{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_count": 23, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/DOJ-OGR-00004894", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/DOJ-OGR-00004894.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page1of 23\n\nEXHIBIT D\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00004894\n\n", "char_count": 95}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "10\natal\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\nL7\n18\n19\n20\nad\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE.:.. Document 311-1\nXj3qlgra SEALED\n\nUNITED STATES. DISTRICT. COURT\nSOUTHERN. DISTRICT. OF NEW YORK\n\nIn re: Grand Jury Proceedings\n\nBefore:\n\nFiled 07/02/21 Page 2 of 23\n\nEx Parte Conference\n\nNew York, N.Y.\nMarch 26, 2019\n4:04 p.m.\n\nHON. COLLEEN MCMAHON,\n\nDistrict Judge\n\nAPPEARANCES\n\nGEOFFREY S.. BERMAN\n\nUnited States Attorney for the\nSouthern District of New York\n\nBY: ALEX ROSSMILLER ,\n\nAssistant United States Attorney\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n\n(212)\n\n805-0300\n\nSDNY_GM_00000853\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004895\n\n", "char_count": 588}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "fe\n\nNO\n\n(es)\n\nis\n\nOl\n\nOv\n\n~]\n\nee)\n\nXO\n\n10\n\nit\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\ndG\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\nai\n\n22\n\n29\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE . Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 3of 23\n\nXj3qlgra SEALED\n\n(In the robing room)\n\nTHE COURT: The following proceeding is being\nconducted ex parte and under seal.\n\nThe problem is, it's not being conducted in a matter,\nand that is one of my first questions to Mr. Rossmiller: Why\nwas this not filed on the Court's docket with a miscellaneous\nnumber? We don't file things under U.S. Attorney numbers.\n\nThis should have been brought as a miscellaneous matter.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: So, your Honor, it was originally\nsubmitted with Judge Sweet --\n\nTHE COURT: I understand what he did, but I will tell\nyou that in the Spinion that will never issue, because Judge\nSweet died, but he had written, and now I'm stuck with this,\nJudge Sweet questioned why you had not made this an \"In re: The\nMatter of Application of the Grand Jury\" or something or other,\nwith a proper miscellaneous docket number. The fact that it\nwould have gone to Judge Sweet doesn't mean anything. I have\nno way to docket USAO No. 2018R01618. That's your reference\nnumber, not ours.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: I understand, your Honor. I think we\nhad understood that the submission should be made to the court\nthat had entered the protective order and that --\n\nTHE COURT: That's true, but that doesn't mean it\ndoesn't get a miscellaneous docket number.\n\nThe first thing that's going to happen, this is going\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000854\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004896\n\n", "char_count": 1569}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n\n25\n\n~ Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 4 of 23\n\nXj3qlgra SEALED\n\nto be re-legended and it's going to get a miscellaneous docket\nnumber .\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Understood, your Honor. I apologize\nfor that oversight.\n\nTHE COURT: It's okay.\n\nAll ents: Now my second question, which is a\nprocedural question, the government here has moved for relief\non behalf of a third party to whom a grand jury subpoena has\nissued, and that third party would like to be relieved of its\nobligations under the protective order, and that third party is\na law firm full of brilliant lawyers that are fully capable of\nmaking a motion bringing a proceeding to be relieved from the\nprovisions of the protective order. Why are you doing this for\nthem?\n\nWhy doesn't Boies Schiller make an application for\npermission to be relieved from the protective order? Because\nit thought it was going to violate some duty that it had to its\nclient in the underlying actions? Did they give you a reason\nwhy. they weren't willing to come to court and --\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER:. No, your Honor. So I can't speak to\nwhy Boies Schiller in particular didn't make their own\napplication.\n\nTHE COURT: Because I understand that you don't think\nthat Martindell is applicable here, but I do, and now I'm the\njudge. I wish I weren't. You know that the Second Circuit has\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000855\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004897\n", "char_count": 1466}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "ee) ~J (op) O1 aS GO NO ee\n\nXO\n\n10\n\n11\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page5of 23\n\nXj3qlgra SEALED\n\nvery clearly said that, and Judge Broderick said in Chemical\nBank the proper procedure is for somebody to make a motion to\nbe relieved from the terms of the protective order. And it\n\nain't you; it's somebody who's subject to the protective order.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: I think a little bit of context may\nhelp explain. how. the procedure developed, your Honor.\n\nOriginally we had submitted an All Writs Act\napplication to Judge Sweet, which we believe was appropriate\ngiven the sort of catch-all function of that --\n\nTHE COURT: Yes, I understand that, but it still has\nto have a docket number in order to be a proceeding in this\ncourt.