{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_count": 43, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/DOJ-OGR-00008311", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/DOJ-OGR-00008311.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: - Ms. Comey: Female, likely in her 40s or 50s, with short hair, wearing professional attire. - Ms. Sternheim: Female, likely in her 40s or 50s, with short hair, wearing professional attire. - Mr. Pagliuca: Male, likely in his 40s or 50s, with short hair, wearing professional attire. - Ghislaine Maxwell: Female, likely in her 40s or 50s, with short hair, wearing professional attire. | TEXT: ``` (Case called) THE CLERK: Counsel, please state your name for the record, starting with the government. MS. COMEY: Good morning, your Honor. Maureen Comey, Alison Moe, Andrew Rohrbach, and Lara Pomerantz for the government. THE COURT: Good morning, everyone. MS. STERNHEIM: Good morning. Bobbi C. Sternheim, Jeffrey Pagliuca, Christian Everdell, Lara Menninger for Ghislaine Maxwell, who is present at counsel table. THE COURT: Good morning, everyone. MR. PAGLIUCA: Good morning, your Honor. THE COURT: Please be seated. All right, we are here for a final pretrial conference in this matter, jury selection to be completed first thing on Monday morning, the 29th. I did note, counsel, after we had the last process, at the recommendation of the jury department, we have kept the unexcused jurors on -- the unused jurors at this point on call in case we need them, and once we have our jury finally selected on the 29th, the jury department will excuse the remaining jurors. That was one note I wanted to make. For purposes of today's conference, there are a few -- I have tried to give written guidance on as much as I could on the outstanding issues. There are a few remaining issues that ``` | OBJECTS: - Paper document with typed text. - Courtroom setting with individuals seated at a table. - Microphone or similar device on the table. | SETTING: - Indoor setting, likely a courtroom or legal proceeding room. - The presence of individuals in professional attire suggests a formal legal environment. | ACTIVITY: - A legal proceeding is taking place, specifically a pretrial confere\n... [truncated, 2645 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00008311/0 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00008311&page=0]", "char_count": 2645}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe)\n\na\nan)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nre\n\nAlison Moe,\n\ncord,\n\n(Case called)\n\nTHE CLERK:\n\nDocument 536\n\nCounsel,\n\nFiled 12/10/21 Page2of43 2\n\nplease state your name for the\n\nstarting with the government.\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\ngovernment.\n\nJe\n\nGhislaine Maxwell,\n\nin this matter,\n\nMonday morning,\n\nrey\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nAndrew Rohrbach,\n\nGood morning.\n\nGood morning,\n\nGood morning,\n\nand Lara\n\neveryone.\n\nyour Honor. Maureen Comey,\n\nPomerantz for the\n\nBobbi C. Sternhein,\n\nPagliuca, Christian Everdell, Lara Menninger for\nwho is present at counsel table.\nTHE COURT: Good morning, everyone.\nMR. PAGLIUCA: Good morning, your Honor.\nTHE COURT: Please be seated.\nAll right, we are here for a final pretrial conference\n\nthe last process,\n\nthe 29th.\n\njury selection to be completed first thing on\n\nI did note, counsel, after we had\n\nat the recommendation of the jury department,\n\nwe have kept the unexcused jurors on -- the unused jurors at\n\nthis point on call in cas\n\nju\n\nry finally selected on the 29th,\n\nxXxCUS\n\nma\n\nke.\n\nWw\n\nthe remaining jurors.\n\nFor purposes of\n\nthe outstanding issues.\n\nI have tried to give writ\n\nneed them, and once we have our\n\nthe jury department will\n\nThat was one note I wanted to\n\ntoday's conference, there are a few\n\nten guidance on as much as I could on\n\nThere are a few remaining issues that\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008312\n\n", "char_count": 1502}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 536 Filed 12/10/21 Page 10 of 43 LBNAMAXTps something, and this witness is technically, I believe, a records custodian. He may be of a higher level than your standard records custodian, but his testimony is sort of ancillary to the charges in this indictment. THE COURT: All right. The purpose of me asking the parties to submit a list of entities or addresses that may be mentioned during trial was to capture this sort of issue. It sounds like the government failed to include a financial institution that will be mentioned during trial. I agree. It's too late to go back and redo that, having failed to do so. So I think if you think it's an issue, it's a peremptory. What else? MS. COMEY: No other issues, your Honor, other than the outstanding ones your Honor outlined. THE COURT: OK. Any -- go ahead. MR. PAGLIUCA: Yes. Your Honor, I wanted to talk a little bit about use of impeachment material during trial. I have a concern -- well, what I am proposing is that if we are going to be either impeaching or refreshing recollection of a particular witness, that we be able to do it electronically. I think that that would be fine, and that's typically how we would do this. The problem with using impeachment material during the course of ``` | OBJECTS: - A piece of paper with text - A pen (partially visible) - A court setting with a judge and attorneys | SETTING: - An indoor setting, likely a courtroom - The presence of legal documents and a pen indicates a formal legal proceeding | ACTIVITY: - A legal proceeding is taking place, with a judge addressing attorneys and discussing the inclusion of certain entities or addresses in the trial list. There is also a discussion about the use of impeachment material during the trial. | NOTABLE: - The document is from a case with the case number 1:20-cr-00330-PAE. - The date of filing is December 10, 2021. - The page number is 10 out of \n... [truncated, 2322 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00008311/2 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00008311&page=2]", "char_count": 2322}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 536 Filed 12/10/21 Page 14 of 43 LBNAMAXTps displaying -- we don't have to be approaching the witness and we can move seamlessly through this. These are all documents that are in the government' possession to begin with, your Honor. These are not things that are unknown at this point. THE COURT: Again, that seems off topic. But -- so it's manageable to give the government paper. MR. PAGLIUCA: It should be. THE COURT: Any reason you can't -- how about this. Prepare it as a binder for potential use, even if it's not the full document, but anything that you might use -- that you think you might use. As you know, it's a known quantity. You have it in a binder and you could direct them to turn to it. If it turns out there's something that you do want to show that you didn't put in the binder, we'll deal with that and you'll be able to show it, either by turning off the counsel screens and showing it on the monitor or we'll hand up paper at that point. MR. PAGLIUCA: I think there is going to be a real problem, your Honor, to do it like that. It just -- THE COURT: Help me understand this as a practical matter. You will have your outline for your cross, and you're going to know enough to tell your paralegal, Put up document number so-and-so, page 7. And that's how your paralegal is going to pull that up and put it on the screen, right? Why ``` | OBJECTS: The image contains text, but no physical objects are visible. | SETTING: The setting appears to be a courtroom or legal proceeding, as indicated by the presence of a judge and the formal language used in the text. | ACTIVITY: The activity depicted is a legal discussion or argument, likely related to a court case, as suggested by the references to documents, the judge, and the attorney. | NOTABLE: The text mentions a case number (1:20-cr-00330-PAE), a document number (536), and a date (12/10/21), indicating that this is a\n... [truncated, 2133 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00008311/3 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00008311&page=3]", "char_count": 2133}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` can't you just have put that in a binder, a paper binder, in advance? And as I said, if there's something that comes up or you realize you neglected to put it in, we could deal with that. But by and large, you're directing them to a tab in a binder, just like you would direct your paralegal to show a particular document on the screen. What am I missing? MR. PAGLIUCA: Well, we can try that, your Honor. And we'll see how it goes. I mean, we'll be prepared to do it both ways. THE COURT: And I assure you, if for some reason there's something you want to show that's not in the binder, we will work that out and you won't be precluded from showing it. But to the extent you've prepared your cross outline and you know what you're going to ask about, just like you would call it up, just have that in a tabbed binder so they can turn to it. And, again, to be completely clear, should there be anything you need to do that wasn't in the binder, you'll be able to do it and we'll either hand up paper in those few instances or we'll turn off the table monitors and show it on the screen. MR. PAGLIUCA: OK, your Honor. Thank you. THE COURT: Thank you. What