{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_count": 17, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/DOJ-OGR-00004001", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/DOJ-OGR-00004001.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 Filed 04/23/21 Page1of17\n\nBOIES\nSCHILLER\ntes LEXNER\n\nSigrid S. McCawley\nTelephone: (954) 377-4223\nEmail: smecawley@bsfllp.com\n\nApril 5, 2021\n\nVIA EMAIL (FILED UNDER TEMPORARY SEAL\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nUnited States District Court\nSouthern District of New York\n40 Foley Square\n\nNew York, New York 10007\n\nRe: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)\nRule 17 Subpoena to Boies Schiller Flexner LLP\n\nDear Judge Nathan:\n\nI write on behalf of Boies Schiller Flexner LLP (“BSF”) in further support of its objections\nto Defendant Ghislaine Maxwell’s motion for an order authorizing a subpoena to BSF pursuant to\nRule 17(c) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure (the “Subpoena”).! As the Defendant’s\nresponse makes clear, she seeks to serve a Rule 17 subpoena on BSF because she is dissatisfied\nwith the Government’s discovery efforts thus far. Thus, she is using Rule 17 to attempt to obtain\ndiscovery that she has been unable to obtain from the Government under Rule 16 and Brady,\nincluding discovery that is subject to a pending motion before the Court. This is an improper use\nof a Rule 17 subpoena. If the Defendant believes that the Government has not fulfilled its\ndiscovery obligations under Rule 16, Brady, or Giglio, she must address that issue with the\nGovernment and the Court rather than serving overbroad and burdensome subpoenas on third\n\nparties. And if the Defendant is not entitled to the discovery she seeks from the Government, then\n\n: The Defendant refers to BSF’s objections as a “motion to quash,” but the Court has not yet\n\ngranted Defendant’s motion to authorize the Subpoena to BSF. BSF thus requests that the\nDefendant’s motion to authorize the Subpoena be denied.\n\nBOIES SCHILLER! FLEXNER: LEP\n\n401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 1200, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 | (t) 954 356 0011 | (f) 8954 356 0022 | www.bsfilp.com\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004001\n\n", "char_count": 1920}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 Filed 04/23/21 Page2of17\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 2 of 17\n\nshe may not use Rule 17 to circumvent Rule 16. For this reason and the additional reasons\nexplained below, the Court should deny the Defendant’s motion to authorize the Subpoena to BSF.\n\n1. Requests 1-5: Communications About the Defendant and 3\nA. The Requests Are Not Specific.\n\nThe Defendant has failed to meet her burden of demonstrating that Requests 1 through 5—\nfor a broad range of communications between BSF and others about the Defendant and gy\nWm —clear Nixon’s hurdles of relevancy, admissibility, and specificity. See United States v.\nNixon, 418 U.S. 683, 700 (1974). As to specificity, Maxwell first argues that Requests 1 through\n5 are sufficiently specific because they “are specific as to date and limited by the identified\nindividuals and subject matter.” Resp. Ltr. at 2. But the specificity hurdle requires more. “In order\nto avoid speculation that the moving party is using Rule 17(c) to circumvent normal discovery\nrequirements, the party’s Rule 17(c) subpoena must be able to reasonably specify the information\ncontained or believed to be contained in the documents sought rather than merely hope that\nsomething useful will turn up.” United States v. Mendinueta-Ibarro, 956 F. Supp. 2d 511, 513\n(S.D.N.Y. 2013) (internal quotation marks omitted). Accordingly, “[r]equests for any and all\ncommunications, even if tied to specific documents and topics, are potentially ‘fishing expeditions’\nfor unspecified materials and insufficiently specific under United States v. Nixon.” United States\nv. Bergstein, No. 16-CR-746 (PKC), 2018 WL 9539775, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 1, 2018).