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Totally understand, your Honor. But\njust with respect to our supplemental submission, Judge Sweet\nhad reached out to us and asked us to submit an argument in\nconnection with our application, and so I think whether that\nwas sort of past experience or his preference, that is why we\nproceeded --\n\nTHE COURT: So here's why I'm being so persnickety.\nForgive me. Not only do I have to like come up to speed pretty\nquickly, but you know -- I assume you know, but I certainly\nknow, and everybody who follows civil litigation knows -- that\nJudge Sweet is about to get reversed in connection with this\nprotective order in the Second Circuit. I mean, I don't have\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000856\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00004898\n", "char_count": 1566}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "fe\n\nN\n\nQ\n\nis\n\nOT\n\nOF\n\n~\n\nes)\n\nLo\n\n10\n\n11\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\nL7\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 6 of 23\n\nXj3qlgra SEALED\n\nthat on any authority other than my reading of the tea leaves\nafter the extensive press reporting and the fact that the\nSecond Circuit has already issued an order giving the parties\nuntil last week to say why the summary judgment papers and all\nthe supporting papers should not be unsealed by the Second\nCircuit and indicating that there would be a further order with\nrespect to all the rest of the, I don't know, 150 or so sealed\ndocuments in connection with the underlying litigation, but you\ncan hear it in the questioning, you can read it in the press\nreports, you can intuit it from the order. I don't know if\nyou've seen the second Circuit's order that issued last week,\nbut = --\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: I have, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Okay. You can intuit that something kind\nof unfavorable to Judge Sweet is happening, it's in the process\nof happening, it seems to me it's about to be happening, in\nconnection with this protective order and its enforceability.\nDoesn't seem that way to you, Mr. Rossmiller?\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Your Honor, I've read the same\narticles and --\n\nTHE COURT: I -mean, really, Mr. Rossmiller?\n\nMR... ROSSMILLER: So I would say, your Honor, that I\nwould expect that any order to disclose materials that were\nfiled in connection with, for example, the summary judgment\npapers, if in fact they are released or if in fact the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000857\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004899\n\n", "char_count": 1614}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 7 of 23\n\n6\nXj3qlgra : SEALED\n\n1 protective order is overturned in some way, that those would be\n2 redacted as to individuals' names, personally identifying\n\n3 information --\n\n4 THE COURT: Probably.\n\n5 MR. ROSSMILLER: -- which I would expect, your Honor.\n6 I don't believe that any indication is that the underlying\n\n7 discovery materials are likely to be unsealed, and I'm not sure\n8 whether that's at issue, but in any event --\n\n) THE COURT: I don't think it is. I think the only\n10 thing that's at issue in the case that the Second Circuit has\n\n11 heard is the publicly -- only here, not publicly -- filed\n\n12 litigation documents, which is essentially a lawsuit, a libel\n13 action that: has been filed and litigated under seal. It was\n\n14 settled by terms that would have expired because the protective\n15 order doesn't extend until it goes on to a trial, but there\n\n16 wasn't a trial.\n\n17 And I'm struggling with this for two reasons.\n\n18 First of all, it's like how much deference to give to\n19 this protective order that was issued by some judge, not\n\n20 myself, on the basis of I-don't know what, except that from the\n\nvan questions that the Second Circuit asked about the litigation\n22 documents, it seemed like they were being critical of Judge\n\n23 Sweet for not having a particularized inquiry into each\n\n24 document that was sought to be filed in accordance with the\n\n25 protective order as to why this contained confidential\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000858\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004900\n\n", "char_count": 1581}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "be\n\ni)\n\nee)\n\nfis\n\nOl\n\na\n\n~]\n\nee)\n\ni<e}\n\n10\n\n11\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 8 of 23\n\nXj3qlgra SEALED\n\ninformation and what was confidential about this, and just\nreading the tea leaves, I'm thinking to myself, what am I\nsupposed to do with this protective order that looks like it\nstands on precarious footing to begin with? Is this the\nso-called improvidently granted protective order? How could I\nknow that? I'm trying to go back in the files to see what\nJudge Sweet relied on in granting the protective order. I have\nno idea if there was an opinion. I have no idea if there\n\nwas -- I mean, he recited the magic words at the beginning of\nthe protective order. But, you know, he was doing this for\nfive years, and he's dead, and I can't ask him. And his law\nclerks weren't around when he did it, although they're trying\nto help me find stuff in the files. So I'm just trying to\nfigure out if there's something that's going to happen in the\nSecond Circuit that would help you out here or that would\nfurther your investigation in a way that would make it not\nnecessary to deal with it.