{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_count": 23, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/DOJ-OGR-00011109", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/DOJ-OGR-00011109.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document690_ Filed 11/19/21 Page1of23\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT fiene: See\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK DOCUMENT\nELECTRONICALLY FILED\n\nDOC #:\nDATE FILED: 11/19/21 _ |\n\nUnited States of America,\n\n_y_\n20-CR-330 (AJN)\nGhislaine Maxwell,\nMEMORANDUM\n\nDefendant. OPINION & ORDER\n\nALISON J. NATHAN, District Judge:\n\nBefore the Court is the Defendant’s fourth motion in limine to “exclude evidence related\nto Accuser-3,” to whom the Court refers as Witness-3, on the grounds that the testimony is not\ndirect evidence of the charged conspiracies and is inadmissible under Federal Rules of Evidence\n404(b) and 403. Dkt. Nos. 387, 444. The Court has twice heard argument related to this motion,\nincluding argument at the November 10, 2021 in camera hearing that was sealed pursuant to\nFederal Rule of Evidence 412. See generally Nov. 1, 2021 Transcript; Nov. 10, 2021 Transcript.\nAt the November 1, 2021 hearing, the Court provided a brief explanation of its current position\nbased on the information then before it, but the Court ultimately reserved ruling pending\nadditional briefing. The Court is now in receipt of the parties’ additional briefing and\naccordingly is prepared to resolve the motion. !\n\nThe Government now proffers that the anticipated testimony of Witness-3 will describe\nhow she met the Defendant and her relationship with the Defendant and Mr. Epstein. In\n\nparticular, Witness-3 is anticipated to testify how Defendant introduced her to Mr. Epstein, how\n\n! This Memorandum Opinion & Order is filed temporarily under seal to permit the parties the opportunity to propose\nsealing or limited redactions pursuant to Lugosch v. Pyramid Co. of Onondaga, 435 F.3d 110 (2d Cir. 2006), and\nFederal Rule of Evidence 412(c)(2).\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011109\n\n", "char_count": 1775}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document690 _ Filed 11/19/21 Page 2 of 23\n\nmassages progressed to involve sexual activity, and Ms. Maxwell’s role in facilitating those\nmassages. Based on all of the information now before the Court, including a substantially more\ndetailed proffer by the Government as to the anticipated testimony, see Gov. Supp. Ltr. at 2-3\n(Nov. 5, 2021); see also Dkt. No. 452 at 42-43, the Court concludes that some of the anticipated\ntestimony may serve as direct evidence of the Mann Act counts.\n\nThe Government rightly acknowledged at the November | pretrial conference that Ms.\nMaxwell cannot be found guilty on this witness’s testimony alone for any of the crimes charged\nin the Indictment. Nov. 1, 2021 Tr. at 67:12-25, 68:13-19, 69:4-9, 70:23-71:2, 72:22-25. As the\nGovernment acknowledged, with respect to the jury’s determination in this case, this witness is\nnot a victim of any of the crimes charged in the Indictment. See id. at 69:4-9; Nov. 10, 2021 Tr.\nat 164:19-165:3.” However, evidence of legal conduct can of course be relevant evidence of\nillegality. And conduct that cannot itself form the basis of a conviction can serve as direct\nevidence of the crimes charged. See, e.g., United States v. Robinson, 702 F.3d 22, 37 (2d Cir.\n2012) (affirming admission of defendant pimp’s relationship with and control over women who\nworked as prostitutes as direct evidence of 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a) charge). Thus some of the\nanticipated testimony described above can serve as direct evidence, notwithstanding the fact that\nthe alleged conduct as to Witness-3 was not illegal for the purpose of the charges in this case.\n\nPortions of the anticipated testimony may also serve permissible purposes under Rule\n404(b), namely proving motive, intent, and knowledge. See Fed. R. Evid. 404(b)(2). The\n\nwitness is expected to testify about certain statements by Ms. Maxwell. For example, the\n\n2 At the November 1 conference, the Court denied the Defendant’s motion to preclude the Government fr\n... [truncated, 2514 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00011109/1 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00011109&page=1]", "char_count": 2514}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document690_ Filed 11/19/21 Page3of23\n\nGoverment expects the witness os:\n\nGov. Supp. Ltr, at 2-3 (Nov. 5, 2021). These statements are relevant because the jury may\nconclude that they tend to establish that the Defendant knew the alleged massages were\n\nsexualized and the Defendant’s motive for facilitating the encounters.