{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_count": 127, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/DOJ-OGR-00007052", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/DOJ-OGR-00007052.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\na\n=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465_ Filed 11/15/21 Page1of127 1\nLB1TMAX1\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nx\nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA,\nVv. 20 CR 330 (AJN)\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\nDefendant.\nx\nNew York, N.Y.\nNovember 1, 2021\n11:05 a.m.\nBefore:\nHON. ALISON J. NATHAN,\nDistrict Judge\nAPPEARANCES\nDAMIAN WILLIAMS\nUnited States Attorney for the\nSouthern District of New York\nALISON MOE\nMAURENE COMEY\nANDREW ROHRBACH\nLARA POMERANTZ\nAssistant United States Attorney\nCOHEN & GRESSER\nAttorneys for Defendant\nCHRISTIAN EVERDELL\nHADDON MORGAN FOREMAN\nAttorneys for Defendant\nJEFFREY PAGLIUCA\nLAURA MENNINGER\nBOBBI C. STERNHEIM\nAttorney for Defendant\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nLD\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007052\n\n", "char_count": 846}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "=\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\na\n=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\n(C\n\nase called)\n\nD\n\nina\n\nBy\n\nPUTY CLERK:\n\nCounsel,\n\nDocument 465\n\nrecord, starting with the government.\n\nMS.\n\ngovernment,\n\nComey, Andrew Rohrbach and Sunny\n\njoined at counsel table by Lara\n\nif, 6UF GfLIeG\n\nspecialist\n\nTH\n\nMS.\n\nSternheim appearing\n\ncounsel tab\n\nSTERNHEIM:\n\nCs\n\nMOE: Good morning,\n\nE COURT: Good morning.\n\nGood morning,\n\nJeffrey Pag\n\nTH\n\nGo\n\nremove my mask whil\n\nod morning,\n\nam told, consistent with\n\nMs\n\ne also present are part of\n\nE COURT: Good morning,\n\nDrescher,\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 2 of 127 2\n\nplease state your name for the\n\nyour Honor, Alison Moe for the\n\nPomerantz, Maurene\n\na paralegal\n\nJudge Nathan, Bobby C.\n\nfor Ghislaine Maxwell.\n\nNext to me at\n\nthe defense team,\n\nliuca, Laura Menninger and Christian Everdell.\n\neveryone.\n. Maxwell. Please be seated.\nthe protocols, that I can\n\nseated here at the bench, and counsel,\n\nwhen they're at the podium, if you wish to speak from the\n\npodium, you may remove your mask. So\n\nWe're here today\n\nmatter. Tr\n\nI will do that.\n\nconference in this\n\nfor a pretrial\n\nial is scheduled to commence with the jury\n\nquestionnaire process beginning\n\nI have indi\nAs\n\nis largely\n\ncated, we wi\n\n1]\n\nbegi\n\nthis Thursday, November 4. As\n\nn trial on November 29.\n\ndiscuss some additional\n\nsee it, the primary purpose of today's conference\n\nto address the parties' motions in limine and then\nlogistical issues.\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007053\n\n", "char_count": 1579}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465_ Filed 11/15/21 Page3of127 3\nLB1TMAX1\n\nCounsel, I'm prepared to turn to the motions first,\nunless there's any reason to deviate from that.\n\nMs. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: No, your Honor, thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Sternheim?\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: Not at this time, Judge.\n\nTHE COURT: All right. am in receipt of the\n\nparties'\n\nvarious motions\n\nin li\n\nmine,\n\nand replies in support.\n\nresponses in opposition,\n\n[ did require the parties to\n\nfile the\n\npapers on the public docket with their proposed redactions so\n\nthat the public could hav\n\nry]\n\nrule on the proposed redac\n\ncan,\n\nredactions.\n\nThe government\n\ndefense 13,\n\nto discuss all\n\nDaubert motion.\n\nthis morning,\n\nto the bulk of\n\nthank counsel\n\nSo\n\nincluding some that\n\nthe same process going\n\nAs\n\n[ will\n\nfor that,\n\nimmediat\n\nforward so as no\n\nfF materials related to pretrial\n\nfiled\n\nI will discuss\n\ntoday,\n\ntions as quickly as\n\nfilings.\n\nas well as the submission to me of\n\naccess to the documents.\n\nbut we will use\n\nt to delay public access\n\nAnd I\n\nthe\n\nunredacted versions with the color coding indicating requested\n\n11 motions\n\nhold a Daubert hearing bet\n\nthat motion.\n\nAs to\n\nthere's a lot of ground to cover.\n\nthe motions now with the exception of\n\nin limine and the\n\nam prepared\n\nthe\n\nindicated in an order that was docketed\n\nFore resolving\n\nfurther\n\nFrom the\n\nSOUTH\n\nthe rest, some I want to hear\nFERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007054\n\n", "char_count": 1557}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\nparties on issues, s\n\ndiscussion.\n\nFor all of\n\nDocument 465\n\nome\n\nor give guidance today,\n\nwill reserve.\n\nOf course,\n\npreliminary rulings based on what\n\nanticipated\n\nto guide the parties in advance of\n\nvidenc\n\nas with all\n\nthem,\n\n[ will\n\nF In some cases, by necessity, I\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 4of127 4\n\nI'm prepared to resolve without further\n\nto the extent I can resolve them\n\nin limine motions, those are\n\nand arguments.\n\nstatements and the like.\n\nknow now about the\n\nMy preliminary rulings are\n\nFacts on\n\ntrial, to guide opening\n\nthe ground, of course, can\n\nchange during trial and you must reraise issues if you think\n\nthe other side has opened the door or that premises of certain\n\npretrial holdings no longer hold.\n\nWith\n\nbegin with the defendant's 12th mot\n\ninvolves terminol\n\nthat motion\n\nthat,\n\nand then address the remaining deft\n\nasked the Court to preclude use of\n\n\"minor victim.\n\nuse the word\n\nIn the det\n\n\" The mot\n\n\"victim\" ;\n\nto be a victim o%\n\nlogy questions tha\n\nfendant's 12th mot\n\nI'm going to move slightly out of order and\n\ntion in limine because it\n\napply throughout. After\n\n[ will address the government's motions in order\n\nfFense motions in order.\n\ntion in limine, the defens\n\nwere, at the relevant time period,\n\nAs my colleague,\n\nthe terms \"victim\" and\n\ntion is denied. Government counsel can\n\nf they're referring to someone alleged\n\nF the crimes charged in the indictment, and\n\nthey may use the word \"minor\" to describe individuals that\n\nunder the age of consent.\n\nJudge Furman, has explained,\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORTERS, PwC.\n\n(212)\n\n805-\n\n0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007055\n\n", "char_count": 1705}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page5of127 5\nLB1TMAX1\n\n1 precluding the term \"victim\" is both unnecessary and\n\n2 imoractical. United States v. Dupigny, 18 CR 528, transcript\n\n3 of October 17, 2019, Docket No. 198 at 50. It is appropriate\n\n4 for the government to use the terms as representative of its\n\n5 litigating position. If the government does this in any way\n\n6 that is atypical or unduly prejudicial, I will revisit.\n\n7 Defense only cites out-of-circuit or state court\n\n8 decisions for the proposition that those terms are inherently\n\n9 prejudicial and harm the presumption of innocence. Numerous\n\n10 courts of appeal disagree with that argument, particularly when\n11 the presentation of evidence and the court's instructions\n\n12 \"taken as a whole clarify the government's burden of proving\n\n13 all elements of the crime.\" United States v. Washburn, 444\n\n14 F.3d, 1007, 1113 (8th Cir. 2006); see also, Server v. Mizell,\n15 902 F.2d 611, 615, (7th Cir. 1990); United States v. Granbois,\n16 119 F.App'x 35, 38-39 (9th Cir. 2004).\n\n17 Defendant's lone district court opinion does not tip\n18 the balance of this authority. I will, of course, instruct the\n19 jury repeatedly that the defendant is presumed innocent and\n20 that it is the government's burden and the government's burden\n21 alone to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Those\n22 instructions will eliminate any potential prejudice. See again\n23 Judge Furman's decision in Dupigny, Docket No. 198 at 49\n24 That matter resolved, I will turn to the government's\n25 first motion. This goes to pseudonyms. The government moves\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007056\n", "char_count": 1677}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB1TMAX1\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\npursuant to the Crime Victims Rights Act,\n\nPage 6 of 127 6\n\n18 USC Section 3771,\n\nto permit certain witnesses and certain non-testifying\n\nwitnesses to be re\n\nthe issue of\n\nor specifically iden\n\ntifying in\n\nferred to by pseudonyms.\n\nAnd there is also\n\ngovernment requests\n\npseudonyms or their\n\nThe defense is already aware of\n\nof these individuals\n\njury will also be aware of\n\nThe request only implicates how those individual\n\nto in open court.\n\nThis\n\nformation.\n\nfirst name.\n\nredacting related exhibits that contain the names\n\nthe\n\nSpecifically,\n\nthat eight individuals be referred to by\n\nthe identities of all\n, and as the government proposes it, the\nindividuals' real identities.\n\nthe\n\nis w\n\nFol\n\nrequest for the\n\nThe burden to justit\n\nstarts with the government.\n\nlimitation.\"\n\nat *l,\n\nan Eastern\n\n421 F.2d 1283\n\ns are referred\n\nll-tread territory,\n\nlowing reasons:\n\nfy this\n\nIt \"mus\n\nUnited States v. Marcus,\n\nMarti,\n\nhere would protect\n\nharassment\n\nother adverse consequences.\n\n(2d Cir.\n\nfrom the media and others,\n\n1970).\n\nthe alleged victims\n\nto protect the dignity and privacy of\n\nand I\n\ntype of\n\nt provide a reason\n\nwhich is 2007 WL\n\nagree with the government that\n\nalleged victims.\n\nthe\n\nwill grant\n\nrequest, of course,\n\nfor the\n\n330388\n\nDistrict decision citing United States v.\n\nlimiting disclosure\n\nfrom potential\nundue embarrassment and\nThe Court has an obligation under\n\nthe Crime Victims Rights Act to take certain measures at trial\n\n18 USC\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\np PiGe\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007057\n", "char_count": 1719}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\na\n=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB1TMAX1\n\nSection 3771(a) (8).\n\nthat have garnered media at\n\nallegations of\n\npseudonyms or\n\nIt is quite common\n\nsex abuse,\n\nfirst names.\n\nDocument 465\n\nfor alleged victims,\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nto tes\n\nCour\n\ns have allowed this\n\nts or adult\n\nnot the alleged victims are minors or adul\n\ntestifying about abuse that allegedly occurred when\n\nminors.\n\nPage 7 of 127 7\n\nboth in cases\nttention and those involving\n\nify or be referred to by\n\nwhether or\n\nLS\n\nLet me give a bit of a\n\nexample,\n\npublicity trial\n\nUnited States v. Kelly,\n\nSs\n\ntring cite here.\n\nNo. 19 CR 286,\n\ninvolving adults\n\nminors,\n\nStates v. Raniere,\n\ninvolving at least one adult\n\nand that's in the\n\nNo.\n\nBastern\n\n18 CR 204\n\ntd\n\nSee,\n\nDistrict of New York;\n\nthey wer\n\nfor\n\nwhich is a high\n\ntestifying about sex abuse as\n\nUnited\n\na high-publicity trial\n\ntesti\n\nfying about sex abuse as\n\nminor; United States v. Dupigny, No. 18 CR 528, involving sex\ntrafficking, United States v. Kelly, No. 7 CR 374, and that\ncould be found at 2008 WL 5068820, which is an Eastern District\n\ncase involving an adult testi\n\nUnited States v.\n\n6161292 (S.D.N.Y.,\n\ntestifying about sex\n\nGardner, No.\n\nDistrict case\n\nGraham,\n\nOctober 201\n\n16 CR 20]\n\nNo.\n\n)\n\nCra\n\nBay\n\nfrom 2016\n\nfying about sex ab\n\n14 CR 500,\n\nta\n\nFficking as minors;\n\nfound at 2016 WL 5404207,\n\nfound at\n\n2015\n\nuse aS a minor;\n\nWL\n\nthat involved adults\n\nan\n\nUnited States v.\n\nFastern\n\ninvolving adults and adults testifying\n\nabout sex abuse as a minor,\n\nand col]\n\nee\n\nting similar cases.\n\nThe practice has been widely permitted because\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n(212)\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.C.\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007058\n\n", "char_count": 1739}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "ay\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB1TMAX1\n\nDocument 465\n\nrequiring alleged victims to publicl\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\ntheir willingness to testify for\n\nchill\n\nfear of\n\npersonal histories publicized. Raniere,\n\nGiven the sensitive and inflammatory nature of\n\nconduct alleged, such publicity may cause\n\nembarrassment,\n\nforward.\n\ndeterred from coming See,\n\nma\n\n-D.N.Y. 2017), Docket No. 34.\n\nLimiting the disclosure of alleged victims'\n\nand other alleged victims of\n\nMartinez,\n\nDocket No.\n\nPage 8 of 127 8\n\ny provide their names could\n\nfF having their\n\n622 at 32.\n\nthe\n\nfurther harassment or\n\nsex crimes may be\n\n17 CR 281,\n\nidentities\n\nin this case\n\ntrue with the identities of\n\nalleged victims themselves, becaus\n\nidentities would necessarily reveal the\n\nfurthers these important interests.\n\ncertain witnesses,\n\nthe disclosure of\n\nThe same is\n\nalthough not\n\ntheir\n\nidentities of\n\nthe\n\nalleged victims.\n\nFirst, the defens\n\nthe contrary.\n\nnot pose a threat to any of\n\ntrue,\n\notherwise, but just because that reason\n\ndisclosures\n\npossibility of other justifications.\n\nneed here to prevent undue embarrassment,\n\npress and third parties,\n\nforward and report alleged abuse.\n\nsufficient\n\nnotes that Ms.\n\nthe witnesses.\n\nfor limitin\n\nis absent in this case does not elimina\n\nAnd again, th\n\nand any resistance of\n\nThat is\n\nharassmen\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\nothers\n\nI'm not persuaded by defense counsel's arguments to\n\nMaxwell does\n\nplainly\n\nand the government does not argue or suggest or allege\n\ng\n\nte the\n\nere is a\n\nt from the\n\nCO come\n\nCases establish that this is\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007059\n\n", "char_count": 1658}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB1TMAX1\n\nMoreover,\n\nbe cured with an appropriate instruc\n\nreason for\n\nalleged victims'\n\nbe drawn against the det\n\nDocument 465\n\nany potential\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 9 of 127 9\n\nprejudice in this regard can\n\nthe precaution is regard\n\ntion explaining that the\n\nFor\n\nMy colleagues\n\nsuch an instruction\n\nprivacy,\n\nin this district and\n\nthe witnesses' and\n\nand that no inference can or should\n\nFendant because of\n\nin similar cases.\n\nthat this sort of\n\ninstruction af\n\nis\n\nfords\n\nunfounded.\n\nsympathy and credibility\"\n\nlaw will\n\nthese precautions\n\nlsewhere have used\n\nThe defense's concern\n\n*\"Court-sanctioned\n\nMy instructions on the\n\nclearly and repeatedly instruct the jury on the\n\npresumption of innocence and their sole role in assessing\n\nwitness credibility\n\nNor am LI\n\ndisclosed some of\n\npersuaded by the det\n\ndisclosure.\n\nsome victims'\n\nnames are publicly avail\n\nAs another district court has held,\n\nfense's arguments that the\nfact that some alleged victims have previously publicly\n\ntheir allegations obviates the need to limit\n\n\"Just because\n\nlable does not mean that\n\nth\n\nthe details of\n\nir\n\nDocket No.\n\nRaniere,\n\nAs\n\ncase, \"Not\n\nDeciding\n\ninvestigation or prosecut\n\nsimply making a public st\n\nall accusat\n\nto participat\n\n662 at 34\n\nxperien\n\nI acknowledged in\n\ntions an\n\ntion\n\nce are alr\n\n, n. Ll?\n\nady available.\"\n\nmy protec\n\nd public s\n\nte in or contribute\n\nis a\n\ntiv\n\norder for this\n\nfar di\n\ntatements are equal.\n\nto a criminal\n\nFferent matter than\n\ntatement relating to Ms.\n\nMaxwell or\n\nJeffrey Epstein.\" Docket No. 37 in this case at 2.\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007060\n", "char_count": 1705}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 10 of 127\n\nThe government anticipates that the alleged victims\n\nwill\n\n\"testify in explicit detail and/or be the subject of\n\nhighly sensitive and personal testimony concerning illegal\n\nsexual abuse.\n\ndisclosure of their names and specif\n\nThus,\n\nin\n\nthere's good reasons to limit\n\nformation during trial\n\nFically identifying\n\nin this highly publicized case\n\ninvolving highly sensitive issues.\"\n\nSince there is a valid reason to limit disclosure\n\nth\n\ndef\n\nthis case,\n\nthe disclosure of\n\nagainst the risks\n\nexample,\n\nns\n\nmust prof\n\nthe relevant int\n\nUnited States v. Marcus,\n\nFormation,\n\nto the witnesses.\n\nfer a particularized\nwhich is\n\nI'll cite here,\n\n10\nt public\nin\nneed for\nweighed\nfor\n\nagain citing the Second\n\nCircuit case in United States v. Marti.\n\nAs both parties acknowledge,\n\npotentially imp]\n\nicat\n\ns the def\n\nAmendment's cont\n\nthe right to cross-examine adverse witnesses.\nCircuit has identit\n\nthe public airing of\n\nFron\n\nidentii\n\nfied two central in\n\nfying in\n\nthe governmen\n\nndant's right under\n\ntation clause which guarantees det\n\nAgain referencing the Marti case,\n\nThe\n\nted, the defense is aware of\n\nthe\n\n421 F.2d 1263.\n\nfirst is not relevant her\n\nbecause, as\n\nalleged victims'\n\nth\n\na\n\nS request\n\ne Sixth\n\nendants\n\nThe Second\n\nterests defendants have in\n\nformation about witnesses.\n\n[ have\n\nnd\n\nwitnesses' identities.\nThe defendant argues that the second interest,\nhowever, is implicated. Namely, defense may need the witness\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007061\n\n", "char_count": 1641}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 11 of 127\n\n11\n\nthat\n\nThat's\n\nthe defense\n\nand witnesses'\n\nthe alleged\n\nto the credibility and elicit\n\ngovernment's\nto 18. And\nrequest to\n\nand some\n\nfF current and past\n\nFically identifying\n\nlines of\n\ninquiry\n\nlable without\n\ncan probe\n\ncareers\n\nLB1TMAX1\n1 to reveal identifying information because knowledge of\n2 information by the jury might be important to its deliberations\n3 as to the witness's credibility or knowledgability.\n4 quoting the Marti case again. In particular,\n5 argues that revealing the alleged victims'\n6 identities is necessary to probe the nature of\n7 victims' occupations as relevant\n8 certain impeachment evidenc\n9 I agree that such cross-examination cannot be unduly\n10 limited and the government concedes the sam The\n11 motions in limine 15, n. 6; government reply at 17\n12 [ will ensure that it is not.\n13 My decision today grants the government's\n14 Limit the public disclosure of the alleged victims\n15 witnesses' names and other specifically identifying\n16 information, such as the specific names ot\n17 emoloyers, names of family members and addresses.\n18 Limiting disclosure of the speci:\n19 information does not limit the anticipated cross-examination\n20 that the defense described in its papers. All\n21 the defense outlined in its response are avail\n22 disclosing specific names of employers or other specifically\n23 identifying information. For example, the defens\n24 the genre, nature, and trajectories of witnesses'\n25 without eliciting the specific employer name,\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT R\n\nG\n\nPORT\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nBRS, Pes\n\nbut the defense's\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007062\n\n", "char_count": 1657}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465_ Filed 11/15/21 Page12 of 127 12\nLB1TMAX1\n\n1 cross-examination should not include specifically identifying\n\n2 information, and counsel must act responsibly doing so. If,\n\n3 after good faith effort in that regard is made and the defense\n4 at some point feels they have hit a wall and can articulate a\n\n5 specific need with respect to a particular line of questioning,\n6 they can reraise the issue with opposing counsel and with me.\n\n7 So that's my ruling on that motion. That said, I do\n\n8 strongly encourage the government to speak candidly with the\n\n9 anticipated witnesses so that they're clear eyed about what\n10 this process will entail, the fact that cross-examination will\n11 not be curtailed beyond the specific identifying information\n12 that form the basis of the government's request, and the\n\n13 possibility that despite these measures their identities may\n\n14 become known and revealed to the public.\n\n15 Should any of those witnesses or the government choose\n16 not to proceed by pseudonym, the government shall let defense\n17 counsel and the Court know. In the meantime, the government\n\n18 and defense counsel shall confer about names that will be used\n19 and any additional process for facilitating the clear\n20 presentation of evidence. The Court will adopt a clear and\n21 straightforward approach and the parties are admonished to come\n22 to agreement on the use of pseudonyms and/or first names.\n23 First assignment, there will be others, by November 10\n24 the parties shall submit a joint letter to the Court under seal\n25 explaining the nomenclature that they propose be employed with\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTRIC\n\nIT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007063\n\n", "char_count": 1715}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page13 of 127 13\nLB1TMAX1\n\n1 respect to the actual identity of each witness.\n\n2 As I mentioned, I do agree with the government that a\n3 limiting instruction explaining the reasons for the precautions\n4 is appropriate. In light of my ruling, I expect the parties to\n5) confer and jointly propose such a Limiting instruction.\n\n6 Homework No. 2. This shall also be filed jointly by\n\n7 November 10, and that can be filed on ECF.\n\n8 There are some logistics of voir dire related to this.\n9 Some of my colleagues have used the list method that the\n\n10 government proposes on page 15, footnote 5 of their motion, and\n11 agree that this proposal makes sense. Once again, the\n\n12 parties shall confer and submit on ECF by November 10 a joint\n13 proposal for any logistical issues related to this for voir\n\n14 dire.\n\n15 That leaves the issue of sealing unredacted exhibits\n16 and the Limited redacting of exhibits containing specific\n\n17 personal identifying information. The government shall manage\n18 the logistics of this process throughout trial. So think\n\n19 through and include in your November 10 submission on ECF the\n20 specifics of this part of the process so that the trial\n21 exhibits can be contemporaneously marked with the appropriate\n22 limited redactions, and the government will need to manage this\n23 on an ongoing basis throughout trial.\n24 Government's motion 2, the alleged victims' prior\n25 consistent statements. So this goes to the admissibility of\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPORTERS, PwC.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007064\n", "char_count": 1589}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\nany alleged victims'\n\ntell\n\ntime.\n\nMs.\n\nany such statements in the government's openings,\n\ncorrect?\n\nMS.\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nto resolve now.\n\nDocument 465\n\nfrom the cross papers here, I\n\nMoe,\n\nMOE:\n\nCOURT:\n\nlet me cont\n\nOkay. Of\n\nprior consisten\n\narguments and the purpose\n\noffered.\n\npapers,\n\nRule 801(d) (1) (\n\nB) (i)\n\nIf this does become an issue,\n\nhearsay a wit\n\nthe charge of\n\nmotive. Of\n\ncourse,\n\nrecent\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nprior consistent s\n\nThe government's reply notes it\n\nto admit any particular prior consistent s\n\nThat's correct,\n\ncourse,\n\nI think the parties agree on\nas they\n\nexcludes\n\ndon't think\n\nPage 14 of 127\n\ntatements.\n\n\"s\n\n14\n\nAs I can\n\nthere's an issue\n\nnot seeking\n\nfirm there will be no mention of\n\nyour Honor.\n\ntatements at\n\nthis\n\nis that\n\nthe admissibility of\n\nany\n\nt statement hinges on defense counsel's\n\nfor which any statements are being\n\nthe applicable law here.\nhave outlined in their\n\nfrom the rule against\n\ntness's prior consistent s\n\nfabrication or improper inf\n\ntatement of\n\nFered to rebut\n\ngovernment s\n\nbe\n\nhas no relevance in rebutting the\n\nU.S.,\n\nTh\n\nfore the motive to\n\n513 U.S.\n\n150,\n\nrul\n\nstatements\n\nfabricate tha\n\n(1995).\n\nluence or\n\nthe prior consistent statement,\n\nt's alleged arose,\n\nfabrication charge.\n\n\"s second subsection excludes prior\n\nshould the\n\nk to have any admitted, must have been made\n\nor else it\n\nTome v.\n\nconsistent\n\nfrom the rule against hearsay when they're offered\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\nBRS, Pes\n\n(212)\n\n805-\n\n0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007065\n\n", "char_count": 1595}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 15 of 127 15\nLB1TMAX1\n\nto rehabilitate a witness attacked on another ground. It's\n\n801(d) (1) (B) (ii). For example, the statement could be admitted\n\nto explain what would otherwise appear to be an inconsistency\n\nin the witness's statement and rebut a charge of faulty memory.\n\nUnited States v. Purcell, 967 F.3d 159, (2d Cir. 2020).\n\nit becomes relevant, the government may offer prior\n\nstatements before the witness testifies if the defense attacks\n\nthe credibility in opening statements and it's clear that the\n\nwitness will be subject to cross-examination. United States v.\n\nFlores, 945 F.3d 687, (2d Cir. 2019). That's restating the\n\napplicable law here that the parties appear to agree to in the\n\nbriefs. The government doesn't anticipate any such effort to\n\noffer such statements at this time and won't mention any in\n\nopening beyond that.\n\nIs there anything specific to flag or discuss here,\n\nfrom the government's perspective?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nEe]\n\nNo, your Honor, thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Sternheim?\n\nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, Laura Menninger. None for\n\nthe defense at this time. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: All right. Thank you.\n\nThe government's 3 and 4, which I'm going to group,\n\nthe government seeks to preclud vidence and arguments by the\n\ndefense, (1) about the investigation in Florida, including the\n\nnon-prosecution agreement, (2) that Ms. Maxwell was not charged\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007066\n", "char_count": 1617}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nNO\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 16 of 127 16\nLB1TMAX1\n\nby the U.S. Attorney's Office in the Southern District of\n\nFlorida, (3) about the scope and timeline of investigation in\n\nNew York, and (4) other evidence that demonstrates the\n\ngovernment's motives for investigating Ms. Maxwell.\n\nThe Court's analysis here is guided by four principles\n\nset by the Second Circuit and the Supreme Court.\n\nFirst, because the government has no duty to employ,\n\nin the course of a single investigation, any particular\n\ninvestigative technique, the failure to utilize some particular\n\ntechnique does not tend to show that a defendant is not guilty\n\nof the crime of which he's been charged and is therefore\n\nirrelevant. United States v. Saldarriaga, 204 F.3d 50, (2d\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCir. 2000). That's the first legal principle that frames the\n\ndiscussion here.