else? No? OK. ``` | OBJECTS: The image contains text, but no physical objects are visible. | SETTING: The setting appears to be a courtroom or legal proceeding, as indicated by the presence of a judge and the formal language used. | ACTIVITY: The activity depicted is a legal discussion or hearing, likely related to a court case, where the judge and attorney are discussing the use of binders and documents during the trial. | NOTABLE: The conversation involves the preparation and presentation of evidence, specifically documents, in a legal context. The judge is providing guidance on how to handle certain situations that may arise during the trial.", "char_count": 1880}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` So defense seeks to preclude, in motion in limine 7, Government Exhibit 52. I'm not going to preclude, but I do think this needs to play out at trial. I need to hear the witness testimony and I'll allow voir dire, given factually what I understand to be the issues surrounding this item, and as I understand it -- the witness is going to -- tell me if I have this wrong. The anticipated testimony, Ms. Comey -- this is for you, Ms. Comey -- the anticipated testimony is that not this exact book but a similar-looking book, characteristically similar, binding, pages, font, etc., was seen by this witness, and she can attempt to authenticate by describing the similarities between what is Government Exhibit 52 and what she saw. Is that the idea? MS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor. Because this witness has not been informed about how that exhibit came into the government's possession, I just wanted to clarify one small thing, which is that this witness won't say that this isn't one of the -- you know, in particular, that because she recognizes it as one in a series, but doesn't know how it came to the government's possession, it's just identifying it in that way. THE COURT: So your understanding is, by the time frame, this wouldn't have been the one that she saw, but she won't know that because you anticipate her testimony to be there were several versions of these and they are all the same. MS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor. ``` | OBJECTS: There are no significant objects present in the image. | SETTING: The setting appears to be a courtroom or legal proceeding, indicated by the presence of a judge and the formal language used. | ACTIVITY: The activity depicted is a legal discussion or hearing, specifically regarding the admissibility of Government Exhibit 52 and the witness's testimony related to it. | NOTABLE: The image does not contain any unusual or concerning elements. It appears to be a standard\n... [truncated, 2088 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00008311/5 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00008311&page=5]", "char_count": 2088}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` THE COURT: So I will allow -- I don't know if it's admissible. I think, from what I see, it's a close question. It's going to turn on the testimony. So I'll allow that testimony to take place. I'll allow voir dire. And then I'll make a ruling, depending on how that goes, as to whether it meets the threshold for admissibility, and the questions that have been raised go to weight. But as I sit here, I don't know until I hear that testimony. I do think that the government needs to make it available for inspection to the defense, and so you'll work out the logistics of that pretrial. To the extent that they want a forensic expert to look at it, a document forensic expert to look at it, you'll work out the logistics to make it available. OK? MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. THE COURT: Any questions about that? MR. PAGLIUCA: No, your Honor, other than one of my requests was that the actual document be here at trial and not a photocopy of one page. MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. The actual exhibit will be here in the courtroom at trial. And we have already made that exhibit available for the defense for inspection. They have personally inspected it, I believe that was on November 1st. THE COURT: Great. I'm happy to hear that. And not just the page but the whole book. ``` | OBJECTS: - A piece of paper with typed text - A court setting with a judge and attorneys | SETTING: - An indoor setting, likely a courtroom, given the presence of a judge and attorneys. | ACTIVITY: - A legal proceeding where a judge is discussing the admissibility of evidence and the logistics of its availability for inspection by the defense. | NOTABLE: - The judge mentions the need for the actual document to be available at trial rather than a photocopy. - The defense attorney, Ms. Moe, confirms that the actual exhibit has been made available for inspection. - The judge expresses satisfaction with the arrangement.", "char_count": 1971}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 536 Filed 12/10/21 Page 18 of 43 LBNAMAXTps MS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor. We made it available for inspection this summer. We notified the defense in a letter that it was available for inspection. The defense asked for an inspection the week before our conference on November 1st. I made it available for inspection that day. They personally inspected it. We're happy to continue to make that available for inspection to the defense. THE COURT: I'm very happy to hear that. Thank you. I appreciate that. And I think that takes care of that for now. I guess one question: I think, given the uncertainty as to admission, the government should not mention it in its opening. MS. MOE: Of course, your Honor. Thank you. THE COURT: Anything before we move on? MR. PAGLIUCA: No, your Honor. Thank you. THE COURT: So next is the admissibility of co-conspirator statements. I do appreciate the efforts to come to reasonable agreement, of course, with the defense preserving objections as to ultimate admissibility. Based on the law, of course the government has to make the showing that's required during the course of the trial. There are two statements that are exemplars that remain in issue, and I think, starting with the second one first: so the second one, it seems to me, is not being offered ``` | OBJECTS: The image contains text but no visible objects. | SETTING: The setting appears to be a courtroom or legal proceeding, indicated by the presence of a judge and attorneys. | ACTIVITY: The activity involves a legal discussion between a judge and attorneys regarding the availability of evidence for inspection and the admissibility of co-conspirator statements during a trial. | NOTABLE: The text indicates a legal proceeding with discussions about evidence and the admissibility of statements.", "char_count": 1910}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 536\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nPage9of43 9\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\n1 THE COURT: What do you propose?\n\n2 MS. MOE: Your Honor, I think at a minimum we propose\n3 some additional follow-up guess for the juror about her role,\n4 whether she interfaces with folks dealing with compliance,\n\n5 which is within the scope of what this witness does, whether\n\n6 there would be any issues about hearing testimony about the\n\n7 financial institution where she works.\n\n8 We have not flagged for our witness that there is a\n\n9 juror, of course, who works with the institution, so it's hard\n10 for us to gauge whether they may have overlapped or whether\n\n11 they would recognize one another in the courtroom. So I\n\n12 recognize it would be difficult to probe this issue without\n13 creating an issue, but we think at a minimum a question about\n14 sort of her role and any issues about being fair or discomfort\n15 about witnesses who are testifying from the financial\n16 institution might address this issue.\n17 THE COURT: Who will I hear from?\n18 MS. STERNHEIM: You'll hear from me, Judge.\n19 think it is a little late. The publicly available\n20 information would have revealed that there are other people who\n21 are in that same institution or have been affiliated with that\n22 institution, some of which were excused, and at least one that\n23 is still here. The government can exercise a challenge if it\n24 wishes. But think it's unnecessary. And it flags something\n25 inappropriately at this stage of the game. It will highlight\n\nSOUTH\n\nFERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008319\n", "char_count": 1599}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\na\noO\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page10of43 10\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nsomething, and\n\nrecords custodian.\n\nstandard records custodian,\n\nthis witness is technically,\n\n[ believe, a\n\nHe may be of a higher level than your\n\nancillary to the charges in this indictment.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT: All right.\n\nThe purpose of\n\nat\n\nbut his testimony is sort of\n\nfF me asking the parties to submit a list\n\nentities or addresses that may be mentioned during trial was\nto capture this sort of issue. It sounds like the government\nfailed to include a financial institution that will be\n\nmentioned during trial.\n\nagre\n\nhaving failed t\n\nit\n\ne. It's too late to go back\n\nand redo that,\n\no do so. So I think if you think it's an issue,\n\n\"Ss a peremptory.\n\nWhat e\n\nlse?