\n\na Id. at 3,9. This testimony is relevant because the jury may conclude that it tends to\n\nestablish the Defendant’s intent to recruit girls for sexualized massages. Po\n\nId. at 3. Although it is not the only\n\navailable interpretation of this evidence, the jury could conclude that\n\nSuch knowledge and intent are of course proper purposes under Rule\n\n404(b).3\n\n3 Defendant argues that this witness’s testimony is impermissible propensity evidence as to Mr. Epstein under Rule\n404(b). Def. Supp. Resp. at 5-7 (Nov. 11, 2021). The Court is unpersuaded. The testimony is not offered to show\nthat Mr. Epstein acted in accordance with a certain character trait on a particular occasion. Rather, it is probative of\nwhether Ms. Maxwell knew of or at least believed he had a sexual interest m 6=6=—Sesté*@Ri which a jury may find\ntends to establish the Defendant’s intent and motive as to the charged crimes. See Roe v. Howard, 917 F.3d 229,\n245-46 (4\" Cir. 2019) (rejecting argument that husband’s assault of a non-party housekeeper was improper character\nevidence under Rule 404(b) in a Trafficking Victims Protection Act action against the wife for facilitating husband’s\nassaults of live-in housekeeper).\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011111\n\n", "char_count": 1564}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document690_ Filed 11/19/21 Page4of23\n\nThe probative value of the anticipated testimony must of course be balanced with any\npotential prejudice under Rule 403. As the Court noted at the November 1 conference, there is a\nrisk that the jury may confuse the issues and think that the sexual conduct this witness is\ndescribing itself constitutes the illegality charged in the Indictment due to the closeness in age of\nthis witness to the age of consent. Nov. 1, 2021 Tr. at 89-90. There is also the risk that the jury\nmay convict Ms. Maxwell due to feelings of immorality or sympathy for the witness despite the\nlack of illegality with regard to the crimes charged in the Indictment. However, the Court\nconcludes that this risk of prejudice can be sufficiently minimized through two avenues. First,\nthe testimony must be carefully limited. Second, there must be a clear limiting instruction.\n\nAs to the first, the witness is limited to stating that sexual activity occurred but is\nprecluded from providing detailed descriptions of the sexual activity. There is little to no\nprobative value of a witness describing sexual activity when that witness’s testimony regarding\nthe sexual activity cannot form the basis for the conviction of the crimes charged. For example,\nany prejudice ion iii described above is substantially diminished\nby limiting the proffered testimony to the Defendant’s interaction with the witness and testimony\nindicating that sexual activity allegedly took place without describing the details of that sexual\nactivity. Unlike the details of the sexual conduct itself, this anticipated testimony would not be\nunduly prejudicial. In contrast, the minimal probative value of the details of sexual conduct\nwould be substantially outweighed by the risk of the jury convicting Ms. Maxwell on an\nimproper basis. The same is true of the witness’s subjective experience of the sexual conduct\nand any emotional or other impact the sexual conduct had on the witness becau\n... [truncated, 2225 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00011109/3 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00011109&page=3]", "char_count": 2225}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document690_ Filed 11/19/21 Page5of23\n\ndescribed above. See Gov. Supp. Ltr. at 12 (Nov. 5, 2021). For example, in a recent murder\ntrial, the Court permitted the nephew of the victim to describe his uncle’s wounds because the\nnephew, who had served as a caretaker, had some information that was not cumulative of the\nmedical records. The Court expressly cautioned the Government that it would not permit\nemotional testimony, or the probative value would be outweighed by the prejudice:\n\n[I]t's clearly a 403 line here. You have cumulativeness with the medical testimony, you\n\nhave graphic descriptions from a relative who cared for the victim which could very well\n\nproduce sympathies and prejudice that would interfere with and overcome the medical\nfacts that you need for purposes of proving causation. .. . | am certainly going to cut off\nthe line at any graphic descriptions. To the extent that walking this person through\nquestions regarding the medical condition is emotional testimony, I think we are — it will\nhave to be stopped.\nUnited States v. Berry, No. 20 Cr. 84 (AJN), Dkt. No. 138 at 13; see also id. at 15. In that case,\nthe Government agreed that the line had to be carefully guarded. /d. at 13-14. The transcript of\nthat ruling is attached for counsel’s reference. See Exhibit A. The Court cautions the\nGovernment to proceed carefully because the Court will not allow testimony that steps over this\n403 line. The Court will allow some leading questions for this portion of the testimony to help\nensure that it does not.