of frustration, and what \n13 \nI'm trying to say is, look, they might be frustrating folks, \n14 \nbut if this had been worked out -- so -- so, looking at this, \n15 \nwe thought we had an agreement, and then they changed things, \n16 \nand I'm saying, look, if you thought you had an agreement, \n17 \ntell them you had an agreement. \n18 \nDon't let them change things. I understand it's \n19 \nfrustrating to you, but if it was right two weeks ago, the \n20 \nfact that they are frustrating attorneys doesn't change the \n21 \nunderlying legal analysis. The attorney's behavior doesn't \n22 \ninform the rightness or wrongness of a certain disposition, \n23 \nto a point. \n24 \nBY \n25 \nQ \nWhat's that point? \nEFTA00009089\n", "char_count": 1404}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "1 \nPage 274 \nA \nSo, I think after the -- now I'm calling it an NPA. \n2 \nI was personally very frustrated with the failure to report \n3 \non October 20, and had I envisioned that entire collateral \n4 \nattack, I think I would have looked at this very differently. \n5 \n6 \nQ \nIn what respect? \nA \nTo the extent that this was -- going back to, for \n7 \nexample, the public corruption prosecutions that we had, one \n8 \nof the values of it was to have a public figure stand up and \n9 \nsay, I did this, and plead. \n10 \nOne of the values was the, you know, avoiding a \n11 \nlong and messy legal process. And so when you put all of \n12 \nthat together, those -- you know, this is why I say it's not \n13 \nquite -- this was the factor that we'd consider, that it's \n14 \nall of this put together, and in something that could have \n15 \nbeen very positive for the victims and for sending a signal, \n16 \nas it dragged on, became exhausting and negative for the \n17 \nvictims. \n18 \nIt put us in a position of what do we do with \n19 \nnotifications. It put us in the position of a lot of appeals \n20 \nto Washington. It put us in the position of having to deal \n21 \nwith complicated legal issues that actually got more messy in \n22 \nterms of how does a federal 22.55 relate to a -- to a state \n23 \ncharge, and had all of that been known, I do think this would \n24 \nhave proceeded differently. \n25 \nQ \nDifferently in what way? \nEFTA00009090\n", "char_count": 1415}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Page 275 \n1 \nA \nSo -- so, if I had factored all of that -- like, I \n2 \ncan't predict it's --\n3 \nQ \nRight. \n4 \nA \n-- what I would have done, but I think if I had \n5 \nknown all that, this could have proceeded very differently. \n6 \nI was very frustrated with the October to June time period. \n7 \nQ \nSo, if you had been back in that timeframe in early \n8 \nSeptember, looking at this with, I don't know, what, Harry \n9 \nPotter character it is --\n10 \nA \nRight. \n11 \nQ \n-- but whoever can see into the future, and -- and \n12 \nanticipated or foresaw --\n13 \nA \nRight. \n14 \nQ \n-- what would have happened, would you have simply \n15 \nsaid, look, we're not going to go the state route, we'll go \n16 \nthe federal route? \n17 \nA \nQuite possibly. \n18 \nQ \nAll right. \n19 \nA \nAnd let me sort of -- we'll probably get into it, \n20 \nbut at some point, I do think the post versus the pre-\n21 \nsignature time period was different for any number of \n22 \nreasons, and we'll probably want to talk about that. \n23 \nQ \nAll right. We will, but now, I'd like to turn to \n24 \nsome of the terms of the --\n25 \nA \nFair. \nEFTA00009091\n", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Page 276 \n1 \nQ \nthe NPA, because you did make -- let me -- let \n2 \nme make sure that this is correct \n3 \n: You skipped this one. \n4 \nBY \n5 \nQ \nOh yeah, before that -- thank you, my colleague \n6 \nreminds me 19e is an exhibit that has a -- an exchange \n7 \nbetween you and \nLourie about the -- at a time when the \n8 \nplea agreement -- the federal plea agreement --\n9 \nA \nRight. \n10 \nQ \n-- was still in play, and the issue is whether you \n11 \nshould sign it, and --\n12 \nA \nRight. \n13 \nQ \n-- you didn't want to, because you never do, but \n14 \nyou say at the bottom, we should only go forward if the trial \n15 \nteam supports and signs this agreement. What did you mean by \n16 \nthat? The -- the first part of it? \n17 \nA \nSo -- so, what I meant by that was I got something \n18 \nthat the -- that is -- the document was unusual. So, my \n19 \nsignature appearing on this