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Your Honor, I'm very sympathetic to\nthat consideration. I think that even were the Second Circuit\nto unseal the entirety of what I believe is at issue, which is,\nas the Court noted, as the Court just noted --\n\nTHE COURT: 150 litigation documents, and I don't\nthink the Second Circuit is going to take the time that would\nbe required to make the inquiry. I'm going to guess that, you\nknow, some poor schlub in the district court is going to have\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000859\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00004901\n\n", "char_count": 1719}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 9 of 23\n\nXj3qligra SEALED\n\nto do that.  And.I hope it's not me. But --\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: And I believe it will apply to the\ndocketed filings in the case and not, for example, the\nunderlying discovery materials, deposition materials,\ninvestigation materials.\n\nTHE. COURT: Okay.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: And so I think that, unfortunately,\nfor the circumstances, for perhaps all of us, that even were\nthe Second Circuit to grant sort of the most expansive\ninvalidation of the protective order or sort of release of\nthese materials, that our application would still be relevant\nand pending and active.\n\nTHE COURT: Would still be relevant and pending and\nactive. Okay.\n\nAnd you can't explain to me why Boies Schiller didn't\nmake a motion. Because there's no question in my mind that\nwere this to be disclosed to the parties -- and I appreciate\nthat we're not going to do that, but were this to be disclosed\nto the parties, Maxwell would protest, and the first thing that\nMaxwell would do would be to.say the government lacks standing,\nit's not a party of the protective order, the issue’ can be\nlitigated, if Boies Schiller chooses to make a motion to seek\nto be relieved from the protective order, or to quash the\nsubpoena or to do something, but the government has no\nstanding. It hasn't moved to intervene in the civil action.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000860\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00004902\n", "char_count": 1511}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "eR\n\nNO\n\n1)\n\nSs\n\n2)\n\nan\n\n~~]\n\nee)\n\ntO\n\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n45\n16\nLy\n18\n19\n20\nal\n22\n23\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 10 of 23\n\nXj3qlgra SEALED\n\nIt hasn't done any of those things. So under Martindeli, the\ngovernment lacks standing, because remember, in Martindell, the\ngovernment only had standing because all the parties were\nfamiliar with the government's application. It wasn't a\nsecret. I don't know why it wasn't a secret, but it wasn't a\nsecret. And nobody objected. And so they said, ah, okay,\nobjection to standing waived.\n\nSo, you know, once again, Judge Sweet, I can tell you,\nwas somewhat troubled by: the procedural posture of the case\neven though, as I understand it, he was perhaps partly to blame\nfor the procedural posture of the case, but it's not like Boies\nSchiller came in here and asked for relief from the protective\norder. And I am curious about why Boies Schiller didn't do\nthat.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: .. Your Honor, what I can tell you about\nthat is we, the government, thought that we were in a position\nto make the application via the All Writs Act submission that\nwe originally made, that that would be an appropriate vehicle\nfor the relief that we, as the government, were seeking in\nconnection with the protective order. So I'm not sure --\n\nTHE COURT: You're seeking to have a third party, to\nhave Boies Schiller, who were counsel for the plaintiffs in the\nMaxwell. action, be relieved from the protective order, but if\nthere's anybody on this planet who is capable of asking,\n\"Please relieve us from the strictures of this protective\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000861\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004903\n", "char_count": 1674}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "ae\n\niS)\n\nics)\n\niS\n\nO1\n\no>)\n\n“J\n\n(ee)\n\nie}\n\n10\n\n11\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\na5\n\n16\n\nL7\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 11 of 23\n\n10\nXj3qigra SEALED\norder,\" it is David Boies and his partners. I mean, really.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: I'm sure you're right, your Honor,\nand --\n\nTHE COURT: They don't need the government's\nprotection.