\n\nSecond, arguments that the government had an improper\n\nmotive generally must be directed to the Court rather than the\n\njury. United States v. Regan, 103 F.3d 1072, (2d Cir. 1997);\n\nsee also, United States v. Farhane, 634 F.3d 127 (2d Cir.\n2011).\n\nThird legal principle: There is no per se bar on\n\nadmitting evidence of the government's charging decisions.\n\nRather, the Court must -- I will quote here -- \"inquire into\n\nits relevance and probative value to the respective case.\"\n\nUnited States v. White, 692 F.3d 235 (2d Cir. 2012); see also,\n\nUnited States v. Ngono, 801 F.App'x. 19 (2d Cir. 2020).\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007067\n", "char_count": 1641}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page17 of 127 17\nLB1TMAX1\n\n1 Fourth, the confrontation clause of the Sixth\n\n2 Amendment guarantees a criminal defendant the right to\n\n3 meaningful cross-examination of government witnesses at trial.\n4 United States v. Figueroa, 548 F.3d 222, (2d Cir. 2008).\n\n5 Indeed, cross-examination is the principal means by which the\n\n6 believability of a witness and the truth of his testimony are\n\n7 tested. Davis v. Alaska, 415 U.S. 308, 316, (1974).\n\n8 With this legal framework in mind, and in light of the\n9 parties' extensive briefing on these issues, I think the\n\n10 admissibility of some of the proposed evidence can be\n\n11 determined now, but the admissibility of other evidence will\n\n12 require additional facts and the context of trial to decide,\n\n13 but I think it's important for me to give guidance.\n\n14 Based on the papers before me, I provide the following\n15 guidance: First, the Court will preclude affirmative evidence\n16 by the defense that goes to the thoroughness of the\n\n17 investigation. Although evidence that goes to the thoroughness\n18 of the government's investigation can in some cases be relevant\n19 and may in some cases be admissible, it's not relevant or\n20 admissible if not probative of the defendant's guilt of the\n21 crimes charged.\n22 In its briefing, the defense relies heavily on Kyles\n23 v. Whitley, 514 U.S. 4 (1995), in which the Supreme Court held\n24 that an informant's statements to police were material for\n25 purposes of Brady disclosures because the statements could be\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007068\n", "char_count": 1629}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page18 of 127 18\nLB1TMAX1\n\nused to \"attack the thoroughness and even the good faith of the\n\ninvestigation.\"\n\nThat holding has only limited relevance here. First,\n\nthe statement at issue in Kyles was probative because it\n\nsuggested the defendant's innocence, not because it was\n\nevidence of the reasons for the charging decision or the\ninvestigation's timeline.\n\nSecond, the Second Circuit in Watson v. Greene\n\nnarrowly construed the holding in Kyles by clarifying that it\n\n\"addresses only the prosecution's obligations to disclose Brady\n\nmaterial\" and \"provides no guidance about what evidence must be\n\nadmitted at trial or what lines of questioning must be\n\npermitted to ensure a meaningful opportunity to cross-examine\n\nadverse witnesses.\" Watson v. Greene, 640 F.3d 501, 512, n. 11\n\n(2d Cir. 2011).\n\nNow the Second Circuit's decision in Watson does,\n\nhowever, suggest that some arguments about the thoroughness of\n\nthe investigation are probative of guilt in some circumstances.\n\nIn that case, law enforcement had received a tip that the\n\ndefendant was innocent because another individual shot the\n\nvictim. The Second Circuit stated that cross-examination of\n\nthe lead investigating officer on that tip was probative\n\nbecause the jury could conclude that law enforcement had\n\nprematurely concluded the defendant was the shooter and it\n\nfailed to investigate diligently the possibility that it was\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007069\n", "char_count": 1638}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 19 of 127 19\nLB1TMAX1\n\nthe other individual. Watson, 640 F.3d, 511-12.\n\nOther courts in this Circuit have described challenges\n\nto the thoroughness of the investigation as a \"common method of\n\nundermining a prosecution\" by, for example, cross-examining\n\nofficers on which leads they followed and which they did not.\n\nSee, for example, Gray v. Ercole -— I don't have that full\n\nquote —- 2011 WL 5082868 (\n\nts\n\n-D.N.Y 2008). Or defense counsel\n\nmay, on cross, examine investigating officers if they\n\nconsidered alternative suspects. United States v. Birbal, 92\n\nCR 98, 1996 WL 192924 at *7, that's the District of the\n\nVermont, 1996. That was affirmed by the Second Circuit at 113\n\nF.3d 1230. And I will quote here, \"The length of the\n\ninvestigation, the investigative techniques used, and the fact\n\nthat the defendant was not initially a target of the\n\ninvestigation are all irrelevant pursuant to\" the principle\n\nthat the government's failure to use particular investigative\n\ntechniques does not tend to show that the defendant is not\nguilty. See, for example, United States v. Duncan, No. 18 CR\n\n289, 2019 WL 2210663 (S.D.N.Y. 2019); see also, United States\n\nV. Aleynikov, 785 F.Supp.2d 46, 65 (S.D.N.Y. 2011).\n\nThe other two cases the defense cites, neither of\n\nwhich is binding on the Court, don't suggest anything different\n\nthan the law I just referred to. In Bowen v. Maynard, the 10th\n\nCircuit held that Brady evidence in the government's possession\n\nwas material because it suggested that another likely suspect\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007070\n", "char_count": 1759}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 20 of 127\n\n20\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\n1 did not have an alibi and suggested that a photo lineup was\n\n2 unduly suggestive. 799 F.2d 593, (10th Cir. 1986). The court\n8 stated that, if disclosed, \"the defense could have\n\n4 cross-examined the detectives about their decision to use the\n\n5 photographs\" that they did as well about their failure to\n\n6 corroborate the other suspect's alibi.\n\n7 And the defense cites another Brady violation in\n\n8 Lindsey v. King where the Fifth Circuit found that a police\n\n9 report was material under Brady because it showed key witnesses\n10 to a murder had changed their story, which on cross-examination\n11 would have meant the destruction of the witness's\n12 identification and the discrediting in some degree of the\n13 police methods employed in assembling the case against the\n\n14 defendant. Lindsey v. King, 769 F.2d 1034, (5th Cir. 1985).\n\n15 These two examples of focused cross-examination to\n\n16 impeach a witness that testified to the defendant's guilt and\n17 thereby throw the product of the government's investigation\n\n18 into doubt are far afield from the specifics of what the\n\n19 defense proposed here. In its brief, the defense seeks to\n20 affirmatively -- and I will quote from their brief -- \"call FB\nal case agents as witnesses\" to ask who they talked to, what\n22 documents they subpoenaed, and when. See, defense's response\n23 at 40. But as the Second Circuit explained in Saldarriaga, the\n24 government's use or non-use of certain investigative techniques\n25 does not tend to show the defendant's innocence of the charges.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.\n(212%) 805-0220\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007071\n\n", "char_count": 1686}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 21 of127 21\nLB1TMAX1\n\n1 The defense also seeks to elicit evidence of the\n\n2 public outcry and scrutiny that preceded the decision to charge\n3 the defendant. The defense refers to public statements made by\n4 assistant United States attorneys -- not those appearing in the\n5) case -- to suggest that Ms. Maxwell was charged for improper\n\n6 reasons.\n\n7 The Court finds that this specific proffered evidenc\n\n8 is irrelevant to the charged conduct and, therefore,\n\n9 inadmissible.\n10 To the extent that the defense's affirmative evidence\n11 in this regard would have some marginal probative value, it is\n12 substantially outweighed by 403 prejudice. See, for example,\n13 United States v. Hill, 12 CR 214, 2014 WL 198813 (E.D.N.Y.\n\n14 2014), affirmed by the Second Circuit, 658 Fed. Appx. 600.\n\n15 Here's the reason for that 403 analysis:\n\n16 First, investigative details are likely to confuse the\n17 jury about the proper standard for determining Ms. Maxwell's\n\n18 guilt by suggesting that the government's choices of\n\n19 investigative techniques are relevant to whether guilt is\n20 proved beyond a reasonable doubt. Moreover, I will instruct\n21 jurors, as is standard, to the effect that the government is\n22 not on trial. And that standard charge can be found in many\n23 cases. Admitting testimony on the investigation would confuse\n24 the jury once it's received that instruction.\n25 Second, these lines of argument are likely to\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n(212)\n\nCT REPORTERS,\n805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007072\n\n", "char_count": 1557}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465_ Filed 11/15/21 Page 22 of 127 22\nLB1TMAX1\n\nsubstantially confuse and delay the trial. The evidence\n\noutlined in the defense's papers, including who was interviewed\n\nand when, what documents were subpoenaed and other details of\n\ninvestigations in two different states and different time\n\nperiods would substantially expand the scope of the trial.\n\nExactly what steps investigators took is not a simple question,\n\nof course. The government would likely present a contrary\n\naccount of events, leading to trials within trials on what law\n\nenforcement did over the course of years. This prejudice would\n\nsubstantially outweigh any minimum probative value that might\n\nbe gained from such a far-flung endeavor.\n\nThird, as to prejudice, th vidence would be\n\ncumulative, demonstrating that an investigation was \"hasty\" and\n\nnot thorough is at best repetitive of the defense's arguments\n\nthat the government collected insufficient evidence of guilt.\n\nThat point is made most clearly and directly by focusing on the\n\nevidence or lack of evidence and credibility or lack of\n\ncredibility of the witnesses presented at trial.\n\nThe second piece of guidance I can provide now is that\n\nthe Court will exclude much of the evidence outlined in the\n\ndefense's papers of the government's alleged motives for\n\ninvestigating and charging Ms. Maxwell. This evidence includes\n\nbut is not limited to the Miami Herald article, statements from\n\nAttorney General William Barr and the like.\n\nTh vidence presented by the government in this trial\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007073\n", "char_count": 1689}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB1TMAX1\n\nis the relevant basis\n\ninnocence. J\n\ninvestigation\n\ngovernment ha\n\nDocument 465\n\n1s not relevant.\n\nIf th\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 23 of 127 23\n\nfor the jury's determination of guilt or\n\ndef\n\nhy and when the government conducted the\n\nbelieves th\n\nns\n\ns a legally improper motive for prosecuting\n\nMs.\n\nMaxwell or somehow\n\nth\n\nperjury or the Like,\nproper remedy is to\n\nSee, Regan,\n\nfor purposes of\n\nUnited States v.\n\nKnox,\n\n103 F.3d 1082.\nthe jury,\n\n687 F.App!x 51,\n\nSecond Circuit\n\nfile a motion\n\nfor\n\nAbsent that\n\nt, th\n\ne\n\nfabricating evidence or suborning\nt has made clear that the\n\nthe Court to consider.\n\nlaw is clear that\n\n\"the government is not on trial.\"\n\nMoreover,\n\nvidence o\n\nprejudicial.\n\nwou\n\napplied in the case.\n\nof improper motives\n\nis strongly suggestive of\n\nFor the reasons\n\nIndeed, the det\n\n(2d Cir.\n\n2017).\n\nI explained a moment ago,\nld confuse jurors as to the proper standard of\n\nfFense's outlined\n\nf motive would be highly\n\nit\n\nguilt to be\n\nvidenc\n\njury\n\nnullification because it suggests a vindictive or political\n\nprosecution which is rightly a mat\n\nCalling witnesses to tes\nmotive would substantially expand the scope of trial,\n\nlikely on hearsay and other\n\nne\n\ninadmissible evidence.\n\ntter reserved to the Court.\n\nfy to the government's\n\nrely\n\nSo what\n\nmotivated a particular investigative step or charging decision\n\nof course doesn't\n\nwould have one story and the government another,\n\nwhich would assist of\n\nor innocence of\n\nthe charges her\n\nbased on of\n\nhave a black or white answer,\n\nthe jury in deciding Ms.\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nLD\n\nand the defense\n\nneither of\n\nMaxwell's guilt\n\nthe government's\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007074\n", "char_count": 1824}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\nDocument 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 24 of 127 24\n\nability to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.\n\nThird piece of guidance: The Court will exclude from\n\nvidence the non-prosecution agreement, both its existence and\n\nits particular terms.\n\nto the bias and\n\nfinancial\n\nThe defense argues the NPA is relevant\n\ninterest of two witnesses. One\n\nanticipated witness received immunity from criminal prosecution\n\nunder the NPA.\n\nAdditional]\n\ny, under the NPA, Epstein agreed to\n\npay for a lawyer\n\nfor an al\n\nleged victim who was anticipated to\n\ntestify and agreed not to contest her civil suit against him.\n\nThe civil suit ended in a settlement with respect to an alleged\n\nvictim.\n\nwitnesses about\n\nOf course, defendants are always able to cross-examine\n\nrelevant bias. For example, cross-examination\n\nabout civil litigation or civil claims against Epstein or\n\nothers and related financi\n\nal incentive are fair grounds.\n\nMoreover, cooperating witnesses are commonly cross-examined\n\nabout how testimony may af\n\nfect the sentence that they receive.\n\nAnd if it were the case that any witness were to receive\n\ntestimonial immunity in this case, the defense may\n\ncross-examine about that.\n\nany bias or incentive to f\n\nto the NPA. Regardless of\n\nmight testify, th\n\nin the Southern\n\nBut the defense has not explained\n\nabricate that results from or relates\n\nhow the witness covered by the NPA\n\nat witness will remain protected under the NPA\n\nDistrict of Florida, and as I already ruled,\n\nthe NPA does not provide protection in the Southern District of\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007075\n\n", "char_count": 1712}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\nNew York.\n\nse\n\nno\n\nthat would be relevant that the det\n\nttlement or\n\nSimilarly,\n\nfinancial\n\nt received under the N\n\nrespect to the NPA.\n\nbe\n\nprejudice\n\nMoreover,\n\neven\n\ni\n\nPA,\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nincentive tes\n\nSO\n\nf ther\n\nIT don't\n\ntifies,\n\nsee any theory of\n\nPage 25 of 127\n\nno matter how a witness who has a\n\nthose benef\n\nlevance, it\n\nwer som r\n\nsubstantially outweighed by a significant\n\nfrom int\n\ninstructed on what th\nneed to have i\ncourse,\nbackground.\nand improper suggestions of\n\nthe jury on the basis of\n\nnever be admitted, but the ra\n\nde\n\nbal\n\nare likely not\n\ngovernment\n\n1s cont\n\n40]\n\nCS\n\nand 403\n\nancing of\n\nThere's a risk of\n\nI will be clear,\n\nfense in its papers does no\n\nFourth guidance:\n\ninvestigation,\n\nwhen it indicted Jef\n\nthe Second Circuit s'\n\nrelevant and therefore\n\nand\n\nrey\n\nt didn't indict Ms.\n\nterms explained.\n\nthe NPA.\n\ntroducing the NPA.\n\nundue delay,\n\nnon-prosecution agreement is,\n\n403\n\nrisk of\n\nIn particular, NPA, o\n\nsympathy or nullit\n\n25\n\nits are\n\nbias\n\nfense has articulated with\n\nwould\n\nThe jury would need to be\n\nand would\n\ntroversial and complicated and has a complicated\n\njuror confus\n\nit's not clear to me the NPA c\n\nt justi\n\nfactors.\n\ntionale now provided by the\n\nion,\n\nfication made to\n\nould\n\nfy admission based on the\n\nThe government's charging decisions\n\ninadmissible.\n\nThe\n\nMaxwell by the end of\nthe government didn't indict Ms.\n\nEpstein originally in New\n\ntated in White,\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT\n\nRE\n\nPORT\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nBRS, P.\n\nthe F\n\nYork.\n\nDOJ\n\nlorida\n\nMaxwell\n\nAs\n\ncharging decisions can be\n\n-OGR-00007076\n", "char_count": 1725}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "=\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\na\n=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465 _ Filed 11/15/21\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\nadmissibl\n\nunder t\n\nhe usual rules of\n\ncourt determined\n\nrelevance\n\nPage 26 of 127 26\n\n‘ In White, the\n\nthat a prior charging decision was admissible\n\nbecause it bore directly on the credibility of a witness that\n\ntestified at the defendant's trial.\n\nAs currently pro\n\nfered by the defens\n\n, the rationale\n\ndoesn't apply here. For example, according to the defense, an\n\nalleged victim's statement to the F\n\nimplicate or exculpate Ms. Maxwell,\n\ndoes imolicate her. On the basis o\n\nassumedly other evidence available\n\nreasons, O\n\nfficials\n\nin the Southern\n\nBI previously did not\n\nbut her st\n\ntLatement today\n\n£ that sta\n\nto them and a host of\n\ntement, and\n\nDistrPiét of\n\nFlorida decided\n\nto not indict Ms.\n\ncould be understood as a determination\ngovernment lacked sufficient evidenc\n\nbut the decision not\n\nof a host of reaso\n\nMaxwell at that time. That\n\ncharging decision\n\nthat in 2008 the\nof Ms. Maxwell's guilt,\n\nto charge -- or it could mean any number\n\nns, but the decision not to charge has little\n\nprobative value that the Court can see as to this case.\n\nCharging decisions, as I said,\n\nare made for a host of\n\nreasons. Trying to sort through those reasons would be\n\nprejudicial\n\npursuant to 403 both because they would require\n\nsignificant time to explore and because juror confusion would\n\nbe likely.\n\nAny consideration of\n\nF the government's decisions\n\nwould also likely rely on hearsay or other inadmissible\n\nvidenc\n\n25\n\nMore importantly, unlike\n\nin White,\n\nassessments of the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT RE\n(212) 805-\n\nevidence in Flor\n\nthose officials'\n\nida in 2008 is not relevant\n\n0300\n\nPORTERS, P.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007077\n\n", "char_count": 1793}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 27 of 127 27\nLB1TMAX1\n\nto the jury's decision now, which is whether there is evidenc\n\nof Ms. Maxwell's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt as the\n\ngovernment will put its case to the jury.\n\nNow there is a difference between admitting a witness'\n\nprior statements for impeachment purposes, which is protected\n\nby the confrontation clause, and admitting prior charging\n\ndecisions. In a case analogous to this one on this issue,\n\nUnited States v. Borrero, another district court judge held\n\nthat a defendant could permissibly cross-examine a witness\n\nabout their prior statement to law enforcement in which they\n\naccused a different individual of the crime for which the\n\ndefendant was later charged. 2013 WL 6020773 (S.D.N.Y. 2013).\n\nThat case docket is 13 CR 58. But the court there did not\n\nadmit the charging decision that the early investigation had\n\nended in a nolle, because it would confuse jurors, require\n\nextended factual disputes, and was, at best, cumulative of the\n\nwitness's statement. As I have explained, the same would\n\nappear to be true her\n\nFifth piece of guidance: In contrast to what\nindicated may not come in, the Court will permit relevant\ncross-examination of the government's witnesses. Defense seeks\n\nto impeach the credibility of some witnesses by admitting those\n\nwitnesses' prior statements to the government that purportedly\n\ndid not implicate Ms. Maxwell. This use of cross-examination\n\nto imoeach a witness that has allegedly changed her story to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007078\n", "char_count": 1713}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\nlaw enforcement is exactly the kind of\n\nthoroughness of the government's inves\n\nCircuit approved in Lindsey v. King.\n\nCourt concludes that this\n\nadmissible.\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 28 of 127 28\n\nattack on the\n\nlin\n\nof evid\n\nne\n\ntigation\n\nProvided\n\nthat the Fifth\n\nthat the rules\n\nfor admitting prior inconsistent statements are satisfied, the\n\nis relevant and\n\nThe defense may also cross-examine about witnesses'\n\nmotives or biases\n\nwitnesses' motives\n\nfor testifyi\n\nng, including,\n\nfor\n\nfor implicating Ms.\n\nEpstein's death.\n\nMaxwell a\n\nexample, the\n\nfter Jeffrey\n\nAdmitting prior statements on\n\ncross-examination may require providing the jury some\n\nbackground informa\n\nthe prior statemen\n\nevidence.\n\n(Continued on next page)\n\nSOU\n\nTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nLD\n\ntion about the prior investigations so that\n\nts are understood in the proper context and\n\nthe jury is provided necessary background to understand that\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007079\n\n", "char_count": 1118}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 29 of 127 29\nLB15MAX2\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT: (Continuing)\n\nimagine this can be done through cross-examination\n\nquestions if the witness has personal knowledge. I would also\n\nencourage the parties to discuss stipulations in this regard to\n\nprovide the jury any necessary and non-prejudicial context or\n\nbackground, or other proposals for permitting the jury to\n\nunderstand the background or context without crossing over into\n\nthe 403 prejudice line.\n\nalso would permit the defense to cross-examine law\n\nenforcement officers about the investigative steps that were\n\ntaken if the government puts the thoroughness of the\n\ninvestigation into issue as this, too, would be permissible\n\nimpeachment and cross.\n\nThese articulated lines of cross-examination of\n\ngovernment witnesses would be relevant to impeach a witness by\n\nsuggesting bias or otherwise implicating their credibility.\n\nMoreover, denying Ms. Maxwell these lines of questioning would\n\nhave implications under the confrontation clause. The Court\n\nexpects that the probative value would not be substantially\n\noutweighed by 403 prejudice if done along the lines of what\n\nhave indicated, especially if accompanied by a limiting\n\ninstruction by the Court that, for example, prior inconsistent\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nstatements are to be considered for their impeachment value and\n\nthe like.\n\nSimilarly, the Court may instruct the jury that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007080\n", "char_count": 1606}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\ncounsel made only a goo\n\nlast sentence.\n\nd\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 30 of 127 30\n\nfaith -- actually, I will retract that\n\nAt base, the Court encourages the parties to confer on\n\nappropriate process for putting background information in front\n\nof the jury, as necessary,\n\nto allow the kinds of\n\ncross—-examination that would be permissible and required under\n\nthe relevant law.\n\nLet me pause and ask counsel if they have any\n\nquestions with respect\n\ntime. Obviously there\nwe go.\n\nMs. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: Not\nyou.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNot at this time,\n\nto the guidance I have offered at this\n\nYour Honor,\n\nmay be issues we will need to take up as\n\nfrom the government, your Honor. Thank\n\nChristian Everdell.\n\nTHE COURT: Thank you.\n\nyour Honor.\n\nNo. 6, evidence that goes to consent issues.\n\nThe government requests to exclude evidence or\n\nargument regarding consent.\n\nNow let me ask counsel, it seems\n\nto me the issues implicated in this motion overlap, at least\n\npotentially, to the issues raised and to be discussed in the\n\n412 motion and I am wondering it\n\ntaking it up at that time,\n\nMS. MOE: Your\n\nfF we should at least begin by\n\nas necessary.\n\nthe government agrees that makes\n\nHonor,\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007081\n\n", "char_count": 1411}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 31 of 127 31\nLB15MAX2\nsense to address this issue at the same tim\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: We agree.\n\nTHE COURT: So we will defer on that. In light of the\noverlap on the 412 issues we will take that up at the 412\nhearing.\n\nGovernment's 7. The government argues that before\noffering evidence or argument of Ms. Maxwell's failure to\ncommit other bad acts it should require the defense to proffer\nthe basis and the relevance of such evidenc Let me hear from\n\nthe government what\n\nwill speak to the defense.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThe concern here is what\n\nthe defense has\n\nthe specific concern is here and then\n\nThank you.\n\nflagged in\n\nits opening papers relating to statements by other victims who\n\nWw\n\ninvestigation.\nopening statement,\nlaw enforcement of\n\nSuch evidence could only\n\nde\n\nissue in this case.\n\nde\n\nand until they prof\n\ncome through,\n\nfense called,\n\nfense should be precluded\n\nEvidence along those lines, i\n\nre interviewed during the course of the governmen\n\nyo prof\n\nt's\n\nfered in an\n\nficer,\n\nas defense witnesses,\n\nAnd so,\n\nfrom opening on\n\ncome in at trial, if\n\nvictims\n\nfor that reason,\n\nFer which victims these st\n\nwho\n\nat all,\n\nor 1f£ asked about in cross-examination of a\n\nwould be inappropriate and hearsay.\n\nthe\n\nif\n\nwho were not at\n\nyour Honor,\n\nthe\n\nthis issue unless\n\ntatements would\n\nthey would anticipate calling as defense\n\nwitnesses at trial so the Court can assess whether that is\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n(212)\n\nCT RE\n805-0300\n\nPORTERS, P.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007082\n\n", "char_count": 1650}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 32 of 127\nLB15MAX2\nrelevant at all.\n\nAs the government set forth in its moving papers, the\ndefendant is not charged with trafficking certain victims and\nso whether or not the defendant is guilty of those crimes is\nirrelevant before this jury.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Sternheim, any mention on opening with\n\nrespect to\nWe wi\non -—- counsel,\n\nMS. S\n\nthis line of --\n\nyour masks are\n\nll ask everyone please make sur\nfully on -- unless you are at the podium.\nTERNHEIM: Judge,\n\njust want to say that we are\n\nhonoring your one counsel rule but we have designated various\n\ntopics.\n\nTHE C\n\nMS. S\n\nOURT:\n\nAppreciate it.\n\nTERNHE\n\nM: So i\n\nTHE C\n\nMS. M\n\nwill be opening on these issues but\n\nOURT:\n\nGo ahead.\n\nENN\n\nNG\n\nBR:\n\nunderstating what is charged in\n\naccusers,\n\nclaim involves a number of\nbelieve they have prof\n\nabout unnamed individuals\n\nrather they have set\n\nYour Honor,\n\nin their exhibits,\n\nthe indictment.\n\nforth an indictment that does not just allege\nforth a conspiracy\n\nother unnamed individuals,\n\nf you will allow us?