\n\nFinally, the Court concludes that this witness’s anticipated testimony as to the sex\ntrafficking counts is inadmissible. Although the Government’s letter points to some relevant\ndirect evidence that this witness could provide regarding these counts, see Gov. Supp. Ltr. at 6-7,\nany minimal probative value of this evidence is diminished by its remoteness in time to the\ncharged sex trafficking conspiracy, which is alleged to have run from\n... [truncated, 2327 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00011109/4 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00011109&page=4]", "char_count": 2327}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document690 _ Filed 11/19/21 Page6of23\n\nthis evidence as to the sex trafficking counts, the witness is precluded from testifying that [i\n\nThe Court thus draws the line described above for limiting Witness-3’s testimony.\nPermitting the entirety of the proffered testimony carries a risk that the jury may convict Ms.\nMaxwell due to conduct that cannot form the basis of a conviction for the charged crimes. But\nby limiting the testimony to the few categories of relevant testimony outlined above, the\nprejudice is substantially minimized.\n\nMoreover, whether as direct evidence of the Mann Act counts or offered for a proper\npurpose under 404(b), this testimony must be paired with a proper limiting instruction to guard\nagainst potential juror confusion. The Defense has submitted proposed limiting instructions, and\nthe Government agrees that some sort of instruction is appropriate, although it disagrees with the\nbasis for the instruction. Dkt. No. 452 at 50 n.12; Gov. Supp. Ltr. at 12 (Nov. 5, 2021). In\naccordance with this ruling, the Court proposes the following instruction before this anticipated\nwitness testifies:\n\nYou will hear testimony from the next witness about interactions that she says she had\n\nwith the Defendant and Mr. Epstein. I instruct you that because the witness was over the\n\nrelevant age of consent at the relevant time period, any sexual conduct she says occurred\nwith Mr. Epstein was not “illegal sexual activity” as the Government has charged in the\n\nIndictment. I instruct you that this witness is not a victim of the crimes charged in the\n\nIndictment. To the extent you conclude that her testimony is relevant to the issues before\n\nyou, you may consider it. However, you may not convict the Defendant on the basis of\n\nthe testimony regarding the sexual conduct between this witness and Mr. Epstein. Nor\nmay you consider this testimony as any kind of reflection on Mr. Epstein’s nor Ms.\n\nMaxwell’s character or propensity to commit any of the c\n... [truncated, 2483 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00011109/5 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00011109&page=5]", "char_count": 2483}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document690_ Filed 11/19/21 Page /7 of 23\n\njurisdiction, e.g. New Mexico] at the relevant time period, the sexual conduct she says\noccurred with Mr. Epstein was not “illegal sexual activity” as the Government has\ncharged in the Indictment. However, to the extent you conclude that her testimony is\nrelevant to the issues before you, you may consider it. However, you may not consider\nthis testimony as any kind of reflection on Mr. Epstein’s nor Ms. Maxwell’s character or\npropensity to commit any of the crimes charged in the Indictment.\n\nThe parties may submit any requested edits to the proposed limiting instructions that are\n\nconsistent with the Court’s ruling or indicate that they have none on or before November 21,\n\n2021.\n\nThis resolves Dkt. Nos. 387, 444.\n\nSO ORDERED.\n\nDated: November 19, 2021 AN \\) if\n\nNew York, New York\n\nALISON J. NATHAN\nUnited States District Judge\n\nDOJ-OGR-O00011115\n", "char_count": 923}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Caédast: 2@2OroCRRIsPAGN Demumesnitass Ariéelinyon21 Padtage 6fdie3 1\n\nL9L5ber1\n1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\n2 x\n3 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, New York, N.Y.\n4 Vv. 20 Cr. 84 (AJN)\n5 RALPH BERRY,\n6 Defendant.\n7 x\n8 September 21, 2021\n9:45 a.m.\n9\n10 Before:\n11 HON. ALISON J. NATHAN,\n12 U.S. District Judge\nAnd A Jury\n13\nAPPEARANCES\n14\nAUDREY STRAUSS\n15 United States Attorney for the\nSouthern District of New York\n16 BY s JACOB R. FIDDELMAN\nDOMINIC A. GENTILE\n17 ADAM HOBSON\nAssistant United States Attorneys\n18\nLAW OFFICE OF MARK S. DEMARCO\n19 Attorneys for Defendant\nBY: MARK DeMARCO\n20 —AND-—\nLAW OFFICES OF EZRA SPILKE, PLLC\n21 BY: EZRA SPILKE\n22\n23\n24\n25\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011116\n\n", "char_count": 757}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaédast: 2@2OroCRRsPAGN Dumumesnitass Ariéelinyoe21 PatpgA ofdie3 2\nL9L5ber1\n\nthe\n\n(Case called)\n\nBE\n\nTHE D\n\nBy\n\niPUTY CLERK: Counsel, please state your name for\n\nrecord, starting with the government.