Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP BOIES, Document 1331-12 SCHILLER & Filed 01/05/24 Page 1 of 10 FLEXNER LLP Sigrid MCC:m(4. titicvay.leste January 30, 2017 Confidential Sealed Filing VlA EMAIL ei FACSIMILE: (212) 805-7925 Honorable Judge Robert W. Sweet District Court Judge United States District Court 500 Pearl Street New York, NY 10007 SweetNYSDChambersraMystuseourts.goy Re: v. Maxwell, Case No.: 15-ev-07433-RWS Dear Judge Sweet, This is a reply letter in support of letter motion to allow for the newlydiscovered witness, . to be called as a witness at trial because she can testify about Defendant's involvement in Epstein's sex trafficking ring based on first-hand experiences and first-hand observations. Defendant Violated Rule 26 By Failing To Disclose This Critical Witness Defendant argues that is somehow to blame for the fact that is only now being discussed as a witness in this case. But only recently learned about this witness because Defendant failed to properly disclose her months earlier. In her response, Defendant does not address the fact that Ms. Ransome and Ms. Maxwell know each other. Indeed, Defendant does not address the fact that and she spent time together on Mr. Epstein's private island, as reflected in the flight logs showing flying to and from the island (where Ms. Maxwell was present): -_-12.;7-tere ,•44.4nQuiv4. 11• ,714/A eA rt .Ifl - i ,I• I I " )b 1G-MS10 • _... ./J9,0c1:Se ‘t-I It . _ R 21 It. vs t• "2.1 i 0 —4--i_ AiNte2 1_1_ rAt.pf I vala.4.4...4a-t-4-4--4 -l :a&t v,;:ues4 1,4L_01,4s.iii S . W s 2, Celie,oArs Civ't i _ vita ltret.ZEttalt29 1---)witias —7 —• • mLfr IL 1-1.5T EAN (CI 1 epstts imi tcif stcp,-1^11.1.v ' /1st -we 6\kht Paz ,, -) icl - melt* 174E1 bleaV — , TTS-sril -1---Wi Ina $'I' L.-wr. ll igetca e Att i actitiG4ACALD LESCeutcr i is r Getten-o Lecoug.-r LV t sti I • ate, 11- / 3otie ti:friwukt• /A 0 tri - Lo alSai GtA4 T.2- Ni4,004r-te racily/ 4 cony rat Ira dermas ,osoby nernittb Ica we Inn