document is not in and of itself \n20 \nunusual. \n21 \nQ \nAnd this would have been the plea agreement -- not \n22 \nthe federal plea agreement, not the -- or was this about the \n23 \nNPA? \n24 \nA \nThis was about the NPA. \n25 \nQ \nOkay. \nEFTA00009092\n", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Page 277 \n1 \nA \nRight, and so the NPA had my signature. Now, the \n2 \nNPA's almost too generous. \n3 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n4 \nA \nSo, that in and of itself is not indicative of \n5 \nsomething, but it does raise my concern. Is this something \n6 \nthat ultimately the trial team does not feel comfortable \n7 \nwith? And if it's something they don't feel comfortable \n8 \nwith, then they should speak up and let me know, because we \n9 \nshouldn't go forward with it. \n10 \nQ \nAnd did you ever have a conversation or a \n11 \ndiscussion about that issue, other than mentioning it? \n12 \nA \nNot -- not to my recollection. I would --\n13 \nQ \nOkay. \n14 \nA \n-- assume based on this that \nwould read it and \n15 \nwould take me at my word and say, look, if -- I think you're \n16 \ngoing in the wrong direction, Alex. You know, I think you're \n17 \ngoing in the wrong direction, or I'm uncomfortable with it. \n18 \nQ \nOkay. All right. \n19 \nBY \n20 \nQ \nDid you ever have a direct conversation with \n21 \nabout wanting her to sign the agreement as opposed \n22 \nto yourself? \n23 \nA \nI -- I did not. This was my -- my communications \n24 \nwith \n, and -- and I really meant that if at the end of \n25 \nthe day, my team isn't comfortable, then you shouldn't go \nEFTA00009093\n", "char_count": 1228}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Page 278 \nforward. \n2 \nQ \nYou never recall hearing from \nthat she was \n3 \nnot comfortable moving forward with the plea agreement? \n4 \nBY \n5 \nQ \nThe NPA? \n6 \nA \nI did not hear -- I don't recall hearing from \n7 \nthat she was not comfortable. I know that at various points \n8 \nshe became frustrated. At various points, \nbecame \n9 \nfrustrated, but they were negotiating this. If at some point \n10 \nthey did not -- they thought this was a mistake, or wrong, or \n11 \nunjust, I would think that they would tell me. \n12 \nQ \nWhat would you have done? \n13 \nA \nSit down and really have a serious conversation \n14 \nabout where this is going, and sit down and hear them out, \n15 \nagain, even if -- at this late phase. \n16 \nQ \nRight. \n17 \nA \nWould be -- I would -- I would think that that's \n18 \nwhat I would have done. \n19 \nQ \nAll right. Let's turn to the NPA. What is it? \n20 \nExhibit 22? Did you read it? We know that you made some \n21 \nfinal tweaks to it. 22. \n22 \nA \nSo --\n23 \nQ \nIs the final -- as signed --\n24 \nA \n22. And so, I would -- again, I don't have an \n25 \nindependent recollection of reading it. I would not have \nEFTA00009094\n", "char_count": 1129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Page 279 \n1 \nmade tweaks to it without reading it. \n2 \nQ \nOkay. \n3 \nA \nAnd so, I think you can infer that I read it. \n4 \nQ \nAll right, and let me say, you -- you were clerk to \n5 \nan appellate -- a very eminent appellate judge, and you \n6 \ndid -- did you do appellate work --\n7 \nA \nI did. \n8 \nQ \n-- yourself? So, you were somebody who's an \n9 \nappellate lawyer, who has that experience at a high level, is \n10 \noften more sensitive to words, and phrasings, and to \n11 \ndocuments, contents, than might be, again, to be -- to \n12 \ncaricaturize a little bit, but a more of a shoot from the hip \n13 \ntrial attorney who spends his days, you know, in a -- in a \n14 \nrough and tumble courtroom, and is it fair to say that you \n15 \nwere more of the former, and more --\n16 \nA \nSo, I would push back. I think that's not \n17 \nrespecting the talent of the trial lawyer, and particularly \n18 \non these types of agreements or documents, these are folks \n19 \nthat sort of have expertise, because even if this was sui \n20 \ngeneris, they have seen a lot of this. \n21 \nQ \nI am not suggesting that \nand \n22 \nLourie --\n23 \nA \nRight. \n24 \nQ \n-- were not up to this. \n25 \nA \nRight. \nEFTA00009095\n", "char_count": 1174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Page 280 \n1 \nQ \nBecause certainly she also had a lot of appellate \n2 \nexperience. I'm simply noting that -- that this seems to be \n3 \nsort of in your wheelhouse. \n4 \nA \nWhat -- look, I