\n\nMS. COMEY: No other issues, your Honor, other than\n\nthe outstanding ones your Honor outlined.\n\nth\n\nTHE COURT: OK. Any —- go ahead.\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: Yes.\n\nYour Honor,\n\npeachment mat\n\nat I am propo\n\npeaching or r\n\nT wanted to talk a little bit about use of\n\nerial during trial. I have a concern -- well,\n\nSing is that if we are going\n\nat we be able\n\nwould be fine,\n\nproblem with using impeachment material during the course of\n\nto do it electronically.\n\nto be either\n\nefreshing recollection of a particular witness,\n\n[T think that that\n\nand that's typically how we would do this. The\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,\n(212) 805-0300\n\nPG\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008320\n\n", "char_count": 1509}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 536 Filed 12/10/21 Page 21 of 43 LBNAMAXTps would largely be in rebuttal to a government witness. Mr. Flatley was disclosed by the government for similar purposes to talk about the retrieval of metadata from some of the devices that were seized from Epstein's home. To the extent Mr. Flatley talks about the retrieval of metadata or what that metadata means, Mr. Kelso may then be a rebuttal witness, but we don't know yet from the government's disclosure exactly what documents Mr. Flatley intends to refer to. And so that's why there isn't more information about what Mr. Kelso might or might not say. Frankly, we think it would largely be factual. It may stray into areas about metadata if Mr. Flatley offers opinions along those grounds, and we think that it's not accurate. If that's true, we can provide an updated disclosure, once we've heard Mr. Flatley's testimony. THE COURT: Mr. Rohrbach. MR. ROHRBACH: Your Honor, the exhibits that Mr. Flatley is going to talk about are now marked as government exhibits, and the defense has Mr. Flatley's 3500 information as well as examples the government has pointed to where Mr. Flatley has offered similar testimony in other cases in this district and in the Eastern District. So I think the government has given ample notice about what Mr. Flatley will testify about. But as a more general matter, to the extent that the defense provides supplemental notice at some point about ``` | OBJECTS: The image contains text but no visible objects. | SETTING: The setting appears to be a courtroom or legal proceeding, as indicated by the presence of legal documents and references to court proceedings. | ACTIVITY: The activity depicted is a legal discussion or argument, likely related to a court case involving Mr. Flatley and Mr. Kelso. | NOTABLE: The document discusses the retrieval of metadata from devices seized from Epstein's home and mentio\n... [truncated, 2132 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00008311/10 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00008311&page=10]", "char_count": 2132}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 536 Filed 12/10/21 Page 22 of 43 LBNAMAXTps whether they're going to cross the line from pure fact testimony to expert testimony, I think we can deal with it at that time. THE COURT: OK. What I would just say is, if your expert, looking at the 3500 material and the disclosure, has different expert views, you need to notice those now. But to the extent it's something that comes out at trial, that couldn't have been anticipated, then you can notice down the road. So just in terms of what, if your expert has testimony now that's different from what's anticipated in light of the government's notice and the marked exhibits and 3500 material, when would you like to provide additional notice? MS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, some of the \"marked exhibits\" are a placeholder for an entire hard drive that has any number of documents on it. If the government is now representing they will only be referring to the documents that are separately marked and not to exhibits that say \"hard drive 58,\" \"hard drive 85,\" \"hard drive 96,\" we could do that, but they haven't made that representation. THE COURT: Fair enough. MR. ROHRBACH: Those drives are marked for identification for authentication purposes, but to the extent that the point is that Mr. Kelso is going to testify about general principles associated with the creation of documents ``` | OBJECTS: The image contains text, but no physical objects are present. | SETTING: The setting appears to be a courtroom or legal proceeding, indicated by the presence of a court document and the formal language used. | ACTIVITY: The activity depicted is a legal discussion or hearing, likely related to a case involving expert testimony and evidence. | NOTABLE: The text refers to a case with the case number 1:20-cr-00330-PAE, and mentions a document filed on December 10, 2021. The discussion involves expert testimony, marked exhibits, and the 3500 mat\n... [truncated, 2084 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00008311/11 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00008311&page=11]", "char_count": 2084}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "[VISION] | PEOPLE: There are no visible people in the image. | TEXT: ``` Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 536 Filed 12/10/21 Page 23 of 43 and the extraction of metadata as his expert testimony, Mr. Flatley's views on those questions should be available through the 3500 material and through his other expert testimony, so there's really no need for any sort of further identification by the government of anything before Mr. Kelso should be able to let us know his views on those questions. MS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, the 3500 material doesn't say Mr. Flatley is going to describe the extraction of user data this way. He's talked about the fact that he has observed the user data, but he hasn't talked about the methods that he's used it. It's not that type of 3500 material from the government. So I don't agree that we could tell from what they have provided thus far exactly what Mr. Flatley's testimony is going to be. And frankly, they said Mr. Flatley was largely a fact witness as well. So if I'm understanding now that they're intending to offer something along the lines Mr. Kelso is, they didn't provide sufficient notice for Mr. Flatley's expertise in that area either. THE COURT: Well, I have to go back and look at the notice. But are you using Flatley as an expert? MR. ROHRBACH: We think Mr. Flatley is primarily a fact witness, but the line between a fact witness in a setting like this and someone testifying on the basis of their expertise is not well settled, and so we've given expert notice ``` | OBJECTS: The image contains text, but no physical objects are present. | SETTING: The setting appears to be a courtroom or legal proceeding, as indicated by the presence of a judge, a court document, and legal terminology. | ACTIVITY: The activity involves a legal discussion regarding the use of an expert witness named Mr. Flatley and the 3500 material. The judge is considering whether Mr. Flatley should be considered an expert witness or a fact witness, and there is a debate \n... [truncated, 2344 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00008311/12 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00008311&page=12]", "char_count": 2344}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page14of43 14\nLBNAMAXTps\n\n1 displaying -- we don't have to be approaching the witness and\n\n2 we can move seamlessly through this.\n\n3 These are all documents that are in the government'\n\n4 possession to begin with, your Honor. These are not things\n\n5 that are unknown at this point.\n\n6 THE COURT: Again, that seems off topic. But -- so\n\n7 it's manageable to give the government paper.\n\n8 MR. PAGLIUCA: It should be.\n\n9 THE COURT: Any reason you can't -- how about this.\n10 Prepare it as a binder for potential use, even if it's not the\n11 full document, but anything that you might use -- that you\n12 think you might use. As you know, it's a known quantity. You\n13 have it in a binder and you could direct them to turn to it.\n14 [f it turns out there's something that you do want to show that\n15 you didn't put in the binder, we'll deal with that and you'll\n16 be able to show it, either by turning off the counsel screens\n17 and showing it on the monitor or we'll hand up paper at that\n18 point.\n\n19 MR. PAGLIUCA: I think there is going to be a real\n\n20 problem, your Honor, to do it like that. It just --\n\n21 THE COURT: Help me understand this as a practical\n\n22 matter. You will have your outline for your cross, and you're\n23 going to know enough to tell your paralegal, Put up document\n24 number so-and-so, page 7. And that's how your paralegal is\n\n25 going to pull that up and put it on the screen, right? Why\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008324\n", "char_count": 1534}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nKn\noO\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page15of43 15\nLBNAMAXTps\n\ncan't you just have put that in a binder, a paper binder, in\n\nadvance? And as I said, if there's something that comes up or\n\nyou realize you neglected to put it in, we could deal with\n\nthat. But by and large, you're directing them to a tab ina\n\nbinder, just like you would direct your paralegal to show a\n\nparticular document on the screen. What am I missing?