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: .Not that I don't begrudge the dozens\nof hours that I have spent on it in lieu of Boies Schiller, but\nI think -- and with apologies of perhaps being persnickety\nmyself, but the relief that we are seeking is not precisely to\nallow Boies Schiller to do something but rather for the\nmodification of the protective order that would then allow\nthat, but we did think that we were able to make the\napplication via the All Writs Act, and I think it was our\ngeneral understanding from Judge Sweet's response asking us for\nsupport for our submission, rather than, for example, denying\nit based on lack of standing at the outset or simply asking us\nto have Boies Schiller make the application. I don't know\nwhat, if any, difference there would be in terms of the legal\nanalysis from Boies Schiller, but I can say that I think the\ncurrent posture does allow the government to explain why the\ninvestigation is extraordinary in the sense of how other\ndecisions and courts have described it and where we, the\ngovernment, are better able to explain --\n\nTHE COURT: But what do you mean by what you just\nsaid? I mean, you have an investigation into an allegation of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000862\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004904\n", "char_count": 1621}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "BR\n\nNO\n\nOO\n\nBs\n\nOT\n\no>)\n\n~J\n\nee)\n\nKe)\n\n10\nik\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\nLy\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 12 of 23\n\n11\nXj3qigra SEALED\nhuman trafficking. I have no idea if you're up against a\nstatute of limitations so that I could take the time that\nreally is needed to kind of grapple with the procedural issues,\nbecause you haven't told me that you're up against a statute of\nlimitations.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER::. I can tell your Honor -- I'm sorry.\n\nI didn't mean to interrupt. But I can tell you that, as most\nof our investigations do, this is moving sort of as fast as\npossible. This was a significant application that we\nthoroughly considered before making and made originally nearly\ntwo months ago, so.we are hopeful to get an answer soon.\nNevertheless, let me say that --\n\nTHE COURT: Unfortunately, but for the dead judge\nopinion and the Supreme Court last month, you would have gotten\nan answer, but --\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: That said, I would not describe this\nas an emergency application. There's not a particular day by\nwhich we are requesting a response. We had hoped to hear back\nfrom Judge Sweet --\n\nTHE COURT: Before.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Before. Yes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: Would that that had happened.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER:. And if I may, just very briefly. I\nthink with respect to the postural question, particularly\nregarding Boies Schiller, Boies Schiller simply isn't ina\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000863\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004905\n\n", "char_count": 1503}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "bea\n\nNO\n\n(eS)\n\nis\n\nO1\n\nfon)\n\n~j\n\nfoe)\n\n\\O\n\n10\n\n141\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\nPal\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 13 of 23\n\n12\nXi3qlgra SEALED\n\nposition to be able to describe the investigation in the way\n\nthat we have in our submission.\n\nTHE COURT: Well, that's clear. That's clear. I\nmean, were I Boies Schiller, I would have -- never mind. We\nwon't say what I. would have done.\n\nSo I'm looking at the protective order itself, and of\ncourse not having been privy to any of the materials in the\ncase -- and they're all under seal, so, I mean, I can dissolve\nthe seal and get them, but there are 150 documents there that\nare under seal for filings, there are multiple documents that\nare under seal.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Not to mention all the underlying\nmaterials, of course.\n\nTHE COURT: Not to mention all the underlying\nmaterials.\n\nSo you argue there isn't any truly confidential\nmaterial in this, this isn't a trade secrets case, and\nobviously it's not a trade secrets case. It's a libel case.\nIt would seem that the most scurrilous of accusations would\nhave already floated across the face of the complaint. But\nSince Maxwell can't object, how can I know that all this is\nabout is information that would be, you know, embarrassing?\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: I would point the Court in the first\ninstance to the definition of \"confidential materials\" in the\nprotective order itself, which describes \"confidential\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000864\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004906\n\n", "char_count": 1542}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 14 of 23\n\n13\nXj3qlgra SEALED\nmaterials\" as “information that is confidential and implicates\ncommon law and statutory privacy interests of plaintiff\nVirginia Roberts.\"\n\nTHE COURT: I have absolutely no idea what that means,\nand you don't either, and none of us does.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: I don't, your Honor, but I think we\nargued in our submission that it, at least on its face, does\nnot implicate the type of materials that are confidential\nbusiness materials, trade secrets --\n\nTHE COURT: Ordinarily the subject of --\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: -- ordinarily the subject of the\nconsiderations developed in some of the cases that we cited.\n\nTHE COURT: Okay.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: And I should also say that in\nresponding to the subpoena, Boies Schiller has the ability to\nsay that they will not produce certain materials because they\nare privileged, because they believe that there is some larger\noverarching confidentiality issue, at which point we would be\nin a different posture. I am not aware that they have\nidentified any materials as confidential that they would\nwithhold, but I do note that we would not ask for and would not\nexpect to receive privileged materials.