apologize. Whether -- I'm not sure \n5 \nwhat in my wheelhouse means. I -- you know, I appear to have \n6 \nread this. I suggested some edits. As I would have \n7 \napproached this document, my assumption would have been I'm \n8 \nlooking at it from my earlier concerns, that -- the policy \n9 \nlevel concerns. \n10 \nDoes it capture that we're deferring to the state? \n11 \nGoing back to the put in the petite policy versus not. Does \n12 \nit capture the policy concerns of -- of appropriately \n13 \nunderstanding that we can't force the state to do something? \n14 \nAnd does it capture the essential elements of the terms that \n15 \nwe had looked for, the \n16 \nQ \nAll right. \n17 \nA \n-- you know, the imprisonment, registration, and \n18 \nrestitution. \n19 \nQ \nAll right. So, one of the things that is a little \n20 \nstriking that's different from the original draft NPA, even \n21 \nas amended by you. So, let's pull out the 16b. Is that --\n22 \nis what I would call the non-admission of guilty, so, in \n23 \nthe -- in the first page of 16b, the first paragraph that's \n24 \nthe first clause after the one through five statutes listing, \n25 \nin 16b, reads, \"It appearing that Epstein has accepted \nEFTA00009096\n", "char_count": 1374}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Page 2 \n1 \nresponsibility for his behavior by his signature on this \n2 \nagreement.\" \n3 \nA \nI'm sorry, you're on 16b? \n4 \nQ \n16b. \n5 \nA \nOkay. It appearing, yes. \n6 \nQ \nOkay. So, his is -- and this is not \nI mean, \n7 \nthis seems to be fairly typical sort of plea agreement \n8 \nlanguage, right? \n9 \n10 \nQ \nAnd if you look at the top of the final NPA, 22, \n11 \nthe third, it appearing clause \n12 \nA \nI'm sorry. Where --\n13 \nQ \nFine. \n14 \nA \n-- where are you? \n15 \nQ \n16b. \n16 \nA \nRight. \n17 \nQ \nHas \n18 \nA \nThe third, it appearing? \n19 \nQ \nIt appearing he has -- the \ndown at the bottom. \n20 \nA \nYeah. \n21 \nQ \nIt says -- refers to at the --\n22 \nA \nIt has accepted responsibility. \n23 \nQ \nsecond up. \n24 \nA \nYes. \n25 \nQ \nExactly. He's accepted responsibility. \nEFTA00009097\n", "char_count": 770}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Page 282 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \nA \nRight. \nQ \nAnd then above in the fourth, it appearing --\nA \nYeah. \nQ \n-- it references the fact that, it appearing, \n5 \n\"Epstein has committed offenses against the United States.\" \n6 \n7 \nA \nYes. \nQ \nOkay? So, he -- there's a sense of acceptance of \n8 \nresponsibility. In the final NPA, which is 22 in your right \n9 \nhand, the --\n10 \nA \nRight. \n11 \nQ \n-- third it appearing clause says nothing about \n12 \nEpstein committing offenses. It simply references the U.S. \n13 \nAttorney's Office and the FBI having conducted their own \n14 \ninvestigation into Epstein's background and any offenses that \n15 \nmay have been committed by Epstein, including --\n16 \nA \nRight. \n17 \nQ \n-- the enumerated statutes. And then following the \n18 \nenumerated federal statutes, there's no reference at all to \n19 \nEpstein accepting responsibility. Do you -- do you -- do you \n20 \nview that -- the removal of that acceptance of responsibility \n21 \nto be something that was appropriate? \n22 \nA \nSo, trying to reconstruct, the focus was on -- and \n23 \nI know I'm repeating myself, but jail time, registration, \n24 \nrestitution. Whether he accepted responsibility for a \n25 \nfederal or for a state, I think my focus would have been on, \nEFTA00009098\n", "char_count": 1246}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Page 283 \n1 \nthese were the terms. Does this encompass those terms? \n2 \nQ \nSo, as that concession is not something material as \n3 \nfar as -- I don't want to use the legal term material, but it \n4 \nwasn't important --\n5 \nA \nSo -- so --\n6 \nQ \n-- to your objectives? \n7 \nA \nSo --\n8 \nQ \nIs that right? \n9 \nA \nFirst, I'm not sure -- so, it wasn't a concession \n10 \nfrom that -- that -- those four bullets, right? It was a \n11 \nconcession from an earlier draft. \n12 \nQ \nRight. \n13 \nA \nAnd so to say it's not important is, again, there \n14 \nwas an early draft. It changed. The focus was in any give \n15 \nand take, drafts change. The focus was, did he go to jail? \n16 \nDid he have to register? Did we have restitution? \n17 \nQ \nAll right. \n18 \nBY \n19 \nQ \nDo you remember noticing that