\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: Well, we can try that, your Honor. And\n\nwe'll see how it goes. I mean, we'll be prepared to do it both\n\nways.\n\nTHE COURT: And I assure you, if for some reason\n\nthere's something you want to show that's not in the binder, we\n\nwill work that out and you won't be precluded from showing it.\n\nBut to the extent you've prepared your cross outline and you\n\nknow what you're going to ask about, just like you would call\n\nit up, just have that in a tabbed binder so they can turn to\n\nAnd, again, to be completely clear, should there be\n\nanything you need to do that wasn't in the binder, you'll be\n\nable to do it and we'll either hand up paper in those few\n\ninstances or we'll turn off the table monitors and show it on\n\nthe screen.\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: OK, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Thank you.\n\nWhat else?\n\nNo? OK.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008325\n", "char_count": 1446}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nDocument 536\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nSo defense seeks to preclude,\n\nExhibit 52.\n\nGovernment\n\nthink this needs\n\nwitness testimony and\n\nwhat\n\nunderstand it --\n\nas L\n\nhave this wrong. The\n\nMs.\n\nis for you, Comey\n\n'm no\n\nto play out at\n\nanticipated test\n\n—- the anticipat\n\nthis exact book but a similar-looking book,\n\nsimilar, binding, pages,\n\nfont,\n\netc.,\n\nand she can attempt to au\n\nt going to preclude,\ntrial.\n\nI'll allow voir dire,\n\nPage 16 of 43 16\n\nin motion in limine 7,\n\nbut I do\n\nI need to hear the\n\ngiven factually\n\nI understand to be the issues surrounding this item,\n\nthe witness is going to -- tell\n\nwa\n\nsimilarities between what is Government\n\nIs that the idea?\n\nsaw.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nwitness has not been informed about\n\nthe government's possession, I\n\nThat's correct,\n\njus\n\nin particular,\n\nthing,\nof the -—- you know,\nit as one in a series,\n\ngovernment's possession,\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nCOURT:\n\nframe,\n\nthis wouldn't hav\n\nbut doesn't\n\nit's\n\nb\n\njust\n\nn th\n\nyour\n\nhow\n\ntimony,\n\nand\n\nme if\n\nMs. Comey -- this\n\nted testimony is that not\n\ncharacteristically\n\ns seen by this witness,\n\nthenticate by describing the\n\nExhibit 52 and what she\n\nHonor. Because this\n\nthat exhibit came into\n\nwhich is that this witness won't\n\nwan\n\nted to clarify one small\n\nsay that this isn't one\n\nrecognizes\n\nthat because sh\nknow how it came to the\niden\n\ntifying it in that way.\n\nSo your understanding is,\n\non\n\nby the time\n\nthat she saw, but she\n\nwon't know that because you anticipate her testimony to be\n\nther\n\nwer\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nseveral versions of\n\nthese and they are all the same.\n\nThat's correct,\n\nyour\n\nHonor.\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT R\n\nG\n\n“PORT\n\nERS, PC.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008326\n", "char_count": 1757}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page1/7of43 17\nLBNAMAXTps\n\n1 THE COURT: So I will allow -- I don't know if it's\n\n2 admissible. think, from what see, it's a close question.\n\n3 It's going to turn on the testimony. So I'll allow that\n\n4 testimony to take place. I'll allow voir dire. And then I'll\n5) make a ruling, depending on how that goes, as to whether it\n\n6 meets the threshold for admissibility, and the questions that\n\n7 have been raised go to weight. But as sit here, I don't know\n8 until I hear that testimony.\n\n9 I do think that the government needs to make it\n\n10 available for inspection to the defense, and so you'll work out\n11 the logistics of that pretrial. To the extent that they want a\n12 forensic expert to look at it, a document forensic expert to\n13 look at it, you'll work out the logistics to make it available.\n14 OK?\n15 MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor.\n16 THE COURT: Any questions about that?\n17 MR. PAGLIUCA: No, your Honor, other than one of my\n18 requests was that the actual document be here at trial and not\n19 a photocopy of one page.\n20 MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. The actual exhibit will be\n21 here in the courtroom at trial. And we have already made that\n22 exhibit available for the defense for inspection. They have\n23 personally inspected it, I believe that was on November list.\n24 THE COURT: Great. I'm happy to hear that. And not\n25 just the page but the whole book.\n\nSOUTH\n\nFERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nERS, PC.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008327\n", "char_count": 1493}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nWw\n\nKn\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n2\n\navailable\n\nin a letter that it was available\n\nasked\n\nfor an inspec\n\nNovember 1st.\n\nDocument 536\n\nThat's correct,\n\nfor inspection this summer.\n\ntion the w\n\nI made it available\n\nThey personally inspected it.\n\nthat available\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT:\n\nappreciate that.\n\nnow.\n\nI guess on\n\nAnd I\n\ne question:\n\nthink, given th\n\nFiled 12/10/21 Page18of43 18\nyour Honor. We made it\nWe notified the defens\nfor inspection. The defense\nk before our conference on\nfor inspection that day.\nWe're happy to continue to make\nfor inspection to the defense.\nI'm very happy to hear that. Thank you.\nthink that takes care of that for\n\nuncertainty\n\nas to admission, the government should not mention it in its\nopening.\n\nMS. MOE: Of course, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Anything before we move on?\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: No, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: So next is the admissibility of\nco-conspirator statements. I do appreciate th Fforts to come\nto reasonable agreement, of course, with the defense preserving\n\nobjections as to ultimate admissibility.\n\ncourse th\n\nduring the course o\nThere are\n\nremain in issue, an\n\nso the secon\n\nfirst:\n\n£ the trial.\n\ntwo statemen\n\nd I think, s\n\nd one,\n\nit seems to me,\n\nSOUT\n\nHERN D\n\nSTRIC\n\nIT REPORT\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nBased on the law,\n\nis not being o\n\nERS, PC.\n\nof\n\ngovernment has to make the showing that's required\n\nts that are exemplars that\n\ntarting with the second one\n\nffered\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008328\n", "char_count": 1526}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 536\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nPage 19 of 43 19\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n1 for the truth, that it is being, as I understand it, being\n2 offered for the effect on the listener, and so really there\n3 is —- it's a potential relevance issue and not a hearsay issue.\n4 I think this needs to play out at trial, but tell me if anybody\n5 disagrees with that.\n6 MS. COMEY: We agree, your Honor.\n7 MR. PAGLIUCA: Agreed.\n8 THE COURT: And then the other one, the government is\n9 seeking admission pursuant to 801(d)(2)(E), and in question is\n10 whether the statement was made during the course of and in\n11 furtherance of that conspiracy.\n12 I don't think I have enough to answer that before me.\n13 So can either hear more now or let it play out at trial.\n14 MS. COMEY: think it should play out at trial, your\n15 Honor.\n16 MR. PAGLIUCA: Yes. agree, your Honor.\n17 THE COURT: Great. Thank you. All right. That takes\n18 care of that.\n19 Next are the four additional individuals that the\n20 defense disclosed as potential experts. So we've got Kelso and\n21 Lopez, who, it strikes me, are primarily potentially fact\n22 witnesses and not expert witnesses, with the exception of that\n23 Kelso tes -- so I think first, let's see if we get agreement\n24 on: Lopez would be fact testimony, correct?\n25 MR. ROHRBACH: That's the government's understanding,\n\nSOUTH\n\nPRN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nERS, P,\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008329\n", "char_count": 1418}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page20o0f43 20\nLBNAMAXTps\n\n1 your Honor, although it's not clear from the expert notice\n\n2 whether they anticipate going beyond pure fact testimony.\n\n3 MR. EVERDELL: Your Honor, at this point we anticipate\n4 him being a fact witness.\n\n5) THE COURT: Summary and fact witness.\n\n6 MS. MENNINGER: Yes.\n\n7 MR. EVERDELL: I think.\n\n8 THE COURT: Doesn't sound like expert to me, so I\n\n9 don't think there's anything to do on that now.\n10 Kelso also seems largely anticipated to summarize data\n11 documents and photographs on electronic devices either as a\n12 fact witness or summary testimony under 1006. And except\n13 Kelso's testimony that may cross over into expert testimony is,\n14 I'm going to quote from the notice, \"generally about computer\n15 forensic principles associated with the creation of document\n\n16 storage and retrieval of digital documents and photographs,\n\n17 including the limits to the information that can be gleaned\n\n18 from the metadata.\"\n\n19 I don't think there's been a sufficient disclosure at\n20 this point pursuant to Rule 16. The disclosure doesn't say\n21 what Kelso's opinions actually are about, as to any of these\n22 topics, or provide any basis for those opinions. So certainly\n23 further disclosure would be necessary before I would allow\n\n24 xpert testimony. Is that anticipated?