\n\nMR. HOBSON: Good morning, your Honor. Adam Hobson,\n\nJacob Fiddelman,\n\nMr.\n\nwasn't bro\n\nas a matter oi\n\nforward.\n\nTH\n\nFA\n\nFor the\n\nand Dominic Gentile for the government.\n\nCOURT: Good morning.\n\ndefendant?\n\nMR. DeMARCO: Good morning. For Mr. Berry, Mark\n\nDeMarco and Ezra\n\nBerry.\n\nTH\n\nPA\n\nSpilke, Ms. Mayerlin Ulerio, and of course\n\nCOURT: Good morning, counsel.\n\nGood morning, Mr. Berry.\n\nTHE DEF\n\nENDANT: Good morning.\n\nTHE COU\n\nI thank\n\nRT: I had hoped to start at 9:00 but Mr. Berry\n\nught until now. Hopefully that won't repeat going\n\nWe will make sure that things are in place to prevent\n\nthat so we can timely get started each day.\n\neveryone for being here on time. Let me ask,\n\nfF procedure, we will wait for the jury department\n\nto let us know when the panel is checked in and assembled and\n\nin their seats,\n\njury selection.\n\nnoted change,\n\ncon\n\nand then can head over to 500 Pearl to commence\n\nMy purpose for today is to confirm the receipt\n\nof the voir dire questionnaire that I sent yesterday with the\n\nmake sure everybody got that. The second is to\n\nfirm that there have been no additional plea offers. And\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011117\n\n", "char_count": 1510}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "ay\n\nCaGase2020-08880d44AR)JN Docounen6983s_ Filed 10/06/21 PBRggS id 6623 3\n\nL9OL5berl\n\nmake sure there ar\n\nlastly, I made the note,\n\nNO\n\nregarding jury selection now that you have been to\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nno questions\n\nthe\n\nwalk-through in the jury selection room where selection will\n\ntake place.\n\nSo, let me ask, everybody received\n\nthe noted changes?\n\nthe voir dire with\n\nHobson?\n\nand nothing additional.\n\nI need to allocute on?\n\nfers have been\n\nMR. HOBSON: Yes, your Honor. We did.\nTHE COURT: Nothing additional, Mr.\nMR. HOBSON: Nothing additional.\n\nMR. DeMARCO: Yes, your Honor;\n\nTHE COURT: Thank you.\n\nAny additional plea offers that\n\nMR. HOBSON: No additional plea of\n\nHonor.\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nxtended, your\n\nTHE COURT: OK.\n\nhas any questions about jury selections.\n\n[ will\n\nprocess,\n\njurors and three alternates, 10 peremptories\n\npanel for the defense, six peremptories\n\nperemptory per side with respect to th\n\nAnd then let me confirm if\n\nalternates.\n\nanybody\n\nTo repeat the basic\n\nqualify 33 potential jurors that represents 12\n\nas to the main\n\nfor the government, one\n\nAnd the\n\nway that we are operating under the COVID protocols,\n\ndepartment will, after the jury panel member\n\nthat the jury department generates, they wil\n\nnumerical order in\n\nthe jury selection room.\n\nthey'll be randomly assigned a number consistent with a list\n\nthe jury\n\ns are checked in,\n\n1 be seated in that\n\nTI understand 1\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTRICT REPORTERS,\n(212) 805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011118\n\n", "char_count": 1550}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaGase2N20-08880d44R)JN Docounsen69838_ Filed 10/06/21 PBRggeé bf 6623 4\n\nL9L5ber1\nthrough 42 will be in the main jury select\nthrough, I believe 82 we will get the\n\ntion room and then 43\n\nsee what the return on the summons is\n\ncourtroom 9\n\nC also at 500\n\nPearl,\n\n—-- wil\n\nwith a live\n\nfinal number once we\n\n1 be seated in\n\nfeed to 9C of\n\neverything taking place in the jury assembly room.\n\nseen after\nwill be sea\nremarks, th\nalong with\n\nassembly ro\n\nwill instruct the jurors not\n\nyou and I ente\n\nted at that po\n\nr the courtroom.\n\nint.\n\nI will make preliminary instructions which you have\n\nThe panel members\n\nI will make my preliminary\n\ne written questionnaire that the jurors can read\n\nwill be handed out at that point,\n\nom and in 9C 8s\n\nquestionnaire with the excepti\n\nhave a \"yes\" response to that\n\nquestionnal\n\nSo\n\nre.\n\n, at that poin\n\nimultaneously through court sta\n\nt I will\n\nboth in the jury\n\nto write anything on the\n\non of circling a number if they\n\nquestion as\n\nI read through the\n\nturn to panel member juror\n\nno. 1 and go through and read the questionnaire getting \"yes\"\n\nor \"no\" response to each question.\n\ntouched upo\n\nfollowing up as appropriate.