change, and thinking \n20 \nit --\n21 \nA \n22 \nQ \n-- just doesn't matter? \n23 \nA \nI don't. In all -- in all candor, until right now, \n24 \nI was not aware of that -- of that change. I doubt I would \n25 \nhave taken two documents and sort of put them side by side, \nEFTA00009099\n", "char_count": 1048}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Page 284 \n1 \nas opposed to, does this capture what we're trying to get to. \n2 \nBY \n3 \nQ \nSo, does that --\n4 \nA \nI was aware of the 24 to 18. \n5 \nQ \nMe-ham. \n6 \nA \nBut up until this question, I wasn't aware of that \n7 \nchange, to my recollection. \n8 \nQ \nSo --\n9 \nBY \nQ \nAnd you're aware of the 24 to 18 because you \nnoticed it in the NPA, or because somebody told you \nseparately? Or do you know? \nA \nI can't -- I can't say other than I was aware. \nBY \nQ \nIn the final NPA on page five, there's a series of \nthings that are included at the bottom of that page, in that \nlong paragraph, and the one that I want to focus on is the \n16 \nimmunity portion. \n19 \nThat was certainly not in the original draft \n20 \nproposed by the U.S. Attorney's Office. In this paragraph, \n21 \nthe United States agrees, \"That it will not institute any \n22 \ncriminal charges against any potential coconspirators of \n23 \nEpstein, including but not limited t \nDid you notice \n25 \nthat provision? \nEFTA00009100\n", "char_count": 983}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "1 \nPage 285 \nA \nI -- I don't recall focusing on the coconspirator \n2 \nprovision. To the extent I reviewed this coconspirator \n3 \nprovision, I can speculate that my thinking would have been \n4 \nthe focus is on Epstein's -- Epstein's going to jail. \nWhether some of his employees go to jail, or other, lesser \n6 \ninvolved, is not the focus of this. \n7 \nQ \nAll right. This particular provision, as you know, \n8 \nhas been --\n9 \nA \nIt has --\n10 \nQ \n-- enormously --\n11 \nA \n-- generated --\n12 \nQ \n-- criticized. \n13 \nA \nEnormous, yes. \n14 \nQ \nFor a number of reasons. One of which is that it \n15 \nis blanket transactional immunity. It gives blanket immunity \n16 \nto unnamed, unidentified --\n17 \nA \nYes. \n18 \nQ \n-- potential coconspirators. People who, even in \n19 \nthe future, if evidence is developed against them, as long as \n20 \nthey could be considered coconspirators of Epstein in this \n21 \nconduct, they have a get out of jail free card. Do you have \n22 \nany idea where that came from? \n23 \nA \nI don't, and I don't want to characterize it as \n24 \ngiving -- I understand how it could be read that way in the \n25 \nrecord. I don't want to characterize it, but I don't know \nEFTA00009101\n", "char_count": 1184}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Page 286 \n1 \nwhere this could have come from. \n2 \nI was -- I would have reviewed this for the policy \n3 \nconcerns. Did it do the -- the sort of the bullet points, \n4 \nand my assumption, rightly or wrongly, would have been that \n5 al \nand \nwould have looked at this, and that this \n6 \nwas -- was appropriate. I understand your point. \n7 \nQ \nAll right, and I believe the point you were \n8 \nreferring to is that when I use the term jail -- get out of \n9 \njail free card, that you recognize this is limited to your \n10 \ndistrict? \n11 \nA \nAnd that's an important point --\n12 \nQ \nOf course. \n13 \nA \n-- to recognize. \n14 \nQ \nOf course, but nonetheless, this does give blanket \n15 \nimmunity to people -- you have no idea who they might be, \n16 \ncorrect? If you had focused on it, would that have raised \n17 \nsome question in your mind? \n18 \nA \nIf -- if there was a discussion like what we're \n19 \nhaving here, then it very possibly could have raised. It's \n20 \ndifficult to say it would have, but I understand your \n21 \nconcern. \n22 \nQ \nAll right, and the named individuals, \n23 \nare all \n24 \nindividuals who were described in the pros memo and so on, \n25 \nand the pros memo does identify that at least one of these \nEFTA00009102\n", "char_count": 1222}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Page 287 \n1 \nwomen herself engaged in sexual activity with minor -- with \n2 \nminor girls. \n3 \n4 \n5 \nA \nYeah. \nQ \nSo that she has liability in and of her own --\nA \nSo, I don't have an independent recollection of \n6 \nthat, but when I reviewed the pros memo, I did notice that. \n7 \nQ \nAll right. Now, you told us this