\n\n25 MS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, this is my witness. He\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008330\n\n", "char_count": 1482}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page21of43 21\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\n1 would largely be in rebuttal to a government witness.\n\n2 Mr. Flatley was disclosed by the government for similar\n\n3 purposes to talk about the retrieval of metadata from some of\n\n4 the devices that were seized from Epstein's home. To the\n\n5 extent Mr. Flatley talks about the retrieval of metadata or\n\n6 what that metadata means, Mr. Kelso may then be a rebuttal\n\n7 witness, but we don't know yet from the government's disclosure\n8 exactly what documents Mr. Flatley intends to refer to. And so\n9 that's why there isn't more information about what Mr. Kelso\n10 might or might not say. Frankly, we think it would largely be\n1] factual. It may stray into areas about metadata if Mr. Flatley\n12 offers opinions along those grounds, and we think that it's not\n13 accurate. If that's true, we can provide an updated\n14 disclosure, once we've heard Mr. Flatley's testimony.\n15 THE COURT: Mr. Rohrbach.\n16 MR. ROHRBACH: Your Honor, the exhibits that\n17 Mr. Flatley is going to talk about are now marked as government\n18 exhibits, and the defense has Mr. Flatley's 3500 information as\n19 well as examples the government has pointed to where\n20 Mr. Flatley has offered similar testimony in other cases in\n21 this district and in the Eastern District. So I think the\n22 government has given ample notice about what Mr. Flatley will\n23 testify about.\n24 But aS a more general matter, to the extent that the\n25 defense provides supplemental notice at some point about\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008331\n\n", "char_count": 1605}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\na\noO\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page22o0f43 22\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nwhether they're going to cross the line from pure fact\n\ntestimony to expert testimony, I think we can deal with it at\n\nthat time.\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nCOURT: OK. What I would just say is, if your\n\nexpert, looking at the 3500 material and the disclosure, has\n\ndifferent expert views, you need to notice those now. But to\nthe extent it's something that comes out at trial, that\ncouldn't have been anticipated, then you can notice down the\n\nroad.\n\nSo just in terms of what, if your expert has testimony\n\nnow that's different from what's anticipated in light of the\n\ngovernment's notice and the marked exhibits and 3500 material,\n\nwhen would you like to provide additional notice?\n\nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, some of the \"marked\n\nexhibits\" are a placeholder for an entire hard drive that has\n\nany number of documents on it. If the government is now\n\nrepresenting they will only be referring to the documents that\nare separately marked and not to exhibits that say \"hard drive\n58,\" “hard drive 85,\" \"hard drive 96,\" we could do that, but\n\nthey haven't made that representation.\n\nTHE COURT: Fair enough.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: Those drives are marked for\n\nidentification for authentication purposes, but to the extent\n\nthat the point is that Mr. Kelso is going to testify about\n\ngeneral principles associated with the creation of documents\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008332\n", "char_count": 1573}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\na\noO\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nand the extraction of\n\nMr.\n\ntestimony,\n\nidentification by the\n\nDocument 536\n\nso there's really no need\n\ngovernment of\n\nshould be able to let\n\nsay Mr.\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nthrough the 3500 material and through his other expert\nfor any sort of\n\nanything before Mr.\n\nthe 3500 materia\n\nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor,\nFlatley is going to describe the ex\nHe's talked about the fact\n\ndata this way.\n\nthe user data,\n\nused it.\n\ngovernment.\n\nhave provided thus\n\nPage 23 of 43 23\n\nfF metadata as his expert testimony,\n\nFlatley's views on those questions should be available\n\nfurther\n\nKelso\n\nus know his views on those questions.\n\n1 doesn't\n\ntraction of user\n\nfar exactly what Mr.\n\ngoing to be.\n\nAnd\n\nwitness as well.\n\nfrankly, they said Mr.\n\nbut he hasn't talked about the\nIt's not that type of 3500 material\nSo I don't agree that we could\n\nthat he has observed\n\nmethods that he's\n\nfrom the\n\ntel]\n\nfrom what they\n\nFlatley's testimony is\n\nFlatley was\n\nSo if\n\nintending to of\n\ndidn't provide suf\n\nficient notice for Mr\n\nfer something along the lines Mr.\n\n. Flatl\n\nlargely a fact\n\nI'm understanding now that they're\n\nKelso is, they\n\ny's expertise in\n\nthat area either.\n\nIT have to go back and look at the\n\ntley is primarily a\n\nTHE COURT: Well,\n\nnotice. But are you using Flatley as an expert?\nMR. ROHRBACH: We think Mr. Fla\n\nfact witness, but the line between a fac\n\nlike\n\nt witness in a setting\n\nthis and someone testifying on the basis of their\nexpertise is not well settled, and so we've given expert notice\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008333\n\n", "char_count": 1706}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe)\n\na\nan)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nin an abundance of\n\nfour other cases\n\ncaution,\n\nin which Mr.\n\nDocument 536\n\nand also\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nPage 24 0f 43 24\n\nidenti\n\nfied\n\nFor the defense\n\nFlatley has testified on a\n\nsimilar topic so they can see --\n\nTH\n\ncrossed over\n\nexample -——\n\nE COURT:\n\nMR.\n\nROHRBACH: f\n\ninto expert opinion about methodology,\n\nmay have a minute,\n\nMr.\n\nfour cases,\n\nFlatley is quali\n\nwhich highlights\n\nprovides in\ntopics.\n\nTo\nraised, either in\n\nthe similar\n\nsomething that's outside\n\nnotice, dep\n\nTH\n\nyour expert\n\ngot some di\n\nE COURT:\n\nfied as an expert\n\nthe vagaries of\n\nformation about the bases of\n\nthis\n\nThat includes his ex-- to the extent it\n\nfor\n\nyour Honor.\n\nthose\n\nin some of\n\nand it\n\nline,\n\nF his opinion about these\n\nthe extent that there is an issue that is not\n\nexemplars w\n\nthe government's expert notice or 3500,\n\nending on exactly what it\n\nSo I\n\nffering expert\n\ncreation of\n\ndocuments,\n\n\"ve given th\n\nthe bounds of\n\nthink what\nlook at the testimony that\n\nopinion as\n\nis.\n\nCO\n\nor in\ntestimony, that might be\nfF the government axe pert\nwe need to do is, you have\nhe's provided. If he's\nForensic principles or\n\ndocuments or storage and retrieval\n\nor what information\n\ngenerally, think you should notice those opinions.\nabsent that, we'll let it play out. OK.\n\nMS. MENNINGER: Certainly, your Honor.\nif Mr. Flatley attemoets to o\n\ncan be gleaned\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.\n\n(212\n\n) 805-0300\n\nof digital\n\nfrom metadata\n\nBut\n\nAnd obviously\n\nFfer opinions during his testimony\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008334\n", "char_count": 1652}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe)\n\na\nan)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 536\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nthat are not disclosed,\n\nthat time.\nTHE COURT: All right.\nJust wi\n\nopinion abou\n\nby which you\n\nthose subjects,\n\ntell\n\nme ij\n\nopinions to\nMS.\n\nTHE\n\nMS.\n\nhearing is,\n\nin other cases.\n\neo)\n\nthe only opinions he may of\n\nffer wi\n\nM\n\nC\n\nM\n\nENN\n\nNG\n\nBR:\n\nOURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nENN\n\nNG\n\nAnd I\n\nBR:\n\nwhen will you\nf your expert has di\nth respect to those\n\nThis Saturday,\n\ndon't —--\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nPage 250f 43 25\n\nI will raise that with\n\nth respect to what you have as\n\nthe Court at\n\nanticipated\n\ngive me the dat\n\nareas.\n\nThey haven't disclosed an opinion\n\nfrferent expert\n\nyour Honor?\n\nI guess what I'm\n\nfer are those disclosed\n\nfrom this\n\ncase. So we will look at those other trial testimony, and any\nopinions in those testimony that our client -- our expert\ndisagrees with we can provide them by this Saturday.\nTHE COURT: That sounds very reasonable to me. OK?\nMR. ROHRBACH: Yes, your Honor. Although we know\nthat, again, in addition to the other -- his testimony in other\ncases, we would point the defens xpert to the 3500 material\n\nas well in\n\nthis case and the government's exhibits.\n\nyour notice should provide\n\nYou're required,\n\nas the\n\nthe opinions\n\nTHE COURT: Well, I mean,\nthe opinions that he's going to offer. Does it?\nTt's not a scavenger hunt.\nfirst matter, to provide, pursuant to Rule 16,\nthat he's going to offer. Have you done that?\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008335\n\n", "char_count": 1577}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nKn\noO\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536- Filed 12/10/21 Page26o0f43 26\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: Yes. The government believes that its\n\nnotice, in combination with its 3500 materials and the cases\n\nit's pointed the defense to, should give th\n\ndefense an\n\nunderstanding of Mr. Flatley's opinions, to\n\nthe extent that\n\nthey're expert opinions at all and not just\n\nTHE COURT: Well —-\n\nfact opinions.