\n\nThe Defendant’s broad requests for all of BSF’s communications with certain individuals\nand entities about general topics over a years-long time period do not meet the specificity\nrequirement, just like numerous of the defendant’s requests in Avenatti failed the specificity\nrequirement\n... [truncated, 2200 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/1 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=1]", "char_count": 2200}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 Filed 04/23/21 Page3of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 3 of 17\n\ndiscussion of corruption in amateur basketball; and (3) that took place within a thirty-nine month\nperiod” failed the specificity requirement, even though the request was limited by time, subject\nmatter, and identified individuals. United States v. Avenatti, No. (S1) 19 CR. 373 (PGG), 2020\nWL 86768, at *6 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 6, 2020) (holding that request “reads like a request under the\nFederal Rules of Civil Procedure” and that “[b]lanket requests of this sort violate the specificity\nrequirement set forth in Nixon”). Judge Gardephe similarly held that Mr. Avenatti’s request for\n“email and text message communications between Franklin and Auerbach that (1) mention\nAvenatti, and (2) were transmitted after Avenatti’s March 25, 2019 arrest” failed Nixon’s\nspecificity requirement, even though that request was also limited by time, subject matter, and\nidentified individuals. United States v. Avenatti, No. (S1) 19 CR. 373 (PGG), 2020 WL 508682,\nat *5 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 31, 2020). Thus, there mere fact that the Defendant’s requests here are\ntethered to a broad time period of five years and broad subject matters (the Defendant and yyy\nWE. for example) cannot save her Requests.”\n\nThe Defendant attempts to distinguish these Requests from those that courts have\ncharacterized as improper “any and all” requests by pointing to the fact that the Requests do not\n\nliterally contain the words “any” or “all.” Resp. Ltr. at 3. But this does not change the fact that\n\n- See also, e.g., Bergstein, 2018 WL 9539775, at *1 (finding that requests seeking “all\ncommunications between Parmar and Bergstein, Albert Hallac, Jeffrey Hallac, or Keith Wellner\nrelated to the negotiations of, documentation of, and performance or non-performance under three\nagreements governing the acquisition of the medical billing business described in the indictment”\nand “all communications between Parmar and\n... [truncated, 2556 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/2 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=2]", "char_count": 2556}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 Filed 04/23/21 Page4of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 4 of 17\n\nthe Requests themselves ask for “communications” between BSF and a designated party about a\ngeneral topic over a five-year period, and then define communications as “all forms of\ncorrespondence.” Request 2, for example, is for “Communications between You and the United\nStates Attorney between 2015 and the date of this subpoena about xg.” defining\n“communications” as “all forms of correspondence”; defining “BSF” as “any owner, shareholder,\npartner or employee of” BSF; and defining “the United States Attorney” as “any employee of the\noffice of the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York.” This Request cannot\nbe read as anything but “a// communications in any form between anyone who has ever worked at\nBSF in any capacity and anyone who has ever worked at the S.D.N.Y. United States Attorney’s\noffice in any capacity between 2015 and the date of this subpoena about yg.” Thus,\ndue to their expansive definitions, the Defendant’s requests are even broader than those that Judge\nGardephe rejected in Avenatti, which were limited to identified individuals.? Requests 1 through\n\n5 of the subpoena thus fail Nixon’s specificity requirement.\n\n3 The Defendant contends that Requests 1 through 5 are similar to those approved by the\n\ncourt in United States v. Wey, 252 F. Supp. 3d 237 (S.D.N.Y. 2017). Resp. Ltr. at 6. But in Wey,\nthe court originally denied the defendant’s motion for the issuance of a Rule 17 subpoena because\nit requested: “All emails and records related to the listing applications and approvals for\n[SmartHeat], [Deer], and [CleanTech], including in particular, any communications regarding, or\ninterpretation or application of, the 300 round-lot shareholder requirement.” /d. at 243. The court\nfound that the defendant “had not identified the documents sought with the requisite specificity\nand had failed to make the necessary showing t\n... [truncated, 2673 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/3 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=3]", "char_count": 2673}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page5of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 5 of 17\n\nThe Defendant argues that Requests | through 5 are not a fishing expedition merely\nbecause the government has admitted “that there were, in fact meetings and communications\nbetween these individuals and the USAO-SDNY about Ms. Maxwell and gg? and\nbecause Virginia Giuffre logged a number of communications on a privilege log in 2016. Resp.