In re: TERRORIST ATTACKS ON SEPTEMBER 11, 2001., 2012 WL 257568 (2012) “iii A. OPlaintiffs Alleged That Defendants Violated the ATS By Intentionally Facilitating 123 International Terrorist ......cecsseccsssesssssssseeessneeessneeessneesssnsesssnsesssnsesesnesssnsesssnsesssnsecesseesessecsesseccaneessaueessaseersneersnseeraneeeeanestan B. Acts of International Terrorism are a Violation of Customary International Law 000... eset 123 1. United Nations Security Council resolutions: ..rccccccsccssceecsesssvessseeseeescessseecnceceuessoeeesesecasescaeeesnsecaseseaeersneeenteccatersnees 125 2. International CONVENLIONS rcccssesssessseesseesssneesssnsesssnsesssnsesssnsesssneesesaecssnseceseecssneeseuseesesecsaneessaueensneersnteetaneeetaneeeeaneetan 126 3. Domestic laws Of NATIONS ecceeccccccssssssesssseessseecsessseeesneceseceseeesnsccusecessersnecsnseceueseoneesusecaseseasersnsesaseceaseesneesnseceneecseesneesaseesaess 128 4. Congress ANd federal COULIS eccsccecsccesssecseeeceeessceeesneecaseccseessneeseseccatessneesesecesesesneesesecaseceasersnsesaseseasersneceeseceaeereneesnseceds 129 C. International Terrorism Is Sufficiently Definite and of Mutual Concern to States cesses: 132 II. The District Court Improperly Dismissed the Torture Victim Protection Act Claims .........ceeeeee 135 IV. The District Court Improperly Dismissed the Negligence And Intentional Tort Claims ....... eee 139 A. The District Court Wrongly Dismissed the Negligence Claims oo... ccecccsesssesseeesceessseeesneeceteeeseersneeenteseatereneess 140 B. The District Court Wrongly Dismissed the Intentional Tort Clatims 2... eesccesseecseesceeseseeeseteceteeeseeeeneeeeeesneess 145 1. Plaintiffs’ Claims Are Not Time-Bar ved ..cecccccsssssssssseessessceeessneeseseccseessneesnseceneessnessnsecasescaressnecaseseaeeesneeenseceaeerensess 145 1. Plaintiffs Pleaded That Defendants Materially Supported l-Qa@G ...scecsssseesessecsesseeeeseieeceteseeeesneeenteseeeeeneess 148 2. Defendants Who Supported al-Qaeda Thro