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: Your Honor, my point is that\n\nMs. Menninger says that she would have her expert review\n\nMr. Flatley's testimony in other cases to see if there are\nopinions he disagreed with, and I just wanted to clarify that\nthe defens xpert should review the material the government\n\nhas provided them.\n\nTHE COURT: That's fine, but it's your notice that\n\nsets up the opinions that your expert is of\n\nfering.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: Yes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: So what they should do\n\nis look at the\n\nnotice, and if their expert has different views than what's in\n\nthe notice, they should provide those views\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: Yes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: f your notice is insuf\n\nficient under Rule\n\n16 to tell us now what opinions your expert\n\nis going to\n\nprovide, then you may have problems down the road. But I'm not\n\ngoing to have them held to a different standard than what the\n\ngovernment has done here.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: Of course, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,\n(212) 805-0300\n\nPG\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008336\n\n", "char_count": 1515}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nKn\noO\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nTH\n\nSaturday, 1\n\nthat your expert has di\n\nprovide not\n\nMS.\n\nTH\nany sense,\nand the\n\nto,\n\nvidence th\n\nma\n\nf there's\n\nE COURT:\n\nCOURT: So\n\nan\n\nDocument 536\n\nFiled 12/10/21 Page27of43 27\n\n, Ms. Menninger, with respect to\n\nything in the notice that's suggested\n\nFferent expert opinions on, please\n\nice. Otherw\n\nMENN\n\nNGER:\n\nAn\n\nbased on the disclosures,\n\ndefense say\n\nimagine you\n\ngovernment\n\nwould hav\n\nise we'll see how it plays out.\n\nOf\n\ncourse. Thank you, your Honor.\n\nI don't have\n\nd then LaPorte and Naso,\n\nwhat evidence this will\n\ngo\n\ns that's because they don't know what\n\nwill produce. What documents do you\n\nthes\n\nMR.\n\ntestify,\n\nissue relates\n\nyour\n\nPAGLIUCA:\n\nHonor. T\n\nto Accuse\n\ndoubt that\n\nendorsed\n\nreally see it playing out.\n\nup; if\n\nas Can.\n\nthat's going\n\nthem just out of\n\nit becomes an issue,\n\ndon't\n\nBut\n\ntestifying at trial.\n\nxperts analyze?\n\nI think it's unlikely that\n\nthey will\n\nhe only document that was potentially at\n\nr No. 2. And I doubt that that --\n\nto become an issue during trial. We\n\ndon't\n\nand I\n\nan abundance of caution,\n\nthink if it comes\n\nit -- if\n\nBut\n\ncertainly I'll give as much notice\n\nreally think they're going to be\n\nTHE COURT: Good enough for me.\nMr. Rohrbach.\nMR. ROHRBACH: I'd like to say it's good enough, your\nHonor. The concern is that if the defense decides mid trial\nthat they would like to call these experts, it's going to\ncreate a difficult situation for the government to file the\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008337\n\n", "char_count": 1654}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe)\n\na\nan)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nappropriate Daubert motion,\n\nNecessary.\n\nthe def\n\nAnd so the governmen\n\nDocument 536\n\nidenti\n\nns\n\nspecific noti\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nFy responsive experts if\n\nPage 28 of 43 28\n\nt asks that the Court preclude\n\nxperts at this time unless they give at least more\n\nce about what\n\nthey might testit\n\nfy to.\n\nTHE COURT: Well, they are precluded without more\nspecific notice. That's true.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: OK. Then that's fine for the\ngovernment, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Yes. I mean, plainly, Rule 16 hasn't been\nmet at this stage, and the representation is, they're not\nanticipating anything coming up. If something comes up, they\nwould have to first provide sufficient notice in order for us\nto be able to resolve this. So it can't being is that could\n\nhave been anticipated at this point.\n\nOK?\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: Yes. Totally understood, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: OK. Thank you.\n\nAll right. Next thing on my checklist, the limiting\ninstructions related to witness 3 that I proposed. Who's\ntaking this one?\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: am, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: So Mr. Rohrbach, you propose -—- so\nsuggested, \"However, you may not convict the defendant on the\nbasis of the testimony regarding the sexual conduct between\n\nthis witness and Mr.\n\nstatement of\n\nYou agree that's a correct\n\nEpstein.\"\nthe law, yes?\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008338\n\n", "char_count": 1502}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 536\n\nFiled 12/10/21 Page 29o0f43 29\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\n1 MR. ROHRBACH: apologize, your Honor. I'm just\n\n2 trying to pull find that. This is for the -—-\n\n3 THE COURT: For witness 3.\n\n4 MR. ROHRBACH: For witness 3. Yes, your Honor, we\n\n5 agree that's a correct statement of the law.\n\n6 THE COURT: But you want to add \"solely.\"\n\n7 MR. ROHRBACH: Yes. The government thinks that that\n8 clarification -—-\n\n9 THE COURT: Let me ask you this. So if you add\n\n10 \"solely,\" then, to my ear, it would mean that you can convict\n11 the defendant on the basis of the testimony of witness 3\n\n12 regarding the sexual conduct between this witness and\n\n13 Mr. Epstein, and other evidence regarding the sexual conduct\n14 between this witness and Mr. Epstein. Is that a correct\n15 statement of law?\n16 MR. ROHRBACH: Yes, your Honor. Insofar as the Court\n17 has ruled that evidence related to witness 3 is direct evidenc\n18 of the offense, if that is offered in combination with other\n19 evidence in the case that goes -—-\n20 THE COURT: No, I think maybe you misunderstood my\nal question. The government has said that the sexual conduct\n22 between Mr. Epstein and this witness took place over all\n23 relevant ages of consent. Correct?\n24 MR. ROHRBACH: Yes, your Honor.\n25 THE COURT: So the defendant can't be convicted based\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008339\n\n", "char_count": 1398}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe)\n\na\nan)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBNAMAXTps\n\non the sexual conduct between this witness and Mr.\n\nDocument 536\n\nMy question is,\n\nCorrect?\nMR. ROHRBACH:\nTHE COURT:\n\"solely,\" this is what\n\nYes.\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nif\n\n[ think\n\nI hear:\n\ntha\n\nconvicted based on this witness's\n\nsexual conduct between Mr.\n\nvidenc\nMr. Epstein. Is tha\nMR. ROHRBACH: see\nwould be a correct statement.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nTHE COURT:\nmeaning,\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\"solely\" is read to modit\n\ncreates a —-\n\nEpstein and this witn\n\nregarding the sexual conduct between\n\nt the defendan\n\ntestimony rega\n\nth\n\nyour\n\nThat would be\n\nThat would\n\nYes.\n\nThat would be\n\nt a correct statement?\n\nin, in--\nbe incorrect.\n\nwrong. As a\n\nHonor's point.\n\nPage 30 of 43 30\n\nEpstein.\n\nyou add\n\nt can be\nrding the\ness, and other\nis witness and\n\nYes, that\n\nlaw.\n\nmatter of\n\nAnd that doesn't solely give it that\n\nsee your Honor's point that if\n\nit becomes amenabl\n\nthat potential meaning?\n\ngovernment's\n\naide\n\nma\n\nCOURT:\n\nway, that would be,\n\nMR. RO\n\nlaw, yes, your Honor\n\npoint is that --\n\nfy the sexual-conduct point,\n\nto that reading.\n\nthen that\n\nThe\n\nAnd should the jury be instructed that\n\nin my mind,\n\nRBACH:\n\nreversible error.\n\nThat would be an incorrect statement of\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT R\n\nPORT\n\nERS, PC.\n\n(212)\n\n805\n\n—0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008340\n", "char_count": 1436}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 536\n\nFiled 12/10/21 Page 31o0f43 31\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\n1 THE COURT: So we won't add \"solely,\" because we don't\n2 want to wrongly instruct the jury about the law. So we'll keep\n3 that one as it is.\n\n4 I need to think about the other on In my mind, this\n5) is an issue that pertains -- I understand there's a witness\n\n6 where the only sexual conduct took place in New Mexico, and I\n\n7 had understood previously that that witness was above the age\n\n8 of consent in New Mexico, but that the government was offering\n9 that evidence as enticement to engage in illegal sexual conduct\n10 in New York. And that's what I was trying to capture in the\n\n11 instruction, so that that evidence could be relevant, the jury\n12 could see that evidence as relevant to the enticement to\n\n13 illegal sexual activity as defined under New York law, which is\n14 the only way that the government has charged this case, other\n15 than the trafficking count -- well, including the trafficking\n16 count, yes.