\nLtr. at 2,3. This does not get the Requests over Nixon’s hurdles—the Defendant is still attempting\nto fish through BSF’s communications in the hopes that something relevant and admissible turns\nup, without setting forth the relevance and admissibility as to each document she seeks. Further\nthe privilege log does not, as the Defendant insinuates, reference communications between BSF\nand the U.S. Attorney as defined in the Subpoena, as the log references only an unspecified “law\nenforcement agency.” /d. at 4.\n\nB. The Defendant Has Not Demonstrated Relevance and Admissibility.\n\nThe Court’s analysis does not stop at specificity—Requests 1 through 5 independently fail\nbecause the Defendant has not demonstrated that all of the communications she seeks are relevant\nand admissible. The Defendant’s sole basis for contending that the wide array of communications\nshe seeks are all relevant to her defense is that the communications are relevant to “two motions\nto suppress based on misrepresentations made by the government to Chief Judge McMahon and a\nmotion to dismiss the indictment for prejudicial delay” because they “would establish the\nsubstance and frequency of the communications between BSF and the government prior to the\ngovernment’s end run around Martindell.” Resp. Ltr. at 6-7. But the Defendant has not met her\nburden of demonstrating relevance and admissibility.\n\nFirst, because Rule 17’s “purpose is trial-focused,” a Rule 17(c) subpoena “may be used\nonly to obtain materials admissible as evidence at trial.” United \n... [truncated, 2147 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/4 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=4]", "char_count": 2147}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 Filed 04/23/21 Page6of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 6 of 17\n\nv. Rajaratnam, 753 F. Supp. 2d 317, 320 (S.D.N.Y. 2011) (Rule 17(c) “was not intended to provide\na means of discovery for criminal cases”; rather, “its chief innovation was to expedite the trial by\nproviding a time and place before trial for the inspection of subpoenaed materials” (emphasis\nadded)). The Defendant has failed to explain how the communications sought in Requests 1\nthrough 5 will be relevant and admissible at trial, and only points to three pending pre-trial motions.\n\nSecond, although BSF cannot fully respond to the Defendant’s relevance arguments as to\nthe Defendant’s two motions to suppress because it has not been provided unredacted versions of\nthose motions and because it has not been provided a copy of the Defendant’s ex parte motion,'\none thing is clear—it is not conceivable that every communication the Defendant requests in\nRequests 1 through 5 would be relevant and admissible at an evidentiary hearing on her motions.\nA defendant must demonstrate that all of the evidence it seeks pursuant to a Rule 17 subpoena\nwould be relevant and admissible, not just that the defendant is likely to find something relevant\nand admissible in the nonparty’s production. See, e.g., United States v. Pena, No. 15 Cr. 551\n(AJN), 2016 WL 8735699, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 12, 2016) (‘Pena has failed to make the requisite\nshowing regarding the admissibility of ‘any and all’ other records regarding the cooperators that\nmight exist at the MDC, MCC, or DOC.”).