From: Daniel Sabba Sent: 12/4/2014 2:55:49 PM To: [email protected] CC: Paul Morris I Stewart 0ldfield Subject: Re: An oil idea ICI Classification: Confidential Jeffrey, I had planned to discuss this idea with you at our call, but we ran out of time. We refreshed the original trade, whose market value is significantly up (mid level at $1.74/bbl from $0.75/bbl). The recent disruptions in WTI have caused transaction costs to increase (vol bid asks in vanilla options on that expiry have more than doubled). Therefore, while the idea was something we liked two weeks ago before the OPEC meeting, we don't think its risk reward is that attractive now given the increased transaction costs. Regards, Daniel From To Cc: Date. Subject: Damcl SabbaidbAbcom jeovacabon@grnail corn. 11:21:2014 02 25 PM An oil idea [CI Classification: Confidential Jeffrey, We are working on ideas to articulate views we heard from clients relating to crude. Specifically, that crude will continue falling in the short time frame, but over the long run will rally. We found the following trade to be very interesting and offer attractive risk reward: Long Dated Knock-In Call on WTI (CL1 Ref: 76) Client buys a call option on CL1. Strike $100/bbl. Expiry: 14-Nov-18. Option only knocks in if on any date before expiry, CL1 settlement price is below $55/bbl Offer price: $1.12/bbl (mid at $0.75/bbl) For comparison, offer for vanilla $100 call is $4.30/bbl If oil touches $50 in the next 3 years and then goes to $125, the option would have an intrinsic value of 525, reaching over 20x payout. Looking forward to connecting on this and other ideas. Daniel Daniel Sabba Key Client Partners Deutsche Bank Securities Inc. Tel. +1 212 454 0857 Mobile Email CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0055660 CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00201844 EFTA01365054