\n\nI don't believe that we\n\nI think the government is\n\nThey have put\n\nthe four main\n\nthat they\n\nand I\n\nfered an intent to put other\n\nvidenc\n\nin their trial\n\ntestimony. For example, there are a number of exhibits that\nthey've set forth that come from a time period outside of the\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\n32\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007083\n", "char_count": 1538}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 33 of 127 33\nLB15MAX2\n1 conspiracy and so forth. So it is our position that if they\n2 open the door to evidence about anyone other than these four\ni) then we would, likewise, be able to talk about the fact that\n4 those other individuals were interviewed by the government and\nby said that Ms. Maxwell is not involved, was not there, and was\n6 not a part of the activities that they're talking about. None\n7 of the cases that the government cited had to do with a\n8 co-conspirator. The evidence was just because a defendant did\n9 not act in conformity with the charged conduct on a separate\n10 occasion, couldn't be set forth by the defense.\n11 THE COURT: Do you agree with that principle?\n12 MS. MENNINGER: Yes, your Honor. If it is good\n13 character evidence, generally I understand the rules of\nvidence wouldn't apply, but what we have here is a 10-year\n15 charged conspiracy with an intent by the government to allude\n16 to other individuals. To the extent they try to put on\n17 evidence in the form of message pads or other types of evidence\n18 that refer to other people, then I think we have the ability to\n19 confront that evidence with the fact that Ms. Maxwell was\n20 reported by those individuals not to have been involved.\n21 THE COURT: Ms. Moe?\n22 MS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor.\n23 The government agrees that this issue can be deferred\n24 until trial unless and until this becomes an issue, provided\n25 the defense counsel doesn't intend to open on this issue.\n\nSOUTHERN LC\n\nSTRICT\n\nREPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 8\n\n05-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007084\n\n", "char_count": 1605}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nHowever,\n\nwould be to\n\neven if\n\nto talk about wh\n\npermit the det\n\nther the def\n\nDocument 465\n\ntheir sex tra\n\nicking.\n\nde\n\nfense\n\nfrom cross-exa\n\nThe remedy would not\n\nmining law enf\n\nhearsay sta\nwould be ext\n\nthrough law\n\nindividuals to assess whether or not\n\ntements tha\n\ntremely con\n\nfusing\n\nthis became an issue at\n\nfFense to call\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nt the trial,\n\nthese relevant\n\nPage 34\n\nof 127 34\n\nthe remedy\n\nwitnesses\n\nndant was or was not involved in\n\nForcement\n\nbe to permit\n\nagents about\n\nenforcement\n\nimplicated the def\n\nde\n\nfendant.\n\nthose witnesses\n\nAnd so,\n\nagents,\n\ndetermin\n\nthose lines,\n\nthe pot\n\nthe s\n\nthemselves and, of\nntial relevance, if\n\nand so the government\n\nthe government submits\n\nthat this could come in at trial would be if\n\ncourse, it\n\ntLatements of\n\nt other individuals provided to them. It\nfor the jury to be hearing,\n\nthese\n\nthose individuals\n\nndant or simply said nothing about the\n\nthat the only way\n\nthe defense called\n\nis diff\n\nicult to\n\nany, of\n\nrespectful\n\ntestimony along\n\nly submi\n\nts that\n\nnone of this should be offered at trial unless and until there\nis an offer of proof along those lines.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Menninger?\n\nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, whether someone said no\none else involved or didn't implicate our client is not\nhearsay, it is the absence of a statement. So I don't\nunderstand the government's position that if an investigator --\n\nTHE COURT: It is not the absence of the statement,\nright? F you are trying to put in an out-of-court statement\nfrom someone who said that Ms. Maxwell wasn't involved, it is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212%) 805-0220\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007085\n\n", "char_count": 1735}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nI\n=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nan out-of\n\nis hearsay.\n\nMS. M\n\nDocument 465\n\nENN\n\nNGER:\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nSlightly di\n\ncourt statement you are putting on\n\nFferent,\n\nenforcement\n\naccuser never said that Ms.\n\nhearsay statement.\n\nPage 35 of 127 35\n\nit\n\nfor the truth,\n\nyour Honor.\n\nIf a witness says they interviewed\n\nMaxwell was involved,\n\nThey just didn't mention her,\n\na law\n\nif\n\nsays they interviewed another accuser and that\n\nthat's not a\n\nit is the\n\nabsence of a statement. And as your Honor just ruled in terms\nof the thoroughness of the investigation, if there is evidenc\nthat the government puts on about these other accusers I think\nthat's what opens the door. It is not us opening the door, it\nwould be them submitting evidence that other people wer\nvictims without putting those people on, putting on message\npads that had their names on it, and then precluding us from\nintroducing evidence that none of those individuals implicated\nMs. Maxwell.\n\nTHE COURT: Right. So, if the government does that\n\nyou are not precluded\n\nfrom putting oth\n\nr evidenc\n\non. The\n\nquestion is what evidence would it be and would it be\n\nund\n\nr th\n\nadmissibl\n\nside intends to open with respect to this issue and I\n\nlargely agree on the\n\nmore guidance\n\nMs.\n\ncan resolve that\n\nfor purposes of\n\nrelevant rules of\n\nevidence.\n\nlegal\n\nin the abstract.\n\nMenninger?\n\nprinciples.\n\nTell me if\n\nopening or preparing\n\nam not sure\n\nIt sounds like neither\n\nthink we\n\nyou need\n\nyour case.\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT\n\nRE\n\nPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007086\n", "char_count": 1652}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 36 of 127 36\n\n. I think it depends on\n\nnk you.\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\nLB15MAX2\n\nMS. MENNINGER: No, your Honor\nthe trial testimony.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: No, your Honor. Tha\n\nTHE COURT: It sounds like th\n\ngovernment does need to\n\nthink about its opening and whether ref\nalleged victims would open the door, po\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor. An\n\ngovernment's position that, to the exte\n\n@)\n\nfFfering anything along these lines, it\n\nrence to non-testifying\n\ntentially, to the issue.\n\nd it remains the\n\nnt the defense is\n\nwould be truth\n\nfor the\n\nand, ther\n\nfore, hearsay. But given the\ndon't intend to open on this issue, we\nopening statements would open the door\n\nare happy\n\nTHE COURT: OK.\n\nMS. MOE: Thank you, your Hono\n\nTHE COURT: OK.\n\nThank you.\n\nNext is government 8 which are\n\nfact that the parties\n\ndon't believe our\n\nto this issu\n\nither, w\n\nto raise this issue at the appropriate time.\n\nEs\n\nprior statements of\n\n[ think\n\nMs. Maxwell. from\n\ncome away\n\nthe defense that this one may be premat\n\nis the specific concern? What are prio\n\nare worried about here?\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor.\n\nFor example, the government ha\n\ndefense in discovery a large volume of\n\nthe papers agreeing with\n\nure but, Ms. Moe, what\n\nr statements that you\n\ns produced to the\n\nelectronically-stored\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nBRS, Pes\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007087\n\n", "char_count": 1506}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 37 of 127 37\nLB15MAX2\n1 information including e-mails between the defendant and Jeffrey\n2 Epstein. It is difficult for the government to determine in\n3 the abstract what the defense might point to, but that night\n4 include, for example, a false exculpatory statement. And so\n5 the government's view is unless and until there is a proffer\n6 from the defense about a specific statement, that the defense\n7 should be precluded from offering a statement along those lines\n8 in opening statements or otherwise.\n9 THE COURT: Who is taking this one?\n10 MR. PAGLIUCA: Your Honor, good morning. Jeffrey\n11 Pagliuca for Ms. Maxwell.\n12 Your Honor, this is a trial time decision. It depends\n13 on what witness is testifying and whether or not there is a\n14 relevant exception to the hearsay rule. [ mean, we understand\n15 the rules, we will follow the rules, and if the witness\n16 testifies and it becomes relevant, we will ask the question.\n17 F there is an objection, the Court will resolve the objection.\n18 THE COURT: And you understand you are going to be\n19 restrained by what one might say is an asymmetry between the\n20 government's ability to use out-of-court statements by the\n21 defendant and the defense's inability to do that, absent some\n22 other -—\n23 MR. PAGLIUCA: Absolutely, your Honor.\n24 THE COURT: OK.\n25 MR. PAGLIUCA: We understand the hearsay rules.\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007088\n", "char_count": 1486}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT:\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 38 of 127 38\n\nFrom your perspective, anything further\n\nthat could be addressed at this\n\nLime or needs to be addressed?\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: On this\nTHE COURT: Yes.\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: No.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Moe?\nMS. MOE:\n\nTHE COURT: The next is\n\npreclud videnc\n\nor argument sounding in nullification.\n\ntopic your Honor?\n\nNo, your Honor. Thank you.\n\ngovernment 9 which is to\n\nagree with the defense that there is no need for me to rule on\n\nthis presently.\n\ntrust that de\n\nfense counsel knows well the\n\nclear rules around any such arguments so it is a bit hard to\n\nthink about what guidance\n\ncan offer here.\n\nis there a specific concern you want to\n\nMs. Moe,\n\nraise?\nMS. MOE Thank you, your Honor.\nAside from the examples\n\nthere is nothing in pa\n\nwe proffered in our motion,\n\nrticular that this motion is aimed at and\n\nso I don't think anything more along those lines to address\n\ntoday.\n\nMS.\n\nST\n\nERNHEIM: Nothing\n\nTHE\n\nGO\n\nat this time.\n\nURT: OK. So nothing referenced with respect to\n\nthe government's concerns about nullification would be\n\nimplicated in the anticipated opening?\n\nMS.\n\nST\n\nERNHEIM: That is\n\ncorrect.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT\n\nREPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007089\n\n", "char_count": 1372}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nTHE\n\n25\n\nCOURT:\n\npreliminary matter,\n\nDocument 465\n\nGovernment 10.\n\nof\n\nand the\n\njustify sealing.\n\ngovernment is saying that\n\nthis motion be sealed.\n\nfootnote 11 in the motion.\n\nAs best\n\nthe de\n\nmake a certain argument\n\nof it.\n\npublicity would amount to\n\nthat argument.\n\nevidence in argument\n\nway. Frankly,\n\nthe government\n\ncou\n\npra\n\nnter to the whole project o\n\nbecause ther\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nLet me say,\n\nthe government requests that the entire\nIT have read the government's let\nIn my mind they don't\nI can understand the argument\n\nfense should be precluded\n\nPage 39 of 127\n\nas a\n\nthe\n\nis right about that then pretrial\n\ncoverage that there is no evidence of\n\n39\n\nCY\n\nCer\n\nfrom\n\nis no evidence in support\n\nthe government is wrong about that then the\n\ncomes in so there is no prejudice either\n\nctice which is to li\n\npreparation and trial ef\n\nlike,\n\nwhat's in and what's out.\n\nficiency and opening s\n\nThat's going\n\nreq\n\nuire litigation\n\nSea\n\nint\n\ngov\n\nwe are going to do at trial.\n\nput\n\nthat\n\n1 this and I\n\nends to make the argument\n\nernment's motion 10.\n\nMS. STERNHE\n\nM:\n\nting on a case and I\n\nbut insofar as th\n\nae A\n\non what's\nthink we can\n\nBut let me begin by\n\nSo I\n\nout.\n\nsimply asking\n\nYour Honor,\n\nknow the governmen\n\ndon't\n\nthat is outlined in\n\ndiscuss it today.\n\nthe de\n\nt is wel\n\nsee a basis\n\nfense i\n\nthe\n\nCertainly we have no burden of\n\n[ think the theory of prejudice here runs\nF pretrial motion in limine\ntigate, for purposes of trial\n\ntatements and the\n\nto sometimes\n\nto\n\nF it\n\n1 aware of\n\nit is too soon to say what\n\ngovernment s KS\n\nto preci\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nDISTR\n\nCT RE\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nPORTERS, PwC.\n\nlude us\n\nfrom\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007090\n", "char_count": 1750}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 40 of 127 40\nLB15MAX2\n1 raising any issues concerning Ms. Maxwell, I think it is\n2 entirely premature and it will depend upon testimony from their\n3 witnesses and they know well what their witnesses have said\n4 that could support that. I don't think we need to delve into\n5 that at this point It is not anything that we are opening on.\n6 We need to see how the evidence plays out.\n7 THE COURT: OK.\n8 MS. MOE: Your Honor, if the defense is not opening on\n9 this issue we are certainly happy to raise it during the trial.\n10 We would ask that the defense be required to front this issue\n11 before asking witnesses questions about this on\n12 cross-examination because for the reasons set forth in the\n13 government's moving papers, the government submits that\nvidence along these lines would not be relevant.\n15 Briefly, your Honor, with respect to the sealing\n16 issue, the government understands the Court's concerns and\n17 would certainly not object to unseeing this portion of the\n18 motion at the conclusion of the trial but ——\n19 THE COURT: [ don't see why -- just don't see how --\n20 obviously some sealing on issues iS appropriate in order to\n21 protect interests that are in play during the course of the\n22 trial. This just doesn't fall within that. So my inclination\n23 is, no -- and I have not had the ability to go through the\n24 complicated set of sometimes overlapping, sometimes not\n25 overlapping redaction requests contained throughout these\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nBRS, P.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007091\n", "char_count": 1584}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBI5SMAX2\n\npapers which is why I\ndocket rather than deprive\n\nwhat is contained in the mot\n\na basis\n\nI don't see\n\nDocument 465\n\ntions,\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nordered you just get them\n\nthe public of seeing\n\nPage 41 of 127\n\nup on the\n\nthe bulk of\n\nbut\n\nfor sealing it in its entirety and I\n\nsee a basis\nrequest.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT:\n\nNo issue\n\nhave had a\n\nrequests,\n\napprove of\n\nfor opening.\n\neverybody understands,\n\nde\n\nand to\n\ndeal with it.\n\nMS. STE\n\nRNHE\n\nM:\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT:\n\nGovernment\n\nmotion is request\n\nde\n\ngrant this motion.\n\nprevailing party after a se\n\n11.\n\nThe\n\nWe will\n\nobviously,\n\nfense will have a basis\n\nfor redaction so\n\nThe\n\n[ think there is nothing\n\nfigure out a process,\n\nlooked at this one\n\nI'm not going to grant that\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\nOnce\n\nchance to rule on the remainder of the sealing\n\nand we will take this up if\n\nfor putting on the docket any redactions that\n\nI think\n\nit arises.\n\nthe extent this issue arises,\n\nWe will.\n\nThank you.\n\nto preclude the d\n\nthat\n\nfor an argument tha\n\nraise it,\n\nfens\n\nthe\n\ntrus again,\n\na i\n\nfendant was a \"prevailing party in civil\n\nlitigation.\"\n\nfact\n\nttlement\n\nthat\n\nirrelevant and highly prejudicial.\n\nin civil\n\nthe defendant was deemed\n\nThe de\n\nfendant, as\n\n41\n\nand\n\ndon't\n\nfurther on 10.\n\nT don't\n\nt they're making\n\nso that we can\n\nfinal issue in the government's\nfrom arguing that the\n\nI will\n\na\n\nlitigation seems\n\nunderstand it, was deemed a prevailing party following a\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007092\n\n", "char_count": 1640}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465_ Filed 11/15/21 Page 42 of 127 42\n\nLB]\n\n5MAX2\n\nvol\n\nuntary dismissal of civil litigation pursuant to a\n\nset\n\nsou\n\nPro\n\nall\n\ntlement agreement, and after the dismissal the defendant\n\nght costs as a prevailing party under Federal Rule of Civil\n\ncedure 54(d) (1), and at least as described in the papers the\n\neged victims opted to pay the fairly minimal amount sought\n\nrather than burden the court and other resources with continued\n\nLae\n\nigation.\n\nThe fact that the defendant received costs pursuant to\n\ncivil procedure 54(d) after a civil\n\nrel\n\nis\n\nthe\n\npre\n\ntha\n\nthi\nadj\ncas\n\nsub\n\ntime needed to explain the di\n\nCass\n\nbal\n\ngra\n\nevance to the charges at hand as\n\nsubstantial danger of confusing\n\nsettlement just has no\n\nfar as\n\njbey. Lt bbe detens licited\n\nvailing party, a layjuror would\n\nt was some kind of adjudication\n\ns case but there is no evidence\n\ncan tell and there\n\nthe issues and misleading\n\nthat the defendant was the\n\nalmost certainly assume that\n\non the merits relevant to\n\nthat there was any relevance\n\nudication on the merits and certainly none relevant to the\n\ne. Any probative value gained by\n\nstantially outweighed by juror confusion and the waste of\n\nyou.\n\nfFfering postures of the current\n\nthe introduction would be\n\ne and the prior civil litigation. So on those 401/403\nancing grounds the government's motion in this regard is\nnted.\nAny questions before I turn to the defense motions?\nMS. MOE: Not from the government, your Honor. Thank\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007093\n\n", "char_count": 1680}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 43 of 127 43\nLB15MAX2\n\n1 MS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, very briefly on the last\n2 issue. I assume that there won't be any argument by the\n3 government or their witnesses that they believe that they had\n4 an adjudication on the merits, in other words both the victims'\n5 compensation fund and the civil litigation, there was no right\n6 of confrontation, Ms. Maxwell wasn't a party to those\n7 settlement agreements. So, to the extent the government tries\n8 to suggest to the jury that they somehow had an adjudication,\n9 someone else found that their claims had merit, I think that\n10 would be confusing to the jury as well and I assume it would\n11 also be deemed by this Court to open the door to an explanation\n12 from the defense about what really happened in those\n13 proceedings.\n14 MS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor.\n15 The government does not intend to elicit any testimony\n16 from the victims about being a prevailing party in any civil\n17 litigation or otherwise. To the extent the government elicits\n18 any testimony about civil litigation from the victims it would\n19 only be in order to front that issue for the jury in\n20 anticipation of cross-examination along those lines.\n21 THE COURT: Right.\n22 MS. MOE: The government certainly wouldn't be\n23 offering that evidence to suggest to the jury in any way that\n24 those were adjudications on the merits, nor could we, those\n25 were civil settlements.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007094\n", "char_count": 1530}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 44 of 127 44\n\nLB15MAX2\n1 THE COURT: Anything further on that, Ms. Menninger?\n2 MS. MENNINGER: didn't hear any reference to the\n3 victim's compensation fund but there certainly was no\n4 adjudication on the merits by a fund that Ms. Maxwell had no\n5 party to the settlement.\n6 THE COURT: Correct.\n7 Same response, Ms. Moe?\n8 MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. And in fact, again, we\n9 would only be eliciting information about that on direct\n10 examination to front that issue for the jury in anticipation of\n11 cross-examination along those lines. To the extent the defense\n12 wishes not to cross-examine the victims about the victims\n13 compensation program, we certainly agree not to address that at\n14 all on direct examination.\n15 THE COURT: I imagine the defense does anticipate\n16 referring to civil settlements and the victims' compensation\n17 fund as part of its cross of anticipated witnesses, correct?\n18 MS. MENNINGER: That is correct, your Honor.\n19 THE COURT: So the government can front those issues\n20 to take out the sting. To the extent there is any\n21 imolication -- it would not be remitted to make any imolication\n22 as to what those settlements or receiving of funds would mean\n23 as to the issues relevant here. The only issue relevant here,\n24 as see it, goes to incentive for bias and credibility issues.\n25 MS. MENNINGER: t just depends on what the witness\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212%) 805-0220\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007095\n\n", "char_count": 1498}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nsays,\n\nimportant\n\npredict, and\n\npredict,\n\nactual testimony.\n\nit may be\n\nsomeone who believed\n\nyour Honor.\n\nDocument 465\n\nfor the Court to be aware of\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nbefore trial\n\nI'm not really sure that the government can\n\nthat they say something\n\nthem, that\n\ncompensation\n\nare used by\n\nthe witness,\n\nWhen they open\n\nthe door through\n\nthere was a victims'\n\nthem. If\n\nfund that believed\n\nour abilit\n\noun\n\nwas no actual const\n\nupon what the wit\n\nthink it's\n\nimportant\n\nPage 45 of 127\n\nbut I\n\nthose kinds of\n\n45\n\nagree that these are issues that it's\n\ncan't\n\nwhat their witnesses will say or suggest in their\n\nfronting it,\n\nthat suggests that there was\n\nwords\n\nthen that becomes problematic in terms\n\nty to be hamstrung in cross-examination that there\n\nwhen the government is trying to use evidence to\n\nbut then potentially opening\n\non the same type of language\nTHE COURT: Ms. Moe?\nMS. MOE: Your Honor,\n\nanticipate that the testimony wo\n\nany event,\n\nFrontation during that process.\n\nfor the Court to sort of\n\nagain,\n\ntnesses say we would re-raise this but I\n\nthink with respect\n\nLO\n\ncounsel has raised, to the exten\n\nt it opened the door\n\nSO;\n\nuld come out that way but,\n\ndepending\n\ndo\n\nhave that in mind\nfront an issue\nthe door to us being open to cross\n\nthat their witnesses used.\n\nthe government doesn't\n\nin\n\nthe specific concern def\n\nns\n\nT don't\n\nbelieve it would open the door to separate collateral issues\n\nabout a separate civil\n\nlawsuit.\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT: Yes.\n\nlawsuit and resolution of\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTRICT\n\nREPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 8\n\n05-0300\n\nthat civil\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007096\n\n", "char_count": 1682}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nMS.\n\nanticipate\n\nTHE\n\n25\n\nMy clerk noted I\n\n5 so we will\n\nMOE:\n\nBut,\n\nCOURT: OK.\n\nDocument 465\n\nbeyond that,\n\nthis would be an issue.\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nyour Honor,\n\nPage 46 of 127 46\n\nwe don't\n\nI think we are in agreement.\n\ninadvertently skipped over Government\n\nreturn\n\nexpectation tha\ninclude statements by individuals that\n\nthe government\n\nargues that\n\nto that.\n\nt the testimony of\n\ncertain w\n\nThis is the government's\n\nitnesses would\n\nt the defense can'\n\nf those non-\n\ncredibility o\n\nstatements would not be admit\n\nCEST\n\nJu.\n\nare not\n\ntestifying and\n\nt attack the\n\nuals because their\n\nfying individ\n\nted\n\nFor their\n\ntruth but, for\n\nexample, their ct on the\nAgain, I think witho\ndifficult to make a defini\n\ntive ruling but I\n\nut more specit\n\ntestifying witness and the like.\n\nicity it is\n\nexamples to give some guidance.\n\nMs. Moe?\nMS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor.\nthink there will be limited testimony\nabout her interaction with other victims.\n\nstatements that would\n\noffered not\n\nthey would be of\n\nexplain\n\n'm happy to hear\n\nfrom a victim\n\nthink the\n\nfrom those other victims would be\n\ncome in\nFor their truth but because they ar\nfered for that effect on li\nthe course of events that followed.\n\nanticipate of\n\na line of\n\nfor their trut\n\nfering any statements\nth and so we don't an\n\ncross-examination about\n\nfrom non\n\ntheir credibility.\n\ninstructions,\n\nstener and to\n\nWe don't\n\n-testifying victims\n\nLicipate opening the door to\n\nAnd so,\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212\n\n)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007097\n\n", "char_count": 1617}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nDocument 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 47 of 127 47\n\nto the credibility of\n\nfor that reason, we would ask that the defense be precluded\n\nfrom opening on this issue or otherwise raising issues related\n\nindividuals who would not be testifying\n\nat this trial including not only non-testifying victims but\n\nalso attorneys.\n\nMS. MENNING\n\nBR:\n\nnon-testifying victim\"\n\nYour Honor, even the statement \"a\n\nis very loaded because who is going to\n\ntestify that that person is a victim and on what ground?\n\nThat's the problem.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nak\n\nWe\n\nll, I wouldn't allow testimony by a\n\nwitness about a characterization that goes to a legal issue so\n\npeople. I can imagine instances in which they testify about\n\nof course they could testify about observations involving other\n\nstatements of others not offered for the truth but I wouldn't\n\nanticipate the government would attempt to do any of that via\n\nany characterization\n\noc\n\nthose individuals that go to legal\n\nconclusions relevant\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nEe]\n\nxe)\n\nDo I have that\n\nYes,\n\nthe jury's role.\nright, Ms. Moe?\n\nyour Honor.\n\nMS. MENNING\n\nBR:\n\nt is interesting, because in their\n\nthat second person isn't going to testify, and the question of\n\noffer of proof they actually say that one witness is going to\n\ntalk about another person being a victim of sexual abuse and\n\nwhether that person was a victim of sexual abuse would turn on\n\nthe age at which they were conducting certain activities. And\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\nDISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007098\n\n", "char_count": 1604}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 48 of 127 48\nLB15MAX2\n\n1 so, just as we were arguing earlier, your Honor, if the\n2 government is trying to put on evidence about other people\n3 being victims, then that opens the door to us challenging that\n4 other person's credibility. I don't have any issue with the\n5 way we briefed it which was it just depends on what is said by\n6 the witness and we will certainly re-raise these issues. But,\n7 the government can't have their cake and eat it, too. If they\n8 want to put on evidence about a broad number of supposed\n9 victims then we have the obligation, ethically, to challenge\n10 whether or not those other individuals are in fact victims.\n11 THE COURT: Well, I think maybe speaking in the\n12 abstract is where the fine points get lost. So if a testifying\n13 witness testifies about something that she observed involving\n14 the defendant and another individual, that doesn't open the\n15 door to attacking the credibility of that other individual.