\n\nFor example, it is entirely unclear how communications regarding yy would\nbe relevant to any of the Defendant’s pretrial motions; her two motions to suppress relate to\n\nevidence obtained by the Government by means of a grand jury subpoena to what appears to be\n\n” If the Court is inclined to grant the Defendants’ motion as to Requests 1 through 5, BSF\n\nrequests that it first be provided with an opportuni\n... [truncated, 2360 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/5 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=5]", "char_count": 2360}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 Filed 04/23/21 Page/7of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 7 of 17\n\nBSF, and her motion to dismiss for pre-indictment delay is based on the time that has passed\nbetween the time at which the Government first learned of the allegations against the Defendant\nand the Defendant’s indictment. ECF No. 134, 138, 140. The public versions of those filings do\nnot mention J at all. Even the relevance of a// communications between BSF and the\nGovernment relating to the Defendant herself is dubious as it relates to these three motions. At\nbase, it is not BSF’s burden to “to cull the good from the bad” among its communications about\nthe Defendant and to determine what would relevant at trial or at an evidentiary hearing. See\nBowman Dairy Co. v. United States, 341 U.S. 214, 220 (1951).\n\nThird, the Defendant has not even attempted to demonstrate that all of the evidence she\nseeks would be admissible. Although the lack of specificity in Requests 1 through 5 makes it\nimpossible to meaningfully debate the admissibility of each piece of evidence she seeks, certainly\nmany of the communications requested will constitute inadmissible hearsay. This is precisely the\npurpose of Nixon’s specificity requirement—to ensure that Rule 17 subpoenas are narrowly\ntailored to obtain only relevant and admissible evidence, not to obtain discovery in the hopes that\nsomething relevant and admissible might turn up, and to allow the recipient to lodge relevance and\nadmissibility objections as to the precise documents being requested. See Avenatti, 2020 WL\n508682, at *4 (“While the specificity requirement is intended to provide the subpoenaed party or\nother party having standing with enough knowledge about what documents are being requested so\nas to lodge any objections on relevancy or admissibility, this requirement also ensures that a Rule\n17(c) subpoena will not be used as a fishing expedition to see what may turn up.” (internal\nquotation marks omitted\n... [truncated, 2208 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/6 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=6]", "char_count": 2208}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page8of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 8 of 17\n\nRequests themselves. Resp. Ltr. at 7. In Requests 3 through 5, the Defendant seeks all\ncommunications between BSF and its co-counsel in a civil litigation against Maxwell (Giuffre v.\nMaxwell, 15-cv-07433-LAP) “between 2015 and the date of this subpoena about any meeting with\nthe United States Attorney concerning Ghislaine Maxwell or i.” Certainly, some\nof these communications, if they exist, may fall under the work product umbrella if they were\ninternal discussions with co-counsel. Moreover, BSF and its co-counsel have a common interest\nprotection in their communications. The Defendant’s overbroad Requests make it impossible for\nBSF to determine how many responsive communications would be protected and why. Again, it\nis the Defendant’s burden to demonstrate that all of the communications she seeks would be\nrelevant and admissible, and it is not BSF’s burden to review broad swaths of material to determine\nwhat the Defendant is entitled to under Rule 17.\n\nC. Communications Between BSF and the Government Are Procurable from the\nGovernment.\n\nEven if Requests 1 through 5 could overcome Nixon’s three hurdles, however, Requests 1\nand 2 would still fail to the extent that they ask for communications with the Government, which\nthe Defendant can procure from the Government. The Defendant admits that the Government has\nthe communications she is seeking, but complains that the Government “has failed to produce, or\neven look for these communications and Ms. Maxwell has no other means to obtain them.” Resp.\nLtr. at 8. In fact, this dispute is currently pending before the Court—the Defendant filed a Motion\nfor a Bill of Particulars and Pretrial Disclosures in which she seeks an order compelling the\nGovernment to disclose the very communications with BSF she seeks in the Subpoena and to\nimmediately disclose all Brady and Giglio materials. ECF Nos. 148, 148-5 (m\n... [truncated, 2127 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/7 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=7]", "char_count": 2127}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 Filed 04/23/21 Page9of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 9 of 17\n\nappears to be BSF, including all communications between the Government and BSF attorneys\nDavid Boies, Sigrid McCawley, and Peter Skinner, and requesting immediate disclosure of Brady\nand Giglio materials).