\n17 And that's what I was trying to capture. And I'll\n18 consider the alterations you're suggesting. What we can't do\n19 is infuse the instruction with the government's case and\n20 arguments. The point here is just to make clear what the\n21 jurors can't do and then, to the extent they otherwise deem th\n22 vidence relevant, they can consider it and we'll give them the\n23 charge at the end of the day. But I'll consider the\n24 suggestions. I haven't -- just haven't had time.\n25 Anything on that?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008341\n\n", "char_count": 1573}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nMR. EV.\n\ndefense's position that the Court's\n\nDocument 536\n\nPRDELL:\n\nYes,\n\nstatement of law.\n\nis cumbersome,\n\nrather than to\n\nAnd\n\nidentified the\n\nalleged events\n\nthink the government's\n\nIt's concise,\n\nyour Honor\n\nFiled 12/10/21 Page 32o0f43 32\n\n. .fdmean, it's the\n\ninstruction is a correct\n\nit's clear,\n\nthe issues for the jurors as opposed to cont\n\nfuse the issues. I\n\nand will clarify\n\ninstruction is exactly the opposite. It\nit is difficult to follow, and it will confuse\nclarify.\n[ will just point out, I think your Honor\n\ncorrect example, which is Accuser 2, which is\n\nthat took place in New\n\nthe age of consent\n\nAnd so this illustra\n\nth\n\na conspiracy wher\n\nof New York law with acts tha\n\njurisdictions which were lega\n\nillega\n\nMexico when she was above\n\nfor those acts in New Mexico.\n\ntes the problem of trying to prove\n\n1 sexual activity is a violation\n\nt took place in other\n\n1 and have nothing to do with New\n\nUnder New Mexico law. I'm sorry. I\n\nfore, your Honor, if\n\nfy to these events that took place\n\nthey're legal under New York law —-\n\nume that the\n\nYork law.\nSo as I think you've discussed bet\nthe witness is going to testi\nin New Mexico, even though\nthere's no issue ther they're going to --\nTHE COURT: Not under New York law.\nMR. EVERDELL:\nmisspoke. Under New Mexico law.\nTHE COURT: Right.\nMR. EVERDELL: They're going to ass\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008342\n\n", "char_count": 1508}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page33o0f43 33\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\npurpose of this testimony is that thes\n\nar\n\nillegal acts that\n\nthey're talking about, and unless they're instructed otherwise\n\nby the Court, they may convict Ms. Maxwell on an improper\n\nbasis, which is that this witness's testimony is talking about\n\nillegal sexual activity, as that's charged in the indictment.\n\nSo there has to be a clarification on this point.\n\nAnd I just would note, your Honor,\n\nthe reason why\n\nwe're here in this position is becaus\n\nthe government has\n\nchosen to add Accuser 2, Accuser 3, people who have nothing to\n\ndo with violations of New York law, in this conspiracy, and if\n\nthey're going to do that and you try to use that as evidence of\n\na violation of New York law --\n\nTHE COURT: Well, the charge is enticement. And, in\nmy mind, this witness is in a very different position than\nwitness 3.\n\nMR. EVERDELL: Yes.\n\nTHE COURT: But it's certainly relevant evidence to\n\nthe enticement charge with respect to New York law. There's no\n\ndoubt about that.\n\nunderstands, though it can be relevant evidence for that, if\n\nBut agree, we have to make sure that the jury\n\nthey want to take it into account for whatever they want to\n\ntake it into account for, what they can't take it into account\nfor is itself the New Mexico activity -- sexual activity as\nitself illegal conduct charged in the indictment.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,\n\n(212) 805-030\n\n0\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008343\n\n", "char_count": 1529}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nWw\n\nKn\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nAnd it's a di\n\nfferent postures,\n\npropose an instruction\n\nDocument 536\n\nand\n\ntherefore di\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\n[ferent\n\nPage 34 of 43 34\n\nBut it seems to me these witnesses are in very\n\nrisk of prejudice.\n\nthat I\n\nfferent\n\ninstruction precisely\n\nthink gets\n\nto the point.\n\nFor\n\nthis reason,\n\nthat\n\nenticement\n\ncharge with respect\n\ncharge\n\nxe)\n\nwith respect to that witness,\n\nconfusing,\n\ntheory into the charge.\n\nis any additional\n\nthat witness,\n\nthat sexual conduct can be relevant evidence of\n\nto violate New York law.\n\nthe\n\nSo I do think some\n\nsome limiting instruction\n\nis necessary.\n\nI won't make it\n\nand I won't allow the government to just insert its\nBut I'll take a look to see if there\nclarification. That would be helpful.\nMR. ROHRBACH: Just in response to Mr. Everdell's\n\npoint,\n\ntoday\n\nabove\n\nletter, that'\n\nTHI!\n\nEe]\n\nthat the government intends to put on,\n\nillegal sexual activity under New Mexico law,\n\nthe releva\n\nyour Honor,\n\nthat the sexual ac\n\nSia\n\nCOU\n\nI'm not going to -- again,\n\nnt age of consent.\n\nAs we briefed\n\nthe government is not prepared to concede\n\ntivity that occurred in New Mexico was\n\nin our\n\nfF New Mexico state law.\n\ncomplex question of\n\nRT:\n\nSo, I mean, if\n\nThat's not how you charged it here.\n\ncharged pursuant to New Mexico law.\n\nis saying is,\n\nyou're going to show that\n\nnot going to misin\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nshouldn't\n\nthere's\n\nthat's not how you charged it.\n\nRight?\n\na factual question\n\nas to whether that was\n\nthen certainly\n\nYou haven't\n\nBut if\n\ngive that charge because in\n\nit was illegal sexual activity --\n\nwhat the government\n\nfact\n\nform the jury that it wasn't illegal under\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORTERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008344\n", "char_count": 1776}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nNew Mexico law if that's s\n\nshow.\n\nour\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: Yo\n\ncharging theory is jus\n\nDocument 536 —~- Filed 12/10/21 Page 35o0f43 35\n\nomething the government is going to\n\nur Honor, we completely agree that\n\nt a violation of the New York statute\n\nand not the New Mexico statute, or any particular New Mexico\n\nstatute. Our point is tha\n\nt it is not a straightforward\n\nquestion that any sexual activity that occurred in New Mexico\n\nwas necessarily above New Mexico's own age of consent. So at\n\nleast the legal accuracy of that has not been established at\n\nthis point.\n\nTHE COURT: Will\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: No\n\nis not planning to put on\n\npar\n\nticular New Mexico offe\n\n18;\n\nthat\n\nwe've established in\n\nit be an issue in trial?\n\n, your Honor, because the government\n\nvidence aimed at meeting any\n\nnse, Since that's not the charges\n\nthis case. That's just a point in\n\nterms of the accuracy of the proposed jury instruction -- that\n\nwhether the sexual conduct was legal or illegal within New\n\nMexico.\n\nyou\n\nTHE COURT: So wh\n\nat I had said was, \"I anticipate\n\n‘ll hear testimony from\n\nthe next witness about sexual\n\nconduct that she says she had with Mr. Epstein in New Mexico.\"\n\nI had suggested, because it's what I understood from\n\nou that because the witness was over\n\nage of consent in New Mexico at the relevant time period,\n\nAnd then\n\nthe parties, \"I instruct y\nthe\n\nthe sexual conduct she say\n\ns occurred with Mr. Epstein was not\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(\n\n212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008345\n\n", "char_count": 1596}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "ay\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536- Filed 12/10/21 Page 36o0f43 36\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nillegal sexual activity, as the government has charged in the\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nindictment.\" So it sounds to me, from what you're saying, is\n\nthat the first part of that sentence may be factually in\n\ndispute. But the key, I think, goes to the latter part of the\n\nsentence, which is that the sexual conduct she says occurred\n\nwith Mr. Epstein was not illegal sexual activity as the\n\ngovernment has charged in the indictment. You agree with that.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: That's correct, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: So let me work on this one, and I'll\n\npropose —- I mean, I'll put out a new proposal after I've had\n\nsome time to absorb.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: f may make just one other point,\n\nyour Honor, related to this, which is that, given that we've\n\ncharged this as a -- minor Victim 2 is only charged in the\n\nconspiracy counts of the indictment. And so whether or not\n\nevents that took place in New Mexico constitute illegal sexual\n\nactivity within the meaning of the Mann Act doesn't bear on\n\nwhether there was an independent to engage -- sorry. It bears\n\non whether there was an intent to engage in illegal sexual\n\nactivity in New York but only insofar as that sexual activity\n\nin New Mexico would satisfy the New York definition of --\n\nTHE COURT: Yes.