\n16 Agree to that basic premise?\n17 MS. MENNINGER: Correct, your Honor; an observation\n18 alone.\n19 THE COURT: And if the witness testifies that another\n20 individual, using the name or pseudonym -- if that is what is\n21 appropriate in light of the Court's ruling, I don't have it\n22 firmly in mind at this point but, just as an example: Someone\n23 told me to go to somebody's home. That doesn't put the\n24 credibility of the out-of-court witness in issue, does it?\n25 Because that is not being offered for the truth. Now, if it\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007099\n", "char_count": 1606}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\nLB15MAX2\nsays go to so and so's home at\nMS. MENNINGER: Or wh\nwhy do I think it is going\nthings -- that is\nnot-—for-the-truth issue.\nTHE COURT:\n\nthe\n\nak\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nto happen ther\n\nPage 49 of 127\n\nthose kinds of\n\n49\n\nfollowing address —-\n\nis going to happen there and\n\nreally getting into the circumventing the\n\ncome in because\n\nMS.\n\nthey would be\n\nMENN\n\nNGER:\n\nHears\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT:\n\nattack credibility.\n\ndo you disagree with any of\n\nfor the\n\nay,\n\nSo they don't come in,\n\nnor. The\n\nright.\n\ntruth.\n\nthat?\n\ngovernment agrees.\n\nMs. Moe,\n\nMS. MOE: No, your Ho\nif this issue arises,\ninstruction about\noffered for their truth.\n\nbe any testimony\n\nfrom an out-—o\n\nWe don't anticipate\n\nf-court declarant\n\n[ don't think those other points could\n\nobviously you can't\n\nAnd\n\nwe would certainly agree to a limiting\nthose out-of-court statements not being\nthat there would\n\nwho 18S a victim\n\noffered for its truth at this trial, and so we don't anticipate\noption the door.\n\nTHE COURT: fF the government thinks any of these, of\nwhat it does intend to offer, is close to the line on that\nquestion, it must raise them before inquiring or raising it in\nopening.\n\nMS. MOE: Certainly, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: OK.\n\nAnything further on that?\n\nSOU\n\nTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nBRS, Pes\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007100\n\n", "char_count": 1454}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\ndisclosure oi!\n\nlot of\n\ngovernment has\nby those orders.\n\nthe defense motion\n\nany alleged co-con\n\nprovided for\n\nF co-conspirator\n\nink about the meaning\n\nSs\n\ne)\n\ntatements.\n\nfully met its disclosure obliga\n\nto preclud\n\nthe government\n\nf prior orders and whether\n\n50\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465_ Filed 11/15/21 Page 50 of 127\nLB15MAX2\n\nMS. MENNINGER: No. Thank you, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: All right.\n\nAnything else before turning to the defense motion?\n\nMS. MOE: No, your Honor.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: No, thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Defense 1 relates to the government's\n\nThe parties spill a\n\nthe\n\ntions as set out\nThe government did not violate my orders and\n\nfrom introducing\n\ncerta\n\nthan any other trial\n\nI do think the defense\n\nI do think the schedule,\n\nspirator statements is denied.\n\nas set out in this\n\nover which I\n\nis wel\n\n]\n\ncase, has\n\ninly a vastly earlier disclosure schedule\n\nhave previously presided and\n\nequipped to know what\n\nis coming\n\nand can responsibly raise issues that can be dealt with in\n\nadvance of\nco-conspirat\ntrial and it\n\nit doesn't\n\ntrial. Here,\n\nfee]\n\nth\n\nhas the government's marked\n\nlike it,\n\ntrial.\n\nd\n\nors who will be mentioned by\n\nwe still have a month\n\nThat said, here is how we will proceed\n\nfense has\n\nexhibits,\n\nto go\n\nand this is another homework assignment.\n\nprovide to the defense th\n\nBy this Thursday,\n\nNovember 4, the gov\n\nronment\n\ncategories of\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nBRS, Pes\n\n(212\n\n)\n\n805-0300\n\nthe names of\n\nthe government at\n\nthe kinds of\n\nthe\n\nand although\n\nbefore\n\non this point —-\n\nt will\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007101\n\n", "char_count": 1679}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nDocument 465 _—‘ Filed 11/15/21\n\nPage 51 of 127\n\nS51\n\nco-conspirator statements that it intends to introduce at trial\n\npursuant to 801 (d) (2) (\nexemplars of\n\nanticipated testimony.\n\nbe\n\nfore,\n\nlitigate anything\nwill do that by November 4th.\n\nmind the well-established law regarding conditional\n\n2)\n\nto\n\nobjections to the introduction of\n\nCen,\n\nferring,\n\nif\n\n_\nE )\nE\n\nand specifically representative\n\neach category whether by exhibit number or\n\n[ think not\n\nf the co-conspirator statements,\n\nthe government,\n\nthere are disputes\n\nThat is a process that\n\nin\n\ninfrequently used,\n\nthat could be litigated.\n\nThe def\n\nnse,\n\nI have used\norder to try to\n\nSo the government\n\nbearing\n\nfully in\n\nadmission\n\nby November 8, any good fai\n\nth,\n\nthe defense should indicate\n\nany such s\n\nremaining that\n\nfal 7\n\nobviously\n\nthe government shall\n\ntatements.\n\nnon-frivolous\nAfter\nwouldn't\n\ninto the law regarding conditional\n\nfile a letter, by November\n\nLQ,\n\nadmission,\n\njustifying\n\nadmission of exemplars and statements over which the parties\ndisagree. So that's the 10th, and then the defense could put\nin an opposition, in writing, by November 12th.\n\nAny questions about that, Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: No, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Sternheim?\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: We are clear, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: think it is probably worth maybe just a\nmoment, because it impacts this issue and some other ones, to\njust discuss one category of potential statements that's been\nflagged and that's alleged co-conspirator statements that date\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nBRS, P.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007102\n\n", "char_count": 1748}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nconspiracy.\n\nLet\n\ndoes the government\n\nme as\n\nk, Ms.\n\nDocument 465\n\nafter what's alleged in the indictment as of\n\nMoe, i\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 52 of 127 52\n\nthe date of the\n\nf are you in position to say,\n\nintend to seek admission of alleged\n\nco-conspirator sta\n\ntements that post-dat\n\nconspiracy alleged in the indictmen\n\nMS.\n\nCon\n\nwou\n\nIn b\n\nMOE:\n\nrief,\n\nYour\n\nas a\n\n[ th\n\nHonor,\n\nthe dates of the\n\nt?\n\nink I would want a moment to\n\nfer with my colleagues about tha\n\npreview,\n\nt and so, if possible, we\n\nld like to address that in our November 10th letter.\n\n[ think to the extent there\n\nwere any statements that post-—da\n\ncharged conspiracy we would be of\n\nth\n\nthey referenc\n\nbe\n\nbrief\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nwait?\n\nCOURT:\n\nMR.\n\nPAGLI\n\nted th\n\nfering\n\nthe\n\ntime frame of\n\nthem only to the extent\n\ncharged conduct.\n\nto confer with my colleagues and\nfore making a representation\n\nthat as well at th\n\nUCA:\n\nAnyone want\n\ntim\n\nthink\n\nto the Court,\n\nsam\n\n[ would like\n\nBut, again,\n\nthrough that in detail\n\nand so we ask to\n\nYour Honor,\n\nto take this now?\n\nOr just\n\nam happy to wait but it\n\nis clear to me that there are post-alleged-conspiracy\n\nstatements\n\nthink we attach what wer\n\nstatements.\n\nwe sit here t\n\nAnd s\n\noday,\n\nthat the government will attempt to introduce and I\n\nth\n\nthose\n\no I don'\n\nwhat those statements may or may not be.\n\nrepr\n\nt think it should be a surprise,\n\nsentative samples of\n\nas\n\nthink whether or not you want to say that those statements go\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nDISTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\nBRS, Pes\n\n(212)\n\n805-\n\n0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007103\n\n", "char_count": 1678}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-\nLB15MAX2\n\nPAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nto something alleged in the indictment doesn't\n\n801 (d) (2) (BE)\ncourse of and 1\nstatements that\n\ntherance o\n\nn fur\n\nanalysis and that is it has to be\n\nf a conspiracy.\n\ndon't have anyt\n\nthing to do with\n\nPage 53 of 127\n\nchange the\nmade in the\n\nSo post-event\n\nthe conspiracy are simoly hearsay and inadmissible.\n\nHonor.\n\nMS. MO\nlike time to th\ndetail,\n\nis that\n\nconspiracy at t\n\nconspiracy even\n\nwould want to t\n\nwant to think\nco-conspirator,\n\n801 (d) (2) (E) at\n\ntime to think\n\nthorough repres\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nschedule that\n\nthrough that\n\nCOURT:\n\nI think that's a pretty simole proposition,\n\nyour\n\nwhether it is being of\n\nall.\n\nentation to the\n\nto mak\n\n[ will s\n\nAnd so we would just ask\n\nfered under Rule\n\nfurtherance of\n\n53\n\nE: Your Honor, among other reasons why we would\nink about this further and address it in more\nRule 801(d)(2)(E) is not limited to the charged\nrial, a statement said in furtherance of the\nif it is not the charged conspiracy. And so we\nhink through that as well. And we would also\nthrough, even if a statement is offered by a\n\nfor additional\n\nsure we giv\nCourt.\n\ntick with the\n\nSo,\n\nI have indicated\n\nbut I do\n\nout statements\n\nindictment and\n\nthat post-—da\n\nthe government will indicate grounds\n\nspecific introduction of any of those anticipa\nOK, Ms. Moe?\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. Thank you\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nthink we will sepa\n\nprocess and\n\nfor the\n\nan accurate and\n\nrate\n\nte the conspiracy as charged in the\n\nted statements.\n\nDOJ-OGR-\n\n00007104\n", "char_count": 1676}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\noutlined\n\n2021. Fi\n\ninadequat\n\n—\neh\nEz\n\nDocument 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 54 of 127 54\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: Yes, your Honor. That's fine.\n\nCOURT: Thank you.\n\nDefendants 2 is the admission of certain evidence\n\nin the government's 404(b) letter dated October 11,\n\nrst, as to the defense argument that there has been an\n\ne notice under 404\n\n(bob), I disagr because th\n\ngovernment's letter and briefing between the government's\n\nletter an\n\nnotice\" o\n\nd the briefing her\n\n, the defendant has \"reasonable\n\nf any 404(b) evidence so the question is whether the\n\nevidence can be properly admitted. I think there is two\n\ncategorie\n\ns of evidence, th\n\nspeak in\n\nappropria\n\ngeneral description and to\n\nte. The governmen\n\nwith that\n\nfirst goes to e-mails, and I will\n\nthe just general description which I think is\n\nt may have attempted to redact some\n\nthe extent that you have, I disagree\n\nbut I will speak generally -- I'm sorry, the defense\n\nrequested redaction as to some general description but I don't\n\nthink it'\n\nthis unde\n\ninstances\n\nover the\n\nbriefing,\n\nS appropriate. So\n\nI'm going to ask the government, if\n\nrstanding is correct, that the e-mails reflect\n\nage of consent.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nEe]\n\nrange is.\n\nwas under\n\nTHE COURT: So you\n\nof the defendant setting up dates that involve women\n\nYour Honor, I think as we noted in our\n\nfor some of the documents it is unclear what the age\n\nwouldn't be able to prove that it\n\nthe age of consent?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007105\n\n", "char_count": 1646}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nDocument 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 55 of 127 55\n\nMS. MOB: Exactly, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: For our purposes I think we need to assume\nover the age of consent, correct?\n\nMS. MOE: Your Honor, I think it would be ambiguous\n\nconduct with respect\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nfollowing statement:\n\nfrom the evidence but we are not prof\n\nfering them as evidence of\n\nto other minors.\n\nOK. So, let's just start with the\n\nYou are seeking to introduce e-mails that\n\ninvolve the defendant setting up people on dates with women\n\nover the age of\n\nMS. MOE:\n\ndetermine the age of\n\nYour Honor,\n\nconsent?\n\nbecause we are not able to\n\nthose individuals --\n\nTHE COURT: Let's assume that you could for some of\nthem. Right? Are you seeking to introduce those? It is clear\nthat the women involved are over the age of the consent. Are\n\nyou seeking to introduce those\n\nMS. MOE:\n\ne-mails?\n\nthink the e-mails that the defense has\n\nmoved to preclude don't say one way or the other the ag\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nCOURT:\n\nclear, it is\n\nto be\n\nYou are fighting my hypo. So,\n\na hypothetical.\n\nfF you have an e-mail involving\n\nthe defendant setting someone up on\n\ngovernment knows is over the age of\n\nargument made here, ar\n\nyou seeking\n\na date with someone who the\n\nthe\n\nconsent on the basis of\n\nto introduce it?\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor.\nTHE COURT: And why?\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007106\n\n", "char_count": 1513}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nde\n\nalthough the\n\nthe tenor of\n\nDocument 465\n\nThe government respecti\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nfense is\n\nfree to characteriz\n\nPage 56 of 127\n\nth\n\nthe e-mail suggests that she is of\n\nSs\n\n56\n\nfully submits that\nas dates,\n\nfering up women\n\nlargely based on descriptions based on physical descriptions\n\nand not in sort of\n\njury would be\n\nde\n\na matchmaking capacity.\n\nfree to conclude\n\nfrom those e-mails\n\nAnd so, I think the\nthat the\nto the men\n\nfendant is serving a particular role with respect\n\nthat she is e-mailing with.\n\nTHE\n\n25\n\nCOURT\n\nfinancial\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nEe]\n\nI think\n\nthat a jury may wonder at this\n\nbetween Ms.\n\nbe willing to serve in a partic\n\nMr.\n\nEpstein,\n\n: Are you suggesting like some kind of\n\narrangement?\n\nNo,\n\nyour Honor.\n\nthe issue,\n\nMaxwell and Mr. Eps\n\nand it is probative of\n\nas reflected in our brie\n\nFing,\n\nis\n\nob\n\ntein\n\nular\n\nand why Ms.\n\nthat\n\nserving a similar role,\n\nalbeit\n\ntrial about the relationship\nMaxwell would\nrole with respect to\n\nissue that she is\n\nin a differen\n\nother men during that same time\n\nTHE COURT\n\nThe indict\n\n: On th\n\ntment ch\n\nframe.\n\ne e-mails,\n\nndant\n\narges the def\n\nand aiding and abe\n\ntting th\n\nto engage in illegal sex\n\ne-mails setting up dates be\n\nhowever you want to describe\n\na\n\ne transport and en\n\nc\n\nit,\n\nt context,\n\ntLicement of\n\ndirect evidence of the crimes charged, they don't arise out of\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nwith\n\nam excluding them.\n\nt with conspiring\n\nfF minors\n\nts and the commercial sex act\ntween non-minors or meetings,\n\ninvolving non-minors are not\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007107\n", "char_count": 1716}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 57 of 127 57\n\n1 the same transaction or series of transactions as the charged\n2 offenses, they're not inextricably intertwined with the\n\n3 evidence nor necessary to complete the story of the crime on\n\n4 trial. The government doesn't allege that the individuals in\n5 these e-mails have anything to do with the crimes charged nor\n6 could they on the assumption that they can't establish that any\n7 of the individuals are below the age of consent.\n\n8 As for 404(b), I am also not convinced. The\n\n9 government argues that the e-mails show motive, intent, plan,\n10 and knowledge. Any potential probative value here would be\n\n11 substantially outweighed by the possibility of confusing the\n12 jury. Thus, I grant the defendant's motion as to Government's\n13 Exhibits 401 through 404, 409, 410, and 413.\n\n14 The next category is the anticipated testimony that --\n15 and this involves someone who has knowledge based this goes\n16 to the post-date conspiracy charged. This is someone who, as\n17 understand it, has knowledge that post dates the conspiracy\n\n18 alleged; is that right?\n\n19 MS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor; and that\n20 testimony will be proffered principally authenticate certain\n21 vidence relevant to the charged conduct.\n22 THE COURT: OK.\n23 Who is taking this? With respect to authenticating\n24 vidence, do you have an objection, Ms. Menninger?\n25 MS. MENNINGER: Yes, your Honor, because it is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007108\n", "char_count": 1542}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 58 of 127 58\nLB15MAX2\n\n1 post-dating the alleged conspiracy. For example, there ar\n\n2 documents -—- I don't know, they weren't specified which\n\n3 documents that this witness intends to authenticate, but among\n4 the documents that I believe the witness may attempt to\n\n5 authenticate, they are dated in 2005 and beyond. And so the\n\n6 question really is whether you can -- it is an authentication,\n7 one, whether that relates to the conspiracy or not. As we set\n8 forth in our reply, your Honor, there is a real concern becaus\n9 a number of, I think, the entire first series of exhibits, are\n10 largely taken from a period outside of the charged conspiracy.\n11 [ think this witness may attempt to authenticate some of those\n12 exhibits and they haven't established why that will be relevant\n13 to the charged time period of the conspiracy. They really\n14 didn't argue 404(b) on this point and we asked for additional\n15 time in terms of the direct evidence because we had just\n16 received these 400 pages that relate to that particular\n17 witness, your Honor.\n18 THE COURT: So the basic contention would be if we\n19 have a document that, on its face, that post-dates the charged\n20 conspiracy. I mean that, alone, is think the first point of\n21 your objection, right?\n22 MS. MENNINGER: Yes, your Honor.\n23 THE COURT: The authentication issue aside. What is\n24 the relevance of a document that, on its face, post-dates the\n25 charged conspiracy? Let's start with that, Ms. Moe.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212%) 805-0220\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007109\n\n", "char_count": 1601}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nMS.\n\nGI\n\nThe category o!\n\nau\n\nMOE:\n\ninformation\n\ncontact information and messages\n\nMr.\n\npossession is relevant regardless of\n\ncorroborative of\n\nth\n\nYes,\n\nDocument 465\n\nyour Honor.\n\nexhibits that\n\nEpstein's residence and,\n\nother\n\nthenticating would include,\n\nin part,\n\nvidenc\n\namong other things,\n\ni\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 59\n\ncont\n\nof 127 59\n\nt this witness would be\n\ntact\n\nFor the minor victims and so the\n\nfrom those vict\n\n1a\n\nfact tha\n\nth\n\nTHE\n\nCOU\n\nRI:\n\nMr.\n\ntains addresses of\n\nEpstein maint\n\nvictims here.\n\nMS.\n\nrespect to the\n\ninclude messages that were let\n\ntime\n\ninclude a name of\n\nthis witness will\n\nMOE:\n\nYes,\n\na vic\n\nbe au\n\nyour Honor;\n\ntim and her con\n\ntwo categories of\n\na\n\neS\n\ntime\n\nt trial.\n\nIs that the context?\n\nexhibi\n\nframe of the charged conspiracy,\n\nft at th\n\nbut more specif\n\nt that\n\ntims was in\nthe defendant's\n\nframe and is\n\nThe charged conspiracy ends and then\n\nindividuals alleged to be\n\nFically with\n\ntSy\n\nresidenc\n\nthe\n\nthey ar\n\ntact int\n\nthenticating those.\n\nfirst would\nduring the\ndated and\n\nFormation and so\n\nThose documents\n\ncome from the time frame of the charged conspiracy and were\ncreated at the time frame of the charged conduct.\nWith respect to a second category of information --\nTHE COURT: And you have a witness who would\nauthenticate that they were created at the time of the charged\nconduct which, presumably, wouldn't be somebody who doesn't\n\ncome onto the scene until after the time period\nconduct. Fair to say?\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,\n(212) 805-0300\n\nof\n\nthe charged\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007110\n\n", "char_count": 1691}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 60 of 127 60\n\nLB15SMAX2\n\nMS. MOE: Your Honor, those records would be\nauthenticated through number of different witnesses; in part,\nlaw enforcement officer describing those exact records being\n\nseized from th\n\nresidenc\n\nand format,\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nCO\n\nMS.\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nCO\n\ntheir employment.\n\nMOE:\n\nmu\n\nMS. MO!\n\ninclude testimony about the\n\nthey were kept,\n\nthese lines.\n\nCircuit's rulings on aut\n\nparticulars of\n\nSo\n\ncontents.\nwitnesses and,\n\ntestimony,\n\nfoundation.\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nadvance\n\nWe think\n\ncollectively,\n\nwe would of\n\nCOURT:\n\nURT:\n\nL's\nPie\n\nwitnesses describing the practice\n\nthose records contemporaneously and doing so in the course of\n\nin 2005 in their general description\n\nfor maintaining\n\nContemporaneous to what?\n\nAt the tim\n\nwas made.\n\nYes,\n\nDuring the period of\n\nyour Honor.\n\nthe messag\n\nthe conspiracy?\n\nAnd that testimony would\n\nformat of\n\nwhere\n\nthese documents,\n\nce\n\nand the practi\n\na document and their\n\nI think this would come in\n\nAnd I\n\nthat 1s consistent with\n\nthentication being based on\n\nat the conclusion of\n\nfer those exhibits based on\n\ndon't think\n\nfor keeping messages along\n\nthe Second\n\nthe\n\ntheir\n\nFormatting and\n\nthrough a number of\n\nthat\n\nthat\n\ncan rule on that in\n\nuntil we hear the authentication\n\nvidenc\n\nbeing\n\nfered.\n\n2)\n\nWhat you have prof\n\nfered I\n\nthink --\n\nthe def\n\nns but it seems\n\n[ wil\n\n1]\n\nhear from\n\nlike those pieces coul\n\nauthent\n\ntLication.\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nDISTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nBRS, Pes\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nld add up to\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007111\n\n", "char_count": 1642}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nBut\n\nDocument 465\n\ntake the example,\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nthat, on its face,\n\npurpose would you be of\n\npost—dates\n\nfering\n\nbook as an example.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes,\n\nthe charged conspiracy,\n\nthat?\n\nyour Honor.\n\nWith respect\n\nto that particular document,\n\nPage 61 of 127\n\n61\n\nif you would, that a document\n\nfor what\n\nAnd let's use the address\n\nthe\n\ntestimony would be that that document belonged to the defendant\n\nand that\n\ninformation\n\nshe -- and the document\n\nitself would include contact\n\nfor some minor victims under a certain heading that\n\nhas relevance to the case and organized in a certain way that\n\nis consistent with victim testimony.\n\nheld on to that\n\nor maintained it\n\nSo, whether th\n\nfollowing the\n\nthe charged conspiracy,\n\nestablish the defendant's knowledge to confirm\n\ntrial.\n\nit would nonetheless b\n\nTHE COURT: c\n\ncreated or\n\nrelevant?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes,\n\nnonetheless memorialized that ini\n\nit would nonetheless b\n\nth\n\nthose victims and to be corroborative of other\n\nvidence wer\n\nthat\n\nmaintained un\n\nf, at the conclusion of the conspiracy,\n\ntil after the charged conspiracy,\n\nyour Honor.\n\nrelevant\n\narguments that\n\nthem and so certainly that would be relevant,\n\nshe didn't know\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nconclusion of\nrelevant\nher contact\n\nexhibits at\n\nt to her knowledge to rebut\n\nthe victims or have contact\n\ndefendant\n\nCO\n\nwith\n\nit wasn't\n\nis it\n\nthe defendant\n\nFormation about those victims,\n\nwith\n\nyour Honor.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007112\n\n", "char_count": 1617}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465_ Filed 11/15/21 Page 62 of 127 62\nLB15MAX2\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nCOURT: Ms. Menninger?\n\nMS. MENNINGER: Your Honor, I ama little confused but\n\nwhat I think I understand the government is saying is that\n\nknowledge after the conspiracy is relevant to the time frame of\n\nthe conspiracy. I don't believe that the witness we are\n\ntalking about, who didn't start working until after the time of\n\nthe conspiracy for Mr. Epstein, would be able to set forth the\n\nfoundation that they're claiming. I believe that this is more\n\nlikely to be a trial-time testimony decision because I think\n\nthere will be some pretty substantial objections to the ability\n\nof this witness to authenticate the document which I know your\n\nHonor is aware from other briefing, is what we consider to be\n\nfrom a very suspect source and obtained years later. There is\n\na lot of notations and things on it that will not be anything\n\nthat this witness can attest to. IT think it is Exhibit 52.\n\nTHE COURT: Yes.\n\nMS. MENNINGER: don't think it is relevant to the\n\ntime period of the conspiracy.\n\nTHE COURT: Right.\n\nI guess the question, given the pieces of\n\nauthentication that the government intends to offer through\n\ndifferent witnesses and what sounds like lines of\n\ncross-examination as to those pieces, I think at that point\n\nam potentially -- at least the government will have to proffer,\n\nput forward questions and get answers from the witness that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007113\n\n", "char_count": 1622}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nwould go\n\nposition\n\nto authen\n\nto rule at\n\nanybody intends\n\nmentioned in opening?\n\nanticipate opening with respect to Government Exhibit\n\nmay address,\n\nexample,\n\nMS.\n\nMOE:\n\nYour Honor,\n\nin opening,\n\nterms of\n\nexception under hearsay in opening statements,\n\nstrongly object to that.\n\nI mean,\n\nthe message pads\n\nMS. M\n\nthe message pads that have a post\n\nENN\n\nNGER:\n\ngrounds to lay a\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nwill authen\n\nwe would be of\n\nMS.\n\nseries of\n\nincluding law ent\n\nf witnesses laying\n\ntLicate?\n\nMOE:\n\n9\n\nYour Honor,\n\nYes.\n\n)\n\nDocument 465\n\nCE Leat LOt..«\n\nt this point b\n\nLet's tak\n\ntake\n\nthat\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\njust don't know if\nut let me ask bo\n\nExhibit 52,\n\nYour Honor,\n\nthe government doesn't\n\nth sides if\n\n52\n\nPage 63 of 127 63\n\nam ina\n\nis that going to be\n\nbut\n\nfor\n\njust re\n\ntha\n\nther categories of exhibits,\nferenced.\n\nt's a problem.\n\nfoundation\n\nthem without a witness who can authentica\n\nstill have not\n\nfoundation or relevance\n\na number of\n\nfering those messages at the\n\nForcement witnesses and employees\n\nthe circumstances under which messages wer\n\ndon't anticipate of\npost-date the tim\nTHE COURT: OR.\n\nframe of\n\nSO\n\nany message pads that post-—da\n\nwe would\n\nIn\n\nt-conspiracy date on\n\nte them under any\n\nt heard appropriate\n\nfor those.\nthe message pads. Who\nwitnesses. I think\nconclusion of a\nfor their authenticity\n\ntalking about\n\nmaintained but we\n\nF the charged conspiracy.