\n\nThe Defendant cannot use Rule 17 to circumvent resolution of an outstanding discovery\ndispute with the Government, especially when that dispute is currently pending before the Court.\nIf the Defendant is entitled to the communications with the Government she requests in Requests\n1 and 2 pursuant to Rule 16, then presumably the Court will order the Government to produce\nthem and she may not use Rule 17 to obtain them from a nonparty instead. See, e.g., Nixon, 418\nU.S. at 699 (documents requested pursuant to Rule 17(c) must not be “otherwise procurable” from\nanother source); United States v. Cole, No. 19 CR. 869 (ER), 2021 WL 912425, at *6 (S.D.N.Y.\nMar. 10, 2021) (explaining that “Rule 17(c) is not the proper method for obtaining” materials that\nthe Government has an obligation to disclose under the Jencks Act, Brady, and Giglio). If the\nDefendant is not entitled to obtain the communications she seeks from the Government under Rule\n16, then they are not discoverable under Rule 17 from a nonparty. See United States v. Boyle, No.\n08 Cr. 523 (CM), 2009 WL 484436, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 24, 2009) (“Defendants may not seek\nmaterial under Rule 17 that they are prohibited from obtaining under Rule 16.”); United States v.\nBarnes, No. 89 04 CR 186 SCR, 2008 WL 9359654, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 2, 2008) (‘[I]f the item\nis not discoverable under Rule 16, a party cannot make it discoverable simply by subpoenaing it\nunder Rule 17.”); United States v. Cherry, 876 F. Supp. 547, 552 (S.D.N.Y. 1995) (“Courts must\nbe careful that Rule 17(c) is not turned into a broad discovery device, thereby undercutting the\nstrict limitation of discovery in criminal cases found in Fed\n... [truncated, 2198 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/8 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=8]", "char_count": 2198}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page10of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 10 of 17\n\nI. Requests 6 and 7: Engagement Letters\n\nThe Defendant provides no explanation at all as to how engagement agreements between\nBSF and Annie and Maria Farmer would be relevant and admissible at trial, and thus cannot clear\nthe Nixon hurdles. She states in a conclusory manner that “[t]he scope and dates of these\nengagements are relevant to Ms. Maxwell’s pending motions” and that “these agreements are\nexculpatory evidence.” Resp. Ltr. at 8. But it is entirely unclear how the fact that the Farmers are\nrepresented by BSF and the dates of the engagement letter could possibly be exculpatory, and the\nDefendant does not attempt to explain that proposition.\n\nNor are the engagement letters relevant to any of the Defendant’s pretrial motions. The\nDefendant’s motions to suppress appear to be based on a theory that the Government improperly\nobtained evidence from BSF while it was representing Virginia Giuffre (not the Farmers) in\nGiuffre v. Maxwell. ECF Nos. 134, 140. The only relevance of Annie Farmer to the Defendant’s\nmotion for dismissal based on pre-indictment delay appears to be based on Maxwell’s statement\nthat Ms. Farmer was interviewed by the FBI in 2006. ECF No. 138 at 2. But the Defendant has\nnot explained how an engagement letter between Annie Farmer and BSF is of any consequence to\nher theory. The Defendant also points out in her motion for dismissal based on pre-indictment\ndelay that Annie Farmer may have cooperated with the Government in the criminal investigation\nof her abuser—an unremarkable proposition. /d. at 18. Not only is it unclear how this theory\nsupports the Defendant’s arguments about pre-indictment delay, but the Defendant again has not\nexplained how an engagement letter with BSF is relevant to this theory.\n\nAs to Maria Farmer, she is only relevant to the motion for dismissal based on\npre-indictment delay insofar as the Defendant \n... [truncated, 2155 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/9 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=9]", "char_count": 2155}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page11of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 11 of 17\n\nNo. 138 at 2 n.2. Again, however, the Defendant does not explain why Maria Farmer’s\nengagement letter with BSF is relevant to support this proposition or is otherwise relevant to the\nmotion. The Defendant’s conclusory arguments that the engagement letters between BSF and the\nFarmers are relevant to something other impeachment are unpersuasive and demonstrate that she\ncannot clear Nixon’s relevance hurdle as to Requests 6 and 7.