\n\nTo the ex\n\nthe answer is \"yes\"\n\ntent that the matters\n\nn could influence other jurors or are of a sensitive\n\nnature, we will bring that juror over to the plexiglass area to\n\nmy right in\n\nfloor where\n\nthat others\n\ntO any nece\n\ncannot hear,\n\nthe jury assembly room,\n\nthere is markings on the\n\nfolks stand and the noise machine will be on so\n\nssary follow-up.\n\nand I will inguire with the juror as\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011119\n\n", "char_count": 1746}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaGase2N20-08880d44R)JN Docounen6988_ Filed 10/06/21 PBRggéLt 623 5\nL9L5ber1\n\nOnce we get through, assuming we get through juror\n\nno. 1 without any for-cause issues, I will turn to juror no. 2\nand say do you have any \"yes\" responses? And then we will take\n\nthose in order as they come.\n\nIf any juror needs to be dismissed for cause, let's\n\nSay juror no. 2 needs to be dismissed for cause, then we will\nproceed with the same process with juror no. 3. Any \"yes\"\n\nquestions, taking those one at a time, continuing until we have\n\n33 qualified jurors.\n\nOnce we have 33 qualified jurors you will exercise\n\nyour peremptory strikes by list and simultaneously, that is,\n\neach side will produce a list with the government's six strikes\n\nas to the main panel and one strike as to the alternate panel,\n\nand the defense will write its list with 10 strikes as to the\n\nmain panel and one strike as to the alternate panel.\n\nObviously, before anyone is dismissed, I will hear from counsel\n\nif any applications or issues need to be raised if you are\n\nsatisfied with our jury. Once we get there we will read the\n\nnames of the selected jurors, dismiss to the jury department\n\nthe unused jurors, and then proceed over back across the street\n\nover here. I believe what we will do is have Ms. Williams take\n\nthe jurors to the jury room, which is an outfitted courtroom so\n\nthey can put their belongings down, she can give them notebook\n\nand pen, bring them back in. At that point she will swear the\n\njury and I will give preliminary instructions and opening\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011120\n", "char_count": 1718}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaGase2N20-0888044AR)JN Docounsen69838 Filed 10/06/21 PBRggé 18 6623 6\n\nL9OL5berl\n\nstatements.\n\nsee. Hopefu\n\nAny questions or issues to raise with the process\n\nhave describ\n\nMR.\n\nvoir dire.\n\nOne thing\n\nWhether that happens today or tomorrow we will\n\nlly today.\n\ned? Mr.\n\nHOBSON:\n\nWe submitted a\n\nHobson?\n\nYour Honor, no. One small thing on the\n\nlist of names for the Court to read.\n\nI wanted to flag for the Court is one of the\n\nwitnesses' names we asked you to include is Jesus Ortiz, and\n\nthe jury.\n\nELE,\n\nCOURT:\n\nLet me see\n\npronunciation issues.\n\nMr.\nquestions or\n\nMR.\n\nTH\n\nPA\n\nyour mask on\n\nDeMarco\n\nthat's how he pronounces his name, with a hard J. I want to\n\nflag that for the Court so that his name is read accurately to\n\nif there are any other\n\n, while I am pulling that up, any other\n\nissues with respect to the process?\n\nDeMARCO\n\nCOURT:\n\n: No, your Honor.\n\nAnd, Mr. DeMarco, you are going to keep\n\nso I don't have to keep coming at you about it?\n\nMR. DeMARCO: I will do my best.\n\nTHE COURT: OK. Don't take it off to talk.\n\nMR. DeMARCO: Sorry?\n\nTHE COURT: Don't take it off to talk.\n\nMR. DeMARCO: OK. I took it off to listen the last\ntime.\n\nTHE COURT: That's an anatomical anomaly.\n\nSOUTH\n\nBERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011121\n\n", "char_count": 1383}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaGase2ND20-00880d44R)JN Docounsen6988_ Filed 10/06/21 PBggd bt 6623 7\n\nL9OL5berl\n\nshould say, of course, o\n\nnce we are in the courtroom\n\nthen counsel in the plexiglass box with the HEPA filter will be\n\nable to remove their mask for quest\n\nioning, and to the extent\n\noutside of the jury we have argument or the like, we can do\n\nthat in there to aid that that process.\n\nSchneider who may be\n\nUlerio, Mayerlin,\n\nOF\n\nIt's Ms.\nMS. ULER\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\nAnd you have a\n\nhere?\n\nMR. DeMARCO: Yes, your Ho\n\nin court.\n\nLHE COURT\n\nMr. Schneider.\n\nin case.\n\nAnd what about\n\nam I saying that correctly?\n\nnother paralegal Dylan\n\nnor, but he won't be with us\n\nJeremy Schneider?\n\nto be with us.\n\nMR. DeMARCO: He is unable\nTHE COURT: He won't be at\nMR. DeMARCO: No. I don't\nTHE COURT: Should I inclu\n\nMR. DeMARCO:\n\nname might come\n\nwhat scenario.\n\nto be sai\n\nfor purposes of\n\nup and I just can't\n\nI think you\n\njust to be saf\n\ntrial at any point?\nexpect him to be here.\n\nde him in the voir dire just\n\nshould, Judge, because his\nsee how or where or under\n\nCs\n\nHis name is on the stipulations, so maybe\n\nBut,\nMR. HOBSON:\nfe.\nTHE COURT:\n\nSOUTH\n\nJust to note,\n\nthe voir dire, and\n\nwhen I do introduce counsel\n\nMr. Berry, and the\n\nBRN DISTRICT RE\n\nPORTERS, PwC.