\n\nTHE COURT: Okay. Did you provide Judge Sweet with a\nproposed order?\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: We did, yes, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000865\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004907\n\n", "char_count": 1460}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "FR\n\nND\n\n.o%)\n\nfiw\n\nO1\n\nep\n\n~l\n\nee)\n\n\\O\n\n10\n\n11\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 15 of 23\n\n14\nXj3qlgra SEALED\nTHE COURT: Could I see what you provided Judge Sweet.\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Yes, of course.\n\nAnd your Honor, just for the record, I'm handing over\nwhat was our initial sealed affirmation and application to the\nCourt for an order under the All Writs Act, and that includes\nan affirmation and application that I signed with an exhibit\nattached of the original protective order, followed by which is\na proposed order for entry by Judge Sweet, which we of course\nwould be happy to submit to the Court in Word form or in\nrevised form, subject to the Court's views.\n\nTHE COURT: Right. I just wanted to see if it hada\ncertain provision.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: If there is a provision that the\nCourt thinks would address some of these issues, we would of\ncourse be happy to hear it.\n\nTHE COURT: Of course I'm not Judge Sweet, so I don't\nknow exactly what was going on in his head.\n\nI assume it would be the government's position that\nreliance on the nondisclosure of confidential materials to law\nenforcement in connection with a grand jury subpoena that has\nbeen duly authorized would be unreasonable. It wouldn't be\npetecneble reliance. to assume that the protective order could\nnever be modified to allow -- I mean, the parties to this\nnegotiated the protective order, and the protective order does\nnot contain the provision that is in every protective order I\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000866\n\nDOJ-OGR- 00004908\n\n", "char_count": 1622}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "10\n\nLt\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\naul\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 16 of 23\n\n15\nXj3qlgra SEALED\nsign, which is, you can disclose it without the permission of\nthe Court if, you know, law enforcement puts a gun to your head\nand. says produce it: That's not in here.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: That's right, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:.. I don't know. It's my understanding that\nit may have been negotiated out.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: It may have been. I will only say\nthat I believe that -- I'm on less firm ground than in the\ncases that we discussed specifically, but I believe that the\nconverse would be void for public policy; in other words, you\nwould not be able to put in --\n\nTHE COURT: That was my question.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: -- you may not disclose this to law\nenforcement even given a duly authorized grand jury subpoena.\n\nTHE COURT: Thank you for saying the words \"void for\npublic policy,\" because I was going there. I take it it would\nbe the government's position that because it would be void as\nagainst public policy to absolutely prohibit the disclosure of\ninformation to law enforcement, that if a party were to say,\n\"But I Foliea on this, that it would not be disclosed to law\nenforcement, \" that that would not, in your view, be reasonable\nreliance.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Yes, your Honor, I think that's\ncorrect, and I think that that is borne out by the opinion in\nChemical Bank, which essentially says: You should have asked,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000867\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004909\n\n", "char_count": 1559}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "oN OVO) Pee Go BO Re\n\n\\o F\n\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\na0\n22\n23\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE § Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 17 of 23\n\n16\nXj3qligra SEALED\nbut of course this is fine for you to disclose this information\nto the government based on the validly issued grand jury\nsubpoena, I think for the same type of reasons that the Court\nis. describing.\n\nTHE COURT: Okay. So let me see what other million\nquestions that I have.\n\nIt's a general subpoena. Did you take them for all\ndiscovery materials? I mean, everything that's in Boies\nSchiller's files, other than privileged documents, which of\ncourse you don't exclude from your subpoena but presumably they\nwill exclude from their production. But it's literally\neverything. So remember, I know very little about the Maxwell\ncase, both because it wasn't my case and, to the shock of\nnearly. everyone that I talk to, we're all too busy to worry\nabout some litigation that's being handled by somebody else;\nand second, it seems to have been litigated entirely under seal\nso how could I have found out anything about it. Everything I\nknow about this case I learned from reading about the Second\nCircuit argument. Literally, everything.