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: And so whether or not --\n\nTHE COURT: I understand. The only fear of confusion\n\nis if they think that you've established the illegal sexual\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008346\n", "char_count": 1592}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 536\n\nFiled 12/10/21 Page 37of43 37\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\n1 activity by having put on evidence of the sexual conduct in New\n2 Mexico.\n\n3 MR. ROHRBACH: Yes, your Honor. And we, for the\n\n4 reason ——\n\ni) THE COURT: [ understand your point, which is whether\n6 or not it violated New Mexico law, that witness, in her\n\n7 telling, was under the age of consent in New York, and\n\n8 therefore it goes to the conspiracy to -- the Mann Act\n\n9 conspiracy count.\n\n10 MR. ROHRBACH: Right, yes.\n\n11 THE COURT: [ get it\n\n12 I will absorb this information and propose -- I do\n\n13 think a charge is necessary, but it has to be correct, and it\n14 sounds like it may not be entirely correct as written. So I'll\n15 propose.\n\n16 MR. EVERDELL: Your Honor, if could just be heard\n\n17 briefly.\n\n18 THE COURT: Sure.\n\n19 MR. EVERDELL: On the point about not being illegal\n20 under New Mexico law, this is really an eleventh-hour issue the\n21 government is raising. They haven't charged it this way.\n22 imagine if they thought this was really a violation of New York\n23 law there would be a substantive —-—\n24 THE COURT: New Mexico law.\n25 MR. EVERDELL: I'm sorry. I keep misstating, your\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008347\n\n", "char_count": 1257}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\na\noO\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 536\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nPage 38 of 43 38\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nHonor.  -—- New Mexico law, that we would have a substantive\nviolation in addition for this witness. We don't. And in fact\nI believe the government, bassed on the case law they're\nciting, the issue they're raising is that there has to be force\ninvolved or coercion involved for this to be something illegal.\n\nAnd that's not how they charge it. Tha\n\nin this case. We've litigated that iss\n\nSo I think\n\nit is a correct statement of\n\nillegal sexual activity under New Mexic\n\nthe instruction should reflect to the j\n\nTHE COURT: [ think\n\ncaptured in \"as charged by the governme\n\nt's never been\n\nxten\n\nan issue\n\nue quit\n\nlaw to say th\n\no law, and tha\n\nury.\n\nnt and\n\nfor purposes of\n\nSively.\nis is not\n\nt's what\n\nthe important point has to be\n\nSo\n\nestablishing the elements that\n\nhear your point. I'm going to\n\nprovide clarity to the jury so\n\nthe jury has to consider.\"\n\nthink about the best way to\n\nthat they know what they can and\n\nwhat they can't do with this evidence.\n\nfrom you\n\nfor\n\nMR. EVERDELL: Thank you, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: I'll do my best. And I'll hear\nafter re-propose.\n\nAnything else on that?\n\nMR. ROHRBACH: No. Thank you, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Anything else, Mr. Everdell?\n\nMR. EVERDELL: No, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: All right. So next is just to go over,\nmake sure wetre all on the same pag that's all I have\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008348\n\n", "char_count": 1600}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "[NO_IMAGE] No rendered image was available for this page; previous OCR-error string was scrubbed.", "char_count": 97}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\nWw\n\nKn\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nstrikes.\nMS. COMEY:\nMS. STERNHEIM:\nTHE COURT: OK.\n\nare any issues to discuss regarding exclusion of\n\nunder Federal\n\nI always ask at the\n\nDocument 536\n\nNo questions,\n\nNo.\n\nfinal\n\nFiled 12/10/21\n\nyour Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\npretrial con\n\nPage 40 of 43 40\n\nthere\n\nference if\n\nRul of\n\nparties have\n\nwe're all on\n\nthan the parties,\n\nwhether they\n\ncase agents,\n\nth\n\nvidenc\n\nfeeds into their war rooms,\n\nsame pag\n\nthat\n\nwitnesses\n\n615. And especi\n\nI want\n\nt anybody who may\n\nwho would potentially be need\n\ncan listen t\n\nor you\n\no tes\n\ntell me.\n\nAre there any potential witnesses who\n\nanticipates would be listening to some or all o\n\nMS.\n\ntestify. After certain victims\n\nCOMEY :\n\nNo,\n\nyour\n\ntimony or be excluded,\n\nally because the\n\nto make sure\n\ntestify, other\n\ning to discuss\n\nexperts or\n\nthe government\n\nthe testimony?\n\nHonor, certainly\n\npresent after the completion of\n\ntheir rights under the Crime Victims\n\nno witnesses\n\ntestify,\n\ntheir\n\ntestimony\n\nthat we know\n\nTHE\n\nMS.\n\ngovernment has -- and we've litigated\n\naccusers'\n\nCOURT: OK.\n\nMENNINGER:\n\nof\n\nwill\n\nthey may choose\n\nbe\n\nnot fore they\n\nto be\n\npursuant to\n\n' Rights Ac\n\nbe listening\n\nMs.\n\nYour\n\nMenninger.\n\nHonor, I would no\n\nwheth\n\nprior inconsistent s\n\ntatements may be\n\nbut otherwise\n\nae\n\nto testimony.\n\nte that the\n\nthe\n\nr any of\n\nadmitted af\n\nter\n\nto the rule, if\n\nI'm sorry,\n\ntheir credibility has been attacked. Pursuant\nthere is later introduction of inconsistent --\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008350\n", "char_count": 1598}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe)\n\na\nan)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 Filed 12/10/21 Page41of43 41\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nmean —--\n\nTHE COURT: You mean prior consistent.\n\nMS. MENNINGER: -- prior consistent we've got a\nproblem at this table misspeaking -- of prior consistent\n\nstatements, that the declarant be made available, subject to\n\nrecross -- or recall to the stand, to explain those supposed\n\nprior consistent statements.\n\nSo I don't know how that bears on the Court's thinking\n\nabout permitting those accusers who may be subject to recall to\n\nlisten in on testimony following their release from their\n\noriginal testimony, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Well, I guess the first question is, under\n\nthe rule, which reads, \"At a party's request, the court must\n\norder witnesses excluded so they cannot hear other witnesses'\n\ntestimony\" -- or I could do it on my own. But guess the\n\nquestion is, is the defens so the government says alleged\n\nvictim witnesses, after they testify, may want to listen to\n\ntestimony after that. Ms. Menninger, are you requesting they\n\nnot do that because of the possibility that they may be\n\nrecalled for rebuttal?\n\nMS. MENNINGER: Yes, your Honor.\n\nMS. COMEY: Your Honor, if we may, we would ask to put\n\nin a letter on this issue, to look into it.\n\nTHE COURT: Yes. Fair enough. And I think you're\n\nright. There may be an intersection between the Crime Victim\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008351\n", "char_count": 1527}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document536 _ Filed 12/10/21\n\nPage 42 of 43 42\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n1 Protection Act and 615. Why don't you both look at it, confer,\n2 see if you can come to agreement, and if not, put ina letter.\n3 MS. COMEY: Thank you, your Honor.\n4 THE COURT: Thank you.\na) MR. PAGLIUCA: Your Honor, one other issue on\n6 sequestration. I was hoping to be able to provide a copy of\n7 Dr. Rocchio's testimony to either Dr. Dietz or Dr. Loftus,\n8 because I anticipate there may be issues that come up that they\n9 need to address during their testimony. And so for that\n10 purpose I would ask for a limited exclusion from Rule 615 for\n11 those witnesses.\n12 MR. ROHRBACH: That's fine with the government, your\n13 Honor.\n14 THE COURT: Thank you. This is why I asked. Make\n15 sure we're on the same pag\n16 Anything else in that regard?\n17 MS. COMEY: Not from the government, your Honor.\n18 THE COURT: When may I have an order-of-witness list?\n19 MS. COMEY: We would propose by Saturday, your Honor?\n20 THE COURT: OK. And, as I always do, I ask at the\n21 final pretrial conference if any plea offers were communicated\n22 to the defense.\n23 MS. COMEY: None were communicated, your Honor.\n24 THE COURT: And Ms. Sternheim, that's accurate; none\n25 were communicated?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTER\n(212) 805-0300\n\nSy Pes\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00008352\n\n", "char_count": 1328}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00008311", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nWO\n\na\noO\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nDocument 536 —~- Filed 12/10/21 Page 43o0f43 43\n\nMS. STERNHE\n\nM: None were communicated.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhat else?\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nAnything?\n\nNothing from the government, your Honor.\n\nAnything from the defense?\n\nMS. STERNHE\n\nM: No. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes. Just\n\nwitnesses who may be\n\nGive me one second?\n\non the point, Ms. Comey, regarding the\n\nrecalled for rebuttal, you'll, both sides\n\nwill look into it, you'll confer, and when would you like to\nput in a letter if there's disagreement?\n\nMS. COMEY: May we submit it by Saturday, your Honor?\n\nTHE COURT: Yes.\n\nMS. COMEY: Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: All right. Nothing further?\n\nThank you, everyone. Have a good Thanksgiving. I'll\nsee you on Monday.\n\n(Adjourned)\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00008353\n", "char_count": 950}]}