\n\n(212) 805-\n\n0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011122\n\n", "char_count": 1398}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "CaGase2D.2-08880d4ARJN Docoureen698s Filed 10/06/21 PRgg81s 0623\n\n8\n\nL9LSberl\n\n1 paralegals, I will ask each of you to stand as say your name\n2 so that the jurors can see you, the panelists can see you. So,\n3 I will note Mr. Schneider is part of the team but not present\n\n4 today and may not be present every day of the trial.\n\n5 Appropriate, Mr. DeMarco?\n\n6 MR. DeMARCO: Yes, Judge.\n\n7 THE COURT: OK. So Jesus Ortiz is the pronunciation.\n8 How about, Mr. Hobson, how do I pronounce no. Q?\n\n9 MR. HOBSON: I believe, your Honor, it is Vyacheslav,\n10 and the last name is Polosin.\n\n11 THE COURT: Vyacheslav Polosin. OK.\n\n12 Special Agent Stefano Braccini?\n\n13 MR. HOBSON: And he is in the courtroom.\n\n14 THE COURT: OK. I think that's it. Other issues to\n15 take up?\n\n16 MR. HOBSON: I don't think so, your Honor.\n\n17 THE COURT: Mr. DeMarco?\n\n18 MR. DeMARCO: No, your Honor. Not now.\n\n19 Judge, how much time do we have before we walk over?\n20 Maybe we could use this time efficiently, because I do have --\n21 raised with the government an issue I was going to raise with\n22 their first witness so you tell me.\n23 THE COURT: [ was told around between 10:00 and 10:30\n24 but we won't know until they actually call over so I'm happy to\n25 use the time and if we get the call, we will pause.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011123\n", "char_count": 1355}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "CaGase2020-08880044R)JN Docounsen6988 Filed 10/06/21 PBRgg@ 1s 6623 9\n\nL9LSberl\n\n1 MR. DeMARCO: OK.\n\n2 THE COURT: Was it an issue you wanted to speak to the\n3 government about first?\n\n4 MR. DeMARCO: I did consult with the government.\n\n5 was unpersuasive. I was hoping to be more successful with your\n6 Honor.\n\n7 THE COURT: OK. And the first witness is?\n\n8 MR. DeMARCO: Mr. Rasheen Vega.\n\n9 THE COURT: Go ahead. And if you could speak into the\n10 mic, please?\n11 MR. DeMARCO: It seems to me, your Honor, from my\n12 reading of the 3500 material, that we can expect Mr. Vega to\n\n13 testify to something like this: That he was the nephew of\n\n14 Mr. Jones, that he was 11 years old at the time that Mr. Jones\n15 was shot in June of 2000, that he witnessed a portion of that\n16 shooting or the aftermath of that shooting which I am OK with.\n17 The problem that I have with his prospective testimony is this:\n18 It also appears from reading the 3500 that the government will\n19 seek to elicit from Mr. Vega testimony about the horrific,\n20 horrific bedsores or compression sores that Mr. Jones was\n21 suffering from at the time of his death. I believe there is at\n22 least notes that Mr. Vega observed the sores to be oozing,\n23 observed Mr. Jones to be in terrible, terrible pain and\n24 suffering at or near the time of his death, and my concern is\n25 that, A, in light of the fact that two doctors are being called\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011124\n", "char_count": 1478}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaédast:2@2OrocRRsP AGN Domuwimenitase Arde inyo271 Pdtpgbdlefdie3\n\nL9OL5berl\n\nby the government and, even apart\n\nfrom that,\n\nMr\n\n10\n\n. Vega is not\n\nqualified to testify about the injuries that he observed; and\nB, that this type of testimony serves no purpose but to elicit\nor garner sympathy from the jury and will be unduly prejudicial\nto Mr. Berry.\n\nSo, that's the basis of my objection to Mr. Vega,\nshould he be asked those types of questions.\n\nTHE COURT: Understood.\n\nMr. Hobson?\n\nMR. HOBSON: Your Honor, there are two large topics\nthat Mr. Vega is anticipated to testify about. [ think it is\nconsistent with what Mr. DeMarco says is, one, he was a\npercipient witness to the shooting itself; and two, he observed\n\nthe victim's\n\nvictim's death.\n\nde\n\nfendant is objecting to.\nobviously a big issue in this case\n\nthat the\n\ninjuries after the shoot\n\nthe victim's care in the 10 years bet\n\nBut here,\n\nCause Ol!\n\nand it is something\n\nting and was involved in\ntween the shooting and the\nI take it it is the second category that the\n\nF death is\n\nthat it\n\nFrom\n\nis our burden to prove,\n\nlead to his death.\n\na result of the shooting,\n\nwaist down and that meant\n\nwhereas h\n\nwheelchair\n\ndev\n\ninjuries\n\nAnd we expect th\n\nthat he was cont\n\ne evidence\n\nthe victim became paralyzed\n\nto show\n\nthe shooting\n\nthat, as\n\nfrom the\n\nFined to a\n\nwas not in a wheelchair before -- and\n\nloped serious complications as a result of\n\nthat including\n\nthe victim's\n\nserious sores which later led to infection and\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011125\n", "char_count": 1669}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaédast: 2@2OrOCRMBRPAGN Demuientase Ariéelinyon241 Patppblefdie@3 11\nL9OL5berl\n\ndeath.