\n\niI. Request 8: Grand Jury Subpoena to BSF\n\nRequest 8 fails for the same reason that Requests 1 and 2 fail. If the Defendant is entitled\nto this information, then she must obtain it from the Government. And if she is not entitled to this\ninformation, she cannot use Rule 17 to circumvent Rule 16’s limitations. See supra Part I.C.\n\nIV. Request 9: Annie Farmer’s Journal\n\nAs to the Defendant’s request for an original copy of Annie Farmer’s entire journal from\nwhen she was a teenager, the Defendant contends that the journal is exculpatory because the\nrelevant passages do not mention the Defendant—but this is information that she already has, and\nshe does not explain why she needs the entire journal prior to trial if she already has the allegedly\nexculpatory information in the journal. The Defendant already has copies of all of the relevant\npages of the journal. She does not explain why she needs to inspect the entire journal “to establish\nwhether the journal is authentic and complete and whether or not spoliation has occurred.” Resp.\nLtr. at 9. This purported need to inspect the journal for authenticity would carry more weight if\nthe journal was inculpatory, and thus she sought to examine the authenticity of the pages containing\nallegations against her, but she contends it is instead exculpatory. If the Defendant seriously\n\ncontends that the journal is relevant because it is exculpatory, and that it is exculpatory because\n\n°\n... [truncated, 2230 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/10 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=10]", "char_count": 2230}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page12of17\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 12 of 17\n\nthe relevant pages do not mention her, she needs no more than the relevant pages that she already\nhas.\n\nIt is thus clear that the Defendant’s purported need for the entire, original journal is not\nbased on the allegedly exculpatory information that it contains (because she already has that\ninformation). Rather, the Defendant seeks the entire journal so that she can fish for other passages\nthat she can use to attempt to impeach Ms. Farmer’s credibility. Such a fishing expedition for\npotential impeachment material goes beyond the permissible bounds of a Rule 17 subpoena. See\nNixon, 418 U.S. at 701 (“Generally, the need for evidence to impeach witnesses is insufficient to\nrequire its production in advance of trial.”). And if the Defendant does not seek the remainder of\nthe journal passages for impeachment, she does not explain how they would otherwise be relevant\nand admissible at trial. The Court should not require production of the entire journal—which\ncontains personal, private information about Ms. Farmer when she was a minor—if Defendant is\nunable to demonstrate that the overbroad Request meets the relevance and admissibility\n\nrequirements and if it will yield no material evidence.°®\n\n6 Even in civil cases, where much broader discovery is permitted under the Federal Rules of\nCivil Procedure than under Rule 17(c), courts have refused to order disclosure of an entire diary\nor journal when the journal contains personal or sensitive entries and the party seeking disclosure\ncannot demonstrate that anything relevant has been withheld. See, e.g., Dubay v. King, No. 3:17-\nCV-348-J-20MCR, 2018 WL 3619636, at *1 (M.D. Fla. July 13, 2018) (“Plaintiff failed to show\nhow the production of Mr. King’s private journal entries—containing information about Mr. King’s\nprivate life and daily musings—relate to the subject matter of the claims in this lawsuit.”); \n... [truncated, 2795 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/11 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=11]", "char_count": 2795}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page13o0f17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 13 of 17\n\nV. Requests 10 and 11: Boots and Photographs\n\nAs to Requests 10 and 11, for boots that Epstein and the Defendant purchased for Annie\nFarmer and various photographs, the Defendant complains that “the government has scrupulously\navoided actually obtaining” this evidence. Resp. Ltr. at 11. But, as explained above, Rule 17 is\nnot a tool that can be used to circumvent discovery disputes with the Government. BSF is a private\nentity with no Brady or other constitutional obligations to the Defendant, and a subpoena to BSF\ncannot be used to replace discovery appropriately aimed at the Government under Rule 16 or to\navoid resolving discovery disputes with the Government.