morning that you \n8 \nhave no recollection of that actually having read the pros \n9 \nmemo back at that time. \n10 \nA \nI think what I said was I don't have a recollection \n11 \nof whether I did or did not read the pros memo. I have \n12 \nsince, when you've provided it, read it, and I note that it \n13 \ndoes reference her. \n14 \nQ \nHaving read it now, does that change your view of \n15 \nanything that we've talked about so far today? \n16 \nA \nSo, reading it 12 years later, knowing all of this, \n17 \npossibly, and part of it is I do think we approach these \n18 \ncases differently, and I think these cases would play out \n19 \nvery differently in court today. I think it's very difficult \n20 \nto sort of go back and recreate a thought process from 12 \n21 \nyears ago. \n22 \nQ \nAnd if you were relying back then on the \n23 \ncharacterization and summary and recounting of this case to \n24 \nyou by your people -- your senior people, \n25 \nA \nMm-hmm. \nEFTA00009103\n", "char_count": 1264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "Page 288 \n1 \nQ \n-- and in particular, \n2 \nA \nRight. \n3 \nQ \nwould you -- do you -- do you have a \ndid --\n4 \ndid anyone in that ground, including IIIIILourie, in any way \n5 \nto your recollection characterize this case as not serious, \n6 \nor as trivial, or as involving non-important -- unimportant \n7 \nvictims? In any way try to diminish either the conduct or \n8 \nthe victims? \n9 \nA \nNot to my recollection. I -- I do think there was \n10 \na concern as to how the victims would present in court, given \n11 \nimpeachment, and given contradictory statements, but that's \n12 \ndifferent than trivializing the case. \n13 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. Back to the immunity provision. \n14 \nWere you aware that none of the four named coconspirators had \n15 \ncooperated? \n16 \nA \nI was not. To my recollection. \n17 \nQ \nAnd do you recall any other case in which blanket \n18 \nimmunity in the V.S. Attorney's Office --\n19 \nA \nRight. \n20 \nQ \n-- was -- in which blanket immunity, really \n21 \nwithout -- virtually without limitation --\n22 \nA \nI -- SO, I --\n23 \nQ \n-- was granted? \n24 \nA \nI don't recall discussion around this provision, \n25 \nand a general matter, I did not discuss the -- in typical \nEFTA00009104\n", "char_count": 1184}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Page 289 \n1 \ncases that came -- that bubbled up to my level, it was -- the \n2 \nfocus was on who the prime, you know, target is, and not on \n3 \nwhat we would do with the coconspirators. And so, I don't \n4 \nrecall, but that doesn't mean it didn't happen. That's just \n5 \nnot typically something that I got involved with. \n6 \nQ \nAnd likewise, non -- immunity being given to non-\n7 \ncooperating coconspirators, or codefendants? Is that \n8 \nsomething that was done in your office? \n9 \nA \nAgain, I -- as a typical matter, we -- I did not \n10 \nget involved with these, but let me -- let me also say that \n11 \nthis wasn't a federal prosecution in the first place. And \n12 \nso, this whole thing is sui generis to some extent. \n13 \nQ \n/t is, but the -- but the grant of immunity is \n14 \nreal, right? \n15 \nA \nI understand where you're coming from. \n16 \nQ \nAll right. If you had focused on that provision, \n17 \nwould you have insisted it come out? \n18 \nA \nOne question I would have had is, if we're \n19 \nnaming -- as I sit here and sort of focus as we are now, but \n20 \nthis is with the benefit of hindsight and criticism --\n21 \nQ \nMM-hmm. \n22 \nA \n-- if there are specific folks, why do we have any \n23 \npotential language? Because that seems quite broad. \n24 \nQ \nIt's -- it's without limitation as to people as \n25 \nlong as they're coconspirators, right? \nEFTA00009105\n", "char_count": 1358}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Page 290 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \nA \nBut -- and so what is -- what is the need for that? \nQ \nOkay. \nA \nAnd I would --\nQ \ni see. \nA \nAnd so, if we had this kind of discussion, I would \n6 \nbe sending \nan e-mail saying, what's the need for this? \n7 \nWhat's up? \n8 \nQ \nBut to be clear, as we sit here today, you have no \n9 \nrecollection of having noticed that? \n10 \nA \nI -- I don't have a recollection of -- if I read \n11 \nover it, my assumption would have been that \nand \n12 \nthought this through and sort of addressed