\n\nSo what assurance do I have that so broad a grand jury\nsubpoena -- given that I have these competing interests between\nthe terms of the protective order and the government's interest\nin conducting an investigation, what assurance do I have that\nyou need all that stuff, that that's all somehow going to be\nrelevant to your investigation? That is a concern from me\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000868\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004910\n", "char_count": 1648}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "BR\n\nNO\n\nOo\n\niS\n\nOi\n\ncep\n\n~~]\n\nee)\n\nKe\n\n10\n\n11\n\nLZ\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\nLZ.\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\noe\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 18 of 23\n\n17\nXj3qlgra SEALED\nbecause I don't know anything about the case.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Okay, your Honor, and I think the\nanswer to that is in a couple parts. The first is, I would\npoint the Court towards some of the opinions that have talked\nabout the government's investigative ability and authority\nbeing broad, and it is the case that sometimes we issue grand\njury. subpoenas =\n\nTHE COURT: But that was true in Martindell too.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Yes, of course, your Honor, but I\njust need to say that it is entirely possible that, in any\ngrand jury subpoena, that materials will come back that are not\nhelpful to our investigation, are not relevant, for whatever\nreason, that it was, however unintentionally, overbroad or\nincluded unnecessary aspects. Here, we are essentially unable\nto significantly narrow the request for information in part for\nexactly the reasons that you describe. We have either little\nor no additional information than the Court does in terms of\nwhat materials there are, who was deposed, and that is in\nmarked contrast to some of the other cases.\n\nTHE COURT: Every other case in the whole world.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Of course, your Honor. Exactly. For\nexactly the reasons we described.\n\nSo what I can say in terms of assurance is, we are not\nsort of an ordinary third-party intervenor. All of these\nmaterials will be subject to the extraordinary protections of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000869\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004911\n\n", "char_count": 1638}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "eS\n\nN\n\n(ee)\n\nAs\n\nU1\n\nOo\n\n~~]\n\nfoe)\n\n\\o\n\n10\n\n11\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n“15\n\n16\n\nLy\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n25\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 19 of 23\n\n18\nXj3qlgra SEALED\nRule 60. We will be extremely restricted in our use of them.\nTo the extent that we receive materials that otherwise wouldn't\nhave been narrowly connected with our investigation, they will\nnot go anywhere that they shouldn't; they will not be treated\nin any way they should not be.\n\nTHE COURT: Let me ask a question that you may not\nwish to answer, and I'll appreciate it if you don't.\n\nIT know who the target of your investigation is, at\nleast the one that you've identified. Is there any expectation\nthat these materials would be used to commence criminal\nproceedings against either of the parties to the libel case?\n\nMR, ROSSMILLER: I can say that just as a general\nmatter, that any materials that we gather in any part of any\ninvestigation that appear to give rise to criminal liability\nfor individuals implicated in those materials could cause us to\nproceed with an investigation of any such individual. That's a\nlittle broad, your Honor, obviously, but --\n\nTHE COURT: Oh, no. I understand what you're saying.\nAnd I think Judge Sweet had some concerns about that.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: But I don't think that there's any\nadditional protection for the parties of the lawsuit as opposed\nto nonparties' information.\n\nTHE COURT: They're the ones who relied on the\nprotective order. Of course you say it's not reasonable to\nrely, but they're the ones who relied on the protective order\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000870\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004912\n", "char_count": 1657}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n+18\n19\n20\n21\n22.\n23\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 20 of 23\n\n19\nXj3qligra SEALED\nin order to give whatever in discovery they gave, whether it\nwas deposition testimony they gave or -- then again, I can't\nfathom why anybody who has any criminal exposure would not have\ntaken the Fifth Amendment in response to questions in a civil\ndeposition, but I don't know.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: So just taking that very briefly in\norder, your Honor, I: do not know, but I think it is entirely\npossible that what we are seeking is page after page of people\ntaking the Fifth. That is entirely possible. But to the\nextent that it is not or there are other materials -- and this\nmay be bad for our argument, but in all transparency and\ncandor, I think there may be other individuals who also relied\non the protective order. .In other words, anyone other than the\nparties who were deposed may have, in theory, and perhaps\nunreasonably, relied on it.\n\nTHE COURT: For example, the target of your\ninvestigation.