\n\nIn any event, the photographs are not “admittedly relevant” and the Defendant has not\nexplained how they would be relevant and admissible as trial. Resp. Ltr. at 11. The photographs\ndo not portray any event described in the indictment. Instead, the photographs depicted in Exhibit\n\nC to the Subpoena that the Defendant seeks are as follows:\n\nAFARMER00010470; | Photographs of Annie Farmer prior to a high school dance,\nAFARMER00011691; | produced in Farmer v. Indyke et al., 19-cv-10475 (LGS-DCF).\nAFARMER00011692\nAFARMER0001 1339 Photograph of Annie Farmer, Maria Farmer, and their younger\nsister, produced in Farmer v. Indyke et al., 19-cv-10475 (LGS-\nDCF).\n\nAFARMER00011688; | Photographs of Annie Farmer in Thailand, produced in Farmer v.\nAFARMER00011690 Indyke et al., 19-cv-10475 (LGS-DCF).\n\nAFARMER00011689; | Photographs of Annie Farmer and a friend in high school, produced\nAFARMER00011693; | in Farmer v. Indyke et al., 19-cv-10475 (LGS-DCF).\nAFARMER00011694\nAFARMER00012106; | Photographs of Maria Farmer on Leslie Wexner’s property in Ohio,\nAFARMER00012107 produced in Farmer v. Indyke et al., 19-cv-10475 (LGS-DCF).\nGIUFFRE007164— Photographs that Virginia Giuffre provided to the FBI of Je\n... [truncated, 2459 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/12 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=12]", "char_count": 2459}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page14of17\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\n\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 14 of 17\n\nThe Defendant has not explained how any of the photographs are relevant to her defense and\nwould “help in establishing her innocence” or why “the dates of creation” or “other specifics”\nabout these photographs are relevant to her defense. Resp. Ltr. at 11.\n\nVI. Request 12: EVCP Material\n\nA. The Request is Not Specific.\n\nThe Defendant does not even address the lack of specificity of her Request for “any\nsubmission to the Epstein Victim’s Compensation Program made by You, including any claims\non behalf of persons who have accused Jeffrey Epstein or Ghislaine Maxwell of any misconduct,\nany releases signed by You or Your Clients, and any compensation received by You or Your\nClients.” This Request on its face includes a// claims that BSF has submitted on behalf of all of\nits clients, including all of the supporting documents (including sensitive medical and therapy\nrecords) that each client submitted with those claims. As BSF explained in its objections, the\nDefendant cannot merely request every piece of highly confidential information that BSF’s clients\nsubmitted to the Program in the hopes that something relevant and admissible turns up. The\nDefendant offered to narrow this Request to EVCP Material submitted on behalf of victims who\nultimately testify in this action. This “narrowing” does not change the improper nature of Request\n12—even the narrower request would call for broad swaths of material that are both irrelevant to\nthe charges against the Defendant and that are highly sensitive in nature.\n\nB. The Defendant Has Not Demonstrated Relevance, Other Than Potential\nImpeachment.\n\nRequest 12 independently fails because the Defendant seeks the EVCP Material only for\nimpeach purposes. The Defendant argues that the EVCP Material is not “mere impeachment\nmaterial” because it is also “Brady material.” Resp. Ltr. at 13. This argument does not make thi\n... [truncated, 2115 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/13 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=13]", "char_count": 2115}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page15of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 15 of 17\n\nexculpatory. Although BSF does not have the benefit of the ex parte submission that the Defendant\ncites, she appears to contend that the EVCP Material will contradict the Government’s theory as\nto the Defendant’s motive for committing the crimes of which she has been indicted: procuring\nunderage girls for Epstein. Resp. Ltr. at 13. But the Defendant does not explain how the EVCP\nMaterial—consisting of claims submitted by victims to an independent claims administration\nprogram, materials supporting those claims (such as medical and therapy records), and\ncompensation determinations for those claims—could possibly contradict the Government’s\ntheory that she committed crimes with the motive of procuring young girls for Epstein.’