it for a reason. \n13 \nQ \nAll right, and if --\n14 \nBY \n15 \nQ \nAnd did you have any -- anyone ever come to you \n16 \nwith the evidentiary issues and say, we need to track this \n17 \ndown before we give such a blanket immunity? \n18 \nA \nI don't recall any conversation around \n19 \ncoconspirators. \n20 \nBY \n21 \nQ \nThis is where there is a mention of computer \n22 \nequipment. There is a provision later in that -- in that \n23 \nsame paragraph that provides that, \"The federal grand jury \n24 \ninvestigation will be suspended, and all pending federal \n25 \ngrand jury subpoenas will be held in abeyance unless and \nEFTA00009106\n", "char_count": 1123}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Page 291 \n1 \nuntil the defendant,\" --\n2 \nA \nRight. \n3 \nQ \n-- \"violates any term of this agreement. The \n4 \ndefendant likewise agrees to withdraw his pending motion to \n5 \nintervene and quash certain grand jury subpoenas. Both \n6 \nparties agree to maintain their evidence, specifically \n7 \nevidence requested by or directly related to the grand jury \n8 \nsubpoenas that have been issued, and including certain \n9 \ncomputer equipment in violate until all of the terms of the \n10 \nagreement have been satisfied.\" Do you -- do you -- do you \n11 \nview that this agreement to suspect the -- at least certain \n12 \naspects of the federal investigation to have been an \n13 \nappropriate concession? \n14 \nA \nYou know, again, my -- my focus was on certain \n15 \npoints. I would have assumed reading this that this was \n16 \nthought through. \n17 \nQ \nOkay. \n18 \nA \nAnd that -- and that people had. \n19 \nQ \nHad -- had --\n20 \nA \nHad thought it through, you. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. Okay. There is what's been criticized \n22 \nas a confidentiality provision. \n23 \nA \nYes. \n24 \nQ \nRight? And that's on that same page, page five, \n25 \nparagraph -- numbered paragraph 13, which provides that, \"The \nEFTA00009107\n", "char_count": 1183}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Page 292 \n1 \nparties anticipate that this agreement will not be made part \n2 \nof any public record.\" \n3 \nAnd then there is an exception for FOIA or \n4 \ncompulsory process from a court, in which the government will \n5 \nprovide notice to Epstein. That seems to be limited to the \n6 \nplacing of this document on the public record, right? As \n7 \nopposed to sharing it, or disclosing it for whatever purpose \n8 \nto individuals. Did -- is that -- is that a distinction that \n9 \nmakes sense? \n10 \nA \nThat is -- that is a fair distinction upon reading \n11 \nthis. I'm not sure that that is a distinction that was -- I \n12 \nmean, I'm basing that on my reading currently, and not as a \n13 \nrecollection. \n14 \nQ \nAnd in fact the parties, both defense counsel and \n15 \neven the U.S. Attorney's Office took the position that this \n16 \nshould never have seen the light of day, even to be disclosed \n17 \nto, you know, victims or other parties and interest, except \n18 \nfor filing it, or except for sharing it on a limited basis \n19 \nwith law enforcement. I think there were e-mails that talk \n20 \nabout if we share it, we'll tell them not to disclose it. \n21 \nA \nMm-hmm. \n22 \nQ \nIs that sort of overstating what this paragraph \n23 \nrequires? \n24 \nA \nPossibly. I can \nyou know, we can get into that, \n25 \nand we can discuss it. I would need to understand a little \nEFTA00009108\n", "char_count": 1361}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Page 293 \n1 \nbit more. I know there was litigation around disclosure on \n2 \nthis, and I'd need to understand much more the positions that \n3 \nwe took and the why before commenting on them. \n4 \nQ \nThere's -- in Exhibit 23, there is a discussion of \n5 \nthe -- the -- whether the NPA after it has been signed could \n6 \nbe revealed -- the existence of it could be revealed to the \n7 \npolice chief, or even the FBI, or the girls, and \n8 \nin the middle of page one, or two thirds of the way \n9 \ndown on page one of Exhibit 23, proposes that if we tell \n10 \nanybody about the NPA, you just ask that -- that the \n11 \nrecipient of that information not disclose it. \n12 \nAnd you then at the top of the page to Lourie and \n13 \nwho is going to take over \n14 \nLourie's position as the managing AUSA in West Palm Beach, \n15 \nshould talk with you about it on Wednesday, about the -- you \n16 \nshould talk about who we tell, and how much. Do you remember \n17 \nthat conversation, and --\n18 \nA \nI -- I don't. I know there were several concerns \n19 \nabout leaks and media, and I imagine that we had a \n20 \nconversation quite literally about who to tell, and how much. \n21 \nQ \nAnd did you -- did you feel that this -- at the \n22 \ntime, as best as you recall, did you feel that that clause \n23 \nbound you to not tell anyone? \n24 \nA \nSo, my recollection of the clause, whether it \n25 \nwas -- whether it was this clause or whether there was a \nEFTA00009109\n", "char_count": 1433}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Page 294 \n1 \ndiscussion, I was \nwas aware of this provision, and my \n2 \nrecollection of this provision is at some point it was raised \n3 \nas something that -- that was the subject of negotiation. \n4 \nQ \nOkay. \n5 \nA \nThat the office policy was that we -- that these \n6 \ntypes of deferred prosecution agreement is not made part of \n7 \nthe public record, and --\n8 \nQ \nMe-hmm. \n9 \nA \n-- therefore that this is not a substantial \n10 \nconcession --\n11 \nQ \nMe-hmm. \n12 \nA \n-- because in the typical course of business, this \n13 \nwould not be part of the public record. \n14 \nQ \nAnd that's because it's a non-prosecution as \n15 \nopposed -- agreement as opposed to a deferred prosecution \nagreement? \nA \nSo, deferred prosecution is not -- to analogize \n18 \nfrom a non-prosecution to a deferred prosecution, these \n19 \nare -- you know, if the non-prosecution is not typically part \n20 \nof the public record, the deferred prosecution, it makes \n21 \nsense that it follows the same. \n22 \nAnd so, it seemed that -- it seemed a concession --\n23 \nI understand how it was perceived publicly after the fact. \n24 \nAt the time, it seemed that we weren't giving up much, \n25 \nbecause the typical policy is this is not part of the public \nEFTA00009110\n", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "Page 295 \n1 \nrecord, and individuals need to file a FOIA. And so by \n2 \nsaying it's not part of the public record, and individuals \n3 \nneed to follow FOIA, if that -- if that is viewed as a \n4 \nconcession, it really isn't. \n5 \nQ \nSo, how would -- I mean, did -- is it -- is it \n6 \nunderstandable that Epstein would not want this document to \n7 \nsee the light of day, because it describes the existence and \n8 \nnature and scope of the federal investigation --\n9 \nA \nRight. \n10 \nQ \n-- and also his concession to liability under \n11 \n22.55? \n12 \nA \nIt's understandable. It was also my impression at \n13 \nthe time that it would see the light of day, because --\n14 \nQ \nMm-hmm. \n15 \nA \n-- if victims have 22.55, the ability to get 22.55, \n16 \nthey obviously have to hear about it from somewhere, and \n17 \ngiven the press interest, eventually this would be FOIA'd. \n18 \nAnd so, from my thinking at the time, rightly or wrongly, \n19 \nthis is a concession that's basically saying we'll follow \n20 \noffice policy, and we're likely going to be FOIA'd on this \n21 \nanyhow, and it can play out in the FOIA. And so, is this \n22 \nreally a --\n23 \nQ \nYeah. \n24 \nA \n-- concession? \n25 \nQ \nAll right. Another piece of the -- the agreement \nEFTA00009111\n", "char_count": 1234}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Page 296 \n1 \nis -- is something that is absent, and that's the sort of \n2 \ntypical language that you find in a -- I think in pretty much \n3 \nany federal plea agreement, which is, this agreement \n4 \nonly -- the defendant understands that this agreement only \n5 \nbinds the U.S. Attorney's Office for whatever district he or \n6 \nshe is in, or --\n7 \nA \nRight. \n8 \nQ \n-- you know, and that -- and that truly what you \n9 \nwould call global dispositions are unusual \n:0 \nA \nRight. \nQ \n-- for the federal government. \n12 \nA \nAnd I would note, you know, and this is after the \n13 \nfact that it does say this district agrees. \n14 \nQ \nokay. Understood, and it's also has you as a \n15 \nparty, not the Department of Justice. \n16 \nA \nRight. \n17 \nQ \nBut it does omit that standard language, and do you \n18 \nknow whether that was done sort of by mistake, or \n19 \nconsciously? \n20 \nA \nI -- I have no -- I can't speak to that. \n21 \nQ \nAll right. another piece is phrasing that you \n22 \ninjected at the -- when you addressed the first -- where it \n23 \nwas -- it was toward the