\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212\n\n) 805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nfering messages in those message books that\n\nthe government will not mention\n\nte the charged conspiracy in its\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007114\n", "char_count": 1726}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "N\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nopening.\n\nMS. MOE: Th\n\nZL\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 64 of 127 64\n\nat's correct, your Honor.\n\nfurther on that?\n\nMs. Menninger, anything\n\nMS. MENNINGE\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nR: Nothing\n\nfurther on that, your Honor.\n\nOK.\n\nAnything fur\n\nto be addressed now,\n\nther in this general category that needs\n\nMS. MENNINGE\n\ngovernment intends to\n\nwas a reference to an\n\ngovernment's briefing\n\nwas mentioned in the\nwas not mentioned in\n\n4A04(b). It is of as\n\nthat your Honor has e\n\nthere.\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nCOURT:\n\nMS. MOE: Ye\n\nWe didn't in\n\nMs. Menninger?\n\nR: f there is no other evidence that the\noffer via Rule 404(b), then no. There\nother exhibit GX-— 416 in the\n\n. That was not one of the exhibits that\n\nRule 404(b) letter. assume because it\n\nthat letter it cannot be of\n\nfered through\n\name type and characteristic of the e-mail\n\nI don't know what the intent is\n\nxcluded so\n\nMs. Moe?\n\nSs, your Honor.\n\noffering it as direct\n\nwere included in our\n\nclude that exhibit in our notice. We are\nvidence, unlike the other evidence which\nnotice. That document is a series of\n\nnotes. The metadata\n\nfor that exhibit reflects that the\n\ndefendant created tha\n\nexhibits outlined in\n\nunlike the other\n\nt series of notes but,\n\nour letter, it doesn't appear that that\n\nwas directed at a thi\n\nrd-party as opposed to Mr. Epstein,\n\nSOUTHE\n\nRN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007115\n\n", "char_count": 1527}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB\n\n1L5MAX2\n\nDocument 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 65 of 127 65\n\nalthough it is not clear from the document to whom it's\n\ndirected.\n\nan\n\ncharged conduct\n\nd 20s,\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nt relates to individuals in their 30s\n\nyour Honor. rT\n\n'm just unclear how it relates to\n\nfemales.\n\nunderag\n\nwasn't speci\n\nTHE COURT: It\n\nt or direct evidence of a conspiracy to abuse\n\nseems like it falls within my -- it\n\nfically moved for exclusion but because of the\n\ngovernment not including it in its notice but I'm not seeing --\n\nwh\n\nam pulling it up but\n\nat I am hearing,\n\ne-mails.\n\nal\n\nde\n\nong wit\n\nfendant\n\nI'm not seeing a notice -- a basis, from\n\ndistinguishing it from my ruling on the\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nEl\n\nYour\n\nHonor, the government submits that\n\nth other exhibits at trial, which will establish the\n\nt's role with respect to Mr. Epstein and her role in\n\nparticular in setting up sexualized massages for him, that this\n\nis corroborative of\n\nthat the det\n\ndo\n\nag\n\ntake steps along\n\nTHE COURT: But\n\nother exhibits and other testimony at trial\n\nFendant did in fact serve that role, was willing to\n\nthose lines. And so, for that reason --\n\ne of consent?\n\nMS. MOE: That\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nit involves, clearly, people over th\n\n's correct, your Honor.\n\nCOURT: Let me just pull it up.\n\nFor the same reasons, 416 is excluded.\n\nMS. MO\n\nma\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nDISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007116\n\n", "char_count": 1535}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\n\nLBI5SMAX2\n\nTHE COURT: Anything else on this?\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nTHE COURT: Next is\n\nNo,\n\nyour Honor.\n\nDefendant'\n\nmotion to exclude the excerpt which, as\n\nwill take up at the Daubert hearing.\n\nLet's take a shor\n\n(Recess)\n\n(Continued next page)\n\nE ¢€omi\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nThank you.\n\nPage 66 of 127 66\n\ns Exhibit 3 which is the\n\nFort break.\n\nI have indicated, we\n\n10-minute break.\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nLD\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007117\n\n", "char_count": 606}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOn\n\nOY\n\n~l\n\njee\n\nKe\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nNO\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBITMAX3\n\nissue of\n\nTHE\n\n25\n\nvidenc\n\nCOURT:\n\nDocument 465\n\nWe'll pick up with\n\nindividual\n\ninadmissibl\n\nDe\n\nthat's not probative of\n\nfense seeks to exclud\n\nrelated to alleged Vict\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nDe\n\nvidenc\n\nfense 4.\n\nPage 67 of 127\n\ntim-3.\n\nrelated to this\n\n67\n\nThis is the\n\nhere.\n\nis\n\nfF the charged conspiracy and\n\nunder 404(b) and 403. There are redactions issues\nRedactions of specific identifying information\n[ don't think that redactions as to some\n\npermissible here.\n\ngenera\n\nidentifying in\n\nformation regarding\n\nNECSSSary,\n\nredactions.\n\ngovernment.\n\nstatute of\n\nlimitations\n\nMs.\n\nI want to begin this one wit\n\nMoe,\n\nlimitations\n\n1 background information that does not\n\nbut we'll proceed bearing in mind the\n\nth questions\n\nso it's a hypothetical.\n\nreveal specif\n\nthe alleged victims is\n\nic\n\nrequested\n\nfor the\n\nI gather\n\nthere's\n\nissues,\n\npertained to this\n\nissue aside, if\n\nindividual, if all\n\nthe testimony of\n\nbut setting the statute of\n\nthe only evidence in the case\n\nthis\n\nindividual is accepted by the jury, could the defendant be\nfound guilty of any crimes charged in the indictment?\n\nMS. MOE: With respect, just so I understand the\nhypothetical, if the only count in the indictment were the Mann\nAct conspiracy --\n\nTHE COURT: No, any of the crimes charged, just\nstipulate to that, but if the only evidence pertains to this\nindividual.\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. The answer is no. In\n\nSOUTHE\n\nRN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212) 805-03\n\n00\n\nLD\n\nDOJ-\n\nOGR-00007118\n", "char_count": 1619}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465 _ Filed 11/15/21\nLB1TMAX3\n\nPage 68 of 127 68\n\nparticular, because with respect to -- that's why I was\n\nclarifying, your Honor. With respect to the Mann Act\n\nconspiracies, the particular criminal sexual\n\nactivity relates\n\nto a particular statute in New York. And with respect to the\n\nsex trafficking -—-\n\nTHE COURT: The particular statute in New York that\n\nthe government her that's 130.053(a), right?\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor.\n\nTH\n\nFA\n\nCOURT: And that establishes 17 as the age of\n\nconsent for the underlying sexual activity that's charged in\n\nthe indictment.\n\nSr\n\nMS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: So the Mann Act is going to the cas\n\nthat the government is going to prove here is going to\n\nincorporate that as the illegal sexual conduct.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nGI\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: So couldn't be convicted with respect to\n\nthat count.\n\nMS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor.\n\nAnd that's\n\namong the many reasons why we submit there's very little\n\npotential prejudice of offering this testimony considering its\n\nrelevance to the counts charged, because given th lements of\n\nthe offense standing alone and the statute of\n\nissue, we think there's no 403 issue here.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nlimitations\n\nTHE COURT: Well, not just with respect to the Mann\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007119\n\n", "char_count": 1475}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 69 of 127 69\n\nLB1TMAX3\n\n1 Act, there's no count charged in the indictment for which the\n\n2 defendant could be convicted -- again, setting aside -- I'm not\n3 dealing with the statute of limitations issue, put it out of\n\n4 your mind. So assuming no statute of limitations issue, could\n5 the defendant be convicted of any count charged in the\n\n6 indictment based on the evidence as it pertains to this?\n\n7 MS. MOE: No, your Honor, we have not charged the cas\n8 that way, and that testimony alone wouldn't satisfy those\n\n9 crimes charged.\n10 THE COURT: And is the government's position that this\n1] individual could be deemed a victim for restitution purposes or\n12 any legal purpose with respect to the crimes charged in this\n\n13 case and the case that the government is going to put on?\n\n14 MS. MOE: Your Honor, with apologies, I haven't\n\n15 thought through the restitution issue. I would want to confer\n16 with my office about that. I'm not certain, your Honor.\n\n17 THE COURT: Well, if the defendant can't be indicted\n18 based on this conduct -- again, assuming no statute of\n\n19 limitations issue, assuming that the jury adopts and accepts\n20 all of the testimony as true, the defendant couldn't be\n21 convicted of any of the crimes charged based on that conduct,\n22 how could that individual be deemed a victim of the crime\n\n23 charged?\n\n24 MS. MOE: understand the Court's point, your Honor.\n25 guess my concern is that the distinction between charging\n\nSOUTHERN DISTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007120\n\n", "char_count": 1582}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465 _ Filed 11/15/21\nLB1TMAX3\n\nbased on that conduct alone and th vidence based on that\n\nPage 70 of\n\n127 70\n\nconduct alone, we submit that, given the course of conduct in\n\nthe charged conspiracy, that Minor Victim-3 is\n\na victim\n\nof an\n\nongoing conspiracy, which is one of agreement and inten\n\nWe submit that her testimony alone wo\n\nuldn't est\n\na violation of the Mann Act, and without the o\n\ncircumstances of other victim testimony, we co\n\nther\n\nuldn't est\n\ntablish\n\ntablish\n\nBut given that the crime here is conspiracy and one of\n\nthat there was an ongoing intent to transport minor vic\n\nagreements and mental states and not about attempts\n\ncertain statutes or agreements to do so, it's about the\n\nintention at the time of agreement during the course of\n\nof conduct.\n\ntims.\n\nto violate\n\na span\n\nTHE COURT: But it has to be an intention to engage in\n\nan illegal act.\n\nMS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: And so I think I need an answer to the\n\nquestion. There is a distinction, surely, between criminality\nand evidence of criminality. You have evidence of criminality,\nwhich is not itself criminality, for sure. You have 403\nquestions and the like. But need to know the government's\nposition I think for a number of things in issue, including\nDefendant's 4. So you have confirmed that the defendant\n\ncouldn't be found guilty of any crimes charged based on the\n\nconduct alleged with respect to what you refer to as alleged\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007121\n", "char_count": 1603}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nVictim-3.\n\nMS.\n\nTHI!\n\nposition is as\n\n=\nG\nPi\n\nMOE: Yes,\n\nCOURT:\n\nDocument 465\n\nyour Honor.\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 71 of 127 71\n\nAnd you're not sure what the government's\n\nto whether alleged Victim-3 could in any legal\n\nsense be deemed a victim of any of the counts charged, despit\nthe I think necessary, but I wasn't sure of the government's\nposition, with respect to the illegality of conduct involving\n\nthe victim.\n\nMS.\n\nmoment to con\n\nMOE:\n\nEz\n\nfer\n\nYour Honor,\n\nwith my colleagues?\n\nnot misunderst\n\nwith them about a specific issue.\nTHE COURT: Okay.\n(Pause)\nMS. MOE: Thank you,\nTHE COURT: One moment,\n\nportion of\n\nthe government's briet\n\nwith apologies,\n\nbecause\n\nyour Honor.\n\nthese questions.\n(Pause)\nTHE COURT: Okay, go ahead.\nMS. MOE: Thank you,\n\nhave pointed out to me, the det\n\n2)\n\nstatute are di\n\nf the element of\n\nFinition of\n\nI want to make sure\n\nhave one\n\nmay I\n\nI'm\n\ntanding the Court's question and want to confer\n\nyour Honor.\n\nI want to pull up this\n\nFing on this which triggered\n\nAs my colleagues\n\na victim\n\nfor purposes\n\nfferent.\n\nto issues of\n\nrestitution\n\nAnd part of\n\nthe statute and pursuant to\n\nthe restitution\n\nour hesitation in speaking\n\nis because\n\nthat implicates the Crime\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\nBRS, Pes\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007122\n\n", "char_count": 1430}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBITMAX3\n\nVictims'\n\non\n\nRights Act,\n\nDocument 465\n\nSO we want to cont\n\nthat issue as well b\n\nfore w\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nFer with victims'\n\nreach a conclusion on\n\nThe definition set\nwhich is 18 USC 3663(a) (2),\n\nterm \"victim\" means a person direc\n\na result of\n\nmay be ordered.\n\nfor purposes of\n\nthe commission of\n\nan of\n\nfense\n\nforth in the rest\n\nPage 72 of 127\n\nthe section,\n\n72\n\ncounsel\n\nthat.\n\ntitution statute,\n\nthe\n\ntly and proximately harmed as\n\nfor which restitution\n\nSo that's the particular issue that we just want to\n\nfor\n\nthink through b\n\nWw\n\nreach a conclusion on in particular\n\nbecause we're mind\n\nful o\n\napologize,\nhypothetical,\n\nTHE\n\nquestion with respec\n\ninitial point, for\n\nit's not\n\nCOURT:\n\nYou will get\n\nurposes,\n\nmy intenti\n\nt to restitution,\n\nestablishing any of\n\nthis individual\n\nrestitution's definition of\n\nthe\n\nOt\n\nfens\n\n\"victim\"\n\non,\n\nes,\n\nthose\n\ncharged account would show to be vic\n\nthe Crime Victims'\ncertainly,\n\nwe wanted to be thoughtful about\n\nbut as\n\nas you said, o\n\nfor whom the government's proof o\n\na]\n\ntims,\n\nRights Act.\n\nSo I\n\nCO\n\nthe government's view is\n\nements as\n\nthink that\n\ndistinction you're trying to draw.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nrecognize Minor Victim-3's testimony alone would not satis\n\nthe elements of\n\nappear,\n\nYour Honor,\n\nthe conspiracy count\n\nour view is nonetheless that\n\nI understand\n\nf the elements\n\nfight the\nt that issue.\n\nt me your views on that\n\nyour\n\nof\n\nthat\n\nis not a victim in the sense -- granting that\ncould be broader than\n\nto the\n\nt's the\n\nour position is that we\n\nit's direct\n\nfy\n\nin which the overt acts\n\nvidenc\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007123\n\n", "char_count": 1734}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "be\n\nNO\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT:\n\nfor purposes of\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nDocument 465\n\nThat's becaus\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nth\n\nPage 73 of 127\n\nrelevant age of\n\n73\n\nconsent\n\nthe case that the government is trying to prove\n\nis the New York statute, which sets 17 as the age of consent,\nand this individual was -- sorry, under 17 is the age of\nconsent, and this individual, when the government understands\nsexual conduct to have occurred, was 17, correct?\n\nMS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Okay.\n\nMS. MOE: t's nonetheless our position this is direct\nevidence for a number of reasons. First, it's —-\n\nTHE COURT: Direct evidence of what?\n\nMS. MOE: Of the charged conspiracy. In part because\nthis conduct occurred at the same time the defendant was\n\nngaged in conduct\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\ntestimony will est\n\ntablish a pat\n\ntheir testimony and demonstrat\n\nt with respec\n\nthe other victims,\n\nis corroborative of\n\nand her\n\nct to\ntern that\ns the def\n\nWith respect to the issue —--\n\nintent.\nTHE\n404(b), right,\nMS. MOE:\n\nCOURT:\n\ncertainly be required to prove at trial the det\n\nNo,\n\nYou've slid between\n\nyour Honor.\n\nknowledge and intent to commit\n\nde\n\nto that issue.\n\nfendant's conduct wit\n\nth respect\n\nIn particular,\n\ndirect\n\nvidenc\n\nndant's knowledge and\n\nand\n\nknowledge and intent?\n\nthese crimes.\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPORTERS, P.\n\nSo the\n\nThe government will\n\nFendant's\n\nto this victim goes directly\n\n[ take the Court's point with\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007124\n\n", "char_count": 1561}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 74 of 127 74\nLB1TMAX3\n\n1 respect to the issue of 17 or under 17, but more broadly,\n\n2 think the question at trial will be about, among other things,\n3 the defendant's knowledge of Jeffrey Epstein's preference for\n\n4 very young girls.\n\na) THE COURT: Well, let's say this individual were 20,\n\n6 is it direct evidence of the crimes being charged?\n\n7 MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor, but for a different reason.\n8 Under those circumstances, it would nonetheless be our\n\n9 position, even if the victim were 18, 19 or 20, that the\n10 defendant's specific conduct towards that victim proves other\n11 aspects of the course of conduct. In other words, the\n12 particular pattern --\n13 THE COURT: This seems to move into the email issue,\n14 which I have excluded. That is to say, you wanted to put in\n\n15 emails of the defendant setting up individuals with other\n\n16 individuals over -- in some cases well over the age of consent,\n17 and I have excluded that. So is there a basis for\n\n18 distinguishing this here?\n\n19 MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor, there certainly is for a\n20 number of reasons. Here, the course of conduct is closely\n21 intertwined. In other words, the defendant's interactions with\n22 this victim closely mirror actions with other victims, for\n\n23 example, introducing sexual topics in a slow and gradual way.\n24 THE COURT: When you say \"victim\" there, do you mean\n25 that in a legal sense? Becaus still want to understand the\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, a ws\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007125\n\n", "char_count": 1547}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\n\nLBITMAX3\n\npoint.\n\nNow one might have al\nconcerns, but is there a legal\nright now in talking to me is just identi\n\nthere a legal sense in which you're prof\n\nas an victim of the crimes cha\n\nll kinds of\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nrged, setting aside you don't\n\nPage 75 of 127 75\n\nfF moral judgments and\nl sense in which the government\nfy the person, or is\n\nfering this individual\n\nhave an answer yet as to whether they may meet some basis for\n\nrestitution should the det\n\nMS. MOE: Yes,\n\nyour Honor,\n\nillustrate,\n\nFenda\n\nnt be convicted.\n\nfor identification purposes and because\n\nvictim's testimony will\n\nthat conduct is as a direct result of\n\nin a way that closely mirrors the way\n\naccess for Mr. Epstein to the other minor\n\nTHE COURT: That is an argument about\n\nof unwanted conduct, and the way in which sh\nthe de\n\nthe de\n\nI'm using that term both\nI think, as the\nshe will describe a course\n\ncame to engage in\n\nvic\n\nfendant's behavior\n\nfendant secured\n\ntims in this case.\n\nconsent being\n\nthe basis for which -- we have put it aside to 412, but asa\n\ngeneral matter you have argued consent is irrelevant because\n\nthe age of consent is the only thing in issue\n\ncharges, but you're saying th\n\nrelevanc\n\ntestimony turns on the government\n\nsexual conduct?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nEe]\n\nNo,\n\nyour Honor,\n\nof\n\nfor these\n\nthis individual's\n\nstablishing nonconsensual\n\nI'm simply explaining why we\n\nare using that term \"victim,\" because that's the way she\n\ncharacterizes that experience,\n\nand I think that will come\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007126\n\n", "char_count": 1658}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 76 of 127 76\nLB1TMAX3\n\n1 across when she describes it.\n\n2 What I mean is not that the relevance turns on whether\ni) or not she consented to that conduct, but the way in which that\n4 occurred closely mirrors exactly how that occurred with other\n\n5 victims. So in terms of proving the methods of the conspiracy,\n6 the means they employed, the defendant's role in the\n\n7 conspiracy, all of which is direct proof of the defendant's\n\n8 guilt, this victim's testimony will be corroborative and\n\n9 establish the defendant's knowledge.\n10 THE COURT: You're saying that would be true\n1] regardless of the age of this individual. could keep doing a\n12 hypothetical, 25, 30, it doesn't matter, from your perspective,\n13 it would be relevant to establishing the conspiracy because it\n14 occurred at the same time?\n\n15 MS. MOE: Your Honor, could see universe in which\n\n16 there were an outer limit on the age a hypothetical victim\n\n17 where this would be relevant. Our view is that the age of this\n18 victim makes it particularly relevant, but it's the other\n\n19 aspects of the course of conduct which are corroborative and\n20 make this direct evidenc Here, this victim was 17, in close\n21 proximity to the age of the other victims, and so her\n22 testimony, among other things, establishes the defendant's\n23 knowledge and awareness of a certain sexual preference for\n24 girls under the age of 18.\n25 THE COURT: But under the age of 18 is legally\n\nSOUTHE\n\nRN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007127\n", "char_count": 1568}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 77 of 127\nLB1TMAX3\n\nirrelevant to the crimes charged, correct? Under the age of\n\nis what is legally relevant.\n\nMS. MOE: That's certainly true with respect to the\n\nelements as to the other victims, but I think as a matter of\n\ncommon sense, a jury understanding that the defendant is\n\nwilling to provide Epstein with a girl at the age of 17 would\n\ncertainly speak to her knowledge of his sexual preferences.\n\nTHE COURT: Why doesn't it speak to a knowledge of\n\nsexual preferences to someone just above the age of consent?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nGl\n\nWell, your Honor, I think the close\n\nproximity of ages, it speaks to her knowledge about his\n\npreference for very young girls.\n\nI would also note that, although the age of 17 is\n\nrelevant with respect to the Mann Act counts, with respect to\n\nthe trafficking counts, the applicable age is there is 18.\n\n77\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT: I began this whole series by asking, like\n\neight times and very clearly, is there any sense in which this\n\nindividual, the conduct that's -- assuming it to all be true\n\nwith respect to this individual, could establish an element of\n\nany of the crimes charged?\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. With respect to that\n\nvictim, that's certainly the case. But speaking to direct\n\nevidence of knowledge and preferences, it's certainly also\n\ndirect evidence of the defendant's knowledge with respect to\n\nthe sex trafficking counts where the age of consent there is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007128\n", "char_count": 1647}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\n\nLBITMAX3\n\n18. And so the fact that the det\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 78 of 127 78\n\nfFendant was taking these steps\n\ntowards a girl who was 17 years old certainly speaks to her\n\nknowledge and willingness to provide such a girl to Epstein\n\nwith respect to the sex\n\nTHE COURT: So\n\nwe're talking Count Five and Count Six,\n\nMS. MOE: Yes,\n\nTHE COURT: On this one,\n\ntrafficking counts as well.\nto prove the sex trafficking count,\nright?\nyour Honor.\nfor sex trafficking, you have\n\nto prove what with respect to H in order to get a conviction?\n\nMS. MOE: That the victims were less than 18 years\n\nold.\n\nto the trafficking counts,\n\nI would note on that score,\n\nthe issue is\n\nacts in exchange for something of value\n\nyour Honor, with respect\n\nabout commercial sex\n\ninvolving individuals\n\nunder 18. Minor Victim-3 would testify about participating in\n\nsexualized massages with\n\nreceiving compensation in part.\n\nEpstein at the\n\ndefendant's urging and\n\nAnd that's one of the many\n\nother reasons why her testimony is corroborative of other\n\nvictim testimony in this case and direct\n\ncharged crimes.\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nconduct took place at th\n\ne\n\nh\n\nage\n\nvidence of the\n\nindividual who says t\n\nage of 18 for purposes o\n\nCOURT: So the conduct took plac the sexual\n\nof 17. Factually, this is an\n\ngovernment can't establish under the\n\ntravel.\n\nMann Act, not to the traf\n\nFicki\n\nng count.\n\n[ guess that goes to the\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007129\n\n", "char_count": 1614}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nthis testimony as direct\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 79 of 127 79\n\nSo on trafficking, the government would seek to have\n\nvidenc\n\ntrafficking count, because the individual of\n\nwith respect to the\n\nlegal age in all\n\nrelevant jurisdictions was under the age of 1\n\nto\n\nhave to spell it out for me.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nEz\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n8. You're going\n\nfense were to\n\nargue that the defendant didn't know that vic\n\nxe)\n\nhave done\n\nthe trafficking count were under th\n\nage o\n\ntims with respect\n\nf 18 or wouldn't\n\nthis if they were under 18 or that she did not know\n\nthat Epstein had a preference for underage girls or his\n\nsexualized massages were with girls under the age of 18, this\n\nwould certainly speak to\n\ndidn't know that\nsexualized, I think the testimony o\n\nthat issue would cer\n\nIn particular, if the det\n\nTHE COURT: Right. Okay.\n\nthat issue.\n\ntainly make that all the more relevant.\n\nfFendant were to argue that she\nt the massages she was arranging were\n\nf the victim speaking to\n\nI'm not sure the government\n\nhad previously argued this constituted direct\n\nvidence of the\n\ntrafficking count, is that right?\nMS. MOE: Your Honor, I would have to review our\nbriefing. I believe we said that it was direct evidence of the\n\ncharged crimes.\n\napologize if\n\nwe were vague about that, but\n\nour view 1s the entire course ot\n\nde\n\nsu\n\nfendant's role and knowledge,\n\nfficient.\n\nF conduct speaks to the\n\nand the proof\n\nhere is mutually\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT RE\n\nPORT\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nBRS, P.\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007130\n", "char_count": 1654}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 80 of 127 80\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nTHE COURT: Who\n\nMR. EVERDELL: M\n\nI think your Hon\n\nthe outset, which is if al\n\nam I hearing from on this one?\n\ne, your Honor. Thank you, your Honor.\n\nor hit it right on the head right from\n\n1 we had were allegations related to\n\nthis particular individual\n\n, we would not have a charged crime\n\nhere because there was no\n\nThe only basis\n\ntried to articulate some\n\nevidence of the charged c\n\nwhat happened to her. Sh\n\ncriminal activity at all.