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER:. For example, the target of our\ninvestigation. But I don't think that the parties would be\ndifferently situated in terms of their rights, and there are\ncertainly many cases:that talk about how the government has the\nability to grant immunity in a criminal investigation, but not,\nof course, through restricting materials --\n\nTHE COURT: But that's the whole point of the\ngovernment needing to follow the procedure, the proper\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000871\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004913\n", "char_count": 1571}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "10\n\nzl\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\na7\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 21 of 23\n\n20\nXj3qlgra SEALED\nprocedure of either having the target of the subpoena make a\nmotion to quash or a motion for relief or the government moving\nfor relief to intervene, instead of engaging in self-help.\nThere isn't an application like this in any case except the\nChemical Bank case, and in the Chemical Bank case, it all was\nex post facto and it all happened.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Right. And I'll just note, without\nwanting to be defensive at all about the posture -- I\nunderstand the Court's questions about that -- I cannot recall\nwhether it was Martindell or one of the other cases, but one of\nthe original cases in this line, one of the issues was that the\ncourt had: gotten on the phone with the judge and requested it,\nyou know, sort of informally, right?\n\nTHE. COURT: Yes.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Despite our errors in the precise\nprocedure, we did want to have a formal application with\nreasons and then subsequently, at the request of Judge Sweet,\nsupporting law. And so I do apologize for the precise posture.\nWe took the approach that we did in the hopes that we could\navoid the types of problems that had been engendered by other\ntypes of applications which I think were made by the government\nin other cases, and so that's what we did here as well.\n\nTHE COURT: Okay. All right. Well, I'll tell you one\nthing that I am going to do. I am going to ask the clerk of\nthe court to assign a miscellaneous number to this case and\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000872\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004914\n", "char_count": 1641}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "fk\n\nNS)\n\nGo\n\nBs\n\nUO\n\noO\n\n~j\n\noO\n\nNe}\n\n10\n\n11\n\n12\n\n13\n\n14\n\n15\n\n16\n\n17\n\n18\n\n19\n\n20\n\n21\n\n22\n\n23\n\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 22 of 23\n\na1.\nXj3qlgra SEALED\neverything will be filed under seal, and it will be \"In Re\nGrand Jury,\" you know, the usual, and it will have the\ntreatment that \"In Re Grand Jury\" materials get, and everything\nwill be filed under seal. But that way I at least have a place\nto put this, okay?\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: I appreciate that, your Honor. I\nthink we had expected that had the order been either granted or\ndenied, that consistent with our usual All Writs application,\nthat it would have then been identified with a number, but\nfrankly, I'm not in the clerk's office, so --\n\nTHE COURT: Okay. But it has to have one, and I'm\nparticularly acutely desirous of making sure that this is filed\nunder a docket number with this court because I am concerned\nabout the way everything has happened to date, given the Second\nCircuit's kind of, it seems to me, obvious displeasure with the\nfact that this whole thing has been litigated under seal. So\ngrand jury material, absolutely. But let's be sure that there\nis a docket, you know, that we don't have something that's off\nthe radar screen.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: Totally understood, your Honor, and I\nappreciate that, and we're grateful to the Court for that.\n\nTHE COURT:. Great. Okay. And you'll get your answer\nby early next week. I have to go to the annual meeting of the\nchief district judges.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: I don't envy the Court that.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000873\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004915\n", "char_count": 1621}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004894", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "ke\n\nNe)\n\n(es)\n\nis\n\nOl\n\nfen\n\n~~]\n\nioe)\n\nto\n\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n\n25\n\nCase 1:20-cr-00330-PAE © Document 311-1 Filed 07/02/21 Page 23 of 23\n\n22\nXj3qigra SEALED\n\nTHE COURT: It would be fine, but my biggest problem,\nfrankly, is I don't know when Judge Sweet's funeral is and I'm\ntrying to figure out when I need to be here for Judge Sweet's\nfuneral. |\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: We're very grateful --\n\nTHE COURT: This goes to the top of the pile. I\nappreciate that this should have been dealt with sooner, and\nI'm sorry that it wasn't dealt with a week sooner or you would\nhave had an. answer.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER: We're grateful for the Court's\nattention and certainly appreciate the opportunity to explain\nhow we ended-up here.\n\nTHE COURT: \"Okay...-Thank you.\n\nMR. ROSSMILLER:. Thank you, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT: I appreciate it, Mr. Rossmiller.\n\ne000\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300 SDNY_GM_00000874\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004916\n\n", "char_count": 947}]}