\n\nWe will not be eliciting expert medical testimony or\n\nopinion from this witness, he will be simply testifying to what\nhe observed with respect to the victim's physical condition\n\nduring the 10 intervening years between the shooting and the\n\ndeath and that's important evidence, it's evidence that will\n\nthen be consistent with things that medical experts to be\n\nqualified as experts will be called to testify about, but those\n\nexperts did not observe these injuries during the 10\nintervening years. They also did not observe Mr. Jones prior\n\nto the shooting. For instance, they wouldn't be able to tell\n\nyou whether he was in a wheelchair before the shooting or after\n\nthe shooting. They wouldn't be able to tell you if he\n\ndeveloped those bedsores before the shooting or after the\n\nshooting. It is Mr. Vega's observations that will allow the\njury to connect those dots. Given how important causation is\nin this case, we think it is important that the jury understand\n\nthose injuries.\n\nTHE COURT: Will medical records, that will be\n\nintroduced, describe the bedsores?\n\nMR. HOBSON: They will describe the bedsores at the\n\ntime of the autopsy which was in November of 2010.\n\nTHE COURT: What is the connection between bedsores\n\nand cause of death? Infection?\n\nMR. HOBSON: Your Honor, essentially what I expect the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011126\n", "char_count": 1583}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaédast:2@2OrocRRsP AGN Demuwimesnitass Arde inyo271 Pdtpgb2.efdie3\n\nL9OL5berl\n\ntes\n\nOL\n\nthe victim.\n\nbedsores or pressur\n\ntimony will be\n\nthe gunsho\n\nSo\n\nres\n\nbody;\n\ncollapsed rectum,\n\nto infections and that in this particular case it\n\ncomplications of\n\nsepsis and that it\n\nkilled Mr.\n\nMR.\n\naide\n\ntp\n\nG\n\nGo\n\nMR.\n\na per\n\nthe pa\n\nJones.\n\nDeMARCO:\n\nCOURT: Su\n\nDeMARCO:\n\n12\n\nfrom the medical experts is that as a result\nt wound, that caused paralysis and paraplegia in\nParaplegia commonly leads to things such as\n\nfrom not being able to move one's\n\nalso other conditions such as a colostomy bag, a\n\nall of which can lead\n\nmanent catheter,\n\nwas the\n\nraplegia that led into in\n\nYour Honor,\n\nfections or\n\nwas the sepsis that ultimately,\n\nif\n\nie »\n\nwere disclosed it's more than that.\n\nwounds,\n\nhe describes a horrii\n\nas the smell of death 1\n\nn Mr. Jones\n\ns facts like these that\n\ntime of his death. It'\non.\nTHE COURT: Ye\nMR. DeMARCO:\n\nparaplegic and he was in a wheel\n\nabout the graphic description of\n\nsores,\n\nMR. HOBSON: Y\n\nSs\n\nFic odor,\n\nIn my reading of\n\nHe\n\nin 2010,\n\n[ may?\n\nthe 3500 notes that\ndescribes oozing-type\n\nthink he described it\n\napartment at or near the\n\nThe paraplegia,\n\nfrom the medical examiners will establish\n\nchair.\n\nam focusing\n\nthe medical testimony\n\nthat Mr. Jones was a\n\nBut, my concern is\n\nour Honor,\n\nwe are certainly cognizant of\n\nthe bedsores,\n\nthe compression\n\nand also the horrific odor witnessed by Mr. Vega.\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nDISTR\n\nCT R\n\nG\n\nPORT\n\nBRS, Pes\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011127\n\n", "char_count": 1631}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nI\n=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaédast:2@2OroCRRsP AGN Demuwmesnitass Arde inyo271 PdtageVordie3\n\nL9OL5berl\n\nnot crossing the 403 lin\nthe jury understand the nature of\n\ncould lead to his death and what\n\nintervening\n\ntime betw\n\nher W.\n\nthink it\n\nn th\n\nlooking\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nYou have cumulativeness with the medical\n\ngraphic descriptions\n\nCOURT:\n\nYes.\n\nWell, i\n\nwhich could very well\n\nproduce sympathies and prejudice\n\nwould interfere with and overcom\n\nneed\n\nfor purposes of\n\nwitness is\n\nexactly\nwitness but\n\ngraphic\n\nthrough\n\ntestimony,\n\nSo,\n\nand\n\ntesti\n\nfying\n\nis\n\n13\n\nimportant that\n\nthese injuries and how they\n\nshooting and the autopsy.\n\nWe\n\nto be gratuitous or to pile on here.\n\nthe injuries were during the\n\nare\n\nt's clearly a 403 line here.\n\nfrom a relative who cared\n\nthe medical\n\nproving causation.\n\nfirst it's d\n\nwhat additional\n\nfacts you\n\nSo,\n\nifficult for\n\nl testimony,\n\nfor the vict\n\nyou have\n\ntim\n\ntha\n\nbecause this\n\nme to know\n\nneed to extract\n\nam certainly going to cut o\n\ndescriptions.\n\nfrom the\n\nfacts that you\n\nthe line at any\n\nTo the extent that walking this person\n\nFic\n\nspeci\n\nFactual quest\n\nI'm going to allow a little bit of\n\ntions you believe\n\nleading\n\nI think we are -- it will have to be stopped.