\n\nfor which -- I think the government has\n\nbasis for its relevance as direct\n\nrimes is her subjectiv xperience of\n\ne was of legal age in every single\n\njurisdiction where thes\n\nissue of consent, while w\n\nit was entirely legal and\n\nvents allegedly took place. So the\n\ne may have moral objections to this,\n\nthe government can't prove otherwis\n\nSo all she's going to tes\n\nabout those instances, an\n\nof the defendant's guilt\nMoreover, your H\n\nmisleads the jury to hear\n\nhappened to her, even tho\n\ndifference, that is going\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nbecause there is no illeg\n\ntify to, presumably, is how she felt\n\nd that is not proof that is probative\n\nof these charges.\n\nonor, it is quite inflammatory and\n\nwhen someone feels a certain way what\n\nugh legally it doesn't make a\n\nto encourage them to feel sympathy\n\nfor her and convict the defendant potentially on a false ground\n\nal conduct here.\n\nYour Honor, I th\n\nat least tried to articul\n\nink the government has articulated or\n\nate at the Court's urging a basis why\n\nthis may be direct eviden\n\nce of the sex trafficking conspiracy.\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007131\n\n", "char_count": 1761}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 81 of 127 81\nLB1TMAX3\nThat really was not spelled out in the briefing.\n\nTHE COURT: think for sure it wasn't, because just\nhearing it for the first time, it strikes me as having\npotential plausibility. That was not present in the papers, so\n\ncertainly will\n\nMOre .\n\nMR.\n\nteed up,\n\nthere is a time di\n\nneed brieti\n\nEVERDELL:\n\ncan\n\nI would have addressed it.\n\nbetw\n\nassure you if\n\nBut\n\nFing and to think about that question\n\nit had been really\n\nwould note that\n\nn the Mann\n\nrence\n\nand the sex traf\n\nThe sex traf\n\nparticular individual\n\ntime 2001 to 2004 is\n\nwas well over the age of\n\nplace in '94 and '95\n\nwell past the age of\n\njurisdictions.\n\ngoing on.\n\nwhen she'\n\nconsent in any of\n\nI don't see how it is probative of\n\nFicking counts.\n\nFicking counts are 2001 to 2004,\n\nAct conspiracies\n\nand this\n\nShe's alleg\n\ns 17 and 18.\n\nconsent by the\n\ning events that took\n2001\n\nto 2004 is\n\nthes\n\ne relevant\n\nthe defendant's\n\nintent -- when someone is presumably allegedly engaging in\n\nSex a\n\nperfectly legal\n\nknowledge, or any of\nAnd by the way, there\nare we talking about\n\nIt seems lik\n\ncts,\n\nthe above of\n\n'\"s no al\n\nhow that is probative of\n\nintent,\n\na sex tra\n\nlegation that\n\nsex tra\n\nicking?\n\nfFficking conspiracy.\n\nshe got paid, so how\n\nthe government is trying to take an\n\nepisode of legal conduct and make it sound salacious for the\njury and use it as direct evidence of conspiracies for which it\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007132\n", "char_count": 1637}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 82 of 127 82\nLB1TMAX3\n\nis entirely irrelevant, every single one of them.\n\nSo our view, Judge, is that her testimony should not\n\ncome in as direct evidence of the conspiracy. At best, what\n\nthe government has articulated they keep talking about\n\npattern, intent, knowledge. That's classic 404(b). So if\n\nwe're going to talk about this witness's testimony at all, we\n\nshould be talking about it in terms of 404(b) and whether it\n\nmeets that test. And it doesn't, your Honor. It is not\n\nprobative of knowledge or intent.\n\nFor a crime that charges causing someone to travel to\n\nengage in a legal sex act as a minor, if that person is neither\n\na minor, did not travel with the intent of doing something\n\nillegal because it was not illegal in any of those\n\njurisdictions, whatever happened, according to her own\n\ntestimony, it is not probative of any of those crimes and for\n\n404(b) purposes, too.\n\nPattern, Judge, if it's modus operandi, that need to\nbe extremely specific before that can come in as modus operandi\nvidence. We can't talk about engaging in social pleasantries\n\nand polite conversation with someone as a pattern. That is not\na pattern that passes muster.\n\nFurthermore, there are huge 403 issues with this\n\nwitness's testimony. If she talks about how she felt about\n\nthes xperiences, that is eliciting sympathy from the jury.\n\nIt is not legally probative and it will lead them to think that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007133\n", "char_count": 1639}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nfelt,\n\nshe\n\nin her words,\n\nDocument 465\n\nthat she\nraises a\npremise,\n\nthat was\n\nwas in\n\nreal probl\n\non a legal\n\nfact engaging in illegal\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nconduct\n\nlem that the jury will\n\nLl convict\n\nsexually abused in these\n\nPage 83 of 127\n\n83\n\ncircumstances,\n\non\n\nAnd it\n\na\n\nfalse\n\nly incorrect assumption that the conduct\n\noccurring was illegal when it wasn't.\n\nSo your Honor,\n\npurpose at this trial.\n\npoints on\n\nFicki\n\ntrat\n\nMS.\n\nMOE:\n\ne by one,\n\nthink that it is none\n\nThank you, your\n\nwith respect to\n\nng counts.\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT:\n\nAm I\n\nnot argued in the papers.\n\nmore spec\n\nthe way w\n\nage of\n\nshould have been more specific about\n\nconduct,\n\nthis dir\n\nMS.\n\nMOE:\n\napologize,\n\nific,\n\ne framed it was about pret\n\n18 and about the course of\n\nBu\n\nand I\n\nt with respect to th\nthink the j\n\nvidence,\n\ndo apologize about\n\nwe object to her test\n\nHonor.\n\nthe time di\n\nyour Honor,\n\nference\n\nconduct,\n\nJus\n\ntimony\n\nthat.\n\nbut\n\ntim\n\nfram\n\nthat.\n\nury would be\n\nthat\n\nwas being\n\necu\n\nLia.\n\na prefere\n\nwould engage in sexual contact\n\n1994 when\n\nnce\n\nfFficked,\n\nfor girls under\n\nthat\n\nthe age of\n\napologize,\n\nthe defendant knew that\n\nFference,\n\nright -- point me to the page.\n\nI do think\n\nfor girls under\n\nand the course of\n\nfree to conclude,\n\nfor any\n\nt to taking those\n\nwe\n\ntheless relevant with respect to the sex\n\nIt's\n\nwe should have been\n\nthat\n\nthe\n\nwe\n\nbased on\nin 2002 and 2003 when Minor Victim-—-4\n\nEpstein had\n\n18 and knew that he\n\nwith\n\nthem becaus\n\nshe knew in\n\nshe was involved in transporting Minor Victim-1\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nthat\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007134\n", "char_count": 1732}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nshe knew about\n\nthat pr\n\nDocument 465\n\nFerenc\n\nbecaus\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 84 of 127 84\n\nof her conduct with\n\nrespect to Minor Victim-2 and with respect to Minor Victim-3.\n\nThat course of\n\nconsistent. And I\n\nthat is powerful proof\n\nconduct continued throughout\n\nie)\n\ndirect evidenc\n\nthink the consistency of\n\nof the crimes charged.\n\na decade and is\n\nthat is part of why\n\nf her knowledge and intent and why it's\n\nWith respect to the question of pr\n\nejudice, the\n\ngovernment doesn't see any risk that this jury could convict on\n\nthis conduct for a number of reasons.\n\nFirst,\n\nthink we're cont\n\nexplain to the jury what\n\nindictment are and what they aren't.\n\nfFident tha\n\ncase in many trials that ther\n\nthat is nonetheless of\n\ncrimes. For example, i\n\nrobbery and th\n\nrobbery the det\n\nconduct but nonetheless of\n\ncrimes charged\n\nevidence or introduce it wit\n\nis lawful conduct to suggest\n\nt the Court\n\nthat the jury would convict based on this conduct alone,\n\nwith respect to the concern that there's a risk\n\nt's jury instructions will\n\nthe elements of\n\n\"s eviden\n\nth\n\nce of\n\nFered as direct\n\nvid\n\ne charges in the\n\nAnd it's certainly the\n\nlawful conduct\n\nr wer\n\nvidenc\n\ntf\n\nFendant bought a ski mask, th\n\nendorses that conduct.\n\nFered as direct\n\nnce of the charged\n\nf this were a case involving a Hobbs Act\n\nthat on the morning of the\n\nat would be lawful\n\nvidence of the\n\nand it would be peculiar to either exclude that\n\nth a limiting instruction that that\n\nt that in some way the Court\n\nTHE COURT: The hypo is interesting. If the ski mask\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007135\n\n", "char_count": 1754}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 85 of 127 85\nLB1TMAX3\n\nis bought that day, it's direct evidence, if it's bought three\n\nyears earlier or three years later, at best it's 404(b)\n\nevidence, not direct evidenc\n\nMS. MOE: Well, here the pattern would be much\n\nstronger, that the defendant participated -- again, to play out\n\nthe analogy -- in a robbery in 1994 involving ski masks, and\n\nanother robbery in 1995 involving ski masks, and again another\n\nrobbery in which the defendant bought ski masks, and then a\n\nrobbery years later in which the perpetrator was wearing a very\n\nSimilar ski mask. That's the pattern here and why this is\n\ndirect evidence of the defendant's methods and her knowledge\n\nand intent.\n\nTHE COURT: That's 404(b), evidence of methods, of MO.\n\nMS. MOE: Here, your Honor, the government certainly\n\nsubmits that this would otherwise be admissible under Rule\n\n404(b), but here where the conduct is intertwined with the\n\nconduct on trial, that it speaks to her knowledge about\n\npreferences and the role that she played and the similarity,\n\nand the fact this happened during the course of the charged\n\nconspiracy the same time the defendant was involved in this\n\nconduct with respect to other --\n\nTHE COURT: During the time of the Mann Act charged\nconspiracy.\n\nMS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Not the trafficking charged conspiracy.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007136\n", "char_count": 1567}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465 _ Filed 11/15/21\n\nPage 86 of 127 86\n\nLB1TMAX3\n\n1 MS. MOE: That's correct, your Honor.\n\n2 THE COURT: So I need to get something in writing on\n3 the trafficking count, because you haven't raised it directly\n4 before and the defense hasn't had an opportunity to respond to\n5 it before.\n\n6 With respect to how this has been argued, I don't\n\n7 think there's a basis to exclude entirely, but let me tell you\n8 my thinking and I will hear a reaction to it.\n\n9 Th vidence related to alleged Victim-3, as the\n10 government describes her, is not direct evidence of the\n11 conspiracy charged in Counts One and Three of the indictment.\n12 Counts One and Three charge the defendant with conspiracy to\n13 entice minors to travel to engage in illegal sex acts and\n\n14 conspiracy to transport minors with intent to engage in\n\n15 criminal sexual activity.\n\n16 The parties agree that alleged Victim-3 was 17 at the\n17 time she was acquainted with the defendant and Epstein in\n\n18 London, England where the age of consent is 16. Moreover, she\n19 can't recall, and the government wouldn't be able to establish\n20 that she was invited to travel with the defendant when she was\n21 17 or 18. And because the alleged victim was over the age of\n22 consent in all relevant jurisdictions and, therefore, any\n23 alleged sexual activity was lawful, the alleged conduct does\n24 not arise out of the same transactions or series of\n25 transactions as the charged offense. It's not inextricably\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007137\n\n", "char_count": 1567}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "ay\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBITMAX3\n\nintertwined with the evidence,\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nAct,\n\non trial, so\n\nMann Act counts.\n\nThere's a prejudice analysis that\n\nDocument 465\n\nand it's not necessary\n\nagain with re\n\nto complete the\n\nI don't think it can be direct\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 87 of 127 87\n\nspect to the Mann\n\nthe crime\n\nstory of\n\nthe\n\nvidence of\n\nit strikes me th\n\nI will get to ina\n\nmoment, but as prof\n\nunder\n\nfered,\n\n404 (b)\n\nas relevant te\n\na proper purpos\n\ndefendant's knowledge,\n\nproffered testimony coul\n\nintent and alleged MO.\n\nld tend to establish\n\nwas aware of, for exampl]\n\nmassages.\n\nthere's no knowledge,\n\nSo if the argument is massages ar\n\nthis witness might hav\n\nle, the sexualized na\n\nsupport that\n\ntestimony that could ref\n\nute that point. The\n\nthe defendant asked the witness\n\ntestimony may serve\n\nthe\n\nstimony of\nFor example, the\n\nthat the defendant\n\nture of the alleged\ne not sexual or\n\ne evidence and\n\ntestimony could\n\nto recruit\n\nunderage girls to engage in similar sexualized massages which\n\ntends to make th\n\nalleg\n\nd MO more probable.\n\nThe testimony that this witness was\n\nby the defendant does not\n\nknowledge, intent or MO\n\nmore, the kind of\n\nwas not a minor pursuant to the age of\n\ntestimony I\n\ntend to establish\n\nallegedly groomed\n\nthe defendant's\n\nms alone without\n\nto groom minor victi\n\nindicated, bec\n\nthis witness\n\nconse\n\nthe relevant jurisdictions.\n\nI will say I\n\ntestimony,\n\nconfusing issues and misleading the jury.\n\nbut there's a risk of\n\nthink there may be room\n\na prejudice\n\naus\n\nnt laws in any of\n\nfor 404(b)\n\n, the risk of\n\nA limiting\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nDISTR\n\nCT REPORTERS,\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007138\n", "char_count": 1748}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "ay\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBITMAX3\n\ninstruction that makes clear that any alleged conduc\n\nNO\n\nlawful\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nand cannot\n\nDocument 465\n\nform the basis of\n\ncertainly would be required to ensure that probative value is\n\nnot substantially outweighed by potential\n\nSo that's my thinking.\n\nthe government\n\nt on the anticipat\n\nproposed limit\n\nbriefing on whether ther\n\nting instruction\n\nas to the traf\n\nFicking count.\n\nSO\n\nthat outlines anticipated testimony\n\n404 (b)\n\nwith respect to\n\nI will ask the gov\n\nthe Mann Act counts,\n\nas\n\na proposed limiting ins\n\nextent the government does have\n\nthought-through argument about direct\n\ntruction in that regard,\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 88 of 127 88\nt was\na conviction in this case\nprejudice.\n\nI'm going to need more from\nted testimony. I want to seea\nthat would go to that, and I want\n\nmight be a basis for direct evidenc\nrnment here for a submission\nthat would be potentially\n\nI've indicated,\n\nand to the\n\nvidenc\n\nI think a not-yet-really\n\nas to the\n\ntrafficking act, I'm open to hearing it.\n\nSo let me look at the calendar. [ will get briefing\nfrom the government and then a response time from the defense.\n\nGovernment by the 5th, defense response by the 10th.\n\nQuestions about that, Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: No, your Honor, thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Mr. Everdell?\n\nMR. EVERDELL: No questions on this schedule or the\nCourt's direction. We would like to clarify one thing, which I\nbelieve the Court said that the parties agree that this\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORTERS, PwC.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007139\n\n", "char_count": 1639}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nW\n\nws\n\nOn\n\nOY\n\n~l\n\noO\n\nKe\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBITMAX3\n\nparticular individua\n\nDocument 465 =F\n\n1 was 17.\n\nshe was 17. It's quite possible, i\n\nolder than that, but\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nagree. Thank you.\n\nWe agree\n\niled 11/15/21 Page 89 of 127\n\n89\n\nthat she alleges that\n\nn fact likely, that she was\n\nFair enough.\n\nAnd I should say on that,\n\ngovernment anticipated putting in evidence about the sort of\n\nsubjective feelings\n\nof the\n\nI wanted to clarify that.\n\nAt least 17, the parties\n\nMs. Moe, I don't know if\n\nrelevance in light o\n\nhere and my ruling,\n\nf the fact of t\n\nthe\n\nindividual. I can't say I see the\n\nhe legality of the conduct\n\nand certainly 403 prejudice would be a\n\nconcern. So if that is something that the government is still\n\ncontemplating, despite what\n\ninclude briefing with respect to that.\n\nMS. MOE: Y\n\nes,\n\nyour Honor.\n\nthat this is a difficult thing to discuss,\n\npoint on that issue.\n\nintending to elicit\n\nBut\n\nany\n\ncertainly find that\n\nCourt's ruling.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nthis individual, all\n\nLor\n\nYou\n\nthe Court,\n\ns the potential,\n\nMy point was simply I\n\ntestimony about that, we would\n\nparticularly in light of\n\nof the conduct with respect to this\n\nindividual, that the sort\n\nof\n\npotential to prejudice the jury by convicting on a basis\n\nwhich may be true, would have the\n\nSOUTH\n\nE RN\n\nDISTRICT RE\n\nPORTERS, PwC.\n\n(212) 805-\n\n0300\n\nI've indicated here, you'll have to\n\nthink it would be obvious based on the way that she presents\nand so that was my\n\ntake the Court's point, if we were\n\nthe\n\ngiven the legality\n\nof feelings as to the immorality or wrongness or damage done to\n\nfor\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007140\n", "char_count": 1698}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 90 of 127\n\nLB1TMAX3\n1 which conviction the government has conceded would be\n2 inappropriate, would be unlawful.\n3 MS. MOE: understand the Court's concern and we\n4 certainly don't anticipate eliciting testimony about the\n5 victim's conclusions about the event or suggesting that it was\n6 unlawful or satisfied certain elements. My point was simply in\n7 describing it, which would be difficult for Minor Victim-3,\n8 that sort of her feelings about that or the circumstances that\n9 that -- in narrating the facts of the event would I think come\n10 to light at trial, but we certainly don't intend to elicit\n11 testimony about conclusions, about things like consent or\n12 whether it was lawful, and particularly in light of the Court's\n13 ruling, and in any event, we wouldn't be seeking to proffer\n14 legal conclusions from a witness.\n15 THE COURT: Okay. Anything further on that, counsel?\n16 MS. MOE: Not from the government, your Honor.\n17 MR. EVERDELL: No, your Honor, thank you.\n18 THE COURT: Defendant's 5 I think we determined is a\n19 non-issue. This goes to evidence that the defense was\n20 concerned in the government presenting regarding flight, and\n21 the government has represented that it will not offer evidenc\n22 as to flight. Is that correct, Ms. Moe?\n23 MS. MOE Yes, your Honor.\n24 THE COURT: Anything else we need to address here?\n25 MR. EVERDELL: No, your Honor.\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\n90\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007141\n", "char_count": 1508}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 91 of127 91\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nTH\n\ntp\n\n25\n\nans)\n\nCOURT: Defendant's 6 is evidence of the\n\ndefendant's alleged false statements and regarding redacting\n\nallegations related to the perjury counts in the indictment,\n\nwhich I severed. The government has agreed not to introduce\n\nevidence of\n\nt\n\nhese alleged false statements and agrees to the\n\nproposed redaction.\n\nAnything else that we need to address here, Ms. Moe?\n\nMOE:\n\nGl\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nEVERDELL: No, your Honor, thank you.\n\nG!\n\naia\n\nfe\n\nD\n\nMS.\n\nMR.\n\nTH\n\nDe\naddressed.\npoint?\n\nMS.\n\nCOURT: Thank you.\n\nndant's 7 is Exhibit 52, which I think we have\n\noOo we need to discuss that any further at this\n\nMOE:\n\nGI\n\nNothing further from the government, your\n\nHonor, thank you.\n\nMR.\n\nPAGLIUCA: Your Honor, I think we do need to\n\ndiscuss this a little bit further.\n\nThe problem that we have on the defense side of this\n\nis that the government says that we can establish a foundation\n\nprovenance of\n\nfor this, but\n\nI'm quite frankly very skeptical about the\n\nthat foundation.\n\nThis is an exhibit that surfaces in 2009, and we don't\n\nknow how it surfaced. Assuming it was stolen by now deceased,\n\ntwice convicted felon Alfredo Rodriguez and sold to the\n\ngovernment,\n\na\n\nssume that for a moment, we don't know where it\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007142\n\n", "char_count": 1493}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 92 of 127 92\nLB1TMAX3\n\ncame\n\ngoing\n\nsuspe\n\nwasn't around in 2004.\n\nfrom\n\nor how it was created.\n\nThe government says that it has a witness that is\n\nCO Ss\n\nay that that was Ms. Maxwell's book. I'm highly\n\nct of\n\nthat to begin with. And secondarily, that witness\n\nthis purported foundation, both of whom were\n\nAnd so we have now two witnesses for\n\nnot employed\n\nduring the relevant timeframe of the conspiracy. So I'm ata\n\nloss,\n\nauthe\n\ndocument.\n\nthen they will say as a business record\n\nwe'll]\n\nThe government says well,\n\nadmi\n\nfrankly, to understand how anyone could either\n\nnticate that document or admit it as some non-hearsay\n\neven if it's not admissible,\n\nthat\n\nis.\n\nt it for some other purpose, which I\n\nAnd if they're admitting it for another purpose,\n\nthe government says\n\ndon't know what\n\ndon't understand the relevance of this, given the inability to\n\nestablish a foundation and to tie it with any alleged conduct\n\nthat is part of the indictment in this case.\n\n5\n\no I don't think we can just leave\n\nhave a discussion about this in the middle o\n\nSeems\n\nthe g\n\nto m\n\novern\n\nthis here and then\n\nf trial. And it\n\ne that in this type of hearing, a pretrial hearing,\n\nment should say here's the witness\n\nauthe\n\nthat\n\nntica\n\n1s wh\n\nthat\n\nwe th\n\nthat is going to\n\nte it, here's how they're going to\n\nauthenticate it,\n\nat we're authenticating it for, here are the pages\n\nink are relevant and here's why.\n\ne don't have anything of that information. We are\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,\n(212) 805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007143\n", "char_count": 1703}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 93 of 127 93\nLB1TMAX3\n\n1 left with: Yeah, we think we can admit this. Given this lack\n2 of evidentiary foundation, I think we should address this issue\n3 now.\n\n4 MS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor.\n\n5 With respect to the particulars in the exhibit, the\n\n6 government has marked and produced to the defens xcerpts from\n7 that book that it intends to offer at trial. So the defense\n\n8 knows the limited number of pages from that book that the\n\n9 government intends to offer at trial.\n\n10 THE COURT: What pages?\n\n11 MS. MOE: Your Honor, I don't have the exhibit numbers\n12 in front of me, but they're included in the subset that we\n13 provided to the Court. [ think there are about -—- I don't want\n14 to guess, but somewhere between four and six particular pages,\n15 one in particular relating to victims in this case. So we are\n16 happy to confer with the defense about those particular\n17 exhibits and then raise those issues to the Court if there is\n18 still confusion on that score.\n19 With respect to the question of authentication,\n20 think the defense's argument confuses the question of chain of\n21 custody with the question of authentication. I know the Second\n22 Circuit has rejected essentially exactly the argument that the\n23 defense is advancing here. For example, in a case of United\n24 States v. Al Farekh, 810 F.App'x 21, (2d Cir. 2020), the\n25 defense argued the government shouldn't be able to offer\n\nSOUTHERN DIS\n\nTR\n\nCT\n\nRE\n\nPORTERS, PwC.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007144\n\n", "char_count": 1546}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nWw\n\na\nOY\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBITMAX3\n\ncertain documents that\n\nDocument 465\n\nwere obtained by an FB\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 94 of 127 94\n\nagent on a USB\n\ndrive, and the au\nfamiliarity with the\nthe documents, their\n\ngovernment did not present\n\nsurrounding the seizure of\n\nappearance,\n\ntrue here.\n\nthentication\n\nLes\n\ntimony was about the\n\nwitnesses with things like handwriting on\n\nstructure and the like.\n\nAnd in that\n\nEvidence 901(b) (4)\n\ncontents\n\ndistinctive characte\n\ncase,\n\nThe same will be\n\nthe Second Circuit said although the\n\nvidenc\n\nthe USB drive,\n\nregarding the circumstances\n\nFederal Rule of\n\npermits authen\n\n, substance,\n\ntLication based on the\n\ninternal patterns or other\n\nristics of\n\nall the circumstance\n\ntestimony at trial\n\nduring the trial,\n\nthe items\n\ntaken together with\n\nWe're ha\n\nbe of\n\ns. And the government submits that the\nwill satisfy all of the aspects of Rule 901\n\npey to submit additional briefing on this\nbut in particular, given we don't intend to\n\nfered in particular related\n\ncase,\n\ncontains contact\ntheir names,\n\nnames of -—-\n\noffer any evidence from this book in our opening statement —--\nTHE COURT: What is it going to be offered for?\nMS. MOE: Your Honor, the evidence from that book will\n\nto the minor victims in this\n\nrelevance of\n\nso that's th\nTHE COURT:\nMS. MOE:\n\nBut why?\n\nt would be a\n\nin\n\normation for\n\nin a section marked\n\nthose documents.\n\npage of that book that\n\nseveral victims,\n\nincluding\n\n\"Massage\" that includes the\n\nthink it's exclusively female girls with\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007145\n\n", "char_count": 1636}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 95 of127 95\nLB1TMAX3\n\nparentheticals like \"Mom\" or \"Parents,\" showing that the\ncontact number for the individuals in a section marked\n\n\"Massage\" is\n\nthe minor victims\n\nin this trial.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIt's not\n\nfor people's parents.\n\nin this case\n\nThat list includes some of\n\nthat the jury will learn about\n\ngoing to be talked about in\n\nn\n\nFront\n\nopenings, but before i\n\nauthentication process happens,\n\nput out speci\n\nwith respect to this,\n\nand with specificity,\n\nthis full\n\nof\n\nthe jury\n\nI would lik\n\nthe government to\n\nfically what it intends to enter into evidence\n\nwho will provide\n\nras to that testimony. And you\n\nframe questions that\n\nauthentication and the proffe\nwi deal with the tim\nwe\nMS. MOE: Certainly,\nTHE COURT:\n\nwhat's been suggested,\n\nunderstanding of\n\nan\n\n[ need to see a little bit\n\nd I\n\nwhat is potentially being of\n\nhave been raised as\n\nyour Honor.\n\nmore than\n\nneed to have a better\n\nfered for.\n\nMS. MOE: Understood, your Honor, certainly.\n\nTHE COURT: So when would you like to do that?\n\nMS. MOE: Your Honor, may I confer with my colleagues?\n\nTHE COURT: Sure.\n\n(Pause)\n\nMS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor. Could we possibly\nsubmit it on November 10, along with other briefing that date?\n\nTHE COURT: That's fine.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007146\n\n", "char_count": 1466}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 96 of 127 96\nLB1TMAX3\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: That's fine, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Respond in the same timefram\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: Understood.\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nCOURT: Defendant's 8 is the search, the El Brillo\n\nWay search. The defendant seeks to prohibit the introduction\n\nof\n\nany items seized during an October 2000 search of\n\nEpstein's Palm Beach residence.\n\nThe defense raises concerns, including how\n\nJeffrey\n\nand where\n\nthe evidence was maintained, the lack of authenticating\n\nwitnesses and\n\nMs.