end. Where --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- you talked about injecting the best efforts \nEFTA00009112\n", "char_count": 1155}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "Page 297 \n1 \nlanguage. \n2 \nA \nYes. \n3 \nQ \nOkay. Does it -- what -- what's -- I believe you \n4 \nmade clear why you did that. That is, to avoid the \n5 \nappearance of having the federal government be dictating \n6 \nanything, but why rely on best efforts, and to what extent is \n7 \nthat even enforceable? \n8 \nA \nSo, first, let me -- let me say it was not to avoid \n9 \nthe appearance. It was to avoid the actual legal discovery \n10 \ndictating, but -- so, Epstein understands that he has no \n11 \nauthority to require -- that -- to undertake discussions and \n12 \nto use -- so, as I recall, if he did not plead, then there \n13 \nwas no agreement. \n14 \nQ \nNo, no, no. This -- I'm sorry. \n15 \nA \nYes. \n16 \nQ \nI don't mean to -- it appears in paragraph --\n17 \nnumbered paragraph --\n18 \nA \nRight. \n19 \nQ \n-- 11, Epstein shall use his best efforts to enter \n20 \nhis guilty plea and be sentenced no later than the --\n21 \nA \nRight. \n22 \nQ \n-- set date, and then in the first paragraph after \n23 \nnumbered clause 11, he will use his best efforts to ensure \n24 \ncompliance with certain procedures, and best efforts to \n25 \nconvince the judge of the Florida court to accept his binding \nEFTA00009113\n", "char_count": 1180}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "Page 298 \n1 \nrecommendation. So, best efforts kind of became a sticking \n2 \npoint in enforcement, didn't it? Because what does it mean? \nF \n3 \nWhat does best efforts mean? \n4 \nA \nSo, I think it's fair to say that one of the issues \n5 \nthat came up after this was entered into was the U.S. \n6 \nAttorney's Office, at least from my perspective, was in a \n7 \nlittle bit of a bind because we had agreed to this, yet he \n8 \nwasn't turning himself in. And so, how do we deal with that? \n9 \nAnd so, that's not a phrase that I focused on at the time. I \n10 \nunderstand your point. \n11 \nQ \nAll right. I'm going to move on from those. Is \n12 \nthere anything else on those NPA clauses? \n13 \nA \nAnd finally, let me -- let me just say you didn't \n14 \nask, we had incredibly experienced attorneys in the office. \n15 \nI assumed, rightly or wrongly, that this language had been \n16 \nthought through and vetted, and you know, sitting here 12 \n17 \nyears later, I understand the issues that have arisen from \n18 \nit, but at the time, these were not issues that were focused \n19 \non. \n20 \nQ \nto your knowledge, who was involved in the \n21 \ndrafting, other than \non your side --\n22 \nA \nRight. \n23 \nQ \n-- and \nLourie, and you, to some extent? \n24 \nA \nSo, I can't say 12 years after the fact, but again, \n25 \nLourie, very experienced head of the Palm Beach Office \nEFTA00009114\n", "char_count": 1354}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00009016", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "Page 299 \n1 \nhas prosecuted any number of cases. \n2 \nQ \nIn -- again, just to keep --\n3 \nA \nRight. \n4 \nQ \n-- perspective and context, the final week that \n5 \nthis was being negotiated, \nLourie was in Washington, and \n6 \nbouncing back and forth on the weekends, because he was in \n7 \ntransition to the front office here in the criminal division \n8 \nin this building. That's a factor in terms of being able to \n9 \ngive attention to some details. Would you agree with that? \n10 \nIt could be a factor? \n11 \nA \nSo, it could be a factor. On the other hand, I'd \n12 \nsay that \nwasn't leaving the department. He is \n13 \nprofessional. He knows his stuff, and you would expect a \n14 \nprofessional -- if they're reviewing a document, whether \n15 \nthey're on vacation, whether they're looking to move from one \n16 \npart of the department to another, that you would expect them \n17 \nto review it, you know, fulfilling their -- their \n18 \nresponsibility to sort of focus in and make sure that -- that \n19 \nit's -- that it encompasses what it should. And that's not a \n20 \ncriticism of \n. That -- that's saying that, well, that \n21 \nmight be a factor. That doesn't lessen from my perspective \n22 \nreliance on his expertise. \n23 \nQ \nNM-hmm. Understood. After the NPA was signed --\n24 \nA \nRight. \n25 \nQ \n-- and \ncame back --\nEFTA00009115\n", "char_count": 1320}]}