\n\nSecond, deeming the EVCP Material “Brady materials” does not render the Request\nappropriate under Rule 17, even if such a characterization were correct. Although the Government\nhas a constitutional duty to produce Brady materials, BSF has no such obligation. Thus, even if\nthe Requests in the Subpoena, including the Request for EVCP Material, might encompass some\nBrady materials, the Subpoena must still satisfy the Nixon requirements. See, e.g., Mendinueta-\nIbarro, 956 F. Supp. 2d at 513 (rejecting the defendant’s argument that under Rule 17 “the\nstringent requirements of Nixon do not apply when a defendant needs the requested information\nfor a fair trial, especially if that material is required to be turned over under Brady or Giglio”);\nUnited States v. Jackson, No. 02 CR. 756 (LMM), 2006 WL 1993251, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. July 14,\n2006) (explaining “that the materials may contain Giglio material does not mean that they can be\nsubpoenaed under Rule 17” and quashing subpoena for failing Nixon’s admissibility requirement);\n\nUnited States v. Scaduto, No. 94 CR. 311 (WK), 1995 WL 130511, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 27, 1995)\n\n7 Again, if t\n... [truncated, 2230 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/14 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=14]", "char_count": 2230}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page16of17\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 16 of 17\n\n(“A general assertion that certain material ‘might contain exculpatory information’ is insufficient\nto prevail against a motion to quash under Rule 17(c).”). BSF has no duty to cull through broad\nsets of documents to determine whether any Brady materials might exist and whether those\nmaterials would be relevant and admissible when the Defendant has failed to meet her burden of\nsatisfying Nixon’s requirements.\n\nSimilarly, the Defendant, likely realizing that she has no viable argument as to the\nrelevance of all of the EVC Material, argues that even if the EVCP Material was relevant only to\nimpeachment, impeachment evidence is discoverable in advance of trial. Resp. Ltr. at 13. This is\na mischaracterization of the law. Each of the cases the Defendant cites relates to the Government's\nobligations under Brady and Giglio. See Poventud v. City of New York, No. 07 CIV. 3998 DAB,\n2015 WL 1062186, at *8 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 9, 2015) (civil § 1983 case in which criminal defendant\ncontended that government violated Brady obligations); United States v. Petrillo, 821 F.2d 85, 90\n(2d Cir. 1987) (affirming denial of a motion for a new trial based on government’s failure to\nproduce Brady and Jencks Act materials); Grant v. Alldredge, 498 F.2d 376, 383 (2d Cir. 1974)\n(vacating judgment of conviction based on Brady violation by government); U.S. ex rel. Meers v.\nWilkins, 326 F.2d 135, 136 (2d Cir. 1964) (affirming grant of habeas corpus petition based on\nBrady violation by government). Not one of the cases that the Defendant cites concerns a Rule 17\nsubpoena to a nonparty because it is well-settled law that a criminal defendant may not use a Rule\n17 subpoena to obtain potential impeachment evidence from a nonparty. Pena, 2016 WL 8735699,\nat *2 (Nathan, J.) (“Rule 17(c) subpoenas may not issue prior to trial to obtain materials usable\nonly to impeach.”).\n\nFor all of t\n... [truncated, 2127 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/DOJ-OGR-00004001/15 or ?id=DOJ-OGR-00004001&page=15]", "char_count": 2127}, {"efta_number": "DOJ-OGR-00004001", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 247 _ Filed 04/23/21 Page17of17\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nApril 5, 2021\nPage 17 of 17\n\nRespectfully submitted,\n\n/s/ Sigrid S. McCawley\nSigrid S. McCawley\n\nDOJ-OGR-00004017\n\n", "char_count": 210}]}