\n\nthe lack of relevance to the charges against\n\nMaxwell. Here, again, the government states that it\n\nintends to call witnesses to establish the authenticity of the\n\nevidence.\n\nthat at trial law ent\n\nSo how do we take this up now, Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. The government\n\nsubmits\n\nforcement witnesses will discuss the search\n\nand lay a foundation for the admission of this evidence.\n\nwitnesses that did exactly what with respect to the\n\nMS. MOE: They were personally involved in\n\nTHE COURT: So as to authentication, you have\n\nsearch?\n\nthe search.\n\nTHE COURT: Okay. So they will describe the process\n\nby which they engaged in the search and the evidence that they\n\nobtained and how it was maintained and the like.\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: And the relevance of the search result\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007147\n\n", "char_count": 1522}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nDocument 465 ‘Filed 11/15/21 Page\n\nevidence is what?\n\nMS.\n\nphotographs\n\nrelevant both to give context to\n\nfrom that residence and\n\nfrom the\n\nMOE: exhibits\n\nYour Honor, a number of\n\nthere are a number of marke\n\nthat residence whi\n\ninterior of\n\nthe jury about wha\n\n97 of 127 oF\n\nwere seized\n\nd\nch are\nt the\n\ninterior looked like but in particular about certain\n\ndecorations in th\n\nwitnesses will describe but also\n\nnumber of,\n\nfor example,\n\nresidence that are both consiste\n\nfor the\n\nillustrate\n\nnude images in the house an\n\nthat give context to sort of\nwould have while inside\n\ncorroborative of\n\nthe knowledge that cer\n\n[. think all tha\n\nthe house.\n\nwitness testimony and, for the\n\ncertain items seized\n\nexample,\n\na massage table was seized\n\nfrom the residence will be\n\nas\n\nmarked as a government exhibit.\n\nnt with what\njury the\nd otherwise\n\ntain people\n\nt will be\n\nSame reasons,\n\nwell. For\n\nfrom that residence and is\n\nTHE COURT: Okay. Who is taking this one?\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: This would be me, your Honor. Again,\nthis is very, suppose, aspirational by the government that\nthey can lay these foundations.\n\nTHE COURT: This sounds like pretty standard stuff\nLaw enforcement had a search warrant, engaged in a search, this\nis what they found, here's how they marked it, here it is.\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: The affiant who conducted the search\n\nand who took\n\nthe items into evidence is deceased.\n\nbelieve, two\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n(212)\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.C.\n805-0300\n\nThere are,\n\nofficers who participated in the search, but ina\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007148\n", "char_count": 1678}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLBITMAX3\n\ndiscrete fashion, and I\n\nabout what the other of\n\nDocument 465\n\nbelieve they do not\n\nFicers did or didn't\n\nsearch.\n\nAnd look,\n\ncould say I was there,\n\nfine.\n\ncan't put it all together\n\nI was over here and did this,\n\nI understand if\nsaw this,\n\nI don't have a problem with\n\nhaven't identified that witness or what\n\nwitness is going to talk about.\n\nsomebody over\n\nfor you 20 years a\n\ncan au\n\nthat. B\n\npie\n\nProblem number two is the timing of\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nthey have a\n\nPage 98 of 127\n\n98\n\nhave knowledge\n\ndo as part\n\nSo what we end up with is this piecemeal approach of:\n\nthere did that,\n\nthat\n\nof\n\nbut\n\nfter the\n\nwitness\n\nfact.\n\nwho\n\nthenticate,\n\nut again,\n\nthat's\n\nthey\n\nthis\n\nces of\n\nthis.\n\nOctober 2005 search wher\n\ntable has to do with 1994,\n\nWhether it was\n\nthat in a moment in time,\n\nitems wer\n\nto now relate back to a 1994 to 2004\n\nthat\n\nSo that's problem number one.\n\nThis is an\n\nthey seized items that they're trying\ntimefram What that\nI don't know. 2004, I don't know.\n\nthere in 2004,\n\nin\n\nwe don't know.\n\nOctober 2005,\n\nseized and that ends up on a search\n\ninventory\n\nfoundation to it.\n\nAnd there may be discrete pieces of\n\ncertain witness might be able to identi\n\nfrom a deceased detectiv\n\nThat's my problem,\n\nthat do\n\nyour\n\nfy,\n\nAl\n\n1 we know is\n\nsomeone says these\n\nwarrant\n\ne500\n\nHonor.\n\nbut I think\n\ndo it, and\n\njust short shrifting the whole eviden\nthese proffers where they're saying we can\nconvinced they can.\nTHE COURT: We're not short shrif\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,\n(212) 805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\n't have any\n\nevidence that a\n\nwe're\n\ntiary process here with\n\nI'm not\n\nFring because it\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007149\n", "char_count": 1769}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 99 of 127 99\n\nL\n\nBITMAX3\n\nhasn't happened yet. What you're making are cross points.\n\nMs. Moe, obviously you're dealing with a time\n\nquestion, and it sounds like one of the primary investigators\n\nor law enforcement who engaged in the search is deceased. So\n\nwhat's the proffer to the Court as to what specifically the\n\ngovernment will do to authenticate these items?\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. On this score, I would\n\nnote there is a difference, certainly, between authentication\n\nand chain of custody. With respect to authentication, law\n\nenforcement witnesses who personally participated in the search\n\nwill describe what they observed in the search and how they --\n\nTHE COURT: The government's proffer to the Court is\n\nthat even though one of the Law enforcement relevant here is\n\ndeceased, that you have other law enforcement who have personal\n\nknowledge of these items being found where they were and seized\n\nwhen they were, t cetera?\n\nmu\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor. I additionally note that\n\nthe search was video recorded, that video has been produced to\n\nthe defense, and so some of these items also appear on the\n\nvideo walk through of that search. And so our view is that\n\ntheir direct testimony about their experiences in the search\n\nsatisfies our obligations with respect to authenticity.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n['m not going to prohibit this in lLimine,\n\nbut questions remain as to the government's ability to\n\nauthenticate the items, and there will be an opportunity for\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007150\n", "char_count": 1711}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 100 of 127 100\nLB1TMAX3\n\nthe defense to engage in the full set of questions that counsel\n\nhas indicated, but for purposes of the in limine motion, it's\n\ndenied.\n\nDefense 19. Here, the defense seeks to suppress\n\nalleged Victim-4's identification of Ms. Maxwell on the ground\n\nthat the government used unduly suggestive photo array\n\nprocedures that violate due process rights.\n\nam prepared to deny this motion. Eyewitness\nidentifications should be excluded when improper police conduct\ncreated a substantial likelihood of misidentification. Perry\n\nv. New Hampshire, 565 U.S. 228, (2012).\n\nfollow a two-step analysis in ruling on the\n\nadmissibility of identification evidence. First, I must\ndetermine whether the pretrial identification procedures wer\nunduly suggestive. Some examples of suggestive procedures\n\ninclude using a very small number of photographs, making\n\nsuggestive comments, or the display of the accused in a way\n\nthat so stood out from all other photographs to suggest to an\n\nidentifying eyewitness that the person was more likely to be\n\nthe culprit. See, United States v. Concepcion, 983 F.2d 369,\n\n(2d Cir. 1992).\n\nLooking at the photo array, neither the photos used or\n\nthe procedure itself was unduly suggestive. The array\n\ncontained a sufficient number of photos larger than many arrays\n\nthat courts have held were not unduly suggestive. Defense's\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007151\n", "char_count": 1608}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "be\n\nNO\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 101 of 127 101\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nargument that the Ms. Maxwell's photo looks like a mugshot and\n\nis different from the others doesn't persuade me here. Alleged\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nVictim-4 identified at least one other photo in the array that\n\nshe thought could be Ms. Maxwell but she ultimately chose\n\nMs. Maxwell's photo, and there were several photos in the array\n\nthat were of roughly the same quality and angle as\n\nMs. Maxwell's photo.\n\nThe defense fails to identify any suggestive comments\n\nmade during the identification that would deem the procedures\n\nunduly suggestive. The government appears to have asked\n\nwhether the individual recognized anyone in the book. So\n\nconclude the identification procedure was not unduly\n\nsuggestive.\n\nEven assuming the photo array was unduly suggestive,\n\nthe identification here had independent reliability factors\n\nmust consider under the totality of circumstances that include\n\nthe opportunity of the witness to view the individual at the\n\ntime of the alleged crime, the witness's degree of attention,\n\nthe accuracy of the the witness's prior description of the\n\nindividual, the level of uncertainty demonstrated, the length\n\nof time between the alleged crime and the confrontation. See,\n\nNeil v. Biggers, 409 U.S. 188, (1972).\n\nHere, the alleged Victim-4 had the opportunity to view\n\nMs. Maxwell. They interacted several times over the span of\n\nyears. As the government points out, the alleged interactions\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007152\n", "char_count": 1667}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\n\nLBITMAX3\n\nwith Ms. Maxwell make th\n\naccurate than other instances wher\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 102 of 127 102\n\nidentification more\n\nalleged victim's\n\nidentii\n\nfication has been\n\ndeemed admissible, like when a witness saw the defendant in the\n\ndistance under street-lit\n\nillumination and was\n\nthe individual seeing them in the neighborhood.\n\n(Continued on next page)\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nLD\n\nfamiliar with\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007153\n\n", "char_count": 606}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\ndeterminative because of\nthe alleged individual and Ms.\n\nable to identi\n\narray with lit\n\nleave it at that.\n\nTh\n\ndef\n\nfy Ms.\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\nLB15max4\n\nTHE COURT: (Continuing)\n\nThe government also correctly notes that\ntime between the alleged misconduct and identi\n\nthe\n\ntle hesitation.\n\nissue but\n\nputs,\n\nsuppression of\n\ngained\nBrown,\n\nDe\n\ne)\n\nns\nI don't see\nin genuine disput\n\nthe\n\nfrequency of\n\nMaxwell.\n\nMaxwell when she got\n\nThe argument that --—\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nica\n\nPage 103 of 127\n\ntion\n\nthe delay in\n\nis not\n\nin\n\nAlleged Vict\n\nto the phot\n\nteractions between\n\ntim 4 was\n\nto in the\n\nI will\n\nrequested an evidentiary hearing on this\n\nidentii\n\nLe,\n\nfacts put\n\nany\n\n784 F. App'x J\nfense 10.\n\nfficers which the def\n\nfrom an evidentiary rehearing,\n\n(2d Cir.\n\n2019)\n\nmoves to exc\n\nExpert testimony by law en\n\nhas noticed inten\n\nto call three law ent\n\nns\n\nforward by the det\n\nlude and\n\nForcement of\n\nfense that\nfacts that would support\nFication so there would be nothing\nsee United States v.\n\nso the request is denied.\nforcement\n\nthe government\n\nficers as\n\nfact witnesses but not as experts. The government represents\n\nthat it will not elicit expert testimony from any of them.\nSo, the law enforcement officers can testify as fact\n\nwitnesses to the facts that they personally perceived but not\n\nprovide test\n\nimony that summarizes parts of\n\nwhich\n\nthe of\n\nprovide test\n\nexperience.\n\nimony that relies on specia\n\nThe government's example of\n\nthe investigation\nfFicer did not personally experience and may not\n\nlized training and\n\na law enforcement\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nBRS, P.\n\n103\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007154\n", "char_count": 1761}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB]\n\n5max4\n\n2)\n\nparticipated in while executing a\n\npermissible\n\nMs.\n\nregarding an\ngovernment\n\nthis and\n\nDocument 465\n\nFficer testifying as to what the\n\nfact testimony.\n\ne)\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nicer himself\n\nsearch seems to me\n\nPage 104 of 127\n\n104\n\nFound and\n\nAnything to take up here from the defense,\nMenninger?\n\nMS. MENNINGER: No, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: No, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Defense 11 is anticipated testimony\n\nintroduced.\n\nMS. MOE: Certai\n\nalleged rape by Je\n\nt to explain what it int\n\nnly,\n\nAs a threshold matter\n\nthere is an overlap her\n\nde\n\nmo\n\ncharacterize\n\npreclude\n\nfendant's motion\n\nb\n\nEEeYy\n\nEpstein. Let me\n\nyour Honor.\n\n, your\n\nth\n\nin\n\nCW\n\nlimine and\n\nit as consen\n\nit, reference it\n\nwould be happy\n\naddress that\n\nto address\n\nissue in the\nTHE COURT: Coun\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nbriefing.\n\ntion seeks to introduce some of\n\nsual\n\nto b\n\nthat\n\n‘ay\n\nthe\n\nthi\n\nand\n\nHonor, I would n\n\narguments in the\n\n412 motion.\n\ns evidence but\n\nonsensual.\n\nnon—-c\n\nnow,\n\nCen.\n\nsel,\n\nYour Honor,\n\next of\n\ndo you\n\nthe 412 briefing\n\nagree?\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORT\n\nBRS, P.\n\n(212)\n\n805-03\n\n00\n\nAnd so,\n\nask the\n\ntends to do with respect to\n\nfor what purpose the testimony would be sought to be\n\note that\n\nI think one\n\nthe other motion seeks to\n\nbut it may be easier to\n\nwe can wait until the 412\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007155\n\n", "char_count": 1491}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 465\nLB1ib5max4\n\nTHE COURT: So to\nissues,\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 105 of 127\n\nthe extent there is overlap in these\n\nit's best to take it up in the 412 proceeding so that\n\nwe can discuss the issues without violating that rule.\n\nadmission of s\n\nwith respect\n\nbefore me, 401\n\nDefendant's 13.\n\nto\n\neveral exhibits.\n\nExhibit 251 and 2\n\nrelevanc\n\n403 prejudice.\n\nauthentication issue so\n\notherwis\n\n294, so some of\n\nI think\n\npreclude this evidence.\n\ncorroborative\n\nrule out 401 but the det\n\nevidence of\n\n88.\n\n1s minimal, at best\nthe same questions around\n\nthat ruling holds.\n\nThis is a motion to preclude the\n\nI'm going to grant the motion\n\nBased on the briefing\n\n, and outweighed by\n\nthe\n\nT won't\n\nIt is potentially\ntestimony and 403 prejudice does not\n\nfense can maintain the search and\n\nauthentication issues that we have discussed.\n\nprobative of\n\nMr. Epstein.\n\nand that\n\ntestimony and I\n\nExhibit 403\n\nthe relationship bet\n\nI won't preclude,\n\nn the d\n\nit's potentially\n\nfendant and\n\nThe government prof\n\nthat it\n\nwill corroborate\n\nthe photo would corroborate anticipated witness\n\ndon't -- so, ther\n\nis 401 r\n\nlevance and not\n\nsubstantially outweighed by any 403 prejudice.\n\nOn th\n\nhad 403 on min\n\nindicated I am\n\nthe relationsh\n\nis last one\n\nExhibit 313\n\ne. SO;\n\nI may have said the wrong number.\n\nnot excluding, it\n\nis potentia\n\nip between the def\n\noutweighed by\n\nAnd t\n\nprejudice.\n\nhen 606, this is\n\nis the photograph that\n\nIT have\n\nlly probative of\n\nndant and Mr.\n\nEpstein and not\n\nthe issue on authentication and\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORTERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\n105\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007156\n", "char_count": 1738}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "N\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB15max4\n\nhearsay grounds that\n\nthe parties address\n\nyou.\n\nDocument 465 ‘Filed 11/15/21 Page 106 of 127 106\n\nI have already indicated I'm going to have\n\nfurther, correct?\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: Yes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: All right.\n\nAny questions about any of those rulings?\n\nMS. MOE: Not from the government, your Honor. Thank\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA: No, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: And about the time frames I have set on\nthe different pieces that require briefing on after everybody\n\nhas. And, you will get\n\nlogistics\n\nMS.\n\nTHE\n\ntp\n\nthe transcript.\n\nMOE: Understood, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nCOURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nWith\n\niss\n\nthat,\n\nues and I\n\nthey want to raise.\n\nSo,\n\nwill\n\nthink we can pick up some outstanding\n\nhear from counsel as to any issues\n\nwe begin our questionnaire process on Thursday.\n\nThe government\n\noriginal matter.\n\nno identi\n\nfyin\n\ng information and make copies for the defense and\n\nfrom the jury department -- the completed questionnaires with\n\nelectronic copy.\n\nfor the Court.\n\nMy request is to give both a paper copy and an\n\nI think that will aid everybody's use of the\n\nmy chambers will produce the copies as an\n\nThe government will take the completed copies\n\ndocument since we have got multiple people looking at them, and\n\nthen of course return the originals to the Court.\n\nSOUTH\n\nBERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007157\n\n", "char_count": 1503}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB15max4\n\nDocument 465 ‘Filed 11/15/21 Page 107 of 127 107\n\n1 Any questions from the government on its obligations\n2 there?\n3 MS. MOE: No, your Honor. Thank you.\n4 THE COURT: The video remarks, at our last conference,\n5 as we discussed, my plan is to video record the preliminary\n6 instructions to be played for each panel before th\n7 questionnaire. sent the parties my script and there were no\n8 objections. I'm actually going to record that tomorrow.\n9 just want, does either party request to s the video befor\n10 it's played for the prospective jurors on Thursday? Obviously\n1] I'm going to record it exactly as stated in the script.\n12 MS. MOE: No, your Honor.\n13 MS. STERNHEIM: Judge, unless you are wearing some\n14 funky t-shirt, no.\n15 THE COURT: It's just a robe. Thank you.\n16 Just in thinking ahead to the voir dire process,\n17 have preliminary instructions that I'm drafting that I will\n18 give to each panel before they are individually brought in for\n19 the voir dire. Thinking ahead again, just for time-saving\n20 purposes, what I propose is we do another video of that so that\n2] it is played for each panel there is a morning panel and\n22 afternoon panel. And the logistics of all of this is\n23 complicated. So, what I propose I will send out, again, my\n24 script, let me know if you have any comments or objections, and\n25 once we all agree I will record it so that the jury staff can\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007158\n\n", "char_count": 1494}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB15max4\n\nust play it\n\nul.\n\nAny\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nGI\n\nTHE\n\nCOURT:\n\nDocument 465\n\nNo,\n\nMs.\n\nMS. STE\n\nRNHE IM:\n\nTHE\n\nhaven't talked\n\nvoir dire days --\n\nCOURT:\n\nthrough\n\nconcerns with that,\n\nthink what\n\n[ think\n\nyour Honor.\nSternheim?\n\nNo.\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nMs.\n\nonce each panel is assembled.\n\nMoe?\n\nThank you.\n\nam also going to do,\n\nto have a morning panel,\n\ncourtroom which is sort of the holding courtroom.\n\nthe specifics of the logistics of\n\nThe\n\nPage 108 of 127\n\n108\n\nwe\n\nthe\n\n[ did generally -- but we are going\n\nthe jurors are going to come in to a\n\npreliminary instructions will be played and then we bring them\n\nin one at a time.\n\nsomewher ls\n\ninstructions.\n\nThe a\n\nOnce we are\n\nso there is no overlap,\n\nthey'll be brought in and the like.\n\nWe will do the\n\nanyone is struck\n\nThose who are not\n\ngive them an instruction sheet that tel\n\nthey're returning\n\nstruck\n\nindividual\n\nvoir dire,\n\nfor cause\n\nfor cause,\n\nFor\n\nthem the basic ins\n\nlike just so they have that and\n\nCourse\n\nthat basic idea.\n\nI want to see ii\n\nthe\n\ntructions about\n\nIT would show you what\n\nwhat\n\nfinal stage of\n\nthey take it\n\nam thinking bet\n\nwith them.\n\nF anybody has any concerns or\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORTERS, PwC.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nobviously if\n\nO\n\nfFrernoon panel is going to assemble\nthey'll be played the\n\nfinished with the morning panel,\n\nfollowing that they'll be excused.\nI propose is that we\nls them where and when\nthe process and remind\n\nmedia restrictions and the\n\nFore we do it but\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007159\n", "char_count": 1626}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 109 of 127 109\nLB1i5max4\n\nobjections.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nGl\n\nNo, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: No objection.\n\nTHE COURT: I do think once we do that, the non-struck\njurors, with that information, can then b xcused for the day\nand returning on -- and obviously I haven't indicated yet --\n\nthe 19th or the 29th, those instructions. But they don't need\n\nto sit around for the rest of the day while we do the other\nindividuals.\nAny objections to that process, Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: No. Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Sternheim?\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: No, thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: There are logistical issues we are dealing\n\nwith for bringing the full panel back for the exercised\n\nperemptories as well as setting up the courtroom with\n\ndistancing issues which turns, to some extent, on the vaccine\n\nstatus of the individuals because we have different spacing\n\nrequirements under the current protocols for the vaccinated\n\nversus unvaccinated. Now, the parties have proposed that I ask\n\nthat question in voir dire and I rejected that because I don't\n\nthink there is any proper basis for striking based on\n\nvaccination status. But what I would propose, in order to\n\npan\nrm\n\n105)\n\ncilitate the Court's logistical process which is complicated,\n\nis that for our non-struck jurors, as we give them th\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007160\n\n", "char_count": 1490}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "ay\n\nLB15max4\n\ninstruction,\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nyour juror number and check a box,\n\nparties.\n\nand the like.\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nthey're handed a sheet of paper\n\nI don't want to say,\n\nvaccinated,\n\nPage 110 of 127 110\n\nwhich says write\n\nnot vaccinated,\n\nand the Court gets that\n\nAnd that way we can set up\n\nfigure out where we are going to put\n\nI have indicated.\n\nMs. Moe?\nMS. MOE:\nyour Honor.\nMS. STERNHEIM: No objection.\nTHE COURT:\nperemptories on the 29th, as\nworking through the logistics.\n\nthere are pros and cons\n\nThis piece helps.\n\nto both, but\n\nthe courtroom,\n\neverybody\n\nbut not the\n\nwe can\n\nfor peremptories\n\nThe government has no objection to that,\n\n[ do think we are going to do the\n\nWe are still\n\nAs\n\nsaid,\n\nI think that the safest\n\ncourse for proceeding with a full jury is to bring them back on\nthe 29th -- I will give you my final resolution as to that when\nI have it -- but my thinking is we are in the courtroom, all of\nus. The panel, approximately 50 to 60 people who I will bring\n\nback are in two other courtrooms because we can't get them all\n\nin one place,\npreliminary quest\n\nand has anybody had media exposure,\n\nWw\n\nith a\n\ntions:\n\nvideo,\n\nanybody does raise their hands,\n\nthose rooms who we can bring in one at a time\n\nAnd assuming not,\n\nin which I\n\nDoes anybody need\n\nwe will have staff\n\netc.\n\nHands raised. If\n\nask some very\n\nto change any answers\n\nin each of\n\nto deal with.\n\nor once we deal with that, that's our panel,\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007161\n\n", "char_count": 1640}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB15max4\n\nthe parties\n\n111\n\nDocument 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 111 of 127\nxercise the peremptories by list, and we are done.\nSo, as say, am still working through the specific\n\nlogistics of\n\nthat but that's my thinking as to how we will do\n\nit.\nAny reactions, Ms. Moe?\nMS. MOE: No, your Honor. Thank you.\nTHE COURT: Ms. Sternheim?\nMS. STERNHEIM: Yes. My only reaction is are we going\n\nto be able to see\n\nquestioning?\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nin each of\n\nCOURT:\n\nthe courtrooms,\n\nthe jurors as they respond to the Court's\n\nSo, I think what we can do is have staf\n\nI will ask my question, anyone who\n\nraises their hand will be brought in individually. F you\nwould like to have someone in each of those rooms for the\nhand-raising, that's fine with me.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: OK.\n\nTHE COURT: We would be happy to do that.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: Thank you.\n\nTHE COURT: But because there are other trials being\n\nselected on the 29th we can't use the jury assembly room and,\n\nin any event, it would slow us down. So I think this is the\nway to go logistically but that's what it will entail for the\nxercised peremptories.\nMS. STERNHEIM: Thank you.\nTHE COURT: One of the obstacles to the jury selection\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212%) 805-0220\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00007162\n", "char_count": 1373}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 112 of 127\n\nLB15max4\n\n1 here is length of trial and the timing of trial. [ would like\n2 the parties, in light of -- you have gotten some rulings,\n\n3 obviously not everything yet -- to think about whether what we\n4 include in the questionnaire is still the six-week time frame\nby that we have indicated. And if it is, it is, but if there is\n6 any basis to suggest a lower estimate as the parties have\n\n7 continued preparing their cases and in light of any rulings,\n\n8 would certainly be open to hearing it if we could safely put a\n9 shorter time frame in the questionnaire. Again, maybe we\n10 can't. So just ask you to think about it and confer and put\n11 in a letter by November 2nd, on ECF, indicating whether the\n12 parties agree that there should be any different estimate to\n13 the trial length than what we have indicated in the current\n\n14 draft of the questionnaire. recognize that may change after\n15 that but for jury selection purposes it won't help us if a few\n16 days later we decide that we could say four weeks instead of\n17 Six weeks. So you will let me know and I will ask the parties\n18 to confer. You don't need to put in specific reasons, just if\n19 you can put in a joint submission as to the parties' best\n20 overall estimate of length of trial is to see if it can be\n21 realistically any shorter than what is in the questionnaire to\n22 help facilitate jury selection.