\n\nto ask the\n\nquestions regarding the medical condition is emotional\n\nI think what you need to think about is what --\n\nthat you need and that\n\nare not cumulative with the medical testimony, but I'm going to\nguard this line very carefully, and you should too.\n\nMR. HOBSON: Your Honor, I understand that. I will\nsay that in meeting with this witness we have tried to follow\nthat line and I am -—- with the ability to maybe construct some\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212%) 805-0220\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011128\n", "char_count": 1804}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Cast: 22OrOCkMBP AEN DonumentGss Ate INIOR2 PateyePofdies 14\n\nL9LSberl\n\n1 of my questions in a leading way, I will hope to enforce that\n2 line. It is, again, certainly not our intention to be\n\n3 gratuitous but to simply get in the nature of the injuries and\n4 their relationship.\n\n5 THE COURT: You don't have pre-autopsy medical records\n6 that you are putting in that describes these injuries?\n\n7 MR. HOBSON: No, your Honor.\n\n8 MR. DeMARCO: I'm sorry. What was that? Pre?\n\n9 THE COURT: No. I asked if there wer\n\n10 MR. DeMARCO: I misunderstood your question, Judge.\n1] I'm sorry.\n\n12 THE COURT: I asked if there were pre-autopsy medical\n13 records that describes these infections and injuries and the\n14 answer is no.\n\n15 MR. DeMARCO: The government has disclosed, pursuant\n16 to Rule 16, some of these records that your Honor references,\n17 SO.\n\n18 MR. HOBSON: Your Honor's question was I think if we\n19 are introducing them. There are voluminous medical records\n20 that are almost incomprehensive to a layperson. We are not\n21 introducing those records.\n22 THE COURT: But you have a medical expert.\n23 MR. HOBSON: We do have a medical expert.\n24 MR. DeMARCO: Your Honor, if I just might add another\n25 fact to this? Based on the exhibit list and the exhibits\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011129\n\n", "char_count": 1330}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCaédest:2@2OrocRRsP AGN Demuwmenitass Arde inyo271 Pdtpgevetdie3\n\nL9OL5berl\n\nprovided to us by the government,\n\nintroduce,\n\nbedsores. So,\n\nsufficiently will\n\nsuffering at\n\nMR. HOBSON:\n\nintroducing,\n\nof the bedsores.\n\nsome of\n\nthe bedsores wer\n\nthrough the medical examiner,\nI think that expert testimony,\n\ndescrib\n\nIn fact,\n\nthe government intends to\n\nphotographs of these\n\nby itself\n\n~\n\nthe bedsores that Mr. Jones was\n\nthe time of his death.\n\nTo be clear of what photographs we are\n\nwe are not introducing the most graphic pictures\n\nwe were concerned in introducing\n\nthe pictures\n\nthat\n\nthey wouldn't fully show how serious\n\nbut we are not going to be putting in the\n\nmost graphic pictures.\n\nTHE\n\nsome permission to\n\ninjuries and sores\n\ngoes but am —- I\nthis is non-expert\n\nSo, the prospect o\n\nand I'm not going\n\nMR. HOBSON:\n\naide\n\nma\n\nMR. DeMARCO:\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nCOURT:\n\nfacts that you need that\n\ntestimony and evidence\n\nWhat\n\nam going to allow is you will have\n\nthe\n\nlead with respect to the description of\n\nand extraction of\n\n. It's going to be brief\n\n1s not cumulative with medical\n\nthat's coming in. We will see how it\n\nintend to be extremely cautious given that\n\nmedical testimony coming from a relative.\n\nf prejudice and emotion and sympathy is real\n\nto let it happen.\n\nCOURT:\n\n(Discussion off\n\nYes, your Honor. We understand.\n\nAnything else?\nNo thank you,\n\nyour Honor.\n\nOK. Any word, Ms. Williams?\n\nrecord)\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\n15\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011130\n", "char_count": 1603}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00011109", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCésash: 220r OCR MBP AGN Decunmentass Ariéelivor221 Paétege@eidig3 16\n\nL9OL5berl\n\nTH\n\nthe marshals need time to get\nunless anyone has anything further,\n\nre-assemble across the street\n\nSo\n\nLG!\n\nans)\n\ntf\n\nCOURT:\n\nThey said 15\n\nto 20 minutes so\n\nimagine\n\nMr. Berry across the street. So,\n\none guestion.\n\nto commence trial?\n\nMr.\n\nwe wil\n\nat 500 Pearl.\n\nHobson,\n\nMR. HOBSON: Yes, your Honor.\nTHE COURT: Mr. DeMarco?\n\nMR. DeMARCO: Yes, Judge.\n\nTHE COURT: Thank you.\n\nMR. DeMARCO: Your Honor,\n\nthe jury room?\n\nTH\n\ntb\n\nG\n\npla\n\nCOURT:\n\njury assembly room.\n\nto assist.\n\nThank you.\n\nll break and\n\nThank you.\n\nis the government ready\n\nwe are going to meet over at\n\nWe will meet in the alcove outside the\n\nThere will be jury department staff there\n\n(Jury selection contained under separate cover)\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nLD\n\nDOJ-OGR-00011131\n\n", "char_count": 979}]}