\n\n23 That's what I have. [ will hear from counsel any\n\n24 other issues. Ms. Moe?\n\n25 MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor; very briefly on two\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212%) 805-0220\n\n112\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007163\n", "char_count": 1653}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nLB15max4\n\nadministrative\n\nFir\n\nst,\n\nthe record at a\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nfinal\n\nDocument 465\n\nitems.\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 113 of 127\n\nit is the practice in this district to place on\n\npretrial\n\nconference the status of plea\n\ndiscussions and so\n\nI just wanted to place on the record --\n\nTHE COURT: I guess I hadn't assumed this is our final\npretrial conference and I do usually do that, but there is no\npoint in not at least doing that now in case we don't get\ntogether again, which seems unlikely. But, go ahead.\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor; for that reason we wanted\nto place on the record that the government has not issued any\nplea offers to the defense and the defense has not requested\nany plea offers from the government, and we would respectfully\nrequest that the Court confer with the defendant that that is\naccurate.\n\nTHE COURT: OK. Ms. Sternheim?\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: Do you want to hear from me?\n\nTHE COURT: will hear from you first and then I will\nask Ms. Maxwell.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: That is correct. We take the position\n\nthat our client has not committed a crime so plea bargaining\n\nwas not an issue.\n\nELE,\n\nCOURT:\n\nMs.\n\nis accurate and correct?\n\nMaxwe\n\nll,\n\nwhat Ms.\n\nSternheim indicated\n\n[ have not committed any crime and -—-\n\nTHE DEFENDANT:\nTHE COURT: And what Ms. Sternheim indicated is\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\n113\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007164\n", "char_count": 1491}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\na\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\nKn\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\nKn\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 114 of 127 114\nLB15max4\naccurate?\n\nTHE DEFENDANT: Oh sorry. Yes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Anything else on that, Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: No, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nJust with respect to the second administrative item,\n\nDaubert hea\n\nfocused on\n\nth\n\ndefense's\n\nring. Becau\n\nthe question\n\nSs\n\ne)\n\nunderstand\n\nthe Court w\n\nthe scope of\n\nthe hearing and,\n\nthe government has received the Court's order related to the\n\nDaubert briefing was\n\nf grooming it would be helpful to\n\nin particular, whether\n\nvidence with\n\nould like the government to present\n\nrespect to\nconclusions\n\nhearing wou\n\nthe full scope of the expert's\n\nfindings and\n\nthat were addressed in the motions or whether the\n\nld be focused on the question of\n\nEe\n\nproffered opinions being of\n\nMS.\n\nTH\n\nissues.\n\nthem out at\n\nMS.\n\nto know in\n\nF COURT:\n\n[ gu\n\nESS\n\nthis point.\n\nMOE: Thank you,\n\nMOE: Thank you,\n\nfered —-\n\nyour Honor.\n\nE COURT: -- in part because of\n\nfF grooming.\n\nI think it goes to each of the\n\noverlap in those\n\nI don't know that it's obvious to me how to separate\n\nIt is very helpful\n\nyour Honor.\n\nadvance of the hearing.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Sternheim, anything on that?\nMS. STERNHEIM: Yes, Judge.\nThese, I guess you put them under the housekeeping\n\ncategory an\n\nd I know tomorrow the government is to respond to a\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007165\n\n", "char_count": 1526}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nling basis.\n\nPage 115 of 127 115\n\nbut we still have\n\nfor her to review to consult with\n\nRecent disclosures that the government\n\nThey're\n\nwhat are you\n\nShe has still\n\nthe government made a 3500\n\nT don't\n\nlementing them and\n\nrepresentation\n\nLB15max4\n\n1 letter that I raised concerning legal mail,\n\n2 the issue that Ms. Maxwell has not received trial-related\n3 discovery that is imperative\n\n4 counsel. It also has bearing on some of the issues\n\n5 THE COURT: What hasn't been received?\n\n6 MS. STERNHEIM:\n\n7 has made, she still has not received some of\n\n8 sent by the government to the MDC.\n\n9 THE COURT: Yes. But, specifically,\n\n10 talking about?\n\n11 MS. STERNHEIM: 3500 material that we -- counsel\n12 received electronically the other day.\n\n13 THE COURT: And by the other day what do you mean,\n14 Ms. Sternheim?\n\n15 MS. STERNHEIM: It was Monday, Judge.\n\n16 not received the production made by the government which I\n17 believe they send via federal express.\n\n18 THE COURT: So, Ms. Moe,\n\n19 production a week ago?\n20 MS. MOE: Your Honor, the government has been\n21 supplementing its 3500 productions on a roll\n22 recall the exact date but we have been suppl\n23 have made productions last week.\n24 THE COURT: And do you know why\n25 is a production made a week ago has not made its way to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007166\n\n", "char_count": 1406}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-003\nLB1ib5max4\n\nMs. Maxwell.\n\nMS.\n\nTH\n\nma\n\nMS.\n\n30-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 116 of 127 116\n\nDo you know anything about that?\n\nMOE: Your Honor if I could have one moment?\n\nGl\n\nCOURT: Sure.\n\nZL\n\nMOE: Thank you.\n\n(Counsel conferring)\n\nMS.\n\ninformation\n\nand whether\n\nwill certain\n\nMOE: Your Honor, I don't have particular\n\nabout the series of disclosures we made last week\n\nor not they've been processed by the MDC but we\n\nly be conferring with the MDC in connection with a\n\nresponse to\nis that, gen\nprocessed th\n\nand produced\n\nthe defense's letter on Friday. Our understanding\n\nerally, that drives have been received by MDC,\n\nrough their warehouse, picked up by legal counsel\n\nto the defense in regular time frame. I can't\n\nspeak to any particular package that was mailed last week\nbecause I am hearing about it now for the first time.\n\nTHE COURT: Well, OK. You will include in your\nletter [ mean, I think at this point a week is too long.\n\nthink the re\n\npresentation in the prior letter was one to two\n\ndays for leg\n\ndifferent?\n\nMS.\n\nreason why I\ncolleague is\nor Wednesday\n\nwe want to j\n\nal mail, maybe this is different because this is\n\nMOE: don't believe so, your Honor. Part of the\n\nwant to look into this and confer with my\n\nwe are not quite sure whether the date was Monday\n\nthat we produced this material to the defense and\n\nust double-check the mailing date to make sure we\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007167\n\n", "char_count": 1588}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nKB\nws\n\nOo\n\n_\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB15max4\n\nDocument 465\n\nhave all our\n\nhappy to address that\n\nTHE\n\n25\n\nCOURT\n\nthere is going to b\n\nscreening process and it getting to the\n\nth other\n\nr ar\n\nfacts s\n\nindividuals\n\ntraight about\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nt the exact timeline.\n\nin the lett\n\nYes,\n\nIs there anything the government\n\nsome time built in\n\ndo address that\n\nLek\n\nPage 117 of 127\n\nheading into trial\n\ntf\n\nand there are a lot of\n\nin the same\n\nde\n\nSs]\n\nfor the\n\nfendant.\n\n117\n\nSo\n\nam\n\nin the letter.\ncan do -—- you know,\n\nfacilities\n\nObviously\n\ninmates,\n\ntuation pretrial,\n\nbut -- so\n\nyou will address what's happening on the institution side in\n\nthe letter.\n\nWhat can the government do to\n\ngoing forward?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nterials as quickly as possibl\n\nYour Honor,\n\nWe have b\n\nwe have been trying\n\nF\n\nterial\n\nthe facility that,\n\nde\n\nknows about\n\nunusual but\ncase.\n\nMy unders\n\ns promptly to the\n\nfendant is in-bound to\n\nfacil\n\nin particul\n\nthe\n\nit and can keep an eye out\n\nwe are happy to continue\n\ntanding is that material\n\nby\n\nthe defendant a\n\nthat issue.\n\ngoing to be frequent but\n\nwitnesses and produce small]\n\nSOUTH\n\nI would not\n\nthe facility\n\na\n\nity.\n\nar,\n\namounts o1\n\na disclosure\n\nn\n\nd\n\nWhen we do so,\n\nfacilitate the process\n\nto produce\n\nExing those\n\nwe notify\n\nfor this\n\nfacility so that\n\nJu.\n\nOL\n\nlegal counsel\n\nwhich I\n\nthink is\n\nls hav\n\nb\n\nto take that step in this\n\nn received\n\n. We will continue to check on\n\nERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT\n\nRE\n\nPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nLD\n\nfF rolling materials.\n\nte that our rolling productions are\n\nlso small as we continue to meet with\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007168\n\n", "char_count": 1692}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 117, "text_content": "=\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\na\n=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nLB15max4\n\nthink the det\n\nmeet with the det\n\ndoing.\n\nconferences that\nunderstanding is\naccess to video cont\n\nso when the def\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nfFense\n\nis well\n\nDocument 465\n\nthey're having with the defendant.\n\nthat this defe\n\nfFerencing se\n\nreceives th\n\nsessions.\n\nAnd so,\n\nmore than is necessary to mak\n\nof\n\nTHE\n\nsubmission we are talking about newly\n\nns\n\nCOURT:\n\nfree to review those with the defendant\n\nthat the defense and the defend\n\nthink those steps are all that is required her\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 118 of 127 118\n\nequipped to print those materials and\nfendant in person about it as they have been\n\nThey can certainly discuss those documents in the video\n\nOur\n\nnse team has a large amount of\n\nssions with this defendant and\n\nose materials,\n\nthey're certainly\n\nin real-time in their\n\nwe are taking every step that we can to ensure\n\nant have those materials but we\n\nand certainly\n\nthe def\n\nthose materials in anticipat\n\nsur ndant is apprised\n\nion of trial.\n\nAs to the\n\nsteps, if you have a new\n\nproduced 3500 material,\n\nlimited volume; correct, Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: And you are going to send that by FedEx —--\nso overnight -- to the facility in each instance, correct?\n\nMS. MOE: Yes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: And you alert BOP counsel, MDC Legal\n\ncounsel that\n\nsomething is coming\n\nfor Ms. Maxwell so they can be\n\non alert. Do you get indication back from legal counsel that\nit's been received and delivered?\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007169\n\n", "char_count": 1632}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 118, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\nLB15max4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nGI\n\nN\n\ndo that mindful of\n\nDocument 465\n\nOo, your Honor.\n\ninmates at the facil\n\ntaken to be responsi\n\nrequests. For examp\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\ntheir obligations towards all of\n\nPage 119 of 127\n\n119\n\nWe have not been asking to\n\nthe other\n\nthe st\n\nity but we appreciat\n\nve to our alerts and about\n\nle, in some instances\n\nI think\n\nps\n\nthey have\n\nthe defense's\n\nthe defense\n\nhas been e-mailing 1]\nnumbers and asking t\nSo that process seem\n\ncreate a system wher\n\negal counsel noting cert\n\ntain tracking\n\nticular warehouse.\n\nhem to check at the par\n\ns to be working.\n\nthe def\n\n24-hour basis, alld\n\nndant is receiving,\n\nI don't think we can\n\nin jail, ona\n\nisclosures.\n\nI thin\n\npractical but\nmay be uploading to\n\ncertain disclosures\n\nde\n\nfendant in person\n\nability to talk abou\n\nprovide her with pap\n\nFicient\n\nmore than suf\n\naide\n\nma\n\nCOURT:\n\nF government sendin\n\nLth\n\nthe facility to\n\nmaterials to Ms. Max\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nie)\n\nO\n\nk especially because,\n\nthe defense through a\n\nin some instances,\n\nI don't think that is\n\nwe\n\nfile sharing program\n\non one day and they may be meeting with the\n\nthe very next day,\n\ner copies if they wish,\n\nWell,\n\ng the materials to the\n\nwell, are you?\n\nf course, your Honor.\n\nOur view is\n\nfacilitate timely movement o\n\nt those materials with the defendant,\n\nand I\n\nthey certainly have the\n\nto\n\nthink that is\n\nfacilit\n\nyou are not suggesting that instead\n\nty and working\n\n£ the\n\nin combination of the\n\nthe defe\n\nshort-term,\n\nde\n\nfendant immediatel\n\nfact that,\n\nin the\n\nnse has the opportunity\n\ny about it if they wish\n\nto,\n\nSOUTH\n\nERN D\n\nSTR\n(212)\n\nCT REPORT\n805-0300\n\nERS,\n\nPG ew\n\nto talk to the\n\nand in longer\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007170\n\n", "char_count": 1805}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 119, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 120 of 127 120\nLB15max4\n\n1 term the defendant will have those materials in a reasonable\n\n2 time frame. I think in combination with those efforts, that's\n3 sufficient.\n\n4 THE COURT: So in your letter tomorrow you will\n\n5 indicate your understanding of the time frame including the\n\n6 specific 3500 material sent last week because, again, the\n\n7 representation I have is that you sent it to the defense on\n\n8 Monday and we are here a week later and Ms. Maxwell hasn't\n\n9 received it. You will find out what the story is with that and\n10 inguire as to whether there are any additional steps that can\n11 be taken in light of where we are in advance of trial to\n12 further facilitate the speedy transmission of the materials to\n13 Ms. Maxwell.\n\n14 MS. MOE: Yes, your Honor.\n\n15 THE COURT: Ms. Sternheim?\n\n16 MS. STERNHEIM: Judge, the procedure is such that even\n17 if I were to hand-deliver it myself she would not get it. E\n18 the government hand delivers it, she will get it. And we have\n19 requested that if they are going to do late-breaking\n20 disclosures, given that we are within weeks now of trial, that\n21 it be hand-delivered with a call to the MDC legal department to\n22 facilitate that.\n23 can't just give her papers. As the Court well\n24 knows, even when I put them in the legal mail box, there is an\n25 issue as to when she gets that. And I know the government will\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007171\n\n", "char_count": 1500}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 120, "text_content": "=\n\nNO\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB15max4\n\nrespond to those issues tomorrow.\n\n[ will\n\nDocument 465\n\nthe government the benefit of\n\ngiv\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\na\n=\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nnot know wh\nso to assum\n\ncomplete th\n\nat\n\ne what we a\n\nwe do when we have a cont\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nBut\n\nre doing is erroneous.\n\nference with Ms.\n\nPage 121 of 127 121\n\nthis is an issue -- and\n\nthe doubt -- they do\n\nMaxwell\n\nwill\n\nBut,\n\nat topic and move on to another one.\n\nTH\nsuggestion.\n\nSO\n\nmay be meeting with witnesses and\n\nthose notes\none or two\n\nproposal is\n\nhand delive\n\nMS.\n\nthat and I\n\nin these cl\nhand-delive\nproduction,\n\nTH\n\na hundred p\n\nMS.\n\nguantity, i\nTH\n\nthis.\n\nMS.\n\nE COURT:\n\n, presumably now,\n\n, an additional 3500 material\n\npages of\n\ntha\n\nred to the\n\nM\n\nt every day that one of\n\nDC\n\non a daily basi\n\n[ want to understand the specif\n\nSy\n\ntaking notes.\n\nduring trial,\n\nic\n\nthe government\n\nI mean, I get\n\nit is\n\nchicken scratch, handwriting.\n\ncf?\n\nby government sta\n\nSTERNHE\n\nM:\n\ndon't think\n\numps. I'mn\n\nred but if\n\nit\n\nOU\n\ncomes that way,\n\nasking\n\nThat would be ideal but\nI think\n\nfor every single\n\nSo your\n\nthose is produced it's\n\nI'm not asking\nit comes more\n\npage to be\n\nthat should be hand-delivered.\n\nE COURT:\n\nages?\n\nAnd what\n\nWhat are we\n\ntalking about?\n\nthey know they are making a\n\ndo you mean by substantial?\n\nSTERNHEIM: Look. You know,\nt is what is in it\nE COURT: Ms. Sternheim,\nSTERNHEIM: 'm trying to be.\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS,\n(212) 805-0300\n\nLD\n\nsubstantial\n\nOver\n\nit is not the\n\nthat may have significance here.\n\nyou have to be realistic on\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007172\n", "char_count": 1642}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 121, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 122 of 127 122\n\nLB15max4\n\n1 THE COURT: [ mean, you have made a lot of this noise\n2 about not having received it, not having received it in time.\n3 am asking for a specific request that's realistic.\n\n4 MS. STERNHEIM: Every day I would like whatever\n\n5 they're producing to be hand-delivered.\n\n6 THE COURT: Well, I deny that request.\n\n7 MS. STERNHEIM: understand that. That's why I\n\n8 didn't raise it but I think there needs to be some mechanism\n\n9 either if a FedEx comes to the facility that it be\n\n10 speed-delivered to Ms. Maxwell. Boxes of legal materials that\n11 have been sent to her, when we follow the tracking, they are\n12 left in a facility, they're not being picked up.\n13 am not privy to what the mail operation is there.\n14 Perhaps the government can get some insight.\n15 THE COURT: When you say they're not being picked up\n16 you are saying that there are some that she has never received?\n17 You are saying she is not receiving it in the one to two to\n18 three-day time frame that you are asking for.\n19 MS. STERNHEIM: submitted a letter to the Court the\n20 ether day. In it there were four indications of items that\n21 were available for pickup. When alerted the MDC to that,\n22 after the second request on Friday, they sent me back\n23 something, We are going to go pick them up. shouldn't have\n24 to push them to go to the post office. can't deliver the\n25 stuff myself because it's not going to be given to her. So you\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007173\n\n", "char_count": 1567}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 122, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB15max4\n\nao\n\ntracking in\n\nthe situation is how\n\nand it's no\n\nt picked up,\n\nDocument 465\n\nthrough the United States post of\n\nformation says available\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nfice,\n\nPage 123 of 127 123\n\n[. don't know what\n\nthe MDC receives its pac\n\nfor pick\n\nthe MDC to get those packages?\n\nwhat am I\n\nto do to pu\n\nbut if the\n\nkages,\nup and days go by\n\nt a candle under\n\nTHE COURT: [ guess I'm still trying to understand\nwhat it is that you are asking the Court to do.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM: 'm asking the Court to have the MDC\nretrieve its mail in a timely manner. [ will notify them if a\nnext-day delivery is on the way, and that it be picked up for\nnext-day and not languish in the post office.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE: Your Honor, we will confer with MDC legal\nabout this issue and their practices and happy to provide the\nCourt with additional information about our disclosures last\n\nweek and the ongoing practices.\n\nthe MDC,\n\nof\n\ncan't speak\n\nbut\n\ndiligently with the det\nand have been taking extraordinary ef\n\ndisclosures are produced promptly and that\n\nde\n\nlearn of a practical\n\nbe open\n\nhave at thi\n\nSs point.\n\nI want\n\nEB@ assure\n\nto the particular mail\n\nsorting practices\n\nthe Court we\n\nFense and with MDC lega\n\nForts to\n\nfendant quickly and we will continue\n\nway of\n\nexpediting\n\nth\n\nto do\n\nthis,\n\nto exploring that but that's all the information\n\nSOUTH\n\nERN D\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPORTERS, P.\n\nhave been working\n\nl on this issue\n\nmake sure the\ney're sent to the\nso. And if we\n\nwe would certainly\n\nthat\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007174\n\n", "char_count": 1675}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 123, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document465- Filed 11/15/21 Page 124 of 127 124\nLB15max4\n1 THE COURT: Thank you.\n2 Can I ask the government, if you have a substantial\n3 production, let's say over 50 pages of documents to review, can\n4 the government have those hand-delivered to the facility?\n5 MS. MOE: No, your Honor.\n6 Respectfully, that is extremely resource intensive, it\n7 requires asking either a member of the prosecution team or\n8 their colleagues who are also working on cases to, instead of\n9 pursuing law enforcement activities or preparing for trial,\n10 spend the day driving to the MDC to hand deliver a drive to the\n11 defendant personally which is a remedy that I'm not aware of\n12 being implemented in any other case and would be sort of an\n13 extraordinary step for this defendant that would be out of step\n14 with the ordinary practice.\n15 THE COURT: We are a month away from trial but if we\n16 are a few days away from trial and suddenly the government has\n17 a substantial production of material for some reason, 50 pages,\n18 a hundred pages, would the government take those steps?\n19 MS. MOE: Your Honor, without having a sense of what\n20 those materials are, what their sensitivities are, whether it\n21 is sort of a relevant matter that we are producing in an\n22 abundance of caution or something that is sensitive that is\n23 urgent that is hard to troubleshoot that issue in advance but\n24 we are mindful of Court's concern and that, even as we approach\n25 trial, that the issue of timing is of particular concern and so\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007175\n\n", "char_count": 1604}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 124, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\nWw\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\nA\nco)\n\nhe\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\nI\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nWO\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB15max4\n\nDocument 465\n\nwould be atten\n\nLiv\n\nthink it is di\n\nTHI!\n\nie\n\nletter.\n\nCOURT: OK.\n\nMs. Sternheim.\n\nMS. S\n\nTERNHEIM:\n\ngoing forward wi\n\nhouse.\n\nShe is woken\nhere and this morning\ncellblock, very cold,\n\nShe is not allowed to\n\nth\n\ngiven very little\n\nhave a utensil\n\n[ wil\n\nto that issue in those circumstances but\n\nFiled 11/15/21 Page 125 of 127 125\n\nFficult assess that in a hypothetical.\n\nll wait for the government's\n\nfor her to use.\n\nOne other issue,\n\nthe production of Ms\n\nJudge; it has to do\n\n. Maxwell to the court\n\nshe arrived at 5:38.\n\nup at approximately 3:45. She is taken\n\nShe sits ina\n\nshe cannot bring any warmer garments.\nlook at her legal materials. She is\n\nfood and whatever she is given doesn't even\n\nAnd, she is shackled. Today\n\nshe had to get on her hands and knees to climb into the van\n\nbecause her leg shackles would not permit her to step up. This\n\nis just not the right thing.\n\nforward to trial\n\nTHE COU\n\nRI:\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nbrought here later.\nher to be let out\n\napplication right\n\nconditions are\n\nThe wear and tear on her going\n\nfive days a week --\n\nWhat is the application, Ms. Sternheim?\n\nfor her to be\n\nThe application is\n\napplication,\n\nThe real\non bail but\nhere, I will\n\njust terrible.\n\nout, she was poked to be woken\n\nI'm not going to make that\n\nobviously, is for\n\nmake it in writing, but these\n\nAnd today,\n\nwhen she was nodding\n\nup just because she's the only\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT REPORT\n\nERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007176\n\n", "char_count": 1617}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 125, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-0\nLB1ib5max4\n\n0330-PAE Document 465\n\nperson sitting ina cel\n\nare going\n\nLs\n\nTha\n\nNutrition is importan\n\nsomething needs to be d\n\nto be fatigued but we all\n\nt, sl\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 126 of 127 126\n\nt's not necessary.\n\neep is important. We all\n\nget to go home, and\n\non\n\nCO\n\ndebilitated during the trial.\n\nTHE COURT: Are you making any allegations of\n\n_\n\ndifferential\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nYes.\n\nNSUE\n\ntreatment as to Ms. Ma\n\nxwell?\n\nI don't know any other client\n\nthat she is not\n\nhave ever had who has been woken up every 15 minutes at night\n\nand then --\n\nTHE COURT: No\n\nabout which is the transport\n\nproceedings.\n\ntf\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\narrived that early.\n\ntaken individual]\n\nabout that\n\nP In other cases that\n\nither th\n\nclients come\n\ncan't speak to that.\n\ny as she has so\n\nfrom the MCC,\n\nand they're transported one way, or\n\nmorning for a court proceeding or trial, and I\n\n9:00, I'm\n\nbetween get\n\nanother defendant seems\n\nI'm talking about what you are talking\n\nto the court house for\n\ndon't know any clients who have ever\n\nThey've never been\n\nI don't have a big history\nI have had in this court house\n\nwhich is no longer here\n\nwhen I come here in the\n\ntold they haven't arrived yet. So\n\nextraordinary.\n\nTHE COURT: Ms.\n\nMS. MOE: Your\n\nH\n\nMoe?\n\nonor,\n\nthe government is learning of\n\nwill get here at\n\n, the differential\n\ntting here at 5:38 and not being here at 9:00 for\n\nSOUTHERN\n\nD\n\nSTR\n\nCT RE\n\nPORTERS,\n\n(212)\n\n805-\n\n0300\n\nPG ew\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007177\n\n", "char_count": 1579}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00007052", "page_number": 126, "text_content": "be\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nws\n\nOo\n\nOY\n\n~]\n\n(oe)\n\nKe}\n\na\nca)\n\n_\nbe\n\nN\n\nWw\n\n=\nws\n\nOo\n\na\nOY\n\na\n~]\n\na\noO\n\na\nKe)\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLB15max4\n\nthis concern\n\nhappy to reach out\n\nassigned to this particular trial\n\nto ask,\n\nwhat time they anticipate producing\n\nand can provid\n\nthe def with that information.\n\nns\n\nTHE\n\ntreatment betw\n\nCOURT:\n\nand whether ther\n\nYes;\n\nn Ms.\n\nproduced\nand currently.\n\nMS.\n\nMOE: Yes,\n\nfrom the MDC to the court house under COVI\n\nYou will inquire as to that.\n\nyour Honor.\n\nTHE\n\nCO\ntiming issue is\nand\n\nnecessary,\n\nMS. MO!\n\nURT: As well as differential\n\n, availability of\n\nthe like.\n\nmu\n\nEB: Certainly, your Honor.\n\nTHE\n\nCO\n\nURT: Ms. Sternheim, anything\n\nis any di\n\nDocument 465 Filed 11/15/21 Page 127 of 127 127\nfor the first time at this conference. I would be\nto both the MDC and the Deputy U.S. Marshal\n\nas a general matter,\n\nthe defendant on trial days\n\nFferential\n\nMaxwell and other defendants being\n\nor not,\n\nFood and comfort items,\n\nD protocols\n\nwhat the\n\nas\n\nfurther?\n\nMS. ST\n\nERNHEIM: No.\n\nThank you, Judge.\n\nTHE\n\nCO\n\nMS.\n\nTHE\n\nCO\n\nMOE:\n\nE\n\nURT: Anything, Ms. Moe?\n\nNo, your Honor. Thank you.\n\nURT: We are adjourned.\n\no0o\n\nSOUTHERN D\n\nSTR\n(212)\n\nCT REPORTERS, P.C.\n805-0300\n\nDOJ-OGR-00007178\n\n", "char_count": 1238}]}